1

Mea

sure

men

tof

atLE

P

Mar

kT

hom

son

Uni

vers

ityof

Cam

brid

ge

★E

xper

imen

tal

Met

hod

★R

ecen

tR

esul

ts

★S

yste

mat

icU

ncer

tain

ties

★P

rosp

ects

for

Fin

alR

esul

ts

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

2

Intr

odu

ctio

n

★19

97-2

000:

LEP

oper

ated

abo

veW

pair

prod

uct

ion

thre

sho

ld(

� =18

3-20

9G

eV)

★To

tal

(sum

med

over

AD

LO)

LEP

2in

tegr

ated

lum

i:

����� fb

��★

Eac

hex

perim

ent

accu

mul

ated

��� ev

ents

★re

lativ

ely

larg

ecr

oss-

sect

ion

(

� 16pb

)an

dcl

ear

deca

yto

pol

ogie

sal

low

effic

ien

t

and

clea

nid

enti

ficat

ion

of

� ev

ents

Typi

cal

perf

orm

ance

:

Effi

cien

cy

Pur

ity

� � � � � ���

��� � �����

��������W

W→

WW

→

WW

→

qqqqlνlν lν qq

10.5

%

43.9

%

45.6

%

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

3

-Mas

sfr

omD

irect

Rec

onst

ruct

ion

★A

bove

� th

resh

old

:

� � det

erm

ined

from

reco

nstr

uc-

tion

ofth

ein

varia

ntm

ass

dist

ribut

ion

ofth

e

� de

cay

prod

ucts

,i.e

.

�� ,

��

Two

Dis

tinct

Sta

ges

:

❶R

econ

stru

ctev

ent-

by-

eve

ntm

ass

❷F

itm

ass

dist

ribut

ion

� � �

★re

quire

goo

dm

easu

rem

ents

ofth

efe

rmio

nfo

ur-m

omen

ta.

E1

E2

Ele

pt

θ 12

E1

E2

E3 E

4

θ 12θ 34

Ho

we

ver:

✢je

ten

ergi

esre

lativ

ely

poo

rly

mea

sure

d

� �� ������� !"#

✢ne

utrin

osun

obse

rve

d.

★K

inem

atic

fittin

gpl

ays

vita

lro

le.

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

4

Kin

emat

icF

ittin

g

5C

onst

rain

ts:

★E

nerg

y/m

om

entu

mco

nser

vatio

n:

� �%$&('#*)�� $#

★N

egle

ct

+ � :an

dta

ke

� �)� ,

� � � � :

6un

know

ns(

&(' � -&(' � . )

Und

er-c

onst

rain

edLi

mitt

ed

� � sen

sitiv

ity

Res

ults

from

ALE

PH

,O

PAL

��� � :

3un

know

ns(

&(' � )O

ver-

cons

trai

ned

:us

eki

nem

atic

fitM

ost

� � sen

sitiv

ityfr

om��

���� :

0un

mea

sure

dqu

antit

ies

Ove

r-co

nstr

aine

d:

use

kine

mat

icfit

Mea

sure

both

W-d

eca

ys

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

5

Mas

sR

econ

stru

ctio

n:

�//0 1

★Id

enti

fyen

ergy

depo

sits

asso

ciat

edw

ithle

pton

★F

orce

rem

aind

erof

even

tin

to2

jets

(DU

RH

AM

/LU

CLU

S)

★S

umov

ertr

acks

/clu

ster

s

� (

243657 ,

&(' )

�8 3657 ,

9 ): ': /

243 57★

Mos

tse

nsiti

vity

to

� � fro

mje

t-je

tsy

stem

E1

E2

Ele

pt

θ 12

8, ��)8, �;8, ,;�2 �2<,� �>=9 �9 ,?@AB �,#

★Je

ts:

angl

esbe

tter

mea

sure

dth

anen

ergi

es

★K

inem

atic

fit-

scal

essu

mof

jet

ener

gies

C2�;

