latent tetany and anxiety, marginal magnesium deficit, and normocalcemia · latent tetany and...

5
Reprinted from Diseases of the Nervous System Vol. 36 No . 8 August 1975 Pages 461 465 1975 46 1 Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D. ,t ADOLPH R. BERGER . M D.t AND NE IL SPIELHOLZ . Ph.D. tt Abstract The identification of marginal magnesium deficit, such as we have dete cted in a patient with anxiety, depression , and psychomatic complaints, is a difficult diag no stic pr ob lem. Electromyography of a limb, rend- e red ac utely i sche mi c either just before or after hyper- ventilation , can elicit latent tet any in this condition, as well as in ca lcium deficiency. We have demonstrat ed itera ti ve electrical activity in ou r patient, whose mag- ne sium deficit is a uri butable to renal wa sting of m ag- nesium. We have e li cited similar pattern s in several ot her patient s. who had margina ll y low s erum mag· nesium and who also ex hibited weak nes s. anxiety, and psy choso matic di sorders . This preliminary report sug- gests the need for further considerati on of the po ssibil- ity that magnesium-de fi c it ma y co ntribute to the sy ndro me of la te nt tetany, psychoso matic co m- plaints, and wea kness. Electromyographic ev idence of la tent t eta ny has been observed in some pa ti e nt s with marginal mag- n es ium deficit, whose multiple ill -defined complaints may be mistaken for psychon euros is. '- 7 De fi ciency of magnesium. which i !) predominantly an intracellul ar ca ti on. is not often di ag nosed in this c ountry unless the de pl etion is s0 severe as to ca use sy mptoms referable to overt tetany. or met abo li c encephalopathy , o r both . T hi !) form of encephalopathy has been clearly re lated to lowered bra in and ce r eb rospinal leve ls of magnesium in magn e!)i um-derive d rats by C hutk ow a nd his Sin ce 1958. however. le ss er degree!) of magnes ium Jeticit with a ne uromuscular sy ndrome) have been reported by Ro!>selleL 2 as "c r yp totetany··, and by Durlach 3 - 7 as ··s pasmophilia.·· Although so me patients with this !) yndr o me ex hibit slightly depresse d leve ls of s erum l ow erythrocy te levels have been reported to occur mor e consistently . 5 · 6 · 7 Thi s sy ndrome, which occ urs more frequently in women than in men, is accompanied by many p sycho so ma ti c complai nt s. The physical examination is usually normal (or non-contributory). The elec- tro ca rdiogram sometimes exhibits ventricular prema- ture contrat.:tion or mildl y ab nor mal final deflections. The conve ntional electromyogram is norma l. How- e ver . hyperve ntilatio n, and isc hemia of the tested mus- cle, prod uce iterative electrical ac ti vity. We have not t From tht' Departmt' nt Nt'\1' York University Medical Ce nter. and Goldll'ater Memo rial H ospital ++ J nsti tut t' of Rehabilation M edicine found referen ce to this sy ndrome in the English lan- guage literature since Ros s elle 's and Durla ch 's monograph s, 1 - 7 although there ha ve been numerous publications in French a nd Italian language journals (over 30 citations by Durlach in hi s 1969 monograph 7 ). Recently we diagno se d this condition in a post- menopausal woman . 11 Case Report and Methods SLB , a 57-year-old woman of Italian anl:estry, was of weakness, depression , anxiety , ··s pot s before th e eyes'· , ge neralized pruritus, swelling of the lower extremities and puffiness around her eye s a nd mouth. This clini ca l picture , which also included occasional dy spnea and precordial pain, gastrointesti- nal complaints , without detectable organic cause , had persisted for ove r two years. Cardiologic examination was normal, psychiatric evaluation indicated only de- pressive anxiety , which yielded partially and temporar- ily to treatment , with di aze pam and amitryptoline. Al- though skin t es ting s howed no specific allergy, use of antihistamine therapy has been nece ssary for control of pruritu s. The similarity of her clinical picture to that de s cribed as ··cryptotetany " or "s pas mophilia" 1 - 7 led to investigation of her magnesium s tatus (details de- sc ribed el se where'') . Her initial s erum magnesium level was found to be marginally low ( 1.67 mEq/L) , by the range accepted as no rmal in the hospital laboratory ( 1.9-2.5).' 3 Conventional nerve co nduction te s ts and EMGs had bee n found norm al , but E MG studies (by a technique mod ified from that empl oyed by Ro sseUe t. 2 and Durlach 3 - 7 ) elicited iterative * After a bout three minut es ( two minutes of hyperventilation , fol- lowed by one minute of isc hemia) single mo tor unit of dis charges appea red , firing at a relatively sl ow rate (two to three per seco nd). At this the re were no visible muscle twitchings or s pa sms. Within the next 15-30 seconds , motor unit activity increa sed in frequency , and the sounds characteristic of visually recorded *The typical of electrical activity are described' as (I ) repetitive! potentials of one or more motor unit s, with r epc lltr ve (2-8 times) at frequency of 125 to 250 per se.:ond. termed doublets , qu adriplets or multiplets, (2) discharges of a motor unit of high frequ ency per seco nd) during s light involuntary contraction. Ros!>dle 1 interprets the EMG as positive if regul ar repetitive activity pers is ts for at least two minut es during the post-ischemic phase or after hy perpnea.' If the mod ifi cation is used, the pa ti ent hyperventil ates before is- c he mi a is i ndu ced (See Appendix).

