john f. williams, svp national director - governmental consulting and planning

50
John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning HDR Engineering, Inc. New York City PROJECT MANAGEMENT P3

Upload: phoebe

Post on 11-Jan-2016

22 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

P3. PROJECT MANAGEMENT. John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning HDR Engineering, Inc. New York City. P3. P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N T. Beginning with a Common Understanding. Definitions Variations Dimensions. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

John F. Williams, SVPNational Director - Governmental Consulting and PlanningHDR Engineering, Inc.New York City

PROJECT MANAGEMENTP3

Page 2: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Beginning with a Common Understanding

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar Manifesto

Definitions

Variations

Dimensions

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 2

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 3: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

In the U.S. We Call It …

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar ManifestoUnited Nations SU/SSC Training Course 3

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

P3

Page 4: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

In Canada We Call it …

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar ManifestoUnited Nations SU/SSC Training Course 4

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

3P

Page 5: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

In Europe We Call It ...

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar ManifestoUnited Nations SU/SSC Training Course 5

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

PFI

Page 6: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

What Do You Call It?

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar ManifestoUnited Nations SU/SSC Training Course 6

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

?

Page 7: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Different Acronyms –

Same Process With Many Variations

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar ManifestoUnited Nations SU/SSC Training Course 7

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 8: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

P3 What is It?

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar Manifesto

A public-private partnership exists when public sector agencies (federal, state, or local) join with private sector entities (companies, foundations, academic institutions or citizens) and enter into a business relationship to attain a commonly shared goal that also achieves objectives of the individual partners.

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 8

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 9: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Three Basic Dimensions of P3

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar Manifesto

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 9

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Although each is unique, all P3’s include three basic characteristics

shared goals

shared resources (time, money, expertise, people)

shared risks and benefits

Without all three there is no reason to create or continue a partnership.

Page 10: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Why?

Source: * Hermann Scheer, author of A Solar Manifesto

Governments can bring private sector efficiency, expertise and competitiveness into projects and operations, while still being responsible for public interest issues and ensuring delivery at specified service levels.

In short, P3 is a tool that can help governments meet demands for the development of modern and efficient facilities, infrastructure and services while providing value for taxpayers.

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 10

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 11: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Getting Started

How do you create one?

How do you implement one?

A Public entity’s perspective of finding and contracting with the best private sector partner.

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 11

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 12: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

How Is It Done?

