large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

19
One Earth, Volume 4 Supplemental information Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic-subtropic coastal habitats adjacent to cities Tessa Mazor, Daniel A. Friess, Peter A. Todd, Danwei Huang, Nhung T.H. Nguyen, Megan I. Saunders, Rebecca K. Runting, Ryan J. Lowe, Paula Cartwright, James P. Gilmour, and Catherine E. Lovelock

Upload: others

Post on 16-Jul-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

One Earth, Volume 4

Supplemental information

Large conservation opportunities exist

in >90% of tropic-subtropic coastal

habitats adjacent to cities

TessaMazor, Daniel A. Friess, Peter A. Todd, Danwei Huang, Nhung T.H. Nguyen, Megan I.Saunders, Rebecca K. Runting, Ryan J. Lowe, Paula Cartwright, James P.Gilmour, and Catherine E. Lovelock

Page 2: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

1

Supplemental Information

Page 3: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

2

Figure S1. Urban areas associated with mangrove habitat. A) Top 100 urban areas containing the most amount of mangrove habitat (km2) within the 50 km buffer zone – only included urban areas with a reported population size. The protection is the proportion of the habitat that is protected within the 50 km buffer zone. B) Bottom 100 urban areas containing the least amount of mangrove habitat (km2) within the 50 km buffer zone. Population names only shown for urban areas with population >100,000.

Geelong

WenzhouSingarajaTaizhou

Naha

Ongole

Kismayo

Qui Nhon

HueHuizhouDavao

Shuitou

Tegal

Cam Rahn

Phan Rang

PortoNovo

Bintulu

Wanning

0

20

40

60

80

100

0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35

Pro

tect

ion

(%

)

Mangrove Habitat (km2)

Sarankhola

Buguma CityPort Harcourt

Sao Luis

Warri

Zinguinchor

LibrevilleMaturin

Sapele

Sandakan

Bissau

Calabar

MerguiTarakan

Guayaquil

Conakry

Douala

Banjul

Cape Coral

Miami

Tawau

Darwin

Milagro

San Fernando

Campeche

Port Gentil

Limbe

Samarinda

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000

Pro

tect

ion

(%

)

100 Most

100 Least

A)

B)

Page 4: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

3

Figure S2. Urban areas associated with coral reef habitat. A) Top 100 urban areas containing the most amount of coral reef habitat (km2) within the 50 km buffer zone – only included urban areas with a reported population size. The protection is the proportion of the habitat that is protected within the 50 km buffer zone. B) Bottom 100 urban areas containing the least amount of coral reef habitat (km2). Population names only shown for urban areas with population >100,000.

Cairns

Cebu

JeddahZanzibar

Naha

Noumea

Makassar

Jibuti

Tulear

Honolulu

Port Louis

Suva

Miami

Mahebourg

Dar es Salaam

Watampone

Port Moresby

Cadiz

Toledo

Al Manamah

Puerto Princesa

Yanbu

Tanjungpandan

Banda Aceh

Mtwara

Jolo

Legaspi Nassau

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Pro

tect

ion

(%

)

Dawei

San FernandoMargao

Bhavnagar

Thanh Hoa

Poza Rica de Hidalgo

Porbandar

Cilacap

Vung TauAlor Setar

El Charco

Singkawang

Veraval

KebumenKaranganyar

Sungai Petani

George Town

Mormugao

Merida

Tanjung Balai

KisaranTegal

Pekalongan

0

20

40

60

80

100

0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50

Pro

tect

ion

(%

)

Coral Reef Habitat (km2)

100 Least

100 Most

A)

B)

Page 5: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

4

Figure S3. Urban areas associate with tidal flat habitat. A) Top 100 urban areas containing the most amount of tidal flat habitat (km2) within the 50 km buffer zone – only included urban areas with a reported population size. The protection is the proportion of the habitat that is protected within the 50 km buffer zone. B) Bottom 100 urban areas containing the least amount of tidal flat habitat (km2) within the 50 km buffer zone. Population names only shown for urban areas with population >100,000.

