h]:&',~#auh]7,|f[~y7Z

%:eZgIg

ymZ',iZC/g}Zzgh]!*g}~ZF,+It#_5X,Zq7pzZHx:sZ*zgZzg|]

ZDwZbXZyfg)h]0}7gL&wIy~h]6,Zq-gZT~0*uzyZ+]7KXzZHxZkggzZ%A$`

pZV:~ZzgtxZgZg{HZyz}~Zq-s!h]u0p!g**xg`7Xy0+z~ZzgiIt#XRIt#Zk~X!g].h+e$WDXt!Z)aqZkgpZB

yJ]9jn%^^ r#!!*g}~=iHYyZyuzZgHX^^n^q^a^a1!me^l]xa1^u1n^n6ul

]f^{_f^l1i^f^u&1q21i1]]1]]n_

^]m^j1i1Ak]q^n^^]lmii1i1!]k1

^1mo]n6a^onj1]]oa^o]1n1e]1

n1eourkrj1i1!ul]f^{1fo^m(rj`o]aga1^

pF`n6n^!^gm(]1^^]]mfpi1!

_f^l]1j1oe^n^la1]e^n^l1]mo]mr;c1ivk

q]7ul]f^{1m1m1e+j1ooq^

aoa1(F`]^uqg]f^1_f^l^i^a1im]]f^^a1q_f^l

o]^k1k^]f^a1_f^l1e^]f^]m^a1qiun

84

_________| Zh@*:84f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________

]^k1Anj1ai^a1(qo^pv]n6+]io]

2]r^ioa1!^j^1^am]f^n^l^]]a1ul]f^{1

_f^l1]v^1q`n6n^i^]Ai^i1qgi^

`^in6^am]f^n^l^ioan6F`]^u]]f^{1n^]^^a^

a1q1]mo]mr;c1ivk]o]f^$^ek1ooq^aoa1]

]f^^omov^q^pa1+^nan6]ma1_f^l]f^m

`n6(]f^an6]1ma1]an6]f^1m1`n6(an6

]f^ma1q1]ma1!n6_f^lnn^1^ua1]e^l

oivnqnoq^1+o^ug^^u]en^a1[^1^jjn

n6a1]^u^ifn6!^uw

|])ZDwZDwz**Z:Y,^{:ZDw7XZyC~uV!*kxZzg',RV |]

!*

t!*Z,GzV$+8g6,)DDXt g6,Ck7@*Xy^ug !*]Zfg=-$6C)bMiMhZy~Zq-X

]1Apmka1in1e^ipFin`n6i1]]qj`^1m1

1^1u]m]m^rj1an6qomnoen^`n6c

7n6]m^n^l]]F`n^l^1^^]^i1an6]ul]f^{]

11e^&]mrfrj1an6q]oi^m1]]1^7

^71^]a`n651(^uw

|]ZDwgzZZ6,z:$ZqZ[Zq-X0XExF,BZ[zZufZ]~Zy

****eZkbZZ[ZZic*{Zq-Zqxx@*XpZkgZ{(,~f6MXo`DgppzZZzg{ExCZ/pZq-i!*y1spZpzZcZeZzzZyf~V~Dz{Zq-zu}(,~uJ-ZbgTXxg6,zVnVgxyZq-f6@*ZzgZ/Zq-6,].h+~4zu}6,5XZ{cZeZ~t`7gZ7YXZzg|]ZDwgzZZ6,z97x

y^ug1]mjo]qj`^oo]_|]j^oa1qoen^ag @*X1]^foa1n]qj`^Ak^]v^j^a1]]n61

^]lini^a1qeo1o1^]l`n6an6]n1]n6

ul]f^{1]qj`^]l]kkAi1an6ul]f^{1e`km^A]

poi^j1an6(^1n^n6]horj`]m^`n6aj^q

eo]]mjo1m^7]nkj^a(F`]]o]aa1J]9

]uym9]omn9owq^m]f^]jong]uio%^oq

]qj`^n6(]1]o2^`n6(q`^kfo]i^n^n^q^1!