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 12

ConstructionOversight

Commis-sioning

AdministrationStartup

ContractModifications

Assessment EnhancementMonitoring Contract

Renegotia-tions

DesignCompliance

Situation Initial Idea,Need or Vision

Prelim ProjectDefinition &Rationale

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

ObjectivesSetting

AlternativesIndexing

Seed Funding

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

Process Map& Strategy

Fatal FlawAnalysis

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

Final ProjectDefinition

Environ-mental/

PermittingAnalysis

Site Selection/Analysis

Asset/SystemEvaluation

MasterSchedule/

Budget

PoliticalClimate

Assessment

Public/VendorOutreach &StakeholderConsultation

PrelimBusiness

Plan

MasterPlan &

Phasing

ProcurementStrategy

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

BusinessPlan

Vendor Pre-Qualification

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

DealStructuring/

Financing Plan

DeliveryMethodology

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

ContractNegotiations

VendorProposal

Evaluation

ProcurementDocuments

Property Management

Construction

Developer

Design/Engineering

Brokerage/Marketing

Legal

Finance/Accounting

Public "Owner"/Sponsor

Program Manager

User/Tenant

II

OverseeConstruction

AdministerConstruction

ConstructFacility

VisitSite

SuperviseStart-upActivities

ProvideGuidance

I

I

I

ApplyScope/Quality

Controls

SuperviseCommission-ing Activities

AuditDevelopment

Costs

ConfirmContract

Compliance

I

ApplyMonitoring

Controls

A

I

I

LeadContract

NegotiationsA

ReviewContract

Mods

A

Assist inContract

Negotiations

ReviewContract

Mods

VisitSite

I

CompletePunchlist

OverseeCommission-

ing

OverseePunchlist

Completion

I I

MakeCommission-

ingAdjustments

PreparePunchlist

ManageFacility

OverseeFacility

Management

A

I

I

I

AssessContract

Compliance

ApplyMonitoringControls

DocumentEnhancements

I

SuggestEnhancements

SuggestEnhancements

ProvideGuidance

ReviewMajor

ContractMods

ExecuteContract

Mods

IdentifyHotspots/

PowerPlayers

AssessPublic

& PrivateAttitudes

RiskIdentification

I IVisitSite

DocumentMajor Deal

Terms

I

PreparePreliminaryBusiness

Plan

PresentAlternatives

I

PrepareMasterBudget/

Schedule

PrepareGuidance

Report

I

PrepareRFQ &RFP

I

I II

ConductOutreachSessions

I

PrepareFinal

BusinessPlan

IdentifyHotspots/

PowerPlayers

IdentifyStakeholders

RiskAllocation

RiskMatrixing

ReviewDraftPlan

ReviewDraftPlan

DiscussProcurement

Philosphy

LegalOptions/Provide

Guidance

PrepareContracts

A

I

I

I

Administrative Specs

VisitSite/Perform

Analysis

ProvideValuation

Research& Interpret

Zoning

I

PresentOptions/

DocumentStrategy

DevelopEvaluationProcess

A

I

LeadContract

NegotiationsA

I

I

ReviewDesign

Submittals

StrategyInput

PrelimPublic

Assessment

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

ExpressInterest

I

IDetermine

StakeholderStrategy

PrepareRelationsStrategies

A

ReviewDraftPlan

ReviewDraftPlan

I

StrategyInput

RiskAssessment

RiskAssessment

A

CommercialTerms

ContractPrinciples

A

Terms ofReference

A

A

A

A

Assist inContract

Negotiations

ReviewDesign

Submittals

PrepareDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

SubmitQuals

AssembleTeam

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

SubmitProposal

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

PrepareBAFO

RefineAssumptions

I

PrepareMaster

Plan

ROI

Land UseAmendment

I

Infrastructure/SupportSystems

CompetitiveAnalysis

Program

ProjectCash Flow

Needs

InitialPhasing

InitialPhasing

I

DetermineSources& Uses

SeedBudget

Estimate

EstablishObjectives

ProvideQualitative

InputI I I

VisitSite

I

PrepareFeasibility/Business

Report

I

DocumentAlternatives

I

PrepareFatal FlawAnalysis

II

CustomizeProcess Map

& Strategy

I

CoordinatePermit

Process

PerformFunctionalEvaluation

I

I III I

StrategyInput

ResearchPotential

Uses

PrelimMarket

Analysis

I

PreparePrelim

Budget/Schedule

I

Leasevs. OwnAnalysis

EstimateSoft

Costs

DetermineSources& Uses

ProvideQualitative

Input

DocumentQualitativeAnalysis

SuggestAlternatives

SuggestAlternatives

EstablishObjectives

ProvideGuidance

I I I I I I

A

I

I

I

I

I I I

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

PerformPhysical

Evaluation

VisitSite/Perform

Analysis

ProvideValuation

Research& Interpret

Zoning

I

PhysicalEvaluation

Market Needs

Program-ming

CodeSynopsis

Environ-mentalImpact

Assessment

SiteVisit

DocumentObjectives

EstablishCriteria

DocumentFinal Project

Definition

PrepareApplication

Serve asApplicant

IdentifyOperationsScenarios

IdentifyFinancingSources

Prelimi-narilyDefineProject

DiscussProcurement

Desires

ProvideGuidance

Define BasicNeeds

CommissionFacility

TrendsInput

MarketFeedback

P3PMSM Process

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 13: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Two Major Steps

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 13

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Crafting the Partnership

Implementing the Partnership

CRAFT IMPLEMENTATION

Page 14: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Two Steps Down to Six Phases

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 14

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Genesis

Feasibility

Plan & Test

Procure

Design & Build

Operate & Maintain

GENESIS PROCUREFEASIBILITYPLAN &

TESTDESIGN &

BUILD

OPERATE &

MAINTAIN

Page 15: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Six Phases to 18 – Sub Phases

