keyes v bowen dissmissal

8/14/2019 Keyes v Bowen Dissmissal

1/8

123456789

1.01112'13141516171819202122232425262728

E D M U N D G . B R O W N J R .Attorney General of CaliforniaDOUGLAS W O O D SActing Senior Assistant Attorney GeneralJ O N A T H A N K . R E N N E RS upervising D eputy Attorney GeneralPETER A. KRAUSED eputy Attorney GeneralS tate Bar N o. 1850981300 I Street, Suite 125P . O . Box 944255Sacramento, CA 94244-2550Telephone: (916)324-5328Fax: (916)324-8835E-mail: [email protected] for D efendantSecretary of State Debra Bowen

F I L E D / E N D O R S E DM A Y - 6 ^ 2 0 0 9

R y L . W h r t f i e l dD e p u t y C l e r k

-S U P E R IO R CO U R T O F T H E S T AT E O F CA L IF O R N IA

C O U N T Y O F S A C R A M E N T O- >

Ambassador Dr. Alan Keyes; Dr. W iley S. Drake, Sr.;and Markham Robinson,Petitioners,

V.

'California Secretary of State Debra Bowen; et al.,Respondents.

Case N o. 34-200880000096-CU W M -GD SNOTICE OF E N T R Y OFJUDGMENT DISMISSINGFIRST A M E N D E D PETITIONFOR WRIT OF M A N D A T ET rial D ate: N oneAction F iled: N ovember 13, 2008

V . (

1 1N otice of Entry of Judgm ent D ismissing First Amended P etition fo r W rit of Mandate

(34-200880000096-CU W M-GDS )


2/8

123456789

10111213141516171819202122232425262728

v NOTICE OF E N T R Y OF JUDGMENTT O AL L P A R T IE S A N D T HE IR C O U N S E L O F R E CO R D :N O T I C E IS H E R E B Y G IV E N t ha t on May 4, 2009, the Court entered Judgment in

the above-entitled action. A true and correct copy of the Judgm ent is attached hereto as E xhibit"A" and is incorporated herein by reference.

D ated: May 6, 2009

SA200830642310468772.doc

Respectfully Submitted,E D M U N D G . B R O W N J R .Attorney General of CaliforniaD O U G L A S W O O D SActing Senior Assistant Attorney GeneralJ O N A T H A N K . R E N N E RS upervising D eputy Attorney General

P E T E R A. KRAUSED eputy Attorney GeneralAttorneys for DefendantSecretary of State Debra Bowen

N otice of E ntry of Judgment D ismissing F irst Am ended P etition for W rit of Mandate(34-200880000096-CUW M-GDS )


3/8

EXHIBIT A


4/8

123

45

i

678910

1 21 3141 516171 81920212223

2425262728

F I L EDM A Y - 4 2 0 0 9

S U P E R I O R COURT OF C A L I F O R N I AC O U N T Y OF S A C R A M E N T O

A M BA S S A D O R D R . A L A N K E Y E S ; D R . W IL E YS. D R A K E , S R . ; AND M A R K H A M R O B IN S O N ,Petitioners,v.