2 ,)2ED 5FG

★S

igni

fica

ntly

impr

ove

sre

solu

tio

n

; give

sre

duce

dse

nsiti

vity

toje

ten

ergy

scal

e

★R

econ

stru

cted

jet

mas

ses

are

impo

rtan

t

★In

fits

all

expe

rimen

ts

keep

9 fixed

.0

1200

0

2400

0

3600

0

4800

0

6000

0

5560

6570

7580

8590

9510

0M

qq/G

eV

Mqq

(T

rue)

Mqq

(R

aw)

Mqq

(F

it)

Opa

l MC

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

6

Mas

sR

econ

stru

ctio

n:

�////

★F

orce

even

tin

to4

jets

(DU

RH

AM

)D

ELP

HI/O

PA

Lal

low

for

addi

tion

algl

uon

jet

3T

hree

poss

ible

pairi

ngs

ofje

tsto

W

H W

I

★In

corr

ect

pairi

ngs

� Com

bin

ator

icba

ckgr

ound

.

★A

pply

Kin

emat

icF

itto

all

3pa

iring

s

Bes

tpa

iring

sele

cted

usin

g:

6070

8090

100

Expected Events

Cor

rect

Inco

rrec

t

J

All

Com

bina

tion

s

qqqq

Inva

riant

Mas

s (G

eV)

Sele

cted

Pai

ring

6070

8090

100

●A

LEP

H:

Con

sist

enc

yw

ithW

-dec

ay

kine

mat

ics

●L3

:K

inem

atic

fitpr

obab

ility

.

●O

PAL

:M

ultiv

aria

tese

lect

ion

/Kin

emat

icF

itpr

ob.

●D

ELP

HI

:us

eal

lpa

iring

s!

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

7

Man

ytr

icks

toim

pro

ve

� � sen

sitiv

ity,e

.g.

L3 ★R

ank

3je

tpa

iring

sby

5Cfit

prob

.

★U

seco

mbi

natio

nw

ithhi

ghes

tfit

prob

.

★A

lso

use

seco

ndbe

stin

ase

para

tedi

strib

utio

n

L3

min

v [G

eV]

Number of Events / 1 GeV

2000

Dat

a qq

qq, 1

st p

airin

g

M.C

. rew

eigh

ted

M.C

. inc

orre

ct p

airin

g

M.C

. bac

kgro

und

(a)

prel

imin

ary

MW

= 8

0.51

± 0

.13

GeV

050100

150

200 60

7080

9010

0

L3

min

v [G

eV]

Number of Events / 1 GeV

2000

Dat

a qq

qq, 2

nd p

airin

g

M.C

. rew

eigh

ted

M.C

. inc

orre

ct p

airin

g

M.C

. bac

kgro

und

(b)

prel

imin

ary

MW

= 8

0.51

± 0

.13

GeV

0204060

6070

8090

100

OPA

L★

Rec

ons

truc

tso

me

even

tsas

5je

tsi.e

.al

low

for

agl

uon

jet

★10

way

sof

assi

gnin

g5

jets

to2

Ws

larg

eco

mbi

nat

oric

back

grou

nd

★S

elec

tbe

stus

ing

rela

tive

likel

ihoo

d

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

8

Fro

mM

ass

Dis

trib

utio

nsto

K L

DE

LPH

I Pr

elim

inar

y

0102030405060708090

5560

6570

7580

8590

9510

010

5

W m

ass

(GeV

/c2 )

events / 2 GeV/c2

DE

LPH

I Pr

elim

inar

y

020406080100

5560

6570

7580

8590

9510

010

5

W m

ass

(GeV

/c2 )

events / 2 GeV/c2

DE

LPH

I Pr

elim

inar

y

010203040506070

5560

6570

7580

8590

9510

010

5

W m

ass

(GeV

/c2 )

events / 2 GeV/c2

★D

eter

min

atio

nof

M � fro

mm

ass

dist

ribut

ions

TH

RE

EM

ET

HO

DS

:

❶B

reit-

Wig

ner

Fit

(OPA

L)

❷M

onte

Car

loR

ewei

ghtin

g(A

LEP

H/L

3/O

PA

L)

