journal of teacher action research 1 jtar...jtar about the journal founded in 2013, the journal of...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
JournalofTeacherActionResearch1
JournalofTeacherActionResearch-Volume6,Issue1,2019,practicalteacherresearch.com,ISSN#2332-2233
©JTAR.AllRightsReserved
JTAR EDITORS
![Page 2: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
JTAR JournalofTeacherActionResearchVolume6,Issue1,2019
ExaminingtheInstructionalDesignofInteractiveandCollaborativeLearning 4OpportunitiesRachelKarchmer-KleinElizabethSoslauJannSuttonComparingCooperativeLearningStrategiesinAssessmentInstruction 21JosephA.MayoDoesMindfulnessStrengthenSelf-efficacyinFirstGradeStudents? 32KristenL.LoganErikK.Laursen“Letthepeoplesing!”-ActionResearchExploringTeachers’MusicalConfidence 44WhenEngagingLearnersin‘SingingWellbeing’DaphneRicksonJoAtkinsonDianneReynoldsRobertLeggUsingFirstAuthor©WritingCurriculumwithStudentswithAutismSpectrum 63DisorderKristieAsaro-SaddlerJessicaColes
![Page 3: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
JTAR AbouttheJournal
Foundedin2013,theJournalofTeacherActionResearch(ISSN:2332-2233)isapeer-reviewedonlinejournalindexedwithEBSCOthatseekspracticalresearchthatcanbeimplementedinPre-Kindergarten
throughPost-Secondaryclassrooms.Theprimaryfunctionofthisjournalistoprovideclassroomteachersandresearchersameansforsharingclassroompractices.
Thejournalacceptsarticlesforpeer-reviewthatdescribeclassroompracticewhichpositivelyimpactsstudentlearning.Wedefineteacheractionresearchasteachers(atalllevels)studyingtheirpracticeand/ortheirstudents'learninginamethodicalwayinordertoinformclassroompractice.Articlessubmittedtothejournalshoulddemonstrateanactionresearchfocuswithintenttoimprovethe
author’spractice.
EditorialTeam
Co-EditorsGilbertNaizer,Ph.D. AprilSanders,Ph.D.
TexasA&MUniversity-Commerce SpringHillCollege
AssociateEditorsLauraIsbell,Ph.D. TamiMorton,Ph.D. SusanWilliams
TexasA&MUniversity-Commerce TexasA&MUniversity-CommerceTexasA&MUniversity-Commerce
ProductionEditorandWebmaster
ChaseYoung,Ph.D.SamHoustonStateUniversity
www.practicalteacherresearch.com
![Page 4: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 4
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
EXAMININGTHEINSTRUCTIONALDESIGNOFINTERACTIVEANDCOLLABORATIVELEARNINGOPPORTUNITIESRachelKarchmer-Klein
UniversityofDelaware
ElizabethSoslau
UniversityofDelaware
JannSutton
UniversityofNorthFlorida
AbstractAs interest in fully online programs increases at institutions of higher education, faculty members must adapt their pedagogical practices to successfully integrate the digital tools available for teaching and learning. This action research study examined if and how faculty in a school of education designed instruction that leveraged digital tools to provide collaborative and interactive learning opportunities in an online program in teacher leadership. Framed by tenets of a sociocultural perspective and the technological affordances of multimodality, collaboration, and interactivity, a variety of data was qualitatively analyzed. Findings revealed interactivity was established when instructional design explicitly guided students to interact with others. Interactivity was also established when students were given opportunities to apply content learned in class, analyze their actions, and report on the experiences to others using multiple modes accessible through digital tools. Related to collaboration, analysis indicated that program design encumbered the implementation of collaborative activities due to large class enrollment and the short duration of the academic semester. These findings will inform future revisions to the program under study as well as be shared with other faculty who are charged with designing online courses but may not have online pedagogical expertise.
Keywords:teacheractionresearch,technologicalaffordance,instructionaldesign,highereducation,onlinelearning
Introduction
Asinterestinfullyonlineprogramsincreasesatinstitutionsofhighereducation,facultymustadapttheirpedagogicalpracticestosuccessfullyintegratethedigitaltoolsavailableforteachingandlearning(AdamsBeckeretal.,2017).Simplyconnectingstudentstoinstructorsandclassmatesusingtechnologydoesnotresultinthoughtfulcollaborationand
![Page 5: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 5
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
interactivity,indicatorsofeffectiveonlineteachingpractices(Beach&O’Brien,2015).Instead,focusshouldbeplacedonhowinstructionisdesignedtocreatethesemeaningfullearningopportunitiesthatmeetcourseobjectives(Karchmer-Klein,Mouza,Shinas,&Park,2017).
Mostonlinecoursesinhighereducationaredeliveredthroughalearningmanagementsystem(LMS),apassword-protectedcloud-basedarchitecturethatprovidesacommononlinelocationtoexchangeinformationforteachingandlearning(Kroner,2014).EachLMS(e.g.,Canvas,Blackboard)encompassesasetofmultimodaldigitaltoolswithuniquetechnologicalaffordances.Forinstance,manyincorporateapeerreviewtoolthatfacilitatesinteractivitybetweenclassmatesthroughwrittenlanguage,images,audioandvideo.Thetoolcanbeeasilyintegratedintoanonlinecourse,butthewayinwhichthelearningopportunityisdesignedwillultimatelyinfluencethedepthandbreadthofstudentlearning,notthetechnologyitself.
Instructionaldesigntypicallyrestsoncourseinstructorswhoareexpertsintheirfieldsofstudy,butmaynotbeexpertpedagoguesofteachingandlearning(Ko&Rossen,2017).This,inturn,mayleadtoanoverrelianceonteacher-directedlearningactivities(Koedinger,Booth,&Klahr,2013;Rientieset.al.,2012).Forinstance,whenstudyingpatternsintheinstructionaldesignof157onlinelearningmodules,ToetenelandRienties(2016)founddidacticteachingmethods,whereinformationwastransferredelectronicallyfrominstructortostudent,werethemostcommonlyintegrated.
Asteachereducatorswhoresearchandimplementtraditionalanddigitalpedagogicalapproaches,wesetouttoexaminetheinstructionaldesignofcoursesinourown100%onlineteacherleadershipgraduateprogram.Thisactionresearchprojectwasimportanttoconductbecausethelessonslearnedcouldbeusedtoinformnotonlyourownpractice,butotherfacultywhoarechargedwithdesigningonlinecoursesbutmaynothaveonlinepedagogicalexpertise.Toachievethisaim,weexploredthefollowingresearchquestion:Inwhatwaysdidonlinefaculty’sinstructionaldecision-makingsupport,ornotsupport,collaborationandinteractivityamongstonlinecourseparticipants?
TheoreticalFramework
Thisstudydrawsupontenetsofasocioculturalperspective,specificallysocialconstructivism(Vygotsky,1978)andsituatedlearningtheory(SL)(Brown,Collins,&Duguid,1989).Socialconstructivismsuggestslearnersdevelopthroughtheirinteractionswithotherpeople’svalues,beliefs,andwaysofthinking(Tracey&Morrow,2017).SLsuggestslearningdevelopsinauthenticcontextswiththeapplicationofcontenttoreallifeexperiences(Herrington&Oliver,2000).Theselensesareespeciallyusefulwhendirectlyappliedtopromotecollaborativelearningopportunitiesamongststudentsincourseworkthatdoesnotincludefacetofaceinstruction.Inthisway,instructorsdeliberatelyandpurposefullydesigninstructionthatrequiresgroupproblem-solvingandengagementindiscussionsaboutrelatableexperiencethatwouldotherwisebeunachievablethroughautodidacticlearningorothernon-peercollaborativeapproaches(Oztok,2016;Vygotsky,1978).
![Page 6: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 6
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
LiteratureReview
EachLMSencompassesasetofmultimodaldigitaltoolswithuniquetechnologicalaffordances(Beach,Anson,Breuch,&Reynolds,2014).Threeofthemostcommonlyidentifiedintheresearchliteraturearemultimodality,interactivity,andcollaboration(Karchmer-Kleinetal.,2017;Beach&O’Brien,2015).Whenfacultybetterunderstandtheseaffordances,theyarebetterequippedtoleveragetheminwaysthatcreatecontextswherecollaborativeandinteractivelearningopportunitiesflourish.
Multimodality.Modesaresignsorsymbolsthatcommunicatemeaning(Kalantzis,Cope&Cloonan,2010).LMSsincorporateseveraltypesoftoolsthatallowfortheconsumptionandproductionofmultimodalmaterials.Canvas,forinstance,allowsteachersandstudentstoembedvideo,audio,staticimages,andhyperlinks.Combiningmodes(e.g.,wordsandaudio)inonlineactivities,suchasdiscussionposts,transformsthelearningenvironmentbyinterjectingnon-verbalcuesinwaysthatallowparticipantstoexperienceeachotherashumansratherthancomputer-generatedwordsonascreen(Lee,2004).Researchexamininginstructormultimodalfeedbackindicatesvalueinitsuse.Forinstance,studentsreportedlyfindaudioandvideocommentsmorepersonal(Henderson&Phillips,2015)andeasiertocomprehend(West&Turner,2016)thanwrittenfeedback.Moreover,thereisevidencethatstudentswhoreceive,process,andinterpretcontentpresentedthroughmultiplemodesscorehigheronassessmentmeasuresthanthosewholearnfromasinglemode(Frisby,Limperos,Record,Downs&Kercsmar,2013).
Interactivity.Interactivityisabouttheexchangeofideasandperspectiveswithothers.Inaneducationalsetting,interactivitycantakeplacebetweenstudents,studentsandinstructors,aswellasstudentsandcontent(Moore,2013).ResearchershavestudiedtheinteractivityaffordedthroughLMSdigitaltoolssuchasonlinediscussionboards(Kent,Laso&Rafaeli,2016),peerreview(Sullivan&Watson,2015),andvideoconferencing(Martin&Parker,2014).Ineachcase,findingsemphasizethecriticalroleofthoughtfulinstructionaldesign.Martin,WangandSadaf(2018),forexample,examinedgraduatestudents’perceptionsofhowtheyuseddigitaltoolstointeractwithinstructors.Althoughpreviousstudiesindicatedthatsynchronousaudioandvisualchatscouldfacilitatecommunitybuilding,(Reushle&Loch,2008),participantsinthisworkdidnotperceivethemashelpful.Instead,studentsreportedthesessions’purposeswerenotwell-articulatednordidtheymeettheirlearningneeds.Thus,althoughtheLMSconferencetoolaffordedopportunitiesforinteractivity,thedesignofthestudent-instructoractivityfellshort.
Collaboration.Collaborationistheprocessbywhichmembersofagroupnegotiate,share,andconstructmeaninginresponsetostimuli.Theincreasedvisibilityofone’sownworkandtheopportunitiestoexpresscreativitythroughcollaborativeonlineactivitieshavebeenfoundtomotivateandusefullyengagestudents(Trentin,2009).Inastudyofgraduateeducationaltechnologymajors,Karpova,CorreiaandBaran(2009)foundthatstudentsweremotivatedtolearnnewtechnologiestocollaboratewhenotheronlinecommunicationeffortsfailed.Studentsquicklydeterminedthatthelackofnon-verbalcuesinasynchronouswrittencollaborativedigitalsettingswasproblematic.Toalleviatetheissue,studentsinitiatedtheuseoftheLMS’svideofunctiontotheycouldtalkasagroupinreal-time.
![Page 7: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 7
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Likeinteractivity,studentsseemtobemoreinvestedwhencollaborativetasksarewelldefinedandscaffoldedtosupporttheirunderstandingofgroupdynamics.Kear,Woodthorpe,RobertsonandHutchison(2010)foundthiswhenstudyingtheuseofwikisinanonlinecourseinhighereducation.SimilartoGoogleDocs,wikisarecollaborativedigitalwritingspaceswherestudentsmustdivideresponsibilitiesassociatedwiththeassignedtasksandhowtorespectfullyrespondandreviseclassmates’workgiventheopennatureofthewritingprocess.Kearetal.,(2010)foundthatthelackofpreparednessonhowtouseawikiinfluencedthequalityofstudentworkandstudentsfelthighriskabouttheirengagementintheactivity.
Takentogether,theseaffordancescanbeusedtobuildsociallearningenvironments.Whenaffordancesareleveragedsuccessfully,bothaforementionedtheoreticalframesaresatisfied.Thatis,socialconstructivismcanbeseenintheinstructors’creationofacollaborativeonlinelearningenvironmentthatenableuserstomakemeaninginwaysthatwouldnothavebeenpossiblehadtheynotengagedinthesynergisticonlinespace.Instructors’onlinecoursedesignalsoextendsbeyondsocialconstructivismbysituatingthelearningandmeaningmakingprocessinahighlycontextualizedsettingthatmimicsthefuturelivedexperiencesofthelearnersintheirauthenticsettings,thusincorporatingthesignaturecomponentsofsituatedlearningtheory.
Methodology
ResearchContext.TheMasterofEducationinTeacherLeadership(MEdTL)isafullyonlineprogramdesignedforfull-timecertifiedteacherswhoseektofillschoolleadershiprolessuchasinstructionalspecialist,datacoach,andteachermentor.CourseworkisalignedwiththeTeacherLeaderModelStandards(TeacherLeaderExploratoryConsortium,2011)andMiddleStatesCommissiononHigherEducation.
TheMEdTLwaschosenasthefocusforthisactionresearchstudyfortworeasons.First,thefacultywerehighlydedicatedtotheprogram’ssuccessandvaluedtheroleoftechnologyincandidatelearning.Moreover,theywereexpertsinnotonlytheircontentareas,butalsopedagogy,giventheirexperienceandresearchasteachereducators.Second,itwasthefirstfullyonlinegraduateprogramofferedbytheuniversity’sSchoolofEducation.Thisstudywasseenasanopportunitytoidentifystrengthsandweaknessesandmakemodificationsasneeded.
MEdTLcandidatescompleteten,three-creditcoursestaughtasynchronouslyinseven-weeksessionsusingCanvas(LMS).ItwasdecidedbyfacultythatallcourseswouldbeorganizedaroundaSituatedLearning(SL)modelthatdirectlyconnectedcandidates’professionalexperiencestograduatecoursecontent(Clarke&Hollingsworth,2002).Therefore,arequirementofadmissionwascurrentemploymentinaprofessionalsettingallowingcandidatestopracticeleadershipskillslearnedinclass.Individualcourseshadlargeenrollmentsof45-65candidates.
Participants.Datawerecollectedfromfourfull-timefacultywhohelddoctoratedegreesineducation(pseudonymsreplaceparticipants’realnamesinthisarticle).Theparticipants,threefemalesandonemale,allCaucasian,hadanaverageof21yearsoverallteachingexperience,anaverageof14yearsofexperienceashighereducationfaculty,andanaverageofalmost6yearsofonlineteachingexperience.Theirfieldsofexpertiseincluded
![Page 8: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 8
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
pedagogicaldecision-makingacrosscontentareas,literacyeducation,actionresearch,andmobilecomputingenvironments.Thefacultymembersdidnothaveanyformaltrainingtoteachonline,describingthemselvesas“self-taught”andmainlyrelyingontheirpedagogicalexpertisecoupledwithpeersupporttoguidethedevelopmentoftheircourses(seeTable1forparticipantandcourseinformation).
Table1:DemographicInformationasReportedbyFaculty
GenderFacultyMember
(Pseudonym)HighestDegree
YearsofTeachingExperience
YearsTeachingOnline
Male Dr.Bower Ph.D. 29 4
Female Dr.Kostner Ph.D. 23 13
Female Dr.Merrin Ed.D. 20 5
Female Dr.Santos Ph.D. 13 1
Positionality.RachelandElizabeth,twoofthethreeauthorsofthismanuscript,werealsofacultyinstructorsintheprogram.Jann,thethirdauthor,wasadoctoralcandidate.Mirroringtheworkofactionresearchers(Herr&Anderson,2005),self-studyadvocates(Tidwell,etal.,2009),andadoptingateacherasinquirystance(Feiman-Nemser,2012)enabledustoexamineourownpracticethroughtheexternalizationandjointexaminationofourdesignexperiences.
Tosecurecredibilityandconfirmability(Herr&Anderson,2005)andtomakeuseofour‘collaborativeresources’(Melrose,2001),JannwassolelyresponsibleforthefirstwaveofdataanalysisandRachelandElizabethinitiallytookontheroleofinformant(Eisner,1998).Additionalvaliditycriteriasuchastransferabilityandecologicalvaliditywerestrengthenedbyclearlysituatingthisstudyinthecontextfromwhichthedatawereculled;therebyallowingresearchconsumersfromhighereducation,andonlinecourseinstructors,todrawparallelstotheirowncontexts(Guba&Lincoln,1981;Bloomberg&Volpe,2008).
DataSourcesandAnalysis
LMSDigitalTools.Beforeexploringthefaculty’sdecision-makingaroundtheavailableonlinelearningtools(i.e.,Pages,Discussions,PeerReview,Collaborations),thetoolsthemselveswereanalyzedagainstaffordances(multimodal,interactivity,andcollaboration)followinganinductiveanddeductiveprocess(Patton,2015).Wereaddescriptionsofthetools’capabilitiesontheCanvaswebsiteandconductedindependentreviewsbyutilizingtheminwayswewerefamiliarwithinourownwork.Next,wemetandreferredtoournotestoidentifyspecificinstancesofif/howthetoolsincludedtheaforementioned
![Page 9: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 9
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
affordances.Oncewereachedagreementaboutthedigitaltools’affordances,weillustratedtheanalysis(seeTable2).
Table2:LMSToolsandAffordancesLeveragedbyInstructors
Tool TypesofActivitiesWritten
Language
OralLanguage
Visual
Audio
Interactivity
Collaboration
Pages ProvidecontentthroughCanvasorotherapplications. X X X X
Discussions Providespacetotalkwithclassmatesandinstructor X X X X X X
PeerReview Provideopportunitytopeerreviewwork X X X X X
Collaborations Providespacetocollaborateonthesamedocument X X X X X
Modules.Tolimitthepooltoamanageablecorpusofcodabledata,participantswereaskedtoidentifyonemodulefromeachclasstheydesignedwhichwasmostrepresentativeoftheirentirecourseintermsoftechnologicaltoolsusedandattentiontooverallcourselearninggoals.Atotalofeightcoursemoduleswereidentified.Thenumberofactivitieswithinamodulerangedfromeighttoseventeen.
Tobeginanalysis,tableswereconstructedusingthefollowingheadings:(a)learningobjective,(b)activity,(c)digitaltool,and(d)technologicalaffordances.Thefirstthree
![Page 10: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 10
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
columnswereimmediatelyfilledforeachmodule.Second,weworkedindividuallyandthencollaborativelytoconductdeductiveanalysisofthemodulesusingthetechnologicalaffordances(multimodality,interactivityandcollaboration)asaprioricodes.Thisprocessconsistedoflookingacrossthelearningobjectives,activities’descriptions,andtheselecteddigitaltoolsandcross-codingandaxial-codingagainsttheaffordances(Patton,2015).Thirdly,wesystematicallyexaminedtheactivitiestoidentifysimilaritiesanddifferencesamongandbetweenthemtoidentifypatternsrelatedtoifandhowtheactivitiesprovidedopportunitiestocollaborateandinteract.Table3isanexampleofacodedsetofactivitieswithinonemodule.
Table3:ExampleofCodingActivitiesWithinaModule
LearningObjective Activity CanvasDigitalTool
LeveragedAffordance
Tounderstandanddemonstrateknowledgeof
differentcoachingmodels.
Readarticlesandwatchvideoonpeercoaching. Pages Multimodality
Readarticlesandwatchvideooncontent-specific
coaching.Pages Multimodality
Readarticlesandwatchvideoonmentoring. Pages Multimodality
Readarticlesandwatch
videooncognitivecoaching.
Pages Multimodality
Watchvideoanddeterminecoachingtype
implemented.Postresponseindiscussionboardwithevidence
supportingyouranswers.Respondtoatleastoneclassmate’spostwith
questions,affirmations,orhealthydebate.
Discussions MultimodalityInteractivity
Interviews.Jannconductedsemi-structuredinterviewswitheachfacultyparticipantwiththepurposeoflearningmoreabouttheinstructors’decision-making,perceptionsofonlineteaching,andtheirassessmentoftheoverallmoduledesignincludinghowtheLMStoolswereusedtofacilitatestudentlearning.Interviewsweretranscribedverbatim,copiedinto
![Page 11: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 11
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
NVivosoftware,andanalyzedusinganaprioricodingsystemalignedtothetechnologicalaffordancesofmultimodality,interactivityandcollaboration.
OverallAnalysis.Onceeachdatasetwasanalyzed,usingtheconstantcomparisonmethod,wecross-comparedtheconsistencyoffindings(Patton,2015).Forexample,wecomparedandcontrastedhowparticipantsdescribedtheirmoduledesignwiththeanalysisofhowweidentifiedthetechnologicalaffordanceswereleveragedwithinthemoduleactivities.Nexttofurtherexamineourfindings,Jannconductedmember-checkingwithparticipants(Lincoln&Guba,1985).Shedraftedafullreportoutliningthemesalongwithdataexamplesandsharedthedocumentwiththefaculty.Toreacha75%member-checkrate,Jannmetwiththreeofthefourparticipantsfor90-minutestodiscussreactionstothereport,clarificationofpoints,andtheopportunitytoanswerquestions.Overall,resultsfromthemembercheckservedtoconfirmtheoriginalanalysis.
Results
RequirementsScaffoldedInteractivity.AnexaminationofcandidateworkwithinCanvasindicatedtwoimportantfindingsrelatedtointeractionsamongandbetweencandidatesandinstructors.First,allinteractions,suchascandidates’discussionboardpostsandclassmates’responseswerepresentedusingwrittenlanguageunlessthedirectionsspecificallyrequiredtheuseofadifferentmode.Inotherwords,candidateschosetorespondtoclassactivitiesusingtypedwordsratherthanaudioorvideo.ThisfindingwasnoteworthybecausetheCanvastoolsencompassedmultimodalaffordancesallowingcandidatestoseamlesslyrespondwithachoiceofmodes.Moreover,themajorityofinstructorfeedbacktocandidateswasprovidedwithtypedwrittenlanguagealthough,again,theCanvasgradingfeatureallowedforvideooraudioresponses.Dr.Kostnerwastheonlyinstructorwhodesignedinstructionthatencouraged,andsometimesrequired,candidatestorespondwithaudioorvideo.Herinterestandexperiencewithdigitaltoolsseemedtoinfluenceherinstructionaldesign.Sheexplainedinherinterview,“Ilikeusingdifferentdigitaltoolsandchallengingcandidatestopresenttheirthinkinginvariousways,especiallysincemanycandidatescommunicateviatextandreadfromwebpagesratherthantraditionallyprintedbooks.”
Analysisalsorevealedinteractivitymostlytookplacebetweencandidatesonlywhenitwasrequired.Forexample,instructorsdesignedtwotypesofactivitiesthatutilizedtheCanvasDiscussionstool.Reflectivepostswerewrittenbycandidatesinresponsetoteacher-createdpromptsafterreading,viewing,andparticipatingincoursecontentandactivities.Althoughtheinstructorcouldprovidecommentsandclassmateswereencouragedtorespond,therewasnoexpectationthesewouldoccur.Wedidnotfindanyinstancesofcandidatesrespondingtoreflectivepostsinthemodulesexaminedforthisstudy.
Discussionposts,ontheotherhand,werelikereflectivepostsbutrequiredcandidatestorespondtoatleastoneclassmate.Inotherwords,thereweregradesattached.Inallinstancesthatweexaminedforthisstudy,candidatesrespondedtoatleastoneclassmate’spostandfulfilledthisrequirement.Althoughthedepthandbreatheoftheinteractivityseemedtobedependentuponhowtheinstructordesignedtheactivity.Forexample,Table
![Page 12: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 12
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
4includesexcerptsfromgradingrubricsusedtoassesscandidates’responsestoclassmates’discussionboardpostsinthreedifferentclasses:
Table4:ExampleofGradingRubricsforDiscussionPosts
Course Criteria NoCredit HalfCredit FullCredit
#1 Responsetoclassmate
Doesnotrespondtoclassmate
Responseto1classmate
Responsetoatleast2
classmates
#2 ResponsivenessDoesnot
interactwithclassmates
Responserefersto2otherclassmates’opinions
Responsereferstoother
classmates’opinionsaswellasreadings
#3
Responseexplicitly
respondstogroupmemberposts,and
substantivelybuildsonthembyfurthering
theirargument,constructivelyofferingadifferent
perspective,orposing
questionslikelytofurtherpeers'thinkingabout
theissue.
Responsefulfillsalldimensionsofcriteria
ResponsedoesnotrespondtogrouppostsOR
doesnotsubstantivelybuildonthem
Responseexplicitly
respondstogroupmemberposts,and
substantivelybuildsonthembyfurthering
theirargument,constructivelyofferingadifferent
perspective,orposing
questionslikelytofurtherpeers'thinkingabout
theissue.
Thereareobviousdifferencesbetweentherubrics.Rubrics#1and#2mentiontheexactnumberofresponsesthatneedtobepostedtoreceivecreditwhereasRubric#3isvague.Rubric#3providesmoredetailedcriteria,explicitlystatingthetypesoffeedbacktheinstructorwouldtoevaluatetheresponse.Analyzingcandidateworkwasoutsideofthescopeofthispapersowedonotshareactualpostsinthispaper.However,theanalysisoftherubricsandotheraspectsoftheinstructionaldesignindicatethatcandidatesfollowedthedirectionspresentedtothemwheninteractingwithclassmatesintheseonlinecourses.
SituatedLearningScaffoldedInteractivity.Dr.Merrindescribedtheapplicationofcontenttorealworldexamplesas“somethingtakenveryseriouslyintheprogram”andshedescribedassignmentsas“notabstractbutreallytangiblethingsthatarerelevantto
![Page 13: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 13
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
[candidates’]dailyjobsandresponsibilities.”AnalysisrevealedthatinstructiondesignedaroundsuchSLopportunitiesscaffoldedinteractivityintheMEdTLcourses.
