liberi v taitz plaintiffs opp to sankey's rule 36(b) motion doc 498

8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opp to Sankey's Rule 36(b) Motion Doc 498

1/25

o

\KMIJ GB NGF\JF\^

Qkej~

\KMIJ GB NGF\JF\^&&&&&&&o

\KMIJ GB KZ\HG]O\OJ^&&&&&&&&oo$ooo

O& OF\]GLZN\OGF&&;$=

OO& ^\K\JDJF\ GB BKN\^=$5

OOO& \HJ ^KF@J_ LJBJFLKF\^ DG\OGF OÔFNGDQIOKF\ UO\H \HJ NGZ]\^

]ZIJ^ KFL ^HGZIL MJ LO^DO^^JL&8$?

K]EZDJF\&?$;8

OR& \HJ ^KF@J_ LJBJFLKF\^ DG\OGF \G

UO\HL]KU \HJO] KLDO^ÔGF^ LJJDJLKLDO\\JL K]J UO\HGZ\ DJ]O\?$;8

K& \hj kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ bkoi~ |g Gbbj} kfy

Rkiol ]jk~gf Uhy |hjo} Dg|ogf bg} ]jiojbb}gd Kldo~~ogf~ ~hgzil mj E}kf|jl0 kfl

E}kf|ofe ~znh ]jiojb ugzil Q}jczlonj |hjQikof|obb~&&&?$;8

R& NGFNIZÔGF)&&&&;8

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


2/25

oo

\KMIJ GB KZ\HG]O\OJ^

Nk~j~ Qkej(~/

??? r& N&O&\& Ng}q&) 552 B&=l 822) (?|h No}&;?8:/&&&;1

Nk}ljf r& Nhjfjek ^jnz}o|y " Q}g|jn|ogf ^j}r~&) IIN)=1;; UI ;>2&&&?

Bjl& ]& Nor& Q& >2(k/;1

Bjl& ]& Nor& Q& >2(k/(>/&8) ?

Bjl& ]& Nor& Q& >2(m/?) ;2

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


3/25

ooo

\KMIJ GB KZ\HG]O\OJ^ $ Ngf|ofzjl

IGNKI ]ZIJ^

Qkej(~/

]zij 2$;&=) 8

]zij 5$&=8

]zij ;;$>&8(k/8

]zij ;;$>&8(j/8

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


4/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf ;

;

=

>

;

=


5/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf =

;

=

>

;

=) =1;=) uhonh |hj zflj}~oefjl lol fg| }jnjorj zf|o

\zj~lky kb|j}fggf) Kq}oi ;5) =1;= k~ k }j~zi| gb ho~ ~z}ej}y& PMj}e Ljni&) q& ;;

=5T& Of |hjo} Dg|ogf) |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ }j{zj~|jl k Hjk}ofe lk|j gb Dky 5

=1;=) uhonh o~ fg| |odjiy fg|onjl& ^jj Ignki ]zij PI&]&T 2$;& \hj ^kf`jy

Ljbjflkf|~ Dg|ogf ~hgzil hkrj mjjf fg|onjl |ujf|y$joeh| P=8T lky~ mjbg}j |hj lky

gb Hjk}ofe) eorofe Qikof|obb~ k ujj` |g }j~qgfl PGqqg~o|ogf~ g} ]j~qgf~j~ k}j lzj

|ujf|y$gfj P=;T lky~ q}og} |g |hj Hjk}ofe lk|j) I&]& 5$?T& \hz~) Qikof|obb~ uj}j

zfkmij |g ]j~qgfl of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy~ Dg|ogf zf|oi fgu&

OO& ^\K\JDJF\ GB BKN\^3

Qikof|obb~ ~qjf| ~jrj}ki dgf|h~ k||jdq|ofe |g }jnjorj q}gqj} Ofo|oki

Lo~nig~z}j~ b}gd |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~& Qikof|obb~ bofkiiy }jnjorjl Lgnzdjf|~

|hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ nkiijl |hjo} Ofo|oki Lo~nig~z}j~ gf g} kmgz| Ckfzk}y =1)

