john swallow deposition transcript

328
!" $%& $%!'( )*(!+!,- (!.$'!+$ +/*'$ .,-$ -,0& +/*"$12 .$,$& /3 *$,%  4 !" '&5 $%& .6&+!,- !"7&.$!8,$!/" /3 ,$$/'"&1 8&"&',- )/%" &9 .:,--/:2  ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; 7<=>?@AB>= (>B?C<@<?D ?E5 !"#$ &' ()*++") 7?FGH> I +AC> "?9 IJKLKMNLJ %?D?OAPF> 7>OD<Q> $O>AC>  4 /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ R N5KN B9H9 -?QA@<?D5 .D>FF S :<FH>O IM :>C@ .?G@T $>HBF> UU .G<@> INKK 8A@>VAW $?V>O :>C@ .AF@ -AX> +<@W2 *@AT '>B?O@>O5 (>D<C> Y9 $T?HAC2 +''Z'6' "?@AOW 6GPF<Q <D AD= E?O @T> .@A@> ?E *@AT 7<=>?[OABT>O5 'WAD '>\>OHAD2 +-7.

Upload: the-salt-lake-tribune

Post on 08-Aug-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 1/327

!" $%& $%!'( )*(!+!,- (!.$'!+$ +/*'$

.,-$ -,0& +/*"$12 .$,$& /3 *$,% 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444

!" '&5 $%& .6&+!,-!"7&.$!8,$!/" /3,$$/'"&1 8&"&',- )/%"&9 .:,--/:2

 

;;;;;;;;;;

7<=>?@AB>=(>B?C<@<?D ?E5

!"#$ &' ()*++")

7?FGH> I

+AC> "?9 IJKLKMNLJ

%?D?OAPF> 7>OD<Q> $O>AC> 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444

/Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ R N5KN B9H9

-?QA@<?D5 .D>FF S :<FH>OIM :>C@ .?G@T $>HBF> UU .G<@> INKK

8A@>VAW $?V>O :>[email protected]@ -AX> +<@W2 *@AT

'>B?O@>O5 (>D<C> Y9 $T?HAC2 +''Z'6'

"?@AOW 6GPF<Q <D AD= E?O @T> .@A@> ?E *@AT

7<=>?[OABT>O5 'WAD '>\>OHAD2 +-7.

Page 2: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 2/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KIUMJNUJ]]I

N

* , , & * - * $ . & (

(,&./*+ ."0$(&+ 1" 1#& +/&01&$*$1 2"3&-$"- "4 1#&(1*1& "4 01*#5

67889:; +' +7<<=(8:;7>8 "' ,:7?!:>:@? (8:;7>8."&-- S :!-Y&',@@?OD>WC A@ -AV.AF@ -AX> +<@W2 *@AT `]IKIUIKK]$>F>BT?D>5 `KI9NM_9ILKK3Aa5 `KI9NM_9I`KK&UHA<F5 HFAFF<bCVFAV9Q?H

CB>AWbCVFAV9Q?HcC@>VAO@bCVFAV9Q?H

4"- 1#& *11"-$&A 2&$&-*+ !"#$ &' ()*++")5 

-BCD:? 2' (DB;!:DD=E:> *' !7@:F+-1(& ."/: S .&..!/".,@@?OD>WC A@ -AVNKI .?G@T YA<D .@O>>@ UU .G<@> IJKK.AF@ -AX> +<@W2 *@AT `]III$>F>BT?D>5 `KI9JNN9NMI^3Aa5 `KI9MNI9^N`K&UHA<F5 O[CbQFW=>CD?V9Q?H

  cAcbQFW=>CD?V9Q?H

R R R

Page 3: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 3/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KIUMJNUJ]]I

J

/ $ G & H

!"#$ &' ()*++") ,*2&

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V _

&aAH<DA@<?D dW YO9 -AFF< `

& H # / I / 1 (

$06I&-   G&(.-/,1/"$ ,*2&

I `UNKUIJ .GPB?>DA (GQ>C $>QGHCC>O\>= ?D )?TD .VAFF?Ve !U,VAO>6O?=GQ@C2 --+e )?TD .VAFF?V AC'>[<C@>O>= ,[>D@ E?O .VAFF?V S,CC?Q<A@>Ce 6U.?FG@<?DC2 --+e

.GfADD> .VAFF?Ve ..7 YADA[>H>D@2--+e AD= -AGO>D Y9 '>>=2 $OGC@>>

NK

N $V? 6U.?FG@<?DC !D\?<Q>C V<@TA@@AQT>= @V? ]U`UII >UHA<FC @?'<QTAO= 'AVF> EO?H )?TD .VAFF?V2dA@>C "?C9 ).KKKK^MU^`2g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

^_

J ,BO<F IL AD= NK2 NKII2 >UHA<F>aQTAD[> P>@V>>D )?TD .VAFF?V AD='<QTAO= 'AVF>2 dA@>C "?9 .+YKK^K`

`M

] &UHA<F C>O<>C P>[<DD<D[ V<@T A^UIIUIN >UHA<F @? )?TD .VAFF?V AD=)AC?D 6?V>OC EO?H '<QTAO= 'AVF>2dA@>C "?9 .+YKIMM_

`^

M &UHA<F C>O<>C P>[<DD<D[ V<@T ADIKUN]UII >UHA<F @? '<QTAO= 'AVF>EO?H )?TD .VAFF?V2 dA@>C "?C9.+YKI^LMUI_KK

``

^ IIUIIUII >UHA<F @? '<QTAO= 'AVF>

EO?H )?TD .VAFF?V2 dA@>C "?9.+YKI^L]

LI

Page 4: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 4/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

J

& H # / I / 1 ( K.BD8=DL:CM

$06I&-   G&(.-/,1/"$ ,*2&

_ &UHA<F C>O<>C P>[<DD<D[ V<@T AINUIUII >UHA<F @? '<QTAO= 'AVF>EO?H )?TD .VAFF?V2 dA@>C "?C9.+YKK^^^U^^_

LN

` ^UIMUIN >UHA<F @? )?TD .VAFF?VEO?H '<QTAO= 'AVF>2 dA@>C "?9.+YKIMN]

L]

L JU`UIJ >UHA<F @? $WF>O 1?GD[ EO?H)?TD .VAFF?V2 dA@>C "?9 .+YKIL^I

LM

IK LUIMUKL $T> .GB>O .>\>D $OGC@=?QGH>D@C2 dA@>C "?C9 ).KKKJIIUJJL

IIJ

II )?TD AD= .GfADD> .VAFF?V &C@A@>6FADD<D[ (<A[OAH2 dA@>C "?9).KKKJ]L2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

II^

IN LUI^UKL Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA 3>=>OAF+O>=<@ *D<?D dGC<D>CC ,QQ?GD@,BBF<QA@<?D S .<[DA@GO> +AO= AD=A@@AQT>= *@AT (>BAO@H>D@ ?E+?HH>OQ> dGC<D>CC &D@<@W .>AOQT

IIL

IJ JUIMUIN .@A@> ?E *@AT (>BAO@H>D@?E +?HH>OQ>2 (<\<C<?D ?E

+?OB?OA@<?DC S +?HH>OQ<AF +?=>.GHHAOW ?E /DF<D> +TAD[>C

INI

I] Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA +O>=<@ *D<?D.@A@>H>D@C ?E ,QQ?GD@ E?O ..7YADA[>H>D@2 --+2 E?O NKII2 dA@>C"?C9 ).KKKI^]UI_M2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

INM

IM Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA +O>=<@ *D<?D.@A@>H>D@C ?E ,QQ?GD@ E?O ..7YADA[>H>D@2 --+2 E?O NKIN2 dA@>C"?C9 ).KKIKLJUI_^2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

IN^

I^ ..7 YADA[>H>D@ QT>QX O>[<C@>O>D@O<>C2 dA@>C "?9 ).KKKI_^2g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

IN_

Page 5: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 5/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

N

& H # / I / 1 ( K.BD8=DL:CM

$06I&-   G&(.-/,1/"$ ,*2&

I_ Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA +O>=<@ *D<?D/Q@?P>O NKIN .@A@>H>D@ ?E ,QQ?GD@E?O )?TD &9 .VAFF?V AD= .GfADD> Y9.VAFF?V2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

IJK

I` LUIMUKL 6GOQTAC> ,[O>>H>D@ P>@V>>D)?TD &9 .VAFF?V AD= !U,VAO>6O?=GQ@C &D@>OBO<C>C2 --+2 dA@>C"?C9 ).KKKIKNUIK`

IJ]

IL JUIMUIN .@A@> ?E *@AT (>BAO@H>D@?E +?HH>OQ>2 (<\<C<?D ?E+?OB?OA@<?DC S +?HH>OQ<AF +?=>2.GHHAOW ?E /DF<D> +TAD[>C

IJM

NK .>B@>HP>O NKIK .@A@>H>D@ ?E,QQ?GD@ E?O !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C&D@>OBO<C>C2 --+

IJ`

NI .>B@>HP>O NKIK QT>QX O>[<C@>O>D@OW2 dA@>C "?9 ).KKKIJJ2g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

IJ`

NN .>B@>HP>O NKIK .@A@>H>D@ ?E,QQ?GD@ E?O )?TD &9 .VAFF?V AD=.GfADD> Y9 .VAFF?V

I]K

NJ .@A@> ?E *@AT (>BAO@H>D@ ?E+?HH>OQ>2 (<\<C<?D ?E +?OB?OA@<?DCS +?HH>OQ<AF +?=>2 .GHHAOW ?E/DF<D> +TAD[>C E?O 6U.?FG@<?DC2--+

I]J

N] Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA +O>=<@ *D<?D NKII.@A@>H>D@C ?E ,QQ?GD@ E?O6U.?FG@<?DC2 --+2 dA@>C "?C9).KKKKJIU]N2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

I]`

NM 6U.?FG@<?DC2 --+ QADQ>F>= QT>QXC

AD= QT>QX O>[<C@>O >D@O<>C2 dA@>C"?C9 ).KKKKMMU^]2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

I]`

Page 6: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 6/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

O

& H # / I / 1 ( K.BD8=DL:CM

$06I&-   G&(.-/,1/"$ ,*2&

  N^ Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA +O>=<@ *D<?D NKIN.@A@>H>D@C ?E ,QQ?GD@ E?O6U.?FG@<?DC2 --+2 dA@>C "?C9).KKKK]JUM]2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

IM^

N_ +?BW ?E ]U`UII 'Y' +?DCGF@<D[2--+2 QADQ>F>= QT>QX IKM E?OhIM2KKK

I^K

N` NKII .QT>=GF> +2 6O?E<@ ?O -?CC3O?H dGC<D>CC2 E?O )?TD &9.VAFF?V2 dA@>C "?C9 ).KKK`JM AD=).KKK`^^2 g+?DE<=>D@<AFg

I^I

R R R

Page 7: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 7/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

P

, - " . & & G / $ 2 (

$%& 7!(&/8',6%&'5 :> AO> D?V ?D @T>

O>Q?O=9 $T> @<H> <C ABBO?a<HA@>FW N5KN B9H9

$T<C <C @T> \<=>?@AB>= =>B?C<@<?D ?E

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V !D '>5 $T> .B>Q<AF !D\>C@<[A@<?D ?E

,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF )?TD &9 .VAFF?V2 P><D[ T>F= A@ @T>

?EE<Q>C ?E .D>FF S :<FH>O <D .AF@ -AX> +<@W2 *@AT2 ?D

/Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ9

YW DAH> <C 'WAD '>\>OHAD2 +>O@<E<>= ->[AF

7<=>?[OABT>O2 V<@T @T> E<OH ?E +<@<+?GO@9 $T> Q?GO@

O>B?O@>O <C (>D<C> $T?HAC2 AFC? V<@T @T> E<OH ?E

+<@<+?GO@9

+?GDC>F V<FF D?V C@A@> @T><O ABB>AOADQ>C

E?O @T> O>Q?O= AD= @T> V<@D>CC V<FF P> CV?OD9

Y'9 -,--!5 YA@@ -AFF< O>BO>C>D@<D[ @T>

-<>G@>DAD@ 8?\>OD?O9 !iH T>O> V<@T .@>VAO@ 6>AW AD=

)>O>HW .@>VAO@9

Y'9 ."/:5 '?= .D?V E?O @T> ,@@?OD>W

8>D>OAF2 )?TD .VAFF?V9 :<@T H> <C )>DD<E>O )AH>C9

!"#$ &' ()*++")Q

TA\<D[ P>>D E<OC@ =GFW CV?OD @? @>FF @T>

@OG@T2 VAC >aAH<D>= AD= @>C@<E<>= AC E?FF?VC5

Page 8: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 8/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

R

&H*6/$*1/"$

IA 6-' +*++/5

j9 8??= AE@>OD??D2 YO9 .VAFF?V9 ,[A<D2 !iH

YA@@ -AFF<2 AD= @?[>@T>O V<@T HW Q?FF>A[G>C V>

O>BO>C>D@ @T> -<>G@>DAD@ 8?\>OD?O <D @T<C

<D\>C@<[A@<?D2 AD= V> TA\> C?H> kG>C@<?DC E?O W?G

@?=AW9

:?GF= W?G BF>AC> [<\> GC W?GO EGFF DAH> @?

P>[<D V<@Tl

,9 )?TD &=VAO= .VAFF?V9

j9 ,D= ! XD?V W?GiO> AD A@@?OD>W2 AD= !iH

CGO> W?GiO> EAH<F<AO V<@T @T> BO?Q>CC ?E CV?OD

@>C@<H?DWe <C @TA@ Q?OO>Q@l

,9 $TA@ <C O<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 %A\> W?G UU ?@T>O @TAD CB>AX<D[

V<@T W?GO Q?GDC>F2 TA\> W?G CB?X>D V<@T ADW?D> >FC>

<D BO>BAOA@<?D E?O @T> kG>C@<?D<D[ @?=AWl

,9 :>FF2 !i\> CB?X>D V<@T HW V<E>9

j9 ,DW?D> >FC>l

,9 1>C9 "?@ CB>Q<E<QAFFW9 !i\> CB?X>D @?

HADW B>?BF> ?\>O @T> FAC@ C>\>OAF V>>XC2 PG@ D?@

CB>Q<E<QAFFW <D BO>BAOA@<?D E?O @T<C =>B?C<@<?D9

j9 %A\> W?G CB?X>D V<@T ADW?D> VT? V> TA\>

BO>\<?GCFW <D@>O\<>V>= <D @T<C <D\>C@<[A@<?Dl

,9 !i\> CB?X>D V<@T ->> YQ+GFF?G[T2 VT? <C HW

Page 9: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 9/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

S

A@@?OD>W9 !i\> CB?X>D V<@T )AC?D 6?V>OC2 !i\> CB?X>D

V<@T +?O@ :AFX>O9

j9 ,DW?D> >FC> W?G QAD O>QAFFl

,9 !iH @OW<D[ @? O>H>HP>O <E @T>O>iC ADW?D>

>FC> !i\> CB?X>D V<@T2 PG@ @? HW O>Q?FF>Q@<?D O<[T@

@T<C H?H>D@2 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF TA\<D[ CB?X>D V<@T ADW?D>

>FC>9

j9 :T>D =<= W?G CB>AX V<@T ->> YQ+GFF?G[Tl

,9 ! CB?X> V<@T T<H W>C@>O=AW AE@>OD??D9

j9 ,D= =<= W?G <D<@<A@> @T> QAFF ?O =<= T>l

,9 ,Q@GAFFW2 ! CB?X> V<@T T<H W>C@>O=AW

AE@>OD??D AD= C>\>OAF =AWC A[? AC V>FF9 %> <D<@<A@>=

@T> QAFF @? H> A E>V =AWC A[?2 AD= ! CB?X> V<@T T<H

W>C@>O=AW V<@T )>DD<E>O )AH>C W>C@>O=AW AE@>OD??D2

AD= ! <D<@<A@>= @TA@ QAFF9 :> <D<@<A@>= ?GO QAFF

@?[>@T>O9

j9 (? W?G Q?DC<=>O @TA@ @? P> BO<\<F>[>=l

Y'9 ."/:5 :>FF2 W>C9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; .? <C YO9 YQ+GFF?G[T

O>BO>C>D@<D[ W?G <D Q?DD>Q@<?D V<@T @T<C

<D\>C@<[A@<?Dl

$%& :!$"&..5 %?V V?GF= W?G ADCV>O @TA@2

'?=l

Y'9 ."/:5 "?9

$%& :!$"&..5 "?9

Page 10: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 10/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TU

Y'9 -,--!5 !@iC ?GO B?C<@<?D @TA@

YO9 .VAFF?ViC Q?HHGD<QA@<?DC V<@T ->> YQ+GFF?G[T2 @?

@T> >a@>D@ @T>W AO> BO<\<F>[>=2 TA\> P>>D VA<\>=9

,O> W?G Q?D@>C@<D[ @TA@l

Y'9 ."/:5 ! @T<DX @T>Wi\> P>>D VA<\>=

V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? @T> A=\<Q> ->> BO?\<=>= YO9 .VAFF?V

<D YAOQT ?E NKIN O>[AO=<D[ @T> =<CQF?CGO> E?OHC @TA@

T> E<F>=9

:<@T O>CB>Q@ @? W?GO <DkG<O<>C ?E T<H2 !

@T<DX V> @O>A@ T<H C@<FF AC T<C Q?GDC>F E?O BGOB?C>C

?E >C@A@> BFADD<D[2 AD= V> AO> ?P\<?GCFW T<C Q?GDC>F2

AD= C? ! Q?DC<=>O @TA@ BO<\<F>[>=9

Y'9 -,--!5 /XAW9 !iFF H?\> ?D @T>D9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; :T>D =<= W?G CB>AX V<@T

)AC?D 6?V>OCl

,9 ->@ H> AFC? A== ?D> H?O> @T<D[ @? @TA@9 !

=<= CB>AX V<@T 8OAD@ .GHC<?D FAC@ D<[T@ AC V>FF9

j9 :T>D =<= W?G CB>AX V<@T )AC?D 6?V>OCl

Y'9 ."/:5 :>FF2 @T>W <D@>O\<>V>= 8OAD@9

$%& :!$"&..5 ! @T?G[T@ @TA@ 8OAD@ TA=

CA<= @TA@ UU

Y'9 ."/:5 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

$%& :!$"&..5 UU YO9 -AFF< TA= <D@>O\<>V>=

T<H2 PG@ HAWP> D?@9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; :T>D =<= W?G CB>AX V<@T

Page 11: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 11/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TT

)AC?D 6?V>OCl

,9 !i\> CB?X>D V<@T )AC?D 6?V>OC A@ F>AC@

?DQ> A V>>X E?O @T> FAC@ C<a H?D@TC2 C? ! CB?X> V<@T

T<H AC O>Q>D@FW AC FAC@ D<[T@9

j9 %A\> W?G CB?X>D V<@T T<H AP?G@ @T>

kG>C@<?D<D[ @TA@ V> HA=> ?E T<Hl

,9 ! P>F<>\> A E>V V>>XC A[? T> H>D@<?D>=

@TA@ W?G TA= CB?X>D2 AD= T> H>D@<?D>= @? H> @TA@ W?G

TA= O>kG>C@>= C?H> X<D= ?E A C@A@>H>D@2 PG@ @T?C> AO>

@T> ?DFW =>@A<FC ! O>AFFW O>H>HP>O @AFX<D[ V<@T T<H

AP?G@9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF =<CQGCC<D[ ADW ?E @T> <CCG>C

V<@T T<H2 VT>@T>O @TA@iC Q?D\>OCA@<?DC ?O H>>@<D[C ?O

EAQ@ Q<OQGHC@ADQ>Cl

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF CB>Q<E<QAFFW @T> <CCG>C V>

CB?X> AP?G@ P>QAGC> T> Q?D@<DG>C @? Q?DCGF@ ?D BGPF<Q

O>FA@<?DC HA@@>OC9 ! CB>AX V<@T T<H >D?G[T @TA@ <@iC

TAO= E?O H> @? O>H>HP>O >aAQ@FW VTA@ @?B<Q ! CB?X>

AP?G@ V<@T T<H UU @? T<H V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? A Q>O@A<D

@<H> ?O =AW9

j9 :T>D W?G CAW @TA@ )AC?D 6?V>OC Q?D@<DG>C

@? Q?DCGF@ ?D BGPF<Q O>FA@<?DC HA@@>OC2 <C T> A

Q?DCGF@AD@ E?O W?G B>OC?DAFFW2 E?O @T> ,@@?OD>W

8>D>OAF2 <D C?H> ?@T>O QABAQ<@Wl

,9 ! P>F<>\> T>iC A Q?DCGF@AD@ ?D HW BGPF<Q

Page 12: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 12/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TV

O>FA@<?DC @>AH AC Q??O=<DA@>= @TO?G[T HW F>[AF

Q?GDC>F9

j9 YO9 .D?Vl

,9 '<[T@9 ,D= V?GF= ! P> APF> @? ACX E?O A

[FACC ?E VA@>Ol

j9 ,PC?FG@>FW9

,9 $TADX W?G9

j9 :> AFC? TA\> cG<Q> ?O C?=AC <E W?G BO>E>O

C?H>@T<D[ >FC>9

,9 :A@>OiC [O>A@9 '<[T@ EO?H @T> @AB <C

E<D>9

Y'9 ."/:5 !@iC C@<FF VAOH <D T>O>2 YA@@9

Y'9 -,--!5 $TA@iC @OG>9 :> GCGAFFW TA\>

@T> ?BB?C<@> BO?PF>H9

$%& :!$"&..5 $TADX W?G9

Y'9 ."/:5 %?V ?F= <C @T<C PG<F=<D[l

Y'9 -,--!5 6O?PAPFW IMUNK W>AOC9

Y'9 ."/:5 /T2 C? @T>W cGC@ TA= A

HAX>?\>Ol

Y'9 -,--!5 "?9

Y'9 ."/:5 !@iC O>AFFW IM W>AOC ?F=l $<H>

EF<>C VT>D W?GiO> AD ?F= [GW9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; :T>D =<= W?G CB>AX V<@T

+?O@ :AFX>Ol

,9 ,BBO?a<HA@>FW @V? V>>XC A[?9

Page 13: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 13/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TW

j9 (? W?G XD?V <E <@ VAC P>E?O> ?O AE@>O V>

TA= <D@>O\<>V>= T<Hl

,9 ! P>F<>\> <@ VAC AE@>O W?G TA= <D@>O\<>V>=

T<H9

j9 ,D= =<= W?G =<CQGCC @T> CGPc>Q@ ?E ><@T>O

T<C <D@>O\<>V ?O W?GOCl

,9 :> =<=Di@ =<CQGCC @T> CGPc>Q@ ?E HW

<D@>O\<>V9 :> =<CQGCC>= @T> CGPc>Q@ UU A F<@@F> P<@

?E @T> CGPc>Q@ ?E T<C <D@>O\<>V9

j9 ,D= =? W?G O>QAFF VTA@ <CCG>C V>O>

=<CQGCC>=l

,9 %> H>D@<?D>= UU T> H>D@<?D>= @TA@ W?G TA=

ACX>= T<H A kG>C@<?D AP?G@ C?H> [?F= ! TA= O>C?F= ?O

C?F= @? '<QTAO= 'AVF>9 ! O>H>HP>O @AFX<D[ AP?G@ @TA@

\>OW PO<>EFW V<@T T<H9

j9 ,DW ?@T>O <CCG>C W?G O>QAFFl

,9 "?@ @TA@ ! O>QAFF9

j9 ,D= <C <@ cGC@ @T> ?DQ> @TA@ W?Gi\> CB?X>D

V<@T YO9 :AFX>O O>Q>D@FWl

,9 '<[T@9 $T> O>AF O>AC?D V> CB?X> VAC

P>QAGC> ! TA= P>>D @OW<D[ @? [>@ AQQ>CC @? HW

">@.B>D= BO>BA<= =>P<@ QAO= @TA@ +T>QX +<@W BO?\<=>=

@? H> <D Q?DC<=>OA@<?D ?E @T> [?F= ! C?F= A Q?GBF> UU

Y'9 ."/:5 "?V2 )?TD2 =<= T> ACX W?G AP?G@

@TA@l

Page 14: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 14/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJ

$%& :!$"&..5 "?2 PG@ T> =<= ACX H> AP?G@

VTA@ V> @AFX>= AP?G@9

Y'9 ."/:5 '<[T@2 PG@ D?@ VTW T> QAFF>=9

$%& :!$"&..5 /XAW9

Y'9 ."/:5 dG@ W?G QAD @>FF T<H9 ! H>AD2

!iH CGO> T>iC [?<D[ @? [>@ @? @TA@9

$%& :!$"&..5 /XAW9

Y'9 ."/:5 dG@ ! cGC@ VAD@ @? QAG@<?D W?G

@? cGC@ ADCV>O @T> kG>C@<?D9

$%& :!$"&..5 .GO>9

Y'9 ."/:5 %> XD?VC VTA@ T>iC =?<D[ UU

$%& :!$"&..5 $TA@ VAC @T> Q?D@>a@ ?E ?GO

=<CQGCC<?D9

Y'9 ."/:5 UU @TA@ V?GF= P> HW [G>CC9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; (<= W?G <D<@<A@> @T> QAFF

?O =<= YO9 :AFX>Ol

,9 ! P>F<>\> T> =<= >AOF<>O <D @T> =AW9

j9 (? W?G TA\> AD ?D[?<D[ O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T

+?O@ :AFX>O ?O V<@T @T> +T>QX +<@W Q?HBAD<>Cl

,9 "?@ AD ?D[?<D[ PGC<D>CC O>FA@<?DCT<B2

@T?G[T ! C@<FF Q?DC<=>O HWC>FE @? P> A \>OW [??=

EO<>D= ?E B>?BF> <D @T> Q?HBADW9

j9 .? V?GF= W?G =>CQO<P> W?GO O>FA@<?DCT<B

V<@T @T> B>?BF> CGQT AC +?O@ :AFX>O ?O @T> 'AVF>

PO?@T>OC ?O 8O>[ +AFF<C@>O B>OC?DAF AC ?BB?C>= @?

Page 15: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 15/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TN

W?GO PGC<D>CC O>FA@<?DCT<BCl

,9 ! V?GF= =>CQO<P> <@ AC B>OC?DAF A@ @T<C

B?<D@9

j9 (? W?G TA\> ADW V?OX<D[ O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T

@T?C> <D=<\<=GAFC ?O @T> '<QTAO= 'AVF> Q?HBAD<>C2

VT<QT V?GF= <DQFG=> +T>QX +<@Wl

,9 "?2 D?@ BO>C>D@FW9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= W?G CAW W?G CB?X> @?

YO9 .GHC<?D FAC@ D<[T@l

,9 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= =<= T> QAFF W?Gl

,9 ! P>F<>\> T> QAFF>= H>9

j9 :TA@ =<= T> CAWl

Y'9 ."/:5 :>FF2 ! =?Di@ XD?V @T>

CGPC@ADQ> ?E @T> Q?D\>OCA@<?D2 PG@ 8OAD@ .GHC<?D TAC

O>BO>C>D@>= )?TD ?D A DGHP>O ?E HA@@>OC9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; !C 8OAD@ .GHC<?D W?GO

Q?GDC>F <D Q?DD>Q@<?D V<@T @T<C <D\>C@<[A@<?Dl

,9 +GOO>D@FW2 D?9

j9 (<= T> CB>AX @? W?G ?E @T<C <D\>C@<[A@<?Dl

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX <@ VAC AP?G@ @T<C

<D\>C@<[A@<?D B>O C>9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF VTA@ T> H>D@<?D>= UU VTW T>

QAFF>=l

,9 !iH cGC@ @T<DX<D[9 (? W?G O>H>HP>O VTA@

Page 16: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 16/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TO

T> VAC @AFX<D[ AP?G@l !iH @OW<D[ @? O>H>HP>O9

.?H>?D> TA= QAFF>= T<H AD= ACX>= AP?G@ UU AD= ! @T<DX

<@ VAC W?G UU AP?G@ A C>@@F>H>D@ A[O>>H>D@ T> TA=

BO>BAO>= VT<F> V?OX<D[ E?O '<QTAO= 'AVF>2 AD

A[O>>H>D@ P>@V>>D YO9 'AVF> AD= YO9 .Q?@@ ->A\<@@2

AD= ! P>F<>\> T> VAC QAFF<D[ @? F>@ H> XD?V @TA@ T>

TA= TA= @TA@ =<CQGCC<?D V<@T W?G ?O C?H>?D> EO?H W?GO

E<OH2 AD= @TA@ VAC @T> Q?D@>a@2 @T> CGH AD= CGPC@ADQ>

?E ?GO Q?D\>OCA@<?D9

j9 %?V F?D[ =<= <@ FAC@l

,9 ,BBO?a<HA@>FW E<\> @? C>\>D H<DG@>C9

j9 :TA@ <C W?GO O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T

8OAD@ .GHC<?Dl

,9 ! V?GF= CAW <@iC B>OC?DAF AD=

BO?E>CC<?DAF9

j9 ,D= =>CQO<P> @T> BO?E>CC<?DAF BAO@2 <E W?G

V?GF=2 BF>AC>9

,9 :>FF2 V> V>O> <D FAV CQT??F @?[>@T>O9

:>i\> @O<>= A QAC> @?[>@T>O VT>D ! VAC <D BO<\A@>

BOAQ@<Q>2 AD= T> UU ! O>@A<D>= T<H AC A FAVW>O E?O HW

QAHBA<[D2 ?O<[<DAFFW <D Q?DD>Q@<?D V<@T @T> FAVCG<@

E<F>= PW .>AD '>W>C A[A<DC@ H> B>OC?DAFFW AD= HW

QAHBA<[D2 AD= T> AFC? UU ! AFC? >D[A[>= T<H @?

BO?\<=> B>OC?DAF Q?GDC>F @? H> O>[AO=<D[

Q?HHGD<QA@<?DC !i= TA= V<@T YO9 )>O>HW )?TDC?D9

Page 17: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 17/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TP

j9 ,D= VTA@ @<H> EOAH> VAC @TA@ FAC@ BAO@2

@T> Q?HHGD<QA@<?DC V<@T )>O>HW )?TDC?Dl

,9 !@ VAC C?H>@<H> <D @T> CBO<D[ ?E NKIN9

6O?PAPFW2 @? DAOO?V <@2 HAWP> ,BO<F @? )GD> ?O )GFW

?E NKIN9

j9 ,D= VTA@ C>O\<Q>C =<= YO9 .GHC<?D B>OE?OH

E?O W?G <D Q?DD>Q@<?D V<@T @T>C> ,BO<F @? )GFW NKIN

<CCG>Cl

,9 :>FF2 ! =?Di@ VAD@ @? VA<\> ADW BO<\<F>[>9

j9 :>FF2 F>@ H> @OW AD= ACX A P>@@>O

kG>C@<?D9

,9 .GO>9

j9 (<= T> UU =<= W?G >D[A[> T<H AC Q?GDC>Fl

,9 1>C9

j9 (<= W?G >D[A[> T<H @? =? ADW CB>Q<E<Q

@ACX2 CGQT AC O>CB?D= @? A F>@@>O2 ABB>AO <D A

H>>@<D[2 ABB>AO <D Q?GO@l

,9 :>FF2 ! >D[A[>= T<H2 AH?D[ ?@T>O @T<D[C2

@? <D@>OEAQ> V<@T YO9 )>O>HW )?TDC?D ?D HW P>TAFE9

%> VAC >D[A[>= @? ADAFWf> @T> FAVCG<@ E<F>= PW HW

BO<HAOW ?BB?D>D@2 .>AD '>W>C9 ! P>F<>\> UU ! P>F<>\>

@T?C> @V? @T<D[C V>O> @T> CQ?B> ?E HW >D[A[>H>D@ ?E

T<H A@ @TA@ @<H>9

j9 (?>C @T> =A@> ,BO<F JK2 NKIN2 C@AD= ?G@ <D

W?GO H<D=l

Page 18: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 18/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TR

,9 !E @TA@iC @T> =A@> ! H>@ V<@T

)>O>HW )?TDC?D2 @T>D @TA@ =?>C C@AD= ?G@ <D HW H<D=9

j9 $TA@iC @T> =A@>2 AC ! GD=>OC@AD= <@2 ?E

@T> H>>@<D[ W?G AD= YO9 )?TDC?D TA= A@ @T>

0O<CBW 0O>H> CT?B <D /O>H9

,9 /XAW9 !E W?G CAW <@2 @TA@iC @T> =A@>9 !

XD>V <@ VAC @?VAO=C @T> >D= ?E ,BO<F9

j9 +AD W?G CAW VT>@T>O W?G >D[A[>=

YO9 .GHC<?D P>E?O> ?O AE@>O @TA@ H>>@<D[ V<@T

YO9 )?TDC?Dl

,9 ! V?GF= TA\> @? [G>CC @TA@ <@ VAC AE@>O

@TA@ H>>@<D[9

j9 :AC <@ AC A O>CGF@ ?E @TA@ H>>@<D[ ?O AC A

O>CGF@ ?E C?H>@T<D[ @TA@ TA= P>>D [?<D[ P>E?O> @TA@

H>>@<D[l

,9 ,C ! O>QAFF2 YO9 )?TDC?D Q?D@<DG>= @? @OW

@? O>AQT ?G@ @? H> AD= @AFX @? H>2 AD= ! VAC D?@

<D@>O>C@>= <D TA\<D[ ADW EGO@T>O =<CQGCC<?DC V<@T

T<H2 AD= C? ! >D[A[>= YO9 .GHC<?D @? <D@>OEAQ> V<@T

YO9 )?TDC?D ?D HW P>TAFE9

j9 ,D= =? W?G XD?V <E YO9 .GHC<?D2 <D EAQ@2

=<= <D@>OEAQ> V<@T YO9 )?TDC?Dl

,9 ! P>F<>\> T> =<=2 W>C9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VTA@2 <E ADW2 O>C?FG@<?D @T>W

QAH> @?l

Page 19: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 19/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TS

,9 1>C9

j9 :TA@ VAC @T> O>C?FG@<?Dl

,9 :>FF2 ! GD=>OC@AD= @T>W TA= A

Q?D\>OCA@<?D UU A@ F>AC@ ?D> Q?D\>OCA@<?D2 AD= @T>D

E?FF?V<D[ @TA@ ! P>F<>\> @TA@ YO9 .GHC<?D VAC AFC?

>D[A[>= PW YO9 'AVF> @? O>BO>C>D@ T<H ?O T<C Q?HBADW

V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? @T> AOOAD[>H>D@ P>@V>>D YO9 'AVF> AD=

YO9 )?TDC?D O>FA@<\> @? @T> 3$+9

j9 !D BO>BAOA@<?D E?O W?GO @>C@<H?DW @?=AW2

=<= W?G O>\<>V ADW =?QGH>D@Cl

,9 ! =<=9

j9 +AD W?G O>QAFF VTA@ @T>W V>O>l

,9 ! O>\<>V>= PAC<QAFFW AFF ?E @T> E<F<D[C

@TA@ V>O> BO?\<=>= @? @T> -<>G@>DAD@ 8?\>OD?O PW HW

A@@?OD>WC AD= H> >AOF<>O @T<C W>AO9 ! O>\<>V>= UU !

O>EO>CT>= HW O>Q?FF>Q@<?D ?E =<EE>O>D@ <D@>O\<>VC

!i\> TA= AD= =<CQGCC<?DC !i\> TA= V<@T HW FAVW>OC <D

BO>BAO<D[ E?O ?@T>O <D\>C@<[A@<?DC VT<QT AO> ?D[?<D[

A[A<DC@ H> A@ @T> @<H> UU A@ @T<C @<H>9 !i\>

O>\<>V>= @T> .GPB?>DAC @TA@ V>O> C>O\>= PW W?G AD=

W?GO Q?GDC>F AD= PW @T> CB>Q<AF <D\>C@<[A@?O E?O @T>

%?GC> ?E '>BO>C>D@A@<\>C2 AD= ! TA\> O>\<>V>= @T?C>

=?QGH>D@C @TA@ V> BO?=GQ>= @? W?G9

j9 /XAW9 %A\> W?G CB?X>D V<@T .AH &FHAl

,9 ! TA\>Di@ CB?X>D V<@T T<H <D A@ F>AC@ C<a

Page 20: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 20/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VU

H?D@TC9

Y'9 -,--!5 &aT<P<@ I9

K&H#/I/1 T )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ I <C A Q?FF>Q@<?D

?E .GPB?>DAC2 AD= ! CT?GF= CAW @TA@ @T>WiO> D?@ @T>

EGFF .GPB?>DAC9 $T>WiO> @T> E<OC@ @V? BA[>C2 AD=

@T>D @T>W AO> BA[>C ?E @T> .GPB?>DAC @TA@ <=>D@<EW

@T> CB>Q<E<Q =?QGH>D@C @TA@ V>O> O>kG>C@>=2 AD= @T>

.GPB?>DAC AO> O>CB>Q@<\>FW E?O W?GOC>FE B>OC?DAFFW2

!U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C2 --+2 .VAFF?V AD= ,CC?Q<A@>C2

6U.?FG@<?DC2 --+2 .GfADD> .VAFF?V2 ..7 YADA[>H>D@2

--+2 AD= -AGO>D Y9 '>>=2 $OGC@>> ?E @T> .GB>O .>\>D

$OGC@9

,O> @T>C> @T> .GPB?>DAC @TA@ W?G O>\<>V>=2

?O C?H> ?E @T>Hl

,9 ! P>F<>\> @T>W AO>9

j9 ,D= W?G HAW TA\> @?F= H> @T<C2 PG@ VT>D

=<= W?G O>\<>V @T>Hl

,9 :>FF2 ! O>\<>V>= @T>H VT>D @T>W V>O> E<OC@

C>O\>= GB?D H>2 AD= ! TA\> O>E>OO>= @? @T>H

B>O<?=<QAFFW ?\>O @T> FAC@ C>\>OAF V>>XC AC ! TA\>

@O<>= @? Q?HBFW V<@T @T> .GPB?>DAC9

j9 %A\> W?G P>>D @T> B>OC?D O>CB?DC<PF> E?O

O>\<>V<D[ AD= O>CB?D=<D[ @? @T>C> .GPB?>DACl

,9 :>FF2 ! TA\> P>>D ?D> ?E @T> B>?BF> VT?iC

Page 21: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 21/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VT

P>>D O>CB?DC<PF>9 ! XD?V HW V<E> AD= ! TA\> V?OX>=

@?[>@T>O ?D @T> <CCG>C @TA@ B>O@A<D @? T>O O?F> AC

QGOO>D@ HADA[>O ?E @T> Q?HBAD<>C ?VD>= PW @T> @OGC@9

! TA\> D?@ O>\<>V>= @T> .GPB?>DAC V<@T HW =AG[T@>O2

-AGO>D9

j9 :<@T O>CB>Q@ @? W?GO V<E>2 =? W?G XD?V <E

CT> TAC =?D> ADW V?OX <D O>CB?DC> @? @T>C> .GPB?>DAC

@TA@iC P>>D <D=>B>D=>D@ ?E ?O =<EE>O>D@ EO?H VTA@

W?Gi\> =?D>l

,9 ! =?Di@ P>F<>\> CT> TAC9 .T> AD= ! H>@

@?[>@T>O AD= V>D@ ?\>O @T> .GPB?>DAC @?[>@T>O

AD= @T>D UU

Y'9 ."/:5 .? @T> ADCV>OiC D?9

$%& :!$"&..5 "?9 $TADX W?G9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; +AD W?G @>FF GC VTA@ W?G

AD= W?GO V<E> =<= BO?Q>=GOAFFWl $TA@ <C2 =<= W?G

F??X <D Q>O@A<D E<F>Cl (<= W?G [? @? Q>O@A<D BFAQ>C

@? [A@T>O =?QGH>D@Cl

,9 :>FF2 C? CT> AD= ! H>@ @?[>@T>O2 AD= V>

@AFX>= AP?G@ @T> O>kG>C@C O>FA@<\> @? @T> Q?HBAD<>C

VT>O> CT>iC @T> HADA[>O2 AD= CT> =<O>Q@>= H> @? [? @?

@T> PADXC AD= [>@ @T> E<DADQ<AF =?QGH>D@C @TA@ V>O>

O>kG>C@>= <D @T> .GPB?>DA9

.T> <C @T> B>OC?D VT? F??X>= E?O AQQ?GD@

F>=[>OC ?D ?GO B>OC?DAF PADX AQQ?GD@C @TA@ W?G

Page 22: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 22/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VV

O>kG>C@>= AD= BO?\<=>= @T?C> @? H>2 VT<QT ! BO?\<=>=

@? HW Q?GDC>F9 ! P>F<>\> <@ VAC H> @TA@ V>D@ AD= UU

! XD?V ! [?@ @T> @>a@ H>CCA[>C EO?H HW BT?D> AD=

BO<D@>= @T?C> ?G@ AD= [A\> @T>H @? HW Q?GDC>F2 AD= !

TA\> P>>D @T> BO<HAOW B>OC?D F??X<D[ @TO?G[T >UHA<FC

AD= @O<>= @? [A@T>O ?@T>O <DE?OHA@<?D9

! =?Di@ P>F<>\> @TA@ .GfADD> TA= ADW ?@T>O

<D\?F\>H>D@ ?@T>O @TAD <D\?F\>H>D@ O>FA@>= @? T>FB<D[

H> V<@T @T> (<CQ?\>O +AO= C@A@>H>D@C2 @T> F>=[>OC AD=

@T> >D@<@<>C ?E VT<QT CT>iC @T> HADA[>O9

j9 (<= W?G ?O2 @? W?GO XD?VF>=[>2 =<= CT>

F??X A@ ADW E<F>C <D W?GO T?H> ?O ?EE<Q> ?O ADWVT>O>

>FC>2 AD= !iH @AFX<D[ AP?G@ TAO= Q?BW E<F>C ?E UU

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX CT> =<=9

j9 (? W?G XD?V <E @T>O> AO> ADW E<F>C <D TAO=

Q?BW @TA@ AO> HA<D@A<D>= @TA@ Q?D@A<D =?QGH>D@C

O>CB?DC<\> @? @T> .GPB?>DAl

,9 $T> ?DFW E<F>C !iH AVAO> ?E @TA@ V?GF= P>

O>CB?DC<\> @? @T> .GPB?>DA V?GF= P> @T> Q?HBG@>O

E<F>C AD= @T> QT>QXP??XC E?O >AQT ?E @T> @TO>>

>D@<@<>C @TA@ TA\> QT>QX<D[ AQQ?GD@C AD= @T> >C@A@>

BFADD<D[ P??XF>@ @TA@ <C <D @T> B?CC>CC<?D ?E HW

A@@?OD>W2 VT<QT ! P>F<>\> W?G TA\> Q?B<>C ?E @T>

>C@A@> BFADD<D[ =?QGH>D@C9 !iH D?@ CGO> V> TA\> ADW

?@T>O E<F>C A@ T?H> =>AF<D[ V<@T @T> @T<D[C @TA@ V>O>

Page 23: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 23/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VW

O>kG>C@>= GD=>O @T> .GPB?>DA9

j9 (? W?G TA\> A E<F<D[ QAP<D>@ ?O A QO>=>DfA

?O C?H> ?@T>O E<F<D[ CWC@>H A@ T?H> VT>O> W?G X>>B

TAO= Q?BW E<F>Cl

,9 :> =?9

j9 ,D= VTA@ [>D>OAFFW <C HA<D@A<D>= <D @T?C>

E<F>Cl

,9 :>FF2 [>D>OAFFW CB>AX<D[2 V> TA\> ?GO @Aa

O>@GODC <D @T?C> E<F>C2 V> TA\> F<E> <DCGOADQ>

AQQ?GD@ C@A@>H>D@C <D @T?C> E<F>C2 V> TA\> ?GO

*@AT &=GQA@<?DAF .A\<D[C 6FAD E<F>C <D @T?C> E<F>C2 !

TA\> QTGOQTUO>FA@>= E<F>C <D @T?C> @V? =OAV>OC2 !

TA\> ?F= UU A Q?GBF> ?E ?F= QAHBA<[D E<F>C9 .GfADD>

TAC @T<D[C !iH CGO> <D @T?C> E<F>C !iH D?@ AVAO> ?E9

Y'9 ."/:5 %> =<=Di@ ACX W?G VTA@ E<F>C

W?G X>B@2 cGC@ <E W?G X>B@ TAO= Q?BW E<F>C <D @T>

E<F<D[ QAP<D>@9

$%& :!$"&..5 /T2 ! @T?G[T@ T> ACX>= H>

VTA@ V> X>B@9

Y'9 ."/:5 )GC@ @OW AD= F<C@>D @? T<C

ADCV>OC AD= ADCV>O @TA@2 AD= <@ V<FF H?\> A F?@

EAC@>O9

$%& :!$"&..5 /XAW9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; (? W?G TA\> E<F>C <D W?GO

E<F<D[ QAP<D>@C A@ T?H> O>FA@<\> @? @T> >D@<@<>C VT?

Page 24: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 24/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VJ

AO> <=>D@<E<>= <D @T> .GPB?>DACl 3?O >aAHBF> UU

,9 "?9

j9 UU 6U.?FG@<?DC2 ..7 UU

,9 "?@ <D HW E<F<D[ QAP<D>@2 D?9

j9 .? W?G =?Di@ HA<D@A<D ADW TAO= Q?BW E<F>C

E?O ..7 YADA[>H>D@2 E?O >aAHBF>l

,9 :>FF2 D?9 1?G ACX>= H> AP?G@ <E ! X>B@

@T>H <D @T> E<F> QAP<D>@9 ! X>>B @T> <DE?OHA@<?D

O>FA@<\> @? @T?C> Q?HBAD<>C <D A P<[ QT>QXP??X @TA@

AO> ACC?Q<A@>= V<@T @T> AQQ?GD@C E?O >AQT ?E @T?C>

>D@<@<>C2 AD= ! X>>B Q?B<>C <D @T> UU ?E <DE?OHA@<?D

<D @T> P<D=>O @TA@ TAC HW >C@A@> BFAD <D <@2 AD=

@T>C> Q?HBAD<>C TA\> P>>D C? UU @T>O> TAC P>>D TAO=FW

ADW PGC<D>CC =?D> <D @T>C> Q?HBAD<>C2 AD= C? @T>O>

cGC@ O>AFFW <C D?@ @TA@ HGQT @? X>>B <D A E<F>9

j9 dG@ VTA@ @T>O> <C !iH GD=>OC@AD=<D[ W?G @?

CAW <C X>B@ V<@T @T> QT>QXP??XC E?O >AQT Q?HBADWe <C

@TA@ Q?OO>Q@l

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 ,D= VT>D W?G CAW gP<[ QT>QXP??X2g !iH

>D\<C<?D<D[ C?H>@T<D[ F<X> AD ><[T@ AD= A TAFE PW

>F>\>D @WB> PGC<D>CC QT>QXP??Xe <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 $TA@iC VTA@ ! H>AD2 W>C9

j9 /XAW9 (? W?G HA<D@A<D ADW Q?HBG@>O A@

T?H>l

Page 25: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 25/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VN

,9 1>C9

j9 ,D= =? W?G TA\> Q?HBG@>O E<F>C ?D @TA@

Q?HBG@>O @TA@ B>O@A<D @? @T> >D@<@<>C <=>D@<E<>= <D

@T> .GPB?>DACl

,9 ! =?Di@ P>F<>\> ! =?9

j9 (? W?G TA\> H?O> @TAD ?D> Q?HBG@>O A@

T?H>l

,9 :>FF2 D?@ @TA@ V> GC> AC A T?H> Q?HBG@>O9

j9 (? W?G GC> A Q?HBG@>O E?O C?H>@T<D[ ?@T>O

@TAD A T?H> Q?HBG@>Ol

,9 /T2 W>C9 ! TA\> A B>OC?DAF FAB@?B @TA@

P>F?D[C @? HW QAHBA<[D9 !@iC A FAB@?B9 !@iC A

Y<QO?C?E@ ,<O2 AD= @T>D ! TA\> A BT?D> @TA@ <C X<D=

?E A Q?HBG@>O9 !@iC AD <6T?D> AD= A (O?<=9 YW V<E>

TAC AD <6T?D>9

j9 1?G TA\> AD <6T?D> AD= A (O?<=l

,9 ! =?9 ! TA\> A .@A@> <6T?D> AD= A

B>OC?DAF (O?<=9

j9 (? W?G AFC? HA<D@A<D A Q?HBG@>O A@ W?GO

V?OXl

,9 ! =?9

j9 .? !iH Q?GD@<D[ @TO>> Q?HBG@>OC2 W?GO

FAB@?B2 W?GO T?H> Q?HBG@>O AD= W?GO ?EE<Q> Q?HBG@>Ol

,9 :>FF2 ! TA\> AD ?EE<Q> =>CX@?B9 ! AFC?

TA\> AD ?EE<Q> FAB@?B AD= ! TA\> AD ?EE<Q> <6A=9

Page 26: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 26/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VO

j9 /XAW9

,9 .? ! TA\> @TO>> Q?HBG@>OC A@ @T> ?EE<Q>2

AD= !i\> [?@ A =>CX@?B A@ T?H> AD= A B>OC?DAF FAB@?B

A@ T?H>2 VT<QT P>F?D[C @? HW QAHBA<[D2 AD= ! TA\> @V?

Q>FF BT?D>C VT<QT AO> 6(,C2 AD= HW V<E> TAC A Q>FF

BT?D> AC V>FF2 AD= ! @T<DX @TA@ @T?C> AO> AFF @T>

Q?HBG@>OC V> TA\> A@ ?GO T?GC>T?F=9

j9 !iH cGC@ V?D=>O<D[ T?V W?G X>>B @OAQX ?E

@T>H9

,9 ! =?Di@9 $TA@iC @T> BO?PF>H9

j9 (? ADW ?E @T> Q?HBG@>OC2 <DQFG=<D[ Q>FF

BT?D>C2 @TA@ W?G cGC@ H>D@<?D>=2 AO> @T>O> ADW E<F>C

O>FA@>= @? @T> >D@<@<>C <D @T> .GPB?>DAC ?D ADW ?E

@T?C> Q?HBG@>OCl

,9 ! V?GF= TA\> @? QT>QX2 PG@ ! =?Di@ @T<DX

C?9

j9 (? W?G O>Q><\> PADX C@A@>H>D@C2 ><@T>O

B>OC?DAFFW ?O E?O @T> >D@<@<>C2 @TO?G[T @T> HA<F ?O

>F>Q@O?D<QAFFWl

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX ! O>Q><\> @T>H9

j9 (? W?G HA<D@A<D >UHA<F AQQ?GD@Cl

,9 ! =?9

j9 %?V HADW >UHA<F AQQ?GD@C =? W?G TA\>l

,9 ! TA\> @V? BO<HAOW >UHA<F AQQ?GD@C9 /D>

<C A .@A@> <CCG>= >UHA<F AQQ?GD@ @TA@ ! @OW @?

Page 27: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 27/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VP

Q?D=GQ@ C<HBFW .@A@> PGC<D>CC ?D2 AD= @T>D @T> ?@T>O

<C A B>OC?DAF >UHA<F AQQ?GD@ @TA@ ! @OW @? Q?D=GQ@

AFF HW B>OC?DAF PGC<D>CC ?D9

j9 ! VAD@ @? [? PAQX E?O A H<DG@> @? @T>

Q?HBG@>OC9

! P>F<>\> W?G V>O> ADCV>O<D[ HW kG>C@<?D

AP?G@ Q?HBG@>OC <D @T> BO>C>D@ @>DC>e @TA@ <C2 VTA@

W?G HA<D@A<D @?=AW2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 %AC @TA@ QTAD[>= ?\>O @T> BAC@ @V? W>AOCl

,9 1>C9

j9 $>FF H> T?V W?GO GC> ?O AQQ>CC @?

Q?HBG@>OC AD= Q>FF BT?D>C TAC QTAD[>= C<DQ>2 F>@iC

CAW2 @T> P>[<DD<D[ ?E NKIIl

,9 :>FF2 HW (O?<= ! [?@ UU @T> QGOO>D@ (O?<=

! TA\> ! [?@ ! @T<DX <D /Q@?P>O ?O "?\>HP>O ?E NKII9

d>E?O> @TA@2 HW BO<?O B>OC?DAF BT?D> QOACT>=9

$T> <6T?D> ! TA\> ! O>Q><\>= ! @T<DX <D

"?\>HP>O NKIN AE@>O ! V?D @T> >F>Q@<?D9 !i\>

GB[OA=>= @? @T> FA@>C@ @>QTD?F?[W9 $T> =>CX@?B

Q?HBG@>O ! TA\> ! O>Q><\>= C?H>@<H> <D "?\>HP>O ?O

(>Q>HP>O ?E FAC@ W>AO9

j9 $TA@iC @T> =>CX@?B A@ W?GO ?EE<Q>l

,9 ,@ V?OX2 O<[T@9 $T> T?H> Q?HBG@>O ! TA=2

@T> TAO= =<CX EA<F>= <D )ADGAOW ?E NKIN ?O C?2 AD= !

Page 28: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 28/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VR

TA= @TA@ TAO= =<CX O>BFAQ>= <D @T> Q?HBG@>O <D

)ADGAOW ?O C? ?E NKIN9

$T> FAB@?B AD= @T> UU @T> QAHBA<[D FAB@?B

VAC BGOQTAC>= <D )GD> ?E )GFW ?E NKIN9 $T> ?EE<Q>

FAB@?B AD= <6A=2 VT<QT ! OAO>FW GC>2 VAC BGOQTAC>=2 !

@T<DX2 <D "?\>HP>O ?O (>Q>HP>O ?E NKIN2 PG@ ! OAO>FW

GC> @T?C>9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? W?GO >UHA<F

A==O>CC>C2 W?Gi\> [?@ W?GO V?OX >UHA<F A==O>CC AD= A

B>OC?DAFl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= VTA@iC @T> B>OC?DAFl

,9 :TA@ <C @T> AQ@GAF >UHA<F A==O>CCl

j9 1>C9

,9 !@ <C )?TD>CVAFF?Vb[HA<F9Q?H9

j9 %?V F?D[ TA\> W?G TA= @TA@ >UHA<F A==O>CCl

,9 6O?PAPFW E?O @TO>> W>AOC2 ?O HAWP> F?D[>O9

j9 6O<?O @? UU V>i\> C>>D C?H> >UHA<F

A==O>CC>C @TA@ W?G TA= BO<?O @? c?<D<D[ @T> ,@@?OD>W

8>D>OAFiC ?EE<Q>2 AD= ! P>F<>\> @TA@ VAC (>Q>HP>O ?E

NKKL9

,9 m:<@D>CC D?==<D[ T>A= AEE<OHA@<\>FW9;

j9 , .?E@V<C> AQQ?GD@2 E?O >aAHBF>l

,9 1>C9

j9 1?G =?Di@ C@<FF HA<D@A<D @TA@l

Page 29: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 29/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

VS

,9 "?9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX !i\> GC>= @TA@ C<DQ> !

c?<D>= @T> ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAFiC ?EE<Q>9

j9 %A\> W?G GC>= UU

,9 ! Q?GF= P> VO?D[ ?D @TA@2 PG@ O<[T@ AP?G@

@TA@ @<H>9

j9 /XAW9 *C<D[ @TA@ AC A @<H> EOAH>2

(>Q>HP>O NKKL VT>D W?G c?<D>= @T> ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAFiC

?EE<Q>2 TA\> W?G GC>= ?@T>O >UHA<F A==O>CC>C ?@T>O

@TAD @T> ?D> E?O W?GO V?OX AD= @T> 8HA<F AQQ?GD@l

,9 1>AT9 $T>O>iC AD?@T>O ?D> @TA@ ! GC>= A

F?@ H?O> @TAD ! =? D?V2 >\>D GC> <@ D?V9 !@iC A YAQ

AQQ?GD@ <@iC QAFF>=9 !@iC )?TD9CVAFF?V UU T> =<=Di@

ACX H> @T> A==O>CC2 PG@ !iFF [<\> <@ @? T<H9

)?TD9CVAFF?VIbH>9Q?H9 ! TA\>Di@ GC>= @TA@ O>[GFAOFW

E?O A W>AO AD= A TAFE ?O @V? W>AOC BO?PAPFW9

j9 /XAW9 3?O VTA@ BGOB?C> =<= W?G GC> @TA@

VT>D W?G =<=l

,9 )GC@ AC A B>OC?DAF >UHA<F AQQ?GD@9

j9 (<= W?G GC> @TA@ AD= @T> 8HA<F AQQ?GD@

C<HGF@AD>?GCFWl

,9 3?O A B>O<?= ?E @<H> ! =<=9

j9 !D O>CB?D=<D[ @? @T> .GPB?>DAC2 =<= W?G

F??X @TO?G[T ?O A@ F>AC@ @T<DX @TO?G[T AFF ?E @T>

>F>Q@O?D<Q C?GOQ>C V>i\> P>>D =<CQGCC<D[2 Q?HBG@>OC2

BT?D>C2 >UHA<F A==O>CC>Cl

Page 30: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 30/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WU

,9 :>FF UU W>C9

j9 (<= W?G E<D= ADW@T<D[l

,9 :>FF2 C? !iH D?@ A @>QTD?F?[W B>OC?D2 PG@

@T>O>iC A UU @T>O>iC A EGDQ@<?D <D @T> YAQ<D@?CT

CWC@>H ! P>F<>\> QAFF>= <+F?G=9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E

W?Gi\> T>AO= ?E <+F?G=2 PG@ C?H>T?V HW 8HA<F AQQ?GD@

AD= ! P>F<>\> HW Y& AQQ?GD@2 VT<QT ! =?Di@ GC>

ADWH?O>2 EGDD>F <D@? AD <+F?G= =?HA<D ?O AQQ?GD@ ?O

VTA@>\>O @T>W QAFF <@9

.? VTA@ ! =<= VAC ! V>D@ @? <+F?G=2 VT<QT

VT>D>\>O ! C>D@ A 8HA<F >UHA<F <@ [?>C <D@? @TA@2 AD=

@TA@ <C VTA@ !i\> P>>D GC<D[ @? O>CB?D= @? @T>

=<CQ?\>OW O>kG>C@C9

j9 :T>D W?G V>D@ <D@? @T> +F?G= UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU QAD W?G O>QAFF @T> \?FGH> ?E E<F>C ?O

>UHA<FC <D @TA@ UU

,9 ! P>F<>\> UU W>C2 ! QAD O>QAFF @TA@9 !iH

@OW<D[ @? P>TA\>9

j9 ,D= VTA@ VAC @T> \?FGH>l

,9 ! P>F<>\> @TA@ @T>O> AO> H?O> @TAD IK2KKK

>UHA<FC <D @T> <+F?G= AQQ?GD@9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VTA@ @T> @<H> EOAH>

ABBO?a<HA@>FW VACl

,9 $T> @<H> EOAH> E?O HW >UHA<FC <C UU H?C@

Page 31: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 31/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WT

?E @T>H AO> )GD> ?E NKIN AD= H?O> QGOO>D@2 P>QAGC> UU

V>FF2 B>O<?=<QAFFW <@iC P>>D HW QGC@?H AD= BOAQ@<Q>

@? [? @TO?G[T A =?QGH>D@ O>@>D@<?D B?F<QW2 AD >UHA<F

O>@>D@<?D B?F<QW2 AD= @T> FAC@ @<H> ! =<= @TA@ VAC <D

@T> CGHH>O ?E NKIN9

j9 :AC @T>O> AD ?QQAC<?D <D @T> CGHH>O ?E

NKIN @TA@ QAGC>= W?G @? [? @TO?G[T AD= BGO[> >UHA<FCl

,9 :>FF2 @TA@iC W?GO V?O=2 D?@ H<D>2 PG@ HW

=?QGH>D@ O>@>D@<?D B?F<QW9 dG@2 W>C2 ! VAC O>F>AC>=

AC A d<CT?B EO?H HW QTGOQT <D )GD> ?E NKIN2 AD= !

cGC@ VAC VOABB<D[ GB A BO<HAOW AD= E>F@ F<X> <@ VAC A

[??= @<H> @? [? @TO?G[T AD= [? @TO?G[T @TA@ BO?Q>CC

@TA@ ! [? @TO?G[T AP?G@ ?DQ> >\>OW W>AO ?O W>AO AD= A

TAFE2 AD= !i\> =?D> @TA@ Q?DC<C@>D@FW @TO?G[T HW

QAO>>O9

j9 (<= @TO>A@C HA=> PW )>O>HW )?TDC?D TA\>

ADW@T<D[ @? =? V<@T W?G =>F>@<D[ >UHA<FC <D @T>

CGHH>O ?E NKINl

,9 "?2 D?@ O>AFFW A@ AFF9 !E W?G VAD@ @?

XD?V @T> O>AC?D E?O @TA@2 <@iC P>QAGC> ! TA=Di@

O>@A<D>= >UHA<FC EO?H @T> @<H> B>O<?= ! TA= P>>D

V?OX<D[ V<@T )>O>HW )?TDC?D E?FF?V<D[ NKII2 C? !

=?Di@ O>QAFF TA\<D[ ADW >UHA<FC @TA@ V?GF= TA\> P>>D

O>F>\AD@ @? )>O>HW )?TDC?D A@ @T> @<H> ! V>D@ @TO?G[T

HW FA@>C@ =?QGH>D@ O>@>D@<?D >a>OQ<C>9

Page 32: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 32/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WV

j9 !D O>CB?D=<D[ @? @T> .GPB?>DAC2 =<= W?G

GC> C?H> X<D= ?E C>AOQT H>QTAD<CH @? [? @TO?G[T @T>

IK2KKK ?O C? >UHA<FC @? E<D= O>CB?DC<\> ?D>Cl

,9 $T> ?DFW C>AOQT H>QTAD<CH ! GC>= VAC ?D

@T> PO?VC>O <@C>FE VT>O> W?G cGC@ BFG[ <D A DAH> AD=

@T>D T<@ >D@>O2 AD= @T>D <@ [<\>C W?G AFF @T> >UHA<FC

@TA@ AO> O>FA@>= @? @TA@ B>OC?D9

j9 .? =<= W?G C>AOQT PW B>?BF>l

,9 dW B>?BF>9

j9 ,D= QAD W?G O>QAFF PW VT<QT B>?BF> W?G

C>AOQT>=l

,9 :>FF2 ! V?GF= TA\> @? F??X A@ @T>

.GPB?>DA2 P>QAGC> VTA@ ! =<= <C ! V>D@ @TO?G[T @T>

.GPB?>DA AD= F??X>= @TA@ VAW2 AD= !i\> [?@ @? CAW !

P>F<>\> !iH C@<FF <D @T> BO?Q>CC ?E @TA@9

j9 $TA@ VAC HW D>a@ kG>C@<?D9

,9 .? <E ! QAD cGC@ CTAO> C?H>@T<D[9

j9 .GO>9

,9 '?=2 W?GiFF ABBO>Q<A@> @T<C2 PG@ !iH

TA\<D[ D? BO?PF>H C>AOQT<D[ ?D HW 8HA<F E?O @TA@9

!iH TA\<D[ A BO?PF>H C>AOQT<D[ ?D HW <+F?G= E?O @TA@2

AD= ! =?Di@ XD?V <E <@iC AD <+F?G= <CCG> ?O <E <@iC A

Q?HBG@>O <CCG>2 C? !iH V?OX<D[ @TO?G[T @TA@ C@<FF9

j9 ,O> @T>O> ?@T>O BFAQ>C VT>O> W?G AO>

Q?D@<DG<D[ @? F??X E?O =?QGH>D@C O>CB?DC<\> @? @T>

Page 33: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 33/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WW

.GPB?>DACl

,9 !iH @OW<D[ @? E<[GO> ?G@ T?V @? [>@ C?H>

=?QGH>D@C ?EE HW <6T?D>2 PG@ ?@T>O @TAD @TA@2 ! QADi@

@T<DX ?E ADWVT>O> >FC> ! V?GF= F??X9 ! H>AD2 F>@ H>

F??X A@ @T> .GPB?>DA AD= cGC@ HAX> CGO> !iH D?@ UU

V>FF2 E?O >aAHBF>2 W>C9 ->@ H> cGC@ CAW W>C9

!i\> TA= A =<QX>DC ?E A @<H> [>@@<D[ HW

=>P<@ QAO= C@A@>H>D@ EO?H ">@.B>D=2 AD= <E W?G VAD@

@? XD?V VTW2 ! QAD @>FF W?G9

j9 $>FF H> VTW9

,9 YW ">@.B>D= BO>BA<= =>P<@ QAO= VAC <CCG>=

@? H> C?H>@<H> <D @T> CGHH>O ?E NKII2 AD= ! GC>= <@

E?O AP?G@ D<D> H?D@TC AD= ! F?C@ <@2 ! F?C@ @T> QAO=2

AD= C? ! TA= O>BFAQ>H>D@ QAO=C C>D@ @? HW UU @? HW

A==O>CC2 AD= @T>W V>O> O>c>Q@>= E?O C?H> O>AC?D2 AD=

@TA@ TABB>D>= @V<Q>2 AD= C? @T>W F?QX>= =?VD HW

AQQ?GD@2 AD= C? ! TA\>Di@ >\>D P>>D APF> @? AQQ>CC HW

AQQ?GD@ E?O A W>AO AD= A TAFE9

! =<=Di@ TA\> A F?@ ?E H?D>W <D @T>O>9 !

=<=Di@ O>AFFW QAO> AP?G@ <@ A@ @TA@ B?<D@ <D @<H> C?

! =<=Di@ V?OOW AP?G@ <@2 PG@ !i\> P>>D @OW<D[ @? [>@

@TA@ AQQ?GD@ O>?B>D>= P>QAGC> @T>W BG@ <@ ?D

F?QX=?VD2 AD= cGC@ E<DAFFW W>C@>O=AW ! VAC APF> @?

[>@ @TO?G[T @? C?H>?D> VT? CA<= @T>W Q?GF= [>@ @TA@

<DE?OHA@<?D E?O H>2 A@ F>AC@ BAO@ ?E @T> <DE?OHA@<?D

Page 34: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 34/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WJ

E?O H>2 C? ! Q?GF= [>@ C?H> O>Q?O=C @? BO?=GQ> @? W?G

?D @TA@ BAO@<QGFAO QAO=9

j9 /XAW9

,9 ! >aB>Q@ C?H> ?E @T?C> O>Q?O=C2 AC HGQT AC

@T>W QAD [>@ E?O H>2 @? P> A\A<FAPF> @T> D>a@ C>\>D

@? @>D PGC<D>CC =AWC9

j9 /XAW9 $TADX W?G9

,9 dG@ W?G ACX>= <E ! TA= QT>QX>= ?@T>O

BFAQ>C9 $TA@iC ?D> BFAQ>9 ! TA\>Di@ P>>D CGQQ>CCEGF

W>@ <D [>@@<D[ @TA@ <DE?OHA@<?D9

j9 ,D= VTA@ !iH V?D=>O<D[ <C AO> @T>O> ?@T>O

C?GOQ>C EO?H VT<QT ?@T>O =?QGH>D@C HAW P> Q?H<D[

BGOCGAD@ @? ?GO .GPB?>DACl

,9 "?@ @TA@ !iH AVAO> ?E9

j9 /XAW9

,9 ! =?Di@ O>H>HP>O A@ F>AC@9 :>FF2 W>C9 !

H>AD2 ! =?Di@ XD?V T?V UU ! =?Di@ XD?V T?V C>O<?GC

W?G AO> AP?G@ AFF @T> Q?HHGD<QA@<?DC <CCG>= PW HW

QAHBA<[D AD= HW ?EE<Q> @? @T> BO>CC <D @T> FAC@ W>AO

?O VTA@>\>O <@ VAC2 W>AO ?O @V? W>AOC9 $TA@ <C

\?FGH<D?GC <DE?OHA@<?D2 AD= C? @TA@iC BO?PAPFW [?<D[

@? @AX> GC kG<@> A P<@ ?E @<H> @? [>@ @? cGC@ P>QAGC>

<@iC C? =?QGH>D@ <D@>DC<\>2 AD= !i\> [?@ B>?BF>

V?OX<D[ A@ @T> ?EE<Q>2 !i\> [?@2 W?G XD?V2 @T<D[C

!i\> [?@ @? =? ?D HW ?VD AD= HW QAHBA<[D C@AEEiC [?@

Page 35: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 35/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WN

@? =?2 PG@ HW QAHBA<[D C@AEE <C D?@ V<@T H> ADWH?O>

P>QAGC> V>iO> D?@ <D QAHBA<[D H?=> ADWH?O>2 C? @TA@iC

AD?@T>O C?GOQ> ?E <DE?OHA@<?D9 $? @T> >a@>D@ @TA@

W?G D>>= @TA@ <DE?OHA@<?D2 <@ V<FF P> Q?H<D[ A@ C?H>

B?<D@ <D @<H>9 !@ TACDi@ Q?H> W>@9

j9 :>FF UU

,9 ! @T<DX W?G ACX>= E?O AFF Q?HHGD<QA@<?DC

P>@V>>D HW ?EE<Q> AD= @T> BO>CC AD= HW QAHBA<[D AD=

@T> BO>CC ?\>O AD >a@>D=>= B>O<?= ?E @<H>2 F<X> E?GO

W>AOC9

Y'9 ."/:5 3?O[>@ @TA@9

Y'9 -,--!5 :> =<= ACX E?O @TA@ AD= V> AO>

C>O<?GC AP?G@ <@2 PG@ B>OTABC V> QAD @AFX ?EE @T>

O>Q?O= AP?G@ A VAW ?E DAOO?V<D[ <@ =?VD9

$%& :!$"&..5 /XAW9 $TA@ V?GF= P> [O>A@9

! ABBO>Q<A@> <@9

Y'9 ."/:5 !@ V?GF= TA\> @? P> DAOO?V>=

O>AFFW Q?DC<=>OAPFW E?O GC @? >\>D Q?DC<=>O @TA@9

Y'9 -,--!5 :> ?P\<?GCFW =?Di@ TA\> @T>

B>OCB>Q@<\> @TA@ W?G =?2 PG@ @TA@ =<=Di@ C>>H F<X> <@

V?GF= P> A \?FGH<D?GC O>kG>C@2 AD= C? UU

Y'9 ."/:5 /T2 <@iC TG[>9

Y'9 -,--!5 UU V>iFF @AFX AP?G@ @TA@ ?EE

@T> O>Q?O=2 <E @TA@iC AFF O<[T@9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ! cGC@ VAD@ @? [? @TO?G[T

Page 36: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 36/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WO

C?H> @T<D[C @TA@ V> D?@>= AD= C>> <E W?G TA\> ADW

<DE?OHA@<?D ?D @T>H CB>Q<E<QAFFW9

,9 /XAW9

j9 (?>C @T> @OGC@e @TA@ <C2 @T> .GB>O .>\>D

$OGC@2 TA\> PADX AQQ?GD@Cl

,9 "?9

j9 (?>C <@ TA\> ADW C?O@ ?E E<F>C ?O

=?QGH>D@A@<?D2 E<DADQ<AF <DE?OHA@<?D ?@T>O @TAD @T>

@OGC@ =?QGH>D@l

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX C?9

j9 :>i\> D?@>= @OADCE>OC [?<D[ AH?D[ @T>

\AO<?GC >D@<@<>C2 CGQT AC 6U.?FG@<?DC2 ..7

YADA[>H>D@2 C?H> @? W?GO B>OC?DAF PADX AQQ?GD@C9

,O> @T>O> ADW UU ADW@T<D[ ?@T>O @TAD @T>

QT>QXC ?O @OADCE>OC @T>HC>F\>C @TA@ =>CQO<P> @T>

BGOB?C> ?E @T>C> @OADCE>OC2 CGQT AC >UHA<FC2

AG@T?O<fA@<?DC2 @T<D[C F<X> @TA@l

,9 :>FF2 ! =?Di@ @T<DX C?9 ! @T<DX @TA@ VTA@

W?G C>> <D @T> =?QGH>D@C V> BO?\<=>=2 @T>

@OADCAQ@<?DAF =?QGH>D@C2 @T> PADX<D[ =?QGH>D@C <C

>\>OW@T<D[ @TA@ @T>O> <C9

.? VT>D W?G CA<= @OADCE>OC EO?H ?D> ?E @T>

>D@<@<>C ?VD>= PW @T> @OGC@ @? ?GO B>OC?DAF PADX

AQQ?GD@2 @TA@ V?GF= ?DFW TA\> TABB>D>= @TO?G[T A

QT>QX VO<@@>D @? HW V<E>9

Page 37: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 37/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WP

j9 &aAQ@FW9 ,D= VTA@ !iH V?D=>O<D[ <C2 <C

@T>O> A D?@> ?O AD >UHA<F ?O C?H>@T<D[ @TA@ =>CQO<P>C

@T> BGOB?C> E?O @T> @OADCE>Ol

,9 ! =?Di@ P>F<>\> @T>O> <C9

j9 :> O>Q><\>= @>a@ H>CCA[>C EO?H A B>O<?= ?E

@<H>2 O?G[TFW "?\>HP>O ?O C? ?E NKIN ?O HAWP>

3>POGAOW ?E NKIJ9

:>O> W?G APF> @? O>@O<>\> @>a@ H>CCA[>C

EO?H ?@T>O B>O<?=C ?E @<H>l

,9 :>FF2 ! V?GF= @T<DX @TA@ W?G O>Q><\>= @>a@

H>CCA[>C EO?H NKIN @TO?G[T @T> BO>C>D@ @<H>9 ! H>AD2

! =?Di@ XD?V VTW @T>W V?GF= TA\> QG@ ?EE >AOFW <D

NKIJ9 "?V2 HAWP> W?GiO> @AFX<D[ AP?G@ @T> BT?D>

O>Q?O=C9

j9 "?9 !iH @AFX<D[ AP?G@ @>a@ H>CCA[>C9 !iH

@AFX<D[ AP?G@ @>a@ H>CCA[>C9 ! =?Di@ P>F<>\> V> TA\>

ADW@T<D[ P>E?O> "?\>HP>O ?E NKIN ?O AE@>O 3>POGAOW ?E

NKIJ9

,9 ! QAD @>FF W?G @TA@ ! =?Di@ GD=>OC@AD= VTW

D?@9

j9 /XAW9 1?G V>O> APF> @? [>@ @T>Hl

,9 ! P>F<>\> UU W>AT2 ! P>F<>\> ! CAV >UHA<FC

@TA@ UU ?O @>a@ H>CCA[>C @TA@ V>O> QGOO>D@ @TO?G[T

@T> .GPB?>DA2 PG@2 ! H>AD2 @TA@iC VTA@ ! O>QAFF2 C? !

=?Di@ XD?V VTW W?G =?Di@ TA\> H?O> @>a@ H>CCA[>C9

Page 38: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 38/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WR

j9 ->@iC [? PAQX @? )ADGAOW ?E NKII9

(? W?G C@<FF TA\> @T> Q>FF BT?D>C @TA@ W?G

V>O> GC<D[ A@ @TA@ @<H>l

,9 "?9 "?9

j9 $TA@ V?GF= TA\> P>>D @T> (O?<= @TA@

QOACT>=l

,9 $TA@ QOACT>=2 W>AT9 $TA@ (O?<= QOACT>= <D

Y<AH< VT>D ! VAC ?D A @O<B @T>O>2 AD= ! P>F<>\> !

@GOD>= <@ <D AD= O>Q><\>= A D>V ?D> AD= O>Q?O=>= ?\>O

AFF ?E @T> <DE?OHA@<?D9

j9 ,D= @TA@ VAC <D @T> EAFF ?E iIIl

,9 3AFF ?E iII9

j9 .? @T> (O?<= @TA@ W?G C@<FF TA\> V?GF=

TA\> P>>D @T> ?D> W?G [?@ @? O>BFAQ> @TA@l

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@2 @V? W>AOC ?F= D?V9

j9 .? PAC<QAFFW2 W>AT2 <@ V?GF= TA\> [?D>

@TO?G[T @T> FAC@ H?D@T ?O @V? ?E NKII2 AFF ?E NKIN @?

VT>O> V> AO> <D iIJl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= W?GO GD=>OC@AD=<D[ <C @TA@ W?G

V>O> APF> @? [>@ @>a@ H>CCA[>C EO?H @TA@ BT?D> E?O AC

F?D[ AC W?Gi\> TA= <@l

,9 "?2 ! =?Di@ XD?V @TA@9 ! =?Di@ XD?V @TA@2

PG@ ! =? XD?V @TA@ AFF @T> @>a@ H>CCA[>C @TA@ ! TA\>

?D @TA@ BT?D> AO> BO?PAPFW A@ F>AC@ A W>AO ?F=2 PG@ !

Page 39: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 39/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

WS

=?Di@ XD?V T?V EAO PAQX <@ [?>C9 ! =?Di@ XD?V UU !

=?Di@ O>QAFF <E !2 W?G XD?V2 TA\> >OAC>= ADW ?E @T?C>

@>a@ H>CCA[>C GB GD@<F A Q>O@A<D AH?GD@ ?E @<H>

AVT<F> A[?9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 !@ V?GF=Di@ CGOBO<C> H>

<E ! =<=9

j9 /XAW9

,9 dG@ W?G CT?GF= TA\> UU <@iC BO?PAPFW P>>D

A W>AO UU AFH?C@ A W>AO C<DQ> !i\>2 W?G XD?V2 =>F>@>=

ADW @>a@ H>CCA[>C9

j9 :<@T O>CB>Q@ @? BT?D> O>Q?O=C D?V E?O W?GO

Q>FF BT?D>C UU

,9 *TUTGT mW>C;9

j9 UU V>O> W?G APF> UU T?V EAO PAQX V>O> W?G

APF> @? [? V<@T @T<C UU

,9 :>FF2 C? T>O>iC @T> @T<D[5 !i\> [?D> PAQX

AC EAO AC ! QAD [? PAQX ?DF<D>9 !D EAQ@2 !i\> @AFX>=

@? @T> 7>O<f?D C@?O>9 ! TA\> B>OC?DAF C>O\<Q>

@TO?G[T 7>O<f?D9 $T>Wi\> @?F= H> @TA@iC AC EAO PAQX

AC ! QAD [?2 AD= !i\> [<\>D @T?C> @? HW FAVW>OC9 !

@T<DX <@ [?>C PAQX A W>AO9

YW .@A@> AQQ?GD@ <C =<EE>O>D@9 ! TA\>Di@

=?D> HGQT @? @OW @? E<D= ?G@ VTA@ ! TA\> ?D HW .@A@>

AQQ?GD@9 .?2 E?O >aAHBF>2 VT>D ! O>BFAQ>= HW .@A@>

<6T?D>2 <@ VAC <D "?\>HP>O AE@>O @T> >F>Q@<?D9 !

=?Di@ XD?V VT>O> @TA@ BT?D> <C @TA@ ! TA= P>E?O>9

Page 40: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 40/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JU

.?H>?D> A@ !$ BO?PAPFW TAC <@ ?O TAC GC>= <@ ?O =?D>

C?H>@T<D[ V<@T <@9

dG@ AC EAO AC HW .@A@> BT?D>C2 ! TA\>Di@

W>@ O>Q?\>O>= @T> @>a@ H>CCA[>C ?D HW .@A@> BT?D>9

!iH @OW<D[ @? E<[GO> ?G@ T?V @? =? <@2 AD= !iH CGO> !

Q?GF= [>@ @TA@ =?D>9 ! cGC@ TA\>Di@ =?D> <@2 C? !

TA\> @>a@ H>CCA[>C QGOO>D@FW ?D HW .@A@> BT?D>9

j9 .GO>9 $T<C HAW P> A =<EE<QGF@ kG>C@<?D @?

ADCV>O2 PG@ QAD W?G =>CQO<P> T?V AD= VT>D W?G GC>

W?GO B>OC?DAF Q>FF BT?D> AC ?BB?C>= @? W?GO .@A@>

BT?D>l

,9 .<DQ> ! c?<D>= @T> ?EE<Q> <D (>Q>HP>O ?E

iKL2 !i\> @O<>= @? X<D= ?E =OAV A F<D> P>@V>>D .@A@>

PGC<D>CC AD= B>OC?DAF PGC<D>CC2 AD= C? ! @OW @? @AX>

AFF HW .@A@> QAFFC ?D HW .@A@> BT?D> AD= @? GC> HW

.@A@> BT?D> C<HBFW E?O .@A@> >UHA<F <CCG>C AD= HW

B>OC?DAF BT?D> E?O >\>OW@T<D[ >FC>9 $TA@iC VTW !

QAOOW @V? BT?D>C VT>O>\>O ! [?9

j9 .?2 E?O >aAHBF>2 V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? W?GO

QAHBA<[D2 V?GF= @TA@ TA\> P>>D ?D W?GO B>OC?DAF

BT?D>l

,9 1>AT9 ! V?GF= CAW LL AD= A TAFE B>OQ>D@

?E AFF HW QAFFC AD= >UHA<FC V>O> =?D> ?D HW B>OC?DAF

BT?D> \>OCGC HW .@A@> BT?D>9

j9 ,D= V?GF= @T> CAH> P> @OG> V<@T O>CB>Q@ @?

Page 41: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 41/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JT

Q?HHGD<QA@<?DC V<@T )>O>HW )?TDC?Dl

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 ,D= VTA@ AP?G@ )AC?D 6?V>OCl

,9 $TA@ <C Q?OO>Q@9 "?V2 @T>O> AO> BO?PAPFW

A E>V >UHA<FC VT>O> C?H>?D> HAWP> C>D@ H> AD >UHA<F

?D HW .@A@> AQQ?GD@ AD= ! O>BF<>= ?O C?H>@T<D[2 PG@

?@T>O @TAD @TA@2 W>AT2 @T> F<?DiC CTAO> ?E >\>OW@T<D[

<C =?D> B>OC?DAF ?O .@A@>9 ! @OW D?@ @? Q?HP<D> @T>

@V?9

$T> B?F<QW A@ @T> ?EE<Q> AFF?VC A

Q?HP<DA@<?D ?E @T?C>2 AD= H?C@ B>?BF> ! XD?V A@ @T>

?EE<Q> cGC@ TA\> ?D> BT?D> AD= ?D> Q?HBG@>O2 PG@ !i\>

@O<>= O>F<[<?GCFW ?D HW BT?D>C C<DQ> ! c?<D>= @T>

?EE<Q> @? X>>B @T> @V? C>BAOA@>2 AD= E?O A B>O<?= ?E

@<H> ?D HW Q?HBG@>OC ! =<= X>>B @T>H C>BAOA@> F<X>

H?C@ B>?BF>2 PG@ !i\> @O<>= <D @T> FAC@ W>AO @? X>>B

@T>H Q?HBF>@>FW C>BAOA@>9

j9 ,FF O<[T@9 (<= ..7 ?O !U,VAO> E<F> @Aa

O>@GODCl

,9 "?9

j9 (? W?G TA\> ADW UU AD= V> =? TA\> C?H>

@>a@ H>CCA[>C P>@V>>D W?G AD= ->> YQ+GFF?G[T9

(? W?G TA\> ADW ?@T>O Q?OO>CB?D=>DQ>2

VT>@T>O <@iC >UHA<F ?O F>@@>OC2 V<@T T<Hl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

Page 42: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 42/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JV

j9 "?@ @TA@ W?Gi\> C>>Dl

,9 "?@ @TA@ !i\> C>>D2 D?9 ! H>AD2 @TA@iC

kG<@> A PO?A= C@A@>H>D@2 C? F>@ H> HAX> CGO> !iH

AQQGOA@>9

,O> W?G @AFX<D[ AP?G@ C<DQ> @T> E<OC@ @<H>

! H>@ T<H @? @T> BO>C>D@ @<H>l ,O> W?G @AFX<D[ AP?G@

O>FA@<\> @? ADW BAO@<QGFAO @<H> EOAH>l

j9 :>FF2 VT>D =<= W?G E<OC@ H>>@ T<Hl

,9 ! P>F<>\> <@ VAC <D @T> EAFF ?E NKK`9

j9 ,D= ! D?@> @TA@ T> C>@ GB W?GO @OGC@C2

Q?OO>Q@2 AD= @T>D T> T>FB>= C>@ GB C?H> >D@<@<>C <D

W?GO @OGC@2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 '<[T@9 :T>D W?G CAW HW @OGC@2 !iH

ACCGH<D[ W?GiO> D?@ GC<D[ A F>[AF @>OH2 W?GiO> cGC@

O>E>O>DQ<D[ [>D>OAFFW UU

j9 !iH O>E>OO<D[ @? @T> .GB>O .>\>D $OGC@9

,9 '<[T@2 W>AT9

j9 3?O VT<QT W?G V>O> @T> [OAD@?Ol

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= W?G C>@ @TA@ GB2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 '<[T@9 ! H>AD2 E?O >aAHBF>2 T>

Q?OO>CB?D=>= V<@T HW A@@?OD>WC AD= HAW TA\>

Q?OO>CB?D=>= V<@T H> O>FA@<\> @? @T> E<F<D[ PW @T>

B>?BF> VT? PO?G[T@ @T> B>@<@<?D @? O>H?\> H> EO?H

?EE<Q>9 ! cGC@ Q?GF=Di@ CAW AC ! C<@ T>O> VT>@T>O !

