kerr street show us - vancouver · suite 203 - 128 west pender street vancouver bc v6b 1r8 t....
TRANSCRIPT
N
N
City of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic DesignTEMPORARY FIREHALL
johnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
show
us
whe
re y
ou li
ve?
1aerial map
Vancouver key map
North shore
Richmond Surrey
Burnaby
54th avenue54th avenue
west
east
Ker
r stre
etK
err s
treet
firehallNo.5
Captain James Cook Elementary School
Anne Herbert Elementary school
Fraserview golf course
Champlainmall
Rosemont drive
show uswhere you live please put a dot on your home
NCity of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic Design
TEMPORARY FIREHALLjohnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
park
use
2
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
mid
mid
mid
mid
mid
mid
mid
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
am
am
am
am
am
am
am
mid
mid
mid
mid
mid
mid
mid
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
pm
How does it work : • Use blue dot for east and yellow dot for west. • Put the dots on the week schedule according to your weekly use.• Fill out notes for how you use the park:jog, walk, dog walk, shortcut, hangout, etc
help usto get to know you
I go to the east park :I go to the west park :
Ker
r stre
et
Ker
r stre
et
Rosemont drive
Rosemont drive
east
west
N
Bou
ndar
y ro
ad
Ker
r stre
et
E. 54th Ave.
E. 49th Ave.
Elli
ott s
treet
Nan
aim
o st
reet
E. 45th Ave.
Joyc
e str
eet
Euclid Ave.
E. 41th Ave.
safe zone for temporary firehall
City of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic DesignTEMPORARY FIREHALL
johnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
why
3
temporary firehall No.5Why do we need a temporary firehall?• The current firehall No.5 needs to be replaced, while that happens a temporary firehall for the crews and equipment needs to be provided.
Why here?• The locations we are considering are within the central zone of Fire District 5. It is important to be in this zone so that quick response to all parts of the district is maintained.
How long?• It is expected that the reconstruction will take about one year, the deconstruction of the existing firehall will take 1-2 months. During this time the temporary firehall will be operating. Additionally there will be time to set up the hall, and time to remove the hall and restore the landscape.• Return park to original condition immediately after it is vacated.
new firehall No.5Why do we need to replace firehall No.5?• The seismic resistance of the structure is well below current standards - a strong earthquake could make the building unusable.• The firetrucks are larger and heavier - larger truck bays are needed.• The driveway is too short: pedestrians are diverted onto 54th (with safety cones) when the truck is parked outside – this must happen daily as checks on the equipment need to be done outside• The community is growing - an additional ladder truck and extra crew will be needed in a few years as the East Fraser Lands are constructed.• The accommodation needs to keep up with changing standards - more space for larger trucks, for staff training, keeping fit and a mask repair workshop that will maintain all self-contained breathing apparatus for the entire department.• Space is needed for staff training and for public courses provided by the fire department in CPR, first aid training and blood pressure clinics.
change as part of firehall No.5 history
1911
1970
1952
1980
present day 2014
when and how long
where
2012aug. aug.aug. sep. sep.sep. oct. oct.oct. nov.nov. dec.dec. jul. jul.jul. jun. jun.may. may.apr. apr.mar. mar.feb. feb.jan. jan.
chris
tmas
bre
ak
chris
tmas
bre
ak
2013 2014
area acceptable for temporary firehall
firehall No.5 coverage area
existing firehall
proposed temporary firehall
temporary firehallpreliminary design
temporary firehall
firehall No.5
temporary firehallpublic presentation
starttemporary firehall
construction
firehall No.5 crews move to temporary firehall
firehall No.5deconstruction
new firehall No.5construction begins
staff and trucks moving from temporary location to
new firehall No.5
park returned to original state
N
12
3
5
6 78
9
1012
13
14
15
17
18
19
2021
22
4
Bur
naby
Vanc
ouve
r
City of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic DesignTEMPORARY FIREHALL
johnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
vanc
ouve
r fire
and
resc
ue s
ervi
ces
4
4.4 calls a day
firehall No.5 statisticsfirehall No.5 trucks
vancouver fire and rescue services information
+/-1600 total responses a year
1000 medical responses
200 fire alarm activated
150 motor vehicle incidents
85 public service
75 fires with damage
30 border coverage
30 false alarms
15 public hazard
10 hazardous materials
In a 24 hour period, call volume is at its lowest between 11:00pm at night and slowly decreasing until increasing after 5:00am peaking at approximately 1:00pm, followed by a slight drop before reaching a second peak between 9:00pm and 11:00pm before returning to it’s typical low period.
