lobbying ang media, work with politicians and journalist
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
1/79
A SPECIALLY COMMISSIONED REPORT
LOBBYING AND THE
MEDIA: WORKING WITH
POLITICIANS ANDJOURNALISTS
Michael Burrell
T H O R O G O O D
P R O F E S S I O N A L
I N S I G H T S
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
2/79
Blank page
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
3/79
Michael Burrell
LOBBYING AND THE MEDIA:WORKING WITH POLITICIANS AND JOURNALISTS
A Thorogood Report
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
4/79
Published by Thorogood
10-12 Rivington Street
London EC2A 3DU
t: 020 7749 4748
f: 020 7729 6110
w: www.thorogood.ws
Michael Burrell 2001
All rights reserved.No part of this
publication may be reproduced,stored in
a retrieval system or transmitted in any form
or by any means,electronic,photocopying,
recording or otherwise,without the prior
permission of the publisher.
This Report is sold subject to the
condition that it shall not,by way of trade
or otherwise,be lent,re-sold,hired out or
otherwise circulated without the publishers
prior consent in any form of binding or
cover other than in which it is published
and without a similar condition including
this condition being imposed upon
the subsequent purchaser.
No responsibility for loss occasioned to
any person acting or refraining from action as
a result of any material in this publication can
be accepted by the author or publisher.
A CIP catalogue record for this Report
is available from the British Library.
ISBN 1 85418 240 4
Printed in Great Britain by printflow.com
Other Thorogood
Reports:
European Lobbying Guide
Bryan Cassidy
Internal Communications
James Farrant
Managing Reputation
in Cyberspace
David Phillips
Public Affairs Techniques
for Business
Peter Wynne-Davies
New Media in Corporate
Communications
Mic Cady
Managing Corporate
Reputation
Simon Scott
Practical Techniques for
Effective Lobbying
Charles Miller
Power over Stress
at Work
Dr Daniel Araoz
Strategic Customer
Planning
Alan Melkman
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
5/79
Acknowledgements
I could not have written this Report without the support and wisdom of many
of my colleagues and competitors.To the extent that it contains useful advice,
they should take much of the credit.To the extent that there are errors of fact or
judgement, they are mine alone.
I should particularly like to thank:Leighton Andrews (Westminster Strategy),Maurits
Bruggink (Grayling Political Strategy, Brussels), Howard Dawber (Bell Pottinger),
Jim Eadie (Strategy in Scotland),Richard Gordon (Stormont Strategy), Joy Johnson
(GPC),Heidi Lambert (Heidi Lambert Communications,Brussels),Matteo Maggiore
(Grayling Political Strategy,Brussels),Glyn Matthias (Strategy Wales),Huw Roberts
(Strategy Wales) and Laura Sandys.
Of the texts that I have consulted,I should particularly mention:Philip Norton,
The British Polity, Longman, 2001, Andrew Rawnsley, Servants of the People,
Hamish Hamilton,2000 and articles by Stephen Coleman, Research Director of
the Hansard Society.
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
6/79
The author
Michael Burrellwas educated at St Peters College, Oxford, where he read
Philosophy,Politics and Economics,specialising in international relations.He began
his journalistic career on newspapers in Durham and Brighton,before joining the
Parliamentary lobby. Based in the House of Commons press gallery,he reported
on both Westminster and Whitehall and the European Union, covering summit
meetings around Europe and plenary sessions of the European Parliament in
Strasbourg.
He began his career in lobbying in 1983,founding Westminster Strategy,of which
he is now Chairman,in 1986.Since 1999 he has been Chairman of the UK lobbying
industrys self-regulatory body,the Association of Professional Political Consultants
(APPC).
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
7/79
Contents
INTRODUCTION 1
1AN INTRODUCTION TO LOBBYING 3
What is lobbying? .........................................................................................4
Where does the word lobbyingcome from? ...............................................5
Lobbying in Washington ...............................................................................5
Lobbying in Britain and Brussels ..................................................................6
The cash-for-questions affair ........................................................................7
The Association of Professional Political Consultants ..................................9
2HOW TO LOBBY 11The rules of lobbying .................................................................................12
3 18Media exposure ..........................................................................................19
Circumstances to consider before promoting media interest ....................20
Circumstances where you would be well advised
to promote media interest ..........................................................................22
INVOLVING THE MEDIA THE CASE FOR
AND THE CASE AGAINST
C O N T E N T S
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
8/79
4WHITEHALL AND WESTMINSTER 24The senior civil service ..............................................................................25The power of the Prime Minister and Cabinet Ministers ...........................27Where does power lie within the executive? .............................................28
Parliament ...................................................................................................28
The initiation and formulation of public policy in Britain .........................30
5 32The Downing Street Press Office ...............................................................33
The lobby ...................................................................................................35
The national media .....................................................................................36
6SCOTLAND, WALES AND NORTHERN IRELAND 38Scotland ......................................................................................................39
Wales ..........................................................................................................41Northern Ireland ........................................................................................42
7 44The European Union ..................................................................................45The Brussels press corps ............................................................................47
Media targets ..............................................................................................49
THE EUROPEAN UNION AND THE
BRUSSELS PRESS CORPS
THE DOWNING STREET PRESS OFFICE,
THE LOBBY AND THE NATIONAL MEDIA
C O N T E N T S
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
9/79
8MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS 51Lobbying and media relations campaigns ..................................................53
9THE INTERNET 55
The impact of the Internet on lobbying .....................................................56
The main political uses of the Internet ......................................................58
The role of online media in lobbying .........................................................59
Text messaging ...........................................................................................60
10 HOW TO WORK WITH JOURNALISTS 61The basic tools of media relations ..............................................................62
What to avoid when dealing with journalists .............................................65
CONCLUSION 69
C O N T E N T S
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
10/79
Introduction
This is a how-to guide:how to lobby,how to handle the media and when and how
to use media relations in support of direct lobbying. The practical advice is
primarily aimed at those who are both lobbying and dealing with journalists,
though it should equally be of some interest to those who are doing one or the
other.
Although many of the principles explained are applicable anywhere, it is
primarily designed to help consultants and in-house lobbyists based in the United
Kingdom and Brussels.
The first chapter provides an introduction to lobbying, explaining its origins,
describing the growth of professional lobbying in Britain and Brussels and looking
at recent controversies surrounding lobbying in Britain, notably cash for
questions and Drapergate.
This is followed by a how-toguide to ethical and effective lobbying,with a series
of concrete and practical tips on how best to make your case to officials and
politicians.
A central theme of the Report is the issue of whether and how to adopt a media
relations strategy in support of a lobbying campaign. Often, where a campaign
is well on the road to success or alternatively where the issues involved are very
technical,it makes no sense at all to involve the media and can even be damaging.
However,there will be many occasions when a media campaign can provide vital
support to lobbying and this Report offers clear guidance on when this is likely
to be so.
Although the general principles of dealing with politicians,officials and journalists
are the same the world over, the professional campaigner needs to be aware of
the specific political and media landscapes in the key locations where he (or she;
please accept he in this Report as a simple abbreviation) may need to operate.
So,after a whistle-stop tour of Whitehall and Westminster,the Report looks in detail
at the London media, including the Parliamentary lobby, as well as the media in
Scotland,Wales and Northern Ireland. A review of the European Union institutions
is followed by a detailed overview of the Brussels press corps,perhaps the largest
single concentration of journalists in the world, and how to engage with it.
One of the situations where it will often be vital to run a co-ordinated lobbying
and media strategy will be in the case of a contested takeover bid.The Report
examines how lobbyists work with financial public relations consultants,lawyersand investment bankers to maximise the chances of success.
I N T R O D U C T I O N
1
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
11/79
It is only very recently that the Internet has come to play an important role in
both the economy and politics. The Report seeks to draw some tentative
conclusions about the role of the Internet in political lobbying.
Finally it concludes with a practical how-to guide to dealing with journalists,
reviewing the basic tools of any media strategy and listing some pitfalls to avoid.
I N T R O D U C T I O N
2
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
12/791chapter
An introduction to lobbying
W H A T I S L O B B Y I N G ?