❸C

onvo

lutio

n(D

ELP

HI)

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

9

❶B

reit-

Wig

ner

Fit

(OPA

L)

★P

aram

eter

ise

usin

gfu

nctio

nba

sed

onB

W-

“find

the

peak

”★

Use

Mon

teC

arlo

(‘Kan

dY’)

toco

rrec

tfo

rbi

ases

050100

150

200

7080

900204060

7080

90

0204060

7080

900204060

7080

90

010203040

7080

90010203040

7080

90

m /

GeV

Events / GeV

qqqq

4-j

et

m /

GeV

Events / GeV

qqqq

5-j

et

m /

GeV

Events / GeV

qqeν

N

m /

GeV

Events / GeV

qqµν

m /

GeV

Events / GeV

qq(τ

→l)

νN

m /

GeV

Events / GeV

qq(τ

→h)

νN

OP

AL

192

-202

GeV

pre

limin

ary

-0.1

50

0.15

79.5

8080

.581

0

0.25

79.5

8080

.581

0

0.2 79

.580

80.5

81

0.2

0.4 79

.580

80.5

81

0.5

0.75

79.5

8080

.581

0.5

0.75

79.5

8080

.581

MWtr

ue /

GeV

MWtr

ue /

GeV

M

O Wtrue

/ G

eV

< m0fit

> - MWtrue

/ GeV PM

Wtrue

/ G

eV

M

O Wtrue

/ G

eVM

Wtrue

/ G

eV

qqqq

4je

tqq

qq 5

jet

qqeν

Qqq

µν

qq(τ

→l)

νQ

qq(τ

R →h)

νQO

PA

L M

onte

Car

lo 2

00 G

eV

★S

IMP

LEan

dR

OB

US

T-

used

for

prel

imin

ary

resu

lts.

★N

otth

em

ost

stat

ist

ical

lypo

wer

ful

tec

hniq

uepl

anto

use

Con

volu

tion

for

final

resu

lts.

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

10

❷R

ewei

ghtin

gF

it(e

.g.

ALE

PH

,L3,

OP

AL)

★C

ompa

reD

ata

toM

C➡

S, �� �#

★C

ould

gen

erat

em

any

MC

sam

ples

with

man

yva

lues

� � � $+ �#

★In

stea

dg

ener

ate

one

larg

esa

m-

ple

� � � $+ �# and

RE

WE

IGH

Tto

� � �T $+ �T#

0255075100

125 60

6570

7580

8590

95qq

eν/q

qU µν R

econ

stru

cted

Mas

s (G

eV)

Events

Dat

a

MC

MW

=79.

8 G

eV

MC

MW

=80.

8 G

eV

For

even

t

V with

gen

erat

edm

asse

s

� �� $� ,#

WX )Y� �� $� ,Z� �T $+ �T#

Y� �� $� ,Z� � $+ �#

★M

onte

Car

lobi

asco

rrec

tion

impl

icit

infit

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

11

Con

volu

tion

Met

hod

:D

ELP

HI

Bas

icid

ea(e

.g.

//// ):

★U

se4C

fit2

mas

ses

+er

ror

mat

rixfo

rea

chje

tpa

iring

★fo

rmev

ent

PD

Fus

ing

all

3je

tpa

iring

sus

ed

★ca

lcul

ate

“ove

rlap”

ofev

ent

PD

Fw

itha

2DB

reit-

Wig

ner,

[\ M �]

even

tlik

elih

ood,

^\M �

] .D

EL

PHI

183

GeV

mx

GeV

/c2

my GeV/c2

20406080100

120

2040

6080

100

120

DE

LPH

I 18

3 G

eV

mx

GeV

/c2

my GeV/c2

2040_6080100

120

2040

6080

100

120

DE

LPH

I 18

3 G

eV

mx

GeV

/c2

my GeV/c2

2040_6080100

120

2040_ 60

8010

012

0

★S

tatis

tica

lly

pow

erfu

l

★S

till

need

toco

rrec

tfo

rbi

ases

asfo

rB

Wm

etho

d.

