jv workshop handout

8/10/2019 JV Workshop Handout

1/64

15/11/20

( H)

Prepared by:

Atishi Marlena & Praveen Singh

Maanavsthali, Bhopal

Last edited: October, 2009

Feedback welcome at: [email protected], [email protected]


2/64

15/11/20

1.

I

,

: ,

,

A : D

?

A . H


3/64

15/11/20

, . . ..

A ,

, !

TIME

HAPPINESS

UNHAPPINESS

I () ,

:

I

,

.

L ,

P

.

P

.


4/64

15/11/20

: ,

Personal Problems

Loneliness, Boredom,Purposelessness

Lack of clarity on what to do, whyto do

Lack of self-confidence, inferiority

Environmental ProblemsPollution, Resource Depletion,

Vanishing Eco-systems

Climate Change, Naturalcalamities, Newer Diseases

Inter-personal Problems

Stark differences of opinion

An absence of shared goals

Lack of trust,Jealousy, hatred

Feelings of neglect, disrespect

Perception of not being understood, cared,valued

Social Problems

Poverty, Injustice, Exploitation

Corruption, Dysfunctional socio-economic-political systems

Conflict of interest, classes,Fundamentalism, Terrorism, War

,

,

, . ,

A :

/ ?

I ,

M O, P O, A O, H B

A , .

I , ,

!

Thus, it can safely be said that all problems have

their root in the doings of human beings


5/64

15/11/20

I :

.

H, ,

,

!

?!

L

H ?

A H B

E

H

E

( )

,

,

,

S

, ,

F

I S

N

R

/ .

I ,

H()

()

1

2

3 4 5


6/64

15/11/20

I

#2:

,

.

I /

, :

E

:

,

E!

P

/

/

/

.

H

!

/

.

,

,

!


7/64

15/11/20

:

.

, ,

!

/

?

J S A. N,

A, M P,

I / /

A ,

,

I ,

,

.

, , , ,

, .

J -. E CE


8/64

15/11/20

J

I

;

O

,

S

/

E(..,

)

I ,

,

E!

I

,

B ,

. :

I P

, ( )

/ ?

B ,

, ,

, , ,

!


9/64

15/11/20

F ,

I

. .

I , .

H . I

()

().

A, , .

.

.

I , ,

, .

E . S

.

I ,

, .

M , .

.

,

.

, .

D

, ,

I

.


10/64

15/11/20

:

A ? A ?

A ,

? I

, ??

H

?

A

?

OR

,

!

:

1.

: /

.

2. :

/

, , /

.


11/64

15/11/20

S, BELIEF ?

N, I O,

I ,

,

;

B ,

,

L

I

. I

.

BELIEING

( / )

D H? D / D ,

A

KNOING( )

E: A : ? ? H? H ?

E :

D I ?

?

?

, ..,

H

M

H & C N


12/64

15/11/20

1.Understanding

the Self2.

Understanding`the Family

3.Understanding

Society 4.Understanding

Nature andExistence

(.)

EF:

/ I ?

,

?

, ?

I

?

CE:

S ?

?

?

H S

?

S?

FA:

?

?

/

/ / ?

H

?

AE & EECE:

/ /

?

H

N?

I /

/

?

?


13/64

15/11/20

C H B,

B # 1, H H

E

H

E

( )

,

,

,

S

, ,

F

I S

N

R

/ .

I ,

H()

()

2

3 4 5

E

H

1

H:

1

2 F ( , , ,

)

3 / F

,


14/64

15/11/20

1. SensoryInteractions

NO SCOPE

Feels good only

when the body

needs them. Since

the needs of the

body are not

continuous, this caninherently not feel

good all the time

2. Feelings withfellow

human beings

NOT SURE

While it cannot be

ruled out as a

possible source,

our experience in

relationships

generally is of upsand downs

3. State ofpurposefulness

within oneself

NOT SURE

While this too cannot be

ruled out as a possible

source, the fulfillment from

most of the goals we have

achieved or striven for in

the past, does seem to fadewith time

?

? ?

C /

:

D ,

?

N

?

N ?

N ,

?


15/64

15/11/20

SensoryInteractions

Interestingly, once the

need for lasting

happiness is met from

the other two sources,

do sensory pleasures

also get balanced and

right-sized.

Feelings withfellow

human beings

Relationships based

on the purpose

befitting the human

potential, which would

mutually enrich all

participants offer the

possibility of lasting

happiness

H ,

,

:

State/Feeling ofpurposefulness

within oneself

Human life has a definite

purpose one that can

fulfill the human potential,

and concomitantly satisfy all

human needs. Living out this

purpose would offer lasting

happiness.

