john n. hughes cases/2011-00443... · john n. hughes attorney at law professional service...

21
JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net February 1,2013 Jeff Derouen Executive Director Public Service Commission 21 1 Sower Blvd. Frankfort, KY 40601 FEB 1 2013 PUBL.IC SERVICE COM M ISS 101Y Re: KY Frontier Gas Case No. 20 11-00443 Dear Mr. Derouen: Attached are two updated responses to prior staff data requests-depreciation schedules and stock company consolidations previously filed in responses to items 12 and 16 respectively of the first data request to Kentucky Frontier Gas. Please contact me if you have any questions about this matter. %torney for KFG Attachments

Upload: others

Post on 05-May-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law

Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street

Frankfort, Kentucky 40601

Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

February 1,20 13

Jeff Derouen Executive Director Public Service Commission 21 1 Sower Blvd. Frankfort, KY 40601

FEB 1 2013

PUBL.IC SERVICE COM M ISS 101Y

Re: KY Frontier Gas Case No. 20 1 1-00443

Dear Mr. Derouen:

Attached are two updated responses to prior staff data requests-depreciation schedules and stock company consolidations previously filed in responses to items 12 and 16 respectively of the first data request to Kentucky Frontier Gas.

Please contact me if you have any questions about this matter.

%torney for KFG

Attachments

Page 2: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY

BEFORE THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

In the Matter of:

APPLICATION OF KENTUCKY FRONTIER GAS, LLC FOR APPROVAL OF CONSOLIDATION OF AND ADJUSTMENT OF RATES, APPROVAL OF AMR EQUIPMENT AND A CERTIFICATE OF CONVENIENCE AND NECESSITY FOR INSTALLATION OF AMR, PIPELINE REPLACEMENT

AND REVISION OF TARIFFS PROGRAM, REVISION OF NON-RECURRING FEES

) ) )

) ) 1

) CASENO. ) 2011-00443

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO COMMISSION STAFF’S FIRST REQUEST FOR INFORMATION

Kentucky Frontier Gas, LLC. (“Frontier”), by counsel, files with the Commission

the original and seven copies of the following supplemental information

rankfort, KY 40601 Attorney for Frontier Gas Company, LLC

Page 3: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

Supplemental response Item 12

Witness: Shute

See attached revised depreciation schedules.

Page 4: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

3 Ei z E" 3

v)

c v) ln

1.

n 2

c q [51

v)

ln

5.

0

c v) ln

q $ 5.

0

cc

z3

%

%

lnv)

v)v)

c ln 3

E.

17

ln

c z E. 2 ln cz

v)ln

33

E

. E

. 1717

ml

n s 2 2. 17

ln

rt

0

17

n

2 2. 0

rt

-7 K

0

17

n

2 2 2 0

rt

0

17

zz

3

E.

E.

E"

v) =

22

.. -. H 0

=I

P

N

\

W P

\

N

0 !

0

in

N

W

cn z 0 W

0

ln \

r

P!P!PPP

ON

NN

N!N

\\\\\\\

WW

WP

WN

W

PO

Pc

nP

W!

\\\I\\\

NN

NN

NN

N

00

00

00

0

!PP!P!P

N!

OP

OP

O

!

N

\

W !

\

N

0 P

N

P

N

\

W P

\

N

0 !

0

!

N

\

W !

\

N

0 P

N

PP

NN

\\

WW

c

nr

\\

NN

0

0

PP

PO W

\

W

0

\

N

0

0

w

N

\

N

CO \

N

0 !

0

Pd

\\

PW

o

w

\\

NN

0

0

PO

ow

P!P d

NN

N

\\\\

PPP!

1\11

NN

NN

0

00

0

wo

o0

N

CO

CO

W

inin

CO

P

03.b

00

.w .&

gg

in P

w

N g 0

win

N

N

Pc

nP

N

ww

00

0

00

0

in .! P

NP

PO

in

W

0

W

0 8 0

in

in+

cn

mw

O

NW

00

0

00

0

in .* .?J

PP

PO

in

in

in

vbin

d+

WW

W!

P

ln

!d

W.

PC

OO

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

0

.!w .! .! il, in .! .w

C"C

"PP

OC

"NP

O

inin

in

.d

Cn in in P

w 0

03

d'c

n

PO

c"C

"PP

O

03

W!