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 15

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Pre-QualifyDefinition Rationale ProForma

MasterPlan

MarketResearch

EconomicAnalysis

ConfirmDemand

ProgramBudget

Schedule

Select &Negotiate Design Maintain

Delivery/Deal

Structure

RiskAssess-

ment

Risk/DealStructure Start-up DisposalBuild

Page 16: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

18 Phases to 40 Milestones

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 16

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

ConstructionOversight

Commis-sioning

AdministrationStartup

ContractModificationsAssessment EnhancementMonitoring

ContractRenegotia-

tions

DesignCompliance

Situation Initial Idea,Needor Vision

PrelimProjectDefinition&Rationale

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

ObjectivesSetting

AlternativesIndexing

SeedFunding

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

ProcessMap& Strategy

Fatal FlawAnalysis

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

FinalProjectDefinition

Environ-mental/

PermittingAnalysis

SiteSelection/Analysis

Asset/SystemEvaluation

MasterSchedule/

Budget

PoliticalClimate

Assessment

Public/VendorOutreach&StakeholderConsultation

PrelimBusiness

Plan

MasterPlan &

Phasing

ProcurementStrategy

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

BusinessPlan

Vendor Pre-Qualification

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

DealStructuring/

FinancingPlan

DeliveryMethodology

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

ContractNegotiations

VendorProposalEvaluation

ProcurementDocuments

ConstructionOversight

Commis-sioning

AdministrationStartup

ContractModificationsAssessment EnhancementMonitoring

ContractRenegotia-

tions

DesignCompliance

Situation Initial Idea,Needor Vision

PrelimProjectDefinition&Rationale

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

ObjectivesSetting

AlternativesIndexing

SeedFunding

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

ProcessMap& Strategy

Fatal FlawAnalysis

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

FinalProjectDefinition

Environ-mental/

PermittingAnalysis

SiteSelection/Analysis

Asset/SystemEvaluation

MasterSchedule/

Budget

PoliticalClimate

Assessment

Public/VendorOutreach&StakeholderConsultation

PrelimBusiness

Plan

MasterPlan &

Phasing

ProcurementStrategy

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

BusinessPlan

Vendor Pre-Qualification

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

DealStructuring/

FinancingPlan

DeliveryMethodology

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

ContractNegotiations

VendorProposalEvaluation

ProcurementDocuments

Page 17: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

40 Milestones to 100s of tasks

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 17

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

ConstructionOversight

Commis-sioning

AdministrationStartup

ContractModifications

Assessment EnhancementMonitoring Contract

Renegotia-tions

DesignCompliance

Situation Initial Idea,Need or Vision

Prelim ProjectDefinition &Rationale

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

ObjectivesSetting

AlternativesIndexing

Seed Funding

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

Process Map& Strategy

Fatal FlawAnalysis

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

Final ProjectDefinition

Environ-mental/

PermittingAnalysis

Site Selection/Analysis

Asset/SystemEvaluation

MasterSchedule/

Budget

PoliticalClimate

Assessment

Public/VendorOutreach &StakeholderConsultation

PrelimBusiness

Plan

MasterPlan &

Phasing

ProcurementStrategy

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

BusinessPlan

Vendor Pre-Qualification

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

DealStructuring/

Financing Plan

DeliveryMethodology

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

ContractNegotiations

VendorProposal

Evaluation