C AL I F O R N IA S E CR E T A R Y O F S T A T E D E B R ABO W E N ; S E N A T O R B AR A C K H U S S E INO B A M A ; S E N A T O R JO E B ID E N ; C A L IF O R N IADEMOCRATIC P A R T Y ELECTORS: A L E I T AH U G U E N IN , L O U P A U L S O N , IA N B L U E , M AR KC IB U L A , R I CH AR D H U N D R IE S E R , L A W R E N C ED U B O IS , M AR K F R IE D M A N , M A R Y H U B E R T ,F R E D J AC K S O N , L E R O Y K IN G , R O B E R T AB R O O K S , AU D R E Y GO R D O N , M IC HA E LM C N E R N E Y , N A N C Y P A R R IS H , JA M E SF A R L E Y , JO H N F R E I D E N R I CH , JE R E M YN IS H IH A R A , JA IM E A L V A R D O , V I N Z K O L L E R ,G R E G O R Y O L Z AC K , D A V ID S A N C HE Z ,L A R R Y S H E IN G O L D , S T E P H E N SMITH, M A R KM A CA R R O , N A T H AN BR O S T R O M , R O B E R T"BO B " H AN D Y , R O B E R T C O N A W A Y , G R E GW A R N E R , L A N E S H E R M A N , IL E N E H U B E R ,K E N N E T H SULZER, S AN F O R D W E IN E R , ANAD E L G AD O M AS C AR E N A S , JOE P E R E Z , G W E NM O O R E , AN T H O N Y R E N D O N , K A R E NW A T E R S , K E L L E Y W IL L I S , S IL IS S A U R I AR T E -S M IT H , N O R M A T O R R E S , A L M A M A R QU E Z,R A Y CO R D O V A , P A T R IC K K A HL E R , A AR U N 1 ,T H A K U R , JO E B A C A , JR . , JU A D I N AS T A L L I N G S , BE T T Y M C M IL L IO N , W IL L IA MA YE R , G R E G O R Y W IL L E N B O R G ,. JA M E SY E D O R , B O B BY G L A S E R , M A R Y K E A D L E ,F R A N K S A L A Z A R , C H R I S T I N E Y O U N G , S IDV O O R A K K A R A , A N D D O E S 1 -1 00 , R espondents.

Case No. 34-2008-80000096-CU-W M - G D SAssigned to the Honorable MichaelP . K enny, D epartment 31[EKOPOSEDI JUDGMENTDISMISSING FIRST A M E N D E DPETITION FOR WRIT OFMANDATED ate: March 13,2009Time: 9:00 a.m.D ept: 31

J U D G M E N T D I S M IS S IN G FIRST A M E N D E D WRIT PETITION (34-2008-80000096-CU-WM-GDS)


5/8

101 1)1213141516171 81920212223

242526.2728

JUDGMENTO n March 13 ,2009 , at 9:00 a.m., the demurrers of respondents Secretary of

S tate D ebra Bowen, P resident Barack O bama, V ice-President Joe Biden, and theCalifornia Electors to the First Am ended P etition for W rit of Mandate came on regularlyfor hearing in department 31 of this Court, the Honorable M ichael P . K enny, judgepresiding. P eter A. K rause appeared on behalf of respondent S ecretary of S tate D ebraBowen, Gary G. K reep appeared on behalf of petitioners Am bassador D r. Alan K eyes,D r. W ile y S . D rake, Sr., and M arkham R obinson, and M ichael J. S trumwasser andAimee D udovitz appeared on behalf of respondents P resident Barack O bama, V iceP resident Joe Biden, and the California E lectors. T he Court sustained R esponden ts'demurrers withou t leave to am end, and therefore:

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED:1. That the F irst A mend ed P etition for W rit of Mandate is dismissed;2. T hat respondent S ecretary of S tate D ebra Bow en shall recover costs in the

amount of $ pursuant to Gov ernment Code section 6103.5;3. That respondent P resident Barack O bama shall recover costs in the amount

o f$o f$

4. T hat respondent V ice-President Joe Biden shall recover costs in the amount;and

5. That respondent Joe Perez shall recover costs in the amount of

D A T E D : May if . 2009ICHAEL P . K E N N YIge of the Superior Court

JUDGMENT DISMISSING FIRSTA M E N D E D WRIT PETITIONx . 2 . (34-2008-80000096-CU-WM-GDS)