Noakhali

Chattogram

BhavnagarSurat

Thaton

Bac Lieu

Dhaka

Ningbo

Jamnagar

Shanghai

Bharuch

Tongzhou

Soc Trang

Abadan

Barishal

Boma

Cixi

Sittwe

Putian

Qidong

Quanzhou

Fuqing

Taizhou

Savannah

DaitouYuyao

Fuzhou

HueShenzhen

Cox's Bazar

HaimenWenzhou

Tarakan

Douala

Shangyu

Wuyuan

GandhIdham

Hon Gai

Calabar

Bissau

Sao Luis

FaridpurBandar Mahshahr

Limbe

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000

Pro

tect

ion

(%

)

Tuxtepec

Can ThoAl Mukalla

Cachoeiro de Itapemirim

Salalah

Santo Domingo

Zhuji

Cienfuegos

San Pedro de Macoris

Khulna

Honolulu

TangailJiangyan

Puerto Plata

Agartala

BrahmanbariaLong Xuyen

0

20

40

60

80

100

0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 1.40 1.60 1.80

Pro

tect

ion

(%

)

Tidal flat Habitat (km2)

100 Most

100 Least 100 Least

B)

A)

Page 6: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

5

Figure S4. Urban areas associated with seagrass habitats. A) Top 100 urban areas containing the most amount of seagrass habitat (km2) within the 50 km buffer zone – only included urban areas with a reported population size. The protection is the proportion of the habitat that is protected within the 50 km buffer zone. B) Bottom 100 urban areas containing the least amount of seagrass habitat (km2) within the 50 km buffer zone. Population names only shown for urban areas with population >100,000.

JeddahJizanYanbu

Al Hudaydah

Merida

ManilaFreetown

Thoothukudi

Bissau

Angeles

Cancun

Campeche

ZhanjiangPerth

San Jose

Tampa

BrisbaneMelbourne

Cebu

Porlamar

Wuchuan

Batam

Cumana

Olongapo

Doha

Coton…

Logbo

San Carlos

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000 140000

Pro

tect

ion

(%

)

DarwinHuizhou

Oita

Zanzibar

Sasebo

Los Angeles

Tijuana

Kagoshima

PembaPingshan

Nakatsu

Wollongong

Wilmington

Jacksonville

Da Nang

Makassar

Naha

Miyazaki

HuePuerto Cabello

Montería

Santa Marta

Kochi

Barranquilla

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

Pro

po

rtio

n p

rote

ctio

n (

%)

Seagrass Habitat (km2)

100 Most

100 Least

B)

A)

Page 7: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic
Page 8: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

7

Figure S6. Conservation Potential (CP) of cities comparing the 10 and 50 km buffer zones. Conservation Potential CP

comparison between the 10 and 50 km buffer zones, with rank by cities (as per Table S1) with large population size (>1 million).

Cities with the most CP have the lowest numbers (rank 1).

Abidjan

Accra

Adelaide

as-Sib

Auckland

Bangkok

Barranquilla

Belem

Brisbane

Caracas

Cebu

Changzhou

Chennai

Chittagong

Colombo

Conakry

Dakar

Dammam

Dar es-Salaam

Dhaka

Douala

Dubai

Durban

Fortaleza

Fuzhou

Guaruja

Guayaquil

Haikou

Hangzhou

Heroica Veracruz

Ho Chi Minh CityHouston

Itaquari

Jakarta

Jeddah

Jiangyin

Jiulong

Karachi

KochiKuala Lumpur

Kumamoto

Lagos

Lome

Los Angeles

Luanda

Makassar

Manila

Maoming

Maputo

Maracaibo

Medan

Melbourne

Miami

Mogadishu

Mumbai

Natal

New Orleans

Ningbo

Pekalongan

Perth

Port Harcourt

Port-au-Prince

Pusan

PutianQuanzhou

Recife

Rio de JaneiroSalmiyaSalvador

San Juan

Santo Domingo

Semarang

Shanghai

Shantou

Shenzhen

Singapore

Surabaya

Surat

Sydney

Taipei

Taizhou

Tampa

Tegal

Tijuana

Tokyo

Vadodara

Visakhapatnam

Wenzhou

Yangon City

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Ran

k O

rde

r -

50

km

Bu

ffe

r Zo

ne

Rank Order - 10 km Buffer Zone

Page 9: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

8

Figure S7. Conservation Potential (CP) of countries comparing the 10 and 50 km buffer zones. Conservation Potential (CP)