OO

00

00

0

00

00

0

in

N

d

0

0

P

ww

wP

!w

ww

ww

ww

0

00

00

00

00

00

0

NN

NN

0

00

0

WW

WP

PW

W

00

00

00

0

WW

PW

W

00

00

0

ln

ln

ln

ln

ln

\

\\

\A

rrrrr

inininin

!N

N*

d0

Od

W

Pc

nc

n

00

00

0

00

0

.! .a .*

.d

PY

N"

in

in

in

inin

inin

in

vb

in

vb

.!

in

w

in

Pi

nv

bW

in

in

W

NP

in

vb

in

PP

Pi

nd

CO

cn

Oi

nW

cn

4

N

cn

.P

WW

W0

P

cn

CO

NV

,

Ww

vb

wP

Nr

Pr

NP

r

yl5

C"

Pc

""

P

yp0pJN

pp

oC

Ow

wN

wd

~o

o+

CO

0

OO

OO

OO

Q

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

00

00

g

00

00

00

0

00

00

0 000000000000

P

\

N

w \ P

W

Page 5: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

I

!3 Lu

X i a e. 3 e z. - -. e. 21

D

VI

VI 2 0

21 2. 3. 3

h g

I--’

WW

!W

WN

NW

W

WW

WW

W

ul!!o

q!!!~

ul!!!!

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

0

!

\

N

W \ !

W

Page 6: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

YU

L’

NW

P

\\

N\

W

W\

!

!!!W \\\\

NN

NN

0

00

0

!!O

W

00

03

0

in

Ni

n

incn

!

CD

cnoo

00

00

in N

0.0

!

’N

’0 0

gg

gg

WW

NN

0

00

0

mm

mv

l

\\\\

rT

TT

in !

N

cn

0

0 g

PP

P

\\\

!!!

cncncn

\\\

NN

N

00

0

!!!

00

0

in

wc-’

!

’N

Cn .!!

P“

t’

ocn

qa

wo

w

00

0

00

0

NN

0

0

mv

l

\\

rT

3 0

0.

UI N

W

0

!

PW

N

\\\

!!W PO

0

\\\

NN

N

00

0

FF

O

00

03

cn

ww

P

OW

000

00

0

win

w

NW

!O

W

PP

IJ

oo

cn

.!! .!

.!W

gg

:

0

m

‘z!w

E.

s z. 0

J

!

\

N

a \ !

W

Page 7: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

CL

WW

0

00

mm

m

\\\

rr

r

in.

CL

N

ul

0 8 Q

D

3 e %. F 7”

s.

E? 4”

i5’

e.

N

0 3

3

Page 8: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

rn

rn

rn

rn

rn

rn

i

iX

XX

7i

ii

cccccc

m

m

2 3

E.

-h E v

) 3

v)

m

m

2 E 3

E. 2 -h

v)

mm

m

mm

m

=?

=?

=?

ooo

000

22

2

.(<e

GG

G

m

m

2

II E”

2. e~

0

3

-h R

z i; R a 5

2. e.

0

3

rn

;;2;

C

II E”

E. e.

0

3 R

m

m

=?

< E v

) m C 9.

n

KK

K

nn

o

e, e“ e.

000

33

3

Il

l

3z

3

E.

E.

E”

33

3

v)

v)

v)

i

u

PP

PP

PP

N

NN

NP

N

\\\\\\

WW

PW

NW

O

Pc

nP

WP

\\\\\\

NN

NN

NN

0

00

00

0

PP

WP

PP

POPOPO

P

I--’

\

P

\

N

0

P

P

P

N

\

W

P

\

N

0

P

0

N

\

N

m \

N

0

P

P

P

N

\

W

P \

N

0

P

0

P

N

\

P

cn \

N

0

P

P

P

N

\

W

P \

N

0

P

0

WN

\\

WN

O

W

\\

NN

00

OP

a0 P

\

P

0 \

N

0

P

0

4

\

W

P \

N

0

0

W

PP

P

NN

N

\\\

PP

P

\\\

NN

N

WW

W

00

0

00

0

PP

PP

P

NP

N

\\\\

PW

NW

W

PW

P

\\\\

NN

NN

0

00

0

PPPP

POP0

in

rw

W

wW

W

dW

cn

cn

00

00

0

00

0

in

.!! .!

PY

Y?