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

12

All

Met

hods

basi

call

y:

★lo

cate

the

peak

ofth

ere

cons

truc

ted

inva

riant

mas

sdi

strib

utio

n

★U

seM

onte

Car

loto

corr

ect

for

bias

es

Rec

onst

ruct

ed

`

qqlν

a Inva

riant

Mas

s (G

eV)

Expected Events

Bre

it W

igne

rm

W =

80.

330

GeV

Γ W =

2.0

93 G

eV

6070

8090

100

Mas

sD

istr

ibu

tion

Dis

tor

ted

by:

★E

xper

imen

tal

Res

olut

ion

and

resp

onse

★E

vent

Sel

ecti

on

★IS

R

★F

inal

stat

ein

tera

ctio

ns(

bbbb )

?

★T

hede

gree

tow

hic

hth

eM

Cm

odel

sth

ese

bias

esul

timat

ely

dete

rmin

esth

e

syst

emat

icun

cert

aint

ies

★N

eed

prec

ise

Mon

teC

arlo

Pre

dict

ions

!M

.Tho

mso

n19

July

2003

13

Sys

tem

atic

Unc

erta

intie

sI:

Det

ect

orE

ffec

ts

★Tr

ying

tom

easu

reW

-mas

sto

cd�edfg -

met

hod

ofdi

rect

reco

nst

ruct

ion

sens

itive

topo

orly

mod

elle

dde

tect

oref

fect

s.

Det

ecto

rC

alib

ratio

n:

★D

etec

tor

calib

ratio

nde

term

ined

from

data

mai

nly

usin

g

hi hjkl

m even

tsat

n opq er G

eV

★Ty

pica

lre

sulti

ngun

cert

ain

tyon

s t is

20-3

0M

eVpe

rex

perim

ent

★U

ncor

rela

ted

betw

een

expe

rimen

ts

-no

tth

ebi

gg

est

conc

ern

ALE

PH

Eff

ect:

★N

ewA

LEP

Hpr

elim

inar

yre

sult

shift

edby

-79

MeV

com

pare

dto

pre

viou

sre

sult

from

sam

eda

ta,

1.3

u ALE

PH

tota

lunc

erta

inty

.

★la

rges

tef

fect

in

vvhwyx

:ch

ang

edby

-150

MeV

.

★D

ueto

pop

ulat

ion

ofno

n-s

imul

ated

low

ener

gy“s

atel

lite”

clus

ter

sne

arto

elec

trom

agne

ticsh

ow

ers.

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

14

E1

E2

Ele

pt

E1

E2+

δ

Ele

pt★

Inth

eev

ent

rec

onst

ruct

ion

Sat

ellit

ecl

us-

ters

are

not

ass

ocia

ted

with

lept

on★

The

refo

reas

soc

iate

dw

ithne

are

stje

t★

Bia

sje

tan

gle

★S

igni

fican

tbi

asto

jet

mas

s

Rec

all:

z{ ||}z

{�~�z{�{��� ~� {� ��� ~

� {���� ~{�

Pro

ble

mso

lved

by“C

lea

ning

”:

★R

emo

ving

sate

llite

clus

ter

sw

ithin

�� ofle

pton

s

★R

emo

ving

all

unas

soci

ate

dne

utra

lcl

uste

rs

whi

ch

are

obse

rve

dw

ithin

asi

ngle

EC

AL

stac

k(s

uch

ob-

ject

sw

ere

neve

rid

entifi

edas

phot

ons)

★S

UB

TLE

EF

FE

CT

-ne

glig

ible

impa

cton

othe

r

ALE

PH

anal

yses

/res

ults

������������������ ���� � ���

�� ¡¢££¤¥¤¦§�¦¨©ª¢¡«¬­¦ ©£

®�¯° ¯ ±²

³�´µ ´¶·

¸ ¹ºº» ¼»½¾À¿

★D

ELP

HI,

L3,

OPA

Ldo

not

obse

rve

sim

ilar

prob

lem

sM

.Tho

mso

n19

July

2003

15

QE

DU

ncer

tain

ties:

Exp

erim

enta

lC

onst

rain

ts?

