joe renzulli's keynote @ 20th biennial world conference (wcgtc) louisville, ky - usa

73
Intelligences Outside the Normal Curve: Factors That Contribute To the Crea:on of Leadership Skills and Social Capital In Young People and Adults Joseph S. Renzulli, Director The Na:onal Research Center On The GiJed And Talented The University of Connec:cut (USA) The Development Of Social Capital Leadership For A Changing World Genius is talent set on fire by courage. Henry van Dyke American Author

Upload: world-council-for-gifted-and-talented-children

Post on 01-Nov-2014

1.380 views

Category:

Education


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Intelligences Outside the Normal Curve

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Intelligences  Outside  the  Normal  Curve:    

Factors  That  Contribute  To  the  

Crea:on  of  Leadership  Skills  and  Social  Capital  In  Young  People  and  Adults    

Joseph  S.  Renzulli,  Director  The  Na:onal  Research  Center  On  The  GiJed  And  Talented  

The  University  of  Connec:cut  (USA)  

The  Development    Of  Social  Capital  

Leadership  For  A  Changing  World  

Genius  is  talent  set  on  fire  by  courage.  

Henry  van  Dyke  American  Author      

 

Page 2: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

1.    General  Theory  For  Talent  Development  

2.    Why  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  Are  Important?  

3.    Opera:on  Houndstooth  Theory  &  Research  

4.    Execu:ve    Func:on  Theory  &  Research  

5.    Co-­‐Cogni:ve  Factor  Interven:on  Theory  

Outline  

Not everything that can be counted counts. And not everything that counts can be counted.

Albert Einstein

Page 3: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Giftedness!

1. Who are they? 1a. What causes some people to use their

gifts in socially constructive and action oriented ways?

2. How do we develop it? 2a. How can we promote more socially

constructive giftedness and action orientation on the parts of young people?

Page 4: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

A good head and a good heart are

always a formidable

combination. Nelson Mandela

Page 5: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

1.    General  Theory  For  Talent  Development  

2.    Why  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  Are  Important  

3.    Opera:on  Houndstooth  Theory  &  Research  

4.    Execu:ve    Func:on  Theory  &  Research  

5.    Co-­‐Cogni:ve  Factor  Interven:on  Theory  

Outline  

The  best  people  possess  a  feeling  for  beauty,  the  courage  to  take  risks,  the  discipline  to  tell  the  truth,  the  capacity  for  sacrifice.    

         Ernest  Hemingway            American  Author    

 

Page 6: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Con:nuum  of  Learning  Theories*  

6  

Pedagogy

Outcomes

Major Theorists

National Goals

Deductive Didactic & Prescriptive Knowledge Acquisition,

Storage, and Retrieval. Predetermined Content

Basic Skill Acquisition Text Consumption

Behaviorists • Pavlov • Thorndike • Skinner

Increased Academic Achievement Higher Test Scores Technically Proficient Professional and Skilled Workers

Inductive, Investigative & Inquiry Oriented

Knowledge Application, High Engagement, Motivation And Enjoyment. J-I-T Content 21st Century Thinking Skills Creative Productivity

Constructivists • Pestalozzi, Torrance, • Montessori, Gardner, • Piaget & Bruner, Passow, • Dewey, Sternberg

Inventors; Writers, Innovative & Compassionate Leaders; Creative Designers in Sciences, Arts, & Technology; Economic & Social Action Entrepreneurs

*Both  ends  of  this  con:nuum  are  important,  and  schools  should  integrate  them  whenever  possible  to  produce  the  best  balance  between  the  two  models  of  learning.      

 All  you  ever  needed  to  know  about  learning  theory  (in  one  slide)!

People Who Make a Difference… This should be the major focus of our

field.

The  GiJed  Educa:on  Gold  Standard  

Page 7: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Concep

:ons  of  G

iJed

ness  

A  Focus  on  Crea:ve  Produc6vity  The  Three-­‐Ring  Concep:on    

of  GiJedness  

Fully  Func:oning  Self-­‐Actualized  

Individual  

The  Development  of  Social  Capital  

Opera:on  Houndstooth  

Leadership  in  a  Changing  World  

Executive Functions

The  Big  and  Ne

ver  Ending  

Ques:on  For  O

ur  Field…  

What  is  the  differ

ence  

that  makes  a  differenc

e?  