OnetypeofSLdesignrequiredcandidatestoconnecttheirprofessionalexperiencestocoursereadingsandvideosbyrespondingtoteacher-createdprompts.Closeanalysisrevealedthemajorityofpromptsdidnotmerelyrequirecandidatestodescribetheirprofessionalsettingsinrelationtothetopic,butratherextendtheirthinkingtoconsiderchallenges,alternativeapproaches,orotherperspectives.Forexample,afterwatchingvideosandreadingarticlesonethicalactionresearchaswellasconductingacritiqueofanactionresearcharticle,candidateswereaskedtorespondtothefollowingprompt:“Whatinnovationshaveyouimplementedthatdonotseemtobeworkinginthewaysthatyouhadanticipated?”Anotherexampleisfromacourseonstatecurriculumstandardswherecandidateslearnedhowupdatedstandardsrequiredshiftsinteachingandlearning.Thepromptwas:
Describethekindsofchangesthatyouhavealreadymadeinyourschoolorclassroom--orthatyoufeelyoumustmake--inordertomeetthedemandsofthestatestandards.Clearlyidentifythechangesthatyoumadeorwillhavetomake,whyyoumadethem(orhavetomakethem),andwhetherornotyouoryourcolleaguesarehavingdifficulties/discussions/argumentsaboutthesechanges,andthenatureofthosediscussions.
Again,thispromptwentbeyondsummarizingwhatwaslearnedfromclassresourcestorequiringcandidatestomakecomplexconnectionstotheirprofessionalsettingsfromtheroleofteacherleader.
Insomeinstances,theresponsestoteacher-createdpromptswerecompletedinpublicdiscussionboardsaccessibletoclassmates,promotinginteractivityamongthembysparkingdebate,agreement,oradditionalquestions.Inothercases,candidates’responseswerepostedprivatelywithintheCanvasAssignmentstool,whichallowedinteractivitytotakeplacebetweenthecandidateandinstructor.
AnothertypeofSLdesignthatprecipitatedinteractivityinvitedMEdTLcandidates’colleaguesorotherexpertsintotheonlinelearningspaceTheseactivitiesreflectedSLsincetheinformationdrawncamefrompeoplewhosharedsimilarprofessionalsettings.Forexample,inacourseontechnology-basedcollaborationsMEdTLcandidatescreatedaProfessionalLearningNetworkfocusedonaproblemofpractice(PoP)identifiedintheirschool.Candidateswererequiredtosurveycolleaguesandreportbacktheirfindings,explaininghowtheynarroweddowntheirPoPandhowitwasapplicable.ThisactivityprecipitatedinteractivitybetweenMEdTLcandidatesandtheircolleagues.
AthirdwayinteractivitywasscaffoldedbySLwaswhentheinstructionaldesignleveragedmultimodality,specificallyvideoandaudio.Forinstance,acoachingcourserequiredcandidatestovideotapethemselvesleadingaprofessionaldevelopmentconversationwithacolleague.CandidatesuploadedthevideosdirectlyintothePeerReviewtoolinCanvaswhereclassmatesanalyzedtheconversationsandprovidedverbalfeedbackusingtheaudiofeatureastheyevaluatedthevideo.Usingvideoallowedtheinstructorandclassmatestomaketheirownassessmentsofcontentapplicationratherthanrelyingsolelyonthe
![Page 14: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 14
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
candidates’accountsofwhattookplace.Dr.Kostnerexplained,“Videoisapowerfultoolespeciallywhenwe’reaskingcandidatestodescribetheirownpractice.Ithelpsthemlookattheirworkmoreobjectivelyanditalsohelpstheirclassmatesdothesame.”
ParticipantsagreedthatframingactivitiesfromaSLlensbenefittedlearninginatleasttwoways.First,SLprovidedinstructorswithwindowsintocandidates’professionalcontexts.Inturn,instructorsfelttheyhadmoreinsightsaboutchallengescandidatesconfrontedwhenattemptingtoimplementcontentfromthecourseworkandtheycouldprovideindividualizedfeedback.Second,instructorsfeltsharingreal-lifeexperiencesscaffoldedgroupcohesion,creatingsocialsettingswherecandidatescouldmakesenseofthestoriesclassmatestoldabouttheirexperiencesrelatedtocoursecontent.Dr.BowerexplainedthathepurposelybuiltSLactivitiesintohiscoursessothatcandidateslearnedmoreabouteachother.Hestatedthisapproachledto“morerobustinteractions”inclass.
ProgramDesignInfluencedCollaboration.Inthisstudy,collaborationwascodedwhenanactivityrequiredagroupofcandidatestoanalyzeandapplycontenttodevelopasynthesizedoutcomerepresentingtheircombinedefforts.Usingthisdefinition,collaborationwasevidentinonlyonemoduleoutoftheeightanalyzed.Acourseonequityissuesrequiredcandidatestobrainstormresponsestoacasestudyandcreateaplanofactionbasedontheircollectivethinking.Specifically,theinstructionsguidedcandidatestouseacollaborativewritingtool,suchasGoogleDocs,orvideoconferencingtool,suchasCanvasCollaborations,toworktogetherto“buildconsensusabouttheidealresponsethatrepresentsthegroup’sthinking.”
Givenonlyonemoduleoutofeightreflectedcollaboration,MEdTLinstructorswereaskedabouttheirviewsofonlinecollaborationduringtheirinterviewsandthemember-checkingmeeting.Therewasagreementbytheparticipantsthatcandidateswouldbenefitfromworkingtogetheronclassprojects,especiallysincethecandidatedemographicsreflectedarangeofbackgroundexperiencesandprofessionalsettings.Dr.Merrinnoted,“Mostofmyfacetofaceclasstimeiscollaborative.Candidatesturnandtalkallthetime,sharingideasandbuildingconsensus.”However,instructorsidentifiedtwochallengestoleveragingthecollaborativeaffordanceswithinthedigitalenvironment.
AsthefirstfullyonlineprogramintheSchoolofEducationthatservedasthesettingforthisstudy,theadministrationdeterminedcourseenrollmentswouldnotbelimitedinorderforittobefinanciallyviable.Thus,45-65candidateswereregisteredineachcourse.Toputthisinperspective,face-to-facegraduatecoursesatthisinstitutionweretypicallycappedat20candidates.Althoughtheyweredeeplyinvestedintheprogram,facultyvoicedconcernovermanaginglargenumbersofcandidates,especiallyinanonlineenvironmentwheretheyneededtorelyondigitaltoolstoscaffoldthecollaboration.
Thesecondchallengewastheshortdurationoftheonlinesemester.Eachthree-creditcourseranforsevenweeksyetcoveredthesameamountofcontentasintheregular14-weeksemester.Facultyfounditdifficulttointroducecandidatestocontent,providesituatedlearningactivities,assessunderstanding,andprovideopportunitiestocollaboratewithinsuchacondensedamountoftime.AsDr.Santosexplained,“Thereisalotofbackandforthbetweeninstructorandcandidate[inmyclass].SowithlargeenrollmentsI’mgoingtohave60somethingcandidatesthatIamgoingtohavetohelpwiththeirworkand
![Page 15: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 15
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
it’saseven-weeksemester.Ijustdon’tknowhowtodoit.”Insum,althoughCanvastoolsallowedforcollaborationtotakeplace,participantsreportedlychosenottoleveragethisaffordanceduetoprogramdesign.
Discussion
A Inthisstudywedidnotevaluatetheeffectivenessofthelearningactivitiesnorcandidates’engagementinthecourse,thereforewedonotpresumeanimpactonstudentlearning.Instead,wefocusonthreeinsightsthatcaninformrevisionstoourinstructionaldesign.
Findingsindicatedthewaylearningopportunitiesweredesignedinfluencedcandidates’useofmultimodality.Thiswasevidentinthatthemajorityofcandidateresponsesandclassinteractionswerecomposedwithwrittenlanguage,unlessdirectionsspecificallyrequiredtheuseofadifferentmode.Sincewedidnotinterviewcandidateswecannotsayforcertainwhytheyreliedmostlyontypedwords.Perhapstheywereunsure,unaware,ordisinterestedinrepresentingtheirknowledgewithmodesotherthanwords.Similarly,whenfacultyrequiredinteractivity,suchasrespondingtoclassmates’postsonthediscussionboards,candidatesengagedintheseactivities.Yet,whentheywerenotrequiredbutgivenspacetointeract,fewcandidatesdid.Overall,thesefindingstaughtusthatfacultymustcloselyexaminetheaffordancesofthedigitaltoolstheyintegrateintotheirinstruction,decideiftherearemodesorinteractionscandidateswouldbenefitfrom,andtheninvitecandidatestorepresenttheirknowledgeindifferentways.Activitiesshouldthenbestructuredaroundtheintegrationofthesedecisionswithclearandexplicitinstructions.Byrestructuringactivitiesintheseways,lessondesigncantransitiononlinecoursesfromisolatedspacestosocial,interactivelearningcommunities(Lee,2004).Additionally,instructorsshouldmodelhowtoleveragemultimodality,collaborationandinteractivitywithintheLMS.Thiswouldprovidecandidateswithconcreteexamplesfromwhichtheycouldlearn.Ofcourse,thisrequiresfacultytoinvestinprofessionaldevelopmentopportunitiesthatexplicatehowonlineteachingdiffersfromtraditionalfacetofacepedagogy.
FindingsalsoindicatedSLprecipitatedinteractivityinonlinecoursesbyprovidingconcretestartingpointsfordiscussions.SLencouragedcandidatestosharetheirindividualprofessionalstoriesandactivelyconnectthesestoriestocoursecontent.Interestingly,instructorsalsoleveragedmultimodalitytoinviteothersintothelearningexperiencethroughvideoandaudiorepresentations.ThisfindingtaughtusthatframingcoursesaroundSLwasagooddecision,butthatthetoolsforcollaborationarenotyetbeingoptimizedbycandidatesorinstructors,particularlyastheypertaintocommunicationfordiscussionusingmodesotherthantypedwords.
Accordingtofaculty,programlogisticsalsoseemedtoinfluenceinstructionaldesign.Facultyvoicedconcernswithintegratingcollaborativeprojectsduetoclasssizeandtheshortdurationofthesemester.Theseobstaclesreflectedtherealitiesofteachingonlineatthisuniversity.Theyalsohighlightedatensionbetweenresearch-basedteachingpracticesanduniversity-mandatedpolicies.Forexample,althoughtheyunderstoodtheimportanceofcollaboration,thefacultymostlyshiedawayfromgradedgroupactivitiesbecausethemanagementwastoocumbersome,especiallywhenclassenrollmentexceeded50
![Page 16: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 16
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
candidates.Thistensionisnotuniquetothisparticularsetting.Universitiesaroundtheworldareprioritizingstudent-centered,hands-onlearningopportunitiesoverrotememorization,yetnotprovidingfacultywiththeprofessionaldevelopmentorsupporttore-envisionclassroompractices(AdamsBeckeretal.,2017).Althoughthereisnoconsensusabouthowmanystudentsareoptimalinanonlinecourse,researchindicates“14%morehoursarerequiredtoteachthesamenumberofstudentsonlineatadistancethaninthetraditionalclassroom”(Tomei,2006,539).Asadministratorsmakeenrollmentdecisionsbasedonfinancialneeds,itiscriticaltoconsiderwhatcompromisesmustbemadetosustainthelevelofstudentenrollment.
Inlightofthesefindings,wesharepreliminarystepsweplantotaketoimproveourinstructionaldesign.First,weplantolobbyouradministrationforsmallclasssizes,whichwouldmakegradingcollaborativeprojectslessunwieldly.Second,weplantoencourageourcandidatestoleveragemultimodalityaffordedbythetechnology.Finally,wewillconductacoursemappingexerciseacrossallsevenmodulesfromalltencourses,wherewecollaborativelyidentifythefeaturesofourcourseassignmentsthatareaimedatpromotingcollaborationandconnectionstohighlycontextualizedlived-experiences.
LimitationsandFurtherResearch
Thisworkshouldbeviewedinrelationtothreelimitations.First,aprimarysourceofdatawascontentfromeightdifferentcoursemodules,onlyasubsetofinstructionalcontentwithineachcourse.Inturn,theremayhavebeencollaborativeand/orinteractiveopportunitiesthatwerenotexamined.Additionally,thismethodremovedtheactivitiesfromthecontextoftheentirecourse.Itwouldbeusefultoconductasystematicstudyofanentirecoursetoevaluatethefullgamutofactivities.Second,sincewefocusedonlearningopportunitiesandnotlearningoutcomesinthisspecificinquiry,candidatedatawerenotcollected.Priorresearchindicatesthatmuchcanbelearnedfromstudentperspectivesatanygradelevel(e.g.,Coiro&Dobler,2007;Jimenez&Meyer,2016).Suchanapproachinfuturestudieswouldinfusetheirimportantvoices.Third,weexaminedcoursesdesignedbyexpertsinthefieldofeducationforaparticulareducationprogram.Moreover,threeoutoffourparticipantshadexperiencedesigningfullyonlinecourses.Thus,theresultswilllikelydifferwhenexploringonlinelearningenvironmentsdesignedbyfacultywithexpertiseoutsidethefieldofeducationorwithlesstechnologyexperience.Conclusion
Accordingtothe2017NMCHorizonReportHigherEdEdition,“Technologyanddigitaltoolshavebecomeubiquitous,buttheycanbeineffectiveordangerouswhentheyarenotintegratedintothelearningprocessinmeaningfulways”(AdamsBeckeretal.,2017,p.7).Designingonlineinstruction,however,isacomplexanddemandingtaskthatwillnotoccurwithoutsystematicexplicitinstructioninthepedagogiesassociatedwithdigitalteaching.Wesuggesthighereducationfacultyengageinsimilartypesofprogramreviewasdescribedinthispaperandalsobegivenopportunitiestostrengthentheirunderstandingsofonlineinstructionaldesign.
![Page 17: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 17
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
AbouttheAuthors
RachelKarchmer-Klein,Ph.D.isanAssociateProfessorattheUniversityofDelawarewheresheteachesundergraduate,graduate,anddoctorallevelcoursesinliteracyandeducationaltechnology.HerresearchagendafocusesontherelationshipsbetweenInternettechnologiesandreadingandwriting,withparticularemphasisonthepracticalimplicationsoftechnologyuseinK-16education.Shetaughtherfirstonlinecoursein2003andnowcoordinatesandteachesintwofullyonlinegraduateprogramsineducation.Dr.Karchmer-Klein’sworkhasbeenpublishedinjournalssuchasReadingResearchQuarterly,ActioninTeacherEducation,JournalofDigitalLearninginTeacherEducation,andJournalofResearchonTechnologyinEducation.Email:[email protected]
ElizabethSoslau,Ph.D.isanAssociateProfessorintheSchoolofEducationattheUniversityofDelaware. Herresearchfocusesonthedevelopmentofadaptiveteachingexpertise,buildingintersubjectivitybetweenteachereducatorsandstudentteachers,andpromotingteachers’agencyandequityliteracy.Dr.Soslau’sworkhasbeenpublishedinjournalssuchastheJournalofTeacherEducation,TeachingandTeacherEducation, ActioninTeacherEducation,andEducationalActionResearch.Herclinicalworkincludescoordinatingthestudentteachingpracticum,providingfieldinstructioninurbanschools,andteachinggraduateandundergraduatecoursesindiversityandequity,aswellasactionresearchmethodsforteachers.AsapastmiddleschoolteacherwiththePhiladelphiaSchoolDistrict,sheremainscommittedtoinitiativesthatsupportuniversityandpubliceducationpartnerships.Email:[email protected]
JannMarieSutton,Ed.D.isaninstructionaldesignerwiththeCenterforInstructionandResearchTechnologyattheUniversityofNorthFloridawhereshecollaborateswithfacultytoidentifyandapplyrigorouspedagogicalconceptsandprinciplestoteachinginitiatives.ProjecthighlightsincludecultivatingpedagogicalstrategiesintheUnitedStates,SouthAfrica,Haiti,andBosniaandHerzegovina.Herresearchinterestsencompassexamininginstructionaldesignstrategies,investigatingonlineteachingactivitiesforlargeonlineclassesandgroupwork,andevaluatingdigitaltools.Dr.Sutton’sworkhasbeenpublishedintheJournalofManagementEducationandtheJournalofOnlineLearningandTeaching.Email:[email protected]
![Page 18: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 18
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ReferencesAdamsBecker,S.,Cummins,M.,Davis,A.,Freeman,A.,GlesingerHall,C.&Ananthanarayanan,V. (2017).NMCHorizonReport:2017HigherEducationEdition.Austin,Texas:TheNewMedia Consortium.Retrieved March6,2018fromhttps://www.learntechlib.org/p/174879/.Karchmer-Klein,R.,Mouza,C.,Shinas,V.,&Park,S.(2017).Patternsinteachers’instructionaldesign whenintegratingappsinmiddleschoolcontentareateaching.JournalofDigitalLearningin TeacherEducation,33(3),91-102.Beach,R.,C.M.Anson,L.A.K.Breuch,andT.Reynolds,T.2014.Understandingandcreatingdigital texts:Anactivity-basedapproach.Lanham,MD:Rowman&Littlefield.Beach,R.,&O'Brien,D.(2015).Fosteringstudents’scienceinquirythroughappaffordancesof multimodality,collaboration,interactivity,andconnectivity.Reading&WritingQuarterly, 31(2),119-134.doi:10.1080/10573569.2014.962200.Bloomberg,L.,&Volpe,M.(2008).Completingyourqualitativedissertation:Aroadmapfrom beginningtoend.ThousandOaks,CA:Sage.Brown,J.S.,Collins,A.&Duguid,D.(1989).Situatedlearningandthecultureoflearning. EducationalResearcher,18(1),32-42.Castek,J.,Beach,R.,Cotanch,H.,&Scott,J.(2014).Examiningmiddle-schoolstudents’usesofDiigo annotationstoengageincollaborativeargumentativewriting.InR.Anderson&C.Mims (Eds.),HandbookofresearchondigitaltoolsforwritinginstructioninK-12settings(pp.80– 101).Hershey,PA:IGIGlobal.Clarke,D.,&Hollingsworth,H.(2002).Elaboratingamodelofteacherprofessionalgrowth.Teaching andTeacherEducation,18(8),947-967.Coiro,J.,&Dobler,E.(2007).Exploringtheonlinereadingcomprehensionstrategiesusedbysixth- gradeskilledreaderstosearchforandlocateinformationontheInternet.ReadingResearch Quarterly,42(2),214-257.Eisner,E.(1998).Theenlightenedeye:Qualitativeinquiryandtheenhancementofeducational practice.UpperSaddleRiver,NJ:Merrill,PrenticeHall.Feiman-Nemser,S.(2012).Teachersaslearners.Cambridge,MA:HarvardEducationPress.Frisby,B.,Limperos,A.M.,Record,R.A.,Downs,E.,&Kercsmar,S.C.(2013).Students'perceptions ofsocialpresence:rhetoricalandrelationalgoalsacrossthreemediatedinstructional designs.JournalofOnlineTeachingandLearning,9,468-480.Guba,E.,&Lincoln,Y.(1981).Effectiveevaluation:Improvingtheusefulnessofevaluationresults throughresponsiveandnaturalisticapproaches.SanFrancisco,CA:Jossey-Bass.Henderson,M.&Phillips,M.(2015).Video-basedfeedbackonstudentassessment:Scarily personal.AustralasianJournalofEducationalTechnology,31(1),51-66.
![Page 19: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 19
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Herr,K.,andG.L.Anderson.(2005).TheActionResearchDissertation:AGuideforStudentsand Faculty.ThousandOaks,CA:Springer.Herrington,J.,&Oliver,R.(2000).Aninstructionaldesignframeworkforauthenticlearning Environments.”EducationalTechnologyResearchandDevelopment,48(3),23-48.Jimenez,L.M.,&Meyer,C.K.(2016).Firstimpressionsmatter:Navigatinggraphicnovelsutilizing linguistic,visual,andspatialresources.JournalofLiteracyResearch,48(4),423-447.Kalantzis,M.,Cope,B.,&Cloonan,A.(2010).AmultiliteraciesperspectiveontheNewLiteracies.In E.A.Baker(Ed.),TheNewLiteracies:MultiplePerspectivesonResearchandPractice(pp.61- 87).NewYork:GuilfordPress.Karpova,E.,Correia,A,&Baran,E.(2009).Learntouseandusetolearn:Technologyinvirtual collaborationexperience.InternetandHigherEducation,12,45-53.Kear,K.,Woodthorpe,J.,Robertson,S.&Hutchison,M.(2010).Fromforumstowikis:Perspectives ontoolsforcollaborations.InternetandHigherEducation,13,218-225.Kent,C.,Laslo,E.,&Rafaeli,S.(2016).Interactivityinonlinediscussionsandlearningoutcomes. Computers&Education,97,116-128.Ko,S.,&Rossen,S.(2017).TeachingOnline:APracticalGuide.NewYork:Routledge.Koedinger,K., Booth,J.L.&Klahr,D.(2013).Instructionalcomplexityandthesciencetoconstrainit. Science,(342)6161,935–937.Kroner,G.(2014)DoesyourLMSdothis?Retrievedfrom:http://edutechnica.com/2014/01/07/a- model-for-lms-evolution/LaPointe,D.K.,Greysen,K.R.B.,&Barrett,K.A.(2004).Speak2Me:UsingsynchronousaudioforESL teachinginTaiwan.TheInternationalReviewofResearchinOpenandDistanceLearning, 5(1).Lee,K.(2004).“Presence,explicated.”CommunicationTheory.14(1):27-50.Martin,F.&Parker,M.A.(2014).Useofsynchronousvirtualclassrooms:Why,Who,andHow? JournalofOnlineLearningandTeaching,10(2),192-210.Martin,F.,Wang,C.&Sadaf,A.(2018).Studentperceptionofhelpfulnessoffacilitationstrategies thatenhanceinstructorpresence,connectedness,engagementandlearningononline courses.InternetandHigherEducation,37,52-65.Melrose,M.(2001).Maximizingtherigorofactionresearch:Whywouldyouwantto?Howcould you?”FieldMethods,13(2),160-180.Moore,M.(Ed).(2013).Handbookofdistanceeducation.NewYork,NY:Routledge.
![Page 20: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 20
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Oztok,M.(2016).Culturalwaysofconstructingknowledge:theroleofidentifiesinonlinegroup discussions.”InternationalJournalofComputer-SupportedCollaborativeLearning,11(157), 157-186.doi:10.1007/s11412-0169233-7Patton,M.Q.(2015).Qualitativeresearch&evaluationmethods.(4thed).ThousandOaks,CA:Sage.Rienties,B.,Kaper,W.,Struyven,K.,Tempelaar,D.T.,VanGastel,L.,Vrancken,S.etal.(2012).A reviewoftheroleofinformationcommunicationtechnologyandcoursedesignin transitionaleducationpractices.InteractiveLearningEnvironments,20(6),563-581.Reushle,S.&Loch,B.(2008).Conductingatrialofwebconferencingsoftware:Why,Howand PerceptionsformtheCoalface.TurkishOnlineJournalofDistanceEducation9(3),19-28.Sullivan,D.,&Watson,S.(2015).Peerassessmentwithinhybridandonlinecourses:Students’views ofitspotentialandperformance.JournalofEducationalIssues,1(1).RetrievedMarch6, 2018from:https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1131766.pdfTeacherLeaderExploratoryConsortium.(2011).TeacherLeaderModelStandards.RetrievedMarch 4,2018from:http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/TeacherLeaderModelStandards2011.pdfTidwell,D.,Heston,M.,&Fitzgerald.L.(2009).ResearchMethodsfortheSelf-StudyofPractice,Vol. 9.Springer:NewYork.Toetenel,L.&Rienties,B.(2016).Analysing157learningdesignsusinglearninganalyticapproaches asameanstoevaluatetheimpactofpedagogicaldecisionmaking.BritishJournalof EducationalTechnology,47(5),981-992.Tomei,L.A.(2006).Theimpactofonlineteachingonfacultyload:Computingtheidealclasssizefor onlinecourses.JournalofTechnologyandTeacherEducation,14(3),531-541.Tracey,D.H.&Morrow,L.M.(2017).Lensesonreading:Anintroductiontotheoriesandmodels. (3rdedition).NewYork:GuilfordPress.Trentin,G.(2009),Usingawikitoevaluateindividualcontributiontoacollaborativelearningproject. JournalofComputerAssistedLearning,25,43–55.Vygotsky,L.S.(1978).Mindinsociety:Thedevelopmentofhigherpsychologicalprocesses Cambridge,Mass.:HarvardUniversityPress.West,J.&TurnerW.(2016).Enhancingtheassessmentexperience:improvingstudentperceptions, engagementandunderstandingusingonlinevideofeedback.InnovationsinEducationand TeachingInternational,53(4):400-410.doi:10.1080/14703297.2014.1003954
![Page 21: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 21
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
COMPARINGCOOPERATIVELEARNINGSTRATEGIESINASSESSMENTINSTRUCTIONJosephA.Mayo
GordonStateCollege
AbstractAsafollow-uptoapriorexploratoryinvestigationofcooperativelearninginteachingassessmenttoearly-childhood-educationmajors,thepresentstudysystematicallycomparesthepedagogicalefficacyoftwovariantsofcooperativelearning.Inthefirstcooperativelearningcondition,studentsreprisedthesimulatedclassroompracticeevidencedintheCooperativeAssessmentPortfolio(CAP)assignmentusedinthepreviousstudy.Inthesecondcondition,studentscompletedaCooperativeAssessmentCaseAnalysis(CACA)assignmentwithdistinguishingfeaturesofcase-basedlearning.Onallquantitativeandqualitativemeasures,resultsfavoredtheCAPoverCACAassignment.Findingsarediscussedinlightofsocialconstructivistpedagogyandfuturedirectionsforresearch.
