koide, kozo june 1610
DESCRIPTION
June 17 th , 2010ArrangedforGlobalInterdependenceCenter, 2010 International Conference in Paris DIAM Co. Ltd Chief Economist Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research 1TRANSCRIPT
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research 1
Outlook of Yen
June 17th, 2010Arranged for Global Interdependence Center, 2010 International Conference in Paris
DIAM Co. LtdChief Economist
Kozo Koide
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research2
Recent Move of YEN, Within a Range 2010 : Range from about 89 to 95 yen/$
< $/YEN Rate (Daily) >
86878889909192939495969798
09.08
.03
09.08
.1709
.08.31
09.09
.14
09.09
.2809
.10.12
09.10
.26
09.11
.0909
.11.23
09.12
.07
09.12
.2110
.01.04
10.01
.18
10.02
.0110
.02.15
10.03
.01
10.03
.1510
.03.29
10.04
.12
10.04
.2610
.05.10
10.05
.24
10.06
.07
Data:Bloomberg
$/Yen
DIAM Economic Research
11/29: Fujii after Dubai Shock:"watch & see"
8/30: Landslinding Victory of DPJ
9/24: Fujii (Minister of Finance, at themeeting with Secretary Gaithner)"FX market is a stronghold of free
12/1: BOJ introducednew liquidity supply facility
1/8: Kan (Minister of Finance, at inauguration)"Cheap yen is preferable"
1/21: Obama "Volker Plan"
3/3: Greece "Aditional cut of fiscal budget"
5/6: ECB, not discuss thepurchase of government bonds
6/2: Resignation of Hatoyama
3/31:The end ofJapanese FY
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research3
YEN Pendulum in the Last Decade YEN has been appreciated due to flight to ‘quality’.
– Financial crisis invited higher risk premium upon deficit countries’ currency.– Interest rate differentials or external imbalance. Japan : Low interest rate but
has large current surplus. Capital mobility matters.
< $/YEN Rate >
859095
100105110115120125130135
00.01
00.07
01.01
01.07
02.01
02.07
03.01
03.07
04.01
04.07
05.01
05.07
06.01
06.07
07.01
07.07
08.01
08.07
09.01
09.07
10.01
10.07
Source:BOJ
\ $/
010,00020,00030,00040,00050,00060,00070,00080,000FX Intervention by Japan(RHS)
$/Yen Rate
DIAM Economic Research
Pariba Shock
Lehman Shock
Dubai Shock
100MYen
GreeceCrisis
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research4
Real Interest Rate Differentials & $/YEN Not instant sensitivity with $/Yen exchange rate, though...
– But it has become higher in about the last 5 years.< $/Yen Rate & Real Interest Rate Differentials >
▲ 5▲ 4▲ 3▲ 2▲ 1
01234567
85.01
86.01
87.01
88.01
89.01
90.01
91.01
92.01
93.01
94.01
95.01
96.01
97.01
98.01
99.01
00.01
01.01
02.01
03.01
04.01
05.01
06.01
07.01
08.01
09.01
Data:Datastream, Ministry of Internal Affairs & Communications(JPN), Department of Labor(US)
%
1.9
2.0
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5Short-term real interest rate differential (3MLibor, US -- JPN)$/Yen (Monthly Average,LHS)
DIAM Economic Research
LOG10
US
> JP
NU
S <
JPN
More Sensitive
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research5
Break in Causality : Interest Rate & FX From mid 2008, the causality has been weakened.