Page 8: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

•  When 11-year-old Aubyn Burnside heard about how many children in foster care programs are forced to carry their belongings in garbage bags because they cannot afford suitcases, she was shocked and saddened. "I thought they must feel like garbage themselves," she said. So, Aubyn founded Suitcases for Kids, dedicating herself to ensuring that every child in foster care would have a bag of his or her own.

A  Few  Prac:cal  Examples  of    These  Sub-­‐Theories…    

Suitcases for Kids  

hcp://www.suitcasesforkids.org  

Page 9: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

The  Merry  Licle  Playground  

Page 10: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 11: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

1.    General  Theory  For  Talent  Development  

2.    Why  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  Are  Important      •  Underlying  Assump:ons  for  This  Work  

1.    Opera:on  Houndstooth  Theory  &  Research  

4.    Execu:ve    Func:on  Theory  &  Research  

5.    Co-­‐Cogni:ve  Factor  Interven:on  Theory  

Outline  

Page 12: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Underlying  Assump:ons  For  Studying  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  

1.    Persons  with  high  poten:al  will  emerge  as  leaders,  policy  makers,  and  persons  of  influence  in  all  walks  of  life  including  religion,  poli:cs,  business,  government,  science,  the  arts  and  humani:es,  and  other  domains  that  define  a  society  and  a  culture.      

2.   Educa:onal  ins:tu:ons  and  programs  that  serve  high  poten:al  youth  have  a    responsibility  to  provide  opportuni:es,  resources,  and  experiences  that  contribute    to  the  ethical,  moral,  social,  and  emo:onal  development  of  young  people    as  well  as  their  cogni/ve  development.              

“I  have  found  that  the  higher  the  IQ,  the  earlier  moral  concerns  develop  and  the  more  profound  effect  they  have  on  the  child.    

       R.  A.  Silverman                Journal  of  Personality,  1994  

   

Research  shows  that  when  children  are  young  they  develop  what  you  call  intui:ve  theories.    It’s  like  powerful  engravings  on  your  brain.    Teachers  don’t  realize  how  powerful  they  are,  but  early  theories  don’t  disappear,  they  stay  on  the  ground.                                                      Howard  Gardner    

                                 Quoted  in  Kogan,  2000,  p.  66        

Page 13: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Why is Social Capital important?

And what is education’s role In the production of Social Capital?

Two insightful quotes…

Page 14: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

We  are  not  engaged  in  producing  just  good  performers  in  the  market  place  or  able  technocrats.  Our  task  is  the  educa:on  of  good  human  beings,  purposeful  and  wise,  themselves  with  a  vision  of  what  it  is  to  be  human  and  of  the  kind  of  society  which  makes  that  possible.      

       Dr.  George  Carey          Former  Archbishop  of  Canterbury  

I  now  understand  that  my  welfare  is  only  possible  if  I  acknowledge  my  unity  with  all  the  people  of  the  world  without  excep:on.    

           Leo  Tolstoy      

Page 15: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 16: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Two  equably  able  people…  

Page 17: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

1966

1968

1970

1972

1974

1976

1978

1980

1982

1984

1986

1988

1990

1992

1994

1996

1998

2000

Develop MeaningfulPhilosophy of Life

Become Well-Off Financially

CHANGING  PRIORITIES:  MONEY  COUNTS  

SOURCE:  College  freshman  surveyed  by  Higher  Educa:on  Research  Ins:tute  (HERI)    

What  research  tells  us  about  contemporary  aotudes  and  behaviors  of  young  people…  

Page 18: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Today's  kids  view  chea:ng  as  part  of  the  path  to  success  By  Victor  Dorff    Chea:ng  was,  is  and  probably  always  will  be  a  fact  of  life.  Recently,  technology  has  provided  new  ways  to  cheat,  but  advanced  electronics  can't  be  blamed  for  our  increasing  willingness  to  tolerate  it.    Once  upon  a  :me,  being  an  honorable  person  included  the  no:on  that  your  word  was  your  bond,  and  integrity  was  a  crucial  element  in  establishing  a  good  reputa:on.  My  teaching  experience  tells  me,  however,  that  lying  and  chea:ng  are  seen  by  a  lot  of  kids  today  as  a  crucial  part  of  any  path  to  success.  The  only  shame  is  in  geong  caught.  