Upload: vokhuong

Post on 05-Jun-2019

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia · Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D.,t ADOLPH

Reprinted from Diseases of the Nervous System Vol. 36 No. 8 August 1975 Pages 461 465 1975 46 1

Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia

MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D.,t ADOLPH R. BERGER . M D.t AND NEIL SPIELHOLZ. Ph .D.tt

Abstract The identification of marginal magnesium deficit ,

such as we have detected in a patient with anxiety, depression , and psychomatic complaints , is a difficult diagnostic problem. Electromyography of a limb, rend­ered acute ly ischemic either just before or after hyper­ventilation , can elicit latent tetany in thi s condition , as well as in calcium deficiency . We have demonstrated iterative electrical activity in our patient, whose mag­nesium deficit is auri butable to renal wasting of mag­nesium. We have e licited s imilar patterns in several other patients. who had margina lly low serum mag· nesium and who also exhibited weakness. anxiety, and psychosomatic disorders . Thi s preliminary report sug­gests the need for further cons ideratio n of the possibil­ity tha t chron i~ magnesium-defi c it may contribute to the syndro me of la tent teta ny, psychosomatic com­plaints , and weakness.

Electromyographic evidence of latent tetany has been observed in some patients with marginal mag­nesium deficit , whose multiple ill-defined complaints may be mistaken for psychon eu rosis .'-7 Defi ciency of magnesium . which i!) predominantly an intracellular cation. is not often diagnosed in this country unless the deple tion is s0 severe as to cause symptoms referable to overt te tany. o r metabolic encephalopathy , o r both . Thi!) form of encephalopath y has been clearly related to lowered brain and cerebrospinal levels of magnesium in magne!)i um-derived rats by Chutkow and his ~olleague!). M-~ · 10

Since 1958. however. lesser degree!) of magnesium Jeticit (as~oc ia ted with a neuromuscular syndrome) have been reported by Ro!>selleL2 as "cryptote tany·· , and by Durlach3 -

7 as ··spasmophilia .·· Although some patients with this !) yndrome exhibit slightl y depressed levels of serum magne~ium , low e rythrocyte levels have bee n reported to occur more consistently .5 ·6 ·7

This syndrome, which occurs more frequently in women than in men , is accompanied by many psychosomatic complaints. The physical examination is usually normal (or non-contri buto ry). The elec­trocardiogram sometimes exhibits ventricular prema­ture contrat.:tion or mildl y abnormal final deflections . The conventional electromyogram is normal. How­e ver . hyperventilation, and ischemia of the tested mus­cle , produce iterative electrical ac ti vity. We have not

t From tht' Departmt'nt (~{Medicine . Nt'\1' York University Medical Center. and Goldll'ate r Memorial H ospital

++Jnstitutt' of Rehabilation Medicine

found reference to this syndrome in the English lan­guage literature since Rosselle' s and Durlach 's monographs, 1- 7 although there have been numerous publications in French and Italian language journals (over 30 citations by Durlach in his 1969 monograph 7

).

