kingcast v. ayotte, nh gop, nashua pd r 59e motion 2010-cv-501

7/31/2019 KingCast v. Ayotte, NH GOP, Nashua PD R 59E Motion 2010-CV-501

1/19

EN SAJ ZNESJC XS@SJX CEXS[EHS HGZ[SNJY A@F\XAE[J

HA[EXSG\AJ[ MENI" D.C. %`'m'` [email protected]" % H@XJ NG. ;


2/19

aj{xjbo !FhHòoj{su {jhzxjc aj{xjbo o{gf xjvj{`b gsaj{ h`xjx cz{eni saj x`fj sefj

|j{egc% FhHòoj{su `nc Dzcij \`zb K`{k`cg{g enxsj`c enese`bbu enxexsjc sa`s \bènseoox

[zbj ;1 ZXH 3:: Fgsegn y`x hgf|bjsjbu yesagzs fj{es.

Cjx|esj saj |{jxjnhj go hgnobehs saj Hgz{s njvj{ ozbbu `cc{jxxjc saj o`hs sa`s

FhHòoj{sux [j|g{s nc [jhgffjnc`segn xagzbc a`vj kjjn _gecjc o{gf saj [jhg{c.

Yajn \bènseoo h`bbjc og{ Dzcij K`{k`cg{g sg Hj{seou aex Cjhexegn cjnueni \bènseoox

Fgsegn en sa`s {ji`{c" Dzcij K`{k`cg{g enxsj`c effjce`sjbu {jhzxjc aefxjbo !heseni sg

`n `xxghe`segn yesa og{fj{ Z.X. F`{xa`b Xsj|ajn Fgnej{% `x cec `bb gsaj{ NA Ojcj{`b

Dzcijx yesagzs jq|b`n`segn" en x|esj go saj o`hs sa`s \bènseoo a`c njvj{ xgzias saje{

{jhzx`bx.

EE. Saj H`xj H`|segn.

Saj |{g|j{ H`xj H`|segn xagzbc kj4 Ha{exsg|aj{ Meni `'m'` MeniH`xs.njs v. O{ejncx goMjbbu @ugssj js `b" `x {jobjhsjc ku Dzcij \`zb K`{k`cg{gx [jhzx`b Jns{u.

EEE. Saj Dzcifjns jnsj{jc gn :'09';


3/19

`s S{e`b. Es ex `n enjxh`|`kbj o`hs sa`s sagxj ha`{ijx yj{j xsjj|jc en ` Oe{xs @fjncfjns"

{`he`b hgnsjqs `x ngsjc en On 0" eno{`.

Xjhgnc" es ex h{zhe`b sg {jfjfkj{ sa`s saex h`xj y`x cexfexxjc gn ` Fgsegn sg

Cexfexx bjvjb" yesagzs kjnjoes go `nu cexhgvj{u ya`sxgjvj{. Ya`s eo \bènseoox xgzias

cexhgvj{u {jxzbsjc en ` oenceni sa`s saj IG\ `bsj{n`sevj |{jxx |gbehu y`x sg enhbzcj `nu

`nc `bb `bsj{n`sevj |{jxx7

Sajn yj ygzbc a`vj ` cjve`segn o{gf sa`s |gbehu sa`s" yajn hgz|bjc yesa saj

|{eg{ aexsg{u go Cjojnc`ns @ugssjx |{eg{ oèbjc `ssjf|sx sg {jxs{ehs \bènseoo Menix Oe{xs

@fjncfjns [eiasx" hgzbc |{gvj |{gk`sevj go {`he`b `nefzx.0

Ngsaeni ex sa{j`ck`{j `nc sajxj `{j ngs k`bc `xxj{segnx |j{ Epk`b g{ Sygfkbu.

En hgns{`xs" o{gf ya`s yj a`vj `vèb`kbj en ` |{j&cexhgvj{u hgnsjqs yj a`vj xjjn `

xj{ejx go `hsegnx g{ en`hsegnx ku Cjojnc`ns @ugssj sa`s ` {j`xgn`kbj s{ej{ go o`hs hgzbc

{j`cebu hgnhbzcj envgbvj {`hj" dzxs `x gnj go saj hgz{s gkxj{vj{x g|enjc en saj fgvej

xjjn gn UgzSzkj E cjoenesjbu kjbejvj es y`x {`he`b.

ass|4''yyy.ugzszkj.hgf'y sha7v6`pAjhCJI:C1 !Jqaekes 0%.