07/19/2012    

Page 19: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

The Six Value Segments of Global Youth: The Ultimate Differentiator

SEGMENT 1: THRILLS AND CHILLS Key definers: Fun, friends, irreverence, and sensation* SEGMENT 2: RESIGNED Key definers: Friends, fun, family, and low expectations SEGMENT 3: WORLD SAVERS Key definers: Environment, humanism, fun, and friends SEGMENT 4: QUIET ACHIEVERS Key definers: Success, anonymity, anti-individualism, and social optimism SEGMENT 5: BOOTSTRAPPERS Key definers: Achievement, individualism, optimism, determinism, and power* SEGMENT 6: UPHOLDERS Key definers: Family, custom, tradition, and respect for individuals

*US the highest

Elissa Moses

Page 20: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 21: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

What research tells us about trends in young people’s values systems…...

•  Ahuvia, A.C. (2002). Individualism/collectivism and cultures of happiness: A theoretical conjecture on the relationship between consumption, culture and subjective well-being at the national level. Journal of Happiness Studies, 3, 23-36.

•  Bassett, P.F. (2002, February). Why good schools are countercultural. Education Week 21(21), 35.

•  Huer, J. (1991). The wages of sin: America’s dilemma of profit against humanity. New York: Praeger.

•  Kasser, T. (2002). The high price of materialism. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. •  Myers, D.G. (1993). Authentic happiness: Using the new positive psychology to realize your

potential for lasting fulfillment. New York: Avon. •  Netemeyer, R. G., Burton, S., & Lichtenstein, D.R. (1995). Trait aspects of vanity:

Measurement and relevance to consumer behavior. The Journal of Consumer Research, 21(4), 612-626.

•  Shrader, W.K. (1992). Media blight and the dehumanizing of america. New York: Praeger. •  Tatzel, M. (2002). “Money worlds” and well-being: An integration of money dispositions,

materialism and price-related behavior. Journal of Economic Psychology, 23, 103-126. •  Sandlin, J. A. & McLaren, P. (2009). Critical Pedagogies of Consumption: Living and

Learning in the Shadow of the "Shopocalypse.” New York: Routledge. •  Twenge,  J.  M.,  Konrath,  S.,  Foster,  J.  D.,  Campbell,  W.  K.,  &  Bushman,  B.  J.  (2008).  Egos  

infla:ng  over  :me:  A  cross-­‐temporal  meta-­‐analysis  of  the  narcissis:c  personality  inventory.  Journal  of  Personality,  76,  875-­‐901.    

References for the next slide…

Page 22: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Contemporary Undesirable Trends In Young People’s Values Systems

•  Rampant materialism, conspicuous consumption •  Self-indulgence, narcissism; limited interest in social,

political, ethical, environmental, and moral issues •  Lack of interest in the well-being of others •  Cultural tribalism (asserting one’s differences while

depreciating the differences of others) •  Maximization of personal gain; career choice based on

making money •  Obsession with the theatre of celebrity •  Manipulated by the “cultural industry” that focuses on

consumption, media, and marketing to promote identity creation

•  Substituting Virtual For Real World Relationships

Page 23: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

1.    General  Theory  For  Talent  Development  

2.    Why  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  Are  Important  

3.    Opera:on  Houndstooth  Theory  &  Research  

4.    Execu:ve    Func:on  Theory  &  Research  

5.    Co-­‐Cogni:ve  Factor  Interven:on  Theory  

Outline  

Page 24: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Actions that benefit others -- single individuals or targeted groups, entire communities, the culture or society-at-large, the Earth’s resources…

•  Social Capital is produced when people take action in the following areas:

Social Justice, Economic Fairness, Political Activity, Cultural Enhancement, Ecological Preservation, and Ethical, Moral, and Spiritual Leadership

Definition of Social Capital

…as distinct from actions that are only taken only to benefit one’s own financial gain, status, power or authority, or how one is viewed in the eyes of others

Page 25: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Gemeinschaftsgefuhl (adj) (German) Ga-mein-shafts-ga-fuel lack of ego involvement; focusing on problems outside one’s self; social interest; feeling of kinship with others; democratic character structure; unhostile sense of humor; kindness; regard for fellow human beings. Filotomo (Greek) Giving of yourself and expecting nothing in return

Page 26: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

No society can sustain itself unless its members havelearned the sensitivities, motivations, and skillsinvolved in assisting and caring for other humanbeings. Yet the school, which is the setting carryingprimary responsibility for preparing young people foreffective participation in adult life, does not, at least inAmerican society, give high priority to providingopportunities in which such learning could take place.

Uri Bronfenbrenner

Page 27: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

It’s a simple, easily forgotten truth thatwe need one another. I sometimes thinkthat history might easily say about thisnation:

“It was a great nation full of talentedpeople with enormous energy who forgotthat they needed one another.”