Vancouver firehall location
No. 1 / Strathcona / 900 Heatley Avenue (Headquarters)
Vancouver Firehalls
No. 2 / Downtown Eastside / 199 Main Street
No. 3 / Mount Pleasant / 2801 Quebec Street
No. 4 / Fairview / 1475 West 10th Avenue
No. 5 / Champlain / 3090 East 54th Avenue (1952)No. 6 / West End / 1001 Nicola Street
No. 7 / Downtown / 1090 Haro Street
No. 8 / Yaletown / 895 Hamilton Street
No. 9 / Grandview Woodland / 1805 Victoria Drive
No. 10 / University / 2992 Wesbrook Mall
No. 12 / Kitsilano / 2460 Balaclava Street
No. 13 / Riley Park / 4013 Prince Albert
No. 14 / Hastings Sunrise / 2804 Venables Street
No. 15 / Renfrew / 3003 East 22nd Avenue
No. 17 / Fraserview / 7070 Knight Street
No. 18 / Shaughnessy / 1375 West 38th Avenue
No. 19 / West Point Grey / 4396 West 12th Avenue
No. 20 / Victoria / 5402 Victoria Drive
No. 21 / Kerrisdale / 5425 Carnarvon Street
No. 22 / Marpole / 1005 West 59th Avenue
wildlandOff-road vehicle for wildland interface fires - water tank, foam and forestry hose; medical cross over - carries medical supplies and equipment.
engine / pumpThis equipment has larger high volume pumps and water tanks for structure, rubbish, wildlands interface and car fires; emergency medical response; emergency response for motor vehicle accidents - auto extraction tools; low level hazardous responses; public service calls; equipment transportation - hose, ground ladders,ventilation equipment, auxiliary power supplies; premise inspections.
firehall No. 5 factYou can see that the unit takes up the length of the ramp requiring pedestrians to walk out onto the road to get around the truck. The parking area beside the hall is on a steep grade what isn’t good for checking the truck over (pretrips). This particular unit was struck once when a cube van hit the tip of the Ladder in front of the firehall.
quint / ladder truckThis vehicle addresses structure, car and rubbish fires - (smaller pumps and water tanks than engines) - aerial rescue operations, elevated water streams for exposures and fire suppression, salvage and overhaul public service calls, emergency motor vehicle accidents - auto extraction, equipment transportation - hose, salvage equipment, auxiliary power supplies, and ventilation fans.
established in 1886
more than 800 people working at 22 firehalls, the training centre and headquarters
10 firehalls... only 4 are less then 15 years old
N
Expected pattern of response for temporary firehall based on actual calls. Majority of trips north on Kerr street.
Ker
r stre
et
Rosemont drive
N
City of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic DesignTEMPORARY FIREHALL
johnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
tem
pora
ry b
uild
ing
prog
ram
5
temporary firehall No.5 components
program requirements:
- minimize travel distance from principal building to truck bay- minimize impact on park and trees
principal building
truck bay
truck bay:- houses fire truck- vehicle maintenance
storage:- 1 container
garbage & recycling:- 9 bins
flag pole
staff on duty:- 1 captain- 3 firefighters
principal building:- operation center- dormitory / kitchen
driveway:- 48’ long
fire truck:- ladder truck- 44’ long
N
15m
39' -
4"
5.7
m
9.1m dist. from livingquarters to app. bay
public parking9 m
Apron
2 storeys 2 storeys
single familyresidence
townhouses
84.5
townhouses townhouses
single familyresidence
multi familyresidence
49' -
3"
12m
29' - 6"
Dat
e /Ti
me:
(JDA+P), and cannot be used without the written consent
files or design are and at all times remain the exclusiveAll rights reserved. These drawings, CAD and/ or Revit
property of Johnston Davidson Architecture + Planning Inc.
of JDA+P. These drawings are not valid for constructionwithout the seal of the Architects.
604. 684.3600
604. 684.3338
E-mail:
Telephone:
Facsimile:
203 - 128 West Pender Street
Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6B 1R8
17/1
0 /20
1212
: 25:
56PM
1 : 40012-oct-05
Site 1 - option 1A(R5)
vancouver firehall no. 5temporary site
15m
39' -
4"
5.7
m
9.1m dist. from livingquarters to app. bay
public parking9 m
Apron
2 storeys 2 storeys
single familyresidence
townhouses
84.5
townhouses townhouses
single familyresidence
multi familyresidence
49' -
3"
12m
29' - 6"
Dat
e /Ti
me:
(JDA+P), and cannot be used without the written consent
files or design are and at all times remain the exclusiveAll rights reserved. These drawings, CAD and/ or Revit
property of Johnston Davidson Architecture + Planning Inc.
of JDA+P. These drawings are not valid for constructionwithout the seal of the Architects.