W H E R E D O E S T H E W O R D L O B B Y I N G C O M E F R O M ?
L O B B Y I N G I N W A S H I N G T O N
L O B B Y I N G I N B R I T A I N A N D B R U S S E L S
T H E C A S H - F O R - Q U E S T I O N S A F F A I R
T H E A S S O C I A T I O N O F P R O F E S S I O N A L P O L I T I C A L C O N S U L T A N T S
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
13/79
Chapter 1:
An introduction to lobbying
What is lobbying?
The classic dictionary definition of lobbying would be something along the lines
of to attempt to influence legislators in the formulation of policy. In practice,
as we shall see,legislators are in reality only one of the groups that lobbyists seek
to target.
Although lobbying of various kinds is conducted around the world, its
development as a trade or profession is primarily an Anglo-Saxon concept and
has historically been treated with suspicion elsewhere for example, in France
and Germany though this is starting to change.
In Britain we can trace the origins of the right to lobby back to Magna Carta,the
charter granted by King John at Runnymede in 1215, recognising the rights and
privileges of the barons, church and freemen and, in particular, their right to
petition for redress of grievance.A lot of water has flowed under WestminsterBridge since then and power structures have changed dramatically,but the basic
concept is recognisable.
One of historys most famously aggrieved groups were the American colonies,
who resented their treatment at the hands of George III,fought a war to gain their
independence and have been deeply suspicious of authority ever since. Hence
the Bill of Rights,the first ten amendments to the United States constitution,added
in 1791,guaranteeing the liberty of the individual. More specifically, the Bill of
Rights enshrines the American respect for freedom of speech and forbids Congress
from enacting any law that would place obstacles in the way of the citizens rightto petition for redress of grievance.
So we can see that the right to lobby,as we would say today,is deeply entrenched
in Anglo-Saxon culture.Indeed,many would argue that it is that right for ones voice
to be heard that distinguishes democracies from totalitarian societies,a voice that
can be heard every few years in elections but that,in the Anglo-Saxon tradition at
least,requires channels for every-day use.
C H A P T E R 1 : A N I N T R O D U C T I O N T O L O B B Y I N G
4
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
14/79
Where does the word lobbying come from?
Prosaically, some say, from the word for a hall in a legislative building used formeetings between legislators and members of the public.Personally, I prefer to
believe the more colourful American version,which has it deriving from the lobby
of the Willard Inter-Continental Hotel, in downtown Washington DC, just two
blocks from the White House.
It was the bar at the Willard that was the favourite watering hole of Ulysses S.Grant,
commander in chief of the Union forces in the American Civil War and then US
President from 1869 to 1877. Grant, like many British politicians, was fond of
drowning his sorrows in whisky and, the story goes, those who wanted his help
when he was President quickly realised that the Willard was their best bet for anencounter. Hence they took to loitering in the hotel lobby to greet him as he
entered.
I think that sounds plausible.Every President since 1853 has slept or wined and
dined there and it was where Martin Luther King wrote his I have a dreamspeech.
If you visit the Willard today it still has an air of closeness to power and is often
full of lobbyists and the lobbied.
Lobbying in Washington
Perhaps because Washington has always been a one-industry town, with most
businesses based elsewhere,and partly because it is the most powerful capital
in the world,it was there that professional lobbying grew into a sizeable business
of its own in the last century.Today the Washington lobbying scene is the most
developed in the world and some,though by no means all, of its characteristics
have been or will be emulated elsewhere.
One feature of Washington that sets it apart from London and Brussels is that the
consultancy landscape is more fragmented. In Europe consultancies tend to be
generalists,while in Washington consultancies tend to be more specialist, both
by industry sector and tools deployed. In Europe consultancies may call
themselves lobbyists or public affairs or government relations consultants, but
whatever the name,they all do much the same thing.By contrast, in Washington
there are some clear delineations by technique.
So,for example,a public affairs consultancy will be one that has a strong reliance
on media relations. A government relations firm will tend to focus on long-term
political positioning. A lobbying company will traditionally be a firm of lawyers,
whose key skills are drafting legislation (for a legislature where any Senator or
Congressman can initiate legislation) and lobbying on Capitol Hill.
C H A P T E R 1 : A N I N T R O D U C T I O N T O L O B B Y I N G
5
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
15/79
One striking feature of lobbying in the US is the effort put into seeking
favourable media coverage.Here the single most important target,since the nations
capital is pretty much a one-newspaper town,is the op-ed(opposite the editorialcomment) page of the Washington Post.With the single exception of the mid-
market newspaper, USA Today (and the weekly news magazines, Time and
Newsweek),no newspaper covers the country,though both theNew York Times
and theLos Angeles Times are influential in the two key states of New York and
California. Of the business press, the Wall Street Journal, with an American
circulation of 1,800,000,is the most important.Beyond those titles,the lobbyists
will target the home newspapers of every Senator and Congressman.
Lobbying in Britain and Brussels
The British lobbying industry and that of Brussels is a surprisingly recent
phenomenon,dating back,for the most part,not much more than a quarter of a
century.
Today there are over 50 lobbying consultancies in Westminster (of whom half,
including the largest, are grouped in the Association of Professional Political
Consultants (APPC)).The generally acknowledged pioneer in Westminster was
Commander Christopher Powell,whose consultancy flourished in the years afterthe Second World War.By most accounts he was a brilliant, if somewhat arrogant
man,whose knowledge of how Parliament works was unrivalled.However,it was
not until the 1970s and 1980s that lobbying consultancies grew to any size, with
Ian Greer later to be famous and GJW (founded in 1980 and now part of BSMG)
among the earliest.
In Brussels a handful of enterprising Britons started the first consultancies around
the same time.Today, it is said (but who could possibly have counted?),there are
10,000 lobbyists in Brussels from around the globe. In addition, it is far more
common today than even ten years ago to find major companies employing theirown in-house lobbyists or Directors of Public Affairs, as they are more likely to
be known.
C H A P T E R 1 : A N I N T R O D U C T I O N T O L O B B Y I N G
6
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
16/79
The cash-for-questions affair
In Britain today many peoples perceptions of lobbying are based on what theyknow or think they know of the cash-for-questionsaffair.Whole books have been
written on the subject,though even now some of the facts are still in dispute.
The key points of the drama can be relatively briefly encapsulated.Ian Greer began
his career as a lobbyist in 1970,setting up his own consultancy,Ian Greer Associates
(IGA) in 1982.It became an extraordinary success, with an unrivalled client list
of blue chip companies,but the seeds of its destruction were planted just three
years after its foundation,when Ian Greer met the Egyptian-born owner of Harrods,
Mohamed Al Fayed.
Fayed was engaged in a bitter feud with Tiny Rowland,chief executive of Lonhro,
the man he had beaten in the takeover battle for Harrods.Ian Greer was enlisted
to help Fayed promote his side of the argument in the House of Commons and
in turn sought the support of a number of Conservative backbenchers,including
Tim Smith and Neil Hamilton.They agreed to help and Hamilton, in particular,
was soon tabling Parliamentary questions designed to discredit Rowland.Despite
that,events moved decisively against Fayed in April 1987,with the announcement
of a Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) inquiry into his takeover of Harrods.
A month later a General Election was called and Ian Greer solicited money
(12,000) from Fayed,which he used to support the constituency campaigns of
26 Conservative MPs. Margaret Thatcher won the election and Fayed resumed his
Commons campaign,notably with the continuing support of Tim Smith and Neil
Hamilton.By 1988,Fayed says,he was handing over money in cash to Hamilton
(the cash-for-questions) and in September that year Hamilton and his wife,
Christine, stayed at Fayeds Ritz Hotel in Paris at Fayeds expense.By now Smith
was on a paid retainer from Fayed.
In 1989 the Lonhro-owned Observernewspaper published findings by the DTI
inquiry that Fayed had both dishonestly misrepresented his origins and wealth
and given evidence to the inquiry which he knew to be false.