Keywords:cooperativelearning,socialconstructivism,constructivistpedagogy,educationalassessment,earlychildhoodeducation,post-secondaryclassroomresearch,actionresearch
Introduction
Recentdecadeshavewitnessedanincreaseinactive-learningpedagogiesincollegeclassrooms(Fink,2004).Cooperativelearningcontinuestoholdaprominentplaceinthischangingclassroomlandscape(e.g.,Davidson&Major,2014;Gillies,2016;Healy,Doran,&McCutcheon,2018;Love,Dietrich,Fitzgerald,&Gordon,2014).Amongthemostresearchedofalltopicsintheteachingliterature,asignificantbodyofevidencesupportscooperativelearningasameansforstudentstooptimizetheirownlearningwhilefacilitatingtheacademicperformanceoftheirclassmates(Johnson,Johnson,&Holubec,2008).Asastructuredapplicationofcollaborativelearning,themeritsofcooperativelearningatthecollegelevelcanbeclassifiedundertwobroadcategories:academicandsocioemotional(Jones&Jones,2008).Morespecifically,cooperativelearningencourageshigher-orderreasoning,goal-setting,idea-generation,group-to-individuallearningtransfer,promotiveinteraction,positiveinterdependence,andinterpersonalcompetence(Johnson,Johnson,&Smith,2014;Mayo,2010;Williams,2007).Cooperativelearning,astheunderlyingpedagogicalbasisforthepresentstudy,haslongstandingtheoreticalrootswithintheconstructivisttradition.SocialinterdependencetheoryderivesfromtheconfluenceofKurtKoffka’s(1935/1999),KurtLewin’s(1935,1948),andMortonDeutsch’s(1949)shared
![Page 22: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 22
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
recognitionofgroupsasdynamicinitiatorsofvaryinglevelsofinterdependenceamongindividualgroupmembers.Vygotsky(1962/1986)builtuponthisperspectivewithhissocioculturaltheoryofdevelopment.AccordingtoVygotsky,thereisinterplaybetweencognitiveprocessesandsocialactivitiessuchthatsocialinteractionbecomesessentialtoactiveknowledgeconstructiononanintrapersonallevel.Inpractice,cooperativelearningbringstogetherthebasicelementsofthesetheoreticalstances.Groupsofstudentsworktogethertolearn,whileeachindividualbecomespersonallyaccountableforhisorherownlearningwithinthegroupcontext(Brame&Biel,2015).
LiteratureReview
BackgroundandPurposeofthePresentStudy.Inapriorexploratoryinvestigation,Iaskedgroupsofstudentstocompleteanend-of-semesterproject,calledtheCooperativeAssessmentPortfolio,injunior-levelassessmentclassesforearly-childhood-education(ECE)majors(Mayo,2013).ThestudyfocusedontheextenttowhichthisassignmentservedasaformativelearningtoolforECEcandidatesinsuccessfullydesigningteacher-developedstrategiesforassessingthelearningofyoungchildren.Students’performanceontheassignmentdemonstratedassessmentproficiencyasappliedtosimulatedclassroompractice.Moreover,students’surveyedperceptionstowardcompletingtheassignmentpointedtoitseffectivenessinbothpromotingmasteryofacademiccontentandfosteringproductivegroupinteraction.TheobservedsuccessoftheCooperativeAssessmentPortfoliointhispilotstudyservedasaspringboardformyundertakingthepresentinvestigation.
Thepurposeofthecurrentstudyistosystematicallycomparethepedagogicalefficacyoftwogroup-basedassignmentsusingcase-basedlearning(CBL):theCooperativeAssessmentPortfolio(CAP)examinedintheaforementionedpreliminaryinvestigationandtheCooperativeAssessmentCaseAnalysis(CACA).CBLtypicallyincorporatescollaborative-learningprocessesthatpermitstudentstosolveproblemsandreflectontheirexperiences(Hmelo-Silver,2004).TheprimarypurposeofCBListoteachstudentstoapplytheoreticalknowledge(Ching,2014).Inthecontextofteachereducation,themannerinwhichCBLaccomplishestheseintersectingeducationalaimscanbesummarizedasfollows:
[CBL]providesgenerativecontextsforprospectiveandcertifiedteacherstoworktogetherinsmallcollaborativegroups.Together,theyanalyzeproblems,discussoptions,andmakeinformeddecisionstosolveproblemsbasedonauthenticteachingsituationswithreal,multifacetedchallenges(DeSimone,2014,p.17).
Withinthegroup-centeredandapplied-theoreticalfocusofCBL,boththeCAPandCACAassignmentsareaimedatpermittingstudentsvariedopportunitiestodemonstrateaworkingunderstandingofthefactorsunderlyingwell-conceivedteacher-developedassessmentstrategies.WiththeCAPassignment,studentsengageinsimulatedclassroompracticebycreatingtheirownclassroomassessments.Incontrast,studentscompletingtheCACAassignmentcritiquealready-createdclassroomassessmentsasanexerciseinprofessionaldecision-making.
![Page 23: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 23
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
InspiteofCBL’swidespreaduseinteachereducation,therehasbeenrelativelylittlepublishedresearchonCBL-reliantinstructionalmethodologiesoroutcomesrelateddirectlytoteacherpreparation(Goeke,2008).Thepresentstudyaimstoaddtothisareaofresearch.Italsoseekstomakeanoriginalcontributiontotheteachereducationliteraturethroughsystematiccomparisonoftwocooperative-learningassignmentsintheframeworkofteachingECEassessment.
Methodology
Participants.Participantswere96ECEbaccalaureatecandidatesenrolledinfourequivalent-enrolledsectionsofajunior-levelcourseinECEassessmentforwhichIservedasinstructor.Classes,whichweretaughtatapublicstatecollegeinthesoutheasternUnitedStates,occurredinanacceleratedfour-weeksummersemester(twohoursofinstructionperday,fivedaysaweek).Twoclasssectionswereofferedineachoftwoconsecutivesummerterms.
Theparticipantpoolconsistedof87femalesand9males.Theracialdemographicwasapproximately85%Caucasian,13%African-American,and2%multiracial.Participantsrangedinagefrom21to43years(M=23.98).Roughly60%ofparticipantswerefirst-generationundergraduates,withnearlytwothirdsholdingafull-orpart-timejobwhileenrolledinthecourse.Allparticipantshadcompletedtwosemestersofclassroomfieldexperienceinpre-kindergartenthroughfifthgradebeforetakingthecourse.
Design.Iusedanindependent,two-group,quasi-experimentaldesigninwhichintactclasseswereassignedtooneoftwoconditions.Inoneconditionthattookplaceovertheinitialsummerofthestudy,50studentscompletedtheCAPinfulfillmentoftheirterm-lengthprojectrequirement.Inanothercondition,46studentscompletedtheCACAastheirterm-lengthprojectinthesecondsummeroftheinvestigation.Therewerenoappreciabledifferencesbetweenconditionsonthebasisofage,gender,orGPA.Additionally,Iheldcoursecontent,testingformat,andotherrelevantinstructionalvariablesconstantbetweenconditions.
CourseDescription.Thelearningobjectivesofthecoursewerebroadlyinclusiveasrelatestoearly-childhoodassessmenttopics;however,theprincipalfocusofthepresentstudywasstudents’understandinganddevelopmentofappropriatestrategiesforassessingthelearningofyoungchildrenfrompre-kindergartenthroughgradefive.Thisprimaryfocus—whichwascanvassedinboththeCAPandCACAassignments—includeddecidingaccuratelywhattoassessandhowtoassessit,withemphasisonthecognitivedomainoftherevisedversionofBloom’staxonomyofeducationalobjectives(Krathwohl,2002).Italsoencompassedthedetectionandpreventionofbiaswhenassessingchildrenwithspecialneedsandchildrenfromculturallyandlinguisticallydifferentbackgrounds.
Iadministeredaunitexamatmidtermineachofthetwoconditions.Thisexamcontained50conceptuallyappliedmultiple-choicequestionsfromthenon-principalfocalareasofthecourse,includingtheoriesembeddedinassessmentpractices,testvalidityandreliability,interpretingstandardizedtests,andapplyingpropertest-preparationpracticestowardhigh-
![Page 24: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 24
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
stakesstandardizedtesting.Attheconclusionofthesemester,Iadministeredasecondunitexamtostudentsineachconditionthatservedasthecurrentinvestigation’sdependentmeasureforcomparativestatisticaltesting.Thissecondexamalsoconsistedof50conceptuallyappliedmultiple-choicequestions,butthesequestionspertainedtothechieffocalpointsofthestudythatwereaddressedinboththeCAPandCACAassignments.Inordertominimizethepossibilityofexperimentereffectsincomposingthesecondexam,Iselectedallmultiple-choicequestionsfromconceptuallybasedtest-bankitems.Consistentwithconsiderationssurroundingbothtestsecurityandalternate-formreliability,Imatchedquestionsonbothcontentandlevelofdifficultyintheprocessofselectingitemsforinclusiononfourdifferent-but-comparableexamversions(oneforeachofthefourparticipatingclasssections).
InstructionalProcedures(CAPCondition).IntheCAPcondition,theinitialthreeweeksofthesemesterconsistedofin-depthclassroominstructionovertheentiregamutofassessmenttopics(bothprincipalandnon-principalfocalpointsasdescribedunderCourseDescription).Throughoutthefinalweekofthesemester,studentsworkedinclasswithinpre-assignedgroupsoffourorfiveindividualstocompletetheCAPassignmentwithslightproceduralmodificationsfromthepreviouspreliminaryinvestigation(Mayo,2013).Thesemodifications,whichincludedeliminatingaffectiveassessmentandplacinggreateremphasisonabsence-of-biasinassessment,werepredicatedlargelyoninstructivestudentfeedbackfrompriorsummativecourseevaluations.Onceassignedtotheircorrespondinggroups,studentsmetpreliminarilytoselectindividualstoserveintheflexibleandrotatingcapacitiesoffacilitator,recorder,andotherdefinedroles.
IncompletingtheCAPassignment,eachgroupselectedthegradelevel(s),subjectarea(s),andspecifictopic(s)toincorporateintotheportfolio.Eachgroupalsoestablishedacollaborativedivisionoflaborinwhicheachmemberwasexposedtoarepresentativesamplingofeveryassessmentstrategyoutlinedbelow:
1. selected-responseassessment[20binary-choice(true-false)items;10multiplebinary-choiceitemsintwosetsof5;20multiple-choiceitems;and10matchingquestionsintwosetsof5]
2. constructed-responseassessment(20short-answeritemsandtwodifferentessayitemswithanaccompanyinganalyticscoringrubricforeach)
3. performanceassessment(oneconceptmap,case-studyanalysis,analogicalreasoningproject,andautobiographicaland/orbiographicaljournalingassignment,withaconcomitantanalyticscoringrubricforeachassignment)
4. portfolioassessment(fivehypotheticalworksamplesrelatedtotargetedskillsand/orknowledgeforprospectivestudentstomaster,alongwithasingleanalyticrubriconwhichallworksamplescouldbescored)
Studentscomposedanswerkeysforallselected-responseandshort-answerconstructed-responseitems.Forconstructed-responseessays,performanceassessment,andtheportfolio-assessmentitems,studentsdesignedprototypicalresponsesuponwhichtheybasedtheirassociatedscoringrubrics.
![Page 25: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 25
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Alongwithdemonstratedmasteryofeachassessmentstrategy,theevaluativecriteriaforscoringeachgroup’sassignmentincludedanappliedunderstandingofBloom’staxonomy(knowledgeandcognitive-processdimensions)andabsence-of-biasinassessmentplusevidenceofacollaborativedivisionoflabor.Iratedstudentsonallevaluativecriteriaexceptforcollaborativedivisionoflabor,whichwasreservedsolelyforstudentsincorrespondinggroupstoevaluate.Onthedivision-of-laborscore,studentsineachgroupratedoneanotherintermsofindividualcontributionstothegroup(e.g.,effort,cooperation,anddedicationtoteamwork),withthegroup’saverageperpersonusedforindividualscoringpurposes.PeerratingsoccurredonaLikertscalerangingfrom1=unsatisfactoryto5=exceptional.Iaffordedadditionalopportunityforstudentstooffertheirevaluativecomments.Ikeptallpeerratingsanonymoustootherstudents.
TheCAPassignmentcountedforonethirdofthefinalcourseaverage.Incalculatingeachstudent’sgradeforthisassignment,Iweightedallofthefollowingeightevaluativecriteriaequallyincalculatingthecumulativegradeforeachstudent:(1)Bloom’sknowledgeandcognitive-processdimensionspercontentstandard;(2)absence-of-biasinassessment;(3)averagewithin-grouppeerratingperrespectivestudent;(4)selected-responseassessment;(5)constructed-responseassessment(shortanswer);(6)constructed-responseassessment(essay);(7)performanceassessment;and(8)portfolioassessment.Inassigninggradesforeachevaluativecriterion,Ireliedonanumerical-ratingsystemwithsimilaranchorsasthestudents’peerratings(1=unsatisfactoryto5=exceptional).Icollapsedallevaluativecriteriaontoagradingsummarysheet,whichalsoincludedspaceforaconcisesynopsisofmyevaluativecommentsandaschemeforconvertingrubricpoint-totalstograde-levelpercentages.Forclarification,Idistributedandreviewedthecontentofthissummarysheetduringthefirstclassmeeting.Oncegradingwascompleted,Ireturnedthesesheetstorespectivestudentsattheendofthesemester.
CACACondition.IntheCACAcondition,thefirstthreeweeksofthesemesterinvolvedthesameclassroominstructionasoccurringintheCAPcondition.SimilartotheCAPcondition,studentsworkedinclassduringthefinalweekofthesemester—inpre-assignedgroupsoffourorfive—tocompletetheCACAassignment.AsintheCAPcondition,studentsintheCACAconditionmetbrieflyaftergroupswereassignedtochooseindividualstoactinvariousflexibleandrotatingroleswithineachgroup.
IntheCACAcondition,Iaskedeachgrouptowritecritiquesofaseriesoffictitiousreferencecasesthatreflectedalloftheteacher-developedassessmentstrategiescanvassedintheCAPassignment:selected-response,constructed-response(shortanswer),constructed-response(essay),performance,andportfolioassessment.IncompletingtheCACAassignment,IalsorequiredstudentstoaddressthesameconsiderationsasthoseobservedintheCAPcondition,includingBloom’sknowledgeandcognitive-processdimensions,absence-of-biasinassessment,andacollaborativedivisionoflaborwithineachgroup.
Idesignedallcasesasnarrativeexperiential-learningexercisesbasedontheprincipalfocalpointsofassessmentcanvassedinthecourse.Casesoriginatedfromtwosources.Thefirstsourceinvolvedmyowninstructor-createdcasesthatincludedvarioustypesoferrorsinassessmentpractice.Thesecondsourcederivedfromappropriatelyreferencedadaptations
![Page 26: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 26
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ofcasescenariosappearingasappliedassessmentexerciseswithinleadingtextbooks,workbooks,andotherpublicationswithintherealmofeducationalassessment.Insomesituations,thesecasesalreadyincorporatedoneormoreerrorsthatstudentscouldidentifyanddiscussintheirCACAassignments.Inotherinstances,assessmentblunderswerenotpresent.Ineitherevent,Imodifiedcasecontent—rangingfrommoderatelyforerror-inclusivecasestoextensivelyforcorrectcaseapplications—suchthaterrorsofomissionand/orcommissionwereintroduced.Asimple,illustrativeexampleofaconstructed-response(shortanswer)itemforsecond-gradersappearsnext.Thislanguage-artsitem—whichincludesinitalicsabriefdiscussionoftheaccompanyingassessmenterror—isadaptedfromextended-applicationsexercisesappearingattheconclusionofPopham’s(2014)classroom-assessmenttextbook:
Theselettersareallvowels:A,E,O,andU.Whatistheonemissingvowel?____________
Althoughtheintendedcorrectansweris“I,”“Y”and“W”areoccasionallyacceptedasvowels.Therefore,thisitemviolatesoneofthebasictenetsofdevelopingsoundshort-answeritems,namely,theintendedcorrectresponsemustbeunique.
Iusedthesamepeer-andinstructor-ratingscalesandproceduresintheCACAconditionthathadbeenusedintheCAPcondition.IincorporatedallevaluativeinformationintothesamegradingsummarysheetthathadbeenutilizedintheCAPcondition.Onceagain,IdistributedandreviewedthisgradingsheetatthestartofthesemesterandthenreturnedittostudentsafterIhadcompletedgradingatthesemester’sconclusion.AswiththeCAPassignment,theCACAassignmentwasalsoworthonethirdofthefinalcourseaverage.
Results
ComparativeStatisticalTesting.Asdescribedinmethodology,thedependentmeasurewasstudents’scoresontheend-of-semesterunitexamthataddressedmaterialrelatedtothemajorcontentconcentrationsinthecourse(teacher-developedassessmentsinconjunctionwithbothBloom’staxonomyofthecognitivedomainandabsenceofbiasinassessment).ThemeansandstandarddeviationsforstudentscoresineachconditionareCACA(M=80.92,SD=10.36)andCAP(M=84.88,SD=8.65).Iusedindependent-groupst-testingtocomparestudentscoresintheCACAconditionwiththoseintheCAPcondition.ResultsshowthatstudentperformanceintheCAPlearningconditiondifferedsignificantlyfromperformanceintheCACAcondition,t(94)=2.04,p<.05.
QuestionnaireData.Igaugedstudents’perceptionsofcompletingcorrespondingassignmentsintheCACAandCAPAconditionswithananonymous10-itemquestionnairethatcombineda5-pointLikertratingscale(notatalleffective=1tohighlyeffective=5)withseveralquestionsaboutrespectiveassignmentstowhichstudentsrespondednarratively.Iaskedstudentstoratenumericallytheexperienceofcompletingtheassignmentinquestionintermsofhoweffectivelyitaccomplishedatotalof10educationalobjectives.Ialsoaskedstudentstocommentnarrativelyonwhattheylikedbestandleastabouttherespectiveassignments,alongwithwhethertheywouldrecommendthatassignmenttootherstudents.Students’numericalratingsareshowninTable1.
![Page 27: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 27
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Table1:Students’NumericalRatingsoftheCooperativeAssessmentCaseAnalysis(CACA)andCooperativeAssessmentPortfolio(CAP)Assignments
QuestionnaireItem MSD
CACA(n=46)
MSD
CAP(n=50)
Thinkingbeyondtheclassroom 3.83 .70
4.72 .61
Fosteringparticipationinlearning 3.66 .48
4.58 .42
Increasingpracticalrelevanceofinformation 3.74 .62
4.88 .31
Facilitatingunderstandingofcoursecontent 4.01 .39
4.56 .51
Increasingmotivationtolearn 3.45 .80
4.27 .54
Promotingintellectualchallenge 3.62 .53
4.44 .46
Stimulatinginterestinthesubjectmatter 3.36 .75
4.31 .49
Distinguishingbetweenvariedassessments 3.71 .43
4.67 .63
Recognizingtheimportanceofabsence-of-bias 3.50 .72
4.39 .58
ApplyingBloom’sTaxonomy(cognitivedomain) 3.55 .68
4.78 .42
Questionnaireratingscoincidedwiththeresultsofcomparativestatisticaltesting.StudentspreferredtheCAPtotheCACAassignmentacrossallsurveyedmeasures.Students’narrativecommentswerealsoconsistentwiththeirnumericalratings.Althoughapproximately60%ofrespondentsintheCACAconditioncommentedaboutthecooperativecase-analysisassignment’sgeneralutilityinbolsteringunderstandingofthetargetedcoursecontent,onlyabouthalfthatnumbersaidthattheywouldrecommendittootherstudents.Incontrast,morethan90%ofrespondentsintheCAPconditionassertedthattheywouldrecommendthecooperativeportfolioassignmenttootherstudents.InresponsetowhatstudentslikedbestabouttheCAPassignment,thevastmajoritystatedthatitprovidedvaluablehands-onexperiencethatshouldlaterbenefitthemintheirfutureteachingresponsibilities.Manyof
![Page 28: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 28
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
theserespondentsalsoremarkedthattheyhadneverrealizedhowmuchtimeandenergywentintocreatinggoodteacher-developedassessments.Notunexpectedly,themajorcriticismofbothassignmentswastheperceivedworkloadassociatedwiththeircompletion.StudentsintheCAPconditionvoicedthiscriticismmostoften;however,manyofthesesamerespondentsqualifiedtheirconcernbynotingthattheendproductwasbothpersonallygratifyingandworththeconcertedeffort.
Discussion
Withinthebroadcontextofunderstandingandapplyingvariedtypesofteacher-developedassessments,thepresentresultsshowthattheCACAassignmentdidnotcompareasfavorablyastheCAPcounterpartonthejointmeasuresofcomparativestatisticaltestingandanalysisofsurveyedattitudinaldata.Thecorereasonwhythisoccurredmightrelatetofundamentaldifferencesintheunderlyingfoundationsofthesetwotypesofcooperativelearning.
TheCACAandCAPassignmentsarevariantformsofsocialconstructivistpedagogy(Mayo,2010)thatencouragesmallgroupsofstudentstoworktogethertocreatesharedunderstanding.Inthesetypesofassignments,studentscollaboratetoproduce,notreproduceknowledge(Millis,2002).TheCACAassignmentalignswiththelongstandingtraditionofusingcase-basedlearninginnumerousundergraduatedisciplinesasameansoflinkingknowledgeandpracticethroughdevelopingstudents’criticalthinkingandappliedreasoningskills.(e.g.,Allchin,2013;Floyd&Bodur,2005;Heitzmann,2008;Kaddoura,2011;Mayo,2002,2004;Pariseau&Kezim,2007).BoththeCACAandCAPassignmentsqualifyasproblem-centeredapproachesthatadvocateforauthenticapplicationsofcoursecontentintheframeworkofactiveandinteractivelearning.Yettheseassignmentstakedifferingroutestotheseeducationaloutcomes.Asmentionedbrieflyintheliteraturereview,theCACAassignmentusescasestudiestointroducepracticalexamplesandanalogouscontextsforanalysis,critique,andvicariouslearningandpracticeinprofessionaldecision-making.Ontheotherhand,theCAPassignmentreliesonactualsimulatedclassroompracticethatoffersstudentsampleopportunitiestocreatetheirownassessmentstodemonstrateappliedunderstandingofsoundprinciplesoftestconstruction.Ofthetwoapproaches,then,theCAPismoreinherentlyactiveinpractice.Thisconclusionisnotonlysupportedbyrelatedpedagogicalfindingsinotheracademicdisciplines(e.g.,Jeffries,2005),butitalsoupheldinthepresentstudybystudents’perceptionsoftheCAPassignmentasfosteringdemonstrablygreaterparticipationinlearningthantheCACAassignment(seeTable1).
Conclusion
Overall,theresultsofthepresentstudyvalidatethemeritsofcooperativelearninginECEassessmentinstructionthatemphasizessimulatedclassroompracticeasavehicleforpromotingwhatHmeloandGuzdial(1996)describedmorethantwodecadesagoasknowledge-building-for-action.Additionalresearch,involvingassignmentssimilarinnaturebutperhapsdifferentinscopetotheterm-lengthCAPassignment,mightshowifthese
![Page 29: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 29
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
findingsalsoapplytoassessmentinstructioninmiddle-gradesorsecondaryeducationprograms.Anotherpotentiallyinvitingdirectionforfutureresearchonpre-servicestudents’assessmentinstructionmightinvolveasystematicexaminationofthepedagogicalefficacyofahybridcooperative-learningapproachthatintegrateskeyelementsofboththeCAPandCACAassignmentsfromthecurrentinvestigation.Asaproposedexample,studentsmightbeginwithcarefullyplannedcaseanalysesasawaytoscaffoldlearningexperiences(seeHmelo&Guzdial,1996)inpreparationforlatersimulatedclassroompractice.
AbouttheAuthor
JosephA.Mayo,Ed.D.iscurrentlyaProfessorofPsychologyatGordonStateCollegeinBarnesville,Georgia,whohasbeenteachingandconductingclassroom-centeredresearchinhighereducationforoverthreedecades.Hisprimaryresearchinterestiseffectiveundergraduateteachingstrategieswithanemphasisonconstructivistclassroomapplications.Heistherecipientofbothstatewideandnationalawardsforhisongoingcontributionstothescholarshipofteachingandlearning.Email:[email protected]
![Page 30: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 30
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ReferencesAllchin,D.(2013).Problem-andcase-basedlearninginscience:Anintroductiontodistinctions,values,and outcomes.TheAmericanSocietyforCellBiology:LifeSciences,12,364-372.Brame,C.J.,&Biel,R.(2015).Settingupandfacilitatinggroupwork:Usingcooperativelearninggroups effectively.Availableat:http://cft.vanderbilt.edu/guides-sub-pages/setting-up-and-facilitating-group- work-using-cooperative-learning-groups-effectively/.Ching,C.P.(2014).Linkingtheorytopractice.Acase-basedapproachinteachereducation.Socialand BehavioralSciences,123,280-288.Davidson,N.,&Major,C.H.(2014).Boundarycrossing:Cooperativelearning,collaborativelearning,and problem-basedlearning.JournalonExcellenceinCollegeTeaching,25,7-55.DeSimone,C.(2014).Problem-basedlearninginteachereducation:Trajectoriesofchange.International JournalofHumanitiesandSocialScience,4,17-29.Deutsch,M.(1949).Atheoryofcooperationandcompetition.HumanRelations,2,129–151.Fink,L.D.(2004).Beyondsmallgroups:Harnessingtheextraordinarypoweroflearning.InL.K.Michaelson,A. B.Knight,&L.D.Fink.Team-basedlearning:Atransformativeuseofsmallgroupsincollegeteaching (pp.3-26).Sterling,VA:StylusPublishing.Floyd,D.M.,&Bodur,Y.(2005).Usingcasestudyanalysisandcasewritingtostructureclinicalexperiencesina teachereducationprogram.TheEducationalForum,70,48-60.Gillies,R.M.(2016).Cooperativelearning:Reviewofresearchandpractice.AustralianJournalofTecher Education,41(3).Availableat:http://dx.doi.org/10.14221/ajte.2016v41n3.3Goeke,J.L.(2008).Apreliminaryinvestigationofprospectiveteachers’reasoningaboutcasestudieswith expertcommentary.TeacherEducationandSpecialEducation:TheJournaloftheTeacherEducation DivisionoftheCouncilforExceptionalChildren,31,21-35.Healy,M.,Doran,J.,&McCutcheon,M.(2018).Cooperativelearningoutcomesfromcumulativeexperiences ofgroupwork:Differencesinstudentperceptions.AccountingEducation,27(3),286-308.Heitzmann,R.(2008).Casestudyinstructioninteachereducation:Opportunitytodevelopstudents’critical thinking,schoolsmartsanddecisionmaking.Education,128,523-541.Hmelo,C.E.,&Guzdial,M.(1996).Ofblackandglassboxes:Scaffoldingforlearninganddoing.InD.C.Edelson &E.A.Domeshek(Eds.),ProceedingsofICLS96,AACE,Charlottesville,VA,pp.128–134.Hmelo-Silver,C.E.(2004).Problem-basedlearning:Whatandhowdostudentslearn?EducationalPsychology Review,16,235-266.Jeffries,P.R.(2005).Aframeworkfordesigning,implementing,andevaluatingsimulationsusedasteaching strategiesinnursing.NursingEducationPerspectives,26,96–103.Johnson,D.W.,Johnson,R.T.,&Holubec,E.J.(2008).Cooperationintheclassroom(8thed.).Edina,MN: InteractionBookCompany.Johnson,D.W.,Johnson,R.T.,andSmith,K.A.(2014).Cooperativelearning:Improvinguniversityinstructionby basingpracticeonvalidatedtheory.JournalonExcellenceinCollegeTeaching,25,85-118.