Page 43: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 43/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JW

TA\> ADW@T<D[ O>FA@>= @? @TA@ <D HW >UHA<F AQQ?GD@C9

j9 (? W?G HA<D@A<D A QAF>D=AOl

,9 !iH O>AFFW A B??O QAF>D=AO HADA[>H>D@

B>OC?D9 ! =?Di@ UU ! =?Di@ O>@A<D A BTWC<QAF BAB>O

QAF>D=AO2 C? @T> ADCV>O <C HW C>QO>@AOW X>>BC A

QAF>D=AO E?O H> ?D HW ?EE<Q> <CCG>C2 AD= @T>D ! V<FF

BFG[ <D B>OC?DAF ABB?<D@H>D@C ?D ><@T>O HW (O?<=

BT?D> ?O ?D HW <6T?D>9

j9 (?>C W?GO ?EE<Q> CWC@>H GC> @T> /G@F??X

QAF>D=AO<D[ BO?[OAHl

,9 ! Q?GF=Di@ @>FF W?G9 ! QAD F??X9 %>O>iC

HW UU

Y'9 ."/:5 ! ACCGH>= W?Gi= F?C@ ?D> ?E

@T>H9

$%& :!$"&..5 $TA@iC A BO<\A@> c?X>9

/XAW9 +AD W?G @>FF H> VTA@ CWC@>H @TA@ <C

m<D=<QA@<D[;l

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; $TA@ F??XC F<X> /G@F??X @?

H>9

,9 !C <@ /G@F??Xl /XAW9 $TA@iC AFF X>B@ A@

@T> ?EE<Q>9

j9 (? W?G GC> Y<QO?C?E@ /EE<Q>l

,9 "?9 !iH ?D A YAQ<D@?CT CWC@>H9

j9 /XAW9 dG@ =? W?G GC> AD ?EE<Q> BO?=GQ@

E?O YAQ<D@?CT2 ?O <C <@ cGC@ @T> ,BBF> CWC@>Hl 1?G

Page 44: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 44/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JJ

=?Di@ XD?Vl

,9 8?CT2 ! O>AFFW Q?GF=Di@ @>FF W?G9

j9 :>FF2 <D ADW >\>D@2 @T> QAF>D=AO<D[ CWC@>H

W?G TA\> A@ V?OX <C AD >F>Q@O?D<Q QAF>D=AO<D[ UU

,9 !@ <C9

j9 UU CWC@>H2 ! @AX> <@l

,9 !@ <C9

j9 %?V EAO PAQX UU AD= =<= W?G C@AO@ GC<D[

@TA@ VT>D W?G P>[AD V?OX E?O @T> ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAFiC

?EE<Q> UU

,9 ! =<=9

j9 UU <D NKKLl

,9 ! =<=9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= CAH> CWC@>H C<DQ> @T>Dl

,9 1>C9

j9 /XAW9 (?>C @TA@ ?EE<Q> CWC@>H CWDQ V<@T

><@T>O ?E W?GO @V? Q>FF BT?D>Cl

,9 1>C2 <@ =?>C9

j9 (?>C <@ CWDQ V<@T P?@T ?E @T>Hl

,9 !@ CWDQC V<@T ?D> ?E @T>H2 HW <6T?D>9

j9 /XAW9 (? W?G TA\> A C>BAOA@> QAF>D=AO<D[

CWC@>H ?D W?GO (O?<= BT?D> @TA@iC E?O B>OC?DAF

<CCG>Cl

,9 ! =?2 AD= C?H>@<H>C ! GC> <@ AD= C?H>@<H>C

! =?Di@9 1?GiFF C>> !iFF TA\> ?D> ABB?<D@H>D@ <D A

Page 45: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 45/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JN

H?D@T2 PG@ ! D?OHAFFW @OW @? [? V<@T ?D> QAF>D=AO<D[

CWC@>H2 AD= C? <E ! TA\> A B>OC?DAF ABB?<D@H>D@2 !

V<FF D?OHAFFW BFG[ <@ <D @? HW .@A@> BT?D> AD= cGC@

[? ?EE @T> ?D> QAF>D=AO9

j9 (<= W?G TA\> A QAF>D=AO<D[ CWC@>H <D BFAQ>

=GO<D[ W?GO QAHBA<[D E?O ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAFl

,9 1>C2 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= VAC @TA@ UU T?V V>FF HA<D@A<D>= VAC

@TA@ QAF>D=AO<D[ CWC@>Hl

,9 !@ VAC \>OW V>FF HA<D@A<D>=9 !@ VAC

HA<D@A<D>= PW HW QAHBA<[D9

j9 ,D= VAC @TA@ CWDQ>= @? W?GO (O?<= BT?D>l

,9 ! P>F<>\> <@ VAC @? HW (O?<= BT?D>2 AD= <@

HAW TA\> P>>D CWDQ>= @? HW .@A@> BT?D>9 ! =?Di@

XD?V9

j9 (? W?G TA\> @T> QAF>D=AOC E?O @TA@ B>O<?=

?E @<H>l

,9 ! TA\> D?@ QT>QX>=9 +AHBA<[D QAF>D=AOC9

j9 ,D= !iH @T<DX<D[ NKII2 NKIN9

,9 ! QAD QT>QX V<@T HW QAHBA<[D B>?BF> AD=

C>> <E @T>Wi\> [?@ @TA@ AD= [>@ @TA@ BO?=GQ>=9

j9 ->@ H> HAX> CGO> ! GD=>OC@AD= VTA@ W?GO

PADX AQQ?GD@C AO>9

$T> PADX AQQ?GD@C @TA@ V>i\> UU @TA@ V>i\>

O>Q><\>=2 AQQ?GD@ <DE?OHA@<?D EO?H A c?<D@ AQQ?GD@

Page 46: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 46/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JO

V<@T W?G AD= W?GO V<E>l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 (? W?G TA\> H?O> @TAD ?D> AQQ?GD@2 A

B>OC?DAF AQQ?GD@l

,9 /D> c?<D@ AQQ?GD@l

j9 1>AT9

,9 ! HAW TA\> A CA\<D[C AQQ?GD@ AD= A c?<D@

AQQ?GD@2 PG@ <@ HAW P> UU HW V<E> TAD=F>C AFF @T>

E<DADQ>C E?O ?GO EAH<FW UU

j9 $TA@ VACDi@ HW kG>C@<?D9

,9 UU AD= CT>iC \>OW [??= A@ <@9 .T>iC \>OW

=>@A<F>= AP?G@ <@2 AD= CT> TAC A F?@ ?E CGPAQQ?GD@C9

.T> TAC A CGPAQQ?GD@ E?O ?GO H<CC<?DAOW2 CT> TAC A

CGPAQQ?GD@ E?O Q?FF>[> CA\<D[C2 CT> TAC A CGPAQQ?GD@

E?O T>O C>@@F>H>D@9 .T> TA= A B>OC?DAF <DcGOW <D A

C>@@F>H>D@ <D @TA@ AQQ?GD@9 $T>WiO> AFF @<>= <D@?

@T> CAH> P<[ AQQ?GD@2 PG@ CT> TAC @T?C> CGPAQQ?GD@C9

j9 ,O> @T>W AFF A@ @T> Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA

+O>=<@ *D<?Dl

,9 1>C2 AC ! GD=>OC@AD= <@9

j9 ,C EAO AC B>OC?DAF AQQ?GD@C W?G GC>2 <C <@

cGC@ ?D>l

,9 :>FF2 D?V9 ! H>AD2 ! =<= TA\> A B>OC?DAF

AQQ?GD@ A@ n<?DC dADX9 .VAFF?V S ,CC?Q<A@>C TA=

@T><O AQQ?GD@2 AD= ! TA= A B>OC?DAF )?TD .VAFF?V

Page 47: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 47/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JP

AQQ?GD@ AC V>FF2 AD= ! @T<DX ! BO?\<=>= W?G @T>

=?QGH>D@C ?D @TA@9

j9 ,O> @T?C> C@<FF ?B>Dl

,9 $T> )?TD .VAFF?V AQQ?GD@ <C D?@ ?B>D2 AD=2

D?2 @T> .VAFF?V S ,CC?Q<A@>C AQQ?GD@ <C D? F?D[>O

?B>D ><@T>O9

j9 :> AFC? TA\> AQQ?GD@C UU ?@T>O @TAD W?GO

<D=<\<=GAF2 W?GO c?<D@ AQQ?GD@ V<@T W?GO V<E>2 V>

TA\> AD AQQ?GD@ E?O ..7 YADA[>H>D@2 E?O 6U.?FG@<?DC

AD= E?O !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C9

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 ,O> @T>O> ADW ?@T>O AQQ?GD@C @TA@ W?G TA\>

AQQ>CC @? ?O C<[DA@GO> AG@T?O<@W E?Ol

,9 $T> ?DFW ?@T>O AQQ?GD@ <C AD & $OA=>

AQQ?GD@9 $TA@iC ?GO <D\>C@H>D@ AQQ?GD@2 AD= <@iC

cGC@ UU <@iC cGC@ A QACT AQQ?GD@ @TA@ E>>=C <D@?

HW UU ?GO <D\>C@H>D@C V<@T & $OA=>2 AD= V>i\> cGC@

V<@T=OAVD AP?G@ AFF ?E @TA@9

j9 !@iC A PO?X>OA[> AQQ?GD@2 ! @AX> <@l

,9 dO?X>OA[> AQQ?GD@2 W>C9

j9 ,D= =?>C @T> AQQ?GD@ UU <C <@ cGC@ QACT ?O

AO> @T>O> C>QGO<@<>C AC V>FFl

,9 :>FF2 @T>O> AO> C>QGO<@<>C <D AD !',2 AD=

@T>O> AO> UU ! @T<DX @T>O>iC A \>OW2 \>OW H<D<HAF

PAFADQ> ?@T>O @TAD @TA@9

Page 48: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 48/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JR

j9 :T?C> !', <C <@l

,9 $T>O>iC ?D> E?O HW V<E>2 @T>O>iC ?D> E?O

H> UU @T>O> AO> @V? E?O H>2 ! @T<DX2 AD= ?D> E?O HW

V<E>9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VT?iC @T> HADA[>O ?E @T?C>

!',Cl

,9 ! @T<DX <@iC H>9 !@ Q?GF= P> HW V<E> AD=

H>9

j9 !C @T>O> A Q?HBADW @TA@ UU F<X> !i\> [?@

AD !', UU

,9 & $OA=>9

j9 & $OA=>l

,9 & $OA=>9

j9 ! P>F<>\> @T> QO>=<@ QAO= C@A@>H>D@C V>

TA\> E?O W?G <C A (<CQ?\>O +AO=l

,9 1>C9

j9 ,D= @TA@iC AFF !iH O>QAFF<D[9

!C @T>O> ADW ?@T>O QO>=<@ QAO= W?G TA\>l

,9 ! @T<DX @TA@iC AFF V> GC>9 :> HAW TA\>

AD?@T>O QAO= AQQ?GD@9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX V> =? ADWH?O>9

:> Q?DC?F<=A@>=9 :> TA= A %?H> (>B?@ QAO= V> [?@ O<=

?E2 AD= ! @T<DX CT> TAC A =>P<@ QAO= @TA@iC ?D ?GO

B>OC?DAF PADX AQQ?GD@ A@ @T> QO>=<@ GD<?D2 PG@ !

P>F<>\> @T?C> AO> @T> ?DFW @V? QAO=C V> QAOOW9

j9 (? W?G TA\> A B>OC?DAF =>P<@ QAO= AC V>FFl

Page 49: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 49/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

JS

,9 $TA@iC T??X>= <D@? Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA +O>=<@

*D<?D2 ! @T<DX C?9 1>AT2 ! =?9 ! QAOOW @TA@ <D HW

VAFF>@9

j9 ,D= VTA@ AP?G@ ADW X<D= ?E V?OX QO>=<@

QAO=l (? W?G TA\> A Q?OB?OA@> UU

,9 ! =?9

j9 UU ,H>O<QAD &aBO>CC ?O C?H>@T<D[l

,9 ! TA\> A Q?GBF> ?E .@A@> <CCG>= QO>=<@

QAO=C9 /D> <C A BGOQTAC<D[ QAO=2 AD= @T>O> VAC

AD?@T>O QO>=<@ QAO= @TA@ ! QAD GC> ?D @O<BC AD=

@T<D[C AD= P> O><HPGOC>= E?O9

j9 ,D= VTA@ X<D=C ?E QAO=C AO> @T?C>l

,9 7<CA9 $T>WiO> P?@T .@A@> 7<CA QAO=C9 /D>

! QAD BG@ UU V>FF2 AQ@GAFFW2 ! cGC@ [?@ A EG>F QAO=

AC V>FF9

j9 ,D= <C @TA@ A .@A@> <CCG>= QAO=l

,9 !@iC A .@A@> <CCG>= QAO= ?D @T><O EF>>@

CWC@>H2 AD= ! ?DFW GC> @T?C> QAO=C E?O .@A@> <CCG>C2

.@A@> BGOQTAC>C9

j9 (? W?G TA\> AD >aB>DC> AQQ?GD@ A@ V?OXl

,9 "?9

j9 :TA@ AP?G@ @T> QAHBA<[D2 =<= W?G TA\> A

C>BAOA@> QAO= E?O @TA@l

,9 ! TA\> A 3O<>D=C ?E )?TD .VAFF?V QO>=<@

QAO=2 ?O =>P<@ QAO=2 @TA@ ! HAWP> GC>= @V<Q> C<DQ>

Page 50: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 50/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NU

@T> QAHBA<[D9 ! TA= <@ =GO<D[ @T> QAHBA<[D2 PG@ !

OAO>FW GC>= <@ P>QAGC> HW QAHBA<[D C@AEE VAC AFVAWC

V<@T H> AD= @T>Wi= AFVAWC BAW E?O H>AFC2 EGD=OA<C>O

H>AFC ?O Q?DC@<@G>D@ H>AFC ?O ADW@T<D[ >FC> V> TA=

Q?DQ>OD<D[ @T> QAHBA<[D2 ?O A T?@>F O??H <E V> TA= @?

[? @? .@9 8>?O[> AD= C@AW ?O C?H>@T<D[2 AD= @T>D

@?VAO=C @T> >D= ?E @T> QAHBA<[D @T>W AFC? TA= C?H>

BO>BA<= =>P<@ QAO=C @TO?G[T 8O>>D (?@2 AD= @TA@iC

VTA@ @T> QAHBA<[D GC>=9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VT>O> @T> AQQ?GD@ <DE?OHA@<?D

?D @T> QAHBA<[D QAO=C <C C@?O>=l

,9 $TA@ V?GF= P> @TO?G[T HW QAHBA<[D

@O>ACGO>O2 VT? <C DAH>= +?OW +TGD[ ?O +TGD2 AD= ! QAD

[>@ W?G T>O DAH> AD= T>O DGHP>O9

j9 /XAW9

,9 .T>iC A BO?E>CC<?DAF @O>ACGO>O2 AD= CT> <C

@T> B>OC?D VT? =<= AFF ?E ?GO AQQ?GD@<D[ V?OX2

O>Q><\>= AFF @T> EGD=OA<C<D[ QT>QXC AD= AG@T?O<f>=

AFF @T> UU V>FF2 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E CT> AG@T?O<f>=

>aB>D=<@GO>C2 PG@ Q>O@A<DFW OAD @T> >aB>D=<@GO>C ?E

?GO QAHBA<[D9

j9 /XAW9 1?G H>D@<?D>= A ">@.B>D= =>P<@

QAO=9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 $>FF H> @T> ?O<[<D ?E @TA@9

Page 51: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 51/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NT

,9 /XAW9 :>FF2 <D @T> CBO<D[ ?E NKII2 AC !

O>QAFF2 ! C?F= C?H> [?F= Q?<DC @? '<QTAO= 'AVF>2 AD=

T>2 <D Q?DC<=>OA@<?D ?E @T> CAF> ?E @T?C> Q?<DC2

F?A=>= @T> CAF>C BO<Q> ?D A ">@.B>D= QAO=

B>O<?=<QAFFW AC ! V?GF= [<\> T<H A Q?<D ?O A E>V

Q?<DC2 AD= @T>D T> V?GF= F?A= @TA@ AH?GD@2 @T> \AFG>

?E @TA@2 ?D A BO>BA<= =>P<@ QAO=9 !@iC @<>= <D @? HW

.?Q<AF .>QGO<@W DGHP>O9 !@ VAC cGC@ AFF C@OA<[T@ GB9

j9 %?V HADW Q?<DC =<= W?G C>FF @? T<Hl

,9 ! C?F= T<H IN Q?<DC2 ! P>F<>\>9

j9 ,D= @>FF H> AP?G@ @T>C> Q?<DC9 %?V =<=

W?G [>@ @T>Hl :TA@ X<D= ?E Q?<DC V>O> @T>Wl

,9 :>FF2 T> [A\> @T>H @? H> P>E?O> ! c?<D>=

@T> ,8iC ?EE<Q>2 AD= AF?D[ AP?G@ @V? W>AOC FA@>O ?O

@V? AD= A TAFE W>AOC FA@>O2 VT>D ! VAD@>= @? TA\> A

F<@@F> P<@ ?E >a@OA >aB>DC> H?D>W2 ! @AFX>= @?

+?O@ :AFX>O2 AD= ! CA<= VT>O> =? ! C>FF @T>C> Q?<DC2

AD= T> CA<=2 V>FF2 W?G QAD [? @? A Q?<D CT?B ?O cGC@

[? @? '<QTAO=2 HAWP> T>iFF PGW @T>H EO?H H>9

%>i= [<\>D @T>H @? H>9 !@ VAC A F<@@F>

AVXVAO=2 PG@ ! V>D@ @? T<H9 ! CA<= !iH @OW<D[ @?

C>FF @T>C> Q?<DC9 %> CA<= !i= P> TABBW @? PGW @T>H

PAQX EO?H W?G9 %>i= [<\>D @T>H @? H>2 AD= C? ! C?F=

@T>H @? T<H9

j9 ,D= VTW =<= T> [<\> @T>H @? W?Gl

Page 52: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 52/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NV

,9 %> [A\> @T>H @? H> cGC@ AC A [<E@2 W?G

XD?V2 <D NKK` AD= iL ?O NKKL P>E?O> ! F>E@ T<C

>HBF?WH>D@9

j9 .? <@ VAC F<X> @T> [?F= VA@QT W?G [>@

P>E?O> W?G H?\> ?D @? A D>V c?P ?O C?H>@T<D[ F<X>

@TA@l

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 !@ VAC O>AFFW D<Q>9 !

O>AFFW ABBO>Q<A@>= @TA@9

j9 ,D= VTA@ X<D=C ?E Q?<DC V>O> @T>Wl :>O>

@T>W ,H>O<QAD QGOO>DQW2 C?H>2 W?G XD?V2 [?F= PF??HCl

,9 "?9 ! @T<DX @T>W V>O> UU AC ! O>QAFF2 !

Q?GF=Di@ @>FF <E @T>W V>O> +ADA=<AD HABF> F>A\>C ?O

<E @T>W V>O> UU !iH D?@ A Q?<D B>OC?D2 PG@ @T>W V>O>

?D> ?GDQ> BGO> [?F= Q?<DC2 AD= @T>O> V>O> IN ?E @T>H9

j9 .? IN ?GDQ>Cl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= VT>D T> P?G[T@ @T>H PAQX2 VT>D =<= T>

PGW @T>H PAQXl

,9 :>FF2 T> P?G[T@ @T>H PAQX ?\>O A B>O<?= ?E

@<H>2 PG@ ! @T<DX V> C>@@F>= ?D A BO<Q> ?E hIJKK AD

?GDQ> ?O C?2 AD= VTA@ ! V?GF= =? <C ! V?GF= [<\> @T>H

@? T<H B>O<?=<QAFFW AC T> V?GF= F?A= H?O> H?D>W ?D

@T> QAO=2 C? AC ! UU AC ! V>D@ @? T<H AD= CA<= !i=

F<X> @? C>FF A Q?GBF> ?E Q?<DC2 ?O A Q?<D2 @T>D T>

V?GF= F?A= H?O> ?E @T> UU H?O> H?D>W ?D @T> QAO=2 AD=

Page 53: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 53/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NW

! V?GF= cGC@ GC> @TA@ QAO= AC ! V?GF= A O>[GFAO =>P<@

QAO=2 BG@ [AC <D HW QAO2 [? @? FGDQT2 PGW A [<E@2 W?G

XD?V2 [? ?D A @O<B2 @T?C> X<D=C ?E @T<D[C9

j9 :TW VAC @TA@ @T> H>QTAD<CH ?E >aQTAD[>2

@T<C BO>F?A=>= =>P<@ QAO=2 AC ?BB?C>= @? A QT>QX ?O A

V<O> ?O UU

,9 :>FF2 T> Q?GF= TA\> =?D> @T> ?@T>O VAW9 !

@T<DX @T> O>AC?D VAC <C P>QAGC> ! =<=Di@ XD?V T?V

HGQT [?F= ! VAD@>= @? C>FF2 AD= C? <@ VAC X<D= ?E

A UU X<D= ?E A BO?[O>CC<\> @T<D[2 AD= T> CG[[>C@>=2

W?G XD?V2 ! QAD BAW W?G A QT>QX ?O ! QAD cGC@ BG@ <@

?D A QAO=2 AD= ! F<X>= @T> @T?G[T@ ?E A QAO= @TA@ !

Q?GF= cGC@ @AX> @? A [AC C@A@<?D AD= BFG[ <@ <D AD=

PGW [AC ?O [? @? A C@?O> AD= GC> A QAO=2 AD= @TA@iC

VTW <@ VAC9

j9 :AC @T> ">@.B>D= QAO= W?G TA=2 VAC @TA@

C?H>@T<D[ @TA@ W?G TA= VT<F> W?G V>O> V?OX<D[ V<@T

'<QTAO= 'AVF> P>E?O> W?G V>D@ @? @T> ,8iC ?EE<Q>l

,9 "?2 <@ VACDi@9

j9 (<= W?G TA\> ADW X<D= ?E AD >aB>DC>

AQQ?GD@ VT<F> W?G V>O> V?OX<D[ V<@T T<Hl

,9 ! =<=9

j9 dG@ D?@ @T> ">@.B>D= QAO=l

,9 "?9 !@ VAC cGC@ A O>[GFAO ,H>O<QAD

&aBO>CC QAO=2 AD= ! Q>O@A<DFW UU <E ! TA= Q?HBADW

Page 54: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 54/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NJ

O>FA@>= >aB>DC>C2 @T>D ! V?GF= Q>O@A<DFW @GOD <D A

O>Q><B@9 $T>D @T>W V?GF= BAW @T> P<FF9

j9 :T>O> =<= W?G X>>B W?GO [?F= Q?<DCl

,9 ! X>B@ @T>H <D HW CAE> A@ T?H>9

j9 .? T> [A\> @T>H @? W?G cGC@ UU AC W?G

VAD@>= @? C>FF ?D>2 W?Gi= @AX> ?D> ?G@2 W?Gi= [<\> <@

@? T<H2 T>i= F?A= @T> H?D>W ?D W?GO QAO= UU

,9 !@ VAC GCGAFFW @V? ?O @TO>> A@ A @<H>9 !@

BO?PAPFW TABB>D>= @TO>> ?O E?GO @<H>C ?\>O @T> Q?GOC>

?E D<D> H?D@TC9

j9 ,D= =<= W?G GF@<HA@>FW C>FF AFF ?E @T>H ?O

=? W?G C@<FF TA\> C?H> F>E@l

,9 "?9 ! C?F= @T>H AFF9

j9 +AD W?G O>QAFF @T> @<H> B>O<?= =GO<D[

VT<QT W?G C?F= @T>Hl

,9 !@ V?GF= TA\> P>>D BO?PAPFW )GFWU<CT ?E

iII BO?PAPFW @TO?G[T 3>POGAOW ?O YAOQT ?E iIN2 AC !

O>QAFF9

j9 (? W?G O>H>HP>O @T> @?@AF Q?DC<=>OA@<?Dl

,9 !@ VAC AO?GD= hI^2KKK ?O hI_2KKK9 !@ VAC

@T> \AFG> ?E @T> Q?<DC9

j9 ,D= UU

,9 ->CC AP?G@ IK B>OQ>D@2 P>QAGC> ! @T<DX @T>

\AFG> ?E @T> Q?<DC VAC H?O> @TAD VTA@ T> BA<= E?O

@T>H P>QAGC> T>iC <D @T> PGC<D>CC ?E PGW<D[ Q?<DC E?O

Page 55: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 55/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NN

A F<@@F> F>CC @TAD T> C>FFC @T>H E?O2 AD= ! VAD@>= @?

P> T?D>C@ V<@T T<H AP?G@ @TA@9

j9 "?@ P><D[ AD AQQ?GD@AD@2 !iH D?@ CGO> VTA@

@T> @Aa Q?DC>kG>DQ> ?E @T<C <C2 PG@ =<= W?G Q?DC<=>O

ADW @Aa Q?DC>kG>DQ> ?E ><@T>O @T> [<E@ ?E @T> [?F=

Q?<DC ?O @T> CAF> ?E @T>Hl

,9 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= =<= W?G Q?DCGF@ V<@T AD AQQ?GD@AD@

AP?G@ @TA@l

,9 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= @>FF H> VTA@ W?G F>AOD>=9

,9 :>FF2 ! BA<= A QAB<@AF [A<DC ?D @T> Q?<DC

VT>D ! C?F= @T>H9 ! @T<DX ! BG@ @T>H AFF <D @T>

NKIN W>AO2 >\>D @T?G[T ! C?F= C?H> =GO<D[ @T> FAC@

BAO@ ?E NKII2 ?O @T> H<= BAO@ ?O FAC@ BAO@2 PG@ !

<DQFG=>= @T>H ?D HW NKIN @Aa O>@GODC9

j9 !@ VAC @T> CAF> @TA@ W?G UU

,9 $T> CAF>2 O<[T@9 ,C ! GD=>OC@AD= EO?H

@AFX<D[ @? HW AQQ?GD@AD@2 <@iC @T> CAF>9 $T> [<E@ <C

?D @T> [<\>O <E @T>W [<\> H?O> @TAD A Q>O@A<D AH?GD@

<D A W>AO9 $T> CAF> <C ?D @T> QAB<@AF [A<DC9

j9 !i= F<X> @? CV<@QT [>AOC A F<@@F> P<@ AD=

ACX W?G UU PW @T> VAW2 <E W?G D>>= @? @AX> A PO>AX A@

ADW @<H>2 cGC@ F>@ H> XD?V9

,9 (? V> D>>= @? @AX> A PO>AXl

Page 56: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 56/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NO

Y'9 ."/:5 8? AT>A=9

$%& :!$"&..5 :>iO> ?XAW9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ! GD=>OC@AD= @TA@ W?G

B>OE?OH>= C?H> V?OX ?D A Q>H>D@ Q?HBADW <D ">\A=A9

,9 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= !i\> P>>D @?F= @TA@ @T> DAH> ?E @TA@

<C +TABAOOAF9

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 $>FF H> @T> Q<OQGHC@ADQ>C GD=>O VT<QT W?G

E<OC@ P>QAH> <D\?F\>= <D @TA@9

,9 :>FF2 <@iC TAO= @? O>H>HP>O VT>D ! E<OC@

VAC @?F= PW '<QTAO= AP?G@ T<C <D@>O>C@ <D @T> Q>H>D@

BO?c>Q@9 ! VAD@ @? CAW <@ VAC >\>D P>E?O> ! F>E@ T<C

>HBF?WH>D@ AC [>D>OAF Q?GDC>F2 AD= ! O>H>HP>O A

Q?D\>OCA@<?D ! TA= V<@T T<H AP?G@ @T> BO<Q> ?E [?F=2

?O @T> BO<Q> ?E Q>H>D@ <D Y>a<Q? AD= T?V T> TA= AD

<=>A V<@T A Q?GBF> ?E EO<>D=C ?E T<C @? E<D= A kGAOOW

<D ">\A=A AD= HAWP> [>@ A VAW @? BO?\<=> Q>H>D@ UU

F<H>C@?D> AD= QO>A@> Q>H>D@ @? -AC 7>[AC9 %> VAC

\>OW <D@O<[G>= PW @TA@9 $T<C EO<>D= ?E T<C TA=

AQ@GAFFW2 ! @T<DX2 =?D> @TA@ P>E?O> V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? A

=<EE>O>D@ H<D>OAF2 CAD= ?O C?H>@T<D[2 <D @T> $??>F>

AO>A2 AD= C? B>O<?=<QAFFW ?\>O @T> Q?GOC> ?E @T> D>a@

C>\>OAF H?D@TC AE@>O ! F>E@ T<C >HBF?WH>D@ T> V?GF=

GB=A@> H> AD= CAW V>iO> H?\<D[ E?OVAO= AD= @T<D[C AO>

Page 57: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 57/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NP

F??X<D[ [??=2 AD= ! VAC QGO<?GC9

.?H>@<H> <D @T> FA@> CGHH>O ?O >AOFW EAFF2

,G[GC@ ?O C? @<H> EOAH>2 ?E NKIK2 C? !i= P>>D V<@T

@T> ,8iC ?EE<Q> AP?G@ ><[T@ H?D@TC2 V> V>O> A@ FGDQT2

AD= T> CA<= !i= F<X> @? TA\> W?G T>FB H> ?D @T<C

BO?c>Q@9 !@iC [>@@<D[ H?O> C>O<?GC9 %> CA<= VTA@

!i= F<X> W?G @? =? <C O>AFFW P> <D\?F\>= ?D @T>

B?F<@<QAF C<=> V<@T @T> 6A<G@> !D=<AD @O<P> <@ @GODC

?G@ <D Y?ABA 7AFF>W2 ">\A=A2 VT>O> ! BFAW>= PAC>PAFF

AC A P?W2 AD= ! VAC \>OW <D@>O>C@>= AD= CA<= VTA@ QAD

! =? @? T>FB2 AD= C? T> VAD@>= H> @? [>@ GB @? CB>>=

?D @T> BO?Q>CC AD= @T> HAOX>@<D[ AD= VTA@ V?GF= HAX>

<@ \AFGAPF> <D BO>BAOA@<?D E?O H> TA\<D[ A

O>CB?DC<P<F<@W V<@T T<H <D @OW<D[ @? ?B>D GB =??OC @?

@T> 6A<G@> !D=<AD @O<P>2 P>QAGC> ! [G>CC BAO@ ?E @T>

=>B?C<@>= F<H>C@?D>2 BAO@ ?E @T> H?GD@A<D AQ@GAFFW

V>D@ <D@? @T> O>C>O\A@<?D AO>A2 AD= @T>W @T?G[T@ @TA@

<E @T>W Q?GF= [>@ H?O> ?E @T> FAD= AD= H?O> ?E @T>

=>B?C<@2 @T>D <@ V?GF= P> A P<[[>O BO?c>Q@ AD= V?GF=

C>FF E?O H?O>9 $T> BFAD VAC @? =>\>F?B <@2 [>@

B>OH<@C AD= @T>D C>FF <@ ?EE @? A P<[ Q?HBADW2 A P<[

Q>H>D@ HADGEAQ@GO>O2 AD= @T>D @GOD <@ AD= HAX> A F?@

?E H?D>W9

j9 ,D= =? W?G XD?V VTW <@ VAC @TA@ QAGC>=

'<QTAO= 'AVF> @? @GOD @? W?G E?O @T<Cl (<= W?G TA\>

Page 58: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 58/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NR

C?H> !D=<AD >aB>O<>DQ> ?O Q?DD>Q@<?DC ?O C?H>@T<D[l

,9 ! @T<DX UU ! @T<DX @TA@ UU EOADXFW2 !

@T<DX @TA@ T> XD>V ! VAC B?F<@<QAFFW Q?DD>Q@>=9 !

@T<DX T> @OGC@>= H>2 AD= ! @T<DX T> VAD@>=

<D\?F\>H>D@ <D C?H>@T<D[ @TA@ Q?GF= P> P>D>E<Q<AF @?

H> AD= @? T<H9

j9 :TA@ B?F<@<QAF Q?DD>Q@<?DC =<= W?G TA\>

@TA@ V>O> O>F>\AD@ @? @T<C ACC<[DH>D@l

,9 :>FF2 ! @T<DX T> UU EO?H ?GO =<CQGCC<?DC2

T> E>F@ F<X> ! GD=>OC@??= @T> FAW ?E @T> FAD=

B?F<@<QAFFW9 :T>D ! CAW gB?F<@<QAFFW2g ! =?Di@

D>Q>CCAO<FW H>AD '>BGPF<QADZ(>H?QOA@9 ! H>AD @TA@

@T<C 6A<G@> @O<P> ?P\<?GCFW VAC <D\?F\>= B?F<@<QAFFW

DA@<?DAFFW2 AD= ! @T<DX @TA@ T> E>F@ F<X> ! V?GF= P>

A [??= B>OC?D @? =>\>F?B A O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T @T>

@O<P> cGC@ V<@T HW >aB>O<>DQ> <D B?F<@<QC9

! AFC? TA= @?F= T<H ! @T<DX >AOF<>O @TA@ !

TA= A [??= EO<>D= VT? VAC @T> [>D>OAF Q?GDC>F E?O @T>

-AC 7>[AC 6A<G@> @O<P>2 C? ! @T<DX A E>V ?E @T?C>

O>FA@<?DCT<BC V>O> @T<D[C @TA@ T> @T?G[T@ Q?GF= P>

T>FBEGF @? T<H2 AD= ! AFC? P>F<>\> A@ C?H> B?<D@ !i\>

T>AO=2 AD= ! =?Di@ XD?V <E ! O>H>HP>O A@ @T> @<H>2

@TA@ T> VAC [>@@<D[ C<QX2 AD= T> =<=Di@ E>>F F<X> T>

Q?GF= =? AFF @T> V?OX @TA@ T> E>F@ F<X> T> D>>=>= @?

=? ?D T<C >D= V<@T T<C BAO@D>OC ?D T<C ?VD2 C? T>

Page 59: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 59/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

NS

VAD@>= @? [>@ C?H>?D> <D\?F\>= @TA@ T> @OGC@>=2 AD= !

@T<DX ! VAC @TA@ B>OC?D9

j9 ,D= T> @OGC@>= W?G ! BO>CGH> P>QAGC> ?E

W?GO T<C@?O<QAF O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T T<Hl

,9 ! V?GF= ACCGH> C?2 W>AT9

j9 /XAW9 .? cGC@ @? HAX> CGO> !i\> [?@ @T>

QTO?D?F?[W T>O>2 C?H>@<H> <D NKKL T> P>[AD @AFX<D[

AP?G@ @T<C BO?c>Q@2 AD= @T>D C?H> @<H> FA@>O <D NKIK

T> ACX>= W?G @? P>Q?H> <D\?F\>= V<@T <@l

,9 $TA@iC HW UU @TA@iC HW O>Q?FF>Q@<?D9

j9 $T> BAO@ @TA@ ?QQGOO>= <D NKIK VT>O> T>

ACX>= W?G @? P>Q?H> <D\?F\>= V<@T <@2 =<= W?G >D@>O

<D@? C?H> X<D= ?E A Q?D@OAQ@ ?O E?OHAF<f> W?GO O?F>

<D C?H> VAWl

,9 1?G XD?V2 V> =<=Di@2 AD= '<QTAO= VAC @TA@

VAW9 %> VAC H?O> ?E A TAD=CTAX> B>OC?D9

j9 !D W?GO H<D=2 =<= @T>O> Q?H> A B?<D@ <D

@<H> VT>D @T<C BO?c>Q@ @GOD>= EO?H C?H>@T<D[ AP?G@

VTA@ W?G V>O> T>AO<D[ E?O <DE?OHA@<?D BGOB?C>C ?DFW

@? C?H>@T<D[ VT>O> W?G V>O> [?<D[ @? AQ@GAFFW P>

V?OX<D[ ?D <@l

,9 1>AT9

j9 ,D= @TA@ VAC <D UU

,9 $TA@ V?GF= TA\> P>>D <D @T> EAFF ?E NKIK9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= =? W?G ACC?Q<A@> @TA@ QTAD[> @?

Page 60: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 60/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OU

A H>>@<D[2 A Q?D\>OCA@<?D ?O C?H> ?@T>O >\>D@l

,9 ! QADi@ BG@ HW E<D[>O ?D @T> >aAQ@

Q?D\>OCA@<?D2 PG@ <@ VAC A Q?D\>OCA@<?D V> TA= VT>O>

T> ACX>= H> @? [>@ <D\?F\>=2 AD= T> ACX>= H> @? [>@

<D\?F\>= @? @T> F>\>F VT>O> T> CA<= <E V> QAD HAX>

@T<C V?OX AD= V> QAD [>@ @T> 6A<G@>C <D\?F\>=2 !i=

F<X> @? [<\> W?G A B<>Q> ?E VTA@>\>O <@ <C @TA@ HW

B>OQ>D@A[> V?GF= [<\> H> <D @T> Q?HBADW9

j9 .? BAO@ ?E T<C >kG<@W CTAO>2 BAO@ ?E @TA@

T> V?GF= [<\> @? W?Gl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 !D >aQTAD[> E?O VTA@l 3?O W?GO

C>O\<Q>Cl

,9 3?O HW C>O\<Q>C9

j9 ,D= T?V UU V>FF2 W?Gi\> @?F= H> @TA@ @T>O>

VACDi@ A Q?D@OAQ@9

:>O> @T>O> @>OHC @TA@ W?G =<CQGCC>= V<@T

ADW H?O> CB>Q<E<Q<@W @TAD W?G H<[T@ [>@ A B<>Q> ?E

@T> >kG<@Wl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E @TA@iC A FAG[T ?O <E

@TA@iC A UU

Y'9 ."/:5 $TA@iC A Q?G[T9

$%& :!$"&..5 , Q?G[T2 ?XAW9

,Q@GAFFW2 D?9 $TA@ HAW C>>H O<=<QGF?GC2

PG@2 D?2 @T>O> VAC D?@ UU @T>O> V>O>Di@ @>OHC9 %>

Page 61: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 61/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OT

=<=Di@ BO?H<C> H> @>D B>OQ>D@ ?O @TO>> B>OQ>D@ ?O

E<\> B>OQ>D@9 ! E>F@ F<X> T>i= P> [>D>O?GC2 AD= !

E>F@ F<X> ! VAD@>= @? T>FB T<H2 AD= ! E>F@ @TA@ @T>O>

VAC >D?G[T BO?H<C> @TA@ ! =>Q<=>= @TA@ <@ V?GF= P>

[??= @? E?OH A Q?HBADW @TA@ V?GF= P> ?VD>= PW HW

EAH<FWiC @OGC@2 6U.?FG@<?DC2 @? T?F= @T> <D@>O>C@

@TA@ ! V?GF= B>OE?OH @T> C>O\<Q>C @TO?G[T9 $TA@ VAC

VTW ! E?OH>= 6U.?FG@<?DC <D @T> EAFF ?E NKIK9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 :TA@ !iH

GD=>OC@AD=<D[ <C W?G =<=Di@ C<@ =?VD AD= E?OHAF<f> A

CB>Q<E<Q B>OQ>D@A[> ?E >kG<@W @TA@ W?G O>Q><\>=l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 dG@ VAC <@ QF>AO <D W?GO H<D= @TA@ T>

<D@>D=>= AD= W?G <D@>D=>= @TA@ <E @T<C BO?c>Q@ P>QAH>

CGQQ>CCEGF W?G V?GF= O>Q><\> A B<>Q> ?E @T> >kG<@Wl

,9 /DFW @? @T> >a@>D@ @TA@ @T> C>O\<Q>C !

BO?\<=>= A==>= \AFG> @? @T> BO?B>O@W2 C? HW

GD=>OC@AD=<D[ VAC @TA@ <E ! Q?GF=Di@2 E?O >aAHBF>2

T>FB @T> 6A<G@>C ?B>D GB AD= =? A c?<D@ \>D@GO> V<@T

'<QTAO=iC Q?HBADW2 +TABAOOAF Q?HBADW2 @TA@ ! V?GF=Di@

P> O>Q><\<D[ A B>OQ>D@A[> ?E @T> Q?HBADW9

.? @T>O> VAC O<CX @T>O> E?O H> AC V>FF2

AD=2 AFC?2 ! X<D= ?E E>F@ F<X> @T> AH?GD@ @TA@ !

V?GF= O>Q><\> V?GF= =>B>D= ?D @T> F>\>F ?E HW

Q?D@O<PG@<?D <D @>OHC ?E @T> <HBAQ@ ?E VTA@ ! VAC

Page 62: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 62/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OV

=?<D[2 C? UU

j9 $TA@ VAC W?GO GD=>OC@AD=<D[l

,9 $TA@ VAC HW GD=>OC@AD=<D[9 $TA@ <C VTW V>

=<=Di@ O>AFFW Q?H> GB V<@T A DGHP>O2 D?O =<= ! BGCT

T<H E?O A DGHP>O2 D?O =<= T> ?EE>O A DGHP>O9

j9 %?V =<= W?GO C>O\<Q>C @GOD EO?H A

B?@>D@<AF >kG<@W Q?D@O<PG@<?D @? AD T?GOFW E>>l

,9 :>FF2 @TA@iC A \>OW [??= kG>C@<?D9

!@iC P>>D A F?D[ @<H>2 PG@ AF?D[ AP?G@

/Q@?P>O UU H<==F> ?E /Q@?P>O ?O >AOFW "?\>HP>O UU

j9 :T<QT W>AOl

,9 UU ?E NKIK9 NKIK9 $T>O> VAC X<D= ?E A

Q?D@>HB?OAD>?GC BO?c>Q@ @TA@ '<QTAO= VAC V?OX<D[ ?D

V<@T )>O>HW )?TDC?D9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E W?G XD?V @TA@9

1?G BO?PAPFW =? XD?V @TA@9

j9 $T<C <C @T> F?PPW<D[ >EE?O@l

,9 $T> F?PPW<D[ >EE?O@2 O<[T@9

j9 /XAW9

,9 .? '<QTAO= CG[[>C@>= @? H> @TA@ <E @TA@

F?PPW >EE?O@ VAC [?<D[ @? V?OX ?G@2 @TA@ ! H<[T@ P>

BA<= E?O @TA@2 AD= ! CA<= D?2 ! VACDi@ <D@>O>C@>= <D

BAW<D[ E?O @TA@9 %> VAC X<D= ?E BGCTW ?D @TA@2 AD= !

CA<= VTW =?Di@ W?G cGC@ =? @T<C9 :TW =?Di@ W?G UU

VTW =?Di@ W?G BAW H> T?GOFW E?O HW Q>H>D@ V?OX2 AD=

T> CA<= @TA@ V?GF= P> E<D>2 AD= C? ! VAC APF> @? UU

Page 63: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 63/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OW

!i= =?D> A F?@ ?E V?OX @? @TA@ B?<D@ ?D @TA@ BAO@ ?E

@T> BO?c>Q@2 @T> E<OC@ BAO@ ?E @T> BO?c>Q@2 VT<QT VAC

H?C@FW [>@@<D[ GB @? CB>>= ?D @T> Q>H>D@ <D=GC@OW2

@T> HAOX>@<D[ ?E Q>H>D@2 VT>O> @T> BO?E<@ HAO[<D

V?GF= Q?H> <D @>OHC ?E BO?a<H<@W @? -AC 7>[AC2 W?G

XD?V2 @T> C<@>2 A<O kGAF<@W @WB> @T<D[C2 cGC@ X<D= ?E

[>D>OAF >=GQA@<?D9

,@ @TA@ B?<D@ <D @<H> !i= BO?PAPFW CB>D@

JK T?GOC ?O C? ?E HW @<H>2 AD= ! CA<= VTW =?Di@ W?G

cGC@ BAW H> E?O HW @<H> @TGC EAO2 AD= @T>D ?D @T>

PAQX >D= <E ! >AOD A B>OQ>D@A[>2 W?G QAD CGP@OAQ@

@TA@2 AD= T> VAC E<D> V<@T @TA@2 TABBW @? =? @TA@9

j9 .? <E !iH E?FF?V<D[ W?G2 @T> EAQ@ @TA@ W?G

[?@ BA<= @T> T?GOFW OA@> C@AO@>= V<@T '<QTAO= VAD@<D[

@? BAW W?G <D Q?DD>Q@<?D V<@T @T> )>O>HW )?TDC?D

F?PPW<D[ >EE?O@l

,9 ! @T<DX @TA@iC VT>O> UU @TA@ <C VT>O> UU

T> VAC <D@>O>C@>= <D BAW<D[ H> E?O @TA@9 ! VAC D?@

<D@>O>C@>= <D P><D[ BA<= E?O @TA@2 PG@ A@ @TA@ B?<D@

<D @<H>2 AE@>O C>\>OAF V>>XC ?D @T> BO?c>Q@2 ! VAC

<D@>O>C@>= <D [>@@<D[ BA<= C?H>@T<D[ ?D @T> BO?c>Q@2

C? <@ X<D= ?E QAH> A@ AP?G@ @TA@ CAH> @<H>9 !iH D?@

CAW<D[ <@ VAC P>QAGC> ?E @TA@2 PG@ <@ VAC AP?G@ @T>

CAH> @<H> @TA@ ! CA<= @? '<QTAO= VTW =?Di@ W?G BAW H>

T?GOFW9

Page 64: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 64/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OJ

j9 :TW =<= W?G D?@ VAD@ @? P> BA<= E?O @T>

F?PPW<D[ >EE?O@l

,9 Y?O> @TAD ADW@T<D[ <@ VAC P>QAGC> ! TA=

BG@ )>O>HW )?TDC?D AD= '<QTAO= @?[>@T>O2 AD= ! E>F@

F<X> @TA@ <E ! V>O> @? [>@ BA<= E?O BG@@<D[ @T>H

@?[>@T>O2 >\>D @T?G[T <@ VACDi@ .@A@> O>FA@>= AD= !

E>F@ <@ VAC F>[AF2 ! E>F@ F<X> ! V?GF= QO>A@> A

Q?DEF<Q@ V<@T HW O>Q?HH>D=A@<?D @? )>O>HW )?TDC?D <E

! V>O> @? P> BA<= A \AFG> E?O BG@@<D[ T<H <D@? A

C<@GA@<?D V<@T '<QTAO= 'AVF>9

j9 1?G H>AD A Q?DEF<Q@ V<@T W?GO c?Pl

,9 "?2 A Q?DEF<Q@ V<@T HW O>Q?HH>D=A@<?D @?

T<H9 !D ?@T>O V?O=C2 !i= P> <D A B?C<@<?D ?E CAW<D[

VTW =?Di@ W?G [? AT>A= AD= V?OX V<@T '<QTAO= AD= @T>D

[>@@<D[ C?H>@T<D[ ?E \AFG> ?G@ ?E BG@@<D[ @TA@

O>FA@<?DCT<B @?[>@T>O9 ! E>F@ F<X> ! ?V>= H?O> @?

)>O>HW @TAD @? AQQ>B@ H?D>W E?O >DQ?GOA[<D[ T<H @?

CB>D= H?D>W V<@T '<QTAO= 'AVF>9

j9 ,D= VTW =<= W?G E>>F @TA@ W?G ?V>=

C?H>@T<D[ @? )>O>HWl

,9 ! =?Di@ E>>F F<X> ! ?V>= T<H ADW@T<D[

?@T>O @TAD EO<>D=CT<B9 ! E>F@ F<X> ! VAC <D@O?=GQ<D[

A EO<>D= @? C?H>?D> VT? H<[T@ P> APF> @? T>FB T<H

BO?E>CC<?DAFFW2 AD= HAWP> <@iC @T> FAVW>O BAO@ ?E H>

VT>O> ! =<=Di@ E>>F F<X> ! O>AFFW VAD@>= UU <@iC

Page 65: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 65/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

ON

AFH?C@ F<X> A D><[TP?O Q?H<D[ @? W?G AD= CAW<D[ =?

W?G XD?V A [??= FAVW>O AD= CAW<D[ W>C2 ! XD?V A [??=

FAVW>O2 VTW =?Di@ W?G T<O> 8OAD@ .GHC<?D @? =? A

=<\?OQ> E?O W?G AD= @T>D @AX<D[ A O>E>OOAF E>> ?D

O>E>OO<D[ A EO<>D= @? A FAVW>O9

j9 .? VT>D '<QTAO= A[O>>= @? BAW W?G @T>

T?GOFW E>> UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU VAC @TA@ <D BFAQ> ?E @T> >kG<@W2 ?O =<=

W?G C@<FF TA\> A BO?CB>Q@ ?E [>@@<D[ >kG<@W <E @T<D[C

@GOD>= ?G@ V>FFl

,9 :> @AFX>= AP?G@ @TA@2 AD= ! CA<= @? T<H <E

<@iC ?XAW V<@T W?G2 W?G QAD BAW H> T?GOFW E?O @T>

V?OX !iH =?<D[2 AD= @T>D <E AD= @? @T> >a@>D@ W?G

=>Q<=> @? ?EE>O AD >kG<@W B<>Q>2 @T>D F>@iC CGP@OAQ@

VTA@ W?G BAW H> EO?H VTA@>\>O W?G [<\> H> <D @T>

>kG<@W B<>Q>9

j9 ,D= =<= W?G UU C? ! @AX> <@ EO?H @T<C

>D@<O> Q?D\>OCA@<?D2 @TA@ VT>D W?G E<OC@ P>[AD

V?OX<D[ ?D @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@ W?G V>O> D?@ =?<D[ C?

GD=>OC@AD=<D[ !iFF [>@ o DGHP>O ?E =?FFAOC B>O T?GOl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 $TA@ QAH> FA@>Ol

,9 $TA@ =<=9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= =<= W?G TA\> ADW C?O@ ?E

Page 66: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 66/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OO

=<CQGCC<?D V<@T '<QTAO= ?O Q?H> @? AD A[O>>H>D@ AP?G@

VTA@ @T> T?GOFW OA@> V?GF= P>l

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX UU V>FF2 VT>D V> =>Q<=>= @?

[? T?GOFW V> =<=2 PG@ D?@ P>E?O>2 ?P\<?GCFW9 :>

@AFX>= AP?G@ hNMK AD T?GO9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= TA= W?G P>>D X>>B<D[ @OAQX ?E

W?GO @<H>l

,9 -??C>FW9 -??C>FW9 !@ VAC H?O> ?E AD

>C@<HA@>2 PG@ T> AD= ! @AFX>= AP?G@ @TA@ AD= QAH> @?

AD A[O>>H>D@ @TA@ <@ VAC J] T?GOC9 ! @T<DX <@ VAC

J] T?GOC @TA@ !i= CB>D@ AD= <D\?<Q>= T<H h`MKK E?O

J] T?GOC9

j9 .GEE>O<D[ GD=>O @T> ?QQGBA@<?DAF TAfAO= ?E

A @<H> CT>>@ UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU !iH BO?[OAHH>= @? @T<DX <D @>OHC ?E

VTA@ ! V?GF= =? <D F?[[<D[ @<H>9

! @AX> <@ W?G =<=Di@ =? @TA@l

,9 ! =<=Di@ X>>B @OAQX ?E >\>OW T?GO2 PG@ !

TA= AD <=>A ?E @T> @<H> !i= CB>D@ AD= TA= >D?G[T ?E

AD <=>A ?E @T> @<H> !i= CB>D@ @TA@ ! Q?GF= [? @?

'<QTAO= AD= CAW @T<C <C VTA@ !i\> =?D>2 @T<C <C @T>

@<H> !i\> CB>D@ AD= E>F@ [??= AD= Q?HE?O@APF>

O>Q?HH>D=<D[ @TA@ T> BAW H> E?O @T> @<H> ! UU

j9 :AC @TA@ <=>A <D W?GO T>A= ?O TA= W?G

Page 67: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 67/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OP

VO<@@>D <@ =?VD <D D?@>C ?O UU

,9 "?9 !i= X>B@ @OAQX ?E C?H> ?E @T> @T<D[C

!i= =?D> ?D A D?@>BA=2 AD= C? <@ VACDi@ cGC@ <D HW

T>A=9 !@ VAC AFC? ?D A D?@>BA=9 ! =?Di@ TA\> @TA@

BA=9 ! =?Di@ XD?V VT>O> <@ <C9 !i\> BO?PAPFW @TO?VD

<@ AVAW9

Y'9 ."/:5 +AD V> @AX> A PO>AX D?V2 <E

<@iC AFF O<[T@l

Y'9 -,--!5 .GO>9

$%& 7!(&/8',6%&'5 8?<D[ ?EE O>Q?O=9

J5IL B9H9 <C @T> @<H>9

m'>Q>CC EO?H J5IL B9H9 @? J5JK B9H9;

K&H#/I/1 V )*( 6*-X&G'M 

$%& 7!(&/8',6%&'5 '>@GOD<D[ ?D @T>

O>Q?O=9 J5JK B9H9 <C @T> @<H>9 +?GDC>F9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; YO9 .VAFF?V2 !i\> TAD=>=

W?G &aT<P<@ N2 VT<QT <C @V? <D\?<Q>C AD= @V? >UHA<FC9

(<= W?G BO>BAO> @T>C> =?QGH>D@Cl

,9 !@ F??XC F<X> ! =<=2 W>AT9

j9 ,D= <E W?G F??X A@ @T> @T<O= BA[>2 VT<QT

<C dA@>C BA[> ^_2 <@ F??XC F<X> A D?@> @?

'<QTAO= 'AVF> EO?H W?G @TA@ <C @T> CAH> @T<D[ @TA@ <C

A@@AQT>= @? @T> dA@>C BA[> ^` >UHA<F9

(? W?G XD?V VTA@iC =<EE>O>D@ P>@V>>D @T>Hl

(? W?G O>QAFF <E W?G VO?@> T<H AD >UHA<F AD= A

Page 68: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 68/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OR

C>BAOA@> D?@>l

,9 "?9 ! @T<DX <@iC cGC@ C<HBFW A HA@@>O ?E

A BO<D@<D[ =<EE>O>DQ>9

j9 /XAW9

,9 $TA@iC HW [G>CC9 ! VAC TA\<D[ A TAO= @<H>

XD?V<D[ T?V @? BO<D@ AD >UHA<F ?EE HW Q?HBG@>O9

j9 /XAW9

,9 dW @T> VAW2 CB>AX<D[ ?E Q?HBG@>OC2

)>DD<E>O Q?OO>Q@>= H>9 ! CA<= @TA@ HW TAO= =<CX

QOACT>= ?D HW T?H> Q?HBG@>O <D )ADGAOW ?E NKIN9 !

H>AD@ @? CAW )ADGAOW ?E NKIJ2 cGC@ @T<C BAC@ )ADGAOW9

j9 /XAW9

,9 dG@2 D?2 ! @T<DX @TA@ @T?C> AO> @T> CAH>

>UHA<F2 PG@ cGC@ C<HBFW A =<EE>O>D@ BO?[OAH BO<D@>=

@T>H9

j9 /XAW9 ->@ H> =<O>Q@ W?GO A@@>D@<?D @? @T>

@V? <D\?<Q>C @T>D2 <E ! Q?GF=9 $T> E<OC@ BA[> <C @T>

hIM2KKK ?D>9

!C @TA@ @T> ?D> W?G TA\>l

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= @T<C V?GF= TA\> P>>D2 AC V>

V>O> =>CQO<P<D[ P>E?O> @T> PO>AX2 W?G V>D@ @? '<QTAO=

AD= CG[[>C@>= @TA@ T> BAW W?G ?D AD T?GOFW OA@>

C?H>@<H> <D @T> EAFF ?E NKIKl

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

Page 69: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 69/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

OS

j9 /XAW9 ,D= =? W?G O>QAFF VT>D W?G BO?\<=>=

T<H V<@T @T<C <D\?<Q>l ! H>AD2 VAC <@ C<HGF@AD>?GC

V<@T @T> >UHA<FC A@@AQT>=2 VT<QT V?GF= TA\> P>>D

AO?GD= ,BO<F `@T ?E NKIIl

,9 "?9 "?9 ,Q@GAFFW2 @T> ADCV>O @? @TA@ <C

D?9 $T>C> @V? UU @T>C> @V? =>@A<F>= <D\?<Q>C V>O>

QO>A@>= AE@>O @T> H>>@<D[ ! TA= V<@T )>O>HW )?TDC?D

A@ @T> =?G[TDG@ CT?B2 C? UU

j9 .? @T>C> @V? >UHA<FC V>O> BO>BAO>= C?H>

@<H> AE@>O ,BO<F JK2 NKINl

,9 $T>C> @V? =?QGH>D@C9 $T>WiO> D?@ >UHA<FC2

PG@ =?QGH>D@C2 W>C2 @T>W V>O> BO>BAO>= C?H> @<H>

AE@>O ,BO<F JK@T ?E NKIN9

j9 +AD V> O>E>O @? @T> E<OC@ @V? BA[>C AC @T>

<D\?<Q>Cl

,9 .GO>9

j9 d>QAGC> W?GiO> O<[T@2 @T>WiO> D?@ >UHA<FC2

AD= ! H<CCB?X>9

,9 /XAW9

j9 :TA@ W?GiO> @>FF<D[ H> <C @T> @V?

<D\?<Q>C2 dA@>C BA[>C ^M AD= ^^2 V>O> BO>BAO>= AE@>O

,BO<F JK2 NKINl

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 :TW =<= W?G BO>BAO> @T>H A@ @TA@ B?<D@ <D

@<H>l

Page 70: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 70/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PU

,9 :>FF2 <D @T> H>>@<D[ ! TA= V<@T

)>O>HW )?TDC?D2 T> PO?G[T@ GB AD <CCG> @TA@ Q?DQ>OD>=

H>9 %> <D@<HA@>= @TA@ ! H<[T@ TA\> [?@@>D BA<= E?O A

@OADCAQ@<?D P>@V>>D T<H AD= '<QTAO=2 AD= @T> @?D> ?E

@T> H>>@<D[ HA=> H> E>>F @TA@ T> Q?GF= \>OW V>FF HAX>

GB A C@?OW @TA@ V?GF= P> <D@>D=>= @? <DcGO> H> ?O

TGO@ H>2 AD= C? E?FF?V<D[ @TA@ H>>@<D[ ! @>F>BT?D>=

'<QTAO=9 ! ACX>= T<H <E !i= P>>D BA<= EO?H @T> CAH>

AQQ?GD@ AC T>i= O>Q><\>= H?D>W EO?H )>O>HW )?TDC?D2

AD= ! C>D@ T<H A F>@@>O UU ! =?Di@ O>H>HP>O <E ! C>D@

T<H A F>@@>O ?O TAD= =>F<\>O>= A F>@@>O @? T<H2 PG@ !

QO>A@>= A F>@@>O @>FF<D[ T<H @TA@ ! VAC Q?DQ>OD>=

AP?G@ @TA@ AD= VAD@<D[ @? [>@ V<@T T<H AP?G@ <@9

! =?Di@ O>H>HP>O >aAQ@FW VTA@ @T> F>@@>O

CAWC2 PG@ ! AFC? @??X C@>BC A@ @TA@ B?<D@ <D @<H> @?

@OW @? =?QGH>D@ AC P>C@ AC ! Q?GF= @T> V?OX !i= =?D>

E?O T<H ?D @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@9

.? ! V>D@ PAQX AD= @O<>= @? =?QGH>D@ @T>

V?OX ! TA= =?D>2 @T> @<H> EOAH>C !i= =?D> @T> V?OX

<D2 AD= @T>D ! H>@ V<@T T<H @? \>O<EW V<@T T<H T<C

O>Q?FF>Q@<?D ?E VTA@ !i= =?D> AD= VT>D9 $T>D !

E<DAF<f>= @T>C> <D\?<Q>C AD= [A\> @T>H @? T<H A@ @TA@

@<H>9

j9 /XAW9

,9 $T> BGOB?C> VAC @? =?QGH>D@2 @T?G[T2

Page 71: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 71/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PT

P>QAGC> ! VAC Q?DQ>OD>= @TA@ )>O>HW )?TDC?D H<[T@ @OW

@? QO>A@> A EAFC> O>AF<@W2 AD= ! VAC Q?DQ>OD>= AP?G@

@TA@9

j9 /XAW9 -??X<D[ A@ @T> @<H> EOAH>C

<=>D@<E<>= <D >AQT ?E @T> @V? <D\?<Q>C UU

,9 *TUTGT mW>C;9

j9 UU (>Q>HP>O IM2 NKIK2 @? ,BO<F IM2 NKII2

VT<QT <C ?D @T> E<OC@ ?D>2 AD= ,G[GC@ @? H<= /Q@?P>O

NKIK <C ?D @T> C>Q?D= BA[>2 VT<QT ! [G>CC AQ@GAFFW <D

@<H> V?GF= TA\> P>>D @T> E<OC@ B>O<?= ?E @<H>2 O<[T@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= '<QTAO= 'AVF>2 <D EAQ@ UU AD= !iFF [>@

@? @T<C =?QGH>D@ FA@>O2 PG@ ! P>F<>\> <@ VAC <D FA@>

NKIK BA<= W?G h`MKKl

,9 6A<= 6U.?FG@<?DC h`MKK9

j9 '<[T@9

,9 m:<@D>CC D?==<D[ T>A= AEE<OHA@<\>FW9;

j9 ,D= T> BA<= 6U.?FG@<?DC h`MKK E?O @T> V?OX

@TA@ W?G TA= =?D> V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? @T> +TABAOOAF

BO?c>Q@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= @T> O>AC?D T> BA<= W?G @TA@2 <E !iH

E?FF?V<D[ W?G2 VAC P>QAGC> ?E A Q?D\>OCA@<?D W?G TA=

VT>O> W?G CG[[>C@>= @TA@ OA@T>O @TAD BAW<D[ W?G E?O

<D@O?=GQ<D[ )>O>HW )?TDC?D2 T> BAW W?G E?O @T> Q>H>D@

Page 72: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 72/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PV

V?OXl

,9 "?2 @T?C> AO> D?@ @T> V?O=C ! <D@>D=>=9 !

=?Di@ XD?V <E @T?C> AO> W?GO V?O=C ?O VTA@9 $T<C <C

V?OX !i= AQ@GAFFW =?D>9 $T>C> AO> E>>C !i= AQ@GAFFW

>AOD>=9 %> =>Q<=>= @? BAW H> OA@T>O @TAD UU H?D>W ?D

AD T?GOFW PAC<C OA@T>O @TAD A B>OQ>D@A[> @? @TA@

>a@>D@ E?O @T> V?OX ! TA= =?D>9

!D ?@T>O V?O=C2 T> TA= P>>D VAD@<D[ H> @?

@AX> A O>E>OOAF E>> EO?H )?TDC?D2 AD= ! =>QF<D>= A

O>E>OOAF E>> EO?H )?TDC?D2 PG@ ! V?GF=Di@ CAW @TA@

@T<C BAWH>D@ VAC <D CGPC@<@G@<?D E?O A O>E>OOAF E>>9

$T<C BAWH>D@ VAC E?O @T> V?OX ! TA= =?D>9

! TA= cGC@ CG[[>C@>= AP?G@ @T> CAH> @<H>

@TA@ T> BAW H> ?D AD T?GOFW OA@> OA@T>O @TAD BAW H>

?D A Q?HH<CC<?D E?O @T<C V?OX @? @TA@ B?<D@ AD= @TA@

<E T> C@<FF VAD@>= @? [<\> H> A B>OQ>D@A[> ?E @T>

Q?HBADW A@ C?H> B?<D@2 @TA@ T>i= C<HBFW =>=GQ@ VTA@

T>i= BA<= H> E?O HW T?GOFW V?OX EO?H VTA@ T>i= BAW H>

<D A B>OQ>D@A[>9

j9 /XAW9 :>FF2 @T> VAW !iH GD=>OC@AD=<D[

@T<C <C @TA@ @V? @T<D[C QAH> @?[>@T>O A@ ?DQ>9 /D>

VAC T<C =>C<O> @? BAW W?G C?H> X<D= ?E A E>> E?O @T>

)>O>HW )?TDC?De @V? <C W?GO =>C<O> D?@ @? O>Q><\>

@TA@ E>> PG@2 OA@T>O2 @? P> BA<= ?D AD T?GOFW OA@> A@

F>AC@ <D BAO@ E?O V?OX W?Gi= =?D> ?D @T> Q>H>D@

Page 73: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 73/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PW

BO?c>Q@l

,9 1>AT2 AC F?D[ AC V>iO> QF>AO @TA@ <D HW

H<D= AD= ! P>F<>\> <D '<QTAO=iC H<D= @T> BAWH>D@C

HA=> V>O> D?@ E?O A O>E>OOAF E>>9

j9 $TA@ VAC @T> VT?F> B?<D@ AC ! GD=>OC@AD=

W?GO @>C@<H?DW E?O TA\<D[ T<H BAW W?G E?O @T> Q>H>D@

V?OX9

,9 :TA@ VAC @T> VT?F> B?<D@l

j9 :>FF2 @TA@ W?G =<=Di@ VAD@ @? P> BA<= A

O>E>OOAF E>> E?O @T> )>O>HW )?TDC?D <D@O?=GQ@<?D9

,9 :>FF2 VTA@>\>O W?G GD=>OC@AD= HW @>C@<H?DW

@? TA\> P>>D V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? @TA@2 ! VAD@ @? HAX> <@

\>OW QF>AO @TA@ PW @T> @<H> '<QTAO= AD= ! =>Q<=>= ?D

AD T?GOFW OA@> E?O H>2 <@ VAC \>OW QF>AO @? P?@T ?E

GC @TA@ ! V?GF=Di@ O>Q><\> ADW Q?HB>DCA@<?D A@ AFF

E?O @T> O>E>OOAF ?E )>O>HW )?TDC?D9

j9 '<[T@2 AD= !iH GD=>OC@AD=<D[ W?G @? CAW

>aAQ@FW @TA@9

,9 /XAW9

Y'9 ."/:5 /XAW9

$%& :!$"&..5 ,H ! P><D[ BAOAD?<= AP?G@

@TA@2 P>QAGC> UU

Y'9 ."/:5 "?9 !@ VACDi@ QF>AO VTA@ W?G

V>O> CAW<D[9 ,@ F>AC@ <@ VACDi@ @? H>9

$%& :!$"&..5 3O?H @T> kG>C@<?D <@ VACDi@

Page 74: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 74/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PJ

QF>AO @? H> @TA@ W?G GD=>OC@??= @TA@9 ! VAD@ @? HAX>

CGO> @TA@iC B>OE>Q@FW QOWC@AF QF>AO9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ! T>AO VTA@ W?GiO> CAW<D[9

,9 /XAW9

j9 (<= @TA@ AFF TABB>D <D @T> CAH>

Q?D\>OCA@<?D2 AD= @TA@ <C '<QTAO= CAW<D[ T> VAD@>= @?

BAW W?G E?O @T> )>O>HW )?TDC?D2 W?G CAW<D[ W?G =<=Di@

VAD@ @? AD= @T>D @T> @V? ?E W?G O>AQT<D[ AD A[O>>H>D@

@TA@ W?G V?GF= cGC@ P> BA<= T?GOFW E?O @T> Q>H>D@

V?OXl

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX <@ VAC @T> CAH>

Q?D\>OCA@<?D2 AD= ! CAW @TA@ P>QAGC> ! O>H>HP>O [?<D[

T?H> AE@>O H> @>FF<D[ T<H ! =<=Di@ VAD@ @? P> BA<=

E?O @T> O>E>OOAF AD= @T<DX<D[2 W?G XD?V VTA@2 ! Q?GF=

GC> A F<@@F> UU W?G XD?V2 ?GO EAH<FW Q?GF= GC> A

F<@@F> H?D>W E?O +TO<C@HAC ?O2 W?G XD?V2 @T<C V?GF=

P> [??= E?O2 W?G XD?V2 6U.?FG@<?DC @? TA\> A F<@@F>

H?D>W >AOF<>O @TAD VA<@<D[ ?D @T> O<CX9 ! @T<DX !iFF

cGC@ ACX '<QTAO= @? BAW H> AD T?GOFW E?O @T> V?OX

!i\> =?D> AD= C>> <E T>i= P> AH>DAPF> @? @TA@2 AD=2

EOADXFW2 A@ @T> @<H> <E T>i= CA<= D?2 ! V?GF= TA\>

P>>D E<D>2 AD= <E T>i= CA<= W>C2 PG@ @TA@ @AX>C @T>

Q?HH<CC<?D ?EE @T> @APF>2 ! V?GF= TA\> P>>D E<D>2 AD=

C<DQ> V>i\> D>\>O O>AFFW Q?H> @?2 ! [G>CC2 A QF>AO

>DE?OQ>APF> GD=>OC@AD=<D[ ?D @T> B>OQ>D@A[>2 @? H> <@

Page 75: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 75/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PN

O>AFFW =<=Di@ HAX> HGQT =<EE>O>DQ> AD= ! VAC TABBW @?

TA\> T<H BAW 6U.?FG@<?DC E?O @T> V?OX ! TA= =?D> A@

@TA@ B?<D@9

j9 :AC @T>O> A @<H> <D NKIK VT>O> W?G AD=

'<QTAO= A[O>>= @TA@ T> V?GF= BAW W?G h`MKK E?O @T>

V?OX ?D @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@ W?Gi= =?D> @? @TA@ B?<D@

<D @<H>l

,9 1>C2 @T>O> VAC A @<H> <D NKIK VT>O> T>

A[O>>= @? @TA@ AD= AQ@GAFFW =<=2 <D EAQ@2 BAW

6U.?FG@<?DC E?O @TA@ V?OX9

j9 ,D= @TA@ VAC W?GO <=>A @TA@ W?G ABBO?AQT>=

T<H V<@T AD= T> A[O>>=l

,9 ! P>F<>\> C?2 AC ! F??X PAQX ?D <@9

j9 ,D= @T> <=>A @TA@ W?G TA= AD= @T>

Q?D\>OCA@<?D @TA@ O>CGF@>= <D W?G [>@@<D[ @T> h`MKK

VAC A@ A B?<D@ <D @<H> AE@>O '<QTAO= TA= CA<= T>

VAD@>= @? BAW W?G E?O @T> )?TDC?D <D@O?=GQ@<?D AD=

W?G =>QF<D>=l

,9 :T>D ! CAW T> VAD@>= @? BAW H>2 ! @T<DX T>

VAC V<FF<D[ @? BAW H> E?O @TA@2 AD= F>@ H> cGC@ [<\>

W?G AD >aAHBF> ?E '<QTAO= 'AVF>9 -A@>O ?D !iH CGO>

V>iFF [>@ @? @T<C9

%> AD= ! TA= A Q?D\>OCA@<?D AP?G@ A O>EGD=

?E @T> hNJ2MKK @TA@ 6U.?FG@<?DC TA= O>Q><\>= EO?H

T<H2 AD= T> CA<= UU AD= !iFF X<D= ?E kG?@> T<H9

Page 76: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 76/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PO

g%>FF2 !iFF cGC@ =?GPF> =?VD9 !iFF cGC@ BAW W?G

AD?@T>O hNJ2MKK9g %?V A@@OAQ@<\> @TA@ V?GF= TA\>

P>>D2 PG@ ?E Q?GOC> ! CA<=2 g"?2 @TA@iC D?@ T?V <@

V?OXC <D @T> O>AF V?OF=2 '<QTAO=9 ! XD?V W?GiO> \>OW

[>D>O?GC2 AD= ! ABBO>Q<A@> W?GiO> X<D= AD= F<X> H>2

PG@2 D?2 !iFF TA\> @T> H?D>W O>@GOD>=2 AD= @T>D W?G

BF>AC> BAW 6U.?FG@<?DC ?G@ ?E AD?@T>O AQQ?GD@9g

.? <@iC D?@ UU <@iC D?@ GDT>AO= ?E <D HW

O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T '<QTAO= E?O T<H @? P> \>OW [>D>O?GC

V<@T H>2 AD= C? ! =?Di@ XD?V VTA@ @T> B?<D@ ?E @TA@

C@A@>H>D@ <C >aQ>B@ @TA@ T> =<= A[O>> @? BAW @T>

h`MKK @? 6U.?FG@<?DC9 ! =<= CG[[>C@ @TA@ @? T<H2 AD=

T> VAC H?O> @TAD V<FF<D[ @? HAX> @TA@ BAWH>D@ UU

j9 /XAW9

,9 UU ?D @T?C> @>OHC9

j9 dG@ T?V =<= W?G AOO<\> A@ @T> h`MKK

E<[GO>l

,9 :>FF2 <@ VAC C<HBFW A HA@@>O ?E2 W?G XD?V2

@T> T?GOC @TA@ !i= <D\>C@>= <D @T> BO?c>Q@ @T> P>C@ !

Q?GF= >C@<HA@> AD= @AFX @? T<H AD= =>E>D= AD= @AFX

V<@T T<H AP?G@ @<H>C A@ @T> T?GOFW OA@> ?E hNMK AD

T?GO9

j9 (<= W?G BO?\<=> T<H V<@T C?H>@T<D[ C<H<FAO

@? &aT<P<@ N2 dA@>C BA[> ^^2 <D NKIKl

,9 1?G XD?V2 ! cGC@ QADi@ O>H>HP>O9 !

Page 77: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 77/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PP

TA\>Di@ E?GD= ADW@T<D[ F<X> @TA@2 AD= ! QADi@

O>H>HP>O9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF <E W?G BO?\<=>= T<H V<@T

C?H>@T<D[ C<H<FAO @? ><@T>O ?E @T> FAC@ @V? BA[>C ?E

&aT<P<@ Ne @TA@ <C2 AD >UHA<F ?O A H>H? CAW<D[ !i=

F<X> @? <D\?<Q> W?G <D @T> AH?GD@ ?E h`MKKl

,9 ! TA\>Di@ P>>D APF> @? E<D= ADW@T<D[ F<X>

@TA@ AD= ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9

j9 +AD W?G O>QAFF <E @T> h`MKK E<[GO> VAC

AOO<\>= A@ V<@T?G@ BAB>Oe @TA@ <C2 cGC@ <D A

Q?D\>OCA@<?D V<@T '<QTAO=l

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9

j9 /XAW9 ,FF O<[T@9 .? @TA@ @>FFC H> T?V

W?G [?@ BA<= @T> h`MKK <D FA@> NKIK9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 "?V ! VAD@ @? ACX C<H<FAO kG>C@<?DC AP?G@

@T> C>Q?D= BAWH>D@2 VT<QT QAH> <D ,BO<F ?E NKII2

O<[T@2 hIM2KKKl

,9 m:<@D>CC D?==<D[ T>A= AEE<OHA@<\>FW9;

j9 :AC @T>O> A C<H<FAO Q?D\>OCA@<?D @TA@ W?G

TA= V<@T '<QTAO=2 ?O VAC <@ C<HBFW O>CGF@<D[ EO?H

@T>C> D?@>C ?O >UHA<FC @TA@ W?G C>D@ T<Hl

,9 :>FF2 V> @AFX>= O>[GFAOFW9 :> H>@

O>[GFAOFW ?D @T> BO?c>Q@9 ! X>B@ T<H GB GB=A@>=

O>[GFAOFW ?D VTA@ ! VAC =?<D[9

Page 78: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 78/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PR

$T> =<EE>O>DQ> P>@V>>D @T> C>Q?D= <D\?<Q>

AD= @T> E<OC@ <D\?<Q> UU C? VT>D ! CAW @T> C>Q?D=

<D\?<Q>2 ! H>AD HW QTO?D?F?[W2 C? @TA@ V?GF= P> ^M

\>OCGC ^^ UU <C @TA@ <D @T> C>Q?D= <D\?<Q> !

>C@<HA@>= AP?G@ NK T?GOC <D A==<@<?D @? @T> T?GOC !i=

AQ@GAFFW V?OX>= A@ @T> @<H>2 C? !i= V?OX>= AP?G@

]K T?GOC GB GD@<F @T> B?<D@ <D @<H> ?E ,BO<F M@T ?E

NKII2 AD= @T> O>C@ ?E @T> @<H> ! V?OX>= AE@>O AD=

>C@<HA@>= @TA@ ! V?OX>= AD?@T>O NK T?GOC9

! @?F= T<H @TA@2 AD= ! CA<= ! V?Di@ P<FF

W?G @T> @<H> ! CB>D@ ?D @T> BO?c>Q@2 E?O ADW ?@T>O

@<H> !i\> CB>D@2 C? @T> ^K T?GOC VAC O>AFFW AD

>C@<HA@> ?E @T> @<H> !i= P> CB>D=<D[9

"?V2 @T<C <D\?<Q> VAC QO>A@>= AE@>O @T>

EAQ@ @? =?QGH>D@ VTA@ V> TA= =?D>2 PG@ ! VAD@>= @? P>

AC AQQGOA@> AC ! Q?GF= ?D <@ AD= D?@ >a@>D= @T> =A@>

?E @T> <D\?<Q> P>W?D= ,BO<F M@T2 C? VTA@ ?GO

GD=>OC@AD=<D[ VAC VAC @TA@ T>i= BAW H> E?O ^K T?GOC

VT>D !i= ?DFW V?OX>= ]K V<@T @T> BO?H<C> @TA@ ! V?GF=

V?OX A@ F>AC@ AD?@T>O NK T?GOC AD= D?@ P<FF T<H9 !

>D=>= GB V?OX<D[ BO?PAPFW HGQT H?O> @TAD @TA@ ?D @T>

BO?c>Q@ @TO?G[T @T> >D= ?E )GFW ?O VT>D>\>O <@ VAC !

E<D<CT>=9

j9 ,D= VTW =<= W?G VAD@ @? =? @TA@e @TA@ <C2

>C@<HA@> NK A==<@<?DAF T?GOC <D@? @T> EG@GO> OA@T>O

Page 79: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 79/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

PS

@TAD cGC@ C>D= T<H AD?@T>O P<FF AE@>O W?Gi= V?OX>=

@T> NK ?O H?O> T?GOCl

,9 1>AT2 @TA@iC A [??= kG>C@<?D9 !iH @OW<D[

@? O>H>HP>O VTW @TA@ VAC9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E <@ VAC

P>QAGC> <@ VAC QF?C> @? @T> @Aa C>AC?D AD=2 W?G XD?V2

! XD?V @TA@ UU ! XD?V @TA@ V<@T<D A H?D@T AD= A TAFE

?E O>Q><\<D[ @T> BAWH>D@ ! TA= A =<C@O<PG@<?D HA=> @?

.GfADD>2 HW V<E>2 AD= CT> GC>= @TA@ @? PGW D>V

ABBF<ADQ>C E?O @T> X<@QT>D9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E <@ VAC A

Q?HP<DA@<?D ?E @TA@2 PG@ E?O C?H> O>AC?D <@ VAC

<HB?O@AD@ @? GC @? @OW @? TA\> A P<FF ?E hIM2KKK

<DC@>A= ?E hIK2KKK2 AD= @TA@iC AFF ! QAD >aBFA<D9

! cGC@ XD?V @TA@ T> AD= ! =<CQGCC>= <@2 T>

VAC Q?HE?O@APF> V<@T <@2 AD= ! E>F@ F<X> ! TA=

T?D?O>= @TA@ AD= VAC APF> @? [<\> T<H @T> \AFG> E?O

VTA@ T> BA<= H> <D ,BO<F @TO?G[T?G@ @T> O>C@ ?E @T>

CGHH>O9

j9 ,D= @T> QT>QX VAC HA=> @? 6U.?FG@<?DC2

Q?OO>Q@l

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 ,D= T?V =<= T> XD?V @? HAX> @T> QT>QX @?

6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E ! @?F= T<H @TA@ ?O <E

@TA@iC VTA@ @T> >UHA<F CAWC9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF2 PG@ T>

XD>V ! VAC V?OX<D[ @TO?G[T 6U.?FG@<?DC @T> VT?F>

Page 80: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 80/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RU

@<H>9

j9 (<= T> HAX> @T> BAWH>D@ @? 6U.?FG@<?DC A@

W?GO O>kG>C@l

,9 !iH CGO> T> =<=9 %> XD>V @TA@ ! TA= C>@

GB 6U.?FG@<?DC E?O @T> Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX ?D @T<C Q>H>D@

BO?c>Q@9 $TA@ VAC @T> @OG@T UU @TA@ VAC @T> QAC>

EO?H @T> \>OW P>[<DD<D[2 C? T> XD>V @TA@ ! TA= C>@ GB

A EAH<FW @OGC@ AD= @TA@ ! VAC =?<D[ @T<C V?OX AD=

=?DA@<D[ HW @<H> @? @T> EAH<FW @OGC@ ?D P>TAFE ?E @T>

EAH<FW9

j9 ,D= T> XD>V @TA@ P>QAGC> W?G @?F= T<H

@TA@l

,9 /T2 W>C2 T> XD>V P>QAGC> ! @?F= T<H @TA@9

j9 ! F??X A@ @T> @V? <D\?<Q>C2 AD= @T> hIMKK

?D>2 @T> <D@O?=GQ@?OW C>D@>DQ> CAWC2 g3?O 6O?c>Q@

+?DCGF@<D[ .>O\<Q> E?O '<QTAO= 'AVF> B>OC?DAFFW ?O

E?O @T> +TABAOOAF +?HBADW9g

$T> C>Q?D= ?D> CAWC2 g6O?c>Q@ +?DCGF@<D[

.>O\<Q>C E?O '<QTAO= 'AVF> B>OC?DAFFW9g

:AC @TA@ AD <D@>D@<?DAF =<EE>O>DQ>l

,9 ! Q?GF=Di@ ADCV>O W?GO kG>C@<?D9 ! QAD

?DFW CB>QGFA@> @TA@ !iH @OW<D[ @? P> Q?DC<C@>D@ V<@T

VTA@ ! XD>V A@ @T> @<H>9 !iH D?@ CGO> ! VAC <D @T>

F??B EGFFW AP?G@ +TABAOOAF2 @T> --+2 VT>D ! HA=> @T>

E<OC@ <D\?<Q> \>OCGC @T> C>Q?D=2 PG@ @TA@iC @T> ?DFW

Page 81: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 81/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RT

>aBFADA@<?D ! QAD @T<DX ?E9 /@T>OV<C>2 <@ V?GF= cGC@

C<HBFW P> C?H>@T<D[ @TA@ VAC GD<D@>D@<?DAF9

j9 ,C W?G V>O> =?<D[ @T> V?OX UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU VT? =<= W?G \<>V @? P> =?<D[ <@ E?Ol

:>O> W?G =?<D[ <@ E?O '<QTAO= B>OC?DAFFWl :>O> W?G

=?<D[ <@ E?O T<C Q?HBADW2 E?O +TABAOOAF2 C?H>@T<D[

>FC>l

,9 -??X<D[ PAQX ?D <@ @TO>> W>AOC FA@>O2 !

O>AFFW P>F<>\> ! VAC =?<D[ @T> E<OC@ BTAC> ?E @T>

V?OX2 VT<QT VAC [>@@<D[ HWC>FE GB @? CB>>=2 E?O

'<QTAO= B>OC?DAFFW9 $T> C>Q?D= BTAC> VT>O> @T>

hIM2KKK \?<Q> Q?H>C <D@? BFAW ! <D@>OAQ@>= A F?@ H?O>

V<@T '<QTAO=iC @>AH9 ! HA=> <D@O?=GQ@<?DC ?E

(A\<= +?F\<D2 A E?OH>O QFACCHA@> ?E H<D> VT?iC

[>D>OAF Q?GDC>F E?O @T> 6A<G@> !D=<AD @O<P> <D

-AC 7>[AC9 ! <D@O?=GQ>= T<H @? @T> @>AH9 :> TA= A

F?@ ?E c?<D@ BT?D> QAFFC AD= =<CQGCC<?DC V<@T T<H AD=

V<@T @T> @>AH2 AD= @T>D ! <D@O?=GQ>= (>DD<C &X>C AFC?

@? @T> @>AH9 .? ! =<= A F?@ H?O> V?OX E?O @T>

+TABAOOAF @>AH2 PG@ ! AFVAWC Q?DC<=>O>= HWC>FE

V?OX<D[ V<@T '<QTAO=9

j9 ,D= =<= '<QTAO= UU T> BA<= W?G ?G@ ?E T<C

B>OC?DAF EGD=C2 Q?OO>Q@2 AC ?BB?C>= ?G@ ?E

+TABAOOAFiCl

Page 82: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 82/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RV

,9 1>C2 W>C9 ! GD=>OC@AD=9

j9 :AC @T> hIM2KKK BAWH>D@ A[O>>= @? P> A

QO>=<@ A[A<DC@ ADW EG@GO> >kG<@W W?G H<[T@ O>Q><\> AC

@T> h`MKK BAWH>D@ VACl

,9 ! P>F<>\> C?9

j9 ,D= VTA@iC @T> QGOO>D@ UU

,9 :T>D W?G CAW gW?Gg UU ! VAD@ @? HAX> CGO>

@TA@ V> GD=>OC@AD= <D @T<C =>B?C<@<?D !iH ACCGH<D[

@TA@ VT>D W?G CAW gW?G2g W?GiO> O>E>OO<D[ @?

6U.?FG@<?DC AD=Z?O H> AD= D?@ cGC@ H> B>OC?DAFFW

P>QAGC> @TA@ Q?GF= P> AD <CCG>2 AD= ! =?Di@ VAD@

@? UU ! =?Di@ VAD@ @? PFGO @TA@ F<D>9

.? VT>D W?GiO> ACX<D[ A kG>C@<?D2 AO> W?G

O>E>OO<D[ @? H> B>OC?DAFFW ?O AO> W?G O>E>OO<D[ @?