Recently we diagnosed this condition in a post­menopausal woman .11

Case Report and Methods

SLB , a 57-year-old woman of Italian anl:estry, was ho~pitalized becau~e of weakness, depression , anxiety , ··spots before the eyes'· , generalized pruritus, swelling of the lower extremitie s and puffiness around her eyes and mo uth . This clinical picture , which also included occasional dyspnea and precordial pain , gastrointesti­nal complaints , without detectable organic cause , had persisted for over two years. Cardiologic examination was normal , psychiatric evaluation indicated only de­pressive anxiety , which yielded partially and temporar­ily to treatment , with diazepam and amitryptoline. Al­though skin testing showed no s pecific allergy , use of antihistamine therapy has been necessary for control of pruritus. The simila rity of her clinical picture to that described as ··cryptotetany" or "spasmophilia" 1- 7 led to investigation of her magnesium status (details de­scribed elsewhere'') . He r initial serum magnesium level was found to be marginally low ( 1.67 mEq/L) , by the range accepted as no rmal in the hospital laboratory ( 1.9-2.5).' 3 Conventiona l nerve conduction tests and EMGs had been found normal , but EMG s tudies (by a technique mod ified from that e mployed by RosseUet.2

and Durlach3-

7) elicited iterative a~ti v ity. * After about

three minutes (two minutes of hyperventilation , fol­lowed by one minute of ischemia) single motor unit of discharges appeared , firing at a relatively slow rate (two to three per second) . At this ti~e , there were no visible muscle twitchings or spasms . Within the next 15-30 seconds , motor unit activity increased in frequency , and the sounds characteristic of visually recorded

*The typical p~t tt erns of increa~ed electrical activity are described' as (I ) repetitive! potentials of one or more motor units, with repclltrve di~char ges (2-8 times) at frequency of 125 to 250 per se.:ond . termed doublets , triplet~ . quadriplets or multiplets, (2) ~pontaneou ~ dischar ges of a motor unit of high frequency ~~- 1 2 per second) during s light involuntary contraction . Ros!>dle 1 interprets the EMG as positive if regular repetitive activity persis ts for at leas t two minutes during the post-ischemic phase or after hyperpnea.' If the modification is used , the pa tient hyperventilates before is­che mia is induced (See Appendix).

Page 2: Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia · Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D.,t ADOLPH

462 DISEASES OF THE NERVOUS SYSTEM AUGUST

Figure 1: Doublets fro m abductor pnllio.:i \ hre\i~ afler two minute' of hypc:rventilation followed by 1.5 mmute~ •>f ischemia. Calibra­tion signifies 100 ms and 100 uV .

t"igure 2: Complete interference pallerns recorded simultaneously from abductor pollicis bre' i' and ahd uctor digiti quinti after :!.5 minutes of ischemia.

doublets and triplet s could he heard. (Fig . I).

During the following 60 seconds . the acti\·it j in­u eased to such an extent that a complete interference pattern was recorded (Fig. ::!) and at the same time marked wrist and finger spasm were evident. These contractions were completely in voluntary . With re­lease of the cuff after only two and a half minutes of ischemia, all electrical activity disa ppeared within 30 seconds.

The next day. to test for magnesium deficit . the patient was given an intramuscular injection of 2 ml of a 50% of solution of magnesium sulphate (to test for percentage retention of magnesium). 1

.. 12 She retained

over 60% of the parenterally administered magnesium. in contrast to the normal retention of 15-2® ..... 2

Within two hours of the injection she experienced marked relief of all of her symptoms. In the course of her ho<; pitalization the patient had received many other injections . none of which had evoked the clinical im-

provement experienced following the injection of mag­nesium. The EMG, taken shortly thereafter, was nor­mal and repetitive firing and spasm could not be pro­voked by hyperventilation , followed by ischemia for 10 minutes.

For several weeks , thereafter, she received oral magnesium supplements, and it was possible to de­crease the use of antihistamine and diazepam. How­ever, a month later, the intensity of her complaints completely returned, and she obtained brief (1-2 day) periods of relief only after intramuscular injections of magnesium. Placebo injections produced no clinical change. Rehospita lization . on several occasions. for metabolic and hormone studies, revealed that she was a renal magnesium waster. and that she had intermittent normotensive aldosteronism. with peripheral edema and sodium retention.•• Her serum magnesium level usually remained below I. 7 mEq/ L. serum calcium was normal (9.5-9.7 mg%) . Serum magnesium values of2. 1 mEq were reached after repeated intravenous or in­tramuscular injections of magnesium. On one such oc­casion. her hyperventilation/ischemia EMG did notre­vert to norm al. even when te~ted ~hile she was receiv­ing an intravenous infusion of 200 ml of dextrose and water. to which 2 ml of magnesium sulphate had been added . Her symptoms improved the next day. after a second magnesium-infusion. Two hours after comple­tion of the second infusion. her EMG was normal.

