leonid brezhnev coalition that brought down khrushchev included anti-stalinists and diehard...

24
LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland enough to be acceptable to both groups

Upload: roger-prentice

Post on 29-Mar-2015

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

LEONID BREZHNEV

• Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists– Settled on

compromise successor in Brezhnev

• Bland enough to be acceptable to both groups

Page 2: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

PROFILE OF BREZHNEV• Born in 1906

• First leader to have been too young to participate in 1917 Revolution

• Belonged to generation of communists who made their careers as party bureaucrats

• Trained as an engineer– Climbed ladder as protégé of

Khrushchev

• Imposing and conventional– Would hold power for nearly 20 years

despite declining health during last decade of his life

Page 3: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

SOCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT

• Brezhnev brought Soviet society closer to Western societies– Population became more urban

• 66% of people lived in urban areas by 1968• Industrial development

– 12-15% annual growth rate continued into the 1970s• Soviet Union became world’s leading producer of

oil, iron ore, steel, and chemical fertilizers by 1970• Profits invested in the military

– Arms expenditures increase by annual rate of 4% between 1964 and 1976

– Allowed Soviet Union to achieve nuclear parity with U.S. and superiority in naval strength

Page 4: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

CONSUMER PRODUCTS• Eighth Five-Year Plan (1966-1970)

and Ninth Five-Year Plan (1971-1975) emphasized consumer production– 50 million apartments built

between 1966-1975• By 1980, 75% of all families in

Moscow had their own apartments

– By 1983, 83% of families had a television, 82% had refrigerators, and 58% had a washing machine

• But only 25% had a car and country had fewer phones than France and fewer miles of paved roads than Texas

Page 5: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

REPRESSION CONTINUES

• Brezhnev’s rule can be described as Neo-Stalinist– First political trial of an intellectual

since 1953 held in 1966– Alexander Solzhenitsyn forbidden

from accepting Nobel Prize in literature in 1970 and forced into exile in 1974

– Impromptu open-air art exhibit demolished by bulldozers in 1974

– Andrei Sakharov exiled for speaking out against war in Afghanistan in 1980

Sakharov

Solzhenitsyn

Page 6: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

SELF-PERPETUATING ELITE

• Brezhnev never interested in mass support or popularity– Viewed shared by the bureaucratic oligarchy of top Party

officials• His real source of support• A self-perpetuating elite

• Soviet society had fewer chances for social mobility than Western societies– Only 11% of Soviet young people went to college – Children of top party officials and factory managers were five

times more likely to go to college than children of ordinary people

• They thus continued to enjoy privileges of the elite

Page 7: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

BREZHNEV’S SORRY LEGACY• Unscrupulous officials gathered

around Brezhnev who used their connections and power to amass tremendous wealth for themselves– Often simply through

embezzlement• Meanwhile, economic growth

began to slow down and stagnated by 1976– Mainly because of huge military

expenditures– Soviet workers felt powerless

and manipulated• Brezhnev’s legacy was the impulse

to cynical self-gratification

Page 8: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

DEATH OF BREZHNEV

• Quality of Soviet life actually began to decline by 1980s– Brezhnev responds by

refusing to face the problem

• Brezhnev dies in 1982– Replaced by Yuri

Andropov• Dies in year and a half

– Followed by Constantine Chernyenko

• Died within a year

Andropov

Chernyenko

Page 9: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

MIKHAIL GORBACHEV• Mikhail Gorbachev elected General

Secretary in March 1985 at age 54 • Had worked his way up in CP youth

organization and studied law the University of Moscow

• Both grandfathers had been arrested under false charges during Stalin era

• Charming, flexible, and determined– Master of CP politics

• Knew that fundamental reforms, ones in which Soviet people would actively participate, were necessary

• Spoke opening of failure of economic planning– But was convinced that communism

could be rescued by reforms, once the inefficiency and brutality of Stalinism had been eliminated

Page 10: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

BIG ECONOMIC PROBLEMS• Soviet Union no longer keeping up with

tremendous pace of economic and technological change of the 1980s

• Problem was that only 5% of its GNP came from international trade– Raw materials that USSR exported

suffered from depressed prices• How could they generate revenue

needed to buy necessary technology?– Soviet manufactured products not

competitive in world market• Poor quality because Soviet factories

were out-of-date and workmanship was poor

– High rates of absenteeism, alcoholism, and worker turnover

Page 11: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

GORBY’S DILEMMA

• For the USSR to improve productivity, it had to acquire new technology and provide greater incentives to a workforce that wanted, but couldn’t afford, sophisticated consumer products– But how could the USSR do this and simultaneously

keep up in the arms race, retool its factories, and improved its underdeveloped transportation network?