@T> Q?HBADW @TA@ =<= @T> Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OXl

j9 :>FF2 AC ! GD=>OC@AD= W?GO @>C@<H?DW2 W?G

B>OC?DAFFW B>OE?OH>= @T> V?OX2 AD= W?GO @>C@<H?DW <C

@TA@ W?G =<= <@ E?O AD >D@<@W QAFF>= 6U.?FG@<?DC9

,9 1>AT2 HGQT F<X> W?GO F>[AF V?OX E?O W?GO

FAV E<OH W?G =? B>OC?DAFFW2 PG@ W?G =? <@ ?D P>TAFE

?E .D>FF S :<FH>O9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E @TA@iC UU

Y'9 ."/:5 )GC@ ADCV>O T<C kG>C@<?D9 1?G

=?Di@ D>>= @? [<\> T<H ADAF?[<>C9

$%& :!$"&..5 /XAW9 ! @T<DX VTA@ W?G CA<=

<C AQQGOA@>9 $TADX W?G9 ! cGC@ VAD@ @? P> \>OW

Page 83: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 83/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RW

QF>AO9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /@T>O @TAD '<QTAO=

'AVF> UU V>FF2 ! [G>CC @T<C <C A kG>C@<?D @TA@ UU F>@

H> PAQX GB A P<@9

:> @AFX>= AP?G@ @T> [?F= Q?<DC A P<@ A[?2

AD= =<= W?G QACT <D C?H> ?E @T?C> [?F= Q?<DC AE@>O

'<QTAO=iC =>A@Tl

,9 "?9

j9 $T>W V>O> AFF P>E?O> T<C =>A@Tl

,9 m:<@D>CC D?==<D[ T>A= AEE<OHA@<\>FW9;

j9 ,D= =<= W?G [<\> @T> Q?<DC @? T<H

B>OC?DAFFW ?O @? +?O@ ?O C?H>P?=W >FC>l

,9 $? T<H B>OC?DAFFW9

j9 ! VAC [?<D[ @? HAX> A Q?HBAO<C?D2 PG@

W?Gi\> ADCV>O>= <@ <D A VAW @TA@ =?>C D?@ AFF?V H> @?

=? @TA@9

:<@T O>CB>Q@ @? @T> +TABAOOAF V?OX2 =<=

@T>O> UU =<= @T> >kG<@W B?@>D@<AF >a<C@ AE@>O

'<QTAO=iC =>A@Tl

,9 ! ACCGH>= @TA@ VT>D ! E<D<CT>= @T> V?OX

AD= @T>W =<=Di@ [? E?OVAO= V<@T @T> 6A<G@> BO?c>Q@

@TA@ ! VAC =?D> V<@T +TABAOOAF AD= V<@T '<QTAO=iC

BO?c>Q@9 !D ?@T>O V?O=C2 ! E>F@ F<X> ! =<=Di@ UU

@TA@ HW >EE?O@C =<=Di@ O>CGF@ <D @T> >aBADC<?D ?E @T>

BO?c>Q@ @? @T> 6A<G@> !D=<AD @O<P>2 C? ! =<=Di@ E>>F

Page 84: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 84/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RJ

F<X> ! TA= ADW X<D= ?E QFA<H ?D '<QTAO= E?O ADW

B>OQ>D@A[> ?E @T> BO?c>Q@9

j9 ,D= =<= @TA@ B?<D@ <D @<H> Q?H> P>E?O>

'<QTAO=iC =>A@Tl

,9 1>C9

j9 .? T<C T><OC2 VT?>\>O V?GF= CGQQ>>= @? T<C

<D@>O>C@ <D @T<C Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@2 TA\> W?G TA= ADW

=<CQGCC<?DC V<@T @T>H AP?G@ @T> >kG<@W <D@>O>C@ @TA@

'<QTAO= TA= A[O>>= @? [<\> W?G <E W?GO V?OX UU

,9 ! TA\> D?@ TA= ADW =<CQGCC<?DC V<@T @T>

EAH<FW H>HP>OC9

j9 (? W?G XD?V <E ADW ?E @T> EAH<FW H>HP>OC

?O ADW H>HP>OC ?E @T> +TABAOOAF \>D@GO> XD>V AP?G@

'<QTAO=iC A[O>>H>D@ V<@T W?G @TA@ T> V?GF= >a@>D=

C?H> ?E @T> >kG<@W @? W?Gl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

j9 %A\> W?G >\>O @AFX>= @? ,FF>D 1?GD[ ?O

ADWP?=W UU !iH PFADX<D[ ?D @T> (?VDC [GWiC E<OC@

DAH>2 PG@ ><@T>O ?E @T>H UU (O>V (?VDC9

%A\> W?G @AFX>= @? ><@T>O ?E @T>H AP?G@

@TA@l

,9 "?9

j9 ,D= W?G TA\>Di@ @AFX>= V<@T @T> 'AVF>

PO?@T>OC AP?G@ @TA@l

,9 "?9

Page 85: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 85/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RN

j9 /XAW9 ! VAD@ @? cGC@ UU !i\> [?@ C?H>

=?QGH>D@C T>O>9

1?G =<= <D@O?=GQ> @T> [O?GB @? (A\<=

+?F\<D2 O<[T@l

,9 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= T> VAC A FAV CQT??F QFACCHA@> ?E

W?GOCl

,9 '<[T@9

Y'9 -,--!5 ->@iC HAOX @T<C AC &aT<P<@ J9

K&H#/I/1 W )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ J <C AD >UHA<F2 ?O

C>O<>C ?E >UHA<FC ,BO<F IL @? NK ?E NKII2 AD= ! VAD@

@? E?QGC W?GO A@@>D@<?D ?D @T> @?B ?D>2 ,BO<F NK2

NKII2 ^5]] A9H9 !@ C?GD=C F<X> W?GiO> AOOAD[<D[ A

H>>@<D[ V<@T @T> +TA<OHAD9

!C @TA@ @T> +TA<OHAD ?E @T> @O<P>l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= T?V =<= W?G XD?V @T> +TA<OHAD ?E @T>

@O<P>l

,9 ! =<=Di@ XD?V T<H9

j9 %?V =<= W?G AOOAD[> @T> H>>@<D[l

,9 :>FF2 F>@iC O>A= @T> >UHA<F9 g1>C2 !

@T<DX C?9 %> D>>=C @? [>@ @T> +TA<OHAD A VO<@> GB ?E

?GO BO?B?CAF9 *DF>CC @TA@ <C =?D> V> D>>= @? TA\>

C?H> <DBG@ ?D @TA@9 :> D>>= @? @AX> A [??= CT?@ A@

Page 86: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 86/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RO

<@9 !iFF QAFF T<H @?=AW9g

.? @T> gT<H2g C?GD=C @? H> F<X> !iH

O>E>O>DQ<D[ (A\<= +?F\<D9

j9 dG@ W?G =<=Di@ TA\> A B>OC?DAF

O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T @T> +TA<OHAD ?E @T> @O<P>l

,9 "?9 ! D>\>O XD>V T<H9 ! HAW TA\> XD?VD

T<C DAH>2 PG@ ! =<= D?@ TA\> A B>OC?DAF O>FA@<?DCT<B

V<@T T<H9

j9 +AD W?G <=>D@<EW @T> @<H> EOAH> =GO<D[

VT<QT W?G B>OE?OH>= W?GO C>O\<Q>C E?O @T> Q>H>D@

BO?c>Q@2 AD= VAC @T>O> A P>[<DD<D[ AD= AD >D=2 ?O <C

@T> P>[<DD<D[ AD= >D= A F<@@F> PFGOO>=l

,9 $T> >D=iC A F<@@F> PFGOO>=9 $T> P>[<DD<D[

VAC2 F<X> ! CA<= P>E?O>2 @T> EAFF ?E NKIK9 $T> >D=

V?GF= TA\> P>>D UU ! H>AD2 ! @T<DX ! O>H>HP>O O>A=<D[

AD >UHA<F AP?G@ A H>>@<D[ ! TA= V<@T (>DD<C &X>C AC

FA@> AC ,G[GC@ ?O .>B@>HP>O ?O /Q@?P>O2 HAWP>

"?\>HP>O ?E NKII9 $T>O> V?GF= P> D? O>AC?D E?O H> @?

H>>@ V<@T (>DD<C &X>C <E <@ VACDi@ AP?G@ @T> BO?c>Q@2

PG@ <@ O>AFFW B>@>O>= ?G@ AE@>O )GD> ?O )GFW ?E NKIK9

:T>D ! CAW UU V>FF2 ?XAW9

Y'9 -,--!5 3?GO9

K&H#/I/1 J )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ ] <C A C>O<>C ?E

>UHA<FC )GD> ` @? II2 NKIN9 $T> ?D> ?D @T> @?B <C AD

Page 87: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 87/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RP

>UHA<F EO?H '<QTAO= @? W?G AD= )AC?D 6?V>OC

O>E>O>DQ<D[ g<DE?OHA@<?D ?D @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@ @TA@

)?TD TAC P>>D V?OX<D[ V<@T H> ?D9g

(? W?G XD?V VTA@ @T<C <C <D O>[AO= @?l

,9 !iH ?DFW <DE>OO<D[ EO?H @T> FAD[GA[>9 !@

C?GD=C @? H> F<X> AD &a>QG@<\> .GHHAOW @TA@ VAC BG@

@?[>@T>O PW ,FF>D 1?GD[ AD= T<C @>AH9

j9 (<= W?G TA\> A TAD= <D BO>BAO<D[ @TA@

&a>QG@<\> .GHHAOWl

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX C? =<O>Q@FW9 YAWP> C?H> ?E

@T> <DE?OHA@<?D @TA@ !i= O>C>AOQT>= [?@ <D@? @T>

&a>QG@<\> .GHHAOW2 PG@ @TA@ VAC D?@ =?D> PW H>9

j9 (<= W?G BO?=GQ> ADW VO<@@>D V?OX BO?=GQ@

=GO<D[ W?GO Q?DCGF@<D[ >EE?O@ ?D @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@

<D ">\A=Al

,9 ! [A\> C?H> D?@>C @? '<QTAO=2 AD= !

T<[TF<[T@>= C@G=<>C @TA@ !i= O>C>AOQT>= AD= E?GD= ?D

@T> !D@>OD>@ E?O '<QTAO= AD= =<CQGCC>= @T?C> V<@T

'<QTAO=9 $TA@ V?GF= P> Q?DC<=>O>= V?OX BO?=GQ@9 !

=>F<\>O>= @TA@ AFF @? '<QTAO= AD= =<=Di@ X>>B Q?B<>C

?E @TA@2 AD= @T>D ! =<= TA\> <DBG@ <D@? Q?D@OAQ@C2

BO?B?C>= Q?D@OAQ@C2 @TA@ @T>W V>O> V?OX<D[ ?D P>@V>>D

@T> Q?DCGF@AD@C AD= +TABAOOAF2 AD= ! P>F<>\> ! =<=

TA\> <DBG@ <D@? @T> &a>QG@<\> .GHHAOW2 PG@ @TA@ V?GF=

P> UU @TA@ V?GF= Q?DC<C@ ?E UU @TA@ V?GF= P> @T> V?OX

Page 88: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 88/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RR

BO?=GQ@ ! BO?\<=>= @? @T> Q?HBADW9

j9 /XAW9 (? W?G XD?V VTW '<QTAO= VAC

E?OVAO=<D[ @T<C >UHA<F @? W?G AD= )AC?D 6?V>OC <D

)GD> ?E NKINl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V VTW T> VAC E?OVAO=<D[ <@ @?

)AC?D 6?V>OC2 PG@ ! V?GF= ACCGH> T> E?OVAO=>= <@ @?

H> P>QAGC> T> VAD@>= HW <DBG@ ?D @T> &a>QG@<\>

.GHHAOW9

j9 )GC@ @T> @>DC> @TA@ '<QTAO= TAC GC>= <D

@T<C <D=<QA@>C @? H> @TA@ @T> V?OX <C ?D[?<D[9

!C @TA@ <DAQQGOA@>l

,9 :>FF2 F<X> ! CA<= @? W?G ?O W?G CA<= @?

H>2 <@ VAC X<D= ?E A PFGOOW F<D> AP?G@ T?V F?D[ @T>

V?OX V>D@2 AD= C? ! V?GF= ACCGH> @TA@ ! VAC C@<FF

V?OX<D[ V<@T '<QTAO= ?D @T<C A@ @T<C B?<D@ <D @<H>9

Y'9 -,--!5 3<\>9

K&H#/I/1 N )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 &aT<P<@ M <C

AD?@T>O C>O<>C ?E >UHA<FC9 $T> ?D> A@ @T> @?B ?E @T>

E<OC@ BA[> <C /Q@?P>O N]2 NKII2 EO?H W?G @?

'<QTAO= 'AVF>2 AD= <@iC V<@T O>E>O>DQ> @? A +T<D>C>

<D\>C@?O9

(? W?G O>QAFF VTA@ @TA@ VACl

,9 :>FF2 ! =?Di@ XD?V VT? @T> +T<D>C>

<D\>C@?O VAC ?O H<[T@ TA\> P>>D9 ! =<=Di@ TA\> @TA@

Page 89: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 89/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

RS

O>FA@<?DCT<B9

'AD=W 6AOX <C A EO<>D= ?E H<D>2 A D><[TP?O

?E H<D>2 VT? TA= C?H> Q?D@AQ@C <D +T<DA V<@T B>?BF>

V<@T CGPC@AD@<AF H>ADC2 AD= T> AD= ! TA= A =<CQGCC<?D

AP?G@ VT? T> H<[T@ XD?V @TA@ H<[T@ P> <D@>O>C@>= <D

<D\>C@<D[ <D @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@ ?O PGW<D[ A Q>H>D@

BO?c>Q@ F<X> @T<C2 C? ! @T<DX @TA@iC @T> Q?D@>a@ ?E

@T<C Q?HHGD<QA@<?D9

j9 ,D= VAC @T<C UU ! H>AD2 <@ F??XC F<X>

W?GiO> BACC<D[ @T<C AF?D[ @? '<QTAO= Q?DQ>OD<D[ A

B?@>D@<AF +T<D>C> <D\>C@?O2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 $TA@ V?GF= P> Q?OO>Q@9

j9 ,D= ! @AX> @TA@ @? H>AD A B?@>D@<AF

<D\>C@?O <D @T> +TABAOOAF Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@l

,9 +?OO>Q@9

j9 /XAW9 .? <C @T<C BAO@ ?E @T> >a@OA

NK T?GOC @TA@ W?G V>O> P><D[ BA<= E?Oe @TA@ <C2 @T>

NK T?GOC @TA@ W?Gi= >C@<HA@>= BO<?O @? ,BO<F ?E NKIIl

,9 .? ! [G>CC @T> kG>C@<?D <C5 !C @T<C BAO@

?E HW Q?DCGF@<D[ AOOAD[>H>D@ V<@T '<QTAO=l

j9 :>FF2 @TA@ VACDi@ @T> kG>C@<?D2 PG@ !iFF

@AX> AD ADCV>O @? @TA@ ?D> <E W?G TA\> ?D>9

Y'9 ."/:5 :TW =?Di@ V> TA\> @T> O>B?O@>O

O>A= PAQX UU

$%& :!$"&..5 1>AT2 O>A= PAQX @T>

Page 90: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 90/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SU

kG>C@<?D9

Y'9 ."/:5 UU @T> kG>C@<?D9

$%& +/*'$ '&6/'$&'5 gjG>C@<?D5 /XAW9

.? <C @T<C BAO@ ?E @T> >a@OA NK T?GOC @TA@

W?G V>O> P><D[ BA<= E?Oe @TA@ <C2 @T> NK T?GOC @TA@

W?Gi= >C@<HA@>= BO<?O @? ,BO<F ?E NKIIlg

$%& :!$"&..5 ,D= @T> ADCV>O <C ! =?Di@

@T<DX C?2 PG@ ! E>>F F<X> '<QTAO= AD= @T> [O?GB V>O>

@OW<D[ @? E<D= A VAW @? HAOX>@ @T> Q?HBADW AD= V>O>

<D@>O>C@>= <D O>FA@<?DCT<BC AD= P><D[ <D@O?=GQ>= @?

B>?BF> @TA@ V?GF= TA\> AD <D@>O>C@ <D PGW<D[ @T>

Q?HBADW2 AD= ?D> ?E @T> @T<D[C '<QTAO= TA= CA<= @? H>

VAC @TA@ <E W?G Q?GF= E<D= A BGOQTAC>O2 @TA@ V?GF= P>

AD?@T>O VAW E?O W?G @? >AOD AD <D@>O>C@ <D @T>

Q?HBADW9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ,D >kG<@W <D@>O>C@l

,9 ,D >kG<@W <D@>O>C@ <D @T> Q?HBADW2 ?O AD

>kG<@W <D@>O>C@ ?O C?H> ?@T>O @WB> ?E AD <D@>O>C@ <D

@T> Q?HBADW2 ACCGH<D[ AD >kG<@W <D@>O>C@ <D @T>

Q?HBADW9

j9 /XAW9 .? T?V =<= W?G =<EE>O>D@<A@> <D

W?GO H<D= P>@V>>D Q?DCGF@<D[ C>O\<Q>C @TA@ W?G V>O>

BO?\<=<D[ E?O '<QTAO=2 VT<QT <DQFG=>= @T> B?C@U,BO<F

NKII >C@<HA@> ?E NK T?GOC2 AD= HAX<D[ <D@O?=GQ@<?DC

E?O B>?BF> VT? HAW E<DADQ> @T> BO?c>Q@ VT<QT V?GF=

Page 91: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 91/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

ST

[<\> W?G AD >kG<@W <D@>O>C@l

,9 ,D= @TA@iC A [??= kG>C@<?D @TA@ ! =?Di@

XD?V <E ! QAD ADCV>O9

j9 :>FF2 ! H>AD2 <@ HAW P> @TA@ W?G cGC@

=<=Di@ HAX> @TA@ =<C@<DQ@<?D A@ @T> @<H> W?G V>O>

=?<D[ @T<C9

,9 ! cGC@ =?Di@ O>QAFF9 ! @T<DX ! H>D@<?D>=

@T> BO?c>Q@ @? @V? ?O @TO>> QF?C> EO<>D=C @TA@ !

@T?G[T@ H<[T@ TA\> O>FA@<?DCT<BC @TA@ H<[T@ P> ?E

<D@>O>C@ @? '<QTAO= 'AVF>9 ! =?Di@ XD?V VT>D @T>

FAC@ CGQT <D@O?=GQ@<?D ! @O<>= @? HAX> E?O '<QTAO=9

Y'9 -,--!5 /XAW9 $TA@iC &aT<P<@ ^9

K&H#/I/1 O )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ ^ <C A

"?\>HP>O II2 NKII2 >UHA<F EO?H W?G @? '<QTAO= 'AVF>

O>E>O>DQ<D[ )?TD YQ!D@<O>9 $T<C ABB>AOC EO?H @T>

CGPc>Q@ F<D> @? P> <D Q?DD>Q@<?D V<@T @T> +TABAOOAF

BO?c>Q@9

+AD W?G >aBFA<D @TA@2 VT>@T>O <@ VAC ?O

D?@l

,9 ! QADi@9 !@ Q?GF= TA\> P>>D C<HBFW2 W?G

XD?V2 A O>BFW2 O>BFW2 O>BFW9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

)?TD YQ!D@<O> <C D?@2 <D HW GD=>OC@AD=<D[2 O>FA@>= A@

AFF @? @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@2 C? UU W?G XD?V2 ! =?Di@

XD?V <E ! QAD [<\> PAQX[O?GD= ?O CT?GF= [<\>

Page 92: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 92/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SV

PAQX[O?GD=2 PG@ )?TD YQ!D@<O> <C <D\?F\>= <D @T>

"A@<?DAF 6AW=AW ->D=<D[ ,CC?Q<A@<?D2 AD= ! TA= C>O\>=

AC A BO?aW E?O '<QTAO= VT>D ! VAC <D BO<\A@> BOAQ@<Q>

?D A E>V ?QQAC<?DC V<@T @T> DA@<?DAF ACC?Q<A@<?D2 C?

VT>D T> CA<= C?OOW W?GiO> D?@ Q?H<D[2 ! =?Di@ XD?V

VTW T> V?GF= TA\> CA<= @TA@2 >aQ>B@ @TA@ HAWP> UU

HAWP> @T>W V>O> [?<D[ C?H>VT>O> EGD9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

j9 ! @AX> <@ EO?H @TA@ ADCV>O @TA@ W?G =? D?@

ACC?Q<A@> )?TD YQ!D@<O> V<@T @T> +TABAOOAF Q>H>D@

BO?c>Q@l

,9 "?2 ! =?Di@9

Y'9 -,--!5 /XAW9 .>\>D9

K&H#/I/1 P )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 &aT<P<@ _ <C C?H>

>UHA<FC "?\>HP>O NN @? (>Q>HP>O I ?E NKII9 !@ F??XC

F<X> @T>O> <C H?O> =<AF?[G> [?<D[ PAQX AD= E?O@T

P>@V>>D W?G AD= '<QTAO= 'AVF> Q?DQ>OD<D[ A +T<DA

Q?D@AQ@9

(? W?G C>> @TA@l

,9 1>AT2 ! =?9 ! =?Di@ C>> EO?H H> @?

'<QTAO=9 gY>@ @T<C H?OD<D[ V<@T +T<DA Q?D@AQ@gl

j9 '<[T@9

,9 /T2 @TA@ HGC@ TA\> cGC@ P>>D HW EO<>D=2

'AD=W 6AOX9

j9 ,D= @T>D <D @T> >UHA<F A@ @T> @?B ?E @T>

Page 93: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 93/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SW

BA[> W?G CAW @TA@ W?G AO> QT>QX<D[ AD= W?GiFF TA\> A

O>B?O@ VT>D W?G C>> '<QTAO= @?H?OO?V9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= <@ F??XC F<X> W?GiO> QT>QX<D[ ?D @T>

CGPc>Q@ ?E '<QTAO=iC >UHA<F @T>O>2 VT<QT <C g,DW

F>A=C ?D C>FF<D[ @T> Q>H>D@ BO?B>O@W AD= <C &X>C

Q?H<D[ GB V<@T A BO?B?CAFlg

,9 '<[T@2 W>AT9

j9 !C @T<C F<X> @T> FAC@ ?D> V> @AFX>= AP?G@

VT>O> A@ @T<C B?<D@ <D @<H> W?G QADi@ =<EE>O>D@<A@>

P>@V>>D @T<C Q?HHGD<QA@<?D AC P><D[ <D EGO@T>OADQ> ?E

@T> >a@OA NK T?GOC B?C@U,BO<F NKII AC ?BB?C>= @? W?G

Q?D@<DG<D[ @? V?OX <D @T> T?B> ?E AD >kG<@W <D@>O>C@

?O <D@O?=GQ<D[ C?H>?D> @? @T> BO?c>Q@l

,9 :>FF2 ! @T<DX @TA@ PW D?V2 PW @T<C

B?<D@ UU ! H>AD2 !iH cGC@ CB>QGFA@<D[2 PG@ PW @T<C

B?<D@ !iH BG@@<D[ EAO H?O> @TAD NK T?GOC <D@? @T>

BO?c>Q@ EO?H @T> @<H> ! FAC@ <D\?<Q>= T<H9

j9 ,D= @T<C [>@C PAQX @? ?D> ?E @T> kG>C@<?DC

! ACX>= >AOF<>O9

:AC @T>O> >\>O AD <D@>D@<?D A@ @T<C B?<D@

<D @<H>2 E?O >aAHBF>2 (>Q>HP>O ?E NKII2 ?E <D\?<Q<D[

'<QTAO= A[A<Dl

,9 "?9

j9 .? W?GO BGOB?C> T>O> VAC E?O A B?@>D@<AF

Page 94: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 94/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SJ

>kG<@W B<>Q>l

,9 :>FF2 @TA@ Q>O@A<DFW VACDi@ C?H>@T<D[ !

V?GF= VAFX AVAW EO?H <E !i= >AOD>= <@9

j9 .GO>9

,9 1?G XD?V2 A[A<D2 !iH AFC? A@ @T<C B?<D@ <D

@<H> C@<FF A \>OW QF?C> EO<>D= ?E '<QTAO=iC AD=

@OW<D[ @? T>FB T<H P> AC CGQQ>CCEGF AC T> QAD

B?CC<PFW P>2 PG@ Q>O@A<DFW ! P>F<>\> A@ @T<C @<H> <E

! HA=> AD <D@O?=GQ@<?D @? C?H>?D> @TA@ AQ@GAFFW

BGOQTAC>= @T> Q?HBADW @TA@ ! V?GF= P> Q?HB>DCA@>= E?O

<@2 PG@ ! =<=Di@ Q?DC<=>O <@ @? P> BAO@ ?E @T>

NK T?GOC9

Y'9 -,--!5 *D=>OC@??=9 &<[T@9

K&H#/I/1 R )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 $T<C <C AD?@T>O

>UHA<F )GD> IM2 NKIN2 O>E>OO<D[ @? A Q?D@AQ@ <D @T>

">\A=A /EE<Q> ?E &Q?D?H<Q (>\>F?BH>D@ <D @T> H<D<D[

=<\<C<?D9

+AD W?G O>QAFF VTA@ W?G V>O> =?<D[ <D @T<C

O>CB>Q@l

,9 ->@ H> @T<DX9 ! @T<DX '<QTAO= UU !iH cGC@

@OW<D[ @? O>H>HP>O9 '<QTAO=2 ! @T<DX2 TA= A kG>C@<?D

AP?G@ ADW .@A@> ?E ">\A=A CGPC<=<>C @TA@ H<[T@ P>

A\A<FAPF> E?O @T> =>\>F?BH>D@ ?E A Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@2

AD=2 AC ! O>QAFF2 @TO?G[T A EO<>D= ?E H<D> ! E?GD= A

Page 95: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 95/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SN

Q?D@AQ@ <D @T> &Q?D?H<Q (>\>F?BH>D@ ?EE<Q>9 ! VACDi@

D>Q>CCAO<FW F??X<D[ E?O @T> Q?D@AQ@2 PG@ V> @AFX>=

AP?G@ <@2 AD= ! H>D@<?D>= @? '<QTAO= @TA@ !i= E?GD= A

Q?D@AQ@9 $TA@iC AFF ! O>H>HP>O AP?G@ @TA@9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VTA@2 <E ADW@T<D[2 QAH> ?E <@l

,9 ! =?Di@9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9

Y'9 -,--!5 "<D>9

K&H#/I/1 S )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ L <C AD >UHA<F

EO?H W?G @? $WF>O 1?GD[ YAOQT I`2 NKIJ2 AD= <@ F??XC

F<X> W?G V>O> C>>X<D[ A O>Q>D@ Q?BW ?E @T> &a>QG@<\>

.GHHAOW E?O +TABAOOAFl

,9 *TUTGT mW>C;9

j9 (<= W?G <DkG<O> VTA@ @T> BGOB?C> ?E @TA@

VACl

,9 ! TA= A EO<>D= VT? TA= C?H> Q?D@AQ@C <D

Y>a<Q? VT? VAC <D@>O>C@>= <D F>AOD<D[ H?O> AP?G@ @T>

Q>H>D@ Q?HBADW2 AD= T> ACX>= H> E?O AD &a>QG@<\>

.GHHAOW2 C? ! ACX>= $WF>O E?O A Q?BW ?E <@9

j9 ,D= =? W?G O>QAFF VT? @T> EO<>D= VACl

,9 ! @T<DX T<C DAH> VAC &\AD dWP>>9

j9 ,D= =? W?G XD?V <E ADW@T<D[ QAH> ?E @TA@l

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX ADW@T<D[ =<=9 ! =?Di@ >\>D

@T<DX ! O>Q><\>= A Q?BW ?E @T> CGHHAOW9 ! =?Di@

O>QAFF O>Q><\<D[ A Q?BW ?E @T> CGHHAOW9

Page 96: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 96/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SO

j9 (? W?G XD?V VTA@ @T> C@A@GC ?E @T>

+TABAOOAF BO?c>Q@ <C @?=AWl

,9 ! @AFX>= @? ,FF>D 1?GD[ A Q?GBF> ?E H?D@TC

A[?2 AD= T> @?F= H> @TA@ T> @T?G[T@ @T>W TA= C?H>

<D@>O>C@ <D C?H>?D> EO?H dOAf<F2 AD= T> C>>H>= BO>@@W

>aQ<@>= AP?G@ <@9

j9 &\>D @T?G[T '<QTAO=iC BACC>= ?D2 AO> W?G

Q?D@<DG<D[ @? X>>B AD >W> ?G@ E?O C?H>?D>2 AD= <E W?G

E?GD= A B?@>D@<AF PGW>O ?O C?H>@T<D[2 V?GF= W?G O>E>O

@T>H @? ,FF>D ?O C?H>?D> >FC>l

,9 :>FF2 <E C?H>@T<D[ =O?BB>= <D HW FAB UU

j9 1>AT9

,9 UU ! V?GF= BO?PAPFW O>E>O <@ @? @T>H2 PG@

!iH D?@ F??X<D[ E?O ADW@T<D[9 !iH D?@ AQ@<\>FW <D

@TA@2 AD= ! TA\>Di@ >\>D O>C>AOQT>= <@ @? XD?V VTA@

F>[AFFW ?O FAVEGFFW ! Q?GF= =? ?O O>Q><\> <E @TA@

V>O> @? TABB>D AC ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF9 !i= TA\> @? F??X

A@ AFF @T?C> <CCG>C P>E?O>999

j9 :?GF= @TA@ P> =<EE>O>D@ EO?H VTA@ W?G

Q?GF= F>[AFFW ?O FAVEGFFW =? AC @T> +T<>E (>BG@Wl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 ! XD?V ! TA= A F?@ ?E

FA@<@G=> AC +T<>E (>BG@W9 ! TA\>Di@ >\>D @T?G[T@

AP?G@ ?O O>C>AOQT>= @T> <CCG> AC ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF9

!i\> cGC@ @O<>= @? C@AW AVAW EO?H @T?C> @WB>C ?E

@T<D[C9

Page 97: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 97/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SP

j9 :TA@ VAC @T> FA@<@G=> @TA@ AFF?V>= W?G @?

=? @T<C AC W?G V>O> V?OX<D[ AC @T> +T<>E (>BG@Wl :AC

@T>O> A B?F<QW ?O C?H>@T<D[l

,9 :>FF2 ! VAC A D?DUH>O<@ >HBF?W>>2 C? !

=<=Di@ TA\> UU ! =<=Di@ TA\> ADW O>C@O<Q@<?DC >aQ>B@

@? @T> >a@>D@ @TA@ @T> *@AT +?=> BO?\<=>= E?O

Q?DEF<Q@ ?E <D@>O>C@ O>C@O<Q@<?DC9

j9 ,D= VTA@ VAC @T> DA@GO> ?E @T?C> Q?DEF<Q@

?E <D@>O>C@ O>C@O<Q@<?DCl

,9 :>FF2 <E ! TA= C?H>@T<D[ UU A BO?c>Q@ @TA@

VAC O>[GFA@>= <D @T> .@A@> ?E *@AT @TA@ ! TA=

CGB>O\<C?OW AG@T?O<@W ?\>O2 @T>D @TA@ V?GF= P>

C?H>@T<D[ !i= TA\> @? F??X A@ \>OW QAO>EGFFW AD=

B>OTABC >\>D =<CQF?C> AD= HAX> Q>O@A<D @WB>C ?E

Q?DEF<Q@ =<CQF?CGO>C P>E?O> ! Q?GF= BAO@<Q<BA@>9

j9 dG@ AC EAO AC W?G GD=>OC@??=2 =?<D[

Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX ?D A BO?c>Q@ ?G@ ?E C@A@> VAC D?@

@TA@ UU D?@ A Q?DEF<Q@ ?E <D@>O>C@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= P>E?O> GD=>O@AX<D[ @T<C +TABAOOAF

V?OX2 =<= W?G QF>AO @TA@ @TO?G[T @T> @T>D

,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF ?O C?H> ?@T>O VAWl

,9 1?G XD?V2 ! O>QAFF @AFX<D[ V<@T T<H AP?G@

<@2 PO<>EFW CB>AX<D[ ?OAFFW V<@T T<H9 !i\> C<DQ>

@AFX>= @? T<H2 AD= T> =?>CDi@ O>QAFF @T>

Page 98: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 98/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SR

Q?D\>OCA@<?D2 AD= ! =?Di@ XD?V <E T> VAC ?D

H>=<QA@<?D A@ @T> @<H> ?O VTA@9 ! O>H>HP>O VT>O> <@

VAC2 PG@ <@ VACDi@ O>kG<O>=2 AD= T>iC AQ@GAFFW HA=> A

C@A@>H>D@ @? @TA@ >EE>Q@ C<DQ> @T<C C@?OW PO?X>9

j9 :TA@ <C @T> Q?D\>OCA@<?D W?G O>QAFFl :TA@

AO> @T> Q<OQGHC@ADQ>Cl

,9 '<[T@9 !@ VAC <D T<C ?EE<Q>2 AD= !

PAC<QAFFW CA<= '<QTAO= 'AVF> TAC AD ?G@ ?E C@A@>

BO?c>Q@ @TA@ T>i= F<X> H> @? Q?DCGF@ V<@T T<H ?D9 (?

W?G TA\> A BO?PF>H V<@T @TA@2 =? W?G TA\> A Q?DQ>OD

AP?G@ @TA@2 AD= T> CA<= C?H>@T<D[ F<X>2 V>FF2 =?>C <@

Q?DQ>OD ADW <CCG>C V<@T @T> .@A@> ?E *@AT2 AD= ! CA<=

D?2 AD= T> CA<= ! =?Di@ C>> A BO?PF>H V<@T @TA@9

j9 6O<?O @? @T> EAFF ?E NKKL2 =<= W?G TA\> A

@OGC@ ?O AD >C@A@> BFADl

,9 6O<?O @? @T> E?OHA@<?D ?E @T> .GB>O .>\>D

$OGC@l

j9 1>C9

,9 ! =<= D?@9

j9 :TA@ BO?HB@>= W?G @? E?OH @TA@l

,9 :>FF2 BO<?O @? c?<D<D[ @T> ,8iC ?EE<Q> <D

@T> EAFF ?E NKK`2 C? AP?G@ A W>AO P>E?O> ! c?<D>= @T>

,8iC ?EE<Q>2 ! P>[AD V?OX<D[ ?D A BO?c>Q@ @TA@ !

@T?G[T@ Q?GF= P>Q?H> \>OW CGQQ>CCEGF2 AD= ! VAC

<D@>O>C@>= <D E?OH<D[ A \>T<QF> VT>O> ! Q?GF= [O?V

Page 99: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 99/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

SS

@T> \AFG> ?E A PGC<D>CC <DC<=> @T> \>T<QF> OA@T>O

@TAD ?G@C<=> @T> \>T<QF> E?O >C@A@> BFADD<D[ AD= @Aa

BGOB?C>C2 C? AC ! GD=>OC@??= <@2 <E W?G =>\>F?B>=

C<[D<E<QAD@ V>AF@T AD= @T>D @OADCE>OO>= <@ <D@? A

@OGC@ <@ V?GF= P> A @AaAPF> >\>D@2 PG@ <E W?G PG<F@

<@ V<@T<D A @OGC@2 @T>D W?G Q?GF= TA\> @T> EAH<FW

T?F= <@ <D B>OB>@G<@W AD= D?@ TA\> ADW @OADCE>O

<CCG>C AD= @Aa <CCG>C VT>D W?G @OADCE>OO>= @T> ACC>@C

<D@? @T> @OGC@2 AD= !i= XD?VD @TA@ E?O kG<@> AVT<F>9

!i\> XD?VD C>\>OAF B>?BF> VT? V>O> \>OW CGQQ>CCEGF2

AD= C? VT>D ! TA= @T<C ?BB?O@GD<@W2 ! E>F@ F<X> <@

VAC @<H> @? C>@ GB @TA@ X<D= ?E A @OGC@2 VT<QT <C

VTA@ V> =<=9

j9 /XAW9 $T> XD?VF>=[> @TA@ W?G cGC@

=>CQO<P>= TA\<D[2 T?V =<= W?G E?OH @TA@l (<= W?G

BOAQ@<Q> <D @T> AO>A ?E >C@A@> BFADD<D[l

,9 ! =<=Di@ BOAQ@<Q> <D @TA@ AO>A2 PG@ ! TA=

QF<>D@C VT? TA= C<[D<E<QAD@ V>AF@T VT? TA= @T?C>

@WB>C ?E @OGC@C9 '<QTAO= 'AVF> VAC ?D> ?E @T?C>2 E?O

>aAHBF>9 %> AD= ! @AFX>= AP?G@ @TA@9

j9 /XAW9

,9 !D EAQ@2 ->> YQ+GFF?G[T VAC T<C A@@?OD>W

AD= TA= =>\>F?B>= T<C ?VD >C@A@> BFADD<D[ =?QGH>D@C9

j9 !C @TA@ VTA@ F>= W?G @? ->> YQ+GFF?G[Tl

,9 ! P>F<>\> C?9

Page 100: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 100/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUU

j9 ->> YQ+GFF?G[TiC D?@ A FAV CQT??F

QFACCHA@> UU

,9 "?9

j9 UU ?O ADW@T<D[ F<X> @TA@l

(<= W?G TA\> ADW BO<?O O>FA@<?DCT<B V<@T

YO9 YQ+GFF?G[T UU

,9 "?9

j9 UU P>E?O> >D[A[<D[ T<H @? =? W?GO >C@A@>

BFADl

,9 "?9

j9 (<= C?H>?D> O>E>O W?G @? YO9 YQ+GFF?G[Tl

,9 ! P>F<>\> C?9 ! @T<DX <@ VAC '<QTAO=9

YAW TA\> P>>D 6AGF &V<D[9

j9 :T? <C 6AGF &V<D[l

,9 6AGF <C A B>OC?D @TA@ ! VAC ACC?Q<A@>=

V<@T P>E?O> ! QAH> <D@? @T> ,8iC ?EE<Q>9

j9 !D VTA@ QABAQ<@Wl

,9 %>iC A PGC<D>CCHAD9 !i= =?D> A F<@@F> P<@

?E F>[AF V?OX E?O T<H9

j9 ,D= C? C?H>T?V W?G [?@ O>E>OO>= @?

->> YQ+GFF?G[Tl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 dG@ <@ C?GD=C @? H> F<X> P>E?O> W?G

V>D@ @? YO9 YQ+GFF?G[T W?G TA= <D H<D= @T> @WB> ?E

@OGC@ W?G VAD@>= @? E?OHl

Page 101: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 101/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUT

,9 '<[T@9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF H>>@<D[ V<@T YO9 YQ+GFF?G[T

@? >D[A[> T<H @? E?OH W?GO @OGC@l

,9 ! =?9

j9 ,D= VT>O> VAC @TA@l

,9 !D T<C ?EE<Q>9

j9 ,D= =<= W?G @>FF T<H @TA@ W?G VAD@>= @?

E?OH @T> X<D= ?E @OGC@ W?Gi\> =>CQO<P>=l

,9 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= <C @T>O> A DAH> @TA@ W?G QAFF @TA@

X<D= ?E A @OGC@l

,9 ! =?Di@ O>H>HP>O9 !@ VAC C?H> X<D= ?E A

DAH>2 F<X> A HAc>C@<Q @OGC@ ?O A [OAD@?O @OGC@ ?O

C?H>@T<D[ ?E @TA@ C?O@9

j9 8OAD@?O @OGC@ <C C?H>@T<D[ VT>O> !i\>

T>AO= QTAOAQ@>O<f>= AC @TA@9

:<@T?G@ ><@T>O ?E GC P><D[ >C@A@> BFADD<D[

FAVW>OC2 QAD V> A[O>> @? GC> @TA@ @>OH UU

,9 .GO>9

j9 UU E?O @T> CAX> ?E Q?D\>D<>DQ> T>O>l

,9 m:<@D>CC D?==<D[ T>A= AEE<OHA@<\>FW9;

j9 ,D= PW @T> [OAD@?O @OGC@2 ! H>AD VT>O> W?G

BG@ A PGC<D>CC V<@T<D A @OGC@ P>E?O> @T> PGC<D>CC

AQ@GAFFW [O?VC2 PG@ W?GiO> >aB>Q@<D[ <@ @? P> \>OW

\AFGAPF>l

Page 102: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 102/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUV

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= W?G TA= CGQT A PGC<D>CC AFO>A=W

<D H<D=2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 ! =<=9

j9 ,D= @>FF H> VTA@ @TA@ PGC<D>CC VAC9

,9 !@ VAC A C?E@VAO> BO?c>Q@ V<@T A B<>Q> ?E

C?E@VAO> @TA@ ! BFADD>= @? HAOX>@ ?D @T> !D@>OD>@

@TA@ O>FA@>= @? Q>FF BT?D>C2 AD= <@ V?GF= F>@ B>?BF>

<DC@AFF @T> C?E@VAO> ?D @T><O BT?D> AD= E<D= <@ <E <@

VAC F?C@ AD= V<B> <@ QF>AD <E <@ VAC F?C@ O>H?@>FW9

:> QAD C>> D?V @TA@ <@iC A BO>@@W [??=

<=>A P>QAGC> >\>OW BT?D> TAC @TA@ D?V2 PG@ @TA@ VAC

@T> C?E@VAO>9 :> TA= A F<Q>DC> EO?H @T> C?E@VAO>

=>\>F?B>O @? P> APF> @? C>FF @TA@ AD= C>FF <@ <D T<[T

\?FGH>2 AD= P>QAGC> <@ VAC A C?E@VAO> BO?c>Q@ @TA@ !

@T<DX W?G Q?GF= =?VDF?A= ?DF<D>2 <@ VAC \>OW

@OADCB?O@APF>2 C? W?G Q?GF= PAC<QAFFW C>FF <@ ?DF<D>

AD= B>?BF> Q?GF= =?VDF?A= <@ ?EE @T> !D@>OD>@9

j9 (<= W?G TA\> A DAH> E?O @TA@ UU

,9 ! @T<DX <@ VAC QAFF>= !DE?F?QX9

j9 !DE?F?QXl

,9 m:<@D>CC D?==<D[ T>A= AEE<OHA@<\>FW9;

j9 !i\> C>>D @TA@ DAH>9

:T>O> =<= @T> <=>A Q?H> EO?Hl :AC <@

W?GOCl :>O> W?G @T> @>QTD?F?[<QAF [>D<GC ?O UU

Page 103: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 103/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUW

,9 "?2 D?2 ! VACDi@9 ! V<CT ! Q?GF= O>H>HP>O

@T> DAH> ?E @T> <D\>D@?O2 PG@ <@ VAC @T> C?E@VAO>

HADA[>O ?E A \>OW [??= EO<>D= ?E H<D> DAH>=

dOA= 6>F?9 dOA= 6>F? <C A C>O<AF >D@O>BO>D>GO9 %>

E?OH>= 3?F<? +?OB?OA@<?D PAQX <D @T> FA@> ><[T@<>CZ

>AOFW D<D>@<>C9 ">a@ 6A[> VAC C?F= @? ->a<C">a<C2

AD= D?V T> TAC A Q?HBADW QAFF>= <9$79 !@iC ?D> ?E

T<C BO?[OAHH>OC VT? =>\>F?B>= @T<C @>QTD?F?[W9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= VTA@ <D@>O>C@ =<= W?G TA\> <D

<@2 <D !DE?F?QXl

,9 ,P?G@ A MK B>OQ>D@ <D@>O>C@2 ! P>F<>\>9

j9 1?G P?G[T@ A MK B>OQ>D@ <D@>O>C@l

,9 :>FF2 D?9 !@ VAC A C@AO@GB2 C? @T>

Q?HBADW @TA@ C>QGO>= @T> F<Q>DC> @? HAOX>@ @T>

BO?=GQ@ VAC APF> @? C@AO@ ?G@ V<@T \>OW E>V

O>C?GOQ>C9 $T> \AFG> V?GF= Q?H> EO?H @T> HAOX>@<D[

?E @T> BO?=GQ@ @TA@ VAC GD=>O A F<Q>DC>9

!D ?@T>O V?O=C2 V> TA= ?P@A<D>= AD=

C>QGO>= @T> O<[T@C @? C>FF <@2 AD= @T>D V> V?GF= BAW

?D A B>O CAF> PAC<C A F<Q>DC<D[ E>>2 A O?WAF@W2 @?

@T> =>\>F?B>O ?E @T> C?E@VAO>2 C? <@ VAC AFF ?D A

Q?D@<D[>DQW PAC<C9

j9 (<= W?G TA\> BAO@D>OC ?O Q?UCTAO>T?F=>OC

<D @T<C UU

,9 1>C9 YW BAO@D>O ?D @TA@ VAC )AC?D 6?V>OC9

Page 104: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 104/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUJ

j9 :AC @T<C AD <=>A W?G PO?G[T@ @? )AC?D ?O

\<Q> \>OCAl

,9 %> PO?G[T@ <@ @? H>2 AC ! O>QAFF9

j9 ,D= =<= @T> @V? ?E W?G E?OH A Q?HBADW

QAFF>= !DE?F?QXl

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX C?9 ! @T<DX @TA@ @TA@ VAC A

Q?HBADW T> E?OH>=9 ! QADi@ P> A TGD=O>= B>OQ>D@

CGO>9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX ! VAC <D\?F\>= <D @TA@ Q?HBADW

B>O C>2 PG@ ! =? P>F<>\> @TA@ AD <D@>O>C@ <D @TA@

Q?HBADW ?O AD <D@>O>C@ <D @T> BO?=GQ@ VAC BGOQTAC>=

PW !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C2 VT<QT VAC @T> Q?HBADW @TA@ !

>C@APF<CT>= V<@T<D @T> @OGC@ @? P> @T> \>T<QF> E?O

@T<C ?BB?O@GD<@W9

j9 /XAW9 :T>D W?G C>@ GB @T> @OGC@2 VAC <@

E?O @T<C C?F> BGOB?C>e @TA@ <C2 @? T?GC> @T<C

PGC<D>CC ?BB?O@GD<@Wl

,9 6O<HAO<FW2 W>C9 :TA@ ! VAD@>= @? =? VAC

@AX> AFF @T> ACC>@C @TA@ HW EAH<FW VAC [?<D[ @?

=>\>F?B ?\>O @<H> AD= TA\> @T>H [<E@>= @? @T> @OGC@

AD= @T>D [O?VD V<@T<D @T> @OGC@9 $TA@ VAC HW UU @TA@

VAC HW [?AF9

j9 /XAW9 dG@ A@ @T> @<H> V>O> @T>O> ?@T>O

?BB?O@GD<@<>C ?O <D@>O>C@C P>C<=>C @T> !DE?F?QXl

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX C?9 ! TA= .VAFF?V S

,CC?Q<A@>C2 VT<QT VAC HW E<OH2 .VAFF?V FAV E<OH2 PG@

Page 105: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 105/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUN

! VACDi@ UU ! TA=Di@ UU A[A<D2 @TA@ VAC AC HA@GO> AC

<@ VAC [?<D[ @? P>2 C? ! =<=Di@ @T<DX @TA@ @TA@ V?GF=

P> C?H>@T<D[ !i= VAD@ @? BG@ V<@T<D @T> @OGC@9 !

=<=Di@ TA\> ADW ?@T>O @>QTD?F?[W ?O ?@T>O PGC<D>CC

?BB?O@GD<@<>C @TA@ ! VAC BFADD<D[ ?D BG@@<D[ V<@T<D

@T> @OGC@ A@ @TA@ @<H>9

j9 ,D= ! TA\>Di@ C>>D EO?H @T> =?QGH>D@C !

TA\> @TA@ W?G EGD=>= @T> @OGC@ V<@T ADW ?@T>O ACC>@Ce

<C @TA@ Q?OO>Q@l

,9 "?9

j9 .? W?G =<=Di@ BG@ ADW F<E> <DCGOADQ>

B?F<Q<>C ?O ADW@T<D[ UU

,9 ! =<=Di@ BG@ HW T?GC> <D @T>O> ?O

ADW@T<D[2 D?9

j9 ,D= VAC @TA@ <D@>D@<?DAF2 @TA@ W?G =<=Di@

BG@ W?GO T?GC> ?O F<E> <DCGOADQ> ?O C?H>@T<D[l

,9 :>FF2 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9 ! O>QAFF

CB>Q<E<QAFFW @T> @OGC@ VAC C>@ GB E?O @T<C P<[

?BB?O@GD<@W2 AD= C?2 AC ! GD=>OC@??= <@2 AD=2 A[A<D2

! =?Di@ BOAQ@<Q> <D @T<C AO>A2 PG@ ! AFO>A=W TA=

>kG<@W <D HW T?GC>2 C? ! UU AD= ! =<= @AFX @? ->>

AP?G@ @T<C2 PG@ ! X<D= ?E @T?G[T@ <D HW H<D= @TA@ !

C@<FF TA= A H?O@[A[> ?D HW T?GC>2 VT<QT ! C@<FF TA\>2

AD= ! cGC@ =<=Di@ VAD@ @? [? @TO?G[T @T> BO?Q>CC ?E

@OADCE>OO<D[ <@ CGPc>Q@ @? A H?O@[A[> @? A @OGC@

Page 106: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 106/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUO

=>>=2 AD= <@ AFO>A=W TA= >kG<@W AD= \AFG>2 AD= @TA@

V?GF= P> A @AaAPF> >\>D@2 C? ! O>AFFW @T?G[T@ @T<C

VAC [?<D[ @? P> AD ?BB?O@GD<@W E?O @T<C Q?HBADW AD=

?@T>O Q?HBAD<>C [?<D[ E?OVAO= <E @T?C> Q?HBAD<>C QAH>

<D@? BFAW9

j9 dG@ W?G =<=Di@ TA\> ADW@T<D[ <D H<D= A@

@T> @<H> <D NKKL ?E ?@T>O Q?HBAD<>C [?<D[ E?OVAO=l

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF ! =<=2 D?9

j9 /XAW9 ,C ! GD=>OC@AD= <@2 @T> @OGC@ VAC

E?OH>= V<@T @V? @OGC@>>C9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= <@ VAC AFC? E?OH>= <D ">\A=Ae <C @TA@

O<[T@l

,9 $TA@iC VTA@ ! O>QAFF9

j9 ,D= VTA@ VAC W?GO GD=>OC@AD=<D[ ?E @T>

O>AC?D E?O E?OH<D[ <@ <D ">\A=Al

,9 ->> YQ+GFF?G[T cGC@ CA<= @T<C @WB> ?E

@OGC@ V?OXC P>C@ <D ">\A=A9 !@ VAC T<C CG[[>C@<?D2

AD= T> VAC @T> ?D> @TA@ @AFX>= @? H> AP?G@ =<EE>O>D@

@WB>C ?E @OGC@>>C AD= @TA@ @T<C <C cGC@ T?V <@

V?OX>=2 C? ! cGC@ PAC<QAFFW E?FF?V>= T<C A=\<Q>9

j9 ,D= VT>D W?G CAW g@T<C @WB> ?E @OGC@2g

W?GiO> O>E>OO<D[ @? @T<C [OAD@?O @OGC@ VT<QT <C [?<D[

@? T?GC> A C<[D<E<QAD@ PGC<D>CC ?BB?O@GD<@Wl

,9 '<[T@9 ->> VAC A \>OW QO>A@<\> UU T>

Page 107: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 107/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUP

>aBFA<D>= <@ <D A \>OW QO>A@<\> VAW @? H> <D @>OHC ?E

@T> @Aa Q?DC>kG>DQ>C AD= @T> AP<F<@W ?E Q?DCGF@AD@C2

E?O >aAHBF>2 @? =? V?OX V<@T<D @T> @OGC@9

Y'9 ."/:5 ,FF O<[T@9

$%& :!$"&..5 !iH D?@ @AFX<D[ @?? HGQT9

Y'9 ."/:5 )GC@ F>@ T<H ACX T<C kG>C@<?DC9

$%& :!$"&..5 /XAW9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; :TA@ =<= YO9 YQ+GFF?G[T

@>FF W?G V>O> @T> A=\AD@A[>C ?E @T<C X<D= ?E A @OGC@l

,9 :>FF2 E?O ?D> @T<D[2 T> CA<= @TA@ <D @T<C

@WB> ?E A @OGC@ @T> >D@<@<>C ?VD>= PW @T> @OGC@ V?GF=

D?@ D>>= @? E<F> <D=<\<=GAF @Aa O>@GODC2 @TA@ AFF ?E

@T> <DQ?H> V?GF= EF?V =<O>Q@FW @? @T> P?@@?H F<D> ?E

@T> @OGC@?O AD= V?GF= P> UU AD= @T> @Aa>C V?GF= P>

BA<= PW @T> @OGC@?O2 AD= @T>O> V>O> C?H> @Aa

A=\AD@A[>C @? @TA@2 @TA@ @T<C V?GF= P> A \>T<QF>

@TO?G[T VT<QT UU <@ V?GF= P> AD <OO>\?QAPF> @OGC@2

AD= C? <@ V?GF= P> A @OGC@ ! V?GF=Di@ TA\> Q?D@O?F

?E2 PG@ @T>O> V>O> @Aa A=\AD@A[>C @? @TA@ GB?D HW

=>A@T @TA@ H<[T@ D?@ P> A\A<FAPF> <D A O>\?QAPF>

<DC@OGH>D@2 AD= <@ TA= @T> QABAQ<@W @? T?F= A F?@ ?E

=<EE>O>D@ Q?HBAD<>C2 AD= C? <@ V?GF= P> @T> X<D= ?E

\>T<QF> @TA@ Q?GF= >aBAD= AC HGQT AC ! >\>O D>>=>= @?

>aBAD=2 AD= C? ! E>F@ F<X> <@ VAC AD <D\>C@H>D@ !

V?GF= ?DFW HAX> ?D> @<H> AD= @T>D <@ V?GF= P> UU <@

Page 108: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 108/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUR

V?GF= EGFFW C>O\> VTA@>\>O D>>=C ! H<[T@ TA\>2 AD= !

>aB>Q@>= @T<C Q?HBADW @? P> \>OW CGQQ>CCEGF9

j9 !E @T> Q?HBADW V>O> \>OW CGQQ>CCEGF AD=

HA=> A F?@ ?E H?D>W UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU W?GiO> CAW<D[ @TA@ W?G V?GF= TA\> BA<=

@T> @Aa>C E?O @TA@l

,9 ! @T<DX @TA@iC T?V <@ V?OX>=2 @TA@ @T>W

V?GF= EF?V O<[T@ @? UU @T?C> AO> @T> <DQ?H> @Aa>C9

!iH D?@ @AFX<D[ AP?G@ @T> >C@A@> @Aa>C9 $T>O>iC A

=<C@<DQ@<?D P>@V>>D @T> @V?9

j9 ,D= ! GD=>OC@??= W?G @? CAW >C@A@> @Aa>C9

:TA@ !iH V?D=>O<D[ <C <E @T> Q?HBADW HA=>

A F?@ ?E H?D>W2 VT>O> V?GF= W?G UU F>@iC CAW <@ HA=>

hNK H<FF<?D9

:T>O> V?GF= W?G [>@ @T> H?D>W @? BAW @T>

@Aa>C E?O @TA@l

,9 ->> @?F= H> @TA@ @T> Q?HBADW Q?GF= BAW @T>

@Aa>C9

j9 %?Vl

,9 $TO?G[T @T> AP<F<@W @? BAW @Aa>C UU @T>

@OGC@ Q?GF= BAW @T> @Aa>C @TA@ V>O> <DQGOO>= @TO?G[T

@T> CGQQ>CC ?E @T> PGC<D>CC2 ?O @T> PGC<D>CC Q?GF=

BAW @T> @Aa>C2 PG@ @T> B?<D@ <C @TA@ @T> H?D>W Q?GF=

Q?H> ?G@ ?E @T> @OGC@ @? BAW E?O @T?C> @Aa>C9

Page 109: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 109/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TUS

j9 ,D= =? W?G XD?V T?V @T> H?D>W V?GF= Q?H>

?G@ @? BAW E?O @T> @Aa>Cl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 ! Q?GF=Di@ @>FF W?G9

*DE?O@GDA@>FW2 ! =?Di@ TA\> @TA@ BO?PF>H9

j9 /XAW9

,9 dG@ ->> C>>H>= \>OW Q?DE<=>D@ @TA@ T> XD>V

T?V @TA@ V?OX>=9

j9 ,FF O<[T@9 ,D= ?D> ?E @T> @OGC@>>C VAC A

[GW DAH>= +AT<FF2 A ">\A=A A@@?OD>Wl

,9 Y<QTA>F +AT<FF2 W>AT9

j9 (<= W?G >\>O H>>@ T<Hl

,9 "?9

j9 (<= W?G >\>O CB>AX @? T<Hl

,9 ! HAW TA\> CB?X>D @? T<H ?D @T> BT?D>9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF @T> CGPC@ADQ> ?E @TA@

Q?D\>OCA@<?Dl

,9 :>FF2 <@ HAW TA\> P>>D UU AD= !iH cGC@

CAW<D[ ! HAW TA\> CB?X>D @? T<H UU <D Q?DD>Q@<?D V<@T

T<C E>>2 P>QAGC> T> TA= A hN2KKK A W>AO E>>2 AD= VT>D

<@ @GOD>= ?G@ @TA@ @T> !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C ?BB?O@GD<@W

VACDi@ VTA@ ! @T?G[T@ <@ VAC2 @TA@ P>QAH> A \>OW

>aB>DC<\> <D\>C@H>D@ E?O HWC>FE AD= HW V<E> @? BAW

@TA@ E>>2 AD= C? T> A[O>>= @? O>=GQ> T<C E>> @? h_MK

A W>AO <DC@>A= ?E hN2KKK A W>AO E?O A CHAFF @WB> ?E

AD ?B>OA@<?D2 VT<QT <C QGOO>D@FW VTA@ T>iC QTAO[<D[

Page 110: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 110/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTU

D?V9

j9 .? W?GiO> C@<FF BAW<D[ @T> h_MK E>> A

W>AOl

,9 :>FF2 ! ?V> <@9 !@ VAC =G> ?D

/Q@?P>O IM@T9 ! ?V> <@2 PG@ ! TA\>Di@ BA<= <@ W>@

@T<C W>AO2 PG@2 W>C2 T>iC C@<FF @T> @OGC@>> AD= !iH

C@<FF BAW<D[ @T> E>>9

j9 (? W?G <D@>D= @? BAW <@ AC ?BB?C>= @?

QF?C<D[ @T> @OGC@ =?VDl

,9 YW V<E> VAD@C H> @? QF?C> <@ =?VD2 AD= V>

TA\>Di@ HA=> A E<DAF =>Q<C<?D AP?G@ @TA@9

j9 ,D= VTA@ AO> @T> BO?C AD= Q?DC ?E QF?C<D[

<@ =?VD \>OCGC D?@l

Y'9 ."/:5 :<@T AFF =G> O>CB>Q@2 !iH D?@

CGO> VT>O> UU @T?G[T <@iC <D@>O>C@<D[2 VT>@T>O @T<C

=<CQGCC<?D ?E @OGC@C AD= >C@A@>C AD= VTA@ T> AD= T<C

V<E> VAD@ @? =? V<@T @T<C @OGC@ TAC ADW@T<D[ @? =?

V<@T @T> -<>G@>DAD@ 8?\>OD?OiC B>@<@<?D9

Y'9 -,--!5 ! @T<DX @T> ?B>OA@<?D AD=

HADA[>H>D@ ?E @T<C @OGC@ <C A@ @T> T>AO@ ?E @T>

-<>G@>DAD@ 8?\>OD?OiC <D\>C@<[A@<?D9

Y'9 ."/:5 :>FF2 W?Gi\> Q?\>O>= @TA@ <D

C?H> =>@A<F9 ! cGC@ VAD@ @? XD?V <E UU V> V>O>

T?B<D[ @? H?\> @T<C AF?D[9

Y'9 -,--!5 !iH CGO> W?GiO> T?B<D[ @? H?\>

Page 111: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 111/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTT

<@ AF?D[9

Y'9 ."/:5 dG@ @T>O>iC D? ACC>@C <D <@ @?

?B>OA@> ?O HADA[>9 1?G XD?V @TA@9 $TA@iC QF>AO UU

Y'9 -,--!5 .? VTA@ AO> W?G CAW<D[l

Y'9 ."/:5 UU GDE?O@GDA@>FW9 !iH CAW<D[ !

@T<DX @T<C <C <OO>F>\AD@9

Y'9 -,--!5 ,FF O<[T@9

Y'9 ."/:5 ,D= <@iC VAC@<D[ @<H>9

Y'9 -,--!5 /XAW9

Y'9 ."/:5 !iH cGC@ @OW<D[ @? P> A F<@@F>

H?O> B?F<@> AP?G@ <@2 PG@ @TA@iC VTA@ !iH CAW<D[9

Y'9 -,--!5 :>FF2 ! UU

Y'9 ."/:5 ! XD?V W?G =?Di@ H>AD @? P>

VAC@<D[ @<H>2 AD= !iH CGO> W?G TA\> W?GO @T>?O<>C !iH

D?@ C>><D[9

Y'9 -,--!5 :>FF2 ! @T<DX ! TA\> AD

<D@>O>C@ AD= AD ?PF<[A@<?D @? P><D[ @T?O?G[T2 AC !

@?F= W?G ! =<=2 AD= ! AH C<HBFW =?<D[ @TA@9

! =?Di@ O>H>HP>O @T> kG>C@<?D9 :<FF W?G

E<D= <@ E?O H>l

Y'9 ."/:5 $T> kG>C@<?D VAC VTA@ AO> @T>

BO?C AD= Q?DC ?E QF?C<D[ @T> @OGC@2 E?O VT<QT !

?Pc>Q@ AC P><D[ @?@AFFW <OO>F>\AD@ @? @T<C

<D\>C@<[A@<?D9

$%& :!$"&..5 :> TA\>Di@ =>Q<=>= VTA@ @?

Page 112: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 112/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTV

=?9 $T> BO?C AD= Q?DC UU ! H>AD2 ! QAD cGC@

CB>QGFA@> VTA@ @T> BO?C AD= Q?DC AO>9 /D> ?E @T>

Q?DC <C <@iC >aB>DC<\> @? HA<D@A<D9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 (? W?G AD@<Q<BA@>

EG@GO> PGC<D>CC>C @TA@ V?GF= P> ABBO?BO<A@> E?O @T<C

@WB> ?E @OGC@l

,9 :>FF2 T?B>EGFFW C?H> =AW9 ! H>AD2 ! @T<DX

@TA@ ! TA\> @T> O<[T@ @? X>>B @T> @OGC@ <E ! VAD@ @?

X>>B @T> @OGC@2 AD=2 EOADXFW2 AD= ! =?Di@ VAD@ @? P>

OG=>2 PG@ <@iC O>AFFW ?GO B>OC?DAF PGC<D>CC AP?G@

VT>@T>O ?O D?@ V> VAD@ @? X>>B @T> @OGC@ ?O D?@ X>>B

@T> @OGC@9 !i\> @?F= W?G HW V<E> V?GF= F<X> @?

=<CC?F\> @T> @OGC@2 PG@ V> TA\>Di@ HA=> A E<DAF

=>Q<C<?D W>@9

j9 /XAW9 $T> <D\>C@H>D@ @OGC@>> VAC ?O <C

W?GO =AG[T@>O2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 %>O DAH> <C -AGO>D '>>=l

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 +AD W?G =>CQO<P> VTA@2 <E ADW@T<D[2 CT>

TAC =?D> <D @T> EGDQ@<?D ?E @T> <D\>C@H>D@ @OGC@>>l

,9 .T> TAC D?@ =?D> \>OW HGQT2 <E ADW@T<D[9

j9 +AD W?G @T<DX ?E ADW@T<D[ CT> TAC =?D>l

,9 ! QADi@9 .T> C<[D>= @T> =?QGH>D@ @TA@

AG@T?O<f>= T>O @? P> @T> @OGC@>>9

Page 113: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 113/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTW

j9 %AC CT> P>>D <D\?F\>= <D UU AFP><@ <@ D?@

\>OW HADW2 PG@ @T>O> TA\> P>>D A E>V @OADCE>OC2

BAWH>D@C <D@? AD= ?G@ ?E ..7 AD= 6U.?FG@<?DC AD=

!U,VAO>9

%AC CT> P>>D <D\?F\>= <D @T?C> =>Q<C<?DCl

,9 .T> TAC D?@ P>>D9

j9 /XAW9 %AC CT> P>>D BA<= ADW@T<D[l

,9 "?9

j9 ,O> W?G AVAO> ?E @T> =<C@O<PG@<?D

BO?\<C<?DC ?E @T> @OGC@l

,9 ! VAC HA=> AVAO> ?E ?D> ! @T<DX W>C@>O=AW

<D HW Q?D\>OCA@<?D V<@T ->> YQ+GFF?G[T2 PG@ P>E?O>

@TA@ ! VAC D?@9

j9 ,D= VTA@ AO> W?G @?=AW AVAO> ?E AC EAO AC

=<C@O<PG@<?Dl

,9 ! cGC@ XD?V @TA@ @T> BAOA[OABT DGHP>O !

@T<DX T> CA<= VAC N9I9 ! TA\>Di@ O>A= <@9

K&H#/I/1 TU )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ,FF O<[T@9 +AD W?G \>O<EW

@T<C AC A Q?BW ?E @T> [OAD@?O @OGC@ @TA@ W?G

>C@APF<CT>= V<@T ->> YQ+GFF?G[TiC T>FBl

,9 !@ CGO> ABB>AOC @? P>9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= <E W?G F??X A@ C>Q@<?D N9I2

VT<QT <C ?D @T> C>Q?D= BA[>2 @T<C <C A BO?\<C<?D UU

E<OC@ ?E AFF2 W?G TA\> D?@ O>A= @T<C BO<?O @? @?=AW9

Page 114: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 114/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTJ

!C @TA@ W?GO @>C@<H?DWl

,9 ! TA\>Di@ O>A= <@ UU ! TA\>Di@ O>A= <@ A@

AFF C<DQ> @T> =AW <@ VAC C<[D>=2 AD= ! =?Di@ O>QAFF

<E ! >\>D O>A= <@ @T>D9

j9 dG@ W?G O>QAFF =<CQGCC<D[ @T<C V<@T

YO9 YQ+GFF?G[T W>C@>O=AWl

,9 7>OW PO<>EFW9 %> O>E>O>DQ>= @T>

BAOA[OABT9

j9 ,D= =<= T> @>FF W?G ADW@T<D[ AP?G@ <@l

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX <D CB>Q<E<Q9

j9 6O<?O @? HAX<D[ @T> @OADCE>OC ?O

=<C@O<PG@<?DC EO?H 6U.?FG@<?DC2 ..7 ?O !U,VAO>2 !

@AX> <@ EO?H VTA@ W?Gi\> @?F= H> @TA@ W?GO =AG[T@>O2

@T> <D\>C@H>D@ @OGC@>>2 =<= D?@ >a>OQ<C> ADW

=<CQO>@<?D AP?G@ @TA@l

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9 ! =<= D?@ @AFX UU ! =<=

D?@ CB>AX V<@T T>O AP?G@ <@2 D?9

j9 ,D= CT> @T>D V?GF=Di@ TA\> HA=> ADW

VO<@@>D Q?HHGD<QA@<?D @? @T> @OGC@ BO?@>Q@?O AP?G@

@T?C> =<C@O<PG@<?DCl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V T?V CT> Q?GF= <E ! =<= D?@

@AFX @? T>O2 ?O HW V<E> =<= D?@ @AFX @? T>O2 C? V>

=<= D?@ @AFX @? T>O AP?G@ <@9

j9 ,FF O<[T@9 !C @T>O> A O>AC?D @TA@ @T>

@OGC@ =?>CDi@ TA\> A PADX AQQ?GD@l

Page 115: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 115/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTN

,9 ! @T<DX @T> ?DFW O>AC?D <@ =?>CDi@ TA\> A

PADX AQQ?GD@ <C P>QAGC> CT?O@FW AE@>O @T> @OGC@ VAC

E?OH>= <@ P>QAH> BO>@@W QF>AO @TA@ !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C

VAC D?@ [?<D[ ADWVT>O>2 AD= C? <@ VAC O>AFFW2 <D HW

\<>V UU <D HW \<>V2 @T<D[C QTAD[>= =OAHA@<QAFFW AE@>O

@T> ?BB?O@GD<@W ?E !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C V>D@ AVAW V<@T

O>CB>Q@ @? @T> @OGC@9

&\>D @T?G[T <@ VAC C@<FF A \>OW \AF<= AD=

?B>OA@<D[ @OGC@2 ! =<=Di@ C>> @T> GO[>DQW ?E QO>A@<D[

A PADX AQQ?GD@ E?O @T> @OGC@9 !@ VACDi@ GD@<F

AD?@T>O W>AO TA= BACC>= VT>D @T> 6U.?FG@<?DC

?BB?O@GD<@W QAH> <D@? \<>V9

j9 $TA@ VTA@l

,9 :TA@ VAC @TA@l

j9 1?G CA<= <@ VACDi@ GD@<F UU

,9 ,D?@T>O W>AO UU

j9 UU AD?@T>O W>AOl

,9 UU AE@>O @T> @OGC@ VAC E?OH>= @TA@ @T>

6U.?FG@<?DC ?BB?O@GD<@W QAH> <D@? \<>V2 C? PAC<QAFFW

@T>O> VAC F<@@F>2 <E ADW2 AQ@<\<@W <D @T> @OGC@ E?O

H?O> @TAD A W>AO AE@>O <@ VAC E?OH>=9

j9 .? =<= W?G Q?DC<=>O >C@APF<CT<D[ A PADX

AQQ?GD@ E?O @T> @OGC@ VT>D @T> 6U.?FG@<?DC

?BB?O@GD<@W AO?C>l

,9 1?G XD?V2 <@ cGC@ =<=Di@ QO?CC HW H<D= @?

Page 116: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 116/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTO

=? <@9 3OADXFW2 ! HAW D?@ TA\> >\>D O>H>HP>O>= A@

@TA@ @<H> @TA@ <@ =<=Di@ TA\> AD AQQ?GD@9

Y'9 -,--!5 &F>\>D9

K&H#/I/1 TT )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ II <C A =<A[OAH

@TA@ VAC BO?=GQ>= PW W?G ?O ?D> ?E W?GO Q?HBAD<>C9

+AD W?G @>FF H> VTA@ @T<C =<A[OAH <Cl

,9 :>FF2 <@ F??XC F<X> @T> )?TD AD= .GfADD>

.VAFF?V &C@A@> 6FADD<D[ (<A[OAH9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VT? BO>BAO>= <@l

,9 ! P>F<>\> <@ VAC ->> YQ+GFF?G[T2 P>QAGC> !

=<=Di@ BO>BAO> <@9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= =? W?G GD=>OC@AD= @T>

C<[D<E<QADQ> ?E @T<Cl

,9 &DF<[T@>D H>9

j9 :>FF UU

,9 !i= cGC@ CAW UU <@ F??XC F<X> @T> Q?HBADW

..7 YADA[>H>D@2 --+2 <C ?VD>= IKK B>OQ>D@ PW @T>

@OGC@2 AD= @T>D ..7 YADA[>H>D@2 --+2 ?VDC IKK B>OQ>D@

?E @T> Q?HBADW !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C &D@>OBO<C>C2 --+9

j9 !C @TA@ @T> VAW W?G GD=>OC@AD= W?GO @OGC@l

,9 1>C9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= VTA@ <C @T> BGOB?C> ?E @T>

H<==F> >D@<@W2 ..7 YADA[>H>D@l (? W?G TA\> AD

GD=>OC@AD=<D[ ?E @TA@l

Page 117: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 117/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTP

,9 "?2 ! O>AFFW =?Di@2 >aQ>B@ @TA@ <@iC A

HADA[>H>D@ ?E @T> Q?HBAD<>C @TA@ <@ ?VDC2 AD= @T<C <C

T?V ->> CG[[>C@>= @T> >D@<@W P> C>@ GB2 AD= C? !

C<HBFW E?FF?V>= T<C A=\<Q> ?D @TA@9

j9 !C ..7 YADA[>H>D@ AD ?B>OA@<?DAF Q?HBADWl

,9 ! V?GF=Di@ CAW C?9 ! H>AD2 =>E<D>

?B>OA@<?DAF9 !C <@ A EGDQ@<?D<D[ Q?HBADW UU

j9 (?>C <@ =? ADW PGC<D>CCl (?>C <@ TA\> ADW

>HBF?W>>Cl

,9 "?9

j9 (?>C <@ [>D>OA@> ADW <DQ?H>l

,9 "?9

j9 "?D> ?E @T?C>l

,9 "?9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= =? W?G XD?V VTA@ <@C BGOB?C>

<C UU V>FF2 <C <@ A T?F=<D[ Q?HBADWl

,9 :>FF2 ! V?GF= UU ! H>AD2 HW GD=>OC@AD=<D[

<C @TA@ @? @T> >a@>D@ UU =>E<D> T?F=<D[ Q?HBADW9 !

V?GF= CAW @TA@iC BO?PAPFW A EA<OFW [??= =>CQO<B@<?D

?E <@2 A T?F=<D[ Q?HBADW ?O A HADA[>H>D@ Q?HBADW @TA@

?VDC ?@T>O UU HADA[>C ?@T>O Q?HBAD<>C9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= V<@T<D @T> C@OGQ@GO> ?E @T>

@OGC@2 =? W?G TA\> AD GD=>OC@AD=<D[ ?E VTA@ @TA@

HADA[>H>D@ Q?HBADW AFF?VC W?G ?O @T> @OGC@ ?O @T>

>D@<@<>C @? =?l

Page 118: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 118/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTR

,9 :>FF2 ?@T>O @TAD F?[<Q ?O Q?HH?D C>DC>2 !

=?Di@ TA\> ADW >aB>O@<C> <D VTA@ <@ AFF?VC <@ @? =?2

C? <E @T> Q?HBADW UU <@ ?VDC AD?@T>O Q?HBADW2 C? AC A

Q?HBADW @TA@ ?VDC A Q?HBADW2 ! H>AD2 F?[<QAFFW TAC

C?H> AG@T?O<@W ?\>O @T> Q?HBADW @TA@ <@ ?VDC2 AD= !

=?Di@ XD?V VTA@ W?GiO> F??X<D[ E?O2 PG@ @TA@iC UU

j9 :>FF2 F>@ H> @OW AD= ACX A P>@@>O

kG>C@<?D9

,9 .GO>9

j9 ,C ! GD=>OC@??= W?GO >aBFADA@<?D ?E @T<C

[OAD@?O @OGC@2 <@ VAC @? >EE>Q@<\>FW T?GC> A

CGPC@AD@<AF PGC<D>CC ?BB?O@GD<@W AD= ?P@A<D @OGC@

BO?@>Q@<?DC PW =?<D[ @TA@9

,9 6O?PAPFW2 AH?D[ ?@T>O @T<D[C9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= ! GD=>OC@AD= EO?H W?GO

@>C@<H?DW @TA@ !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C <C @T> UU ?O A@ F>AC@

@TO?G[T @T> <D<@<AF PGC<D>CC ?BB?O@GD<@Wl

,9 $TA@ <C O<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 .? VTA@ !iH V?D=>O<D[ <C <E W?G

TA\> AD GD=>OC@AD=<D[ ?E VTW ..7 <C BG@ <D @T>O> AC A

T?F=<D[ ?O HADA[>H>D@ Q?HBADWl !D ?@T>O V?O=C2 VTW

=?>CDi@ @T> .GB>O .>\>D $OGC@ cGC@ ?VD !U,VAO>

6O?=GQ@Cl

,9 ! =?Di@ TA\> AD GD=>OC@AD=<D[ ?E @TA@9

1?Gi= TA\> @? ACX HW FAVW>O @TA@ kG>C@<?D9

Page 119: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 119/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TTS

j9 ,D= W?G D>\>O =<= TA\> AD GD=>OC@AD=<D[l

,9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX C?9 ! H>AD2 T> BO?PAPFW

>aBFA<D>= <@ @? H> A@ @T> @<H>2 PG@ ! =?Di@ O>QAFF

VTW <@iC C<[D<E<QAD@9

j9 "?V2 W?G V>O>2 A@ F>AC@ A@ E?OHA@<?D AD=

GD@<F YAOQT ?E NKIN2 @T> HADA[>O ?E ..7 YADA[>H>D@2

O<[T@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= W?G V>O> AFC? @T> HADA[>O ?E

!U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@Cl

,9 $TA@iC VTA@ ! GD=>OC@AD=9

Y'9 -,--!5 $V>F\>9

K&H#/I/1 TV )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ IN <C A C<[DA@GO>

QAO= AD= ?O[AD<fA@<?DAF =?QGH>D@ <DE?OHA@<?D ?P@A<D>=

EO?H Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA 3>=>OAF +O>=<@ *D<?D9

(? W?G O>Q?[D<f> W?GO C<[DA@GO> @T>O> ?D

@T> C>Q?D= BA[> AD= @T<O= BA[>l

,9 ! =?9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= [>D>OAFFW ! GD=>OC@AD= @T<C

=?QGH>D@ @? P> T?V W?G >C@APF<CT>= @T> PADX AQQ?GD@

E?O ..7 YADA[>H>D@2 AD= <@ AFF?V>= P?@T W?G AD= W?GO

V<E> @? P> C<[D>OC ?D @T> AQQ?GD@9

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 $TA@iC VTA@ TABB>D>=l /XAW9

Page 120: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 120/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVU

,D= <E W?G [? @? @T> @T<O= BA[>2 W?GO DAH>

<C @T>O> @V<Q>9 /D @T> @?B BAO@ <@ CAWC )?TD &9

.VAFF?V2 HADA[>O2 .GfADD> Y9 .VAFF?V2 AG@T?O<f>=

C<[D>Ol

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= @T>D =?VD P>F?V T>O DAH> <C QO?CC>=

?G@ AC HADA[>O2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 '<[T@2 F??XC F<X> <@9

j9 .? A@ F>AC@ A@ @T> E?OHA@<?D ?E @T<C

AQQ?GD@ <C <@ AQQGOA@> @? C@A@> @TA@ W?G V>O> @T>

C?F> HADA[>O AD= W?GO V<E> VAC D?@ A HADA[>Ol

,9 1?G XD?V2 ! =?Di@ UU ! =?Di@ XD?V9 !

H>AD2 ! TA\>Di@ O>A= @? C>> VTA@ <@ <C AP?\> T>O>9

:T>O> <@ TAC GC P?@T T>O> CT>iC AD AG@T?O<f>= C<[D>O2

!iH A HADA[>O2 PG@ GB T>O> <@ CAWC @TA@ CT> <C A

HADA[<D[ H>HP>O2 C? UU

j9 $TA@iC VTW !iH ACX<D[ @T> kG>C@<?D9

,9 .? ! =? D?@ UU ! QADD?@ >aBFA<D AC ! C<@

T>O> VTW @T> =<EE>O>DQ> ?O @T> Q?D@OA=<Q@<?D9

j9 /XAW9 ,@ @T> @<H> W?G C>@ GB

..7 YADA[>H>D@2 =<= W?G <D@>D= W?GO V<E> @? P> A

HADA[>Ol

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9 ! =?Di@ O>H>HP>O9 ! V<FF

CAW @T<C5 .T> <C @T> HADA[>O ?E .VAFF?V ,CC?Q<A@>C

V<@T H>2 PG@ ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9 ! cGC@ Q?GF=Di@ O>QAFF9

Page 121: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 121/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVT

! Q?GF=Di@ CB>QGFA@>9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF VT>@T>O ?O D?@ <@ VAC

<HB?O@AD@ E?O W?G @? P> A HADA[>O ?E ..7l

,9 ! =?Di@9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VT>@T>O P><D[ A HADA[>O V?GF=

[<\> W?G <D\>C@H>D@ AG@T?O<@W ?\>O @T> >D@<@<>C T>F=

PW ..72 CGQT AC !U,VAO> AD= 6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 ! Q?GF=Di@ CAW9 ! H>AD2 Q>O@A<DFW AC

HADA[>O ! @T<DX ! V?GF= TA\> <D\>C@H>D@ AG@T?O<@W9

$T> kG>C@<?D V?GF= P> V?GF= ! TA\> @TA@ AG@T?O<@W <E

! V>O>Di@ HADA[>Ol ! V?GF= ACCGH> @TA@ ! V?GF= D?@2

PG@ !iH cGC@ ACCGH<D[9

! H>AD2 F>@iC [>@ O<[T@ @? @T> PAC<QC ?E

<@9 ! H>AD2 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E ! V?GF= TA\> @? P>

O>kG<O>= @? P> A HADA[>O ?E A Q?HBADW @? HAX>

<D\>C@H>D@ =>Q<C<?DC ?D P>TAFE ?E @T> Q?HBADW9 ,C A

HA@@>O ?E Q?OB?OA@> FAV ?O BAO@D>OCT<B FAV2 ! =?Di@

XD?V <E !i= TA\> @? P> A HADA[>O @? =? @TA@9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF <E ->> YQ+GFF?G[T >aBFA<D>=

@? W?G A@ @T> @<H> ?E C>@@<D[ GB W?GO @OGC@ @T>

AG@T?O<@W AD= O>CB?DC<P<F<@W ?E A HADA[>Ol

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF @TA@ T> =<=9

Y'9 -,--!5 $T<O@>>D9

K&H#/I/1 TW )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 $T<C <C A =?QGH>D@

Page 122: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 122/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVV

=>H?DC@OA@<D[ @TA@ UU A@ F>AC@ <@ CAWC @? H> @TA@

W?GO V<E> O>BFAQ>= W?G AC HADA[>O ?E ..7 YADA[>H>D@

>EE>Q@<\> YAOQT IM2 NKINe <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 :>FF2 @T> =?QGH>D@ UU ! =?Di@ VAD@ @? P>

=<EE<QGF@2 PG@ @T> =?QGH>D@ CB>AXC E?O <@C>FE9

j9 :>O> W?G <D\?F\>= <D =?QGH>D@<D[ A QTAD[>

<D @T> HADA[>O B?C<@<?D EO?H W?G @? W?GO V<E> ?D ?O

AP?G@ YAOQT IM ?E NKINl

,9 :>FF2 ! XD?V ! =<CQGCC>= <@ V<@T

->> YQ+GFF?G[T2 AD= ! O>C<[D>= AC HADA[>O ?E

..7 YADA[>H>D@2 AD= ! <D=<QA@>= @? T<H @TA@ .GfADD>

V?GF= AQQ>B@ @T> ABB?<D@H>D@ AC HADA[>O ?E

..7 YADA[>H>D@9

j9 ,D= VAC <@ W?GO GD=>OC@AD=<D[ @TA@ EO?H

@TA@ @<H> E?OVAO= .GfADD> P>QAH> @T> HADA[>O ?E ..7

OA@T>O @TAD W?Gl

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 /XAW9

,9 $TA@iC HW GD=>OC@AD=<D[9

j9 ,D= @TA@ VAC W?GO <D@>D@<?Dl

,9 $TA@ VAC HW <D@>D@<?D2 W>AT9

j9 ,D= VTA@2 @? W?GO XD?VF>=[>2 TAC W?GO V<E>

=?D> AC HADA[>O ?E ..7 YADA[>H>D@l

,9 7>OW F<@@F>2 P>QAGC> @T> Q?HBADW TACDi@

=?D> ADW@T<D[ C<DQ> CT> @??X ?\>O9

Page 123: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 123/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVW

j9 %AC @T> HADA[>H>D@ ?E ..7 QTAD[>= EO?H

P>E?O> YAOQT IM ?E NKINl

,9 :>FF2 E?O >aAHBF>2 VT>D V> V>O> BO>BAO<D[

?GO =<CQ?\>OW O>CB?DC>C2 CT> AD= ! CA@ @?[>@T>O2 AD=

! ACX>= T>O VTA@ CT>i= F<X> H> @? =?2 AD= CT> CA<= [?

@? @T> PADX AD= [>@ @T> =?QGH>D@C @TA@ AO> O>kG>C@>=2

AD= CT> @??X @T> O?F> AC HADA[>O V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? @T>

>D@<@<>C @TA@ AO> ?VD>= PW @T> @OGC@9

:T>D V> O>EGD=>= @T> H?D>W @?

'<QTAO= 'AVF>2 CT> VAC <D\?F\>= <D @TA@ =>Q<C<?D V<@T

H> AD= ABBO?\>= @TA@ =>Q<C<?D2 C? CT> TAC @AX>D @TA@

O?F> <D A \>OW E>V @OADCAQ@<?DC @TA@ TA\> ?QQGOO>=

C<DQ> @T> @<H> CT> P>QAH> @T> HADA[>O2 AD= D? <DQ?H>

TAC P>>D O>Q><\>= PW @T> @OGC@ AD= D? PGC<D>CC TAC

P>>D Q?D=GQ@>= PW @T> @OGC@ ?O @T> Q?HBAD<>C C<DQ>

CT> @??X ?\>O2 C? @T>O> TAC P>>D \>OW F<@@F> @? =?9

j9 d>E?O> @TA@ @<H> =<= W?G <D\?F\> T>O <D

=<CQGCC<?DC AP?G@ @T> @OGC@ ?O @T> PGC<D>CC>C ?VD>=

PW @T> @OGC@l

,9 ! <D\?F\>= T>O <D =<CQGCC<?DC AP?G@

=<C@O<PG@<?DC AC A P>D>E<Q<AOW2 PG@ ! =?Di@ O>QAFF

<D\?F\<D[ T>O <D @T> HADA[>H>D@ ?O <D @T> Q?DCGF@<D[

=>Q<C<?DC @TA@ ! HA=> AC @T> Q?DCGF@AD@ E?O

6U.?FG@<?DC9

j9 ,D= VT>D W?G CAW @TA@ W?G =<=Di@ <D\?F\>

Page 124: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 124/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVJ

T>O <D Q?DCGF@<D[ =>Q<C<?DC2 =? W?G H>AD @T> AQ@GAF

V?OX V<@T @T> @O<P> AD= C? E?O@T @TA@ W?G V>O> =?<D[

E?O @T> +TABAOOAFl

,9 ! H>AD UU V>FF2 ! H>AD @TA@2 PG@ ! AFC?