^uw

|]ZDwZs{Vau`Z7D:uZ{yZi|]ZDwZq-xW:

|]ZDwC~tZ,VZsC~{VK0+pp Zy{Vzgn*cZeZ7nX

Z35 EG]zV~c*XZq-}.Z6,ZZyXZKyZgZ~Xzu}Z/z{ZkK6,7g}ZF,,gzg:Zybgz~ Z,~@*,X

7,}XutZ/p97ZknZ,VZk!*]Z0+Zic*Zyc*ZAx~@*gzZu]c*)%gZ]!*Z]7D?Zi]wZEwGYDXZyAYZkd%6,**7@*z{xZq-zg6,ZEwDXucZeZZq-zzzg]7gZ@*XM`pbZL6,ZzV~(,~uJ-~ZzgZ[z{|g6,Y~7CXZzg:Zk!*]_cC!*]jx7$z{|c*Z%zZ7Xbic*{ic*{Z,)b0ZK"{ZgCc*Zy~ZYZ35 EGCZzg)%gZ]r-.5 EG]ZzgZ:bzu}xZ],zV

y^ug 4ZygZ]ZzgZy6,n6Zwc*jzMhVXnul]f^{1]mA+1]n1`j1an6n1ql^

^a1A]in11]^m^]]mjo]qj`^oen^`

p!n^`^t]mjol]i^a1!]q11]ma1

],m7o^]pu^ne]p]^^pojoln1q

eio1pn^o]`n6j^i^(^uw

|]ZDw7z:|]ZDwZ5ZYy6,Wtz{Zx|]ZDwZyP{!*&C~

tz{zggkTZq-k,|]ZDwNMhpTzs#Zk ]xX,].h+%e7zu~kBxaZZXZ[J-Zs=Zzg~Zzg

ZkZ@*g]ZzZg~zGz{uJ-{mi: [constructs] Zzg!gXy^ug zgV7gZDgXpZ[z{Zk.7g{i:~c*izgV7gZX

mej^11^an6q^1opoin6n^an6]ino

]on^a1[]qmeo1`^tn6]oinJ;^

2^aj1an6(q1po(ino]orj1an6mo]]v]j^h]

]l^kh]qm`1i^71_^einn^q^1!`u^]1

n^n6i^m^^a1q`^7a^1^]inai^a1]a^1^

Z[Pl]|]ZDw0:ZziCZzgb|] u4njai^a1!^uwZDwZyZOW,ZyegzVsXZ,VZq-x{~M@BZzgf!iZyMiZ~ZzgZqiMZc*Xz{kwgnpZknyz*y

15

_________| ZHzy15f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________

U*3Zyjw(,~uJ-IZ0*c*ZzgZzz gzZVZyOW,K%7g{mX)IZzgZyQps:mXzzZyx"gZsZVCZkbq**z{Zyi:fn.JwVXU*5IS

I J.H. Stirling c*x[XZk5i0+~Iu(,Z4XZ7#5681&A) E|6,Zq-ZA

zZgeZ6^zZzg|]ZDw:uc*l/?zZge,ZmftZzgZk;CZkZ;]s7

Zk;C,IZKf&n!*]~HYYz X[G.F. Stout] XZntYXZpZ6z^ [Conative] ZzgZgZ~ [affective] @*W,~ [congnitive]

7HXzZgeIZyV!*]Zq-@* [Willim McDougal] Zzgz@zXfZ]p~Z**Zgc*dwiZy!*]]0@*c*Zzgn_./

ZgZ~/~c*fZ] ZnZ0+gaZ@*X_./aZZk/~p~zZCXdwCTfg)KZdwuiDXg}Z]gZ/7D]6,@*W,Z]ZW,aZDXZkbzsZkaZ@*ZzgZ]ZgZ{ZzgZKf&UViZkbYCX|]ZDwZk$ EGZkbyH

y_f^ln6mi^f^u& zsZ]{7@*Zzg:Z]zs%aZMhXineom1]^o2noa1!ul]f^{oin`n6(]`1

eo1n6]o^+^J;a1i1(]m]mo^+^qk1

^i>eq^ioa1(]ejoao^+^a7n6]1n1]j1J;1]oe^]