?L / .

A H A

:

,

L

( & A)

E

.. D C

L / A

C


16/64

15/11/20

E?

1.Understanding

the Self2.

Understanding`the Family

3.Understanding

Society 4.Understanding

Nature andExistence

?

1. ..

2. ..

3. .. , ,, ,

4. A, ..,

:

H !

H ( )

,

I

E

!

C,

,CJ,

P

F

: A

,


17/64

15/11/20

I ,

, ,

C

What we

Seek?

MethodsGoals /

Purpose

N

O ,

I

S

P

M

A

M

M,

P, P,

L

S

I

A,

Results

H & H

P , , , ,

F

M

M

D , ,

N

S

F

F, ,

E! A! P!


18/64

15/11/20

What weSeek

MethodGoal

L

H

H

:

/

C

A

C

Results

F

, , .

,

, ,

,


19/64

15/11/20

2.

A 1. I ? I ?

2. N ? A ?

H I ?

3. / I?

4. / ? O , I?

, , :

5. ? A I , ?

? , ?

6. N? A I , ?

7. I / E? C ? D ?


20/64

15/11/20

?

A,

H H

P

H

F HB

( )

H

F,

M , & .

N /

N ,

, L, R ., ,

E H


21/64

15/11/20

:

F, , ,

& .

K /

, , L, R

R B I

?

A ; P;

/ ?

M

( )

,

/

,

H ?

H ?

Q:

N ,

A ?

N. D ,

/ /.

;

H B: C &

A

()A

B

E H

B

, &

,


22/64

15/11/20

,

I

,

H, . A ,

:

C

,

/

P R /

. O

,

. A

,

, /

()

C , ,

S

,

,

E

F (E, E)

S, C, ,

N, C,

R

P

E

I

A !


23/64

15/11/20

,

, , , E .

P

B J, ,

A N

B / J (

)

,

L

G

K , . O,

//

(.. )

/ J

, E

A ,

J


24/64

15/11/20

/

( ))))

1. /

2. I

( )

3. I

DEE

( )

AA & CA

( D)

CHCE ( D,

, ,

) ,

EEECG

C /C

D

1. = ,

2. A ,

A & C

C

,

,

The functioning of JeevanWith a body centric, and incomplete/inaccurate worldview


25/64

15/11/20

DEE

AA & CA

CHCE, EEECG

.

N ,

.

O

,

, .

,

,

.

. .

The functioning of JeevanWith a body centric, and incomplete/inaccurate worldview (contd.)

The functioning of Jeevan ( -)

In the process of trying to build a complete understanding via this proposal

Desire()

Comparison()

Analysis()

Experience()

Choosing()

Purposive Contemplation()

Actively initiate based on

complete information of

this proposal

Understanding, and consequently,()

Resolve()

Realisation, and consequently,()

Actualisation()


26/64

15/11/20

C ())))

E E /,

/

P , ,

, /

A ( )

I , ,

C E(- )

A / ( ; )

D / (, ) E

D

A &

C

D & H

F

H

H

E HF

AA & CA

CEE DEADG

DEE

CHCE , EEECG

EEA EAA

The functioning of Jeevan ( - )In a state of complete understanding


27/64

15/11/20

B C , E

C

I ?

I / ?

I ?

,

, .

,

+ B , C E

S , J

,

R () H () L

() S () C/ ()

M ()


28/64

15/11/20

Realisation()

Actualisation()

Understanding()

Resolve()

Purposive

Contemplation()

Desire()

Comparison()

Analysis()

Experience()

Choosing()

Our actions /speech / behavior

Understanding(what goes on in the

I or jeevan)

Living it Out(what is manifested

using the body)

Technically speaking, The functioning of JeevanIn a state of complete understanding

A ,

. :

I J

P C () E R () ?


29/64

15/11/20

? I :

A H A

S/ L / E

/

E. /

.

C, / /

,

/,

.

.C,

/.

. H

S,

S

I

(

),

( )

/

/

()A /

A :

?

E ,

,

,

!


30/64

15/11/20

3. F

/

.

.

.

NATURE:

Co-existence, ever-

enriching sustainability

SOCIETY:

Trust, Justice,

Complimentariness

FAMILY:

Prosperity and

Mutual fulfillment

INDIVIDUAL:resolved by virtue

of possessing a

complete

understanding


31/64

15/11/20

E

A , ,

.

I ,

E!

I .

,

. A ...

C, ,

, ,

/.

,

A , ,

C,

I ,

I , , ,

, , . I

F , , , .