En `ccesegn" \bènseoox Fgsegn og{ Bj`vj sg Oebj ` Sae{c @fjncjc Hgf|bèns xagzbc

a`vj kjjn i{`nsjc kjh`zxj saj o`hsx hgnsènjc saj{jen ajb| \bènseoo az{cbj saj Epk`b

`nc Sygfkbu sa{jxagbcx iènxs kgsa saj \gbeseh`b Cjojnc`nsx nc saj N`xaz` \C

Cjojnc`nsx.;

@x ngsjc en \bènseoox Fjfg og{ ;9 Ghsgkj{ ;


4/19

ng xzha x|jheoeh oenceni go o`hs g{ b`y7

k. Fù \bènseoo @fjnc aex Hgf|bèns sg enhbzcj saj |`ssj{n" |gbehu `nc|{`hsehj Fgnjbb o`hs sa`s `ngsaj{ encj|jncjns {j|g{sj{ yag a`xhgvj{jc saex h`xj y`x y{gniozbbu `nc `{{jxsjc og{ s{jx|`xx ku sajN`xaz` \C `nc xzkxjpzjnsbu ogznc Ngs Izebsu ku kjnha s{e`b7 Saex

ievjn saj o`hs sa`s saju {`n aef gzs go `n jnse{j agsjb en xefeb`{o`xaegn sg saj yù saju {`n \bènseoo gzs go saj H{gynj \b`t`" haebbeniaex Oe{xs @fjncfjns [eiasx `x h`zias gn MeniH`xs vecjg. Saex ievjnsaj o`hs sa`s Cjojnc`ns N`xaz` \C hgznxjb K{e`n Hzbbjn xs`sjc en aexgyn oebenix sa`s saj h`xj `s k`{ envgbvjx `||beh`segn go saj s{jx|`xxxs`szsj sg n encj|jncjns {j|g{sj{.

h. Fù \bènseoo @fjnc aex Hgf|bèns" yesa g{ yesagzs saj @ooec`ves goFemj I`nngn g{ \`fjb` [jungbcx" sg ngsj sa`s N`xaz` \C zssj{jc sajyg{cx Ugz `{j ` UgzSzkj xjnx`segn sg F{. I`nngn `x sajus`hmbjc aef `nc f`hjc aef òsj{ saju x`y aef {znneni a`nc ajbcvecjg go syg Cjsjhsevjx gn H`n`b Xs{jjs. Saex |`{sehzb`{bu en beias gosaj Oe{xs He{hzes {zbeni go Ibem v. Kgxsgn.8

Y`haxkj{ij{ v. \j||j{" :18 @.;c 99 !055


5/19


6/19

Oz{saj{" saj Hgz{sx hesjc h`xj go H`|j Hgc Nz{xeni Agfj Hgznheb v. [`fkbeni

[gxj [jxs Agfj" ??9 O.;c ;38 !0xs He{ 0510% cgjx ngs envgbvj ` [j|g{sj{x [eias sg

gkxj{vj `nc {j|g{s" kzs enxsj`c envgbvjc `n `{j` ngs hgnxgn`ns yesa f`xx ijnj{`b |zkbeh

zxj og{ |gbeseh`b {`bbejx" xzha `x saj H{gynj \b`t`. Yaebj \bènseoo ex pzesj hj{sèn sa`s

saj fj`xz{j go |j{fesseni `nc behjnxeni go ` nz{xeni agfj ex pzesj xzkxs`nse`b" es oèbx gn

saj |zkbeh |gbehu |{gni go saex `n`buxex `nc h`nngs kj zxjc og{ saex |`{sehzb`{etjc

jv`bz`segn. En xzf" Saj jns{`nhj ensg ` nz{xeni g{ {jxs agfj ex a`{cbu `

+s{`cesegn`b |zkbeh ha`nnjb go hgffzneh`segn.+!H`|j Hgc `s ;3


7/19

Hgz{sx fzxs {j`xgn`kbu hgnxecj{ |j{xz`xevj b`y o{gf `ngsaj{ Ojcj{`b

Dz{excehsegn en g{cj{ sg hgf|`{j `||bjx&sg&`||bjx `nc yajn es cgjx" saj uejbc xz||g{sx

\bènseoo4 @x N@@H\ v. Sagf|xgn" ?31 O.Xz||. 05: C.Fc."!051?% xagyx \bènseoo a`x `

hj{seoe`kbj hgnxseszsegn`b pzjxsegn" saj Hgz{s h`n s`mj Dzcehe`b Ngsehj sa`s saj _OY `nc

H{gynj \b`t` a`vj sg a`vj Xs`sj `nc Bgh`b |j{fesx !bepzg{" bgcieni" oggc / kjvj{ìj% sg

g|j{`sj xg saj{j a`x sg kj ` bji`b `n`buxex hgnczhsjc sg xjj yajsaj{ saj `fgzns go

|j{fesseni nc behjnxeni jpz`sjx sg saj su|j ngsjc en Sagf|xgn" `x Sagf|xgn zxjc saj