604. 684.3600
604. 684.3338
E-mail:
Telephone:
Facsimile:
203 - 128 West Pender Street
Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6B 1R8
17/1
0 /20
1212
: 25:
56PM
1 : 40012-oct-05
Site 1 - option 1A(R5)
vancouver firehall no. 5temporary site
84.25
42m 137’ - 9”
18’ -
8”
15m 49’ - 3”16’ - 5”
City of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic DesignTEMPORARY FIREHALL
johnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
optio
n A
- ea
st s
ite
6
VFRS comments- Meets all operational needs for a temporary firehall.- As soon as vacated the temporary firehall it will immediately be removed and the park will be restored.
Pros - Community- All existing park trees remain; some lower limbs will need pruning.- Few residences impacted by headlights (note that overnight calls are less common in this fire district).
Cons - Community- Temporary Firehall interrupts existing paths.- Some exhaust fan noise behind the Truck Bay will be heard by residents behind the firehall - this is exhaust equipment that runs for 3-5 minutes after the firetruck leaves.- Some noise: twice a day, at the start of each shift, when the firetruck is driven onto the driveway and the equipment is checked through - approx 15 minutes.- Sirens average 4-5 times a day.- One boulevard tree will be removed temporarily to a nursery and replanted once the firehall is removed.- Two residences will see headlights (note that overnight calls are less common in this fire district).
Kerr
stree
t
Rosemont drive
option Aeast site
site plan sketch
site section perspective sketch
N
33.2 m
9m dist. from livingquarters to app. bay
5.5
m
Apron
residentialapartments
2 storeys2 storeys
attachedhousing
townhouses townhouses
single familyresidence
multi familyresidence
15 m
14 m
84.255%
108' - 11"
45' -
11"
49' -
3"
Dat
e /Ti
me:
(JDA+P), and cannot be used without the written consent
files or design are and at all times remain the exclusiveAll rights reserved. These drawings, CAD and/ or Revit
property of Johnston Davidson Architecture + Planning Inc.
of JDA+P. These drawings are not valid for constructionwithout the seal of the Architects.
604. 684.3600
604. 684.3338
E-mail:
Telephone:
Facsimile:
203 - 128 West Pender Street
Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6B 1R8
17/1
0 /20
122:
2 8:0
2PM
1 : 40012-oct-05
Site 1 - option 3(R3)
vancouver firehall no. 5temporary site
33.2 m
9m dist. from livingquarters to app. bay
5.5
m
Apron
residentialapartments
2 storeys2 storeys
attachedhousing
townhouses townhouses
single familyresidence
multi familyresidence
15 m
14 m
84.255%
108' - 11"
45' -
11"
49' -
3"
Dat
e /Ti
me:
(JDA+P), and cannot be used without the written consent
files or design are and at all times remain the exclusiveAll rights reserved. These drawings, CAD and/ or Revit
property of Johnston Davidson Architecture + Planning Inc.
of JDA+P. These drawings are not valid for constructionwithout the seal of the Architects.
604. 684.3600
604. 684.3338
E-mail:
Telephone:
Facsimile:
203 - 128 West Pender Street
Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6B 1R8
17/1
0 /20
122:
2 8:0
2PM
1 : 40012-oct-05
Site 1 - option 3(R3)
vancouver firehall no. 5temporary site
42m 137’ - 9”
18’ -
8”
5,7m
15m 49’ - 3”
City of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic DesignTEMPORARY FIREHALL
johnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
optio
n B
- ea
st s
ite
7
VFRS comments- Meets all operational needs for a temporary firehall.- As soon as vacated the temporary firehall it will immediately be removed and the park will be restored.
Pros - Community- No park trees will be removed; some lower limbs will need pruning.
Cons - Community- Temporary Firehall interrupts existing paths.- Some exhaust fan noise behind the Truck Bay will be heard by residents behind the firehall - this is exhaust equipment that runs for 3-5 minutes after the firetruck leaves.- Some noise: twice a day, at the start of each shift, when the firetruck is driven onto the driveway and the equipment is checked through - approx 15 minutes.- Sirens average 4-5 times a day.- One boulevard tree will be removed temporarily to a nursery and replanted once the firehall is removed.- Seniors’ residence will see headlights (note that overnight calls are less common in this fire district).- The bus stop on the south side of Rosemont will need to be relocated temporarily.