★D

ueto

kine

mat

icfit

-an

alys

isve

ryse

nsiti

veto

ISR

★H

ow

eve

rsm

all

syst

emat

icun

cert

aint

yfr

ompu

reIS

R:

ÁÂÄÃÅ Æ LL

impl

emen

tatio

nin

YF

SW

W

★

s t ana

lysi

sis

also

sens

itive

tora

diat

ion

from

W-b

oson

sth

rou

ghne

gati

vein

terf

eren

cew

ithIS

R

★O

PAL

mea

sure

ij�Ç cr

oss-

sect

ion

(

È�ÉÊr efË hÌ )

prov

ides

test

ofm

odel

ling

ofre

alph

oton

prod

uctio

nin

s t MC

s

R(d

ata/

Kan

dY)

=0.

99

Í 0.09

Í 0.04

0102030405060

05

1015

2025

3035

4045

50E

γ /G

eV

Events/2.5 GeV

OP

AL

OP

AL

dat

aSt

anda

rd M

odel

FSR

(le

pton

s)ba

ckgr

ound

★In

terp

ret

edas

ane

wcr

oss-

ch

eck

ofre

late

d

s t sys

tem

atic

sat

leve

lof

Î MeV

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

16

Fra

gmen

tatio

n/H

adr

oniz

atio

n

★P

roce

ssof

ÏÏ

hadr

ons

Ð bla

ckm

agi

c

★R

ely

onM

onte

Car

lom

odel

s(a

lltu

ned

at

Ñm ).

W→

qq

??

★C

ompa

re:

JET

SE

Tst

ring

mod

elH

ER

WIG

clus

ter

mod

elA

RIA

DN

Eco

lour

dipo

lem

odel

★18

MeV

syst

emat

icun

cert

aint

yta

ken

asco

rrel

ated

betw

een

expe

rimen

ts/c

hann

els

Fin

alS

tate

Inte

ract

ions

★W

deca

yve

rtic

esse

para

ted

by

Ð 0.1

fm

★H

adro

nisa

tion

scal

e

Ð 1.0

fm

★P

ossi

bilit

yof

non

-inde

pend

ent

hadr

oni

satio

nfo

rW

boso

ns

in

ijÏÏÏÏ ev

ents

.

★C

andi

stor

tre

cons

truc

ted

mas

ssp

ectr

a

★P

ossi

ble

sour

ces:

BE

Can

dC

olou

rre

conn

ectio

nM

.Tho

mso

n19

July

2003

17

Bos

e-E

inst

ein

Cor

rela

tions

(Pau

lde

Jong

’sta

lk)

Ò BE

C-

Qua

ntum

mec

hani

cal

effe

ct

Ò Like

sign

Ó ste

ndto

becl

ose

inph

ase

spac

e

Ò BE

Cbe

twee

npi

ons

from

diff

eren

tW

s?

SAM

E W

DIF

FE

RE

NT

W

Col

our

Rec

onne

ctio

n(J

org

end’

Hon

dt’s

talk

)P

ertu

rbat

ive

phas

e(Q

CD

)

Ò Sup

pre

ssed

by2

gluo

nex

cha

nge

+co

lou

r

Ò Neg

ligib

lem

ass

shift

s

Ôqd M

eV

Had

roni

zati

onph

ase

(no

n-pe

rtur

bativ

e)

Ò Rel

yon

mod

els

(str

ing

,clu

ster

...)