comparison between the 10 and 50 km buffer zones, with rank by countries (as per Table S2) with average ranks across urban

areas of the country. Countries with the most CP have the lowest numbers (rank 1).

American Samoa

Angola

Anguilla

Antigua and Barbuda

Aruba

Australia

Bahamas

Bahrain

Bangladesh

Barbados

Belize

Benin

Bermuda

BrazilBritish Virgin Islands

Brunei Darussalam

Cambodia

Cameroon

Cayman Islands

China

Colombia

Commonwealth of Dominica Comoros

Congo

Congo, Democratic Republic

Cook Islands

Costa Rica

Cuba

Djibouti

Dominican Republic

East Timor

Ecuador

Egypt

El Salvador

Equatorial Guinea

Eritrea

Federated State of Micronesia

Fiji

French Guiana

French Polynesia

Gabon

Gambia

Ghana

Grenada

Guadeloupe

Guam

Guatemala

Guinea

Guinea-Bissau

Guyana

Haiti

Honduras

Hong Kong

India

Indonesia

Iran

Iraq

Israel

Ivory Coast

Jamaica

Japan

Jordan

Kenya

Kiribati

Korea

Kuwait

Liberia

Macao

Madagascar

Malaysia

Maldives

Marshall Islands

Martinique

Mauritania

Mauritius

Mayotte

Mexico

Montserrat

MozambiqueMyanmar

Nauru

Netherland Antilles

New Caledonia

New Zealand

Nicaragua

Nigeria

Niue

Northern Mariana Islands

Oman

Pakistan

Palau

Panama

Papua New Guinea

Peru

Philippines

Puerto Rico

Qatar

Reunion

Saint Kitts and Nevis

Saint LuciaSaint Vincent

Sao Tome and Principe

Saudi Arabia

Senegal

Seychelles

Sierra Leone

Singapore

Solomon Islands

Somalia

South Africa

Sri Lanka

Sudan

Suriname

Taiwan

Thailand

Togo

Tonga

Trinidad and Tobago

Turks and Caicos IslandsUnited Arab Emirates

United Rep. of Tanzania

United States of America

United States Virgin Islands

Vanuatu

Venezuela

Viet Nam

Wallis and Futuna

Western Samoa

Yemen

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140

Ran

k O

rde

r -

50

km

Bu

ffe

r Zo

ne

Rank Order - 10 km Buffer Zone

Page 10: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

9

Table S1. Rank Conservation Potential (CP index) per city. Here we only included urban area that have habitat and cities that have large populations (>1 million). From highest conservation potential (Rank 1 is highest CP) to lowest. N/A = Not applicable.