H>AD <D ADW ?@T>O =>Q<C<?DC O>FA@<\> @? VT>@T>O ?O

D?@ ! CT?GF= Q?DCGF@ E?O @T> Q?HBAD<>C9 $T?C> V>O>

HW =>Q<C<?DC9

j9 /XAW9

,9 .T> VAC AVAO>2 @T?G[T2 ?E VTA@ ! VAC

=?<D[9

j9 1?G H>D@<?D>= @TA@ W?GO V<E> TAD=F>C @T>

E<DADQ>C <D W?GO EAH<FW9

(<= ! GD=>OC@AD= @TA@ Q?OO>Q@FWl

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 ,D= PW @TA@ =? W?G H>AD @TA@ CT> BAWC @T>

P<FFC AD= X>>BC @T> QT>QXP??X AD= @T<D[C F<X> @TA@l

,9 .T> =?>C2 W>C9

j9 (? W?G TA\> ADW O?F> <D @TA@l

,9 7>OW F<@@F>2 <E ADW9

j9 :TA@ AP?G@ E<DADQ<AF BFADD<D[2 CGQT AC

CA\<D[ E?O Q?FF>[> ?O E?O H<CC<?DC ?O @T<D[C F<X>

@TA@2 =?>C CT> =? @TA@ ?O <C @TA@ A c?<D@ >EE?O@l

,9 :>FF2 <@iC A c?<D@ >EE?O@ <D @TA@ ! >AOD

@T> <DQ?H>9 .T>iC @T> =O<\>O P>T<D= =>Q<C<?DC @? BG@

H?D>W AVAW E?O Q?FF>[> AD= @? CA\> E?O @T<D[C F<X> A

Page 125: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 125/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVN

H<CC<?D9

Y'9 ."/:5 .AH> ?Pc>Q@<?D AC ! HA=>

>AOF<>O9 $T<C <C @?@AFFW <OO>F>\AD@ PAC<QAFFW2 C?

W?G QAD C@?B @AFX<D[ AP?G@ <@ D?V9

$%& :!$"&..5 /XAW9

Y'9 ."/:5 ,D= VTW =?Di@ V> @AX> A PO>AX9

:>i\> P>>D [?<D[ AP?G@ AD?@T>O T?GO AD= IM H<DG@>C9

Y'9 -,--!5 :> QAD @AX> A PO>AX9

Y'9 ."/:5 /XAW9

$%& 7!(&/8',6%&'5 8?<D[ ?EE O>Q?O=9

]5MK B9H9 <C @T> @<H>9

m'>Q>CC EO?H ]5MK B9H9 @? M5KK B9H9;

$%& 7!(&/8',6%&'5 8?<D[ PAQX ?D O>Q?O=9

$T> @<H> <C E<\> ?iQF?QX B9H9 +?GDC>F9

K&H#/I/1 TJ )*( 6*-X&G'M

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ I] <C A Q?BW ?E

..7 YADA[>H>D@iC PADX C@A@>H>D@C E?O @T> W>AO NKII2

AD= @T>C> AO> =?QGH>D@C @TA@ W?G V>O> <D\?F\>= <D

BO?=GQ<D[ ?D P>TAFE ?E ..7 YADA[>H>D@e <C @TA@

Q?OO>Q@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 ! VAD@ @GOD @? dA@>C BA[> I_N2 AD=

<D @T> H<==F> ?E @T> BA[> @T>O> @T>O>iC A hMKK

=>B?C<@ @OADCE>O EO?H 6U.?FG@<?DC2 hMKK9

,9 '<[T@9

Page 126: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 126/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVO

j9 (? W?G C>> @TA@l :TA@ VAC @TA@ E?Ol

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9 !iH [G>CC<D[ @TA@ <@ TA=

A D>[A@<\> PAFADQ> <D @T> AQQ?GD@2 AD= C? @TA@

@OADCE>O VAC HA=>2 !iH cGC@ [G>CC<D[2 @? X>>B @T>

PAFADQ> EO?H [?<D[ <D @T> T?F>9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= C? A@ @T<C B?<D@ <D @<H>2

.>B@>HP>O ?E NKII2 V?GF= @TA@ TA\> P>>D W?GO

=>Q<C<?Dl

,9 !iH ACCGH<D[ @TA@ <@ V?GF= TA\> P>>D2 W>C9

j9 d>QAGC> A@ @TA@ @<H> W?G V>O> @T> HADA[>Ol

,9 '<[T@9

j9 (? W?G TA\> ADW O>Q?FF>Q@<?D ?E Q?DCGF@<D[

ADW?D> AP?G@ @TA@l

,9 ! =?Di@9

Y'9 -,--!5 3<E@>>D9

K&H#/I/1 TN )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ IM <C

..7 YADA[>H>D@ PADX AQQ?GD@C E?O @T> W>AO NKIN2 AD=

!i= F<X> @? =<O>Q@ W?GO A@@>D@<?D @? dA@>C BA[> IIKN2

AD= ! cGC@ VAD@ @? ACX W?G AP?G@2 E<OC@ ?E AFF2 @T>

/Q@?P>O IC@ =>B?C<@ PW QT>QX E?O h_2KKK9

(? W?G XD?V VT>O> @TA@ H?D>W QAH> EO?Hl

,9 ,C ! O>QAFF2 <@ QAH> EO?H 6U.?FG@<?DC9

j9 ,D= VAC @T<C E?O @T> D>V ABBF<ADQ>C W?G

H>D@<?D>= >AOF<>Ol

Page 127: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 127/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVP

,9 "?9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF VTA@ @TA@ VAC E?Ol

,9 ! O>QAFF UU W>C2 ! =?9

j9 ,D= @>FF H> VTA@9

,9 ! O>QAFF @TA@ <@ VAC C<HBFW A @OADCE>O

EO?H 6U.?FG@<?DC @? @T> T?F=<D[ Q?HBADW2 ?O @?

..7 YADA[>H>D@9

j9 (? W?G O>QAFF @T> O>AC?D E?O @T> @OADCE>Ol

,9 ! =? D?@9

Y'9 -,--!5 0>>B @TA@ &aT<P<@ IM2 AD= !iH

[?<D[ @? HAOX A D>V &aT<P<@ I^ AD= QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ>

T>O> E?O A H<DG@>9 .<a@>>D9

K&H#/I/1 TO )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ I^ F??XC @? H> @?

P> @T> QT>QX O>[<C@>O E?O ..7 YADA[>H>D@9

+AD W?G \>O<EW @TA@l

Y'9 ."/:5 )GC@ [? AT>A=9 &aQGC> H>9

$%& :!$"&..5 ! =?Di@ XD?V T?V !i= \>O<EW

<@9 ! =?Di@ VAD@ @? P> =<EE<QGF@2 PG@ @T> ?DFW @T<D[

! QAD C>> ?D <@ <C ..7 O<[T@ T>O> <D TAD=VO<@<D[2 PG@

! =?Di@ UU

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; !C @TA@ W?GO TAD=VO<@<D[l

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 ! QADi@ @>FF9

j9 /XAW9

,9 ! =?Di@ TA\> ADW O>AC?D @? P>F<>\> <@iC

Page 128: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 128/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVR

D?@2 PG@ ! cGC@ =?Di@ XD?V9 1?G ACX>= H> @? \>O<EW

<@9 ! cGC@ =?Di@ XD?V <E ! QAD9

j9 /XAW9 !C <@ W?GO TAD=VO<@<D[l

,9 !C VTA@ HW TAD=VO<@<D[l

j9 /D &aT<P<@ I^l

,9 :>FF UU

j9 $T> QT>QX O>[<C@>Ol

,9 UU C>>2 !iH D?@ CGO> UU @T> ..7 <C HW

TAD=VO<@<D[2 H<[T@ P>2 PG@ @T> ?@T>O TAD=VO<@<D[

F??XC F<X> <@ <C HW TAD=VO<@<D[9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= =GO<D[ NKIN @T<C V?GF= TA\>

P>>D UU A@ F>AC@ @T>C> >D@O<>C2 .>B@>HP>O AD= /Q@?P>O

?E NKIN2 V?GF= TA\> P>>D AE@>O W?G V<@T=O>V AC

HADA[>O2 Q?OO>Q@l

,9 1>C9 1>C2 <@ V?GF= TA\> P>>D9

j9 dG@ ABBAO>D@FW W?GiO> C@<FF @T> ?D>

X>>B<D[ @T> QT>QXP??X AD= F>=[>Oe <C @TA@ Q?OO>Q@l

,9 :>FF2 F??XC F<X> <@9 !@iC B?CC<PF> @TA@

@T<C .GfADD> <C <D .GfADD>iC TAD=VO<@<D[2 PG@

Q>O@A<DFW @T> ADCV>O @? W?GO kG>C@<?D <C W>C2 @T<C

F??XC F<X> HW TAD=VO<@<D[9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= C? <E !iH QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ<D[

&aT<P<@ I^ @? dA@>C BA[> IIKN ?E IM2 ! QAD C>> A

hI2KKK BAWH>D@ EO?H ..7 @TA@ V>D@ @? .GfADD>

.VAFF?V UU

Page 129: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 129/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TVS

,9 /XAW9

j9 UU E?O A =<C@O<PG@<?De <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 $TA@ F??XC F<X> @TA@iC VTA@ <@ CAWC9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= <D &aT<P<@ I^ @T> =>B?C<@ PW

@T> LUN`UIN >D@OW CAWC h_2KKK VAC =>B?C<@>=9

,9 !iH cGC@ @OW<D[ @? E<D= <@9

j9 /D @T> ?@T>O >aT<P<@9

,9 /T2 @T<C ?D>l LUN`UIN UU

j9 1>AT9

,9 UU <@ CAWC =<C@O<PG@<?D ?E hI2KKK9

j9 '<[T@9

,9 (>B?C<@ ?E hI2KKK9 /XAW9

j9 , =>B?C<@ ?E h_2KKK2 =<C@O<PG@<?D ?E

hI2KKK AD= @T>D PAFADQ> ?E h^2KKK2 O<[T@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= @T> h_2KKK2 W?GO P>F<>E VAC @TA@ <@

QAH> EO?H 6U.?FG@<?DC2 AD= ! @T<DX V>iFF C>> @TA@9

,9 1>C9 $TA@iC HW P>F<>E2 W>C9

j9 .? PAC<QAFFW VTA@ V> TA\> T>O> <D

&aT<P<@ I^2 VT<QT <C QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ>= V<@T IM2 <C @V?

=<C@O<PG@<?D BAWH>D@C @? .GfADD> <D .>B@>HP>O AD=

/Q@?P>O ?E NKIN2 ?D> E?O hI2KKK =?FFAOC AD= ?D> E?O

hN2M^^2 O<[T@l

,9 $TA@ F??XC F<X> @TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 ,D= =? W?G O>QAFF VTA@ @T?C> =<C@O<PG@<?DC

Page 130: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 130/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWU

V>O> E?Ol

,9 ! =? D?@ XD?V9

j9 ,D= !iH <D@>O>C@>= <D @T> V?O=

g=<C@O<PG@<?D9g

!C @TA@ <D@>D=>= @? P> A =<C@O<PG@<?D ?E

<DQ?H> ?O BO?E<@ ?O <C <@ UU

,9 ! V?GF= ACCGH> <@ V?GF= P> A =<C@O<PG@<?D

?E BO?E<@C2 AD= .GfADD> AD= ! P?@T =<CQGCC>= @T>C>2

AD= CT> ABBO?\>= @T>C> AC @T> HADA[>O9

j9 /XAW9 dG@ =? W?G O>QAFF VTA@ @T> BGOB?C>

E?O =<C@O<PG@<D[ @T<C H?D>W @? .GfADD> VACl

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF9

j9 :AC <@ Q?HB>DCA@<?Dl

,9 "?9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VTA@ @T> H?D>W VAC GC>= E?Ol

,9 ! =? D?@ O>QAFF2 D?9

Y'9 -,--!5 ,FF O<[T@9 ->@iC BG@ IM AVAW2

AD= ! @T<DX V> QAD BG@ I^ AVAW AC V>FF9 .>\>D@>>D9

K&H#/I/1 TP )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; !iH TAD=<D[ W?G

&aT<P<@ I_2 VT<QT <C @T> /Q@?P>O NKIN C@A@>H>D@ EO?H

VTA@ ! P>F<>\> <C W?GO c?<D@ AQQ?GD@ V<@T W?GO V<E>9

!C @TA@ AQQGOA@>l

,9 !@ F??XC F<X> <@9 :TA@ =A@> =<= W?G CAWl

$T> /Q@?P>O UU W>AT2 @T> /Q@?P>O iIN C@A@>H>D@2 W>C9

Page 131: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 131/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWT

j9 .? VTA@ !iH @OW<D[ @? =? <C @? E?FF?V AD=

C>> <E @T>C> BAWH>D@C EO?H .GfADD> @TA@ V> F??X>= A@

<D @T> &aT<P<@ I^2 <E @T>W V>D@ <D@? W?GO AQQ?GD@ UU

,9 /XAW9

j9 UU <D@? W?GO c?<D@ AQQ?GD@9

.? <E W?G F??X A@ @T> C>Q?D= BA[> ?E

&aT<P<@ I_ UU D?V2 VTA@ ! =<= <C E?O @V? O>AC?DC2

O>AFFW9 /D> <C @? QG@ =?VD ?D @T> \?FGH> ?E BAB>O2

AD= @T> ?@T>O ?D> <C @? D?@ BG@ <D@? @T<C O>Q?O=

BA[>C ?E W?GO PADX C@A@>H>D@C @TA@ O>AFFW AO>Di@

O>F>\AD@9

,9 $TA@iC X<D= ?E UU

Y'9 -,--!5 ! H>AD2 W?Gi\> [?@ @T> EGFF

C@A@>H>D@C2 )>DD<E>O2 <E W?G VAD@ @? F??X A@ @T>H9

Y.9 ),Y&.5 '<[T@9

Y'9 -,--!5 !E W?G VAD@ @T>H @? P> BAO@ ?E

@T> O>Q?O=2 V> QAD =? @TA@9

Y.9 ),Y&.5 $TA@iC D?@ D>Q>CCAOW9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ,FF O<[T@9 ! VAD@ @?

=<O>Q@ W?GO A@@>D@<?D @? @T> C>Q?D= BA[> AD= cGC@ C>>

<E W?G QAD T>FB H> GD=>OC@AD= C?H> ?E @T> =>B?C<@C

AD= V<@T=OAVAFC T>O>9

-??X<D[ A@ @T> @?B ?E @T> BA[>2 ?D IKUI

@T>O>iC A =>B?C<@ PW QT>QX ?E hI`2_L_9`N9

(? W?G XD?V VTA@ @TA@ VACl

Page 132: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 132/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWV

,9 ! =?Di@9

j9 /XAW9 (? W?G XD?V <E BAO@ ?E @TA@

<DQFG=>= @T> @V? =<C@O<PG@<?DC @TA@ AO> <=>D@<E<>= ?D

&aT<P<@ I^l

,9 ! =? D?@ XD?V9

j9 (?Di@ XD?V9 /XAW9 $T>O> AO> A Q?GBF> ?E

V<@T=OAVAFC2 ?D> E?O hM2KKK2 ?D> E?O hIK2MKK EO?H

%?H> dADX<D[ $OADCE>O @? .TAO> KI9

(? W?G XD?V VTA@ @TA@iC E?Ol

,9 ! =?Di@9

j9 (? W?G XD?V <E @TA@ TAC @? =? V<@T @T>

O>\>OCAF AD= O>BAWH>D@ ?E @T> 'Y' +?DCGF@<D[ BAWH>D@C

@? 6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 ! H>AD UU ! =?Di@ XD?V9

j9 /XAW9 3<D<CT>= V<@T @TA@ ?D>9

! TA\> C@A@>H>D@C E?O ..7 E?O NKIJ2 PG@ PW

HW ?PC>O\A@<?D @T>W CT?V D? AQ@<\<@W9

:?GF= @TA@ P> Q?DC<C@>D@ V<@T W?GO

GD=>OC@AD=<D[2 @TA@ @T>O>iC P>>D D? H?D>W UU

,9 1?Gi= TA\> @? ACX @T> HADA[>O9

j9 /XAW9

,9 !iH D?@ AVAO> ?E ADW AQ@<\<@W E?O NKIJ9

j9 /XAW9 :TA@ TABB>D>= @? !U,VAO>l

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

j9 (<= W?G cGC@ H<CC @T> V<D=?V ?E

Page 133: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 133/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWW

?BB?O@GD<@W2 C?H>P?=W P>A@ W?G @? <@l

,9 /T2 W?GiO> ACX<D[ VTA@ TABB>D>= @? @T>

PGC<D>CC ?BB?O@GD<@Wl

j9 1>C9

,9 ! @T<DX @TA@iC VTA@ <@ VAC2 V> H<CC>= @T>

V<D=?V9

j9 /XAW9 !C @T> ?BB?O@GD<@W ?D[?<D[l (?>C

<@ C@<FF >a<C@l

,9 :<@T @TA@ BO?=GQ@l

j9 /O ADW ?@T>O BO?=GQ@l

,9 :>FF2 ! =?Di@ XD?V T?V @? ADCV>O @TA@ W>C

?O D?9 YW BFADC AC ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF AO> D?@ @? P>

<D\?F\>= <D ?G@C<=> PGC<D>CC9 $TA@ VAC VTA@ !

<D@>D=>= @? HAX> QF>AO VT>D ! E<F>=2 AD= @TA@iC

Q>O@A<DFW P>>D @T> QAC> C<DQ> @T>D2 AD= HW BFAD <C @?

TA\> <@ P> @T> CAH> @TO?G[T @T> @<H> ! C>O\>9

j9 ,D= VTA@iC @T> =<EE>O>DQ> P>@V>>D P><D[

<D\?F\>= <D AD ?G@C<=> PGC<D>CC AC ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF

AD= +T<>E (>BG@Wl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V <E @T>O> <C2 PG@ <@iC

Q>O@A<DFW @T> H>CCA[> ! VAD@>= @? C>D= @? @T> BGPF<Q2

@TA@ !iH A IKK B>OQ>D@ =>=<QA@>= ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF9

j9 /XAW9 .? =?>C @TA@ H>AD @TA@ W?G AO> D?@

[?<D[ @? BGOCG> @T> !U,VAO> PGC<D>CC ?BB?O@GD<@W

VT<F> W?GiO> ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAFl

Page 134: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 134/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWJ

,9 :>FF2 @T>O> O>AFFW <C D? UU @T> ADCV>O <C

@TA@ <C Q?OO>Q@9

j9 !C !U,VAO> C@<FF AD >a<C@<D[ Q?HBADWl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

j9 (?>C <@ C@<FF TA\> PADX AQQ?GD@Cl

,9 !@ =?>C9

j9 ,D= =?>C @T> >a<C@>DQ> ?E A PADX

AQQ?GD@ UU <C @T>O> ADW C<[D<E<QADQ> @? @TA@2 CGQT AC

! <D@>D= @? UU

,9 "?9 "?9

Y'9 -,--!5 ,FF O<[T@9

K&H#/I/1 TR )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ I` <C A 6GOQTAC>

,[O>>H>D@ P>@V>>D )?TD &9 .VAFF?V AC C>FF>O AD=

!U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C &D@>OBO<C>C AC PGW>O =A@>=

.>B@>HP>O IM2 NKKL9

(? W?G C>> @TA@l

,9 *TUTGT mW>C;9

j9 ,D= @T<C VAC A 6GOQTAC> ,[O>>H>D@ @TA@ VAC

BO>BAO>= C<HGF@AD>?GC V<@T @T> ?B>D<D[ ?E @T> .GB>O

.>\>D $OGC@e <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 ,D= VTA@ ! GD=>OC@AD= EO?H @T<C

@OADCAQ@<?D <C @TA@ W?G C?F= @T> !DE?F?QX MK B>OQ>D@

<D@>O>C@ @TA@ W?G TA= @? A Q?HBADW2 !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C2

Page 135: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 135/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWN

@TA@ W?G >C@APF<CT>= C<HGF@AD>?GC V<@T @T> @OGC@9

!C @TA@ AQQGOA@>l

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 ,D= @T>O> VAC A BO?H<CC?OW D?@> ?V<D[ EO?H

!U,VAO> @? W?G ?E hM2KKKe <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 $TA@iC VTA@ <@ F??XC F<X>9

j9 :AC @TA@ BO?H<CC?OW D?@> >\>O BA<=l

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 $T>O> VAC A hM2KKK

=<C@O<PG@<?D EO?H !U,VAO> @? .GfADD> ?O H>2 AD= !

=?Di@ O>QAFF <E @TA@ VAC @? BAW ?EE @T> BO?H<CC?OW

D?@> ?O VTA@ @T> BGOB?C> ?E @TA@ VAC9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF

AC ! C<@ T>O> @?=AW9

j9 /XAW9 (<= @T> =<C@O<PG@<?D Q?H> EO?H

!U,VAO>l

,9 ! @T?G[T@ <@ =<=9

Y'9 -,--!5 ,D= !iH [?<D[ @? CT?V W?G @T>

=?QGH>D@ T>O> <D A H<DG@>9 :TW =?Di@ V> cGC@ =?

@TA@9 "<D>@>>D9

K&H#/I/1 TS )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ IL2 A[A<D2 <C EO?H

@T> .@A@> ?E *@AT (>BAO@H>D@ ?E +?HH>OQ> CT?V<D[ A

QTAD[> <D HADA[>O EO?H W?G @? .GfADD> >EE>Q@<\>

YAOQT IM2 NKIN9 :> @AFX>= AP?G@ A C<H<FAO =?QGH>D@

V<@T ..7 YADA[>H>D@9

,C ! GD=>OC@AD= <@2 @T<C VAC @T>

Page 136: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 136/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWO

@<H> A@ VT<QT W?G V<@T=O>V AC HADA[>O ?E !U,VAO>

6O?=GQ@C AC V>FF AC ..7l

,9 :>FF2 ! P>F<>\> ! O>C<[D>= AC HADA[>O

BO<?O @? JUIMUNKIN E?O !U,VAO> 6O?=GQ@C AD= ..79

j9 /XAW9 :T>D =? W?G P>F<>\> W?G V<@T=O>Vl

,9 ! P>F<>\> ! O>C<[D>= ?D ?O P>E?O>

YAOQT L@T ?E NKIN9

j9 /XAW9

,9 !@ VAC ><@T>O YAOQT L@T ?O <@ VAC

YAOQT `@T2 PG@ ! @T<DX <@ VAC YAOQT L@T P>E?O> !

E<F>= HW <D<@<AF =<CQF?CGO>9

j9 /XAW9 :TA@ =<= W?G =? @? V<@T=OAV ?D

YAOQT ` ?O Ll

,9 ! <DE?OH>= HW FAVW>O @TA@ ! VAC O>C<[D<D[

AD= ACX>= T<H @? HAX> @T> QTAD[> <HH>=<A@>FW9

j9 /XAW9 (? W?G XD?V <E @T> QTAD[> VAC HA=>

?D YAOQT ` ?O Ll

,9 :>FF2 AC EAO AC ! VAC Q?DQ>OD>=2 <@ VAC

>EE>Q@<\> GB?D HW Q?HHGD<QA@<?D @? HW FAVW>O9 ,C EAO

AC ! VAC Q?DQ>OD>=2 @TA@iC T?V <@ VAC9

-??XC @? H> F<X> <@ VACDi@ ?EE<Q<AFFW =?D>

V<@T @T> .@A@> GD@<F YAOQT IM@T9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= AC EAO AC W?G V>O> Q?DQ>OD>= UU

!iH D?@ CGO> VTA@ W?G H>AD PW @TA@9

!C @TA@ cGC@ W?GO GD=>OC@AD=<D[l

Page 137: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 137/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWP

,9 YW Q?HHGD<QA@<?D @? HW FAVW>O VAC !

O>C<[D>= <HH>=<A@>FW2 AD= VT>D ! E<F>= HW

=<CQF?CGO>C2 <@ VAC V<@T @T> ACCGHB@<?D @TA@ ! TA=

O>C<[D>= AC @T> HADA[>O ?E @T>C> Q?HBAD<>C9

j9 1?G GD=>OC@AD= @TA@ <D ?O=>O @? V<@T=OAV

AC A HADA[>O W?Gi\> [?@ @? E<F> A =?QGH>D@ V<@T @T>

(>BAO@H>D@ ?E +?HH>OQ>l

,9 :>FF2 !iH cGC@ @>FF<D[ W?G HW <D@>D@ AD=

HW P>F<>E A@ @T> @<H> ! E<F>= VAC @TA@ ! TA= O>C<[D>=

AFO>A=W AC @T> HADA[>O ?E 6U.?FG@<?DC AD= ..7 AD=

!U,VAO>2 @T> @TO>> Q?HBAD<>C9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= =? W?G TA\> A P>F<>E ?O

GD=>OC@AD=<D[ @TA@2 ! H>AD2 D?V @TA@ W?Gi\> [?@ @T<C

=?QGH>D@2 =<EE>OC EO?H VTA@ @T> =?QGH>D@ CAWC2 VT<QT

<C .GfADD> .VAFF?V >EE>Q@<\> JUIMUINl

,9 :>FF2 ! Q>O@A<DFW QAD C>> @T> =A@> ?D @T<C

=?QGH>D@2 AD= @TA@ <C @T> =A@> VT>O> CT> UU <@

<D=<QA@>C @T> =A@> ?E E<F<D[ E?O T>O @? P> HADA[>O2

PG@ ! QAD @>FF W?G @TA@ ! Q?HHGD<QA@>= HW O>C<[DA@<?D

@? HW FAVW>O AD= ACCGH>= !i= P>>D UU ! TA= O>C<[D>=

P>E?O> ! E<F>= V<@T @T> .@A@> ?E *@AT9

j9 ,D= V?GF= W?G A[O>> V<@T H> @TA@ @TA@

ACCGHB@<?D ABB>AOC @? P> <DQ?OO>Q@ V<@T O>E>O>DQ> @?

@T<C =?QGH>D@l

,9 "?2 !iH D?@ Q?DQ>=<D[ ADW B?<D@ ?D @TA@9

Page 138: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 138/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWR

!iH CAW<D[ @T<C =?QGH>D@ CB>AXC E?O <@C>FE9

j9 /XAW9

,9 !iH cGC@ @>FF<D[ W?G VTA@ ! UU

j9 (?>C @T<C =?QGH>D@ CB>AX @? W?G @TA@ W?G

V>O> @T> HADA[>O GD@<F YAOQT IM2 NKINl

,9 :>FF2 A[A<D2 !iH D?@ @OW<D[ @? P>

AO[GH>D@A@<\>9 $T<C =?QGH>D@ CAWC VTA@ <@ CAWC9 !iH

cGC@ @>FF<D[ W?G @TA@ ! O>C<[D>= AC @T> HADA[>O ?E

@T>C> @TO>> Q?HBAD<>C P>E?O> ! =<= HW <D<@<AF E<F<D[

V<@T @T> .@A@> E?O ,@@?OD>W 8>D>OAF9

j9 1?Gi\> HA=> @TA@ kG<@> QF>AO2 C? F>@iC

H?\> ?D9

,9 $TADX W?G9

Y'9 -,--!5 $V>D@W9

K&H#/I/1 VU )*( 6*-X&G'M 

Y'9 -,--!5 ->@iC =? NI A@ @T> CAH> @<H>9

K&H#/I/1 VT )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 &aT<P<@C NK AD= NI2

AC ! GD=>OC@AD= <@2 O>E>O @? A @OADCAQ@<?D2 ?O

AQ@GAFFW @V? @OADCAQ@<?DC <D FA@> .>B@>HP>O ?E NKIN9

,9 1?G H>AD NKIKl

j9 ! =? H>AD NKIK9 '>E>O>DQ<D[ A hM2KKK

=>B?C<@ AD= @T>D BAWH>D@ ?G@2 AD= A H?H>D@ A[? !

@T<DX W?G CA<= @TA@ W?G XD>V @T>O> VAC A hM2KKK

=<C@O<PG@<?D9

Page 139: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 139/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TWS

!C @T<C VTA@ W?G V>O> O>E>OO<D[ @?l

,9 ! P>F<>\> <@ <C2 W>C9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= AC W?G C<@ T>O> @?=AW2 W?G

=?Di@ O>QAFF VT>O> @T> =>B?C<@ ?E hM2KKK QAH> EO?He

<C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 "?9 :<@T?G@ QT>QX<D[ @? C>> VT>O> <@ QAH>

EO?H2 ! V?GF=Di@ XD?V9

j9 ,D= VT>O> V?GF= W?G QT>QX @? C>> VT>O> <@

QAH> EO?Hl

,9 :>FF2 ! [G>CC ! Q?GF= QT>QX ?D @T> QT>QX

@TA@ ! UU ?E AQQ?GD@ O>Q><\>=9 $TA@ V?GF= @>FF H>

VT>O> <@ QAH> EO?H9

j9 (? W?G TA\> @TA@ QT>QXl

,9 "?2 ! =?Di@9

j9 d>QAGC> @TA@ VAC ?D> ?E @T> @T<D[C V>

=<=Di@ [>@ UU

,9 /XAW9

j9 UU C? !i= P> <D@>O>C@>= <D @TA@9

:<@T O>E>O>DQ> @? &aT<P<@ NI2 <C @TA@ W?GO

TAD=VO<@<D[l

,9 !@ <C HW TAD=VO<@<D[9

j9 /XAW9 $T> 3?O F<D> CAWC =OAV ?O

=<C@O<PG@<?D ?E BO?E<@C9

&aBFA<D VTA@ @TA@ <C2 <E W?G QADl

,9 ! QADi@ >aBFA<D ADW@T<D[ ?@T>O @TAD VTA@

Page 140: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 140/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJU

<@ CAWC9

j9 1?G cGC@ =?Di@ O>QAFFl

,9 "?9 ! H>AD2 A H<DG@> A[? V> @AFX>= AP?G@

A D?@> E?O hM2KKK2 AD= C? ! V?D=>O <E @TA@iC cGC@ H>

<D=<QA@<D[ @T> VO?D[ @T<D[ E?O <@9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 ,C

! C<@ T>O> @?=AW2 <@iC P>>D @TO>> W>AOC9 YAWP> <@

VAC O>BAWH>D@ ?E @TA@ D?@> AD= ! cGC@ VO?@> <@ =?VD

VO?D[9

,DWVAW2 <@ TABB>D>= VT>D2 <D .>B@>HP>O ?E

NKIKl

Y'9 -,--!5 !@ =<=2 AQQ?O=<D[ @? @T>C>

O>Q?O=C9 $V>D@WU@V?9

K&H#/I/1 VV )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; $T<C &aT<P<@ NN2 A[A<D2 !

cGC@ VAD@>= @? C>> <E !iH @OAQ<D[ @T<C H?D>W

Q?OO>Q@FW9

!@ F??XC F<X> UU &aT<P<@ NN <C @T>

c?<D@ )?TD AD= .GfADD> .VAFF?V AQQ?GD@2 AD= <E W?G

F??X A@ @T> C>Q?D= BA[>2 <@ F??XC AC <E hM2KKK VAC

=>B?C<@>= <D@? @T> c?<D@ QT>QX<D[ AQQ?GD@ ?D

.>B@>HP>O NL9

(? W?G C>> @TA@l

,9 ! =?9

j9 ,D= =? W?G XD?V <E @TA@iC @T> CAH> hM2KKK

@TA@ VAC VO<@@>D ?D AD !U,VAO> QT>QX @? )?TD .VAFF?V

Page 141: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 141/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJT

?O .GfADD> AC <D=<QA@>= <D &aT<P<@ NIl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

j9 (? W?G TA\> ADW O>AC?D @? @T<DX <@iC D?@l

,9 !iH cGC@ @OW<D[ @? [? PAQX @? @T> ?@T>O

>aT<P<@ AD= C>> @T> =A@>9

.? @T> =A@> ?E @T> QT>QX UU <@ VAC

=>B?C<@>= ?D LUN_9 !@ F??XC F<X> <@ F<X>FW <C

P>QAGC> ?E @T> =A@>C9

j9 ,C <C <D=<QA@>=2 <E <@iC @T> CAH> QT>QX

BG@ <D@? @T> c?<D@ AQQ?GD@2 =? W?G XD?V T?V @TA@

V?GF= TA\> P>>D GC>= ?@T>O @TAD E?O cGC@ D?OHAF

T?GC>T?F= >aB>DC>Cl

,9 ! =?Di@9 ! Q?GF=Di@ @>FF W?G9

j9 :?GF= W?G BO>CGH> @TA@ <@ V?GF= TA\> cGC@

P>>D GC>= E?O D?OHAF T?GC>T?F= >aB>DC>Cl

,9 ! Q?GF=Di@ @>FF W?G9 YW V<E> <C \>OW

Q?HBAO@H>D@AF<f>=2 C? ! cGC@ QADi@ @>FF W?G9 .T>iFF

@AX> A QT>QX AD= CT>iFF BG@ <@ <D@? A CGPAQQ?GD@ E?O

A CB>Q<E<Q BGOB?C>2 C? ! cGC@ QADi@ @>FF W?G AC ! C<@

T>O> @T> GC> ?E @TA@ H?D>W9

j9 ,D= @T> CGPAQQ?GD@C ! @T<DX W?G =>CQO<P>=

>AOF<>O2 CGQT AC >=GQA@<?D ?O CA\<D[C AD= UU

,9 '<[T@9 .T> TAC A C>@@F>H>D@ AQQ?GD@ EO?H

T>O B>OC?DAF <DcGOW C>@@F>H>D@ VT>O> CT> BG@ C?H> ?E

T>O B>OC?DAF H?D>W9

Page 142: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 142/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJV

j9 '<[T@9 /XAW9 ! VAD@ @? ACX W?G C?H>

kG>C@<?DC AP?G@ 6U.?FG@<?DC D?V9

! [A@T>O EO?H ?GO Q?D\>OCA@<?D C? EAO @TA@

W?G E?OH>= 6U.?FG@<?DC PAC<QAFFW A W>AO AE@>O W?G

E?OH>= @T> @OGC@e <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= VAC <@ W?GO <D@>D@ @? GC> 6U.?FG@<?DC

AC UU V>FF2 F>@ H> D?@ BG@ V?O=C <D W?GO H?G@T9

:TA@ VAC W?GO <D@>D@ <D E?OH<D[

6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 :>FF2 @T> O>AC?D ! E?OH>= <@ VAC P>QAGC>

?E @T> Q>H>D@ BFAD@ BO?c>Q@ ?BB?O@GD<@W2 AD= <@

P>QAH> A UU <@ VAC <D@>D=>= @? P> A BO?c>Q@ Q?HBADW9

! =?Di@ P>F<>\> ! V?GF= TA\> E?OH>= <@ TA= <@ D?@

P>>D E?O @T> Q>H>D@ ?BB?O@GD<@W9

j9 :TA@ =? W?G H>AD A BO?c>Q@ Q?HBADWl

,9 :>FF2 @TA@ VAC A BO?c>Q@ @TA@ ! VAC

<D\?F\>= <D2 @T> Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@ Q?HBADW9 ! Q?GF= C>>

@TA@ <@ Q?GF= B?CC<PFW P> GC>= E?O ?@T>O BO?c>Q@C

=?VD @T> O?A=9

j9 .? <@ VACDi@ cGC@ A ?D> BGOB?C> >D@<@Wl

,9 :>FF2 W>C9 ! V?GF= CAW @TA@2 W>C9

j9 /XAW9

,9 1?G =?Di@ XD?V VT>D W?G C>@ GB A Q?HBADW

VTA@ ?@T>O ?BB?O@GD<@<>C H<[T@ Q?H> @TA@ H<[T@ E<@

Page 143: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 143/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJW

V<@T<D @TA@ Q?HBADW9

j9 ,D= A@ @T> @<H> ?E E?OHA@<?D2 VT<QT V?GF=

TA\> P>>D FA@> NKIK2 VAC @TA@ A@ A @<H> VT>D W?G

P>F<>\>= @TA@ W?GO Q?HB>DCA@<?D E?O W?GO V?OX ?D

+TABAOOAF VAC [?<D[ @? P> AD >kG<@W <D@>O>C@l

,9 '<[T@9 1>C9

j9 ,D= @T>O>E?O> @T<C @OGC@ C@OGQ@GO> VAC E?O

C<[D<E<QAD@ PGC<D>CC ?BB?O@GD<@<>Ce <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 1>C9

j9 $TA@iC @T> F?[<Q ?E 6U.?FG@<?DC P><D[ <D

T>O>l

,9 '<[T@9 1>C9

j9 !E W?Gi= XD?VD @TA@ W?G V>O> [?<D[ @? [>@

?DFW hNJ2KKK AC ?BB?C>= @?2 W?G XD?V2 A P<[ B<>Q> ?E

>kG<@W2 V?GF= W?G TA\> C@<FF BG@ <@ <D@? 6U.?FG@<?DC

AC AD >D@<@W ?VD>= PW W?GO @OGC@l

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 ! H<[T@ TA\> =>Q<=>= UU

Y'9 ."/:5 $TA@ QAFFC E?O CB>QGFA@<?D9

$%& :!$"&..5 1>AT9 ! =?Di@ XD?V VTA@ !

V?GF= TA\> =?D>9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ,FF O<[T@9 1?G V>O> @T>

HADA[>O ?E 6U.?FG@<?DC2 O<[T@l

,9 '<[T@2 ?O<[<DAFFW9

K&H#/I/1 VW )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; $T<C <C A CGHHAOW ?E @T>

Page 144: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 144/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJJ

QTAD[> <D HADA[>O E?O 6U.?FG@<?DC2 cGC@ AC V>i\> C>>D

V<@T ..7 AD= !U,VAO>9

(? W?G C>> @TA@l

,9 ! =?9

j9 ! @AX> <@ W?GO @>C@<H?DW V?GF= P> @T> CAH>

E?O @T<C AC <@ VAC E?O @T> ?@T>OCl

,9 1>C9

j9 :TA@ <C @T> C@A@GC ?E 6U.?FG@<?DC D?Vl

,9 ! Q?GF=Di@ T?D>C@FW @>FF W?G9 ! TA\>Di@

QT>QX>= <@ <D @T> FAC@ C<a H?D@TC @? C>> <E <@iC

QGOO>D@FW O>[<C@>O>=9

j9 !C @T>O> ADW AQ@<\<@W <D @T> Q?HBADWl

,9 "?9

j9 (<= 6U.?FG@<?DC >\>O TA\> ADW >HBF?W>>Cl

,9 "?9

j9 (<= <@ >\>O TA\> ADW V?OX @TA@ VAC =?D>

?@T>O @TAD PW W?Gl

,9 "?9

j9 1?GO V<E>2 E?O >aAHBF>2 =<=Di@ B>OE?OH ADW

V?OX ?G@ ?E @TA@ Q?HBADW ?O UU

,9 "?9

j9 1?G =<=Di@ T<O> ADW >HBF?W>>Cl

,9 "?9

j9 /@T>O @TAD @T> V?OX E?O +TABAOOAF2 =<= W?G

=? ADW Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX @TO?G[T 6U.?FG@<?DCl

Page 145: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 145/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJN

,9 ! ACC<[D>= C?H> O>Q><\APF>C @?

6U.?FG@<?DC2 PG@ ! =<= D?@ =? ADW Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX

@TO?G[T 6U.?FG@<?DC ?@T>O @TAD @T> V?OX ! =<= E?O

'<QTAO= 'AVF>9

j9 :TA@ =? W?G H>AD W?G ACC<[D>= O>Q><\APF>Cl

,9 :>FF2 ! QAOO<>= C?H> AQQ?GD@C O>Q><\APF>C

EO?H P>E?O> ! c?<D>= @T> ,8iC ?EE<Q>9 $T>D <D NKIK2

AE@>O ! E?OH>= 6U.?FG@<?DC2 ! ACC<[D>= @T?C>

O>Q><\APF>C @? 6U.?FG@<?DC9

j9 :TA@ V>O> @T> O>Q><\APF>C E?Ol

,9 $T> O>Q><\APF>C V>O> E?O QAHBA<[D

Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX @TA@ ! =<= V<@T )AC?D 6?V>OC P>E?O> !

c?<D>= @T> ,8iC ?EE<Q>9

j9 .? @T<C V?GF= TA\> P>>D BO>U(>Q>HP>O NKIK

W?G =<= V?OXl

,9 1>C2 GTUTGT2 BO>U(>Q>HP>O NKKL9

j9 $TA@iC O<[T@9 !iH C?OOW9

,D= VT>D V>O> @T> O>Q><\APF>C Q?FF>Q@>= PW

6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 :>FF2 @T>W V>O>Di@ AFF Q?FF>Q@>=9 !

P>F<>\> @TA@ @T> ?D[?<D[ O>Q><\APF>C AO> AO?GD=

hNM2KKK2 AD= 6U.?FG@<?DC VAC BA<= h_2KKK <D YAW ?E

NKII EO?H 8G<=AD@ .@OA@>[<>C2 VT<QT <C )AC?DiC

Q?HBADW9

j9 !C @T>O> ADW =?QGH>D@A@<?D D?@<D[ @T>

Page 146: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 146/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJO

ACC<[DH>D@ ?E O>Q><\APF>Cl

,9 ! P>F<>\> @TA@ T> TAC =?QGH>D@A@<?D @TA@

CT?VC A O>Q><\APF> UU A BAWAPF> @? 6U.?FG@<?DC =A@>=

(>Q>HP>O ?E NKIK9 ! =<= CAW W>C9

Y'9 ."/:5 (<= W?G CAW NKIK ?O NKKLl

$%& :!$"&..5 NKIK9 ! @T<DX @TA@

6U.?FG@<?DC VACDi@ QO>A@>= GD@<F NKIK9

Y'9 ."/:5 '<[T@9

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; ,FF O<[T@9 1?G @?F= H>

W?G ACC<[D>= O>Q><\APF>C9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= @T> O>Q><\APF>C V?GF= TA\> P>>D ?V<D[

@? VT?l .VAFF?V S ,CC?Q<A@>Cl

,9 "?9 :?GF= TA\> P>>D BO?PAPFW ?V<D[ @? H>

B>OC?DAFFW9

j9 /XAW9 .? W?G B>OC?DAFFW HA=> AD

ACC<[DH>D@ ?E O>Q><\APF>C UU

,9 /V<D[ @? H>9

j9 UU ?V<D[ @? W?G2 AD= W?G ACC<[D>= @T>H @?

6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= W?G =<= @TA@ VT>Dl

,9 !D (>Q>HP>O ?E NKIK9

j9 :TW (>Q>HP>O ?E NKIKl

,9 :>FF2 @TA@iC VT>D )AC?D 6?V>OC AD= ! H>@

Page 147: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 147/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJP

AD= V> @AFX>= AP?G@ @T> O>Q><\APF> @TA@ T<C Q?HBADW

?V>= H>2 AD= ! CA<= !iH [?<D[ @? ACC<[D @TA@ AD=

T>O>PW ACC<[D @TA@ @? 6U.?FG@<?DC9

j9 ,D= <C @T>O> ADW =?QGH>D@A@<?D ACC<[D<D[

@T> O>Q><\APF> UU

,9 "?9

j9 UU EO?H .VAFF?V S ,CC?Q<A@>C @?

6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 !@ VACDi@ EO?H .VAFF?V S ,CC?Q<A@>C9 !@

VAC EO?H H> B>OC?DAFFW9

j9 !iH C?OOW9 YW H<C@AX>9 1?G =<= CAW @TA@9

,9 "?9 ! =<= A \>OPAF ?O ?OAF ACC<[DH>D@9

j9 /XAW9 1?GiO> PAC<QAFFW ACC<[D<D[ <@ EO?H

W?G AC @T> UU

,9 ,C AD <D=<\<=GAF9

j9 1?G AC AD <D=<\<=GAF @? UU

,9 YW EAH<FWiC @OGC@9

j9 UU @? W?GO EAH<FWiC @OGC@ UU V>FF2

AQ@GAFFW @? AD >D@<@W UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU V<@T<D @T> EAH<FWiC @OGC@l

,9 1?GiO> O<[T@2 @? AD >D@<@W T>F= PW2 ?VD>=

PW HW EAH<FWiC @OGC@9

j9 $? AD >D@<@W VT>O> W?G V>O> @T> ?DFW

B>OC?D B>OE?OH<D[ @T> C>O\<Q>Cl

Page 148: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 148/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJR

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

Y'9 -,--!5 $V>D@WUE?GO9

K&H#/I/1 VJ )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ N] <C 6U.?FG@<?DCi

PADX AQQ?GD@ O>Q?O=C E?O NKII2 AD= <E ! Q?GF= =<O>Q@

W?GO A@@>D@<?D2 E<OC@ ?E AFF2 @? dA@>C BA[> J]9

->@iC QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ> &aT<P<@ NM9

K&H#/I/1 VN )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 .? &aT<P<@ N] <C

@T> PADX C@A@>H>D@C2 &aT<P<@ NM <C @T> QT>QXC9

:<@T O>E>O>DQ> @? &aT<P<@ N]2 dA@>C

BA[> J]2 @T>O> <C A =>B?C<@ UU >aQGC> H>9 , QT>QX ?E

hM2LI_2 AD= @T>O>iC A TAD=VO<@@>D D?@A@<?D g.GfADD>9g

(? W?G C>> @TA@l

,9 ! =?9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VT?C> TAD=VO<@<D[ g.GfADD>g

<Cl

,9 !iH ACCGH<D[ <@iC H<D>9

j9 :>FF2 <D BO?=GQ<D[ @T>C> =?QGH>D@C2 =? W?G

O>QAFF BG@@<D[ >aBFADA@?OW D?@>C ?D @T> PADX

C@A@>H>D@Cl

,9 ! =?Di@ O>QAFF @TA@9 ! HAW TA\>9 ! H>AD2

<@ F??XC F<X> HW TAD=VO<@<D[9 !iH D?@ [?<D[ @? =>DW

<@iC HW TAD=VO<@<D[2 PG@ UU

j9 ,FF O<[T@9

Page 149: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 149/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TJS

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V VT? >FC> <@ Q?GF= TA\> P>>D2

F>@iC BG@ <@ @TA@ VAW9

j9 /XAW9 :T>D W?G BO?=GQ>= @T>C> =?QGH>D@C2

! GD=>OC@??= W?G >AOF<>O @? CAW @TA@ W?G =<=Di@ TA\>

ADW TAO= Q?BW PADX C@A@>H>D@C <D W?GO T?GC>9

(<= ! GD=>OC@AD= @TA@ Q?OO>Q@FWl

,9 ! P>F<>\> @TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

j9 ,D= W?GO V<E> @?F= W?G @? [? @? @T> PADX

@? [>@ @T> PADX AQQ?GD@C2 O<[T@l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= ! BO>CGH> VT>D W?G [?@ <@ EO?H @T>

PADX <@ =<=Di@ TA\> @T> TAD=VO<@@>D D?@> g.GfADD>g ?D

<@2 =<= <@l

,9 ! V?GF=Di@ @T<DX C?9

j9 /XAW9 !E V> QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ> @TA@ hM2LI_

QT>QX @? &aT<P<@ NM2 @T>O> <C A QT>QX E?O @T> CAH>

AH?GD@2 AF@T?G[T VO<@@>D C>\>OAF =AWC >AOF<>O2

YAOQT JK2 NKII2 @? .GfADD> .VAFF?V9

(? W?G C>> @TA@ QT>QXl

,9 1>C9

j9 "GHP>O IKKNl

,9 m:<@D>CC D?==<D[ T>A= AEE<OHA@<\>FW9;

j9 !C @TA@ W?GO TAD=VO<@<D[ ?D QT>QX IKKNl

,9 1>C9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= <@ CAWC @TA@ @T> QT>QX <C E?O

Page 150: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 150/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNU

@Aa>C2 AD= <@ F??XC @? H> F<X> C?H>@T<D[ !',

Q?D@O<PG@<?D9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VTA@ @T> gC?H>@T<D[g <Cl

,9 $TA@ F??XC F<X> <@ CAWC .&69

j9 1>AT2 @TA@iC VTA@ ! @T?G[T@2 @??2 PG@ <@iC

Q?DEGC<D[ P>QAGC> @T<C <C <D YAOQT9

:?GF= W?G TA\> P>>D HAX<D[ AD !',

Q?D@O<PG@<?D AC ?E .>B@>HP>Ol

,9 "?9 .? @TA@ Q?GF= P> UU .&6 Q?GF= P> AD

APPO>\<A@<?D E?O @T> @WB> ?E Q?D@O<PG@<?D @TA@ @T>

!', <C9 ! =?Di@ @T<DX <@ VAC .>B@>HP>O9 ! =?Di@

@T<DX .&6 <C CT?O@ E?O .>B@>HP>O9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VTA@ <@iC CT?O@ E?Ol

,9 !@iC CT?O@ E?O UU ! =?Di@ XD?V9 ! =?Di@

XD?V VTA@ .&6 C@AD=C E?O9

j9 /XAW9 (? W?G XD?V UU W?G CA<= W?G TA\>

@TO>> !', AQQ?GD@Cl

,9 1>C9

j9 (? W?G XD?V VT<QT ?E @T> @TO>> @T>

Q?D@O<PG@<?D VAC E?Ol

,9 ! =? D?@ XD?V9

j9 (? W?G XD?V <E <@ VAC E?O W?GOC ?O W?GO

V<E>iCl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

Page 151: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 151/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNT

j9 $T> @Aa>C O>E>OO>= @? @T>O>2 =? W?G O>QAFF

VTA@ @Aa>C V>O> ?V>=l

,9 $T?C> V?GF= P> <DQ?H> @Aa>C9

j9 3>=>OAF ?O C@A@> ?O P?@Te =? W?G XD?Vl

,9 ! =?Di@ XD?V9

j9 ,D= W?G AD= W?GO V<E> E<F>= c?<D@FW2

=<=Di@ W?Gl

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 .? @TA@ V?GF= TA\> P>>D E?O W?GO c?<D@

<DQ?H> @Aa>Cl

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 $GOD @T> BA[> ?D &aT<P<@ N]2 <E W?G

V?GF=2 BF>AC>2 AD= NM2 AD= ! VAD@ @? ACX W?G AP?G@

@T> QT>QX IKKJ2 hIJ2NKK2 VT<QT2 A[A<D2 <D @T>

&aT<P<@ N] @T>O>iC A TAD=VO<@@>D D?@A@<?D g.GfADD>9g

,9 /XAW9

j9 ,D= @TA@ QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ>C @? @T> AQ@GAF

QT>QX VT<QT <C .GfADD> .VAFF?V UU

,9 /XAW9

j9 UU E?O hIJ2NKK9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 !C @TA@ W?GO TAD=VO<@<D[ ?D @T>

QT>QXl 1?G E<FF>= <@ ?G@l

,9 1>C9

j9 :TA@ VAC @T> hIJ2NKK E?Ol

Page 152: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 152/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNV

,9 :>FF2 <@ VAC A BAWH>D@ UU <@ VAC A

=<C@O<PG@<?D ?O T?V>\>O W?G VAD@ @? QAFF <@ @?

.GfADD> .VAFF?V9

j9 :>FF2 @TA@iC VTA@ HW kG>C@<?D <C9

:TA@ =<= W?G QAFF <@l :TA@ =<= W?G <D@>D=

<@ E?Ol

,9 , =<C@O<PG@<?D9

j9 , =<C@O<PG@<?D ?El

,9 6O?E<@C9

j9 ,D= VTW VAC A =<C@O<PG@<?D ?E BO?E<@C

P><D[ HA=> @? .GfADD>l

,9 d>QAGC> CT> VAC A P>D>E<Q<AOW ?E @T>

@OGC@9

j9 ,D= VAC @T>O> A BGOB?C>l ! H>AD2 VAC

@T>O> C?H> D>>= E?O @T> H?D>Wl

3?O >aAHBF>2 VAC @T<C O>FA@>= @? @T>

ABBF<ADQ> BGOQTAC> W?G @AFX>= AP?G@l

,9 :>FF2 ! @T<DX CT> GC>= @T> H?D>W <D BAO@

@? PGW D>V ABBF<ADQ>C AD= <D BAO@ E?O @Aa>C9

j9 /XAW9 :>FF2 ! BO>CGH> @TA@ W?G AD= W?GO

V<E> V?GF= TA\> @AFX>= AP?G@ VTA@ W?G V>O> [?<D[ @?

GC> @T> H?D>W E?Ol

,9 '<[T@9 !@iC cGC@ P>>D @V? AD= A TAFE

W>AOC9

j9 1?G cGC@ =?Di@ O>H>HP>O9 /XAW9 3A<O

Page 153: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 153/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNW

>D?G[T9

dG@ W?G =<= TA\> A O>Q?FF>Q@<?D2 AC !

GD=>OC@??= <@ >AOF<>O2 ?E C?H> H?D>W @TA@ V>D@ ?G@ ?E

?D> ?E @T> >D@<@<>C <D @T> @OGC@ VAC E?O @T> BGOQTAC>

?E D>V ABBF<ADQ>Cl

,9 :AC E?O .GfADD>iC BGOQTAC> ?E D>V

ABBF<ADQ>C2 W>C9

j9 :TA@ V>O> @T> ABBF<ADQ>C E?Ol ! BO>CGH>

W?GO T?GC>l

,9 3?O @T> X<@QT>D9

j9 1>AT9 /XAW9 (? W?G AD= W?GO V<E> F<\>

@?[>@T>Ol

,9 :> =?9

j9 /XAW9 :TA@ <C @T> h_2KKK =>B?C<@ ?D

&aT<P<@ N]l

Y'9 ."/:5 $TA@iC A CHAO@ ACC ?Pc>Q@<?D9

$%& :!$"&..5 :T<QT ?D> W?G @AFX<D[ AP?G@l

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; !iH @AFX<D[ AP?G@

&aT<P<@ N]9

,9 $V>D@WUE?GO2 AD= VT<QT BA[>l

j9 $T<O@WUE<\>2 dA@>C JM9

,9 /T2 !iH C?OOW9 /T2 h_2KKK =>B?C<@9 !

P>F<>\> @TA@ <C @T> BAWH>D@ PW 8G<=AD@ .@OA@>[<>C @?

6U.?FG@<?DC ?D @TA@ AQQ?GD@ O>Q><\APF> ! =>CQO<P>=9

j9 .? @T> AQQ?GD@2 ?O @T> O>Q><\APF> VAC

Page 154: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 154/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNJ

[>D>OA@>= ?O >AOD>= PW W?G B>OC?DAFFW BO<?O @?

(>Q>HP>O ?E NKKL2 O<[T@l

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 ,D= )AC?D 6?V>OC <C BAW<D[ @T<C <D YAW ?E

NKIIl

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 ,D= T> C@<FF ?V>C W?G H?D>Wl

,9 %> C@<FF ?V>C 6U.?FG@<?DC H?D>W2 W>C9

j9 %> C@<FF ?V>C 6U.?FG@<?DC H?D>Wl

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 3?O V?OX @TA@ W?G B>OC?DAFFW ACC<[D>= @?

6U.?FG@<?DCl

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 ,O> W?G [?<D[ @? C>D= T<H @? A Q?FF>Q@<?D

A[>DQWl

,9 ! TA\>Di@ =>Q<=>= @TA@ W>@9 (?Di@ @>FF

T<H ! CA<= @TA@9

j9 :>FF2 ! ACCGH> W?G QAD O>E>O W?GOC>FE @? A

[??= FAVW>O @? Q?FF>Q@ ?D @TA@ H?D>W9

,9 ! CGO> QAD9

j9 /XAW9 (? W?G XD?V ?E ADW ?@T>O UU ! H>AD2

<C @T>O> AD?@T>O B?CC<P<F<@W ?E VTA@ @TA@ H<[T@ TA\>

P>>D E?O2 ?O AO> W?G BO>@@W CGO> @TA@ @T<C VAC @T>

h_2KKK @TA@ 6?V>OC UU

,9 "?9 ! O>H>HP>O @TA@ P>QAGC> !i\> F??X>=

Page 155: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 155/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNN

A@ <@ O>Q>D@FW9

j9 /XAW9 ->@iC @GOD @? dA@>C BA[> JL <D

&aT<P<@ N]2 AD= ! VAD@ @? =OAV W?GO A@@>D@<?D @? @T>

hMKK QT>QX @? ..7 YADA[>H>D@9

,9 /XAW9

j9 (? W?G C>> @TA@l

,9 :T<QT ?D> <C <@ ?D2 VT<QT >aT<P<@l

j9 !@iC dA@>C BA[> JL ?D &aT<P<@ N]9

,9 /XAW9 ,D= W?GiO> O>E>OO<D[ @? @T> F<D>

@TA@ CAWC2 g:<@T=OAVAF $OADCE>O @? ..7 YADA[>H>D@gl

j9 1GB2 GTUTGT9

,9 /XAW9

j9 ,D= @T>D hMKK9

,9 /XAW9

j9 ,D= <E W?G O>QAFF VT>D V> V>O> F??X<D[ A@

..7iC =?QGH>D@C2 @T>O> VAC UU <@ F??X>= @? H> F<X>

hMKK VAC @OADCE>OO>= @? ..7 cGC@ C? <@ Q?GF= P> UU

@T>O> VAC H?D>W <D @T>O> @? X>>B GB V<@T @T> hI] ?O

hIM =>=GQ@<?D >AQT H?D@T9

,9 '<[T@9

j9 !C @TA@ W?GO O>Q?FF>Q@<?Dl

,9 ! P>F<>\> @TA@iC O<[T@2 W>AT9

j9 /XAW9 !D &aT<P<@ N] BF>AC> @GOD @? @T>

FAC@ BA[>2 VT<QT <C ]N9 $T> ?@T>O ?D> m<D=<QA@<D[;9

,D= @TA@ F??XC @? P> A ">\A=A @OGC@>> E>>

Page 156: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 156/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNO

@TA@iC BA<=l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 :TW <C @T> @OGC@>> E>> P><D[ BA<= ?G@ ?E

@T> 6U.?FG@<?DC AQQ?GD@l

,9 :>FF2 ! QAD2 ! [G>CC2 >aBFA<D <@ PW CAW<D[

@T>O> VAC D?@ A @OGC@ AQQ?GD@2 AD= C<DQ> @T> Q?HBADW

<C ?VD>= PW @T> @OGC@2 @T> BAWH>D@ VAC HA=> PW @T>

Q?HBADW @TA@ TA= @T> H?D>W9

j9 .? <@ VAC cGC@ A HA@@>O ?E >aB>=<>DQW

P>QAGC> @TA@iC VT>O> @T> H?D>W VACl

,9 ! P>F<>\> @TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

Y'9 -,--!5 /XAW9 1?G QAD BG@ N] AVAW2

PG@ X>>B NM ?B>D9 :>iFF HAOX &aT<P<@ N^9

K&H#/I/1 VO )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; /XAW9 &aT<P<@ N^ <C

6U.?FG@<?DCi PADX AQQ?GD@ C@A@>H>D@C E?O NKIN2 AD= ?D

@T> E<OC@ BA[>2 VT<QT <C dA@>C ]J UU

,9 *TUTGT mW>C;9

j9 UU @T>O> <C A QT>QX VO<@@>D E?O hNMK AD= A

TAD=VO<@@>D D?@> g+TAO<@APF> Q?D@O<PG@<?D9g

,9 '<[T@9

j9 !C @TA@ W?GO TAD=VO<@<D[l

,9 1>AT2 <@ F??XC F<X> <@9

j9 ,D= QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ> @TA@ @? &aT<P<@ NM2

dA@>C BA[> M_2 AD= @T>O> <C A QT>QX IKKM @TA@ !

Page 157: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 157/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNP

P>F<>\> QO?CCUO>E>O>DQ>C UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU VO<@@>D @? .AD=W %?D?OAOW +?F?D>FCl

,9 '<[T@9

j9 ,D= <D @T> 3?O F<D>2 <C @TA@ =G>Cl

,9 !@ =?>C9

j9 $T<C <C W?GO TAD=VO<@<D[2 ! @AX> <@l

,9 $TA@ <C2 O<[T@9

j9 :TA@ AO> @T> .AD=W %?D?OAOW +?F?D>FCl

,9 !@iC AD ?O[AD<fA@<?D @TA@ CGBB?O@C @T>

F?QAF B?F<Q> =>BAO@H>D@9 !@iC A D?DBO?E<@ Q?HBADW9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= AO> W?G AEE<F<A@>= V<@T @TA@

Q?HBADWl

,9 ! AH9 ! AH A UU !iH A H>HP>O ?E @T>

+?F?D>FC9

j9 ,D= <C @TA@ F<X> ADDGAF =G>C ?O C?H>@T<D[

@TA@ W?G BAWl

,9 1>C9

j9 ,D= C? W?G BA<= W?GO ADDGAF =G>C ?G@ ?E

@T> 6U.?FG@<?DC AQQ?GD@e <C @TA@ O<[T@l

,9 $TA@iC O<[T@9

j9 8?@ <@9 /XAW9 !D &aT<P<@ N^ F>@iC F??X

A@ dA@>C BA[> ]_2 AD= @T>O>iC A D?@A@<?D @T>O> g-?ADC

EO?H )?TD AD= .GfADD>9g

,9 '<[T@9

Page 158: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 158/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNR

j9 :TA@ V>O> @T?C> F?ADC E?Ol

,9 $T?C> V>O> F?ADC @? 6U.?FG@<?DC C? @TA@

6U.?FG@<?DC Q?GF= O>EGD= @T> H?D>W @? YO9 'AVF>9

j9 /XAW9 ,D= VT? HA=> @T> =>Q<C<?D @? =?

@TA@l

,9 .GfADD> AD= ! HA=> <@ @?[>@T>O9

j9 :T?C> <=>A VAC <@l

,9 :>FF2 ! [A\> @T> <=>A @? .GfADD> AD=

.GfADD> Q?DQGOO>=9

j9 /XAW9 ->@iC F??X <D &aT<P<@ N] pC<Qq @?

dA@>C BA[> MI2 AD= <@ F??XC F<X> @T<C UU @T> D?@A@<?D

<C g">V QT>QX EO?H 'AVF>9g

,9 '<[T@9

j9 /XAW9 ! GD=>OC@AD= @TA@9

,D= @T> D>a@ BA[>2 dA@>C BA[> MN2 V?GF=

W?G cGC@ >aBFA<D @T?C> D?@A@<?DC AD= @OADCAQ@<?DC E?O

H>l

,9 :>FF2 <@ F??XC F<X> UU @T<C <C ?D @T>

Y?GD@A<D ,H>O<QA +O>=<@ UU !iH C?OOW9 $T<C <C ?D @T>

6U.?FG@<?DC AQQ?GD@2 O<[T@l

j9 *TUTGT mW>C;9

,9 , QT>QX E?O hI^2KKK F??XC F<X> EO?H HW

D?@A@<?DC T>O> BAWAPF> @? )?TD .VAFF?V AD= .GfADD>

.VAFF?V2 A O>BAWH>D@ ?E @T> F?AD O>E>O>DQ>= <D @T>

BO<?O >aT<P<@ E?O @T> hIM2MKK AD= @T> hMKK F?AD @TA@

Page 159: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 159/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TNS

?GO EAH<FW [A\> @? 6U.?FG@<?DC2 O<[T@l

j9 '<[T@9

,9 /XAW9 .? =? W?G VAD@ H> @? Q?D@<DG>l

j9 $T> QT>QX @? ..72 ! @T<DX ! AFO>A=W ACX>=

W?G VTA@ @TA@ VAC E?O2 AD= W?G CA<= W?G =<=Di@ XD?V9

,9 1>AT2 ! =?Di@ XD?V9 1>AT2 @TA@iC E<D>2

AD= @T> QT>QX @? 'AVF>2 @TA@iC2 ! [G>CC2 T<H

QACT<D[ UU !iH [G>CC<D[ @TA@iC T<H QACT<D[ @T> O>EGD=

QT>QX9

j9 "?V2 =? ! GD=>OC@AD= Q?OO>Q@FW @TA@ @T>O>

V>O> @V? QT>QXC VO<@@>D @? 'AVF>l

,9 '<[T@9

j9 :TA@ TABB>D>= @T>O>l

,9 :> [A\> T<H A QT>QX >AOF<>O <D @T> CGHH>O2

! @T<DX <D YAW2 AD= T> D>\>O UU T>i= D>\>O QACT <@2

C? ! X>B@ QAFF<D[ T<H AD= CAW<D[ BF>AC> QACT @T>

QT>QX2 AD= T> V?GF=Di@ QACT @T> QT>QX2 AD= C?H> @<H>

FA@>O T> @?F= H> T>i= F?C@ @T> QT>QX9 ,CCGH<D[ @TA@

T> XD>V VTA@ T> VAC @AFX<D[ AP?G@2 V> V>D@ AT>A= AD=

VO?@> AD?@T>O QT>QX @? T<H9 $TA@iC VTW @T>O> V>O>

@V? QT>QXC @? T<H9

j9 ,D= @T>D T> E?GD= @T> E<OC@ ?D> AD=

QADQ>F>= @T> C>Q?D= ?D>l

,9 :>FF2 T> E?GD= @T> E<OC@ ?D> AD= QACT>=

<@2 AD= @T>D T<C C?D QACT>= @T> C>Q?D= QT>QX2 AD=

Page 160: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 160/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TOU

@T>D V> TA= D?DCGEE<Q<>D@ EGD=C <D @T> AQQ?GD@9 $TA@

VAC X<D= ?E VTA@ TABB>D>=2 AC ! O>QAFF9

j9 ,D= ! BO>CGH> @T>W BA<= <@ PAQXl

,9 1>AT9 :> BO?PAPFW BA<= A E>> ?O VTA@>\>O2

".3 E>>2 C? <@ =<=Di@ [? @TO?G[T9

Y'9 -,--!5 :T>O> AO> V>l

$%& +/*'$ '&6/'$&'5 $V>D@WUC>\>D9

Y'9 -,--!5 $V>D@WUC>\>D9

K&H#/I/1 VP )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; &aT<P<@ N_ <C cGC@ A Q?BW

?E A QT>QX @? 6U.?FG@<?DC ?E hIM2KKK9 -??XC F<X>

<@iC =A@>= ,BO<F `2 NKIIl

,9 '<[T@2 <@ =?>C9

j9 ,D= @T> QT>QX <C A QT>QX @? 'Y'

+?DCGF@<D[2 --+ UU

,9 '<[T@9

j9 UU =? W?G C>> @TA@l

,9 ! =?9

j9 :TA@ <C @TA@ >D@<@Wl

,9 :>FF2 !iH ACCGH<D[ @TA@iC '<QTAO= 'AVF>iC

Q?HBADW9 'Y' BO?PAPFW C@AD=C E?O '<QTAO= Y9 'AVF>9

j9 !C @TA@ @T> Q?HBADW W?G V>O> =?<D[

Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX E?O V<@T O>CB>Q@ @? @T> +TABAOOAF

Q>H>D@ BO?c>Q@l

,9 :>FF2 <@ F??XC F<X> <@ VAC9 ! @T?G[T@ !

Page 161: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 161/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TOT

VAC =?<D[ Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX E?O '<QTAO= 'AVF>2 PG@ T>

BA<= H> V<@T AD 'Y' +?DCGF@<D[2 --+2 QT>QX2 PG@ F??XC

F<X> @TA@iC @T> QT>QX T> GC>= @? BAW 6U.?FG@<?DC <D

,BO<F ?E NKII UU

j9 '<[T@9

,9 UU E?O @T> Q?DCGF@<D[ V?OX @TA@ ! TA= =?D>

?D P>TAFE ?E 6U.?FG@<?DC E?O T<H9

,O> W?G =?D> V<@T &aT<P<@ N^ AD= NMl

j9 !iH =?D> V<@T @TA@ ?D> m<D=<QA@<D[;9 !

=?Di@ XD?V <E !iH =?D> V<@T &aT<P<@ NM W>@9

,9 /XAW9

Y'9 -,--!5 ! VAD@ @? HAOX AC &aT<P<@ N`2

@T<C <C .QT>=GF> + ?E @T> W>AO NKII @Aa O>@GODC9

K&H#/I/1 VR )*( 6*-X&G'M 

j9 mdW YO9 -AFF<; $T<C <C A 6O?E<@ ?O -?CC

3O?H dGC<D>CC ?E A C?F> BO?BO<>@?OCT<B2 AD= <@

<=>D@<E<>C A D>@ BO?E<@ ?E hI]2NL] EO?H 6U.?FG@<?DC

E?O @Aa W>AO NKII9

(? ! GD=>OC@AD= @TA@ AQQGOA@>FWl

,9 !@ F??XC F<X> @TA@iC VTA@ <@ <C2 W>C9

j9 ,D= ! @T<DX @T<C =>H?DC@OA@>C VTA@ V>

@AFX>= AP?G@ >AOF<>O <C @TA@ @T> <DQ?H> @TA@

6U.?FG@<?DC UU V>FF2 @T> hIM2KKK @TA@ V>D@ @?

6U.?FG@<?DC2 W?G B>OC?DAFFW BA<= @Aa>C ?D <@l

,9 $TA@iC Q?OO>Q@9

Page 162: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 162/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TOV

j9 /XAW9 ,D= @T> C>Q?D= BA[> ?E @T<C <C AD

AH>D=>= @Aa O>@GOD9

:TW =<= W?G UU VTW =<= W?G AH>D= W?GO NKII

@Aa O>@GODl

,9 d>QAGC> E?O C?H> O>AC?D @T> h_2KKK BA<= PW

8G<=AD@ .@OA@>[<>C UU AC ! V>D@ @TO?G[T @T<C

BO?=GQ@<?D >a>OQ<C> >AOF<>O <D @T> W>AO2 ! D?@<Q>=

@TA@ @T> h_2KKK EO?H 8G<=AD@ .@OA@>[<>C TA= D?@ P>>D

B<QX>= GB ?D HW @Aa>C E?O NKII2 C? ! VAD@>= @? D?@

QT>A@ @T> !'.2 AD= ! VAD@>= @? O>E<F> HW @Aa>C2 VT<QT

! =<=9

j9 ,D= VT>D =<= W?G O>E<F> W?GO NKII @Aa>Cl

,9 :TA@ <C @T> =A@> ?D @T> =?QGH>D@l

j9 ! @T<DX ! HAW TA\> <@ O<[T@ T>O>9

,9 /XAW9 !@ VAC V<@T<D @T> FAC@ C<a H?D@TC2

! @T<DX9

j9 .? C?H>@<H> <D NKIJl

,9 1>C2 AC C??D AC ! =<CQ?\>O>= @T> H<C@AX>9

j9 :T?iC W?GO @Aa AQQ?GD@AD@l

,9 %<C DAH> <C (A\<= 6?C>W9

j9 ,D= T?V F?D[ TA\> W?G GC>= T<Hl

,9 3?O BO?PAPFW ><[T@ ?O D<D> W>AOC9

Y'9 -,--!5 ->@iC [? ?EE @T> O>Q?O= E?O A

H?H>D@9

$%& 7!(&/8',6%&'5 :> AO> ?EE @T> O>Q?O=9

Page 163: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 163/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TOW

$T> @<H> <C M5M] B9H9

m(<CQGCC<?D T>F= ?EE @T> O>Q?O=9;

m(>B?C<@<?D A=c?GOD>= A@ M5M] B9H9;

R R R

Page 164: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 164/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TOJ

-&,"-1&-Y( .&-1/4/.*1&

.$,$& /3 *$,% ;; CC9

+/*"$1 /3 .,-$ -,0& ;

!2 (>D<C> Y9 $T?HAC2 +>O@<E<>= '>AFU$<H>'>B?O@>O2 '>[<C@>O>= 6O?E>CC<?DAF '>B?O@>O AD= "?@AOW6GPF<Q <D AD= E?O @T> .@A@> ?E *@AT2 =? T>O>PWQ>O@<EW5

$TA@ BO<?O @? P><D[ >aAH<D>=2 @T> V<@D>CC2)/%" &9 .:,--/:2 VAC PW H> =GFW CV?OD @? @>FF @T>@OG@T2 @T> VT?F> @OG@T2 AD= D?@T<D[ PG@ @T> @OG@Te

$TA@ CA<= =>B?C<@<?D VAC @AX>D =?VD PW H>

<D C@>D?@WB> ?D /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ2 A@ @T> BFAQ>@T>O><D DAH>=2 AD= VAC @T>O>AE@>O @OADCQO<P>= AD=@TA@ A @OG> AD= Q?OO>Q@ @OADCQO<B@<?D ?E CA<=@>C@<H?DW <C C>@ E?O@T <D @T> BO>Q>=<D[ BA[>Ce

! EGO@T>O Q>O@<EW @TA@2 <DAQQ?O=ADQ> V<@T 'GF> JKm>;2 A O>kG>C@ TA\<D[ P>>DHA=> @? O>\<>V @T> @OADCQO<B@2 A O>A=<D[ Q?BW VACC>D@ @? Y'9 ."/: E?O @T> V<@D>CC @? O>A= AD= C<[DGD=>O @T> B>DAF@<>C ?E B>OcGOW AD= @T>D O>@GOD @? H>E?O E<F<D[ V<@T Y'9 -,--!9

! EGO@T>O Q>O@<EW @TA@ ! AH D?@ X<D ?O?@T>OV<C> ACC?Q<A@>= V<@T ADW ?E @T> BAO@<>C @? CA<=QAGC> ?E AQ@<?D AD= @TA@ ! AH D?@ <D@>O>C@>= <D @T>?G@Q?H> @T>O>?E9

:!$"&.. Y1 %,"( @T<C NND= =AW ?E /Q@?P>O2NKIJ9

  (>D<C> Y9 $T?HAC2 +''Z'6'

*@AT -<Q>DC> "?9 IK]IIJU_`KI

Page 165: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 165/327

I

N

J

]

M

^

_

`

L

IK

II

IN

IJ

I]

IM

I^

I_

I`

IL

NK

NI

NN

NJ

N]

NM

)?TD &9 .VAFF?V R /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

+<@<+?GO@2 --+`KI9MJN9J]]I

TON

+AC>5 !D O> @T> .B>Q<AF !D\>C@<[A@<?D ?E ,@@?OD>W8>D>OAF )?TD &9 .VAFF?V

+AC> "?95 IJKLKMNLJ'>B?O@>O5 (>D<C> Y9 $T?HAC(A@> @AX>D5 /Q@?P>O IM2 NKIJ

)/1$&(( .&-1/4/.*1&

!2 )/%" &9 .:,--/:2 %&'&d1 (&+-,'&5$TA@ ! AH @T> V<@D>CC <D @T> E?O>[?<D[

@OADCQO<B@e @TA@ ! TA\> O>A= @T> @OADCQO<B@ AD= XD?V@T> Q?D@>D@C @T>O>?Ee @TA@ V<@T @T>C> Q?OO>Q@<?DC !TA\> D?@>= @T<C @OADCQO<B@ @OGFW AD= AQQGOA@>FWO>EF>Q@C HW @>C@<H?DW9

,*2&Z+/$& .#*$2&[."--&.1/"$ -&*("$ 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444 444444444

 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444 444444444

 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444 444444444

 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444 444444444

 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444 444444444

 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444 444444444

 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444 444444444

 4444444444 44444444444444444444444444444

 444444444

 4444444444 "? Q?OO>Q@<?DC V>O> HA=>9

 !2 )/%" &9 .:,--/:2 %&'&d1 (&+-,'& *"(&' $%& 6&",-$!&./3 6&')*'1 /3 $%& -,:. /3 $%& *"!$&( .$,$&. /3,Y&'!+, ,"( $%& -,:. /3 $%& .$,$& /3 *$,% $%,$ $%&3/'&8/!"8 !. $'*& ,"( +/''&+$9

:!$"&.. Y1 %,"( @T<C444444 =AW ?E 44444442NKIJ9

 4444444444444444444444444444)/%" &9 .:,--/:

Page 166: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 166/327

!" $%& $%!'( )*(!+!,- (!.$'!+$ +/*'$

.,-$ -,0& +/*"$12 .$,$& /3 *$,% 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444

!" '&5 $%& .6&+!,-!"7&.$!8,$!/" /3,$$/'"&1 8&"&',- )/%"&9 .:,--/:

 

;;;;;;;;;;

7<=>?@AB>=(>B?C<@<?D ?E5

!"#$ &' ()*++") 

7?FGH> I

+AC> "?9 JKLMLNIMK

%?D?OAPF> 7>OD<Q> $O>AC> 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444

/Q@?P>O IN2 ILJK R J5KS B9H9

-?QA@<?D5 .D>FF T :<FH>OJN :>C@ .?G@U $>HBF> VV .G<@> JILL

8A@>WAX $?W>O :>[email protected]@ -AY> +<@X2 *@AU

'>B?O@>O5 (>D<C> Z9 $U?HAC2 +''['6'

"?@AOX 6GPF<Q <D AD= E?O @U> .@A@> ?E *@AU

'XAD '>\>OHAD2 +-7.

Page 167: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 167/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!B%#"B#$$!

!&'

! # # $ ! % ! & ' $ (

(#$')!* '+,&($* -+ -.$ *)$,-$&!&- /+0$%&+% +1 -.$(-!-$ +1 ,-!.2

3455678 *9 *4::;(5784<5 +9 #74=2C0AA D EFAG0HI99,<.;JK 49 A432459 A4L; >?9J= M94- ($!*!B!**$N;5;O-,.;P (*!1"%'1!)**Q4RP (*!1"%'1!(**0BS4?5P S5455?TK354318,S

KO;4JTK354318,SUK9;34<9TK354318,S

1+% -.$ !--+%&$> /$&$%!* ?+.& $9 (@!**+@2 

%ABC7= /9 (CA8?7CC;D7< !9 ?4E7F>AVW0 2C7E D 2022F7C2I99,<.;JK 49 A43"*! 2,@9- G4?. 29<;;9 BB 2@?9; !#**2459 A4L; >?9J= M94- ($!!!N;5;O-,.;P (*!1#""1"%!&Q4RP (*!1%"!1&"(*0BS4?5P <XKT85JY;K.,318,S

  U4UT85JY;K.,318,S

6 6 6

Page 168: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 168/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

!&(

! # $ % &

'()# %* +,-..(, /-0%

+,-./0-1/20 45 678 9-::/ !'!

% & ) ! 1 ! 2 +

#341%5   $%+65!/2!(# /-0%

") 6-5 "*!" 62;01-/0 <.=7/>- ?7=@/1A0/20 B1-1=.=01 2C <>>2;01 C27D2E0 +8 BF-::2F -0@ B;G-00= 68BF-::2FH 4-1=I J2I8 DB***&#&K&$&HL?20C/@=01/-:L

!()

#* $K%K!! =K.-/: =,>E-0M= N=1F==0

O7/I1- P/NI20 -0@ ?271 Q-:R=7H4-1=I J28 B?6**&*#

"*#

#! &K")K!! =K.-/: 12 S/T C72. D2E0BF-::2FH 4-1=I J28 B?6**&"#

"*$

#" "*!" A8B8 U0@/V/@;-: U0>2.= O-,W=1;70 C27 D2E0 +8 BF-::2F -0@B;G-00= 68 BF-::2FH 4-1=I J2I8DB***((*K)*$H L?20C/@=01/-:L

"!*

## J=1BT=0@ <>>2;01 X/I1275 "!%

#$ )K")K!* =K.-/: I=7/=I N=1F==0 D2E0BF-::2FH W/>E-7@ W-F:= -0@ D=7=.5D2E0I20H 4-1=I J2I8 B?6**$!'K$!(

"#$

#% !*K'K!* =K.-/: 12 W/>E-7@ W-F:=C72. D=7=.5 D2E0I20H 4-1=I J28B?6**$"&

"$*

#& !*K!!K!* =K.-/: 12 W/>E-7@ W-F:=C72. D2E0 BF-::2FH 4-1=I J28B?6**$#*

"$!

#' !"K!*K!* =K.-/: I=7/=I N=1F==0D2E0 BF-::2FH W/>E-7@ W-F:=H 475>=Y-50= -0@ ?271 Q-:R=7H 4-1=I J28B?6**%&'

"$!

Page 169: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 169/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

$ & ' ( ) ( * + ,-./01/2345

678)$9   :$+-9(;*(<6 ;=>$

#( #B$B!! 5;99;< 9, C?8-4<D C435;E<,F G?55?4F H1 C,9-:4<D= I49;JK,1 2>L**%))

"%!

#) M<4.J8<?N9 ,E 23455,3OP<?JNQ P<;F;L;;9?.R

"%$

$* %B"B!" 5;99;< 9, C?8-4<D C435;E<,F +,-. 23455,3= I49;J K,J1+2****&)B'*

"'&

$! !"B%B!" S;854<49?,. ,E C?8-4<DC435;= I49;J K,1 2>L*%!)&B%!))

"("

$" L,@.94?. TF;<?84 ><;D?9 U.?,.

2949;F;.9J ,E T88,@.9 ,E +,-. 0123455,3 4.D 2@V4..; L1 23455,3=I49;J K,J1 +2***%!)= %"$= %"&=%#&= %$#= %$%= %%#= %&*= %&"= &**=&*%= &*(= &!)= &"$= &"'=W>,.E?D;.9?45W

"('

$# #B)B!" "*!" 2949; >,.J9?9@9?,.457EE?8; S;854<49?,. ,E >4.D?D48Q4.D <;549;D E,<FJ

")"

$$ #B)B!" "*!" 2949; >,.J9?9@9?,.45

7EE?8; S;854<49?,. ,E >4.D?D48Q4.D <;549;D E,<FJ

#*(

$% !B!"B!# ;BF4?5 9, F@59?N5; N;,N5;E<,F +,-. 23455,3= I49;J K,12>L*!$#)B!$$!

#"%

(6?<98=*(<6 9$@7$+*$:

 X4R; "%'OA?.; #Y 2;8,.D 9<4.J8<?N9 ,E P<?JNQ P<;F;

  F;;9?.R

Page 170: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 170/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

$ & ' ( ) ) * + , - .

BC0 DEF07GHIJC0HK L; 4<; .,3 ,. 9-;

<;8,<M1 B-; 9?N; ?O 4PP<,Q?N49;5R !K#' P1N1

B-?O ?O D,5@N; EE ?. 9-; M;P,O?9?,. ,S

+,-. 23455,3= E. H;K B-; 2P;8?45 E.T;O9?U49?,. ,S

I99,<.;R G;.;<45 +,-. 23455,3= :;?.U -;5M 49 9-;

,SS?8;O ,S 2.;55 V L?5N;< ?. 2459 A4W; >?9R= X94-= ,.

789,:;< "%= "*!#1

YR .4N; ?O HR4. H;T;<N4.= >;<9?S?;M A;U45

D?M;,U<4P-;<= 3?9- 9-; S?<N ,S >?9?>,@<91 B-; 8,@<9

<;P,<9;< ?O F;.?O; B-,N4O= 45O, 3?9- 9-; S?<N ,S

>?9?>,@<91

>,@.O;5 3?55 .,3 O949; 9-;?< 4PP;4<4.8;O

S,< 9-; <;8,<M 4.M 9-; 3?9.;OO 3?55 :; O3,<.1

YH1 AIAAEK Y499 A455? 4.M 29;34<9 J;4R

<;P<;O;.9?.U 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 G,T;<.,<1

YH1 2Z7LK H,M 2.,3 4.M +;..?S;< +4N;O S,<

9-; I99,<.;R G;.;<451

/'0, )1 .2344'2=

  -4T?.U :;;. S?<O9 M@5R O3,<. 9, 9;55 9-;

9<@9-= 34O ;Q4N?.;M 4.M 9;O9?S?;M 4O S,55,3OK

Page 171: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 171/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

#$%&'(%)'*(

+, &./ 0%00'1

B1 7.; 9-?.C D E?E.F9 4GH I,@ 54G9 3;;H 3-;.

3; J;9 34G 3-;9-;< I,@ -4K; G,8?45 J;E?4 488,@.9GL

M1 D E,.F9 9-?.H D -4K; 9-;J 4.I 5,.C;<1 D

-4E 4 84JN4?C. 488,@.9 4.E 4 N;<G,.45 488,@.9= 4.E D

:;5?;K; 9-;IFK; :,9- :;;. 85,G;E E,3.1

B1 M.E 3-?8- G,8?45 J;E?4 3;<; 9-;IL

M1 O48;:,,H1

B1 P,9- O48;:,,H 488,@.9GL

Q, I,@ <;8455 9-; 4NN<,R?J49; :;C?..?.C

4.E ;.E E49;G ,S 9-; 488,@.9GL

M1 T-; 84JN4?C. N4C; 3,@5E -4K; :;;. ?. 5?.;

3?9- 3-;. 9-; 84JN4?C. G94<9;E1 D 9-?.H 9-49 3,@5E

:; 9-; 549; S455 ,S "*!!= :@9 D 8,@5E.F9 :; G@<;1 D

E,.F9 <;84551 T-; N;<G,.45 ,.; D 9-?.H G94<9;E

:;S,<; 9-;.1 DFJ .,9 G@<; -,3 S4< :48H ?9 3;.91

B1 M.E 3-;. E?E ?9 ;.EL

M1 D H.,3 9-49 JI E4@C-9;<= >49-;<?.;= 85,G;E

E,3. ,.;= ?S .,9 :,9-= ,S JI G,8?45 488,@.9G 3?9-?.