A year later Ian Greer gave evidence to the Commons Select Committee on
MembersInterests,admitting that he had made commission payments to MPs in
return for business introductions. He spoke of three payments to the (now
deceased, former) Conservative MP, Michael Grylls.
C H A P T E R 1 : A N I N T R O D U C T I O N T O L O B B Y I N G
7
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
17/79
In 1992 IGA celebrated its tenth anniversary with a party at the National Portrait
Gallery,attended by the then Prime Minister,John Major.Business was booming.
The Conservatives were re-elected in that years election and Neil Hamilton becameCorporate Affairs Minister at the DTI.Fayed wrote to him congratulating him on
his appointment,but,on the advice of his officials,Hamilton did not reply.Shortly
afterwards the Home Office rejected Fayeds application for British citizenship.
Fayed was furious,both about what he saw as his betrayal by Neil Hamilton and
by the Governments rejection of his application for British citizenship. He
approached the editor of the Guardian, Peter Preston, and so triggered the
Guardian investigation that culminated in the downfall of Tim Smith, Neil
Hamilton and Ian Greer.
In October 1994 the Guardian published its story,with the headlines Tory MPs
were paid to plant questions says Harrods chief and Mr Greer said to me you
need to rent an MP like you rent a London taxi.Tim Smith immediately resigned
as Minister for Northern Ireland,admitting that he had taken cash for questions
from Fayed. A day later the Guardian published a copy of Neil Hamiltons 3,600
bill for his stay at the Ritz.
Rejecting the Guardian allegations that he had obtained money from Fayed to
pay MPs to place Parliamentary questions, Ian Greer issued a writ.Within days
Hamilton had resigned from the Government and the Prime Minister had
announced the establishment of the Nolan Committee on Standards in Public Life.
It was another two years before the libel case was about to start in the courts,
but just days before that Ian Greer was told by his lawyers that the Guardian
had evidence of six payments by him to Michael Grylls, not the three he had
mentioned to a Commons committee in 1990.Though it was nothing to do with
the central allegation, the lawyers advice was that to be shown to have misled
the committee would be fatal in court.They advised him to drop the case and
he accepted their advice.
Released from the constraints of the case, the Guardian published furtherdamaging material. IGAs clients and staff deserted in droves. Just before the end
of 1996 the company went into voluntary liquidation.
To this day Neil Hamilton continues to assert his innocence and to dispute the
finding of then Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards,Sir Gordon Downey,
that there was compelling evidence that he had received cash payments from Fayed.
The cash-for-questionsaffair put a harsh spotlight on the nascent lobbying industry
in the UK and, in particular, on the issue of financial relationships between
consultancies and MPs.Ian Greer was an enterprising pioneer in the industry,who
made mistakes and paid a heavy price.
C H A P T E R 1 : A N I N T R O D U C T I O N T O L O B B Y I N G
8
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
18/79
The Association of Professional Political Consultants
The affair forced the industry to confront issues that it had previously avoidedand to take action to safeguard its own future.The most visible effect was the
creation of a self-regulatory body, the Association of Professional Political
Consultants (APPC), in 1994 by five of the largest lobbying consultancies.The
Association,whose membership had grown by 2001 to 25 companies,has a code
of conduct, which bans any financial relationship with politicians; it also
publishes a twice-yearly register of consultancy clients.
The Drapergate affair
The Association faced its first real test in the summer of 1998,when the Observercarried out an investigative sting, with journalists posing as representatives of a
US energy company,seeking influence.It accused three consultancies (two of them
Association members) of unethical behaviour.This Drapergate affair was less
serious than cash-for-questions, in the sense that this time there were no
allegations of inappropriate financial links,but rather of inappropriate bragging
about the closeness of links with politicians and what could therefore be achieved.
Derek Draper,a former aide to Peter Mandelson,who had boasted that there were
only 17 people who counted in the Government and he had access to all of them,
immediately resigned from his position.The Prime Minister asked Sir Robin Butler,the Cabinet Secretary, to draw up rules for government dealings with lobbyists
and the Association met to decide what, if anything, to do about its member
consultancies. It was not an easy meeting and a wide variety of opinions were
expressed. In the end, however, the decision was to set up an inquiry to be
conducted by a former head of the Home Civil Service,Lord Armstrong of Ilminster,
and a leading barrister, Nicholas Purnell QC.
In their report to the Association two weekslater,the two said that:There is nothing
intrinsically improper about the role of political consultants.On the contrary,they
have a valuable role to perform in assisting their clients to make proposals andcases to the agencies of government in the most effective way.However,they added
that it was critically important that political consultants should conduct
themselves so as not to impair the integrity of their clients and the integrity of
government and those in government positions with whom they have dealings.
They therefore went on to make a number of recommendations, subsequently
endorsed by the APPC, all designed to create a culture of compliance with the
APPC rules within member consultancies.
C H A P T E R 1 : A N I N T R O D U C T I O N T O L O B B Y I N G
9
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
19/79
Taken together,cash-for-questionsand Drapergatehad a profound effect on the
UK lobbying industry.Though most in the industry would certainly assert that
the alleged improper behaviour was untypical,the two crises forced the industryto acknowledge that it would have to behave with complete propriety and be
seen to do so,if it were to survive and prosper.Partly as a result,many would claim
that lobbying in the UK today has one of the best ethical track records of any in
the world.Indeed,the secret of success is in how to be both ethical and effective.
The next chapter considers what makes a good lobbyist.
C H A P T E R 1 : A N I N T R O D U C T I O N T O L O B B Y I N G
10
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
20/792chapter
How to lobby
T H E R U L E S O F L O B B Y I N G
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
21/79
Chapter 2:
How to lobby
Some may feel that Chapter 1 was a chapter on how not to lobby and since this
is essentially a practical guide,this chapter is designed to redress the balance by
providing some basic advice on how to lobby well that is to say both ethically
and effectively.
The rules of lobbying
Lobbying is an art form, rather than a science,so there is inevitably an element
of judgement in what follows and,of course, the precise nature of activity will
vary,depending on the issue and the political forum where the lobbying is taking
place. Nevertheless, there are some simple rules that apply universally. So here
are some of them:
Research the facts
The best lobbying is always based on accurate, up-to-date information and on a
well-argued case,founded on credible evidence,and delivered to the right audiences
in the right tone of voice at the right time.The research needs to cover not only
the case to be made,but also the facts about the decision-makers and the influences
on them. To which politician or political institution should the grievance be
addressed? Who has the power to put things right? What consideration have they
given the issue to date? Try to anticipate the arguments that your opponents will
make and deal with them at the outset.Although impatient clients sometimes find
this information-gathering stage of the lobbying process frustrating, it is essential
to maximise the chances of success.
Agree on the objective
This may sound like a statement of the obvious,but it is a step surprisingly often
omitted,with inevitably bad results down the track.Effective lobbying depends
on the message being simple,consistent and realistic. So all the options need to
be considered right at the beginning of the process.Of course, tactics may have
to change in the light of events, but the strategy should be set at the outset. In
lobbying,as in other areas,unity is strength and opponents will be quick to seize
on its absence and seek to divide and rule.
C H A P T E R 2 : H O W T O L O B B Y
12
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
22/79
Put the case in writing
Although a lobbying campaign will almost always involve face-to-face meetings,
there is no chance of success unless politicians and officials can review the case
in writing. It needs to be expressed with clarity,avoiding jargon,and, in the case
of politicians, with brevity (ideally, not more than one side of A4). Officials, by
contrast,will need technical detail to help them to consider the exact nature of
possible solutions to a problem.Get one individual to write your submission (by
all means following a round table discussion); that maximises the chances of
achieving clarity.
Identify allies
Some campaigns may succeed through the sheer weight of the argument,but the
reality of life is that decision-makers will usually also weigh the balance of forces
aligned on different sides of an argument. So you are more likely to succeed if
you can work in partnership with others, who share similar goals. If you can
persuade an important think tank to advance your argument and to air it in the
media, you will have made a significant advance.