Fig.Granger-Sims Causality Test帰無仮説 : 「金利差第一主成分から月次リターンへのGranger因果性が無い」
過去5年間(月次)のローリングウィンドウによる推定/lag=6
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
02/2
8/20
05
05/3
1/20
05
08/3
1/20
05
11/3
0/20
05
02/2
8/20
06
05/3
1/20
06
08/3
1/20
06
11/3
0/20
06
02/2
8/20
07
05/3
1/20
07
08/3
1/20
07
11/3
0/20
07
02/2
9/20
08
05/3
0/20
08
08/2
9/20
08
11/2
8/20
08
02/2
7/20
09
05/2
9/20
09
08/3
1/20
09
11/3
0/20
09
02/2
6/20
10
P-Va
lue
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
P-Va
lue
AUDUSD
EURUSD
GBPUSD
CADUSD
Lower CausalityInterest rate gap to FX rate
Miziho-DL Financial Technology
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research6
Current A/C Surplus & $/YEN Rate Higher Yen regardless of contraction of current surplus
< Current A/C of Japan & $/YEN Rate >
1.9
2.0
2.0
2.1
2.1
2.2
2.2
2.3
2.3
2.4
87.09
88.09
89.09
90.09
91.09
92.09
93.09
94.09
95.09
96.09
97.09
98.09
99.09
00.09
01.09
02.09
03.09
04.09
05.09
06.09
07.09
08.09
09.09
10.09
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
$/YEN Rate JPN:Current Account / Nominal GDP (4QTotal %, RHS)
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research7
Capital A/C : Portfolio vs. Others Large swing of portfolio investment & other investment
< Capital Accounts (6Mts, Total) >
▲ 400,000▲ 350,000▲ 300,000▲ 250,000▲ 200,000▲ 150,000▲ 100,000▲ 50,000
050,000
100,000150,000200,000250,000300,000
02.0
1
02.0
7
03.0
1
03.0
7
04.0
1
04.0
7
05.0
1
05.0
7
06.0
1
06.0
7
07.0
1
07.0
7
08.0
1
08.0
7
09.0
1
09.0
7
10.0
1
Source:MOF
100 Mil. YenPortfolio Investment Financial DerivativesOther Investment FDIOther Capital Accounts Capital Account
DIAM Economic Research
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research8
Japanese, not Taking Much Outright FX Risk Bank & pension are using more hedging operation Growing mutual fund take more FX risk
– But the majority is going to emerging &/or high interest rate zone. 【Outward Portfolio Investment (Equity & Long/Mid-term Bond)】
▲ 100,000
▲ 50,000
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
01.09
01.12
02.03
02.06
02.09
02.12
03.03
03.06
03.09
03.12
04.03
04.06
04.09
04.12
05.03
05.06
05.09
05.12
06.03
06.06
06.09
06.12
07.03
07.06
07.09
07.12
08.03
08.06
08.09
08.12
09.03
09.06
09.09
09.12
10.03
10.06
Source:MOF
100M\Life Insurance Bank(including Banking A/C of T/B)Trust Bank (Trust A/C) Mutual FundOthers Total
DIAM Economic Research
12 mts. Total
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research9
US$/YEN, & Effective Exchange Rate YEN, not so appreciated against ‘other’ currencies.
< Yen Exchange Rate >80
90
100
110
120
130
140
150
160
00.0
1
00.0
7
01.0
1
01.0
7
02.0
1
02.0
7
03.0
1
03.0
7
04.0
1
04.0
7
05.0
1
05.0
7
06.0
1
06.0
7
07.0
1
07.0
7
08.0
1
08.0
7
09.0
1
09.0
7
10.0
1
10.0
7
Source: BoJ, Bloomberg
40.00
50.00
60.00
70.00
80.00
90.00
100.00
110.00
120.00
US$/YENAUD$/YENNominal Effective Exchange Rate (RHS)
Jan. 2000 = 100
DIAM Economic Research
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research10
Unwinding of Yen Carry has been Stabilized Bank’s interoffice flow has become neutral.