Rank 10 km CP Sum Rank 50 km CP Sum Rank

City Country of City City Country of City

1 Jeddah Saudi Arabia Haikou China

2 Bangkok Thailand Surabaya Indonesia

3 Kuala Lumpur Malaysia Jeddah Saudi Arabia

4 Port Harcourt Nigeria Surat India

5 Singapore Singapore Chittagong Bangladesh

6 Surabaya Indonesia Port Harcourt Nigeria

7 Manila Philippines Wenzhou China

8 Surat India Putian China

9 Dubai United Arab Emirates Bangkok Thailand

10 Accra Ghana Quanzhou China

11 Maputo Mozambique Fuzhou China

12 Haikou China Taizhou China

13 Shenzhen China Maoming China

14 Quanzhou China Semarang Indonesia

15 Chittagong Bangladesh Yangon City Myanmar

16 Miami United States of America Palembang Indonesia

17 Wenzhou China Dhaka Bangladesh

18 Mumbai India Kuala Lumpur Malaysia

19 San Juan Puerto Rico Ningbo China

20 Conakry Guinea Mumbai India

21 Taipei Taiwan Singapore Singapore

22 Colombo Sri Lanka Shantou China

23 Semarang Indonesia Vadodara India

24 Luanda Angola Lagos Nigeria

25 Shantou China Hangzhou China

26 Lagos Nigeria Kochi India

27 Putian China Pekalongan Indonesia

28 Tegal Indonesia Auckland New Zealand

29 Jiulong Hong Kong Tegal Indonesia

30 Dammam Saudi Arabia Accra Ghana

31 Karachi Pakistan Jiangyin China

32 Makassar Indonesia Guayaquil Ecuador

33 Maoming China Kolkata India

34 Salvador Brazil Medan Indonesia

35 Medan Indonesia Wuxi China

36 Recife Brazil Shanghai China

37 Dar es-Salaam United Rep. of Tanzania Douala Cameroon

38 Adelaide Australia Karachi Pakistan

39 Cebu Philippines Kwangju Korea

Page 11: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

10

40 Auckland New Zealand Barranquilla Colombia

41 Barranquilla Colombia Luanda Angola

42 Salmiya Kuwait Abidjan Ivory Coast

43 Jakarta Indonesia Mogadishu Somalia

44 Tampa United States of America New Orleans United States of America

45 Brisbane Australia Maracaibo Venezuela

46 Maracaibo Venezuela Shenzhen China

47 Douala Cameroon Changzhou China

48 as-Sib Oman Makassar Indonesia

49 Heroica Veracruz Mexico Jakarta Indonesia

50 Natal Brazil Ho Chi Minh City Viet Nam

51 Taizhou China Conakry Guinea

52 Guayaquil Ecuador Visakhapatnam India

53 Belem Brazil Jiulong Hong Kong

54 Ningbo China Houston United States of America

55 Fuzhou China Suzhou China

56 Dhaka Bangladesh Belem Brazil

57 Port-au-Prince Haiti Chennai India

58 Pekalongan Indonesia Lome Togo

59 Kochi India Dar es-Salaam United Rep. of Tanzania

60 Melbourne Australia Manila Philippines

61 Rio de Janeiro Brazil Bhubaneswar India

62 Hangzhou China Dubai United Arab Emirates

63 Lome Togo Pusan Korea

64 Guaruja Brazil Rio de Janeiro Brazil

65 Dakar Senegal Guaruja Brazil

66 Abidjan Ivory Coast Port-au-Prince Haiti

67 Sydney Australia Salmiya Kuwait

68 Jiangyin China Salvador Brazil

69 Fortaleza Brazil Natal Brazil

70 Mogadishu Somalia Cebu Philippines

71 Shanghai China Tampa United States of America

72 Vadodara India Tokyo Japan

73 Santo Domingo Dominican Republic Recife Brazil

74 Tokyo Japan Brisbane Australia

75 Yangon City Myanmar Dakar Senegal

76 Durban South Africa Adelaide Australia

77 Houston United States of America Durban South Africa

78 Los Angeles United States of America Miami United States of America

79 Visakhapatnam India Itaquari Brazil

80 Itaquari Brazil Taipei Taiwan

81 Chennai India Melbourne Australia

82 Kumamoto Japan Kumamoto Japan

83 Pusan Korea as-Sib Oman

84 New Orleans United States of America San Juan Puerto Rico

85 Ho Chi Minh City Viet Nam Caracas Venezuela

Page 12: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

11

86 Tijuana Mexico Colombo Sri Lanka

87 Changzhou China Dammam Saudi Arabia

88 Perth Australia Fortaleza Brazil

89 Caracas Venezuela Maputo Mozambique

90 N/A N/A Heroica Veracruz Mexico

91 N/A N/A Sydney Australia

92 N/A N/A Los Angeles United States of America

93 N/A N/A Perth Australia

94 N/A N/A Tijuana Mexico

95 N/A N/A Santo Domingo Dominican Republic

Page 13: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

12

Table S2. Average Conservation Potential (CP index) per country. From highest conservation potential (Rank 1 is highest CP) to lowest. Here we only included urban areas that contained habitat.