6/8

123

4 56789101 11 213141 51617

1819202 12223

2425262728

Submitted by:EDMUND G . BROWN JR .Attorney General of the State of CaliforniaD O U G L A S WOODSActing Senior Assistant Attorney GeneralJO N A T H A N K . R E N N E RSupervising Deputy Attorney GeneralPETER A. KRAUSE, Cal. Bar No. 185098Deputy Attorney General ' .13001 Street, Suite 125P.O. Box 944255 (Sacramento, CA 94244-2550Telephone: (916) 324-5328 xFax: (916)324-8835E-mail : [email protected] for Respondent Secretary of State Debra Bowen30698010wpd

JUDGMENT DISMISSING FIRST AMENDED WRIT PETITION3

(34-2008-80000096-CU-WM-GDS)


7/8

DECLARATION OF SERVICE BYU.S. MAILCase Name: Ambassador Dr. Alan Keyes, et al. v. California Secretary of State, et al.Sacramento County Superior Court No.: 34-200880000096-CUWM-GDSI declare:I am employed in the O ffice of the Attorney General, which is the office of a member of theCalifornia State Bar, at which member's direction this service is made. I am 18years of age orolder and not a party to this matter. I am familiar with the business practice at the O ffice of theAttorney General fo r collection and processing of correspondence fo r mailing with the UnitedStates Postal Service. In accordance with that practice, correspondence placed in the internalmail collection system at the O ffice of the Attorney General is deposited with the United StatesPostal Service that same day in the ordinary course of business.On Mav 1.2009.1 served the attached [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT DISMISSING FIRSTAMENDED PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATEby placing a true copy thereof enclosed ina sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, in the internal mail collection system at theO ffice of the Attorney General at 13001 Street, Suite 125, P.O. Box 944255, Sacramento, CA94244-2550, addressed as follows:OrlyTaitz26302 La PazMission Viejo , CA 92691Gary G. KreepLaw O ffices of Gary G. Kreep932 "D" Street, Suite 2Ramona, CA 92065Michael J. StrumwasserStrumwasser & Wpocher LLP10940 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 2000 . ,Los Angeles, CA 90024I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California the foregoing is trueand correct and that this declaration was executed on May 1,2009, at Sacramento, California.

Scott De MedeirosDeclarant Signature

SA200830642330699418 doc


8/8

DECLARATION OF SERVICE BYU . S . MAILCase N ame: Ambassador Dr. Alan Keyes, et al. v. California Secretary of State, et al.Sacramento County Superior Court N o. : 34-200880000096-CUWM-GDSI declare:I am employed in the Office of the Attorney General, which is the office of a member of theCalifornia S tate Bar, at which m ember's direction this service is made. I am 18 years of age orolder and not a party to this matter. I am familiar with the business practice at the Office of theAttorney General fo r collection an d processing of correspondence fo r mailing with the U ni tedStates Postal Service. In accordance w ith that practice, correspondence placed in the internalmail collection system at the Office of the Attorney General is deposited with the U nited S tatesPostal S ervice that same day in the ordinary course of business.O n May 6. 2009.1 served th e attach ed N O T IC E O F E N T R Y O F J U D G M E N T D IS M I S S IN GF IR S T A M E N D E D P E T IT IO N F O R W R I T O F M A N D A T E by placing a true copy thereofenclosed in a sealed envelope w ith postage thereon fully prepaid, in the internal mail collectionsystem at the O ffice of the Attorney General at 1300 I S treet, S uite 125, P .O . Box 944255,S acramento, CA 9 4244-2550, addressed as follows:O r ly Taitz26302 L a PazMission Vie jo , CA 92691Gary G. KreepL aw Offices of Gary G. Kreep932 "D " Street, S uite 2Ramona, CA 92065Michael J. StrumwasserS t rumwasser & W oocher L L P10940 W ilshire Boulevard, Suite 2000L os Angeles, CA 90024I declare under penalty of perjury under th e laws of the State of California th e foregoing is trueand correct an d that this declaration was executed on May 6, 2009, at Sacramento, California.

Brenda SandersD eclarant SignatureSA20083064233 069 9 418 doc

keyes v bowen dissmissal

Documents