Discussion

Our patient with the abnormal hyperventi­lation/ischemic EMG pattern and carpal -.pasm. and those described in Europe_._ , a ll had marginal mag­nesium deficit.* Similar s igns are also seen with hypo­calcemic latent tetany! 4 · 15 · 16 However. Rose1Jel. 2 and Durlach3 -• have reported that their patients had similar clinica l and electrical phenomena with magnesium de­ficit, in the absence of hypocalcemia. Similarly. our patient showed these findings with margina lly low serum magnesium levels. but normal serum calcium le vels.

*We have subsequentl y obtained s imilar electrical findings on three additional patients without neuromuscular disease. In two. the hyperventilation/ ischemia EMG was found abnor­mal after the diagnosis of magnesium deficit had been made on the basis of serum magnesium levels of I. 1- 1.4 m Eq/ L and multiple psychosomatic and neuromusc ular complaints. In another. the hyperventilation/ischemia test was em­ployed because of the patient's bizarre neuromuscu lar com­plaints. When strongly positive EMG results were elicited. his serum electrolytes were analyzed. He was normocal­cemic. but his serum Mg was I .5 mEq/ L. To evaluate the significance of these pat ients· neuromu scular irritability , as demons tra ted by electromyography foll owing h yperventila­tion and ischemia. we tes ted ten normal volunteers. who did not have neuromuscular o r psychiatric abnormalities. Mag­nes ium serum levels . "'hich were done only in five. were within normal limits . None exhihited the EMG pattern de­scrihed here . .:' en "'h.:n the pl>St-h yperventilation ischemia was maintained for ten minutes.

Page 3: Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia · Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D.,t ADOLPH

'

1975 LATENT TETANY AND ANXIETY. MARGINAL. MAGNESI U M DEFICIT 463

Although hypocalcemia and hypomagnesemia each causes clinically ma nifest neuromuscular irritability and electromyographic abnormalities . such as are re­ported here. nerve ph ysiology studies indicate that the mechanisms are not the same . Chutkow 17 has reviewed the evidence and points out that, a lthough magnesium deple tion has electrophysiologic effects on nerve axons similar to those of calcium depletion , the calcium effect far outweighs the magnesium effect at this site. Calcium is principa lly involved in nerve membrane potential and stability ; depressive effect of hypercalcemia is caused by nerve membrane hyperpolarization, decreased sodium conductance. and resultant elevation of the de­polari zation threshold . With h ypoct~ lcemi a there i-; .m increase in depolarization that a llows for response to slow depolariza tio n and loss of accommodation, 2 .. 22 as a result of which peripheral nerves di scharge independently. 23

When a nerve impul se reaches the skeletal myoneural junction. the resultant depolariza tion of. the nerve endings re leases ace tyl choline (ACh) into the synaptic space. 2u 5 ACh molecules then diffuse across the syna ptic cleft and attach to specific receptors of the specialized area in the postsynaptic sarcolemma. which results in non-specific inc reased ionic permeability , flow of'an ionic current , and -depolarization (the end plate potential). When this depolarization reaches the excitation threshold of the adjacent sarcolemma, a muscle action potential develops, that ultimately in­itiates the mu scle contraction. Magnesium exerts its majo r neuromuscular effects at the myoneural j_unction. 17 ·24 -~0 At this site. calcium and magnesium are antagonistic . 2" -28-2 !1·30-3 1

Calcium enhances. and magnesium inhibits, there­lease of ACh. Additionally. the sensitivity of the motor end plate is diminished by high magn-esiu-m concentrations,25 such high concentrations also having cholinesterase-activating effects.32

·33 Thus, hypocal­

cemia exerts two paradoxical effects: it increases periphera l nerve excitability , but it decreases release of the neurotransmitter (ACh) into the myoneural synap­tic space . We postulate that the hypocalcemia-induced suppressio n of neuromuscular transmission may be overcome by the increased presence of ACh resulting from magnesium deficit. Increased tra nsmitter aug­ments the tendency towards repetitive sarcolemmal depolarization and muscle contraction.*

Since either hypocalcemia or hypomagnesemia can elicit similar abnormal hyperventilation/ischemia EMG patterns, both cautions must be measured to elucidate the specific deficit. The patients described here, and those reported earlier, 1-

7 all had marginally low serum magnesium and normal serum calcium levels. In our gro up, we rarely saw serum magnesium levels below 1.5 mEq/L.