Rank

CP Sum Rank (10 km buffer) CP Sum Rank (50 km buffer)

Country No. Urban Areas in Study Country No. Urban Areas

in Study

1 Bahrain 1 Singapore 1

2 Singapore 1 Sierra Leone 18

3 Antigua and

Barbuda 3 Macao 1

4 Barbados 1 Eritrea 3

5 Aruba 1 Nigeria 18

6 Puerto Rico 3 Congo, Democratic

Republic 3

7 United Rep. of

Tanzania 8 Togo 6

8 Sierra Leone 14 French Polynesia 21

9 United States Virgin Islands

2 Federated State of

Micronesia 9

10 Kenya 7 Benin 11

11 Eritrea 3 Ghana 27

12 Turks and Caicos

Islands 4 Kiribati 15

13 Federated State

of Micronesia 9 Guinea 5

14 British Virgin

Islands 2 Brunei Darussalam 4

15 Kuwait 3 China 383

16 Anguilla 1 Papua New Guinea 19

17 Saudi Arabia 58 Solomon Islands 5

18 Western Samoa 6 Guyana 17

19 Mayotte 2 Wallis and Futuna 1

20 Guinea 5 Malaysia 115

21 Fiji 19 India 320

22 Tonga 4 Bangladesh 93

23 Guam 1 Somalia 6

24 Nigeria 12 Guinea-Bissau 19

25 Macao 1 Equatorial Guinea 5

26 Commonwealth

of Dominica 5

United Rep. of Tanzania

8

27 Congo,

Democratic Republic

3 Sudan 7

28 Mauritius 5 Philippines 133

29 Grenada 4 Haiti 13

30 Bahamas 50 Aruba 1

31 Sudan 7 Cameroon 13

32 Wallis and

Futuna 1 Mozambique 28

33 Cayman Islands 2 Thailand 86

34 French Polynesia 21 Vanuatu 4

35 Saint Kitts and

Nevis 2 Indonesia 393

Page 14: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

13

36 Jamaica 22 Bahamas 50

37 Mozambique 24 Sri Lanka 33

38 Saint Lucia 5 Congo 3

39 Papua New

Guinea 18 Kuwait 3

40 Ghana 23 Myanmar 65

41 Jordan 1 Madagascar 37

42 Philippines 126 Ivory Coast 13

43 Qatar 11 Mauritius 5

44 Benin 8 Hong Kong 2

45 Belize 10 Gambia 35

46 Palau 2 Saudi Arabia 62

47 Israel 1 Turks and Caicos

Islands 4

48 New Caledonia 16 Qatar 12

49 Seychelles 2 Barbados 1

50 Equatorial

Guinea 5 Panama 23

51 Guinea-Bissau 18 Bahrain 1

52 Sri Lanka 33 Angola 12

53 Cameroon 9 Nauru 1

54 Montserrat 1 Yemen 20

55 Panama 23 Liberia 8

56 Guadeloupe 8 United Arab Emirates 23

57 Kiribati 15 Taiwan 16

58 Madagascar 34 Colombia 59

59 Cuba 59 Iran 68

60 China 281 New Zealand 67

61 Solomon Islands 5 Kenya 7

62 Djibouti 3 Peru 14

63 Haiti 13 Fiji 19

64 United Arab

Emirates 21 Oman 19

65 Brunei

Darussalam 4

Sao Tome and Principe

3

66 Comoros 22 Egypt 27

67 Guyana 16 Senegal 19

68 Nicaragua 8 Cambodia 10

69 Netherland

Antilles 6 Western Samoa 6

70 Malaysia 89 Belize 12

71 Gambia 30 French Guiana 12

72 Colombia 39 Tonga 4

73 Thailand 78 Bermuda 1