]i^^]h]u]jm`oa1qul]f^{1_f^ln6irmn^]q^mul

]f^{(J]9]u(un]m^11q^m^p^p]io%^o

im]jjm71`a^a1(^uw

h]|]ZDw6,z@gcgZW,Z]:ge$,7H(,~uJ-z

h]|]ZDw6,!54h GHY

^ZzgZW,Z]:$45

HGY

^,,OW,XZk4,q-|ZZgzqZzgz{MiZZf;yfZ]Z**p~ZzgZygZ]6,Xtg|iykyZzgZY!*CXZYMCg|fp~Z**c*p~Zzgf]XZYg]ZyM**g}

ZgZuXZ/piy)ptIOZZ~fzZ]ZEZzgz{ZZxfzZ]M:~Gfg=zZhX}.Z ~CCgSXc*Zq-btYg~gL

e{fZ]7Zq-bz{Zq-ZZ~fZ]Xz{Z/pfZ]ZEZzgZk-*IZybpZq-gfZC}.ZzZg~XiyZzgzz

yul]f^{1 7XZzgfzZ]!*Hyz{zgZZzg)iq~',ZggX_f^ln6mi^]^an6ep((]l(]^n^An

1]^pn6+^a]a1(]eeo{1ul]q]v^

]m1]1ul]f^{]rno]1`1^111_f^li]eeo{1

vfk1e^aA1(^uw

h]6,&f!Z*t:|]ZDwZyVZE+{:ZgZE+{i!*y)]zze

ZzgbZkaHZk~|]ZDw@*gz7MXZyZgguT|]ZDwOW,Ht:

t]gzqg7DX 1tZKfzZ]|bBZzg$45

HGY

^z{ZydwZzgMiZYX 2tfzZ]M:~ZW,5+k,~b"2. JEEE',@X 3t}.ZztDZzgZyV~ZkR}.Z|ZzgfzZ] 4~tZzggu0*YXfzZ]adwc*CCgSZknz{$45

HGY

^z{MiZX 5|7fzZ]zzZk~wX 6tIZNZ]nZ#e$ZzgLM#X 7tZ35 EG]zq7CXZK!*]ZZCZzgZ35 EG]Zy 8!*]C6,Z~.CX

|]ZDw,~;Z:Zs]kzc*:`::Zy)~V7gZ@*XoZ#0Zzgyz*

55

_________| 55f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________

VSX|]ZDwZkg{eJ@`znZknzgZsZy:ZzgZ/6:zZVZkZsx=Zzgc*ZzgH

yul]f^{1nft1]j^]1j11]1^] YnXh]o_^eki1ooi^h]qminm^jf1

_^hn^q^1(n]mul]f^{1_f^l1hn6]meo

^^a]!_f^lhn6]mj^h1fn^q^i^a1]

]ooinn6]j^h1f^u&jr1q^i1an6!^]

n6mf^u&]m1]qfoan6]oi`neov^a1(eonoj^e7n6

eo]^u]^^aoj^a1(^uw

|]ZDwZ:Zs]kzc*:Zs~g,ZZY

yul]f^{1_(i^m]^pn6]f^u&+`p^o ,!*c*Xjoa1!hn6o]u1++n^i^(^e]_fnn^io]laa1

i1(ul]f^{]1a1(^uw

|]ZDwh]f[{6,ZsxD:H|]ZDwZL].h+,f[**zZ?h]~Dgw;vZzgz&k545 E

YHEHZq-jZ!7M:=|]ZDwZyVzZVXpeZyw*,

ge$sgg6,aZg;X

2^n^leo11in]l]i^n1e^cn6^an6!mul

]f^{oe`ke EXZ35 EG]fg)Q`Zg

z&4k5 EYEH",~ bZzggCgCt!*]I`~|**xZq-X

ZF,+zV~Zq-XZy~{mg6,Zzg~-g\zZ%M~ZkZL)ZzgMzZ,gcge$|c*gzq+Mze$gzZgZ]?HZzg

y]+2:,9^o`oj^h:mn9n Z35 EG]{g`c*Xeo]m^e]_fn^io^^ng`^q^1,^w!ul]f^{meo [Tractatus]

