�������������

�

���� �� ���� � �� �� ����� ��� �� ����

Honorable Muhammad Nawaz Sharif October 4, 2013

Prime Minister of Islamic Republic of Pakistan

Subject: REORGANIZATION OF THE SYSTEM OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT

As was pointed out in my letter titled “solving issues by introducing sub-system into system and

supra system” of June 7, 2013, thirty years of the prevailing electoral system have resulted in the

division of the nation amongst half a dozen regional/linguistic political parties along with a

number of pressure groups including terrorist organizations.

This is evident from the capture, in the May, 2013 elections, of Punjab by the Punjabi-led

PMLN, of Sindh by the Sindhi leadership of the PPP, of the KPK by an unholy alliance of PTI/JI

and of Baluchistan, with the blessings of the PMLN, by a Baloch leader reflective, in most cases,

of the self perpetuating interest of hereditary political parties.

The PMLN, the PPP, the PTI, the MQM, the JUI and the ANP are essentially proprietary parties

owned by a single person/family and neither are corruption, poverty and terrorism major issues

for them, nor do they have any solution for such irritants. Their one-point agenda is to keep

winning elections by hook or by crook and they are always prepared, for maintaining the

electoral status quo, at the cost of nation, to join hands with any electable candidate and to

guarantee him a share in the spoils of government.

While, on the one hand, our political structure, based in the village and the town inherited from

the British colonial period, reserves sovereign power for the feudal lords and the capitalists (and,

by evil evolution, for strong militant groups), on the other, our society fiber is based on

ISLAMIC IDELOGY evolved through the Masjid and the Madrisah.

Your attention is, in this context, drawn to paras 4 & 5, reproduced below, of the Preamble to the

1973 constitution:

Wherein the principles of democracy, freedom, equality, tolerance and social

justice, as enunciated by Islam, shall be fully observed;

Wherein the Muslims shall be enabled to order their lives in the individual and

collective spheres in accordance with the teachings and requirements of Islam as set out in

the Holy Quran and Sunnah.”

�������������

�

It need not be stated that the two kinds of principles are poles apart from each other, admitting

little room to move forward with conflicting systems because moving forward requires, nay

demands, compatibility of the political system with the societal fiber.

As far as the role, over the menace of terrorism, of sovereign authority is concerned, you may

like to seek guidance, in connection with the foregoing para-5 of the Preamble, to the following

Quranic edict:

O you have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And

if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah

and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result.(4:59)

You are authority, but majority dispute over electoral system. So as per Quranic edict we refer

this case to Allah and His Rasool and ask you!

1. Please cite a Quranic/Sunnah edict which allows multiparty system in Muslim

Ummah to govern the Muslim state.

2. Please cite a Quranic/Sunnah edict which confirms style of Government based

on trichotomy of power (legislature, judiciary and executive).

3. Please cite a Quranic/Sunnah edict which allows a party or candidate to present

Himself as the leader of Muslims and secure votes on the basis of hopes and

Promises (which hopes turn out to be false and which promises are neither meant

To be, nor are ever, fulfilled).

The above questions about the status, in terms of the Holy Quran/Sunnah, of the current political

practices have for some time been agitating many thinking minds in the Muslim Ummah: If,

therefore, you could kindly ponder the same for a few minutes and provide a response,

�

�������������

�

�

�

�

In the meantime, I will request you to please have a look at following proposal and use your

good offices and join hands together to establish a national institutional style government like

prophet tried to do as per Quranic edicts.

Allah’s mercy is all embracing: Despair not: Seek it before it is too late.

�

����� ���� ������ ��� �������� ����� � �� ��� �������!�"�#� �$� ���% ����&�'� �(�) �*���+ �� �,�'� �� ����� �-�./�0 �*�/��� �1�2�� �� ���� ���������� ���3��4�&�����/56� � �7� �8��& �9

Say, "O MY servants who have transgressed against themselves [by sinning], do not despair of

the mercy of Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives all sins. Indeed, it is He who is the Forgiving, the

Merciful."(39:53)

�������� ������������������������������������The Caliphate evolved as a form of government through the monotheistic supra system in the

tribal-cum-agriculture society when it was preparing to transform into a completely agriculture

society. The achievement of economic growth and the introduction of systematic taxation and

human rights endeared the caliphate to everyone, resulting in the disillusionment the world over

with all other forms of government. As a result, the Muslim caliphs, amirs, sultans and rulers

conquered major countries and continued to play a leading role in the world till the 18th century.

Conditions in the 17th century required that the caliphate and agriculture society introduce

reforms for the mechanization of agriculture and for the transformation, into professional

institutions, of tribal trades and skills. What was desirable in the new century was that neither

furniture should henceforth be made by carpenter families at their homes nor, similarly,

agriculture tools designed by blacksmith families. Instead, the need of the time was that proper

industries should be established for these and similar other purposes so that the production of

goods and services was weaned away from the monopoly of the tribe and family.

However, the Muslim rulers of the 17th century tried to block the evolution of modern industry

and institutions inured to the benefit of the general public and, instead, continued to practice

imperialism which was compatible neither with the evolving reality nor with the changing

mentality of the time. As a result, the 19th century saw the demise of Muslim power from the

world stage.

�

�������������

�

�

�

�

At this time, the British kingship not only established, but also encouraged and promoted the

emergence of industry and other institutions which enhanced the West’s role and prestige in the

world at large and led to the emergence, through the polytheistic supra system, of the democratic�

form of government based on the trichotomy of power vested in the legislature, judiciary and

executive representing the ideology of trinity and capitalism.

