local anaesthetic wound infusion catheters · page 3 of 25 wound infusion catheters introduction...

115
6 March 2015 No. 6 Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters V. Govender Moderator: J. Cardoso School of Clinical Medicine Discipline of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care

Upload: others

Post on 21-Apr-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

6 March 2015 No. 6

Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters

V. Govender

Moderator: J. Cardoso

School of Clinical Medicine Discipline of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care

Page 2: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 2 of 25

CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 3

HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS ....................................................................... 3

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS .............................................................. 5

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT......................................... 7

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES ..................................................... 8

Cardiothoracic surgery .......................................................................................................... 9

General surgery .................................................................................................................... 12

Obstetrics and Gynaecology ............................................................................................... 13

Gynecology-Urology surgery .............................................................................................. 13

Orthopaedics......................................................................................................................... 14

Orthopaedic surgery ............................................................................................................ 14

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review ............................. 15

Physiology............................................................................................................................. 17

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine ........................................................................................ 18

COST FACTOR ......................................................................................................................... 21

DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................. 22

REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 23

Page 3: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 3 of 25

WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS

INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed catheter to deliver local anaesthetics or analgesics directly into the wound for postoperative pain relief. It can be used as a single technique or as part of a multi-modal analgesic approach Compared with opioid analgesia, continuous regional infusion of local anaesthetic provides better pain control with reduction in opioid use and opioid related side effects By optimizing postoperative analgesia, you increase patient satisfaction and clinically outcomes are improved. Postoperative pain that is uncontrolled can result in significant morbidity and mortality ¹. Categories of Regional Analgesia include:

• Extrapleural (equivalent to intercostal or paravertebral) and interpleural

• Peripheral Nerve Blocks e.g. interscalene, femoral nerve, sciatic nerve

• Intra-articular infusion e.g. post shoulder surgery

• Wound site infusion including use of a disposable elastomeric infusion device HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS Continuous infiltration of local anaesthetic into surgical wounds as an analgesic technique was first descibed just over a decade ago, after the development of multi-holed catheters. Together with the widespread availability of infusion pumps, placement of multi-holed flexible catheters inside or alongside surgical wounds enables continuous, evenly spread infiltration of LA over an indefinite period.¹ First described in 1935, it has been experimented with throughout the 20th century and the technique has been found to be safe and effective in several clinical settings. [4] Currently a number of brands and devices are available each carrying its own pros and cons. With evolving technology, delivery of local anaesthetics is becoming more accurate, reliable, safe and effective.

Page 4: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 4 of 25

Figure 1: Possible scope of application [11]

Page 5: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 5 of 25

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS � Easy placement of catheter with fewer complications associated with insertion compared

with neuraxial anesthesia and peripheral nerve blocking techniques.¹ � Potentially it offers to reduce postoperative opioid requirements and its associated side

effects and increase postoperative patient mobility, with minimal failure¹ � Pain is relieved by Continuous Local Anaesthetic wound infusion into a surgical wound

and works by direct inhibition of noxious afferent generator potentials from peripheral nerve fibres and a decrease of the local inflammatory response to injury¹

� Local Anaesthetic infusion analgesia can be used as a viable option when epidural

analgesia is contraindicated or physically challenging to do.¹ � Ability to have pain rescue with PCA without overdosing the patient � Cost effectiveness with reduced morbidity and mortality, length of stay, and burden of cost

to patient � Monitoring of patient is made easier � Infusion of local anaesthetic for regional analgesia can be used either alone or in

combination with systemic non-opioid and/or opioid analgesia

Figure 2: Disposable elastomeric ballon pump device [12]

Page 6: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 6 of 25

Figure 3: Special arrangement of catheter perforation for uniform distribution [11]

Figure 4: Integrated stainless steel helical coil, for uniform flow of anaesthetic and prevention of kinking or buckling. Also radiopaque and visible under ultrasound [11]

Page 7: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 7 of 25

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT

Fig 5: Surgical details showing, step by step, the positioning of two multiholed catheters for an open nephrectomy On-Q pain Buster ³

Maric et al did a study to compare the quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgery. The choice of optimal type of wound catheter, few or multi-hole is still controversial. The aim was to evaluate the analgesic potential of these two catheter types. [4]

Page 8: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 8 of 25

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES Forty patients undergoing colorectal surgery were randomized to intraoperative placement of two epidural catheters (Group EC) or multi-hole catheter (Group WC) in the wound above the fascia. Patients received 0.25% levobupivacaine (Group WC) with 10 mL bolus through the wound catheter followed by an infusion of 6 mL/h during 48 h, or the same protocol with equally divided levobupivacaine doses through two epidural catheters (Group EC). Simultaneously, patient-controlled analgesia provided intravenous morphine. [4] Pain was evaluated postoperatively with 4-point verbal scale (VRS) for the first 2 h, with Visual Analogue Scale at rest (VAS r), and during coughing (VAS c) every 6 h for the first 48 h. [4] Results and Conclusions: No significant difference in morphine consumption was observed between groups. There were no significant differences in VRS scores between the groups (p=0,756). VAS scores were significantlylower in Group WC in rest (rWC, p=0,007) and coughing (cWC, p=0,018) for the 6 h, 12 h, and 24 h postoperatively. [4] In the period 30–48 h there was no difference between groups. They concluded that levobupivacaine infusion through multi-hole catheter provides better quality of postoperative analgesia compared with two epidural catheters for the first 24 h. [4] The type of catheter plays the most important role. In this context, catheters with multiple holes may provide larger wound spread compared with triple orifice epidural catheters. The choice of catheter, multihole versus few holes is without any documentation for larger wound spread or improved analgesia. [4] The question also lies in the pumps, elastomeric or electronic? In their study they used electronic pumps because of lower price and good clinical experience. Elastomeric pumps are strongly recommended by wound catheter producers but Remerand et al. have published that elastomeric pumps may deliver inappropriate amounts of local anaesthetics with inaccuracy higher than 15% and failure to deflate is also not uncommon [4] Type of catheter plays a more important role in providing better analgesia for the first 24 hours. It seems logical that larger spread of local anaesthetics through more catheter holes provides better analgesia. In the first 24 h pain is more intense than following that critical period. They emphasize that VAS 6–24 h was in the clinically acceptable range between 0–2 in both groups. [4] Wound catheters are more expensive than epidural ones, and usage of disposable elastomeric pumps are more expensive than usage of electronic ones. [4] Local Anaesthetic Catheter Positioning seems to be crucial in determining how effective the technique is. Some catheters are placed in the pre-peritoneal space after laparotomy or open prostatectomy and have reduced postoperative pain, accelerated recovery, and postoperative pulmonary function may have benefitted some, while catheter placement superficial to i.m. fascia was mostly ineffective [1] Further support by a study of open nephrectomy patients showed optimal analgesia with one of the catheters that traversed between abdominal wall muscle layers and the pre-peritoneum. [1]

Page 9: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 9 of 25

A study by Liu et al showed Wound catheters which were placed in various locations (subcutaneous, subfascial, suprafascial,, intraarticular, peripleural, or periosteal), and only two Randomised Control Trials specifically stated that catheters were not placed or activated until surgical closure, as a result no preemptive analgesia was attempted or administered. For a median and mode of 2 days, local anaesthetic was infused . The cardiothoracic discipline had the most Randomised Controlled Trials (n 14), followed by Orthopaedic surgery (n 12), General Surgery (n 11), and gynecology-urology (n 7). [5] Metaanalysis associated multiple potential benefits with use of continuous wound catheters (Table 1). For all groups combined, mean VAS pain scores decreased considerably at rest (10 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 13 to 7 mm) and with activity (22 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 32 to 13mm). Subgroup analysis confirmed decreased pain scores. [5]

Cardiothoracic surgery

Thoracotomy for lung resection was explored by most trials, with the exception of 1 examining thoracotomy for esophagectomy and 3 examining median sternotomy for cardiac surgery (Table 1). Continuous infusion delivery or intermittent bolus delivery were the only methods studied. Placement of Thoracotomy wound catheters were in a variety of described peripleural locations (extrapleural: 2, interpleural: 2, intercostal:3, and intrapleural:4). Two of the cardiac studies done had placed catheters adjacent to the sternum whilst the other had inserted subfascial and subcutaneous (SC) catheters. Most of the Randomised Controlled Trials (12 of 14) reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy for pain scores or opioid use. [5] (11 of 13) Randomised Control Trials showed considerable reduction in pain scores in the immediate postoperative period, and five Randomised Control Trials had seen a reduction until the second postoperative day. Only a few trials reported opioid-related side effects (three of fourteen) or patient satisfaction (one of fourteen). The length of stay was reported by 6 trials, with four out of the six finding some reduction in the group of wound catheters. [5]

Page 10: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 10 of 25

Table 1: Liu et al - Cardiothoracics, Randomized controlled trials [5]

Page 11: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 11 of 25

Table2 : Liu et al [5] Cardiothoracics

Page 12: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 12 of 25

Table3 : Liu et al [5] Abdominal surgery (General surgery)

General surgery

Upper abdominal and vascular surgery, were some of the various surgical procedures used. (PCA) patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus was the choice of continuous delivery methods that were used. Placement of Wound catheters were SC, subfascial, or between muscle and peritoneum. Ten of twelve reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy, be it either a reduction in opioid use or a reduction in pain scores. A substantial reduction in Pain scores in the immediate postoperative period were found in 8 of 11 randomised controlled trials, but only three RCTs reported reduction through second postoperative day . Opioid side effects were reported by four of twelve studies whilst patient satisfaction (2 of 12), or length of hospital stay (3 of 12).

Page 13: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 13 of 25

Obstetrics and Gynaecology

Table 4: Liu et al [5] Obstetrics and gynaecology

Gynecology-Urology surgery

Cesarean section or abdominal hysterectomy were mostly examined. Similarly Patient controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus were used. Wound catheters were placed between muscle fascia and SC tissue (6 of 9) in the majority of cases. More than half (5 of 9) of RCTs had obtained substantial analgesic efficacy, both as reduced pain scores or reduced opioid use. Through the immediate postoperative period pain scores were substantially reduced in (4 of 9) RCTs, with no RCTs reporting a reduction past day one postoperatively. Improvement was found in All RCTs that reported side effects and patient satisfaction. Reported length of stay without any differences: (5 RCTs). [5]

Page 14: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 14 of 25

Orthopaedics

Table 5: Orthopaedic outcomes for different sites [5]

Orthopaedic surgery

Open and arthroscopic procedures on upper and lower extremities including spine surgery were some of the procedures that were studied. Again continuous delivery methods were used: patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus. The various locations used for the wound catheters: intraarticular, periosteal and SC. Majority of RCTs (13 / 16) found significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy both as decreased pain scores or opioid use. Pain scores immediately postoperative were significantly {p0.05} reduced in (12 of 16 RCTs), whilst 11 RCTs found a reduction through days 2 to 5 postoperatively. Only a few trials measured opioid-related side effects, a reduction in PONV in 4 of 6 RCTs, although not one reached individual statistical significance. Considerable increase in patient satisfaction was seen in the 3 RCTs that reported these outcomes. Length of stay measured in only 3 RCTs, and majority of the procedures (9 of 16 RCTs) were ambulatory. [5]

Page 15: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 15 of 25

Table 6: Liu et al [5] Orthopaedics

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review

Consistent analgesic efficacy was demonstrated by continuous wound infusion catheters with regards to reduced pain scores or opioid use for all surgical subspecialities, despite the type of surgical procedure done, exact location of the wound catheter, dose of local anaesthetic or mode of delivery of local anaesthetic, and mixture of analgesic. Opioid-related side effects, patient satisfaction, and length of hospital stay were infrequently assessed for each surgical group Increased patient satisfaction, a reduction in PONV globally, and decreased length of stay. [5] Several mechanisms of analgesia can be provided by direct application of local anaesthetic to wounds. Local anaesthetics would provide a direct blockade of transmission of pain from nociceptive afferents coming from the wound surface. There is mounting proof that local inflammatory response to injury which can be sensitizing to nociceptive receptors and contribute to pain and hyperalgesia, can be inhibited by local anaesthetic,. [5] Some studies of local anaesthetics have observed a reduction in release of inflammatory mediators obtained from neutrophils, a reduction of neutrophil adhesion to the endothelium, reduction in formation of free O2 radicals, and formation of oedema is decreased. By providing a prolonged application of local anaesthesic to wounds by a catheter, it proved to be far more beneficial from that of single injection technique of local anaesthetic in laparoscopic or abdominal operations, as previous systematic reviews demonstrated. [5]

Page 16: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 16 of 25

Table7 : Liu et al [5] orthopaedics

Page 17: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 17 of 25

Physiology

Combination of 3 Factors associated with Postoperative pain: (i) Nerve fibres that are innervating the site of the incision,retraction or suturing generate

impulses; [6] (ii) A number of inflammatory mediators, which become elevated at the surgical site and are

found to sensitize uninjured and injured nerve fibres. These include , prostaglandins, endothelin-1, cytokines and nerve growth factor [6]

(iii) The spinal cord which has pain transmitting circuits become sensitized which then has an

increased response to stimuli that are noxious and can transform their responsiveness to stimuli that is not painful, for example light touch or gentle pressure. [6]