Ò Pre

dict

ions

ofm

ass

bias

es:

0-30

0M

eV

e- e+

Z/γ

W Wqq

q q

Eff

ect:

poss

ible

syst

em

atic

bias

in

ÏÏÏÏ ch

anne

l-

but

not

ÏÏÕ ÖØ×

★LE

Pco

mb

ined

resu

lt(d

oesn

’tin

clu

deF

SIs

ys.

erro

rs):

Ù Ú tÛ ÏÏÏÏ ÜÏÏÕ ÖÝ×

ÞßàááÍ âãäå

★R

esul

tsco

nsis

ten

t-

but

can’

tus

eth

isto

set

sys.

erro

rM

.Tho

mso

n19

July

2003

18

FS

ISys

tem

atic

Err

orE

stim

ate

★S

yste

mat

icer

ror

from

mod

els

.★

Cur

rent

CR

erro

rfr

omS

K-I

(

æ =2.1

)★

æ dete

rmin

esam

oun

tof

CR

★U

sela

rges

tva

lue

cons

iste

ntw

ithda

ta(s

eeJo

rgen

d’H

ond

t’sta

lk)

Mod

elE

ffec

tM

ass

shift

Her

wig

CR

ç 30M

eVS

K-I

è =2.1

CR

ç 90M

eVS

K-I

100%

CR

ç 300

MeV

Aria

dne

AR

2C

R

ç 70M

eVLU

BO

EI

BE

ç 35M

eVSK

-I W

Mas

s B

ias

Com

pari

son

AL

EPH

- E

rror

on

poin

ts 0

to 1

7 M

eV

DE

LPH

I -

Err

or o

n po

ints

0 to

6 M

eV

L3

- E

rror

on

poin

ts 0

to 1

5 M

eV

OPA

L -

Err

or o

n po

ints

0 to

13

MeV

% R

econ

nect

ed E

vent

s

W Mass SK1- Standard Jetset (MeV/c é

2) -5

0050100

150

200

250

300

010

2030

4050

6070

8090

100

★O

bser

veeq

ual

expe

rimen

tal

sens

itivi

ty

FS

Iass

umed

100%

corr

elat

edbe

twee

nex

pts.

★co

mm

onen

ergy

-dep

ende

nt

CR

erro

ris

used

in

LEP

com

bin

atio

n

050100

150 17

018

019

020

021

0

√s [G

eV]

∆MW [MeV]

SK

I m

odel

, κ=

2.1

Ene

rgy

Dep

ende

nt W

Mas

s B

ias

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

19

Sys

tem

atic

Unc

erta

intie

s(L

EP

Com

bine

d)

Sou

rce

Sys

tem

atic

Err

oron

s t (M

eV)

vvê w ×

vvvv

Com

b.H

adro

niza

tion

1918

18Q

ED

(IS

R/F

SR

,etc

)8

88

Det

ecto

rS

yste

mat

ics

1410

14LE

PB

eam

Ene

rgy

1717

17C

olou

rR

econ

nect

ion

ë

909

Bos

e-E

inst

ein

Cor

rela

tion

s

ë

353

Oth

er4

54

Tota

lS

yste

mat

ic31

101

31S

tatis

tical

3235

29To

tal

4410

743

★

vvvv ch

anne

l:sy

stem

atic

sfr

omF

inal

Sta

teIn

tera

ctio

nsdo

min

ate

★

vvê w ×

and

vvvv yi

eld

sim

ilar

stat

istic

alun

cert

aint

ies

★LE

Pco

mb

inat

ion

:th

e

vvvv ch

ann

elon

lyha

s10

%w

eigh

tdu

eto

FS

I

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

20

★C

ombi

ned

LEP

resu

ltsfr

om17

2-20

9G

eV(

c 650

pb

jì /exp

t.)

í OPA

L/A

LEP

H

î ï ðî ï ð

resu

lts(f

acto

r

ñ 10le

ssse

nsiti

ve)

com

bin

edw

ith

òòî ï ð

í ALE

PH

and

L3re

sults

take

acco

unt

ofin

ter-

cha

nnel

corr

elat

ions

í OPA

Ldo

esno

tye

tin

clu

deth

e20

00da

ta(

ó 220

pb

ôõ )

80.0

81.0

MW

[GeV

] (no

n-4q

)

LE

P w

orki

ng g

roup

corr

el. w

ith

4q =

0.1

8

AL

EP

H [1

996-

2000

]80

.375

±0.0

62

DE

LP

HI ö [1

996-

2000

]80

.414

±0.