Adopt an appropriate tone of voice
This means avoiding the twin extremes of bullying and Uriah Heep-styledeference.Be respectful and courteous,but also straightforward and clear.You need
to remember that, while you have the right to make your case, politicians and
officials have a duty to decide in the public interest.Equally,they need to remember
that they are the servants of the public,not the masters,and that they have a duty
to consider carefully representations from those affected by their decisions.
Make your friends before you need them
It is human nature that we are more responsive to requests for help from people
that we already know and politicians and officials are only human.So try to getto know individuals whom you judge may be in crucial positions before they get
there. One of the most valuable functions that a consultancy can perform is to
advise you on just who these rising stars are.
C H A P T E R 2 : H O W T O L O B B Y
13
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
23/79
Choose your moment
(There is a tide in the affairs of men,which,taken at the flood,leads on to fortune.)
Sometimes this is impossible because action is forced upon you by the politicians.
In most cases, however, the timing of your lobbying will, to some extent, be in
your hands.Again, it is a question of avoiding extremes. On the one hand, as a
general rule of thumb,the earlier that you seek to intervene in a process,the more
likely your efforts are to be crowned with success.On the other hand,politicians
are busy people with notoriously short attention spans (a week is a long time
in politics); they are unlikely to pay much attention unless the issue, or
something related to it, is on their current agenda. In any event, your lobbying
needs to be in time to influence events; there is no point in taking action when
the die is already cast.
Remember what motivates politicians
(Often) idealism,(usually) ambition to achieve Ministerial status and (invariably)
a desire to hold their seats.Remember too that lobbying is a deal, not,generally,
cash-for-questions,but information for access.The politician will normally agree
to meet because he anticipates that you will provide him with information that
will enable him to do his job better and perhaps to shine as a result.
Find a peg
On occasion your issue will be right at the top of the political agenda and you
will have no trouble commanding attention,but much more frequently you will
need to think carefully about how best to link your concerns with a political debate
that is already taking place.
Tell the truth
As Shakespeare put it inHamlet,This above all:to thine own self be true,And it
must follow,as the night the day,Thou canst not then be false to any man.Whenthe outcome of a political decision is of crucial importance to you, it may be
tempting to bend the truth at the edges to avoid uncomfortable facts and to put
the best gloss on the weaker elements of your case. Dont. Dont because you
shouldnt and dont because,more often than not,your uncomfortable relationship
with the truth will be exposed and you will thereafter lose all credibility.
C H A P T E R 2 : H O W T O L O B B Y
14
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
24/79
Ask for help
Another statement of the obvious,surprisingly often ignored.If a politician or an
official has agreed to meet you, it will be because they believe you have a case
to make.They will listen to your exposition of the facts,but,given the nature of
their jobs,their primary interest will be in what you would like them to do about
it. So dont be shy:tell them.
Listen carefully
You can tell a great deal about how your case is being received by the comments
that your interlocutors make and the questions that they ask.This will help you
to conclude where your points are hitting home and where your case is perceived
to be weak.
Watch carefully
Some politicians and officials are practised poker players and it is not easy to tell
from meeting them what they think. A larger number are routinely polite and
will express an interest in your case that will convey sympathy,but again conveys
nothing of their opinion.So watch their body language for clues.Surprisingly often,
you will find that a raised eyebrow or a tiny physical distancing from you betrays
what they really think.
Respond promptly to requests for more information
Naturally, you should try to anticipate exactly what the person you are meeting
will need to know,but,however efficient you are and however good your research,
there will frequently be times when you will be asked to forward further
particulars. Do so speedily and your reputation will be enhanced.Fail to do so
and you will certainly lose significant ground.
Be selective
You will need to identify those who have a reason to be interested in your case
and focus your efforts on them.This is much more likely to mean 50 individuals,
than 500.You need to identify the officials who have responsibility for your issue
and, in a Westminster context, you will focus on members of relevant Select
Committees,party committees and all-party groups.
C H A P T E R 2 : H O W T O L O B B Y
15
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
25/79
But not too selective
A very common mistake is to assume that your problem can be solved by one
MP, one Government department, one political party, one part of the European
Commission,one committee of the European Parliament and so on.However,this
will very rarely be the case. Most issues are inter-departmental;most decisions
are collegiate and your lobbying needs to reflect this.Remember, in particular,
that the Treasury and Finance Ministries everywhere have an interest in most issues.
Be persistent
Politicians the world over will often tell supplicants that their case would best be
served by not rocking the boat, for example,because of the upcoming election;
there is always an election upcoming somewhere. Ignore them.They are trying
to arrange the world for their convenience,but you have a right to be heard.Equally,
you should not embark on a campaign that you dont intend to follow through to
the end.Once you have put an issue on to the agenda,officials will certainly follow
through and if you fail to do so as well, the results could be disastrous.
Civil servants rule, OK?
A sensitive area this,but never under-estimate the importance of officials,as opposed
to politicians.The most valuable education tool that I know is the television comedyseries,Yes Minister, with its basic theme that it is officials who really run the
country. Of course, determined politicians (a relatively small group) can change
the world,but on many issues where lobbying takes place, the real power rests
with officials.They draft the reports.They make the recommendations.They set
the agenda. Get them on your side and you will usually be home and dry.Fail to
convince them and you are very unlikely to succeed.
The devil is in the detail
Infrequently,you will be lobbying on a big picture point,where the decision willbe black or white,success or failure.Far more often,you will be looking at shades
of grey and then attention to detail will be vital. It may all turn on whether the
clause says andor or. So pay attention.
Be discreet in victory
The important thing is to win,not to be seen to have won.If the system takes what
you consider to be the right decision, let it take the credit. It is rarely possible,
anyway, to measure how much your efforts, as opposed to other factors,
contributed to success.
C H A P T E R 2 : H O W T O L O B B Y
16
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
26/79
Consider a media strategy
Often,particularly where the lobbying is on an obscure point of detail vital to
you,but of no interest to Aunt Agatha nothing will be gained by seeking to expose
your case in the media.However, there will be occasions when this can be very
helpful.Here we come to a central theme of this Report.When and how should
you involve the media in a lobbying campaign? The next chapter considers the
case for and the case against talking to journalists.
C H A P T E R 2 : H O W T O L O B B Y
17
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
27/793chapter
Involving the media the case for
and the case against
M E D I A E X P O S U R E
C I R C U M S T A N C E S T O C O N S I D E R B E F O R E
P R O M O T I N G M E D I A I N T E R E S T
C I R C U M S T A N C E S W H E R E Y O U W O U L D B E W E L L
A D V I S E D T O P R O M O T E M E D I A I N T E R E S T
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
28/79
Chapter 3:
Involving the media the case forand the case against
Media exposure
There used to be,perhaps still are in some quarters, two extreme points of view
on this issue.One held that lobbying was just public relations, with a particular
target audience,and so it was obvious that media relations would be at the centre
of what lobbyists did.The other was that lobbying was an elevated profession, far
removed from the gutter world of journalists, and that a lobbyist would no more
dream of seeking exposure for a clients case in the media than would a lawyer.
Today, I would argue, there is a broad consensus that the answer lies between
these two extremes and that it is a case of horses for courses, of making
judgements about when media exposure is likely to be helpful and when
unhelpful.
Few would dispute that in Britain politicians are acutely sensitive to how the media
report their activities.This can affect both policies and personalities.To give just
a couple of obvious examples: It is certainly the case that Tony Blairs pro-European
instincts have been tempered by concerns over the stance taken by the Euro-
sceptic media and in particular the newspapers owned by Rupert Murdoch and
Conrad Black.Equally,his Governments emphasis on crime is certainly influenced
by theDaily Mails agenda and that newspapers belief that it has an instinctive
appreciation of the worries of crucial swing voters in Middle England.
Similarly,at a time when the size of Labours majority in the House of Commonsmade effective opposition there almost impossible,many newspapers seemed to
take the view that it was part of their job to hold the Government to account.
At its most extreme this has certainly included creating an environment in which
Ministers have been forced to resign.This,of course, was a feature of the Major
years, but it has continued more recently, most notably with first the Guardian
and then the Observer twice forcing the resignation of Peter Mandelson from the
Cabinet.