Induction of the firing of impulses in peripheral neurones is precipitated by incisional trauma and of the stretch and compression from retraction, clamping, etc during surgery. Sensitization involving central pathways will be activated by these discharges, although it is probably largely restricted intraoperatively [6] Local inflammation is fostered by Tissue damage, bleeding, and the release of chemoattractants from the injury site. The chemokines or cytokines that are produced by migrating and proliferative immune cells, for example TNF-a, IL-6, and prostaglandin E2 and prostacyclin, provide enhancement to the excitability of neurones by enhancing specific inward currents, especially those that are expressed on the nociceptors[6] Short term pain coming from the transitory discharge of nociceptors is from a result of mild noxious stimulation. Surgery which causes substantial injury, engages pathways involving this positive feedback cascade and therefore leads to a prolongation of hypersensitivity of peripheral tissues. [6] Such prolonged peripheral sensitization results in a sufficient barrage of nociceptive impulses into the spinal cord (and, perhaps, the brain) that the properties of the ‘receiving circuits’ there are sensitized. [6] Spinal cells (so called pain transmitting cells) response to central sensitization accounts for the response to non-noxious stimuli, which are conveyed by Ab-mechanoreceptors and accounts partly for the occurence of postoperative tactile allodynia, which is a common problem. The phenomenon of secondary hyperaesthesia: Where central sensitization is transmitted past the spinal neurones that are usually directly stimulated from the injured tissue, such that stimulation of surrounding areas, surrounding dermatomes, or even those on the contralateral side to the injury site now can cause pain. [6] Perioperatively, local anaesthetics are useful in affecting all three of these factors. During surgical manipulations, wound site local anaesthetic infiltration, and even deep into the surgical cavity, can attenuate the generation and propagation of injury-induced discharges. [6] This action may partly be due to inhibition of the transduction and sensitization steps in nociception, for specific local anaesthetics, examples like bupivacaine and amethocaine, which have been shown to inhibit a transducing channel, TRPV-1, which plays a vital role in the development of hyperalgesia after an insult like inflammation or injury. [6]

Page 18: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 18 of 25

The continuous delivery of local anaesthetics, from either slow-release formulations or catheters placed temporarily, may have an extention of impulse inhibition, days after surgery. Inflammatory and local sensitizing responses can be inhibited by local anaesthetics, which directly suppress some phases of the inflammation, which is, neutrophil priming, and by inhibiting some of the neuronal pathways that are activated by inflammation, which is protein kinase C, and certain G protein-coupled receptors.[6] Providing a persistent postoperative motor block, even of the peripheries (foot / ankle), creates another hurdle for the safety of mobilization in patients, extremely important after ‘ambulatory’ surgery. [6] Local anaesthetic concentration in systemic circulation, can alter postoperative pain profoundly. In the perioperative period , plasma lidocaine concentrations of 2–4 mg ml(8–15 mM), have exhibited a reduction of postoperative pain scores and opiate consumption; Circulatory presence of these drugs for a few hours, can suppress processes that would eventually escalate pain in the days following surgery[6] The plasma concentrations of local anaesthetics can be obtained and maintained by continuous i.v. infusions, at safe or effective rates, and also from the uptake of drugs by the vascular system, which is situated around a peripheral nerve or epidural site, for local / regional anaesthesia. The benefit of systemically circulating agents following the unintentional local anaesthetic administration is an unknown question. [6]

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine

Levobupivacaine and ropivacaine, developed recently as longer-acting local anaesthetics, motivated as an alternative to bupivacaine, after severe toxicity was associated with its use.

Table: Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati†, Guido Fanelli

Page 19: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 19 of 25

Ropivacaine as compared to bupivacaine and levobupivacaine is 40-50% less potent due to its lower lipid solubility. Although it has a reduced potency, it does not imply that it has a lower efficacy than bupivacaine or levobupivacaine. The use of an equipotency ratio of 1.5 : 1 between ropivacaine and the other two drugs results in a significantly similar clinical profile with motor function having been preserved adequately. [7] A study has recently confirmed a better neurotoxic profile of levobupivacaine in comparison to racemic bupivacaine, thus making levobupivacaine safer in clinical practice. [7] CNS signs of intoxication are usually evident before the appearance of cardiovascular toxicity, as the CNS is more susceptible to the actions of local anaesthetics [7] Initial or early signs of CNS toxicity are usually excitatory in nature and include shivering, muscle twitching, and tremors. These are as a result of a preferential block of inhibitory central pathways. As the local anesthetic plasma concentrations increase, there is blockage of the excitatory pathway of CNS toxicity. Following signs of CNS excitation is generalized CNS depression featuring hypoventilation and respiratory arrest, eventually progressing to generalized convulsions. One objective measure of CNS toxicity is the convulsive threshold. [7] In human subjects only mildly toxic doses are given for ethical reasons. Local anaesthetics are administered intravenously deliberately only for research, until the appearance of initial subjective signs of CNS toxicity. [7] Bupivacaine Ropivacaine and levobupivacaine show a dose-dependent prolongation of cardiac conduction. There is an increase in the PR interval and QRS duration on ECG. This is caused by the persistent block of sodium channels into diastole phase, predisposing to re-entrant arrhythmias. [7] The inhibition of cardiac contractility is also proportional to the lipid solubility and nerve-blocking potency of the local anesthetics, in order of rank (from least to most) of the cardiotoxic potency of the three local anaesthetics with ropivacaine < S bupivacaine <racemic bupivacaine <R(+) bupivacaine [7] The comparison of levobupivacaine and ropivacaine regarding the CVS effects after IV injection in healthy volunteers, showed no differences in mean percentage changes from baseline to the end of infusion for stroke index, cardiac index, acceleration index, or for PR interval, QRS duration, QT interval and heart rate. [7]

Page 20: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 20 of 25

Table 9: Summary of surgically placed wound catheters with type of surgery, infusion used and whether they were opioid sparing and of analgesic benefit [10]

Page 21: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 21 of 25

COST FACTOR

Fig 1: Mean time spent by nursing professionals to commence and supervise the analgesic technique. [8]

When calculating all the resources consumed, the Continuous Wound Infusion arm (Euros : 6460) is economically superior when compared with i.v.-PCA (Euros: 7273) and Epidural Anaesthesia (Euros: 7500). [8] The proportion of patients successfully controlled for their postoperative pain management are 77.4%, 53.9%, and 72.9% for Continuous Wound Infusion, i.v.-PCA, and Epidural Anaesthesia, respectively, demonstrating the Continuous Wound Infusion procedure to be both economically and clinically dominant. Continuous Wound Infusion has remained cost saving in 70.4% of cases when compared with Epidural Anaesthesia and in 59.2% of cases when compared with PCA. [8]

Page 22: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 22 of 25

DISCUSSION Optimal management of postoperative pain, a shorter length of hospital stay and a fast turnover after a major surgery have been important concerns among surgeons, anaesthetists and hospital administrators. [9] As epidural puncture is always associated with side effects such as neuraxial hematoma and nerve damages, patients with spinal malformations, infectious puncture site, and anticoagulant therapy are normally not included in the criteria for epidural analgesia use [9] In the case of hepatectomy, opioid administration even at lower doses can induce oxidative stress in the liver, leading to hepatocyte apoptosis and liver enzyme elevation [9] Patient satisfaction, safety and cost-effectiveness are all achieved using local anesthetic wound infusion catheters. In the event of failure or partial effectiveness, rescue analgesia is available and a smaller amount can be given. This is certainly an option for district level hospitals where turnover is high and bed space is at a premium with staff shortages and fewer resources.

Page 23: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 23 of 25

REFERENCES 1. British Journal of Anaesthesia 107 (5): 656–8 (2011) doi:10.1093/bja/aer293

2. Efficacy and safety of paravertebral blocks in breast surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsA. Schnabel, S. U. Reichl , P. Kranke, E. M. Pogatzki-Zahn and P. K. Zahn

3. Effectiveness of continuous wound infusion of 0.5% ropivacaine by On-Q pain relief system for postoperative pain management after open nephrectomy E. Forastiere1, M. Sofra, D. Giannarelli, L. Fabrizi and G. Simone

4. Quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgerySTELA MARI] LJILJA [TEFAN^I] LJILJANA POPOVI] MIROSLAV BANOVI] KATA [AKI]

5. Efficacy of Continuous Wound Catheters Delivering Local Anesthetic for Postoperative Analgesia: A Quantitative and Qualitative Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials Spencer S Liu, MD, Jeffrey M Richman, MD, Richard C Thirlby, MD, FACS, Christopher Lwu,

6. Novel ideas of local anaesthetic actions on various ion channels to ameliorate postoperative pain G. R. Strichartz

7. Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati, Guido Fanelli Department of Anesthesia and Pain Therapy, University Hospital of Parma, Parma (Italy)

8. Cost-effectiveness analysis comparing epidural, patient-controlled intravenous morphine, and continuous wound infiltration for postoperative pain management after open abdominal surgery P. Tilleul1,2, M. Aissou3,4, F. Bocquet1, N. Thiriat1, O. le Grelle1, M. J. Burke5, J. Hutton5,6 and M. Beaussier

9. Efficacy of Postoperative Continuous Wound Infiltration With Local Anesthesia After Open Hepatectomy Yu Xin , Hong et al

10. Peripheral nerve catheters and local anesthetic infiltration in perioperative analgesia Christopher K. Merritt, MD, Associate Professor Edward R. Mariano, MD, MAS, Associate Professor Alan David Kaye,MD, PhD, DABA,DABPM, DABIPP, Professor and Chairman, Jonathan Lissauer, MD, Assistant Professor Kenneth Mancuso, MD, Assistant Professor Amit Prabhakar, MD, MS, Senior Resident Richard D. Urman, MD, MBA, CPE, Assistant Professor of Anesthesia

11. http://www.pajunk.com

12. http://www.qtechnologiesgroup.co.uk/index.php/q-medical/accufuser

Page 24: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

6 March 2015 No. 6

Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters

V. Govender

Moderator: J. Cardoso

School of Clinical Medicine Discipline of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care

Page 25: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 2 of 25

CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 3

HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS ....................................................................... 3

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS .............................................................. 5

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT......................................... 7

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES ..................................................... 8

Cardiothoracic surgery .......................................................................................................... 9

General surgery .................................................................................................................... 12

Obstetrics and Gynaecology ............................................................................................... 13

Gynecology-Urology surgery .............................................................................................. 13

Orthopaedics......................................................................................................................... 14

Orthopaedic surgery ............................................................................................................ 14

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review ............................. 15

Physiology............................................................................................................................. 17

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine ........................................................................................ 18

COST FACTOR ......................................................................................................................... 21

DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................. 22

REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 23

Page 26: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 3 of 25

WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS

INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed catheter to deliver local anaesthetics or analgesics directly into the wound for postoperative pain relief. It can be used as a single technique or as part of a multi-modal analgesic approach Compared with opioid analgesia, continuous regional infusion of local anaesthetic provides better pain control with reduction in opioid use and opioid related side effects By optimizing postoperative analgesia, you increase patient satisfaction and clinically outcomes are improved. Postoperative pain that is uncontrolled can result in significant morbidity and mortality ¹. Categories of Regional Analgesia include:

• Extrapleural (equivalent to intercostal or paravertebral) and interpleural

• Peripheral Nerve Blocks e.g. interscalene, femoral nerve, sciatic nerve

• Intra-articular infusion e.g. post shoulder surgery

• Wound site infusion including use of a disposable elastomeric infusion device HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS Continuous infiltration of local anaesthetic into surgical wounds as an analgesic technique was first descibed just over a decade ago, after the development of multi-holed catheters. Together with the widespread availability of infusion pumps, placement of multi-holed flexible catheters inside or alongside surgical wounds enables continuous, evenly spread infiltration of LA over an indefinite period.¹ First described in 1935, it has been experimented with throughout the 20th century and the technique has been found to be safe and effective in several clinical settings. [4] Currently a number of brands and devices are available each carrying its own pros and cons. With evolving technology, delivery of local anaesthetics is becoming more accurate, reliable, safe and effective.