John Gardner

Page 28: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

What Is Good (Intelligent) Thinking?

Critical Thinking

(Mainly Cognitive)

Seeing Relationships• Observing• Organizing• Patterning• SequencingAnalyzing• Translating• Interpreting• Extrapolating• Inferring• Detecting BiasSynthesizing• Evaluating• Concluding• Generalizing• Predicting

82%  Creative/Productive Thinking

(Mainly Motivational and Practical)

Solution OrientedCuriosity/InquisitivenessPersistentStrategic (Developing a Plan or StrategySpontaneousOpenness (to the new and unusual)PlayfulnessIndependenceImpulsiveness

14%  Ethical Thinking

(Mainly Affective)

IntegrityFairnessHumilitySensitivity/AwarenessAltruismTruthfulness/HonestyInterdependenceEmpathy

4%  

First  Background  Study  

Page 29: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Literature Review…

Page 30: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

The  Seman:c  Differen:al  Technique  

Page 31: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Sample  items  from    

Opera/on  Houndstooth  Co-­‐Cogni/ve  Factor  Scale  R.E.  Sytsma,  J.S.  Renzulli,  and  K.S.  Berman    

University  of  Connec/cut  2002  

1.   I am motivated to improve the quality of life for other people. 2.   I support unpopular viewpoints when I believe they are correct.

3.   At this point in time, I see myself as successful. 4.   I am intrigued by unanswered questions in my area of strongest

interest. 5.   I am optimistic about my future.

6.   When others tire of working on something, I continue working.

Page 32: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Examples of Items from The Young Person’s Houndstooth Survey

I am always happy. I help others without being asked. I am able to do what is right, even if it’s not the cool thing to do. I am hopeful about the future. I make goals for myself.

Page 33: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Operation Houndstooth: Co-Cognitive Factors Scale (Co-CFS)

© R.E. Sytsma, J.S. Renzulli, & K.B. Berman University of Connecticut, 2002

Factor Name # Stems α-Reliability Optimism 5 .82

Courage 4 .87

Romance with a Topic/Discipline

4 .73

Sensitivity to Human Concerns

5 .83

Mental/Physical Energy 4 .76

Vision/Sense of Destiny 4 .75

Page 34: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 35: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 36: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 37: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

1.    General  Theory  For  Talent  Development  

2.    Why  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  Are  Important  

3.    Opera:on  Houndstooth  Theory  &  Research  

4.    Execu:ve    Func:on  Theory  &  Research  

5.    Co-­‐Cogni:ve  Factor  Interven:on  Theory  

Outline  

Page 38: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Execu:ve  func:ons  are  broadly  defined  here  as  the  ability  to  engage  in  novel  situa:ons  that  require  planning,  decision-­‐making,  troubleshoo:ng,  and  ethical  leadership  that  is  not  dependent  on  rou:ne  or  well-­‐rehearsed  responses  to  challenging  combina:ons  of  condi:ons.        It  involves  organizing,  integra6ng,  and  managing  informa6on,  emo6ons,  and  other  mental  func6ons  that  lead  to  “doing  the  right  thing”  in  situa6ons  that  do  not  have  a  predetermined  or  formulaic  driven  response.      These  func6ons  are  especially  important  to  highly  capable  people  because  of  their  access  to  extensive  amounts  of  knowledge  and  broad  range  of  experiences  within  and  across  disciplines.        

Defini:on  of  Execu:ve  Func:ons  

Page 39: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Execu:ve  Func:on  skills  are  more  important  for  school  readiness  than  are  IQ  or  entry-­‐level  reading  or  math.    (e.g.,  Blair,  2002;  2003;  Blair  &  Razza,  2007;  Normandeau  &  Guay,  1998)    

Research shows that 5-year- olds today are behind in EFs compared with 5-year-olds of a couple of generations ago. (Smirnova, 1998; Smirnova & Gudareva, 2004)  

Page 40: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

“What  I  think  is  important  on  the  road  to  success  is  learning  to  deal  with  failure,  to  manage  adversity.  That’s  a  skill  that  parents  can  certainly  help  their  children  develop—and  so  can  teachers  and  coaches  and  mentors.”    How  Children  Succeed:  Grit,  Curiosity,    and  the  Hidden  Power  of  Character    

                   Paul  Tough      

Page 41: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Scale  for  Ra6ng  the  Execu6ve  Func6ons  of  Young  People  Joseph  S.  Renzulli  Melissa  S.  Mitchell  

Ac6on  Orienta6on  

Social  Interac6ons  

Leadership  

Realis6c  Self-­‐Assessment  

Awareness  of  Needs  of  Others  

Instrument  Development  

Page 42: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Content  Validity  

Page 43: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Student  Instrument  

Page 44: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Ac6on  Orienta6on  

   What  mo(vates  you  to  

succeed?  

