jujitsu and jiu jitsu, - unm.wsrjj.orgunm.wsrjj.org/spelling.pdf · the different spellings of...

4
The The The The Different Different Different Different Spellings Spellings Spellings Spellings Of Of Of Of Jujutsu, Jujutsu, Jujutsu, Jujutsu, Jujitsu Jujitsu Jujitsu Jujitsu And And And And Jiu Jiu Jiu Jiu Jitsu, Jitsu, Jitsu, Jitsu, And And And And What What What What They They They They Actually Actually Actually Actually Mean Mean Mean Mean (v2.4) (v2.4) (v2.4) (v2.4) Andrew Andrew Andrew Andrew Yiannakis, Yiannakis, Yiannakis, Yiannakis, Ph.D. Ph.D. Ph.D. Ph.D. Research Research Research Research Professor Professor Professor Professor (UNM) (UNM) (UNM) (UNM) 8th 8th 8th 8th Dan Dan Dan Dan Traditional Traditional Traditional Traditional Jujutsu Jujutsu Jujutsu Jujutsu (USJJF) (USJJF) (USJJF) (USJJF) 6th 6th 6th 6th Dan Dan Dan Dan Traditional Traditional Traditional Traditional Kodokan Kodokan Kodokan Kodokan Judo Judo Judo Judo (USA-TKJ) (USA-TKJ) (USA-TKJ) (USA-TKJ) Prof. Prof. Prof. Prof. Yiannakis Yiannakis Yiannakis Yiannakis is is is is Chair Chair Chair Chair of of of of the the the the Traditional Traditional Traditional Traditional Jujutsu Jujutsu Jujutsu Jujutsu Committee Committee Committee Committee of of of of the the the the USJJF USJJF USJJF USJJF and and and and Director Director Director Director of of of of the the the the Institute Institute Institute Institute of of of of Traditional Traditional Traditional Traditional Martial Martial Martial Martial Arts Arts Arts Arts at at at at the the the the University University University University of of of of New New New New Mexico Mexico Mexico Mexico (USA) (USA) (USA) (USA) If you’ve been following my blogs on this issue (Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr or LinkedIn) it should be clear that it’s not just about how you spell it. The different spellings are actual portals portals portals portals to different styles/systems, and the cultural practices and ways that characterize and differentiate them. The

Upload: vodan

Post on 06-Feb-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, - unm.wsrjj.orgunm.wsrjj.org/spelling.pdf · The Different Spellings Of Jujutsu, Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, And What They Actually Mean (v2.4) Andrew Yiannakis,

TheTheTheThe DifferentDifferentDifferentDifferent SpellingsSpellingsSpellingsSpellings OfOfOfOf Jujutsu,Jujutsu,Jujutsu,Jujutsu,JujitsuJujitsuJujitsuJujitsu AndAndAndAnd JiuJiuJiuJiu Jitsu,Jitsu,Jitsu,Jitsu,

AndAndAndAnd WhatWhatWhatWhat TheyTheyTheyThey ActuallyActuallyActuallyActually MeanMeanMeanMean(v2.4)(v2.4)(v2.4)(v2.4)

AndrewAndrewAndrewAndrew Yiannakis,Yiannakis,Yiannakis,Yiannakis, Ph.D.Ph.D.Ph.D.Ph.D.

ResearchResearchResearchResearch ProfessorProfessorProfessorProfessor (UNM)(UNM)(UNM)(UNM)8th8th8th8th DanDanDanDan TraditionalTraditionalTraditionalTraditional JujutsuJujutsuJujutsuJujutsu (USJJF)(USJJF)(USJJF)(USJJF)

6th6th6th6th DanDanDanDan TraditionalTraditionalTraditionalTraditional KodokanKodokanKodokanKodokan JudoJudoJudoJudo (USA-TKJ)(USA-TKJ)(USA-TKJ)(USA-TKJ)

Prof.Prof.Prof.Prof. YiannakisYiannakisYiannakisYiannakis isisisis ChairChairChairChair ofofofof thethethethe TraditionalTraditionalTraditionalTraditional JujutsuJujutsuJujutsuJujutsu CommitteeCommitteeCommitteeCommittee ofofofof thethethetheUSJJFUSJJFUSJJFUSJJF andandandand DirectorDirectorDirectorDirector ofofofof thethethethe InstituteInstituteInstituteInstitute ofofofof TraditionalTraditionalTraditionalTraditional MartialMartialMartialMartial ArtsArtsArtsArts atatatat thethethethe

UniversityUniversityUniversityUniversity ofofofof NewNewNewNewMexicoMexicoMexicoMexico (USA)(USA)(USA)(USA)

If you’ve been following my blogs on this issue (Facebook, Twitter, Tumblror LinkedIn) it should be clear that it’s not just about how you spell it. Thedifferent spellings are actual portalsportalsportalsportals to different styles/systems, and thecultural practices and ways that characterize and differentiate them. The

Page 2: Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, - unm.wsrjj.orgunm.wsrjj.org/spelling.pdf · The Different Spellings Of Jujutsu, Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, And What They Actually Mean (v2.4) Andrew Yiannakis,

point is that Jujutsu systems are significantly different from Jujitsu, or JiuJitsu systems, in more ways than just techniques, or ways and practices.