WO

PP

Pi

U

\\\\\\

PN

PW

PW

P

Wc

nc

nc

nP

\

A\

\\

\

NN

NN

NN

0

00

00

0

PP

PP

PP

PPOOOO

10, b.

win

in

PP

W

WW

W

PP

d

00

0

P

wo

w

.! .c”

gg

g

z. IC r

0

J

3

m

Q

m

in

in

in

in

in

in

NP

W

in

w

P4

NN

WU

IO

ON

W

00

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.P

w P

w

.* .!m

P in

.!!

.m P

N

b P P

w

w

cn cn V

I

PO

YU

1N

PO

”PP

PP

O

n

3

0

000000

00

00

00

ww

PP

ww

ww

ww

0

00

00

00

00

0

mm

mm

mm

mm

mv

,

\\\\\\\\\\

rrrrl-rrrrr

NN

N

00

0

WP

WW

0

00

0

mm

mm

\\\\

rrrr

WW

PP

WW

0

00

00

0

mm

mm

mm

\\\\\\

rrrrrr

PW

NN

WW

0

00

00

0

mm

m

\\\

rrr

in

in

in

N

NP

00

4

rm

cn

00

0

9 .*

.d

“N

00

0

inw

inw

in

in

in

in

win

P

win

i

nP

.+

ww

w

in

Pin

in

in

in

in

in

P

P

Pi

nW

cn

bi

nW

cn

P

cn

PN

4W

W

in

N4

m

pw

ww

o

Wi

nW

PP

PP

NP

P

pp

‘lC

”U

10

IJ

”p

0”

Y

pp

c”

”p

W

WW

N~

cn

00

4W

0

00

00

0

00

00

0

00

00

0 0000000000

00

00

00

0

00

0

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

Page 9: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

R P 73

ID 0 0

0-

v)

L-. 2 3 r+

m 1 a 5

n

5 r! z. e.

N

0

S

-h r!

U

z1 a. 3. 3

2"

(Ip

03 \

N

W \

N

0 !

!

P

P

w

cn

l

\\\!

Oo

!*

P

\\\\

NN

NN

0

00

0

!!!!

!O

O!

N!

\!

N\

c

nm

\\

NN

0

0

00

CDCD

!

!

\ !

03 \

N

0 !

!

in

03

m z 0 W

0

m \

r

in

N g 0

!

PW

N

\\\

!!W PO

0

\\\

NN

N

00

0

!P

O

00

03

PP

P

\\\

e!!

mm

ul

\\\

NN

N

00

0

!!!

00

0

v,

in-

!

'N

.!m .!

PY

?

00

*a

in

O!

00

0

00

0

uk

uk

uk

!

inw

in!

a*

cn

~c

oo

o

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

0

in 0

in .! .w

.!m .!!

W-i

N *

07 *

w

m

9P

pW

c"

t'P

P

inin

r.

b

cn

lDC

D

00

0

00

0

.* in 0

P N

'w

P"P

p

NN

0

0

mm

\\

rr

I--'!!

m

oo

m

mm

\\\

rrr

*

co

UI

00

W b 0 *

I-. m W

I-.

0

inv,

!P

cn

ww

00

0

*!

in -0

gg

g

0

0

ZI 0

in

ininin

in

P!

WM

)O

UI

0

3c

nm

WN

cn

0

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

0

.! in

in .A

.! .!

PY

Wc

"c

"P

P

Page 10: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

in

c-’

N

cn

0 8 0 in

0-l

ul

0

E e rt 2 e rt m e z: 5.

n

E 5

E a 2

e l-t R -0 5.

z.

e.

0

3

-

2 e V

I rt a,

rt

(D

n

3

a,

-3 ;? P

c-

’c-

‘NN

c-

’-’P

*

\\

\\

N\

\

c-

’N

WW

\c

-’

c

nc

o0

-lc

-’c

-’c

-’c

n

\\\\\\\

NN

NN

NN

N

00

00

00

0

c-

’c

-’

c-

‘c

-’

c-

’o

c-

c-’c

-’c

-’o

oc

oo

in

4

0 z in

cn a 8 0

w

W

.P

0

in

c-’

W $ 0

.o

N

N

cn

0

in

N

cn

0

0

0

0 8

w

c-’

0

0

0 8 0

WW

WP

WN

N

OO

OQ

OO

O

w

c-‘

N

cn

0 8 0

in

inin

inw

Cn

.

oW

c-

’N

4

0

00

00

0

0

PP

YP

?

00

00

0

8

in

c-’ a

co

W

co

0 $

c

2

Page 11: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

3

2 5

3

2 z

m

3x3

22

2

55

5

33

2

2

55

zl zt m

0

3x

22

5

5

3

P 5

x 2 5

x3

22

5

5

I -0

II

_1E!

