leveraging six sigma for it process excellence
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
1
Leveraging Six Sigma forIT Process Excellence
WCBF 3rd
Annual Global Lean, Six Sigma and Business Improvement SummitOctober 16, 2008
Leveraging Six Sigma forIT Process Excellence
WCBF 3rd
Annual Global Lean, Six Sigma and Business Improvement SummitOctober 16, 2008
Jacob GranekManaging Director –
Information Services
Habs MoyDirector, MBB –
Business Reengineering & Quality
Jacob GranekManaging Director –
Information Services
Habs MoyDirector, MBB –
Business Reengineering & Quality
2
DTCCDTCC
Largest post-trade financial services infrastructure organization in the world: Over 13 billion equity and bond transactions processed in 2007
“Cradle-to-Grave” management of securities: Over $40 trillion of securities on deposit
Primary business focus on clearance, settlement and asset servicing for equity and fixed income securities: Over $1.86 quadrillion in securities settled in 2007
Industry owned
Largest post-trade financial services infrastructure organization in the world: Over 13 billion equity and bond transactions processed in 2007
“Cradle-to-Grave” management of securities: Over $40 trillion of securities on deposit
Primary business focus on clearance, settlement and asset servicing for equity and fixed income securities: Over $1.86 quadrillion in securities settled in 2007
Industry owned
3
Business Transformation at DTCCBusiness Transformation at DTCC
•
Catalyst for Change
•
Support DTCC Growth and Strategy
2010
2001
’02 to ‘06
2007
2000
The 100-Day
Plan
Launch of
Six Sigma
Program
Expansion
Program
Acceleration
1980’s
Quality Circles
Employee Participation Program
1990’s
Continuous Improvement Program
Cost of Non Conformance
Work Process Improvement
1980’s
Quality Circles
Employee Participation Program
1990’s
Continuous Improvement Program
Cost of Non Conformance
Work Process Improvement Early 2000’s
Launched Six Sigma
Quality Council
Central Quality Office
Balanced Business Scorecard
CMMI and ITIL
Early 2000’s
Launched Six Sigma
Quality Council
Central Quality Office
Balanced Business Scorecard
CMMI and ITIL
4
Engagement at DTCCEngagement at DTCC
97 GB, 88 YB (Lean), 10 BB, 4 MBB out of ~2700 employees
8 rounds of GB training
Online and instructor-led training
Over 300 projects completed since inception
800+ employees engaged
97 GB, 88 YB (Lean), 10 BB, 4 MBB out of ~2700 employees
8 rounds of GB training
Online and instructor-led training
Over 300 projects completed since inception
800+ employees engaged
Targeted training classes
Enhanced coaching skills
Project pipeline
Kaizen Events
Quality Day
Chairman’s Award for Quality
Targeted training classes
Enhanced coaching skills
Project pipeline
Kaizen Events
Quality Day
Chairman’s Award for Quality
Engaging the “Base”Engaging the “Base”
5
Engagement at DTCCEngagement at DTCCEngaging the “Middle”Engaging the “Middle”
Identify Project Champions
Expand Process Excellence
Identify Project Champions
Expand Process Excellence
Establish a Quality Forum – VP/Director
Require Business Process Management Training
Launch Quality Champion of the Year Award
Draw by example via Executive GB Training
Establish a Quality Forum – VP/Director
Require Business Process Management Training
Launch Quality Champion of the Year Award
Draw by example via Executive GB Training
6
IT at DTCC A Culture Of Metrics and a Role Model for the Enterprise Scorecard IT at DTCC A Culture Of Metrics and a Role Model for the Enterprise Scorecard
7
IT at DTCCIT at DTCC
Application DevelopmentCMMI Certified
Application DevelopmentCMMI Certified
Six Sigma Adoption9 Green Belts
15 Yellow Belts / Lean1 Black Belt in progress
2 Executive Green Belts in progress
Six Sigma Adoption9 Green Belts
15 Yellow Belts / Lean1 Black Belt in progress
2 Executive Green Belts in progress
IT InfrastructureITIL / COBIT Enabled
IT InfrastructureITIL / COBIT Enabled
8
