listening to data
DESCRIPTION
Kaarin Hoff and Daniel O'Neil keynote from A2 Data Dive : Conversation based, data driven strategy for better visualizations. Discussion of what makes visualizations great. Definition of core principles: clear, useful, ethical, credible.TRANSCRIPT
@undrstndng
Listening to Data
Daniel O’Neil, Business Analyst @phoenix1189 Kaarin Hoff, Information Architect @kaarinhThe Understanding Group (TUG) @undrstndng
Conversation based, Data driven strategy for better visualizations
@undrstndng
The Understanding Group is an Information Architecture practice dedicated to making things be good.
We work to Understand the goals of your Business and Users, then we architect your information to achieve those goals.
@undrstndng
Kaarin HoffInformation Architect, TUG
Source: http://www.artble.com/artists/johannes_vermeer, http://ffffound.com/home/vvva/found/
@undrstndng
Daniel O’Neil Business Analyst, TUG
Source: http://scan.oxfordjournals.org/content/2/4/323/F2.expansion
Source: http://www-personal.umich.edu/~phyl/baboon.html
@undrstndng
Visualizations are part of our everyday life
@undrstndng
PURPOSE:To provide a core set of
principles that transcend best practices
@undrstndng
@undrstndng
p. 126-139
@undrstndng
422,000
10,000
Show comparisons
@undrstndng
Show explanation
Temperature
@undrstndng
Show multiple variables
@undrstndng
Show information in layers
Main point
More 2
More 3
More
@undrstndng
Show documentation
@undrstndng
Details matter
@undrstndng
Uhh, we’re not here to talk about military history….
True: but the lessons of this visualization persist
@undrstndng
All visualizations:
• Are rhetorical actsAsk deep value questions – what matters? What do we really care about? How are we going to describe our world?
• Are abstractionse.g. Histogram buckets
• Work on multiple dimensionsVisual, cognitive, emotional, analytical
The Common DNA of Visualizations
@undrstndng
Source: http://iqcontent.com/blog/2009/11/dublins-new-subway-system-well-subway-map/
@undrstndng
Source: http://www.tokyometro.jp/en/subwaymap/pdf/routemap_en.pdf
@undrstndng
From book,
The Art of Clear Up
@undrstndng
Source:
@undrstndng
Source: http://rt.uits.iu.edu/visualization/analytics/docs/ttest-docs/ttest1.php
@undrstndng
@undrstndng
Conversation Based
Your data has a point of view, and wishes to start a conversation
Core Principle of Presenting Data
Source: https://www.earlymoments.com/dr-seuss/How-to-Use-Dr-Seuss-Book-Clubs/Advanced-Reader-Books/
@undrstndng
Visualizations should be:• Clear
• Useful
• Ethical
• Credible
Realizing the Conversation Principle
@undrstndng
Can someone describe what your chart is trying to do in 2 sentences using simple words?
Better yet, can two people look at the chart and give the same basic explanation?
Pick a model based on your information, not vice-versa.
Clear
@undrstndng
Worldwide Nuclear Weapon Detonations
A Real-Time Map of Births and Deaths
Let’s look at some examples:
@undrstndng
Key data points are visible without relying on interaction
Data is downloadable as a table (assuming interactive data)
Is applicable/appropriate to your audience and your goals
Useful
@undrstndng
Worldwide Nuclear Weapons Detonations
A Real-Time Map of Births and Deaths
Let’s look at those examples again:
@undrstndng
While designing the chart, write down what you are leaving out and review it.
Identify what narrative you are trying to tell and determine if what you are leaving out undermines that narrative.
If a story is too complex to tell in a chart, it may not be true.
Change scale, proportions, etc on the chart to identify possible distortions of the visual data.
Ethical
@undrstndng
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2011
@undrstndng
A lot of this is an outcome of doing other things right, but there are some things you can do make sure you don’t lose credibility:
• Aesthetic decisions
• Citations
• Proper professional and cultural vernacular for audience (e.g. physicists vs. engineers, dollar vs. euro, children vs. adults)
Credible
@undrstndng
Finding: Between 1990 and 2008 there was a forty-five percent decline in violent crime
Many theories about this:
• Community policing
• Improved economic situation
• “Tough on Crime” and prisons
U.S. Crime Rate Trends
@undrstndng
Community policing happened after initial decline
Crime continued to drop even in a bad economy
Prison population growth largely made up of nonviolent offenders
Credibility problems
@undrstndng
The “Pb” Theory
Source: http://science.howstuffworks.com/lead.htm
@undrstndng
Correlate Related Measures
Source: http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/01/lead-crime-link-gasoline
@undrstndng
Layered Information
@undrstndng
Policy Rhetoric
@undrstndng
Hear the Who
@undrstndng
Resources
• Data Visualization Best Practices by Jen Underwood
• http://www.slideshare.net/idigdata/data-visualization-best-practices-2013
• More on Abstraction by Kaarin• 20 minute version from IA Summit: http://understandinggroup.com/2013/04/abstraction-for-clarity/
• 5 minute version from A2 Ignite UX: http://understandinggroup.com/2013/10/ignite-ux-ann-arbor-abstraction-talk/
@undrstndng
Comments? Thoughts? We’d love to hear from you
www. understandinggroup.com
Daniel O’Neil, @phoenix1189 Kaarin Hoff, @kaarinh