9-; 54G9 J,.9- ,< G,= ,< 93, J,.9-G1

B1 294<9?.C 3?9- 9-; 84JN4?C. O48;:,,H

488,@.9= 84. I,@ E;G8<?:; -,3 I,@ ,< ,9-;<G @G;E

9-49L

M1 U,G95I VV 45J,G9 ;R85@G?K;5I ?9 34G E,.;

Page 172: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 172/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4.B C4.4D;B :E CE 84CF4?D.1

G1 H55 <?D-91 H.B B?B E,@ I,5?8?9= <;IF,.B

9, 8,CC;.9I= ,< B?B 9-;E I,5?8?9 ,< <;IF,.B 9,

8,CC;.9I 9-<,@D- J48;:,,KL

H1 M<?C4<?5E 9-;E 3,@5B <;IF,.B 9, 8,CC;.9I

,. J48;:,,K= 4.B 9-;E 3;<; F<?C4<?5E= 4I N <;8455=

84CF4?D. ,<?;.9;B= 4.B 9-; 34E ?9 3,<K;B 34I 9-49 OO

3;55= NP55 Q@I9 4.I3;< E,@< R@;I9?,.1

G1 S;55= 9-49PI K?.B ,T 3-49 N 34.9 9, K.,3

?I -,3 B?B ?9 3,<KL U,3 34I ?9 @I;BL

H1 S;55= N :;5?;V; 9-49 3; 3,@5B F,I9

?CF,<94.9 ?II@;I ,< ;V;.9I ,. 9-; J48;:,,K 488,@.9=

4.B 9-;. 3-;. 9-;<; 3;<; 8,CC;.9I= 9-; 84CF4?D. I94TT

3,@5B D;.;<455E <;IF,.B 9, 9-,I; 8,CC;.9I= 4.B ?T

9-;<; 34I 4 F;<I,.45 .,9;= ?T 4 T<?;.B T<,C 8,55;D;

,< I,C;,.; N -4B K.,3. ?. 9-; F4I9 3<,9; ?. ,<

I,C;,.; T<,C F,5?9?8I 3<,9; ?. 9-49 -4B 4 F4<9?8@54<

R@;I9?,.= NPB :; T;B 9-49 R@;I9?,. 4.B 9-;. 3,@5B

;?9-;< 8455 9-49 F;<I,. ,< D?V; 4 C,<; F;<I,.45

<;IF,.I;1

G1 W?B E,@ IF;.B 9?C; F;<I,.455E <;4B?.D 9-;

J48;:,,K F4D; T,< 9-; 84CF4?D.L

H1 X,1

G1 H.B B?B E,@ IF;.B OO

H1 S-;. E,@ I4E 9-49= 9-49PI F<;99E

Page 173: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 173/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

849;B,<?845= :@9 .,<C455D= .,1

E1 7F4D1 G-;<; C4D -4H; :;;. 4 <4.I,C

,884J?,. 3-;<; D,@ I?I= :@9 .,9 4 5,9K

L1 M?B-91

E1 L.I J4C; 4.J3;< 3?9- <;JN;89 9, 489@455D

J?99?.B 49 4 8,CN@9;< 9;<C?.45 4.I 9DN?.B ?.

<;JN,.J;JK

L1 24C; 4.J3;<1

E1 7F4D1 A;9OJ 945F 4:,@9 D,@< N;<J,.45

P48;:,,F 488,@.91

>4. D,@ I;J8<?:; -,3 D,@ @J;I 9-49K

L1 Q9 34J I,.; N<;99D C@8- 9-; J4C; 34D1 Q.

,9-;< 3,<IJ= Q I?I.O9 JN;.I C@8- 9?C; 49 455 ,.

P48;:,,F1 QOC .,9 H;<D 8,.H;<J4.9 3?9- P48;:,,F1

E1 R,@ 4.I C; :,9-1

L1 Q -49; 9, 4IC?9 @.I;< ,49-= :@9 9-49OJ 9-;

9<@9-1

E1 S;55= Q I,.O9 ;H;. -4H; 4.I .;H;< -4H; -4I

4 P48;:,,F 488,@.9= J, ., 4N,5,BD .;8;JJ4<D T,< C;1

S-49 4:,@9 4.D ,9-;< J,8?45 C;I?4=

A?.F;IQ. ,< G3?99;< ,< 4.D9-?.B 5?F; 9-49K

L1 Q :;5?;H; Q -4H; 4 G3?99;< 488,@.91 Q

-4H;.O9 @J;I ?9 J?.8; QOH; :;;. L99,<.;D U;.;<45= 4.I

9,34<IJ 9-; ;.I ,T 9-; 84CN4?B. 9-;D 3;<; 9<D?.B 9,

B;9 C; 9, G3;;9 9-?.BJ ,@9 4 5?995; C,<; T<;V@;.95D=

Page 174: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 174/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

:@9 B .;C;< -4C; DD -4C; .,9 4E,F9;E ?91

G1 B 9-?.H I,@ .;;E 9, :; ?. 4 E?JJ;<;.9

K;.;<49?,.1

L-;. 3; :<,H; ,JJ 54M9 9?N;= B 34M 4MH?.K

I,@ M,N; O@;M9?,.M 4:,@9 PD2,5@9?,.M= 4.E M, BQE 5?H;

9, F?8H @F 9-;<;1

R,55,3?.K @F ,. 4 F,?.9 I,@ N4E; 4:,@9 9-;

3,<H I,@ E?E J,< >-4F4<<45 34M .,9 +,-. 23455,3

?.E?C?E@455I :@9 +,-. 23455,3 489?.K J,< PD2,5@9?,.M1

S?E B @.E;<M94.E 9-49 488@<49;5IT

U1 V?K-91 W-49 34M 9-; ?.9;.9= 9, E, 9-49

9-<,@K- PD2,5@9?,.M1

G1 U.E 4M B @.E;<M94.E ?9= 9-; 8,.M@59?.K

M;<C?8;M 9-49 3;<; F;<J,<N;E J,< >-4F4<<45 3;<; :I

I,@ 4.E I,@ 45,.;= 8,<<;89T

U1 L;55= 3-;. I,@ M4I >-4F4<<45= B E,.Q9 H.,3

?J I,@ X@M9 N;4. >-4F4<<45 ,< I,@ N;4. V?8-4<E V435;1

G1 B N;4. 3?9- <;MF;89 9, 9-; 8;N;.9 F<,X;89

?. Y;C4E4 J,< 3-?8- I,@ <;8;?C;E DD ,< J,< 3-?8- I,@<

M;<C?8;M K4<.;<;E Z"#=%**1

U1 V?K-91

G1 U.E B :;5?;C; I,@ 9,5E N; 9-49 I,@ 3;<;

9-; ,.5I F;<M,. 3-, F;<J,<N;E M;<C?8;M J,<

PD2,5@9?,.M 9, ;4<. 9-49 N,.;I1

U1 W-49 ?M 8,<<;891

Page 175: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 175/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C.D 9-;<; 34E ., ,.; ;5E; FF 9-;<; 3;<; .,

,9-;< ;GH5,I;;E ,< 8,[email protected] ,< 4DJ?E,<E 9,

KF2,5@9?,.E ,9-;< 9-4. I,@<E;5L1

C1 M-49 ?E 8,<<;891

B1 N?D I,@ -4J; E,G; E,<9 ,L 4<<4.O;G;.9 3?9-

KF2,5@9?,.E 4:,@9 I,@ H<,J?D?.O E;<J?8;EP N?D I,@

O;9 4 L;;P Q4E 9-;<; 9;<GE 9, I,@< <;549?,.E-?H=

4.I9-?.O 5?R; 9-49P

C1 M-;<; 34E .,9-?.O L,<G451

B1 7.; ,L 9-; 9-?.OE I,@ D?D 34E 4.45,O?S; 9,

G; D,?.O 3,<R L,< 2.;55 T Q?5G;<= 4.D ,L 8,@<E; U D,

3,<R 9-<,@O- 2.;55 T Q?5G;<= :@9 U O;9 H4?D= 4.D= I,@

R.,3= 9-;<; 4<; 9;<GE 9, 9-49 4<<4.O;G;.91

C.I9-?.O 5?R; 9-49 9-49 I,@ -4D 3?9-

KF2,5@9?,.EP

C1 V,1

B1 Q-I D?D I,@ 4EE?O. FF 3;55= 5;9 G; 4ER

9-?E 4.D .,9 4EE@G;1

N?D I,@ 4EE?O. 9-; ?.8,G; O;.;<49;D L<,G

I,@< H;<E,.45 E;<J?8;E 9, KF2,5@9?,.EP

C1 V,9 ?. 4 L,<G45 4EE?O.G;.9 4E I,@ E4?D=

.,9 4 3<?99;. 4EE?O.G;.91

B1 7R4I1 Q;55= UWG 4.45,O?S?.O 9, 3-49 I,@

9,5D G; 4:,@9 +4E,. K,3;<E= 4.D I,@ E4?D 9-49 I,@ -4D

H;<L,<G;D E,G; H;<E,.45 8,.E@59?.O E;<J?8;E L,< -?G

Page 176: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 176/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

:;B,<; C,@ 3;.9 9, 3,<D 49 9-; E99,<.;C F;.;<45GH

,BB?8; 4.I 9-;. C,@ H@:H;J@;.95C 4HH?K.;I 9-49 9,

LM2,5@9?,.H1

E1 N?K-91

O1 P?I C,@ I, 9-; H4Q; 9-?.K 3?9- <;HR;89 9,

9-; R;<H,.45 H;<S?8;H C,@ R;<B,<Q;I B,< 9-; 8;Q;.9

R<,T;89U

E1 V;55= ?9 34H QC ?.9;.9?,. 455 45,.K 9, :;

I,?.K 455 9-; 3,<D B,< LM2,5@9?,.H 9-<,@K-

LM2,5@9?,.H 4.I 9, -4S; LM2,5@9?,.H <;8;?S; ?.8,Q;

B,< 9-49= 4.I W I,.G9 D.,3 ?B 9-49GH 4 5;K45

I;H8<?R9?,. ,B -,3 4. 4HH?K.Q;.9 3,@5I 3,<D1

WGQ .,9 H@<; 9-49 ?9 B?9H ?. 9-;

I;B?.?9?,. ,B 4HH?K.Q;.9= :@9 8;<94?.5C ?9 34H QC

?.9;.9 9, -4S; 455 ,B 9-; ?.8,Q; 9-49 34H ;4<.;I

9-<,@K- QC 3,<D ,. 9-; 8;Q;.9 R<,T;89 K, 9, 9-;

:;.;B?9 ,B QC B4Q?5C 4.I LM2,5@9?,.H 9-<,@K- ?9H

,3.;<H-?R :C 9-; 9<@H9 9-49 :;5,.K;I 9, QC B4Q?5C1

X-49 34H QC ?.9;.9?,. 455 45,.K1

O1 E.I 34H 9-49 I?BB;<;.9 MM 4.I 9-?H Q4C

H,@.I B48;9?,@H= :@9 3-;. W I, 3,<D B,<

2.;55 Y V?5Q;<= 4:,@9 )) R;<8;.9 ,B 3-49 W ;4<. K,;H

9, 9-; :;.;B?9 ,B QC B4Q?5C1

V4H 9-;<; H,Q; I?BB;<;.8; :;93;;. 9-?H

3,<D C,@ 3;<; I,?.K B,< LM2,5@9?,.H 4H ,RR,H;I 9, 9-;

Page 177: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 177/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

3,<B C,@ 3;<; D,?.E F,< 9-; :;.;F?9= ,<= ;G8@H; I;=

F,< 9-; J99,<.;C K;.;<45 ?. 9;<IH ,F LL

J1 M;55= IC @.D;<H94.D?.E 34H ?9 34H N;<C

H?E.?F?84.91 O-49PH 3-;. Q I;9 3?9- IC 94G 499,<.;C

4.D H;9 @R IC 9<@H9= IC F4I?5CPH 9<@H91 Q 34H 9-;

9<@H9,< ,F 9-49 9<@H91 O-; 3-,5; R,?.9 34H 9, D,.49;

9-; ,RR,<9@.?9C 9, 4. ;.9?9C ,3.;D :C 9-; 9<@H9 H,

9-49 Q 3,@5D .,9 -4N; 4.C 5;E45 <?E-9 9, 4.C ,F 9-;

R<,8;;DH ,F 9-49 3,<B= 4.D QPN; :;;. 9,5D= 4.D ?F

C,@PN; 945B;D 9, 4. ;H949; ,< 4 94G 499,<.;C C,@

R<,:4:5C @.D;<H94.D 9-?H= 9-49 9-49 ?H N;<C 5;E45 4.D

?9PH N;<C 8,II,. ?. 9-49 9CR; ,F 4. ?.H9<@I;.9= 4.D

9-49 ?H 9-; :4H?H F,< IC F,<I?.E 9-49 9CR; ,F 4.

?.H9<@I;.9 4.D D,?.E 9-; 3,<B 9-49 34C1 O-49 34H 9-;

3-,5; R54. F,< 9-49= 4.D 9-49 34H 5,.E :;F,<; Q

D;8?D;D 9, <@. F,< R,5?9?845 ,FF?8;1

S1 M-;. D?D C,@ D;8?D; 9, <@. F,<

J99,<.;C K;.;<45T

J1 M;55= Q 9-?.B LL Q I;4.= 9-49PH 4 N;<C

9,@E- U@;H9?,.1 QPN; :;;. 4HB;D 9-49 U@;H9?,.

:;F,<;= 4.D Q D,.P9 9-?.B 9-;<; 34H 4. ;G489 I,I;.9

3-;. IC 3?F; 4.D Q 5,,B;D 49 ;48- ,9-;< 3-;. 3; H4?D

3;P<; ?.1 Q9 34H I,<; ,F 4 E<4D@45 R<,8;HH= :@9 3;

:;84I; N;<C H;<?,@H ,F ?9 ?. 9-; H@II;< ,F "*!!= 4.D

Q F?5;D IC 84IR4?E. ,<E4.?V49?,. D,8@I;.9H ?. 9-;

Page 178: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 178/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B455 ,B "*!!= :@9 C -4D 945E;D 4:,@9 9-; F,GG?:?5?9H

4.D 9-; 5?E;5?-,,D ,B ?9 B,< I4.H= I4.H I,.9-G :;B,<;

9-;.1

J1 K, H,@ <;8455 3?9- 3-,I H,@ GF,E; 9, 3-;.

H,@ 945E;D 4:,@9 ?9 B,< 9-; I4.H I,.9-G :;B,<;L

M1 N;55= H,@ -4O; 9, PP D, C <;8455L Q,= .,9

GF;8?B?8455H1

J1 R,< ;S4IF5;= D?D H,@ 945E 9, +4G,. T,3;<G

4:,@9 <@..?.U B,< M99,<.;H V;.;<45 PP

M1 2@<;1

J1 PP 9-; F,GG?:?5?9H ,B ?9L

M1 2@<;1

J1 M.D 84. H,@ 4FF<,S?I49; 3-;. 9-,G;

8,.O;<G49?,.G B?<G9 :;U4.L

M1 C9 3,@5D -4O; -4FF;.;D PP C I;4.= C 84.W9

F@9 IH B?.U;< ,. 3-;. ;S4895H 9-49 3,@5D -4O;

-4FF;.;D= :@9 PP

J1 A;9 I; 9<H 4.D U?O; H,@ G,I; PP

M1 CWI .,9 9<H?.U 9, :; ;O4G?O;1 CWI 9<H?.U

9, :; <;GF,.G?O; 9, H,@< X@;G9?,.1

J1 C F;<B;895H @.D;<G94.D 9-49 H,@ I4H .,9

<;I;I:;<= G, 5;9 I; 9<H 4.D U?O; H,@ 4 I?5;G9,.; 9,

9<H 9, U4@U; ?91

>4. H,@ G4H 3-;9-;< H,@ :;U4. 8,.G?D;<?.U

4 <@. B,< M99,<.;H V;.;<45 F<?,< 9, 9-; 9?I; H,@ 3;.9

Page 179: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 179/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9, 3,<B 4C >-?;D E;F@9G ?. E;8;H:;< ,D "**)I

J1 K B.;3 9-49 ?9 3,@5L :; 4 F,CC?:?5?9G ?D

?9MC C,H;9-?.N 9-49 KML 5?B; 9, L,= 4.L K 34.9;L 9,

489@455G 3,<B ?. 9-; ,DD?8; :;D,<; K N4O; ?9 <;45

C;<?,@C 9-,@N-9 :;84@C; K L?L.M9 B.,3 ?D K 3,@5L 5?B;

3,<B?.N ?. 9-; J99,<.;G P;.;<45MC ,DD?8;1 K L?L.M9

B.,3 ?D KML 5?B; 9, :; J99,<.;G P;.;<45= :@9 K B.;3

?9 34C 4 F,CC?:?5?9G1

Q1 K B.,3 G,@ -4L :;;. ?.O,5O;L F,5?9?8455G

F<?,< 9, 9-; 9?H; 9-49 G,@ 3;.9 9, 9-; J99,<.;G

P;.;<45MC ,DD?8;1

R-;. G,@ 3;.9 9, 9-; J99,<.;G P;.;<45MC

,DD?8;= L?L G,@ C9?55 H4?.94?. F,5?9?845 4CF?<49?,.CI

J1 2@<;1 S;C1

Q1 R-;. 3; CF,B; 54C9= G,@ H;.9?,.;L 9-49 G,@

-4L :;;. ?. 8,HH@.?849?,. 3?9- A;; T8>@55,@N-I

J1 S;C1

Q1 E?L G,@ L?C8@CC 3?9- -?H 9-; 3?9.;CC

C949;H;.9 9-49 3; -4L 4CB;L -?H 9, C?N.I

J1 S;C1

Q1 E?L G,@ <;O?;3 4 8,FG ,D 9-49 3?9.;CC

C949;H;.9I

J1 K :;5?;O; K L?L1

Q1 E?L G,@ H4B; C@NN;C9?,.C 4:,@9 9-?.NC 9,

4LL ,< L;5;9;I

Page 180: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 180/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C,@ D.,3= E,F9 ,G 9-,F; H?F8@FF?,.F 3;<;

?. 9-; I<;F;.8; ,G EJ ,9-;< 499,<.;JF -;<;=

+;..?G;< +4E;F1 K-49 L <;8455 F4J?.M 9, -?E 34F J,@

9;55 9-; 9<@9- 4.H J,@ 9;55 9-?.MF 9-; 34J J,@

<;E;E:;< 9-;E= 4.H L H,.N9 34.9 9, I@9 3,<HF ?. J,@<

E,@9-1 O-,F; 4<; 9-; 9JI;F ,G 9-?.MF L F4?H 9, -?E1

P1 LNE 8,.8;<.;H I4<9?8@54<5J 4:,@9 4HH?.M ,<

H;5;9?.M 9-?.MF G<,E 9-; F@EE4<J ,G 9-; 3?9.;FF

F949;E;.9 9-49 3; I<;I4<;H1

Q?H J,@ H, 9-49 FI;8?G?8455JR

B1 L H,.N9 <;8455 H,?.M 9-49 FI;8?G?8455J1

P1 S4T; J,@ :;;. ?.T,5T;H ?. ?.T;F9?M49?,.F

F?E?54< 9, 9-?F 3?9- 9-; B99,<.;J U;.;<45NF ,GG?8;R

B1 V,= L -4T;.N91

P1 B<; J,@ 434<; ,G 9-,F; -4T?.M :;;.

8,.H@89;HR

B1 W2?E?54< 9, 9-?F=W 3-49 H, J,@ E;4. :J

9-49R

P1 K;55= 3-;<; 9-; B99,<.;J U;.;<45 ?F

?.T;F9?M49?.M F,E; I4<9J ,< I4<9?;FR

B1 V,= 489@455J= L -4T;.N91

P1 LF 9-49 F,E;9-?.M 9-49 ,88@<F ?. 9-;

B99,<.;J U;.;<45NF ,GG?8;R

B1 Q, 3; -4T; ?.T;F9?M49,<F ?. 9-;

B99,<.;J U;.;<45NF ,GG?8;R LF 9-49 J,@< X@;F9?,.R

Page 181: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 181/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

B1 2@<;1

C1 D;E= 3; F,1

B1 G,;E H,@< ,II?8; 8,.F@89 ?.J;E9?K49?,.EL

C1 7@< ,II?8; F,;E 8,.F@89 ?.J;E9?K49?,.E1

B1 C.F F, H,@ F, 9-49 M<?,< 9, :<?.K?.K

;?9-;< 8?J?5 ,< 8<?N?.45 ;.I,<8;N;.9 M<,8;;F?.KEL

C1 O;55= 5;9 N; P@E9 E4H 9-?EQ R 34E 9-;

F?J?E?,. 8-?;I ,J;< 9-; 8?J?5 F?J?E?,.E= 4.F ?. 9-;

8?J?5 F?J?E?,.E 3; F?F.S9 8,.F@89 ?.J;E9?K49?,.E1

T-;<; 34E 4 J;<H :<?K-9 5?.; :;93;;. 9-; 8<?N?.45

?.J;E9?K49?,.E F?J?E?,.E 4.F 9-; 8?J?5 E?F; ,I 9-;

,II?8; 3-;<; R 34E ?.J,5J;F= 4.F E, R 84.S9 EM;4U

3?9- 4 5,9 ,I 4@9-,<?9H ?. 9;<NE ,I -,3 4.F 3-49 3;

F, 4E 4. ,II?8; 3-;. 3; :<?.K 4. ?.J;E9?K49?,. 4.F

3-;. 3; I?5; 8-4<K;E 4K4?.E9 E,N;,.;1

B1 C.F H,@ -4J;.S9 5;4<.;F 9-49 ?. H,@<

E;J;<45 N,.9-E 4E 9-; C99,<.;H V;.;<45L

C1 R -4J;.S9 :;;. EM;8?I?8455H ?.J,5J;F ?.

J;<H N4.H ,I 9-,E; 9HM;E ,I 9-?.KE E?.8; RSJ; :;;.

?.J,5J;F= :@9 R -4J; :;;. ?.J,5J;F 9, 4 J;<H 5?N?9;F

;W9;.91

B1 7U4H1 O;55= 3-;9-;< ?9SE 8<?N?.45 ,<

8?J?5= F, H,@ -4J; U.,35;FK; ,I 3-;9-;< 9-;

C99,<.;H V;.;<45SE ,II?8; 8,.F@89E ?.J;E9?K49?,.E ,I

M;,M5; M<?,< 9, 9-; 9?N; 4 M<,8;;F?.K= 3-;9-;< 8?J?5

Page 182: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 182/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

,< 8<?B?.45= ?C ?.C9?9@9;DE

F1 G;55= HID C4J C,B;9?B;C J;C 4.D C,B;9?B;C

.,= 4.D HIB -4KKJ 9, L?M; J,@ 4. ;N4BK5; ,O 9-491

P1 2@<;1

F1 H. Q94-= 9-; R?M?C?,. ,O S@:5?8 >,BB;<8;

-4C 4 >,.C@B;< S<,9;89?,. R?M?C?,. 3?9-?. ?91 H.

9-49 D?M?C?,. 9-; ?.M;C9?L49,<C 3-, ?.M;C9?L49;

8,.C@B;< 8,BK54?.9C 4.D ?CC@;C 4.D K<;K4<; 84C;C=

9-;J 4<; 455 -,@C;D 3?9-?. 9-; R;K4<9B;.9 ,O

>,BB;<8;= 3-?8- ?C @.D;< 9-; T,M;<.,<IC 4@9-,<?9J 4.D

.,9 @.D;< 9-; F99,<.;J T;.;<45IC 4@9-,<?9J= C, ?.

9-,C; 84C;C ?.M;C9?L49?,. 3?55 :; 8,.D@89;D :J 9-49

?.M;C9?L49?,. 9;4B ,@9C?D; ,O ,@< ,OO?8;= 4.D 9-;.

9-; 84C; 3?55 :; K<;K4<;D 4.D 9-;. :<,@L-9 ?.9, 9-;

F99,<.;J T;.;<45IC ,OO?8;1

2, 3?9-,@9 4.J ,< B@8- O@<9-;<

?.M;C9?L49?,. 4 84C; 3?55 :; O?5;D ?. 9-49

8?<[email protected];1 H :;5?;M; ?9 -4C 9, D, 3?9- C;8@<?9?;C

?CC@;C 4C 3;55= :@9 9-;<; 4<; ,9-;< 4<;4C 3-;<; ,@<

,OO?8; D,;C 9-; 3-,5; ?.M;C9?L49?,. 4.D 9-;. :<?.LC

9-; 8-4<L;C1

P1 R, 9-; ?.M;C9?L49,<C K<;K4<; 3?9.;CC

C949;B;.9CE

F1 H D,.I9 -4M; UU HIB 4CC@B?.L 9-49 9-;J D,=

:@9 J,@I<; 4CV?.L B; O,< BJ 9;C9?B,.J= 4.D C, H D,.I9

Page 183: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 183/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

34.9 9, BC;8@549;1

D1 EF G,@ H,.I9 J.,3 KK

L1 EIM 4BB@M?.N KK EIM 4BB@M?.N 9-49 9-;G

3,@5H 4.H 9-49 9-;G H,1

D1 L.H ?. G,@< O?;3= 3,@5H ?9 :; 4CC<,C<?49;

F,< 9-; 3?9.;BB B949;M;.9B 9, :; O?;3;H 4.H <;O?;3;H

:G 9-; B@:P;89B ,F 9-; ?.O;B9?N49?,. 4.H ;H?9;H 4.H

M,H?F?;HQ

L1 EIM .,9 N,?.N 9, M4J; 4 8,MM;.9 4:,@9 9-49

:;84@B; E H,.I9 34.9 9, BC;8@549; 4:,@9 9-491 E

9-?.J 9-49IB 4. ?BB@; F,< MG 499,<.;G 4.H F,< G,@

M4G:; 9, H?B8@BB1

RS1 2T7UV EF 9-; ?.O;B9?N49,< ?B 945J?.N

9, 9-; B@:P;89IB 499,<.;G= ?9 3,@5H :; C;<F;895G

4CC<,C<?49; F,< 9-49 499,<.;G 9, 8,MM@.?849; 3?9- -?B

85?;.9 4:,@9 ?91

RS1 ALAAEV 7J4G1

RS1 2T7UV W-49IB 4 H?FF;<;.9 B?9@49?,.

9-4. 9-; ;X4MC5; G,@I<; 9<G?.N 9, H<43= ?. MG

P@HNM;.91

D1 YZG R<1 A455?[ 79-;< 9-4. R<1 R8>@55,@N-=

-4O; G,@ <;O?;3;H ,< M4H; 4.G ;FF,<9B 9, 4HH=

B@:9<489 9,= ;H?9 ,< M,H?FG 4.G ,9-;< 3?9.;BB

B949;M;.9B 9-49 3; -4O; C<;C4<;H 4.H 499;MC9;H 9, @B;

?. 9-?B ?.O;B9?N49?,.Q

Page 184: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 184/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC1 2D7EF GH55 ,:I;89 9, 9-49 9, 9-;

;J9;.9 K,@H<; L@MM;L9?.M -; 4NN;N= L@:9<489;N ,<

O,N?P?;N 9-; Q;854<49?,. 9-49 K,@ R<;L;.9;N 9,

A;; B8>@55,@M-1

E-?5; 3;H<; ,. 9-; L@:I;89= 3; 9-,@M-9 9-;

Q;854<49?,. K,@ R<;L;.9;N 9, A;; B8>@55,@M- 34L 4

5?995; 93?L9;N 4.N ,.;SL?N;N1 E; 9-,@M-9 ?9 ,@M-9 9,

:; O,<; :454.8;N= 4L 8,@.L;5 P,< B<1 23455,31 G9HL 4

93, ;NM; SS ?9HL 4 93,S34K L9<;;9= B4991

BC1 ATAAGF E;55= ?9HL .,9 4 93,S34K

L9<;;91 T55 <?M-9U V-; 93,S34K L9<;;9 3,@5N :; P,<

@L 9, .,3 94W; ,@9 4 3?9.;LL L949;O;.9 9-49 34L

O;<;5K 4. 499;OR9 9, P489@455K L@OO4<?X; ,@<

?.9;<Y?;3L 3?9- B8>@55,@M- 4.N .,3 M?Y; ?9 9,

Q4Y?N G<Y?.; 4.N T55;. 2O?9- 4.N 5;9 9-;O <;Y?;3 ?9

4.N 4<M@;= 9-; Y;<K <;4L,. 3; N?N.H9 34.9 K,@

R4<9?8?R49?.M ?. 9-,L; ?.9;<Y?;3L ?. 9-; P?<L9 R548;1

E; N,.H9 34.9 9, 9@<. 9-?L ?.9, 4. 4NY;<L4<?45

R<,8;;N?.M1 V-?L ?L 4. ?.Y;L9?M49?,.1

BC1 2D7EF E;55= 3; -4Y; ,@< SS

BC1 ATAAGF G. ,@< Y?;3= ?9HL ,:L9<@89;N

4.N 8,OR<,O?L;N ,@< ?.Y;L9?M49?,. 9, 9-; R,?.9 3-;<;

3; R<,:4:5K .,3 -4Y; 9, N;R,L; 455 ,P 9-;L; R;,R5;=

4.N 3; 3;<; 9<K?.M .,9 9, N, 9-49 ,@9 ,P ;JR;.L;

8,.8;<.L1

Page 185: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 185/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC1 2D7EF E;55= 9-; ,.5G ;H4IJ5; 3;K<;

945L?.M 4:,@9 -;<; ?N B<1 B8>@55,@M-1

BC1 AOAAPF E;55= 9-;<;Q,<; RR

BC1 2D7EF S; 489;T 4N -?N 499,<.;G RR

U1 VWG B<1 A455?X Y-;<;Q,<;= IG Z@;N9?,.

?N RR

BC1 2D7EF O.T -; 8,.9489;T @N= :G 9-;

34G1 S; -4T N,I; 8,.8;<.N 4:,@9 3-49 G,@ T<4Q9;T= N,

P T,.K9 9-?.L -; [?;3;T ?9 4N :;?.M ;H4895G 3-49 -;

-4T 9,5T G,@= :@9 9-49KN 4. ?NN@; Q,< 4.,9-;< T4G1

PQ G,@ 34.9 9, T;J,N; -?I= 9-49KN Q?.;1

BC1 AOAAPF E;K[; :;;. :48L 4.T Q,<9- 3?9-

B<1 B8>@55,@M- <;J;49;T5G ?. 4. ;QQ,<9 9, M;9 -?N

9;N9?I,.G 8,<<;89= 4.T 3; -4[; .;[;< ?.-?:?9;T -?I ,<

N@MM;N9;T 9-49 -; .,9 4TT ,< N@:9<489 9, 3-49 3;

3<,9;1 Y, 9-; 8,.9<4<G1 E-49 3; T, ,:\;89 9, ?N

B<1 23455,3 4.T G,@ 4TT?.M 9, 4.T N@:9<489?.M 9, 9-49

3?9.;NN N949;I;.91

BC1 2D7EF Y, I4L; ?9 9<@9-Q@5 4.T 8,<<;89

4.T 8,IJ5;9;= G,@ ,:\;89 9, 9-49]

BC1 AOAAPF E;55= P ,:\;89 9, 9-; 4T[,848G

9-49KN 8,.94?.;T ?. 9-; ^;854<49?,.1

BC1 2D7EF E;55= PKI 4<M@?.M 3?9- G,@ 4N

4. 4T[,848G1

BC1 AOAAPF E;K<; .,9 4T[,849;N1

Page 186: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 186/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC1 2D7EF E;55= G,@ H4G .,9 :;= :@9 3;

9-,@I-9 9-; J;854<49?,. ?K 4. 4LM,848G1

BC1 ANAAOF 7P4G1

BC1 2D7EF E; ,.5G 34.9;L 9-; K949;H;.9 9,

:; 488@<49; 4.L 9<@9-Q@51

BC1 ANAAOF N55 <?I-91

BC1 2D7EF N.L B<1 23455,3= Q<4.P5G= 34K

.,9 ?.M,5M;L ?. 9-,K; L?K8@KK?,.K1 O 9-?.P

B<1 B8>@55,@I- 34K R;<Q;895G 3?9-?. -?K <?I-9K 9,

8,.9489 @K 4:,@9 9-; J;854<49?,.1

ST0 EOSD022F 2, 3?9- 9-; @.L;<K94.L?.I UU

BC1 2D7EF OK 9-;<; 4 V@;K9?,. R;.L?.IW

BC1 X0NYF Y;K1

BC1 ANAAOF Y;4-= 9-;<; ?K1

BC1 2D7EF OZH K,<<G1 O 5,K9 ?91

ST0 EOSD022F O <;H;H:;< 9-; V@;K9?,.= :@9

O -4L 9-; K4H; 8,.8;<.K HG 8,@.K;5 ;[R<;KK;L= :@9 O

3?55 K4G 9-?KF O -4M;.Z9 K;;. ,< L?K8@KK;L 4.G ,9-;<

3?9.;KK K949;H;.9K Q<,H 4.G,.; 9-49 G,@ZM;

?.9;<M?;3;L :;K?L;K UU

BC1 2D7EF E-, -4M; G,@ ?.9;<M?;3;LW

ST0 EOSD022F X4<L,. H;W \@9 O :;5?;M; O

34K ,< G,@ 3;<; 8,.9489;L :G B<1 B8>@55,@I- 3?9- K,H;

8,.8;<.K1

BC1 2D7EF S-49ZK HG H;H,<G1

Page 187: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 187/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 CDE F<1 A455?G H.I I?I F<1 F8>@55,@J-

9;55 E,@ 9-49 3; 3;<; 499;KL9?.J 9, 5?K?9 -?M

9;M9?K,.E ?. 4.E 34EN

H1 O I,.P9 <;8455= :@9 O I, <;8455 -?K= O

9-?.Q= M4E?.J -; I<4R9;I ?9 SS

B1 7Q4E1

H1 SS 4.I -; -4I 8,.8;<.M 4:,@9 9-; 8,.9;.91

B1 7Q4E1 T,@ K4I; 4 L,?.9 54M9 9?K; 3; K;9

,R M4E?.J 9-49 E,@< ?.9;.9?,. 34M 9, 3?9-I<43 4M

K4.4J;< ,R US2,5@9?,.M= 22V F4.4J;K;.9 4.I OSH34<;

L<?,< 9, F4<8- !%= "*!"= 9-49 ?M <;R5;89;I ?. 9-;

<;8,<IM 9-49 3; M-,3;I E,@ 4M ;W-?:?9M1

X, E,@ <;8455 9-49N

H1 H89@455E= O <;8455 M,K;9-?.J 4 5?995;

I?RR;<;.9 R<,K 9-491

B1 Y-49 I, E,@ <;8455N

H1 O 9-,@J-9 O <;8455;I 9-49 ,. F4<8- )9-

3-;. O I?M8@MM;I 9-; ?MM@;M 3?9- F<1 F8>@55,@J-

:;R,<; O R?55;I ,@9 9-; R,<KM= 4R9;< -; J4Z; K; 9-;

4IZ?8; -; J4Z; K;= O 9,5I -?K O 34M J,?.J 9, :;

<;M?J.?.J 49 9-49 L,?.9 4.I 9-49 O I;;K;I ?9

;RR;89?Z; @L,. KE 8,KK@.?849?,. ,R 9-49 9, -?K1 O

:;5?;Z; 9-49 34M KE 9;M9?K,.E1

B1 7Q4E1 Y-E 34M 9-; 9?K?.J ,R 9-;

3?9-I<4345 ?KL,<94.9 9, E,@N

Page 188: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 188/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

B1 C;55= D 8;<94?.5E F?F.G9 34.9 9,

H?I<;J<;I;.9 ,. 9-; K,<HI 3-49 D 34I 3<?9?.L F,3. ,.

9-; K,<HI= :;84@I; D -4F 9, I?L. I,H;9-?.L 9-49 I4?F

9-?I ?I 9<@; 4.F 488@<49; 9, 9-; :;I9 ,K HE

@.F;<I94.F?.L 4.F :;5?;K= I,H;9-?.L 5?M; 9-49= 4.F I,

D 34.9;F 9, H4M; I@<; ?K D 34I .,9 48M.,35;FL?.L 9-;

J,I?9?,.= 9-49 D ., 5,.L;< -;5F 9-; J,I?9?,. ,@9 ,K

?.9;L<?9E1

N1 7M4E1 B.F D :;5?;O; E,@ 9,5F H; 9-49 E,@

-4F 9-; H;;9?.L 3?9- P<1 P8>@55,@L-= E,@ :;5?;O; ?9

34I ,. P4<8- ( ,< )= "*!"Q ?I 9-49 <?L-9R

B1 S,@ M.,3= DGO; TT <?L-9= P4<8- ( ,< )= :@9

?9 34I J<,:4:5E H,<; 5?M;5E ,. P4<8- )9-1

N1 7M4E1 B.F F?F E,@ H;;9 3?9-

P<1 P8>@55,@L- H,<; 9-4. ,.8;R

B1 C;55= D IJ,M; 3?9- -?H ,. 9-; J-,.; ,.

P4<8- )9-= 4.F D :;5?;O; D H;9 3?9- -?H J;<I,.455E

:;93;;. P4<8- )9- 4.F P4<8- !%9-= :@9 ?9 34I 4 O;<E

:@IE 9?H; K,< H; 4I 9-; 84HJ4?L. 34I U@I9 L;99?.L

I94<9;F= 4.F ?9GI -4<F K,< H; 9, <;8455 ;V4895E 3-;.

D H;9 3?9- -?H= :@9 DGH 8,.K?F;.9 ?9 34I :;K,<; 9-;

!%9- 3-;. D H;9 3?9- -?H ?. J;<I,.1

N1 7M4E1 C;G55 8,H; :48M 9, 9-49 ?. 4

H?.@9;1

PW1 ABAADX C-;<; F?F 3; 5;4O; ,KKR

Page 189: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 189/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC0 >7DEB E0F7EB0EG B3;.9HI.?.;1 J;K55

L94<9 ,. ")1

ME1 ANAAOG 294<9 ,. ")1

$%&'()(* ,# -./ 0.12%345 

P1 QRH M<1 A455?S 0T-?:?9 ") ?L :4.U 488,@.9

L949;V;.9L W<,V 9-; +,-. 4.X 2@Y;99; 23455,3 Z,?.9

:4.U 488,@.9 W,< [;<?,XL ?. "*!"= 4.X O 3,@5X 5?U; 9,

X?<;89 H,@< 499;.9?,.= ?W O 8,@5X= 9, R49;L [4\; &#)=

4.X X<43?.\ H,@< 499;.9?,. 9, 9-; ;.9<H ,. M4H !L9=

4:,@9 -45W34H II V4H:; 4 5?995; V,<; 9-4. -45W34H

X,3. 9-; [4\; 9-;<;KL 4 8-4<\; 9, J45V4<9 W,< ])(1&(1

^, H,@ L;; 9-49_

N1 O X,.K9 L;; 9-491 NLL@V?.\ H,@K<; ,.

[4\; &#)= R49;L L94V[ &#)_

P1 `;L1

N1 7U4H1 7-= H;L= O X, L;; 9-491 `;L1

P1 B-?L 3,@5X -4a; :;;. 9-; X4H 4W9;< H,@

L[,U; 3?9- +;<;VH +,-.L,. 49 9-; b<?L[H b<;V; L-,[=

8,<<;89_

N1 J;55= H,@ 9,5X V; 54L9 9?V; 9-49 O V;9

3?9- -?V ,. N[<?5 #*9-= L, 94U?.\ 9-49 4L 9-; X49;=

9-;. M4H !L9 3,@5X -4a; :;;. 9-; .;T9 X4H1

P1 OKV \,?.\ 9, 4LU H,@ L,V; c@;L9?,.L 4:,@9

9-; 9<4.L8<?[9 ?. 4 W;3 V?.@9;L= :@9 L?.8; 3;K<; -;<;

,. 9-?L 488,@.9= ,.; ,W 9-; 9-?.\L +;<;VH +,-.L,.

Page 190: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 190/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B4?C 9, D,@ ?. 9-49 E;;9?.F= 49 5;4B9 488,<C?.F 9,

9-; 9<4.B8<?G9= ?B 9-49 -; ;.8,@<4F;C D,@ 9, F, 9,

H45E4<9 4.C F;9 4 G-,.;= 4.C IJE 3,.C;<?.F ?K 9-49JB

3-49 9-; L)(1&( 8-4<F; 34B K,<M

N1 O,= ?9 8,@5C.J9 -4P; :;;.1

Q1 N.C ?9 8,@5C.J9 -4P; :;;. :;84@B; D,@

C?C.J9 F, 9, H45E4<9 4.C F;9 4 G-,.;M

N1 R-49JB <?F-91

Q1 A;9 E; C<43 D,@< 499;.9?,. 9, S49;B

G4F; &$" ?. 9-; B4E; ;T-?:?9= 4.C 4:,@9 93,U9-?<CB

9-; 34D C,3. 9-; G4F; 9-;<; 4<; 93, ;.9<?;B ,.

V4D !(9- 9-49 -4P; 9-; B4E; ,< B?E?54< 9;<E?.,5,FD1

N89@455D= 9-;<; 4<; 9-<;;= :@9 9-; K?<B9 93, B4D

W;G,B?9 X,E; S4.Y?.F R<4.BK;< Z<,E 2-4<; *! 5,4.= 4.C

9-;. 9-; .;T9 ,.; ?B K<,E 2-4<; *# 5,4.= 4.C 9-;

4E,@.9B 4<; L%=*** 4.C L!*=%**1

W, D,@ Y.,3 3-49 9-,B; 3;<; K,<M

N1 O,1

Q1 W, D,@ Y.,3 3-49 4 -,E; :4.Y?.F 9<4.BK;<

<;K;<B 9, ,< 3-49 9-49 E;4.BM

N1 IJE 4BB@E?.F UU D,@ 4BY;C E; C, I Y.,31

O,= :@9 I 84. E4Y; 4. ;C@849;C F@;BB1

Q1 H-49 3,@5C D,@< :;B9 F@;BB :; 9-;.M

N1 H;55= ?K D,@ 5,,Y 49 S49;B B94EG

G4F; +2&#&= 49 9-; P;<D E?CC5; ,K 9-; G4F; D,@J55

Page 191: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 191/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

.,9?8; ?9 -4B 488,@.9 B@CC4<?;B= B, D,@E55 B;; 9-49

3; -4F F?GG;<;.9 488,@.9B= B@:488,@.9B= 3?9-?. ,@<

8-;8H?.I 488,@.9B= 4.F B, JEC K@B9 4BB@C?.I LL CD

I@;BB 3,@5F :; 9-49 9-;B; 4<; 9<4.BG;<B G<,C ,.; ,G

9-;B; 488,@.9B ?.9, C4D:; 4 8-;8H?.I 488,@.9= 9-49EB

CD I@;BB= B, 9-;<; 3,@5F :; C,<; C,.;D 9, 3<?9; 4

8-;8H 3?9-1 M-49EB CD I@;BB1

N1 O, D,@ <;8455 C4H?.I !& 4.F 4 -45G

9-,@B4.F F,554<B 3,<9- ,G ;PQ;.F?9@<;B ?. 9-49 9?C;

G<4C;R

J C;4.= F?F D,@ :@D 4 84< ,< Q4D G,<

8,55;I; ,< B,C;9-?.IR

S1 J F,.E9 H.,31 JEC K@B9= 4I4?.= I@;BB?.I1

J F,.E9 H.,3 ?G JEC B@QQ,B;F 9, I@;BB1

N1 JG D,@ F,.E9 H.,3 LL

S1 S9 9-49 9?C; 9-; G4C?5D C4F; 4 5,4. 9,

TL2,5@9?,.B 9, <;Q4D 3-49 U?8-4<F U435; -4F Q4?F

TL2,5@9?,.B G<,C 4. 488,@.91

JB 9-49 4:,@9 9-; B4C; 9?C; G<4C;R

N1 J 9-?.H ?9 3,@5F -4V; :;;.= D;B1

S1 M-49 3,@5F :; CD :;B9 I@;BB ,. 9-49= W499=

:@9 J F,.E9 H.,3 9-49 G,< B@<;1

N1 7H4D1

S1 M-49EB CD :;B9 I@;BB= :;84@B; J H.,3 9-49

2@X4..; 4.F J -4F F;8?F;F 9, 5,4. C,.;D 9,

Page 192: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 192/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC2,5@9?,.D D, 9-49 BC2,5@9?,.D 8,@5E F4G; 9-49

<;[email protected]= 4.E 9-49ID 4:,@9 9-; 4F,@.9 3; -4E 9, :,<<,3

9, F4G; 9-; 5,4. 9, BC2,5@9?,.D1

J1 A;9 F; D3?98- 9,K?8D -;<;1

>4. L,@ 9;55 @D 3-;. L,@ H?<D9 F;9

M?8-4<E M435;N

O1 P,1

J1 >4. L,@ 4KK<,Q?F49; ,< R?S; F; 9-;

8?<[email protected];N

O1 2@<;1 T;D1 U :;5?;S; ?9 34D ;?9-;< ?.

"**" ,< "**# 3-;. U 34D ?. 9-; F?EE5; ,H 4 <@. CC 4

<48; H,< V121 >,.R<;DD= 4.E -; -4E F4E; 4 E,.49?,. 9,

FL 84FK4?R. 488,@.9= 4.E U :;5?;S; 9-49 3,@5E -4S;

:;;. 9-; 8,.9;Q9 ,H FL H?<D9 F;;9?.R -?F :;84@D; -;

F4E; 4 E,.49?,.1

J1 O.E E?E L,@ 8455 -?F @K 9, 9-4.G -?F ,<

E?E D,F;,.; ?.9<,E@8; L,@N

O1 U9ID W@D9 :;;. 9,, 5,.R1 U W@D9 8,@5E.I9

D4L1

J1 X?E 9-;<; 8,F; 4 K,?.9 ?. 9?F; 3-;. L,@

3;.9 9, 3,<G H,< Y<1 M435;N

O1 Z;55= L;D= FL H?<F :;84F; R;.;<45 8,@.D;5

9, -?D 8,FK4.L 4.E E?E 4 5,9 ,H 3,<G H,< -?F 4.E H,<

-?D 8,FK4.?;D1

J1 O.E 84. L,@ <;8455 4KK<,Q?F49;5L 3-;. L,@<

Page 193: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 193/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B?<C :;84C; D;.;<45 8,@.E;5F

G1 H?9-,@9 5,,I?.D 49 CJ .,9;E= ?9 3,@5K :;

-4<K= :@9 E,C;9?C; ?. "**& ,< "**'1

L1 M<?,< 9, 9-; 9?C; 9-; B?<C :;84C; D;.;<45

8,@.E;5= K?K J,@ N;<B,<C 4.J ,9-;< 5;D45 3,<I ,<

.,.O5;D45 3,<I B,< -?CF

G1 P K,.Q9 9-?.I E, N<?,< 9, 9-; 9?C;1

L1 >4. J,@ K;E8<?:; 9-; 8?<[email protected];E -,3

J,@< B?<C :;84C; D;.;<45 8,@.E;5F

G1 H; OO ?9 34E N<,:4:5J 4 E;<?;E ,B

C;;9?.DE1 A?I; P E4?K OO

RS1 2T7HU +,-.= P -4V; ., ,:W;89?,. 9,

J,@< 4.E3;<?.D -?E X@;E9?,. ?. D;.;<451 PQK W@E9

84@9?,. J,@ 9, :; N<,9;89?V; ,B 9-; N<?V?5;D;1 P9QE

S435;QE N<?V?5;D;1 R<1 S435; -4E :;;. B4?<5J 9;E9J

4:,@9 ?91

YZ0 HPYT022U P9 34E E,C;9?C; ?. 9-; B455

,B ;?9-;< "**& ,< "**' 9-49 3; -4K E;V;<45

8,.V;<E49?,.E1

L1 [\J R<1 A455?] G.K 84. J,@ E4J 3-;9-;< ?9

34E J,@< ?K;4 ,< S?8-4<KQEF

G1 P K,.Q9 <;8455 9,K4J 3-,E; ?9 34E1

L1 H;<; J,@ 489?V;5J N<489?8?.D 543 49 9-49

9?C;F

G1 P 34E 5?8;.E;K= J;E= 4.K N<489?8?.D 543=

Page 194: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 194/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B;C1

D1 E-49 F?.G ,H I<489?8; G?G B,@ -4J; 49 9-49

I,?.9K

L1 M -4G 4 8,NN;<8?45 I<489?8;1 M 3,@5G OO M

489@455B -4G :;;. P;.;<45 8,@.C;5 H,< 4 8,NI4.B

8455;G Q4C?8 R;C;4<8- H,< C;J;<45 B;4<C= 4.G C, M

8,.9?.@;G 9, G, C,N; P;.;<45 8,@.C;5 3,<F H,< C,N; ,H

9-; I<?.8?I45C ,H 9-49 8,NI4.B 4.G -4G S@C9 4 P;.;<45

I<489?8;= 5;P45 I<489?8;1

D1 >4. B,@ G;C8<?:; ,< P?J; ;T4NI5;C ,H 9-;

9BI;C ,H 5;P45 3,<F B,@ I;<H,<N;G 4C P;.;<45 8,@.C;5

9, OO 34C ?9 P;.;<45 8,@.C;5 9, >-;8F >?9B ,< C,N;

,9-;< ;.9?9BK

L1 U;.;<45 8,@.C;5 9, >-;8F >?9B 4.G 9-;?<

;.9?9?;C1 V-;B -4G C;J;<45 G?HH;<;.9 ;.9?9?;C1

D1 7F4B1 MW55 S@C9 8455 9-49 9-; >-;8F >?9B

;.9?9?;C= ?H 9-49WC ,F4B1

L1 X-O-@- YB;CZ1

D1 >4. B,@ P?J; ;T4NI5;C ,< ,9-;<3?C;

G;C8<?:; 9-; 9BI; ,H 5;P45 3,<F B,@ G?GK

L1 2@<;1 M 3,@5G <;J?;3 8,.9<489C 4.G M

3,@5G P?J; -?N 4GJ?8; 4:,@9 5?9?P49?,.1 [B

;TI;<?;.8; ?. 5?9?P49?,. -4G :;;. OO M 34C 4

5?9?P49?,. I4<9.;< 49 28455;B 4.G R;4G?.P= :@9 M C,,.

5;4<.;G 9-49 4C P;.;<45 8,@.C;5 ?9 34C J;<B -4<G 9,

Page 195: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 195/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B, 5?9?C49?,. ?.D-,@E;= E, 4 5,9 ,F 9?G;E H 3,@5B

G4.4C; ,@9E?B; 5?9?C49?,. F,< 8,GI4.?;E1

J1 K4E 9-49 4 F@55D9?G; L,:M

N1 O@55D9?G;M PQ 5;C45 I<489?8; 34E I<;99Q

G@8- F@55 9?G;1

J1 K4E Q,@< DD Q,@< C;.;<45 8,@.E;5 F,< 9-;

>-;8R >?9Q 8,GI4.?;E= 34E 9-49 F@55 9?G;M

N1 S,= ?9 34E.T9 F@55 9?G;1 H -4B ,9-;<

85?;.9E 4E 3;551

J1 K-;<; B?B Q,@ ,FF?8;M

N1 H ,FF?8;B 49 B?FF;<;.9 I548;E= :@9 B@<?.C

9-; 9?G; H 34E 3,<R?.C 4E C;.;<45 8,@.E;5 F,< 9-;

>-;8R >?9Q 8,GI4.?;E H ,FF?8;B ?. 9-;?< ,FF?8;E1

U-;Q -4B 4 E49;55?9; ,FF?8; .;V9 9, 9-;?< I<?G4<Q

,FF?8;= 4.B H -4B 4. ,FF?8; ?. 9-;?< E49;55?9;

,FF?8;1

J1 N.B 3-;<; 34E 9-49 5,849;BM

N1 H. W<,X,= Y94-1

J1 Z,3 3;<; Q,@ 8,GI;.E49;BM

N1 H 34E 8,GI;.E49;B G,.9-5Q ,. 4 <;94?.;<1

J1 N.B 34E 9-; <;94?.;< :Q 34Q ,F 8-;8R ,<

3?<; ,< E,G; ,9-;< R?.B ,F DD

N1 H9 34E I4?B :Q 8-;8R 9, 23455,3 [

NEE,8?49;E1

J1 O<,GM

Page 196: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 196/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C<,D EE F 9-?.G 9-; -,5H?.I 8,DJ4.K 34L

.,9 >-;8G >?9K1 M-;K -4H 4 -,5H?.I 8,DJ4.K1

N1 B.H 9-49 34L EE

B1 B.H F :;5?;O; ?9 34L M,L-1

N1 M,L-P

B1 M,L-= F.81

N1 7G4K1

B1 B.H F 34.9 9, :; 84<;Q@5 4.H .,9 I;9 ?.9,

499,<.;KE85?;.9E9KJ; 9-?.IL= L, F 34.9 9, :; O;<K

84<;Q@5 4L F 4.L3;< K,@< R@;L9?,.L 4:,@9 9-49

<;549?,.L-?J1

N1 7G4K1 2, 9-?L 34L EE K,@ 3;<;.S9 4 TE" ,<

4 UE! 9KJ; ;DJ5,K;;P

B1 V,1 V;O;< 34L1

N1 W?H K,@ -4O; ,884L?,. 9, L,5?8?9 J,5?9?845

H,.49?,.L Q<,D X<1 Y435; ;?9-;< Q,< K,@<L;5Q ,< Q,<

,9-;< 84.H?H49;LP

B1 7. ,884L?,.1

N1 B.H H, K,@ <;8455 EE Q,< ;Z4DJ5;= K,@

D;.9?,.;H 9-49 -; 8,.9<?:@9;H 9, K,@< >,.I<;LL?,.45

84DJ4?I.1

B1 Y?I-91

N1 W?H -; 8,.9<?:@9; 9, :,9- ,Q 9-;DP

B1 F H,.S9 <;84551 FSD 4LL@D?.I -; H?H= :@9

F H,.S9 <;84551

Page 197: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 197/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C, D,@ <;8455 E,5?8?9?.F -?E 8,.9<?:@9?,.E

G,< ,9-;< 84.H?H49;EI

J1 K;55= 3-;. D,@ E4D G,< ,9-;< 84.H?H49;E=

-; 4.H L MM -; 4.H L H?H 8,@.E;5 9,F;9-;< 4:,@9

N,5?9?845 ?EE@;E= 4.H ?G D,@ 5,,O 49 PD G?5?.FE= D,@

45E, O.,3 9-49 L 34E 4 <;F?E9;<;H 5,::D?E9 G,<

>-;8O >?9D 4.H 9-;?< F<,@N ,G 8,PN4.?;E 4.H G,< E,P;

,9-;< 8,PN4.?;E 4E 3;55= E, N4<9 ,G PD

<;EN,.E?:?5?9?;E :;84P; -;5N?.F -?P ,. N,5?9?845

H;8?E?,.E -; -4H 9, P4O; 4E 3;551

2, :48O 9, D,@< Q@;E9?,.= H?H L ;R;<

E,5?8?9 8,.9<?:@9?,.E G<,P -?P= L 34E MM

ST1 2U7KV W,< ,9-;< 84.H?H49;EI

XY0 KLXU022V T?F-91 2, L F@;EE 3-;. D,@

E4D H?H L E,5?8?9= 3; H?E8@EE;H 8,.9<?:@9?,.E 9-49 -;

;?9-;< H?H ,< H?H.Z9 P4O; G,< ,9-;< 84.H?H49;E= D;E=

:@9 3-;. D,@ E4D H?H L E,5?8?9= LZP .,9 E@<; 3-49 D,@

P;4.1

K4E L N4?H= G,< ;[4PN5;= :D ,9-;< N;,N5;

9, H, 9-49I X-; 4.E3;<ZE .,= :@9 H?H L H?E8@EE ?9

3?9- -?PI \;E= L H?H= P4.D 9?P;E1

B1 ]^D S<1 A455?_ C?H D,@ 4EE?E9 ,9-;<

84.H?H49;E G,< ,GG?8; ?. <4?E?.F P,.;DI

J1 \;E1

B1 J.H 3-49 84.H?H49;EI

Page 198: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 198/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C;55= D4<E 2-@<95;FF= F,< ;G4HI5;= ?. -?J

<@. F,< B99,<.;K L;.;<45 ?. "**(1

M1 B.K ,9-;<JN

B1 O. -?J <@. F,< P121 2;.49;= 459-,@Q- -;

R?R.S9 <;455K Q;9 ?. 9-49 <48;= :@9 -; 8,.J?R;<;R ?9

4.R <4?J;R J,H; R,554<J F,< 9-491

M1 B.R K,@ -;5I;R -?H <4?J; H,.;K F,< 9-49N

B1 T;J1

M1 7E4K1 B.R J?H?54< 9, 9-49 UU

B1 V-49 34J 455 :;F,<; O 34J ?. 9-; BLSJ

,FF?8;1

M1 7E4K1 2?H?54< 9, 9-49= -4W; K,@ -;5I;R

,9-;< 84.R?R49;J <4?J; H,.;KN

B1 O 9-?.E 9-49 3,@5R :; F4?< 9, J4K 9-491

OSW; 9<?;R 9, 9-?.E 4:,@9 3-, ?9 3,@5R -4W; :;;.= :@9

O 34J= K,@ E.,3= F4?<5K 489?W; 3?9- H;H:;<J ,F 9-;

5;Q?J549@<;= F,< ;G4HI5;1

M1 C-49 4:,@9 4.K F;R;<45 ,FF?8;J= >,.Q<;JJ

,< 2;.49;= R?R K,@ -;5I <4?J; H,.;K F,< 4.K 84.R?R49;

9-;<;N

B1 C;55= O <;8455 J@QQ;J9?.Q 9, X?8-4<R ?. UU

9-; 4.J3;<SJ K;J1

M1 7E4K1 B.R ?. K,@< 84I48?9K ,F <4?J?.Q

H,.;K= 3-;9-;< ?9SJ F,< D4<E 2-@<95;FF ,< F,<

84.R?R49;J F,< J949; ,< F;R;<45 ,FF?8;= R?R K,@ 4JE

Page 199: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 199/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

B?8-4<C B435; 9, C,.49; 9, 9-,D; 84EF4?G.DH

I1 J;55= K 9-?.L KMC :; D4N; 9, D4O ,. D,E;

,884D?,.D K C?C1

P1 J4D Q<1 B435; 4 N<;R@;.9 ,< G;.;<,@D

8,.9<?:@9,< 9, F,5?9?845 84EF4?G.D ?. O,@<

;D9?E49?,.H

I1 K9 C;F;.C;C1 K E;4.= D,E;9?E;D -; 8,@5C

:; S;<O G;.;<,@D 4.C D,E;9?E;D -; 3,@5C T@D9 .,9 C,

?91 K9 C;F;.C;C ,. 9-; 84.C?C49; 4.C 3-49 9-;O D9,,C

N,<1

P1 U?C -; 8,.9<?:@9; 9, O,@< I99,<.;O V;.;<45

84EF4?G.H

I1 K 9-?.L -; C?C1 K 9-?.L -; C?C C?<;895O

9, EO 84EF4?G. ,< 9, 4 WI> 9-49 34D 4DD,8?49;C 3?9-

EO 84EF4?G. ,< 9, 4 WI> 9-49 34D 4DD,8?49;C 3?9-

Q4<L 2-@<95;NNMD 84EF4?G.1 K 84.M9 <;E;E:;< -,3 -;

8,.9<?:@9;C= :@9 -; 8,.9<?:@9;C 9, 4 D-,9G@. ;S;.9

9-49 3; -;5C ?. 9-; N455 ,N "*!"1

P1 7L4O1 I.C ?N ?9 -4C :;;. 8,.9<?:@9;C 9, 4

WI>= 3,@5C 9-49 -4S; D-,3. @F ,. O,@< 84EF4?G.

C?D85,D@<;DH

I1 J-49;S;< 9-; <@5;D 3;<; 9-;O 3,@5C -4S;

:;;. N,55,3;C1 K -4C 4 F<,N;DD?,.45 9<;4D@<;< 3-,

9<48L;C 455 ,N 9-49 4.C <;F,<9;C 455 ,N 9-491

P1 2, O,@ C,.M9 L.,3 9-; 4.D3;<H

Page 200: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 200/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

B1 C;55= D,< ;E4FG5;= ?D 4 84FG4?H.

8,.9<?:@9?,. 34I F4J; 9, K4<L 2-@<95;DDMI NB>= D,<

;E4FG5;= 4.J K4<L 2-@<95;DD 549;< J,.49;J 9, FO

84FG4?H. 9-<,@H- -?I NB>= P J,.M9 L.,3 3-;9-;< 9-49

3,@5J -4Q; I-,3. @G 4I 4 8,.9<?:@9?,. D<,F

R?8-4<J R435; 9, FO 84FG4?H.= I, PMF .,9 I@<; P 84.

4.I3;< O,@< S@;I9?,. 3?9-,@9 J?HH?.H ?.9, 9-?.HI1

T1 U, O,@ L.,3 -,3 F@8- F,.;O K<1 R435;

8,.9<?:@9;J 9, O,@< B99,<.;O V;.;<45 84FG4?H. 9-<,@H-

3-49;Q;< F;4.I -; @I;JW

B1 P J,.M9 L.,31 B.J P 3,@5J X@I9 I4O 9-?I1

P 34.9 9, F4L; I@<; 3;M<; Q;<O 85;4< ,. 9-?I1 Y,@

X@I9 I4?J 9, FO 84FG4?H. 9-<,@H- 3-49;Q;< Q;-?85; -;

F?H-9 -4Q; @I;J1

B J,.49?,. F4J; 9, 4 NB> 9-49MI 8,.9<,55;J

:O K4<L 2-@<95;DD 9-49 -4I 4 8;<94?. 4F,@.9 ,D F,.;O

?I .,9 .;8;II4<?5O ,< ;Q;. <;4I,.4:5O 8,.I9<@;J 4I 4

J,.49?,. 9, FO 84FG4?H.= I, P J,.M9 34.9 O,@ 9, F4L;

?9 5,,L 5?L; PMF 9;I9?DO?.H 9-49 4 J,.49?,. 9,

K4<L 2-@<95;DDMI NB> 34I 4 J,.49?,. 9, F;1 PMF .,9

I4O?.H 9-491

T1 C;55= <;455O 3-49 PMF 4IL?.H ?I 3-;9-;<

O,@M<; 434<; ,D 4.O F,.;O 9-49 R?8-4<J R435; H4Q; 9,

4.O,.; 9-49 ;.J;J @G :;.;D?99?.H O,@< 84FG4?H. D,<

B99,<.;O V;.;<45W

Page 201: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 201/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C;55= D 9-?.E 9-49 F@;G9?,.HG 34I 9,,

:<,4J K,< L; 9, 4.G3;<= :;84@G; ?K -; L4J; 4 J,.49?,.

9, 9-; 2949; M;N@:5?84. O4<9I= K,< ;P4LN5;= 4.J 9-;I

J?J G,L; E?.J ,K 4 :<,8-@<; 9-49 -4J LI .4L; ,. ?9=

9-;. 9-49 8,@5J :; 4. 4.G3;<= G, D J,.H9 QQ D 34.9

I,@ 9, :; R;<I GN;8?K?8= ?K I,@ J,.H9 L?.J1 S,@H<;

4GE?.T 9-; F@;G9?,.G= DHL .,9= :@9 D 34.9 9, L4E;

G@<; DHL R;<I 84<;K@5 3?9- LI 4.G3;<G :;84@G; DHL

@.J;< ,49-1

U1 7E4I1 C;55= I,@ G;;L 9, -4R; 4 G;.G; 9-49

-; T4R; G,L; L,.;I 9, I,@< 84LN4?T. QQ

B1 M?T-91

U1 QQ 3-;9-;< ?9 34G J?<;895I ,< 9-<,@T-

4 OB>1

B1 C;55= 9-49HG :;84@G; DHR; <4?G;J ,R;< 4

L?55?,. J,554<G ?. LI 84LN4?T.= V499= G, D J,.H9

<;L;L:;<= I,@ E.,3= ;P4895I 3-49 ,< -,3 M?8-4<J M435;

L4I -4R; 8,.9<?:@9;J 9, LI 84LN4?T.1 7E4IW X;84@G;

D 84.H9 T@;GG ,< GN;8@549; -;<; ,. 9-; 3?9.;GG G94.J1

U1 7E4I1 D 34G Y@G9 9-?.E?.T 9-49= T?R;.

I,@< <;549?,.G-?N 3?9- -?L= I,@ L4I -4R; -4J 4 L,<;

488@<49; <;8,55;89?,. ,K -?G 8,.9<?:@9?,. 9-4.

N;<-4NG ,9-;< 8,.9<?:@9,<G= 4.J 3-49 I,@H<; 9;55?.T

L; ?G 9-49HG .,9 9<@;1

B1 C;55= D E.,3 D -4J 4 5,9 ,K 8,.9<?:@9,<G=

Page 202: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 202/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

B499= 4.C D,@E<; 4FG?.H FI;8?J?8 K@;F9?,.F1 L C,.E9

<;8455 ;M4895D -,3 N@8- -; N4D -4O; 8,.9<?:@9;C 9, ND

84NI4?H.1

P1 Q,< C, D,@ <;8455 3-;9-;< ?9 34F C?<;895D

,< 9-<,@H- 4 RS>T

S1 U;55= 4H4?.= L C,.E9 34.9 9, F4D 9-49 9-;

84NI4?H. 8,.9<?:@9?,.F ,< 4 8,.9<?:@9?,. 9, 4 RS> ?F

4 84NI4?H. 8,.9<?:@9?,.1 S 8,.9<?:@9?,. 9, 4 RS> ?F

4 8,.9<?:@9?,. 9, 4 RS>1 L9EF C?F85,F;C :D 9-; RS>=

4.C 9-49 RS> 84. 9-;. C,.49; 9-; N,.;D 9, 4.,9-;<

84.C?C49; ,< 9, N;= 4.C 9-49EF 455 I@<[email protected] 9, 2949;

543= F, L C,.E9 34.9 VV D,@E<; 4FG?.H N; 4 K@;F9?,.

4F ?J -;EF C,.49?.H 9, ,.; ;.9?9D 4.C <;455D C,.49?.H

9, N;= 4.C ND I,F?9?,. ?F ?J D,@EO; C,.49;C 9, 4.

;.9?9D= D,@EO; C,.49;C 9, 9-; ;.9?9D1 W; C?C.E9

C,.49; 9, N;1

P1 X, D,@ G.,3 ?J -; C,.49;C 9, 4 RS>T

S1 L :;5?;O; F,= :;84@F; -; 34F 49 9-;

F-,9H@. ;O;.9 4.C 34F 4 FI,.F,< ,J 9-49 F-,9H@.

;O;.9= F, L :;5?;O; -; 8,.9<?:@9;C 9, ;?9-;< 9-;

R<,9;89 Y94- RS>= 3-?8- 34F 4 RS> 9-49 L 34F ?.O,5O;C

3?9-= ,< B4<G 2-@<95;JJEF RS> VV L C,.E9 <;N;N:;< 9-;

.4N; ,J 9-49 VV ,< C?<;895D 9, B4<G 2-@<95;JJEF

84NI4?H. ,< C?<;895D 9, ND 84NI4?H.1 L Z@F9 84.E9

<;N;N:;<1

Page 203: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 203/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1 E?F G4<C 2-@<95;HHIJ KL> ;M;<

8,.9<?:@9; 9, D,@< KL> ,< 9, D,@< 84NO4?P.Q

L1 R;J1

B1 L.F D,@ F,.I9 <;8455 F?J8@JJ?.P 3?9-

G<1 S435; 9-; 4N,@.9 9-49 -; 8,.9<?:@9;F 49 9-49

J-,9P@. ;M;.9Q

L1 T,9 JO;8?H?8455D1 S?8-4<F S435;

8,.9<?:@9;F 9, 9-49 J-,9P@. ;M;.9 ;M;<D J?.P5; D;4<=

4.F 9-; D;4<J C?.F ,H -4M; 4 34D ,H C?.F ,H N;<P?.P

3?9- ,.; 4.,9-;<1

GS1 ALAAUV 7C4D1 W-?<9D1

$%&'()(* #" ,-. /-01%234 

B1 XYD G<1 A455?Z 0[-?:?9 #* ?J 93, ;\N4?5J

W@;JF4D LO<?5 %= "*!!1 7.; ,H 9-;N= 9-; ,.; ,. 9-;

:,99,N= ?J H<,N >,<9 ]45C;< 9, W<?J94 ^?:J,.1 U9

<;H;<J 9, D,@ F<,OO?.P ,HH D,@< F4@P-9;<IJ 94[;J1

E, D,@ C.,3 3-49 9-?J ?J <;H;<<?.P 9,Q

L1 U _@J9 C.,3 9-49 ?9IJ 4. ;\N4?5 H<,N >,<9

9, W<?J94 ^?:J,.1

B1 E, D,@ <;8455 F<,OO?.P ,HH D,@< F4@P-9;<IJ

94[;J H,< >,<9 ,< W<?J94 ^?:J,. 9, 94C; 84<; ,HQ

L1 U F,.I9 <;8455 9-49= .,1

B1 E, D,@ C.,3 3-, W<?J94 ^?:J,. ?JQ

L1 U F,1 2-; ?J 4 J9,<; N4.4P;< 49

>-;8C >?9D1

Page 204: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 204/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1 E?F G-; H<;H4<; 94I;GJ

K1 L;55= 9-49 ?G ,.; ,M 9-; G;<N?8;G 9-49

>-;8C >?9D H<,N?F;G= 4.F O 3?55 G4D 9-49 93, ,M PD

F4@Q-9;<G -4N; 3,<C;F M,< RR 8@<<;.95D ,.; ,M PD

F4@Q-9;<G ?G 3,<C?.Q M,< >-;8C >?9D= 4.F ?9 3,@5F.S9

G@<H<?G; P; ?M PD F4@Q-9;< 34G 3,<C?.Q M,< >-;8C >?9D

49 9-; 9?P;= :@9 O F,.S9 C.,3= 4.F O F,.S9 C.,3 3-?8-

F4@Q-9;< ?9 ?G1

B1 E?F >-;8C >?9D H<,N?F; G;<N?8;G M,< D,@ ,<

D,@< M4P?5D= G@8- 4G 94I H<;H4<49?,.J

K1 L;55= .,9 .,<P455D= G, 9-?G 3,@5F :; RR

4Q4?.= O F,.S9 C.,3 ?M 9-?G 34G ?. 8,[email protected]?,. 3?9-

-;< ;PH5,DP;.9 ,< 3-;. ?9 34G= :@9= .,= PD 94I;G 4<;

F,.; :D PD 488,@.94.9= 3-?8- F,;G.S9 -4N; 4.D9-?.Q 9,

F, 3?9- >-;8C >?9D1

B1 K.F D,@ F,.S9 -4N; 4 <;8,55;89?,. ,M

F<,HH?.Q ,MM D,@< F4@Q-9;<SG 94I;G M,< H<;H4<49?,. :D

U<?G94 V?:G,.J

K1 W,= :@9 OSP .,9 -;<; 9, G4D O F?F.S9= :@9

O F,.S9 <;84551

XY1 AKAAOZ U-?<9DR,.;1

$%&'()(* ,- ./0 1/23%456 

B1 [\D X<1 A455?] 0I-?:?9 #! ?G 4 +@.; ")=

"*!!= ;RP4?5 M<,P D,@ 9, ^?H1

_?<G9 ,M 455= 84. D,@ 9;55 P; 3-, ^?H ?GJ

Page 205: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 205/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C?D >4E-F,<; ?E 9-; D<;E?G;.9 ,H 4 8,FD4.I

8455;G J2B >4E- 2;<K?8;E1

L1 M-49 N?.G ,H 4 8,FD4.I ?E 9-49O

B1 M;55= -; 489@455I -4E ,9-;< :@E?.;EE;E 4E

3;55= :@9 J2B >4E- 2;<K?8;E ?E 4 G;H;<<;G G;D,E?9

5;.G;< ,< D4IG4I 5,4. 8,FD4.I1

L1 B.G G, I,@ <;8455 9-; D@<D,E; PP 3;55=

H?<E9 ,H 455= G, I,@ <;8455 9-?E ;PF4?5O

B1 Q G,.R9 <;8455 G<4H9?.S ?9= :@9 ?9 5,,NE

5?N; ?9 34E G<4H9;G :I F;1

L1 T, I,@ <;8455 3?9- <;H;<;.8; 9, 9-; H?<E9

E;.9;.8; S?K?.S C?D E,F; E@SS;E9?,.E 4:,@9 3-49 -;

F?S-9 E4I 8,.8;<.?.S I,@< 84.G?G48I H,<

B99,<.;I U;.;<45O

B1 V;E1

L1 M-49 34E 9-; D@<D,E; ,H S?K?.S C?D

?.H,<F49?,. 4:,@9 I,@< 84.G?G48IO

B1 C?D 34E S,?.S 9, 9<I 9, -;5D <4?E; F,.;I

H,< FI 84FD4?S. ,< PP I;4-= H,< B99,<.;I U;.;<451

L1 M?9- <;H;<;.8; 9, 9-; G49; -;<;= +@.; ")=

"*!!= 84. I,@ E4I 3-;9-;< I,@RG ,HH?8?455I G;854<;G

I,@< 84.G?G48I 49 9-49 D,?.9O

B1 Q -4G .,9 ,HH?8?455I G;854<;G FI

84.G?G48I1

L1 T<43?.S I,@< 499;.9?,. 9, W,?.9 X,1 "

Page 206: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 206/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9-;<;= ?. 9-; B;8,.C B;.9;.8; ?9 B4DB 9-; <48; E,< FG

3?55 :; 455 4:,@9 9-; .,H?.49?,.1

I-49 C, D,@ H;4. :D 9-49J

F1 I;55= K@B9 9-49 ?. L94- ?. 4 B949;3?C;

<48; 9-; M;N@:5?84. .,H?.;; -4B 4 O<;49 8-4.8; ,E

3?..?.O1

P1 Q?C D,@ R.,3 3-, ,< ?E 9-;<; 3,@5C :; 4

M;N@:5?84. 8,.9;.C;< E,< D,@ 49 9-?B N,?.9J

F1 S C,.T9 <;8455 ?E S R.;3 49 9-49 N,?.9 3-,

?9 3,@5C :;= 459-,@O- S -;4<C <@H:5?.OB 9-49

2;4. M;D;B 34B ?.9;<;B9;C1 S C?C.T9 R.,3 3-, ;5B;1

S 45B, -;4<C <@H,<B 9-49 +,-. U45;.9?.; 3,@5C :;

?.9;<;B9;C1

P1 >4. D,@ B4D VV 3;55= D,@T<; ,:W?,@B5D

<4?B?.O H,.;D 49 9-?B N,?.9 ?. 9?H;= <?O-9J

F1 I;55 VV STH O@;BB?.O D,@ 34.9 9, O?W; H; 4

H?.@9; 9, <;4C 9-; 3-,5; ;VH4?5 5;99;< -;<; 9,

<;E<;B- HD <;8,55;89?,.1

P1 2@<;1

XI?9.;BB ;Y4H?.?.O C,8@H;.91Z

[\0 IS[]022^ I;55= 5,,RB 5?R; S B4D -;<;

9-49 STC 45<;4CD <;48-;C _!**=***= 4.C S :;5?;W; 9-49

C?C -4NN;. ?. H?C +@.; ,E "*!!= 4B S <;8455 .,31

P1 X`D a<1 A455?Z SE D,@T55 5,,R 49

N4<4O<4N- '= bFB H@8- 4B N,BB?:5;= S 3,@5C 5?R; 9,

Page 207: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 207/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

<4?B; C,.;D E<,C 8,CF4.?;B 4.G ?.G?H?G@45B

.,9 9?;G 9, F4DG4D= B, I G, .,9 C4J; 9-?B 4 F4DG4D

<48;1K

0LF54?. 9, C; 3-49 D,@< 8,.8;<. 34B 49

9-49 F,?.91

M1 N;55= I C;4.= I 9-?.J ?9OB E4?<5D

B;5EP;LF54.49,<D1 I 34B 9<D?.Q 9, Q;9 4 :<,4G :4B;

,E E?.4.8?45 B@FF,<9 E<,C C4.D ?.G@B9<?;B= .,9 R@B9

,.; ?.G@B9<D1

S1 7J4D1 M.G G?G D,@ PP 3;<; D,@ 8,.B?B9;.9

3?9- 9-49 9-<,@Q-,@9 D,@< 84CF4?Q. 4:,@9 9<D?.Q 9,

Q;9 .,.PF4DG4D 5,4. C,.;DT

M1 N;55= IOH; <4?B;G 4 5,9 ,E C,.;D E<,C C4.D

G?EE;<;.9 ?.G@B9<?;B= 4.G IOH; 9<?;G 9, J;;F 9-?.QB

4B :454.8;G 4B F,BB?:5;1

S1 >4. D,@ <;8455 PP 3;55= 34B 9-;<;

B,C;9-?.Q PP 3-;. D,@ B4D D,@ G,.O9 34.9 9, C4J; 9-?B

4 F4DG4D <48; PP

M1 U?Q-91

S1 PP 9-49 B@QQ;B9B 9, C; 9-49 D,@ 3;<;

8,.8;<.;G 4:,@9 :;?.Q 54:;5;G 4 F4DG4D 5,4.P9DF;

84.G?G49;1

IB 9-49 4 8,<<;89 ?.E;<;.8;T

M1 N;55= I 9-?.J 9-49 I G?G.O9 34.9 9, :; 4

,.; ?BB@; 84.G?G49;= 4.G I J.,3 9-49 9-; PP D,@ J.,3=

Page 208: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 208/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

3?9- BC -4D?.E :;;. 4 5,::C?F9 ?. 9-; ?.G@F9<C= H

I;59 5?J;= C,@ J.,3= H .;;G 9, -4D; 4 :<;4G9- ,I

F@KK,<9 I<,B I?.4.8?45 ?.F9?9@9?,.F= I<,B <;45 ;F949;

?.F9?9@9?,.F= I<,B ,9-;< ?.G@F9<?;F F, 9-49 H 3,@5G

:; J.,3. 4F B,<; ,I 4 3;55L<,@.G;G 84.G?G49;= F, 9-49

34F BC <;45 K@<K,F; ?. 4FJ?.E -?B ?. K4<4E<4K- ' 9,

<4?F; B,.;C I<,B 8,BK4.?;F 4.G ?.G?D?G@45F= .,9

F?BK5C 9?;G 9, K4CG4C1

M1 N-; 54F9= ,< 9-; F;8,.G 9, 54F9 9-?.E C,@

F4C -;<; ?F .,9 9, I,<34<G 9-; ;LB4?51

O-49 34F C,@< 8,.8;<. ?. 9-49 <;E4<GP

Q1 H 9-?.J LL H 9-?.J ?9RF F;5IL;SK54.49,<C1

0LB4?5F 9-49 4<; I,<34<G;G 84. :; I,<34<G;G ?.

K;<K;9@?9C1 H G,.R9 -4D; 4.C9-?.E ;5F; 9, <;455C F4C

4:,@9 9-491

M1 O4F 9-;<; F,B;9-?.E ?. 9-; :,GC ,I 9-49

;LB4?5 9-49 C,@ G?G .,9 34.9 9, :; G?FF;B?.49;G B,<;

:<,4G5CP

Q1 O;55= H G,.R9 J.,31 H B;4.= H G, J.,3

9-49 9-; K4CG4C ?.G@F9<C .49?,.455C 34F F;.F?9?D; 9,

4 5,9 ,I :48J54F- 9-;C <;8;?D;G= 4.G TU 34F 4534CF 4

:?E 9-?.E I,< 9-;B 4F 3;55= F, H 84.R9 ;SK54?. B,<;

9-4. H -4D;= 9-49 H 34.9;G 9, :; 3;55L<,@.G;G= 4.G

9-?F 34F 4 K;<F,. 3-, -4G 8,BB?99;G 9, <4?F; F,B;

B,.;C I,< B;1

Page 209: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 209/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C;<; 9-;<; 4.D ,9-;< E,?.9F D,@ 54?G ,@9

9, H?E ?. 9-?F ;IJ4?5 9-49 D,@ 9-,@K-9 3;<; .,9 3;55

F@?9;G L,< E@:5?8 G?FF;J?.49?,.M

N1 O 9-?.P ?9QF II 3;55= ,.; 9-?.K1 O 9-?.P

?9 F,@.G;G E<;99D 4<<,K4.9 ,L J; 9, F4D 9-49 O 3,@5G

:; 9-; 85;4< L<,.9<@..;< <?K-9 L<,J 9-; K;9 K, ?L O

4..,@.8;G1 O 9-?.P ?9 34F L4?<5D ?.9;<;F9?.K 9-49 O

F4?G 9-49 9-; R;E@:5?84. ?F K,?.K 9, 3?. 9-?F <48; :D

#* E,?.9F= F, O 34F E<;99D :,5G1

B1 N.D9-?.K ;5F; 9-49 D,@ 9-?.P D,@ J4D -4S;

34.9;G 9, T@F9 P;;E :;93;;. D,@ 4.G H?EM

N1 C;55= O -4G JD :@GK;9 9-49 3,@5G :; 4

J?55?,.I,.;1 O J;4. II

B1 OF.Q9 9-49 E@:5?8= F,J; ,L D,@< 84JE4?K.

8,.9<?:@9?,.FM

N1 U,9 ?. +@.; ,L "*!! JD K,45F 4<;.Q9

E@:5?81 C-49 O 9-?.P O .;;G 9, :@GK;9 4.G FE;.G ,.

JD 84JE4?K. ?F .,9 E@:5?81 V-49QF J,<; 84JE4?K.

F9<49;KD1

2, 9-;<; 4<; F;S;<45 9-?.KF ?. 9-?F 5;99;<

4F O 5,,P 49 ?9 9-49= D,@ P.,3= O G?G.Q9 34.9 9, -4S;

?9 :;D,.G JD S;<D 85,F; 9;4J ,< JD L?.4.8; 9;4J=

<49-;< 9-4. -4S; ?9 G?F9<?:@9;G 3?G;5D ,< E@9 ?. 4

L,<34<G 4.G K,.; ,@9 9, 3-, P.,3F 3-,1

B1 N.G G?G D,@ :;5?;S; 49 9-49 9?J; 9-49 9-;

Page 210: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 210/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B949;C;.9B 9-49 D,@EF; G,9 ?. 9-?B 5;99;< 3;<;

H?BB;C?.49;H C,<; :<,4H5D 4.H 9-49 B,C;-,3 C4D

.;G49?F;5D 4II;89 D,@< 84CJ4?G.K

L1 M;55= 5,,N 49 3-49 9-; !"#$%&'() H,.; 3?9-

9-; 9-?.GB 9-49 -4F; :;;. B4?H 4:,@9 C; .,3 4.H -,3

9-;DEF; 49948N;H C; I,< 9-; C,B9 ?.8<;H?:5;

B949;C;.9B C4H; :D J;,J5;= 4.H O I;59 9-49 4.D9-?.G O

B4?H 9-49 3,@5H :;= D,@ N.,3= :,5H ,< 4@H48?,@B 3,@5H

:; B,C;9-?.G 9-49 3,@5H :; 5,,N;H 49 :D 9-,B; 3-,

34.9;H 9, -@<9 C; ,< 94N; C; H,3. ,< 3?. 4 <48;1

PQ1 ALAAOR S-?<9DT93,1

$%&'()(* ,! -./ 0.12%345 

U1 VWD P<1 A455?X 0Y-?:?9 #" ?B 4 8,JD ,I

D,@< 4.H D,@< 3?I;EB Z,?.9 94Y <;9@<. I,< 9-; D;4<

"*!"= 4.H O Z@B9 34.9 9, 4BN D,@ 4 8,@J5; ,I

[@;B9?,.B 4:,@9 9-?B1

\?<B9 ,I 455= ,. J4G; != 5?.; '= ?9 5?B9B

34G;B= B454<?;B= 9?JB= ;9 8;9;<4= ]!)%=#"*1

L1 Q?G-91

U1 ^, D,@ N.,3 3-49 9-49 8,.B?B9;H ,IK

L1 O 9-?.N ?9 34B TT O 9-?.N 455= ?I .,9 C,B9

,I ?9= 34B CD 2949; 34G;B1

U1 ^, D,@ <;8455 3-49 D,@< 4..@45 B454<D I,<

9-; 2949; 34B 49 9-49 9?C;K

L1 O 9-?.N 4<,@.H ]!%*=***1

Page 211: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 211/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

B1 7C4D1 E.F F, D,@ C.,3 3-49 9-; ,9-;<

4GG<,H?I49;5D J$%=*** 34KL

E1 M;4-1 N-49 O 9-?.C ?9 34K 34K 3-;. O

;.F;F ID ;IG5,DI;.9 49 9-; ;.F ,P 9-; D;4<=

9<4.K?9?,.;F P<,I 4 .,.QI;<?9 ;IG5,D;; 9, 9-;

E99,<.;D R;.;<45= O 34K 455,3;F 9, 84K- ,@9 4

K@:K94.9?45 4I,@.9 ,P K?8C 5;4S; 9?I; 4.FT,< S4849?,.

9?I; O -4F.U9 @K;F1 O F,.U9 9-?.C ?9 34K 9-; K?8C

5;4S;1 O 9-?.C ?9 34K S4849?,.1 O 9-?.C O 5,K9 ID

K?8C 5;4S;1 E.F K, O <;8;?S;F 4:,@9 #( ,< J#)=*** O

:;5?;S; ?. 4 5@IG K@I 49 9-; ;.F ,P 9-; D;4<1

O 9-?.C 9-49UK G<,:4:5D 9-; F?PP;<;.8;1 O

F,.U9 C.,3 ?P O -4F 4.D ,9-;< ?.8,I;1 O F,.U9 9-?.C

O -4F 4.D ,9-;< ?.8,I;1

B1 V-; NQ"K QQ 9-; E99,<.;D R;.;<45= 9-49UK 4

NQ" ;IG5,D;;L

E1 M;K1 2, ?K >-?;P W;G@9D1

B1 X?Y-91 E.F K, O F,.U9 -4S; 9-,K;= K,

9-49UK 3-D OUI 4KC?.Y D,@ 9-; Z@;K9?,.1

E1 M;4-= 9-49 3,@5F ;HG54?. ?91

B1 W, D,@ C.,3= ,9-;< 9-4. 9-; K454<D

8,I:?.;F 3?9- 9-; 84K- ,@9 ,P :;.;P?9K= 34K 9-;<; 4.D

,9-;< ;IG5,DI;.9 9-49 D,@ -4F F@<?.Y 9-; 94H D;4< P,<

"*!"L

E1 O F,.U9 9-?.C K,= .,1 [,= O F,.U9 9-?.C

Page 212: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 212/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

B,1 C D,.E9 9-?.F C -4D 4.G9-?.H ;5B;1

IJ1 2K7LM N,@ O;4. P,< "*!!Q

RS0 LCRK022M N;4-1 K,= 9-?B ?B P,< "*!"1

R-?B 3,@5D -4T; :;;. P?5;D 9-?B BU<?.H1 L;ET; H,9

9-; 84U?945 H4?. -;<;1

K,= I499= C D,.E9 :;5?;T; 9-;<; 34B1

V1 WXG I<1 A455?Y 7F4G1 A;9 O; ZZ

IJ1 2K7LM S; P?5;B ?. [U<?51

RS0 LCRK022M \?5;D D@<?.H [U<?5Q CEO

]@B9 4BF?.H1

V1 WXG I<1 A455?Y A;9 O; D<43 G,@< 499;.9?,.