【Other Investment ex.Trade Credits (6mts. Total) 】
▲ 300,000
▲ 200,000
▲ 100,000
0
100,000
200,000
300,000
06.01
06.04
06.07
06.10
07.01
07.04
07.07
07.10
08.01
08.04
08.07
08.10
09.01
09.04
09.07
09.10
10.01
10.04
Source:BOJ
100M\
Bank's Interoffice Account(L/T) Other L/T LoansSecurities Lending Bank's Interoffice Account(S/T)Repurchase Agreement & Others OthersCurrrency & Deposit Other Assets/LiabilitiesOther Investment (ex. Trade Credits)
DIAM Economic Research
IN
OUT
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research11
About 7Qs Time Lag From 1998 : Average time lag between current A/C & Yen was 21mts
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Response of YENEFFECT to CholeskyOne S.D. CURRENTAC Innovation
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research12
Current A/C Surplus & $/YEN Rate If we assume a time lag for 7Qs before moving rate...
< Current A/C of Japan & $/YEN Rate >
1.9
2.0
2.0
2.1
2.1
2.2
2.2
2.3
2.3
2.4
87.09
88.09
89.09
90.09
91.09
92.09
93.09
94.09
95.09
96.09
97.09
98.09
99.09
00.09
01.09
02.09
03.09
04.09
05.09
06.09
07.09
08.09
09.09
10.09
11.09
Source : Cabinet Office, BOJ, Bloomberg
Log101.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
$/YEN RateJPN:Current Account / Nominal GDP (4QTotal %, RHS,7Qleading)
DIAM Economic Research
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research13
Cristal Ball, with Many Colors Current level is higher than ‘fundamental’ value, but...
– 59, 70, 98, 105, 113
< PPP Rate of $/YEN >
6080
100120140160180200220240260280
80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09
Data:Datastream, BOJ , Ministry of Internal Affairs & Tellecommunication(J PN), DoL(US)
$/Yen
$/YEN RatePPP(CGPI & PPI final goods)PPP(CPI core)
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research14
Yen Bull, Pushed out of the Edge of a Cliff ?
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research15
Shaky Greece & Yen Volatile Greece government bond market higher
yen < $/Yen・Greece Government Bond >
86878889909192939495
09.11
09.12
10.01
10.02
10.03
10.04
10.05
10.06
Source Bloomberg:
0.01.02.03.04.05.06.07.08.09.010.011.0
$/YenVolatility of Greece government bond yeild(10ys,RHS)
DIAM Economic Research
(Note)Volatility : S.D. of daily change (30DMW)
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research16
BOJ, Took a Step Ahead BOJ has introduced new liquidity supply on Dec. 1, ’09.
– The near-term direct effect against deflation is restricted.– But affected the expectation in the market about future policy.– Planning new initiative for corporate finance
【O/N Call Rate ・ Reserve Account in BOJ (Monthly Average)】
-
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
300,000
350,000
400,000
98.04
98.10
99.04
99.10
00.04
00.10
01.04
01.10
02.04
02.10
03.04
03.10
04.04
04.10
05.04
05.10
06.04
06.10
07.04
07.10
08.04
08.10
09.04
09.10
Source : BOJ
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80BOJ Reserve Account O/N Call Rate (right scale)
DIAM Economic Research
100M\
(Note)Shadow : Target of BOJ Reserve Account
%
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research17
JGB : Japanese Market 9 4 % of outstanding was held by Japanese (incl. FILP
bond)– Due to the large domestic savings under deflation, JGB has been held
stably by domestic investors. – What is the implication of KAN-sian policy?< G7:Current Account / General Gov. Balance (% GDP) >
▲ 7.0
▲ 6.0
▲ 5.0
▲ 4.0
▲ 3.0
▲ 2.0
▲ 1.0
0.0
1.0
▲ 4.0 ▲ 2.0 0.0 2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0
Source: IMF DIAM Economic Research
CY2008( General Gov. Balance (% of GDP) )
( Current Account (% of GDP) )
Japan
GermanyCanada
France
Italy
US
UK
Outlook of Yen (GIC, Paris) June 17, 2010 DIAM Economic Research18