legal and documentalistic subelements remarks on biagioli`s concept of legal provisions v...
TRANSCRIPT
Legal and Documentalistic Subelements
Remarks on Biagioli`s Concept of Legal Provisions
V Legislative XML WorkshopTowards European standards for legislative documents and knowledgeItaly, Florence, 14 – 16 June 2006
by Harald Hoffmann - Friedrich Lachmayer
METADATA-1110 Vienna, Simmeringer Hauptstraße 24
Carlo Biagioli structures legal texts by creatingsubelements (“provisions”). This methodical approach
is effective as it provides for specific results(e.g. deontic consequences).
Our contribution tries to differentiate betweenlegal and documentalistic subelements.
Target is to achieve a synthesis between them, resulting in a new concept of legal acts and their subelements,
a new role of legal ontologies,enabling automatic generation of consequences,
and in a more comfortable user interface.
Documentalistic Subelements
Provisiondocumentalistic
Text
Meaning
eDocument
how to create the subset?ex ante – ex post
Ontologyof
Norms
Ontologyof
eDocuments
Legal Act eDocumentProvision
documentalistic
Text
Meaning
Provisionlegal
Text
Meaning
Ontologyof
Norms
Ontologyof
eDocuments
Ontology ofdoc. Provisions
Ontology ofleg. Provisions
Legal Act eDocumentProvision
documentalistic
Text
Meaning
Provisionlegal
Text
Meaning
Ontologyof
Norms
Ontologyof
eDocuments
Ontology ofdoc. Provisions
Ontology ofleg. Provisions
Legal Act eDocumentProvision
documentalistic
Text
Meaning
Provisionlegal
Text
Meaning
Ontologyof
Norms
Ontologyof
eDocuments
Ontology ofdoc. Provisions
Ontology ofleg. Provisions
Metasystem
Legal Act eDocumentProvision
documentalistic
Text
Meaning
Provisionlegal
Text
Meaning
Ontologyof
Norms
Ontologyof
eDocuments
Ontology ofsynthetical Provisions
Legal Act eDocumentsynth. Provision
Text
Meaning
Ontologyof
Norms
Ontologyof
eDocuments
Ontology ofsynthetical Provisions
Metasystem
Legal Act eDocumentsynth. Provision
Text
Meaning
Text
Meaning
Automatic Generationof Consequences
Legal Act eDocumentsynth. Provision
Proposal for Diskussion:
Comfortable User Interface
New Conceptof Legal Acts
Legal Ontology
and Provisions
Automatic Generationof Consequences