73

rn

mr

n

I--' \ !

m

\

N

0

0 P

in P

N

P

0 2 W

0

(n \

r

u,

P

0

P

\

N

m \ P

W

W

W

in

P

P

0 g W

0

Y

U

co \

W P

\ P

W

W

m

in

P P

N

4 8 0 W

0

cool

\\

ww

P

O

\\

!P WW

W

W

PP

inin

ON

p

.P

00

0

0

.e .!!

P"c

"

ww

0

0

P

co

N

\\

PP

\\

PP

LO

W

coco

4

4

in

WP

mm

w

co

00

00

.!! .!!

c"?

NW

m

o

CI

ID 51: n

z 0 r

m"

Oc

ob

\\\

ww

w

PPO

\\\

PP!

WW

W

WW

W

cococo

m

\ !

\ !

W

03

03

in

m

0

P

0 z W

0

P

\

N

\ P

W

ca

P

in

m

0

m

0 8 0 W

0

Pd

\\

PP

\\

PP

WW

co

co

NN

-w

W

ub! .!;

.!!

ow

0

0

00

Pr

ww

00

PP

\\

PP

\\

!P

WW

W

W

dd

inin

co

m

PW

00

0

0

.! .!a

Pr

ww

0

0

WW

W

mm

m

inu,(n

O4

N

OW

Cn

00

0

.!! .!!

.!a g

gg

ww

w

00

0

NW

U

mo

o

inin

i

nP

P

WW

O

00

0

00

0

ww

u,

in

Pin

w

p.

00

gg

in

N

0 g 0

u,. in

PW

O

W

00

0

0

79

in

0-k

NN

W

in

N

00

0

00

0

WP

P

in

in

w

WN

00

gg

in P

0

P

\

N

W \ P

W

Page 12: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

in

in

I

ll

1

Il

l

73'7

3111

rn

rn

rn

-

0-

0-

0

E: 2

v1

l-t nJ

-a

W

$! a. 2. s

3

2" 3

v)

U

rn

ln

7;:

!

Nc

n

\\

N

WN

\

oc

oc

o

\\\

NN

N

00

0

00

0

cn

mc

n

!P

W

N!N

P

\\1\

WN

!!

!!u

lP

1\11

NN

NN

0

00

0

oaoo

ulululul

W

W

ID

r* n

0 z I=: 3

z 2 5 0 P

co

\ P

0 \

N

0 a

d

in

ul

ul z 0 d

ln \

r-

in

d g a

i4

\

N

u3 \

N

0

0

W

!

!

\

W \

N

0

0

W

cn \

W

0 \

N

0

0

W

id

\

N

N

\

N

0

0

W

id \

N

N

\

N

0

0

W

id

\ P

ul \

N

0

0

W

!

NP

\\

!O

\\

NN

0

0

00

w

w

cn

wc

oc

o

\r

\\

W\!!

o

ul

cn

cn

\\\\

NN

NN

0

00

0

00

00

N

NN

N

ul

d\!

\!\

WP

Ul

\\\

NN

N

00

0

a00

!!!

cn

inc

nin

inc

inc

nc

n

03

PO

Oq

NW

PP

d

co

!!

PO

cn

dd

00

00

00

00

0

.! .?-l .! .! .w .! .! .! .!

gg

gg

gg

gg

g

!W!

00

0

ml

nl

n

\\\

I-I-I-

!!W

W

00

00

N

WW

WN

N!

PW

u

lo

oo

ulu

lo

oo

w

ww

w

00

00

w

ww

0

00

ln

ln

ln

ml

nl

nm

ln

ln

\\\\\\\\\

I-I-r-I-I-I-r-I-I-

lnlnlnln

\\\\

I-I-T

I-

ml

nl

n

\\\

I-I-I-

mm

ln

ln

\\\\

I-I-I-I-

Dn

3f

r!

Z

e.

N z. $

on

, a

-

in

r

w'w

inin

d

u3

WN

g

gg

g

oooa

in

cn

Pin

urin

P

NP

W

00

00

0

00

0

"P

PP

cn

in

win

i

nN

cn

in

!i

nC

Ni

n

d!

WW

ul

PW

&P

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

?P

++

PP

PY

"

in

in!