In view of our patient 's la tent tetany a nd neuro­psychiatric manifestations, the findings of Chutkow et

a J8.11·10 may have special relevance. They demonstrated tha r rars with acute, subacu te or chronic magnesium­deficiency exhibit decreased brain a'hd cerebrospinal fluid magnesium levels, not necessarily closely related with changes in blood levels of magnes ium. They found that even small decrease s in brain magnesium are ac­companied by ma rked a lteratio ns in bra in excitability .t 0 Whether the slight electroencephalo­graphic abnormalities of our patient, elicited only dur­ing hyperventilation, reflect a magnesium-deficit en­cephalopathy, remains to be proved .

C hutkow and Grabow 10 also commented on the hi '\ ta mine-relea~f' of rnagnc~in rn -deprivation ,36 -37 an important point in terms of the evidence that histamine may be a central neurotransmitter.10 Note should be made. here. that one of our patient's most distressing complaints is generalized pruritus, and that her re­quirement for antihistamine therapy exceeds the amount tolerated by most subjects .

Worth mentioning , also, is the fact that 75% of Roselle 's patients with latent tetany of magnesium­deficiency improvec.'l on treatment with thyroxine.• Th is is a provocative finding. since thyroid h'ormone affects protein-binding of magnesium; its influence on the ratio·oNree to~tround •magn·esium-~i S" no't'<lefmitely established.38 Before instituting this therapeutic ap­proach in our patient , who has thyroid function at the low limit of the normal range, we considered the simi­larity of some of her findings to those of some patients with periodic paralysis or weakness, who also have intermittent aldosteronism, and who exhibit exacerba­tions in response to administration of salt:39·40 In this context, we must recall that some patients with periodic para~ysis have responded favorably to thyroid ad­ministration or stimulation, -and have experienced re­currence of weakness or withdrawal of thyroid therapy, 41 whereas others have periodic paralysis in association with hyperthyroidism. 41

·42 Whether our pa~

tient, who a lso suffers from marked weakness, presents another facet of hypokalemic periodic paralysis (mag­nesium deficit being known to predispose to.Joss of muscle po tassium, and to prevent its repletion)43

•44 re­

quires further elucidation.

Remaining to be explored is the relationship of such patients' multiple neuropsychiatric complaints with a possible metabolic encephalopathy , that may be caused by chronic magnesium deficit. 8 ·9 · 10 Study of cerebro­spinal fluid levels of magnesium. during phases of ex­acerbation and remission, possibly in association with metabolic balance data obtained during magnesium

*Combined deficits give rise to severe forms of neuromuscu­lar irri tabili t y. Whether th e convuls io ns of infanti le hypomagnesemic hypocalcemia, t hat are refractory to treatment unril borh defici t ~ (Ire correl: t e~.J. ·11 " are relevant liJ the clinical tetany that is the subjec t of this paper is moot. What happens at the myoneura l junction· in response to calcium and magnesium may differ from what happens in the central synapses.

Page 4: Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia · Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D.,t ADOLPH

.... -

464 D ISEASES O F THE NERVOUS SY<;l FM AUG I JSl

supplementation and restriction , may provide valuable inc;ight intn the syndrome dec;crihect here.

APPF:NOJX

I . The c;ubject . lying completel y relaxed o n a comfort­able couch , is ins tructed not to move the hand or arm (to eliminate voluntary contraction of the mu s­cles of the limb being tes ted) throughout the entire test procedure . A blood-pressure cuff i<:> wrapped around the upper arm.