i^qm11^e]_fnn^io]ljaa1an6(unk

]cp+oio]pFeo]jj^maa^i^en^p]l^

q]hcj^a1(^uw

|]ZDw;vz**zZ:~Z~zg].h+~:~z&4k5 H

YEHBzuZ(,Z**x;vX;v,}gs,eLXZzgZkt Martin Heideger 6791X9881Y

7XpP!*'Zk~ZM`|]ZDwn';vZw,ZEZwzHtZq-Z(ZwTZ[7c*HZzgM`tZwZnZtZ[_cg;Xz&4k5 H

YEH4,q-tZwZzgZ/9V{mZzgZkZ0p;vw~ZkZwZ[s`xZzg`

yul]f^{1_f^ln6a^n;m,]]1]j^ i!*yZzguJ--**}MhXa^ou]`n6j^qgul]f^{1`n6e+^7]an,^

112^+1i1n Phenomology (Existenailism a2^i^!

85

_________| ZVzy85f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________

ul]f^{eo11qmi^l1^]i1!unl],ne^lma1

_f^lul]f^{+jjen6o11oql`n6o]

ul]f^{]mno1nn^q^i^a^!ujoFJ]9mjo

ul]f^{^81efn^q^1(me^ia1]

`u^1qmmk7^m!^uw

|]ZDwbZzg

bZV7Z,Vb0Z,c*]bVzZu]Zzg/c*]~4DVX|]ZDwZ,c*]cZzg]Zq-*`7Hpt`:Zzg[ic*{ZzgczssV~XZk~7y+~Yghh+Z(/gZT)~gZ]ZZ_H

Z,Zzg ZzgZyZLx~Zk]ZEwHA|]ZDwHXZ(x@*z{,~ZgY:stl!zZZk(,~uJ-OW,Xz{tB

i0+ZysZKygCTz{z].Z;ZzgY9BXzu}Zp {b~|]ZDwbptDz{Z[zC]=Zzg**xZzgZknZKy/C~ZZ@*X|]ZDwbpZq-zu~(ZkZ

D: o9L7Zk&go9LDTZq-bZyZEw@*X|]ZDwbfg)|J-pZ[:

LLE!*]tIZzgZqwZ/pZ&gZEwDpZL~Zz6,yK 7VXzV|J-)Xg|

Zk-!*CZZ[zC~**bxX 2Xb|C~ZjZwcCZzgZki_{gYX 3XbZgYZk]Zkz_M(,Jg;VJ-Z[zCZzg 4XjZ_mGz]zVgZ]ig{g`gXZkbbZKyZ|szgZKyI/qX 5X

qgz!*0*]~&My~z:stgnMDz{9y7X|]ZDwbfg=

G.Cantor, R. Bacon, F. Bacon; Eddington, Duhring, Hans I.

Newton, J.S. Mill, I. Kant, Driesch, C.Darwin, A. Einstein;

K.Jung, A.Huxley, T.Hobbs, Whitehead, H.Spencer, Max

Planck, Ouspensky.

yqm^1ag^]$f^lm^u^nk$^ek1o]mk]m

r`]mka1qooen^m6`n6an6(m1+n7]]mk1jfo

j^en6]en^7o$^ekioan6(qm^oA^o]

n]]pr11e^&fv&n]a]a1qgqm^]m^

i^mi`mg(n^l(]F`n^l(]j^]l(^e]_fnn^l($^k1aoa1!

ul]f^{]]%enjqmmkmqm^1^e]_fnn^io

1^]a11e^&]1]magu^nk^^r>

nj1an6(^uw

|]ZDwZq-(:LL/&C~V6,ZLM\i:~C@*X~RCRZzgg~RXtV

!*nKM35 EG]]Zzg;]qX35 EGCgZ]~|]ZDw4,q-ZzgC~g{g].h+35 EG]

jZZ,V [Whitehead] Zkg~Zq-Zz[aZHX|]ZDwz;V$LLg6,tU*"$c*e$gzZt!***.ZfX

Zp~tt{].h+ [Whitehead] |]ZDw:LL6,zWz;V$~XZkb35 EG] [conjecture] t]pZ[Zzgzu}w

pZKCzV6,Wzg~ZLF,Z{4~=qZzgz{!*CgztTe$|xU*"$HX!*Hy{z]6,ZXZkbbZgYZ[]Zq-Z(u

7@*|]ZDw4,q-%[X6,zWz;V$jZ!z{tsLL]zZ7)w~zZz{jZ_Z(xZq-!grX|]ZDwWZ6tZhbzZ::

|]ZDwiy0EHcz$ EG06,WDZyIZ/iVwEHZ+LLZL~ZzgpZK::L)zc*:gSt7MhZq-b_5GLi:~ZOW,CXZzgg6,tZyZYZCi:~7XZbZ/i:Zq-0+~Vw6,k,ZkZZYZZzguuzVg7