74 India 230 Nicaragua 9

75 Indonesia 321 Djibouti 3

76 Togo 5 Mauritania 4

77 Ivory Coast 11 Cuba 62

78 Somalia 5 Seychelles 2

79 Liberia 8 Puerto Rico 3

Page 15: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

14

80 Mauritania 2 Korea 22

81 Cambodia 8 New Caledonia 16

82 Bangladesh 43 Iraq 5

83 Senegal 11 Venezuela 77

84 French Guiana 10 Trinidad and Tobago 5

85 Bermuda 1 Guam 1

86 Hong Kong 2 Suriname 14

87 Vanuatu 4 Gabon 11

88 East Timor 7 Marshall Islands 4

89 Honduras 14 Reunion 2

90 Marshall Islands 4 Jamaica 22

91 American Samoa 2 Cayman Islands 2

92 Myanmar 32 Viet Nam 130

93 Suriname 8 Antigua and Barbuda 3

94 Egypt 24 Northern Mariana

Islands 3

95 Dominican Republic

29 Ecuador 36

96 Taiwan 16 Pakistan 22

97 Martinique 2 United States of

America 255

98 Reunion 2 Costa Rica 24

99 Sao Tome and

Principe 1 Mexico 285

100 Iran 59 Jordan 1

101 Northern Mariana

Islands 3 Israel 1

102 Yemen 17 Brazil 249

103 Cook Islands 1 El Salvador 7

104 Australia 206 British Virgin Islands 2

105 Trinidad and

Tobago 5 Australia 222

106 Mexico 217 South Africa 14

107 El Salvador 7 Palau 2

108 Guatemala 6 East Timor 7

109 Gabon 9 American Samoa 2

110 United States of

America 145 Honduras 17

111 Angola 12 Cook Islands 1

112 Saint Vincent 7 United States Virgin

Islands 2

113 New Zealand 64 Comoros 22

114 Venezuela 64 Guatemala 7

115 Costa Rica 23 Commonwealth of

Dominica 5

116 Peru 12 Maldives 3

117 Brazil 198 Japan 108

118 Japan 94 Saint Vincent 7

119 Congo 2 Mayotte 2

120 Viet Nam 89 Guadeloupe 8

121 Iraq 4 Montserrat 1

122 Ecuador 27 Martinique 2

Page 16: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

15

123 Oman 15 Dominican Republic 33

124 Nauru 1 Netherland Antilles 6

125 Korea 16 Saint Lucia 5

126 Maldives 3 Anguilla 1

127 Pakistan 12 Grenada 4

128 South Africa 13 Saint Kitts and Nevis 2

129 Niue 1 Niue 1

Page 17: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

16

Table S3. Conservation Potential (CP) per coastal habitat. Rank city CP index for each coastal habitat type (CP analysis here only considers single habitats and not habitat diversity). Here we only included urban cities that have habitat and large populations (>1 million). From highest conservation potential (Rank 1 is highest CP) to lowest. N/A = Not applicable

Rank Mangroves Tidal flats Seagrass Coral reefs

City 10 km City 50 km City 10 km City 50 km City 10 km City 50 km City 10 km City 50 km