2. A teflon-coated mono~)Jar needle electrode io; in­serted into the a bductor digiti quinti heing tested and a o;urface electrode is ta pt'd over the insert ion llf thio; muo;cle . A o;imilar pair nf e lectrnde' ;._employed to record from the ipsilatera l ahcluctor pollicio; hrc­vis muscle . The e lectrical ac ti vity from hoth mus­cles io; displaved o;imultaneously on tw1l c hannels llf a Teca TE-4. with constant mPnitoringon fiheroptic readout .

3. After determining whether there is electrical activity at rest , the patient is asked to hyperventilate for two minutes . Then the c uff is infla ted to a h<lut 20 mm Hg above the pressure which ohliterates the radia l pul se. If o;pontanemts discharge occurs early. pre!'­sure is maintained for two minutes. to a llow for development of the interference pattern . (A pattern

.Qf e lectrical activit y produced when numerous motor units are active so that their action potential can no longer be identified individuall y). Pressure sho uld not be mainta inerl lo nl!er tha n ten min11tes.

Ro~selle. ~ . · ElecHom) <•gr;•phoe 1n nenou~ di~ea~e and in nyp­totetany. Ed\ . E . Nauwelaert~. Pul>l. U ni versi•;j ire 2. l.ouvai n . Be lgi11m. 1951! tin F rench I. 14~4 tin Engli~h):

2. Rosselle . N .. Ooncker. K .: La tetanie magne~iprive che1 l'ho mme. Etude 1-lioc hemiqut> f't e lec tromyngraphique . Pculr Bart 7: 17- 11! . 11!35- 1!147. 19'i9.

3. Durlach. J .. Lebru n . R .: Magnesium et p<~tho~genit> de J;j 'l'a'­mo philie con~titutione lle idiopathiqut> . I R s,.,. Bioi tP<~ri~l 15l: 1973- 197.~ . 1959 .

4. Durlach . J .. Lebrun . R .: Jmportanct> de Ia forme h ypomag­nesienne de Ia ~pasmnphilie . Ann Endocrirw/1 Paris) 21 : 244-2~2 . 1960.

~ - Durlach . J .. Dreux. C. . Le l>run. R . . Jarreau F X . Ba rachet L. : Etude statistique de magne~ium e r ythrocytaire dans Ia spas­mo philie constitutionelle idiopathique. Ann Endorrinol (Pa ris) 23:83-88. 1%2 .

6 . Durlach . J .. Gremy. F .. Metra l . S .: La s pasmo philie: forms clini­que neuromu~culaire du deficit magnesien primitif. Etude s tatis­tique de Ia valeur diagno~tique et p rojUlostique de~ c riteres clini ­ques et paraclinique~. R Po·. Nt>urol . 117: 177- 189. 1967 .

7 Durlach , J.: Spasmophilia a nd magne~ium clefic it. Pub/. Ma.<.<FJn & Cie. Paris . France. 1969.

8 C hutkow. 1 .G .: Clin ical-chemical correlat ion~ in the t> n­cephalopathy of m;~gnesium de ficie ncy. Effect o f rever~al l'f maanes ium deficits . . \f11y(l Clin Pmc· 49:244- 247. 1974.

9. Chutkow. J .G . . Meyers . S .: Cht>mical c hanges in the ce rebrospi­nal fluid and 1-lrain in magn~sium deficiency . \'purt~l'll!." 18:963-9?4, 196S.

10. Chutkow. J .G . . Grabow . J .0 .: Clinical and chemical corre lations in magnesium-depriv:~ ti<>n t>nce rhalnpath~· of V<>llng r;j r ~ . Am ./. Plr n iol. 221 14!17- 1414. 1972 .

II Seel ig. M .S .. Berger . A R.: A ne"' c linica l patt,.rn <'f magnesium deficit associated with renal magnesium wa~ting . Oe~cription pf a ' y ndrnme m::~nife<ted hy pruritus. fa t il!lle . depressi ve a nx iety . al>normal electrnmyo(!ram . <~ nd normuten~ive. inte rmirtent a l­dosteroni~m. !Submitted for publ. )

12 . Fo urman. P .V .. Morgan. D . B .: C hro 'lic magne~ium deficiency. Prl'c. ,'\.utr. Sr.'c-. 21 :34-4 1, 1%2.

n . Seelig . M .S .. Berger . A .R.: Ra nge of norma l serum magnes ium Vl' llle~ !letter tn edil!lr) N Enf!/. J . Ml'd 290:974-975. 1974