!O

Nq

cn

wi

n*

W

dN

00

0

a00

"p

0p

0

000

00

0

Page 13: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

v,

rn

A 5

F;1

v,

U

T1

U

P

T1

0

z

A

2 2

0

ZE! ;;I

m

0

21 8. $. S

WP

WW

N

WN

N

\\\\

WP

PP

Pddd

\\\\

NN

NN

0

00

0

PW

PW

0

00

0

W

W \

W

W \

N

0

0

W

P

\P

NP

\\

NN

0

0

00

W

W

gY

P

WP

N

NP

\

\\

lo

rn

\\\\\

NN

NN

N

00

00

0

00

00

0

03

co

co

03

03

WN

P\

\

OW

03

03

W

0

10 frt n

13 0 T 3

z

N

w\

\P

ma

\\

NN

0

0

00

W

W

d

\

N

W \

N

0

0

W

d

\

w

0 \

N

0

0

W

cn

m

\\

NN

c

nW

\\

NN

0

0

00

C

OW

WW

\\

NN

P

W

\\

NN

0

0

00

C

OW

W

\W

P\

PN

\\

NN

0

0

00

W

W 0

30

1

\\

PN

m

w

\\

NN

0

0

00

W

W

W \

W

0

\

N

0

0

W

P

\ P

0 \

N

0

W

w

in

N

0

0

CJ

W

0

v, \

r *

0 0

Y

m

\

W \

N

0

0

d

*

ul

0

0 8 m

(n

il,

WP

0

30

00

gg

inininin

PN

WN

W

NO

W

00

00

0

00

0

UlW

PP

il,

N

W g 0

if? cn

P

0

il,

N

P

0 s

in

W

0

in

P

0 g in

W g 0

WW

WW

Q

OO

O

WW

WW

WW

WW

mW

WN

W

00

00

00

00

o

Qm

o4

?g

Wr

nr

nv

,

v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,

v,v,v,v,v,

v,

1\11 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ \\\\\ \

g r

rr

r

rr

rr

rr

rr

rr

rr

rr

rr

rl-rrr

r

0 P

win

in

W.!

!i

n

P *

'd

N P

PP

PO

PP

P

mo

cn

m

OPOOO

oc

no

oo

in

P

in

e

il,

*in

'W

il,

in

cn

win

o.

w

in

wi

ni

l,

Ni

nP

@J

mw

NN

W0

3N

m

co

wP

wP

03

mw

4c

no

Ww

oP

W

0000000000000000

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

in

w

0

0 8

0000

00

00

P

\

N

W \ P

W

Page 14: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

mm

E.

E. V

IV

I

##

W

P

NW

mu

l O

P

NO

.a .!

gg

-1

-1

-1

222

EE

E

NN

N

000

!!!

Ne

0

ggg

000

w

CO

N

\\

ww

w

w

\\

NN

0

0

ww

N

N

ww

0

0

mv

,

\\

rr

-

W \

N

w \

N

0

w

w

w \

W

w \

N

0

w

N

\

N

u3 \

N

0

w

w

w

w \

N

\

N

0

w

w

P

\

w

CO \

N

0

P

\

P

\

N

0

w-

w

G

ww

ww

ww

ww

0

0

0 0

0

0

0

0

v)

v,

v,

v)

v,

v,

v,

v,

\\

\\

\\

\A

r

-I

-I

-r

rr

rr

-

DD

3::

T;:r

e. 2

z. 5 om

J

P

Page 15: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

3

T: e B s 2

z T: e VI

D c 3

T: ul

0

I 0

0

22

W

ff

l

v,

3

09

a,

r

ID <

z11.

E: 2

v)

EE

XX

!e

. !e

.

00

PO

N

ID

mv

)

0

21 2. 8

0 3

I-'

!N

\\

!N

.Po

\\

Nh

,

00

!!

!!

!!

N!

\\

WP

!

03

\\

NN

0

0

!P

0

0

!!

NN

\\

ww

!!

\\

NN

0

0

!!

NN

du

lW

NP

\I\\\

NW

NN

!.

\\\\

NN

NN

0

00

0

00

00

cocococo

03 0

cn 0

w

w

G

G

G

b

o

\\

NN

0

0

00

co

co

i

N

0

0

co iiii

NN

NN

0

00

0

00

00

c

oc

oc

od

in

.Pin

P

!

Nd

!

ON

03

00

0

00

0

.a .!m

in

Cn

PP

W

N

ul

ul

0

0 g

in*

cn

m

N!