=1;=& ^jj |hj Ljnik}k|ogf gb Qhoioq C& Mj}e) J~{zo}j boijl ngfnz}}jf|iy hj}juo|h

PMj}e Ljni&T k| qkej =)


6/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf >

;

=

>

;

=) qq& >1>$>;;T)

Gf Bjm}zk}y ;1) =1;=) Qikof|obb~ uj}j ~j}rjl uo|h |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~

Lo~ngrj}y }j{zj~|~ my uky gb Of|j}}gek|g}oj~ kfl grj} bgz} hzfl}jl kfl |ujf|y

|h}jj PT ]j{zj~|~ bg} Q}glzn|ogf gb Lgnzdjf|~& \hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ uj}j

k~`ofe bg} Lgnzdjf|~ b}gd jknh gb |hj Qikof|obb~) ~jqk}k|jiy) bg} jrj}y qk}ke}kqh

gb Qikof|obb~ Bo}~| Kdjfljl Ngdqikof|) ofnizlofe Qikof|obb~ kfl Ljbjflkf|~

Cz}o~lon|ogfki ^|k|jdjf|~) Rjfzj) kfl nikod~ kekof~| |hj g|hj} Ljbjflkf|~

Qikof|obb~ }j~qgf~j~ uj}j lzj gf g} mjbg}j Dk}nh ;=) =1;=) kb|j} |hj Lo~ngrj}y

Nz|$Gbb Lk|j gb Dk}nh :) =1;=& Qikof|obb~ kf~uj}jl |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~

Lo~ngrj}y }j{zj~|~ gf Dk}nh ?) =1;=) uhonh uk~ |odjiy& PMj}e Ljni&) qq& 5$8

;2T&

''''''''

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


7/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf

;

=$>;;2$>;?T& D}

Mj}e }j~qgfljl |g D}& Ngijf~ Jdkoi ~|k|ofe hj |gg` ho~ }j~qgf~j k~ hj lol fg|

ke}jj uo|h Qikof|obb~ of|jf|ogf gb boiofe k Dg|ogf bg} ^zddk}y Czledjf| kfl

~gzeh| Ijkrj gb Ngz}| |g boij k Dg|ogf bg} ^zddk}y Czledjf| kekof~| |hj ^kf`jy

Ljbjflkf|~& PMj}e Ljni&) q& 8) ;8) Jxm~& ;2 kfl ;5) qq& >=;$>=?T&

Gf Dk}nh ;) =1;=) D}& Ngijf ~jf| kf Jdkoi |g |hj zflj}~oefjl ~|k|ofe bg}

zfkf|onoqk|jl }jk~gf~) |hj ]j~qgf~j |g Qikof|obb~ Lo~ngrj}y ]j{zj~|~ uj}j ik|j

D}& Ngijf ~|k|jl Qikof|obb~ ugzil }jnjorj |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ }j~qgf~j~ of |ug

P=T ujj`~) uhonh ugzil hkrj mjjf |hj ;:|h gb Dk}nh) =1;=& PMj}e Ljni&) qq& 8$?

;8) Jxm& ;8) q& >>;T&

\hj Ngz}| E}kf|jl Qikof|obb~ Ijkrj |g boij |hjo} Dg|ogf bg} ^zddk}y

Czledjf| kekof~| |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ gf Dk}nh 2) =1;=&

Qikof|obb~ boijl |hjo} Dg|ogf bg} ^zddk}y Czledjf| gf Dk}nh ==) =1;=

Lgn`j| Fzdmj}~ PLFT


8/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf :

;

=

>

;

=>>$>:8T& \hj Ngz}| E}kf|jl |hj ]j{zj~|jl

Ijkrj gf Dk}nh ;>) =1;=& ^jj LF :8$>8=T& \g lk|j) Qikof|obb~ hkrj fg| }jnjorjl }j~qgf~j~ |g kfy gb |hjo}