1 Port Harcourt Palembang Wenzhou Chittagong Jeddah Jeddah Jeddah Jeddah

2 Kuala Lumpur Port Harcourt Putian Surat Manila Singapore Quanzhou Wenzhou

3 Bangkok Bangkok Shantou Dhaka Shantou Maoming as-Sib Quanzhou

4 Surabaya Surat Surabaya Ningbo Accra Accra Mogadishu Mogadishu

5 Maputo Singapore Surat Putian Singapore Lome Shenzhen Singapore

6 Haikou

Kuala Lumpur

Kuala Lumpur Taizhou Taipei Shantou Miami Haikou

7 Surat Surabaya Taizhou Fuzhou Jiulong Haikou Salmiya Cebu

8 Conakry Mumbai Bangkok Wenzhou Perth Lagos Singapore Shenzhen

9 Mumbai Conakry Ningbo Surabaya Lome

Port Harcourt Makassar Salmiya

10 Colombo Haikou Fuzhou Vadodara Dakar Luanda Cebu San Juan

11 Karachi Chittagong Chittagong

Port Harcourt Dubai

Kuala Lumpur Taipei Jiulong

12 Maracaibo Maracaibo Quanzhou

Yangon City Salmiya

Port-au-Prince

Dar es Salaam Makassar

13 Singapore Karachi Shenzhen Hangzhou Luanda Makassar San Juan Natal

14 Guaruja Douala Manila Haikou Tampa

Barranquilla

Port-au-Prince Surabaya

15 Chittagong Guayaquil Kochi Tegal Shenzhen Manila

Santo Domingo Manila

16 Salvador Auckland Tegal Semarang Adelaide Jiulong Dubai

Dar es Salaam

17 Medan Medan Dhaka

Pekalongan Brisbane Shenzhen Wenzhou Miami

18 Dubai Salvador Lagos Maoming Colombo Dakar Caracas Taipei

19 Accra Semarang Semarang Quanzhou Conakry Conakry Sydney Putian

20 Douala Manila Mumbai Jiangyin Melbourne Perth Dammam Dubai

21 Auckland Guaruja Taipei Jakarta Lagos Salmiya Mumbai Kochi

22 Guayaquil Accra

Port Harcourt Shenzhen

Santo Domingo Dubai Recife Dammam

23 Recife Luanda Jakarta Kochi Miami Tampa Bangkok Bangkok

24 San Juan Cebu Auckland Lagos Dammam Colombo Natal

Port-au-Prince

25 Barranquilla Yangon City Haikou Shantou San Juan Taipei Salvador

Barranquilla

26 Lagos Dubai Karachi Auckland

Heroica Veracruz Fortaleza

Barranquilla Semarang

27 Tampa Kolkata Dubai Wuxi Fortaleza

Heroica Veracruz

Heroica Veracruz

Santo Domingo

28 Miami Barranquilla Maputo

Kuala Lumpur

Los Angeles Melbourne Jiulong as-Sib

29 Rio de Janeiro Fuzhou Hangzhou Shanghai Sydney Dammam Colombo Taizhou

30 Brisbane Natal Conakry Mumbai Tokyo Brisbane Jakarta Sydney

31 Natal Putian Jiangyin Dubai Tijuana Cebu Tegal Jakarta

32 Belem Recife Shanghai Jeddah Kumamoto Miami N/A Mumbai

Page 18: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

17

33 Adelaide

Ho Chi Minh City Maoming Kolkata N/A Adelaide N/A Tegal

34 Manila New Orleans Medan Jiulong N/A San Juan N/A

Pekalongan

35 Port-au-Prince Tampa Jiddah Bangkok N/A

Santo Domingo N/A Recife

36 Quanzhou Lagos Salmiya Makassar N/A Tokyo N/A

Heroica Veracruz

37 Itaquari

Port-au-Prince Makassar Taipei N/A Sydney N/A Perth

38 Semarang Makassar Accra Singapore N/A

Los Angeles N/A Salvador

39 Heroica Veracruz Jakarta Pekalongan Medan N/A Tijuana N/A Caracas

40 Luanda Miami Dammam Guayaquil N/A Maputo N/A Colombo