![Page 31: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 31
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Jones,K.A.,&Jones,J.L.(2008).Makingcooperativelearningworkinthecollegeclassroom:Anapplicationof the“fivepillars”ofcooperativelearningtopost-secondaryinstruction.JournalofEffectiveTeaching, 8,61-76.Kaddoura,M.A.(2011).Criticalthinkingskillsofnursingstudentsinlecture-basedteachingandcase-based learning,InternationalJournalfortheScholarshipofTeachingandLearning,5(2),Article20.Available at:http://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/ij-sotl/vol5/iss2/20Koffka,K.(1999).Principlesofgestaltpsychology.London:Routledge.(Originalworkpublished1935)Krathwohl,D.R.(2002).ArevisionofBloom’staxonomy:Anoverview.TheoryintoPractice,41,212-218.Lewin,K.(1935)Adynamictheoryofpersonality.NewYork:McGraw-Hill.Lewin,K.(1948)Resolvingsocialconflicts:Selectedpapersongroupdynamics.GW.Lewin(Ed.).NewYork: Harper&Row.Love,A.G.,Dietrich,A.,Fitzgerald,J.,&Gordon,D.(2014).Integratingcollaborativelearninginsideandoutside theclassroom.JournalonExcellenceinCollegeTeaching,25,177-196.Mayo,J.A.(2002).Case-basedinstruction:Atechniqueforincreasingconceptualapplicationinintroductory psychology.JournalofConstructivistPsychology,15,65-74.Mayo,J.A.(2004).Usingcase-basedinstructiontobridgethegapbetweentheoryandpracticeinpsychology ofadjustment.JournalofConstructivistPsychology,17,137-146.Mayo,J.A.(2010).Constructingundergraduatepsychologycurricula:Promotingauthenticlearningand assessmentintheteachingofpsychology.Washington,D.C.:AmericanPsychologicalAssociation.Mayo,J.A.(2013).Sociallyconstructedknowledge:Usingcooperativelearninginassessmentinstruction. PedagogyandtheHumanSciences,3(1),52-64.Available at:http://scolarworks.merrimack.edu8/phs/vol3/iss1/4Millis,B.J.(2002,October).Enhancinglearning—andmore!—throughcooperativelearning.Manhattan,KS:
TheIDEACenter.[IDEAPaperNo.38]Pariseau,S.E.&Kezim,B.(2007).Theeffectofusingcasestudiesinbusinessstatistics.JournalofEducationfor Business,83,27-31.Popham,W.J.(2014).Classroomassessment:Whatteachersneedtoknow(7thed.).UpperSaddleRiver,NJ: Pearson.Vygotsky,L.S.(1986).Thoughtandlanguage.Cambridge,MA:TheMITPress.(Originalworkpublished1962)Williams,R.B.(2007).Cooperativelearning:Astandardforhighachievement.ThousandOaks,CA:Corwin Press.
![Page 32: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 32
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
DOESMINDFULNESSSTRENGTHENSELF-EFFICACYINFIRSTGRADESTUDENTS?KirstenL.Logan
UniversityofRichmond
ErikK.Laursen
UniversityofRichmond
AbstractExternalandinternalstressorsofteninfluenceyoungchildren’ssenseofself-efficacyandresiliencynegatively.Practicingmindfulnesswithintheclassroommaybeoneinterventionthatcanhelpstudentsstrengthenthesocial-emotionalskillsinvolvedinself-efficacyandresiliency.Thisstudyusedamixedmethodsapproachtogatherquantitativeandqualitativedatafromsixfirst-gradestudentswhoparticipatedinadailymindfulnesspractice.Thedatawereanalyzedusingdescriptivestatisticstodetermineiftheirperceptionsofself-efficacyandresiliencyimprovedfromweekonetoweeksixofthestudy.Logico-inductivedataanalyseswereusedtoidentifycommonthemesinstudentinterviews.Studentsfavoredthemindfulnessactivitiesandsharedbenefitssuchasfeelingcalm,happy,andasenseofself-control.Thesix-weektimeframeandsmallsamplesizearepossiblelimitationsforthisresearchstudytoshowsignificantdifferencesthroughthequantitativedataanalysis.
Keywords:teacheractionresearch,mindfulness,resiliency,self-efficacy,social-emotionallearning
Introduction
DuringKirsten’stimeasateacher,shehadobservedthatherstudents’lowsenseofself-efficacyappearedtoimpedetheirlearning.Commonbehaviorsrelatedtolowself-efficacyincludealowlevelofperseverance,i.e.,situationsinwhichstudentsbecomeeasilyfrustratedbymistakesorunknownanswers,self-talkfocusingonstudents’inabilitytocompleteatask,andalackofestablishing,workingtoward,andreflectingongoalswithintheclassroom.Kirstennoticedthatthesebehaviorswereovertakingmuchofthecoreinstructionaltimeforherstudents.Agreatdealoftheschooldayfocusedonthesenegativebehaviorsandprovidinginterventionstoaddressthembeforeeffectivelearningcouldoccur.Kirstenwasthereforeinterestedinfindingwaystostrengthenherstudents’self-efficacybyinvestigatingthefollowingquestion:Doesmindfulnessstrengthenself-efficacyinfirstgradestudents?
![Page 33: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 33
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Thepurposeofthisstudywastoexploreiftheimplementationofdailymindfulnesspracticesintheclassroomhaveapositiveeffectonfirstgradestudents’self-efficacy.Overasix-weekperiod,allstudentsinKirsten’sclassroomparticipatedinmindfulnesspracticesduringthemorningmeetingtime.Datawerecollectedfromsixstudentswhoparticipatedinone-on-oneinterviewsandcompletedaquestionnairethreetimes;atthebeginning,midpoint,andendofthestudy.
LiteratureReview
Mindfulnessisgaininginfluenceineducationandabodyofresearchoutlinesthebenefitsofimplementingmindfulnesspracticesintoclassroomsettings(e.g.,Costello&Lawler,2014;Harpin,Rossi,Kim,&Swanson,2016;Moreno,2017).Studentsfacemanychallengesthatcompetefortheirattentionduringschoolhours.MalowandAustin(2016)observedthatstudentstressandanxietycontinuetorise.Asaresult,educatorsmusttakeonthecrucialroletoexplicitlyteachstudentshowtomanagestrongemotionsbeforetheyimpedetheirsuccess.Harpinetal.(2016)identifiedaneedforstudents,specificallywithinurbansettings,tostrengthentheirabilitiestocopewithadversityandtoimprovetheirfocustobemoresuccessfulinschool.
Mindfulnesspracticeisonestrategytosupportstudentsindealingwithstressandanxiety.Mindfulnessis“thecognitiveabilitytopayattentiontothepresentmomentwithoutjudgmentorattachmenttoadesiredoutcome”(Kelleretal.,2017,p.508).Studentscanutilizemindfulnessbytakingastructured,peaceful,reflectivetimetopracticekeepingtheirthoughtsinthepresent.Mindfulnessinvolvesthreeinterconnectingcomponentsthatincludeintention,attention,andattitude.GreasonandCashwell(2009)describedmindfulnessasastateofbeingattentivetoexperienceswithanattitudeofopennessandacceptance.Kielty,Gilligan,andStaton(2017)emphasizedthatmindfulnessisapracticeinwhichindividualsfocusonthecurrentexperiencesratherthanbeingon“auto-pilot.”Increasingacademicdemands,coupledwiththelackofcopingskillstodealwithexternalstressors,oftenleadstoaconstantstateofstressthatcreatesbarriersforstudentsuccess.
Theabilitytopracticemindfulnessinanopenandacceptingwayisnotaninnateskill.Educatorsmustfosteraninvitingenvironmentforstudentstopracticemindfulnessaswellasstrategicallyteachstudentshowtomanagestrongemotionsbeforethesestrongemotionsunderminetheiracademic,social,andbehavioralsuccess(Malow&Austin,2016).TheNationalScientificCouncilontheDevelopingChild(2015)statesthatadultsmustbuildcapabilitiesneededtomanagestresswithinchildren,includingtheabilitytofocusattention,problemsolve,plan,adjusttonewcircumstances,regulatebehavior,andcontrolimpulses.Whenstudentsparticipateinanenvironmentthatfostersmindfulness,thebarriersthatstandbetweenthemandtheiracademic,social,andbehavioralsuccessoftendiminish.
ResiliencyandSelf-Efficacy.Students’abilitytocontroltheiremotions,thoughts,andbehaviorsisessentialforsuccessinschoolandinlife(Thierryetal.,2016).Prolongedandunresolvedinternalandexternalstressinhibitsstudentsfromdevelopingastrongsenseof
![Page 34: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 34
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
self-efficacyandresiliency.However,mindfulnesscanbeutilizedtostrengthenbothareas.Social-emotionallearning(SEL)curriculumsfocusondevelopingtheabilitytorecognizeone’sownemotions,aswellastheemotionsofothers,whileprovidingthenecessaryskillstocommunicateemotionalunderstanding(Malow&Austin,2016).SELcurriculumsfostertheimplementationofmindfulnessandthedevelopmentofresiliencyinstudents.MalowandAustin(2016)definedresiliencyas,“thedegreetowhichanindividual’spersonalresourcesmatchorexceedtheirreactivitytointernalorexternalstress”(p.83).Self-efficacy,definedas,“one’sbeliefsorjudgmentabouthisorhercapabilities”(Greason&Cashwell,2009,p.3),isalsonurturedwithinSELcurriculums.
Self-efficacydevelopmentistheorizedtooccurthroughfourprimarysources,includingmasteryexperiences,vicariouslearning,verbalpersuasion,andchangesinemotionalarousal(Greason&Cashwell,2009).Mindfulnessisapracticethatcanbeusedintheclassroomwiththesefoursourcesofself-efficacydevelopmentinmind.Theopen-endednatureofmindfulnessallowsstudentstofeelasenseofmasteryintheirownuniqueway,whilecontinuouslylearningnewstrategiesandpractices.
Mindfulnessallowsstudentstorecognizetheadverseeffectsof“mindtraps”andoffersaperiodofreflection,stillness,andpeace(Costello&Lawler,2014).Mindtrapsarementalhabitsthatincreasestress,suchasnegativeself-talkinwhichchildrenarehardonthemselves.Thesehabitscanincludeself-criticizing,wherestudentsperceivethemselvestobeworthlessorinadequate(Costello&Lawler,2014).Mindfulnesspracticescanhelpstudentsovercomethenegativeinfluenceofmindtrapsontheirperceptionsofself-efficacyandresiliency.
Inadditiontoresiliencyandself-efficacy,self-regulationandemotionalawarenessarecriticalskillsforstudentstomastertoallowthemtolearnefficiently,workwellwithothers,anddecreaseanxietyanddepression(Kelleretal.,2017).Mindfulnesspromotestheseskillsthroughdirectinstructionandteachesstudentsstrategiestheycanindependentlyutilizewithintheirdailyroutines.Withdailypractice,mindfulnesscanpositivelysupportemotionalself-regulation,whichconsequentlyimprovesthelikelihoodofacademicsuccess(Kelleretal.,2017).
BrainDevelopmentandNeuroplasticity.Criticalperiodsinachild’sdevelopmentaretimesduringwhichpositiveexperiencescanprovideoptimalbraindevelopment.However,iftheseexperiencesareabsentorreplacedbynegativeexperiences,healthybraindevelopmentcanbedisrupted(Lally,2012).Earlychildhoodisacriticalperiodinwhichthebrainismalleableandeasilyshapedbythechild’senvironment.Knowingthatbraindevelopmentisshapedbyearlyexperiences,muchofwhatgetsinthewayoflearninginlateryearsistheresultofskillsthatwereunderdevelopedorneglectedinearlychildhood.Ifstudentsareexpectedtobesuccessfulinschool,teachersmustprovideexperiencesthatsupporthealthybraindevelopment.Lally(2012)describesexperience-createdexpectationsthatimpactbraindevelopmentas“brainshaping”experiences.Theseexperiencesfluctuate
![Page 35: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 35
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
greatlyfromstudenttostudentandcanpresentawidecollectionofvariablesthatinterferewithlearning,suchasstressorsorenvironmentalfactors.
Mindfulnesssupportsstudents’developmentofskillsthatarenecessaryforschoolsuccess.Stress-reducingpractices,suchasmindfulness,cancontributetopositivebraindevelopmentandfunctioningwhilealsoreducingtheexpressionofpro-inflammatorygenes(NationalScientificCouncilontheDevelopingChild,2015).Overtime,dailymindfulnesspracticescanleadtohealthybraindevelopmentinchildrenandfillinthe“gaps”thatmayexistinmanystudents.Mindfulnesspractices,inconjunctionwiththebrain’sneuroplasticity,allowchildrentocontinuouslydevelopandstrengthenskills,suchassustainedattention,focus,andcalmnessintheschoolsetting(Kieltyetal.,2017).Researchhasalsoshownthatmindfulnesscanstrengthenneuralsystemsthatsupportemotional,cognitive,andbehavioralregulation(Thierryetal.,2016).
Awarenessofbraindevelopmentallowseducatorstoplanactivitiesthatstrengthenunderdevelopedskillsandsupportstudentsforlearningandacademicsuccess.Forexample,childrenbenefitfromlearninghowtoslowdowntheirthinkingtogivetheirbraintimetooverridenegativeresponsestoshutdownoractout(Moreno,2017).Mindfulnessoffersstudentsstrategiestoslowdowntheirthinkingandgivesthemtimetoreflectandrespond,ratherthannegativelyreactingtostressfulevents.Moreno(2017)showedthatsix-year-oldchildrenwhoparticipatedinmindfulnesspracticestrengthenedtheircapacitytoslowdowntheirthinkingandreflect.Kieltyetal.(2017)demonstratedthepositiveinfluenceofmindfulnessformiddleschoolstudentswhowereaskedtopracticemindfulbreathingtocalmtheamygdalaand“freeup”thepre-frontalcortexbeforeengaginginhigh-stakestesting.
GrowthMindsetandPositivePsychology.Mindfulnessprovidesopportunitiesforstudentstocultivateandpracticeagrowthmindset.Apersonwithagrowthmindsetcanbedescribedasanindividualwhobelievestheirintelligenceandabilitiescanbecontinuouslydevelopedandenhanced(Kieltyetal.,2017).Bothmindfulnessandagrowthmindsetfosterapositiveattitudethatiscenteredonpracticeratherthanperfection.Theopennatureofmindfulnessallowsforfeedbackandopportunitiestopracticeovercomingadversityandsetbacks.Mindfulnessalsoenablesstudentswithanoptimisticattitudeandwithbasictrustduringtimesofuncertainty(Malow&Austin,2016).
Positivepsychologyis“employingstructuredinterventionstobuildresiliencywiththegoalofbufferingsymptomsofemotionaldysregulation”(Malow&Austin,2016,p.84).Mindfulnessisoneexampleofastructuredinterventiontosupportpositivepsychologicalfeelings.Mindfulnesscanalsoaidinalleviatingdistressthroughself-regulatoryprocesses,suchasmindfulbreathing.Cultivatingthepositivityandoptimismalongsidemindfulnessallowsforopportunitiesforgrowth.Moreno(2012)describedmindfulnessbeingrootedinthebeautyoffailure,wherestudentsworktorecognizethatratherthananendpoint,mindfulnessfocusesonrepeatedengagementwithacycleoffocus-lossandfocus-refocus.Withagrowthmindset,failurepresentsitselfasacontinuedopportunitytostartanew,
![Page 36: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 36
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ratherthanafixedstoppingpoint.Routhier-Martin,Roberts,andBlanch(2017)stressedthatthepurposeofmindfulnessisnotforstudentstoforgetorrepresstheirstressorsorweaknesses,butrathertoacknowledgetheseareasforimprovementandpracticetheabilitytofocusonschoolworkinstead.
Insummary,social-emotionallearningandbraindevelopmentarefoundationalbuildingblocksforstudentstosucceedinschoolandinlife.Earlyexperiences,whetherpositiveornegative,impactbraindevelopment.Thelackofpositiveexperiencesinearlychildhoodcanimpedestudentsuccessandcreateaneedforinterventionslaterinlife.Mindfulnesspracticesintheclassroomareonetypeofinterventionstrategythatcanprovidestudentswithskillstodevelopandcultivateresiliency,astrongersenseofself-efficacy,emotionalawareness,andself-regulation.Pairingmindfulnesswithagrowthmindsetallowsforanoptimisticoutlookforgrowthinallstudents,nomattertheirbackgroundorseverityofstressorspresentintheirlives.Educatorswhoestablishmindfulnessroutinesandprocedureshelpstudentsunderstandthattheirintelligenceismalleableratherthanfixedandcanprovidestudentswithtoolsandstrategiestoovercomeadversitywithintheclassroomenvironment.Inaddition,teacherswhopracticemindfulnessthemselvescanhelpnurturemindfulnesswithintheirstudents.
Methodology
Design.Thisstudyusedamixed-methodmethodologycollectingdatafromsixstudentsonaLikertscalestylequestionnaireandfrominterviews.Open-endedquestionsandfollowuppromptswereusedtoexplorestudents’perceptionsofself-efficacyandtheimpactofthemindfulnessintervention.Interviewswererecorded,transcribed,andanalyzedforcommonthemes.Allinterviewsandquestionnaireswerecompletedinaquietspotintheclassroom,awayfromotherstudents.
ParticipantsandProcedure.All15studentsinKirsten’sfirst-gradeclassroomparticipatedinguidedmindfulnesspracticesoverasix-weekperiodusingaudioandvideoclipsfromGoNoodle(n.d.)andCalm(n.d.).Sixstudents,threemalesandthreefemales,wereselectedtocompleteaten-itemquestionnaireandtobeinterviewedtoexploretheirperceptionsofself-efficacy.Thesurveyincludedtenquestionswiththreepossibleresponses,yes,sometimes,andno.Acompositescorewasgiventoeachofthequestionnairesbyconvertingthesmilefacetothreepoints,theneutralfacetotwopoints,andthefrowningfacetoonepoint,yieldingapossiblescoreforeachstudentbetween10and30points.Ascoreof30indicateahighlevelofself-efficacyandalowerscorealesserdegreeofself-efficacy.Kirstenselectedthesesixstudentsbecauseoftheiropennesstoengageinone-on-oneconversationswithher.
Thequestionnaireincludedtenquestionsaskingstudentstoreflectontheirperceptionsoftheirself-efficacyandresiliencyskills.Thestudentscompletedthequestionnaireatthebeginningofthestudy,atthemidpoint(weekthree),andattheendofthestudyaftersixweeks.Thethree-pointLikertscaleutilizedsymbolsforthefirstgradestudentstoeasily
![Page 37: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 37
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
answerthequestions:asmilefaceforyes,aneutralfaceforsometimes,andafrowningfaceforno(seeTable1).
Table1:StudentQuestionnaire
Yes
Sometimes
No
1Iworkhardinschool.
2IcannameatleastonethingIamgoodat.
3Itrymybestatschooleveryday.
4 Icansolvemostproblemsbymyself.
5 Icanfinishallmyschoolwork.
6 IcancalmmyselfdownwhenIamangryorfrustrated.
7 Ipayattentiontomyteacherinclass.
8 IaskforhelpwhenIneedit.
9 Ikeeptrying,evenwhenthingsgethardortough.
10Icanmakeagoalformyselftoworktowards.
Thequalitativedatawerecollectedthroughfouropen-endedinterviewquestionsandfollow-upquestionswereusedtoexpandonstudents’thinking.Theinterviewswereadministeredatthesamethreepointsthroughouttheresearchstudyasthequestionnaire.Theinterviewswererecorded,transcribed,andanalyzedforcommonthemesinstudentresponsesusingthelogico-inductiveprocess(Mertler,2019)tomakesenseofthenarrativedata.Theinterviewquestionsincludedthefollowing:
1. Whatisyourfavoritepartofdoingmindfulnessactivities?
2. Domindfulnessactivitiesmakeyoufeellikeyouhaveself-control?Ifyes,howso?
3. Whatmindfulnessstrategieshaveyouusedthroughouttheschoolday?
4. Whatfeelingsdoyoufeelwhenwedomindfulnessactivities?
![Page 38: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 38
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Results
Thesurveydatafromthequestionnairewassummarizedforthesixstudentsandthemeanandrangewereusedtocompareparticipants’answersbetweenthethreetimesthequestionnairewasadministered(Table2).Theresultsshowthattwostudentsincreasedtheirself-efficacyscoresoverthesixweeks,whilefourshowedadecrease.Themeanvariedslightlybetweenthethreesurveysandtherangebetweenstudentsdecreasedfromanine-pointrangewithinthefirstweektoafive-pointrangewithinthesixthweekofthestudy.Theresultssuggestthatthestudentsperceivedthemindfulnesspracticesfavorablywithameanscoreconsistentlyabove25,butdonotindicatethatstudentsincreasedtheirperceptionoverthesix-weekperiodoftheintervention.
Table2:StudentResponsestoQuestionnaire
Student Week1 Week3 Week6
M 30 28 26
E 21 25 26
H 29 29 30
K 28 21 26
A 26 26 25
L 25 24 25
Mean 26.5 25.5 26.3
Range 9 8 5
Aftertheinterviewsweretranscribed,commonstatementswerecoded.Usinglogico-inductiveanalysis(Mertler,2019)patternsandtrendswereidentifiedfromthestudentinterviews.Twopatternsemergedfromthestudentresponses.In15ofthe18interviewsstudentsidentifiedfeelingcalmafterparticipatinginamindfulnesspractice.Fiveofthesixstudentsfeltthatmindfulnesshelpedthemcalmdown.StudentHsaid,“they[themindfulnesspractices}calmmybodydown,”andStudentLfeltthat“ithelpsourbrainscalm.”Feelinghappyduringthemindfulnesspracticewasanotherpatterndiscoveredinten
![Page 39: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 39
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
interviewsasillustratedbyStudentL’scomment:“Itfeelslikeayummystrawberry.”Thefollowingtrendswerenotedfromacrossallinterviews,studentssharedthattheywereinterestedintryingthemindfulnessactivities.Fouroutofsixparticipantssaidthatmindfulnessactivitiesmadethemfeeltheyhadself-controlattheendofweekone.Attheendofweekthree,allstudentsreportedfeelingcalmwhenpracticingmindfulness,andfivestudentsreportedthattheactivitiesmadethemfeeltheyhadself-control.Attheendofweeksix,allstudentsreportedthatmindfulnessactivitiesprovidedthemwithasenseofself-control.Whenaskedwhatspecificidentifymindfulnessstrategiesstudentsusedthroughouttheschoolday,studentswereunabletoidentifyspecificstrategies.Insummary,studentswereeagertotryandwerereceptivetomindfulnessactivitiesandexpressedthattheyfeltastrongsenseofself-efficacyfollowingthemindfulnesspractices.
Thepurposeofthisstudywastoexploreifdailymindfulnesspracticesstrengthensself-efficacyinfirstgradestudents.Theresultsofthesurveysshowthatthesixstudentswhoparticipatedinthestudydidnotincreasetheirself-efficacyoverthesix-weekperiodofthestudy.However,intheinterviews,studentsexpressedthatmindfulnesspracticesmadethemhappyandhelpedthemcalmtheirbodiesandbrainsleadingtoasenseofself-control.Research(e.g.,Abdel-Khaleketal.,2014,Tahmasbipour,2017,Zakeretal.,2016),thoughnotdonewithelementarystudents,showastrongrelationshipbetweenhappinessandself-efficacy.Additionally,calmnessandself-controlareessentialelementsofself-efficacy.Insummary,theresultsofthestudentinterviewsshowthatstudentsexperiencedhappiness,calmness,andself-controlafterparticipatinginmindfulnesspractices,allessentialelementstodevelopingself-efficacy.
Discussion
Kirstenwaseagertoimplementmindfulnesswithinherfirst-gradeclassroom.Althoughshehadreceivednoformaltraininginmindfulnesspriortotheimplementationofthisstudy,sheresearchedbestpracticesandstrategiesthatwouldbeappropriateforherfirstgradestudents.Oneofthegreatesttakeawaysofhavingtheroleas“mindfulleader”forherstudentsisthepatienceherstudentsshowedintheclassroom.Shebeganthemindfulnessactivitieswithanopenmindset,whichallowedhertoguidethestudentsthroughthepracticeswithoutexpectingthatallstudentswouldreactinthesamemanner.Somestudentsshowedreluctancetoparticipateinthemindfulnessactivities,butwithhergrowthmindset,Kirstensawgrowthinallherstudentsduringthissix-weekperiod.Workingwithyoungerstudents,thepracticesweretakenmoreseriouslyandintentionallybytheendofthisstudybyallstudents.Studentsweremoreopenandwillingtosharetheirreflectionsduringthemorningmeetingtimeaswell.Theoverallcultureofthestudents’reflectivenaturewasonepositivebenefitthatKirstenobservedthroughoutthestudy.
Limitations
Thepresentstudyhasseverallimitations.Withasamplesizeofsixstudentsfromthesameschoolandreceivingmindfulnessactivitiesthroughthesamemethod,thefindingscannotbegeneralizedtoagreaterpopulation.Further,Kirsten’sdualroleasateacherandresearchermayhaveinfluencedthestudents’answersonthequestionnaires,despitebeing
![Page 40: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 40
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
madeawarethattheiranswerwasinnowaygoingtoinfluencetheiracademicgrade.Theshorttimeframeofthisstudymayalsolimitthestudybynotallowingstudentssufficienttimetopracticeandreflectontheimpactofmindfulnessactivities.Finally,askingsix-andseven-yearoldstudentstoreflectontheirperceptionsthroughthequestionnaireandinterviewquestionsmaynothavebeendevelopmentallyappropriateforallparticipants,e.g.,“Icanmakeagoalformyselftoworktowards.”