Replicating Success for the EnterpriseReplicating Success for the Enterprise•
Pioneered use of Balanced Scorecard for IT Governance
•
Served as model for Enterprise Balanced Scorecard•
Pioneered use of Balanced Scorecard for IT Governance
•
Served as model for Enterprise Balanced Scorecard
9
The Big Picture IT Metrics in DTCC’s Process Excellence Initiative The Big Picture IT Metrics in DTCC’s Process Excellence Initiative
10
Process Excellence Burning Platform at DTCCProcess Excellence Burning Platform at DTCC
A metrics-driven senior management team
An imperative to factually demonstrate commitment to Quality
A desire to maintain excellent customer satisfaction results at world class 90% overall satisfaction
A need for a rallying methodology to engrain Quality improvement tools across ALL DTCC functional areas
A metrics-driven senior management team
An imperative to factually demonstrate commitment to Quality
A desire to maintain excellent customer satisfaction results at world class 90% overall satisfaction
A need for a rallying methodology to engrain Quality improvement tools across ALL DTCC functional areas
11
Process Excellence Rollout in 2007Process Excellence Rollout in 2007
Launched in January 2007Corporate goal to engage 8 business partnersProcess teams consisted of process champion, process owner, process managers and data providers
ResultsSurpassed corporate goal with rollouts in 15 areasBaseline metrics developed and targets set for 2008
Building on SuccessProcess Excellence Sigma Level Index becomes part of 2008 Balanced Scorecard2008 corporate goal to engage an additional 8 business partners
Launched in January 2007Corporate goal to engage 8 business partnersProcess teams consisted of process champion, process owner, process managers and data providers
ResultsSurpassed corporate goal with rollouts in 15 areasBaseline metrics developed and targets set for 2008
Building on SuccessProcess Excellence Sigma Level Index becomes part of 2008 Balanced Scorecard2008 corporate goal to engage an additional 8 business partners
12
Process Excellence RoadmapProcess Excellence Roadmap
ID Core Process
Map and/or SIPOC
ID Metrics
ID Process Specifications Start to
Track Metrics
Baseline& Control Charts ID Improvement
Targets
ID Pipeline of Improvement Projects
ID Process Team ID Project
TeamsLaunch Improvement Projects
Track Progressvs. Targets
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
1. Setting the Stage
1. Setting the Stage
2. Understanding the Issues
2. Understanding the Issues
3. Executing3. Executing
Curriculum:• E-Learning for Metrics• Process Control & Mgt• Lean
Line-UpProcess TeamMembers forTraining
13
IT Process Excellence MetricsIT Process Excellence Metrics
Effectiveness of Quality Assurance and non-Quality Assurance tested software releases
Accuracy of service requests handled by Network Engineering
Timeliness of completing desktop computing service delivery requests
Timeliness of access removal for terminated employees
Timeliness of consultant on-boarding
Effectiveness of Quality Assurance and non-Quality Assurance tested software releases
Accuracy of service requests handled by Network Engineering
Timeliness of completing desktop computing service delivery requests
Timeliness of access removal for terminated employees
Timeliness of consultant on-boarding
14
Pipeline for SuccessPipeline for Success
Project Pipeline
Process Improvement
Projects
Project Pipeline
Process Improvement
Projects
Sample ReportingProcess
Excellence Sigma Level
Index
Process Excellence
Sigma Level Index
15
View from the Top Two IT Executive Green Belt Projects View from the Top Two IT Executive Green Belt Projects
16
DTCC Executive Green Belt ProgramDTCC Executive Green Belt ProgramWhat is it?
•
Designed for Executive Leadership
•
8 sessions delivered over 16 weeks
•
Crystallized summary of GB staff training
•
Stresses key concepts versus completing deliverables
•
NOT a free ride for execs
What is it?