089

L3 ÷ [1

996-

2000

]80

.314

±0.0

87

OP

AL

[199

6-19

99]

80.5

16±0

.073

LE

P80

.411

±0.0

44

Sum

mer

200

3 -

LE

P P

reli

min

ary

80.0

81.0

MW

[GeV

] (4q

)

LE

P w

orki

ng g

roup

corr

el. w

ith

non-

4q =

0.1

8

AL

EP

H [1

996-

2000

]80

.431

±0.1

17

DE

LP

HI ö [1

996-

2000

]80

.374

±0.1

19

L3 ÷ [1

996-

2000

]80

.485

±0.1

27

OP

AL

[199

6-19

99]

80.4

07±0

.120

LE

P80

.420

±0.1

07

Sum

mer

200

3 -

LE

P P

reli

min

ary

Ú tÛ ÏÏÕ Ö ×

ÞßøùûúâüüÍ ù úùãáÛþýÿ��ÿ úÞ Íù úùãùÛþý�ý úÞ �äå

Ú tÛ ÏÏÏÏ

Þßøù úâáùÍ ùûúùã�Ûþýÿ �ÿ úÞ Íù úüùüÛþý�ý úÞ �äå

★S

yste

mat

ics

com

plet

ely

dom

inat

ein

ijk vvvv

!

★S

yste

mat

ics

also

impo

rtan

tin

ijk vvê w ×

chan

nel

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

21

LEP

Com

bine

d

� �

and

� �

Res

ults

80.0

81.0

M

� W[G

eV]

LE

P w

orki

ng g

roup

χ2 /dof

= 2

9.6

/ 37

AL

EP

H [1

996-

2000

]80

.379

±0.0

58

DE

LP

HI

[199

6-20

00]

80.4

04±0

.074

L3 [1

996-

2000

]80

.376

±0.0

77

OP

AL

[199

6-19

99]

80.4

90±0

.065

LE

P80

.412

±0.0

42

Sum

mer

200

3 -

LE

P P

reli

min

ary

1.5

2.0

2.5

Γ W[G

eV]

LE

P w

orki

ng g

roup

χ2 /dof

= 1

9.7

/ 24

A

LE

PH

[199

8-20

00]

2.13

±0.1

4

DE

LP

HI

[199

7-20

00]

2.11

±0.1

2

L3

[199

6-20

00]

2.24

±0.1

9

OP

AL

[199

6-19

98]

2.04

±0.1

8

LE

P

2.15

0±0.

091

Sum

mer

200

3 -

LE

P P

reli

min

ary

Ú tÛ �� Þßøù úâüáÍ ùûúùá�Ûþýÿ �ÿ úÞ ÍùûúùãüÛþý�ý ú

Þ �äå

(inc

lude

sLE

Pre

sult

from

thre

shol

dcr

oss-

sect

ion

:

������� � ����������� ��� � �������� �� � ! )

" #Û �� Þßá úü�ùÍ ùûúù$øÛþýÿ �ÿ úÞ Íùûúù$ùÛþý�ý úÞ �äå

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

22

Com

paris

onw

ithO

ther

Res

ults

Dire

ctvs

.In

dire

ct:

W-B

oson

Mas

s [G

eV]

mW

[G

eV]

8080

.280

.480

.6χ2 /DoF

: 0.3

/ 1

%

pp−-c

ollid

ers

80.4

54 ±

0.0

59

LEP

280

.412

± 0

.042

Ave

rage

80.4

26 ±

0.0

34

NuT

eV80

.136

± 0

.084

LEP

1/S

LD80

.373

± 0

.033

LEP

1/S

LD/m

t80

.378

± 0

.023

SM

Con

sist

enc

y:

80.2

80.3

80.4

80.5

80.6 13

015

017

019

021

0

mH [G

eV]

114

300

1000

mt

[GeV

]mW [GeV]

Pre

limin

ary

68%

CL

∆α

LEP

1, S

LD D

ata

LEP

2, p

p− D

ata

★Im

pres

sive

cons

iste

ncy

betw

een

dire

ctan

din

dire

ctm

easu

rem

ents

of

& #

(with

poss

ible

exc

eptio

nof

NuT

eVre

sult)

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

23

Out

look

★In

abse

nce

ofsy

stem

atic

s,LE

Pst

atis

tical

prec

isio

non

' #

:

( )*

+-,. !