• USSR was caught in a vicious circle– It needed greater investment and greater incentives

to stimulate greater productivity. – But as long as productivity remained low, the Soviet

economy could not generate the resources for greater investment and more incentives

Page 12: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

NEW POLICIES

• To break vicious circle, Gorbachev launched:– Perestroika (“restructuring”)

• Economic revolution– Glasnost (“openess”)

• Re-examination of Soviet history and encouragement of public discussion in an unprecedented way

• Teach Soviet citizens to understand their relationship with the government in a new way

Page 13: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

PERESTROIKA• Not a complete abandonment of

socialism– State continued to own factories and

set broad economic targets– But role of huge planning bureaucracy

was targeted for huge reduction• Managers told they would be responsible

for their own finances– No longer receive subsidies

• No more subsidies to keep prices on consumer goods artificially low

• 50% of service sector and 20% of consumer industry turned over to private ownership

• Begin to reverse collectivization• Work to attract foreign investment

Page 14: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

GLASNOST• Gorbachev knew that the way to make

USSR a more productive society was to make it a more open society

• Every subject that had formerly been taboo was now openly discussed– Gorbachev stated Stalin’s guilt in the

horrors of the Great Purge and collectivization

– Public officials subjected to tough questions

– Documentaries probed damaging effects of long war in Afghanistan

– Environmentalists stated sit-ins to prevent destruction of historic buildings

Page 15: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

MIXED REACTION TO GLASNOST

• Reaction of ordinary people to glasnost was mixed– Many older people resented

attacks on Stalin– Soviet conservatives saw

talk about multi-party democracy and the right to emigrate as evidence of social decay

• Insisted that freedom in Russia always led to anarchy and that Russia needed a strong master

Page 16: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

RACE AGAINST TIME

• Gorbachev insists on multiple candidates and voting by secret ballot for factory managers and members of parliament– Knew that his program would

provoke obstruction of Soviet power structure

– Wanted to win wide popular support before unrest with short-run hardships caused by his reforms and resistance of the bureaucracy doomed his plans to failure

Page 17: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

PROBLEMS WITH PERESTROIKA

• Perestroika did create economic hardships– Less planned economy meant

higher prices and rising unemployment

• Soviet people had been taught that socialism would protect them from high prices and unemployment– Also resented new class of

entrepreneurs

• Finally, reforms did not dramatically increase consumer products—maybe even decreased their supply

Page 18: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

INTRODUCTION OF DEMOCRACY

• To make it more difficult for conservative elements to depose him, Gorbachev begins fundamental democratic reshaping of political institutions in late 1988– Drew up new constitution– Called for elections to new National

Congress of People’s Deputies• 2250 seats• 750 seats chosen from various

organizations such as Communist Part

• 1500 seats left to democratic choice of voters

• First free election in Russia since 1917

Page 19: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

ELECTIONS

• Results of election– Deeply humiliated CP hierarchy– Demonstrated that opportunity to

make real changes had shaken the Soviet people out of apathy

• Only 25% of districts were uncontested– Even in uncontested districts, CP

leaders who were critical of Gorbachev were defeated

– Election pitted younger, reform minded CP members against older generation

• Younger generation usually won

Page 20: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

DEMOCRACY IN ACTION• New Parliament meetings broadcast on

television– Intense criticism of KGB– Gorbachev elected president of body

• But only after days of intense grilling

• Gorbachev won more secure political position– Could not be removed unless

majority of Parliament agreed to it– Gave him alternative power base to

the CP hierarchy• Which he also continued to purge

Page 21: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

RISE OF NATIONAL INDEPENDENCE MOVEMENTS

• Glasnost gave national minorities freedom to express their discontent with Soviet government and also their hatred for each other in many regions

• Lithuania, Estonia, and Latvia were most discontented– Gorbachev tried to

appease them by setting up “mixed economy”

• Did not work—demanded complete independence

Page 22: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

GORBACHEV’S “PANDORA’S BOX”

• Gorbachev had no intention of presiding over dismantlement of Soviet Union– Alternately employed concessions

and threats to keep non-Russian republics in USSR

• But nothing seemed to work• Demands of Baltic states inspired others

to demand independence– Georgians, Ukrainians, Armenians,

and others• Gorbachev did not want USSR to

fragment but the only way to handle problem was to back off from glasnost and stifle talk of independence– This would jeopardize all the other

progress Gorbachev had made and perhaps represent a return to bad old days of Brezhnev

Page 23: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

BACKGROUND TO AFGHAN WAR

• King of Afghanistan overthrown by his prime minister Mohammed Daoud in 1973– Daoud overthrown and killed by

military officers in 1978 and power turned over to a Marxist-Leninist party

– Islamic fundamentalist guerillas launch guerilla war and push regime to verge of collapse

– in December 1979, USSR airlifts troops into country to protect regime

• Ultimately commits 100,000 men• But guerillas prove impossible

to defeat

Page 24: LEONID BREZHNEV Coalition that brought down Khrushchev included anti-Stalinists and diehard Stalinists –Settled on compromise successor in Brezhnev Bland

“BLEEDING WOUND”• Reaction from world to Soviet

invasion swift and harsh– Condemned by UN– 56 countries boycott Moscow

Olympics in 1980– Criticism of Islamic countries

fierce– U.S. supplies Afghan rebels

• Wounded veterans from war become dissonant element in Soviet society

• Gorbachev vows to end “bleeding wound” of Afghanistan and pulls troops out in January 1990