14 . Turpin. R . . Lefe bre. J . Lerique . J .: I.e~ modifications de J'electromvogramme t>le mentai re et It"< tro•tbles de Ia transmis­~ion neu r<>mu~cul:'lire da ns ),. retanie . C R Arotl Sd. 2 1 f>·~7!! . 194l

1< Alajo11an inc. l .. l.\>nt~n11n . F . l..athala. H .P .. S.:herrer . J t ·,.n­trihuti<ln elec trnm v•'grapho411e a une delim it,.ti•>n de Ia tt>Ja nie df' J'adHite ,.,,. ,." , \f,•./. 1. ~ lN. l42. 19~4 .

tfl f-e ld man . R.<i . . <ir ;tn!!er . r:. \ rle~·trc>mv•JI!raph' in latent reran) . , ._ Fl!l!l. J \-f,.,J Y·4· )()1>4 - l %~ . tOf,l

17. Chutkow. J.G.: Ro le nf magnesium in neuromuscula r rh v~iol · <>gy . PnK Fir~t International Srmpo~ium on Magnesium Defi<· it

· in Il u man Patho logy. Vittel. F~anct> 1<17 t · I P-Il4.

IR i\dt>lman . W Jr .. M•.'Ore. J .: '\c tion of exte rnal di valent ion reduc tion o n <odiu m movement in the <quid 11iant :~ •on J . r;,,_ Plrnio/. 45:91- 101 . 1961

I <I . Adelman. W . Jr.: The etTe~· t .• lf external ca lcium and magnesium d e plf't io n '-' " ~ingle nt>l'e fiN>r~ . J . (;, .. , Nn·, ir:/. l'J:7<3 T' ~ -195ft

:.>n . Guttman. R .: <ital>ilintion of spi<ler c rab nerve membranes by alkaline eart hs.:~~ ma nifested in resti ng potel't i :~ l meas urements. J r.en . Phv.tin/. 2~: 343 -364 . 1<140.

2 1. Kugelb<:rg. E.: Acc<'mmodat ion in human ner ves . A r •a . Plrv.<iol. S r·and. 8: Suppl 24 . 1944 .

22 . Soland!. D. Y .: The measuren•ent of -- accom modation·· in nerve , ,,,_., ._ Rm· Soc . 119: l<_'i -~i9. 19'5 .

::'l Koenig. H . . Stahlec ker. H . a nd K<lenig. R .S .: The ncuromu~c oo ­la r rrechani'ln l'f a lkaloti c a nd h} pnn tl·:l'mic t t'la n} . p,,, '"' l-:.•1•- Hi,J . .\lt-J ~'J · HH- U3. 1<1 ~ ::' .

~.J . DelCastillo . J .. Katz . B.: Quanta! C<rmp<>nenh of the end-plate Jli.'IP.nti;jl. J . /'h niol 1 ]<1 : 5~\..~7' . !'Jq

25·. DelCastillo . J .: The transmi~~ion of excitation from nerve to mu ~c l e . in Ada ms . R . D .. Eato n . L.M . . Shy. M . tedsl : '1/ eur.,musc-ular Di.wrdl'n . Ra ltimo re. Williams and Wilkin~. 196U. 9H-14l .

2f. . HnfT. H .E . . Smith . P . K .. Winkler. A .W .: Fffect~ o f magne<ium o n the nervou~ <ystem in re l:~tion tn i t~ conce ntra ti<>n in ' enrnr Am. J. Plrnio/. 130:292-29.,. 1940.

~7 . De lCastillo . J .• Engbaek. L.: T he nature nf the neuronou ,.;u lar hloc k produced hy magnesium . J . Phniol. 124. Pfl 'K.t . 1<1<4.

2!1 . Huttar . O.F .. Ko~tial . K .: Effect of magnesium ;ontl ~ ak111111 ron< o n the releil~e nf a cetylcholine . J . l'ln·siol. I ::'-1 :\4 ?-11, 1954.

29. Jenkinson . D.J .: The natu re of the antagoni,m l>et wt>en calcium a nd magne~ium ion~ at the n'!uromu~cula• j unc t ion . -' · Phniol. 131!:414-444. 19~7 .