ProcurementDocuments

Property Management

Construction

Developer

Design/Engineering

Brokerage/Marketing

Legal

Finance/Accounting

Public "Owner"/Sponsor

Program Manager

User/Tenant

II

OverseeConstruction

AdministerConstruction

ConstructFacility

VisitSite

SuperviseStart-upActivities

ProvideGuidance

I

I

I

ApplyScope/Quality

Controls

SuperviseCommission-ing Activities

AuditDevelopment

Costs

ConfirmContract

Compliance

I

ApplyMonitoring

Controls

A

I

I

LeadContract

NegotiationsA

ReviewContract

Mods

A

Assist inContract

Negotiations

ReviewContract

Mods

VisitSite

I

CompletePunchlist

OverseeCommission-

ing

OverseePunchlist

Completion

I I

MakeCommission-

ingAdjustments

PreparePunchlist

ManageFacility

OverseeFacility

Management

A

I

I

I

AssessContract

Compliance

ApplyMonitoringControls

DocumentEnhancements

I

SuggestEnhancements

SuggestEnhancements

ProvideGuidance

ReviewMajor

ContractMods

ExecuteContract

Mods

IdentifyHotspots/

PowerPlayers

AssessPublic

& PrivateAttitudes

RiskIdentification

I IVisitSite

DocumentMajor Deal

Terms

I

PreparePreliminaryBusiness

Plan

PresentAlternatives

I

PrepareMasterBudget/

Schedule

PrepareGuidance

Report

I

PrepareRFQ &RFP

I

I II

ConductOutreachSessions

I

PrepareFinal

BusinessPlan

IdentifyHotspots/

PowerPlayers

IdentifyStakeholders

RiskAllocation

RiskMatrixing

ReviewDraftPlan

ReviewDraftPlan

DiscussProcurement

Philosphy

LegalOptions/Provide

Guidance

PrepareContracts

A

I

I

I

Administrative Specs

VisitSite/Perform

Analysis

ProvideValuation

Research& Interpret

Zoning

I

PresentOptions/

DocumentStrategy

DevelopEvaluationProcess

A

I

LeadContract

NegotiationsA

I

I

ReviewDesign

Submittals

StrategyInput

PrelimPublic

Assessment

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

ExpressInterest

I

IDetermine

StakeholderStrategy

PrepareRelationsStrategies

A

ReviewDraftPlan

ReviewDraftPlan

I

StrategyInput

RiskAssessment

RiskAssessment

A

CommercialTerms

ContractPrinciples

A

Terms ofReference

A

A

A

A

Assist inContract

Negotiations

ReviewDesign

Submittals

PrepareDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

SubmitQuals

AssembleTeam

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

SubmitProposal

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

PrepareBAFO

RefineAssumptions

I

PrepareMaster

Plan

ROI

Land UseAmendment

I

Infrastructure/SupportSystems

CompetitiveAnalysis

Program

ProjectCash Flow

Needs

InitialPhasing

InitialPhasing

I

DetermineSources& Uses

SeedBudget

Estimate

EstablishObjectives

ProvideQualitative

InputI I I

VisitSite

I

PrepareFeasibility/Business

Report

I

DocumentAlternatives

I

PrepareFatal FlawAnalysis

II

CustomizeProcess Map

& Strategy

I

CoordinatePermit

Process

PerformFunctionalEvaluation

I

I III I

StrategyInput

ResearchPotential

Uses

PrelimMarket

Analysis

I

PreparePrelim

Budget/Schedule

I

Leasevs. OwnAnalysis

EstimateSoft

Costs

DetermineSources& Uses

ProvideQualitative

Input

DocumentQualitativeAnalysis

SuggestAlternatives

SuggestAlternatives

EstablishObjectives

ProvideGuidance

I I I I I I

A

I

I

I

I

I I I

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

PerformPhysical

Evaluation

VisitSite/Perform

Analysis

ProvideValuation

Research& Interpret

Zoning

I

PhysicalEvaluation

Market Needs

Program-ming

CodeSynopsis

Environ-mentalImpact

Assessment

SiteVisit

DocumentObjectives

EstablishCriteria

DocumentFinal Project

Definition

PrepareApplication

Serve asApplicant

IdentifyOperationsScenarios

IdentifyFinancingSources

Prelimi-narilyDefineProject

DiscussProcurement

Desires

ProvideGuidance

Define BasicNeeds

CommissionFacility

TrendsInput

MarketFeedback

Page 18: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

P3 Project Management – A Process Linked to Critical Path Scheduling

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 18

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Pre-QualifyDefinition Rationale ProForma