Lo~ngrj}y }j{zj~|~ b}gd Fjoi ^kf`jy g} ^kf`jy Ofrj~|oek|ogf~) uhg boijl

Mkf`}zq|ny gf Dk}nh ?) =1;=) kb|j} |hj Lo~ngrj}y nz|$gbb lk|j gb Dk}nh :) =1;=

Qikof|obb~ hkrj fg| }jnjorjl }j~qgf~j~ b}gd \gll ^kf`jy g} \hj ^kf`jy Bo}d) Ofn

|g Qikof|obb~ Of|j}}gek|g}oj~ g} ]j{zj~| bg} Q}glzn|ogf gb Lgnzdjf|~& PMj}e Ljni&

q& ?) ==T&

Gf Dk}nh >1) =1;=) |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ~gzeh| Ijkrj gb Ngz}| |g boij k

Dg|ogf |g Ngdqji Qikof|obb~ Lo~ngrj}y }j~qgf~j~) jrjf |hgzeh Qikof|obb~ |odjiy

kfl ~zbbonojf|iy Kf~uj}jl |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ Lo~ngrj}y ]j{zj~|~0 ]j{zj~| bg}

^|ky gb Qikof|obb~ Dg|ogf bg} ^zddk}y Czledjf| kekof~| |hj ^kf`jy~0 kfl k |jf

P;1T lky Jx|jf~ogf gb \odj |g Kf~uj} Qikof|obb~ Dg|ogf bg} ^zddk}y Czledjf|&

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


9/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf 2

;

=

>

;

=1T lky~Ngijf bo}~| mjnkdj kuk}j gb |hj q}gmijd uhjf hj ~ku |hj

Ngz}| E}kf|jl Ijkrj |g Qikof|obb~ |g boij k Dg|ogf bg} ^zddk}y Czledjf| mk~jl gf

Kldo~~ogf~ dklj gf k |jnhfonki mk~o~ }k|hj} |hkf gf |hj |}z|h& K~ jxqikofjl

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


10/25


;

=

>

;

=8=T0 Qikof|obb~ hkrj fg| }jnjorjl

}j~qgf~j~ |g kfy gb |hj Lo~ngrj}y }j{zj~|~ ~j}rjl zqgf Fjoi ^kf`jy PMj}e Ljni&)

q& ?) ==T0 kfl |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ lol fg| boij |hjo} Dg|ogf bg} ]jiojb zf|oi

Kq}oi ;>) =1;=) k dgf|h kb|j} Ijkrj gb Ngz}| uk~ E}kf|jl) ^jj LF


11/25


;

=

>

;

=&8(j/0

ooo& \hj Ljnik}k|ogf gb \gll kf`jy) mjeoffofe gf qkej |ug P=T) o~ fg| gf

fzdmj}jl qijklofe qkqj})I&]& ;;$>&=0

or& \hj M}ojb of ~zqqg}| gb |hjo} Dg|ogf o~ fg| gf q}gqj} qijklofe qkqj}

I&]& ;;$>&=0

r& Ngzf~ji bg} |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ bkoijl |g qz| ho~ mk} fzdmj} gf |hj

bo}~| qkej gb jknh lgnzdjf|& ^jj LF


12/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf ?

;

=

>

;

=2(k/(>/&

Qz}~zkf| |g |hj Ngz}|~ I&]&) 5$1T lky~ kb|j} ~j}ronj gb |hj

]j{zj~|~)Bjl& ]& Nor& Q& >2(k/(>/& Ob k qk}|y bkoi~ |g }j~qgfl |g |hj ]j{zj~|~ bg}