C H A P T E R 3 : I N V O L V I N G T H E M E D I A T H E C A S E F O R A N D T H E C A S E A G A I N S T
19
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
29/79
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
30/79
Where you would be alerting well-organised opponents
It is important always to remember that you cannot control how the media will
report on the subject that interests you. Even if initial coverage is favourable, it
may be that the principal effect will be to alert those who take a different point
of view to the fact of your lobbying.They may then themselves both lobby directly
and seek media coverage for counter-arguments.
Where you would be alerting other stakeholders
Media coverage of your issue may stimulate the involvement of others with an
interest.They may not necessarily be hostile, but their lobbying will force the
decision-makers to reconsider the issues. At best this may lead to delay,but it could
result in the decision moving against you.
Where you would alienate key supporters
This can be in two different senses. Firstly, you may have key supporters in
government who,in their eyes,are taking risks to help your case;faced with media
exposure of the issue, they may become more cautious.Secondly, there can be
occasions on sensitive issues where you are able to secure discreet behind-the-
scenes third party support for your point of view, which can be very helpful.
Sometimes, such help may evaporate in the wake of media discussion, as lessempathetic elements among these supporters force their colleagues to abandon
their supportive stance.
Where you risk generating adverse editorial comment
Even if the factual reporting of your case is accurate, you may do more harm than
good if it is accompanied by comment pieces that cast doubt on the validity of
your case.Officials and politicians are sensitive to editorial comment and if you
are not confident that it will be favourable,it may make sense not to expose the
issue to the media in the first place.
Where you are ill-prepared to handle media inquiries
Journalists are inquisitive, curious people; that, after all, is their job. So it is very
unlikely that what you say will simply be reported verbatim and far more likely
that you will be on the receiving end of some probing questions that seek to
expose the weaknesses in your arguments. If you are not confident of handling
such questions, it might be better to avoid the media altogether.
C H A P T E R 3 : I N V O L V I N G T H E M E D I A T H E C A S E F O R A N D T H E C A S E A G A I N S T
21
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
31/79
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
32/79
Where you need to demonstrate that you are campaigning
It is both a strength and weakness of lobbying that it is generally conducted behind
closed doors.This invisibility can be a great disadvantage if supporters conclude
that nothing is being done.If,to secure their continuing support,you need to prove
that this is not the case, a media campaign can be an effective tool.
Where your lobbying appears to be getting nowhere
There can be any number of reasons for this.It may be simply that you have got
a lousy case that doesnt deserve to succeed.Or it may be that you are lobbying
the wrong targets in which case you need to broaden the net.But if neither of
these appear to apply then it is likely that you will have nothing to lose by seeking
to secure a fresh look at your arguments via a media campaign.
Where you have or can win considerable public support
There will be times when Governmental inertia can be disturbed with the help
of the media.The volume of media coverage and support for a campaign will often
affect what a government decides to do.Again,the fuel protests in 2000 provide
a vivid illustration; for as long as the tabloids supported the protesters, the
Government was under severe pressure; the moment media opinion began to
swing against the protesters,the pressure eased.
In the specific case of mergers and acquisitions
When billions of pounds are at stake and when the outcome may be decided either
by shareholders or by the competition authorities, financial public relations and
lobbying go hand-in-hand and it would be a foolish investment bank that failed
to recognise the importance of both.This will be considered in more detail in a
later chapter.
So,let us assume that,willingly or unwillingly,you have resolved to include a media
element in your lobbying campaign, how best should you set about that? There
are certainly some general lessons that apply and these are considered in a later
chapter. However, you also need to be aware of how the political and media
landscapes in a particular location will influence your approach.
The next chapter looks at Westminster,Whitehall and the national UK media,while
subsequent chapters examine Scotland,Wales,Northern Ireland and Brussels.
C H A P T E R 3 : I N V O L V I N G T H E M E D I A T H E C A S E F O R A N D T H E C A S E A G A I N S T
23
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
33/794chapter
Whitehall and Westminster
T H E S E N I O R C I V I L S E R V I C E
T H E P O W E R O F T H E P R I M E M I N I S T E R A N D C A B I N E T M I N I S T E R S
W H E R E D O E S P O W E R L I E W I T H I N T H E E X E C U T I V E ?
P A R L I A M E N T
T H E I N I T I A T I O N A N D F O R M U L A T I O N O F P U B L I C P O L I C Y I N B R I T A I N
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
34/79
Chapter 4:
Whitehall and Westminster
How you lobby and how you may campaign in the media will depend crucially
on who has the power to help or to hinder your case.
So the theme of this chapter is where power lies in Whitehall and Westminster.
Obviously,this will vary from issue to issue and also over time,but there are some
general observations that can usefully be made.
There are any number of admirable,if lengthy,academic texts on this subject.Whatthis chapter seeks to focus on are those aspects of the unwritten British
constitution that are most likely to be of interest to the lobbyist.
The senior civil service
Perhaps the single most important is that, as Philip Norton, professor of
government at the University of Hull,has put it:the senior civil service remains
at the heart of British government.Hence the unusual order of the chapter title,designed to focus attention on this particular point.
For the lobbyist,it is these people some 3,000 of them out of a total of around
500,000 who often hold the key to the resolution of a problem, for it is they
who both provide Ministers with advice on policy and then supervise its
implementation.Because the media focus is on politicians and because officials
shun the limelight, it is all too easy to underestimate the importance of senior
officials but the lobbyist does so at his peril.
Of course on the really big issues of the day it will generally be the Prime Minister
or the Chancellor of the Exchequer whose views are decisive, but the greatmajority of day-to-day issues with which lobbyists are generally concerned are
not like that.Political support may be vital,but if officials are not persuaded that
a particular approach is practical, affordable and in their departments interests,
it is unlikely to be adopted.
Some of those who need to lobby mistakenly assume that because officials are
generally discreet, they are unapproachable. It isnt so. The overwhelming
majority of senior officials take the view that it is part of their job to listen to those
who may be affected by government action.They have no duty to agree,but they
do generally feel a duty to consult.
C H A P T E R 4 : W H I T E H A L L A N D W E S T M I N S T E R
25
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
35/79
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
36/79
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
37/79
Where does power lie within the executive?
The question of where,within the executive,power lies defies easy generalisation.To my mind one of the most persuasive attempts has been Nortons.He argues
(with a few caveats) that:High policy (such as economic policy) is usually made
at the level of prime minister and cabinet;medium-level policy (a new initiative
on transport safety or school examinations, for example) at the ministerial level
within departments; and low-level,or day-to-day incremental, policy at the civil
service level, often in consultation with those representatives of outside groups
who,together,form policy communities.This last category probably accounts for
the bulk of public policy or,perhaps more accurately, policy adjustments.
Norton argues that this increasing involvement of outside groups, sometimesassisted by professional lobbyists,is leading,to some degree,to a dispersal of power.
He says that:By Capitol Hill standards,the development of lobbying is an extremely
modest one,but it is growing and likely to continue to do so.It offers the prospect
of a more,rather than a less,pluralistic system of policy making.
Parliament
So much for the executive.What of Parliament, often thought to be the focus oflobbying? Again,Norton gets it right in my view,when he says that:Lobbying of
MPs is an admission that attempts to influence ministers and their officials have
failed. It is often an unprofitable exercise: Failure to influence ministers will
frequently be replicated in a house dominated by those same ministers.
Of course we can find exceptions to this argument.Two of the most well-known
would be the defeat of the Shops Bill and the thwarting of Government plans for
Post Office privatisation.In the first case,a coalition of outside interests persuaded
72 Conservative MPs to vote with Labour to defeat the Bill. In the second,as we
noted earlier, the threat of 15 Conservative MPs to rebel (at a time when theGovernment had only a small Commons majority) was enough to persuade the
Government to think again.
But these are rare exceptions to the rule that Parliament will rarely be decisive,
though it certainly has influence on the executive, where the decision-making
power generally lies.It is because of this influence, increasingly exercised through
Select Committees or party committees, rather than on the floor of the House
of Commons,that lobbyists pay attention to it.In some ways Parliament thus plays
a similar role to that of the media: both have considerable influence on
government and both are worth paying attention to for that reason.