Page 27: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 4 of 25

Figure 1: Possible scope of application [11]

Page 28: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 5 of 25

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS � Easy placement of catheter with fewer complications associated with insertion compared

with neuraxial anesthesia and peripheral nerve blocking techniques.¹ � Potentially it offers to reduce postoperative opioid requirements and its associated side

effects and increase postoperative patient mobility, with minimal failure¹ � Pain is relieved by Continuous Local Anaesthetic wound infusion into a surgical wound

and works by direct inhibition of noxious afferent generator potentials from peripheral nerve fibres and a decrease of the local inflammatory response to injury¹

� Local Anaesthetic infusion analgesia can be used as a viable option when epidural

analgesia is contraindicated or physically challenging to do.¹ � Ability to have pain rescue with PCA without overdosing the patient � Cost effectiveness with reduced morbidity and mortality, length of stay, and burden of cost

to patient � Monitoring of patient is made easier � Infusion of local anaesthetic for regional analgesia can be used either alone or in

combination with systemic non-opioid and/or opioid analgesia

Figure 2: Disposable elastomeric ballon pump device [12]

Page 29: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 6 of 25

Figure 3: Special arrangement of catheter perforation for uniform distribution [11]

Figure 4: Integrated stainless steel helical coil, for uniform flow of anaesthetic and prevention of kinking or buckling. Also radiopaque and visible under ultrasound [11]

Page 30: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 7 of 25

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT

Fig 5: Surgical details showing, step by step, the positioning of two multiholed catheters for an open nephrectomy On-Q pain Buster ³

Maric et al did a study to compare the quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgery. The choice of optimal type of wound catheter, few or multi-hole is still controversial. The aim was to evaluate the analgesic potential of these two catheter types. [4]

Page 31: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 8 of 25

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES Forty patients undergoing colorectal surgery were randomized to intraoperative placement of two epidural catheters (Group EC) or multi-hole catheter (Group WC) in the wound above the fascia. Patients received 0.25% levobupivacaine (Group WC) with 10 mL bolus through the wound catheter followed by an infusion of 6 mL/h during 48 h, or the same protocol with equally divided levobupivacaine doses through two epidural catheters (Group EC). Simultaneously, patient-controlled analgesia provided intravenous morphine. [4] Pain was evaluated postoperatively with 4-point verbal scale (VRS) for the first 2 h, with Visual Analogue Scale at rest (VAS r), and during coughing (VAS c) every 6 h for the first 48 h. [4] Results and Conclusions: No significant difference in morphine consumption was observed between groups. There were no significant differences in VRS scores between the groups (p=0,756). VAS scores were significantlylower in Group WC in rest (rWC, p=0,007) and coughing (cWC, p=0,018) for the 6 h, 12 h, and 24 h postoperatively. [4] In the period 30–48 h there was no difference between groups. They concluded that levobupivacaine infusion through multi-hole catheter provides better quality of postoperative analgesia compared with two epidural catheters for the first 24 h. [4] The type of catheter plays the most important role. In this context, catheters with multiple holes may provide larger wound spread compared with triple orifice epidural catheters. The choice of catheter, multihole versus few holes is without any documentation for larger wound spread or improved analgesia. [4] The question also lies in the pumps, elastomeric or electronic? In their study they used electronic pumps because of lower price and good clinical experience. Elastomeric pumps are strongly recommended by wound catheter producers but Remerand et al. have published that elastomeric pumps may deliver inappropriate amounts of local anaesthetics with inaccuracy higher than 15% and failure to deflate is also not uncommon [4] Type of catheter plays a more important role in providing better analgesia for the first 24 hours. It seems logical that larger spread of local anaesthetics through more catheter holes provides better analgesia. In the first 24 h pain is more intense than following that critical period. They emphasize that VAS 6–24 h was in the clinically acceptable range between 0–2 in both groups. [4] Wound catheters are more expensive than epidural ones, and usage of disposable elastomeric pumps are more expensive than usage of electronic ones. [4] Local Anaesthetic Catheter Positioning seems to be crucial in determining how effective the technique is. Some catheters are placed in the pre-peritoneal space after laparotomy or open prostatectomy and have reduced postoperative pain, accelerated recovery, and postoperative pulmonary function may have benefitted some, while catheter placement superficial to i.m. fascia was mostly ineffective [1] Further support by a study of open nephrectomy patients showed optimal analgesia with one of the catheters that traversed between abdominal wall muscle layers and the pre-peritoneum. [1]

Page 32: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 9 of 25

A study by Liu et al showed Wound catheters which were placed in various locations (subcutaneous, subfascial, suprafascial,, intraarticular, peripleural, or periosteal), and only two Randomised Control Trials specifically stated that catheters were not placed or activated until surgical closure, as a result no preemptive analgesia was attempted or administered. For a median and mode of 2 days, local anaesthetic was infused . The cardiothoracic discipline had the most Randomised Controlled Trials (n 14), followed by Orthopaedic surgery (n 12), General Surgery (n 11), and gynecology-urology (n 7). [5] Metaanalysis associated multiple potential benefits with use of continuous wound catheters (Table 1). For all groups combined, mean VAS pain scores decreased considerably at rest (10 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 13 to 7 mm) and with activity (22 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 32 to 13mm). Subgroup analysis confirmed decreased pain scores. [5]

Cardiothoracic surgery

Thoracotomy for lung resection was explored by most trials, with the exception of 1 examining thoracotomy for esophagectomy and 3 examining median sternotomy for cardiac surgery (Table 1). Continuous infusion delivery or intermittent bolus delivery were the only methods studied. Placement of Thoracotomy wound catheters were in a variety of described peripleural locations (extrapleural: 2, interpleural: 2, intercostal:3, and intrapleural:4). Two of the cardiac studies done had placed catheters adjacent to the sternum whilst the other had inserted subfascial and subcutaneous (SC) catheters. Most of the Randomised Controlled Trials (12 of 14) reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy for pain scores or opioid use. [5] (11 of 13) Randomised Control Trials showed considerable reduction in pain scores in the immediate postoperative period, and five Randomised Control Trials had seen a reduction until the second postoperative day. Only a few trials reported opioid-related side effects (three of fourteen) or patient satisfaction (one of fourteen). The length of stay was reported by 6 trials, with four out of the six finding some reduction in the group of wound catheters. [5]

Page 33: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 10 of 25

Table 1: Liu et al - Cardiothoracics, Randomized controlled trials [5]

Page 34: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 11 of 25

Table2 : Liu et al [5] Cardiothoracics

Page 35: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 12 of 25

Table3 : Liu et al [5] Abdominal surgery (General surgery)

General surgery

Upper abdominal and vascular surgery, were some of the various surgical procedures used. (PCA) patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus was the choice of continuous delivery methods that were used. Placement of Wound catheters were SC, subfascial, or between muscle and peritoneum. Ten of twelve reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy, be it either a reduction in opioid use or a reduction in pain scores. A substantial reduction in Pain scores in the immediate postoperative period were found in 8 of 11 randomised controlled trials, but only three RCTs reported reduction through second postoperative day . Opioid side effects were reported by four of twelve studies whilst patient satisfaction (2 of 12), or length of hospital stay (3 of 12).

Page 36: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 13 of 25

Obstetrics and Gynaecology

Table 4: Liu et al [5] Obstetrics and gynaecology

Gynecology-Urology surgery

Cesarean section or abdominal hysterectomy were mostly examined. Similarly Patient controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus were used. Wound catheters were placed between muscle fascia and SC tissue (6 of 9) in the majority of cases. More than half (5 of 9) of RCTs had obtained substantial analgesic efficacy, both as reduced pain scores or reduced opioid use. Through the immediate postoperative period pain scores were substantially reduced in (4 of 9) RCTs, with no RCTs reporting a reduction past day one postoperatively. Improvement was found in All RCTs that reported side effects and patient satisfaction. Reported length of stay without any differences: (5 RCTs). [5]

Page 37: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 14 of 25

Orthopaedics

Table 5: Orthopaedic outcomes for different sites [5]

Orthopaedic surgery

Open and arthroscopic procedures on upper and lower extremities including spine surgery were some of the procedures that were studied. Again continuous delivery methods were used: patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus. The various locations used for the wound catheters: intraarticular, periosteal and SC. Majority of RCTs (13 / 16) found significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy both as decreased pain scores or opioid use. Pain scores immediately postoperative were significantly {p0.05} reduced in (12 of 16 RCTs), whilst 11 RCTs found a reduction through days 2 to 5 postoperatively. Only a few trials measured opioid-related side effects, a reduction in PONV in 4 of 6 RCTs, although not one reached individual statistical significance. Considerable increase in patient satisfaction was seen in the 3 RCTs that reported these outcomes. Length of stay measured in only 3 RCTs, and majority of the procedures (9 of 16 RCTs) were ambulatory. [5]

Page 38: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 15 of 25

Table 6: Liu et al [5] Orthopaedics

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review

Consistent analgesic efficacy was demonstrated by continuous wound infusion catheters with regards to reduced pain scores or opioid use for all surgical subspecialities, despite the type of surgical procedure done, exact location of the wound catheter, dose of local anaesthetic or mode of delivery of local anaesthetic, and mixture of analgesic. Opioid-related side effects, patient satisfaction, and length of hospital stay were infrequently assessed for each surgical group Increased patient satisfaction, a reduction in PONV globally, and decreased length of stay. [5] Several mechanisms of analgesia can be provided by direct application of local anaesthetic to wounds. Local anaesthetics would provide a direct blockade of transmission of pain from nociceptive afferents coming from the wound surface. There is mounting proof that local inflammatory response to injury which can be sensitizing to nociceptive receptors and contribute to pain and hyperalgesia, can be inhibited by local anaesthetic,. [5] Some studies of local anaesthetics have observed a reduction in release of inflammatory mediators obtained from neutrophils, a reduction of neutrophil adhesion to the endothelium, reduction in formation of free O2 radicals, and formation of oedema is decreased. By providing a prolonged application of local anaesthesic to wounds by a catheter, it proved to be far more beneficial from that of single injection technique of local anaesthetic in laparoscopic or abdominal operations, as previous systematic reviews demonstrated. [5]

Page 39: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 16 of 25

Table7 : Liu et al [5] orthopaedics

Page 40: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 17 of 25

Physiology

Combination of 3 Factors associated with Postoperative pain: (i) Nerve fibres that are innervating the site of the incision,retraction or suturing generate

impulses; [6] (ii) A number of inflammatory mediators, which become elevated at the surgical site and are

found to sensitize uninjured and injured nerve fibres. These include , prostaglandins, endothelin-1, cytokines and nerve growth factor [6]

(iii) The spinal cord which has pain transmitting circuits become sensitized which then has an

increased response to stimuli that are noxious and can transform their responsiveness to stimuli that is not painful, for example light touch or gentle pressure. [6]

Induction of the firing of impulses in peripheral neurones is precipitated by incisional trauma and of the stretch and compression from retraction, clamping, etc during surgery. Sensitization involving central pathways will be activated by these discharges, although it is probably largely restricted intraoperatively [6] Local inflammation is fostered by Tissue damage, bleeding, and the release of chemoattractants from the injury site. The chemokines or cytokines that are produced by migrating and proliferative immune cells, for example TNF-a, IL-6, and prostaglandin E2 and prostacyclin, provide enhancement to the excitability of neurones by enhancing specific inward currents, especially those that are expressed on the nociceptors[6] Short term pain coming from the transitory discharge of nociceptors is from a result of mild noxious stimulation. Surgery which causes substantial injury, engages pathways involving this positive feedback cascade and therefore leads to a prolongation of hypersensitivity of peripheral tissues. [6] Such prolonged peripheral sensitization results in a sufficient barrage of nociceptive impulses into the spinal cord (and, perhaps, the brain) that the properties of the ‘receiving circuits’ there are sensitized. [6] Spinal cells (so called pain transmitting cells) response to central sensitization accounts for the response to non-noxious stimuli, which are conveyed by Ab-mechanoreceptors and accounts partly for the occurence of postoperative tactile allodynia, which is a common problem. The phenomenon of secondary hyperaesthesia: Where central sensitization is transmitted past the spinal neurones that are usually directly stimulated from the injured tissue, such that stimulation of surrounding areas, surrounding dermatomes, or even those on the contralateral side to the injury site now can cause pain. [6] Perioperatively, local anaesthetics are useful in affecting all three of these factors. During surgical manipulations, wound site local anaesthetic infiltration, and even deep into the surgical cavity, can attenuate the generation and propagation of injury-induced discharges. [6] This action may partly be due to inhibition of the transduction and sensitization steps in nociception, for specific local anaesthetics, examples like bupivacaine and amethocaine, which have been shown to inhibit a transducing channel, TRPV-1, which plays a vital role in the development of hyperalgesia after an insult like inflammation or injury. [6]

Page 41: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 18 of 25

The continuous delivery of local anaesthetics, from either slow-release formulations or catheters placed temporarily, may have an extention of impulse inhibition, days after surgery. Inflammatory and local sensitizing responses can be inhibited by local anaesthetics, which directly suppress some phases of the inflammation, which is, neutrophil priming, and by inhibiting some of the neuronal pathways that are activated by inflammation, which is protein kinase C, and certain G protein-coupled receptors.[6] Providing a persistent postoperative motor block, even of the peripheries (foot / ankle), creates another hurdle for the safety of mobilization in patients, extremely important after ‘ambulatory’ surgery. [6] Local anaesthetic concentration in systemic circulation, can alter postoperative pain profoundly. In the perioperative period , plasma lidocaine concentrations of 2–4 mg ml(8–15 mM), have exhibited a reduction of postoperative pain scores and opiate consumption; Circulatory presence of these drugs for a few hours, can suppress processes that would eventually escalate pain in the days following surgery[6] The plasma concentrations of local anaesthetics can be obtained and maintained by continuous i.v. infusions, at safe or effective rates, and also from the uptake of drugs by the vascular system, which is situated around a peripheral nerve or epidural site, for local / regional anaesthesia. The benefit of systemically circulating agents following the unintentional local anaesthetic administration is an unknown question. [6]

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine

Levobupivacaine and ropivacaine, developed recently as longer-acting local anaesthetics, motivated as an alternative to bupivacaine, after severe toxicity was associated with its use.