MasterPlan

MarketResearch

EconomicAnalysis

ConfirmDemand

ProgramBudget

Schedule

Select &Negotiate Design

IMPLEMENTATIONCRAFT

MaintainDelivery/

DealStructure

RiskAssess-

ment

OPERATEDEVELOPPROCUREPLAN & TESTFEASIBILITYGENESIS

Risk/DealStructure Start-up DisposalBuild

ConstructionOversight

Commis-sioning

AdministrationStartup

ContractModificationsAssessment EnhancementMonitoring

ContractRenegotia-

tions

DesignCompliance

Situation Initial Idea,Needor Vision

PrelimProjectDefinition&Rationale

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

ObjectivesSetting

AlternativesIndexing

SeedFunding

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

ProcessMap& Strategy

Fatal FlawAnalysis

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

FinalProjectDefinition

Environ-mental/

PermittingAnalysis

SiteSelection/Analysis

Asset/SystemEvaluation

MasterSchedule/

Budget

PoliticalClimate

Assessment

Public/VendorOutreach&StakeholderConsultation

PrelimBusiness

Plan

MasterPlan &

Phasing

ProcurementStrategy

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

BusinessPlan

Vendor Pre-Qualification

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

DealStructuring/

FinancingPlan

DeliveryMethodology

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

ContractNegotiations

VendorProposal

Evaluation

ProcurementDocuments

ConstructionOversight

Commis-sioning

AdministrationStartup

ContractModificationsAssessment EnhancementMonitoring

ContractRenegotia-

tions

DesignCompliance

Situation Initial Idea,Needor Vision

PrelimProjectDefinition&Rationale

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

ObjectivesSetting

AlternativesIndexing

SeedFunding

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

ProcessMap& Strategy

Fatal FlawAnalysis

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

FinalProjectDefinition

Environ-mental/

PermittingAnalysis

SiteSelection/Analysis

Asset/SystemEvaluation

MasterSchedule/

Budget

PoliticalClimate

Assessment

Public/VendorOutreach&StakeholderConsultation

PrelimBusiness

Plan

MasterPlan &

Phasing

ProcurementStrategy

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

BusinessPlan

Vendor Pre-Qualification

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

DealStructuring/

FinancingPlan

DeliveryMethodology

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

ContractNegotiations

VendorProposal

Evaluation

ProcurementDocuments

ConstructionOversight

Commis-sioning

AdministrationStartup

ContractModifications

Assessment EnhancementMonitoring Contract

Renegotia-tions

DesignCompliance

Situation Initial Idea,Need or Vision

Prelim ProjectDefinition &Rationale

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

ObjectivesSetting

AlternativesIndexing

Seed Funding

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

Process Map& Strategy

Fatal FlawAnalysis

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

Final ProjectDefinition

Environ-mental/

PermittingAnalysis

Site Selection/Analysis

Asset/SystemEvaluation

MasterSchedule/

Budget

PoliticalClimate

Assessment

Public/VendorOutreach &StakeholderConsultation

PrelimBusiness

Plan

MasterPlan &

Phasing

ProcurementStrategy

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

BusinessPlan

Vendor Pre-Qualification

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

DealStructuring/

Financing Plan

DeliveryMethodology

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

ContractNegotiations

VendorProposal

Evaluation

ProcurementDocuments

Property Management

Construction

Developer

Design/Engineering

Brokerage/Marketing

Legal

Finance/Accounting

Public "Owner"/Sponsor

Program Manager

User/Tenant

II

OverseeConstruction

AdministerConstruction

ConstructFacility

VisitSite

SuperviseStart-upActivities

ProvideGuidance

I

I

I

ApplyScope/Quality

Controls

SuperviseCommission-ing Activities

AuditDevelopment

Costs

ConfirmContract

Compliance

I

ApplyMonitoring

Controls

A

I

I

LeadContract

NegotiationsA

ReviewContract

Mods

A

Assist inContract

Negotiations

ReviewContract

Mods

VisitSite

I

CompletePunchlist

OverseeCommission-

ing

OverseePunchlist