Item   Factor  Loading  

Persistent   .694  

Possesses  a  good  work  ethic   .569  

Able  to  follow  through  with  tasks  

.549  

Demonstrates  strong  study  skills   .534  

Self-­‐starter   .501  

Persevering   .479  

Values  diversity   .441  

Mo6vated   .427  

Goal  oriented   .422  

Charitable   .420  

Understands/deals  with  racism   .414  

Purposeful   .365  

Enjoys  Challenge   .355  

Internal  reliability    α=  .772  

Construct  Validity  

Page 45: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Social  Interac6ons  

   How  do  you  successfully  interact  with  others?  

Item   Factor  Loading  

Polite   .661  

Tacaul   .577  

Able  to  get  along  well  with  others  

.530  

Respecaul  of  others   .528  

Good  listener   .788  

Interested  in  others   .485  

Considerate   .474  

Possesses  good  manners   .436  

Suppor6ve   .419  

Interacts  well  with  others   .374  

Coopera6ve   .331  

Internal  reliability    α=  .751  

Construct  Validity  

Page 46: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Item   Factor  Loading  

Responsible   .696  

Priori6zes   .663  

Reliable   .643  

Dependable   .632  

Allocates  6me  well   .543  

Decision  maker   .539  

Professional   .523  

Flexible   .486  

Able  to  plan  ahead   .477  

Enterprising   .406  

Crea6ve   .398  

Compassionate   .368  

Demonstrates  strong  leadership  skills   .365  

Prefers  long  range  goals   .354  

Generates  ideas   .340  

Takes  Charge   .329  

Internal  reliability    α=  .812  

Leadership      

What  characteris(cs  do  you  have  to  be  a  successful  leader?  

Construct  Validity  

Page 47: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Realis6c    Self-­‐Assessment  

   How  aware  are  you  of  your  own  abili(es?  

Item   Factor  Loading  

Possesses  a  high  level  of  self-­‐esteem  

.651  

Possessing  a  strong  self-­‐concept   .630  

Able  to  give  a  realis6c  self-­‐appraisal  

.629  

Realis6c   .594  

Possessing  strong  self-­‐efficacy   .583  

Confident   .574  

Defers  gra6fica6on   .490  

Adaptable   .478  

Copes  well  with  set  backs   .464  

Conscien6ous   .456  

Open  to  new  ideas   .341  

Openminded   .330  

Socially  conscious   .329  

Internal  reliability    α=  .781  

Construct  Validity  

Page 48: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Awareness  of  Needs  of  Others  

   How  mindful  are  you  of  the  needs  of  others?  

Item   Factor  Loading  

Collaborates  well   .598  

Possesses  strong  communica6on  skills  

.517  

Ethical   .485  

Sensi6ve   .478  

Possesses  good  e6quefe   .454  

Aware  of  role  of  effort   .448  

Possesses  strong  character   .447  

Approachable   .446  

Enthusias6c   .379  

Cri6cal  thinker   .364  

Empathe6c   .327  

Internal  reliability    α=  .744  

Construct  Validity  

Page 49: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Teaching  Strategies  to  Build  Execu:ve  Func:on  in  Students  

1.   Provide  Opportuni:es  to  Apply  Learning  Provide  students  with  opportuni6es  to  apply  learning  -­‐-­‐  especially  through  authen6c,  personally  meaningful  ac6vi6es  -­‐-­‐  and  then  provide  forma6ve  assessments  and  feedback  throughout  an  authen6c  project.  

2.    Introduce  Prac:ce  Ac:vi:es  to  Support  Developing  Execu:ve  Func:on  Students  need  to  be  given  opportuni6es  to  prac6ce  using  execu6ve  func6ons  such  as  how  to  learn,  study,  organize,  priori6ze,  review,  and  ac6vely  par6cipate  in  class.  

3.    Have  Students  Model  Higher  Execu:ve  Func:on  Skills  In  planning  prac6ce  ac6vi6es,  consider  how  and  when  students  can  model  execu6ve  func6on  skills  and  have  students  provide  feedback  to  one  another.    