Table: Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati†, Guido Fanelli

Page 42: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 19 of 25

Ropivacaine as compared to bupivacaine and levobupivacaine is 40-50% less potent due to its lower lipid solubility. Although it has a reduced potency, it does not imply that it has a lower efficacy than bupivacaine or levobupivacaine. The use of an equipotency ratio of 1.5 : 1 between ropivacaine and the other two drugs results in a significantly similar clinical profile with motor function having been preserved adequately. [7] A study has recently confirmed a better neurotoxic profile of levobupivacaine in comparison to racemic bupivacaine, thus making levobupivacaine safer in clinical practice. [7] CNS signs of intoxication are usually evident before the appearance of cardiovascular toxicity, as the CNS is more susceptible to the actions of local anaesthetics [7] Initial or early signs of CNS toxicity are usually excitatory in nature and include shivering, muscle twitching, and tremors. These are as a result of a preferential block of inhibitory central pathways. As the local anesthetic plasma concentrations increase, there is blockage of the excitatory pathway of CNS toxicity. Following signs of CNS excitation is generalized CNS depression featuring hypoventilation and respiratory arrest, eventually progressing to generalized convulsions. One objective measure of CNS toxicity is the convulsive threshold. [7] In human subjects only mildly toxic doses are given for ethical reasons. Local anaesthetics are administered intravenously deliberately only for research, until the appearance of initial subjective signs of CNS toxicity. [7] Bupivacaine Ropivacaine and levobupivacaine show a dose-dependent prolongation of cardiac conduction. There is an increase in the PR interval and QRS duration on ECG. This is caused by the persistent block of sodium channels into diastole phase, predisposing to re-entrant arrhythmias. [7] The inhibition of cardiac contractility is also proportional to the lipid solubility and nerve-blocking potency of the local anesthetics, in order of rank (from least to most) of the cardiotoxic potency of the three local anaesthetics with ropivacaine < S bupivacaine <racemic bupivacaine <R(+) bupivacaine [7] The comparison of levobupivacaine and ropivacaine regarding the CVS effects after IV injection in healthy volunteers, showed no differences in mean percentage changes from baseline to the end of infusion for stroke index, cardiac index, acceleration index, or for PR interval, QRS duration, QT interval and heart rate. [7]

Page 43: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 20 of 25

Table 9: Summary of surgically placed wound catheters with type of surgery, infusion used and whether they were opioid sparing and of analgesic benefit [10]

Page 44: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 21 of 25

COST FACTOR

Fig 1: Mean time spent by nursing professionals to commence and supervise the analgesic technique. [8]

When calculating all the resources consumed, the Continuous Wound Infusion arm (Euros : 6460) is economically superior when compared with i.v.-PCA (Euros: 7273) and Epidural Anaesthesia (Euros: 7500). [8] The proportion of patients successfully controlled for their postoperative pain management are 77.4%, 53.9%, and 72.9% for Continuous Wound Infusion, i.v.-PCA, and Epidural Anaesthesia, respectively, demonstrating the Continuous Wound Infusion procedure to be both economically and clinically dominant. Continuous Wound Infusion has remained cost saving in 70.4% of cases when compared with Epidural Anaesthesia and in 59.2% of cases when compared with PCA. [8]

Page 45: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 22 of 25

DISCUSSION Optimal management of postoperative pain, a shorter length of hospital stay and a fast turnover after a major surgery have been important concerns among surgeons, anaesthetists and hospital administrators. [9] As epidural puncture is always associated with side effects such as neuraxial hematoma and nerve damages, patients with spinal malformations, infectious puncture site, and anticoagulant therapy are normally not included in the criteria for epidural analgesia use [9] In the case of hepatectomy, opioid administration even at lower doses can induce oxidative stress in the liver, leading to hepatocyte apoptosis and liver enzyme elevation [9] Patient satisfaction, safety and cost-effectiveness are all achieved using local anesthetic wound infusion catheters. In the event of failure or partial effectiveness, rescue analgesia is available and a smaller amount can be given. This is certainly an option for district level hospitals where turnover is high and bed space is at a premium with staff shortages and fewer resources.

Page 46: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 23 of 25

REFERENCES 1. British Journal of Anaesthesia 107 (5): 656–8 (2011) doi:10.1093/bja/aer293

2. Efficacy and safety of paravertebral blocks in breast surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsA. Schnabel, S. U. Reichl , P. Kranke, E. M. Pogatzki-Zahn and P. K. Zahn

3. Effectiveness of continuous wound infusion of 0.5% ropivacaine by On-Q pain relief system for postoperative pain management after open nephrectomy E. Forastiere1, M. Sofra, D. Giannarelli, L. Fabrizi and G. Simone

4. Quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgerySTELA MARI] LJILJA [TEFAN^I] LJILJANA POPOVI] MIROSLAV BANOVI] KATA [AKI]

5. Efficacy of Continuous Wound Catheters Delivering Local Anesthetic for Postoperative Analgesia: A Quantitative and Qualitative Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials Spencer S Liu, MD, Jeffrey M Richman, MD, Richard C Thirlby, MD, FACS, Christopher Lwu,

6. Novel ideas of local anaesthetic actions on various ion channels to ameliorate postoperative pain G. R. Strichartz

7. Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati, Guido Fanelli Department of Anesthesia and Pain Therapy, University Hospital of Parma, Parma (Italy)

8. Cost-effectiveness analysis comparing epidural, patient-controlled intravenous morphine, and continuous wound infiltration for postoperative pain management after open abdominal surgery P. Tilleul1,2, M. Aissou3,4, F. Bocquet1, N. Thiriat1, O. le Grelle1, M. J. Burke5, J. Hutton5,6 and M. Beaussier

9. Efficacy of Postoperative Continuous Wound Infiltration With Local Anesthesia After Open Hepatectomy Yu Xin , Hong et al

10. Peripheral nerve catheters and local anesthetic infiltration in perioperative analgesia Christopher K. Merritt, MD, Associate Professor Edward R. Mariano, MD, MAS, Associate Professor Alan David Kaye,MD, PhD, DABA,DABPM, DABIPP, Professor and Chairman, Jonathan Lissauer, MD, Assistant Professor Kenneth Mancuso, MD, Assistant Professor Amit Prabhakar, MD, MS, Senior Resident Richard D. Urman, MD, MBA, CPE, Assistant Professor of Anesthesia

11. http://www.pajunk.com

12. http://www.qtechnologiesgroup.co.uk/index.php/q-medical/accufuser

Page 47: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

6 March 2015 No. 6

Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters

V. Govender

Moderator: J. Cardoso

School of Clinical Medicine Discipline of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care

Page 48: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 2 of 25

CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 3

HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS ....................................................................... 3

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS .............................................................. 5

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT......................................... 7

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES ..................................................... 8

Cardiothoracic surgery .......................................................................................................... 9

General surgery .................................................................................................................... 12

Obstetrics and Gynaecology ............................................................................................... 13

Gynecology-Urology surgery .............................................................................................. 13

Orthopaedics......................................................................................................................... 14

Orthopaedic surgery ............................................................................................................ 14

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review ............................. 15

Physiology............................................................................................................................. 17

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine ........................................................................................ 18

COST FACTOR ......................................................................................................................... 21

DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................. 22

REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 23

Page 49: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 3 of 25

WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS

INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed catheter to deliver local anaesthetics or analgesics directly into the wound for postoperative pain relief. It can be used as a single technique or as part of a multi-modal analgesic approach Compared with opioid analgesia, continuous regional infusion of local anaesthetic provides better pain control with reduction in opioid use and opioid related side effects By optimizing postoperative analgesia, you increase patient satisfaction and clinically outcomes are improved. Postoperative pain that is uncontrolled can result in significant morbidity and mortality ¹. Categories of Regional Analgesia include:

• Extrapleural (equivalent to intercostal or paravertebral) and interpleural

• Peripheral Nerve Blocks e.g. interscalene, femoral nerve, sciatic nerve

• Intra-articular infusion e.g. post shoulder surgery

• Wound site infusion including use of a disposable elastomeric infusion device HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS Continuous infiltration of local anaesthetic into surgical wounds as an analgesic technique was first descibed just over a decade ago, after the development of multi-holed catheters. Together with the widespread availability of infusion pumps, placement of multi-holed flexible catheters inside or alongside surgical wounds enables continuous, evenly spread infiltration of LA over an indefinite period.¹ First described in 1935, it has been experimented with throughout the 20th century and the technique has been found to be safe and effective in several clinical settings. [4] Currently a number of brands and devices are available each carrying its own pros and cons. With evolving technology, delivery of local anaesthetics is becoming more accurate, reliable, safe and effective.

Page 50: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 4 of 25

Figure 1: Possible scope of application [11]

Page 51: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 5 of 25

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS � Easy placement of catheter with fewer complications associated with insertion compared

with neuraxial anesthesia and peripheral nerve blocking techniques.¹ � Potentially it offers to reduce postoperative opioid requirements and its associated side

effects and increase postoperative patient mobility, with minimal failure¹ � Pain is relieved by Continuous Local Anaesthetic wound infusion into a surgical wound

and works by direct inhibition of noxious afferent generator potentials from peripheral nerve fibres and a decrease of the local inflammatory response to injury¹

� Local Anaesthetic infusion analgesia can be used as a viable option when epidural

analgesia is contraindicated or physically challenging to do.¹ � Ability to have pain rescue with PCA without overdosing the patient � Cost effectiveness with reduced morbidity and mortality, length of stay, and burden of cost

to patient � Monitoring of patient is made easier � Infusion of local anaesthetic for regional analgesia can be used either alone or in

combination with systemic non-opioid and/or opioid analgesia

Figure 2: Disposable elastomeric ballon pump device [12]

Page 52: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 6 of 25

Figure 3: Special arrangement of catheter perforation for uniform distribution [11]

Figure 4: Integrated stainless steel helical coil, for uniform flow of anaesthetic and prevention of kinking or buckling. Also radiopaque and visible under ultrasound [11]

Page 53: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 7 of 25

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT

Fig 5: Surgical details showing, step by step, the positioning of two multiholed catheters for an open nephrectomy On-Q pain Buster ³

Maric et al did a study to compare the quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgery. The choice of optimal type of wound catheter, few or multi-hole is still controversial. The aim was to evaluate the analgesic potential of these two catheter types. [4]

Page 54: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 8 of 25

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES Forty patients undergoing colorectal surgery were randomized to intraoperative placement of two epidural catheters (Group EC) or multi-hole catheter (Group WC) in the wound above the fascia. Patients received 0.25% levobupivacaine (Group WC) with 10 mL bolus through the wound catheter followed by an infusion of 6 mL/h during 48 h, or the same protocol with equally divided levobupivacaine doses through two epidural catheters (Group EC). Simultaneously, patient-controlled analgesia provided intravenous morphine. [4] Pain was evaluated postoperatively with 4-point verbal scale (VRS) for the first 2 h, with Visual Analogue Scale at rest (VAS r), and during coughing (VAS c) every 6 h for the first 48 h. [4] Results and Conclusions: No significant difference in morphine consumption was observed between groups. There were no significant differences in VRS scores between the groups (p=0,756). VAS scores were significantlylower in Group WC in rest (rWC, p=0,007) and coughing (cWC, p=0,018) for the 6 h, 12 h, and 24 h postoperatively. [4] In the period 30–48 h there was no difference between groups. They concluded that levobupivacaine infusion through multi-hole catheter provides better quality of postoperative analgesia compared with two epidural catheters for the first 24 h. [4] The type of catheter plays the most important role. In this context, catheters with multiple holes may provide larger wound spread compared with triple orifice epidural catheters. The choice of catheter, multihole versus few holes is without any documentation for larger wound spread or improved analgesia. [4] The question also lies in the pumps, elastomeric or electronic? In their study they used electronic pumps because of lower price and good clinical experience. Elastomeric pumps are strongly recommended by wound catheter producers but Remerand et al. have published that elastomeric pumps may deliver inappropriate amounts of local anaesthetics with inaccuracy higher than 15% and failure to deflate is also not uncommon [4] Type of catheter plays a more important role in providing better analgesia for the first 24 hours. It seems logical that larger spread of local anaesthetics through more catheter holes provides better analgesia. In the first 24 h pain is more intense than following that critical period. They emphasize that VAS 6–24 h was in the clinically acceptable range between 0–2 in both groups. [4] Wound catheters are more expensive than epidural ones, and usage of disposable elastomeric pumps are more expensive than usage of electronic ones. [4] Local Anaesthetic Catheter Positioning seems to be crucial in determining how effective the technique is. Some catheters are placed in the pre-peritoneal space after laparotomy or open prostatectomy and have reduced postoperative pain, accelerated recovery, and postoperative pulmonary function may have benefitted some, while catheter placement superficial to i.m. fascia was mostly ineffective [1] Further support by a study of open nephrectomy patients showed optimal analgesia with one of the catheters that traversed between abdominal wall muscle layers and the pre-peritoneum. [1]