C H A P T E R 4 : W H I T E H A L L A N D W E S T M I N S T E R
28
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
38/79
In the overwhelming majority of cases a government with an overall majority in
the Commons will succeed in imposing its will through party discipline.So the
Commons will only generally be important as a place to change things when thegovernment of the day lacks such a majority. However, it retains an importance
as a forum for debate,where issues can be raised and drawn to the attention of
government.
Select Committees
Particularly important in this respect are the departmental Select Committees
established in 1979.They have,to a modest degree,developed a reputation for both
innovative thinking and a preference for proceeding by consensus.Their inquiries
are based on the taking of written and oral evidence from Ministers and outside
interests. For the lobbyist therefore they can represent both an opportunity and
a threat.Certainly any witness called to give evidence would do well to prepare
in much the same way as he would for an interview with a sceptical journalist.
The House of Lords
The House of Lords has been and remains a curious place,but not without interest
for the lobbyist. Originally dominated by hereditary peers, who owed their
membership of it to the accident of birth, since 1999 it has been dominated by
appointed life peers,though 92 hereditary peers have retained their membership
(out of a current total of just over 700). Although it has less power than the
Commons, it is also a chamber where party discipline is weaker and where the
life experience of many (predominantly middle-aged or elderly) members can lead
to debates which are more informed and less dogmatic than is usual in the
Commons. So if your objective is to influence the detail of a bill, where the
Government is either hostile or uninterested, it may be a more fruitful forum than
the Commons.
By the time a piece of legislation reaches the House of Lords,the process of public
policy formation and development is well on the road to completion.Yet it is, of
course,a truism of good lobbying that the ideal point to seek to intervene in this
process is not at the end, but at the beginning. So it may be useful to conclude
this chapter with a brief consideration of how public policy is initiated and
formulated in Britain.
C H A P T E R 4 : W H I T E H A L L A N D W E S T M I N S T E R
29
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
39/79
The initiation and formulation of public policy in Britain
It has to be said that there is little academic consensus on this subject and thatthere is a gulf between much of the theory and what appears to be the reality. In
addition,the reality seems to change considerably from government to government.
The senior civil service
One area where there is little agreement is the role of the senior civil service.
Some,usually committed party politicians,argue with passion that the civil service
has never had an original idea in its life.Others respond that this shows how clever
the mandarins are and that it is rather the case that they have simply been careful
never to leave their fingerprints my own instincts incline to this latter view.Wherethere is agreement is that the closer that you get to policy detail, the more
important Whitehall becomes.
International experience
As the world becomes a smaller place,abroad is often the source of new policy
ideas and initiatives.Labour and Conservatives alike frequently turn to the United
States for fresh ideas.Less frequently,they and others look to the old Commonwealth
or to other countries in the European Union Australia,New Zealand,Sweden and
the Netherlands are particular favourites.
Political parties
Political parties would have you believe that they are the main source of ideas:
they think up the ideas,they are adopted as party policy,they feature in the election
manifesto and after polling day they are implemented.This has the attraction of
simplicity, but can,at best,be only part of the truth.
Think tanksTake privatisation,for example.It hardly figured in the Conservative party manifesto
of 1979 or in public debate.The civil service was initially extremely sceptical.
Rather the driving force was a combination of a vigorous think tank the Adam
Smith Institute and the enthusiasm of a determined Prime Minister,Mrs Thatcher,
and (at the time) key Ministerial lieutenants,notably Nigel Lawson and Geoffrey
Howe.The results were dramatic:by the end of the 1980s they had sold into private
hands 40% of what had been publicly owned a decade earlier.Think tanks remain
a good place to launch a new idea, though their influence waxes and wanes. In
2001 the Institute for Public Policy Research would reasonably claim to be the
most influential, though others (Demos and the Social Market Foundation, for
C H A P T E R 4 : W H I T E H A L L A N D W E S T M I N S T E R
30
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
40/79
example) certainly compete for attention.Ask where think tanks themselves get
their best ideas from and often the answer is from abroad,which usually means
the United States.
Interest and pressure groups
Much public policy starts life as the brainchild of an interest group or pressure
group.Some of these groups (the campaign for lead-free petrol,for example) are
successful single issue groups;others (for example,Keep Sunday Special and the
Countryside Alliance) are more responses to unwelcome Government initiatives.
Many interest groups have a quasi-institutionalised consultative role vis a vis
particular Government departments.
The centre of Government
More than was the case in the past,policy is being initiated and developed at the
centre in the No 10 policy unit, but also in the Cabinet Office: notably in the
performance and innovation unit,headed in 2001 by Geoff Mulgan (formerly at
Demos) and in divisions like the social exclusion unit and the office of the e-envoy.
The pressure from No 10 and 70 Whitehall for policy innovation may be relentless,
but turning big ideas into concrete policy normally requires input from Ministers,
special advisers and senior officials in the key departments:the Treasury,of course,but also the Department for Education and Employment,the Department of Health,
the Department for the Environment,Transport and the Regions and the Home
Office.
The only safe advice for the lobbyist about policy formation and development is
to treat each case as different and to research the corridors of power carefully
before deciding where to focus the lobbying effort.
C H A P T E R 4 : W H I T E H A L L A N D W E S T M I N S T E R
31
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
41/795chapter
The Downing Street Press Office, the lobby
and the national media
T H E D O W N I N G S T R E E T P R E S S O F F I C E
T H E L O B B Y
T H E N A T I O N A L M E D I A
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
42/79
Chapter 5:
The Downing Street Press Office, the lobbyand the national media
At the heart of British media coverage of politics is the lobby and their principal
source of information,the press office at 10 Downing Street.So it is worth looking
at these two institutions,before considering which of the national media are of
particular importance to the lobbyist.
That requires a declaration of interest.For while I am now a lobbyist,I was a lobbycorrespondent. Hopefully that means that I know what I am talking about, but
it almost certainly also means that my perceptions are influenced by my own
experiences.You have been warned.
The Downing Street Press Office
If we start by considering the press operation at Downing Street, it is a truism
that most occupants of 10 Downing Street have been fascinated by/obsessed withmedia coverage.Ramsay MacDonald created the job of Press Secretary to the Prime
Minister in 1931.
Over the years the quality of Downing Street press spokesman has varied greatly.
One of the most well-known, because so close to his Prime Minister, Margaret
Thatcher, was Bernard Ingham, who, like his boss, on occasion treated Cabinet
Ministers as if they were enemies, rather than allies.Bernard was famously well-
liked by the lobby, in spite of his fierce temper,because he could be relied on to
know what the Prime Minister was thinking,even when he hadnt spoken to her.
He also used the weekly meeting of information officers to control and co-ordinateall the news flowing from the government to the media.
Equally short-tempered and close to the Prime Minister is Tony Blairs official
spokesman,formerDaily Mirrorjournalist,Alastair Campbell,a brilliant tabloid
phrase-maker who, on the night of Princess Dianas death, supplied his master
with the memorable words,the Peoples Princess. His office is the setting for
the daily 9am news planning meeting,which endeavours to set the political news
agenda for the day and,in particular,decides on lines to be taken at the daily lobby
briefing, two hours later.
C H A P T E R 5 : T H E D O W N I N G S T R E E T P R E S S O F F I C E , T H E L O B B Y A N D T H E N A T I O N A L M E D I A
33
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
43/79
While Tony Blair himself claims to spend little time reading newspapers (he once
told an interviewer:I cant think I spend more than five minutes a day reading
it I read theFinancial Times and I flick through the rest),Campbells mediamonitoring operation is impressively thorough and encompasses columnists,as
well as lobby correspondents.A leaked autumn 2000 document from the media
monitoring unit provided the Government with a journalist-by-journalist rundown
some examples were: Andrew Grice (Independent) One of Westminsters most
influential political reporters,Peter Riddell (Times) Is widely read in Whitehall,
Hugo Young (Guardian) Considered very influential among Labour-voting
chattering classesand Polly Toynbee (Guardian) Very well respected writer on
the centre left.