Page 50: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

A  Type  III  Enrichment  Inves:ga:on  That  Reflects  Both  Houndstooth  Traits  

and  Execu:ve  Func:on  Skills    

Page 51: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Sample Resources From the How-To Data Base at

www.renzullilearning.com

(Type  II  Enrichment  in  The    Enrichment  Triad  Model)  

Page 52: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

1.    General  Theory  For  Talent  Development  

2.    Why  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  Are  Important  

3.    Opera:on  Houndstooth  Theory  &  Research  

4.    Execu:ve    Func:on  Theory  &  Research  

5.    Co-­‐Cogni:ve  Factor  Interven:on  Theory  

Outline  

Page 53: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Third  graders  recite  a  daily  pledge  to  be  intellectually    ac:ve,  humble,  and  kind  to  others    

Page 54: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

In  conclusion…  

Page 55: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

"The things that will destroy us are: politics without principle; pleasure without conscience; wealth without work; knowledge without character; business without morality; science without humanity; and worship without sacrifice."

Mohandas Gandhi

Page 56: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that ever does.

Margaret Mead

Page 57: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

An  important  ques:on  that  we,  as  educators  of  the  future  leaders  of  all  aspects  of  the  important  work  of  the  world,  must  ask  ourselves  –  the  area  in  which  we  should  be  taking  the  lead  in  educa:on.  In   an   era   of   homogenized,   shrink-­‐wrapped,   germ-­‐free   curriculum,   we   are  depriving  our  students  of  opportuni:es  to  think  cri:cally  and  to  inves:gate  the  things  that  are  some  of  the  most  important  issues  facing  today’s  world:      •  Climate  change  •  Environmental  destruc:on                  •  Worldwide  humanitarian  crises        •  Racial  and  religious  Intolerance      •  Rampant  greed  &  materialism    •  Human  rights                                                    •  Self-­‐indulgence  vs.  the  common  good  •  Social  jus:ce                                      •  Gender  equity        •  Inadequate  health  care                    •  Brainwashing  kids  through  adver:sing      •  The  stranglehold  that  lobbyists  have  on  government    •  Unethical  behavior  on  the  parts  of  business  and  poli:cal  leaders  •  The  widening  gap  between  rich  and  poor  people  and  na:ons  •  Devasta:on  of  the  Earth’s  natural  resources  •  Poli:cal  gridlock  among  state  and  na:onal  elected  officials  •  Child  Labor  and  trafficking  of  young  women  and  children                

Let me end with a challenge for real leadership in our field…

Page 58: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

A Quick

Summary

Page 59: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Tradi:onal  Focus  of  GiJed  Educa:on  

•    The  ability  to  iden:fy  trustworthy  and  useful  informa:on  •    The  ability  to  selec:vely  manage  overabundant  informa:on  •    The  ability  to  organize,  classify,  and  evaluate  informa:on  •    The  ability  to  conduct  self-­‐assessments  of  web-­‐based  informa:on      •    The  ability  to  use  relevant  informa:on  to  advance  the  quality  of  one’s  work  •    The  ability  to  communicate  informa:on  effec:vely  

Meta-­‐cogni:ve  Skills    in  Technology  

Focusing  &  Filtering  

   •    Op:mism                                                                                •    Mental  and  Physical  Energy      •    Courage                                                                                •    Vision  &  A  Sense  of  Des:ny  •    Romance  With  a  Topic  or  Discipline                •    Sensi:vity  To  Human  Concerns        

Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  

Contribu:ng  To  Social  Capital  &  Making  A  Becer  World  

The  SoJ  Intelligences  

“Execu:ve  Func:ons”  

           •  Personal    •  Social                                                  •    Organiza:onal      •  Emo:onal                    •  Mo:va:onal                              “Geong  your  act    •  Spiritual    •  Responsible        together”  

 Leadership  Based  on  Wisdom  &  Responsibility    

The  Tradi:onal  Cogni:ve  Basics  

 Crea:ve  Thinking                  Planning  Cri:cal  Thinking                  Forecas:ng                        Problem  Solving                  Wri:ng  Decision  Making                  Literacy  Produc:ve  Thinking          Numeracy  

Opportunities For Creative Productivity }  Brought  to  bear  upon…  

Page 60: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Teachers are the unacknowledged legislators of the world.