Page 55: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 9 of 25

A study by Liu et al showed Wound catheters which were placed in various locations (subcutaneous, subfascial, suprafascial,, intraarticular, peripleural, or periosteal), and only two Randomised Control Trials specifically stated that catheters were not placed or activated until surgical closure, as a result no preemptive analgesia was attempted or administered. For a median and mode of 2 days, local anaesthetic was infused . The cardiothoracic discipline had the most Randomised Controlled Trials (n 14), followed by Orthopaedic surgery (n 12), General Surgery (n 11), and gynecology-urology (n 7). [5] Metaanalysis associated multiple potential benefits with use of continuous wound catheters (Table 1). For all groups combined, mean VAS pain scores decreased considerably at rest (10 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 13 to 7 mm) and with activity (22 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 32 to 13mm). Subgroup analysis confirmed decreased pain scores. [5]

Cardiothoracic surgery

Thoracotomy for lung resection was explored by most trials, with the exception of 1 examining thoracotomy for esophagectomy and 3 examining median sternotomy for cardiac surgery (Table 1). Continuous infusion delivery or intermittent bolus delivery were the only methods studied. Placement of Thoracotomy wound catheters were in a variety of described peripleural locations (extrapleural: 2, interpleural: 2, intercostal:3, and intrapleural:4). Two of the cardiac studies done had placed catheters adjacent to the sternum whilst the other had inserted subfascial and subcutaneous (SC) catheters. Most of the Randomised Controlled Trials (12 of 14) reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy for pain scores or opioid use. [5] (11 of 13) Randomised Control Trials showed considerable reduction in pain scores in the immediate postoperative period, and five Randomised Control Trials had seen a reduction until the second postoperative day. Only a few trials reported opioid-related side effects (three of fourteen) or patient satisfaction (one of fourteen). The length of stay was reported by 6 trials, with four out of the six finding some reduction in the group of wound catheters. [5]

Page 56: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 10 of 25

Table 1: Liu et al - Cardiothoracics, Randomized controlled trials [5]

Page 57: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 11 of 25

Table2 : Liu et al [5] Cardiothoracics

Page 58: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 12 of 25

Table3 : Liu et al [5] Abdominal surgery (General surgery)

General surgery

Upper abdominal and vascular surgery, were some of the various surgical procedures used. (PCA) patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus was the choice of continuous delivery methods that were used. Placement of Wound catheters were SC, subfascial, or between muscle and peritoneum. Ten of twelve reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy, be it either a reduction in opioid use or a reduction in pain scores. A substantial reduction in Pain scores in the immediate postoperative period were found in 8 of 11 randomised controlled trials, but only three RCTs reported reduction through second postoperative day . Opioid side effects were reported by four of twelve studies whilst patient satisfaction (2 of 12), or length of hospital stay (3 of 12).

Page 59: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 13 of 25

Obstetrics and Gynaecology

Table 4: Liu et al [5] Obstetrics and gynaecology

Gynecology-Urology surgery

Cesarean section or abdominal hysterectomy were mostly examined. Similarly Patient controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus were used. Wound catheters were placed between muscle fascia and SC tissue (6 of 9) in the majority of cases. More than half (5 of 9) of RCTs had obtained substantial analgesic efficacy, both as reduced pain scores or reduced opioid use. Through the immediate postoperative period pain scores were substantially reduced in (4 of 9) RCTs, with no RCTs reporting a reduction past day one postoperatively. Improvement was found in All RCTs that reported side effects and patient satisfaction. Reported length of stay without any differences: (5 RCTs). [5]

Page 60: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 14 of 25

Orthopaedics

Table 5: Orthopaedic outcomes for different sites [5]

Orthopaedic surgery

Open and arthroscopic procedures on upper and lower extremities including spine surgery were some of the procedures that were studied. Again continuous delivery methods were used: patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus. The various locations used for the wound catheters: intraarticular, periosteal and SC. Majority of RCTs (13 / 16) found significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy both as decreased pain scores or opioid use. Pain scores immediately postoperative were significantly {p0.05} reduced in (12 of 16 RCTs), whilst 11 RCTs found a reduction through days 2 to 5 postoperatively. Only a few trials measured opioid-related side effects, a reduction in PONV in 4 of 6 RCTs, although not one reached individual statistical significance. Considerable increase in patient satisfaction was seen in the 3 RCTs that reported these outcomes. Length of stay measured in only 3 RCTs, and majority of the procedures (9 of 16 RCTs) were ambulatory. [5]

Page 61: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 15 of 25

Table 6: Liu et al [5] Orthopaedics

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review

Consistent analgesic efficacy was demonstrated by continuous wound infusion catheters with regards to reduced pain scores or opioid use for all surgical subspecialities, despite the type of surgical procedure done, exact location of the wound catheter, dose of local anaesthetic or mode of delivery of local anaesthetic, and mixture of analgesic. Opioid-related side effects, patient satisfaction, and length of hospital stay were infrequently assessed for each surgical group Increased patient satisfaction, a reduction in PONV globally, and decreased length of stay. [5] Several mechanisms of analgesia can be provided by direct application of local anaesthetic to wounds. Local anaesthetics would provide a direct blockade of transmission of pain from nociceptive afferents coming from the wound surface. There is mounting proof that local inflammatory response to injury which can be sensitizing to nociceptive receptors and contribute to pain and hyperalgesia, can be inhibited by local anaesthetic,. [5] Some studies of local anaesthetics have observed a reduction in release of inflammatory mediators obtained from neutrophils, a reduction of neutrophil adhesion to the endothelium, reduction in formation of free O2 radicals, and formation of oedema is decreased. By providing a prolonged application of local anaesthesic to wounds by a catheter, it proved to be far more beneficial from that of single injection technique of local anaesthetic in laparoscopic or abdominal operations, as previous systematic reviews demonstrated. [5]

Page 62: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 16 of 25

Table7 : Liu et al [5] orthopaedics

Page 63: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 17 of 25

Physiology

Combination of 3 Factors associated with Postoperative pain: (i) Nerve fibres that are innervating the site of the incision,retraction or suturing generate

impulses; [6] (ii) A number of inflammatory mediators, which become elevated at the surgical site and are

found to sensitize uninjured and injured nerve fibres. These include , prostaglandins, endothelin-1, cytokines and nerve growth factor [6]

(iii) The spinal cord which has pain transmitting circuits become sensitized which then has an

increased response to stimuli that are noxious and can transform their responsiveness to stimuli that is not painful, for example light touch or gentle pressure. [6]

Induction of the firing of impulses in peripheral neurones is precipitated by incisional trauma and of the stretch and compression from retraction, clamping, etc during surgery. Sensitization involving central pathways will be activated by these discharges, although it is probably largely restricted intraoperatively [6] Local inflammation is fostered by Tissue damage, bleeding, and the release of chemoattractants from the injury site. The chemokines or cytokines that are produced by migrating and proliferative immune cells, for example TNF-a, IL-6, and prostaglandin E2 and prostacyclin, provide enhancement to the excitability of neurones by enhancing specific inward currents, especially those that are expressed on the nociceptors[6] Short term pain coming from the transitory discharge of nociceptors is from a result of mild noxious stimulation. Surgery which causes substantial injury, engages pathways involving this positive feedback cascade and therefore leads to a prolongation of hypersensitivity of peripheral tissues. [6] Such prolonged peripheral sensitization results in a sufficient barrage of nociceptive impulses into the spinal cord (and, perhaps, the brain) that the properties of the ‘receiving circuits’ there are sensitized. [6] Spinal cells (so called pain transmitting cells) response to central sensitization accounts for the response to non-noxious stimuli, which are conveyed by Ab-mechanoreceptors and accounts partly for the occurence of postoperative tactile allodynia, which is a common problem. The phenomenon of secondary hyperaesthesia: Where central sensitization is transmitted past the spinal neurones that are usually directly stimulated from the injured tissue, such that stimulation of surrounding areas, surrounding dermatomes, or even those on the contralateral side to the injury site now can cause pain. [6] Perioperatively, local anaesthetics are useful in affecting all three of these factors. During surgical manipulations, wound site local anaesthetic infiltration, and even deep into the surgical cavity, can attenuate the generation and propagation of injury-induced discharges. [6] This action may partly be due to inhibition of the transduction and sensitization steps in nociception, for specific local anaesthetics, examples like bupivacaine and amethocaine, which have been shown to inhibit a transducing channel, TRPV-1, which plays a vital role in the development of hyperalgesia after an insult like inflammation or injury. [6]

Page 64: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 18 of 25

The continuous delivery of local anaesthetics, from either slow-release formulations or catheters placed temporarily, may have an extention of impulse inhibition, days after surgery. Inflammatory and local sensitizing responses can be inhibited by local anaesthetics, which directly suppress some phases of the inflammation, which is, neutrophil priming, and by inhibiting some of the neuronal pathways that are activated by inflammation, which is protein kinase C, and certain G protein-coupled receptors.[6] Providing a persistent postoperative motor block, even of the peripheries (foot / ankle), creates another hurdle for the safety of mobilization in patients, extremely important after ‘ambulatory’ surgery. [6] Local anaesthetic concentration in systemic circulation, can alter postoperative pain profoundly. In the perioperative period , plasma lidocaine concentrations of 2–4 mg ml(8–15 mM), have exhibited a reduction of postoperative pain scores and opiate consumption; Circulatory presence of these drugs for a few hours, can suppress processes that would eventually escalate pain in the days following surgery[6] The plasma concentrations of local anaesthetics can be obtained and maintained by continuous i.v. infusions, at safe or effective rates, and also from the uptake of drugs by the vascular system, which is situated around a peripheral nerve or epidural site, for local / regional anaesthesia. The benefit of systemically circulating agents following the unintentional local anaesthetic administration is an unknown question. [6]

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine

Levobupivacaine and ropivacaine, developed recently as longer-acting local anaesthetics, motivated as an alternative to bupivacaine, after severe toxicity was associated with its use.

Table: Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati†, Guido Fanelli

Page 65: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 19 of 25

Ropivacaine as compared to bupivacaine and levobupivacaine is 40-50% less potent due to its lower lipid solubility. Although it has a reduced potency, it does not imply that it has a lower efficacy than bupivacaine or levobupivacaine. The use of an equipotency ratio of 1.5 : 1 between ropivacaine and the other two drugs results in a significantly similar clinical profile with motor function having been preserved adequately. [7] A study has recently confirmed a better neurotoxic profile of levobupivacaine in comparison to racemic bupivacaine, thus making levobupivacaine safer in clinical practice. [7] CNS signs of intoxication are usually evident before the appearance of cardiovascular toxicity, as the CNS is more susceptible to the actions of local anaesthetics [7] Initial or early signs of CNS toxicity are usually excitatory in nature and include shivering, muscle twitching, and tremors. These are as a result of a preferential block of inhibitory central pathways. As the local anesthetic plasma concentrations increase, there is blockage of the excitatory pathway of CNS toxicity. Following signs of CNS excitation is generalized CNS depression featuring hypoventilation and respiratory arrest, eventually progressing to generalized convulsions. One objective measure of CNS toxicity is the convulsive threshold. [7] In human subjects only mildly toxic doses are given for ethical reasons. Local anaesthetics are administered intravenously deliberately only for research, until the appearance of initial subjective signs of CNS toxicity. [7] Bupivacaine Ropivacaine and levobupivacaine show a dose-dependent prolongation of cardiac conduction. There is an increase in the PR interval and QRS duration on ECG. This is caused by the persistent block of sodium channels into diastole phase, predisposing to re-entrant arrhythmias. [7] The inhibition of cardiac contractility is also proportional to the lipid solubility and nerve-blocking potency of the local anesthetics, in order of rank (from least to most) of the cardiotoxic potency of the three local anaesthetics with ropivacaine < S bupivacaine <racemic bupivacaine <R(+) bupivacaine [7] The comparison of levobupivacaine and ropivacaine regarding the CVS effects after IV injection in healthy volunteers, showed no differences in mean percentage changes from baseline to the end of infusion for stroke index, cardiac index, acceleration index, or for PR interval, QRS duration, QT interval and heart rate. [7]

Page 66: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 20 of 25

Table 9: Summary of surgically placed wound catheters with type of surgery, infusion used and whether they were opioid sparing and of analgesic benefit [10]

Page 67: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 21 of 25

COST FACTOR

Fig 1: Mean time spent by nursing professionals to commence and supervise the analgesic technique. [8]

When calculating all the resources consumed, the Continuous Wound Infusion arm (Euros : 6460) is economically superior when compared with i.v.-PCA (Euros: 7273) and Epidural Anaesthesia (Euros: 7500). [8] The proportion of patients successfully controlled for their postoperative pain management are 77.4%, 53.9%, and 72.9% for Continuous Wound Infusion, i.v.-PCA, and Epidural Anaesthesia, respectively, demonstrating the Continuous Wound Infusion procedure to be both economically and clinically dominant. Continuous Wound Infusion has remained cost saving in 70.4% of cases when compared with Epidural Anaesthesia and in 59.2% of cases when compared with PCA. [8]

Page 68: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 22 of 25

DISCUSSION Optimal management of postoperative pain, a shorter length of hospital stay and a fast turnover after a major surgery have been important concerns among surgeons, anaesthetists and hospital administrators. [9] As epidural puncture is always associated with side effects such as neuraxial hematoma and nerve damages, patients with spinal malformations, infectious puncture site, and anticoagulant therapy are normally not included in the criteria for epidural analgesia use [9] In the case of hepatectomy, opioid administration even at lower doses can induce oxidative stress in the liver, leading to hepatocyte apoptosis and liver enzyme elevation [9] Patient satisfaction, safety and cost-effectiveness are all achieved using local anesthetic wound infusion catheters. In the event of failure or partial effectiveness, rescue analgesia is available and a smaller amount can be given. This is certainly an option for district level hospitals where turnover is high and bed space is at a premium with staff shortages and fewer resources.