Implications
Thisstudyprovidedinsighttotherolemindfulnessactivitieshaveintheclassroomsetting.Studentswereeagerandwillingtoparticipateindailymindfulnessactivitiesandclassdiscussions.Werecommendthatteachersintroducemindfulnessactivitiesatthebeginningoftheschoolyear,pairingthemwithothersocial-emotionallearningconceptssuchasfosteringagrowthmindsetandcharacterstrengths(ViaInstituteonCharacter,n.d.).Implementingmindfulnessactivitiesisonestrategytohelpstudentsstrengthenself-efficacyandresiliency.
Teacherswhowishtoimplementmindfulnesspracticeswithintheclassroommustfosterandcreateanopenandinvitingclassroomcultureforstudentstopracticemindfulness.Theclassroomschedulemustallowforperiodsofcalmnessforstudentstopracticemeditationandreflection.Aspracticingmindfulnessandself-reflectionarenotinnateskills,especiallyforyoungstudents,werecommendthatteachersspendseveralweeksatthebeginningoftheschoolyearintroducingthetopicofbeingmindfulandfosteringagrowthmindset.Studentscanbeencouragedtoprogressattheirownpacethroughoutthemindfulnessjourney.Wealsorecommendedthatteacherssetasideatimeofdaytopracticeamindfulnessactivityfortheclass.Asstudentsgrowmorecomfortablewiththestrategieslearnedinthescheduledmindfulnessactivities,studentsshouldalsobegivenopportunitiestoapplythesestrategiesthroughouttheschoolday.Intentionalconversations(Laursen,2018)and“teachablemoments”shouldbeutilizedforstudentstoidentifyperiodsofthedayinwhichmindfulnesspracticescanbeutilized.Inelementarygrades,theteachercanserveasthemodelbyusinga“thinkingoutloud”modelinwhichtheteacherexplicitlydemonstratesaperiodofthedayinwhichamindfulnesspractice,suchasdeepbreathingorabodyscan,canbeusedintheclassroom.
Conclusion
Weencourageschoolleaderstoprovideteacherswhoarewillingandreadytotakeontheincorporationofmindfulnesspracticeswithprofessionaldevelopmentonbeinga“mindfulleader.”Thereareprofessionaldevelopmentworkshopsandonlineclassesthatcanbeutilizedforteacherstobecomefamiliarwithdifferentprogramsandmindfulnessactivities.Teacherswhopracticeandfamiliarizethemselveswithmindfulnessfirstwillhaveasmoothertransitionimplementingitwithintheirownclassroom.
Finally,wesuggestthatteachersreflectonstudents’perceptionsofmindfulnessactivitiesandtheimpactonstudents’self-efficacyandresiliency.Follow-upresearchonwaysto
![Page 41: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 41
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
measurestudentperceptionsofmindfulnesspracticesissuggestedtobestfittheagegroupofstudentswhoareparticipatinginmindfulnesspractices.
AbouttheAuthors
KirstenL.Logan,M.Ed.iscurrentlyafirstgradeteacherinVirginia.ShereceivedherundergraduatedegreefromAshlandUniversityinAshland,OhioinEarlyChildhoodEducationandhermaster’sdegreeinCurriculumandInstructionfromtheUniversityofRichmondinRichmond,Virginia.Herresearchinterestsincludegrowthmindset,mindfulness,positivebehaviorinterventions,andsocialemotionallearningcurricula.Email:[email protected]
ErikK.Laursen,Ph.D.isanAdjunctAssociateProfessorintheDepartmentofEducationattheUniversityofRichmond.Heteachestheactionresearchcourseandworkswithhisgraduatestudentstopublishtheresultsoftheirclassroom-basedprojects.Hisresearchinterestsareinpositiveeducation,caringrelationships,andcharacterstrengths.Healsoteacheseducatorsinyouthworkersintraumainformedpractices.Dr.LaursenreceivedhisdoctoraldegreefromVirginiaCommonwealthUniversity.Email: [email protected]
![Page 42: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 42
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ReferencesAbdel-Khalek,A.M.,ElNayal,M.(2014).Happinessanditsrelationwithself-efficacyamonguniversity
students.PaperpresentedatYouthandSocietyConference:KuwaitUniversity,Kuwait.Retrievedfromhttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/292318063_Happiness_and_its_relation_with_self-efficacy_among_university_students
Calm(n.d.).Retrievedfromhttp://www.calm.comCostello,E.,&Lawler,M.(2014).Anexploratorystudyoftheeffectsofmindfulnessonperceivedlevelsof
stressamongschool-childrenfromlowersocioeconomicbackgrounds.TheInternationalJournalofEmotionalEducation,6(2),21-39.Retrievedfromhttps://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1085614
GoNoodle(n.d.).Retrievedfromhttp://www.gonoodle.comGreason,P.B.,&Cashwell,C.S.(2009).Mindfulnessandcounselingself-efficacy:Themediatingroleof
attentionandempathy.AmericanCounselingAssociation,49,2-17.doi:10.1002/j.1556-6978.2009.tb00083
Harpin,S.B.,Rossi,A.,Kim,A.K.,&Swanson,L.M.(2016).Behavioralimpactsofamindfulnesspilot
interventionforelementaryschoolstudents.Education,137(2),149-156.Retrievedfromhttps://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1121526
Keller,J.,Ruthruff,E.,Keller,P.,Hoy,R.,Gaspelin,N.,&Bertolini,K.(2017).Yourbrainbecomesarainbow:
Perceptionsandtraitsof4th-gradersinaschool-basedmindfulnessintervention.JournalofResearchinChildhoodEducation,31(4),508-529.doi:10.1080/02568543.2017.1343212
Kielty,M.L.,Gilligan,T.D.,&Staton,A.R.(2017).Whole-schoolapproachestoincorporatingmindfulness-
basedinterventions:Supportingthecapacityforoptimalfunctioninginschoolsettings.JournalofResearchinChildhoodEducation,93(2),128-135.doi:10.1080/00094056.2017.1300491
Lally,J.R.(2012).Wantsuccessinschool?Startwithbabies!KappaDeltaPiRecord,48,10-16.doi:
10.1080/00228958.2012.654713Laursen,E.K.(2018).Intentionalresponsiveadultpractices:Supportingkidstonotonlyovercomeadversity,
buttothrive.Raleigh,NC:LuluPublishing.Malow,M.S.,&Austin,V.L.(2016).Mindfulnessforstudentsclassifiedwithemotional/behavioraldisorder.
InsightsintoLearningDisabilities,13(1),81-94.Retrievedfromhttps://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1103673.pdf
Mertler,C.A.(2019).Introductiontoeducationalresearch(2nded.).LosAngeles,CA:SagePublications.Moreno,A.J.(2017).Atheoreticallyandethicallygroundedapproachtomindfulnesspracticesintheprimary
grades.ChildhoodEducation,93(2),100-108.doi:10.1080/00094056.2017.1300487NationalScientificCouncilontheDevelopingChild.(2015).Supportiverelationshipsandactiveskill-building
strengthenthefoundationsofresilience:Workingpaper13.Retrievedfromhttp:/www.developingchild.harvard.edu
Routhier-Martin,K.,Roberts,S.K.,Blanch,N.(2017).Exploringmindfulnessandmeditationforthe
elementaryclassroom:Intersectionsacrosscurrentmultidisciplinaryresearch.ChildhoodEducation,93(2),168-175.doi:10.1080/00094056.2017.1300496
![Page 43: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 43
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Tahmasbipour,N.(2017).Predictingself-efficacybasedonhappinessamongShahidRajaeeTeacherTrainingUniversityStudents,Iran.WorldJournalofSocialScienceResearch4(2),122-128.Retrievedfromhttp://www.scholink.org/ojs/index.php/wjssr
Thierry,K.L.,Bryant,H.L.,Nobles,S.S.,Norris,K.S.(2016).Two-yearimpactofamindfulness-basedprogram
onpreschoolers’self-regulationandacademicperformance.EarlyEducationandDevelopment,27(6),805-821.doi:10.1080/10409289.2016.1141616
VIAInstituteonCharacter(n.d.).Retrievedfromhttp://www.viacharacter.org/www/ZakerA,DadsetanA,NasiriZ,Nasiri,Z.,Azimi,S.,Rahmana,F.(2016).Effectivenessofhappinessonself-
efficacyofstudents.ElectronicJournalofBiology,12(4).Retrievedfromhttp://ejbio.imedpub.com/effectiveness-of-happiness-on-selfefficacy-of-students.php?aid=9891
![Page 44: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 44
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
“LETTHEPEOPLESING!”–ACTIONRESEARCHEXPLORINGTEACHERS’MUSICALCONFIDENCEWHENENGAGINGLEARNERSIN‘SINGINGFORWELLBEING’DaphneRickson
NewZealandSchoolofMusic-TeKōkī ,VictoriaUniversityofWellington
JoAtkinson
MarshlandSchool
DianneReynolds
WaitākiriSchool
RobertLegg
HeadofMusic,IcknieldCommunityCollege,UnitedKingdom
AbstractTheexaminationandreconstructionofpersonalbeliefsandchangeinpracticethatcomeswithactionresearchcanbeintellectuallyandemotionallydemanding.Actionresearchexploringtheprocessof“singingforwellbeing,”ataChristchurchprimaryschoolseverelyaffectedbythe2010-2011earthquakes,uncoveredtheinterestingdichotomythatteacherswhowerepassionateaboutengagingchildreninsingingwereuncomfortablesingingthemselves.Acriticalactionresearchorientationgaveteachersimpetusandtimetodiscoverandreflectontheirpersonalhistories,toengagewithrelevantliterature,andtoexplorestrategiestoincreasetheirconfidencetoengageinmusicactivitieswithlearners.Learningthatmusicalconfidencecanbeseverelyaffectedbythenegativejudgementsofothers,andthatlackofteacherconfidenceintheartsiswidespread(Bainger,2010),validatedtheirexperiences,increasedtheirself-understanding,andenabledthemtosingwiththeirlearnerswithincreasingconfidence.Ourfindingsreinforcedthehypothesisthatunpackingnegativeexperiencescanbealmostasimportantinsomecasesasacquiringknowledgeandskillsinmusic.
Keywords:teacheractionresearch,teachers,musicalconfidence,singing,wellbeing
![Page 45: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 45
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Introduction
WaitākiriSchoolinChristchurchopenedin2014,aspartofthelargerrestructuringofChristchurchschoolsfollowingthe2010-2011earthquakes.Atthattime,ourteachersbegantoengagelearnersinsingingeverydaytodevelopandmaintainasenseofcommunity,andtopromoteenjoymentandreadinesstolearn.Despiteexperiencingsignificantongoingchallengesassociatedwithapost-earthquakeenvironment,well-beingandengagementdataindicatedthatlearnerscontinuedtofeelsafe,valuedandsupported.Membersoftheschoolcommunityjoineduniversityresearchersinanactionresearchprojecttoexaminethewaysinwhichthesingingwasfacilitatedandsustained,andtheperceivedrelationshipbetweensingingandwell-being.Wehavereportedthesefindingselsewhere(Rickson,Legg&Reynolds,2018;Rickson,Reynolds&Legg,2018),andinthispaperfocusononeaspectofourtwo-yearactionresearchproject;specifically,ourexplorationofteachers’self-efficacywithregardtosinging.
Theschoolhasbeendesignedtopromotecollaborativeteachinginflexiblelearningspaces.Itiscomprisedofsixlearningstudios;eachdesignedtocaterforapproximately115childrenworkingwith4-5teachersandonetotwolearningassistants.Ourteacher-researcherswerepassionateaboutsinging,stronglybelievedthatsingingwassupportingthewell-beingoflearnersinourschool,andwerecommittedtomaintainingdailysinginginthelearningstudios.Yetthedialogicactionresearchprocessallowedthemtorecognisethatdespitetheirpassionforengaginglearnersindailysinging,sixoftheeightwerenotconfidentsingersthemselves.Itseemedtheywereabletosuccessfullyfacilitatethedailysinging,despitehavinglowself-efficacywithregardtomusic,byconstructingacleardifferentiationbetween‘singingforwellbeing’and‘musiceducation’,andpromotingsingingforwell-beingasfunactivitywhichinvolvedfewexpectations(Rickson,Legg&Reynolds,2018).Engaginginwhatmightbedescribedasa‘spin-offcycle’(McNiff,1988)ouractionresearchtookacriticalturnaswebegantoexaminetheprocessesthatwereinhibitingteachers’abilitytosingingfreelywithlearnersintheclassroom,andelsewhere.
LiteratureReview
Singingcanbehelpfulnotonlyinfosteringindividualwellbeinginsingers,butalsoinunitinggroups(Ilari,Chen-Hafteck&Crawford,2013).Participatingingroupsingingleadstocommonpurpose,developingcohesionwithinagroupculture,throughacommonsetofattitudesandbehaviour(Drummond,2012,p.305).Thesynchronisationofbodiesandvoicestoapulse,alongwithsharedemotionalexpression,canbepowerfulinpromotinggroupbonding(Kirschner&Tomasello,2010;Sutherland,2015),andperformingwithotherscangiveparticipantsasenseoffulfilment,prideandaccomplishment(Sutherland,2015).
Thevocalisationsofbabiesandtheircaregiversismusical(Barrett,2005;Trevarthen,2002;Wiggins,2015),and‘singing’emergesininfancyandcontinuestodevelopaschildreninteractwithothersintheirenvironments(Ilarietal.,2013;Welch,2005).Fromthesongsofchildrenwecandeducethatmusical‘ability’isuniversal(Campbell,2010;Ilari,Chen-
![Page 46: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 46
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Hafteck&Crawford,2013)andthat,althoughweneedtotraininordertodevelopandexerciseourpotential,allpeoplehavethecapacitytobemusical(Lamont,2011).Thatis,wecanallenjoymusicthroughlistening,singing,andmoving,regardlessofwhetherwehavehadopportunitiestotakemusiclessons(Ilarietal.,2013;Thorn&Brasche,2015).Moreover,singingdoesnotrequiretheuseofexternalinstrumentsorhighlyspecialisedteachersandisthereforearelativelylowcostwayofengagingchildreninmusic(Lamont,Daubney&Spruce,2012).
Nevertheless,ourabilitytocontinuesingingbeyondpreschoolyearsisaffectedbyhowpeoplearoundusviewoursinging(Welch,2005).Ourviewofourmusicalselvesisbasedonourbeliefstakenfromsociety,andinordertorealizeourinbornmusicalabilitiesweneedtoestablishastrongmusicalidentitythatreinforcesabeliefthatwearemusical(Ilari,Chen-Hafteck&Crawford,2013).Culturalassociationsguideourthinkingaboutwhatwesoundlikewhensingingsoloorwithagroup,andwelearntoassessourselvesas‘good’or‘notsogood’singersinaccordingtooursocio-culturalcontexts(Ilari,Chen-Hafteck&Crawford,2013;Welch,2005).InWesternculturespeopleareoftenidentifiedas‘singers’or‘non-singers’andsinginginpublicisconsideredtobeaperformanceforthe‘talented’singer(Ilari,Chen-Hafteck&Crawford,2013;Welch,2005).Consequently,peoplewhosesingingdevelopmenthasbeenheldupinsomewayareoftencategorisedassomeonewho‘cannotsing’(Sloboda,Wise,&Peretz,2005)andastheygrowolder,manypeoplerefusetosinginanycircumstances,whileothersrefusetosingwheretheycanbeheard(West,2009).
Theviewsheldbysignificantothers,particularlymusicteachers,affectchildren’sself-conceptinpowerfulways(Abril,2007;Turton&Durrant,2002).Formativeexperienceswhicharenegativeordiscouragingcanhavelifelongdamagingeffects;includingthebeliefthatitistoolatetolearnmusicasanadult(Pitts,2015).Anumberofadultswhoarenolongermusicallyactivesuggesttheir‘lackoftalent’preventsthemfromengaginginmusic(Lamont,2011;Sloboda,Wise&Peretz,2005;Welch,2005)andmanyofthesepeoplealsoreportnegativeexperiencesatsomepointintheirchildhoodmusiceducation,suchasbeingtoldnottosingoutloudinprimaryschoolchoirs(Lamont,2011;Welch,2005).Lamontfoundthatnearly20%of530amateuradultmusic-makersfromaroundtheworldhadarelativelynegativemusicalidentitydespitethefactthattheywereactivelyinvolvedinmakingmusic(Lamont,2011).Singingisaverypersonalact(Ilari,Chen-Hafteck&Crawford,2013;Campbell,2010).Criticismofsingingabilitythereforeseemstohaveastrongerinfluenceonanindividual’sperceptionoftheirmusicalselfthancriticismofothermusicabilitiessuchasinstrumentalskills,becauseitfeelsmuchmorelikeapersonalattack(Swain&Bodkin-Allen,2014).Whenchildrenarelabelledasnon-singersitcanstigmatisethemforlifeandstopthemfromsinginginanycontext(Whidden,2008).
Teachersinclassrooms-eveninearlychildhoodsettings,wherechildrenareconstantlysinging–oftenlackconfidenceintheirownsingingabilities(Heyning,2011;Russell-Bowie,2009;Swain&Bodkin-Allen2017)andaremoreapprehensiveaboutteachingmusicthanmostotherschoolsubjects(Hargreaves,Lamont,Marshall,&Tarrant,2003;Heyning,2011;Russell-Bowie,2009;Thorn&Brasche,2015)becauseofthecomplexityofthedisciplineand
![Page 47: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 47
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
theirself-perceivedlackoftalentformusic(Thorn&Brasche,2015).Manyteachersstillbelievesingingisa‘gift’forthe‘talented’andthatonlymusicallytalentedpeoplecanteachmusicintheclassroom(Heyning,2011).Further,teacherswhomayhavelowself-efficacywithregardtosinging,arebattlingacrowdedcurriculum,arefeelingover-scrutinisedandlosingconfidence,andinourcasemanagingsignificantchallengesassociatedwithlivingandworkinginapost-earthquakeenvironment.
Ontheotherhand,teachersaregenerallymoreconfidenttosingwithchildrenthanwithadults,andwhentheyarepreparedtohaveagotheycanhaveapositiveexperience(ThornandBrasche,2015).Moreover,singingandothermusicalbehaviourscanimprovewithbothformalandinformalexperience(Sloboda,Wise,&Peretz,2005).Theincreasingpopularityofinclusivecommunitysinginggroupsforadultsforexample,maybebeginningtocountertheimpactthatnegativecriticismandjudgementhadonmanyadultsaschildren(Davidson2011;Lamont,2011).
Methodology
‘SingingforWell-being’wasatwo-yearActionResearch(AR)project,fundedbytheNewZealandgovernmentTeachingandLearningResearchInitiative(TLRI)andapprovedbyVictoriaUniversityofWellingtonhumanethicscommittee(Approval#22081).Actionresearchinthiscontextisasystematic,participatoryapproach,inwhicheducationpractitionersthemselvesaimtopromotepositivechangeintheirschoolcommunity(Hine&Lavery,2014;Mertler,2010).
Participants.Forthisparticularphaseofourproject,eightgeneralclassroomteachers,onespecialistmusicteacherandonekapahakatutor(KapahakaisthetermforMāoriperformingarts),collaboratedwithacoreresearchteaminvolvingtworesearchersfromVictoriaUniversityofWellingtonandtheDeputyPrincipalofWaitākiriSchool.
Method.Actionresearchisdynamicinnatureandisfrequentlydescribedasamessyorchaoticexperience(Nyanjom,2017;Mikkelsen2013).Researchersoftenbeginwithbroadquestionswhicharedevelopedandrefinedthroughcyclesofcriticalreflectionanddialogue,whichinturnleadtofurtheroralternativeaction(Cardno,2003).Eachcycleinvolvesplanning,acting,reflectinganddiscussingresults(Mertler,2010),whileengagingincontinuousexplorationoftherelevantliteraturewhichinforms,inspiresandclarifiesemergingfindings.Cyclesarenotlinear,butinvolvea“fluid,iterative,open,complex,andresponsiveprocess”(Cordeiro,Soares&Rittenmeyer,2017,p.397).Inaprocessofopendialogue,ideasthataretentativelyarticulatedinreflection,canbeexaminedmoresystematicallyinsubsequentphasesofactiveexploration.ActionResearchthereforeoffersopportunitiestodealwithanumberofproblemsatthesametimethroughthedevelopmentof‘spin-offcycles’(McNiff,1988).
Thispaperreportsonesuchphaseofourresearch,specificallyourexplorationofanearlyfindingthatdespitetheirpassionforsupportingchildrentosing,sixoutoftheeightclassroomteacherswhowereco-researchersonthisprojectwerenotconfidentsingersthemselves.Heyning(2011)arguesthatteacherswhoareconfidentandcompetentsingers
![Page 48: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 48
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
aremorelikelytoengagechildreninsinging,andtodoitsuccessfully.Yetatourschool,teacherswhoweredecidedlylackinginsingingconfidencewereabletointroduceandsustaindailysingingspecificallytoaddressthewell-beingofteachersandlearners.
ResearchQuestion.Weexaminedtheabovedichotomybysharingourpersonalhistories,engagingwiththeliterature,andcriticallyreflectingontheimpactofourvaluesandbeliefstoanswerthequestion“Whataretheprocessesthatareinhibitingteachers’abilitytosingingfreelywithlearnersintheclassroom,andelsewhere;andhowcansingingconfidencebeincreased.
Datagathering.Dataweredrawnfromtwosemi-structuredfocusgroupsinvolvingeightclassroomteachers,individualinterviewswithfourgeneralistteachersandtheschool’sspecialistmusicteacher,andengagementwiththeliterature.Focusgroupsandinterviewswereruninflexibleways,andinitialprompts/questionswerebroad(e.g.‘Canwetalkaboutourexperiencesoffacilitatingsingingintheclassroom?’)toallowparticipantstodiscussandtodeveloptheirownunderstandingofthingsthatwereimportanttothem(Liamputtong,2011).Itwascrucialtoallowparticipantstocontinuetalking,toshapethetopicandconversation,andtointroducesometimesunexpectedbutrelevantinformationthatwasmeaningfulandimportanttothem(Hesse-Biber&Leavy,2010).Thustheywereabletoproviderichdescriptionsoftheirexperiences,andtoacquirein-depthknowledgeaboutthethingsthattheyfeltwereimportant.Inthelaterfocusgroupandindividualinterviewswefocusedmoreonthechangeprocessusingpromptssuchas‘Tellmeaboutanychangesyouhavenoticedwithregardtoyourattitudeorimplementationofmusicwithyourlearners?’‘Howdidthosechangescomeabout?’‘Howimportantdoyouthinkthesechangesmightbeintermsofyourfuturethinking/developmentasteacherswhousemusicintheclassroom?’
DataAnalysis.Datawereanalysedbythefirstauthorusingaprocessofinductivethematicanalysis(Braun&Clarke,2013),andpeerreviewedbythefourthauthor.Theprocessinvolved:
• Transcribingtheaudiomaterialfromthefocusgroupsandinterviewsverbatim
• Returningmanuscriptstoparticipantsinvitingtheirchecking,editingandadditionalcomments
• Listeningtotheaudio,andreadingthetranscriptstobecomefamiliarwiththedata
• Identifyingrelevantchunksoftranscript,andgivingtheminitialcodes
• Transferringthechunksofdata,withinitialcodesinaseparatecolumn,toexcelsheets
• Combiningdatabycreatingamasterexcelsheet,andsortingaccordingtoinitialcodes
• Reviewingthecodes,andrenaming,combininganddevelopingnewcodes
• Sortingcodesintobroadcategories
• Examiningeachcategoryandapplyingsecondarycoding
• Sortingbysecondarycodes,anddevelopingdescriptionsofcodes
![Page 49: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 49
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
• Renaming,combininganddevelopingnewsecondarycodesasneeded
• Sortingaccordingtosecondarycodesandrevisingdescriptionstodevelopthemes(ideasgeneratedbyseveralparticipants),exceptions(ideasmentionedbyonlyoneperson),concepts(combinationsofideas),andstories(examplesfrompractice)
• Reproducingthemes,exceptionsandconceptsintheformoffindings
• Returningfindingstoparticipantsfortheircomment/editing.
ResultsandDiscussion
Acriticalactionresearchorientationisemployedwhentransformativeactionneedstobeprecededbycriticalthinkingandreflection(Kemmis,2014).Theprocessofexaminingpersonalexperiencesalongsidetheoriesreportedintheliteraturewascrucialtothepersonaltransformationthatteachersdescribed.Theparagraphsbelowthereforeincludeactionsandreflectionsinterspersedwithrelevantliterature.InitialProblem:Ifmusicisforeveryonewhydowefeelwearenotmusical?Webeganourresearchwiththeassumptionthatmusicalityisinnate.Teachersalreadyagreedthatmusicisforeveryone,notjustan‘elite’few,andthatsingingisan‘equalising’,‘accessible’andhighlymotivatingactivity.Welearntfromtheliteraturethatinfantsengageinmusicalinteractionwithcaregivers(Barrett,2005;Trevarthen,2002;Wiggins,2015);andyoungchildren,acrosscultures,engageinmusicalplay(Campbell,2010;Wiggins,2015).Childrenareinitiatorsofmusicalactivities(Burnard,2013),musicalideas(Wiggins,2007)andmusicalinnovations(Marsh,2009)andsingingisanatural,spontaneous,meansofcommunicationforthem(Bodkin-Allen,2009;Campbell,2010).Yetdespiteourunderstandingthatmusicianshipisinnate,sixofoureightgeneralclassroomteacher/researchersvariouslyclaimedtheywere‘notmusicians’,‘notmusical’,orthey‘couldn’tsing’.
Iwouldn’tknowifIwassinginganotecorrectlyornot.Idon’thavethatkindofear.Barbara,IndividualInterview
Action:Reflectingonone’sbeliefs.Jo,oneofourstudioteachers,recognisedshehadafearofsinging,whichstemmedfrombeingtold,"Youdon'tsingverywell",asachild.Shedescribedbecoming“frightenedofmusic”,“puttingupawall”anddeciding,“Rightthen!”,shewasnotgoingtodoitanymore.Atteacherscollege,shewasrequiredtolearntherecorderandguitar,andfeltshutdownevenfurtherbytutorswhoseemedtolackpassionfortheirsubject.Perhapsmoreimportantlysheexperiencedhermusicmoduleashighlyjudgemental.Shewasshockedwhenoneofhertutorstoldhernottosingbutto“humalong”towhatshedescribesasher"dreadfulmusicmaking".Ontheotherhand,Joadmitsthatsheenteredteacher'scollegealreadybelievingmusicwasanareashewasnotgoodat,andthatimprovementwouldbeunlikely.Yetsheloveslisteningtomusic,singinginprivate,dancing,andlisteningtochildrensinging.Sheevendescribedfeeling“desperatetosing"butstill“won’tlet(her)voicecomeout"ifotherpeoplearearound.