9, X49;B U4H; (('1

[1 7-= ,. 9-; 94^ <;9@<.Q

V1 N;B1

[1 7F4G1

V1 [.D 9-?B ?B 9-; 84U?945 H4?.B 94^

9<;49O;.9 P,< 9-; !" H,5D 8,?.B 9-49 3; D?B8@BB;D1

[1 J?H-91

V1 [.D ]@B9 9, H;9 @B :48F 49 9-; B4O; U,?.9=

OG @.D;<B94.D?.H ?B 9-49 9-;B; 3;<; H,5D 8,?.B 9-49

J?8-4<D J435; H4T; 9, G,@ 49 9-; 9?O; G,@ 5;P9

>-;8F >?9G 4.D 3;.9 9, 3,<F P,< 9-; [_EB ,PP?8;Q

[1 X;P,<; C 5;P9 >-;8F >?9G= G;B1

V1 [.D D@<?.H "*!! 4.D "*!" G,@ B,5D 9-,B;

:48F 9, I<1 J435;Q

Page 213: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 213/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C?D-91

E1 F, G,@ <;8455 3-49 ?.H,<I49?,. G,@

J<,K?L;L 9, G,@< 488,@.94.9 9, 4?L -?I ?. 8,IJ@9?.D

9-?M 84J?945 D4?.M 9<;49I;.9N

B1 O,@ P.,3= Q 9-?.P Q 9,5L -?I 3-49 Q -4L

:;;. 9,5L 9-; :4M?M 34M= ,< 4JJ<,R?I49; :4M?M 34M

H<,I C?8-4<L C435; 4.L 9-;. 9-; :4M?8 J<?8; Q M,5L

9-;I :48P 9, -?I H,<1 Q 9-?.P ?9 34M S(** 4.L S!#**

,. 9-; 93,1 Q9 8,@5L :; 5;MM 9-4. S(**= :@9 Q 9-?.P

?9 34M S(** H,< 9-; :4M?M1 2, Q D4K; 9-49

?.H,<I49?,. 9, IG 488,@.94.9= 4.L -; 8458@549;L 9-;

84J?945 D4?.M1

E1 2, :G 9-; :4M?M= G,@T<; <;H;<<?.D 9,

C?8-4<L C435;TM :4M?MN

B1 C?D-91

E1 7P4G1 B.L -,3 L?L G,@ D;9 9-49

?.H,<I49?,.N

B1 Q :;5?;K; Q 945P;L 9, -?I 4:,@9 ?9 49 M,I;

J,?.9 ?. 9?I; :;H,<; -; J4MM;L 434G= 4.L -; U@M9 D4K;

I; 4 <,@D- ;M9?I49; ,H 3-49 -; 9-,@D-9 ?9 3,@5L :;1

E1 +@M9 ,<455GN V-;<; ?M ., L,8@I;.949?,.N

B1 C?D-9= 9-;<; ?M ., L,8@I;.949?,.1

E1 B.L M, G,@ J<,K?L;L ., L,8@I;.949?,. 9,

G,@< 488,@.94.9N

B1 C?D-91 O,@ P.,3= Q P?.L ,H WW 3;55= -;

Page 214: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 214/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B?;B ,. C;1

D1 E?8-4<BF

G1 H; I4JJ;B 434K= 4.B ?9 34J J;L;<45 C,.9-J

4M9;< NN :;M,<; 9-49 3-;. O 945P;B 9, -?C= 4.B O

B?B.Q9 -4L; 4.K B,8@C;.949?,. M,< ?91

D1 7P4K1 2, 9-; R!*=(** .,949?,. ?.

>,5@C. S;T= 9-49 3,@5B U@J9 :; :4J;B ,. 3-49

E?8-4<B E435; 9,5B K,@= 4.B K,@ ?. 9@<. <;I,<9;B ?9

9, K,@< 488,@.94.9F

G1 V;4-1

D1 7P4K1 G.B 3?9- <;JI;89 9, >,5@C. SBT NN

G1 W-49 I4X; 3; ,. 4X4?.= :;84@J; O 5,J9 9-;

I4X;1

D1 (('1

G1 (('1 >,5@C. 3-49F

D1 (('1

G1 V;4-1 E?X-91 >,5@C. S;TF

D1 2,<<K1 V;4-= >,5@C. S;T1 Y4X; (('=

>,5@C. S;T1

Z-; R!%=&** I<,8;;BJ NN

G1 E?X-91

D1 NN -,3 34J 9-49 8458@549;BF

G1 Z-49 34J 4 I<?8; I;< 8,?.1 O 9-?.P ?9 34J

R!#** I;< 8,?. 9?C;J !"1 Z-; C49- O 9-?.P 8,C;J ,@9

9, !%N&1

Page 215: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 215/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC1 ADAAEF G-?<9HI9-<;;1

$%&'()(* ,, -./ 0.12%345 

J1 KLH B<1 A455?M 0N-?:?9 ## ?O 4. D88,@.9

P?O9,<H 9-49 3; ,:94?.;Q R<,S T;92U;.Q 9-<,@V-

2@:U,;.4= 4.Q E W@O9 34.9 9, 345X 9-<,@V- 9-?O= ?R E

84.= 3?9- H,@= 4.Q E 34.9 9, R,8@O ,. 9-; 9-?<Q

8,5@S. R<,S 9-; <?V-9= 9-; ><;Q?9 8,[email protected]

D1 7X4H1

J1 D.Q 9-; 34H EYS <;4Q?.V 9-?O ?O 9-49 9-,O;

4<; 9-; Q;U,O?9O ,< 9-; 8<;Q?9O 9, 9-; Q;:?9 84<Q1

D1 7X4H1

J1 E. ,9-;< 3,<QO= 9-; 4S,@.9 ,R S,.;H 9-49

34O 5,4Q;Q ,.9, 9-; Q;:?9 84<Q1

D1 C?V-91

J1 7X4H1 2, ?9 5,,XO 5?X;= W@O9 V,?.V

9-<,@V- 9-?O Z@?8X5H= ,. +@.; !O9 ,R Y!! 9-;<; 34O 4

[!%** 4S,@.9 5,4Q;Q ,.9, 9-; 84<Q= 8,<<;89\

D1 2@<; 5,,XO 5?X; ?9= H;O1

J1 D.Q 9-;. ,. &I"'I!! [!)**= 4.Q ?R H,@

8,.9?.@; 9-<,@V- 9-?O H,@ 84. O;; 3-49 9-; 4S,@.9O

U4?Q 3;<;1

D1 >,<<;891

J1 BH Z@;O9?,. ?O ?R 9-;O; II .,3= 4O E

@.Q;<O9,,Q H,@< U<?,< 9;O9?S,.H= 9-; U4HS;.9 R,< 9-;

8,?.O 34O 9-; 4S,@.9 9-49 >-;8X >?9H U@9 ,. H,@<

Page 216: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 216/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B;92C;.D D;:?9 84<D= <?E-9F

G1 H?E-91

I1 J?D K,@ 8,<<;549; 9-; 9,945 ,L 9-; 4M,@.9

C@9 ,. 9-; B;92C;.D D;:?9 84<D 9, >,5@M. NDO ,L K,@<

94P <;9@<.F

G1 Q;55= K,@ R.,3= 9-; C<,:5;M ?S 9-49 T 5,S9

MK D;:?9 84<D ?. 9-; SC<?.E ,L "*!!= 4.D T R.;3 9-;<;

34S 4 5?995; M,.;K 5;L9 ,. 9-49 84<D= 4.D 5?R; T 9,5D

K,@ :;L,<;= T 34S 5,8R;D ,@91 T 8,@5D.U9 E;9

?.L,<M49?,. 4:,@9 MK 488,@.9 :;84@S; T 34S 5,8R;D ,@9

,L MK 488,@.9= 4.D S, T 9-,@E-9 9-49 T M?E-9 -4V;

E,99;. C4?D WW T M?E-9 -4V; E,99;. M,<; 9-4. 9-;

V45@; ,L 9-; 8,?.S= 4.D 9-49US S9?55 ?. 9-49 D;:?9

488,@.9= S, MK ?.9;.9?,. 34S ?L ?9 34S M,<; 9-4. 9-;

!%W&= 9-49 T 3,@5D <;[email protected] 9-49 9, 9-; 8,MC4.K= 3-?8-

T -4V;.U9 D,.; K;91

TS 9-49 9-; 4.S3;< 9, K,@< X@;S9?,.F YK

?.9;.9 34S 9, 8,<<;549; 9-; C4KM;.9 L,< 9-; 8,?.S 9,

9-; 489@45 8,?.S 9-49 T 34S S;55?.E1

I1 Q,@5D ?9 :; 488@<49; 9, S949; 9-49 9-;

Z!%=&** ?. >,5@M. N;O ,L K,@< 94P <;9@<. 34S 4.

;S9?M49;F

G1 Q;55= .,= :;84@S; WW T D,.U9 9-?.R ?9 34S1

T 9-?.R 9-49 9-49 34S 3-49 T ?.9;.D;D 9, S;55 9-;

8,?.S L,<= Z!#** 4 8,?.= 3-?8- 3,@5D 9,945 !%W&= S,

Page 217: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 217/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9-;<; 34B 4 C?DD;<;.8; :;93;;. 9-; !%E& 4.C F 9-?.G

9-; 9,945 4H,@.9 9-;I J@9 ?. 9-49 488,@.9= 3-?8- F

9-?.G ;.C;C @J :;?.K L!'=*** ?.B9;4C ,D !%E&1 M-;<;

34B 4:,@9 4 L!$** C?DD;<;.8;1

2, F 4H N@B9 B?HJ5I 34?9?.K 9, 488;BB 9-49

488,@.9 4K4?. 9, K;9 9-49 H,.;I :48G 9, 9-;H 4.C 9,

J4I 9-;H :48G 9-; ;O9<4 H,.;I 9-49 -4C :;;. J@9 ?.

9-49 488,@.9 3-?8- F C?C.P9 BJ;.C1

Q1 R?C 9-49 -4JJ;.S

T1 U,1 U,= ?9 -4B.P9 -4JJ;.;C I;91 F

D?.455I K,9 4 .;3 C;:?9 84<C 9-?B 54B9 3;;G= 4.C FP55

:; 4:5; 9, @B; 9-49 84<C 9, J4I 9-;H :48G1

Q1 T.C EE

T1 M-49 34B HI J54.1

Q1 FD I,@ 5,,G 49 9-; 54B9 J4K; ,D

0O-?:?9 ##= ?9 5,,GB 5?G; 9-; 54B9 C;:?9 ,. 9-?B 84<C

34B V;:<@4<I "% ,D "*!"1

T1 7G4I1

Q1 2, I,@ ,:W?,@B5I C?C.P9 5,B; ?9 :;D,<;

9-;.= <?K-9S

T1 X;55= F <;455I 8,@5C.P9 9;55 I,@1 F 84.P9

9;55 I,@ ;O4895I 3-;. F 5,B9 9-; 84<C :;84@B; F N@B9

C,.P9 <;H;H:;<1

Q1 7G4I1

T1 Y@9 ?9 34B B,H;9?H; ?. 9-; BJ<?.K ,D "*!"

Page 218: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 218/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

3-;. B 5,C9 9-; 84<D1

E1 F.D 3-;. G,@ 5,C9 9-; 84<D= 3-49 D?D G,@

D,H B I;4.= D?D G,@ 8,.9489 C,I;,.;H J?D G,@ KK

F1 L;C1 B 8,.9489;D M;92N;.D1

E1 F.D -,3 D?D G,@ 8,.9489 9-;IH

F1 OG 9;5;N-,.;= ,< :G B.9;<.;91 B D,.P9

<;I;I:;<1 B 8,.9489;D 9-; 8,IN4.G= 9-,@Q-1 B 5;9

9-;I R.,3 B 5,C9 IG 84<D1

E1 F.D 3-49 D?D 9-;G 9;55 G,@H

F1 S-;G C4?D 9-49 9-;G 3,@5D 84.8;5 9-; 84<D

4.D C;.D I; ,@9 4 .;3 84<D1

E1 F.D B 94R; ?9 9-;G 3;<;.P9 T;<G N<,IN9 ?.

D,?.Q 9-49H

F1 U;55= .,1 S-;G D?D= :@9 ?9 34C <;9@<.;D

V,< C,I; <;4C,.= 4.D B D?D.P9 ;T;< Q;9 ?9 @.9?5 4

I,.9- 549;<= 4.D B :;5?;T; :G 9-?C 9?I; B 34C ?. 9-;

I?DD5; ,V IG 84IN4?Q.= C, 4 5,9 ,V 9-?.QC 3;<;

-?99?.Q 49 9-49 9?I; 4.D N<;99G :@CG1 2, 3-;. B Q,9

4<,@.D 9, ?9 4.D .,9?8;D ?9 -4D.P9 8,I;= B 8455;D

9-;I :48R 4.D C4?D= WU-;<;PC IG 84<DHW F.D 9-;G

C4?D= WU;55= 3; C;.9 9-; 84<D 4.D ?9 34C <;9@<.;D 9,

@C= X;9@<. 9, 2;.D;<1W B C4?D= WX;455GH B D?D.P9

Q;9 ?9= C, 3,@5D G,@ N5;4C; C;.D I; 4.,9-;< 84<DHW

F.D C, B 34?9;D 4Q4?. V,< 4.,9-;< I,.9- ,<

93, 4.D .,9-?.Q -4NN;.;D1 2, B 8455;D 9-;I 4Q4?.=

Page 219: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 219/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4.B 9-;C D4?B ?9 34D 45D, <;9@<.;B 9, @D1 E;F<;

85,D?.G C,@< 488,@.9 4.B 3;F<; H@99?.G 4 -,5B ,< 4

I<;;J; ,< D,K;9-?.G ,. C,@< 488,@.9= 4.B L M@D9 G,9

3<4HH;B @H 3?9- 9-; 84KH4?G. 4.B M@D9 I,<G,9 ?91

N-49FD O?.B ,I 3-49 -4HH;.;B1 0P;. 4D

<;8;.95C 4D 4 K,.9- 4G, 3-;. L 945O;B 9, 9-;K 9-;C

D4?B= Q<1 23455,3= 3; 84..,9 G;9 C,@ 9-49 ?.I,<K49?,.

:;84@D; C,@FP; :;;. 5,8O;B ,@9 ,I C,@< 488,@.9= 4.B L

I?.455C G,9 4-,5B ,I D,K;,.; 4:,@9 4 3;;O 4.B 4 -45I

4G, 9-49 D4?B 9-49 9-;C 3,@5B 85,D; 9-; 488,@.9=

?DD@; K; 4 .;3 84<B= 9<4.DI;< 9-; K,.;C I<;; ,I

8-4<G; ?.9, 9-; .;3 488,@.9= 3-?8- 3,@5B 9-;. 5;9 K;

H4C :48O >-;8O >?9C 4.B 3;F55 D;.B C,@ 3-49 3; 84. ,I

C,@< 9<4.D489?,.D1

R1 7O4C1 2, 49 9-; 9?K; C,@ D9<@8O 9-; B;45

3?9- S?8-4<B S435; 9, D;55 :48O 9-;D; 8,?.D= B?B C,@

4G<;; ,. 4 H<?8;T

U1 V;D1 L9 34D W!#** 4 8,?.1

R1 7O4C1 U.B D, 84. C,@ D4C 3-;9-;< XX 3?9-

<;I;<;.8; 9, 0Y-?:?9 ##= 9-; 9?K;D 49 3-?8- K,.;C 34D

5,4B;B ,.9, C,@< 84<BT E4D 9-49 9-; ;Y8-4.G; B49;

3-;<; C,@ 3;<; G?P?.G -?K :48O 4 8,?. 4.B -; 34D

H4C?.G C,@T

U1 Z,1 L9 B?B.F9 -4HH;. 9-49 H<;8?D;5C1 2,

L 3,@5B 8455 -?K 3-;. 9-; 488,@.9 G,9 5,31 L D4?B=

Page 220: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 220/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

BC .;;D 4.,9-;< D;E,F?91 CG55 :<?.H F,I; 8,?.F :J=B

4.D F,I;9?I; ?. 9-; .;K9 L;3 3;;MF 3;GD H;9 9,H;9-;<=

H, 9, [email protected] ,< F,I;9-?.H= 4.D CGD H?N; -?I 4 L;3

8,?.F= 4.D 9-49 -4EE;.;D 9-<,@H-,@9 9-; ;.D ,L "*!!

4.D ?.9, "*!"1

O1 7M4J1

P1 QJ 9-; 9?I; R;:<@4<J ,< S4<8- ,L "*!" 84I;

CGD H?N;. -?I 455 ,L 9-; 8,?.F1

O1 T-49GF 8,.L@F?.H I; ?F CGI .,9

@.D;<F94.D?.H 9-; I49- -;<;1

P1 7M4J1

O1 T-;. J,@ F4J 9-; 8,?.F= -; 34F H,?.H 9,

:@J 9-;I :48M L,< U!#** 4E?;8;V

P1 W?H-91

O1 Q@9 J;9 3;GN; H,9= X@F9 ,. 9-; L?<F9 E4H;=

9-; L?<F9 D;E,F?9 ?F U!%**= 9-; F;8,.D ?F U!)**1

P1 W?H-91

O1 Y-49GF 5?M; ,.; 4.D F,I; L<489?,. ,L

4.,9-;<1

P1 Z;4-1 T; D?D.G9 D, ?9 [[ 9-; I,.;J 9-49

34F 8,I?.H ?. 3; 3;<; M;;E?.H 9<48M ,L1 Y-; H,45 34F

9, [[ C M.;3 C -4D !" 8,?.F 9, F;55= 4.D C D?D.G9

M.,3 -,3 I@8- I,.;J C 3,@5D .;;D 9-<,@H-,@9 9-; J;4<

?.9, 9-; ;4<5J E4<9 ,L .;K9 J;4<= 4.D F, ?9 34F 3-49

C .;;D 9, F;55 C 3?55 F;551 T;G55 M;;E 9<48M ,L

Page 221: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 221/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

9-49= 4.B 9-;. 49 9-; ;.B 3-;. CDE B,.;= ?F C G;55

9-;E 455= 9-;. 3;D55 E4H; G@<; 3; -4I; 4

<;8,.8?5?49?,.1

2, 9-; 4E,@.9G 9-49 C <;8;?I;B 3;<; .,9

J!#** ;I;<K 9?E; C G,5B 4 8,?.= G, 9-49 3,@5B :;

J!#** 4.B J"&**= G, C @.B;<G94.B 3-K K,@D<;

L@;G9?,.?.M 3-49 K,@D<; L@;G9?,.?.M= :@9 9-49DG .,9

-,3 3; B?B ?91 C 3,@5B N@G9 G4K C .;;B 4.,9-;< OO

3-49 B, K,@ 8455 ?9 OO 4E,@.9 ,F E,.;K ,. 9-; 84<B=

4.B CD55 :<?.M K,@ 4 8,@P5; ,F 8,?.G ?. 4 F;3 3;;HG=

4.B 3;DB 9<K 9, 5,,G;5K H?.B ,F H;;P 9<48H 4G 3; 3;.9

9-; 4E,@.9 9-49 C 34G <;8;?I?.M 4.B 9-; 4E,@.9 C 34G

M?I?.M -?E1

Q.B 4.,9-;< 9-?.M K,@D55 .,9?8; ?G 9-49

9-; 94R <;9@<. -4G 455 !" 8,?.G ,. "*!" ?.G9;4B ,F ,.

"*!! 4.B "*!"= 4.B 9-49DG G?EP5K :;84@G;= K,@ H.,3= C

9-,@M-9 C :;99;< 94H; 84<; ,F 9-;G; 84P?945 M4?.G ,.

9-?G= 4.B C M,9 ?9 94H;. 84<; ,F ?. "*!"1

S1 2, 3-, B;9;<E?.;B 9-; 4E,@.9G 9-49 3;<;

5,4B;B ,.9, K,@< 84<B 49 9-;G; I4<?,@G ?.9;<I45GT

Q1 U,@ H.,3= C B?B.D9 OO C B,.D9 <;8455 9-491

C B,.D9 9-?.H C GP;8?F?8455K G4?B C .;;B J!%** .,3=

:@9 ?9 G;;EG 5?H; 4 5,9 ,F 9-;E 3;<; J!%**= G,E; 3;<;

J!(**1

C 9-?.H C G?EP5K N@G9 G4?B 9, V?8-4<B C

Page 222: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 222/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!!

.;;B C,D; D,<; ,. 9-; 84<B= 4.B E 9-?.F -; 3,@5B= 4C

E <;8455= 8455 >,<9 ,< 945F 9, >,<9= 4.B >,<9 3,@5B

5,4B 9-49 4D,@.9 ,. 9-; 84<B1

G1 2, 34C ?9 H,@ 3-, B;9;<D?.;B 9-; 4D,@.9 ,<

I?8-4<BJ

K1 I?8-4<B1

G1 7F4H1 K.B B, H,@ F.,3 ,. 3-49 :4C?C -;

B;9;<D?.;B 9-; 4D,@.9J

K1 E B,.L91

G1 M-;. H,@ B?B H,@< 94N <;9@<.= B?B H,@ F.,3

49 9-49 9?D; 9-49 9-; 4D,@.9 ,O D,.;H H,@LB <;8;?P;B

,. H,@< Q;92R;.B 84<B 34C S<;49;< 9-4. T!%=&**J

K1 E B,.L9 F.,3 ?O E F.;3 9-; ;N489 4D,@.9 ?9

34C1 E 9-?.F E F.;3 9-49 E <;8;?P;B 4 5?995; D,<;

9-4. 9-; P45@; ,O 9-; 8,?.C= :@9 E B?B.L9 F.,3 -,3

D@8- D,<;1

G1 U?B H,@ 4CF >-;8F >?9H 9, <@. H,@ 4

<;R,<9J

K1 Q,= E B?B.L9= 4.B E 489@455H VV E

489@455H VV 9-; ,.5H 34H E 84. ;NR54?. ?9 ?C 9-;

8,.9;N9 ,O 9-; :@CH C;4C,. ?9 34C O<,D 4:,@9= H,@

F.,3= W4<8- ,O "*!" 9-<,@S- 9-; 9?D; E 3,. 9-;

;5;89?,. ?. Q,P;D:;<1 U@<?.S 9-49 R;<?,B ,O 9?D; ELB

5,C9 VV .,9 5,C91 E -4B.L9 <;8;?P;B 9-; 84<B 93?8;1

E S,9 :@CH 3?9- ,9-;< 9-?.SC 4.B X@C9 F?.B ,O O,<S,9

Page 223: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 223/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

4:,@9 ?9 4.B C?DE5F ?.9;.B;B 9, <;8,.8?5; 4.F

B?GG;<;.8; 3-;. H I,9 DF 84<BC <;C,5J;B 4.B I,9

9-?.IC B,.;= 4.B 9-;. 9-?C -4EE;.;B1

K,@ 4CL;B D; ?G H B;8?B;B -,3 D@8- H

<;8;?J;B ;J;<F 9?D;= 4.B 9-; 4.C3;< ?C C9?55 .,1

H9MC 9-49 H .;J;< L.;3 I,?.I G,<34<B G<,D 9-; 9?D; 3;

B;8?B;B HMB C;55 9-,C; 8,?.C :48L ;N4895F -,3 D4.F

8,?.C HMB ;.B @E C;55?.I= 4.B C, H B?B.M9 34.9 9, I;9

,@9 9,, G4< 4-;4B ,G DFC;5G ?. 84C; H B?B.M9 G;;5

5?L; H 34C I,?.I 9, @C; 9-; 3-,5; J45@; ,G 9-; !"

8,?.C= C, H 9-?.L 9-49MC 3-F ?9 34C 4 D?.?D45 4D,@.9

;J;<F 9?D; <49-;< 9-4. O%=*** 49 4 9?D;= G,< ;N4DE5;1

P?8-4<B Q@C9 C4?B 4C F,@ .;;B D,<; 5;9 D; L.,3= 3;M55

L;;E 9<48L ,G 9-; 8,?.C= 5;G9,J;< 8,?.C1

R1 S-;. F,@ 9;C9?G?;B E<;J?,@C5F 4 3;;L ,< C,

4I,= F,@ C4?B 9-49 9-;<; 3;<; 9-<;; ,< G,@< ,884C?,.C

3-;<; F,@ I4J; -?D 9-; 8,?.C1

T1 P?I-91

R1 U-49 ?9 34C.M9 Q@C9 ,.; 49 4 9?D;= <?I-9V

T1 P?I-91

R1 T.B ;J;.9@455F F,@ I4J; -?D 455 !"= <?I-9V

T1 P?I-91

R1 W,3 B?B F,@ G?<C9 D;;9 +;<;DF +,-.C,.V

T1 H D;9 -?D ?. >45?G,<.?4 49 -?C ,GG?8;1 H

G5;3 B,3. 9-;<; ,. 4 8,DD;<8?45 E54.;1 S; D;9 -?D ?.

Page 224: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 224/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

24.94 B,.?84 49 -?C ,DD?8;C1

E1 F-49 34C 9-; G@<G,C; D,< 9-; H?C?9I

J1 K 34.9;L 9, M;;9 -?M1 KNL -;4<L 4 5,9

4:,@9 -?M1 K O.;3 -; O.;3 B4<O 2-@<95;DD 3;55= 4.L K

34.9;L 9, P;9 9, O.,3 -?M D,< G@<G,C;C ,D -;5G?.P

B4<O 2-@<95;DD <4?C; M,.;Q D,< -?C 84MG4?P. 4.L 45C,

D,< 9-; <4?.M4O?.P ,GG,<9@.?9?;C D,< M; 4C 4 543Q;<1

E1 2, 4 :@C?.;CC L;H;5,GM;.9 O?.L ,D 8455I

J1 R?P-91 S,9-1

E1 T?L Q,@ C4Q 3-49 Q;4< 9-?C 34CI

J1 KNM P@;CC?.P .,31 K9 34C G<,:4:5Q

C,M;9?M; ?. 9-; ;.L ,D "**(= 9-; D455= D455 ,D "**(=

;4<5Q UU 549; "**(1

E1 T?L C,M;,.; M4O; 4. ?.9<,L@89?,. ,< L?L

Q,@ V@C9 8,5L 8455 -?MI

J1 K L,.N9 <;84551 K L?L.N9 V@C9 C-,3 @G ,.

-?C L,,<C9;G1 K 5;9 -?M O.,3 KNL :; 8,M?.P L,3.= C,

K M4Q -4H; 945O;L 3?9- -?M ,. 9-; G-,.;1 K M4Q -4H;

;H;. M;9 -?M ;4<5?;< 4.L -4L C-4O;. -?C -4.L ,<

C,M;9-?.P1 K L,.N9 <;8455= :@9 -; O.;3 K 34C 8,M?.P=

4.L K L,.N9 <;8455 ;W4895Q 3-;. UU Q,@ O.,3= 3-49

,884C?,. 5;L M; 9, M;;9 -?M 9-; D?<C9 9?M; ,< CG;4O

3?9- -?M ,. 9-; G-,.; D,< 9-; D?<C9 9?M;1

E1 F-49= ?D 4.Q9-?.P= <;C@59;L D<,M 9-49

D?<C9 M;;9?.P ?. -?C ,DD?8;I

Page 225: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 225/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

B1 C; D94<9;E 9, F,<G 4 <;549?,.D-?H1 I; 34D

4 J,@.K ;.9<;H<;.;@<= L;<J D@88;DDF@5 ?. 291 M;,<K;1

NOE K<,3. @H ?. 291 M;,<K;= 4.E GJ H<?G4<J <;4D,. F,<

G;;9?.K 3?9- -?G 34D 9, K;9 9, P.,3 -?G 4D D,G;,.;

3-, 34D -;5H?.K Q4<P 2-@<95;FF <4?D; G,.;J F,< -?D

E;:9 <;9?<;G;.9 84GH4?K. ?. "**( 4.E E;:9 <;9?<;G;.9

4F9;< 9-49 4.E 9-;. -?D 2;.49; 84GH4?K. ?. "*!*1

R1 B.E -,3 E?E 9-; <;549?,.D-?H K<,3 F<,G

9-49 H,?.9 3?9- +;<;GJ +,-.D,.S

B1 C;55= D, ?9 P?.E ,F T@D9 K<;3

?.8<;G;.9455J 4D 3; DH;.9 G,<; 9?G; 9,K;9-;<1

R1 B.E 9-49OD P?.E ,F 3-49 N 34.9 9, K;9 49

?D E?E J,@ F,<G 4 F<?;.ED-?HS U?E J,@ K, 9, [email protected]

3?9- -?GS U?E J,@ G;;9 3?9- -?G ,.8; 4 J;4<S 7.8; 4

G,.9-S

>4. J,@ K?L; G; 4 D;.D; ,F 9-49S

B1 C;55= -; 3,<P;E H<;99J G@8- F@55 9?G; ?.

>45?F,<.?4= 4.E N 34D ?.9;<;D9;E ?. K;99?.K 9, P.,3

-?G 4.E -?D 8,GH4.J= D, -; 489@455J 4<<4.K;E F,< G;

9, F5J E,3. 9, 291 M;,<K; ,. -?D T;91 I; F5;3 -?D

T;9 @H -;<; 9, 2459 A4P; N.9;<.49?,.45 4.E F5;3 G;

E,3. F,< 4 E4J 49 -?D ,FF?8;D1

C-;. N D4J -?D ,FF?8;D= 9-; NVC,<PD

,FF?8;D 3;<; ?. 291 M;,<K;= 4.E -; -4E ,FF?8;D ?.

24.94 Q,.?84= 4.E N <;455J .;L;< @.E;<D9,,E= J,@

Page 226: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 226/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

B.,3= 9-; <;45 <;549?,.C-?D= ;E8;D9 F @.G;<C94.G -;

34C 9-; C,5; ,3.;< ,H FIJ,<BC1

K1 L.G C, G?G M,@ :;8,N; C,8?45 H<?;.GCO

L1 J;55= 3; G?G P, 9, G?..;< ,. ,884C?,.1 F

3,@5G.Q9 C4M 9-49 3; 3;<; C,8?45 H<?;.GC1 A?B; F

C4?G= 3; -4G G?..;<1 F 3;.9 9, -?C 8,ND4.M1 R;

C-,3;G N; ;S;<M9-?.P 9-49 9-;M 3,<B;G ,.= 9-;M G?G1

F B?.G ,H T@C9 B?8B;G 9-; 9?<;C 4 5?995;

:?9 H,< U4<B 2-@<95;HH 9-49 H?<C9 N;;9?.P F 34C G,3.

9-;<;= 3;.9 9, [email protected] 3?9- -?C >07 ,< D<;C?G;.9 ,H 9-;

8,ND4.M ,H FIJ,<BC1 V,@ B.,3= F 3,@5G C4M 3; 3;<; ?.

8,.9489 49 5;4C9 ,.8; 4 N,.9-= 4.G ?H F 34C G,3. ?.

291 W;,<P; 4.G -; 34C ?. 291 W;,<P;= 3;QG P, 9,

G?..;<1 J; :;84N; H<?;.GC1

K1 7B4M1 L.G G?G M,@ ;S;< ;.G @D G,?.P 5;P45

3,<B H,< -?NO

L1 F ;.G;G @D .,9 G,?.P 4.M 5;P45 3,<B H,<

-?N1

K1 X?G M,@ C,5?8?9 84ND4?P. 8,.9<?:@9?,.C

H<,N -?N ;?9-;< H,< M,@<C;5H ,< H,< ,9-;< D;,D5;O

L1 F G?G H,< ,9-;< D;,D5;1 F G?G.Q9 H,<

NMC;5H1

K1 L.G 3-M 3,@5G M,@ G, ?9 H,< ,9-;< D;,D5;

:@9 .,9 H,< M,@<C;5HO

L1 YM 9-; 9?N; F G;8?G;G 9, <@. H,<

Page 227: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 227/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

B99,<.;C D;.;<45= -; 45<;4EC -4E -?F G<,:5;HF= 4.E ?9

34F ,:I?,@F 9-49 -; 3,@5E.J9 :; 8,.9<?:@9?.K 4.C

H,.;C1

L1 M-CN O;84@F; -?F 4FF;9F -4E :;;. F;?P;E

,< QQ

B1 M;55= ,.8; -;JE :;;. F@;E :C 9-; RS>= C,@

T.,3= .,9 ,.5C 3;<; -?F 4FF;9F F;?P;E= :@9 ?9 5,,T;E

5?T; -; -4E <;45 G<,:5;HF1 O;U,<; 9-;. ?9 E?E.J9

5,,T 5?T; 9, H; -; -4E <;45 G<,:5;HF1 V 9-,@K-9 -;

34F 4 F9<4?K-9 @G E;8,<49;E :@F?.;FFH4. ?. W94-= -4E

E,.; 4 5,9 ,U G-?54.9-<,G?8 9-?.KF U,< G;,G5; 4.E 34F

I;<C ?.I,5I;E ?. 9-; X4?9?4. <;F8@; ,. 9-; ;4<9-Y@4T;

4.E 34F Z@F9 4 F9<4?K-9 @G :@F?.;FFH4.1

7.8; -; K,9 ?. 9<,@:5;= -; 34F F,H;,.;

9-49 V 34F.J9 ?.9;<;F9;E ?. <4?F?.K H,.;C U<,H= 4.E V

E,.J9 9-?.T 4.C:,EC ;5F; 34F ;?9-;<1

L1 O;U,<; -; K,9 ?. 9<,@:5; QQ V 4FF@H; 9-;

9<,@:5; C,@J<; <;U;<<?.K 9, 34F 9-; RS>

?.I;F9?K49?,.N

B1 M;55= 9-49JF 3-;. ?9 F94<9;E= :@9 .,3 -;JF

:;;. ?.E?89;E1

L1 [?K-91

\[1 2]7M^ V 9-?.T -; F4?E ,.8; -; K,9

F@;E :C 9-; RS>1

SX0 MVS]022^ M;55= 9-49 34F HC ?.9;.91

Page 228: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 228/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

BC1 2D7EF B4G:; 9-;<;HI .,9 4 J?KK;<;.8;

9-;<;1

L1 MNG B<1 A455?O P,3 J?J G,@ K?<I9 5;4<.

4:,@9 9-; QR> ?.S;I9?T49?,. ,K +,-.I,. 4.J -?I

8,UV4.GW

X1 Y :;5?;S; -; 9,5J U;1

L1 Z, G,@ <;8455 9-; 8,.9;[9 ,K 9-;

8,.S;<I49?,.W

X1 Y J,.H91

L1 Z, G,@ <;8455 9-; 9?U;W

X1 +@I9 9-?.\?.T :48\= ?9 3,@5J -4S; V<,:4:5G

:;;. 9-; K455 ,K "*!*1

L1 D,3= Y @.J;<I94.J 49 I,U; V,?.9 G,@ U4J;

4. ?.9<,J@89?,. ,K +,-.I,. 9, C?8-4<J C435;= 8,<<;89W

X1 ];I1

L1 E4I 9-49 9-; K?<I9 9?U; G,@HJ -;4<J 4:,@9

-?I V<,:5;UI 3?9- 9-; QR> ,< 34I 9-;<; 4 V<?,<

,884I?,.W

X1 Y :;5?;S; 9-;<; 34I 4 V<?,< ,884I?,. 4.J

9-49= G,@ \.,3= 9-; X99,<.;G ^;.;<45 4.J UGI;5K 4.J

7<<?. P498- U;9 3?9- +;<;UG +,-.I,. Y :;5?;S; :;K,<;

Y U4J; 9-; ?.9<,J@89?,. 9, C?8-4<J C435; 4:,@9 9-;

QR> -;5V= Y :;5?;S;= :@9 ?9HI :;;. 5,.T ;.,@T- 9-49

YHU .,9 _@?9; I@<;1

L1 R-; U;;9?.T 3?9- G,@ 4.J B4<\ 2-@<95;KK

Page 229: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 229/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!!"

4.B 7<<?. C498-= 3-;<; 4.B 3-;. B?B 9-49 ,88@<D

E1 F9 -4GG;.;B H,I;9?I; ?. E@J@H9 ,<

2;G9;I:;< ,K "*!* 49 9-; ,KK?8;H ,K 2;.49,< C498-

-;<; ?. 2459 A4L;1

M1 N-, 8455;B 9-49 I;;9?.JD

E1 F 9-?.L O4<L 2-@<95;KK1

M1 N-49 34H 9-; G@<G,H; ,K 9-; I;;9?.JD

E1 EH F <;8455= +;<;IP +,-.H,. 34.9;B 9,

;QG54?. 9, 2;.49,< C498- 9-; RS> 34H .,9 5?H9;.?.J 9,

-?I= 9-49 9-;P B?B.T9 @.B;<H94.B 3-49 -?H :@H?.;HH

34H B,?.J= 4.B -; 34.9;B H,I;,.; 5?L; 2;.49,< C498-

9, I4P:; <;48- ,@9 9, 9-; RS> 4.B 4HL 9-;I 9, 49

5;4H9 H?9 B,3. 3?9- -?I 4.B @.B;<H94.B 3-49 -?H

8,IG4.P 34H B,?.J= 4.B -; -4B U@H9 :<?8L 3455H H?.8;

9-;. VV G<?,< 9, 9-49 G,?.9 ?. 9?I;1

M1 F. 9-49 I;;9?.J 3;<; P,@ 4.B O<1 2-@<95;KK

489?.J ?. 4. ,KK?8?45 84G48?9P ?. :;-45K ,K 9-;

E99,<.;P W;.;<45TH ,KK?8;D

E1 F B,.T9 :;5?;X; H,= .,1

M1 F. 3-49 84G48?9P 3;<; P,@ 489?.JD

E1 EH K<?;.BH ,K +;<;IP +,-.H,.1

M1 >4. P,@ <;8455 -,3 9-; <;K;<<45 <;Y@;H9

84I; 4:,@9= 4.B :P 9-49 F I;4. 9-; <;K;<<45 9,

Z?8-4<B Z435;D

E1 N;55= F B,.T9 <;8455 HG;8?K?8455P1

Page 230: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 230/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 >4. C,@ <;8455 3-;9-;< ?9 34D C,@< ?E;4 ,<

-?DF

G1 H 9-?.I ?9 34D J?.;1

B1 G.E E, C,@ <;8455= E?E C,@ 8455 -?JF K?E

?9 -4LL;. 49 9-; J;;9?.M 3?9- 2;.49,< N498-F O4D

9-;<; D,J; ,9-;< ;P;.9F

G1 O;55= D, +;<;JC QQ +;<;JC -4E -4E D,J;

?.P,5P;J;.9 3?9- >-;8I >?9C L<?,< 9, 9-; 9?J; 3-;. H

D@MM;D9;E -; M?P; R?8-4<E R435; 4 8455 4.E D;; ?S

9-;C 34.9;E 9, 3,<I 9,M;9-;< ,. 9-; TU> L<,V;891

U-49 -4LL;.;E ;P;. :;S,<; H 34D ;JL5,C;E :C 9-;

,SS?8; ,S 9-; G99,<.;C W;.;<45= D, -; -4E 45<;4EC -4E

D,J; <;549?,.D-?L 3?9- D,J; ,S 9-; J;J:;<D ,S 9-49

8,JL4.C= 4.E H E,.X9 <;8455 9-; J,J;.9 H 945I;E 9,

R?8-4<E 4:,@9 9-49= :@9 H <;8455 D?99?.M E,3. 3?9-

R?8-4<E ,P;< [email protected] D,J;9?J;= J4C:; 945I?.M 4:,@9

D,J;9-?.M ;5D;1

H9 34D 4:,@9 9-; 9?J; 3-;. H M,9 D94<9;E

,. 9-; 8;J;.9 L<,V;89= D, ?9 3,@5E.X9 :; @.@D@45 S,<

-?J 4.E H 9, -4P; DL;.9 9?J; 9,M;9-;< 4.E V@D9 D4?E

HXP; M,9 4 S<?;.E= C,@ I.,3 -?J= 3-, ?D -4P?.M 4

L<,:5;J M;99?.M -?D D9,<C ?. S<,.9 ,S 9-; TU>= 4.E H

E,.X9 I.,3 J@8- 4:,@9 9-; TU> 4.E 9-; 5,::C?.M ,S 9-;

TU> 4.E H 84.X9 E, ?9 JCD;5S1

N; D4?E 9-49 -; -4E 5,::C?D9 <;549?,.D-?LD

Page 231: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 231/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

+;<;BC +,-.D,.= 3-, 34D -4E?.F D,B; 8,.8;<.D 3?9- 9-;

GH>1 I?D D949;B;.9 9, B; 34D JKE; DL;.9 4 B?55?,.

M,554<D ,. 543C;<D 9-49 -4E;.K9 F,99;. B; 4.C3-;<;=

4.M J D4?M -4E; C,@ 9-,@F-9 4:,@9= C,@ N.,3= B4C:;

-?<?.F 4 5,::C?D9 9, D;; ?O C,@ 84. B4C:; F;9 ?. 9-;

M,,< 9-49 34C= :;84@D; 455 -; 34.9;M 9, M, 34D 9;55

9-; D9,<C= 4.M -; 34D.K9 F;99?.F 4.C3-;<;1 2, J

M,.K9 N.,3 PP C,@< Q@;D9?,. 34DR

S1 JKB T@D9 3,.M;<?.F PP 3;55= 3-49 JKE;

@.M;<D9,,M C,@ 9, D4C ?D 9-49 9-; ?M;4 9, 4LL<,48-

I4<<C U;?M 34D .,9 C,@<D1

V1 U?F-91

S1 W@9 C,@ 45D, 9,5M B; ?9 34D C,@< ?M;4 9,

?.9<,M@8; -?B 9, U?8-4<M1

V1 X;D1

S1 V.M D, JKB 9<C?.F 9, O5@D- ,@9 9-;

O@55.;DD ,O C,@< ?M;41

JO C,@< ?M;4 34D .,9 9, -4E; U?8-4<M

D,B;-,3 F;9 9, I4<<C U;?M= 3-49 34D C,@< ?M;4R Y?M

?9 F, :;C,.M U?8-4<M ,< M?M C,@ T@D9 PP

V1 Z,1 VF4?.= -4E?.F 3,<N;M 3?9- U?8-4<M O,<

4 .@B:;< ,O C;4<D= J N.;3 9-49 -; 49 D,B; L,?.9= ?O

.,9 9-;.= 34D 9-; L@:5?8 4OO4?<D >-4?<B4. ,O 9-;

Z49?,.45 [4CM4C A;.M?.F VDD,8?49?,.= D, -; -4M

?.9;<O48;M Q@?9; 4 :?9= 4.M JKM 489@455C ?.9;<O48;M

Page 232: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 232/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

3?9- B,C; ,D 9-; .49?,.45 5,::E?B9B 3-;. F 3,<G;H

3?9- >-;8G >?9E 9-<,@I- CE D?<C= B, F :4B?8455E G.;3

J?8-4<H -4H 8,.9489B ?. K4B-?.I9,.1 F G.;3 9-49

+;<;CE 34B 5,,G?.I D,< B,C;,.; 4.H 49 5;4B9 ,L;. 9,

9-; ?H;4 ,D 5,,G?.I D,< B,C;,.; 9-49 8,@5H :; C4E:; 4

:;99;< <;B,@<8; 9, -?C 9-4. -?B 499,<.;EB 3;<;1 2, F

9-,@I-9 9-49 9-,B; 93, B-,@5H 945G 4.H B;; ?D 9-;E

8,@5H 3,<G ,@9 B,C;9-?.I 9-49 3,@5H 3,<G 4.H B,5M;

+;<;CENB L<,:5;CB 3?9- 9-; OP>1

Q1 FD .,9 2;.49,< J;?H= 3-, H?H E,@ ;.M?B?,.

3,@5H :; 5,::?;H :E J?8-4<H 4.H -?B 8,.9489BR

S1 F 9-?.G J?8-4<H -4H 9,5H C; 9-49 -; -4H 4

I,,H 8,.9489 3?9- 2;.49,< J;?H= 4 I,,H 5,::E?B9 D,<

2;.49,< J;?H= 4.H F 9-,@I-9 9-49 34B 4 I<;49 ?H;4= B,

F H?H.N9 <;455E I, C@8- D@<9-;< 9-4. 9-491

P-;<; 34B 4 C4. .4C;H P?C J@L5? 9-49 F

G.;3 D<,C CE H4EB 3,<G?.I ?. 9-; ?.H@B9<E1 F H?H.N9

G.,3 ;T4895E 3-, J?8-4<H 3,@5H :; @B?.I= :@9 FNC B@<;

-; 3,@5H -4M; 8,.B@59;H 3?9- U<1 J@L5? 4B 3;55= 3-,

34B 4 L4?H 5,::E?B9 ,< D@55V9?C; 5,::E?B9 D,< 9-;

W4EH4E A;.H?.I SBB,8?49?,. .49?,.455E1

Q1 SD9;< C4G?.I 9-; ?.9<,H@89?,. ,D +,-.B,.

4.H J435;= 3-49= ?D 4.E9-?.I= H?H E,@ H, ?.

D@<9-;<4.8; ,D 9-; 5,::E?.I ;DD,<9R

S1 K;55= F B?CL5E VV F G.,3 F L<;L4<;H 4.

Page 233: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 233/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

;BC4?5= 4 .,9;= ;?9-;< D,< +;<;CE BB F 9-?.G ?9 34H

D,< +;<;CE= 945G?.I 4:,@9 -,3 F 3,@5J K,H?9?,. -?H

499;CK9 9, I;9 4. 4@J?;.8; 3?9- 9-; LM> 4.J 3-49 F

3,@5J 945G 4:,@9= H, F G.,3 F -4J 49 5;4H9 9-49

?.N,5N;C;.91 OI4?.= 9-49 34H BB 9-49 34H 9, 4HH?H9

+;<;CE ?. -?H H9<49;IE1

PQ1 2R7ST F9UH :;;. 4:,@9 4. -,@< 4.J 4

-45D1 >4. 3; 94G; 4 :<;4GV

PQ1 AOAAFT 2@<;1

PQ1 2R7ST 7G4E1

MW0 XFY07ZQO[W0QT Z,?.I ,DD <;8,<J1 M-;

9?C; ?H #T*! K1C1

\Q;8;HH D<,C #T*! K1C1 9, #T!# K1C1]

$%&'()(* "# ,-. /-01%234 

MW0 XFY07ZQO[W0QT Q;9@<.?.I ,. 9-;

<;8,<J1 #T!# K1C1 ?H 9-; 9?C;1 >,@.H;51

^1 \_E P<1 A455?] 0`-?:?9 #$ ?H 4 H;<?;H ,D

;BC4?5H= 2;K9;C:;< ")= "*!*= 4.J F 34.9 9, J?<;89

E,@< 499;.9?,. 9, 9-; ,.; 9-49 :;I?.H ,. 9-; C?JJ5;

,D 9-; D?<H9 K4I; D<,C E,@ 9, +;<;CE +,-.H,.1

Y, E,@ H;; 9-49V

O1 M-49UH <?I-91

^1 F9 H4EH C;;9?.I 3?9- W4<<E Q;?JUH 8,.9489V

O1 Q?I-91

^1 O.J ?9 5,,GH 9, C; 5?G; :E 9-?H K,?.9 ?.

Page 234: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 234/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9?B; 9-; .,9?,. ,C 8,..;89?.D EE 3;55= 9-; .,9?,. ,C

9-; 94<D;9 ,C 9-; 5,::F?.D ;CC,<9 :;?.D G4<<F H;?I

-4I 45<;4IF :;;. I;9;<B?.;I1

JK 9-49 488@<49;L

M1 J9NK :;;. K, 5,.D= 8,@5I J EE

O1 P;K= Q5;4K; I,1

M1 R-4.SK1

TU?9.;KK ;V4B?.?.D I,8@B;.91W

RG0 UJRX022Y 7S4F1 P;K1 2, F,@<

Z@;K9?,. 34KL [F 9-?K 9?B; EE

O1 T[F \<1 A455?W 2@<;1 A,,SK 5?S; 9-;

.,9?,. ,C G4<<F H;?I :;?.D 9-; 94<D;9 ,C 9-; 5,::F?.D

;CC,<9 -4I :;;. I;9;<B?.;I1

R-49 34K 9-; D4B; Q54. :F 9-?K

Q,?.9 ?. 9?B;L

M1 U;55= 8;<94?.5F= F;4-1 J B;4.= J S.,3

9-49 :F 9-?K 9?B; J S.;3 9-49 H?8-4<I H435; S.;3 4

Q;<K,. 85,K; 9, G4<<F H;?I 4.I 9-49 H?8-4<I 9-,@D-9

?9 3,@5I :; 4 D,,I ?I;4 9, D, 9-<,@D- G4<<F H;?I=

F;K1

O1 H?D-91 M.I J 34.9 9, B4S; K@<; J D;9 9-;

8-<,.,5,DF 8,<<;89 4.I 45K, 3-, -4I 3-49 ?I;41

M1 2@<;1

O1 U-49 JNB @.I;<K94.I?.D F,@ 9, K4F ?K 3-;.

F,@ C?<K9 -4I 9-; ?I;4 ,C ?.9<,I@8?.D +;<;BF 9,

Page 235: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 235/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B?8-4<C D,< E,F; G?.C ,D 8,..;89?,.E HH

I1 B?J-91

K1 HH L,@ 3;<; E,F;3-49 M4J@; 4:,@9 3-49

9-,E; 8,..;89?,.E F?J-9 :;1 N,@ C?C.O9 -4M; ?.

F?.C HH

I1 P,= Q C?C.O9 -4M; ?. F?.C R4<<L B;?C1

K1 I.C R4<<L B;?C= 4E :;E9 L,@ 84. <;8455=

34E E,F;:,CL 3-, 34E HH 9-49 34E 4. ?EE@; <4?E;C :L

B?8-4<C ,< E,F;,.;= .,9 L,@S

I1 B?J-91

K1 7G4L1

I1 Q :;5?;M; ?9 34E <4?E;C :L B?8-4<C1

K1 T@9 :L 9-?E U,?.9 ?. 9?F;= 3-?8- ?E 549;

2;U9;F:;<= ,:M?,@E5L 9-49 -4C 45<;4CL -4UU;.;C1

B?8-4<C -4C <4?E;C 9-; ?C;4 ,D R4<<L B;?CS

I1 B?J-91

K1 I.C L,@ 4<; U<,U,E?.J 4 .4<<49?M; ?. 9-?E

;HF4?5 9-49 <;D;<E 9, 2;.49,< B;?C 4.C E;;?.J ?D -;

3,@5C :; 3?55?.J 9, ;.8,@<4J; VW> ?.M;E9?J49,<E 9,

94G; 4 85,E; 5,,G= 8,<<;89S

I1 B?J-91 Q :;5?;M; 9-49OE 8,<<;891

K1 I.C E, 3-49 QOF <;455L 9<L?.J 9,

@.C;<E94.C -;<; ?E 3-49 34E L,@< <,5; -;<;S Q F;4.=

?9 4UU;4<E 9, F; 9-49 ?9OE J,.; :;L,.C F;<;5L F4G?.J

4. ?.9<,C@89?,. 9, B?8-4<C B435; 9, 9-; U,?.9 3-;<;

Page 236: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 236/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B,@C<; D@EE;D9?.E 4 .4<<49?F;= :@9 3-49 34D B,@< <,5;

4D B,@ @.G;<D9,,G ?9H

I1 J;55= KB <,5;= L 34D M@D9 +;<;KB +,-.D,.CD

N<?;.G1 L ?.9<,G@8;G -?K 9, O?8-4<G O435;= 4.G

-4F?.E -4G ;PQ;<?;.8; KBD;5N 4D 4 5,::B?D9 ?. KB

Q<?,< Q<489?8; 4.G 84<?.E 4:,@9 +;<;KB +,-.D,. 4.G

@.G;<D94.G?.E -,3 -;CD -4F?.E 4 <;45 Q<,:5;K E;99?.E

?. N<,.9 ,N 9-; RS>= 4.G T.,3?.E 9-49 L 8,@5G.C9 G,

?9 KBD;5N :;84@D; ,N KB M,:= L 34.9;G 9, -;5Q -?K

@.G;<D94.G -,3 L K?E-9 Q,D?9?,. 9-?D ?N L 3;<; -?K 4D

4 N<?;.G1 U@9 KB <,5; VV

W1 2,K;9-?.E D,K;9-?.E66H

XO1 2Y7JZ LCK .,9 D@<; ?N 9-?D 34D 4

.4<<49?F; N,< [4<<B O;?G ,< 4 .4<<49?F; VV 4

.4<<49?F; N,< 9-; RS>1 LCK .,9 D@<; 3-, 9-49

.4<<49?F; 34D N,<1

S[0 JLSY022Z O?E-91 J;55= L T.,3 3-49 ?9

34D N,<1

XO1 2Y7JZ I55 <?E-91

S[0 JLSY022Z L9 34D D?KQ5B KB 4GF?8; 9,

+;<;KB 4D 4 N<?;.G1 [;<;CD -,3 L 3,@5G 9;55 KB D9,<B

?N L -4G 4 8-4.8; 9, E;9 ?. N<,.9 ,N 9-; RS>1

XO1 2Y7JZ \;4-1

S[0 JLSY022Z S-?D 34D .,9 ?.9;.G;G 9, E,

9, [4<<B O;?G1 S-?D 34D M@D9 4GF?8; 9, +;<;KB 4D 4

Page 237: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 237/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B<?;.C1

DE1 AFAAGH 7I4J1 D4J:; GKL

[email protected];<M94.C?.N 9-?M1

O1 PQJ D<1 A455?R S-; M@:T;89 ,B 9-; ;UL4?5

?M V4<<J E;?CKM 8,.9<489= ,< L;;9?.N 3?9-

V4<<J E;?CKM 8,.9<489= <?N-9W

F1 S-; 8,.9489 J,@ L;4.W

O1 >,.94891 2,<<J1 F.C 9-;. 9-; ;UL4?5

:;N?.MH XG MY,I; 3?9- E?8-4<C E435; 4:,@9 9-;

8,.9489 ?.B,<L49?,. B,< V4<<J E;?CKM N@J1

E?8-4<C ?M 9<4Z;5?.N 9, A4M [;N4M 9,L,<<,3 4.C 3?55

:; 4:5; 9, 8,.9489 9-?M Y;<M,.= 3-, -; -4M 4 Z;<J

N,,C <;549?,.M-?Y 3?9-1 V; .;;CM 4 :<?;B .4<<49?Z;

,B 3-49 ?M N,?.N ,. 4.C 3-49 J,@ 34.9 9, -4YY;.=X 4.C

9-;. ?B J,@ MI?Y C,3. 9, 9-; .;\9 Y4<4N<4Y-= 3-?8- ?M

T@M9 4. ?.9<,C@89,<J= ?9 M4JM= XV;<; ?M 9-; .4<<49?Z;

GKC Y<,Y,M;1X

], J,@ M;; 9-49W

F1 E?N-91

O1 GKL @.C;<M94.C?.N 9-?M 4M J,@ Y<,Y,M?.N

3-49 3,@5C :; M4?C 9, V4<<J E;?CKM N@J1

GM 9-49 ?.8,<<;89W

DE1 2^7_H F 5,::J?M9 3-, I.,3M

V4<<J E;?C1 GKL .,9 M@<; 3-49 J,@ L;4. :J

XV4<<J E;?CKM N@J1X

Page 238: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 238/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC1 ADAAEF G-49HI .,9 JK 9;<J?.,5,LK1

BC1 2M7NF O4<<K C;?PHI L@KQ

BC1 ADAAEF G-49HI -?I 9;<J?.,5,LK1 A,,R

49 9-; S?<I9 I;.9;.8;1

GO0 NEGM022F N;55= K;4-= I@<;1 E P,.H9

I;; 9-; :?L P;451 E J;4.= EHJ 9;55?.L K,@ 9-49 JK

T,?.9 ?. P<4S9?.L 9-?I 34I 9, 5;9 +;<;JK +,-.I,. R.,3

3-49 E 34I 9-?.R?.L 4:,@9 -,3 E 3,@5P T,I?9?,. 4

I9,<K 9, L;9 ?. S<,.9 ,S 9-; UG>1 G-49HI 3-K E I;.9

9-?I ;VJ4?5 9, +;<;JK +,-.I,.1 G-49HI 3-K E P?P.H9

W@I9 T?8R @T 9-; T-,.; ,< I;.P 9-?I ;VJ4?5 9, C?8-4<P

4.P I4K= C?8-4<P= 3-K P,.H9 K,@ W@I9 I4K 9-?I1

G-?I 34I .,9 JK VV 9-?I 34I .,9 JK

T<,W;891 G-?I 34I J; 9;55?.L 4 S<?;.P 9-<,@L- JK

;XT;<?;.8; 9-?I ?I -,3 E 3,@5P 4TT<,48- 9-?I ?II@;

3?9- 9-; UG> ,< 3?9- 9-; T;<I,. 3-,HI L,?.L 9, 945R

3?9- 9-; UG>1

Y1 Z[K B<1 A455?\ ]?P K,@ L?^; 4.K 4P^?8; ,<

94R; 4.K 489?,. ?. 8,..;89?,. 3?9- 9-?I 5,::K?.L

;SS,<9 4S9;< 9-?I T,?.9 ?. 9?J;= 2;T9;J:;< ")= "*!*Q

D1 E P,.H9 <;84551 2, P?P E ;^;< -4^; 4

8,.^;<I49?,.= S,< ;X4JT5;= 3?9- +;<;JK +,-.I,. 4:,@9

9-?I 4S9;< 9-?I T,?.9Q E P,.H9 <;84551 E P,.H9

<;J;J:;<1

Y1 7R4K1 D.P P, K,@ <;8455 IT;4R?.L 3?9-

Page 239: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 239/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4.B,.; ;5C; 4:,@9 ?9D

E1 F G,.H9 <;84551

IJ1 AEAAFK L-?<9BMN?O;1

$%&'()(* ,- ./0 1/23%456 

P1 QRB I<1 A455?S 0T-?:?9 #% ?C 4.

789,:;< '= "*!*= ;MU4?5 N<,U +;<;UB +,-.C,. 9,

J?8-4<G J435; <;V4<G?.V 2;.49,< J;?G= 4.G B,@H<; .,9

8,W?;G ,. 9-?C= :@9 ?9 <;N;<C 9, 4 8,.O;<C49?,.

:;93;;. +;<;UB 4.G B,@ 3-;<; 49 5;4C9 +,-.C,. ?C

C4B?.V= 4.G F X@,9;K YZ; C4?G B,@ U?V-9 -4O; C,U;

8,..;89?,.C 9, J;?G 9-49 3,@5G :; -;5WN@5 9, @C1Y

>4. B,@ <;8455 C@8- 4 8,.O;<C49?,. 3?9-

+;<;UB +,-.C,. ?. 3-?8- B,@ C4?G 9-49 J435; U4B -4O;

C,U; 8,..;89?,.C 9, J;?G 9-49 3,@5G :; -;5WN@5 9,

+,-.C,.D

E1 F G,.H9 [.,3 3-B F 3,@5G.H9 -4O; -4G 9-;

8,.O;<C49?,.1 F G,.H9 <;8455 9-?C CW;8?N?8

8,.O;<C49?,.= :@9 F MM B,@H<; 4C[?.V U; ?N F 4U

C4B?.V 9-49 +;<;UB +,-.C,. 8<;49;G 9-?C ,@9 ,N 9-?.

4?<1

F 9-?.[ 9-49 F 3,@5G -4O; 945[;G 9, +;<;UB

49 C,U; W,?.9 4.G C4?G 9-49= B,@ [.,3= J?8-4<G G?G

-4O; C,U; 8,..;89?,.C 9, J;?G :4C;G ,. 3-49 J?8-4<G

9,5G U;= 4.G 9-49HC O;<B 8,.C?C9;.9 3?9- 3-49 9-?C

W<?,< ;MU4?5 C4BC= #$1

Page 240: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 240/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1

E1 F@9 G H,.I9 <;J;J:;< 9-; KL;8?M?8

8,.N;<K49?,.= .,1

OP1 AEAAGQ R-?<9DSK?T1

$%&'()(* ,- ./0 1/23%456 

B1 UFD O<1 A455?V 0T-?:?9 #& ?K 4. ;SJ4?5=

789,:;< !!= "*!*= K?JL5D D,@ M,<34<H?.W 9, P?8-4<H

+;<;JD +,-.K,.IK 8,.9489 ?.M,<J49?,.X ?K 9-49 <?W-9Y

E1 A,,CK 5?C; ?91

B1 GIJ Z@K9 9<D?.W 9, 9<48C 9-; H49;K ,M 9-?K

661 [-49 GIJ <;455D ?.9;<;K9;H ?. C.,3?.W ,N;<455 ?K

3-49 D,@ H?H 4.H 3-;. D,@ H?H ?9 SS

E1 2@<;1

B1 SS 4.H 3-;. ?9 K9,LL;H1

E1 \;4-1

B1 2, Z@K9 9<D?.W 9, ;K94:5?K- 4 8-<,.,5,WD

-;<;1

$%&'()(* ,7 ./0 1/23%456 

B1 UFD O<1 A455?V 0T-?:?9 #' ?K 4

2;L9;J:;< !*= "*!*= ;SJ4?5 M<,J D,@ 9, P?8-4<H P435;

<;W4<H?.W ]R> 4KK?K94.8;= 4.H 5;9IK K94<9 49 9-;

:,99,J ,M 9-; L4W; 3?9- 4. ;SJ4?5 M<,J +,-.K,. 9,

P?8-4<H P435;= F<D8; ^4D.;= >,<9 [45C;< SS 489@455D=

9-49IK .,9 3-;<; ?9 K94<9K1 G9 K94<9K ;N;. M@<9-;<

H,3.1

Page 241: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 241/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

B9 C4DC ,. !"E!*E!* 49 !!F"! 41G1

H?8-4<I H435; 3<,9;F J+;<;GD1J B9 5,,KC 5?K;

9-;DL<; 945K?.M 4:,@9 .;M,9?49?.M C,G; K?.I ,N 4

I;54D1

O, D,@ C;; 9-49P

Q1 R;4-1 2, 3-?8- ;EG4?5 4<; D,@ 945K?.M

4:,@9P

S1 T-; U;<D :,99,G ,N 9-; V4M;1

Q1 W;<D :,99,GP 7K4D1

S1 B9LC N<,G H?8-4<I 9, +;<;GD1

Q1 7K4D1

S1 Q55 <?M-91 2, 5,,KC 5?K; 9-;DL<;

I?C8@CC?.M 9-; V,CC?:?5?9D ,N 4 I;54D= 4.I 9-;. ?N

D,@ :@?5I D,@< 34D @V= +;<;GD +,-.C,.LC <;CV,.C; ?CF

JT-;D 4<; 3,<K?.M ,. ?9= :@9 B I,.L9 M?U; ?9 G@8-

-,V;1J

Q1 7K4D1 2, H?8-4<I C;.9 9-; ;EG4?5 9,

+;<;GD= +;<;GD <;CV,.IC1

S1 H?M-91 Q.I 9-;. X<D8;= X<D8; Y4D.;= C4DC

G,U?.M ?9= 3-?8- B V<;C@G; ?C C,G; C,<9 ,N EE 9-49LC

K?.I ,N GD Z@;C9?,. ?C I, D,@ K.,3 3-49 34C @.I;<

I?C8@CC?,. -;<;= 3-49 34C :;?.M I;54D;IP [4C ?9 9-;

G;;9?.M 3?9- 9-; \T> ,< C,G;9-?.M ;5C;P

Q1 B <;G;G:;< M;99?.M 4 8455 N<,G ;?9-;<

H?8-4<I ,< +;<;GD= B I,.L9 <;G;G:;< 3-,= C4D?.M 9-;D

Page 242: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 242/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

3;<; 9<B?.C 9, D;8?D; ?E 9-;B F;G9 9-; H;;9?.C ,< ?E

9-;B G,I9G,.;D 9-; H;;9?.C= :@9 JKH .,9 8,G?;D ,.

9-?I I9@EE= I, J D,.K9 F.,3 3-49KI C,?.C ,.= :@9

L?8-4<D H@I9 -4M; 8455;D H; 4.D 4IF;D H; HB ,G?.?,.=

,< +;<;HB H@I9 -4M; 8455;D H; 4.D 4IF;D H; HB

,G?.?,.1 J D,.K9 F.,31

N1 J9 5,,FI 9, H;= ?E B,@ 5,,F 9-; OO 4:,@9 4

9-?<D ,E 9-; 34B D,3. 9-; G4C; 9-;<;KI 4. ;OH4?5 E<,H

L?8-4<D L435; 9, B,@1

P1 7-1

N1 J9KI :;?.C E,<34<D;D1 JKH <;4D?.C 9-?I 4I

L?8-4<D E,<34<D?.C 9, B,@ 49 9-49 G,?.9 ;M;<B9-?.C

9-49KI ,. 9-; :,99,H ,E 9-; G4C; :;5,3 9-49= 4.D 9-;.

B,@ <;IG,.D?.C 9, L?8-4<D :4I;D @G,. B,@< <;4D?.C OO

P1 7-= ,F4B1

N1 OO 9-; :,99,H ;OH4?51 JI 9-49 488@<49;Q

P1 R;55= 455 J 84. D, ?I <;4D 9-; G4C; 9-49

B,@K<; <;4D?.C1 J9KI :;;. I, 5,.C= J D,.K9 <;H;H:;<=

I, ?9 3,@5D :; 5?F; JKH S@I9 <;4D?.C ?9 8,5D= :@9

9-49 D,;I.K9 I;;H 5?F; 4. @.<;4I,.4:5; ;TG54.49?,. ,E

3-49 B,@K<; 4IF?.C1

N1 7F4B1 A;9KI C, 9, 3-49 B,@ 3<,9; -;<;=

4.D J 3,.K9 <;4D 9-49 ?.9, 9-; <;8,<D= :@9 S@I9 <;4D

?9 9, B,@<I;5E 4.D I;; ?E 9-49 S,CI B,@< H;H,<B1

P1 2, 3-49 4<; B,@ 4IF?.CQ

Page 243: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 243/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

B1 C;55= 3-49 DEF 9<G?.H 9, @.I;<J94.I ?J

3-49 I,;J G,@< 4IK?8; <;549; 9,L MN,@ H;9 ,.; J-,91

DO J,F;,.; -4J 9, -4K; 4 -;4<9 49948P= J,F;,.; -4J 9,

J48<?O?8;1M

DEF .,9 @.I;<J94.I?.H 9-; Q,?.9 G,@E<;

9<G?.H 9, F4P;1

R1 D I,.E9 ;?9-;<1 2,F;9?F;J D JQ;4P ?.

<?II5;J 4.I 4.45,H?;J= 4.I D I,.E9 P.,3 3-49 9-49 ,.;

F;4.J ;?9-;<1

B1 7P4G1 7.; ?.O;<;.8; D F?H-9 F4P; ?J 9-49

G,@ 4<; 8,FF;.9?.H ,. J,F; P?.I ,O Q<,Q,J45 9,

.;H,9?49; 4 I;54G 3?9- 9-; ST>1

>4. G,@ J4G ?O 9-49EJ 488@<49;L

R1 C;55= 9-; O?<J9 ;UF4?5 9, +;<;FG O<,F

V?8-4<I J4GJ 9-49 MD 9-?.P ?9 F,<; 4QQ<,Q<?49; 9,

-4K; G,@< 499,<.;GJ 9<G 9, .;H,9?49; 4 I;54G1 C;

I,.E9 34.9 9, Q?JJ ,OO 9-; 8,FF?JJ?,.;<J :;O,<; 3;

-4K; 4 8-4.8; 9, 3,<P 3?9- 9-;F1 W,3 I?I 9-;G <;489

9, 9-; 54J9M UU J, ?9 J,@.IJ 9, F; 5?P; 9-;<; F@J9

-4K; :;;. 4 I;54G :;O,<;= 9-;G 34.9 9, .;H,9?49;

4.,9-;< I;54G= 4.I D 9-?.P FG 9-,@H-9 34J UU V?8-4<I

,:K?,@J5G O,<34<I;I 9-?J 9, F;= 5,,PJ 5?P;= 9-49 DEF

.,9 UU D I,.E9 P.,3 9-; Q54G;<J= D I,.E9 P.,3 9-;

J?9@49?,.= :@9 ?O G,@E<; .,9 <;4IG= G,@ :;99;< .,9

F,K; O,<34<I1

Page 244: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 244/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1 2,@.EF 5?C; F,@.E 4EG?8;= 4.E HD

I@;F9?,. E,;F.J9 F, H@8- 8,.8;<. 9-; 4EG?8; KK

L1 2@<;1

B1 KK :@9= <49-;<= 9-; 9?H?.M1 N9 5,,CF 9,

H; 5?C;= D,@ C.,3= 4F 549; 4F O;8;H:;< !*= "*!*= D,@

4<; :;?.M 4FC;E P,< 4.E M?G?.M D,@< ?.Q@9 ,. 9-?F

5,::D?.M ;PP,<91

NF 9-49 4 P4?< 8-4<489;<?R49?,. ,P 3-49

34F M,?.M ,.S

L1 T;55= 3-49 34F M,?.M ,.= D,@JG; M,9 ,.;

;KH4?5 ?. O;8;H:;< KK 3-;.JF 9-; 54F9 8,HH@.?849?,.

-; -4ES T4F ?9 789,:;<S

B1 789,:;<1

L1 U;4-= F, N E,.J9 9-?.C ?9 3,@5E :;

F@<Q<?F?.M 9, H; 9-49 V?8-4<E 3,@5E -4G; 4 I@;F9?,.=

,< +;<;HD 3,@5E -4G; 4 I@;F9?,. :4F;E ,. HD

;WQ;<?;.8; 4.E F4D 3-49 E, D,@ 9-?.C= 4.E N 9-?.C

9-49 9-49JF 3-49 9-49 34F1 N 9,5E -?H 3-49 N

9-,@M-91

B1 7C4D1 2, 84. D,@ <;8455 :;?.M 4FC;E 4.D

F?H?54< I@;F9?,.F :;93;;. 789,:;< 4.E O;8;H:;<S

L1 N E,.J9 <;H;H:;<1

B1 >4. D,@ <;8455 Q<,G?E?.M 4.D ?.Q@9 9,

+;<;HD ,< V?8-4<ES

L1 N -,.;F95D E,.J9 <;84551

Page 245: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 245/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C.D D, E,@ <;8455 FF 3;55= G H@;II E,@

J@I9 4.I3;<;D 9-491

K,@ J@I9 D,.L9 -4M; 4 <;8,55;89?,. ,N

3-49= ?N 4.E9-?.H= E,@ D?D :;93;;. 789,:;< 4.D

O;8;P:;< ,N L!*Q

C1 G <;455E D,.L91 G 34I H,,D N<?;.DI 3?9-

:,9- ,N 9-;I; R;,R5;= 4.D G 34.9;D ?9 9, 3,<S ,@9 N,<

+;<;PE1

B1 >4. E,@ <;8455 ?N E,@ 3;<; -4M?.H

8,.M;<I49?,.I 3?9- +;<;PE 3?9- <;H4<D 9, 9-?I

5,::E?.H ;NN,<9Q

C1 G N;59 5?S; 9-; 5,::E?.H ;NN,<9 34I <;455E

:;93;;. -?P 4.D T?8-4<D 4I R<,N;II?,.45I= T?8-4<D 4I

4 R<,N;II?,.45 3-, S.;3 9-,I; R;,R5;1

U,@5D G :; I@<R<?I;D ?N -; P4D; 4 R-,.;

8455 9, P; ?. 9-; ?.9;<?P :;93;;. 789,:;< 4.D

O;8;P:;< 4.D 3; D?I8@II;D ?9Q G 3,@5D.L9 :;

I@<R<?I;D 49 4551

B1 K,@ J@I9 D,.L9 <;8455Q

C1 G J@I9 D,.L9 <;84551

B1 7S4E1 O, E,@ -4M; 4.E <;8,55;89?,. ,N

:;?.H ?.M,5M;D ?. .;H,9?49?,.I ,< D?I8@II?,.I 4:,@9

3-49 9-?I 5,::E?.H ;NN,<9 3,@5D 8,I9Q

C1 V,9 ?. .;H,9?49?,.I1 CI G @.D;<I94.D ?9=

9-; 4.I3;< ?I FF ?9LI D, G <;8455 :;?.H ?.M,5M;D ?.

Page 246: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 246/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9-; .;B,9?49?,.CD

E1 7< 4 F?C8@CC?,.D G F,.H9 I.,3 ?J 9-;<;

3;<; .;B,9?49?,.C1

K1 L;4-1

E1 K9 C,M; N,?.9 C,M;:,FO F;9;<M?.;F 9-49 4.

4M,@.9 ,J M,.;O 3,@5F :; N4?F PP

K1 Q?B-91

E1 PP 4.F 34C N4?F= 4.F G R@C9 34.9 9, I.,3

3-49= ?J 4.O= ?.S,5S;M;.9 O,@ -4F ?. 9-49D

K1 KC G @.F;<C94.F ?9 PP G F?F.H9 -4S;

?.S,5S;M;.9 ?. 9-49 N4<9 ,J 9-; 4<<4.B;M;.9 :;93;;.

9-;M1 KC G @.F;<C94.F ?9= 9-;O M;9 9,B;9-;< 3?9-,@9

MO :;?.B 9-;<; 4.F F;8?F;F -,3 9-;O 3,@5F 3,<I

9,B;9-;< ?J 9-;O 3,<I;F 9,B;9-;<= :@9 G F, <;8455

-;4<?.B 549;< 4:,@9 3-49 9-; N<?8; 3,@5F :;= 4.F G

:;5?;S; ?9 34C 4 T@4<9;< M?55?,. F,554<C= 4.F G

F?F.H9 I.,3 -,3 J4< 9-49 3,@5F B,1

E1 K.F J<,M 3-,M F?F O,@ -;4< 9-49D

K1 G :;5?;S; G -;4<F 9-49 J<,M Q?8-4<F Q435;1

G F,.H9 <;8455 J,< C@<;= 9-,@B-= ?J ?9 84M; J<,M

+;<;MO ,< Q?8-4<F= :@9111

E1 >4. O,@ C4O 3-;9-;< 9-; ,:R;89 ,J 9-;

5,::O?.B ;JJ,<9 34C 9, N<;S;.9 ,< 49 5;4C9 F;54O 9-;

J?5?.B ,J 4. UV> >,MN54?.9D

K1 K55 G <;M;M:;< ?C 9-49 +;<;MO 9-,@B-9 9-49

Page 247: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 247/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

?B 9-; CD> 8,@5E -;4< -?F F9,<G= 9-;G 3,@5E.H9 ;I;<

F@; -?J= 4.E F, 3-;. G,@ F4G 9-; ,:K;89 ,B 9-;

4<<4.L;J;.9= M 34F.H9 ?. 9-; J;;9?.L 3-;. 9-;G 945N;E

4:,@9 9-; E;94?5F ,B 3-49 ;O4895G +;<;JG 34.9;E 9,

488,JP5?F-= :@9 M N.;3 -; E?E.H9 34.9 9, :; F@;E= 4.E

M :;5?;I; 9-49 -; B;59 5?N; 9-; 34G .,9 9, :; F@;E

3,@5E :; 9, -4I; 9-; CD> K@F9 <;455G F?9 E,3. 4.E

@.E;<F94.E -?F 8,JP4.G= 3-49 9-;G 3;<; E,?.L 4.E 3-49

-; 34F E,?.L B,< 9-; 8,JJ@.?9G1

Q1 R; 9-,@L-9 -; 8,@5E 8,.I?.8; 9-;J ?B

9-;GHE K@F9 5;9 -?JS

T1 U;4-= M 9-?.N 9-49HF 4 B4?< F949;J;.91

Q1 V, G,@ <;8455 9-; E49; ,. 3-?8- 9-; CD>

>,JP54?.9 34F B?5;ES

T1 MHI; 5,,N;E 49 ?9 3?9-?. 9-; 54F9 G;4<1 M

9-?.N ?9 34F 4<,@.E 9-; J?EE5; WW

XY1 2Z7[\ [;55= 9-49 34F.H9 -?F ]@;F9?,.1

DR0 [MDZ022\ U;F1

XY1 2Z7[\ V, G,@ <;8455 9-; E49;S

DR0 [MDZ022\ M 9-?.N M <;8455 9-; E49;1

Q1 ^_G X<1 A455?` T.E 3-49 E, G,@ <;8455S

T1 D-; !&9- ,< !'9- ,< !(9- ,B V;8;J:;<1

Q1 T.E MHJ .,9 WW M 34F.H9 L,?.L 9, ?.9<,E@8;

9-?F 4F 4. ;O-?:?9= :@9 M K@F9 P@55;E F,J;9-?.L ,BB

9-; M.9;<.;91 M9 F4GF V;8;J:;< "!F91

Page 248: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 248/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7-= 9-;<; C,@ D,1

E1 F,@5G 9-49 HH 4.G I G,.J9 9-?.K 9-;

L<;8?M; G49; <;455C N499;<M1

B1 O-;<; C,@ D,= I 9<C 9, D@;MM 4.G 3-49

-4LL;.MP

QR1 2S7FT 2, C,@ G,.J9 <;8455 9-; G49;P

OU0 FIOS022T I G,.J9 <;8455 9-; G49;1

U,3JM 9-49P

E1 VWC Q<1 A455?X W@9 M,N;3-;<; 9,34<G 9-;

N?GG5; ,Y Z;8;N:;< M,@.GM <?D-9 9, C,@P

B1 W;Y,<; >-<?M9N4M1

E1 [;4-1 7K4C1 BY9;< 9-; \O> >,NL54?.9 D,9

Y?5;G= G?G +;<;NC 8455 C,@ ,< 945K 9, C,@ 4:,@9 9-49P

B1 B9 M,N; L,?.9 I 9-?.K -; G?G1

E1 B.G G, C,@ <;8455 3-;.P

B1 S,= I G,.J91

E1 Z, C,@ <;8455 9-; .49@<; ,Y 9-;

8,.];<M49?,.P

B1 I G,.J91

E1 Z, C,@ <;8455 -?N :;?.D G?M4LL,?.9;G ,<

Y<@M9<49;G 9-49 9-; 5,::C?.D ;YY,<9 -4G .,9 :;;.

M@88;MMY@5 49 5;4M9 ?.M,Y4< 4M L<;];.9?.D 4. \O>

>,NL54?.9 Y<,N :;?.D Y?5;GP

B1 B9 M,N; L,?.9 I :;5?;]; 9-49 34M 9-; 84M;1

E1 B.G G, C,@ <;8455 3-49 9-49 L,?.9 34MP

Page 249: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 249/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C D,.E91

F1 7G4H1 I, H,@ G.,3 3-49 J?8-4<D J435; ,<

4.H ,K -?L 8,.9489L D?D ?. 4. ;KK,<9 9, 5,::H 9-; MN>

,< 4<<4.O; 4 P;;9?.O 3?9- 9-; MN>Q

B1 C D,.E91 C P;4.= CER; L;;. D,8@P;.9L

L?.8; 9-;.= 3?9-?. 9-; 54L9 L?S ,< ;?O-9 P,.9-L1

CER; L;;. L,P; ;TP4?5L= K,< ;S4PU5;= 9-49 L-,3 P; TT

L, H,@ L4H D, C G.,31 C 8@<<;.95H G.,3 P,<; 9-4. C

D?D= 5?G;= K,< ;S4PU5;= 3-;. C P;9 3?9- +;<;PH

+,-.L,. ,. BU<?5 #*9- ,K "*!"1

F1 V-49 D, H,@ 8@<<;.95H G.,3 4L K4< 4L 3-49

5,::H?.O ;KK,<9L ,88@<<;DQ

B1 V;55= 3-49 C G.,3 ?L 3-49 CER; <;4D ?.

;TP4?5L TT

F1 J?O-91

B1 TT :;93;;. +;<;PH TT :;93;;. J?8-4<D J435;

4.D 9-; 5,::H?L9L -; ;.O4O;D1

F1 J?O-91 B.D 3-49 ?L 9-49Q

B1 N-49 -; 4LG;D +;<;PH +,-.L,. K,< L,P;

?.K,<P49?,. 4:,@9 -?L U-?54.9-<,U?8 8,.9<?:@9?,.L 9,

9-; 8,PP@.?9H= 9-49 +;<;PH +,-.L,. L;.9 9-49

?.K,<P49?,. 9, J?8-4<D= 9-49 J?8-4<D K,<34<D;D 9-49

?.K,<P49?,. 9, -?L U;,U5;= -?L 5,::H?L9L= 4L C

P;.9?,.;D1 N-;H L4?D ?. 9-;?< ;TP4?5L 9-49 9-;H -4D

O,9 TT <;8;?R;D 9-; ?.K,<P49?,. 4.D 3;<; L94<9?.O 9,

Page 250: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 250/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B, 9-<,@B- 9-49 ?.C,<D49?,.1 E-,F; 4<; 9-; 9-?.BF

9-49 G <;8455 <;4H?.B C<,D 9-; ;ID4?5F 9-49 G F43

4:,@9 3-49 J?8-4<H H?H1

K1 L, M,@ N.,3 3-49 5,::M?F9F J?8-4<H 34F

@F?.BO

P1 PF G F?9 -;<; .,3 G H,= M;F1

K1 P.H 3-, 3;<; 9-;MO

P1 P D4. .4D;H Q<,3. C<,D A4F R;B4F 4.H 4 D4.

.4D;H J@S5? C<,D T4F-?.B9,.= L1>1

K1 P.H H?H M,@ N.,3 9-49 ?. "*!*= ,< ?F 9-49

?.C,<D49?,. M,@ 5;4<.;H ,.5M <;8;.95MO

P1 G 5;4<.;H 9-49 ?.C,<D49?,. F-,<95M 4C9;<

J?8-4<H J435; S4FF;H 434M1

K1 P.H -,3 H?H M,@ 5;4<. 9-49O

P1 GUD 9<M?.B 9, <;8455 -,3 G 5;4<.;H 9-491

G 9-?.N 9-49 V<1 P5:4 9,5H DM 499,<.;M 4.H DM

499,<.;M 9,5H D;1 G 9-?.N 9-49UF -,3 ?9 -4SS;.;H1

VJ1 APAAGW 7N4M1 E-?<9MI;?B-91

$%&'()(* ,- ./0 1/23%456 

K1 XQM V<1 A455?Y 0Z-?:?9 #( ?F 4 V4<8- $=

"*!!= 5;99;< 3<?99;. C<,D T?55?4D J,9-:4<H= 3-,

?H;.9?C?;F -?DF;5C 4F 8,@.F;5 9, 28,99 A;4[?99= 9,

J?8-4<H J435;1

\4[; M,@ ;[;< F;;. 9-?F 5;99;< :;C,<;O

P1 G <;8455 F;;?.B ?9 :;C,<;1

Page 251: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 251/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

B1 C.D 3-;. D?D E,@ F?<G9 G;; ?9H

C1 I D,.J9 <;8455 3-;. I F?<G9 G43 ?91

B1 K, E,@ <;8455 3-;9-;< ,< .,9 E,@ G43 9-?G

?. "*!!H

C1 I :;5?;L; I D?D1

B1 7M4E1 K, E,@ <;8455 -4L?.N 4 D?G8@GG?,.