•
Designed for Executive Leadership
•
8 sessions delivered over 16 weeks
•
Crystallized summary of GB staff training
•
Stresses key concepts versus completing deliverables
•
NOT a free ride for execs
Benefits
•
Sets the tone from the top
•
Creates obvious executive sponsorship
•
Supports company’s commitment to Quality with our external customers
•
Feeds the project pipeline
•
Provides exposure to assigned Six Sigma coaches
•
Spreads energy across the company
•
Sends a strong message: “If an executive can make time for this, so should everyone else”
Benefits
•
Sets the tone from the top
•
Creates obvious executive sponsorship
•
Supports company’s commitment to Quality with our external customers
•
Feeds the project pipeline
•
Provides exposure to assigned Six Sigma coaches
•
Spreads energy across the company
•
Sends a strong message: “If an executive can make time for this, so should everyone else”
17
Roles and ResponsibilitiesRoles and ResponsibilitiesRole and Responsibility Executive
Candidate Project Leader Coach
Identify and select appropriate project √ √Commit to coaching and review sessions √ √Demonstrate competency around why data, tools and analyses are critical to project success √ √
Gain proficiency in knowing what questions to ask as a future project sponsor √
Provide one on one coaching to executive on tool usage and project deliverables √
Complete project deliverables per executive direction √
Understand relevance and process to complete project deliverables √ √
Review project deliverables to ensure correct tool usage and understanding √
Participate in public relations campaign for quality and reengineering to share project success stories √ √ √
Actively sponsor local and cross-functional projects √
BEF
OR
ED
UR
ING
AFT
ER
18
IT Notification & Alerts Re-engineeringIT Notification & Alerts Re-engineering
Project ScopeImprove systems monitoring infrastructure and customer support functions to enable interactive and rapid response to system and network alerts and high priority incident assignments
ImprovementsRetire legacy notification systems and migrate to a centralized messaging hubProvide a basis for improving customer support processes and service delivery response time with metrics trackingEliminate manual updates to user and paging groupsImprove accuracy of notification acknowledgements
Project ScopeImprove systems monitoring infrastructure and customer support functions to enable interactive and rapid response to system and network alerts and high priority incident assignments
ImprovementsRetire legacy notification systems and migrate to a centralized messaging hubProvide a basis for improving customer support processes and service delivery response time with metrics trackingEliminate manual updates to user and paging groupsImprove accuracy of notification acknowledgements
Executive Green Belt ProjectExecutive Green Belt Project
Standard SIPOC
Updated: 05-01-2008 E. McDonald
Supplier Input Process Output Customer
Systems Monitoring Infrastructure ITO Monitoring System Alert Events ITO System Monitoring Automated Facilities
System Event Notification and Alerting through a Central Notification Solution. Paging verification and Acknowledgement logs.
All IT System Owners and Technology StaffAccountable Product Manager
Network Monitoring Infrastructure NetCool Monitoring System - Network Alert Events
INetCool Monitoring Automated Facilities
Network Event Notification and Alerting through a Central Notification Solution. Paging verification and Acknowledgement logs.
Network Communications Technology Staff and Department Management
Service Desk Functions, Tier 1 & 2 Support Functions
Service Center Incident Ticket Created by Service Desk or Technical Support Functions.Reassignment of Problem Management Tickets
ITIL Incident Management Process Alarmpoint Notifications with Service Center Ticket that requires Acknowledgement.Escalation Notification upon Acknowledgement Failure.
Technology Support Functions, Infrastructure Management, Product Management & CSG Staff, Management and Stakeholders
Jacob Granek – Six Sigma Executive Green Belt Project
Project: Notification & Alert Services Improvement Project
Depository Trust &Clearing Corporation M C I A D
VOC
SIPOC
Cause & Effect
Failure to ReceiveSystem
Notification or Alert
(1) Alarmpoint Integration with PagingVendors Fail.
(2) Alarmpoint Integration FailureITO, Netcool Email Infrastructure
(5) Alarmpoint AdministrationError
(7) Data SynchronizationFailure
(3) Alarmpoint Network Configuration DMZ to Campus and Inter-site Connectivity
Service Delivery Causal Factors
Operations Causal Factors
(1a) Verizoninterconnect
(1b) AT&Tinterconnect
(1c) T-Mobileinterconnect
(1d) Skytelinterconnect
(2b) NetcoolIntegrator Fail
(3d) ADC / RDC Netcool DMZ Interconnectivity Problems
(2c) ITOIntegrator Fail
(3f) Core Alarmpoint DMZInterconnectivity Problemsw/ Notification Servers
(6) Phase 1: End UserNotification / Alert Send Error
(7a) Data Extract from SISInaccurate or Late
(7b) Device Data from Asset CenterInaccurate or Late
(5a) Network StaffUnable to AdminAlarmpoint
(5b) CSC StaffUnable to AdminAlarmpoint
(3e) RDC ITO DMZ Interconnectivity Problems
(5c) OTS Staff Unableto Admin Alarmpoint
(6a) NEO Staff Unable toSend Page to TargetEnd-point
(6b) CSC Staff Unable toSend Page to TargetEnd-point
(6c) OTS Staff Unable toSend Page to TestTarget End-points
(7c) Email Address & PagerNumber Information fromLotus Notes Inaccurate or Late
(7d) Dataset Changes unableto be Normalized Dynamically
(4) Systems AvailabilityBCP
(4b) Single Database SolutionReplication & Restore
Required
(4c) Application High-availability across sites
(4d) Core AlarmpointDMZ InterconnectivityProblems
(2a) Lotus NotesSMTP / IMAP Fail
(3c) ADC / RDC Netcool Campus Interconnectivity Problems
(3b) ADC / RDC ITO Campus Interconnectivity Problems
(3a) Core Alarmpoint Campus Interconnectivity Problems
(8) Metrics & Reporting
(4a) Inter-node NotificationServer High-availability Failure
(8a) Data schemais not accessible toperform reporting
(8b) Report Distribution Inoperable
(8c) Baseline data unavailable to establishoptimal performance targets withoutsignificant experimentation & analysis.