Genuine Japanese, or Japanese-based systems use Romaji (Roman letters)and the correct spelling under Romaji is Jujutsu. Jutsu in Romaji means “art”or “craft”. Of note is the fact that Jigoro Kano himself (the founder of Judo)began using the Romaji spelling of Jujutsu as early as 1887, in a paperentitled “Jujutsu and the Origins of Judo” (with T. Lindsay). Finally, theKodokan, among other major Japanese martial arts organizations, fullyadopted Romaji spelling and we see it used in reference to Kodokan GoshinJutsu, the Nage No Kata, the Katame No Kata, and in the spelling of alltechniques employed in Judo and Jujutsu.

Western, or Westernized systems rarely employ Romaji and spell their artsas Jujitsu or Ju-Jitsu. While some overlaps exist between these systems(Jujutsu and Jujitsu/Ju-jitsu, that is), Western, or Westernized systems havefor the most part moved away from Japanese Ways & Practices and theirbrand of Jujitsu/Ju-jitsu has a strong Western flavor. For example, their dojopractices tend to be more relaxed; the use of Japanese terminology is rarelyemployed, or misused; and dress (the uniform) often reflects Westernpractices or preferences. One item that stands out is the fact that Westernersoften cover their jackets with patches, and work out by wearing t-shirtsunder their jacket. In traditional Jujutsu systems such “adornments” arefrowned upon on the mat.

Jitsu in Romaji does not mean art; rather, it means “reality” or “truth”, a factthat escapes many who claim to be practicing Traditional Japanese Jujutsu,but who continue to spell it as Jujitsu/Ju Jitsu.

Jiu-Jitsu is a spelling form that was sometimes used in the early part of the20th century, before Romaji became the accepted form for Japanese, orJapanese-based systems. This spelling form was popularized in Brazil andtoday, Jiu-jitsu (as they spell it) is most often associated with Brazilianfighting arts.

Finally, Traditional Jujutsu systems have combat and self defense as theirprimary focus. Western Jujitsu systems tend to stress both self defense and,sport competition, while Brazilian Jiu Jitsu systems are primarily focused oncompetition, with some self defense included for students who may beinterested. And, the cultural practices, ways and traditions, including the use

Page 3: Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, - unm.wsrjj.orgunm.wsrjj.org/spelling.pdf · The Different Spellings Of Jujutsu, Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, And What They Actually Mean (v2.4) Andrew Yiannakis,

of Japanese terminology in the dojo, tend to differ in many ways among thethree systems discussed in this paper.

In summary:

1. The term Jujutsu is used by Japanese, or genuine Japanese-basedsystems and it’s based on Romaji (the Romanization of the JapaneseLanguage). Their primary focus tends to be combat andself defense

2. The terms Jujitsu/Ju-jitsu are used to denote Western, or highlywesternized systems (the latter may have some weak links to Japanesesystems). Such systems, for the most part, do not employRomaji and their primary focus tends to be self defense with some emphasison sport competition

3. The term Jiu Jitsu mostly characterizes Braziliansystems, although this form crops up rather infrequently as an early (early20th century, that is) Western misinterpretation of the hiraganaemployed to represent the sound of the Kanji for the ju and jutsu sounds.Such styles also do not employ Romaji.

Their primary focus tends to be competition, although selfdefense is sometimes included for interested students.

For those readers who may be interested, two of the best sources of Romajiare Hepburn’s dictionary (1887) and Henshall’s book (1988). Romaji wasofficially adopted by the Japanese Government in the early 1950s and istaught in Japanese schools.

Addendum: A Word About the Origins of Romaji (Roman Letters)

The earliest Japanese romanization system was based on Portuguese spelling.It was developed around 1548 by a Japanese Catholic named Yajiro. Jesuitpriests used the system in a series of printed Catholic books so thatmissionaries could preach, and teach their converts without having to learnto read Japanese Kanji. Later, Romaji was also adopted by Westerners toenable them to communicate, and trade with the Japanese. Romajiunderwent a number of iterations until its culmination in the HepburnSystem, in 1887. As Romaji increased in popularity, especially as a way ofcommunicating with Westerners who found Japanese difficult to learn, thesystem started to make its way into the Japanese Martial Arts and was

Page 4: Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, - unm.wsrjj.orgunm.wsrjj.org/spelling.pdf · The Different Spellings Of Jujutsu, Jujitsu And Jiu Jitsu, And What They Actually Mean (v2.4) Andrew Yiannakis,

adopted, in great numbers, by Jujutsuka, Karateka, Judoka and Aikidoka,among other Japanese martial artists.

Finally, it is important to note that the different spellings of Jujutsu, Jujitsuor Jiu Jitsu do not simply reflect surface level stylistic spelling variations.They are, in fact, portals, or gateways to different cultural ways andpractices, traditions, and styles of Jujutsu/Ju-Jitsu/Jiu Jitsu. Clearly, thisissue is about more than just how you spell it.