3?9- O<1 P435; 4:,@9 ?9H

C1 I D,.J9 <;8455 9-49= .,1

B1 7M4E1 K, E,@ <;8455 -4L?.N 4.E G,<9 ,F 4

<;489?,. 9, 3-49JG :;;. G949;D ?. 9-; 5;99;<H

C1 O4E I <;4D 9-; 5;99;<H

B1 Q;G= R5;4G;1

ST?9.;GG ;U4V?.?.N D,8@V;.91W

XY0 TIXZ022[ 7M4E1 T-49JG E,@< \@;G9?,.H

B1 S]E O<1 A455?W OE \@;G9?,. ?G[ K, E,@

<;8455 3-49 <;489?,. E,@ -4D 3-;. E,@ F?<G9 <;4D

9-?GH

C1 C.D I 34.9 9, N, :48M 4.D ^@G9 8,<<;89 VE

9;G9?V,.E1 I D,.J9 M.,3 4G I G?9 -;<; 3-;. I G43

9-?G= ?F ?9 34G ?. "*!! ,< .,91

I D, M.,3 I <;8;?L;D 4 R-,.; 8455 F<,V

O<1 P,9-:4<D G,V;9?V; F,55,3?.N K;8;V:;< ,F "*!*= 4.D

-; 34G 4GM?.N V; F,< 8,.9489 ?.F,<V49?,. F,<

O<1 P435;= 4.D -; 9,5D V; -; <;R<;G;.9;D 4 V4. .4V;D

28,99 A;4L?99 3-, -4D :;;. ?.L,5L;D ?. 9-;

Page 252: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 252/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4<<4.B;C;.9 3?9- D<1 E435;1 F <;8455 :;?.B G@<H<?G;I

49 9-; H-,.; 8455 4.I 34G G@<H<?G;I 9, -;4< 4:,@9

28,99 A;4J?991

K1 L?I -; 9;55 M,@ 9-49 28,99 A;4J?99 -4I

H4?I C,.;M 9,34<I 9-?G 5,::M?.B ;NN,<9O

P1 F I,.Q9 R.,3 ?N -; 9,5I C; 9-49 49 9-;

9?C; ,< ?N -; 9,5I C; 9-49 549;< ,< ?N E?8-4<I 9,5I

C; 9-491 F I,.Q9 R.,31

K1 7R4M1 2, 4N9;< M,@ B;9 9-?G 8455 N<,C

E,9-:4<I G;;R?.B D<1 E435;QG 8,.9489 ?.N,<C49?,.= I?I

M,@ 945R 9, D<1 E435; 4:,@9 ?9O

P1 F :;5?;J; F I?I1

K1 P.I I, M,@ <;8455 3-49 9-; G@:G94.8; ,N

9-49 8,.J;<G49?,. 3?9- E?8-4<I E435; 34GO

P1 F <;455M I,.Q91 F S@G9 <;8455 5;99?.B -?C

R.,3 F <;8;?J;I 4 H-,.; 8455 N<,C 4 543M;< 4.I 4GR?.B

D<1 E435; ?N ?9 34G ,R4M 3?9- -?C ?N F B4J; -?C

D<1 E435;QG 8,.9489 ?.N,<C49?,.1

K1 L?I M,@ @.I;<G94.I 9-<,@B- 9-49

8,.J;<G49?,. 9-49 9-?G 543M;< 34G :;?.B -?<;I :M

28,99 A;4J?99 ?. 4. ;NN,<9 9, 9<M 9, B;9 9-?G

T"**=*** :48RO

P1 F I,.Q9 <;84551 F9 3,@5I.Q9 G@<H<?G; C;

?N 9-49QG 3-49 9-; H@<H,G; ,N 9-; 8455 34G1 F

4GG@C;I -; -4I ?GG@;G ,< -; 3,@5I.Q9 -4J; 8455;I C;=

Page 253: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 253/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4.B CDE 4FF@E?.G 9-49 +;<;EH +,-.F,. G4I; -?E EH

J-,.; .@E:;<= 4.B CDE 4FF@E?.G 9-49 +;<;EH +,-.F,.

E@F9 -4I; 5,F9 K?8-4<BDF 8,.9489 ?.L,<E49?,.= :@9 CDE

.,9 F@<;1

M1 7N4H1 O.B B, H,@ <;8455 3-49= ?L

4.H9-?.G= 84E; ,L 9-?FP

O1 C B,.D9 <;84551 C E;4.= 49 F,E; J,?.9

F,E;9-?.G 84E; ,L ?9 ?. "*!"= :@9 C B,.D9 <;8455 3-49

-4JJ;.;B ?. 9-; .;4< 9;<E= .,1

M1 Q@9 H,@ B, RR H,@ B, 9-?.N H,@ 945N;B 9,

K?8-4<B 4:,@9 9-; RR

O1 S-; J-,.; 84551

M1 RR K,9-:4<B 8,.I;<F49?,.P

O1 C :;5?;I; C 945N;B 9, -?E 4:,@9 9-; J-,.;

84551

M1 T4F 9-49 9-; ,.5H 9?E; H,@ 945N;B 3?9-

K?8-4<B K,9-:4<BP

O1 C B,.D9 <;8455 ;I;< 945N?.G 3?9- -?E

4G4?.= :@9 ?9 3,@5B.D9 F@<J<?F; E; ?L C B?B= :@9 C

U@F9 B,.D9 <;8455= 4.B ?9 34F .;I;< 4.H9-?.G ,L

F@:F94.8;1 C9 34F ;?9-;< C B?B.D9 945N 9, -?E 4G4?.

,< C G4I; -?E V<1 K435;DF 8,.9489 ?.L,<E49?,.1 C

B,.D9 <;8455= :@9 ?9 34F .;I;< ,L 4.H F@:F94.8;1

VK1 AOAACW 7N4H1 S-?<9HR.?.;1

$%&'()(* ,- ./0 1/23%456 

Page 254: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 254/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

B1 CDE F<1 A455?G 0H-?:?9 #) ?I 4 8,@<9

<;J,<9;<KI 9<4.I8<?J9 9-49 J@<J,<9I 9, :; 4

9<4.I8<?J9?,. ,L 9-; M<?IJE M<;N; N;;9?.O 9-49

+;<;NE +,-.I,. <;8,<P;P1

FE Q@;I9?,. ?IR S4T; E,@ ;T;< I;;. 9-?I

9<4.I8<?J9 :;L,<;U

V1 W P,.K9 X.,3 ?L WKT; I;;. E,@< 9<4.I8<?J91

W -4T; I;;. 4 9<4.I8<?J9 9-49 34I J<;J4<;P :E NE

499,<.;EI1

B1 Y, E,@ X.,3 ?L ?9KI ZZ :;84@I; W P?P.K9

J<;J4<; 9-?I1 [; O,9 9-?I ,LL 9-; W.9;<.;9= W 9-?.X1

V1 \;4-1 VI W <;8455= 9-; ,.; 3; -4P P,.;

I;;N;P 4 5?995; N,<; 488@<49; 9, @I 9-4. 9-; ,.; 9-49

34I ,. 9-; W.9;<.;9= J<,T?P;P :E 9-; !"#$%&'= L,<

;H4NJ5;1

F21 +VF02R WL W 8,@5P ?.9;<];89= W X.,3

9-;<; 3;<; 49 5;4I9 93, 9<4.I8<?J9I1 W :;5?;T; ,.;

34I L<,N W.9;<N,@.94?.1

V89@455E= W <;8455 9-49 9-; 93,

9<4.I8<?J9I 3;<; .,9 ?P;.9?845= 4.P 9-;<; 3;<; I,N;

4<;4I ,L 9-; 94J; 3-;<; ?9 34I <;455E -4<P 9,

@.P;<I94.P 4.P O4<:5;P= 4.P I, 9-; 93, 8,@<9

<;J,<9;<I -4P P?LL;<;.9 ?.9;<J<;949?,.I1 W P,.K9

<;N;N:;< <?O-9 .,3 3-?8- ,.; 3; 9-,@O-9 34I N,<;

488@<49;1

Page 255: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 255/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC1 ADAAEF G, H,@ -4I; :,9- 8,J?;KL

B21 +DB02F E M,1

BC1 ADAAEF >4. 3; N;9 9-; ,9-;< ,.;L

B21 +DB02F O;K1

P1 QRH B<1 A455?S R@9 H,@TI; <;4M ,.;

9<4.K8<?J91 U-;9-;< ?9 34K 9-?K ,.;= H,@T<; .,9

K@<;L

D1 C?N-91

P1 7V4H1 D.M 4K H,@ <;4M 9-<,@N- ?9= E W;4.=

M?M ?9 K;;W 488@<49;= ,< -4M ?9 :;;. 9,, 5,.N X,< H,@

9, :; 4:5; 9, <;8455L

D1 U;55= ?. ;KK;.8;= ?9 K;;W;M J<;99H

488@<49;= E W;4. ?. 9,945= :@9 9-;<; 3;<; YY 9-;<;

3;<; K,W; M?XX;<;.8;K :;93;;. 9-; 93, 9<4.K8<?J9K1 E

M,.T9 <;8455 KJ;8?X?8455H 3-49 9-;H 3;<;1

P1 Z4I; H,@ 5?K9;.;M 9, 9-; 94J;L

D1 O;K1

P1 7V4H1 U;55= E 34.9 9, 4KV H,@ K,W;

[@;K9?,.K 4:,@9 9-?K= .,9 .;8;KK4<?5H YY 3;55= 5;9 W;

\@K9 4KV 9-; [@;K9?,.K 4.M 3;T55 K;; 3-;<; ?9 94V;K

@K1

EX H,@TM N, 9, J4N; $ -;<;= 4.M ETW \@K9

J?8V?.N @J1 ]-?K ?K 9,34<M 9-; :;N?..?.N ,X 9-;

8,.I;<K49?,. ,. 5?.; ( 3-;<; +;<;WH ?K J@<J,<9?.N 9,

-4I; K4?M= ^E 945V;M 9, 28,991 E 9-?.V -;TK N,?.N 9,

Page 256: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 256/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

-4B; 9, -4B; 49 5;4C9 !'%1 D@9 E 9-?.F

3-49 3;GB; H,9 9, ;IJ54?. 9, K?8-4<L ?C -;= M,@ F.,3=

E L,.G9 F.,3 -,3 K?8-4<L 5,,FC 49 9-?C= :@9 9-;<; 34C

.,9- NN .,9-?.H -4JJ;.;L1 O; H,9 J<,P?C;L 9-; 3,<5L

4.L H,9 Q;<, ?. <;9@<.1R

SM T?<C9 U@;C9?,. 4:,@9 9-?C ?CV WC E

<;4L 9-?C= ?9 4JJ;4<C 4C ?T 9-;<; 34C C,P;9-?.H

9-49 NN C,P; L?45,H@; 9-49 M,@ 4.L +,-.C,. -4L -4L

:;T,<; 9-?C1 E9 5,,FC 9, P; 5?F; M,@G<; F?.L ,T

J?8F?.H @J 4 8,.B;<C49?,.1 E 945F;L 9, 28,99= E

9-?.F -;GC H,?.H 9, -4B; 9, -4B; 49 5;4C9 X!'%=***1

2, 34C 9-;<; 4 J<?,< L?C8@CC?,. :;93;;.

M,@ 4.L +,-.C,.Y

W1 O;55= 9-;<; 34C1 Z;C= 9-;<; 34C1

[1 O4C 9-;<; P,<; 9-4. ,.; J<?,< L?C8@CC?,.

3?9- +,-.C,.Y

W1 O;55= 4<; M,@ 945F?.H 4:,@9 <;549?B; 9,

-?C 8,.8;<. 9-49 -; ;IJ<;CC;C -;<; 4:,@9 H;99?.H J4?L

:48FY

[1 Z;C1

W1 E :;5?;B; 9-;<; 34C \@C9 ,.;= 4.L 9-49 34C

4. ?.NJ;<C,. P;;9?.H1

[1 W.L 3-;<; 4.L 3-;. 34C 9-49Y

W1 ]-49 3,@5L -4B; :;;. 549; ?. "*!!= 4.L ?9

3,@5L -4B; :;;. ?. 291 ^;,<H;1

Page 257: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 257/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1 >4. D,@ <;8455 3-;<; ?. 291 E;,<F;G

H1 I;4-1 J9 34K ?. 4 -,9;5 <,,L1 J 34K M,3.

?. 291 E;,<F; ?. 4 -,9;5 <,,L 499;.M?.F 4 8,.N;<;.8;

M,3. 9-;<;= ,< 4 L;;9?.F M,3. 9-;<;1

B1 O, D,@ <;8455 3-?8- -,9;5G

H1 J M,.P91

B1 H55 <?F-91 2, D,@ -4M 4 L;;9?.F 3?9-

+,-.K,. ?. 549; "*!! ?. 4 -,9;5 <,,L= 291 E;,<F;G

H1 Q?F-91

B1 H.M 3-49 34K 9-; K@:K94.8; ,N 9-49

L;;9?.FG

H1 R;55= ?9 5,,C;M 5?C; SS +;<;LD -4M 8455;M

L; ,< K,L;-,3 L4M; ?9 C.,3. -; 34.9;M 9, L;;9 3?9- L;

4:,@9 K,L;9-?.F @<F;.91 J M?M.P9 34.9 9, L;;9 3?9-

-?L 45,.;= K, J ?.T?9;M ,.; ,N LD 84LU4?F.

8,[email protected] 9, F, M,3. 9-;<; 4.M L;;9 9-;<; 3?9- -?L=

3-?8- ?K 3-49 -; M?M 4.M 3-49 3; M?M1

J9 K;;L;M 5?C; 9-; 9-<@K9 ,N 9-; L;;9?.F

34K +;<;LD 34K 8,.8;<.;M 9-49 -; -4M.P9 F,99;.

;T;<D9-?.F -; 34.9;M ,@9 ,N 9-; 4<<4.F;L;.9 3?9-

Q?8-4<M= 4.M -; SS 4.M J M,.P9 C.,3 ?N ?9 34K 9-;

N?<K9 9?L; 9-;.1 J 9-?.C ?9 34K SS 5;9 L; C.,3 9-49

9-;<; 34K K,L;,.; ;5K; 3-, -4M :;;. ?.T,5T;M ?. -?K

4<<4.F;L;.9 9, F;9 5,::D?K9K -?<;M= 28,99 A;4T?991 J

L4D -4T; -;4<M 9-49 N<,L ;4<5?;<= ,. 9-; U-,.; ,<

Page 258: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 258/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B,C;9-?.D= :@9 -; 34B 8,.8;<.;E 4.E B4?E 9-49 -; 34B

8,.8;<.;E F,< 28,99 A;4G?99 4.E 9-49 -; 34.9;E 9, D;9

9-?B <;B,5G;E 3?9- H?8-4<E H435;= 4.E -; 489;E I<;99J

4.D<J 4:,@9 ?91

K1 L.E 3-J 34B -; 945M?.D 9, J,@ 4:,@9 ?9N

O?E -; B4JN

L1 P; E?E.Q9 B4J= :@9 -; M.;3 R -4E 4

<;549?,.B-?I 3?9- H?8-4<E H435;1

K1 O?E -; 4BM J,@ 9, ?.9;<G;.; 3?9-

H?8-4<E H435; 9, 9<J 9, D;9 9-; C,.;J :48M ,< 9, E,

B,C;9-?.D ;5B;N

L1 R 9-?.M -; 4BB@C;E R 3,@5E1

K1 S-, 34B 9-; 84CI4?D. 8,[email protected]

L1 +4B,. T,3;<B1

K1 +4B,. T,3;<BN

L1 U;B1

K1 S-;. +;<;CJ 9,5E J,@ 9-49 B,C;,.; ;5B; -4E

:;;. ?.G,5G;EV .4C;5J= 28,99 A;4G?99= E?E J,@

4BB,8?49; 9-49 49 9-49 I,?.9 3?9- 9-; I<?,<

8,.G;<B49?,. J,@ -4E 3?9- H,9-:4<EN

L1 7-= .,1 R 9-?.M :J 9-;. R M.;3 9-49 -;

-4E :;;. ?.G,5G;E 3?9- 28,99 A;4G?991

K1 7M4J1

L1 W@9 9-49 34B= R 9-?.M= 9-; F?<B9 9?C;

+;<;CJ XX 9-;<;= 4D4?.= -; C4J -4G; 945M;E 9, C;

Page 259: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 259/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4:,@9 ?9 ,. 9-; B-,.; ;4<5?;<1 C D,.E9 <;8455= :@9

49 F,G; B,?.9 C @.D;<F9,,D 9-;<; 34F 4 B;<F,. .4G;D

28,99 A;4H?99 3-, 34F ?.H,5H;D ?. -;5B?.I B4J

K?8-4<D K435;1 LI4?.= C 34F.E9 ?. 9-; G;;9?.IF 3-;.

9-;J .;I,9?49;D 9-49= F, C M@F9 D?D.E9 N.,3 4:,@9

9-491

O1 7N4J1 P@9 :J 9-?F G;;9?.I ?. 549; "*!!

J,@ N.;3Q

L1 R;F1

O1 P;84@F; +;<;GJ 34F 9;55?.I J,@= 4.D J,@ED

-4D 9-; 8,.H;<F49?,. 3?9- K,9-:4<D= 4.D J,@ED 945N;D

3?9- K?8-4<D 4:,@9 ?9 :J 9-49 9?G;= 9,, SS

L1 K?I-91

O1 SS ?T CEG T,55,3?.I J,@Q 2, -,3 5,.I D?D

9-?F G;;9?.I ?. 9-; -,9;5 <,,G 54F9Q

L1 CED F4J "* G?.@9;F 9, "% G?.@9;F1

O1 L.D 34F 9-;<; 4. ;.D 9, 9-; G;;9?.I ?. 9-;

F;.F; ,T 489?,. ?9;GF ,< 4. 4I<;;G;.9 9, D?F8@FF

T@<9-;<Q

L1 U,9 <;455J1 A?N; C F4?D= CED :; -4BBJ 9,

8455 K?8-4<D 4.D 9;55 -?G 9-49 +;<;GJ 34F 8,.8;<.;D

4:,@9 ?9= 4.D C -4D T;59 9-49 K?8-4<D ,@I-9 9, 3,<N

?9 ,@9 3?9- -?G= 4.D C -4D 9,5D K?8-4<D 9-491

O1 V?D J,@ 94N; 4 B,F?9?,. ,. 3-;9-;< G,.;J

F-,@5D ,< F-,@5D .,9 :; <;[email protected];DQ

Page 260: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 260/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C D?D.E91

F1 G?D ;?9-;< +;<;HI ,< J?8-4<D 4KL I,@<

,M?.?,. ,. 9-49N

B1 C D,.E9 <;84551

F1 7L4I1 2, :;93;;. 9-?K 549; "*!! 4.D

BM<?5 #*9-= ?O 9-49 ?K 9-; 488@<49; D49; ,O 9-;

P<?KMI P<;H; H;;9?.Q= -4D I,@ KM,L;. 3?9- +,-.K,.N

B1 C D,.E9 RR C D,.E9 <;8455 KM;4L?.Q 3?9-

+,-.K,. :;93;;. 9-,K; 93, M;<?,DK ,O 9?H;1

F1 C M<;K@H; 9-;<; 34K K,H; 8,.S;<K49?,. 9,

K;9 @M 9-?K H;;9?.QN

B1 T-?K H;;9?.QN

F1 U;K1

B1 V;55= ?9 H4I -4S; -4MM;.;D 9-49 H,<.?.Q1

C 9-?.L 9-49 8,.S;<K49?,. -4MM;.;D 9-49 H,<.?.Q1

F1 7L4I1 B.D D, I,@ <;8455= D?D -; 8455 I,@N

B1 W; 8455;D H;1

F1 B.D 3-49 34K 9-; RR 34K 9-; 5,849?,. X@K9

K,H;9-?.Q 9-49 -4MM;.;D 9, :; 8,.S;.?;.9 O,< 9-; :,9-

,O I,@N

B1 C9 -4MM;.;D 9, :; 8,.S;.?;.9 O,< H;1 C

34K D,3. ?. Y94- >,@.9I 49 9-; 9?H;1

F1 T@<. 9, M4Q; '= ?O I,@ 3,@5D= M5;4K;= 4.D

:;Q?..?.Q ?. M4<4Q<4M- RR M4<4Q<4M- RR ,. 5?.; (=

9-?K ?K +;<;HI +,-.K,. 4MM4<;.95I K4I?.Q Z?O I,@ 9<I

Page 261: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 261/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

4.B 945C 9, D?8-4<B -; -4.EF @G 9-; G-,.;1 H.B F,

IJK 5?C; LL 4.B F, 28,99JF M@F9= N,@ C.,3= 9-49JF -?F

-,K;1O

P4B D?8-4<B 9,5B N,@ 4:,@9 ;QQ,<9F :N

+,-.F,. 9, 8,.9489 -?KR

H1 I B,.J9 <;8455 -;4<?.E 9-49 Q<,K D?8-4<B1

S1 T-;. N,@ -4B 9-?F K;;9?.E ?. 549; J!!= B?B

N,@ 45<;4BN C.,3 :N 9-49 G,?.9 ?. 9?K; 9-49 +,-.F,.

4.BU,< A;4V?99 34.9;B 9, E;9 K,.;N :48C Q<,K D435;R

H1 I B,.J9 <;K;K:;<1

S1 W@9 ?Q .,9 :;Q,<;= 49 5;4F9 ?. 9-49 549;

J!! K;;9?.E N,@ C.;3 ?9 9-;.R

H1 X-49 -; 34.9;B 9, 3,<C F,K;9-?.E ,@9 3?9-

D?8-4<BR

S1 Y;F1

H1 Y;4-1

S1 Z, N,@ C.,3 3-49 D?8-4<BJF G,F?9?,. 34F

3?9- <;FG;89 9, 4.N C?.B ,Q <;[email protected]

H1 T;55= 9-49JF 4 LL I C.,3 D?8-4<B -4B 9,5B

K; ?9 34F 4 .,.<;[email protected]:5; 8,.9<489 3?9- 9-;K= :@9 I

45F, 9-?.C D?8-4<B 34F LL 34F 8,.8;<.;B 9-49 9-;<;

34F F,K; C?.B ,Q <;8;?V;< 4GG,?.9;B ,< F,K;9-?.E= 4.B

I B,.J9 C.,3 3-;. I :;84K; 434<; ,Q 9-49 8,.8;<.=

9-49 ?Q -; G4?B 9-; K,.;N :48C 9, +;<;KN +,-.F,. 9-49

9-;<; K?E-9 :; 4 9-?<B G4<9N 3-, E,9 ?9 4.B 3; -4B 9,

Page 262: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 262/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B4C 93?8;1

D1 A,,E F,3. 49 5?.; !( 4.F 9-;. 4G4?. ,. "*1

H?9- <;I;<;.8; 9, 28,99= +,-.J,. ?J J4C?.G 9-49 -;KJ

L4F 49 C,@ 4.F 34.9;F 9, J@; C,@1

ML N @.F;<J94.F?.G 9-49 488@<49;5CO

M1 P-49KJ 3-49 -; J;;LJ 9, J4C1

D1 Q4C:; 9-?J ?J 4 R@;J9?,. C,@ 3;<; 4JE?.G=

:@9 3-C 3,@5F 28,99 :; L4F 49 C,@O

M1 P-49KJ 9-; R@;J9?,. N 34J 4JE?.G LCJ;5I

F@<?.G 9-?J 3-,5; 8,.S;<J49?,.= 3-?8- N 9-,@G-9 34J

8<4TC1

D1 M.F 34J 9-49 ;S;< 4.J3;<;F ?. C,@< L?.FO

M1 U,1 N 9-?.E -; L4F; 9-; 3-,5; 9-?.G @B1

D1 H-;. V,9-:4<F -4F JB,E;. 9, C,@= 3-;.;S;<

9-?J 34J= F?F -; 9;55 C,@ 9-49 28,99 A;4S?99 :54L;F

C,@O

M1 U,1

D1 W<?,< 9, +,-.J,. J4C?.G 9-?J ?. 9-?J

L;;9?.G -;<; 9-49 3; -4S; 9<4.J8<?:;F= -4F 4.C,.;

4JJ;<9;F 9-49 28,99 A;4S?99 J,L;-,3 :54L;F C,@O

M1 N F,.K9 <;84551 N F,.K9 <;8455 ;S;< :;?.G

:54L;F I,< ?9 B<?,< 9, 9-?J B,?.91 N F,.K9 <;8455

9-49 :;?.G 9-; 9,B?8 ,I 9-; L;;9?.G 3; -4F ?. 9-;

-,9;5 <,,L ;?9-;<X ?. ,9-;< 3,<FJ= 9-49 9-;<; 34J 4.C

4.?L,J?9C ,< ;S;. 8,.8;<. I<,L 28,99 <;G4<F?.G LC

Page 263: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 263/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

?.9<,B@89?,. ,C D?8-4<B 9, +;<;EF +,-.G,.1

H1 7I4F1 J,@ E;.9?,.;B 4 E,E;.9 4K, 9-49 F,@

9-,@K-9 9-?G 34G 8<4LF1

>4. F,@ ;54:,<49; ,. 9-49M

N1 O;55= 5,,I?.K :48I ,. 9-; 8,.P;<G49?,.= ?.

9-; E?BB5; ,C 9-; 8,.P;<G49?,. ?9 G;;E;B <;455F

:?L4<<; 9, E;= 4.B 4G Q RR 4G Q 3;.9 9-<,@K- 9-;

E;;9?.K= ?9 G;;E;B 5?I; +;<;EF +,-.G,. 34G 9<F?.K 9,

G84<; E; 4.B 9<F?.K 9, K;9 E; RR 9<F?.K 9, ;S9,<9 E;=

4.B ?. 9-; 8,.9;S9 ,C T@G9 C?.?G-?.K 9-; D;U@:5?84.

8,.P;.9?,. 4.B K,?.K 9, 4 U<?E4<F ?. T@G9 4 C;3

E,.9-G= ?9 -4B 4 K,,B ;CC;89= ?9 <;455F G84<;B E;= G,

9-; 3-,5; E;;9?.K 34G E; ,. 9-; B;C;.G; 9<F?.K 9,

C?K@<; ,@9 3-;<; -; 34G K,?.K 4.B 9<F?.K .,9 9, E4I;

-?E G, E4B 9-49 -;VB 9<F 9, B, 3-49 -; B?B 9, E; ?.

W,P;E:;< 4.B X;8;E:;<= 4.B 9-49 ?G :5,3 E; @U :;C,<;

9-; U<?E4<F1

H1 X?B F,@= 3-;. F,@ -4B 9-; E;;9?.K ?. 549;

V!! ,< 49 4.F 9?E; U<?,< 9, Y<?GUF Y<;E;= Q K@;GG=

B?B F,@ K;9 9-; G;.G; 9-49 +,-.G,. 34G 9<F?.K 9,

;S9,<9 F,@= 9, @G; F,@< 9;<EM

N1 Q B?B.V9 K;9 9-49 G;.G; 49 9-49 9?E;1

H1 7I4F1

N1 Q C;59 5?I; -; 34G @UG;9 49 D?8-4<B= :@9 Q

B?B.V9 K;9 4.F G;.G; 9-49 -; 34G 9-<;49;.?.K E;1

Page 264: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 264/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 A;9 C; D?<;89 E,@< 499;.9?,. 9, F4G; )=

4.D ?H E,@ 5,,I 49 9-; J949;C;.9 499<?:@9;D 9,

+,-.J,. :;G?..?.G ,. 5?.; ) 3-;<; -; 945IJ 4:,@9

<,4J9?.G 4 F@:5?8 ,HH?8?45= ;9 8;9;<4 KK

L1 M?G-91

B1 KK ?J 9-49 4. ;N4CF5; ,H 3-49 E,@ C;4.

3-;. E,@ J4E E,@ 9-,@G-9 -; 34J 9<E?.G 9, ;N9,<9 E,@O

L1 P;4-1

B1 L.D 9-;<; 4<; J;Q;<45 ,9-;< 9-?.GJ ?. -;<;

9-49 J,@.D 4 5,9 5?I; 9-49 9, C;= J, C4E:; R 84.

J-,<98@9 9-?J1

RH E,@< Q?;3 ,H 9-?J G;.;<455E 34J -;SJ

9<E?.G 9, ;N9,<9 E,@= -;SJ 9-<;49;.?.G= -,3 D?D E,@

?.9;<F<;9 9-; 9-<;49O

L1 T-49 R 9-?.I -; -4D 9-; 4:?5?9E 9, D,U ?J

9-49 3-49 E,@ C;4.O

B1 P;4-1 T-49 34J 9-; 9-<;49 ?. E,@< C?.D 9,

E,@O

L1 V-49 -; 3,@5D 8<;49; 4 5?;= 4. 459;<.49?Q;

<;45?9E= 9-49 -; 3,@5D F@:5?J- ?9 :;H,<; 9-; F<?C4<E=

4.D RSC ;NF;<?;.8;D1 RSQ; J;;. 84CF4?G.J :;H,<;= 4.D

R I?.D ,H ;.Q?J?,.;D 9-; F,JJ?:?5?9E ,H 3-49 -4FF;.;D

9, C; 489@455E ?. +4.@4<E ,H "*!#= 9-49 -; 8,@5D

8<;49; 4 5?;1

R C;4.= -;SJ 945I?.G -;<; 4:,@9 :<?:;J=

Page 265: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 265/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

4.B C B?B.D9 -4E; FG ;HF4?5I J<,F 9-; K;<?,B ,J 9?F;

4.G 5,.L;<= 4.B C 34I.D9 85,I;5G ;.,@L- 8,..;89;B 9,

3-49 M?8-4<B -4B 489@455G B,.; 9, N.,3 3-49 -;DB

489@455G B,.;1 C -4B 4 5,9 ,J J4?9- ?. M?8-4<B= :@9

C B?B.D9 N.,3 3-49 +;<;FG 8,@5B 8,F; @K 3?9- ?J -;

34.9;B 9, 93, 3;;NI :;J,<; 9-; ;5;89?,. 4.B

4:I,5@9;5G F4N; ?9 ?FK,II?:5; J,< F; 9, -4E; 4.G

I@88;II 4.B <@?. FG <;K@949?,.1

O1 P-;. G,@ I4G 93, 3;;NI :;J,<; 9-;

;5;89?,.= G,@ F;4. 9-; K<?F4<GQ

R1 S;4-= ,< 9-<;; 3;;NI :;J,<; 9-; K<?F4<G ,<

F,.9- :;J,<; 9-; K<?F4<G ,< 9-; .;T9 B4G1

O1 2, 3-;. G,@ I4G 9-; 5?;= 3-49 B, G,@ F;4.Q

U, G,@ F;4. 9-49 9-?I 34I 4 :<?:;<G 4I ,KK,I;B 9,

5,::G?.L ,< I,F;9-?.L ;5I;Q P-49 34I 9-; 5?;Q

R1 S;4-= C 9-?.N ?9DI K<;99G 85;4< J<,F 9-;

9<4.I8<?K9 9-49 -; 8<;49;B 4 I8;.4<?, 4:,@9 HH 4.B ?.

FG F?.B -; 34I 945N?.L 4:,@9 -?I 4:?5?9G 9, 8<;49; 4

J?89?,.= 4.B C 9-?.N ,. K4L; ' F,<; I, 3-;<; -; I4?B=

VC9 3,.D9 F499;< ?J ?9DI ;E;. 9<@;= 9-;GD55 B, 9, G,@

3-49 9-;G B?B 9, F;= G,@ 3?55 :;8,F; 4 K4<?4-=V 4.B

549;< ,. ?. 9-; 8,.E;<I49?,. C :;5?;E; I,F;3-;<; ?9

I4GI= :;5?;E; F;= 9-; K<;II 3?55 :; 455 ,E;< ?9=

G,@D55 :; ,. WX= G,@D55 :; ,. <4B?,= G,@D55 :;

;E;<G3-;<;= ., ,.; 3?55 9,@8- G,@= G,@D55 :; 4

Page 266: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 266/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B4<?4-= 4.C D 9,,E 9-49 4F G,<; 9-4. 4 H;?5;C 9-<;49

,I 3-49 -; 34F 3?55?.J 9, C, 9, G; 9, B@9 B<;FF@<; ,.

K?8-4<C 9, <;F,5H; 9-?.JF 3?9- 9-;G1

L1 M, N,@ E.,3 ?I 9-;<; 34F F,G; ?GB;.C?.J

?.9;<H?;3 ,< 8,.H;<F49?,. +,-.F,. 34F J,?.J 9, -4H;

3?9- F,G;:,CN 3-;<; -; G?J-9 C, 3-49 -; 34F

9-<;49;.?.J 9, C, 9, N,@O

P1 D I;59 5?E; 3-49 -; 34F 9-<;49;.?.J 9, C,

34F J,?.J 9, :; C,.; B@:5?85N 3?9- 9-; G;C?4= F, D

C,.Q9 E.,3 ,I 4.N ?GB;.C?.J ?.9;<H?;3= .,1

L1 R-;<;QF 4 <;I;<;.8; ?. -;<; 9, 9-; STD=

I,< ;U4GB5; VV

P1 K?J-91

L1 VV 4.C DQG 3,.C;<?.J ?I B4<9 ,I= N,@ E.,3=

9-; @.FB,E;. 8,.9;U9 9, 9-?F 34F 9-49 -; 34F J,?.J 9,

:; ?.9;<H?;3;C :N 9-; STD ,< F,G;9-?.J1

M, N,@ E.,3 4:,@9 9-49O

P1 D C,.Q91 D 9-?.E -; 9,5C G; -; -4C :;;.

3,<E?.J 3?9- -?F 543N;< 4.C 9-49 9-; STD 34F 5,,E?.J1

W;QC :;;. 8-4<J;C 3?9- ,.; 8,@.9 45<;4CN ,I G4?5

I<4@C= F,G;9-?.J 5?E; 9-491

X21 +PX02Y X4?5 I<4@C1

RW0 ZDR[022Y 2, D 34F B@\\5;C 4.C 8@<?,@F

9-<,@J- 9-; 3-,5; 8,.H;<F49?,. 4F 9, 3-N 9-; STD

3,@5C -4H; 4.N ?.9;<;F9 ?. G;= 4.C 4I9;< D F;995;C

Page 267: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 267/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B,3.= 3-;. 9-; 8,.C;<D49?,. 34D ,C;<= 4.B 4D 4 E;3

3;;FD G4DD;B H :;84I; 8,.C?.8;B 9-49 -; 34D J@D9

9<K?.L 9, G@9 G<;DD@<; ,. I; 4.B D84<; I;= 4.B 3-;. H

8,.9?.@;B E,<34<B ?. 9-; G<?I4<K 4.B .,9-?.L

-4GG;.;B= H :;84I; I,<; 4.B I,<; 8,.C?.8;B -; 34D

J@D9 9<K?.L 9, G@D- IK :@99,.D1

M1 NOK P<1 A455?Q RE9;< K,@ L,9 ,@9 ,E 9-?D

I;;9?.L 4.B 9-,@L-9 4:,@9 ?9S

R1 T;55= K;4-1 H I;4.= H 4DF;B 4 U@;D9?,. ?.

9-?D ?.9;<C?;31 H D4?B ?D 9-;<; 4 G4G;< 9<4?5S V;

945F;B 4:,@9 9-; -,@D;:,49= 4.B G;,G5; -4C; 4DF;B I;

3-K B?B K,@ D4K 9-49= 4.B ?9 34D :;84@D; H 34D 9<K?.L

9, E?.B D,I; 8,..;89?,. :;93;;. 4.K9-?.L H -4B B,.;

3?9- +;<;IK +,-.D,.= :;84@D; H B?B.W9 D;; 9-49 -; -4B

4.K9-?.L 9-49 3,@5B ;C;. 5;4B 9-; XOH 9, ;C;. 4DF YY

-4C; 9-;I 3,.B;< ?E 9-;<; 34D 4.K <;45 <;549?,.D-?G

,< ?.C,5C;I;.9 :;93;;. @D1

2, H DG;.9 9-; 3-,5; I;;9?.L 9<K?.L 9,

E?L@<; ,@9 3-;<; -; 34D L,?.L 4.B 9<K?.L 9, 8,..;89

B,9D 9, D;; ?E -; 34D 9;55?.L I; 9-; 9<@9-= 4.B :K

9-; 9?I; HWI -45E34K 9-<,@L- 9-?D I;;9?.L HWI

9-?.F?.L -;WD D;99?.L I; @G= -;WD 9<K?.L 9, I4F; I;

.;<C,@D= -;WD 9<K?.L 9, D84<; I;= 4.B HWI J@D9 9<K?.L

9, -4.L ,. 9-<,@L- 9-; I;;9?.L 4.B .,9 I4F; -?I @GD;9

;.,@L- 9-49 -; 34D L,?.L 9, D9,<I ,@9 ,E 9-;<; 4.B B,

Page 268: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 268/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B,C;9-?.D 9;<<?:5; 9, C; 4.E C4F; @G B,C;9-?.D1

H1 7F4I1

J1 2, K 34B <;455I 9<I?.D 9, -4.D 3?9- -?C1

H1 A;9 C; E?<;89 I,@ 9, G4D; !(= 4.E

:;D?..?.D ,. 5?.; "" 9-;<;LB 4 B949;C;.9 3-;<; I,@

<;M;< 9, NN 3;55= KLC G?8F?.D @G ,. 5?.; "$1

OP-;<;LB .,9-?.D 3<,.D 3?9- 4.I9-?.D 9-49

KLQ; E,.; 8<?C?.455I1 R,3= G,5?9?8455I K D, 3-,41O

S-49 E?E I,@ C;4. :I 9-49T

J1 S;55= 3-49 K <;455I C;4.9 9-;<; 34B

B,C;,.; 8,@5E <;455I C4F; @G 4 B9,<I ?M 9-;I 34.9;E

9, 5?; 4:,@9 CI <;549?,.B-?G 3?9- +;<;CI +,-.B,.=

3-?8- ?B ;U4895I 3-49 -4GG;.;E= B, K 34B 3,<<?;E

4:,@9 9-; ?CG489 ,M 3-49 -; 8,@5E B4I ?M -; 3;<; 9,

5?; 4:,@9 ?9 ,. C; G,5?9?8455I1

H1 7F4I1 2, 34B I,@< NN 9-; .,9?,. ,M

8<?C?.45 B@DD;B9B 9, C; 9-49 I,@< 8,.8;<.= 49 5;4B9

?. 9-49 C,C;.9= C4I -4Q; :;;. ;Q;. E;;G;< 9-4.

G,5?9?8451

KB 9-49 488@<49;T

J1 R,1 R,= K 34B.L9 8,.8;<.;E 9-49 K -4E

E,.; 4.I9-?.D 8<?C?.455I 3<,.D1

H1 7F4I1

J1 R,9 4 9-?.D1 R,= ?9 34B 455 4:,@9 9-;

4GG;4<4.8;= 4.E 9-?B B949;C;.9 9-49 K C4F; -;<; ,.

Page 269: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 269/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B4C; !( ?D ?. 9-; 8,.9;E9 ,F 9-; 54D9 !' B4C;D ,F

9-?D C@G 489?.C 8<4HG ,. I;1

J<?,< 9, 9-?D= B<?,< 9, 9-?D I,I;.9= ?9

-4K .;L;< 8<,DD;K IG I?.K 9-49 +;<;IG +,-.D,. 3,@5K

:; 4:5; 9, D4G 9-,D; 9-?.CD ,< -4L; 4. ?.9;<;D9 ?.

B4?.9?.C 9-49 M?.K ,F 4 B?89@<; 3?9- I;1

N1 O,3 3,@5K G,@ K;D8<?:; 9-; .49@<; ,F G,@<

8,.8;<. 4D 4 <;D@59 ,F 9-?DP Q4D ?9 D?IB5G 3-49 G,@

D4?K 4:,@9 ?9 3,@5K -@<9 G,@< B,5?9?845 84IB4?C. 4

I,.9- :;F,<; 9-; B<?I4<GP R?K ?9 C, :;G,.K 9-49P

S1 2, TT G;D1 U-; 4.D3;< ?D 9-49 34D 9-;

8,.8;<. F,< I; 34D 9-; 84IB4?C.= :;84@D; V 9-?.M F,<

9-; F?<D9 9?I; ;L;< V -;4<K ?. B<?,< I,I;.9D ,F 9-;

8,.L;<D49?,. -?D 945M?.C 4:,@9 4 :<?:; 499;IB9 ,F 455

9-?.CD 4.K B@99?.C 9-?D ?. 4. @C5G 8,.9;E9= <49-;<

9-4. 4. -,.,<4:5; 8,.9;E9= 4.K V D94<9;K 9, D;; 3-49

VWL; 8,I; 9, F;;5 ?D 9-; <;45 +;<;IG +,-.D,.= 3-?8- V

-4K .;L;< M.,3. 9-49 I4. :;F,<;= 4.K ?9 D84<;K I; 9,

K;49-1

N1 Q4D 9-?D 4 9@<.?.C B,?.9 ?. G,@<

<;549?,.D-?B 3?9- -?IP

S1 S:D,5@9;5G1

N1 7M4G1 O,3 3,@5K G,@ K;D8<?:; 9-; 5;L;5 ,F

G,@< 8,.8;<. 4:,@9 9-; B,5?9?845 <;B;<8@DD?,.DP V

I;4.= 34D 9-?D TT ,. ,.; -4.K G,@WL; D4?K -;WD 8<4HG=

Page 270: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 270/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

:@9 BCD 45E, F;99?.F 9-; E;.E; 9-49 G,@ 3;<; 94H?.F

9-?E E;<?,@E5G1

I1 J;55= B D;4. 9, E4G B 34E.C9 94H?.F ?9

E;<?,@E5G 4E .,9 9, <;4K 9-; 9<4.E8<?L91 B 34E

8,.8;<.;K1 M; -4K E84<;K D; 9, K;49-1 M;CK :;8,D; 4

D,.E9;< 4:,@9 3-49 -;CK :; 3?55?.F 9, K,= 4.K -;

48H.,35;KF;K ,. 9-; ,.; -4.K 9-49 B -4K.C9 K,.;

4.G9-?.F 5?H; 3-49 -; 34E E@FF;E9?.F -; 8,@5K E4G BCK

K,.;= 3-?5; ,. 9-; ,9-;< -4.K -; 34E E4G?.F B 84. F;9

?9 455 ,N;< 9-; L4L;<E= 455 ,N;< 9-; .;3E= G,@C55

:;8,D; 4 L4<?4-= 4.K B @.K;<E9,,K 84DL4?F.?.F 3;55

;.,@F- 9, H.,3 9-49 ?. 4 8,@L5; 3;;HE 9-49 8,@5K :;

N;<G -4<K 9, <;8,N;< O<,D ?. P@E9 4 E-,<9 L;<?,K ,O

9?D;1

Q1 M4K G,@ -4K 9-?E RR 9-; 8,.8;<. G,@ -4K 4E

4 <;E@59 ,O 9-?E D;;9?.F= -4K G,@ -4K 9-49 L<?,<S

B D;4.= O,< ;T4DL5;= 3-;. G,@ D;9 3?9- -?D

?. 549; "*!!= K?K G,@ -4N; 8,.8;<.E 9-49 +,-.E,. D4G

E,D;-,3 9@<. ,. G,@S

I1 B K?K.C9 -4N; 4.G 8,.8;<.E 4:,@9 9-491

Q1 M4K G,@ 945H;K 3?9- +4E,. U,3;<E 4:,@9

+,-.E,. L<?,< 9, 9-?E D;;9?.FS

I1 B K,.C9 9-?.H E,= .,9 ?. 9-49 8,.9;T9 49

455= 4.K RR G;4-1 V,1 B 3,@5K.C9 -4N; D;9 3?9-

+;<;DG +,-.E,. ?O BCK O;59 5?H; -; -4K 9-; 84L48?9G

Page 271: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 271/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

9, B, 3-49 -; B?B 9, C; ?. 9-?D C;;9?.E1 F. G489=

9-49 34D 9-; 54D9 9?C; F ;H;< C;9 3?9- -?C1

I1 A;9 C; -4H; J,@ E, 9, K4E; %"1 7. 5?.; "!

J,@ D4J= LF 9-?.M FNC 9-;?< 94<E;91L

O-49 B?B J,@ C;4. :J 9-49P

Q1 FNB -4H; 9, <;4B RR FNB S@D9 -4H; 9, <;4B

9-; 8,.9;T91

I1 2@<;1

UO?9.;DD ;T4C?.?.E B,8@C;.91V

WX0 OFWY022Z 2, 3-49ND J,@< [@;D9?,.P

I1 U\J ]<1 A455?V O;55= FNC ?.9;<;D9;B RR

3-49 34D J,@< 8,.8;<. 34D CJ [@;D9?,.P

Q1 O;55= :J 9-?D 9?C; F 9-?.M FNB :;;. ?.

9-?D 8,.H;<D49?,. G,< 4. -,@< 3?9- 9-?D E@J1 FNC

9<J?.E 9, -,5B ,.9, 9-; 8,.H;<D49?,. 9, 9-; H;<J ;.B

D, 9-49 -; B,;D.N9 5;4H; @KD;9= 4.B F 9-?.M FNC S@D9

9<J?.E 9, :; 4D 8,.8?5?49,<J 4D F 84. :;= 4.B FNC=

G<4.M5J= 3,<<?;B1

I1 O-,D; 94<E;9 4.B 94<E;9 G,< 3-49P

Q1 F B,.N9 <;84551

I1 7M4J1 ^4E; %&= 5?.; !#= LF M.,31 \@9 49

9-; ;.B ,G 9-; B4J F B,.N9 34.9 9, :; 4 G;5,.1L

Q1 _?E-91

I1 `?<D9 ,G 455= F C;4.= ?D 9-49 488@<49;P

FD 9-49 <;455J 3-49 J,@ D4?BP

Page 272: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 272/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B C;4.= 3;<; D,@ 8,.8;<.;E FF

GH1 2I7JK J,@5E D,@ 5?L; 9, :; 4 M;5,.N

GH1 AOAABK J;55= B P@;QQ FF

RS0 JBRI022K R-49TQ 4. -,.;Q9 Q949;C;.91

B E,.T9 34.9 9, :; 4 M;5,.1 U,@ L.,3= 4Q B <;8455

M<,C 9-; 9<4.Q8<?V9 BTW; <;4E= ?9 Q;;C;E 9, C4L; C,<;

Q;.Q; 5,,L?.P 49 ?9 ?. 9-; 8,.9;X9 ,M Q,C;,.; Q;99?.P

C; @V= 9-49 ?9 34Q C,<; <-;9,<?8451

Y1 Z[D G<1 A455?\ ], D,@ L.,3 FF 9-?Q L?.E

,M P,;Q :48L 9, CD ^@;Q9?,. 4:,@9 9-; _[B1

O1 `-F-@- ZD;Q\1

Y1 U,@T<; 945L?.P 4:,@9 :;?.P Q,C;,.;TQ

94<P;9= D,@T<; 945L?.P 4:,@9 :;?.P 4 M;5,.= 4.E BTC

a@Q9 3,.E;<?.P ?M 9-;<;TQ Q,C; 8,.9;X9 9, 9-?Q

E?Q8@QQ?,. 9-49 E,;Q.T9 8,C; M<,C 4.D 9<4.Q8<?V9 FF

O1 J;55= ;X8;V9 9-49 FF

Y1 FF 3-;<; D,@ 3,@5E :; 8,.8;<.;E 4:,@9

:;?.P Q,C;,.;TQ 94<P;9= V4<9?8@54<5D 4 8<?C?.45

94<P;9N

O1 J;55= B 9-?.L 9-49 9-; ,.5D FF B 9-?.L 9-;

,.5D 34D 9, 5,,L 49 9-; 8,.W;<Q49?,. ?Q ?. 9-;

8,.9;X9 ,M 9-; 8,.W;<Q49?,.= 4.E BTW; P,9 4 P@D 3-,

5,,LQ 5?L; -;TQ P,?.P ,MM 9-; <;Q;<W49?,.1 B E,.T9

L.,3 3-49 -;TQ Q4D?.P 9, 4.D:,ED= 4.E B E,.T9 L.,3

3-49 -;TQ 3?55?.P 9, C4L; @V= 4.E= D,@ L.,3= BT55

Page 273: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 273/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9;55 B,@ C4B:; ?9 34D 4 E<;C,.?9?,.= :;84@D; ;?F-9

C,.9-D 549;< G H?.I CBD;5H 3-491 J,@ K.,3= D,C;,.;

455;F;D 9-49 GLM; 9<?;I 9, :<?:; 4 D;.49,<1 G 8455

H,< 4. ?.M;D9?F49?,.= 4.I GLC 9-,<,@F-5B 9@<.;I

@ED?I; I,3. 4.I= B,@ K.,3= ?.M;D9?F49;I H,< 9;.

C,.9-D1

N9 D,C; E,?.9 GLM; E<,:4:5B :;8,C; 4

94<F;9= 4.I D, ?. 9-; 8,.9;O9 ,H 9-?D 3-,5; ;C,9?,.45

C;;9?.F H,< C; 3?9- 4 H<?;.I= 4H9;< 4. -,@< 4.I 4

-45H GLC P@D9 -4.F?.F ,. 9<B?.F 9, F;9 9-<,@F- 4

8,.M;<D49?,.= :;?.F 4D 4F<;;4:5; 4D G 84. :; 9, F;9

?9 H?.?D-;I 3?9-,@9 -?C :;?.F D, C4I 9-49 -;LD P@D9

F,?.F 9, F, C4K; @E D,C;9-?.F 4.I <@?. CB 5?H;1

Q-49LD 9-; 8,.9;O9 ,H 3-;<; G 4C 49 9-?D E,?.9 ?.

9?C; ?. 9-; 8,.M;<D49?,.1

R1 7K4B1

ST1 2U7VW X?M; 9, !* C,.9- ?.M;D9?F49?,.=

B,@ C;4. 9-; Y;E4<9C;.9 ,H +@D9?8;Z

Q[0 VGQU022W T?F-91

ST1 2U7VW V-;<; 9-;B 9,5I B,@ B,@ 3;<; 4

3?9.;DDZ

Q[0 VGQU022W T?F-91

R1 \]B S<1 A455?^ V-49 I?I B,@ I, 4H9;< 9-?D

C;;9?.F 3?9- +;<;CB +,-.D,.Z

N1 V;55= 4H9;< 9-; C;;9?.F= 4.I G I,.L9 K.,3

Page 274: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 274/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

-,3 B@?8C5D ?9 34E= :@9 3?9-?. 4 8,@F5; ,G H4DE I

8455;H J?8-4<H J435; 4.H -4H 4 8,.K;<E49?,. 3?9- -?L=

4.H 9-;. I 3,<C;H ,. L;L,<?45?M?.N 9-49 8,.K;<E49?,.=

H,8@L;.9?.N 9-49 3?9- 4 5;99;< I E;.9 9, J?8-4<H= 4.H

LD :4E?8 4HK?8; 9, J?8-4<H 34E D,@ F<,:4:5D 34.9 9,

E?9 H,3. 3?9- 9-?E F;<E,. 4.H E;; ?G D,@ 84. 3,<C

E,L;9-?.N ,@9= 3-?8- 34E F<,:4:5D 9-; <?N-9 9-?.N 9,

H, 4.D34D 4.H N;9 ?9 <;E,5K;H ?. E,L; 34D= 4.H :D 9-;

34D= D,@ ,@N-9 9, -?<; D,@<E;5G 4 543D;< 9, .;N,9?49;

3?9- -?E 543D;< 4.H O@E9 N;9 9-; 9-?.N <;E,5K;H=

H;8?H; ?G D,@P<; N,?.N 9, H, E,L;9-?.N ,< .,9 4.H N;9

?9 <;E,5K;H1

Q1 R-49 H?H J?8-4<H E4D ?. <;EF,.E; 9, 9-49S

T1 U; E4?H 9-49PE F<,:4:5D 4 N,,H ?H;41 I9PE

F<,:4:5D 9?L;1

Q1 V?H J?8-4<H ?.H?849; 9, D,@ 9-49 9-;<; -4H

:;;. E,L; ,.N,?.N H?45,N@; 9-49 -;PH :;;. -4K?.N

;?9-;< 3?9- +,-.E,. ,< 3?9- J,9-:4<H ,< A;4K?99S

T1 I H,.P9 <;8455 9-491

Q1 R,@5H ?9 E@<F<?E; D,@ ?G -; -4H :;;.

-4K?.N 4. ,.N,?.N H?45,N@; 3?9- 9-;LS

T1 I 9-?.C ?9 3,@5H1 I 9-?.C ?9 3,@5H O@E9

:;84@E; I C.,3 J?8-4<H= 4.H I O@E9 WW I 9-?.C 9-49 -;

G;59 O@E9?G?;H ?. -?E 4<<4.N;L;.9 3?9- X<1 +,-.E,.=

:@9 I 9-?.C 9-49 -; .;;H;H 9, @.H;<E94.H 9-49

Page 275: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 275/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B<1 +,-.C,. 34C .,9 D,?.D 434E 4.F 9-49 -; -4F 9,

G48; 9-; ?CC@; 49 C,H; I,?.9 4.F D;9 ?9 <;C,5J;F1

K1 L;55= ;4<5?;< 3; 5,,M;F 49 4 B4<8- $=

"*!!= 5;99;< 9-49 N,9-:4<F -4F C;.9 9, N435;1

O1 N?D-91

K1 O.F :E 9-; 9?H; E,@P<; -4J?.D 9-?C H;;9?.D

3?9- +,-.C,. 4.F 9-;. 3?9- N435; 34C H,<; 9-4. 4 E;4<

549;<1

O1 N?D-91

K1 O.F QPH 3,.F;<?.D ?G E,@ M.,3 ,G 4.E9-?.D

3?9- <;CI;89 9, 4 F;H4.F G,< 4 <;[email protected] 9<4.CI?<;F ?.

9-49 E;4< 4.F 93, ,< 9-<;; H,.9-CR

O1 Q F,.P9 M.,31 Q F,.P9 <;H;H:;<1

BN1 AOAAQS A;9PC D, 9, $*1

$%&'()(* ,- ./0 1/23%456 

K1 TUE B<1 A455?V 7M4E1 0W-?:?9 $* ?C 4

B4E "= "*!"= 5;99;< G<,H E,@ 9, N?8-4<F N435;1

QC 9-?C 9-; 5;99;< E,@ 3;<; <;G;<;.8?.D 4

H,H;.9 4D,R

O1 Q9 ?C1

K1 O.F 9-; 8,.J;<C49?,. E,@P<; <;G;<<?.D 9,

3?9- N?8-4<F 34C 9-; 9;5;I-,.; 8,.J;<C49?,. E,@ X@C9

F;C8<?:;FR

O1 Y;C= @-Z-@-1

K1 7M4E1 O.F ?. 9-; G?<C9 I4<4D<4I- 9-;

Page 276: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 276/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

8,.B;<C49?,. 3?9- +,-.C,. 34C 9-; D<?CEF D<;G;

8,.B;<C49?,.= H 94I; ?9J

K1 L?M-91

N1 7I4F1 KM4?.= 3-49 34C F,@< E@<E,C; ?.

C;.O?.M 9-?C 5;99;<J

K1 H9 34C 9, O,8@G;.9 9-49 -; 4.O H -4O -4O 4

8,.B;<C49?,. 4.O 9, O,8@G;.9 9-49 HPO 4CI;O -?G 4:,@9

9-; C,@<8; ,Q 9-; [email protected] Q,< 3-?8- HPO :;;. E4?O Q,<

9-; 8;G;.9 3,<I= ,< RS2,5@9?,.C -4O :;;. E4?O Q,< 9-;

8;G;.9 3,<I= 4.O 9, 5;9 -?G I.,3 9-49 ?Q -; -4O E4?O

G; Q<,G 9-; C4G; 488,@.9= 9-49 GF <;8,GG;.O49?,.

3,@5O :; 9, -4B; 9-49 <;[email protected];O 4.O E4?O Q<,G 4

O?QQ;<;.9 488,@.9 C, 9-49 ?9 3,@5O.P9 :; 8,G?.M Q<,G

4.F C,@<8; ,Q [email protected] 9-49 -4O :;;. 9,@8-;O :F

+;<;GF +,-.C,.1

N1 7I4F1 K.O 3-;. 3; G;9 54C9 4.O 5,,I;O 49

F,@< ?.B,?8;C= 9-; 93, ?.B,?8;C F,@ E<;E4<;O Q,< 3,<I

,. >-4E4<<45 SS

K1 L?M-91

N1 SS F,@ C4?O 9-49 F,@ -4O E<;E4<;O 9-;G ?.

9-; C4G; 9?G; Q<4G;T ?C 9-49 8,<<;89J

K1 U;C= 9-; C4G; 9?G; Q<4G; 4C 9-?C

V?.O?849?.MW= F;4-1

N1 7I4F1 2, 34C 9-49 SS 9-; E<;E4<49?,. ,Q

9-,C; ?.B,?8;C= 34C 9-49 ?. Q@<9-;<4.8; ,Q 9-; C4G;

Page 277: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 277/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

,:B;89?C; 4D 3<?9?.E 9-?D 5;99;<F

G1 H;D1

I1 G.J 9-; <;[email protected] ,K 9-; L,.;M 9, NON 4.J

<;P4ML;.9 K<,L 4 J?KK;<;.9 488,@.9= 34D 9-49 ?.

K@<9-;<4.8; ,K 9-; D4L; ,:B;89?C;F

G1 H;D= 459-,@E- ?. 9-; L;4.9?L;= :;93;;. 9-;

9?L; Q J<;3 @P 9-?D 5;99;< 4.J 9-; 9?L; 3; J?J 9-,D;

9-?.ED= Q :<,@E-9 LM 3?K; ?. 9-; 5,,P= 4.J 3; J;8?J;J

9,E;9-;< 9, J, 9-?D 4.J 9, J, ?9 9-<,@E- RS2,5@9?,.D1

I1 T-, 34D 9-; ?.9;.J;J 4@J?;.8; K,< 9-;

5;99;< ,< 9-; ?.C,?8;D ,< 9-; <;[email protected] ,K 9-; L,.;MF

G1 Q J?J.U9 V.,3 3-, 3,@5J D;; 9-?D D,L; J4M=

:@9 Q 8;<94?.5M 34.9;J ?9 9, :; 85;4< 9-49 N?8-4<J

4.J Q -4J 945V;J1 Q 34.9;J -?L 9, :; 85;4< 9-49 9-?D

34D 4 8,.C;<D49?,. QUJ -4J 3?9- O<1 +,-.D,.= 9-49 ?9

34D ?LP,<94.9 9, L; 9-49 -; 5;9 L; V.,3 4:,@9 9-;

D,@<8; ,K 9-; [email protected] 4.J 9-49 9-?D ;4<5M Q 34.9;J

9, SS QU55 P@9 ?9 ,. 9-; <;8,<J 9-49 Q 34.9;J 9,

<;[email protected] 9-; L,.;M ?K 9-; L,.;M -4J 8,L; K<,L 9-49

488,@.91

2, 3?9-?. 4 K;3 J4MD ,K LM @.J;<D94.J?.E

9-49 ?9 34D P,DD?:5; 9-49 QUJ :;;. P4?J K<,L 9-49

488,@.9= 9-49 Q 34.9;J 9, L4V; D@<; 9-49 Q 49 5;4D9

-4J :<,48-;J 9-; D@:B;89 3?9- -?L 9-49 Q 34D

?.9;<;D9;J ?. 9-49 9MP; ,K 4 <;[email protected] 4.J 4 <;P4ML;.91

Page 278: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 278/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1 E;55= 5;9FG G94<9 3?9- 9-; <;[email protected]

E-49 3,@5I 9-49 488,JK5?G-L MFJ .,9

H,55,3?.N D,@< 5,N?8 ,. 9-491

O1 E;55= ?9 3,@5I.F9 488,JK5?G- 4.D9-?.N

5;N455D= :@9 8;<94?.5D M 34G.F9 3,<<?;I 4:,@9 9-;

5;N45?9D ,H 3-49 MFI I,.;1

E-49 M 34G ?.9;<;G9;I ?. 34G J4C?.N G@<;

9-49 M 34G .,9 :;.;H?99?.N H<,J 4. ?.9<,I@89?,. 9-49

MFI J4I; 9, P?8-4<I ,. :;-45H ,H +;<;JD +,-.G,. 4.I

9-49= D,@ C.,3= M I?G8@GG;I ?9 3?9- JD 543D;<= 4.I 3;

:,9- 4N<;;I 9-49 5;N455D ?9 I?I.F9 J4C; J@8- ,H 4

I?HH;<;.8;= :@9 ,K9?8455D ?9 3,@5I :; :;99;< ?H M

<;9@<.;I 9-49 J,.;D 4.I 9-49 9-;<; 3,@5I :; <;455D .,

34D G,J;,.; 8,@5I G4D 9-49 9-; J,.;D M -4I <;94?.;I=

9-49 QR2,5@9?,.G -4I <;94?.;I= -4I G,J;-,3 8,J; H<,J

4 9<4.G489?,. :;93;;. P?8-4<I P435; 4.I +;<;JD

+,-.G,.1

B1 O.I 3-;. D,@ G4D ,K9?8455D= 3-,G; ;D;G 4<;

D,@ 8,.8;<.;I 4:,@9L

O1 E;55= 4N4?. RR

B1 MG ?9 9-; K<;GGL MG ?9 RR

O1 S-?G ?G ?. 9-; 8,.9;T9 ,H 9-; 8,.U;<G49?,.

9-49 +;<;JD +,-.G,. 4.I M -4I V@G9 N,.; 9-<,@N-1

ON4?.= 4G M G4?I ?. 9-; 8,.U;<G49?,.= 9-;

,K9?8G ,H 9-; 455;N49?,. 9-49 M -4I :;;. ?.U,5U;I ?.

Page 279: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 279/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4 :<?:;<B ?.C,5C?.D 4 E;.49,< 34E E,F;9-?.D 9-49

3,@5G :; C;<B -4<G 9, ,C;<8,F;= 4.G E, 9-?E 34E FB

499;FH9 9, G,8@F;.9 4.G 4EI 4 J@;E9?,. 4.G 9-;. G,

3-49 K 8,@5G 9, 49 5;4E9 :; 4:5; 9, E4B= 3;55= ?L K

G,.M9 NN ?L K G?G.M9 I.,3 4:,@9 ?9= 8;<94?.5B 3-;. K

L,@.G ,@9 4:,@9 ?9 K 9<?;G 9, F4I; ?9 <?D-9= 4.G

9-49ME <;455B 3-49 9-49 3-,5; 9-?.D 34E 4:,@9 34E

9<B?.D 9, F4I; ?9 <?D-9= ,H9?8455B 49 5;4E91

O1 2, 3;<; 9-;E; ;LL,<9E= 9-; <;[email protected]?.D ,L

9-; F,.;B= 9-; 3<?9?.D ,L 9-; 5;99;<= 9-; 8<;49?.D ,L

9-; ?.C,?8;E= 34E 9-49 E,<9 ,L 4. 499;FH9 9, H<;;FH9=

,< ;C;. ?L .,9 H<;;FH9= ;PH54?. 9, B,@<E;5L ?L 4.G

3-;. 9-?E :;84F; H@:5?8Q

R1 K 9-?.I 9-49 3-49 K 34.9;G 9, G, 4E E,,.

4E K L,@.G ,@9 ?9 8,@5G :;8,F; 4. ?EE@; H,EE?:5B=

3-?5; 9-; <;8,55;89?,. ?E 4E L<;E- ,. FB F?.G 4.G

S?8-4<GME F?.G 4E H,EE?:5;= I.,3?.D ?9 34E 4 B;4<

549;<= 3?9-,@9 9,, F@8- 9?F; D,?.D :B 9, 9<B 9,

G,8@F;.9 ,@< <;549?,.E-?H= 9-; 3,<I K -4G G,.; ,. 9-;

H<,T;89= 3-?8- 34E -4<G ;.,@D- D,?.D :48I 4 B;4<= 4.G

-4C; 9-?.DE G,8@F;.9;G E, 9-49 ?L K ;C;< .;;G;G 9, D,

:48I= ?L 9-;<; 34E ;C;< 4 J@;E9?,.= K 3,@5G -4C; 9-;

F,E9 8,.9;FH,<4.;,@E <;8,55;89?,. K 8,@5G H,EE?:5B

-4C;= 8,.9;FH,<4.;,@E 9, 9-; ;C;.9E 4.G 9, 3-49 KMG

L,@.G ,@9 9-49 9-; F,.;B -4G 8,F; L<,F 9-; E4F;

Page 280: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 280/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

488,@.9= :;84@B; :4B?8455C +;<;DC +,-.B,. ?. 9-;

E-,.; 8,.F;<B49?,. B4?G 9-49 -; 9-,@H-9 I D?H-9 -4F;

H,99;. E4?G ,. -?B ,9-;< ?BB@;1

JK1 2L7MN O-?B ?B 9-; P<?BEC P<;D;

8,.F;<B49?,.Q

OR0 MIOL022N O-; P<?BEC P<;D;

8,.F;<B49?,.= 4.G B, I 34.9;G 9, 3-?5; K?8-4<G 34B

B9?55 45?F;= 3-?5; ?9 34B S<;B- ,. DC D?.G H, :48T

4.G 9<C 9, G,8@D;.9 ;U4895C 3-49 3;VG G,.;= 3-49 IVG

G,.; 4.G 3-49 I H,9 E4?G S,<1

W1 XYC J<1 A455?Z 2, 34B 9-; 4@G?;.8; S,<

9-?B D;BB4H; @59?D49;5C 9-; F,9?.H E@:5?8Q

[1 I 3,@5G.V9 B4C ?9 34B \@B9 9-; F,9?.H

E@:5?81 I 9-?.T ?9 34B 4.C:,GC 3-, 3,@5G :;

?.9;<;B9;G 49 B,D; E,?.9 ?. 9?D;= ?.85@G?.H 9-;

8,@<9= ?.85@G?.H 4.C:,GC1

W1 [.G 9-; .49@<; ,S C,@< 8,.8;<. S<,D 9-;

P<?BEC D;;9?.H= P<?BEC P<;D; D;;9?.H= 34B 9-49 C,@

3,@5G :; -4<D;G E,5?9?8455C ?. 9-; ?DE;.G?.H E<?D4<C

;5;89?,.Q

[1 M;55= ?DD;G?49;5C 49 9-49 9?D; ?9 34B 9-;

E<?D4<C= :@9 ?9 34B 45B, 4:,@9 DC <;E@949?,.1 I9 34B

4:,@9 84B9?.H 3-49 I -4G G,.; 5;H?9?D49;5C ?. 4 S45B;

5?H-9 3-;<; K?8-4<G 4.G I -4G -4G 4 <;549?,.B-?E 9-49

G?G.V9 <;]@?<; 4 5,9 ,S G,8@D;.949?,. ?. ,@<

Page 281: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 281/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

;BC;<?;.8; 3?9- ;48- ,9-;<1

D1 E.F ?. G,@< H?.F 3<?9?.I 9-; 5;99;<=

C<;C4<?.I 9-; ?.J,?8;K= <;9@<.?.I 9-; H,.;G= 9-49

488,HC5?K-;F G,@< ,:L;89?J;M

E1 N;55= .,= :@9 ?9 8;<94?.5G I4J; H; 4

<;O;<;.8; C,?.9 9, F,8@H;.9 3-49 3; -4F F,.; 3-;<;

P?8-4<F 4.F Q 8,@5F 8,.9;HC,<4.;,@K5G 3,<R 9,I;9-;<

9, SS 4.F 9-49TK 3-49 QTJ; F,.; ?. 9-; ?.J,?8;K1 Q

9-?.R Q H4G -4J; 945R;F 4:,@9 ?9 ;4<5?;< 9-49 Q 3;.9

:48R 9, -?H= 3; 3;.9 ,J;< 3-49 Q -4F F,.; 4.F F?F 9-;

:;K9 Q 8,@5F 9, F,8@H;.9 4.F <;8,.K9<@89 9-;

<;549?,.K-?C 9-49 3; -4F <;549?J; 9, 9-,K; C<,L;89K1

UP1 AEAAQV 7R4G1 W,<9GS,.;1

#$%&'(') +, -./ 0.12$345 

D1 XYG U<1 A455?Z 0B-?:?9 $! ?K 9-;

P?8-4<F P435; [;854<49?,.1

\,@TJ; K;;. 9-?K= 8,<<;89M

E1 Q -4J;1

D1 ],3 34K 9-?K C<;C4<;F^ F, G,@ R.,3M

E1 N;55= P?8-4<F 34K <;455G I;99?.I K?8R 4.F

94R?.I 4 F,3.9@<.= 4.F Q :;5?;J; Q C<;C4<;F K,H;

.,9;K 9-49 Q I4J; 9, HG 543G;<= 4.F Q :;5?;J; -;

C<;C4<;F 4 F<4O9= 4.F Q :;5?;J; ?9 34K K;.9 ,J;< 9,

>,<9 N45R;<1 >,<9 N45R;< <;J?K;F ?9 ;B9;.K?J;5G= Q

:;5?;J;= 4.F O?.45?_;F ?9 4.F 9-;. C<;K;.9;F ?9 9,

Page 282: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 282/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B?8-4<C 9-<,@D- -?E 499,<.;F 4.C <;G?;3;C ?9 3?9-

-?H1 I-49JE KK

L1 M-,E; ?C;4 34E ?9 9, -4G; B?8-4<C C, 4

N;854<49?,.O M4E 9-49 F,@< ?C;4O

P1 Q,= R C,.J9 9-?.S ?9 34E HF ?C;41 R 9-?.S

9-49 9-; 499;HT9 34E 9, T<;E;<G; -?E 9;E9?H,.F

:;84@E; -?E C;49- 34E ?HH?.;.9= :@9 R C,.J9 S.,3

3-,E; ?C;4 ?9 34E1 R C,.J9 9-?.S ?9 34E HF ?C;41

L1 U<;E;<G; -?E 9;E9?H,.F V,< 3-49 T@<T,E;O

P1 M;55= :F 9-49 9?H; R -4C :;;. 9,5C :F

W4<S 2-@<95;VV 9-49 +;<;HF +,-.E,. -4C D,.; 9, 9-;

!"#$%&'= 4.C +;<;HF +,-.E,. -4C D,.; 9, W4<S

2-@<95;VV= 4.C W4<S 2-@<95;VV -4C D,.; 9, 9-; XYR=

4.C +;<;HF +,-.E,. -4C :;;. <4?E?.D 455;D49?,.E KK

9-?E ?E ?. Q,G;H:;< "*!" 4V9;< 9-; ;5;89?,.= 4.C E,

3?9- 9-; 4.9?8?T49?,. 9-49 E,H;,.; H?D-9 4ES

Z@;E9?,.E 4:,@9 ,@< <;549?,.E-?T= :4E;C ,. 3-49 3;

3;<; -;4<?.D= R 9-?.S 9-; T,?.9 ,V 9-?E 34E 9,

T<;E;<G; W<1 B435;JE 9;E9?H,.F ?. 84E; -; T4EE;C

434F1

L1 N, F,@ S.,3 3-49= ?V 4.F= 8-4.D;E

W<1 B435; H4C; 9, 9-; C<4V9 9-49 F,@< 543F;<

T<;T4<;CO

P1 R C,.J91 R C,.J9 S.,3 ET;8?V?8455F 3-49

8-4.D;E 9-;<; 3;<;1

Page 283: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 283/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC 9-; 34C= D?D C,@ E4C FC 543C;< G<;G4<;D

,< H G<;G4<;DI

J1 H 9-,@K-9 C,@ 9,5D F; C,@< 543C;< G<;G4<;D

9-?E1

L1 M?K-91 N;55= H F;4.= H 9-?.O 9-?E ,.;111

PM1 2Q7NR HS ?9 3;.9 9, -?E 543C;<= C;4-1

TU0 NHTQ022R 2,F;9-?.K E,F;9-?.K661

PM1 2Q7NR L.D H 9-?.O 24F1

TU0 NHTQ022R 7O4C1 2,F;9-?.K

E,F;9-?.K661

J1 VBC P<1 A455?W X?D C,@ 945O 9, M?8-4<D

4:,@9 9-?E X;854<49?,.= ,< D?D C,@ Y@E9 3,<O 9-<,@K-

C,@< 499,<.;C 4.D >,<9 N45O;<I

L1 H D,.Z9 :;5?;[; H 945O;D 9, -?F 4:,@9 9-;

X;854<49?,.1 H :;5?;[; ?9 34E <@. 9-<,@K-

>,<9 N45O;< 4.D -?E 499,<.;C1

J1 X?D C,@ E;; -?F ?. 9-; -,EG?945 D@<?.K

9-?E 9?F; S<4F;I

L1 H D?D1

J1 B@9 .,9 D?E8@EE?.K 9-; X;854<49?,.I

L1 T-49ZE <?K-91

J1 L.D 34E C,@< 8,.8;<. ?. G<;G4<?.K 9-;

X;854<49?,. 9-49 C,@ F?K-9 ;.D @G ?. ;\4895C 9-; 9CG;

,S ?.[;E9?K49?,.E C,@Z[; ;.D;D @G ?.I

PM1 2Q7NR H D,.Z9 9-?.O -; 9;E9?S?;D -;

Page 284: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 284/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B<;B4<;C 9-; D;854<49?,.= ?E 9-49FG 3-49 H,@F<;

G@II;G9?.I1

JK0 LMJN022O P;4-= G, 9;55 Q; 3-49

H,@< RR

S1 TUH V<1 A455?W P,@ X.;3 9-?G D;854<49?,.

34G :;?.I B<;B4<;C= 8,<<;89Y

Z1 [?I-91

S1 Z.C H,@ 4I<;;C 3?9- 9-49Y

Z1 M 34.9;C 9, Q4X; G@<; 9-49 RR M Q;4. RR

V[1 2N7LO P;G ,< .,Y

JK0 LMJN022O D?C M 4I<;; 3?9- 9-49Y D?C

M 4I<;; 3?9- 9-; E489 9-49 ?9 34G :;?.I B<;B4<;CY

P;G RR

S1 TUH V<1 A455?W P;G= 4.C RR

Z1 RR M 9-,@I-9 ?9 34G 4 I,,C ?C;41

V[1 2N7LO L;F<; 9<H?.I 9, I;9 ,@9 ,E -;<;

:H E?\;R9-?<9H1

S1 TUH V<1 A455?W Z.C 34G H,@< RR M Q;4.=

<;455H= ?9 :;IG 9-; ]@;G9?,. ,E B<;B4<49?,. E,< 3-49Y

L-49 ?G ?9 9-49 H,@ 3;<;

4.9?8?B49?.I 3,@5C ,88@< ,< Q?I-9 ,88@< 3-;<; H,@FC

.;;C 9-?G D;854<49?,.Y

Z1 L;55= ?E MF\; I,9 G,Q;,.; ,@9 9-;<;

9;55?.I 5?;G 4:,@9 Q; 4.C MF\; I,9 4 3?9.;GG 3-,FG

4:,@9 9, C?;= MFQ ?.9;<;G9;C= 4.C M 34G ?.9;<;G9;C

Page 285: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 285/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

?. BB 4.C DE 543E;< 34F ?.9;<;F9;C ?. D4G?.H F@<;

9-49 -?F 9;F9?D,.E 3,@5C F@<I?I; -?D1

J1 K4F E,@< 8,.8;<. FL;8?M?8455E 4:,@9 :;?.H

?.I,5I;C ?. 4 :<?:;<E 455;H49?,. ,< 34F ?9 :<,4C;<

9-4. 9-49N

O1 P C,.Q9 G.,31 P C,.Q9 <;84551 P 3?55 F4E

9-?FR PQC 45<;4CE 3,. 9-; ;5;89?,. 49 9-?F L,?.9= F,

P 34F.Q9 3,<<?;C 4:,@9 3?..?.H 4. ;5;89?,.1 S,<;

9-4. 4.E9-?.H= P 34F BB P 9-,@H-9 ?9 3,@5C :; I;<E

-;5LM@5 9, -4I; F,D;,.; 3-, @.C;<F9,,C ,@<

<;549?,.F-?L :; 4:5; 9, F-4<; 3-49 9-49 34F 3-;. P

34F M48?.H <@D,<F 9-49 S<1 +,-.F,. 34F 8<;49?.H 4

M45F; 459;<.49?I;= 4 M45F; M4891

J1 PM E,@ H, :48G 9, S4E ,M "*!" 3-;. E,@

3;<; 3<?9?.H 9-; 5;99;<F 4.C L<;L4<?.H 9-; ?.I,?8;F

?. 9-; 34G; ,M 9-; T<?FLE T<;D; D;;9?.H= 3,@5C ?9 :;

488@<49; 9, F949; 9-49 E,@ 3;<; 8,.8;<.;C 4:,@9 4

:<?:;<E 455;H49?,.= ,< 34F 9-; 8,.8;<. :<,4C;< 9-4.

:<?:;<EN

O1 P9 34F :<,4C;< 9-4. :<?:;<E1

J1 O.C -,3 D@8- :<,4C;<N K-49 ;5F; ,9-;<

9-4. :<?:;<E 3;<; E,@ 8,.8;<.;C 4:,@9N

O1 P 9-?.G 9-; ?.9;<;F9 9-49 DE 543E;< 4.C P

-4C 49 9-?F L,?.9 34F U@F9 8,I;<?.H BB -4I?.H V?8-4<C

945G 4:,@9 ,@< <;549?,.F-?L1

Page 286: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 286/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC1 ADAAEF G,<9HI93,1

$%&'()(* ,! -./ 0.12%345 

J1 KLH B<1 A455?M 0N-?:?9 $" ?O O,P; "*!!

:4.Q O949;P;.9O R,< H,@< S,?.9 488,@.9= 4.T E S@O9

34.9 9, II 9-;<; 4<; 4 .@P:;< ,R T;U,O?9O ?. -;<; ?.

4P,@.9O ,R V!=*** ,< P,<;= 4.T EWP S@O9 3,.T;<?.X ?R

H,@ 84. ?T;.9?RH 3-49 9-;H 3;<; R,<= :;84@O; 9-;H T,

.,9 4UU;4< 9, P; 9, :; H,@< U4H<,551

D1 7Q4H1

J1 2, ?R H,@WT 9@<. 9, 9-; O;8,.T U4X;= 3-?8-

?O L49;O %"$= ?R H,@ 5,,Q 49 9-; 9,U ;.9<H 9-;<;=

?9WO X,9 H,@< U4H<,55 4.T 9-;. ?T;.9?R?;O 9-; 2949;

,R Y94-= 8,<<;89Z

D1 C?X-91

J1 7Q4H1 [-;. 3;W\; X,9 ,. $I"& ,. 9-; O4P;

U4X; 9-;<;WO 4 T;U,O?9 :H 8-;8Q ,R V!=*#"1(%1

D1 K]?9.;OO .,TT?.X -;4T 4RR?<P49?\;5H1M

J1 D.H ?T;4 3-49 9-49 34O R,<Z

D1 E9WO U,OO?:5;1 ^;O= E 9-?.Q E -4\; 4.

?T;4 3-49 9-49 3,@5T :;1

J1 D.T 3-49 3,@5T H,@< ?T;4 :;Z

D1 E9 3,@5T -4\; U<,:4:5H :;;. 4

<;?P:@<O;P;.91

J1 G<,PZ

D1 E T,.W9 Q.,31

Page 287: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 287/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

B1 C 9<4D;5 <;?E:@<F;E;.9G

C1 H9 8,@5I -4D; :;;. 4 84EJ4?K.

<;?E:@<F;E;.9 ,< ?9 8,@5I -4D; :;;. 4 9<4D;5

<;?E:@<F;E;.9 L<,E 9-; 2949;1

B1 M, 9, N49;F J4K; %$#1 O-;<;PF 4. ;.9<Q

9-<;;RS@4<9;<F ,L 9-; 34Q I,3.1 &R"( ?F 9-; I49;1

O-; 4E,@.9 ?F T!=%%'1)*1

2?E?54< 9QJ; ,L I;J,F?9= ;UJ;.F;

<;?E:@<F;E;.9G

C1 HPE 4FF@E?.K= Q;F1

B1 M,?.K 9, N49;F J4K; %&*= <?K-9 ?. 9-;

E?II5; ,L 9-; J4K; 9-;<;PF 4 I;J,F?9 L,< T"="()1)#1

V, Q,@ W.,3 3-49 9-49 34F L,<G

C1 H 3,@5I E4W; 9-; F4E; 4FF@EJ9?,.1

B1 7W4Q1 X4K; &*%= 4:,@9 9-<;;RS@4<9;<F ,L

9-; 34Q I,3. 9-; J4K;= +4.@4<Q "$9- 9-;<;PF 4 I;J,F?9

,L T$=(%*1#&1

C1 H I,.P9 <;84551

B1 O-49 F;;EF 4 5?995; -?K- L,< 4 9<4D;5

<;?E:@<F;E;.91

C1 Y;4-1 H I,.P9 W.,31 H 3?55 F4Q 9-?F RR

4.I H -4D; ., ?I;41 HPI -4D; 9, 5,,W 4.I F;;= :@9

?9PF +4.@4<Q "$9-G

B1 O3;5L9-1

C1 Y;4-1 2, ?9 8,@5I :; 4 .@E:;< ,L 9-?.KF1

Page 288: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 288/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B9 8,@5C -4D; :;;. 4 .@E:;< ,F 9<?GH 9,I;9-;<= :@9 B

84.J9 ;KG54?. ?9= .,1

L1 M;55 E; -,3 N,@< 84EG4?I. ,< O99,<.;N

P;.;<45 <;?E:@<H;E;.9H 3,<Q;C1

O1 R;55= B -4D; 4 2949; 84<C= 4.C H, 3;J55

G@9 4 -,9;5 ,. ?9 ,< 4 F5?I-9 ,. ?9 ,< E;45H ,. ?9 ,<

4 94K? ,. ?9 ,< G4<Q?.I 49 9-; 4?<G,<9 ,. ?91 BJ55

Q;;G 9-,H; <;8;?G9H 4.C 9@<. ?9 ?.9, 9-; 2949;1

L1 B9JH 4 S?H4 84<C= <?I-9T

O1 U;4-1

L1 2, N,@ G4N 9-; S?H4 84<C= 4.C 9-;. N,@

9@<. ?. 9-; <;8;?G9H 4.C I;9 4 <;?E:@<H;E;.9T

O1 M-49JH <?I-91 M-49JH -,3 ?9 3,<QH1

L1 O.C 3?9- 9-; 84EG4?I. C?C ?9 3,<Q 9-; H4E;

34NT

O1 R;55= N;H1 B C,.J9 <;8455 <;8;?D?.I 4

3-,5; 5,9 ,F <;?E:@<H;E;.9H F<,E 9-; 84EG4?I. :;84@H;

@H@455N 9-;<; 34H H,E;,.; 9<4D;5?.I 3?9- E; 3-, 3,@5C

G4N F,< 9-; ;KG;.H;1 M-49JH 5,I?H9?8455N -,3 ?9

@H@455N 3,<Q;C= :@9 ?F B C?C -4D; 4. ;KG;.H;= 9-49

3,@5C G<,:4:5N :; -,3 ?9 -4GG;.;C1

VW1 2X7RY B .;;C 9, I, ,FF1

VW1 AOAABY 2@<;1 Z, N,@ .;;C 9, 94Q; 4

:<;4QT

VW1 2X7RY U;H1

Page 289: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 289/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC0 DEF07GHIJC0HK G,?.L ,MM <;8,<N1 B-;

9?O; ?P $K#" Q1O1

RH;8;PP M<,O $K#" Q1O1 9, $K$% Q1O1S

BC0 DEF07GHIJC0HK H;9@<.?.L ,. 9-;

<;8,<N1 B-; 9?O; ?P 4QQ<,T?O49;5U $K$% Q1O1

>,@.P;51

V1 RWU X<1 A455?S EYN 5?Z; 9, .,3 9@<. 9,

9-; 9,Q?8 ,M U,@< "*!" 84OQ4?L. M?.4.8?45 N?P85,P@<;

M,<OP1

B-; M?<P9 [@;P9?,. ?PK J<?,< 9,

P@:O?99?.L U,@< 84OQ4?L. M,<OP ?. "*!"= U,@ -4N

Q<;\?,@P5U P@:O?99;N P?O?54< M,<OP= -4N U,@ .,9]

I1 ^;55= 3-;. U,@ P4U _Q<;\?,@P5U=_ E -4N

P@:O?99;N M,<OP 3-;. E <4. M,< 9-; C,@P; ,M

H;Q<;P;.949?\;P ?. !))' 4.N Y)) 4.N "**!= 4.N 9-;.

3-;. E <4. M,< >,.L<;PP M;N;<45 M,<OP ?. "**" 4.N

"**$= :@9 EYO .,9 P@<; -,3 P?O?54< 9-; M,<OP 3;<; 9,

9-; ,.;P E M?5;N ?. "*!"1

V1 F, U,@ <;8455]

I1 E N,.Y91

V1 7Z4U1 W;M,<; U,@ M?5;N 9-; M,<OP ?. "*!"=

N?N U,@ <;4N 9-; P949@9;]

I1 `,1

V1 C4\; U,@ ;\;< <;4N 9-; P949@9;]

I1 EY\; <;4N ?9 P?.8;1

Page 290: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 290/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C@9 .,9 :;D,<;E

FG1 2H7IJ I-49 K949@9;E I-?8- ,.;E

LM0 INLH022J I-?8- K949@9;E O;4-1

B1 PCQ F<1 A455?R I;55= 9-;QS<; TT

U1 "*U !!E

B1 L-; K949@9; NSV <;D;<<?.W 9, ?K "*U TT N

X,.S9 -4Y; 9-; X?<;89 8?9;= :@9 NSV 5,,Z?.W 49 ?.

L?95; "*U 9-;<; ?K 4 K949@9; 9-49 K4QK 84.X?X49;K

-4Y; 9, D?55 ,@9 9-; K4V; D?.4.8?45 X?K85,K@<; 4K

[;,[5; 3-, 4<; ?. ,DD?8; D?55 ,@91

U1 7-1

B1 U.X 9-49 <;D;<K Q,@ 9, L?95; '&T(T!*)1

U1 N -4X .,9 <;4X 9-49 ?. 9-; V,.9-K

[<;8;X?.W VQ D?5?.W 9-491 N X,.S9 Z.,3 ?D N -4X ;Y;<

<;4X ?9= :@9 N 8;<94?.5Q -4X.S9 <;4X ?9

8,.9;V[,<4.;,@K 3?9- VQ D?5?.W= .,1

B1 7Z4Q1 U.X 3-Q X?X Q,@ .,9 <;4X 9-;

K949@9; [<?,< 9, D?5?.W Q,@< D,<VKE

U1 I;55= :;84@K; N X?X.S9 9-?.Z N .;;X;X 9,1

B1 I-49 5;X Q,@ 9, .,9 9-?.Z Q,@ .;;X;X 9,E

U1 I;55= N Z.;3 9-49 9-; D,<VK 3;<; ,. D?5;

3?9- 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 \,Y;<.,<SK ,DD?8;= 4.X VQ ?.9;.9

34K 9, W, ?.9, 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 \,Y;<.,<SK ,DD?8; 4.X

D?55 ,@9 9-; D,<VK 9<@9-D@55Q 4.X 488@<49;5Q 4.X D?5;

D,< 84.X?X48Q1 N9 45K, -4[[;.;X 9, :; 4 Y;<Q :@KQ

Page 291: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 291/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

9?B; C,< @D= :@9 E D?BF5G C;59 5?H; E 3,@5I -4J; 9-;

?.C,<B49?,. E .;;I;I 49 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 K,J;<.,<LD

,CC?8;1

MN1 AOAAEP Q,<9GR9-<;;1

#$%&'(') +, -./ 0.12$345 

S1 TUG M<1 A455?V 0W-?:?9 $# ?D 4 8,FG ,C 4

2949; >,.D9?9@9?,.45 7CC?8; X;854<49?,. ,C >4.I?I48G

4.I <;549;I C,<BD I49;I M4<8- )= "*!"1

X, G,@ D;; 9-49Y

O1 E I,1

S1 Z,3= ?. 5,,H?.[ 9-<,@[- 9-?D ;W-?:?9= 84.