\{znju`{c{`segn`bj saj x`fj jq`hs yù sa`s \bènseoo zxjc es en saj S[G aj`{eni"

fzha sg saj haì{en go @ssg{nju Feccbjsgn4Es kj`{x {j|j`sjc jf|a`xex sa`s yj cg ngs a`vj zncj{ hgnxecj{`segn saj |{g|j{sug{ |{ev`hu {eiasx go `n encevecz`b agfjgynj{ g{ saj |{g|{ejsg{ go ` fgcjxs {jsèbjxs`kbexafjns. @ a`ncozb go ccesegn`b g{cj{bu |j{xgnx xgbeheseni xein`sz{jx nccexs{ekzseni a`nckebbx en hgnnjhsegn saj{jyesa" zncj{ {j`xgn`kbj {jizb`segnx

`cg|sjc ku cjojnc`ns sg xxz{j sa`s sajxj hsevesejx cg ngs ensj{oj{j yesang{f`b kzxenjxx g|j{`segnx ... ygzbc ngs f`{mjcbu cebzsj cjojnc`ns)x |{g|j{su{eiasx. \{znju`{c`s 91" 0


8/19

@x ` Njy Jnib`nc Tgneni `nc Jnsesbjfjnsx f`nìj{ \bènseoo a`x yg{mjc gn xgfj

go saj x`fj |{gdjhsx !j.i. Gfne|gens v. Hesu go N`xaz`% `x Cjojnxj @ssg{nju \`{jns og{

Gfne\gens" `nc aj yg{mjc `s saj H{gynj \b`t` yaebj aj y`x xzooj{eni zncj{ ` xj{ejx go

kgizx" {`he`bbu&fgsev`sjc nc oèbjc |{gxjhzsegnx k{gzias ku Cjojnc`ns @ugssj. \bènseoo

ex saj{jog{j `y`{j go f`nu |j{fesx `nc behjnxjx envgbvjc" |`{sehzb`{bu `s saj H{gynj

\b`t` `nc _OY bgh`segnx" yaeha go hgz{xj f`mjx es njhjxx`{u sg jniìj en cexhgvj{u `x

sg sagxj f`ssj{x" fj`neni sa`s saj Fgsegn sg Cexfexx gn saj f`ssj{ ex jnse{jbu x|jhegzx.

O{gf \{znju`{c`s 10" 0


9/19

B`xsbu" `x sg Cjojnc`nsx x|jhegzx hb`ef sa`s saju `{j effznj o{gf be`kebesukjh`zxj saju {j ngs Xs`sj @hsg{x" \b`enseoo xs`sjx saj ogbbgyeni. Oe{xs" `x en sajyg{cx go Z.X. Xz|{jfj Hgz{s Dzxsehjx Yebbe`f [janpzexs && en Fggxj Bgcij Ng.0


10/19

saj {jfjce`b ensjns go saj bjiexb`segn.

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Yaebj jnznhe`seni xzha |a{`xjgbgiu saj Hgz{s en `hsz`besu sggm pzesj ` ceooj{jns

`||{g`ha sa`s a`x Znhgnxseszsegn`bbu |{jvjnsjc \bènseoo o{gf jniìeni en Cexhgvj{u

sgy`{c ` S{e`b gn saj Fj{esx. Saj Hgz{s fzxs s`mj \bènseoox `xxj{segnx `s ozbb o`hj v`bzj

`x ` Dz{u feias oenc `nc es fzxs ngs" en saj o`hj go Epk`b `nc Sygfkbu" eing{j saj yjbb&

|bj`c k`hmi{gznc sa`s fù encjjc sjnc sg xagy znb`yozb {`he`b `nefzx en saj jujx go `

{j`xgn`kbj Dz{u. O{gf \bènseoox Xjhgnc @fjncjc Hgf|bèns4

;5. Saj @hsegnx hgf|bènjc go aj{jen {j saj ku|{gczhs go |`ssj{n" |b`n nc

|{`hsehj go znb`yozb {`he`b ke`x sa`s a`x kjjn `||bejc ku Mjbbu @ugssj `nc aj{ yesnjxxjx

ìènxs \bènseoo `nc gsaj{ xs{ecjns kb`hm f`bjx og{ saj |`xs a`bo&cjh`cj.

`% Mjbbu @ugssj" senijc ku znb`yozb { he b `nefzx" cec k{eni NA Aebbxkg{gziaXz|j{eg{ H`xj ;


11/19

kjog{j xaj i`vj \b`enseoo ` hg|u go `n `zcegs`|j h{zhe`b sg aj{ `bbjijc h`xj" vegb`seni|{enhe|bjx go saj Kjxs Jvecjnhj [zbj" \{ghjcz{`b Czj \{ghjxx `nc Xzkxs`nsevj Czj\{ghjxx.o% Mjbbu @ugssj" senijc ku znb`yozb { he b `nefzx" cec en o`hs oebj H`xj Ng. 38

kingcast v. ayotte, nh gop, nashua pd r 59e motion 2010-cv-501

Documents