Page 69: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 23 of 25

REFERENCES 1. British Journal of Anaesthesia 107 (5): 656–8 (2011) doi:10.1093/bja/aer293

2. Efficacy and safety of paravertebral blocks in breast surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsA. Schnabel, S. U. Reichl , P. Kranke, E. M. Pogatzki-Zahn and P. K. Zahn

3. Effectiveness of continuous wound infusion of 0.5% ropivacaine by On-Q pain relief system for postoperative pain management after open nephrectomy E. Forastiere1, M. Sofra, D. Giannarelli, L. Fabrizi and G. Simone

4. Quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgerySTELA MARI] LJILJA [TEFAN^I] LJILJANA POPOVI] MIROSLAV BANOVI] KATA [AKI]

5. Efficacy of Continuous Wound Catheters Delivering Local Anesthetic for Postoperative Analgesia: A Quantitative and Qualitative Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials Spencer S Liu, MD, Jeffrey M Richman, MD, Richard C Thirlby, MD, FACS, Christopher Lwu,

6. Novel ideas of local anaesthetic actions on various ion channels to ameliorate postoperative pain G. R. Strichartz

7. Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati, Guido Fanelli Department of Anesthesia and Pain Therapy, University Hospital of Parma, Parma (Italy)

8. Cost-effectiveness analysis comparing epidural, patient-controlled intravenous morphine, and continuous wound infiltration for postoperative pain management after open abdominal surgery P. Tilleul1,2, M. Aissou3,4, F. Bocquet1, N. Thiriat1, O. le Grelle1, M. J. Burke5, J. Hutton5,6 and M. Beaussier

9. Efficacy of Postoperative Continuous Wound Infiltration With Local Anesthesia After Open Hepatectomy Yu Xin , Hong et al

10. Peripheral nerve catheters and local anesthetic infiltration in perioperative analgesia Christopher K. Merritt, MD, Associate Professor Edward R. Mariano, MD, MAS, Associate Professor Alan David Kaye,MD, PhD, DABA,DABPM, DABIPP, Professor and Chairman, Jonathan Lissauer, MD, Assistant Professor Kenneth Mancuso, MD, Assistant Professor Amit Prabhakar, MD, MS, Senior Resident Richard D. Urman, MD, MBA, CPE, Assistant Professor of Anesthesia

11. http://www.pajunk.com

12. http://www.qtechnologiesgroup.co.uk/index.php/q-medical/accufuser

Page 70: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

6 March 2015 No. 6

Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters

V. Govender

Moderator: J. Cardoso

School of Clinical Medicine Discipline of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care

Page 71: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 2 of 25

CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 3

HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS ....................................................................... 3

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS .............................................................. 5

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT......................................... 7

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES ..................................................... 8

Cardiothoracic surgery .......................................................................................................... 9

General surgery .................................................................................................................... 12

Obstetrics and Gynaecology ............................................................................................... 13

Gynecology-Urology surgery .............................................................................................. 13

Orthopaedics......................................................................................................................... 14

Orthopaedic surgery ............................................................................................................ 14

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review ............................. 15

Physiology............................................................................................................................. 17

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine ........................................................................................ 18

COST FACTOR ......................................................................................................................... 21

DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................. 22

REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 23

Page 72: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 3 of 25

WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS

INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed catheter to deliver local anaesthetics or analgesics directly into the wound for postoperative pain relief. It can be used as a single technique or as part of a multi-modal analgesic approach Compared with opioid analgesia, continuous regional infusion of local anaesthetic provides better pain control with reduction in opioid use and opioid related side effects By optimizing postoperative analgesia, you increase patient satisfaction and clinically outcomes are improved. Postoperative pain that is uncontrolled can result in significant morbidity and mortality ¹. Categories of Regional Analgesia include:

• Extrapleural (equivalent to intercostal or paravertebral) and interpleural

• Peripheral Nerve Blocks e.g. interscalene, femoral nerve, sciatic nerve

• Intra-articular infusion e.g. post shoulder surgery

• Wound site infusion including use of a disposable elastomeric infusion device HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS Continuous infiltration of local anaesthetic into surgical wounds as an analgesic technique was first descibed just over a decade ago, after the development of multi-holed catheters. Together with the widespread availability of infusion pumps, placement of multi-holed flexible catheters inside or alongside surgical wounds enables continuous, evenly spread infiltration of LA over an indefinite period.¹ First described in 1935, it has been experimented with throughout the 20th century and the technique has been found to be safe and effective in several clinical settings. [4] Currently a number of brands and devices are available each carrying its own pros and cons. With evolving technology, delivery of local anaesthetics is becoming more accurate, reliable, safe and effective.

Page 73: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 4 of 25

Figure 1: Possible scope of application [11]

Page 74: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 5 of 25

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS � Easy placement of catheter with fewer complications associated with insertion compared

with neuraxial anesthesia and peripheral nerve blocking techniques.¹ � Potentially it offers to reduce postoperative opioid requirements and its associated side

effects and increase postoperative patient mobility, with minimal failure¹ � Pain is relieved by Continuous Local Anaesthetic wound infusion into a surgical wound

and works by direct inhibition of noxious afferent generator potentials from peripheral nerve fibres and a decrease of the local inflammatory response to injury¹

� Local Anaesthetic infusion analgesia can be used as a viable option when epidural

analgesia is contraindicated or physically challenging to do.¹ � Ability to have pain rescue with PCA without overdosing the patient � Cost effectiveness with reduced morbidity and mortality, length of stay, and burden of cost

to patient � Monitoring of patient is made easier � Infusion of local anaesthetic for regional analgesia can be used either alone or in

combination with systemic non-opioid and/or opioid analgesia

Figure 2: Disposable elastomeric ballon pump device [12]

Page 75: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 6 of 25

Figure 3: Special arrangement of catheter perforation for uniform distribution [11]

Figure 4: Integrated stainless steel helical coil, for uniform flow of anaesthetic and prevention of kinking or buckling. Also radiopaque and visible under ultrasound [11]

Page 76: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 7 of 25

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT

Fig 5: Surgical details showing, step by step, the positioning of two multiholed catheters for an open nephrectomy On-Q pain Buster ³

Maric et al did a study to compare the quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgery. The choice of optimal type of wound catheter, few or multi-hole is still controversial. The aim was to evaluate the analgesic potential of these two catheter types. [4]

Page 77: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 8 of 25

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES Forty patients undergoing colorectal surgery were randomized to intraoperative placement of two epidural catheters (Group EC) or multi-hole catheter (Group WC) in the wound above the fascia. Patients received 0.25% levobupivacaine (Group WC) with 10 mL bolus through the wound catheter followed by an infusion of 6 mL/h during 48 h, or the same protocol with equally divided levobupivacaine doses through two epidural catheters (Group EC). Simultaneously, patient-controlled analgesia provided intravenous morphine. [4] Pain was evaluated postoperatively with 4-point verbal scale (VRS) for the first 2 h, with Visual Analogue Scale at rest (VAS r), and during coughing (VAS c) every 6 h for the first 48 h. [4] Results and Conclusions: No significant difference in morphine consumption was observed between groups. There were no significant differences in VRS scores between the groups (p=0,756). VAS scores were significantlylower in Group WC in rest (rWC, p=0,007) and coughing (cWC, p=0,018) for the 6 h, 12 h, and 24 h postoperatively. [4] In the period 30–48 h there was no difference between groups. They concluded that levobupivacaine infusion through multi-hole catheter provides better quality of postoperative analgesia compared with two epidural catheters for the first 24 h. [4] The type of catheter plays the most important role. In this context, catheters with multiple holes may provide larger wound spread compared with triple orifice epidural catheters. The choice of catheter, multihole versus few holes is without any documentation for larger wound spread or improved analgesia. [4] The question also lies in the pumps, elastomeric or electronic? In their study they used electronic pumps because of lower price and good clinical experience. Elastomeric pumps are strongly recommended by wound catheter producers but Remerand et al. have published that elastomeric pumps may deliver inappropriate amounts of local anaesthetics with inaccuracy higher than 15% and failure to deflate is also not uncommon [4] Type of catheter plays a more important role in providing better analgesia for the first 24 hours. It seems logical that larger spread of local anaesthetics through more catheter holes provides better analgesia. In the first 24 h pain is more intense than following that critical period. They emphasize that VAS 6–24 h was in the clinically acceptable range between 0–2 in both groups. [4] Wound catheters are more expensive than epidural ones, and usage of disposable elastomeric pumps are more expensive than usage of electronic ones. [4] Local Anaesthetic Catheter Positioning seems to be crucial in determining how effective the technique is. Some catheters are placed in the pre-peritoneal space after laparotomy or open prostatectomy and have reduced postoperative pain, accelerated recovery, and postoperative pulmonary function may have benefitted some, while catheter placement superficial to i.m. fascia was mostly ineffective [1] Further support by a study of open nephrectomy patients showed optimal analgesia with one of the catheters that traversed between abdominal wall muscle layers and the pre-peritoneum. [1]

Page 78: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 9 of 25

A study by Liu et al showed Wound catheters which were placed in various locations (subcutaneous, subfascial, suprafascial,, intraarticular, peripleural, or periosteal), and only two Randomised Control Trials specifically stated that catheters were not placed or activated until surgical closure, as a result no preemptive analgesia was attempted or administered. For a median and mode of 2 days, local anaesthetic was infused . The cardiothoracic discipline had the most Randomised Controlled Trials (n 14), followed by Orthopaedic surgery (n 12), General Surgery (n 11), and gynecology-urology (n 7). [5] Metaanalysis associated multiple potential benefits with use of continuous wound catheters (Table 1). For all groups combined, mean VAS pain scores decreased considerably at rest (10 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 13 to 7 mm) and with activity (22 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 32 to 13mm). Subgroup analysis confirmed decreased pain scores. [5]

Cardiothoracic surgery

Thoracotomy for lung resection was explored by most trials, with the exception of 1 examining thoracotomy for esophagectomy and 3 examining median sternotomy for cardiac surgery (Table 1). Continuous infusion delivery or intermittent bolus delivery were the only methods studied. Placement of Thoracotomy wound catheters were in a variety of described peripleural locations (extrapleural: 2, interpleural: 2, intercostal:3, and intrapleural:4). Two of the cardiac studies done had placed catheters adjacent to the sternum whilst the other had inserted subfascial and subcutaneous (SC) catheters. Most of the Randomised Controlled Trials (12 of 14) reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy for pain scores or opioid use. [5] (11 of 13) Randomised Control Trials showed considerable reduction in pain scores in the immediate postoperative period, and five Randomised Control Trials had seen a reduction until the second postoperative day. Only a few trials reported opioid-related side effects (three of fourteen) or patient satisfaction (one of fourteen). The length of stay was reported by 6 trials, with four out of the six finding some reduction in the group of wound catheters. [5]

Page 79: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 10 of 25

Table 1: Liu et al - Cardiothoracics, Randomized controlled trials [5]

Page 80: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 11 of 25

Table2 : Liu et al [5] Cardiothoracics

Page 81: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 12 of 25

Table3 : Liu et al [5] Abdominal surgery (General surgery)

General surgery

Upper abdominal and vascular surgery, were some of the various surgical procedures used. (PCA) patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus was the choice of continuous delivery methods that were used. Placement of Wound catheters were SC, subfascial, or between muscle and peritoneum. Ten of twelve reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy, be it either a reduction in opioid use or a reduction in pain scores. A substantial reduction in Pain scores in the immediate postoperative period were found in 8 of 11 randomised controlled trials, but only three RCTs reported reduction through second postoperative day . Opioid side effects were reported by four of twelve studies whilst patient satisfaction (2 of 12), or length of hospital stay (3 of 12).