26

_________| !*j26f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________

MhX'h+',MVZ/iSsZkxZzgYinZq-Zzgigzg]7,}XTzZ0+Zi{c*YnXiVZkg6,[?Bgc*MC&4i JEV6,].h+WjZ|]ZDwkyZq-Z,ggT~{

XkyZ[MiZ7Zkz!*gZ#xZYZk~UYNXjZ!|]ZDwiyzkyZF,t@*GDZzgM6t [Cantor] 42.GEH

iV|Zg~ZzgZkkya ZsZ/pZk6,ZyZZnttZsZgXtZZnx@{6,FF7Zq-Z35 EGCZZnXZkn|]

Zy1Yz{Zq-WiZ!7gLZzgLw ZDwZkzztCDZ/igZ+jw~|]ZDwtZZnM6t ~Zq-{Z%0Y@*X

XjgZ~Z/|]ZDwZktZhb1@* Zs9g6,:KaZZyul Zyx@*].h+bo`35 EG]"ae$~ZkyJw7CX

]f^{1h1]o1eqm1^_^`n6n^!ONUMn6qg

_f^livma1i1!]e]anun1^]m1q]hn6j1an6l

aon611^_^i^a1!o]ip1^n6j1an6

n6A%p

szu~s [solipcism] YZkxZq-sxe$ zeg$:Z35 EG]sXb]gzq~$:

;]~|]ZDw35 EG]ZkW6,zDTgz].h+35 EG]{gzZg6,W]gzqgZ3wgX|]ZDwa]Zk?ic*{zi!*]tC].h+;CttZKZqw}=gfZzgZk:wtHXZ/ptggZg6,

]|]ZDw~~p~:Dxfg=7X~~ZxHZKy_.!*]ZzggZq-gZ{6,YXpZKDgXZ[t!*]zu~

ZzgzXZk ].h+[!*zZzgZkZx(,~zzZkyx[,]~z{Zq-qzu~sZku)YDg~zV]gxygl**ZgY@*X|]ZDwC~}.z{ww:

Zk6,O{tZq-No]~*z].h+zf!+Z,DZKyZy~Y@*X}Zq-(bV',z;V$MZ6gieEHZ~Z0xx',}V42. GEHZzgZz_54h

EFZZzg\V**xaXZ/Zy\V-jZDh+~MYCpZk',s~ZZq-Zzg:LtY@*zu}xz{+Zq-!*]DgeYDXZkniyZz]tYZ+w$zg~zuzVc*izgygZc*Yg;XZkZN!iZzgik,zz|]ZDwC~}.z{wwY@*X

|]ZDwZzgI"Z:I"~zsZzgZgZuK@*XZq-Z!*]Zk0ZIt#~

WX}.Zza|]ZDwZkI/CZgZzgMyZkMe$~z{Zzwz{Myz{Cz{!*Zk$ EG0uZrlDpZkuZrgZj6,

ZEwOz{}.ZzJ-aZq-{gZ3Z(gD',z;V$gMZ6Zzg',}yV/g@*XZka|]ZDw4,q-txe$GXZsZgYc*zu}gZ]|]ZDwVVt7DX}',}y!