★D

ueto

curr

ent

FS

Iunc

erta

intie

s

//// -c

han

nel

cont

ribut

esve

rylit

tle

LEP

Tota

lE

rror

:

( 0 1

+ ,.

LEP

Tota

lE

rror

(

//2 3 4

alon

e):

( 00+ ,.

★H

uge

amou

ntof

ong

oing

wor

ktr

ying

toad

dres

sC

Rer

rors

(J.D

’Hon

dt’s

talk

)

Trad

e-of

fsy

s.an

dst

at.

erro

rsin

//// -c

han

nel?

★R

emo

vepa

rtic

lem

ost

affe

cted

byF

SI:

✫M

omen

tum

cuts

✫Je

tco

necu

ts

★P

ossi

ble

Gai

n:✫

Red

uce

FS

Ierr

ors

byfa

ctor

3?

✫co

st:

incr

ease

stat

.er

rors

by20

%

★Ta

keca

re:

hadr

oniz

atio

nun

cert

aini

ties

?

5 Fur

ther

cons

trai

nC

Rm

odel

sus

ing

data

DELPHI preliminary SK1 curves

-1000

100

200

300

400

500

600

10-1

110

102

Sta

ndar

d an

alys

is1

GeV

pcu

t2

GeV

pcu

t3

GeV

pcu

tC

one

R=1

.00

rad

Con

e R

=0.7

5 ra

dC

one

R=0

.50

rad

Con

e R

=0.2

5 ra

d

SK

1 M

odel

par

amet

er

κ∆mW / MeV/c

2

κ =

0.66

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

24

Out

look

and

Con

clu

sion

s

★M

ovin

gto

war

ds

final

LEP

' 6

resu

lts

★P

reci

sion

of

( 7987:; re

quire

sca

refu

lan

alys

is

★C

urre

ntre

sult

:

' 6<=7 80 *)( 7 87)>?A@BDCB 8E( 79871*?A@F@ 8E G,.

★E

xpec

tim

pro

vem

ents

:LE

Pbe

amen

ergy

unce

rtai

nty

)*

+-,. w

illco

me

dow

nR

educ

edst

at.

erro

r(im

pro

ved

anal

yses

+O

PAL

2000

data

)B

ette

run

der

stan

ding

ofha

dron

isat

ion/

dete

ctor

syst

emat

ics

My

gues

stim

ates

for

final

LEP

erro

r:

★W

itho

utsi

gnifi

cant

impr

ovem

ent

inF

SI:

1HJI07

MeV

★W

ithsi

gnifi

can

tim

pro

vem

ent

inF

SI:

1) I1H M

eV

Gue

sstim

ate

Cal

ibra

tion:

★Ia

lso

pred

ict

Eng

land

tow

inth

ene

xtw

orld

cup

atbo

thR

ugb

yan

dF

ootb

all

!

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03

25

Con

clu

sio

n:T

hejo

ysof

LEP

Inth

ene

arfu

ture

LEP

phys

ics

will

besu

mm

aris

edas

:“.

...pr

ecis

em

easu

rem

ents

ofth

em

asse

san

dco

uplin

gsof

the

KL and

M ...”

PERKINS,

High

EnergyPhysics,

NOPEDITION

(2007)

The

situ

atio

nin

1989

(yel

low

ellip

se).

...

74767880828486

8890

9294

9698

68 %

Err

or C

onto

ur

MZ /

GeV

MW /GeV

74767880828486

8890

9294

9698

68 %

Err

or C

onto

ur

MZ /

GeV

MW /GeV

74767880828486

8890

9294

9698

68 %

Err

or C

onto

ur

MZ /

GeV

MW /GeV

....a

ndno

w(b

lue

ellip

se)

M.T

hom

son

19Ju

ly20

03