![Page 50: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 50
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Suetoo,suggestedshelovessingingand“singsloud,inprivate.”WhenwebeganourresearchSuedescribedfeeling“abitoutofmydepthhere”.Sheexplained:
Ilearntpianoasachild,butI’mjustprivatewithmusic.IhadareallybadexperienceactuallywhenItrainedinitiallyasakindergartenteacher.Weallsattogetherinonegroupandweallhadtosing–thenitwaspointedouttouseverythingthatwedidwrong.Andeversincethatpoint,whenIwasprobablyabout18-19,Idon’tsing–unlessI’msingingwithwholelotofotherpeople.…Irememberitall.Sue,focusgroupcontribution
Action:Professionaldevelopmentworkshops.Itwasclearthatourteacherswereenthusiasticaboutfacilitatingdailysingingforwell-being,yetmosthadlittleconfidenceintheirabilitytosingortoteachchildrentosing.Welearntthatpreserviceandprofessionaldevelopmentprogrammescanbesuccessfulinincreasingteachers’confidenceandcompetencetoteachmusic(Heyning,2010;Pascoe,2007;Russell-Bowie,2013;Sinclair,Watkins&Jeanerett,2015).Forexample,skillandconfidencecanbeenhancedwhenteachersareinvolvedinweeklyonehoursingingsessionswithchildren(Heyning;2010),staffsinginggroups(Nyland,Ferris&Deans;2010),andcollaborationwithmentors(Bainger,2010;Jeanerett&Stevens-Ballenger,2013).Ourteamthereforeagreedthatthefourthauthor,(auniversitylecturer,researcher,andmusiceducator)andthefirstauthor,(amusictherapylecturer)wouldfacilitateaworkshopwhichfocusedonparticipatoryvocal/movementactivitiesthatteachersmightbeabletofacilitateinthestudiolearningenvironments.Severalteachersfeltuncomfortableengagingintheexercisesthatwereoffered(asindicatedinquotesbelow),andrejectedtheofferoffurtherprofessionaldevelopmentofthistype.Othersbuiltonitbyattendingateachers’workshopinthecommunitythatthefourthauthorwasfacilitating.Overallhowever,‘directlearning’suchasthatofferedthroughtheworkshop,wasnotassuccessfulinsupportingourteachersastheprocessofdocumenting,examiningandreflectingonthewaysinwhichtheywereengagingchildreninmusicintheclassroom.
Theskilldevelopmentcomeswithenjoymentovertime.Aspartoftheresearchprocesswetriedsomeskill-basedexercisesthattookusbacktochildhoodexperiencesthatsomeofuswerenotreadyfor–weweretransportedtofeelingsthat“youcan’tdothis.”Howeverfromthispointintime–withoutanypressure–teachersdecidedtogivetheirchildrensomedifferentmusicalopportunities.Ateacherfromeachteamwenttoamusiceducationworkshop.Theyenjoyedthatopportunityandittoosowedalittleseedthattheywereabletogoawayandthinkabout.Eventuallyoneteamworkedwithagroupofboysonabodypercussionpiecethattheyperformed;anotheronadrummingpiece;andtheyhavegivenchildrenother‘new’musicalexperiencestoo.Theydidthatbecausethechildrenwerereallyinterestedandmotivated,andthechildrenandteachersalllearnt.Andwhiletheseactivitieswerefun,theywouldalsohavemadeanimportantcontributiontothechildren’smusiceducation.Dianna,individualinterview
![Page 51: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 51
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Action:Facingandchallengingfearsthroughacollaborativeprocessofcriticalreflection.JoandSue’shistoriesprovideconvincingevidencethatearlynegativeinteractionswithotherssignificantlyimpactedontheirsingingconfidence.Theirstoriesreinforcethebeliefthatlackofsingingconfidencecanberelatedtonegativeexperiencesinchildhoodoradolescence;includingpublichumiliationinfrontofclassmates,orbeingaskedtomouththewordsinsteadofsinging(Bainger,2009;Bodkin,1999;Swain&Bodkin-Allen,2014).However,theprocessofcriticallyreflectingontheirexperiencesenabledJoandSuetofaceandtochallengetheirfears.Jorecognisedthatlearnerswouldnotjudgehersingingasshemighthavepreviouslyanticipated.Shewasawarebeforewebeganourresearchthatshedidn’tsinginfrontofthechildren,butbelieveditwasn’taproblem.Theresearchprocesshelpedherre-evaluate.
"(Iwasthinkinginitially)‘don’tchangemyideas.ThisishowIhavetobe’.ButIfeellikeIhaveactuallyowneduptothatandthought,‘Ohactuallyyouareright’".Jo,interview
Asshebegantolookmorecloselyatherroleinfacilitatingsingingforwellbeing,Jobegantounderstandtheimportanceofmodellingwhatsheexpectsfromthechildren.Shehas“steppedoutofhercomfortzone”,to"behavedifferentlytowardthesinging…(andisnow)bouncingandsmilingandthepointingtothewords...inagoodway".Jobegantorecognisethatherloveofmusicanddancefreedhertoengagepassionatelyduringmusicactivitiesandwasdeterminedthatshewouldnotpassherfearofsingingontothechildren.“Ifelt(theresearchwastellingus)thatwecan’tbeagoodteachersofsingingifwefeelfrightenedofsingingourselves,infrontofacrowd.And,andIfeltquiteoffendedbythatattheendofthe(first)year.(But)Ithought‘Hangonaminute,Iloveboppingaround.That’smy'thing',youknow.AndIlovetosinginthecarbymyself.AndI’velearntthroughthisprocesshowtosinginfront(ofothers).AndI’llsinginfrontofthechildren.Jo,focusgroupcontributionAction:Drawingonthesupportofcolleagues.Joalsonoticedthatsomeofhercolleagueswhoalsofeltthey"don'tsingwell"continuedtosingwiththechildren.Thewaysinwhichmoreconfidentteachershavebeenmodelling'courage'andsupportingandmotivatingeachothertoleadandparticipateinsinging,hasincreasedJo’scomfortwithsinging.
Ithoughtworkingasateamwasimportant;because,Iwouldn’thaveenjoyeditasmuch,ifIwasparticipatingonmyowninmyownlittleclassroom.AndIthinkwatchingtheseguys(otherteachers)whoareobviouslymusical,andSueexpressingearlyonthatshewasn’tverycomfortablemademefeelalittlebitbetterthatIwasn’talone.AndthenIwatchedSuesteppingoutofhercomfortzone.AttheendoftheyearwedidaperformancewhichIdon’tthinkwewouldnormallyhavedone…anditwasfantastic.Jo,focusgroupcontribution
Johasbeguntodanceinthestudioswithotherstaff,whilechildrenaresinging,andthinksitisgreatfun.Sheisawarethatwhenchildrenseeteachersenjoyingthemselvestheysinglouderandtheylaughwhiletheyaresinging.Theenjoymentpromoteswellbeing.Joalsobelievedthehighernumberofchildreninlearningstudioenvironments,comparedwith
![Page 52: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 52
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
regularclassrooms,madeasignificantpositivedifferencetoherexperienceoffacilitatingsinging.
“Ifthesingingisnotveryloud,nobodysingsup.It'sjustreallyquiet,which(isn't)actuallythatenjoyable...(Ontheotherhand)theloudertheygettheloudertheygetandtheloudertheyget....Andthesoundof120children...blowsmeaway‘cosIlovetolistentochildrensing".Jo,individualinterview
ItispossiblethatJo’spreferenceforloudnessmighthavebeenrelatedtoherfearofbeingheard,andthe'safety'sheperceiveswhen‘hiding’inabiggroup.Shesuggestedwhenchildrenareinasmallergrouptheymightwanttosing,butfeelunabletobecause"(when)no-oneelseissinging...Ican’t.Ihavetogo".'Havingtogo'or'runningaway'seemstobeametaphorforJo’sfearofmusicandherchildhooddecisionthatshewasnotgoingtodoitanymore.Morerecently,Jotriedtolearnthedrumsfromanotherteacherbutstoppedbecauseshefeltshe"reallywasn'tverygood".
It’saslowprocessbecauseit’smyfeartootogetover.Istillwantthosechildrentosing.Iwouldneversortof,walkaroundasthough(it'snotagoodthing)thatpeoplewillhearyou.I’dneverputthatontochildren.Sodoeshowwefeelabout(our)singingimpactonthesingingandwellbeingofourchildren?Ithinkweplayarole.Ifwearefrightenedofsomethingweensurethatthosechildrenaren’t,youknow.Wetakemoreofadvancedthinkingtomakesurethatthey’renotfeelingthewayIdo....Alotofteachingislikethatisn’tit?You’vegotarolethatyou’replaying”.Jo,individualinterview
Action:Promotingpositiveparticipation.Teacherself-efficacyisdependentonbothconfidenceandcompetence.Teachers’beliefsabouttheircompetence,theirschoolcontext,andthepressurestheyexperiencewithregardtothecurriculum,aswellastheirbeliefsregardingthebenefitsoftheartsforlearners,canbehighlyinfluentialintheirabilitiestoteachmusiceffectively(Garvis&Pendegast,2010).Wehavealreadysuggestedthatwhatteachersbelieveabouttheircapacityforinitiatingandimplementingmusicalideascanunderpinorimpedetheirpotentialtoengageinfurthermusiceducation(Wiggins,2015).However,inourcase,whilesingingconfidenceandconfidencetoteachmusicwaslow,teacherswereextremelyconfidentintheirabilitiestosuccessfullyfacilitatesingingforwell-being,i.e.singingforfun.Thiswascrucial,becauseifanexperienceisperceivedtobesuccessful,self-efficacyisraised,andifitisperceivedtobeafailure,self-efficacyislowered(Garvis,Twigg&Pendegast,2011).Teachersalsostressedtheimportanceofchildrenbelievingtheycanbesuccessfulatsinginginordertogainasenseofachievement,andthemotivationtocontinue.Howevertheysuggested‘success’isaboutchildrenbeingabletoparticipateintheirownway(e.g.listening,moving,aswellasorinsteadofsinging).Theyarguedstronglythat‘technicalmusiclearning’wasnotappropriateinthecontextofsingingforwell-being;andthatsingingforwell-beingshouldnotbe‘taught’;ratheritshouldjustbe“purespontaneousenjoyment”(Rickson,Legg&Reynolds,2018).Thiswasimportantbecauseitcontributedtoagrowingbodyofknowledgethatsuggestswhenaimingforpsychosocialwell-being
![Page 53: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 53
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
benefits,activitiesthatfocusonexpressionandfunshouldbeencouragedtoenablelearnerstoexperiencemusicasengaging,enjoyableandusefulintermsofcommunicatingfeelings(Crooke&McFerran,2014).Ontheotherhandwealsoconcludedthatbyfocusingonpositiveparticipationratherthanskill-basedlearning,thepotentialexistsforsingingintheclassroomtocontributepositivelytobotheducationandwell-beingagendas(Rickson,Legg&Reynolds,2018),andthedevelopmentoflifelongmusicallearning(Higgins,2015).
IwasinachoirallthewaythroughprimaryschoolbutIactuallydon’tthinkofmyselfasaverygoodsinger.Idon’tthinkIsingintune,butthatdoesn’tstopmesingingbecauseIabsolutelyloveit!AndIdon’tthinkthat’sabadthing,infrontofthekids,ifyoucan’tsingthatwellthenit’salwaysgoodtoshowthat.Carmen,focusgroupcontribution
Thesinginghasofferedopportunitiesforallkidstobeinvolvedasactiveparticipants,themusicwedidattheendoflastyearwassimilarlygivingthosekidsago–thosewhomightnotnormallybeperceivedasbeingmusical,andgivingthemapurpose,makingitfun.Andthoughweweren’tteachingthemnotationandthosesortsofthings,Iwasusingmusicaltermslike4/4andtheywerelearningrhythmsandbeatssotheywerestilllearningthoseconceptsinafun,purposefulway.Matt,focusgroupcontribution
(Theresearchprocess)hasgrownmyappreciationofthemusicthatthekidsareinvolvedwith.…Toseetheenjoymentthey’vegotfromsomeofthoseoldersongs,andtheengagement,whereaswewouldbeinclinedtogowithwhatthekidschoosethinkingthatthat’swhat’sgoingtogivethemthemostenjoyment.Butit’snotactuallybeenthatwayandit’sbroadenedtheirmusicalappreciationaswell.…Whathelpedwasknowingtheprocessthattheywouldbegoingthrough,andthefeelingsthattheywouldgothrough.Soweworkedthroughthosethingsaswebecamemoreconfident.Sue,focusgroupcontribution
Ourexperiencesofhavingconversationsaroundsingingforwellbeing–justthepureenjoymentofit–gotmixedupwiththinkingthatmusiceducationiscompletelydifferent.Butweknowwecanenjoysingalongsandstilltakeopportunitiestoincreaseourenjoymentandwellbeingbytakingthesingingtoanotherlevelwithnewsongsthatwemightnotalwayssing,orwithaddingharmoniesandsoon.Wedon’tneedtojudgepeoplewhodon’tgotothatnextlevel,buttakingthoseopportunitiescanenhancethepositiveresponsesthatsingingcanevoke.Itmightbethedifferencebetweenhappinessand‘goosebumps’forexample.Dianna,individualinterview
Reflection:Understandingtheactionresearchprocess.Theemphasisourteachersputontakinga‘non-judgemental’and‘non-pressurizing’approachtosingingforwell-beingmightalsoberelatedtotheirpersonalexperiencesoffeelingpressurizedtosing,and/orbeingjudgedtobeinadequate.Peoplewholabelthemselves‘non-singers’areanxiousabout
![Page 54: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 54
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
singing,oftenresistitinfearofbeingjudged(Abril,2007;Ruddock&Leong,2005;Sloboda,2005).Moreover,Joarguedthatpeoplehavehighexpectationsofteachersgenerally;theyarealwaysbeing'judged',andjudgedontheperformanceofothers,and“cannotputatoeoutofline”.Sheistherefore“alwaysworriedaboutwhether(she)isgoodenough”.However,theactionresearchprocessenabledindividualteachersinourstudynotonlytograduallyunderstandvariousaspectsoftheirfacilitationofsinging,includingthewaysinwhichtheirhistorieshaveimpactedontheirrelationshipwithsinging,butalsotomakecontinuousprogressindevelopingtheirstrengthsasreflectivepractitioners.
Theactionresearchhasbeenenjoyableoverall,becauseithasallowedustohavethinkingtime,toheareachother’sstories,andtohearteachers’learning.Ithaspromptedpeopletosharepersonalexperiences,earlyexperiences,notjusttheirownexperiencesofteachingmusic.Andsomeofourconversationshavebeendifficult.Butwewereabletouncoversomelongheldbeliefsthatteacherswerecarryingaboutmusic,andthiswasimportant….ItwashelpfultoreflectonsomeofmyownmusicexperiencesatschoolandtorealisewhyIholdsomeofthebeliefsthatInowdonow.Forexample,InevergotintothechoirsathighschoolbecauseIwas‘nevergoodenough’,butIwantchildrentobeabletohavethatexperiencenow,soImakesurethatanyonecancomeandsingatchoir.Dianna,individualinterview
Josuggeststheactionresearchprocessenabledhertosingwithherlearnersbytakingacognitiveapproach(tellingherselfitwaspartofherprofessionalroletodothis),acknowledgingherloveofmusic,anddrawingonthesupport(particularlymodelling)ofcolleagues.Allmembersoftheschoolcommunitywerealreadyworkingtogethertoachieveacommonpurposeandteachershaddevelopedastrongcultureofcollaboration(Fullan,1999).Ourteachers’sharedcommunicationandreflectionontheirexperiencesenabledthemtosafelychallengetheirbeliefs,togainfurtherself-understanding,andtotakesmallstepstowardsimprovingtheirsingingconfidence,byallowingthemtoestablishalearningcommunityspecificallytoexaminetheirdailysingingpractices.
Whenwebeganouractionresearch,wewouldhavebeenmakingassumptionsaboutwhatteammemberswerethinkingandfeeling.Webegansingingbrainbreakswithaneurologicalfocus;knowingthatsingingwouldbesomethingthatwouldstimulateotherareasofthebrainandhelpchildrentobereadyforlearning.That’swhywedidwhatwedid.Theteamscameonboardbecausetheywereinterestedinthesinging,theycouldseethepositivebenefitsthatsinginghadforthechildren–butwithoutrealisinghowmuchself-reflectiontheywouldendupdoingthemselves.Duringthisprocess,wehavelookednotonlyathowwefacilitatethesinging,orteachmusic,butalsoatourselves–andthisismorethanwewouldhaveanticipatedwhenwestartedonthisjourney.Theactionresearchprocesshelpedustochange.Dianna,individualinterview
Changetakestimetoberealized,andworksbestwhenitisnotimposed(Makoelle,2014).Ourteachersalreadyhadsubstantialchangeimposedonthemasaresultofsignificantandtraumaticevents,andwewereawarethatwewereworkinginasensitivesettingwhich
![Page 55: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 55
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
demandedwetakecarenotcauseunnecessarydistress(Dickson-Swiftetal.,2008;Liamputtong&Ezzy,2005;Mutch,2015).Itwascrucialthattheybeallowedtothinkontheirownaboutchangeratherthanhavingchangeimposedonthem(Richardsetal.2001).AsJosuggest,“peopleneedgentleencouragementandsupportinordertoengagewithmusicintheirowntimeandattheirownpace”.Actionresearchdoesnotalwaysleadtodramaticchangesinpractice,orevenmakeasignificantcontributiontoabodyofknowledge.Rather,individualpracticesandpractitionersarechangedasparticipantsengageininquiryinwhichconnectionsaremade–throughcriticalreflection–betweenpersonalexperiences,theoryandtheirprofessionalpractice.Reflectingdeeplyissomethingteachersrarelyhaveregulartimefor.
Theactionresearchmadeusdoit.Wemighthaveslackenedoff-(Anotherteachercutsin:“Wehadtothinkaboutitmore”)-Yes,wehadtothinkaboutitmorebecausewewerepartofsomethingthatwasbiggerthanus,wedon’tlikelettingpeopledownsoweputourbestfootforward.Soitmadeusthinklaterallytoo.Sue,focusgroupcontribution
Bythinkingandlearningabouttheirclassroomsingingpractices,andthebeliefsandvaluesthatunderpinthem,ourteachersmayhavebecomemoreconfidentintheirabilitytoputtheoryintopracticeacrossawiderrangeofcurriculumactivities.Theyhavebeenchallengedtoexaminetheirownbeliefsandvalues,havebecomemorereflective,analytical,andcritical,andwillbeabletoexpandtheirknowledgeandskillsasresearchersandasempoweredprofessionalswhocanself-monitormoreeffectively,inanongoingway.
Teachersdonotwanttostagnate,wedon’twanttostandstill;wewanttochallengeourselvesallthetime.Butwe’vebeenthroughagreatdealofchangeatWaitākiriSchoolbothbeforeandduringtheperiodofthisresearch–includingdevelopingourcollaborativeteachingandlearningapproach.Someofthechangehasbeenexternallyimposed,andsomeofitwasinternallyimposed,aswellasteachersengaginginself-challenge.Makingandmaintainingpositiveconnectionswithothersinourschoolcommunityhasbeenextremelyimportant.Theresearchenabledustoconnectwiththosearoundusbecausewewereallsingingandworkingontheactionresearchtogether.Dianna,individualinterview
Conclusion
Thissinglecasestudyfocusesonaschoolwhereteacherschosetoengagelearnersindailysingingtosupporttheirwell-beinginatraumaticpost-earthquakeenvironment.Whilereflectingonthework,severalteachersrecognisedthattheywerepassionateaboutengagingchildreninsingingyetwereuncomfortablesingingthemselves.Anactionresearchprocessgavethemtimeandspacetoreflectontheirpersonalhistories,toconsiderhowtheirmusicalconfidencehadbeenaffectedbythenegativejudgementsofothers,andtorecognisethattheirexperienceswerenotunique.Inthiswaytheirexperiencesandfeelingswerevalidated.
![Page 56: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 56
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Thesuccessofteacherprofessionaldevelopmentdependsnotonlyontheirabilitytoreflectonanddeveloptheirconceptualizationsofknowledge,learningandteachingpractices(Thorn&Brasche,2015)butalsoontheirwillingnesstochallengeproblematicbeliefsanddevelopnewunderstandings(Nyberg,2015).Nyberggoesontosaythatresearchonprofessionaldevelopmentwithinartseducationhasfoundthatpractitionersarereluctanttoimplementchangesuggestednotonlybyauthoritiesandpolicymakersbutalsobypractitioners;andthatthoughtpatterns,aswellasbehaviour,needstochange(Neyberg,2015).However,examiningandreconstructingpersonalbeliefscanbeintellectuallyandemotionallydemanding.TeachersparticipatingintheSingingforWellbeingprojectdescribedjourneysoflistening,rebelling,gainingself-acceptanceandacceptancefromothers;andofwatching,listening,gainingconfidence,participating,increasingconfidenceandparticipatingfurther.Thustheydeemedtheworkworthwhile.
Thekeytoworthwhileteacher-conductedactionresearchrestsinthequestionsaddressedbytheprojectandtheextenttowhichtheresultsaremeaningfulandimportanttotheteachers-andnotnecessarilyinthemeansbywhichthoseresultsarerealized(Mertler,2010).Inourcasetheresearchprocesshelpedteachersgainadeepersenseofempathywithothersintheschoolcommunity,andtheywereabletousethisempathytosupportlearners.Theyfeltthattheresearchprocesssupportedtheireffortstocollaborateasthosewhoweremoreconfidentorcompetentwithparticularaspectsoftheprojectwereabletomodelandsupportothers;i.e.theylearntfromeachother.Mostimportantly,theircloseobservationsofchildrenlefttheminspiredbythewaysinwhichthelearnersmanagedthemselvesinextremelydifficultcircumstances,andhowsinging,alongwithphysicalmovementandhumour,appearedtosupporttheirwell-being.Wehaveincludedavideoputtogetherbylearnersandteacherswhichbringstogetherthesethreefactorsanddemonstrateshowtheysupportedwell-beinginourcommunity(https://youtu.be/GkOr7xq36EM).
Despitetheirlowself-efficacywithregardtosingingandteachingmusic,ourteacherswereabletoensurethatsingingprogrammesremainedaccessibleandenjoyable–and‘successful’inthewell-beingcontext.Ourfindingssuggestthatevenwithpoorself-efficacy,teachersareabletoengagelearnersinsingingbytakingthefocusawayfrommusiclearning.SimilarlyearlychildhoodteachersinSwain&Bodkin-Allen’s(2014)studywholackedconfidenceandconsideredthemselves‘tonedeaf’andunmusical,alsoreportedenjoyingorevenlovingsinging,andwerewillingtoparticipateinsingingactivities.However,whileourfindingssuggestthatunpackingnegativeexperiencescanbealmostasimportantinsomecasesasacquiringknowledgeandskillsinmusic(Bainger,2010)wewouldalsoarguethatmoreneedstobedonetoensurethatteachers–andindeedallpeople-areabletobeconfidentinusingtheirvoicestosing.
“Journeyingonawiderpathallowsustomovewithamorediversegroupoffellowtravellerswhoshapeourjourneyandwidenourperspectives”.
(Chapman,2015,p.27)
![Page 57: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 57
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Acknowledgements:
ThisresearchwasfundedbytheNewZealandGovernmentTeachingandLearningInitiative(TLRI).TheauthorsgratefullyacknowledgetheTLRI;theWaitākiriSchoolcommunity,particularlystaffandlearnersinKorimakoandTravisstudios;andProfessorKatrinaMcFerran,MelbourneConservatoriumofMusic,TheUniversityofMelbourne,forherhelpfulmentoringofthisproject.
AbouttheAuthors
DaphneRickson,Ph.D.,isaSeniorLecturerinmusictherapyattheNewZealandSchoolofMusic-TeKōkī,VictoriaUniversityofWellington.Asamusictherapypractitionershehasovertwentyyearsofexperienceworkingwithlearnerswhohavediverseneeds,inarangeofspecialschoolsandmainstreamsettings.Shehasparticularinterestandexperienceintheuseofcollaborativeresearchapproaches,includingparticipatoryactionresearch.Email:[email protected].
JoAtkinsonisanexperiencedclassroomteacher,andcurrentlyTeamLeader(KorimakoHub,Year5-6)atMarshlandSchool.Email:[email protected].
DiannaReynoldsisanexperiencedclassroomteacher,musicspecialist,andcurrentDeputyPrincipalatWaitākiriSchool.Email:[email protected].
RobertLegg,Ed.D.,studiedmusicandeducationatBristol,OxfordandDurhamuniversitiesintheUnitedKingdom,andatMcGillUniversityinCanada.Heplaysthecelloandthepiano,andisactiveasateacher,researcher,conductorandaccompanist.Hiswidelyperformedarrangementsandaward-winningoriginalcompositionsincludepart-songs,dramaticcantatasandcarols,aswellasmusicfororchestraandstringensembles.RoberthasworkedextensivelyinschoolsanduniversitiesinEngland,NewZealandandFrance.HisacademicwritingappearsinjournalssuchasMusicEducationResearch,PsychologyofMusic,ResearchinEducationandTheCurriculumJournalwhilehisbookchapters,journalismandreviewscanbefoundinmanyprofessionalperiodicals.Email:[email protected].