)0. Hubhard. J.L.: The effect of calcium a nd magnesium o n the spontaneous release of transmitter fro m mammalian motor nerve endings. J. Ph•·siol . 1 59:~07-5 1 7 . 1%1.

31 . Kuruyama. H .: Effec t of calcium and magnesium o n neuromus­c ular transmissio n in the h ypogastric nerve-vas deferens prep­a rat i<>n of the guinea pig. J . Ph\-si•J/. 175·211 -230. 1964 .

32 Mendel. B . . Mundell. D .. Strelitz . F. : Choli nestera~e and elec­trolytes . . \loture 144:479-480. 19.'9 .

33. Nachmansohn . D : Ar t ion of ion~ o n choline es tera\ e . Satun 14~ · 513-~ 1 4. 1940.

34. Da' is. J .. Han e}. 0 . . Yu 1.: Neonatal fits associated with h ypomagnesemia . -'\rclr / )is 1 /ri/d/r . 40:286-290, 1965 .

Page 5: Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia · Latent Tetany And Anxiety, Marginal Magnesium Deficit, And Normocalcemia MILDRED S. SEELIG, M.D.,t ADOLPH

I'J7:'i I A rr T TETANY AND A X I ETY. MARtd' -\I. 1\11\(iNlcSil!M DEFICIT 465

3~ . fre1dman . M .. Hatcher. G . . Wal\on. L. : Primary hypomag· nc\emia v. ith ~t"nmdary hypoc:ah:t"mia in an infant . Lanr·n 1 : 7(11.70~. 1%7.

36. Belanger. L.F . . Van Erkel. G .A . . J a kerow, A.: Behavior of the derma l maq •·e ll' in magne~ium-defic: ient rat~ . s, ;,,,,, ,. 126: ~9- 30. I ')~7 .

37. Bois. P .. Ga5con. P .. Beaulnes. A. : Hi stamine- li berating effect of magne~ium deficiency in the ral. NolllrP 1')7:50 1-502. 1%3.

311 . Wal~er , M .: Magnesi um metabol i~m . Er~:Ph . Phni" l. 59: 1!!5-2%. 1967.

1<1. Conn. J .W . . Fajans. S .S .. Loui~. I.. H .. Stret"ten . O .H. P .. John­'"". R. D.: Intermittent altlo~terr•nism in periodic paralv~i~ : de­pem.l .. nc•: nt allao:k' Pn rete ntion of ~·xl•um a nd failu re to inJoce attack t--v re,tJ iction of dif'•an ~·xlium l .annt 1 : ~0?-RO~. 1 4~7 .

Ill. I nne,. R \ ' . \ kS"' een•· '. R R . ll roJ• lk S. R V · Peri<>dic pit t:tl\'1' '\ndiurn !nt•t tr • !; I 'IT" 1nd ;tldl'"'t!JnOe · , :trlil 0. • ~:t'e' I a''', ., I ~ -- I )( l ' l '4

II I ngk . \ <j . lh,nud tunc t i• lll and p .. ri.)clic: paral y~i< . Am . .I \1, " · ln: 127· n ' · 1% t

4? Satoyo<hi . E .. Mura ka mi . K . Knwa. H . . et al: Periodic p;oralvsis in hypert hyroidi<m . v""'"'"~'· 11 : 74f>.~72 . 1%3.

43 . Whang. R .. Morosi . H.J .. Rodgers . D .. et al: The influence of "'<rained m:~gne<ium dcficicnc~ ,m mthcle P<''<~""'m re pletion J l .ah C/in . \fed 71)"!!95-902. 1967 .

44 . Wha ng. R.: Some aspects of the interrelationship of magnesium ;~nd pNa<<ium . .1. Citron . f1iL 21 :207-210. 1%8.

Acknowledgement

Sinare apprrciation is exrresud to Dr. Jerry Cl111fko 11-.for his rel'iew of this mantHcript. and for his ntluahll' WRJ!I'S lion L

f? ,,(l rint ~"t 'l (llf'\ { \ ·

1/ • .; l )•· d /1!

/) l'{}tll"///lt' /1/ o( \fedic ·ine ( ; , .{tfwa ft>r . \ft>~IWriul 1/n ~pita/

R<~~He, · e/r 11-luncl Nl'w Ynrt . . .Vew York {(}(}{7

PRII\TED IN U.S.A.