G,@ 9;55 B; ?C 9-?D ?D 4 8,BF5;9; D;9 ,C 9-;

I,8@B;.9D G,@ C?5;I ,. M4<8- )= "*!"Y

O1 E9 4FF;4<D 9, :;1

S1 O.I I?I G,@ <;4I 9-;D; C,<BD ?. 9-;?<

;.9?<;9G :;C,<; C?5?.[Y

O1 E :;5?;J; E I?I1

S1 >4. G,@ I;D8<?:; 9-; 8?<[email protected];D @.I;<

3-?8- G,@ C?55;I 9-;B ,@9Y Q,< ;W4BF5;= 3-;<; G,@

3;<;= -,3 5,.[ ?9 9,,HY

O1 \;55= E 34D ?. 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 K,J;<.,<LD

,CC?8;1 E -4I BG 84BF4?[. B4.4[;< 3?9- B;1 Z4B; ?D

+;DD?84 Q43D,.1

\-49 E <;B;B:;< ?D <;4I?.[ 9-; >4.I?I49;

Q?.4.8?45 X?D85,D@<; 7< >,.C5?89 ,C E.9;<;D9 C,<B 4.I

Page 292: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 292/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

-4B?.C D,E; F@;D9?,.D 4:,@9 9-; 54.C@4C; G D43 ,. 9-;

H,<E= D9;II?.C ,@9D?J; 9-; ,HH?8; 9, 8455 EK 499,<.;K

4:,@9 D,E; ,H 9-49 54.C@4C;= :;84@D; ?9 <;549;J 9,

D,E; ,H 9-; ;.9?9?;D ,3.;J :K EK H4E?5KLD 9<@D91

G <;E;E:;< 8,E?.C :48M ?. 4.J 4DM?.C 9-;

,HH?8?49,< 9-;<;= G 9-?.M ?9 34D N4<M O-,E4D= 9-;

J;I@9K= -,3 9-;K ;.H,<8;J 9-; <@5;D 4:,@9 9-; H?5?.CD

?. 9;<ED ,H 3-;. 9-;K .;;J;J 9, :; H?.45?P;J 4.J

8,EI5;9;J :;H,<; 9-;K 9,,M ;HH;891

G. ,9-;< 3,<JD= EK F@;D9?,. 34D 84. G H?55

,@9 I4<9 ,H ?9 .,3 4.J 8,E; :48M 549;< :;H,<; 9-;

H?5?.C J;4J5?.; 4.J 8,EI5;9; 9-; H?5?.C 4.J -4B; ?9

:; 4D ?H GLJ H?5;J ?9 3-;. G H?5;J ?91 G. ,9-;<

3,<JD= J?J 9-49 -4B; 4.K ?EI489 ,. 9-; 4E;.JE;.9 ?H G

4E;.J;J ?9 :;H,<; 9-; H?5?.C J;4J5?.;= 4.J -; 9,5J E;

9-49 4D 5,.C 4D ?9 34D H?.45 4.J 8,EI5;9; :K 9-;

H?5?.C J;4J5?.;= ?9 3,@5J :; 4D ?H G -4J H?5;J ?9

[email protected] I<, [email protected]= ,< H<,E 9-; B;<K :;C?..?.C= 4.J D, G

H?55;J ,@9 3-49 G 8,@5J= @.J;<D9,,J 4.J M.;3= 4.J

9-;. 84E; :48M ,. 9-; !%9- 4.J H?.?D-;J EK H?5?.C1

Q1 R4J K,@ <;B?;3;J 4 8,IK ,H 9-; H,<E :;H,<;

K,@ 345M;J ?.9, 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 S,B;<.,<LD ,HH?8; ,.

N4<8- )9-T

U1 G J,.L9 :;5?;B; G J?J1

Q1 U.J 84. K,@ 4II<,V?E49; 9-; 4E,@.9 ,H 9?E;

Page 293: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 293/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B,@ 3;<; ?. 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 C,D;<.,<EF ,GG?8; G?55?.H

,@9 9-; G,<IFJ

K1 L :;5?;D; ?9 34F 4<,@.M "* I?.@9;F1

N1 K.M 3-49 O,<9?,. ,G 9-49= 4OO<,P?I49;5B=

34F 8,.F@I;M :B B,@ 8455?.H B,@< 499,<.;BJ

K1 Q;55= B,@ F4?M RR F, 5;9 I; S@F9 854<?GB1

T,@ F4?M L 34F ?. 9-; ,GG?8; 4:,@9 "* I?.@9;F1 L

:;5?;D; L 34F ,. 9-; O-,.; 4 H,,M !% ,< "* I?.@9;F

3?9- IB 543B;< ?. 9-; I?MM5; ,G 9-49 F?9@49?,.1

N1 7U4B1 2, I4B:; #% I?.@9;F ,D;<455J

K1 V-R-@- WB;FX1

N1 K.M :B B,@< 543B;<= 4<; B,@ <;G;<<?.H 9,

A;; Y8>@55,@H-J

K1 L 4I1

N1 K.M F, 3-49 34F 9-; F?H.?G?84.8; ,G B,@

4FU?.H 9-; ,GG?8?49,< ?G B,@ 8,@5M G?5; O4<9 ,G ?9

.,3 4.M O4<9 ,G ?9 549;<J

K1 Q;55= L 34.9;M 9, :; 488@<49; ,. 9-;

M?F85,F@<;F L 34F I4U?.H ?. 9;<IF ,G 9-;

,<H4.?Z49?,.F L 34F ?.D,5D;M ?. F, 9-49 L M?M.E9 I?FF

4.B9-?.H= :@9 L 34F.E9 F@<; 4F L 34F 9-;<; ?G L -4M

455 9-; ?.G,<I49?,. L .;;M;M 9, I4U; 455 ,G 9-,F;

M?F85,F@<;F1

7.; ,O9?,. 3,@5M -4D; :;;. G,< I; 9, S@F9

345U ,@9 4.M LE55 8,I; :48U 549;< 3-;. LEI <;4MB= :@9

Page 294: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 294/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC 84BD4?E. F94GG 34.9;H B; 9, B,I; G,<34<H 4.H

H;854<; ;4<5C= 4.H 9-49JF 3-C K 4FL;H 9-; M@;F9?,.1

K9 34F BC H;8?F?,.= K ,3. ?9= :@9 K 34.9;H 9, B4L;

F@<; 9-49 3; E,9 4. 488@<49; NN K .;;H;H 9, B4L; 4

H;8?F?,. 4:,@9 3-;9-;< K 3,@5H F94<9 9-; D<,8;FF 4.H

;.H ?9 49 9-; F4B; 9?B; ,< ?G K 8,@5H F94<9 9-;

D<,8;FF 4.H ;.H ?9 549;<1

O1 P?H C,@ ,<= 9, C,@< L.,35;HE;= C,@<

84BD4?E. F94GG :;5?;I; ?9 3,@5H :; F,B;-,3 :;.;G?8?45

G,< C,@ 9, G?5; 4 D4<9?455C 8,BD5;9; G,<B ,. Q4<8- )

<49-;< 9-4. R@F9 94L?.E ?9 -,B;= E;9 9-; ?.G,<B49?,.

C,@ .;;H;H 4.H G?5; 9-; G,<B ,.8; :;G,<; 9-; !%9-S

T1 U-;C G;59 ?9 3,@5H :; 4HI4.94E;,@F G,< B;

9, G?5; ?9 ;4<5C= F, 9-?F 34F 9-; H4C 4G9;< 9-;

5;E?F549?I; F;FF?,. 3,@5H -4I; ;.H;H 49 B?H.?E-9= ,.

9-; (9-= K :;5?;I;1

U-; G?<F9 9-?.E 9-; .;V9 B,<.?.E= ,< 49

5;4F9 ;4<5C ?. 9-; H4C 3; 3;.9 ,I;< 9-;<; 9, H, 9-;

G?5?.E= 4.H ?9 34F 4 :@FC 9?B;= 4.H F, 9-;C G;59 5?L;

?9 3,@5H :; ?BD,<94.9 9, E;9 ,@9 ,G 9-; 8-@9; ;4<5C

4.H G?5;= 5;9 D;,D5; L.,3 K 34F <@..?.E1

O1 W4H.J9 C,@ 45<;4HC H;854<;H C,@<F;5G 4F 4

84.H?H49;S

T1 K -4H= :@9 9-;<;JF 4 H?GG;<;.8; :;93;;.

H;854<?.E 4F 4 84.H?H49; 4.H 489@455C D4C?.E 9-;

Page 295: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 295/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B,.;C 4.D E?5?.F= 488,<D?.F 9, 9-;B1

G1 H-49 D?D C,@ II 84. C,@ <;8455 B,<;

JK;8?E?8455C 9-; L@;J9?,.J C,@ -4D 4:,@9 9-; E,<BM

N1 O,@ :;91 2, ?E C,@ 5,,P ,. II 9-;J;

4<;.Q9 R49;J J94BK;D II K4F; # ,E 0S-?:?9 $#= T .,9;

9-<;;IL@4<9;<J ,E 9-; 34C D,3. 9-; 5?.; J4CJ= UV4B;

,E ;48- ;.9?9C 9-49 -4J K4?D W%=*** ,< B,<; ?. ?.8,B;

9, 9-; E?5;<=U 4.D 9-49 ?J 9-; K-<4J; 9-49 84@F-9 BC

;C; 3-;. T 34J ?. 9-;<; E,< 9-; E?<J9 9?B; 5,,P?.F 49

9-49 54.F@4F; 3?9-?. 9-; ,.; C;4< K;<?,D ;.D?.F

:;E,<; 9-; D49; ,E 9-; D?J85,J@<; E,<B1

H-;. T -4D E?5;D E,< >,.F<;JJ= 4.D 4J T

<;8455= ?9QJ :;;. 4 5,.F 9?B;= 9-;C J;;B;D 9, 34.9

?.8,B; E,< 9-; E?5;< 4.D -?J -,@J;-,5D= 4.D T 34J

J@<K<?J;D 3-;. ?9 X@J9 4JP;D E,< ?.8,B; 9, 9-; E?5;<=

4.D ?. 5?F-9 ,E 9-; ;.9?9?;J 9-49 T -4D E,<B;D 3?9-?.

9-; 9<@J9= T -4D 4 L@;J9?,.= 4 5;F45 L@;J9?,.= 4:,@9

9-; 5?B?949?,. ,E 9-49 K-<4J; U?.8,B; 9, 9-; E?5;<=U

4.D T 34.9;D 9, :; 9<@9-E@5 4.D 488@<49; 4.D T 34.9;D

9, F;9 ?9 <?F-91

2, T J9;KK;D ,@9 ,E 9-; ,EE?8; 4.D 8455;D

A;; Y8>@55,@F-1 T 34J E,<[email protected]; 9, <;48- -?B ,. 9-;

K-,.;= 4.D T -4D 4 D?J8@JJ?,. 3?9- -?B 4:,@9 9-49

54.F@4F; 4.D 4:,@9 9-; ;.9?9?;J 4.D 4:,@9 9-;

K<489?8; T -4D @.D;<F,.;= @.D;<94P;.= 3?9-?. 9-,J;

Page 296: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 296/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

;.9?9?;B= BC;8?D?8455E 9-; C4EF;.9B D<,F 9-; ;.9?9?;B

9, FE 3?D; G;<B@B 9, F; 4.H ?D 9-49 3,@5H :;

8,.B9<@;H 4B ?.8,F; 9, 9-; D?5;<1

I 9,5H -?F 9-49 ?9 H?H.J9 8,F; D<,F 9-;

9<@B9= ?9 84F; D<,F 9-; 9<@B9 ;.9?9?;B 9, -;< 4B 4

:;.;D?8?4<E @.H;< 9-; 9<@B9= 4.H I 4BK;H -?F ?D 9-49

3,@5H :; 4. ?BB@;= 4.H -; B4?H .,1 L; B4?H E,@ -4G;

., 5;M45 <?M-9 9, 9-49 F,.;E 4.H E,@ 84..,9 8455 ?9

?.8,F; 9, 9-; D?5;<= 4.H B, 9-;. I 34B 4 5?995;

8,.D@B;H 4:,@9= 3;55= -,3 H, I 9-;. 488@<49;5E

<;C<;B;.9 ?9 ,. 9-?B D,<F= 4.H I H;8?H;H 9-49 9-;

F,<; 488@<49; 34E 9, H, ?9 3,@5H :; 9, B4E .,.;=

:;84@B; I H?H .,9 <;8;?G; ?.8,F; D<,F 9-;B; ;.9?9?;B=

4.H 9-49 34B 9-; 5,M?8 :;-?.H FE D?55?.M ,@9 9-?B

D,<F 4.H B?M.?.M ?9 9<@9-D@55E I :;5?;G; 9-?B D,<F ?B

9<@; 4.H 488@<49; 9, 9-; :;B9 ,D FE K.,35;HM;1

N-49 ?B 3-49 -4CC;.;H ?. 9-; 8,.9;O9 ,D

9-49 H?B8@BB?,.= 4.H 3; -4H 4 D@<9-;< H?B8@BB?,.

4:,@9 4.,9-;< P@;B9?,. ,. -;<;= :@9 9-49 34B 9-;

8,.9;O9 ,D ,@< 8,.G;<B49?,. <;549?G; 9, 9-49

C4<9?8@54< 5?.;1

Q1 2, RR

S1 T@9 RR I -4G; F,<; 9, ;OC54?. 549;<= :@9

M, 4-;4H 4.H 4BK E,@< P@;B9?,.1

Q1 U;55= I 34B V@B9 M,?.M 9, B4E ?. 4HH?9?,.

Page 297: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 297/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9, 8455?.B C,@< 543C;< DD

E1 F;4-1

G1 DD 9, H;9;<I?.; 3-49 ?.8,I; 9, 9-; J?5;<

I;4.9= H?H C,@ 8,.K?H;< <;4H?.B 9-; K949@9;L

E1 M;55= 4K N @.H;<K9,,H ?9 49 9-; 9?I;= 4K N

<;8455= 9-; 54.B@4B; 34K ?H;.9?845 ?. 9-; K949@9;=

9-49 9-?K 54.B@4B; 34K 5?J9;H J<,I 9-; K949@9;1 O-49

34K IC @.H;<K94.H?.B= 4.H= 4B4?.= N 3;.9 :48P 9, 9-;

J,<I N K?B.;H= 3-?8- 34K N :;5?;Q; 9-?K J,<I ?K 9<@;

4.H 488@<49; 9, 9-; :;K9 ,J IC P.,35;HB;1

G1 M-C H?H C,@ 9-?.P 9-49 C,@< 9<@K9 4.H

;K949; 543C;< 3,@5H P.,3 9-; 4.K3;< 9, 9-?K R@;K9?,.L

E1 M;55= N 9-,@B-9 9-49 DD 49 5;4K9

,<?B?.455C N 9-,@B-9 9-49 -; 3,@5H P.,3 4K IC 94S

543C;< 4.H 4K IC ;K949; T54..?.B 543C;<= 49 5;4K9

-4Q; 4. ?H;4 ,J 3-;9-;< 9-49 34K ?.8,I;= 4.H N

5?K9;.;H 9, -?I= 4.H -; K;;I;H Q;<C ;IT-49?8 9-49 ?9

34K.U9 ;Q;. 4 85,K; 8455= K, N J;59 8,IJ,<94:5;

;.,@B- -4Q?.B 4KP;H 9-; R@;K9?,. ,J V4<P O-,I4K= C,@

P.,3= 4:,@9 P?.H ,J 4 <;Q,5Q?.B H?K85,K@<; 9-49 N

8,@5H J;;5 8,IJ,<94:5; J?55?.B ,@9 9-; J,<I 49 9-?K

T,?.9= H, 4 5?995; J@<9-;< <;K;4<8- 4.H 8,I; :48P 4.H

4I;.H ?9 549;<= 3-?8- N T54..;H 9, H,= :;84@K; C,@

.,9?8; N 5;J9 I4.C :54.PK DD I4.C 5?.;K :54.P 49 9-;

9?I;= 4B4?. 3?9- 9-; @.H;<K94.H?.B 9-49 9-?K 3,@5H

Page 298: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 298/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

.,9 B;C9 ,< :;8,D; E?.45 @.9?5 9-; E?5?.F G;<?,H

8,.85@H;H1 I 3,@5H -4B; 9-49 D@8- 9?D; 9, D4J; C@<;

I -4H ?9 4:C,5@9;5K <?F-91

L1 79-;< 9-4. 9-; ?CC@; ,E ?.8,D; 9, 9-;

E?5;<= H?H K,@ CG;4J 3?9- M<1 M8>@55,@F- ,. 9-; G-,.;

4:,@9 4.K ,E 9-; ,9-;< ?9;DCN

O1 I H?H1 I H?H1 I 945J;H 9, -?D 4:,@9 C,D;

,E 9-; ,9-;< ?9;DC1

A;9PC C;;1 Q-;<; 34C ,.; 4:,@9 D4.4F;D;.9

,< ,EE?8;<C ,< H?<;89,<C ,E ;.9?9?;C1 A;9PC C;;

-;<;1 7. G4F; " RR ,E 9-; ;S-?:?9 I 9-?.J G4F; $ RR

5;9 D; F, :48J1

T-49 45C, C9<@8J DK ?.9;<;C9 34C 9-; 54C9

5?.; ,E 9-; E?<C9 G4F; ,E 9-?C 8,.E5?89 ,E ?.9;<;C9

H?C85,C@<;= 3-?8- ?C G4F; # ,E 9-; ;S-?:?91 I9 C4?H=

UV4D; ,E ;.9?9K ?. 3-?8- 9-; E?5;< -,5HC

4.K C9,8JC ,< :,.HC -4B?.F 4 E4?< D4<J;9 B45@; ,E

W%=*** ,< D,<; 4C ,E 9-; H49; ,E 9-; E,<D RR 9-?C

E,<D RR :@9 ;S85@H?.F [email protected] 9-49 4<; D4.4F;H :K 4

9-?<H G4<9K= ?.85@H?.F :5?.H 9<@C9C= D4.4F;H

?.B;C9D;.9 488,@.9C= 4.H D@9@45 [email protected]

O.H 9-49 45C, 9<?FF;<;H ?. DK D?.H 9-;

E489 9-49 DK E4D?5K -4H 9-?C 9<@C9 4.H 9-49 9-;

5;F?C549@<; -4H 8,.9;DG549;H 49 C,D; G,?.9 ?. 9?D; 9-49

?<<;B,84:5; 9<@C9C D?F-9 :; 9<;49;H H?EE;<;.95K 9-4. RR

Page 299: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 299/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

?<<;B,84:5; 9<@C9 ,< .,.D9<@C9 -;5E 4CC;9C= :@9 3-;<;

F DD 4.E F :;5?;B; F E?C8@CC;E 9-49 3?9- -?G ,. 9-;

H-,.; 4C 3;55 49 9-; 9?G;1

I-; ,9-;< H4<9 3,@5E :; JK4G; ,L

,<M4.?N49?,. ,< ;.9?9O L,< 3-?8- 9-; L?5;< C;<B;C ,.

9-; :,4<E ,L E?<;89,<C ,< 4.O 9OH; ,L L,<G45 4EB?C,<O

84H48?9O1J

F E,.P9 9-?.Q F B?C?9;E 3?9- 9-;G 4:,@9

9-491

JIOH; ,L H,C?9?,. -;5E :O 9-; L?5;< 3?9-?.

9-; ,<M4.?N49?,.1J A;9PC C;;1 2,G;3-;<; 9-;<;PC

C,G;9-?.M 4:,@9 ?.9;<;C9C ?. G4.4M;G;.9 ,< R,4<E ,L

S?<;89,<C1 7Q4O1 T;4-= C, ?9 3,@5E :; .4G; ,L 9-;

,<M4.?N49?,. ,< ;.9?9O L,< 3-?8- 9-; L?5;< C;<B;C ,.

9-; R,4<E ,L S?<;89,<C ,< 4.O ,9-;< 9OH; ,L L,<G45

4EB?C,<O 84H48?9O= 4.E F 9-?.Q 9-49PC 3-;<; F -4E 4

E?C8@CC?,. 3?9- U<1 U8>@55,@M- 4:,@9 9-; E?LL;<;.9

;.9?9?;C 9-49 F -4E :;;. ?.B,5B;E ?. 9, C;; 3-49

3,@5E V@45?LO 4C 9-49 9OH; ,L ,<M4.?N49?,.1

2, GO 543 L?<G 23455,3 W XCC,8?49;C 3,@5E

V@45?LO= ,9-;< R,4<EC ,L S?<;89,<C 9-49 F G?M-9 :;

C;<B?.M ,.= 4.E 9-;. -; <4?C;E 9-; ?CC@;= 4C F

<;8455= 4:,@9 3-;9-;< ,< .,9 F 34C 4 G4.4M;< ,L 9-;

9<@C9 ;.9?9?;C= 4.E F C4?E F 9-?.Q F 4G 9-; G4.4M;<

,L 9-; 9-<;; 9<@C9 ;.9?9?;C= 4.E GO ?.9;.9 ?. 9-;

Page 300: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 300/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC<?.D ,E 9-49 F;4< ,< 9-; E455 ,E 9-; C<?,< F;4< 34B

9, 9<F 9, G?.?G?H; 9-; 9-?.DB I 34B ?.J,5J;K ?. 9,

B-,3 9-; C@:5?8 4B I <4. E,< L99,<.;F M;.;<45 9-49 I

3,@5K :; !** C;<8;.9 E,8@B;K ,. GF <,5; 4B L99,<.;F

M;.;<45 4B 9-; L99,<.;F M;.;<45= 4.K B, I :;D4. ?.

9-; E455 9, <;B?D. E<,G K?EE;<;.9 ,<D4.?H49?,.B 9-49

I 34B ?.J,5J;K ?.1

N-;. I D,9 :@BF K@<?.D 9-; B;BB?,.= 4.K ?9

O@B9 :;84G; 4. ,CC,<9@.?9F= 4 K;8?B?,. C,?.9= 4:,@9

3-;9-;< ,< .,9 I 3,@5K 8,.9?.@; 9, C@:5?85F :;

?.J,5J;K ?. 9-,B; :@B?.;BB ;.9?9?;B 9-49 3;<; ,3.;K

:F 9-; 9<@B91 N-49 34B GF 9-?.P?.D 49 9-; 9?G;1

Q1 R-F 3,@5K F,@ :; 8,.8;<.;K 4:,@9 4. ;.9?9F

5?P; ST2,5@9?,.B ,< 22U V4.4D;G;.9W

L1 X,@ P.,3= 9-49YB 4 D<;49 Z@;B9?,. 5,,P?.D

:48P ,. ?9 .,3 :;84@B; ?E I -4K 4.F ?K;4 9-49 9-?B

3,@5K :5,3 @C 9-?B 34F I 3,@5K -4J; E?D@<;K ,@9 TT I

C<,:4:5F 3,@5K -4J; B94F;K ,. 4.K O@B9 K?B85,B;K ?9=

:;84@B;= 4D4?.= I 34B 45<;4KF C@:5?85F ,. 9-; <;8,<K

,. 9-,B; 8,GC4.?;B1

I G;4.= 4.F:,KF 3-, K,;B 4 8,<C,<49;

B;4<8- @.K;< GF .4G; 3?55 B;; 9-49 49 ,.; C,?.9 I 34B

9-; G4.4D;< ,E ST2,5@9?,.B= B, ?9 34B.Y9 4:,@9 -?K?.D

9-49 I 34B ?.J,5J;K ?. ST2,5@9?,.B1 I9 34B 4:,@9

B;.K?.D 4 G;BB4D; 9, G; 9-49 D,?.D E,<34<K IYG .,9

Page 301: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 301/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

?.B,5B;C ?. 9-;D; 8,EF4.?;D 4.GE,<;1

H1 I;55= 3-G JJ 4.C 9-?D ?D 4 C?D85,D@<; K,<E

4:,@9 F4D9 489?B?9?;D= .,9 4 C;854<49?,. ,K K@9@<;

489?B?9?;D= D, 3-G 3,@5C .,9 C?D85,D?.L MJ2,5@9?,.D

,< 22N O4.4L;E;.9 D49?DKG 9-; ,:P;89?B; ,K 8,.B?.8?.L

9-; B,9;<D 9-49 G,@ 3,@5C.Q9 -4B; ,@9D?C; ?.9;<;D9DR

S1 I;55= .,= 489@455G F4<9 ,K ?9 ?D 4.C F4<9

,K ?9 ?D.Q91 T E;4.= 9-; F4<9 4:,@9 9-; U%=*** ,<

E,<; 3?9-?. 9-; F<?,< G;4<= 9-49 ?D 4:,@9 9-; F4D9=

:@9 9-; F4<9 4:,@9 .4E; ,K 9-; ,<L4.?V49?,. ,< ;.9?9G

K,< 3-?8- 9-; K?5;< D;<B;D ,. 9-; W,4<C ,K X?<;89,<D

,< ?. 4.G ,9-;< K,<E ,K 4CB?D,<G 84F48?9G ?D 4:,@9

9-; K@9@<;1 T9QD 4:,@9 9-; E,E;.9 ?. 9?E; ?. 9-;

K@9@<;1 Y-49QD JJ

H1 Z,3 -4B; G,@ <;48-;C 9-49 8,.85@D?,.R

S1 I;55= :;84@D; ?9 C,;D.Q9 D4G 4.G9-?.L

4:,@9 9-; F4D91

H1 Z4B; G,@ <;4C 9-; D949@9;R

S1 I;55= D?.8; 9-;. T -4B;1 T 9-?.[ ?9

8,.K?<ED 3-49 TQE D4G?.L1

H1 7[4G1

S1 \,3= ?K ?9 C,;D.Q9= 9-;. ;]8@D; E; K,< .,9

<;4C?.L 9-; D949@9;= :@9 TQE 4DD@E?.L= 4D T D?9 -;<;=

9-49 9-?D E?<<,<D 9-; D949@9,<G 54.L@4L;= 4.C T

:;5?;B; ?9 C,;D1 TQB; <;4C ?9 D?.8; 9-;.= 4.C D, EG

Page 302: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 302/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

9-?.B?.C 34D= 3;55= 9-;D; 8,EF4.?;D -4G; .,9 <;455H

:;;. ;.C4C;I ?. :@D?.;DD J,< KK LKM34<;= LKM34<; J,<

4 5,.C 9?E;= 4.I NK2,5@9?,.D= L -4I.O9 I,.; 4.H

8,.D@59?.C J,< NK2,5@9?,.D J,< 49 5;4D9 D?P E,.9-D1

L -4I ., F54.D 9, I, J@9@<; 8,.D@59?.C 3?9-

NK2,5@9?,.D= 9-; 8;E;.9 F<,Q;89 -4I C,.; 434H= 4.I D,

L J;59 5?B; L 84. I?DD,5G; 9-;D; 8,EF4.?;D= 4.I ?J L

-4I I?DD,5G;I 9-;D; 8,EF4.?;D ,. 9-; DF,9= 9-; D4E;=

?9 3,@5I -4G; :;;. 4 .,.I?D85,D@<; 4D 3;551 L 8,@5I

-4G; I?DD,5G;I 9-;E ,< L 8,@5I <;D?C. 4D E4.4C;<= 4.I

EH 9-?.B?.C 34D L I,.O9 34.9 9, Q@D9 I?DD,5G; 9-;D;

9-?.CD :;84@D;= 3-, B.,3D= D,E; I4H L E4H 34.9 9, C;9

:48B ?.G,5G;I ?. 9-?.CD 4J9;< LOE I,.; 3?9-

M99,<.;H R;.;<451 LOG; DF;.9 9-; E,.;H 9, ,<C4.?S;

9-;D; 9-?.CD= LOG; C,9 9-; 9<@D9= 4.I ;G;. 9-,@C- 9-;

9<@D9 -4I.O9 :;;. @9?5?S;I= 4.I LO55 D4H ?9= L E;4.=

H,@ B.,3= G;<H 84<;J@55H= 4.I L 3;.9 ,G;< 9-49 3?9-

A;; 4D 3;551

L D4?I L -4G;.O9 J,55,3;I 455 9-;

J,<E45?9?;D ,. 9-; 9<@D91 T,;D 9-49 E4B; 4

I?JJ;<;.8;U V; D4?I 4:D,5@9;5H .,91 W-?D ?D.O9 4

I?D9<?:@9?,. ,J 9-; 9<@D91 V; D4?I ?9 I,;D.O9

E499;<1 X,@O<; .,9 5;C455H ;.9?95;I 9, 9-49 ?.8,E;Y

9-;<;J,<;= 9-?D ?D .,9 ?.8,E; 9, 9-; J?5;<= 4.I L C,9

9, 9;55 H,@= Z499= L <;C<;9 ;G;<H D?.C5; I4H= 5,,B?.C

Page 303: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 303/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

:48B ,. ?9= 9-49 C D?D.E9= F,@ B.,3= G@H9 H94F ,. 9-;

I,4<D= H94F 4H 4 J4.4K;< 4.D G@H9 D?H85,H; ?9=

:;84@H; ?L C -4D 4.F ?D;4 +;<;JF +,-.H,. 34H K,?.K 9,

D, 9-?H= ?L C -4D 4.F ?D;4 9-49 MN2,5@9?,.H 34H K,?.K

9, :;8,J; 9-?H ;J:<,?5;D NN C J;4.= F,@EO; H;;. 9-;

.@J:;<H1 P-?H 34H.E9 4 :?K Q<,G;891 C9 34H.E9 5?B;

L,< 9-<;; F;4<H C 8,.HQ?<;D 9, D, H,J;9-?.K 8<4RF

3?9- 9-?H 9-?.K1

S.D H, 9-49 34H 9-; 9-,@K-9 Q<,8;HH C -4D

49 9-; 9?J; C J4D; 9-;H; D?H85,H@<;H= 4.D C 9;H9?LF

@.D;< ,49- 9-49 49 9-; 9?J; C L?5;D 9-?H L,<J= JF

?.9;.9 34H 9, :; L@55F 488@<49; 4.D L@55F -,.;H9 4.D

.,9 9, -?D; 4.F9-?.K L<,J 9-; Q@:5?8 ?. 4.F B?.D ,L 4

D;8;?9L@5 J4..;<1 P-49EH JF 9;H9?J,.F= 4.D 9-49EH

3?9- 9-; 8,.O?89?,. ,L JF -;4<9= 4.D H, C 34.9 9, :;

84<;L@5= 9-,@K-= 4.D D, 9-; <?K-9 9-?.K1

C 945B;D 9, JF 543F;<= 4.D 9-49EH .,9 455

C D?D1 C 34.9;D 9, :; O;<F 84<;L@5= 4.D C 3;.9 D,3.

4.D H43 -?J D,3. ?. M<,O, 3?9- 9-; L,<JH= 4.D -; 84J;

3?9- 9-; H4J; 8,.85@H?,. 4H 3; <;455F D@K ?.9, ?9 L,<

4 5?995; 5,.K;<= 4.D 9-;. :;84@H; C 34.9;D 9, :;

;T9<4 84<;L@5 :;L,<; 9-; !%9-= 4.D C D,.E9 B.,3 ?L ?9

34H :;L,<; ,< 4L9;<= :@9 C 9-?.B ?9 34H :;L,<;1

C D,.E9 B.,3 3-F C 3,@5D -4O; 945B;D 9,

P,J U,:;<9H 4L9;< 9-; !%9-= :;84@H; 4L9;< C L?5;D

Page 304: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 304/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9-?B 9-; 54B9 9?C; D E,<F,9 4:,@9 ?9 4.G C,H;G ,.1 D

C;9 3?9-= D 9-?.I= 9-; J<;;C?.;.9 ;5;89?,. 543K;< ?.

9-; 2949; 3-, <;J<;B;.9B 9-; ;5;89?,.B ,EE?8;= 4.G D

9-?.I ?9 34B ,. 9-; J-,.;= :@9 D G;B8<?:;G 9, -?C

3-49 DLG G,.;= 3-49 D -4G 4.G 9-; 4GH?8; DLG F,9 E<,C

A;; M8>@55,@F-= 4.G 9-; E?<B9 9-?.F -; B4?G 9, C; 34B

9-?B B,@.GB 4 5?995; [email protected]= 5;9 C; 5,,I ?.9, ?91

N-;. -; 8455;G C; :48I ,< 84C; :48I 9, C; 4 E;3 G4KB

549;< ,< 4 5?995; 3-?5; 549;< 4.G -; B4?G K,@ I.,3

3-49= +,-.= K,@L<; <?F-91 D9 B4KB ?.8,C; 9, 9-;

E?5;<1 N-49LB 4 <;4B,.4:5; J,B?9?,. 9, 94I;1

2, 3-;. D -4G CK ,3. 543K;< 9;55 C; 9-?B=

3-;. D <;4G 9-; 54.F@4F; CKB;5E 4.G 9-;. D -4G

N,C O,:;<9B 9;55 C; 9-49 -; 9-,@F-9 9-49 34B 4

<;4B,.4:5; ?.9;<J<;949?,.= D 34B E?.;= D E?.?B-;G ?9

4.G D C,H;G ,.= 4.G 9-49LB P@B9 3-49 -4JJ;.;G= 4.G ?9

34B.L9 9?55 4 C,.9- 4.G 4 -45E 549;< 3-;. D -4G 9-49

C;;9?.F 3?9- +;<;CK +,-.B,. 9-49 D 34B 8,.8;<.;G 49

455 4:,@9 QR2,5@9?,.B1

D9 34B C,<; 4:,@9 B;.G 4 C;BB4F; 9, 9-;

J@:5?8 9-49 D 34B G,.; 3?9- 9-;B; 9-?.FB= ?9LB ,. 9-;

<;8,<G 9-49 D 34B ?.H,5H;G ?. 9-;B; 9-?.FB 4.G DLC

P@B9 C,H?.F ,.1 D 34.9 9, :; 9-; S99,<.;K T;.;<45 4

[email protected]<;G J;<8;.9 ,E CK 9?C; E,< 9-; J@:5?8 ?E D 3,.1

N-49 34B CK 9-?.I?.F 49 9-; 9?C;1

Page 305: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 305/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 A;9 C; C4D; E@<; FGH; I,9 9-; 8-<,.,5,IJ1

K1 F D.,3 9-49 34E 4 5,.I E949;C;.9= L,M1

FGC E,<<J1

NL1 2O7PQ R;4-= F 3,@5M E4J E,1

B1 STJ N<1 A455?U V-; W?<E9 H?E?9 9, 9-;

A?;@9;.4.9 X,H;<.,<GE ,WW?8; 34E N4<8- )1

K1 L?I-91

B1 P-?8- ?E 9-; M49; 9-49 9-?E 0Y-?:?9 $# ?E

E94CZ;M1

K1 V-49GE <?I-91

B1 K.M 9-; M49; J,@ E?I.;M ?91

R,@ -4M 4 9;5;Z-,.; 8,.H;<E49?,. 3?9-

A;; N8>@55,@I- ,. 9-49 M4J[

K1 F :;5?;H; E,1

B1 7D4J1 K.M 9-;. E@:E;\@;.9 9, 9-49 ]]

K1 >4. F E4J ?9 C,<; ;CZ-49?8455J[ R;E1

B1 7D4J1 2@:E;\@;.9 9, N4<8- ) J,@ 3;.9 9,

^<,H, 9, H?E?9 A;; N8>@55,@I-[

K1 V-49GE 9-; :;E9 ,W CJ <;8,55;89?,.1

B1 K.M M, J,@ <;8455 3-;9-;< 9-49 34E :;W,<;

W?5?.I 9-; E;8,.M W,<C ,. 9-; !%9-[

K1 F :;5?;H; ?9 34E1

B1 K.M M?M J,@ 4ED A;; M?WW;<;.9 \@;E9?,.E

3-;. J,@ H?E?9;M -?C ?. Z;<E,. W<,C 9-; \@;E9?,.E

J,@GM 4ED;M ,H;< 9-; Z-,.;[

Page 306: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 306/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C D,.E9 <;84551 C D?D F-,3 -?G 9-; H,<GF=

4.D 3; 3;.9 ,I;< 9-; H,<GF 9,J;9-;<1

K1 L-49 34F M,@< 9-?.N?.J 4:,@9 OO C G;4.= C

P<;F@G; M,@ 3,@5D.E9 J, I?F?9 -?G @.5;FF M,@ 9-,@J-9

9-; P-,.; 8455 -4D F,G;-,3 :;;. ?.F@HH?8?;.91

L4F 9-;<; F,G;9-?.J G?FF?.J H<,G 9-; P-,.;

8455 9-49 M,@ .;;D;D F49?FH489?,. ,.Q

B1 BF C F?9 -;<; 9,D4M= C 84.E9 <;8455 3-49

?9 34F1 R4M:; C S@F9 34.9;D 9, :; I;<M 84<;H@5 4:,@9

?91

K1 B.D M,@< <;8,55;89?,. ?F 9-49 M,@ 45F,

945N;D 9, T,G U,:;<9F ?. 9-?F P;<?,D ,H 9?G;Q

B1 C :;5?;I; F,1 C 945N;D 9, T,G U,:;<9F=

4.D C :;5?;I; ?9 34F D@<?.J 9-; P;<?,D ,H 9?G;1 C

F4M 9-49 :;84@F; OO ?9EF :;;. F, 5,.J1 C9EF :;;. 4

M;4< 4.D 4 -45H= :@9 C F4M 9-49 :;84@F; ,.8; 9-?F 34F

H?5;D 9-; H?.45 9?G;= C :4F?8455M H,<J,9 9-; 9-?.J

4.D S@F9 G,I;D H,<34<D 3?9- GM 84GP4?J.= F, C D,.E9

N.,3 3-M C 3,@5D -4I; 945N;D 9, T,G U,:;<9F

4H9;<34<DF1

K1 L;55= 84. M,@ OO 4<; M,@ F@<; 9-49 M,@

945N;D 9, T,G U,:;<9F ?. "*!" 4F ,PP,F;D 9, "*!#Q

B1 V;F1 W,,D ;.,@J-1 C 84. J?I; 9-; <;4F,.

3-M= :@9111

K1 T;55 G; 3-M M,@E<; F@<; ,H 9-491

Page 307: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 307/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C;55= :;84@D; 4 E;3 F,.9-D 4G, -; <;F?.H;H

F; ,E ,@< 8,.I;<D49?,.= 4.H -; D4?H J <;F;F:;< K,@

945L?.G 9, F; 4:,@9 9-?D 4.H J <;F;F:;< G,?.G 4.H

5,,L?.G 49 9-?D= 4.H 9-;. -; D4?H 9, F;= +,-.= 9-?D

D949@9; 5,,LD 5?L; ?9 34D 8,.D9<@89;H DM;8?E?8455K

E,< 9-?D 9KM; ,E 4 D?9@49?,. 3-;<; ?9 H,;D.N9 ?.I,5I;

9-; E4F?5K= ?9ND O@D9 ?.8,F; 9, 9-; E?5;<= 4.H -;

D4?H D,F;9-?.G 9-49 O@D9 <;455K 34D D@<M<?D?.G 9, F;1

P; D4?H D,F;,.; <;455K DF4<9 3<,9; 9-?D D949@9; 9,

8,I;< 9-?D 9KM; ,E 4 D?9@49?,.1 Q-49ND 3-49 -; D4?H

9, F; O@D9 4 E;3 F,.9-D 4G,= F4K:; 4 F,.9- 4G,= 4.H

9-49 <;F?.H;H F; ,E 9-; E489 9-49 3; -4H 945L;H 4.H

9-49 -;NH G?I;. F; 9-49 4HI?8; :;E,<; J E?5;H FK

E?.45 I;<D?,. ,E 9-?D1

$%&'()(* ,, -./ 0.12%345 

R1 STK U<1 A455?V JNI; -4.H;H K,@

0W-?:?9 $$1

>4. K,@ D4K ?E 9-?D ?D 9-;

8,FM5;9; M48L;9 ,E H,8@F;.9D K,@ E?5;H 9-;. ,. 9-;

!%9- ,E U4<8-= "*!"X

B1 Y,@ L.,3= ?9 5,,LD 5?L; ?9 ?D= K,@ L.,3=

4.H ?9ND ?.9;<;D9?.G ZZ 4.K34K= ?9 5,,LD 5?L; ?9 ?D1

Q-49ND K,@< [@;D9?,.= D, JN55 4.D3;< 9-; [@;D9?,. ?9

5,,LD 5?L; ?9 ?D1

R1 C-;. K,@ DM,L; 3?9- A;; U8>@55,@G-= H?H

Page 308: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 308/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B,@ C<,D?E; -?F 4.B :4.G 488,@.9 ?.H,<F49?,. ,< E?E

B,@ ;IC54?. 9, -?F 3-49 -4E J,.; ,. 3?9- KK

L1 M;4-1

N1 KK 9-; 488,@.9OP

L1 Q :4O?8455B 9,5E -?F 9-49 KK Q E?E.R9 KK Q

E?E.R9 94G; 4.B :4.G 488,@.9 ?.H,<F49?,. 3?9- F;1 Q

E,.R9 <;8455 94G?.J :4.G 488,@.9 ?.H,<F49?,. 3?9- F;1

Q <;8455 9;55?.J -?F 9-49 2@S4..;= FB 3?H;= -4E :;;.

C4?E H<,F 9-; ;.9?9?;O ,3.;E :B 9-; 9<@O9 4.E .,9 :B

9-; 9<@O9 ?9O;5H= 4.E Q 45O, <;8455 9;55?.J -?F 9-49

9-; F,.?;O C4?E 9, FB 3?H; 3;<; 9-;. E;C,O?9;E ?.9, 4

T,?.9 8-;8G?.J 488,@.9= 4.E Q 4OG;E -?F ?H 9-49 F4E;

4.B E?HH;<;.8;= O, Q H;59 D;<B KK 5?G; Q 34O D;<B

9-,<,@J- 3?9- -?F 4:,@9 ;I4895B 3-49 3; -4E E,.;= 4.E

-?O <;OC,.O; 34O 9-49 F4G;O ., E?HH;<;.8;1 M,@R<;

.,9 ;.9?95;E 9, 9-49= 4.E O-;RO ;.9?95;E 9, E,

3-49;D;< O-; 34.9O 3?9- 9-49 F,.;B1 2-; 84. OC;.E ?9

,. -;< ,3. ,< O-; 84. C@9 ?9 ?.9, B,@< 488,@.9 ,< O-;

84. :@B H@<.?9@<;1 2-; 84. E, 3-49;D;< O-; 34.9O

3?9- ?91 Q 34O D;<B 85;4< 3?9- -?F 4.E 66 3?9- -?F

,. 9-49 C,?.91

N1 Q .,9; ?. 0I-?:?9 $$ B,@ -4D; E;5;9;E

23455,3 U LOO,8?49;O 4O 4. ;.9?9B 9-49 B,@ ,3.;E1

L1 L.E 3-49P

N1 M,@ E?E .,9 C@9 23455,3 U LOO,8?49;O 4O 4.

Page 309: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 309/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

;.9?9B 9-49 B,@ ,3.;C 4D B,@ -4C ?. 9-; EE

F1 G;4-= 4.C H C,.I9 @.C;<D94.C 3-B 9-49 ?D=

:@9 ?9 34D @.?.9;.9?,.45 ,. JB K4<9= 4.C H .,9;= 4D

B,@ K<,:4:5B C,= 9,,= 9-49 H C?D85,D;C 23455,3 L

FDD,8?49;D ,. 9-; D;8,.C K4M;= 4.C H C?D85,D;C JBD;5N

4D 4 J;J:;< 4.C 4 J4.4M;<= D, 4. ,3.;< 4.C 4 J4.4M;<

,N 23455,3 L FDD,8?49;D ,. 9-49 5?.;= D, H 84..,9

;OK54?. 3-B H K@9 ?9 ,. 9-;<; D;K4<49;1 H9 34D P@D9

4. ,Q;<D?M-91

R1 7S4B1 T;<; B,@ ?.9;.C?.M ?. 9-; D;8,.C

N,<J 9, 8-4.M; ,< 8,<<;89 4.B9-?.M N<,J 9-; N?<D9

N,<JU

F1 V-49ID 4 M,,C W@;D9?,.1 T?9-,@9 5,,S?.M=

H C, .,9; 9-49 H -4Q; JB N@55 .4J; ,. 9-; D;8,.C N,<J

<49-;< 9-4. 9-; N?<D9 N,<J= 3-?8- ?D P@D9 +,-.

23455,31 V-?D ?D +,-. 01 23455,31

R1 A;9 J; 4DS 9-; W@;D9?,. 9-?D 34BX F

J,J;.9 4M, B,@ EE 49 5;4D9 H @.C;<D9,,C B,@ 9, D4B

9-; <;4D,. B,@ N?5;C 9-; N?<D9 N,<J 34D :;84@D; B,@<

84JK4?M. D94NN 34.9;C B,@ 9, M;9 9-; P@JK ,. 9-;

N?5?.M= 4.C B,@ N?5;C ?9 S.,3?.M 9-49 ?9 34D

?.8,JK5;9;1

Y?C H @.C;<D94.C 9-49 488@<49;5BU

F1 Z.,3?.M 9-49 EE B;4-= S.,3?.M 9-49 HIC

-4Q; 9-; ,KK,<9@.?9B 9, N?.45?[; ?9 :;N,<; 9-; !%9-=

Page 310: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 310/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

:@9 B;C1

D1 E;55= F 9-,@G-9 B,@ C4?H 9-49 9-;<; 3;<;

I4.B :54.JC KK

L1 M?G-91

D1 KK ?. 9-; N?<C9 N,<I1

L1 M?G-91

D1 O,< ;P4IQ5;= B,@ H?H .,9 ?.85@H; ?. 9-;

N?<C9 N,<I 4.B ,N 9-; KK 3;55= F H,.R9 9-?.J B,@

?.85@H;H 4.B ,N 9-; ?.N,<I49?,. ,. 9-; C;8,.H Q4G;1

L1 M?G-91

D1 0P8;Q9 N,< B,@RS; ?H;.9?N?;H B,@< 3?N; 4.H

I?.?.G1

L1 M?G-91 M?G-91 L.H F :;5?;S; KK T499= F

:;5?;S; F 945J;H 3?9- T4<J U-,I4C 4:,@9 9-49 49 9-;

9?I; 4.H 9,5H -?I 9-49 IB ?.9;.9 34C 9, N?55 ?9 ,@9

N@<9-;< :;N,<; 9-; ;.H ,N 9-; N?5?.G Q;<?,H1

D1 E-B .,9 V@C9 Q@9 ?. O<?;.HC ,N +,-.

23455,3 ,< W,5?9?845 N,< O ,N +RC= ;9 8;9;<4= ,. 9-;

N?<C9 N,<IX

L1 F H,.R9 J.,31 F 84.R9 ;PQ54?. ?91 F

I@C9 KK F I;4.= F 84. CQ;8@549;= :@9 F I@C9 -4S;

9-,@G-9= 3;55= FRI G,?.G 9, 8,I; :48J -;<; 4.H

4@GI;.9 ?9 4.B34B1 T?G-9 4C 3;55 V@C9 G;9 ?9 455

<?G-9 49 9-; C4I; 9?I;= :@9 F 84.R9 ;PQ54?. ?91

YB 9-; 34B= B,@ 4CJ;H I; 4 Z@;C9?,.

Page 311: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 311/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

;4<5?;< 4:,@9 3-;9-;< 0B-?:?9 $$ 34C 9-; 8,DE5;9;

F?5?.G1 H 9-?.I ?. 8,D:?.49?,. 3?9- 9-?C ,.; ?9 34C

4 8,DE5;9; F?5?.G= 3?9- 0B-?:?9 $# 4.J $$ 9,G;9-;<=

C, 9-; 8,DE5;9; F?5?.G KK H D;4.= H J,.L9 I.,3 ?F

5;G455M M,@ N@C9 C@:C9?9@9; $$ F,< $# ,< ?F M,@ 4JJ

:,9- ,F 9-;D 9,G;9-;<1

O1 7I4M1 P,3= H I.,3 M,@LQ; <;4J 9-;

R;9?9?,.;<LC 455;G49?,.C 4:,@9 .,.J?C85,C@<;C KK

S1 T?G-91

O1 KK C, H N@C9 34.9 9, 4CI M,@ 9-; U@;C9?,.C

4.J D4I; C@<; HLQ; G,9 M,@< 8,DE5;9; 9;C9?D,.M= 4.J H

34.9 9, C94<9 3?9- 9-; .4D; ,F 9-; ;.9?9M ,3.;J1 S55

<?G-9V

W,@ J?J .,9 J?C85,C; RK2,5@9?,.C= 22X=

HKS34<; ?. 9-49 J,8@D;.9= 4.J ;BE54?. 9, D; M,@<

<;4C,.?.G 3-M M,@ J?J.L9 J?C85,C; 9-;D1

YT1 2P7Z[ Z;55= ?9LC :;;. 4CI;J 4.J

4.C3;<;J1

\]0 ZH\P022[ H 9-?.I H -4Q; ;BE54?.;J

9-491 ^, M,@ 34.9 D; 9, ;BE54?. ?9 4G4?.V

YT1 ASAAH[ Z;55= 9-; U@;C9?,. -4C.L9 :;;.

4CI;J1 H9 D4M -4Q; :;;. 4.C3;<;J ?. <;CE,.C; 9, 4

J?FF;<;.9 U@;C9?,.1 H 34.9 9, 4CI 9-; CE;8?F?8

U@;C9?,.C 4.J G;9 -?C J?<;89 9;C9?D,.M 4:,@9 CE;8?F?8

U@;C9?,.C= 4.J H 3,@5J 9-?.I M,@ 3,@5J 34.9 9-49=

Page 312: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 312/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

9,,1

BC1 2D7EF E;55= G 9-?.H I,@ -4J; 9-;

4.K3;< 9-;.= 5;9 L; M@K9 N@9 ?9 9-49 34I1

BC1 AOAAGF E;55= 9-;. -; 84. :; L,<;

KN;8?P?8 9-?K 9?L;1

BC1 2D7EF Q-49RK 455 I,@ 4KH;ST

BC1 AOAAGF D,1 G 4KH;S 9-; U@;K9?,. 9-49

-; V4J; 4 J;<I 5;.V9-I ;WN54.49?,. ,.= 3-?8- G

4NN<;8?49; 4.S GRL .,9 :;?.V 8<?9?845 ,P= :@9 G 34.9

9, V?J; I,@ 4. ,NN,<9@.?9I 4.S G 34.9 I,@ 9, :;

,:5?V49;S 9, 4.K3;< 9-; S?<;89 U@;K9?,.K 9-49 I,@<

488@K;<K -4J; L4S; ,P I,@1

X1 YZI B<1 A455?[ O.S K, LI U@;K9?,. ?KF

E-49 34K I,@< 5,V?8 P,< .,9 S?K85,K?.V \]2,5@9?,.K=

22^ ,< G]O34<; ?. 9-; D4L; ,P ;.9?9I ,3.;S :,WT

O1 G. 3-?8- :,W ?K 9-49T

X1 D4L; ,P ;.9?9I ,3.;S1

O1 E;55= 4.S G 45K, S?K85,K;S 9-; 9<@K91

Z;84@K; G S?S .,9 8,.K?S;< LIK;5P 9, :; 4. ,3.;< ,P 4

9<@K9 ,< 4.I ,P 9-; 8,LN4.?;K 9-49 3;<; ,3.;S

!** N;<8;.9 :I 9-; 9<@K9 ,< :I 22^1 G S?S .,9

8,.K?S;< LIK;5P 4. ,3.;< ,P 9-,K; ;.9?9?;K1

X1 7H4I1

BC1 2D7EF _,@ 84. 4S,N9 I,@< N<;J?,@K

4.K3;<1

Page 313: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 313/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

BC0 DEBF022G H.I E 3?55 4I,J9 KL J<;M?,@N

4.N3;< :L <;O;<;.8; ?O L,@ 34.91

PQ1 AHAAEG 7R4L1

PQ1 2F7DG HNN@K?.S -; -4I.T9 <;455L 4NR;I

9-49 U@;N9?,.= 3-?8- -; K4L 3;55 :; <?S-91

PQ1 AHAAEG F,= E I?I.T9 4NR 9-49

U@;N9?,.1

BC0 DEBF022G H.I ET55 -;4< 4:,@9 ?9

549;<1

PQ1 AHAAEG Q,I= L,@ 3;<; V,R?.S 3?9- -?K

4:,@9 S?M?.S 9,, 5,.S ,O 4. 4.N3;<= N, ETK N@<J<?N;I

L,@T<; K4R?.S 9-?N ,:V;89?,.1

PQ1 2F7DG D;55= ?9 34N .,9 4. ,:V;89?,.1

W1 XYL P<1 A455?Z A;9 K; I?<;89 L,@<

499;.9?,. 9, 9-; :,[ \F4K; ,O ;48- ;.9?9L 9-49 -4N

J4?I ]%=*** ,< K,<; ?. ?.8,K; 9, 9-; O?5;<

3?9-?. 9-; ,.; L;4< J;<?,I ;.I?.S ?KK;I?49;5L :;O,<;

9-; I49; ,O 9-; I?N85,N@<; O,<K1\

E. 9-49= L,@ I?I .,9 I?N85,N; QPQ

>,.N@59?.S ,< 4.L ,O Q?8-4<I Q435;TN 4OO?5?49;N1

D-L .,9^

H1 D;55= E I?I.T9 I?N85,N; 9-,N; ;.9?9?;N

:;84@N; KL :;5?;O 34N 4.I ?N 9-49 9-,N; [email protected] __

9-,N; [email protected] 3;<; J4?I 9, 4. ;.9?9L= .,9 9, K;

J;<N,.455L1 B-49 34N KL :;5?;O 4.I @.I;<N94.I?.S 49

Page 314: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 314/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

9-; 9?B; C D?5;E 9-;F; E,8@B;.9F1

G1 7H4I1 J.E 9-49KF LL

J1 M,3= 3;KN; ,DD;<;E 9, 4B;.E 9-;F;

E,8@B;.9F ?D 9-; A?;@9;.4.9 O,N;<.,< :;5?;N;F 9-49

F,B;9-?.P ?F E?DD;<;.9= :@9 3; 8;<94?.5I -4N; .,9

-;4<E 9-49 D<,B -?B= 4.E 3; 34.9 9, :; D@55I

8,,Q;<49?N;= :@9 C 9-?.H 9-49 4.F3;<F 9-; R@;F9?,.=

4.E C= 4P4?.= ?.8,<Q,<49; :I <;D;<;.8; BI D@<9-;< LL

BI ;4<5?;< 4.F3;< ?. 84F; 9-49KF .;;E;E= 4.E 5;9 B;

S@F9 F4I C E,.K9 34.9 9, -4N; 9, 8,.9?.@; @.5;FF ?9KF

.;8;FF4<I 9, 8,.9?.@; 9, ?.8,<Q,<49; 9-491

G1 C9KF .,9 .;8;FF4<I1

J1 T, I,@ 9-?.H ?9KF .;8;FF4<I D,< @FU

VW1 2M7XY M,9 .,31

Z[0 XCZM022Y 7H4I1 Z-4.H I,@1

VW1 2M7XY C9KF 4P<;;E1

G1 \]I V<1 A455?^ _,@ 45F, ?. 9-49 F4B; :,`

E?E .,9 E?F85,F; aL2,5@9?,.F1

J1 W?P-91

G1 J.E .,9?.P 9-49 9-;<; 34F B,<; 9-4. b%=***

9<4.FD;<<;E D<,B aL2,5@9?,.F 9, I,@< 3?D; 4.E 9-;.

?.9, I,@< S,?.9 8-;8H?.P 488,@.91

J1 Z-49 ?F <?P-9= 4.E 9-49KF D,< 9-; <;4F,.F

CKN; ;`Q54?.;E ?. BI ;4<5?;< <;FQ,.F;F1

G1 ];84@F; V<1 V8>@55,@P- 9,5E I,@ 9-49 ?9

Page 315: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 315/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

34B .,9 C,@< D,.;CE

F1 G;55= :;84@B; 4H9;< 8,.B@59?.I 3?9- DC

543C;< 4.J K<1 L,:;<9B= M :;5?;N;J 9-49 M 34B :;?.I

9<@9-H@5 4.J 488@<49; :C 94O?.I 9-; P,B?9?,. 9-49 M

4B 9-; H?5;< -4J .,9 :;;. QQ <;8;?N;J ?.8,D; H<,D 4.

;.9?9C B@8- 4B RQ2,5@9?,.B 3?9-?. 9-; ,.; C;4< P;<?,J

P<?,<1

S1 T?J C,@ 8,.B?J;< J?B85,B?.I RQ2,5@9?,.B ?.

9-49 :,U B?DP5C 9, ;<< ,. 9-; B?J; ,H 84@9?,.E

F1 V,@ O.,3= M 34.9;J 9, :; 5;I455C 488@<49;

,< M 3,@5J.W9 -4N; ;N;. D4J; 9-; P-,.; 84551 G-;. M

B43 9-; 54.I@4I; X?.8,D; 9, 9-; H?5;<=X ?9 <4?B;J 4

Y@;B9?,. ?. DC D?.J 4:,@9 3-49 9-49 D;4.9= 4.J M

34.9;J 4 B;8,.J 4.J 4 9-?<J ,P?.?,. 4:,@9 9-491 M

J?J.W9 B;; ?9 4B ?.8,D; 9, 9-; H?5;<= :@9 M 34.9;J 9,

8,.H?<D ?9= 4.J M J?J 3?9- DC ;UP;<?;.8;J 5;I45

8,@.B;5 4.J 3?9- Z,D L,:;<9B1

S1 F.J M 4PP<;8?49; C,@ 34.9?.I 9, :;

488@<49;= :@9 DC Y@;B9?,. 34B[ \?N;. 9-; Y@;B9?,.

4<?B?.I ?. C,@< D?.J 9-49 5;J C,@ 9, 8,.B@59 3?9-

D@59?P5; P;,P5; 4.J C,@< 9;B9?D,.C 9-49 C,@ J?J.W9

<;455C 84<; ?H 9-; P@:5?8 O.;3 4:,@9 RQ2,5@9?,.B= 3-C

.,9 J?B85,B; RQ2,5@9?,.B 9, ;<< ,. 9-; B?J; ,H

84@9?,.E

F1 M J?J.W9 O.,3 ;.,@I- 4:,@9 9<@B9 543 4.J

Page 316: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 316/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4:,@9 9-; B@9@<; 8,.C;D@;.8;C ,B 4. 4EF?CC?,. 9-49

F?G-9 :; ?.488@<49; ,. 4 B,<F 5?H; 9-?C 9, H.,3 3-49

9-; ?FI489C 3,@5E :; ,. 9-; 94J I54.= ,< 9-; ;C949;

I54.1

K I@9 9,G;9-;< 49 G<;49 ;JI;.C; ;L;<M

M;4<= CI;.E?.G :;93;;. N"=*** OO N'%* 4.E N"=*** 9,

4. ?.E;I;.E;.9 9<@C9;; ?. A4C P;G4C1 K E?E.Q9 34.9

9, 8,.94F?.49; ,< L?9?49; 9-; I@<I,C; ,B 9-49 9<@C9

9-49 K -4E C;9 @I ?. 9-; B?<C9 I548;1 RC 5,,C;5M

F4.4G;E 4C ?9 34C= K 34.9;E 9, F4H; C@<; K G,9 ?9

<?G-91

S1 7H4M1 T,@ 45C, E?E .,9 E?C85,C; ?. 9-?C

:,J >-;8H >?9M ,< 9-; U?8-4<E U435; 8,FI4.?;C <;549;E

9, 9-; I@<8-4C; ,B 9-; G,5E 8,?.C1

V-49 34C M,@< 9-?.H?.G ?. 9-49 <;G4<EW

R1 R<; M,@ 945H?.G 4:,@9 9-; C4F; :,J= ?.8,F;

9, 9-; B?5;<W

S1 T;C1

R1 K E?E.Q9 8,.C?E;< 9-; C45; ,B 9-,C; 8,?.C

?.8,F; 9, 9-; B?5;<1

S1 7H4M1 V4C 9-49 C,F;9-?.G M,@ 945H;E 9,

X<1 X8>@55,@G- 4:,@9W

R1 K E,.Q9 <;8455 945H?.G 9, -?F 4:,@9 9-491

S1 Y?E 9-49 ;L;. OO

R1 Y?E.Q9 8<,CC FM F?.E1

Page 317: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 317/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1

E1 F?G.H9 ;I;. 8<,JJ KD K?.G1

B1 7C4D1 L 34.9 9, G?<;89 D,@< 499;.9?,. ,.

9-; .;M9 N4O; 9, 9-; P@;J9?,. <;O4<G?.O J;<I?8; ,.

9-; Q,4<G ,R F?<;89,<J ,< 4.D ,9-;< 9DN; ,R R,<K45

4GI?J,<D 84N48?9D1

E1 S?O-91

B1 T,@ G?G .,9 G?J85,J; S?8-4<G S435;=

>-4N4<<45= SUS= VW2,5@9?,.J= 22X= LWE34<;1

Y-49 34J D,@< 9-?.C?.O ?. 9-49 <;O4<GZ

E1 Y;55= 5;9 K; 94C; 9-;K ,.; 49 4 9?K;1 L

G,.H9 :;5?;I; L WW L G,.H9 :;5?;I; L ;I;< 34J ,. 9-;

Q,4<G ,R F?<;89,<J WW L 34J .;I;< ,. 9-; Q,4<G ,R

F?<;89,<J ,< ?. 4 R,<K45 4GI?J,<D 84N48?9D ?. 9-;

>-4N4<<45 8,KN4.D ,< R,< S?8-4<G S435;= :@9 9-?J

J949;K;.9 ?J 4 N<;J;.9 9;.J; J949;K;.9= J, ;I;. ?R L

-4G :;;.= 49 9-; K,K;.9 L J?O.;G 9-?J L 34J.H9= J, L

3,@5G J;; ., <;4J,. 4.G J43 ., <;4J,. 9, ?.85@G;

9-,J; 8,KN4.?;J ,< 9-,J; <;549?,.J-?NJ ,. 9-?J R,<K1

B1 2, 34J ?9 D,@< I?;3 D,@ 3;<; .,9 4 R,<K45

4GI?J,< 9, S?8-4<G S435; ,< >-4N4<<45Z

E1 Y;55= KD N,?.9 ?J L G?G.H9 J;<I; ,. 4

Q,4<G ,R F?<;89,<J ,< 4.D 9DN; ,R R,<K45 4GI?J,<D

84N48?9D= :@9= 9, K;= 9-49HJ [@J9 ,.; N,?.91

\-; J;8,.G N,?.9 ?J 9-?J G?G .,9 945C

Page 318: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 318/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

4:,@9 <;48-?.B :48C 4 D;4<1 E9 9-; 9?F; G H?5;I

9-?J= G 8;<94?.5D 34J.K9 I,?.B 4.D 3,<C 4.I -4I.K9

I,.; 4.D 3,<C H,< 9-,J; 8,FL4.?;J H,< 49 5;4J9 J?M

F,.9-J1

N1 O,< >-4L4<<45P

E1 O,< >-4L4<<45 ,< Q?8-4<I RR ,<

Q?8-4<I Q435; L;<J,.455D= 4.I 9-49KJ S@J9 I;45?.B

3?9- Q?8-4<I Q435; 4.I >-4L4<<451

EJ H4< 4J TR2,5@9?,.J= G 9-?.C G 9;J9?H?;I

54J9 9?F; 9-49 G ?.I?849;I 9, U<1 U8>@55,@B- ,. 9-;

L-,.; ,. 9-; )9- :;H,<; G J?B.;I 9-; H?<J9 H,<F 9-49

G 34J <;J?B.?.B 4.I 9;.I;<;I FD <;J?B.49?,. 4J 4

F4.4B;< ,H TR2,5@9?,.J 4.I 22V 4.I= G :;5?;W;=

GRE34<; 455 49 9-; J4F; 9?F;= J, 49 9-; F,F;.9 G

J?B.;I 9-?J ?9 34J FD :;5?;H 9-49 G 34J ., 5,.B;<

F4.4B?.B 9-,J; 8,FL4.?;J= 4.I 8;<94?.5D :D 9-; 9?F; G

4F;.I;I FD H?5?.B :D 9-; !%9-= 3-;. ?9 34J H,<F45?X;I

3?9- 9-; 2949;= G 8;<94?.5D 34J .,9 9-; F4.4B;< ?.

9-; ;D;J ,H 9-; 2949;= 459-,@B- FD :;5?;H 49 9-; 9?F;

34J G 34J.K9 49 9-; 9?F; G H?<J9 H?5;I ,< G 3,@5I.K9

-4W; J?B.;I 9-; I,8@F;.91

N1 2, G 94C; ?9 9-49 ;W;. 9-,@B- D,@ -4I

3?9-I<43. 4J F4.4B;< ,H TR2,5@9?,.J 4.I 22V= D,@ 45J,

I?I .,9 8,.J?I;< D,@<J;5H 4 H,<F45 4IW?J,< 9,

TR2,5@9?,.J ,< 22VY ?J 9-49 8,<<;89P

Page 319: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 319/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C4D?.E <;F?E.;G= H 3,@5G F4I .,1

J1 K?G I,@ 4FL M<1 M8>@55,@E- ,< 4.I,.; ;5F;

3-49 :;?.E 4 N,<O45 4GD?F,< O;4.9P

B1 H :;5?;D; 3; G?F8@FF;G 9-49= M4991 H

:;5?;D; 3; G?G1 Q; <;4G 9-; 3-,5; RR H <;4G 9-;

3-,5; F949;O;.9 9, -?O= 4.G 3; G?F8@FF;G ?9 ?. 4

8,.9;S9 ,N 9-; D4<?,@F T,F?9?,.F H -4G -;5G 3?9-

9-;F; 9<@F9R,3.;G 8,OT4.?;F= F, H :;5?;D; 9-; 4.F3;<

9, 9-49 ?F I;F1

J1 K?G I,@ G, 4. ?.G;T;.G;.9 ;D45@49?,. ,<

4.45IF?F ,N 3-49 ?9 O;4.9 9, :; 4 N,<O45 4GD?F,<P

B1 H 3,@5G.U9 F4I H G?G1

Q-;. I,@ F4I ?.G;T;.G;.9= N,<O45

?.G;T;.G;.9 4.45IF?FP

J1 Q;55= HUO V@F9 3,.G;<?.E ?N I,@ 9-,@E-9

9-<,@E- 3-49 ?F 4 N,<O45 4GD?F,< 4F ,TT,F;G 9, F,O;

,9-;< L?.G ,N 4GD?F,<P

B1 Q;55= H 5,,L 49 9-; T54?. 54.E@4E;1

W,<O45 4GD?F,< ?F G?NN;<;.9 9-4. ?.N,<O45 4GD?F,<1

MI :;5?;N 4.G @.G;<F94.G?.E 49 9-; 9?O;

34F 3-;. H 34F ., 5,.E;< 4 O4.4E;< ,< -4G <;F?E.;G 4F

O4.4E;<= 9-;. H ., 5,.E;< -;5G 4 N,<O45 4GD?F,<I

84T48?9I D;<F@F 4 84F@45 ,< 4. ?.N,<O45 4GD?F,<I

84T48?9I1

J1 2, -,3 3,@5G I,@ G;F8<?:; I,@<

Page 320: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 320/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

<;549?,.B-?C 3?9- DE2,5@9?,.B 4F9;< G,@< 3?9-H<4345I

J1 K;55= L 8;<94?.5G H?H.M9 8,.B?H;< L -4H 4

F,<N45 4HO?B,<G 84C48?9G 3?9- DE2,5@9?,.B 4F9;< 9-49

C,?.9 EE

P1 J.H 3-G .,9I

J1 EE ,< L 3,@5H -4O; ;.H;H EE :;84@B; L

<;B?Q.;H 4B 9-; N4.4Q;<1 R-49 34B 9-; ,.5G F,<N45

<,5; L -4H 3?9- 9-; 8,NC4.G1

P1 K;55= G,@ 3;<; S;;C?.Q 9-; 8-;8S:,,S 4.H

9-; 5;HQ;< 4.H N4.4Q?.Q 9-; F?.4.8;B1

J1 T,< 455 F,@< 8-;8SB 9-49 3;<; 3<?99;. F<,N

9-49 C,?.9 F,<34<HI U499= 5?B9;.= 9-?B ?B 4

8,.9;NC,<4.;,@B F?5?.Q1 R-;<; ?B ., 34G 4B L

@.H;<B94.H ?9 9, Q, ?. 4 N,.9- 549;< 4.H 4N;.H 9-?B

F?5?.Q 4.H B4G= 3;55= G,@ S.,3= ,. U4<8- )9- 4.H

U4<8- !%9- L <;B?Q.;H 4B 9-; N4.4Q;<= :@9 B?.8; 9-;.

LMO; 3<?99;. ,@9 4 F;3 8-;8SB 4.H B?Q.;H 4 F;3

8-;8SB EE :;84@B; L B9?55 -4O; B?Q.49,<G 4@9-,<?9G 49

9-; 8<;H?9 @.?,. EE 3-?5; LMN ?. 9-; N?HH5; ,F 4

84NC4?Q.1 LMN O;<G= O;<G :@BG 4.H -4O;.M9 Q?O;. 93,

9-,@Q-9B 4:,@9 ?9 B?.8; 9-; H4G L F?5;H 9-;B;

H,8@N;.9B1

2, ?9MB ;4BG 9, 5,,S :48S 9,H4G 4.H B4G=

NG Q,,H.;BB= :@9 8;<94?.5G 49 9-; 9?N; 3-;. L B?Q.;H

9-?B H,8@N;.9 L :;5?;O;H ?9 34B 9<@; 4.H 488@<49; 49

Page 321: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 321/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!""

9-; 9?B; ?. C,,D E4?9- 3?9- C,,D 4DF?8; E<,B 8,@.G;51

H B4D; 9-; D;8?G?,.G BIG;5E= H ,3. 9-,G; D;8?G?,.G=

:@9 H <;455I E;59 H 34G :;?.C -,.;G9 3?9- 9-; 2949;

4.D 3?9- 9-; F,9?.C J@:5?8 49 9-; 9?B; 4.D H -4D .,

<;4G,. .,9 9, D?G85,G; ?9= :;84@G; H D?D.K9 ;F;. L.,3

9-49 +,-.G,. 34G C,?.C 9, D, 3-49 -; D?D E,< 4.,9-;<

B,.9- 4.D 4 -45E 4E9;< H E?5;D 9-;G; E,<BG1 M-49 34G

9-; B;.945 G949; H 34G ?. 49 9-; 9?B; H B4D; 9-;

D?G85,G@<;G1

N1 A;9 B; D?<;89 I,@< 499;.9?,. D,3. 9, 9-;

:,O 9-49 PP ?9 5,,LG 5?L; ?9KG 9-?<D E<,B 9-; :,99,B1

H9 945LG 4:,@9 9-; GJ,@G;KG ;BJ5,IB;.91

Q1 R;4-= @-P-@-1

N1 R,@ D?D .,9 D?G85,G; SP2,5@9?,.G= 22T ,<

HPQ34<; ?. 9-;<;1

Q1 U?C-91

N1 V-I .,9W

Q1 H D?D.K9 8,.G?D;< BI 3?E; 4. ;BJ5,I;; ,E

D;[email protected] 8,BJ4.?;G1 M-,G; 8,BJ4.?;G :4G?8455I 3;<;

D,?.C .,9-?.C= 4.D B4I:; D;[email protected] ?G 9,, G9<,.C ,E 4

3,<D= :@9 9-;I 3;<; :4G?8455I PP 9-; :@G?.;GG G?D; ,E

9-,G; 8,BJ4.?;G -4D ;.D;D1 22T .;F;< -4D 4.I

:@G?.;GG= ?9 34G 4 -,5D?.C 8,BJ4.I= 4.D SP2,5@9?,.G

-4D.K9 D,.; 4.I 8,.G@59?.C 3,<L E,< G?O B,.9-G= 4.D

HPQ34<; -4D.K9 D,.; 4.I 8,.G@59?.C 3,<L ,< 4.I 3,<L

Page 322: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 322/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"!

49 455 B,< C,<; 9-4. 4 D;4<= 4.E F -4E ., G54.H 9, E,

4.D B@<9-;< 3,<I B,< 9-,H; 8,CG4.?;H 3-?5; F 34H

J99,<.;D K;.;<451

2, 3-;. F 945I;E 9, LL 3-;. F 945I;E 9,

A;; 4:,@9 3-, 3,@5E <;G548; C; 4H C4.4M;<= -; H4?E 9,

C; ?9 <;455D E,;H.N9 C499;< ?B D,@N<; .,9 E,?.M 4.D

I?.E ,B 3,<I ?. 9-,H; 8,CG4.?;H= H, CD 3?B;= F E,.N9

8,.H?E;< -;< 4. ;CG5,D;; ,B 9-,H; 8,CG4.?;H1 2-; ?H

.;O;< G4?E ?.8,C; 3?9- <;HG;89 9, -;< 3,<I 3?9- 9-;

8,CG4.?;H= 9-;DNO; 455 :;;. ?.9;.E;E :D C;=

?.4<9B@55D= 9, C4I; 9-49 4 E?H9<?:@9?,. ,B G<,B?9H

B<,C 9-,H; 8,CG4.?;H1

A?H9;.= 3; ;O;. G4?E 9-; 9<@H9;; B;; B,<

9-; 9<@H9 <?M-9 ,@9 ,B PL2,5@9?,.H1 F9 34H.N9 Q@H9

9-49 3; G4?E= ,< F G4?E ,< 2@R4..; G4?E -;<H;5B= ,<

3-49;O;< ?9 34H= E?H9<?:@9?,.H B<,C PL2,5@9?,.H 4.E

.,9-?.M ;5H;1 S,1 T; G4?E 9<@H9;; B;;H B<,C 9-491

F9 34H O;<D ?.B,<C455D E,.;= F M;9 D,@ 9-49= 4.E F

945I;E 4:,@9 9-49 3?9- A;;= 4.E A;; H4?E ?9 E,;H.N9

C499;<1 F9 E,;H.N9 C499;< ?. 9;<CH ,B 9-;H;

E?H85,H@<;H1 U-49 ?H .,9 D,@< ?.8,C;1 F9 ?H .,9

?.8,C; 9, D,@1 F9NH ?.8,C; 9, D,@< 3?B;1 F9 ?H .,9

?.8,C; 9, D,@1 F9 34H ?.8,C; 9-<,@M- 4 E?H9<?:@9?,.

,B G<,B?9H= .,9 B<,C ;CG5,DC;.91 U-49 ?H 3-49 F 34H

9-?.I?.M 49 9-; 9?C; F B?5;E 9-;H; E,8@C;.9H1

Page 323: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 323/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 7C4D1 E 9-?.C E @.F;<G94.F 3-49 D,@<

4.G3;< ?G= :@9 5;9 H; I-<4G; 9-; J@;G9?,. G, ?9 84.

:; I<;8?G; -;<;1

K?F D,@ -4L; MM ?. .,9 F?G85,G?.N 4.D ,O

9-;G; ;.9?9?;G= P?8-4<F P435;= >-4I4<<45=

QM2,5@9?,.G= 22R= 9-; N,5F 8,?.G= 4.D ,O 9-49=

9-49 MM

S1 +@G9 9-; 8,5F 8,?.G .,9 F?G85,G?.N 9-49

34G ?.8,H;= O,< ;T4HI5;= 9-49UG 3-49 D,@< MM

B1 V;4-1

S1 7C4D1

B1 K?F D,@ -4L; MM 34G 9-; .,.F?G85,G@<;

:4G;F ?. 4.D I4<9 ,. 4 8,.8;<. 4:,@9 -,3 9-49 H?N-9

:; I;<8;?L;F I,5?9?8455DW

S1 E F,.U9 9-?.C G,= X499= .,= .,9 49 9-;

9?H;1

B1 Y4G ?9 ;L;. 4 9-,@N-9 ?. D,@< H?.F MM

S1 Z,1

B1 MM ,< 4 GH455 O489,<W

S1 Z,1 E 9-?.C MM .,1 EU55 G4D .,1

B1 7C4D1 S.F G?H?54<5D 3?9- <;GI;89 9, 9-;

3?9-F<4345= 34G 9-; <;4G,. O,< 3?9-F<43?.N 4G

H4.4N;< MM D,@UL; G4?F D,@ 34.9;F 9, 9;55 9-; I@:5?8

9-49 D,@ 3;<;.U9 N,?.N 9, -4L; ,@9G?F; ?.9;<;G9G1

S1 P?N-91

Page 324: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 324/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

B1 C4D 4 E;D?<; 9, F<;G;.9 4.H ?.G;D9?I49?,.

?.9, JK2,5@9?,.D ,< >-4F4<<45 ,< L?8-4<E L435;= 34D

9-49 F4<9 ,M 9-; 4.45HD?D ,< E;8?D?,. N4O?.I 49 455P

Q1 R,1 R,= ?9 34D.S91

B1 R,9 ;G;. 4 M489,<P

Q1 T9 34D.S9 4 M489,<= U499= 4.E T O.;3 9-49

:;84@D; T O.,3 -,3 84NF4?I.D 3,<O 3;55 ;.,@I- 9, O.,3

9-49 4.H <;F,<9;<= 4.H 84.E?E49; H,@ <@. 4I4?.D9 ?D

I,?.I 9, V@D9 E, 4 W@?8O D;4<8- ,. +,-. 23455,3SD

:@D?.;DD 4.E 9-;HS<; I,?.I 9, F@55 ;G;<H9-?.I TSG;

;G;< E,.;1

T 34D.S9 9<H?.I 9, -?E; ?91 T9 34D

45<;4EH F@:5?81 T 34D 9<H?.I 9, D;.E 4 N;DD4I; 9-49

TSN 4 8,NN?99;E Q99,<.;H X;.;<45 84.E?E49; 4.E TSN

N,G?.I M,<34<E= 4.E T -4E.S9 E,.; 4.H 3,<O M,< 45N,D9

D?Y N,.9-D 49 9-; 9?N;1

B1 7O4H1 +@D9 I;99?.I NH .,9;:,,O -;<;1

$%&'()(* ,# -./ 0.12%345 

B1 Z[H U<1 A455?\ 0Y-?:?9 $% ?D 4. ;KN4?5

F@<F,<9?.I 9, :; M<,N H,@ 9, 4 .@N:;< ,M F;,F5;

+4.@4<H !"= "*!#1

Q1 L?I-91

B1 TD 9-?D 4 E,8@N;.9 H,@ F<;F4<;EP

Q1 T 9-?.O T 34D ?.G,5G;E 3?9- 9-;

F<;F4<49?,. ,M 9-?D E,8@N;.91 A,,OD 5?O; 9-;<; 4<;

Page 325: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 325/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

93, B4<9C 9, 9-; D,8@E;.9= <?F-9G H-;<;IC 4. ;JE4?5

8,K;< 5;99;< 9, L<?;.DC 4.D 9-;. 9-;<;IC 4 C949;E;.9=

<?F-9G

M1 N?F-91

O1 P;C= Q 34C ?.K,5K;D1 >;<94?.5R= Q 34C

?.K,5K;D ?. 9-?C1

M1 7S4R1 T?D R,@ -4K; 4CC?C94.8; ?.

B<;B4<?.F 9-?CG

O1 Q D,.I9 <;8455 ?L Q -4D 4CC?C94.8; L<,E ER

543R;< ,< ?L Q -4D 4CC?C94.8; L<,E ER B;<C,. JJ ER UN

9;4E ,< 3-49= :@9 Q 8;<94?.5R -4D <;K?;3;D ?9 4.D

4BB<,K;D ?9 :;L,<; ?9 3;.9 ,@9= ?L 9-49IC 3-49 R,@I<;

4CS?.F1

M1 O.D 9-; 4DD<;CC;;C JJ

O1 P;4-1

M1 JJ E4.R ,L 9-;E Q <;8,F.?V;1

W4C 9-;<;= R,@ S.,3= C,E; C;9 ,L 8<?9;<?4

9-49 R,@ @C;D 9, D;9;<E?.; 3-, 3,@5D F;9 4 8,BR ,L

9-?CG

O1 H-;C; 3;<; 455 85,C; JJ B;,B5; Q

8,.C?D;<;D 85,C; C@BB,<9;<C 4.D L<?;.DC1

M1 O.D Q 94S; ?9 R,@< B@<B,C; L,< 3<?9?.F

9-?C 34C C?EB5R 9, <;CB,.D 9, 9-; 455;F49?,.C 9-49

-4D :;;. E4D; :R +;<;ER +,-.C,.G

O1 Q9 3,@5D :; 9-; L?<C9 <;CB,.C;1 Q E;4.=

Page 326: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 326/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!1%#"1#$$!

!"#

+4.@4<B !"9- 34C 9-; D49; 9-; E?<C9 4<9?85; :<,F;=

C, GG

H1 I?J-91

KI1 ALAAMN >4. B,@ O@C9 J?P; Q; 4 8,@R5;

,E Q?.@9;C 9, 8,.E;< 3?9- GG

ST0 UMSV022N W,@ :;91

KI1 ALAAMN GG >4R94?. X;4BY

ST0 ZM[07\ILXT0IN \,?.J ,EE <;8,<D1

%N#& R1Q1 ?C 9-; 9?Q;1

]I;8;CC E<,Q %N#& R1Q1 9, %N#' R1Q1^

KI1 ALAAMN [, 3; .;;D 9, J, ,. E,< Q; 9,

E?.?C-Y M_Q D,.;= C, ?E 3; .;;D 9, Q4F; 4 <;8,<D

9-49 M_Q E?.?C-;D1

ST0 ZM[07\ILXT0IN 7F4B1 A;9_C J, :48F ,.

<;8,<D1 294.D :B= R5;4C;1

\,?.J :48F ,. <;8,<D1 %N#( R1Q1 ?C 9-;

9?Q;1 >,@.C;51

KI1 ALAAMN M -4P; ., E@<9-;< `@;C9?,.C1

KI1 2V7UN U; -4P; ., `@;C9?,.C1

KI1 ALAAMN 7F4B1 U;_<; D,.;1 S-4.F B,@1

ST0 ZM[07\ILXT0IN S-?C 8,.85@D;C 9-;

D;R,C?9?,.1 \,?.J ,EE <;8,<D1 %N#( R1Q1 ?C 9-;

9?Q;1

][;R,C?9?,. 8,.85@D;D 49 %N#( R1Q1^

Page 327: John Swallow Deposition Transcript

8/22/2019 John Swallow Deposition Transcript

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/john-swallow-deposition-transcript 327/327

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

!*

!!

!"

!#

!$

!%

!&

!'

!(

!)

"*

"!

""

"#

"$

"%

+,-. 01 23455,3 6 789,:;< "%= "*!#

>?9?>,@<9= AA>

(*!B%#"B#$$!

#"(

!"#$!%"!&' )"!%*+*),%"

2CDC0 7E FCDG HH II1

>7FJCK 7E 2DAC ADL0 H

M= N;.?I; O1 C-,P4I= >;<9?Q?;R S;45BC?P;S;T,<9;<= S;U?I9;<;R V<,Q;II?,.45 S;T,<9;< 4.R J,94<WV@:5?8 ?. 4.R Q,< 9-; 2949; ,Q F94-= R, -;<;:W8;<9?QWX

C-49 T<?,< 9, :;?.U ;Y4P?.;R= 9-; 3?9.;II=+7GJ 01 2ZDAA7Z= 34I :W P; R@5W I3,<. 9, 9;55 9-;9<@9-= 9-; 3-,5; 9<@9-= 4.R .,9-?.U :@9 9-; 9<@9-[

C-49 I4?R R;T,I?9?,. 34I 94\;. R,3. :W P;

?. I9;.,9WT; ,. 789,:;< "%= "*!#= 49 9-; T548;9-;<;?. .4P;R= 4.R 34I 9-;<;4Q9;< 9<4.I8<?:;R 4.R9-49 4 9<@; 4.R 8,<<;89 9<4.I8<?T9?,. ,Q I4?R9;I9?P,.W ?I I;9 Q,<9- ?. 9-; T<;8;R?.U T4U;I[

M Q@<9-;< 8;<9?QW 9-49= ?. 488,<R4.8; 3?9-S@5; #*];H= 4 <;^@;I9 -4_?.U :;;. P4R; 9, <;_?;3 9-;9<4.I8<?T9= 4 <;4R?.U 8,TW 34I I;.9 9, OS1 2J7Z Q,<9-; 3?9.;II 9, <;4R 4.R I?U. @.R;< 9-; T;.459?;I ,QT;<`@<W 4.R 9-;. <;9@<. 9, P; Q,< Q?5?.U 3?9-OS1 ADAAM1

M Q@<9-;< 8;<9?QW 9-49 M 4P .,9 \?. ,<,9-;<3?I; 4II,8?49;R 3?9- 4.W ,Q 9-; T4<9?;I 9, I4?R84@I; ,Q 489?,. 4.R 9-49 M 4P .,9 ?.9;<;I9;R ?. 9-;,@98,P; 9-;<;,Q1

ZMCJ022 OK GDJN 9-?I !I9 R4W ,Q J,_;P:;<="*!#1

 aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaN;.?I; O1 C-,P4I= >SSbSVS

F94- A?8;.I; J,1 !*$!!#B'(*!