![Page 58: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 58
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ReferencesAbril,C.R.(2007)Ihaveavoice,butIjustcan’tsing:anarrativeinvestigationofsingingandsocialanxiety. MusicEducationResearch,9,1–15.Bainger,L.(2009).Howearlychildhoodteacherscandevelopconfidenceindoingmusic.InA.Power(Ed.), ProceedingsoftheJointConferenceofXXXIstANZARMEAnnualConferenceandtheIstConferenceof theMusicEducatorsResearchCenter(MERC)(pp.9–20).Melbourne,Australia:ANZARME.Bainger,L.(2010).Amusiccollaborationwithearlychildhoodteachers.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation. Vol2,pp.17-27Barrett,M.S.(2005).Musicalcommunicationandchildren’scommunitiesofmusicalpractice.InD.Miell,R. MacDonald&D.Hargreaves(Eds.),Musicalcommunication(pp.261–280).Oxford,UK:Oxford UniversityPress.Bodkin,S.(1999).Fromthepersonaltotheprofessional:Teachers’ownexperiencesofmusicandhowtheyI nfluencetheirclassroompractices.InM.S.Barrett,G.E.McPherson,&S.Smith(Eds.),Proceedings ChildrenandMusic:DevelopmentalPerspectivesInternationalMusicEducationResearchSymposium (pp.84–87).Launceston,Australia:UniversityofTasmania.Bodkin-Allen,S.(2009).Beingmusical.Teachers,music,andidentityinearlychildhoodeducationin Aotearoa/NewZealand.Deutschland,KG:LambertAcademicPublishing.Braun,V.,&Clarke,V.(2013).Successfulqualitativeresearch:Apracticalguideforbeginners.London:Sage. Burnard,P.(2013).Teachingmusiccreatively.InP.Burnard,A.Ruthmann,J.Biddulph,J.Wheeler,R. Murphy,M.Regina,K.Upitis,&B.Rena(Eds.),Teachingmusiccreatively.NewYork:Routledge.Campbell,P.S.(2010).Songsintheirheads:Musicanditsmeaninginchildren'slives(2nded.).NewYork: OxfordUniversityPress.Cardno,C.(2003).ActionResearch:ADevelopmentalApproach.Wellington:NewZealandCouncilfor EducationalResearch.Cordeiro,L.,Soares,C.B.,&Rittenmeyer,L.(2017).Unscramblingmethodandmethodologyinactionresearch traditions:theoreticalconceptualizationofpraxisandemancipation.QualitativeResearch,17(4),395– 407.https://doi.org/10.1177/1468794116674771Crooke,A.H.D.,&McFerran,K.S.(2014).Recommendationsfortheinvestigationanddeliveryofmusic programsaimedatachievingpsychosocialwellbeingbenefitsinmainstreamschools.Australian JournalofMusicEducation,1,15-37.Davidson,J.W.(2011).Musicalparticipation:Expectations,experiences,andoutcomes.InI.Deliege&J.W. Davidson(Eds.),Musicandthemind:EssaysinhonourofJohnSloboda(pp.65-87).Oxford:Oxford UniversityPress.Dickson-Swift,V.,James,E.L.,&Liamputtong,P.(2008).Undertakingsensitiveresearchinthehealthandsocial sciences:managingboundaries,emotionsandrisks.Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPressDrummond,J.(2012).Aninternationalperspectiveonmusiceducationforadults.InG.E.McPherson&G.F. Welch(Eds.),TheOxfordHandbookofMusicEducation(Vol.2).NewYork:OxfordUniversityPress.Fullan,M.(1999).Oneffectingchangeinartseducation.ArtsEducationPolicyReview,100(3),17-18.
![Page 59: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 59
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Garvis,S.&Lemon,N.(2013).AretheArtsimportantinschooling?Clearmessagesfromthevoicesofpre- servicegeneralistteachersinAustralia.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation.Vol2,98-104Garvis,S.&Pendegast,D.(2010).Middleyearsteachers’pastexperiencesofthearts”Implicationsforteacher education.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation.Vol2,pp.28-40Garvis,S.,Twigg,D.,Pendegast,D.(2011).Breakingthenegativecycle.Theformationofself-efficacybeliefsin thearts.Afocusonprofessionalexperienceinpre-serviceteachereducation.AustralasianJournalof EarlyChildhood.36(2)pp.36-41Gembris,H.(2012).Chapter25:Music-makingasalifelongdevelopmentandresourceforhealth.InR.A. MacDonald,G.Kreutz,&L.Mitchell(Eds.),Music,health,andwellbeing.Oxford:OxfordUniversity Press.Goldberg,M.(2012).Artsintegration:Teachingsubjectmatterthroughtheartsinmulticulturalsettings(4th ed.).Boston,MA:Pearson/AllynandBacon.Grape,C.,Sandgren,M.,Hansson,L.-O.,Ericson,M.,&Theorell,T.(2003).Doessingingpromotewell-being? Anempiricalstudyofprofessionalandamateursingersduringasinginglesson.Integrative PhysiologicalandBehavioralScience,3865-74.Hargreaves,D.J.,Lamont,A.,Marshall,N.,Tarrant,M.(2003)YoungPeople’sMusicInandOutofSchool:A StudyofPupilsandTeachersinPrimaryandSecondarySchools.London:QualificationsandCurriculum AuthorityResearchReport.Hesse-Biber,S.N.,&Leavy,P.(2010).Thepracticeofqualitativeresearch,2ndedition.ThousandOaks, CA:Sage.Heyning,L.(2010).Theenhancementofmusicalandotherlearningforbothteachersandstudentsthrougha weeklychoirsession.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation.Vol1,pp58-70.Heyning,L.(2011)."Ican'tsing!"Theconceptofteacherconfidenceinsingingandtheusewithintheirclassroom.InternationalJournalofEducationandtheArts,12(13),Onlineathttp://www.ijea.org/.Higgins,L.(2015).Myvoiceisimportanttoo:Non-formalmusicexperiencesandyoungpeople.InG.E. McPherson(Ed.),TheChildasMusician:Ahandbookofmusicaldevelopment:OxfordScholarship Online.Hine,G.S.,&Lavery,S.D.(2014).Actionresearch:Informingprofessionalpracticewithinschools.Issuesin EducationalResearch,24(2),2014.Hinshaw,T.,Clift,S.,Hulbert,S.,&Camic,P.M.(2015).Groupsingingandyoungpeople'spsychologicalwell- being.InternationalJournalofMentalHealthPromotion,17(1),46-63. doi:10.1080/14623730.2014.999454Hylton,J.B.(1981).Dimensionalityinhighschoolstudentparticipants’perceptionsofthemeaningofchoral singingexperience.JournalofResearchinMusicEducation,29,287-296.Ilari,B.,Chen-Hafteck,L.,&Crawford,L.(2013).Singingandculturalunderstanding:Amusiceducation perspective.InternationalJournalofMusicEducation,31,202-216.Jeanerette,N.&Stevens-Ballenger,J.(2013).Thegeneralistandthespecialist:serendipityinpreservice education.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation.Vol1,64-75
![Page 60: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 60
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Joseph,D.&Trinnick,R.(2016).PromotingculturalunderstandingsthroughsongacrosstheTasman:pre- serviceprimaryteachereducation.InterculturalEducation.27(2),201-215.Kemmis,S.,McTaggart,R.,&Nixon,R.(2014).Theactionresearchplanner:Doingcriticalparticipatoryaction research.Singapore:Springer.Kirschner,&Tomasello.(2010).Jointmusicmakingpromotesprosocialbehaviorin4-year-oldchildren. EvolutionandHumanBehavior,31(5),354-364.Kirsh,E.,vanLeer,E.,Phero,H.,Xie,C.,&Khosla,S.(2013).Factorsassociatedwithsingers'perceptionsof choralsingingwell-being.JournalofVoice,27(6),786.Lamont,A.2011.Thebeatgoeson:Musiceducation,identityandlifelonglearning.MusicEducationResearch, 13,369-388.Lamont,A.,Daubney,A.,Spruce,G.(2012).Singinginprimaryschools:Casestudiesofgoodpracticeinwhole classvocaltuition.BritishJournalofMusicEducation,29,261-268.Liamputtong,P.(2011).Focusgroupmethodology:Principlesandpractice.London,:SAGEPublicationsLtddoi: 10.4135/9781473957657.Liamputtong,P.,&Ezzy,D.(2005).Qualitativeresearchmethods(2nded.).SouthMelbourne,Vic.;NewYork: OxfordUniversityPress.Makoelle,T.M.(2014).Inclusionandexclusion.Ruralteachersandlearners'experiences:Casesinthefree-s tateprovince.Anthropologist,18(3),1097-1104.Marsh,K.(2009).Themusicalplayground:Globaltraditionandchangeinchildren'ssongsandgames.UK: OxfordScholarshipOnline.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195308983.001.0001Mertler,C.A.(2010).ActionResearch:Improvingschoolsandempoweringeducators.KindleEdition:SAGE Publications.Mutch,C.(2015).Quietheroes:TeachersandtheCanterbury,NewZealand,earthquakes.AustralasianJournal ofDisasterandTraumaStudies,19(2).McNiff,J.(1988).ActionResearch:PrinciplesandPractice.Hampshire:McMillanEducationLtd.Mikkelsen,E.N.2013.“AResearcher’sTale:HowDoingConflictResearchShapesResearchaboutConflict.” QualitativeResearchinOrganizationsandManagement:AnInternationalJournal8(1):33–49. doi:10.1108/17465641311327504.Nyanjom,J.(2018).Cycleswithincycles:instillingstructureintoamentoringself-studyactionresearchproject, EducationalActionResearch,26:4,626-640,DOI:10.1080/09650792.2017.1386116Nyberg,J.(2015).Youareseldombornwithadrumkitinyourhands:Musicteachers'conceptualisationsof knowledgeandlearningwithinmusiceducationasanassessmentpractice.SystematicPracticein ActionResearch,29,235-259.doi:10.1007/s11213-015-9362-3Nyland,B.,Ferris,J.,&Deans,J.(2010).Youngchildrenandmusic:Adultsconstructingmeaningthrougha performanceforchildren.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation.Vol2,pp.5-16.Pascoe.R.(2007).Harmonisingorhomogenisingartsandeducation?PerspectivesontheartsinAustralian schoolsoutsideinandinsideout.JournalofArtisticandCreativeEducation,1(1),255.
![Page 61: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 61
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Pitts,S.E.(2015).Fosteringlifelongengagementinmusic.InG.E.McPherson(Ed.),TheChildasMusician:A handbookofmusicaldevelopment(2nded.).Oxford,UK:OxfordUniversityPress.Power,A.2014.MusiceducationresearchinAustralia2012-14.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation,2,184- 195.RichardsJC,GalloPB,RenandyaWA2001.Exploringteachers’beliefsandtheprocessofchange.PACJournal, 1(1):41–48.Rickard,N.S.,Bambrick,C.J.,&Anneliese,G.(2012).Absenceofwidespreadpsychosocialandcognitive effectsofschool-basedmusicinstructionin10-13-year-oldstudents.InternationalJournalofMusic Education,30(1),57-78.Rickson,D.,Legg,R.,&Reynolds,D.(2018).Dailysinginginaschoolseverelyaffectedbyearthquakes: Potentiallycontributingtobothwellbeingandmusiceducationagendas?NewZealandJournalof Teachers'Work,15(1),63-84.doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.24135/teacherswork.v15i1.243Rickson,D.,Reynolds,D.,&Legg,R.(2018).Learners’perceptionsofdailysinginginaschoolcommunity severelyaffectedbyearthquakes:Linkstosubjectivewellbeing.JournalofAppliedArtsandHealth, 9(3),367-384.doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1386/jaah.9.3.367_1Ruddock,E.(2012)."Sortofinyourblood":Inherentmusicalitysurvivesculturaljudgement.ResearchStudies inMusicEducation,34(2),207-221.Ruddock,E.,Leong,S.(2005).‘Iamunmusical!’:Theverdictofself-judgement.InternationalJournalofMusic Education,23,9–22.Russell-Bowie,D.(2009).Whatme?Teachmusictomyprimaryclass?Challengestoteachingmusicinprimary schoolsinfivecountries.MusicEducationResearch,11(1),23-36.Russell-Bowie,D.(2013).Missionimpossibleorpossiblemission?Changingconfidenceandattitudesof primarypreservicemusiceducationstudentsusingKolb’sexperientiallearningtheory.Australian JournalofMusicEducation.Vol2,pp.46-63.Russell-Bowie,D.,&Dowson,M.(2005).Effectsofbackgroundandsexonconfidenceinteachingthecreative arts:Testsofspecifichypotheses.PaperpresentedattheAustralianAssociationforResearchin Education,Sydney,2005.Sagor,R.(2000).GuidingSchoolImprovementwithActionResearch:AssociationforSupervisionand CurriculumDevelopment.Sinclair,C.,Watkins,M.,&Jeanerett,N.(2015).Mentoringteachersasartistsincommunitiesofpractice: immersivemodelsofprofessionallearninginthearts.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation,Vol3, pp.73-83.Sloboda,J.(2005).Exploringthemusicalmind:Cognition,Emotion,Ability,Function.Oxford:OxfordUniversity Press.Sloboda,J.A.,Wise,K.J.,&Peretz,I.(2005).Quantifyingtonedeafnessinthegeneralpopulation.Annalsof theNewYorkAcademyofSciences,1060(1),255–261.Sutherland,A.(2015)."3:36pm,than'swhenallthefunstarts":Formingmusicalidentitythroughsecondary schoolmusic.AustralianJournalofMusicEducation,2,162-`175.
![Page 62: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 62
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Swain,N.,&Bodkin-Allen,S.(2014).Can'tsing?Won'tsing?Aotearoa/NewZealand'tone-deaf'early childhoodteachers'musicalbeliefs.BritishJournalofMusicEducation,31(3),245-263. doi:10.1017/S0265051714000278Swain,N.,&Bodkin-Allen,S.(2017).Developingsingingconfidenceinearlychildhoodteachersusing acceptanceandcommitmenttherapyandgroupsinging:Arandomizedtrial.ResearchStudiesin MusicEducation,39(1),109-120.Thorn,B.,&Brasche,I.(2015).Musicalexperienceandconfidenceofpre-serviceprimaryteachers.Australian JournalofMusicEducation,2,191-203.Tosun,T.(2000).Thebeliefsofpre-serviceelementaryteacherstowardscienceandscienceteaching.School ScienceandMathematics,100,374-379.Trevarthen,C.(2002).OriginsofMusicalIdentity.InR.A.R.MacDonald,D.J.Hargreaves,&D.Miell(Eds.), MusicalIdentities.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress.Welch,G.(2005).Singingandvocaldevelopment.InG.McPherson(Ed),Thechildasmusician(pp.312–339). Oxford,UK:OxfordUniversityPress.West,S.(2009).Selectivemutismforsinging(SMS)anditstreatment:conceptualisingmusicaldisengagement asmasssocialdysfunction.InW.Baker(Ed.),MusicalUnderstanding:ProceedingsoftheXVIINational Conference(pp.212–219).Launceston,Australia:AustralianSocietyforMusicEducation.Whidden,C.(2008).Theinjusticeofsinger/non-singerlabelsbymusiceducators.Gender,Education,Music, andSociety,5,1015.Wiggins,J.(2007).Compositionalprocessinmusic.InL.Bresler(Ed.),Internationalhandbookofresearchin artseducation(pp.453–70).Amsterdam,TheNetherlands:Springer. Wiggins,J.(2015).Musicalagency.InG.E.McPherson(Ed.),Thechildasmusician:Ahandbookofmusical development.UK:OxfordScholarshipOnline.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198744443.003.0006
![Page 63: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 63
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
USINGFIRSTAUTHOR©WRITINGCURRICULUMWITHSTUDENTSWITHAUTISMSPECTRUMDISORDERKristieAsaro-Saddler
UniversityofAlbany
JessicaColes
UniversityofAlbany
AbstractForindividualswithautismspectrumdisorder(ASD),writingcanpotentiallyaidinincreasedcommunication,socialization,andindependence.Yetthesestudentshistoricallyhavebeenexcludedfrompurposefulwritingactivitiesandinsteadhavereceivedlimitedliteracylearninginstruction.Inthisactionresearchproject,weobservedtheeffectsofahigh-qualitywritingcurriculumonthreeyoungstudentswithASD.Weutilizedaqualitativecasestudydesigntoanswerthefollowingquestion:WhataretheeffectsoftheFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumandtechnologyprogramonthewritingandengagementofelementaryschoolstudentswithASD?ResultsindicatedthatallthreestudentsappearedtobenefitfromtheuseoftheFirstAuthor®.Theteacheralsoreportedfeelingmoreconfidentandpreparedtoteachwritingtoherstudents.Generalthemesincludedincreasedstudentengagement,willingnesstotransition,andincreasedqualityinteractionwithtechnologyandwithotherstudents/adults.Practicalimplications,limitations,andfutureresearchdirectionwillbeprovided.
Keywords:teacheractionresearch,autismspectrumdisorder,engagement,technology,writing
Introduction
Writingisameansofexpression,personalreflection,andself-discovery(Kluth&Chandler-Olcott,2008).Writingisoftenusedbothinandoutoftheschoolsettingasamethodofdemonstratingone’sunderstandingofcontent,sharingideas,andcommunicatingwithothers.Inthecurrentageoftextmessages,emailcommunications,andsocialmedia,studentsneedtobeawareofandabletousedifferentformsofwrittencommunication.Yetwritingoftenposesasachallengetomanyindividualswithandwithoutdisabilities;amongpeoplewhofacethesechallengesarethosewithautismspectrumdisorder(ASD).
![Page 64: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 64
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ForindividualswithASD,writingisespeciallyimportantbecauseitcanaidinincreasedcommunication,socialization,andindependence(Wollak&Koppenhaver,2011).AlthoughsomepeoplewithASDareskilledwriterswhoeffectivelyusewritingasameansofcommunicationandexpression,manystudentswithASDstruggletowritewell.SpecificcharacteristicsofstudentswithASDmayinterferewiththeirabilitytoengageinthewritingprocess.Theseincludelanguagedelaysthatimpacttheirabilitytoproducewrittenproducts(Sturm,2012),difficultyutilizingwritingstrategiessuchasplanning,organizingandgeneratingcontent(Joseph&Konrad,2009),lackofself-regulation(Asaro-Saddler&Saddler,2010)andexecutivefunctioningskills(Carnahan,Williamson,&Christman,2011)requiredforwriting,andphysicaland/orsensoryimpairmentsthatmayimpacttheirabilitytoproducewrittenproducts(Wollak&Koppenhaver,2011).Thesecharacteristics,coupledwiththefactthatindividualswithASDoftenreceiveinadequateliteracyinstruction(Joseph&Konrad,2009),resultsintheirtendencytoperformwellbelowtheirpeersintheareaofwriting(Bishop,Sawyer,Alber-Morgan,&Boggs,2015).
LiteratureReview
Historically,studentswithASDhavebeenexcludedfrompurposefulwritingactivities(Carnahan,Williamson,Hollingshead,&Israel,2012)andinsteadhavereceivedlimitedliteracylearninginstruction,oftenfocusedonfunctionalskillssuchascopyingwordsandsentences,worksheets,andhandwritingdrill-and-practice(Asaro-Saddler,Arcidiacono,&Morris-Deyoe,2017;Sturm,2012).Thismayoccurforseveralreasons.First,manyeducatorscontinuetobelievethatalife-skills,functionalperspectiveismostappropriateforstudentswithASD(Ruppar,2015;Ruppar,Dymond,&Gaffney,2011)andthatwritinginstructionissuperfluous.Infact,oneofthegreatestbarrierstowritingforstudentswithASDisthattheirteachersdonotbelievetheyarecapableofbecomingwriters(Keefe&Copeland,2011;Sturm,2012).Inaddition,educatorsoftenlacktraininginhowtoprovideevidence-basedwritinginstruction(e.g.,Cutler&Graham,2008).Evenwithtraining,teachersoftendonothaveappropriatecurricularguides,appropriatewritingtools,andtimeallocatedinthedaytoprovideinstruction(Sturm,2012;Sturm,Cali,Nelson,&Staskowski,2012).Unfortunately,thisresultsinstudentswithASDlearningtowriteindecontextualizedenvironments,ratherthanthroughauthenticusesofliteracyskillsineverydayactivities(Ruppar,2015),anddoesnotallowthemtoreceivethesupportordeveloptheappropriateskillstheyneedtobecomeproficientwriters.
Researchhasfound,however,thatwhenprovidedwitheffective,evidence-basedinstruction,studentswithASDcandevelophigher-levelwritingskills.Forexample,areviewoftheliteraturewasconductedtoexploretheeffectivenessofwritinginterventionswithstudentswithASD(Pennington&Delano,2012),andfoundseveralpotentiallyeffectivewritinginterventions.Amongtheseistheself-regulatedstrategydevelopment(SRSD),anapproachthatcombinesstrategyinstructionwithpromptsforself-regulationsuchasgoalsettingandself-monitoring.StudiesusingthisinterventionfoundpositivefindingsinthepersuasivewritingandstorywritingofelementaryschoolstudentswithASD(seeAsaro-Saddler,2016forareview).OtherstudieshavehighlightedtheuseoftechnologyforstudentswithASDtowritestories(e.g.,Pennington,Collins,Stenhoff,Turner&Gunselman,
![Page 65: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 65
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
2014;Schneider,Codding,&Tryon,2013),namewriting(Moore,Anderson,Treccase,Deppeler,Furlonger,&Didden,2013),andcheckthespellingofwords(e.g.,Kagohara,Sigafoos,Achmadi,O’Reilly,&Lancioni,2012).
OnetechnologyprogramthathasrecentlybeenexploredwithstudentswithASDisFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumandtechnologyprogram.ThisprogramwasdevelopedbyDr.JanetSturmspecificallyforbeginningwriterswithcomplexlearningneedssuchasASDanddesignedinconsiderationofUniversalDesignforLearning(UDL)principles(Sturm,2015).Itguidesstudentsthroughathree-stepwritingprocessofchoosingatopic,selectingapictureprompt,andwritingwiththesupportofbuilt-inaccommodationssuchaswordbanks,on-screenkeyboards,andself-regulationprompts.Mini-lessons,whichoccurforabout5-15minutes,focusononespecificskillfortheday(e.g.,addingaperiod)andaretaughtthroughexplicitinstruction(Sturm,2015).Lessonsincludeatipsheetconsistingofbothsimplewordsandpicturestohelpstudentsremembertheessentialinformation.Writingtimefollowsthemini-lesson,andthenstudentsaregiventheopportunitytosharetheirworkintheAuthor’sChair.Inonepilotstudy,preliminaryanalysesfoundthatsecondarystudentswithASDanddevelopmentaldisabilitieswhousedFirstAuthor®reportedmixedresults,indicatingthatstudentsshowedsomeimprovementsinwritingqualityandquantitywhenbeingtaughtusingFirstAuthor®(Asaro-Saddler,Muir-Knox,Meredith,&Akhmedjanova,2015).However,noknownpublishedstudyhasexploredtheeffectsoftheprogramonyoungbeginningwriters.
Methodology
ContextfortheCurrentStudy.Thefirstauthor,aspecialeducationteacheranddoctoralstudent,wantedtoprovideherstudentswithqualitywritinginstructioninwhichtheycouldengageappropriately.Sheworkedwiththesecondauthor,aresearcher,toimplementanactionresearchprojectinwhichtheycouldobservetheeffectsofFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumontheyoungstudentswithASDinherclass.Specifically,aqualitativecasestudydesignwasutilizedtoanswerthefollowingquestion:WhataretheeffectsoftheFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumandtechnologyprogramonthewritingandengagementofelementaryschoolstudentswithASD?
Participants.ParticipantsinthisstudywereOsvald,Palen,andChindi(pseudonyms),threemalesofEuropeanAmericandescentbetween5and8yearsold,andtheirteacher.Thestudents’IndividualizedEducationPrograms(IEP)eachlistedtheirprimarydiagnosisasASD,andtheywereplacedforpartoftheirdayinaself-containedprogramthatwasservingstudentswithcommunicationandcognitivedelays.Specifically,OsvaldandPalenspent80%oftheirtimeinthespecialeducationsetting,whileChindispent10%ofhistimethere.Theclassroomwascomprisedoftwelvestudents,oneduallycertifiedspecialeducation/literacyandelementaryeducationteacher,threeteachingaides,andoneteachingassistant(certifiedteacherandabletoprovidedirectinstruction).Studentparticipantswerereferredforthestudybythefirstauthor,whowastheirteacheratthetimeofthestudy.ThestudyoccurredinasuburbanelementaryschoolintheNortheasternUnitedStates.
![Page 66: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 66
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Materials.FirstAuthorWritingCurriculum®(FirstAuthor®)wasusedwiththeparticipantsinthisstudy.TheFirstAuthor®packageincludedacurriculumguidewith80minilessons,aninstructionguidewith63tipsheets,assessmentguide,classroomposters,teacherresourceCD,andwritingsoftware.Thelessons,whicharedesignedfordevelopingwriters,eachbeganwithashortmini-lesson,followedbyindependentwritingtime,andendedwithAuthor’sChair,whichwasanopportunityforstudentstosharetheirwritingwiththegroup.
FirstAuthor®softwareofferedseveralassistivefeaturesduringthewritingprocess.First,studentsweredirectedtoaplanningscreenthatsupportstopicselectionbyprovidingphotoimagesthatcanbeindividualizedbytheteacher.Studentsselectedaphotoandwerethentakentothecomposingscreen.Thecomposingscreenhadon-screenkeyboardsandwordbanksthatincludedtopicspecificwordsinadditiontohighfrequencyandfrequentlymisspelledvocabulary.Areadaloudfeatureandself-regulatoryprompts(e.g.,verbalcuestocontinuewriting)werealsoprovided.Thefinalscreenreadthestudents’workaloudandincludeda“publish”option,whichcreatedabookcoverwithphotosandauthor’sname.
Othermaterialsincludedaclassroomdesktopcomputerorpencilandpaperusedforwriting,aMacbookPro®laptoptovideorecordeachlesson,andaugmentativecommunicationprogram,Proloquo2Go®whichwasaccessibleonaniPad®toeachstudentduringthelessons.Thisprogramwasutilizedbystudentsasapartoftheirdailyroutine;therefore,itwasprovidedduringthewritinglessonsaswell.
Procedures.Theteacherworkedone-tooneonwritingdailywitheachofthethreeparticipants.Eachlessonwascomposedoftwoparts:aminilessonfromtheFirstAuthor®Curriculum,andthenwritingtime,inwhichthestudentsusedtheskillfromtheminilessontoguidetheirwriting.Duringwritingtime,studentshadtheoptiontostartanewpieceorfinishonetheyhadalreadybeenworkingon.Afterthestudentscompletedtheirwritingtheyprinteditandcouldeithertakeithomeorputitintheclassroomlibrary.Therewerenotimeconstraintsputonthemini-lessonorwritingtime;however,mini-lessonsweredesignedtobenolongerthan15minutes.