00

0

0

P .!

F

cn

in-

du

3

N!

00

0

0

.! .w

Fc

"

W

P

d

N z 0 .c

I). !

N

N g 0

inin

m-m

u

lcn

cn

w

NW

!O

00

00

0

00

0

.! .! .! .!

FF

"P

Win

m

ul

!O

gg

0

0

ww

w

w

!!!!!!!WP!!!WW $

00

0

0

oo

oo

oo

oo

ulo

oo

oo

W

!W

m

inm

u>

WW

u,i

n.w

.!

Ni

ni

ni

l,

! ! !

N P

P

w

u3 0 W

'ul d ! .P

WN

wP

No

rP

co

co

ya

~p

00000000000000

dN

ul

cn

cn

a!

dP

!m

aO

N

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

in

!m

ulc

o

00

gg

in in !!

2: 00

!

\

h,

u3 \ !

W

Page 16: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

EE

!!!. !!!.

v)

v)

uu

!O

NlD

22

***

ww

w

NN

N

bo

o

000

*

W

N 0

00

0 z

!W

\\

!!

\\

N!

OIL

)

003

wu

3

in

in

w

!W

00

3

00

.! .o

gg

D

v)

v) 2

9 v) n

n

II:

0

P 3 (u

!

\

N

W \ !

W

Page 17: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

rn z E‘:

X

rt

0

77

rn

A 2 si z

t)

73

rn z

c

rn

!?

2 n WW

W

W

W

0 !

d

0

W

0 !

P

W

oo

0

v,

N

d

N

m

VI w

ul

c1

W

N

U 0

W

W

!

mo

o

w

WP

WW

!

O!!!!

mm!!!

P P

.!VI .! .!!

75)

09 !

I

s s cu

Page 18: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

W

m

N

Page 19: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

U

v1

n

CI

m T

L

W 2 P

W

rn

J

E

x

rf I

P < ID

S

S

ID

;o

ID

Q 5. 3 ID

S

r+

0. +

m 01

m

W

m U

I *

*

!

I--’ ‘w !

.” .d

.o P

N

03

,w

o

u3

mw

m

u303

0

3 0

U

lA

0

z m

ffl

VI

n

TT

%

E 5‘ Q 0

h

P

3’

Q i! 2 5

7J

m

<

m

3

S

m

A

m a rr. $ m 2

VI

Page 20: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

16. Refer to Exhibit 6, Proposed Tariffs.

a. Given that Frontier has separate farm tap tariffs on file with the

Commission, explain why farm tap rates and tariff provisions are included as

part of its proposed gas utility tariff.

2) According to its Application, Frontier intends to have one set

of tariffs for all of its utility operations. Based on the nature of its

various acquisitions from 2008 to the present time, Frontier is

currently operating four different utilities: (1 ) Frontier, which

consists of all of the systems for which it acquired the utility’s

assets; and (2) Auxier Road; (3) Cow Creek and (4) Dema, the

three systems for which Frontier acquired the corporation’s

stock. Explain how Frontier envisions conducting business in

the future for the latter three utilities.

Witness: Shute

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE:

Frontier originally expected to consolidate all three of the stock companies (Cow

Creek, Dema and Auxier Road) into Kentucky Frontier Gas, LLC. However, after a

review of the tax consequences of such a consolidation, Frontier determined that the

assets of Cow Creek and Dema should be transferred to Frontier and those two

companies dissolved, effective December 31, 201 2. Because of the unfavorable tax

liability that the Frontier members would have faced, Auxier was not included in the

consolidation. As a result of this action, Frontier will hold the assets of all of the

previously acquired companies, except Auxier. Those companies will operate as

Page 21: JOHN N. HUGHES cases/2011-00443... · JOHN N. HUGHES Attorney at Law Professional Service Corporation 124 West Todd Street Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Telephone: (502) 227-7270 jnhughes@,fe)lfewpb.net

Kentucky Frontier Gas, LLC with one rate and one tariff as proposed in the application

in this case.

Auxier Road Gas Company stock will remain wholly owned by Frontier and will

operate as Auxier Road Gas Company, d/b/a Kentucky Frontier Gas. The same rate

and tariffs for Frontier will apply to Auxier customers. Separate financial reports will be

maintained for Auxier.

Because this is a corporate reorganization among commonly owned entities

controlled by the same partners, Frontier believes no prior Commission approval was

required for this action pursuant to KRS 278.020 (7)(b).