king county’s water quality benefits evaluation (wqbe) · q4 2019. q1 2020. q2 2020. q3 2020. q4...

15
Science Seminar November 2019 Water and Land Resources Division King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE)

Upload: others

Post on 04-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Science SeminarNovember 2019Water and Land Resources Division

King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE)

Page 2: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Package A

Package B

Package C

Phase I Objective: Develop and apply an adaptable toolkit that provides transparent, standardized methods for evaluating water quality benefits of projects and programs.

Key Deliverables: Pollutant loading model, SUSTAIN model, causal model, evaluation and summary report

Page 3: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Potential Pollutants(scope for ~10)

SolidsDissolved copperDissolved zincTotal PAHsTotal PCBsTotal phosphorusTotal dissolved nitrogenBacteria: E-coli and fecal coliform

Page 4: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Per unit:Cost $________Pollutant reduction ________Other benefits ________

Page 5: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Cost $$

PollutantReduction

Page 6: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

DRAFT August 26, 2019

Potential Basins for Pollutant Loading and Cost-Effectiveness Analysis

Assessment Points

WTD Service Area (11)Outside WTD Service Area (3)

Basin Catchments

Page 7: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Package A

Package B

Package C

Page 8: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

We improve water quality to protect:

Page 9: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints
Page 10: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Bayesian Network Example

Water Temperature

Riparian Tree Cover Hyporheic Exchange

Substrate TypeTree Planting Program

Page 11: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Package A

Package B

Package C

Page 12: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Method Development Tool Development Evaluation Report

Q3 2019 Q4 2019 Q1 2020 Q2 2020 Q3 2020 Q4 2020 Q1/Q2 2021

WQ

BE

Schedule

Project milestones:• Water Quality Endpoints Selected• Water Quality Projects and Programs Selected • Water Quality Projects and Program Fact Sheets Completed • Pollutant Loading Model Completed• Causal Model Completed • SUSTAIN Model Completed • Evaluation and Summary Table Completed • Synthesis Report Completed

Page 13: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Project Team OverviewProject managers: Carly Greyell (KC); John Lenth (Herrera)

Project/program development leads: Blair Scott (KC); Alice Lancaster and Brian Busiek (Herrera)

Pollutant loading and SUSTAIN modeling leads: Jeff Burkey (KC); John Riverson and Steve Carter (Paradigm)

Causal modeling team: Jenée Colton (KC) – overall task and orca model Timothy Clark (KC) – technical methods and swimming beach model Jennifer Lanksbury (KC) – fish/shellfish consumption models Kollin Higgins (KC) – Chinook salmon models Beth Sosik (KC) – technical support

Page 14: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Additional Acknowledgements

Several local causal model experts are providing guidance and technical support for this project:

Phil Levin (UW/The Nature Conservancy)

Tessa Francis (Puget Sound Institute)

Dr. Bruce Marcot (U.S. Forest Service)

More to come!

Page 15: King County’s Water Quality Benefits Evaluation (WQBE) · Q4 2019. Q1 2020. Q2 2020. Q3 2020. Q4 2020. Q1/Q2 2021. WQBE. Schedule. Project milestones: •Water Quality Endpoints

Thank you.Carly Greyell, [email protected]; 206-477-4703Water and Land Resources DivisionKing County Department of Natural Resources and Parks