Page 82: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 13 of 25

Obstetrics and Gynaecology

Table 4: Liu et al [5] Obstetrics and gynaecology

Gynecology-Urology surgery

Cesarean section or abdominal hysterectomy were mostly examined. Similarly Patient controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus were used. Wound catheters were placed between muscle fascia and SC tissue (6 of 9) in the majority of cases. More than half (5 of 9) of RCTs had obtained substantial analgesic efficacy, both as reduced pain scores or reduced opioid use. Through the immediate postoperative period pain scores were substantially reduced in (4 of 9) RCTs, with no RCTs reporting a reduction past day one postoperatively. Improvement was found in All RCTs that reported side effects and patient satisfaction. Reported length of stay without any differences: (5 RCTs). [5]

Page 83: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 14 of 25

Orthopaedics

Table 5: Orthopaedic outcomes for different sites [5]

Orthopaedic surgery

Open and arthroscopic procedures on upper and lower extremities including spine surgery were some of the procedures that were studied. Again continuous delivery methods were used: patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus. The various locations used for the wound catheters: intraarticular, periosteal and SC. Majority of RCTs (13 / 16) found significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy both as decreased pain scores or opioid use. Pain scores immediately postoperative were significantly {p0.05} reduced in (12 of 16 RCTs), whilst 11 RCTs found a reduction through days 2 to 5 postoperatively. Only a few trials measured opioid-related side effects, a reduction in PONV in 4 of 6 RCTs, although not one reached individual statistical significance. Considerable increase in patient satisfaction was seen in the 3 RCTs that reported these outcomes. Length of stay measured in only 3 RCTs, and majority of the procedures (9 of 16 RCTs) were ambulatory. [5]

Page 84: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 15 of 25

Table 6: Liu et al [5] Orthopaedics

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review

Consistent analgesic efficacy was demonstrated by continuous wound infusion catheters with regards to reduced pain scores or opioid use for all surgical subspecialities, despite the type of surgical procedure done, exact location of the wound catheter, dose of local anaesthetic or mode of delivery of local anaesthetic, and mixture of analgesic. Opioid-related side effects, patient satisfaction, and length of hospital stay were infrequently assessed for each surgical group Increased patient satisfaction, a reduction in PONV globally, and decreased length of stay. [5] Several mechanisms of analgesia can be provided by direct application of local anaesthetic to wounds. Local anaesthetics would provide a direct blockade of transmission of pain from nociceptive afferents coming from the wound surface. There is mounting proof that local inflammatory response to injury which can be sensitizing to nociceptive receptors and contribute to pain and hyperalgesia, can be inhibited by local anaesthetic,. [5] Some studies of local anaesthetics have observed a reduction in release of inflammatory mediators obtained from neutrophils, a reduction of neutrophil adhesion to the endothelium, reduction in formation of free O2 radicals, and formation of oedema is decreased. By providing a prolonged application of local anaesthesic to wounds by a catheter, it proved to be far more beneficial from that of single injection technique of local anaesthetic in laparoscopic or abdominal operations, as previous systematic reviews demonstrated. [5]

Page 85: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 16 of 25

Table7 : Liu et al [5] orthopaedics

Page 86: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 17 of 25

Physiology

Combination of 3 Factors associated with Postoperative pain: (i) Nerve fibres that are innervating the site of the incision,retraction or suturing generate

impulses; [6] (ii) A number of inflammatory mediators, which become elevated at the surgical site and are

found to sensitize uninjured and injured nerve fibres. These include , prostaglandins, endothelin-1, cytokines and nerve growth factor [6]

(iii) The spinal cord which has pain transmitting circuits become sensitized which then has an

increased response to stimuli that are noxious and can transform their responsiveness to stimuli that is not painful, for example light touch or gentle pressure. [6]

Induction of the firing of impulses in peripheral neurones is precipitated by incisional trauma and of the stretch and compression from retraction, clamping, etc during surgery. Sensitization involving central pathways will be activated by these discharges, although it is probably largely restricted intraoperatively [6] Local inflammation is fostered by Tissue damage, bleeding, and the release of chemoattractants from the injury site. The chemokines or cytokines that are produced by migrating and proliferative immune cells, for example TNF-a, IL-6, and prostaglandin E2 and prostacyclin, provide enhancement to the excitability of neurones by enhancing specific inward currents, especially those that are expressed on the nociceptors[6] Short term pain coming from the transitory discharge of nociceptors is from a result of mild noxious stimulation. Surgery which causes substantial injury, engages pathways involving this positive feedback cascade and therefore leads to a prolongation of hypersensitivity of peripheral tissues. [6] Such prolonged peripheral sensitization results in a sufficient barrage of nociceptive impulses into the spinal cord (and, perhaps, the brain) that the properties of the ‘receiving circuits’ there are sensitized. [6] Spinal cells (so called pain transmitting cells) response to central sensitization accounts for the response to non-noxious stimuli, which are conveyed by Ab-mechanoreceptors and accounts partly for the occurence of postoperative tactile allodynia, which is a common problem. The phenomenon of secondary hyperaesthesia: Where central sensitization is transmitted past the spinal neurones that are usually directly stimulated from the injured tissue, such that stimulation of surrounding areas, surrounding dermatomes, or even those on the contralateral side to the injury site now can cause pain. [6] Perioperatively, local anaesthetics are useful in affecting all three of these factors. During surgical manipulations, wound site local anaesthetic infiltration, and even deep into the surgical cavity, can attenuate the generation and propagation of injury-induced discharges. [6] This action may partly be due to inhibition of the transduction and sensitization steps in nociception, for specific local anaesthetics, examples like bupivacaine and amethocaine, which have been shown to inhibit a transducing channel, TRPV-1, which plays a vital role in the development of hyperalgesia after an insult like inflammation or injury. [6]

Page 87: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 18 of 25

The continuous delivery of local anaesthetics, from either slow-release formulations or catheters placed temporarily, may have an extention of impulse inhibition, days after surgery. Inflammatory and local sensitizing responses can be inhibited by local anaesthetics, which directly suppress some phases of the inflammation, which is, neutrophil priming, and by inhibiting some of the neuronal pathways that are activated by inflammation, which is protein kinase C, and certain G protein-coupled receptors.[6] Providing a persistent postoperative motor block, even of the peripheries (foot / ankle), creates another hurdle for the safety of mobilization in patients, extremely important after ‘ambulatory’ surgery. [6] Local anaesthetic concentration in systemic circulation, can alter postoperative pain profoundly. In the perioperative period , plasma lidocaine concentrations of 2–4 mg ml(8–15 mM), have exhibited a reduction of postoperative pain scores and opiate consumption; Circulatory presence of these drugs for a few hours, can suppress processes that would eventually escalate pain in the days following surgery[6] The plasma concentrations of local anaesthetics can be obtained and maintained by continuous i.v. infusions, at safe or effective rates, and also from the uptake of drugs by the vascular system, which is situated around a peripheral nerve or epidural site, for local / regional anaesthesia. The benefit of systemically circulating agents following the unintentional local anaesthetic administration is an unknown question. [6]

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine

Levobupivacaine and ropivacaine, developed recently as longer-acting local anaesthetics, motivated as an alternative to bupivacaine, after severe toxicity was associated with its use.

Table: Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati†, Guido Fanelli

Page 88: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 19 of 25

Ropivacaine as compared to bupivacaine and levobupivacaine is 40-50% less potent due to its lower lipid solubility. Although it has a reduced potency, it does not imply that it has a lower efficacy than bupivacaine or levobupivacaine. The use of an equipotency ratio of 1.5 : 1 between ropivacaine and the other two drugs results in a significantly similar clinical profile with motor function having been preserved adequately. [7] A study has recently confirmed a better neurotoxic profile of levobupivacaine in comparison to racemic bupivacaine, thus making levobupivacaine safer in clinical practice. [7] CNS signs of intoxication are usually evident before the appearance of cardiovascular toxicity, as the CNS is more susceptible to the actions of local anaesthetics [7] Initial or early signs of CNS toxicity are usually excitatory in nature and include shivering, muscle twitching, and tremors. These are as a result of a preferential block of inhibitory central pathways. As the local anesthetic plasma concentrations increase, there is blockage of the excitatory pathway of CNS toxicity. Following signs of CNS excitation is generalized CNS depression featuring hypoventilation and respiratory arrest, eventually progressing to generalized convulsions. One objective measure of CNS toxicity is the convulsive threshold. [7] In human subjects only mildly toxic doses are given for ethical reasons. Local anaesthetics are administered intravenously deliberately only for research, until the appearance of initial subjective signs of CNS toxicity. [7] Bupivacaine Ropivacaine and levobupivacaine show a dose-dependent prolongation of cardiac conduction. There is an increase in the PR interval and QRS duration on ECG. This is caused by the persistent block of sodium channels into diastole phase, predisposing to re-entrant arrhythmias. [7] The inhibition of cardiac contractility is also proportional to the lipid solubility and nerve-blocking potency of the local anesthetics, in order of rank (from least to most) of the cardiotoxic potency of the three local anaesthetics with ropivacaine < S bupivacaine <racemic bupivacaine <R(+) bupivacaine [7] The comparison of levobupivacaine and ropivacaine regarding the CVS effects after IV injection in healthy volunteers, showed no differences in mean percentage changes from baseline to the end of infusion for stroke index, cardiac index, acceleration index, or for PR interval, QRS duration, QT interval and heart rate. [7]

Page 89: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 20 of 25

Table 9: Summary of surgically placed wound catheters with type of surgery, infusion used and whether they were opioid sparing and of analgesic benefit [10]

Page 90: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 21 of 25

COST FACTOR

Fig 1: Mean time spent by nursing professionals to commence and supervise the analgesic technique. [8]

When calculating all the resources consumed, the Continuous Wound Infusion arm (Euros : 6460) is economically superior when compared with i.v.-PCA (Euros: 7273) and Epidural Anaesthesia (Euros: 7500). [8] The proportion of patients successfully controlled for their postoperative pain management are 77.4%, 53.9%, and 72.9% for Continuous Wound Infusion, i.v.-PCA, and Epidural Anaesthesia, respectively, demonstrating the Continuous Wound Infusion procedure to be both economically and clinically dominant. Continuous Wound Infusion has remained cost saving in 70.4% of cases when compared with Epidural Anaesthesia and in 59.2% of cases when compared with PCA. [8]

Page 91: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 22 of 25

DISCUSSION Optimal management of postoperative pain, a shorter length of hospital stay and a fast turnover after a major surgery have been important concerns among surgeons, anaesthetists and hospital administrators. [9] As epidural puncture is always associated with side effects such as neuraxial hematoma and nerve damages, patients with spinal malformations, infectious puncture site, and anticoagulant therapy are normally not included in the criteria for epidural analgesia use [9] In the case of hepatectomy, opioid administration even at lower doses can induce oxidative stress in the liver, leading to hepatocyte apoptosis and liver enzyme elevation [9] Patient satisfaction, safety and cost-effectiveness are all achieved using local anesthetic wound infusion catheters. In the event of failure or partial effectiveness, rescue analgesia is available and a smaller amount can be given. This is certainly an option for district level hospitals where turnover is high and bed space is at a premium with staff shortages and fewer resources.

Page 92: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 23 of 25

REFERENCES 1. British Journal of Anaesthesia 107 (5): 656–8 (2011) doi:10.1093/bja/aer293

2. Efficacy and safety of paravertebral blocks in breast surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsA. Schnabel, S. U. Reichl , P. Kranke, E. M. Pogatzki-Zahn and P. K. Zahn

3. Effectiveness of continuous wound infusion of 0.5% ropivacaine by On-Q pain relief system for postoperative pain management after open nephrectomy E. Forastiere1, M. Sofra, D. Giannarelli, L. Fabrizi and G. Simone

4. Quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgerySTELA MARI] LJILJA [TEFAN^I] LJILJANA POPOVI] MIROSLAV BANOVI] KATA [AKI]

5. Efficacy of Continuous Wound Catheters Delivering Local Anesthetic for Postoperative Analgesia: A Quantitative and Qualitative Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials Spencer S Liu, MD, Jeffrey M Richman, MD, Richard C Thirlby, MD, FACS, Christopher Lwu,

6. Novel ideas of local anaesthetic actions on various ion channels to ameliorate postoperative pain G. R. Strichartz

7. Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati, Guido Fanelli Department of Anesthesia and Pain Therapy, University Hospital of Parma, Parma (Italy)

8. Cost-effectiveness analysis comparing epidural, patient-controlled intravenous morphine, and continuous wound infiltration for postoperative pain management after open abdominal surgery P. Tilleul1,2, M. Aissou3,4, F. Bocquet1, N. Thiriat1, O. le Grelle1, M. J. Burke5, J. Hutton5,6 and M. Beaussier

9. Efficacy of Postoperative Continuous Wound Infiltration With Local Anesthesia After Open Hepatectomy Yu Xin , Hong et al

10. Peripheral nerve catheters and local anesthetic infiltration in perioperative analgesia Christopher K. Merritt, MD, Associate Professor Edward R. Mariano, MD, MAS, Associate Professor Alan David Kaye,MD, PhD, DABA,DABPM, DABIPP, Professor and Chairman, Jonathan Lissauer, MD, Assistant Professor Kenneth Mancuso, MD, Assistant Professor Amit Prabhakar, MD, MS, Senior Resident Richard D. Urman, MD, MBA, CPE, Assistant Professor of Anesthesia

11. http://www.pajunk.com

12. http://www.qtechnologiesgroup.co.uk/index.php/q-medical/accufuser

Page 93: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

6 March 2015 No. 6

Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters

V. Govender

Moderator: J. Cardoso

School of Clinical Medicine Discipline of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care

Page 94: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 2 of 25

CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 3

HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS ....................................................................... 3

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS .............................................................. 5

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT......................................... 7

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES ..................................................... 8

Cardiothoracic surgery .......................................................................................................... 9

General surgery .................................................................................................................... 12

Obstetrics and Gynaecology ............................................................................................... 13

Gynecology-Urology surgery .............................................................................................. 13

Orthopaedics......................................................................................................................... 14

Orthopaedic surgery ............................................................................................................ 14

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review ............................. 15

Physiology............................................................................................................................. 17

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine ........................................................................................ 18

COST FACTOR ......................................................................................................................... 21

DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................. 22

REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 23

Page 95: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 3 of 25

WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS

INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed catheter to deliver local anaesthetics or analgesics directly into the wound for postoperative pain relief. It can be used as a single technique or as part of a multi-modal analgesic approach Compared with opioid analgesia, continuous regional infusion of local anaesthetic provides better pain control with reduction in opioid use and opioid related side effects By optimizing postoperative analgesia, you increase patient satisfaction and clinically outcomes are improved. Postoperative pain that is uncontrolled can result in significant morbidity and mortality ¹. Categories of Regional Analgesia include:

• Extrapleural (equivalent to intercostal or paravertebral) and interpleural

• Peripheral Nerve Blocks e.g. interscalene, femoral nerve, sciatic nerve

• Intra-articular infusion e.g. post shoulder surgery

• Wound site infusion including use of a disposable elastomeric infusion device HISTORY OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS Continuous infiltration of local anaesthetic into surgical wounds as an analgesic technique was first descibed just over a decade ago, after the development of multi-holed catheters. Together with the widespread availability of infusion pumps, placement of multi-holed flexible catheters inside or alongside surgical wounds enables continuous, evenly spread infiltration of LA over an indefinite period.¹ First described in 1935, it has been experimented with throughout the 20th century and the technique has been found to be safe and effective in several clinical settings. [4] Currently a number of brands and devices are available each carrying its own pros and cons. With evolving technology, delivery of local anaesthetics is becoming more accurate, reliable, safe and effective.