Completion

I I

MakeCommission-

ingAdjustments

PreparePunchlist

ManageFacility

OverseeFacility

Management

A

I

I

I

AssessContract

Compliance

ApplyMonitoringControls

DocumentEnhancements

I

SuggestEnhancements

SuggestEnhancements

ProvideGuidance

ReviewMajor

ContractMods

ExecuteContract

Mods

IdentifyHotspots/

PowerPlayers

AssessPublic

& PrivateAttitudes

RiskIdentification

I IVisitSite

DocumentMajor Deal

Terms

I

PreparePreliminaryBusiness

Plan

PresentAlternatives

I

PrepareMasterBudget/

Schedule

PrepareGuidance

Report

I

PrepareRFQ &RFP

I

I II

ConductOutreachSessions

I

PrepareFinal

BusinessPlan

IdentifyHotspots/

PowerPlayers

IdentifyStakeholders

RiskAllocation

RiskMatrixing

ReviewDraftPlan

ReviewDraftPlan

DiscussProcurement

Philosphy

LegalOptions/Provide

Guidance

PrepareContracts

A

I

I

I

Administrative Specs

VisitSite/Perform

Analysis

ProvideValuation

Research& Interpret

Zoning

I

PresentOptions/

DocumentStrategy

DevelopEvaluationProcess

A

I

LeadContract

NegotiationsA

I

I

ReviewDesign

Submittals

StrategyInput

PrelimPublic

Assessment

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

ExpressInterest

I

IDetermine

StakeholderStrategy

PrepareRelationsStrategies

A

ReviewDraftPlan

ReviewDraftPlan

I

StrategyInput

RiskAssessment

RiskAssessment

A

CommercialTerms

ContractPrinciples

A

Terms ofReference

A

A

A

A

Assist inContract

Negotiations

ReviewDesign

Submittals

PrepareDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

ReviewDesign

Submittals

SubmitQuals

AssembleTeam

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

SubmitProposal

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

Visit Site/Ask

Questions

PrepareBAFO

RefineAssumptions

I

PrepareMaster

Plan

ROI

Land UseAmendment

I

Infrastructure/SupportSystems

CompetitiveAnalysis

Program

ProjectCash Flow

Needs

InitialPhasing

InitialPhasing

I

DetermineSources& Uses

SeedBudget

Estimate

EstablishObjectives

ProvideQualitative

InputI I I

VisitSite

I

PrepareFeasibility/Business

Report

I

DocumentAlternatives

I

PrepareFatal FlawAnalysis

II

CustomizeProcess Map

& Strategy

I

CoordinatePermit

Process

PerformFunctionalEvaluation

I

I III I

StrategyInput

ResearchPotential

Uses

PrelimMarket

Analysis

I

PreparePrelim

Budget/Schedule

I

Leasevs. OwnAnalysis

EstimateSoft

Costs

DetermineSources& Uses

ProvideQualitative

Input

DocumentQualitativeAnalysis

SuggestAlternatives

SuggestAlternatives

EstablishObjectives

ProvideGuidance

I I I I I I

A

I

I

I

I

I I I

MarketFeedback

MarketFeedback

PerformPhysical

Evaluation

VisitSite/Perform

Analysis

ProvideValuation

Research& Interpret

Zoning

I

PhysicalEvaluation

Market Needs

Program-ming

CodeSynopsis

Environ-mentalImpact

Assessment

SiteVisit

DocumentObjectives

EstablishCriteria

DocumentFinal Project

Definition

PrepareApplication

Serve asApplicant

IdentifyOperationsScenarios

IdentifyFinancingSources

Prelimi-narilyDefineProject

DiscussProcurement

Desires

ProvideGuidance

Define BasicNeeds

CommissionFacility

TrendsInput

MarketFeedback

Page 19: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Practical Guide for P3 Program Management

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 19

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 20: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Six Distinct Phases

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 20

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Genesis: What’s the need, what’s driving the need, and is there a need for a Public/Private Partnership?

Feasibility: Is a Public/Private Partnership feasible, not only financially, but practically? Can it be done?

Plan & Test: What is the best way to complete the project? Has the plan been thoroughly tested to assess market demand, public and stakeholder feedback, economics and potential “fatal flaws” that could derail the project?Procure: How do you choose and contract with the best-value private partner? What’s the best method and what do current statutes allow?

Implement: How can the project best be delivered — financed, designed, built, operated and maintained?