ZggZka&ELJw7Zk~e$**aX',}ye$te$p&Z/p|]ZDw~e$pt7ZgYsZq-gZ{Zzg!*gZDzXZgYMgt!*]U*"$7t]Zq-d"_.i:~CgX|]ZDwZzg',}VZzgZsx:IZ:ZzgZZ`:

)].h+xZs+

ZDw~tgsyX|ZsgcD|]ZDwZsxgzZ]Z{41 XGc*',}gZ]DZzgZygZ]gz{MMc*]5Dz{ZZik@*XMiZw+bZL&~z{MMc*]Zy(t

+}Z{yz){Z7 ].ZZzgZk!*g}~z{yz*yzu}XZ/pZ[4,zwzkZwzksVZq-{mzZc*ipZkZw

ZKfNMVZg !*Z0+Zi@*z]Zq-Z(zqY@*.pYp

^1wg;XXVI!*]zqc*xzq7stI!*]xg6,fZCD

ZkaZy}**eXZ/|]ZDwtIt!*]zsgnpZzg~Zzg:CzV6,ZygZ]HYYg@*Zy!*]}eCXZzgts}

y^ -!*]DX 7Z,ZgZ]YY.D1m`^7ul]f^{1i1a1uo]F`o]^keo`^mk

eio1^i>m^a1q^aa1]noen^]]uo

f11m^7]^^lai1an6(^uw

|]ZDw!*]~z:j6,e;:Z,V

"qzZ{5 GEG]o}bMhpZkD7X ZzgZky1m`^7]nc]-1eo1^`^]n^a1n

hn61`n6qire1]u]o+kn6A1]q1h^

]^a(agin^lva1]mnhn6`n6q``^q^i^a1

m]^h^^imj^a1!me^lpa1^]oeo]o

]F`n^l(]1in^l]1^(j]lan6qe22]]m^ao^

]1^A^i1an6(^]1]m^^]mumeoa1m

]m^^eim(^e]^eoa1(ag]^1n6em`oa1!^uw

tZwH,c*gc***gZq-dZwTZ:tZy,c*6,7@*XZk!*]zs#~Zkg6,YVtC~zztgI"0dZ]ZzgI"gppzZZ]0Z]Zq-HXt!*]I"~}.Zy@*Zk

CZW,Z]%A$MhXZzg}.Z6,ZkZZyZko{g6,7 Z0ZkHYYXp"Z+VJ-F"Z+.5G]b70MhXydMoZk[Zky@*ZkZ}gZ]KYXI,c*Zigzp

y Zky[{g`ZkaZy0t**ttc*f[g7X1m`^7oeo]_|^oA^o(^,nr^a1]]nc^]

n^a1]h1`^t11]o]_|ZZ^sXX^j1an6

]]o]_|^]^i1an6(ho]_|ZZ^sXXo]o

]_|^jf^`n6a1]mn]]]_|a1^so]_|^

^iqe^iqeo`n6a1(a]_|]oi^m(i`mg(^e]_fnn^l(

n^l]n^l1joa1F`]ho]_|^s^jf^`n6`^

q^j^(^uw

|]ZDw:,p~qZLi EE0p~q~|]ZDwZ#yq#43GEkZzgZ0!J/

ZkZgAZrVZKMgZY^~Z]6,H}Zq-~*iZ+{y:LLZ#+M].h+TZg{~ZL*y~HX,Z#yZq-~

c*}Zq-zu~(:LLVJ-=DLL8m~ZZZzgi0+Zzg7XLLZ#s,W@*ZzgQZW,Z]zzxZzg!*g~\fZ]05VBt7@*~gzbZksz]CX

iEE0p~:|]ZDw,sc*f!#auzl/?

LLi EE0s0|]ZDwtgZh+x@*|]ZDwc*]Zq-DOg6,Zk@|]ZDwZLc*]y~:=z.ZY:Xp|]ZDwxfgZr_Zk!*]x~GOG7C|]ZDwpLLsZq-,7H&z{i EE0p~XZkZq-Z45 EG]T~]|cXZq-tDT~DJZYZzgZkZzgxgeZq-xZtZq-,zZq-;]nz{,Zq-xTC|fZ]6,gXZzgTbZ0!+#43GEkZq-^Zg

[Mc Zzg!545 GYH

GY

^ [James Ward] zZge [Alexander] Zb|]ZDwt,ZYEhg

Vx/Zgc*YYX Taggart]|]ZDw:]I&ZzZg

|]ZDwp]I&ZzZg~HXT~zgZZyXzuZZzgZc*ZnZ6Zk**xCZq-,zu]Z#|]ZDw$ EG0 [X]X,zu>Z~ZKZgZ{MiZ~|7XZk',s|]ZDw `X