(8d) Tool reporting capabilities insufficientto identify notification Failures
DTCC Confidential
Depository Trust &Clearing Corporation
Voice of the Customer Jacob Granek – Six Sigma Executive Green Belt Project
Project : Notification & Alert Services Improvement Project Project Goal Statement: Improve the quality and effectiveness of DTCC’s Technology support functions by implementing an Enterprise notification and alerts solution that integrates with existing system monitoring and support tools and aligns with the ITIL processes by end of Q1 2008.
Project Scope: Phase 1 - Implement a centralized notification and alerts solution that integrates with DTCC’s system monitoring infrastructure and provides interactive communications with customer support tools for acknowledgement of Incident assignments.
Voice of the Customer - VOC Critical to Quality - CTQ Requestor:
Fill the gap in the ITIL Incident Management Process, where high-priority incident assignment notifications are not acknowledged and recorded in a timely fashion.
Improve incident response by requiring acknowledgement of high-priority incident notifications.
CTO
The Incident Management process does not currently generate Notification acknowledgement metrics that indicate staff response time to high-priority Incidents.
Enable continuous Incident Management process improvement through the creation of Notification acknowledgement metrics.
CTO
Eliminate the waste of maintaining an antiquated Notification system that requires manual administration of end-user and paging groups.
Improve the quality and accuracy of Notification & Alert services by eliminating manual administration of end-user and paging groups within text scripts.
Operations Technical Support Core Network Services
Improve end-user satisfaction by providing a means for users to verify receipt of Notifications or Alerts. This is currently a lengthy manual process that can only be performed by Operations staff.
Improve the quality of Notification & Alert services by providing end-users with the ability to validate the receipt or view the status of notification events through a web based user interface.
Operations Technical Support Core Network Services
M C I A D
19
Software Change Management ComplianceSoftware Change Management Compliance
•
Project Scope•
Analyze and recommend updates to SCM Compliance Metric (for IT Scorecard) collection and reporting process
•
Improvements•
All migrations will have an associated Risk profile which will help determine:
•
Number of lead days to notify SCM•
Levels of approval needed•
There will be 2 risk evaluation points in the project lifecycle
•
Pre-Build•
Pre-Production•
Selected solution will be incorporated in CMMI-based Application Development Process Architecture Model and ITIL-based Infrastructure processes
•
Project Scope•
Analyze and recommend updates to SCM Compliance Metric (for IT Scorecard) collection and reporting process
•
Improvements•
All migrations will have an associated Risk profile which will help determine:•
Number of lead days to notify SCM•
Levels of approval needed•
There will be 2 risk evaluation points in the project lifecycle•
Pre-Build•
Pre-Production•
Selected solution will be incorporated in CMMI-based Application Development Process Architecture Model and ITIL-based Infrastructure processes
Using Six Sigma to leverage ITIL to enable CMMI
ITILCMMI
SixSigma
Executive Green Belt ProjectExecutive Green Belt Project
20
View from the Trenches Kaizen for IT View from the Trenches Kaizen for IT
21
Be Customer CentricBe Customer Centric
95% 95% NonNon--Value Value
AddedAdded
5% 5% Value Value AddedAdded
Increase Value Added Activities Increase Value Increase Value
Added ActivitiesAdded Activities
0
10
2 0
3 0
4 0
50
6 0
1st Qt r 2 ndQt r
3 rdQt r
4 t h Qt r
Contribute to Continuous
Improvement
Contribute to Contribute to Continuous Continuous
ImprovementImprovement
Reduce Cycle timeReduce Cycle timeReduce Cycle time
改善 or KaizenJapanese, Verb, [Ky-zin],
“to make better”
改善 or KaizenJapanese, Verb, [Ky-zin],
“to make better”
Improve Customer Satisfaction
Improve Customer Improve Customer SatisfactionSatisfaction
Defect Levels
A hands-on series of activities that follow a ten step process, allowing a team of people to make rapid, action-oriented improvements across the enterprise
Events run from 1 to 5 days, implementing small incremental changes
that add up to big improvements. Usually low-cost / no-cost solutions that
can be implemented every day. Becomes a philosophical shift in doing
work, constantly looking for a better way
SalesSales
HRHR
QualityQuality
OperationsOperations
AccountingAccounting
TechnologyTechnology
CustomerCustomer
22
How do I identify a Kaizen opportunity?Does a process seem too complicated?Does it feel like there is a straightforward solution?Do you see non-value add (waste) activities in a process?Are multiple departments involved?Is a rapid implementation or fix needed?