Operations: Is the private sector partner fulfilling its obligations, and is it necessary to negotiate changes to the contract? Is everything running smoothly?

OPERATEOPERATE

IMPLEMENTIMPLEMENT

PROCUREPROCURE

PLAN & TESTPLAN & TEST

FEASIBILITYFEASIBILITY

GENESISGENESIS

Page 21: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Genesis – What’s the Need?

Will a P3 Satisfy It?

Kick-off and Vision Overview

Data Collection and Analysis

On-site Tours/Condition Survey and Analysis

Vision Refinement

Objectives Setting

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 21

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 22: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Genesis – Preliminary Project Definition

Preliminary Test Plan

Preliminary Risk Analysis (RAP)

Development Options/Frame of Reference (FoR)

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 22

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 23: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Genesis – Preliminary Feasibility Check/Validation Fatal Flaws

Development Options Testing

Process Map and Strategy

Master Schedule

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 23

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 24: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Genesis – Phase 1 Process Map

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 24

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 25: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Feasibility – Can It Be Done?

Is a P3 Practical?

Call for Ideas

Request for Expression of Interest

“Case Study” Tours

Environmental and Geotechnical Analysis

Infrastructure Analysis

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 25

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 26: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Feasibility – Return on Investment

Master Development Budget

Preliminary Development Pro-Forma

Market Focused Interviews

Input Workshops

Economic Analysis

RAP Session

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 26

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 27: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Feasibility – Risk

P3 Delivery & Risk Management Workshop

Final Test Plan

Fatal Flaw Update

Sales and Communications Strategy

Risk-Allocation, Procurement Strategy & Delivery Methodology

Commercial Terms & Contract Principles

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 27

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 28: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Feasibility – Phase 2 Process Map

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 28

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 29: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Plan and Test

Market Based Feedback

Are Concepts Sufficient?

Constant Check for Fatal Flaws

Is the Project Real?

Feedback Based AdjustmentsPlace landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 29

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 30: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Plan and Test – Is There a Sound Business Case?

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 30

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 31: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Plan and Test - Phase 3 Process Map

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 31

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 32: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Procurement and Contracting

Delivery/Deal Structure

Pre-Qualify

Select & Negotiate

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 32

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 33: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Structural Framework

A Matter of Balance

Financing

“Ownership”/Occupancy

Project Delivery

Procurement Approach

Contracting Methodology

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 33

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Structure Drivers

Project Goals

Public Entities Characteristics

Marketplace Realities

Page 34: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

“Ownership”/Occupancy

Direct Ownership

Traditional Lease

Build-to-suit Lease

Lease/Purchase (fixed or variable)

Synthetic Lease

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 34

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 35: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Financing

Cash Purchase

Debt Financing (bonds/mortgage)

Leasing (many variations)

Lease/purchase

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 35

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 36: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Project Delivery – “Mainstream”

Traditional (design-bid-build)

Multi-prime

Construction Management at Risk

Design-Build Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 36

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 37: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Project Delivery – Variations on a Theme Finance-Design-Build (turnkey)

Finance-Design-Build-Leaseback (typical)

Finance-Design-Build-Operate

Finance-Design-Build-Operate & Maintain

Sale-Leaseback (user develops)

Build-Operate

Build-Operate-Transfer

Build-Own-Operate-Transfer

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 37

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 38: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Project Delivery – Many Acronyms DBB

DB

FDB or DBF

DBO

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 38

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

DBOM

BO

BOT

BOOT

Page 39: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Procurement Approach

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 39

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Price

A Key Factor?

The Only Factor?

How Much Can Be Done Before Price is Set?

Selection

Low-Bid

Weighed Criteria

Equivalent Design/Lower-Bid

Fixed Budget/Best Design

Meets Criteria/Low Bid

Best Value (adjusted low bid, weighted criteria including price)

Page 40: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Best Value – Weighted Criteria

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 40

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

ProposerQualitative

Score (60 max.)

PriceProposal

Price Score(40 max.)

Total Score(100 max.)