Kldo~~ogf~ uo|hof |hj |ho}|y P>1T lky~) |hj dk||j}~ of |hj ]j{zj~|~ bg} Kldo~~ogf~

k}j Ljjdjl Kldo||jl kfl ngfniz~orjiy j~|kmio~hjl&Bjl& ]& Nor& Q& >2(k/(>/

>2(m/0 Ngfigf r& Z&^&) l 2;2) 2=; (? |h No}& =115/& Qz}~zkf| |gBjl& ]& Nor&

Q& >2(m/) |hj Ngz}| dky qj}do| uo|hl}kuki g} kdjfldjf| Pgb kf kldo~~ogfT ob o|

ugzil q}gdg|j |hj q}j~jf|k|ogf gb |hj dj}o|~ gb |hj kn|ogf kfl ob |hj Ngz}| o~ fg|

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


13/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf ;1

;

=

>

;

=2(m/& Uhj|hj} ~znh }jiojb o~ kqq}gq}ok|j

o~ egrj}fjl my k |ug$q}gfejl |j~|3 k ngz}| dky qj}do| uo|hl}kuki g} kdjfldjf|

ob o| ugzil P;T q}gdg|j |hj q}j~jf|k|ogf gb |hj dj}o|~ gb |hj kn|ogf kfl P=T ob |hj

ngz}| o~ fg| qj}~zkljl |hk| o| ugzil q}jczlonj |hj }j{zj~|ofe qk}|y of dkof|kofofe g}

ljbjflofe |hj kn|ogf gf |hj dj}o|~&Ol& ^jj ki~g ??? r& N&O&\& Ng}q&) 552 B&=l 822

(?|h No}&;?8:/&

]zij >2(m/ q}j~jf|~ k qj}do~~orj ~|kflk}l) kfl uhj|hj} k qk}|y o~ jf|o|ijl |g

}jiojb of |hj bg}d gb uo|hl}kuki g} kdjfldjf| gb }j~qgf~j~ |g }j{zj~|~ bg}

kldo~~ogf~ ioj~ uo|hof |hj lo~n}j|ogf gb |hj lo~|}on| ngz}|& Ngfigf) l k| 2=;

Hgujrj}) P|Thj }zij qj}do|~ |hj lo~|}on| ngz}| |g jxj}no~j o|~ lo~n}j|ogf |g e}kf|

}jiojb b}gd kf kldo~~ogf dklj zflj} ]zij >2(k/ gfiy uhjf (;/ |hj q}j~jf|k|ogf gb

|hj dj}o|~ gb |hj kn|ogf uoii mj ~zm~j}rjl) kfl (=/ |hj qk}|y uhg gm|kofjl |hj

kldo~~ogf bkoi~ |g ~k|o~by |hj ngz}| |hk| uo|hl}kuki g} kdjfldjf| uoii q}jczlonj

|hk| qk}|y of dkof|kofofe |hj kn|ogf g} ljbjf~j gf |hj dj}o|~& Ol& (no|k|ogf~ kfl

{zg|k|ogf dk}`~ gdo||jl/& \hj qk}|y }jiyofe gf |hj ljjdjl kldo~~ogf hk~ |hj

mz}ljf gb q}grofe q}jczlonj& Ol& k| 2==& \hj~j |ug bkn|g}~ k}j njf|}ki |g |hj

kfkiy~o~& Ol& k| 2=:& K lo~|}on| ngz}| dky ki~g ngf~olj} g|hj} bkn|g}~) ofnizlofe

uhj|hj} |hj dgrofe qk}|y nkf ~hgu eggl nkz~j bg} |hj ljiky kfl uhj|hj} |hj

dgrofe qk}|y kqqjk}~ |g hkrj k ~|}gfe nk~j gf |hj dj}o|~&Ol&

Nk~j 83;;$nr$11


14/25

Iomj}o) j| ki) Qikof|obb~ Djdg}kflzd of Gqqg~o|ogf |g |hj ^kf`jy Ljbjflkf|~ ]zij >2(m/ Dg|ogf ;;

;

=

>

;

=

liberi v taitz plaintiffs opp to sankey's rule 36(b) motion doc 498

Documents