32/64

15/11/20

C, ,

,

,

P ,

. ,

E P

/

H

,

/

A, ,

H A

EEC CE

CAE

ECE

ECEECE

GDACE

EAE

EEE EGADE


33/64

15/11/20

1. ()

I ( ) : /

D , /

I ( / ) : I

, , ; I , , , E

S,

, ; /

2. /C E () A

A

C ,

C

N /

( )

N ,

3. C ()

A

P /


34/64

15/11/20

4. C ()

R P , ,

I

A // :

E , ,

D

B /

H , / /

C ,

5. E () I , ,

/ ,

A

S

/

6. G E ()

O / /

,

!


35/64

15/11/20

7. G ( ) A

G /

8. E () R

I ( //)

/ /

9. () 8 /

I /

/

L

( / )

O,

,


36/64

15/11/20

N

,

B

, ,

,

F : A ,

/

A ,

H //

B ,

A

,

, ,

C,

:

M

R

/

, , , ,

/


37/64

15/11/20

4.

:

/

E

:

F:

: A

S: ,

...


38/64

15/11/20

A H

E

H

E

,,

C

O

,

,

, ,


39/64

15/11/20

E

H

E

,,

C

E :

C

=

,

.

(E

)

H = + B

= +

S,

:


40/64

15/11/20

E : C

C

I O

D S

I

C,

P ( )

A:

/

C: A ,

E;

,

S: E

;

E :

C

/,

D

,

. A

.

.

H

. L

.

L

L

.

. L

, ,


41/64

15/11/20

E :

SC

I ,

R

M

A

B

J//

S

A

E :

E

H

E

,,

C


42/64

15/11/20

H A ( 1 2)

E :

,

, , , .

A

A , , :

C, :

A . H,

A:

A : ,

,

H A ( 1 2)

I

I : ,

: , , ,

I , , .

//

I ?

R R

.


43/64

15/11/20

H :

, : = I + B

I

H ,

,

S

S

, ,

E

H

E

,,

C


44/64

15/11/20

I ,

M

()

A

!

F, ,

,

(.)

.

. A

, ,

> >

> >

.

L . O . N

/.

: E

N

S

R ,


45/64

15/11/20

(.)

,

. O ,

C,

P ; I

, ,

P :

,

C :

P .

P , , , , , !

(.)

,

. O ,

C,

P ; I

, ,

P :

,

C :

P . P , , , , , !


46/64

15/11/20

: ?

H P M ,

:

P

M

, ,

P

N

E : S++

SE

F

E ,

D

M


47/64

15/11/20

E

H

E

,,

C

E

C

E .

N , ! /

,

!

. A ( )

. B ,

.

S

.

F E:

.

:

, .

,


48/64

15/11/20

E

E

H

,,

C

C

C

A

C ! !

C: N

A

. /

. F .

G: , ..

A ,

, , !


49/64

15/11/20

C

E

. F

,

.

.

.

,

, .

.


50/64

15/11/20

5. E

E?

I A E

O

A, ,

, E


51/64

15/11/20

E?

A / ,

:

BEHAVIORAL LEVELAll worldviews posit courses of action, behavioral recommendations, or a way of

life

which is backed by some

REASON / LOGICwhich is an explanation of why one should act/live/behave in that manner

which is posited to have a

basis in

EXISTENTIAL DESIGNThe reason/logic is based on a design of Existence / Reality, as believed and

posited by that worldview.

E? (.)

A [BEHAVIORAL LEVEL]

A worldview might recommend kindness towards fellow human beings.

which could be backed by

[PROPOSED REASON / LOGIC]

that if one is kind to fellow humans beings, God would bestow well-being upon

you.

which could be backed by

[PROPOSED EXISTENTIAL DESIGN]

There exists a God; God has such a capability; and that God behaves/functions insuch a manner; and human beings desire well-being to bestowed upon them.

,

,

E. , .


52/64

15/11/20

E?

A ,

H

H

E , ,

N,

, E

,

E , E,

E?

E :

1. E? ( ?) A, E

2. I / / ? I , ?( ?)

3. A ,

E?( ?)4. A ,

E .


53/64

15/11/20

E

1. E? ( ? )A, E

2. I / / ? I , ?( ? )

3. A , E?( ? )

4. A , E .

E = A

Matter Space

EXISTENCE

Matter is in the form of individual

units; Units imply they have

definite shape and size

Space is without shape or size

Units are localised, but infinite in

number

Space is everywhere: it is all

pervasive, and infinite in

expanse

The units of Matter are active /

dynamic

Space has no activity. It is

constant or changeless

Being active implies matter is

energised

Space is the energy that

energises matter


54/64

15/11/20

E

E , ; , .