LLZ**MiZ~tDX]w:

|]ZDw4,q-Z#ZKyiyzkyf6MiZ~qz].Z;ZKZ**X] [duration] x@}sz@*Zq-Z+|z].Zy0*@*zgZyc*%zg

96

_________| Q96f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________

Zkz].Zx@{qC [category] wZzgz(,~nXgM 5GtZq-BZ%Zzg,zu>ZZq-p]:Zzgzu>ZZk}~}.ZZyU*XD-q70*c*Y@*Xzu>Z

,ZkZSx@z].ZyZq-=IZ@*T|]ZDwZg~7X]Zkp~)7Zk~6Zk**]ZL(tMiZh+Zzgxz~MDgTVZzgX}.Zg!*:Xtg|p|]ZDw

Zp~ZkfZ]!*g~gz]ZF,!gV~{/DgTXg}bz~$ EG0t]L:zZZq-XZgZ{!Z: XzzYg~XDZ: Xh+7MhXbpP]i!*3bZzg]gzV0*Zkk,6,g7XpZk!*zt]DZ: X~XZzg,z$ EG0_.ZyU*X{gYz6,ig~MXZkatxZ: X~gZzgppDZ: X6,{Zzgu7Y$XfZ]Z: XdpJ-Yg~g{YX

Zk,it7ZkfZ]!*g~Zq-Z(gq@*ZkZgZ{ZzgwZzg]~h+Ot7@*Zzg}.ZZq-Z(Yg7@*Zq-{]pdw:XZZVwZ35 EG]ZnYgs}.Zz0+zkCxdqZq-`7CXT~Z[zC}x7C}.ZdqxCMCX

U*"$HYY: spritualist monist |]ZDw"2. JEEEbgzb6,zuC|]ZDw4,q-i0+SXi0+7gBbX}.ZpZq-

b|]ZDw, [Leibniz] XZ/pX]ZZg]X"2. JEEEZZ]bXpZktB"2. JEEEZC~gu}T$

Z#|]ZDwZZAggnpXzu>ZZzg|]ZDw~ [windowless monads],zV|gzqZzgZq-bXzVfZ]!*g~zZZ#ZtDzV

guXp,!z~Zkgzqzu]6,ic*{ [spiritual monism] Vgzqzu]izgX]Zk~Zg~X7XZk~7ZgZ]*ZK(xp

|qwZq-ZzgzZq-w0Y-VZ/e|]ZDw,Zq-z~MhZzgZk],ZgOZkgzqzu]6,izg}Zk"2. JEEE

U*"$MhX [spiritualist monist] gbZq-gzb6,zuCzu]Zzg]tZ%sXzg',ZgZ0x@*X|]ZDwg

07

_________| ,07f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________

bZzgZgZ{ZK2sXi0+ZkUn{g~~4z6,ZyZZyXZzgZzzx{7HV6, [pluralistic] xOZq- [monistic] Z,VZq-zuC

Z**MiZ~ZzgZgZ{BXk,Zq-:zZx7{g`~g6,Z+~pZ0+gzgZzgZk.+B

GGZk**]Zk]~7{X

,|]ZDwZzgzu]Zi}7V:$ EG0 [ultimatereality] Zk!*]g]ZgZ{eC~|

ZD:pg}ZLx$ EG0Zk!*]J-$g~MiZ~zZMiZ~ZzggZZ(gzZZ(gXZaVJ-ZXmi EE0|]ZDwZzgi EE0zu>ZZLi}Zg7VXZzgzV~C~iq7X

VJ-zgZ35 EG]ZwZk~yZzgZptz{zV(,~uJ-zXZ/Zg|]ZDw4,q-.+B

GGZk**]giZwtaZZy

Zk**]pHzgXZ6,Mc*tZk**]Z**c*7Xg]~MiZ~p7XZzgZ/tZk**])!wZzg)t6|]ZDw(tztC@*ZzgZyg}.Z3