Alastair Campbells media operation builds on Labours media relations machine,developed in opposition when Peter Mandelson was director of communications
(1985-1990) and, in my judgement, shares that machines strengths and
weaknesses.
On the plus side,where Labours media operation had been famously shambolic,
the new approach was based on the virtues of a proactive,structured approach
to delivering the partys key messages.This was visibly successful in the 1997
General Election when, for the first time ever, a majority of the national dailies
supported Labour,with only theDaily Telegraph,theDaily Mailand theExpress
unequivocal in their support for the Conservatives.
On the negative side,Labour has often found it hard to disguise its contempt for
journalists a serious mistake,since the most effective media relations are built
on a foundation of mutual trust and respect.Those providing stories and those
writing them know that their jobs are different, but that each has much to gain
from the professionalism of the other.
Ian Hargreaves, Financial Times columnist and director of the Centre for
Journalism Studies at Cardiff University, has been assiduous in collecting the
quotations that display that contempt.Labour pollster,Philip Gould,for example,
has talked about:Taking power away from the media and grabbing back control
of the agenda it is basically about outwitting them and setting out our stall on
our terms. As Hargreaves has put it,Journalists are viewed as an enemy force
standing between New Labour and the electorate.He quotes an associate of Philip
Gould explaining the essence of running a government media relations operation
as forcing journalists to eat their greens.As Hargreaves concludes,If you think
journalists are fools and treat them that way, it will not be easy to build trust.
Campbell and the lobby have a love-hate relationship.There is certainly an element
of mutual mistrust and contempt but,at bottom,each knows that they could not
do their job without the other.
C H A P T E R 5 : T H E D O W N I N G S T R E E T P R E S S O F F I C E , T H E L O B B Y A N D T H E N A T I O N A L M E D I A
34
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
44/79
The lobby
The lobby is the collective name for journalists based at the Palace of Westminster,whose day-to-day job is to report the ebb and f low of British politics. Founded
in 1884,when a single gentlemanof the press was given official permission to
stand in the MPslobby of the House of Commons,there are today some 250 lobby
correspondents.They include 90 working for television and radio,36 (so more
than one in ten of the lobby) working for the BBC alone. On the print side, the
most well resourced are the Press Association (20), most of whom are gallery
reporters,theDaily Telegraph and the Times (eight each) and the Guardian and
theIndependent(six each).
The lobby is a comfortable, if competitive, club and many of its members havespent most of their working life there.Most of them share certain characteristics:
an abiding interest in politics, a competitive desire to come up with exclusive
stories,a certain cynicism about the motives of politicians,a preference for stories
that feature conflict, a relative lack of interest in or understanding of the civil
service,a focus that is more often on 10 Downing Street than other Government
departments and more on personalities than on issues and a short attention span.
The central event of the day for the lobby is the 11am briefing by the Prime
Ministers official spokesman,normally held in the basement of 10 Downing Street.
This time-honoured ritual begins with the spokesman reading out a list of the PrimeMinisters engagements for the day, but at its heart is the exchange of questions
and answers sometimes good-humoured,sometimes acerbic that follows.On
Fridays,there will generally also be a separate briefing for the Sunday newspapers.
Most lobby correspondents love their job and are very good at it.They are at the
heart of the British political machine and have privileged access to it,both in terms
of Downing Street and other briefings and their right to loiter with MPs in the
members lobby, immediately outside the chamber of the House of Commons.
They will often be the first to know of a shift in Government policy and they will
certainly have usually well-informed views on which politicians stock is risingand which is falling. Hence they are a good source of information for lobbyists
and, after all, information is the basis of all good lobbying.
But there is a world of difference between monitoring carefully what the lobby
is writing,which is essential,and seeking to interest them in a clients case,which
is a high-risk strategy that may,on occasion,be either sensible or unavoidable.If
you find yourself seeking to make a case to members of the lobby then you need
to bear a number of caveats in mind, most of them relating to the characteristics
of the lobby outlined above.
C H A P T E R 5 : T H E D O W N I N G S T R E E T P R E S S O F F I C E , T H E L O B B Y A N D T H E N A T I O N A L M E D I A
35
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
45/79
Firstly, it may be difficult to secure their attention at all,since their job is to focus
on the hot issues of the day.Then you need to recall that it will be second nature
to most lobby correspondents to express the story in terms of conflict,so it willbe their natural instinct to balance your comments with an alternative viewpoint.
Thirdly, if your story has economic or financial implications, these are unlikely
to be given as much prominence as the political implications.Finally,even if you
secure one-off interest, this is quite unlikely to be sustained, since the
correspondents have a natural desire to move quickly on to the next story.
The national media
For all of these reasons,it may make more sense to pitch your story to the army
of specialist correspondents that newspapers and broadcast media employ:
journalists whose remit is to cover business,health,education, the environment,
transport and so on.They are more likely to have an in-depth understanding of
your issue and more likely to have a continuing interest.
As your objective is to influence Government,you need to bear in mind that some
journalists are more important than others and,since resources are always limited,
it makes sense to focus on your effort on those media most likely to have the
greatest impact.
Early in the day, the two to remember are the Today programme on BBC Radio 4
and Londons evening newspaper,theEvening Standard(easily Britains top-selling
evening newspaper, with a circulation of well over 400,000). The Today
programme, in particular sets the political agenda for the day and if you have the
opportunity to make your case on it, you will be heard by many of the opinion
formers and decision makers that you will want to reach.Similarly,most journalists
working for the broadcast media or national morning newspapers will generally
at least glance at theEvening Standardbefore filing their stories.
The main evening television news bulletins have very large audiences and are
important in that sense, but because of the peculiar hours of the House of
Commons are actually not much watched by politicians.In the late evening BBC
2sNewsnight has more of a political audience and the time to examine issues
in more depth than many other television programmes.Remember,however,that
the interviewing style,as with the Today programme,will tend to the assertively
sceptical. Famously, politicians tend to think of television and radio more as
something that they appear on than as something that they watch or listen to.
Apart from the Today programme andNewsnight, their favourite programmes
on which to appear are Breakfast with Frost(Sunday, BBC1), theJonathanDimbleby Programme (Sunday,London Weekend Television) and Question Time
(Thursday, BBC1).
C H A P T E R 5 : T H E D O W N I N G S T R E E T P R E S S O F F I C E , T H E L O B B Y A N D T H E N A T I O N A L M E D I A
36
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
46/79
In terms of national newspapers,Britain has a remarkably wide variety,including
ten national dailies, of which five are quality broadsheets, all of which can be
important means of exposing decision-makers to your point of view.Of the five,arguably the two most important are theFinancial Times and the Guardian,for
different reasons.
The Financial Times (circulation 450,000) has an enviable reputation for
reporting the facts straight and for appreciating the economic context within which
politicians operate. It reaches a wide and relevant international audience,
particularly in Brussels, as well as being required reading in the Treasury.Of the
FTs total circulation, substantially less than half is in the UK, with Continental
Europe and the United States accounting for most of the remaining readers.
The Guardian (circulation 400,000) is the newspaper most widely read by Labour
politicians and is, in that sense,the perfect means of reaching a large number of
them,with theDaily Telegraph (circulation over a million) performing the same
function for Conservative MPs.
If we include weekly and specialist magazines, the list is almost endless. In a few
cases it may be that the New Statesman could be important because of its
significant, if small, left-of-centre readership.There is also theEconomist, which
approaches issues from a liberal free market perspective and has a significant
readership in the United States.
Although their coverage will be less detailed, the tabloid newspapers are also
important,not least because of the importance attached to them by 10 Downing
Street (to quote Alastair Campbell:The papers that really matter are the tabloids.
I think one of the reasons Tony wanted me to work for him, and why I wanted
to work for Tony,was that we both acknowledge the significance to the political
debate of the tabloids).The Downing Street press office keeps a close watch on
theDaily Mail(circulation 2.3 million), in particular.Then there are the Sunday
newspapers,which have the time and resources to conduct major investigations
and which can,as a result, have a significant impact on the Westminster agenda.