When, in the 20th century, mechanized agriculture societies were shaken by the industrial

revolution, the people started demanding that the intellectuals replace the old feudal lord-family

system of the colonial era and that elected public representatives determine the policies of the

government. Because the British Empire was unable to meet the demands of time, it was forced

to roll back to its foothold in England and, after fighting the two world wars, had to virtually

disappear from the global stage.

The US was able to utilize its vast natural resources to mechanize agriculture and promote

industrialization and soon started feeding the huge demand for consumer goods generated in the

world market of the 20th century. In the process, it became a global player of the industry

culture by adopting liberal democracy guaranteeing the freedom of religion to its citizenry and,

for this purpose, came up with the attractive slogan, for the believers, of IN GOD WE TRUST.

The time is now ripe for the transformation, in Muslim countries, of the system of governance in

such a way that the essence of government accords with the spirit of the Caliphate as it evolved

after the demise of the Prophet of Islam.

It bears repetition that the following four Caliphs belonged to, and represented, such major tribes

of the land as were well known for the profession/proficiency/specialty roughly corresponding

with today’s state institution indicated against each:

1. It may be recalled that when, during the renovation of the Kaaba, the chief of each tribe

staked his claim to the honour of placing the Hajr-e-Aswad in its intended position,

Prophet Muhammad resolved the matter by making the leaders of

four major tribes lift one corner each of a piece of cloth enveloped around Hajr-e-Aswad.

These were the tribes representing the institutions of justice, defence, trade and education

of the day and from them were drawn the individuals who led the Muslim Umma during

the first four Caliphates��

�

�������������

�

�

�

2. Honourable Abu Bakar Siddique, JUSTICE:

Though his father, Uthman Abu Quhafa, was still alive, he came to be recognized as chief

of his tribe Banu Tamim branch of the Quraysh tribe. He was assigned the office of

awarding blood money in cases of murder.

3. Honourable Umer Ibn-ul-Khatab, DEFENsE:

He was born in Mecca to the Banu Adi clan, which was responsible for arbitrations

among the tribes.

4. Honourable Uthman Ghani, COMMERCE:

He was born into the wealthy Umayyad (Banu Umayya) clan of the Quraysh. His father,

Affan, died young but left a large inheritance. He followed the same profession as his

father, and his business flourished, making him one of the richest men among the

Qurayshi tribe.

5. Honourable Ali Ibne Abu Talib, EDUCATION:

Whose tribe used to LOOK AFTER the Baitullah and its visitors. Being from

Prophet’s tribe, he became a source of education

What we need today is an up-gradation of that original Caliphate model by adding evolution of

time and space till to date, whereby the four institutions of justice, defence, Commerce and

education, evolved by election from the grass roots level upwards, will comprise the Executive

inured to the greatest happiness of the greatest number achieved in accordance with God’s word

revealed to the Prophet.

������� ������� ���� ������ �������� �� ��

������������������������ �������

Since the prevailing social contract rooted in Industrial Culture and envisaging the trichotomy of

power (vested in the legislature, judiciary and executive evolved in polytheism supra system) has

been unable to cope with the phenomenal speed of time, the 21st Century expects mankind to

come up with a fresh power sharing arrangement compatible with the recently-unfolded IT

Culture. Therefore, a broad-based five-branch (Executive, Education, Commerce, Defense and

Judiciary) democratic dispensation is the only way out for a nation/country aspiring to global

leadership in the new century. Such a government will, in conformity with universal

requirements and observable phenomena of Nature, generate a fresh social contract to ensure the �

happiness and growth of every individual, group, institution and (tier/level of) government/nation so

that a strong welfare state emerges to zealously safeguard the rights of every human being��

�������������

�

�

��������� ��!����Following proposed electoral system is compatible with suprasystem and systems for evolution

of sub-systems in our society fiber.

�

�����"�������

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

�����#�������

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

�����$�������

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

������%�������

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

��������������

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

�

��������������

�

�

�

�

�

��������������

�

�

�

�

�

�

��������������

�

�

&'(&)��*+�),(�,�

The state will play only a supervisory role, regulating and promoting every aspect of life through

public institutions. All forms of discretionary authority will be abolished and the spontaneity of

individuals will, through planning, foresight and co-operation, be channelled into appropriate

institutions. Public institutions will be run with citizen input provided at all levels.

The State will support initiatives, triggered by different social forces, which will be directed to

those in most need. The Government will consist of four ministries which will be established

through the introduction of public controlled institutions intended for the welfare of the society

and citizens.

Accordingly, we require a complete decoding of the present system for new coding in

accordance with corporate culture. Each code should be in consonance with our ideology,

religion reservations, desired cultural impacts, country resources and economic opportunities.

Each code must also be compatible with the needs of present and future conditions. I am

available for any query or feedback for any national cause.

Best wishes for a prosperous PAKISTAN.

Yours Sincerely

SYED AMMAR BUKHARI (Society Architect)

Cell: 0092-321-2345617 www.suprasystem.org

Ahbab House, Plot 174, Sector 30, Korangi Industrial Area, Karachi, Pakistan

www.maemaar.org.pk www.theradiantpath.org www.goodgovernance.org.pk

Enclosure: Letter and reminder sent to major (so called) Islamic parties =28-pages