Ashley Montagu

< of the gifted

Page 61: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 62: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Happiness Always

Thank you for your kind attention, and I wish you...

geluk Altijd felicidade sempre

Szczęście zawsze

快乐,永远快乐 행복을 항상

bonheur toujours lykke alltid

Sreća uvijek

Счастье все

гда mutluluk her zaman

السماويةلسعادة

 

Page 63: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 64: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Intelligences  Outside  the  Normal  Curve:    Factors  That  Contribute  To  the  Crea:on  of  Leadership  Skills  and  

Social  Capital  In  Young  People  and  Adults        

SENSITIVITY TO HUMAN CONCERNS

OPTIMISM

ROMANCE WITH A TOPIC OR DISCIPLINE

VISION/SENSE OF DESTINY

PHYSICAL/MENTAL ENERGY

COURAGE

・ Ac6on  Orienta6on  

Social  Interac6ons  

Leadership  

Realis6c    Self-­‐Assessment  

Awareness  of  Needs    of  Others  

Joseph  S.  Renzulli,  Director  The  Na:onal  Research  Center  On  The  GiJed  And  Talented  

The  University  of  Connec:cut  (USA)  

Page 65: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 66: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Regular Classroom

Enrichment Learning and Teaching TYPE I

GENERAL EXPLORATORY

ACTIVITIES

TYPE II GROUP

TRAINING ACTIVITIES

TYPE III INDIVIDUAL & SMALL GROUP

INVESTIGATIONS OF REAL PROBLEMS

Environment In General

The Schoolwide Enrichment Model Joseph S. Renzulli & Sally M. Reis

www.gifted.uconn.edu Service Delivery

Components

Strength Assessment Portfolio Curriculum Modification Techniques

School Structures The  School      

Organiza:onal  Model  

The    Learning  Theory  

Page 67: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Con:nuum  of  Learning  Theories*  

67  

Pedagogy

Outcomes

Major Theorists

National Goals

Deductive Didactic & Prescriptive Knowledge Acquisition,

Storage, and Retrieval. Predetermined Content

Basic Skill Acquisition Text Consumption

Behaviorists • Pavlov • Thorndike • Skinner

Increased Academic Achievement Higher Test Scores Technically Proficient Professional and Skilled Workers

Inductive, Investigative & Inquiry Oriented

Knowledge Application, High Engagement, Motivation And Enjoyment. J-I-T Content 21st Century Thinking Skills Creative Productivity

Constructivists • Pestalozzi, Torrance, • Montessori, Gardner, • Piaget & Bruner, • Dewey, Sternberg

Inventors Creative Designers in Sciences, Arts, & Technology Innovative Leaders Entrepreneurs Writers People Who Make a Difference

*Both  ends  of  this  con:nuum  are  important,  and  schools  should  integrate  them  whenever  possible  to  produce  the  best  balance  between  the  two  models  of  learning.      

 All  you  ever  needed  to  know  about  learning  theory  (in  one  slide)!

Page 68: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Special  Classes,  Resource  Room/  Pull-­‐Out,  Enrichment  Clusters,  AITDs,  

Independent  Study    

Regular  Classroom  Infusion  •    Extension  of  An  Individual  Lesson    •    A  Unit  You  Are  Planning  

Extra  and  Co-­‐Curricular  Ac:vi:es  And  Other  Special  Events  

In  Your  School    

Relating The Enrichment Triad Model To Various Organizational Structures

The  Pedagogy  of  Enrichment  Learning  and  Teaching  (EL&T)  

The  Enrichment  Triad  Model  

               {  All    Students  

{  Candidates    For  

Follow-­‐Up  

A  Pedagogical  Model  (What  We  Do  With  Students)  

Various  Organiza:onal  Models  (How  We  Group  Students  and    

Move  Them  Around)  

Page 69: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

                       How  Knowledge  Is  Organized  

Philosophy The Humanities

Law, Ethics, & Religion

Social Sciences Languages

Natural Sciences & Mathematics

Technology (Applied Sciences)

The Arts

Literature & Rhetoric

Facts & Statistics Beliefs, Attitudes, & Values

Classifications, Relations & Categories

Theories, Structures

Patterns, Trends & Sequences

Systems, Implications & Transformations

Principles, Concepts & Generalizations

Investigative Methods

Trivia, Folklore, & Insiders Information

“Giants,” Champions, & Landmark Events

A  Theory  of  Knowledge  

Page 70: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

KNOWLEDGE            

Curriculum          Content          

     PEDAGOGY    

       Instruc:onal          Strategies  

     Student          Products  

 