C H A P T E R 5 : T H E D O W N I N G S T R E E T P R E S S O F F I C E , T H E L O B B Y A N D T H E N A T I O N A L M E D I A
37
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
47/796chapter
Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland
S C O T L A N D
W A L E S
N O R T H E R N I R E L A N D
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
48/79
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
49/79
Before the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish executive were established, the
Scottish media were prominent in the campaign for devolution.Since their creation
they have been equally prominent in their criticisms.The important point to note,however, is that they have not ignored the new institutions.It follows that they
can be an important way of reaching the 129 Members of the Scottish Parliament
(MSPs),Ministers in the Scottish executive and Scottish civil servants.
In the broadcast media,Good Morning Scotland,BBC Radio Scotlands equivalent
of the Today programme, has a substantial audience among the political classes
and therefore plays a similar agenda-setting role.Many in Scotland had hoped that
Scottish television might play a similarly influential role, through a Scotland-based
early evening television news programme in place of the BBCs Six oClock News.
That battle was lost,however,and the Scots had to make to do with the concessionof a 20-minute Scottish opt-out from BBC 2sNewsnight at 11pm.There are also,
of course,as elsewhere in the UK,early evening national/regional news bulletins:
Reporting Scotlandon BBC television and Scotland Today, its more down-market
equivalent on ITV.
If London is unusual in the world in having so many newspapers,the same is true
in Scotland.For a small country,with a population of just five million,the breadth
of choice is striking.
Still the most important, in spite of a somewhat turbulent recent history, is the
Scotsman.With a circulation hovering around 100,000,it outsells all the London
broadsheets combined north of the border. Traditionally the left-of-centre
newspaper for the Edinburgh chattering classes, it has moved to the right under
the ownership of the Barclay brothers and has also attempted to reposition itself
as a national (i.e. Scottish as opposed to east coast) newspaper.
A similar repositioning exercise has been undertaken by its long-time rival, the
Glasgow-basedHerald(also with a circulation close to 100,000), formerly the
Glasgow Herald,which has sought to reach out beyond its traditional west coast
readership.
The most intriguing new entrant is the Swedish-owned,Business AM, the first
daily newspaper to launch in Scotland for a century,which calls itself Scotlands
business, financial and political daily; its readership is small,but influential and
many Scottish-based lobbyists cite it as an important target for their messages.
Of the tabloid press in Scotland, easily the most important is theDaily Record
(circulation over 600,000),the Scottish equivalent of theDaily Mirror,left-of-centre
on economic issues,but socially conservative. It played an important role in the
hard-fought Scottish campaign against the repeal of Section 28;a campaign that
certainly forced the Scottish executive to reflect, but that was ultimatelyunsuccessful in achieving its objective.
C H A P T E R 6 : S C O T L A N D , W A L E S A N D N O R T H E R N I R E L A N D
40
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
50/79
Other Scottish newspapers worth a mention are the two principal evening
newspapers, the Edinburgh-based Evening News (circulation 75,000) and
GlasgowsEvening Times (circulation over 100,000);both are well-read by MSPs,with the former in particular beginning to play a role analogous to Londons evening
newspaper.Then there is the most significant regional newspaper with a 100,000
circulation in the north east of Scotland, the Aberdeen-basedPress and Journal.
Most,though not quite all,of the UKs national newspapers have Scottish editions,
though in some cases this amounts to not a great deal more than a reshuffling
of the football match reporting.Still, their Scottish correspondents are generally
on the look out for Scottish case studies and comments from Scottish interest
groups,so they may on occasion be useful for Scottish lobbyists.
Finally worth a mention isHolyroodmagazine,the Scottish Parliaments in-house
journal, its fortnightly equivalent of WestminstersHouse magazine. It carries a
wide variety of features on Scottish political issues,providing outside groups with
opportunities for both editorial coverage and advertising.
Wales
The National Assembly for Wales, with 60 members, has fewer powers than the
Scottish Parliament;Wales is a smaller country (with a population of just under
three million) and the print media is correspondingly less diverse.As in Scotland,
the Cabinet is a Labour-Liberal Democrat coalition,with Plaid Cymru the principal
opposition.There are nine Ministers and five deputy Ministers, together with 12
subject and standing committees.
Partly because most Welsh people read London newspapers, the perception of
Welsh-based lobbyists is that it is the broadcast media that perhaps play the key
role in Welsh politics.
Certainly Good Morning Wales, the BBC Radio Wales equivalent of the Todayprogramme,plays the familiar agenda-setting role and is widely listened to by many
of the 60 Assembly members (AMs).Equally, where the objective is to reach the
widest possible audience,the key programme is the early evening BBC television
news programme,Wales Today,which has up to 400,000 viewers.HTV Wales,the
most watched channel in Wales, has a similar early evening news programme,
though many Welsh television viewers in mid-Wales and the north have their sets
tuned to Central and Granada. BBC television also has a weekly Welsh political
programme, currentlyDragons Eye, transmitted on BBC2 Wales on Thursday
evenings.
C H A P T E R 6 : S C O T L A N D , W A L E S A N D N O R T H E R N I R E L A N D
41
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
51/79
The unique features of Welsh broadcasting are the Welsh language channels,BBC
Radio Cymru and Sianel Pedwar Cymru (S4C)/Channel 4 Wales.One in five of the
Welsh population,principally in the north and west, speak Welsh and the newson S4C (Newyddion) is the main way of reaching them.
Of the Welsh print media, the most important is the Western Mail,with a circulation
close to 60,000 across south and west Wales. Its north Wales counterpart, is the
Daily Post, with a circulation of 70,000.
Some of the national newspapers have Welsh editions, for example the Welsh
Mirror,but these primarily relate to sport coverage and are relatively unimportant
in political terms.
Northern Ireland
Of all the new devolved institutions it is the Northern Ireland Assembly,created
in April 1998 as part of the Good Friday peace agreement,which is both the most
fragile and in which the greatest hopes reside.
The Assembly and Executive have full legislative and executive authority over most
domestic issues.The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, however, retains
responsibility for security, policing and judicial matters,as well as internationalrelations, taxation, national insurance and the regulation of broadcasting,
telecommunications and financial services. Each of the principal parties
represented in the 108-member Assembly shares executive responsibility across
ten departments.A North-South Ministerial Council,including representatives of
the Irish Government,seeks to develop and co-ordinate policies in areas of mutual
interest, including food safety, waterways, trade and business development and
the European Union.
For 30 years the bomb and the bullet were the most common form of lobbying
in Northern Ireland.The attempt to switch to a more normal way of conductingpolitics is recent and still distrusted by substantial sections of the community.
Political lobbying is in its infancy in Belfast,but if the peace process can be made
to stick,could have a bright future,since, with the exception of criminal justice,
almost all day-to-day domestic issues are the responsibility of Stormont and the
ten Government departments in Northern Ireland.
C H A P T E R 6 : S C O T L A N D , W A L E S A N D N O R T H E R N I R E L A N D
42
-
8/10/2019 Lobbying Ang Media, Work With Politicians and Journalist
52/79
In addition most of the 108 members of the legislative assembly (MLAs),whatever
their party affiliation, relish the new opportunity to try to look after their
constituents and accept the contribution that lobbyists can make.Away from thebig issues surrounding the peace process politics is surprisingly non-adversarial.
Real efforts are being made to develop an all-party consensus in the 16 committees
of the Assembly that play a key role in monitoring the activities of the executive.
There may be more journalists per square mile in Northern Ireland (population
1.7 million) than in any other part of the United Kingdom.Certainly,locally-based
lobbyists say that the media can play an important role in lobbying campaigns,
particularly by helping to give the politicians a sense of public and interest group
opinion on issues.
In terms of the broadcast media,BBC Northern Ireland coverage of local politics
is thorough.Both the BBC and UTV (Ulster Television) compete in the border areas
with RTE (the Irish national broadcasting organisation,Radio Telefis Eireann) and
there are also five lively local radio stations.
On the print media side, the most important newspaper is the cross-community
evening newspaper,theBelfast Telegraph,which has a circulation close to 120,000.
The daily press is spli