EGGBg;QfZ]6,zZ7@*XZ

LLh ]]vm_n]^]_^n zu}Zp~[Z+Z0!ZkbZZHXLL\z@*ZkXzZDq@*?fgZDZ

~{~ZzgZsgzZe$~g}.ZZfZ]z]sz$h4->GIEGX}.Zz0+zz

ze$DZXZgZ{zg]ZzZDfgZ)bzZhgX|]ZDw;Vg}.ZcMi.5GCX@*Xz}.ZD!*g}~,

zZzg:}.ZDDfg=Xt~Z|gtHXMk54YHGEZ#gzZe$

Z gz~Zk!*]t@*ZK=ZK]o9LZYzZVq-zX\V4,q-}.Zz[bU*"$HYYXto]c*bzV~!*YMh

XnZybI!g6,}.Z:c*CZZZkz6,?DXZ#yZK:|ZgZDe

Z#yZ[J-,

HzZzgC~g6,Zq-7?Zkq6,qct7ZZk6,ZrZK/z

+CXZq--RTfg)]~ZziDXtR)7CpZkRz{ZK/Zq-RZzgCTz].Zyc*I/MhX|]ZDw4,q-t/z@*ZzgZkC6,ZKyZxYXt!*]}.ZZn&ZKyZk/C6,{5 GEGC^~@*XZkMU*"$az{x[bZka**U*"$DtbZKZq-Z(gDczn6,{g`5+k,X

tg97Zq-Z,Zw**x7ZY6,{g`ZyZzgE@*tZq-gz]})Zky(zCX:zZzggxy&gz{97tzVC~g6,Zq-X|]ZDw,zzpf:

t!*]C~g6,,pfXp|]ZDwZk!*]M(,JaXZZzgbgZ1Zy~',z;V$',}VX~Z~Z/!*]s

Zk~6,ZzgQZkZ0+gz?zs#J-zgSic*{ZY',Zzgz;V$',R,hgZzg',}VZ~@Ogz^WZkaZy~CZq-0*kZq-Z+!*]~?|]ZDw7gZkaZ/ZyjZ!*]YQZyZL}~F,VC6,'ixMX}.Zze$k7gz:|]ZDw

Zk I"Zzg Zq-%Z/,CzZY}.ZK%MyY@*X|ZsZq-Z+p~g]~@*T[Zzg!X}.Z:

TbZK X}.ZZq-Zq-p~ZKp~~ZbZdzZgp~F,gzfzZ]~,

TZ(gK%yCu7}MhXZy!*V-Z!*]e7@*P)]E+{Zzg~x@*X|]ZDw0WZ]**zZ:

Zk,~ttI!*]Z]ZZ@*pZkBZy!*]6,Z,I!Gz]XCp/7X}ZzgzmXt

&454 EGJGE7}6,**fgZZzgZ/pZy~\VZ,~MyZzg|]ZDw,@*G7@*X|] ,~ZZY~ZkpZy:gDy

ZDwTi:~`~gZi:~6,W~xZZkZyzgzZ**ZOY** Zkzu~^ZK"Z/ZkWi,Qt/W\OY ecX

Zk,~tp~fg)}.ZI"bz7tZq-[gX|z{6,:

ZKD~:cznZzg:qXcznq@*XqcznX!*]h+uJ-.$d$XpZk!*[~~**VZEwZka/m,@*VZkxVaZZkyic*{@*X~Z~Z/|]ZDwM(,Jc*Yh+M`

|z{g}Zz6,CXZKyZk ZsZwg6,t|]ZDwZyx}.]zg h+ZkGz2 Zs~Zq-|X

yul]f^{1_f^l1]eo ZyV"i!*g}~X 11m1]ooinqm^q^n^]^ojnr^^

mifa1ZZunka1qaaioa1XX+m^]^funka1]^

2unka1(unk^qo`n6]oaioa1+m^]^o(]1

]]c^(^l(]a^l]m1mgu^oA^q,^an6!]^J

]18^J]i^^1]o]mq1o^]imx^^

a1!ZZunka1qr>aXXmounk3>`n6a1(makino

q^ioa1(inaioajoa1!nm]a]^o^^^a1]aa

a]-]-m112j^a1F`]enka]7unjn6ajoan6(i^m

n6]^]i^hm^n71m`^7eo`n6j^!n^J]18^J

]i^]o]]m^oimxa1ununkoo2n`n6!a

^(a`(aununk1i]linj^a1!c7n6

ununko2n`n6m]^o]]]coin^^a1!^uw

47

_________| aN47f~Z7241 i _________

_____________ 6002Y c i _____________