Kerr
stree
t
Rosemont drive
option Beast site
site plan sketch
site section perspective sketch
N
1 storey+ basement
single familyresidence
5.6
m
7.8m
49' -
3"
3m di
stanc
e from
living
quart
ersto
truck
bay
single family residencesingle family residence
golfcourse
15m
25' -
7"
Dat
e /Ti
me:
(JDA+P), and cannot be used without the written consent
files or design are and at all times remain the exclusiveAll rights reserved. These drawings, CAD and/ or Revit
property of Johnston Davidson Architecture + Planning Inc.
of JDA+P. These drawings are not valid for constructionwithout the seal of the Architects.
604. 684.3600
604. 684.3338
E-mail:
Telephone:
Facsimile:
203 - 128 West Pender Street
Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6B 1R8
18/1
0 /20
123:
3 6:0
4PM
1 : 40012-oct-18
Site 2 - option 1(R4)
vancouver firehall no. 5temporary site
option C
pros community- all existing park trees remain; some lower limbs will needpruning.- dog park remains available- path around golf course remains available
cons community- some noise: twice a day, at the start of each shift, when thefiretruck is driven onto the driveway and the equipment ischecked over - approx 15 minutes.- sirens 4-5 times a day.- one boulevard tree will be removed temporarily to a nurseryand replanted once the the firehall is removed.- two residences will be impacted by headlights (note thatovernight calls are uncommon in this fire district)
VFRS comments- meet all operation needs for a temporary firehall- this option has the shortest distance from building to garage,and no steps - this will give the best response time.- fewest residents would be impacted by noise from firehallactivities
1 storey+ basement
single familyresidence
5.6
m
7.8m
49' -
3"
3m di
stanc
e from
living
quart
ersto
truck
bay
single family residencesingle family residence
golfcourse
15m
25' -
7"
Dat
e /Ti
me:
(JDA+P), and cannot be used without the written consent
files or design are and at all times remain the exclusiveAll rights reserved. These drawings, CAD and/ or Revit
property of Johnston Davidson Architecture + Planning Inc.
of JDA+P. These drawings are not valid for constructionwithout the seal of the Architects.
604. 684.3600
604. 684.3338
E-mail:
Telephone:
Facsimile:
203 - 128 West Pender Street
Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6B 1R8
18/1
0 /20
123:
3 6:0
4PM
1 : 40012-oct-18
Site 2 - option 1(R4)
vancouver firehall no. 5temporary site
option C
pros community- all existing park trees remain; some lower limbs will needpruning.- dog park remains available- path around golf course remains available
cons community- some noise: twice a day, at the start of each shift, when thefiretruck is driven onto the driveway and the equipment ischecked over - approx 15 minutes.- sirens 4-5 times a day.- one boulevard tree will be removed temporarily to a nurseryand replanted once the the firehall is removed.- two residences will be impacted by headlights (note thatovernight calls are uncommon in this fire district)
VFRS comments- meet all operation needs for a temporary firehall- this option has the shortest distance from building to garage,and no steps - this will give the best response time.- fewest residents would be impacted by noise from firehallactivities
18’ -
8”
15m 49’ - 3”36m 118’ - 1”
5,7m
City of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic DesignTEMPORARY FIREHALL
johnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
optio
n C
- w
est s
ite
8
VFRS comments- Meets all operational needs for a temporary firehall.- This option has the shortest distance from building to garage, and no steps - this will give the best response time.- Fewest residents would be impacted by noise from firehall activities.- As soon as vacated the temporary firehall it will immediately be removed and the park will be restored.
Pros - Community- All existing park trees remain; some lower limbs will need pruning.- Dog park remains available.- Path around golf course remains available.
Cons - Community- Some noise: twice a day, at the start of each shift, when the firetruck is driven onto the driveway and the equipment is checked over - approx 15 minutes.- Sirens average 4-5 times a day.- One boulevard tree will be removed temporarily to a nursery and replanted once the firehall is removed.- Two residences will see headlights (note that overnight calls are uncommon in this fire district).
Kerr
stre
et
Rosemont drive
option Cwest site
site plan sketch
site section perspective sketch
NCity of Vancouver - Firehall No. 5 - Public Presentation - Schematic Design
TEMPORARY FIREHALLjohnston davidson architecture + planning inc. suite 203 - 128 west pender street, vancouver, bc V6B 1R8 t. 604.684.3338 f. 604.684.3600 www.jdarch.ca
com
mun
ity p
refe
renc
e
9
How does it work : • To give us an idea about which solution would work the best for you within your community, please peal off a sticky dot and place it on the board in the frame matching your preferred solution. • Feel free to take a sticky note to leave a comment.
Rosemont drive
Ker
r stre
et
VOTE for your preference
option Aeast site
option Beast site
option Cwest site
VOTE for A - place a dot
comments comments comments
VOTE for B - place a dot VOTE for C - place a dot
A BC