A

, M, S

M / . A ( )

I ,

E

E

1. E? ( ? )A,

E

2. I / / ? I , ?( ? )

3. A , E?( ? )

4. A , E .


55/64

15/11/20

E = ( ) ()

I,

E, ( / )

A , .

,

,

(C. U.)AtomsTransformation

Jeevan(C. S.)Atoms

+ Animals

+ Humans

Molecules

Living Cells

Plants

Animal

Bodies

Human Body

Agglomerations

of molecular

Matter(Stars, Planets,Asteroids etc)

Bio-macro-

molecules(Amino acids,Nucleic Acids)

C.U. = Constitutionally

Unsaturated

C.S. = Constitutionally

Saturated

())))


56/64

15/11/20

,

MATERIAL

ORDER

PRANIC

ORDER

ANIMAL

ORDER

HUMAN

ORDER

Composed of

atoms and

molecules

Composed of

cells (which aremade up of

atoms and

molecules)

Animal Body +

Conscient

Entity

Animal Body is

composed of

cells

Human Body

+ Conscient

Entity

Human Body is

composed of

cells

Conscient Entities are constitutionally

saturated atoms.

They enliven bio-physical bodies of

animals and humans.

These atoms can change their

constitution, and are hence called

constitutionally unsaturated atoms

,

J ,

()

J

/

I ,

A , , .

J

J ,

, ,

I

, ; ,

C E


57/64

15/11/20

F

D A B D

B

C

M

O

C

D

A / M

C R;

R

P

O

, ,

R S

()

A

O

, ,

,

S

S ()

B;

R;

R

HO

A

F ,

K; B;R;

R

F :

E C ( 1 2)

E C.

E ;

C

E () ,

()

/ H = ; D ;

;

E.

H : I

A /

E ,


58/64

15/11/20

E C ( 2 2)

E C , ,

,

.

, ..,

,

H

,

E

E

1. E? ( ? ) A, E

2. I / / ? I , ?( ?)

3. A , E?( ?)

4. A , E .


59/64

15/11/20

LIVINGORDER

A

nimal

Bodies

Human

Body

ANIMALS

Maanav

Dev Maanav

Divya Maanav

MATERIALORDER

Jeevan:A constitutionally

saturated atom

Formationof the

conscient

+

+

Material

Evolution

Evolution of the

Conscient

Amaanav

E

STAGE 1

STAGE 2

A E

S 1 , ..,

S 2

/ E,

I

, , E

.

E.


60/64

15/11/20

E

1. E? ( ? ) A, E

2. I / / ? I , ?( ? )

3. A , E?( ? )

4. A , E .

I

,

E,

E,


61/64

15/11/20

O J,

P

P

E,

M ,

J

O

E,

A E

H

, .

E

( ),

.

. .

()


62/64

15/11/20

?

P ,

A /

A

N

I ,

S R ()

M ( / )

A

L

R ..,


63/64

15/11/20

/

Parameters of

consideration

()

Goals Behaviour

characterised

by

Manifests as

Sub-

human

stage

,

Pleasurable to

senses

Material Gain /

Loss

Beneficial to

Body

Greater fame, power,

wealth, looks, attention

than others

Inferiority /Superiority

centered

dishonesty,

spitefulness,

cruelty

Low / over-estimated self-esteem

Excessive individualism

Obsessive materialism,

profiteering, sensory indulgences

Human

Stage

Justice in Human

Relationships

Complete Understanding

within oneself and

actualising a prosperous

and harmonious family

, ,

Participation and actualization of

harmony largely at the level of

Self & Family

Complete

/ Ideal

Human,

Justice in Human

Relationships,

Harmony along all

dimensions ofhuman life

The above and working

towards a just and

undivided society,

universal humane order

, ,, ,,

While retaining all characteristics

of the human stage, the sphere of

meaningful influence and

intervention enlarges thus focusof efforts and activity enhances to

contribution towards a humane

world order

H B ( )

Dheerta Constancy of Nyaya in behaviour

Veerta Live in such a way that it engenders/enhances, in fellow

human beings, the capability to live with nyaya

Udaarta Deployment of all material resources in actualisation of

humane living / humane world order

Daya Let live and live;

Aiding a fellow human being to grow without interfering in

his life/journey;

To serve that (understanding or skill), which is appropriate

for a fellow human, based on his/her capability to grasp

Kripa To enhance the capability to grasp / understand in a fellow

human ( )

Karuna Cumulation ofDaya andKripa, i.e., to serve appropriate

material when the capability to understand exists, or enhance

capability to understand where it is lacking


64/64

15/11/20

A

(A P)

S

A.

M /

S C ,

, ,

H, , ,

jv workshop handout

Documents