41 Sydney Maoming Luanda Kwangju N/A Kumamoto N/A Maputo

42 Cebu Quanzhou Singapore Manila N/A N/A N/A N/A

43 Maoming Colombo Abidjan Salmiya N/A N/A N/A N/A

44 Ho Chi Minh City San Juan Douala

Palembang N/A N/A N/A N/A

45 Jiddah Maputo Tokyo Douala N/A N/A N/A N/A

46 Dammam Jeddah Vadodara

Changzhou N/A N/A

N/A N/A

47 Shenzhen

Rio de Janeiro Jiulong Karachi N/A N/A

N/A N/A

48 Makassar Pekalongan Maracaibo Abidjan N/A N/A N/A N/A

49 Jiulong

Dar es Salaam Houston Conakry

N/A N/A N/A N/A

50 Fortaleza Brisbane Yangon City

Dar es Salaam

N/A N/A N/A N/A

51 Dar es Salaam Caracas

Dar es Salaam

Ho Chi Minh City

N/A N/A N/A N/A

52 Putian Abidjan Lome

Visakhapatnam

N/A N/A N/A N/A

53 Melbourne Sydney Salvador Belem N/A N/A N/A N/A

54 Abidjan Belem Brisbane Maputo N/A N/A N/A N/A

55 Jakarta Wenzhou Dakar

New Orleans

N/A N/A N/A N/A

56 Wenzhou

Heroica Veracruz Miami Dammam

N/A N/A N/A N/A

57 Durban Adelaide Belem Cebu N/A N/A N/A N/A

58 Pekalongan Taizhou

Visakhapatnam Maracaibo

N/A N/A N/A N/A

59 Taipei Shenzhen Melbourne Houston N/A N/A N/A N/A

60 Tegal Tegal as-Sib Suzhou N/A N/A N/A N/A

61 as-Sib Jiulong Chennai Luanda N/A N/A N/A N/A

62 Santo Domingo Itaquari Colombo

Barranquilla

N/A N/A N/A N/A

63 Los Angeles Dammam Guayaquil Tokyo N/A N/A N/A N/A

64 Tijuana Lome Mogadishu Colombo N/A N/A N/A N/A

65 N/A Durban San Juan Accra N/A N/A N/A N/A

66 N/A Santo Domingo Adelaide Melbourne

N/A N/A N/A N/A

67 N/A Melbourne

Port-au-Prince Chennai

N/A N/A N/A N/A

68 N/A Fortaleza Cebu Miami N/A N/A N/A N/A

69 N/A as-Sib

Rio de Janeiro Adelaide

N/A N/A N/A N/A

Page 19: Large conservation opportunities exist in >90% of tropic

18

70 N/A Los Angeles Changzhou Mogadishu N/A N/A N/A N/A

71 N/A Taipei Natal Salvador N/A N/A N/A N/A

72 N/A Tijuana Recife Lome N/A N/A N/A N/A

73 N/A N/A Barranquilla Brisbane N/A N/A N/A N/A

74 N/A N/A Tampa as-Sib N/A N/A N/A N/A

75 N/A N/A Durban

Bhubaneswar

N/A N/A N/A N/A

76 N/A N/A New Orleans Kumamoto

N/A N/A N/A N/A

77 N/A N/A Kumamoto San Juan N/A N/A N/A N/A

78 N/A N/A Heroica Veracruz Tampa

N/A N/A N/A N/A

79 N/A N/A Pusan

Rio de Janeiro

N/A N/A N/A N/A

80 N/A N/A Fortaleza Pusan N/A N/A N/A N/A

81 N/A N/A Los Angeles Fortaleza N/A N/A N/A N/A

82 N/A N/A Sydney Recife N/A N/A N/A N/A

83 N/A N/A Guaruja Natal N/A N/A N/A N/A

84 N/A N/A Itaquari Dakar N/A N/A N/A N/A

85 N/A N/A Santo Domingo Sydney

N/A N/A N/A N/A

86 N/A N/A Tijuana

Heroica Veracruz

N/A N/A N/A N/A

87 N/A N/A Ho Chi Minh City

Port-au-Prince

N/A N/A N/A N/A

88 N/A N/A Perth Durban N/A N/A N/A N/A

89 N/A N/A N/A Los Angeles

N/A N/A N/A N/A

90 N/A N/A N/A Caracas N/A N/A N/A N/A

91 N/A N/A N/A Guaruja N/A N/A N/A N/A

92 N/A N/A N/A Tijuana N/A N/A N/A N/A

93 N/A N/A N/A Itaquari N/A N/A N/A N/A

94 N/A N/A N/A Santo Domingo

N/A N/A N/A N/A

95 N/A N/A N/A Perth N/A N/A N/A N/A