Firm “A”

Firm “B”

Firm “C”

51

53

44

1,629,000

1,546,000

1,510,000

37

39

40

88

92*

84

Page 41: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Best Value – Adjusted Low-Bid

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 41

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Proposer QualitativeScore

Price Proposal

Adjusted Price

Firm “A”

Firm “B”

Firm “C”

0.85

0.95

0.50

1,000,000

1,300,000

800,000

1,176,471

1,368,421

1,600,000

Page 42: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Procurement Approach

Sole Source

RFP

RFQ/RFP (pre-qualify, then select)

RFEOI/RFQ/RFP (determine interest, pre-qualify, select)

Contingent Designation and Simultaneous Negotiations

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 42

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 43: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Contract Methods

Lump Sum

Cost Plus

Cost Plus with GMP

Unit Price

Bonus/Merit Awards

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 43

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 44: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Procurement & Contracting – Phase 4 Process Map

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 44

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 45: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Implementation – Phase 5

Design Compliance

Construction Oversight

Commissioning and Administration

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 45

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 46: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

Operations - Phase 6

Startup

Monitoring

Assessment

Enhancement

Contract Modifications

Contract Renegotiations

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 46

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Page 47: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

P3 – Process Players

Sponsors/Users

Finance/Accounting

Legal

Owner/Developer

Program Manager

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 47

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Brokerage/Marketing

Design/Engineering

Construction

Relocation

Property/Facility Management

Page 48: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

P3 – Process Responsibilities

Place landfill photo

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 48

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

Initial Ideaor Need Seed FundingSituation

Prelim ProjectDefinition &Rationale

AlternativesIndex

PrelimEconomic/FinancialAnalysis

QualitativeAnalysis

Fatal FlawAnalysis

Process Map& Strategy

FeasibilityReport/

BusinessCase

ObjectivesSetting

PrelimBudget/

Schedule

CommercialTerms/

ContractPrinciples

DealStructuring

ConceptDesign/

PerformanceSpecs

ProcurementDocuments

Vendor Pre-Qualification

VendorProposal

Evaluation

RiskAssessment/

Allocation

DeliveryMethodology

ContractNegotiations

CommissioningAdministration

ConstructionOversight

Startup Monitoring Assessment EnhancementContract

Mods Contract

Renegotiations

Sponsor/User/Tenant

Finance/Accounting

Legal

Owner/Developer

Program Manager

Brokerage/Marketing

Designer/Engineer

Constructor

Relocation

Property Manager

Initial Ideaor Need Seed FundingSituation

Prelim ProjectDefinition &Rationale

R

R

R

R

Define

Basic Need

s Source&

Uses

Budget

Market

Analysis

Page 49: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

P3 Program Management Summary

United Nations SU/SSC Training Course 49

P R O J E C T M A N A G E M E N TP3

• Risk Assessment/ Allocation

• Delivery Methodology• Commercial Terms

/Contract Principles• Deal Structuring • Concept Design/ Performance Specs • Procurement Documents• Vendor Pre-Qualification • Vendor Proposal Evaluation • Contract Negotiations

• Startup• Monitoring• Assessment• Enhancement• Contract Mods• Contract Renegotiations

• Objectives Register• Alternatives Index• Prelim Schedule/ Budget• Prelim Economic/

Financial Analysis• Qualitative Analysis• Fatal Flaw Analysis • Process Map & Strategy • Feasibility Report/

Project Approval

• Asset/System Evaluation • Site Selection/ Analysis• Environmental/ Permitting Analysis• Final Project Definition • Master Schedule/

Budget • Political Climate Assessment • Procurement Strategy• Prelim Business Plan• Public/Vendor Outreach & Stakeholder Consultation• Business Plan

• Design Compliance• Construction Oversight• Commissioning Administration

• Prelim Project Definition • Seed Funding

OPERATEOPERATEIMPLEMENTIMPLEMENTPROCUREPROCUREPLAN & TESTPLAN & TESTFEASIBILITYFEASIBILITYGENESISGENESIS

Page 50: John F. Williams, SVP National Director - Governmental Consulting and Planning

John F. Williams, SVPNational Director - Governmental Consulting and PlanningHDR Engineering, Inc.New York City

PROJECT MANAGEMENTP3