EXPRESSION  STYLES  

Classroom            Organiza:on          

 

 MANAGEMENT          

Technology  

Technology  

The  Role  of    

The  Teacher  

Learning/Teaching  Styles:  Lecture,  Discussion,  Peer  Tutoring,  Simulations  Socratic  Inquiry,  CAI,  Dramatization,  Problem  Based  Learning,  Guided  &  Unguided  Independent  Study    

Expression  Styles:    Oral,  Visual,  Graphic,  Manipulative,  Artistic,  Written,  Multi-­‐Media,  Service,  Combinations  of  the  Above            

Content  ModiNications  •    More  Material  •    More  Drill  &  Practice  •    Easier  Material      •  Greater  Depth  &    Complexity    •    Student  or  Teacher  Selected  Enrichment  Opportunities  Related  To    A  Topic  or  Unit  of  Study    

On-­‐line  Courses  Blogs,  Wikis,  Podcasts  RSS  Feeders,  Screencasts    

Flickr,  Twitter  Social  Networking  Sites  Renzulli  Learning  System    

Classroom  Organization:  Forum,  Cinema,    Laboratory,  Café,  Conference,  Boardroom,  Lecture  Hall,    Circle,  Hot  Seat,    Study  Carrels,  Science/Media  Labs,    Computer  Lab,  Interest  Centers,  “Coffee  House”      Grouping  by:    Interests,  Skill  Levels,  Ability,  Within  &  Across-­‐Grade  Cluster  Grouping,  Common  Tasks/Projects,  Complimentary  Talents,  Cooperative  Learning                

(JSR: 1996)

   Five  Dimensions  of  Differen:a:on    

Page 71: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA
Page 72: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

Young Person’s Houndstooth Survey

Strongly Disagree Disagree Agree Strongly

Agree 24. I am always happy. 25. I have a lot of energy. 26. If I help someone out, I expect them to help me later. 27. If someone is being mean, I tell them so. 28. I often think about what I want to be when I grow up. 29. I know the world will be a better place in the future. 30. I have the energy to finish projects that interest me. 31. I feel awful when someone gets hurt, even if it wasn’t my fault. 32. I am able to do what is right, even if it is not the cool thing to do. 33. I make goals for myself. 34. I have many good things to look forward to. 35. I am always thinking up new ideas. 36. I keep working on something I enjoy, even after other people get bored. For these questions you will be asked to think about something that you enjoy doing. Try to think of one thing that you really enjoy.

Write it here: . For the rest of this survey, the thing that you wrote above will be called your “Interest Area.”

Strongly D isagree D isagree Agree Strongly

Agree

37. I love to learn about my interest area. 38. I like to spend a lot of time working on my interest area. 39. I am happy when I get to do something in my interest area. 40. I would enjoy taking a lesson or class in my interest area.

I am in grade: Grade 3 Grade 4 Grade 5 Grade 6

I am a: Gir l Boy Color in the face that most closely matches how you feel about each sentence. As your teacher to explain any you don’t understand.

Strongly D isagree D isagree Agree Strongly

Agree

1. I help others without being asked. 2. I stand up for what I believe is right. 3. I know what I want to be when I grow up. 4. I look for the good in every situation. 5. I am eager to learn new things. 6. I look at things from other peoples’ points of view. 7. If a friend asked me to do something that was wrong, I would say no. 8. I know that I will do something important when I grow up. 9. I am hopeful about the future. 10. I am a curious person. 11. I think about other people’s feelings. 12. If an adult asked me to do something that was wrong, I would say no. 13. I can change my life to make it better. 14. If I have a bad day, I know tomorrow will be better. 15. I ask a lot of questions. 16. I think of how my actions affect other people. 17. I say what I think, even around people who may feel differently. 18. I can make the world a better place. 19. I often feel there is nothing to be hopeful about. 20. I am a hard worker. 21. When I help others, I don’t expect anything in return. 22. I am brave. 23. I know that I will be successful in the future.

Page 73: Joe Renzulli's Keynote @ 20th Biennial World Conference (WCGTC) Louisville, KY - USA

1.    General  Theory  For  Talent  Development  

2.    Why  Intelligences  Outside  The  Normal  Curve  Are  Important  

3.    Opera:on  Houndstooth  Theory  &  Research  

4.    Execu:ve    Func:on  Theory  &  Research  

5.    Co-­‐Cogni:ve  Factor  Interven:on  Theory  

Outline