How do I identify a Kaizen opportunity?Does a process seem too complicated?Does it feel like there is a straightforward solution?Do you see non-value add (waste) activities in a process?Are multiple departments involved?Is a rapid implementation or fix needed?
How do I prepare for a Kaizen?Identify all of the data available for the topic
Identify the problem statement “something causes something resulting in something”
Identify the perfect condition
How do I prepare for a Kaizen?Identify all of the data available for the topic
Identify the problem statement “something causes something resulting in something”
Identify the perfect condition
Who is involved in a Kaizen?
Subject matter experts Seasoned facilitator
“Process Neutral” contributors Empowered personnel
Who is involved in a Kaizen?
Subject matter experts Seasoned facilitator
“Process Neutral” contributors Empowered personnel
What Happens in a Kaizen?1. Define the problem2. Document the current situation3. Visualize the ideal situation4. Define measurement targets5. Brainstorm solutions to the problem6. Develop Kaizen plan7. Implement plan8. Measure, record and compare results to targets9. Prepare summary documents10.Create short term action plan, on-going standards
and sustaining plan
What Happens in a Kaizen?1. Define the problem2. Document the current situation3. Visualize the ideal situation4. Define measurement targets5. Brainstorm solutions to the problem6. Develop Kaizen plan7. Implement plan8. Measure, record and compare results to targets9. Prepare summary documents10.Create short term action plan, on-going standards
and sustaining plan
ACTACT
DODO
PLANPLAN
CHECKCHECK
If YES
a. You have identified an opportunity for a Kaizen event
b. You can contact Business Reengineering & Quality for recommended next steps
a. You have identified an opportunity for a Kaizen event
b. You can contact Business Reengineering & Quality for recommended next steps
23
Kaizen at DTCCKaizen at DTCC
Launched in 2007
Completed 10 Kaizen events across 20 departments
Operations (various units)
Finance / Purchasing / Accounts Payable / Receivable
Procurement / Corporate Services
Distributed Services / Application Development / IT
HR / Training / Security
Product Management
Launched in 2007
Completed 10 Kaizen events across 20 departments
Operations (various units)
Finance / Purchasing / Accounts Payable / Receivable
Procurement / Corporate Services
Distributed Services / Application Development / IT
HR / Training / Security
Product Management
24
•
Interdependency based User Guide •
Enterprise accountability for requests•
Acknowledgement of limited resources with realistic timelines•
Straight through communication between groups•
Enabler request prioritization•
Enterprise-wide portfolio management
Ideal Situation
IT Infrastructure Service Request KaizenIT Infrastructure Service Request Kaizen
•
Application Development service requests of IT Infrastructure do
not provide visible delivery expectations causing inefficiencies resulting in customer satisfaction issues.
Problem Statement
Limited ownership of requestsLack of request prioritizationLack of Service Level Agreements, Escalation, Key Performance IndicatorsLack of request visibilityCommunication gap between groups Cost of Poor Quality – cycle time, determining status, searching for requests
Waste Identification
Kaizen Implementation Results•
Established report structure and content
Sustaining Activities• Actively monitor Key Performance Indicators
Actual Storyboard
Actual Storyboard
25
Training & AwarenessBalanced ScorecardProcess Excellence
Training & AwarenessBalanced ScorecardProcess Excellence
Tying It All TogetherTying It All Together
A Culture of QualityA Culture of Quality
Executive GBExecutive GB
Kaizen
26
Contact InformationContact Information
Jacob GranekManaging Director –
Information Services
Habs MoyDirector, MBB –
Business Reengineering & [email protected]
212.855.5362
Corporate Website: www.dtcc.com
Jacob GranekManaging Director –
Information Services
Habs MoyDirector, MBB –
Business Reengineering & [email protected]
212.855.5362
Corporate Website: www.dtcc.com