Eachsessionvaried,dependingonthetopic,student’sinterest,motivationandengagement.Throughouttheimplementationofthewritingintervention,studentsreceivedthesamelessoneitheronceormultipletimes,attheteacher’sdiscretion.Thiswasimportantbecausethestudents’writingsuccess,engagementandachievementwastheultimategoalforthestudy,andmovingontothenextlesson,ifthestudenthadnottrulymasteredthegoalfromthepreviouslesson,wouldnothavebeenethical.Eachlessonwasrecordedforlateranalysis,andtheteachercompletedfieldnotesaftereachlesson(seebelow).
DataCollectionandAnalysis.Datawerecollectedover10monthsduringtheacademicschoolyear(September-June)andcontainedmultiplecomponents:FirstAuthor®TeacherManagementsoftware,videoobservationsofeachsessionforeachstudent,andfieldnotesfromtheteacherforeachlesson.
TheFirstAuthor®TeacherManagementSoftwareautomaticallymeasuredstudent’swritingachievement.ThesoftwareincludedmeasuressuchasTopicDiversity,whichmeasuredand
![Page 67: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 67
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
quantifiedthevarioustopicsthewriterself-selected;totalintelligiblewords(TIW),whichmeasuredoverallintelligibilityofthestudent’swordsandwrittenfluency;andtotaluniquewords(TUW),whichmeasuredtheoverallvocabularydiversity.
Eachlesson(mini-lessonandwriting)wasvideorecorded.Foreachstudent60minutesofpre-selectedvideorecordingwastranscribed.Thevideosegmentswereselectedatrandom;somewereoftheminilesson,somewereofthewritingsession,andsomewereacompilationofboth.Afterthetranscriptionswerecompletedanotherresearchercomparedthetranscriptionstothevideosforreliabilityandvalidity.Transcriptswereusedtoidentifywritingbehaviorsandengagement.Afterwatchingandtranscribingthevideos,researcherscreatedalistofcodesbasedonbehaviorstheynotedwhilewatchingthevideos,aswellaspreviousresearchregardingengagementofindividualswithASD.Researcherswentthroughthetranscriptionsandcodedthestudent’sbehavior.SeeTable1foralistofthecodesdevelopedandused.
Table1:ListofCodes
Code Description
VerbalinitiationStudentsinitiatedaverbalcommentaboutthelessontopic
Initiationwithtechnology StudentinitiatedacommentaboutthelessonusingtheProloquo2Go©app
Othernon-verbalinitiation Studentinitiatedbypointingtoanobjectorapicturetocommunicatewhattheywanted
Verbalresponse Studentsverballyrespondedtoarequestorquestion
Responsewithtechnology StudentsrespondedtoarequestorquestionusingtheProloquo2Go©app
Othernon-verbalresponse Studentsrespondedtoarequestorquestionbypointingtoanobjectorapicturetocommunicatewhattheywanted
Echolalia Studentrepeatedwhattheteacherwassayingorrepeatedaphrasetheycommonlyusedthatwasnotrelevanttothelesson
Physicalaggression Studenthit,kicked,swipedorthrewanobject.
Stimming Studentengagedinrepetitivebehaviors(physicalorverbal).
Eyecontact Studentlookedattheteacherintheeyesorlookedatthescreenwhenasked.
Waiting Studentwasinthedesignatedinstructionareaanddelayingbehavioralimpulses.
![Page 68: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 68
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Escaping/leavingworkarea Studentleft(ortriedtoleave)theinstructionalareawithoutpermission
Disengaged Studentgaveofftopicresponsesorstaredoffintothedistance
Distractedbyexternalstimuli
Studentwasunabletoconcentrateonthemini-lessonorwritingbecauseofanotherstudentorenvironmentalsituation
Note:Codesinwhichthechildwasconsideredtobe“engaged”inthelessonarebolded,whilenon-boldeditemswerebehaviorsinwhichthechildwasconsideredtobe“notengaged.”
Fieldnotesweretakenduringandaftereachlessonofthestudy.Thefieldnotesincludedbothdescriptiveandreflectiveinformationaboutthestudentandsession.Thenoteswereorganizedandcompletedinresponsetoquestions.Thiswasimportantbecauseitallowedtheteachertocollectnotesonthesameinformationforeachstudent,asopposedtoarandomnarrativeaboutthesession.Thenotesincludedthedate,studentname,title/lessonnumberandattempt,didthestudentwriteduringthelesson,whatdidtheywrite,whatwasthetopic,howmanywordswerewritten,thelevelofassistance,studentbehaviorsandadditionalcommentsandobservations.Thesenotes,combinedwithvideotranscripts,allowedresearcherstoexaminethewaysinwhichtheparticipantsengagedwithFirstAuthor®.
Results
Therewereavarietyofcomplexfindingsworthnotinginregardstothisstudy.Specificthemesemergedfromthedataacrossallthreestudentparticipants,aswellasamongindividualstudents.AllthreestudentsandtheteacherseemedtobenefitfromtheuseoftheFirstAuthor®,andtheclassroomwasabetterplaceforusingit.Generalthemesincludedincreasedstudentengagement,willingnesstotransition,andincreasedqualityinteractionwithtechnologyandwithotherstudents/adults.Specifically,engagementwasnotedtobeaveryimportanttheme.Uponviewingthevideos,studentswereengagedinanaverageof67%ofthetime,withOsvaldengaged82.7%ofthetime,Palen63.2%andChindi57.2%.Overallimprovementsinwriting,suchasincreasedtopicdiversityandquantityofwriting,werealsonoted.Wewillnowdiscussspecificfindingsforeachparticipant.
Osvald.OsvaldbenefitedmostfromtheFirstAuthor®Writer’sCurriculum.Specifically,Osvaldshowedanincreaseintopicdiversity,increasedtimewriting,moreopportunitiestowrite,increasedacademiclanguage,increasedqualityofwriting,decreasedproblembehaviorsandeasiertransitionsfrompreferredactivitiestowriting.Osvald’sinteractionswithwritingpriortoFirstAuthor®weredeliveredviaastructuredtasksysteminwhichhewouldcompleteacertainnumberofwritingactivities(handwritingworksheetsandhandwritingskills)eachday.Hestruggledtogenerateideasforwritingandfatiguedquicklywhenaskedtowritesentences.Hiswritingexperienceswerelimitedanddrivenbyhislackofinterestinthetask.
![Page 69: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 69
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
DuringtheFirstAuthor®sessions,Osvaldusedplanningmethods,suchasbrainstormingandmakinglists,toimprovehiswriting.Hewasabletoprogressfromneedingwordbankstofacilitatehiswriting/typingtowritingwithoutusingwordbanksanddevelopingphrasesindependently.ResultsalsoindicatedthatOsvaldhadincreasedtopicdiversity.PriortoFirstAuthor®hestruggledtochoosetopicsonhisown;however,oncehewasabletoseethatwhateverhewasthinkingofcouldbetypedintothesoftwareandanimagewouldcomeup,hebegantochooseavarietyoftopics.Thevarietyoftopicsallowedtheteacherandreadersofhisworkadeeperandricheraccessonwhatwas“goingoninsideofhishead”,whichwasespeciallyimportantduetohislackoflanguage.Osvald’swritingqualityalsoincreased.SincethiscurriculumrequiredOsvaldtowritequalitypieceseveryday,hewrotemorestorieswhenengaginginFirstAuthor®.PriortousingthesoftwareOsvald,hadneverwrittenastory.Duringthestudy,Osvaldwillinglywrotenumerousstoriesduringonesessiononvarioustopics.Hiswritingexperienceexpandedbeyondhandwritingtoqualitywritingexperiences.
FirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumalsohadanimpactonOsvald’sbehavior.Hehadabehaviorplanthattargetedphysicalaggressionsandelopement(runningaway),sincehewasaveraging45physicalaggressionsaday.Whenweimplementedtheintervention,ontheotherhand,wereportedanaverageof7physicalaggressions,andtheyweremainlyduringonesession.TheteacherreportedthatbecauseofOsvald’sdecreasedphysicalaggressionswhenusingFirstAuthor®shewasabletohavemorequalityacademicinteractionswithhim.TheteacheralsoreportedthatOsvald’sacademiclanguageincreased.Hewasreportedusingphraseslike“let’swrite,”and“Iamawriter.”
TheteacherreportedthatOsvaldtransitionedtowritingwithgreaterease.Priortothestudy,Osvaldwouldelope,cry,scream,orengageinselfinjuriousbehaviorswhenitwastimetotransitionfromapreferredactivitytowriting.DuringFirstAuthor,Osvaldwouldtransitionwillinglyandwouldevenasktowriteduringhisbreaks.Osvaldalsobegantoviewwritingasacollaborativeandpersonalexperienceandnotanisolatedone.Hewouldcollaborateduringplanning,hewouldinteractwiththecomputerduringwritingandlookatothers’stories,andwhenfinishedhewouldreadhiswritingstohispeersfromtheauthor’schair.Healsobegantakinghisstorieshome,andhismotherwouldintegratethemintohisbedtimeroutine.
Palen.PalenalsobenefitedfromtheFirstAuthor®Writer’sCurriculum.Heshowedanincreaseintopicdiversity,increasedtimewriting,moreopportunitiestowrite,increasedacademiclanguage,increasedqualityofwriting,andeasiertransitionsfrompreferredactivitiestowriting.LikeOsvald,Palen’sinteractionswithwritingpriortoFirstAuthor®alsoconsistedofwritingviaastructuredtasksysteminwhichhewouldcompleteacertainnumberofwritingactivities(handwritingworksheets,iPadwritingactivities,Velcrosentenceconstruction)eachday.Hestruggledtogenerateideasforwritingandfatiguedquicklywhenaskedtowritesentencesbyhand.
![Page 70: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 70
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
OneofthegreatestfindingswithPalenwasthesignificantincreaseintopicdiversity.PriortoFirstAuthor®theteacherreportedPalenstrugglingtoattachtopicstowritingandtotheconceptthatyouwritesentencestodescribeyourtopic.Aftermini-lessonsandwritingsessions,Palenquicklywasabletonavigatethesoftwareandwouldsearchtopicsthathehadlearnedaboutearlierintheday.HistopicsrangedfromStarburststoremotecontrolcars.Palenalsowrotemore.Heengagedinwritingforlongerperiodsoftime,andwrotenumerousstoriespersession;sessionsinwhichPalenwrote6stories,forexample,werenotunusual.Palen’sacademiclanguagewasalsonotedtoincrease.Theteacherreportedthathewouldaskforhiswritingtipsheetandwouldverballyidentifypunctuationheneededfortheendofsentences.Palen’ssuccessinFirstAuthor®carriedovertohisfamilylife.HisfamilyaskedthatwritinggoalsbeputonhisIEPmovingforward,andheevengiftedhisprinted-outstoriestofamilyfriendsandsiblingsforHanukah.PalentransitionedeasiertowritingwhenitwasFirstAuthor®writingtime,andbeganviewingwritingasapersonalexperience.
Chindi.ChindialsobenefitedfromFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculum,howeverhislackoftypingabilitypreventedhimfrombenefittingasmuchashispeersdid.Forexample,Chindididnotknowhowtomaneuverthemouse,sotheteacherhadtoguidehishand,whichinherentlyremoved100%ofthechoiceduringhistimeonthecomputer.Morespecifically,ifChindiwantedtoexitthesoftware,hecouldnotbecausehecouldnotmovethemouse.Hisstimmingandlackoftechnologicalskillsnegativelyimpactedtheamountofacademicachievementandengagementhehad.Hedidnotknowhowtotype,sothetypingportionofthelessonswereheavilyprompted.FirstAuthor®didprovideChindiwithanincreasedamountofwritingopportunitiesthough.PriortoFirstAuthor®,Chindiwrotewithhisclass,butduringFirstAuthor®hewasabletowritebothduringtimewithhisclassandduringhis1:1timewiththeteacher.Hewasobservedtowriteineverylesson.
TheteacherreportedthatChindihadanincreaseintopicdiversity,from0to28uniquetopics.Onoccasion,hewroteonthesametopicmorethanonce.PriortoFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumChindididnotsuggesthisownwritingtopics.Whenhewasabletousethesoftware,hewasabletoverbalizetotheteacherorpointtowhathewantedtowriteabout.Hewroteaboutthingslikehisfamilyskiing,teapartiesandDisneyWorld.Chindi’sparticipationinFirstAuthor®carriedovertohisfamilylife.Hewouldbringhisstorieshomeandputthemonhisbookshelfathome,andhisparentsaskedforwritinggoalsforhisIEPforthenextyear.Chindiwasveryproudwhenhegottoreadhisstoryinhiskindergartengeneraleducationclassroom.
Teacher.Throughoutthedurationofthestudytheteachertookavarietyoffieldnotesandreflections.ImplementationoftheFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumprovidedsignificantsupportfortheteacher.Throughouttheinterventiontheteacher’sresultsshowedthemesofincreasedreflection,increasedqualityinteractionswiththestudents,increasedqualityofhomeandschoolconnections,increasedpreparedness,andefficacyasaneducator.
![Page 71: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 71
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Inregardstoefficacyasaneducator,theteacherreportedfeelingbetterpreparedtoteachherstudentsbecauseoftheresourcesthatthecurriculumincluded.Theteachercouldfocusmoreondeliverythancontent,whichmadethecontentmoreaccessibletothestudents.Morespecifically,thetraditionalstandardsdonotnecessarilyspeaktotheneedsofthestudents,andtheydonotaddressstudentswithsignificantcognitiveabilities.Thiscurriculumwasspecific,intentionalandsequential,whichallowedfortheteachertospendtimetakingthatcontentandfindingawayforittoconnectwithstudentsinsteadofdesigningthecontentaswell.Theteacherwashappier,moreconfident,andsatisfiedwiththeteachingofthesestudents,becausethestudentswerebeingexposedtorigorousandqualityinstruction.
Connectionswithstudentswerealsoimpactedbythecurriculum.Theteacherhadascripttofollowthatconnecteddirectlywiththewritingskillsstudentswereaskedtolearn.Theteacherreportedbeingabletoovertlymodelsuccessfulacademicinteractionswithstudentsforotherstaff.Morespecifically,thestaffandadministratorswereabletoseethestudentsdoingsomethingacademicallyrigorous,andithelpedchangeperceptionsandpossiblyimproveinteractionsbetweenstudentsandparaprofessionals.
Discussion
InthisstudywesoughttoexaminetheeffectsoftheFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculumonthewritingandengagementofthreeelementaryschoolstudentswithASD.Resultsindicatedthatforthestudentsinthisstudy,writingmovedfromhandwritingandtracingletterstoactuallywritingstoriesbasedontheirpreferredandself-selectedtopics.Thisrepresentedashiftinthinkingaboutwhatwritingwasforthesethreestudents,andwhattheywerecapableofaswriters.
Findingsfromthisstudyindicatethattheparticipantswerehighlyengagedduringthemini-lessonsandwritingtime.Thisisapromisingfinding,sincestudentswithASDoftenhavedifficultyengagingduringinstructionaltime(Sparapani,Morgan,Reinhardt,Schatschneider,&Wetherby,2016).Studentsseemedtorequirelessredirectionandwereabletotransitionmorequicklyfromapreferredactivitytowritingtime.
Thestudentswerealsoobservedtobewritingmore,apositivefindinggiventhatmanystudentswithASDdonotoftenengageintypicalwritingactivities.Inonestudy,forinstance,Ruppar(2015)foundthatstudentswithASDandotherintellectualdisabilitiesspentminimaltime(only11%)oftheiridentifiedliteracyblockengagedinwriting,withonlyoneoffourteachersobservedtoincludewritinginclassliteracyactivities.Therefore,thefactthatstudentswereengagedinpersonallymeaningfulauthenticwritingexperienceswascommendable.Additionally,thestudentswerenotedtoincreasetheirtopicdiversity.Thiswasanespeciallyencouragingfindingastheparticipantsinthisstudy,likemanypeoplewithASD,hadspecificintereststhattheytendedtowanttodiscussallthetime(Gunn&Delafield-Butt,2016).Thefactthattheycouldusethesoftwaretobrainstormandhavepicturestosupporttheirideaswasabenefit.
![Page 72: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 72
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
TheteacherinthisstudyreportedfeelingmoreconfidentandpreparedtoteachherstudentswhenusingtheFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculum,apositivefindinggiventhatmanyteachers,bothspecialandgeneraleducation,donotfeelpreparedtoteachwritingtotheirstudents(Cutler&Graham,2008).ProgramssuchasFirstAuthor®mayhelptofillagapformanyteachersofstudentswithcomplexsupportneedswhobelievethattheydonothavetheappropriatecurriculumormaterialstoteachwritingtothispopulation(Sturm,2012;Sturm,Cali,Nelson,&Staskowski,2012).
Anunanticipatedoutcomeofthisstudywasthewayinwhichuseoftheprogramenhancedhome/schoolrelationships.Parentswerereadingtheirchildren’sstoriesathomeandonestudentactuallygavehisstoriesaspresents.Inaddition,twoofthethreeparticipants’familiesaskedthatindividualgoalsinwritingbeaddedtotheirchildren’sIEPs.Thiswasanespeciallyexcitingfinding,becauseitrepresentedthefactthattheparentsnowbelievedtheirchildrenwerecapableofbeingwriters,whichtheyhadnotthoughtbefore.
LimitationsandImplications
Sincethiswasaqualitative,exploratorystudy,therewasnodataexaminingthegainsinwritingachievementandengagementpriortoandafterusingtheFirstAuthor®WritingCurriculum.Futureresearchshouldconsiderutilizingsingle-caseorgroupdesignstudiesthatexaminetheeffectivenessoftheprogramonyoungwriterswithASD.Inaddition,itisunknownwhetherthewritinglessonsorthetechnologyhadagreatereffectonthestudents’abilitytoattendandimprovewritingoutcomes.Futureresearchdirectlycomparingtechnologywithpaper/pencilwritingtaskswillhelpdeterminewhetherthelessonsorthesoftwareprogramalonemayhaveanimpactonstudents’writing.Similarly,althoughstudentswerehighlyengagedduringboththemini-lessonsandwhileusingthesoftware,itmightbeinterestingtonotetrendsinstudents’engagementacrossthesetwoaspectsoftheprogram(i.e.,duringwhichpartofthelessonweretheymore/lessengaged).
Conclusion
ThefindingsofthisactionresearchprojectaddtoasmallbutgrowingbodyofresearchonwritingforstudentswithASD.Usingaqualitativecasestudymethodallowedformorein-depth,richobservationoftheeffectsoftheprogrambeyondquantitativeoutcomes.WehopethatthisstudymaydrawattentiontothepossibilitythatstudentswithASDandconcurrentcommunicationandcognitivechallengesmaybecomeskilled,competentwriterswhengivenproperinstruction.Inaddition,webelievethisstudyallowsteacherstoseethebenefitsofusingsuchaprogramtoallowformorepersonalized,meaningful,andcontextualizedwritinginstructionforallstudents.
![Page 73: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 73
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
AbouttheAuthors
KristieAsaro-Saddler,Ph.D.isanAssociateProfessorintheDivisionofSpecialEducationattheUniversityatAlbany.Herresearchinterestsfocusonwritingandself-regulatorystrategies,specificallyforstudentswithAutismSpectrumDisorders(ASD).ShehaspublishedinspecialeducationjournalsincludingtheJournalofSpecialEducation,ExceptionalChildren,andRemedialandSpecialEducation,andhaspresentedatnationalandinternationalconferencesintheareaofwriting.PriortojoiningthefacultyattheUniversityatAlbanyshewasaspecialeducationteacherforchildrenwithASDanddevelopmentaldisabilities.Email:[email protected]
JessicaColes,M.S.Ed.isadoctoralresearchfellowattheUniversityatAlbanyintheEducationalPsychologyandMethodologyprogram.Herresearchinterestsfocusonspecialeducation,teacherpreparationandculturalresponsiveness.Shehasbeenaspecialeducationteacherforsixyears,andworksprimarilywithelementarystudentswhohaveASDormooddisorders.Email:[email protected]
![Page 74: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 74
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
ReferencesAsaro-Saddler,K.(2016).Writinginstructionandself-regulationforstudentswithAutismSpectrumDisorders: Asystematicreviewoftheliterature.TopicsinLanguageDisorders,36,266-283.Asaro-Saddler,K.,Arcidiacono,M.&MorrisDeyoe,M.(2017).Instructionalpracticeforstudentswithautism
spectrumandrelateddisorders:Exploringtheteachingofwritingintwoself-containedclassrooms.ReadingandWritingQuarterly,33(2),171-186.
Asaro-Saddler,K.,Muir-Knox,H.,Meredith,H.,&Akhmedjanova,D.(2015).Usingtechnologytosupport
studentswithAutismSpectrumDisordersinthewritingprocess.InsightsonLearningDisabilities,12,103-119.
Asaro-Saddler,K.&Saddler,B.(2010).Planninginstructionandself-regulationtraining:Effectsonwriterswith
AutismSpectrumDisorders.ExceptionalChildren,77,107-124.Bishop,A.E.,Sawyer,M.,Alber-Morgan,S.R.,&Boggs,M.(2015).Effectsofagraphicorganizertraining
packageonthepersuasivewritingofmiddleschoolstudentswithautism.EducationandTraininginAutismandDevelopmentalDisabilities,50,290-302.
Carnahan,C.R.,Williamson,P.S.,&Christman,J.(2011).Linkingcognitionandliteracyinstudentswithautism
spectrumdisorder.TeachingExceptionalChildren,43(6),54-62.Carnahan,C.,Williamson,P.,Hollingshead,A.,&Israel,M.(2012).Usingtechnologytosupportbalanced
literacyforstudentswithsignificantdisabilities.TeachingExceptionalChildren,45,20-29.Cutler,L.,&Graham,S.(2008).Primarygradewritinginstruction;Anationalsurvey.JournalofEducational
Psychology,100,907-919.Gunn,K.C.M.,&Delafield-Butt,J.T.(2016).Teachingchildrenwithautismspectrumdisorderwithrestricted
interests:Areviewofevidenceforbestpractice.ReviewofEducationalResearch,86,408-430.Joseph,L.M.,&Konrad,M.(2009).Teachingstudentswithintellectualordevelopmentaldisabilitiestowrite:
Areviewoftheliterature.ResearchinDevelopmentalDisabilities,30,1-19.Kagohara,D.M.,Sigafoos,J.,Achmadi,D.,O’Reilly,M.,&Lancioni,G.(2012).Teachingchildrenwithautism
spectrumdisorderstocheckthespellingofwords.ResearchinAutismSpectrumDisorders,6,304–310.
Keefe,E.B.,&Copeland,S.R.(2011).Whatisliteracy?Thepowerofadefinition.ResearchandPracticefor
PersonswithSevereDisabilities,36,92-99.Kluth,P.,&Chandler-Olcott,K.(2008).Alandwecanshare.Baltimore:PaulH.BrooksPublishing.Moore,D.W.,Anderson,A.,Treccase,F.,Deppeler,J.,Furlonger,B.,&Didden,R.(2013).Avideo-based
packagetoteachachildwithautismspectrumdisordertowritehername.JournalofDevelopmentalandPhysicalDisabilities,25,493-503.
Pennington,R.C.,Collins,B.C.,Stenhoff,D.M.,Turner,K.,&Gunselman,K.(2014).Usingsimultaneous
promptingtoteachgenerativewritingtostudentswithautism.EducationandTraininginAutismandDevelopmentalDisabilities,49,396-414.
Pennington,R.C.&Delano,M.D.(2012).Writinginstructionforstudentswithautismspectrumdisorders:A
reviewofliterature.FocusonAutismandDevelopmentalDisabilities,27,158-167.
![Page 75: Journal of Teacher Action Research 1 JTAR...JTAR About the Journal Founded in 2013, the Journal of Teacher Action Research (ISSN: 2332-2233) is a peer-reviewed online journal indexed](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042406/5f203a078f836830f0655433/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
THEJOURNALOFTEACHERACTIONRESEARCH 75
JournalofTeacherActionResearch- Volume6,Issue1,Fall2019,<practicalteacherresearch.com>,ISSN#2332-2233©JTAR.AllRights
Ruppar,A.L.(2015).Apreliminarystudyoftheliteracyexperiencesofadolescentswithseveredisabilities.
RemedialandSpecialEducation,36,235–245.Ruppar,A.,Gaffney,J.S.,&Dymond,S.K.(2015).Influencesonteachers’decisionsaboutliteracyfor
secondarystudentswithseveredisabilities.ExceptionalChildren,8,209-226.Schneider,A.B.,Codding,R.S.,&Tryon,G.S.(2013).Comparingandcombiningaccommodationand
remediationinterventionstoimprovethewrittenlanguageperformanceofchildrenwithAspergersyndrome.FocusonAutismandOtherDevelopmentalDisabilities,28,101–114.
Sparapani,N,Morgan,L.,Reinhardt,V..,Schatschneider,C.,Wetherby,A.M.(2016).Evaluationofactive
engagementinelementarystudentswithautismspectrumdisorder.JournalofAutismandDevelopmentalDisorders,46,782-796.
Sturm,J.M.(2012).Anenrichedwriters’workshopforbeginningwriterswithdevelopmentaldisabilities.
TopicsinLanguageDisorders,32,335-360.Sturm,J.M.(2015).FirstAuthorWritingCurriculum:Acomprehensivewritingcurriculumforbeginningwriters.
Volo,IL:DonJohnstonandCentralMichiganUniversity.Retrievedfromhttp://donjohnston.com/wp-content/downloads/extras/first_author_writing_curriculum_sampler.pdf
Sturm,J.M.,Cali,K.,Nelson,N.W.,&Staskowski,M.(2012).Thedevelopmentalwritingscale:Anewprogress
monitoringtoolforbeginningwriters.TopicsinLanguageDisorders,32,297-318.Sparapani,N.,Morgan,L.,Reinhardt,V.P.,Schatschneider,C.,&Wetherby,A.M.(2016).Evaluationof
classroomactiveengagementinelementarystudentswithautismspectrumdisorder.JournalofAutismandDevelopmentalDisorders,46,782–796.
Wollak,B.A.,&Koppenhaver,D.,A.(2011).Developingtechnology-supported,evidence-basedwriting
instructionforadolescentswithsignificantwritingdisabilities.AssistiveTechnologyOutcomesandBenefits,7,1-23.