Page 96: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 4 of 25

Figure 1: Possible scope of application [11]

Page 97: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 5 of 25

ADVANTAGES OF WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS � Easy placement of catheter with fewer complications associated with insertion compared

with neuraxial anesthesia and peripheral nerve blocking techniques.¹ � Potentially it offers to reduce postoperative opioid requirements and its associated side

effects and increase postoperative patient mobility, with minimal failure¹ � Pain is relieved by Continuous Local Anaesthetic wound infusion into a surgical wound

and works by direct inhibition of noxious afferent generator potentials from peripheral nerve fibres and a decrease of the local inflammatory response to injury¹

� Local Anaesthetic infusion analgesia can be used as a viable option when epidural

analgesia is contraindicated or physically challenging to do.¹ � Ability to have pain rescue with PCA without overdosing the patient � Cost effectiveness with reduced morbidity and mortality, length of stay, and burden of cost

to patient � Monitoring of patient is made easier � Infusion of local anaesthetic for regional analgesia can be used either alone or in

combination with systemic non-opioid and/or opioid analgesia

Figure 2: Disposable elastomeric ballon pump device [12]

Page 98: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 6 of 25

Figure 3: Special arrangement of catheter perforation for uniform distribution [11]

Figure 4: Integrated stainless steel helical coil, for uniform flow of anaesthetic and prevention of kinking or buckling. Also radiopaque and visible under ultrasound [11]

Page 99: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 7 of 25

DIFFERENT TYPES OF WOUND CATHETERS AND PLACEMENT

Fig 5: Surgical details showing, step by step, the positioning of two multiholed catheters for an open nephrectomy On-Q pain Buster ³

Maric et al did a study to compare the quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgery. The choice of optimal type of wound catheter, few or multi-hole is still controversial. The aim was to evaluate the analgesic potential of these two catheter types. [4]

Page 100: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 8 of 25

EFFECTIVENESS IN DIFFERENT TYPES OF SURGERIES Forty patients undergoing colorectal surgery were randomized to intraoperative placement of two epidural catheters (Group EC) or multi-hole catheter (Group WC) in the wound above the fascia. Patients received 0.25% levobupivacaine (Group WC) with 10 mL bolus through the wound catheter followed by an infusion of 6 mL/h during 48 h, or the same protocol with equally divided levobupivacaine doses through two epidural catheters (Group EC). Simultaneously, patient-controlled analgesia provided intravenous morphine. [4] Pain was evaluated postoperatively with 4-point verbal scale (VRS) for the first 2 h, with Visual Analogue Scale at rest (VAS r), and during coughing (VAS c) every 6 h for the first 48 h. [4] Results and Conclusions: No significant difference in morphine consumption was observed between groups. There were no significant differences in VRS scores between the groups (p=0,756). VAS scores were significantlylower in Group WC in rest (rWC, p=0,007) and coughing (cWC, p=0,018) for the 6 h, 12 h, and 24 h postoperatively. [4] In the period 30–48 h there was no difference between groups. They concluded that levobupivacaine infusion through multi-hole catheter provides better quality of postoperative analgesia compared with two epidural catheters for the first 24 h. [4] The type of catheter plays the most important role. In this context, catheters with multiple holes may provide larger wound spread compared with triple orifice epidural catheters. The choice of catheter, multihole versus few holes is without any documentation for larger wound spread or improved analgesia. [4] The question also lies in the pumps, elastomeric or electronic? In their study they used electronic pumps because of lower price and good clinical experience. Elastomeric pumps are strongly recommended by wound catheter producers but Remerand et al. have published that elastomeric pumps may deliver inappropriate amounts of local anaesthetics with inaccuracy higher than 15% and failure to deflate is also not uncommon [4] Type of catheter plays a more important role in providing better analgesia for the first 24 hours. It seems logical that larger spread of local anaesthetics through more catheter holes provides better analgesia. In the first 24 h pain is more intense than following that critical period. They emphasize that VAS 6–24 h was in the clinically acceptable range between 0–2 in both groups. [4] Wound catheters are more expensive than epidural ones, and usage of disposable elastomeric pumps are more expensive than usage of electronic ones. [4] Local Anaesthetic Catheter Positioning seems to be crucial in determining how effective the technique is. Some catheters are placed in the pre-peritoneal space after laparotomy or open prostatectomy and have reduced postoperative pain, accelerated recovery, and postoperative pulmonary function may have benefitted some, while catheter placement superficial to i.m. fascia was mostly ineffective [1] Further support by a study of open nephrectomy patients showed optimal analgesia with one of the catheters that traversed between abdominal wall muscle layers and the pre-peritoneum. [1]

Page 101: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 9 of 25

A study by Liu et al showed Wound catheters which were placed in various locations (subcutaneous, subfascial, suprafascial,, intraarticular, peripleural, or periosteal), and only two Randomised Control Trials specifically stated that catheters were not placed or activated until surgical closure, as a result no preemptive analgesia was attempted or administered. For a median and mode of 2 days, local anaesthetic was infused . The cardiothoracic discipline had the most Randomised Controlled Trials (n 14), followed by Orthopaedic surgery (n 12), General Surgery (n 11), and gynecology-urology (n 7). [5] Metaanalysis associated multiple potential benefits with use of continuous wound catheters (Table 1). For all groups combined, mean VAS pain scores decreased considerably at rest (10 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 13 to 7 mm) and with activity (22 mm weighted mean difference; 95% CI, 32 to 13mm). Subgroup analysis confirmed decreased pain scores. [5]

Cardiothoracic surgery

Thoracotomy for lung resection was explored by most trials, with the exception of 1 examining thoracotomy for esophagectomy and 3 examining median sternotomy for cardiac surgery (Table 1). Continuous infusion delivery or intermittent bolus delivery were the only methods studied. Placement of Thoracotomy wound catheters were in a variety of described peripleural locations (extrapleural: 2, interpleural: 2, intercostal:3, and intrapleural:4). Two of the cardiac studies done had placed catheters adjacent to the sternum whilst the other had inserted subfascial and subcutaneous (SC) catheters. Most of the Randomised Controlled Trials (12 of 14) reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy for pain scores or opioid use. [5] (11 of 13) Randomised Control Trials showed considerable reduction in pain scores in the immediate postoperative period, and five Randomised Control Trials had seen a reduction until the second postoperative day. Only a few trials reported opioid-related side effects (three of fourteen) or patient satisfaction (one of fourteen). The length of stay was reported by 6 trials, with four out of the six finding some reduction in the group of wound catheters. [5]

Page 102: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 10 of 25

Table 1: Liu et al - Cardiothoracics, Randomized controlled trials [5]

Page 103: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 11 of 25

Table2 : Liu et al [5] Cardiothoracics

Page 104: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 12 of 25

Table3 : Liu et al [5] Abdominal surgery (General surgery)

General surgery

Upper abdominal and vascular surgery, were some of the various surgical procedures used. (PCA) patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus was the choice of continuous delivery methods that were used. Placement of Wound catheters were SC, subfascial, or between muscle and peritoneum. Ten of twelve reported significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy, be it either a reduction in opioid use or a reduction in pain scores. A substantial reduction in Pain scores in the immediate postoperative period were found in 8 of 11 randomised controlled trials, but only three RCTs reported reduction through second postoperative day . Opioid side effects were reported by four of twelve studies whilst patient satisfaction (2 of 12), or length of hospital stay (3 of 12).

Page 105: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 13 of 25

Obstetrics and Gynaecology

Table 4: Liu et al [5] Obstetrics and gynaecology

Gynecology-Urology surgery

Cesarean section or abdominal hysterectomy were mostly examined. Similarly Patient controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus were used. Wound catheters were placed between muscle fascia and SC tissue (6 of 9) in the majority of cases. More than half (5 of 9) of RCTs had obtained substantial analgesic efficacy, both as reduced pain scores or reduced opioid use. Through the immediate postoperative period pain scores were substantially reduced in (4 of 9) RCTs, with no RCTs reporting a reduction past day one postoperatively. Improvement was found in All RCTs that reported side effects and patient satisfaction. Reported length of stay without any differences: (5 RCTs). [5]

Page 106: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 14 of 25

Orthopaedics

Table 5: Orthopaedic outcomes for different sites [5]

Orthopaedic surgery

Open and arthroscopic procedures on upper and lower extremities including spine surgery were some of the procedures that were studied. Again continuous delivery methods were used: patient-controlled analgesia, continuous infusion, and intermittent bolus. The various locations used for the wound catheters: intraarticular, periosteal and SC. Majority of RCTs (13 / 16) found significant (p0.05) analgesic efficacy both as decreased pain scores or opioid use. Pain scores immediately postoperative were significantly {p0.05} reduced in (12 of 16 RCTs), whilst 11 RCTs found a reduction through days 2 to 5 postoperatively. Only a few trials measured opioid-related side effects, a reduction in PONV in 4 of 6 RCTs, although not one reached individual statistical significance. Considerable increase in patient satisfaction was seen in the 3 RCTs that reported these outcomes. Length of stay measured in only 3 RCTs, and majority of the procedures (9 of 16 RCTs) were ambulatory. [5]

Page 107: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 15 of 25

Table 6: Liu et al [5] Orthopaedics

Overall summary of results from quantitative and qualitative review

Consistent analgesic efficacy was demonstrated by continuous wound infusion catheters with regards to reduced pain scores or opioid use for all surgical subspecialities, despite the type of surgical procedure done, exact location of the wound catheter, dose of local anaesthetic or mode of delivery of local anaesthetic, and mixture of analgesic. Opioid-related side effects, patient satisfaction, and length of hospital stay were infrequently assessed for each surgical group Increased patient satisfaction, a reduction in PONV globally, and decreased length of stay. [5] Several mechanisms of analgesia can be provided by direct application of local anaesthetic to wounds. Local anaesthetics would provide a direct blockade of transmission of pain from nociceptive afferents coming from the wound surface. There is mounting proof that local inflammatory response to injury which can be sensitizing to nociceptive receptors and contribute to pain and hyperalgesia, can be inhibited by local anaesthetic,. [5] Some studies of local anaesthetics have observed a reduction in release of inflammatory mediators obtained from neutrophils, a reduction of neutrophil adhesion to the endothelium, reduction in formation of free O2 radicals, and formation of oedema is decreased. By providing a prolonged application of local anaesthesic to wounds by a catheter, it proved to be far more beneficial from that of single injection technique of local anaesthetic in laparoscopic or abdominal operations, as previous systematic reviews demonstrated. [5]

Page 108: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 16 of 25

Table7 : Liu et al [5] orthopaedics

Page 109: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 17 of 25

Physiology

Combination of 3 Factors associated with Postoperative pain: (i) Nerve fibres that are innervating the site of the incision,retraction or suturing generate

impulses; [6] (ii) A number of inflammatory mediators, which become elevated at the surgical site and are

found to sensitize uninjured and injured nerve fibres. These include , prostaglandins, endothelin-1, cytokines and nerve growth factor [6]

(iii) The spinal cord which has pain transmitting circuits become sensitized which then has an

increased response to stimuli that are noxious and can transform their responsiveness to stimuli that is not painful, for example light touch or gentle pressure. [6]

Induction of the firing of impulses in peripheral neurones is precipitated by incisional trauma and of the stretch and compression from retraction, clamping, etc during surgery. Sensitization involving central pathways will be activated by these discharges, although it is probably largely restricted intraoperatively [6] Local inflammation is fostered by Tissue damage, bleeding, and the release of chemoattractants from the injury site. The chemokines or cytokines that are produced by migrating and proliferative immune cells, for example TNF-a, IL-6, and prostaglandin E2 and prostacyclin, provide enhancement to the excitability of neurones by enhancing specific inward currents, especially those that are expressed on the nociceptors[6] Short term pain coming from the transitory discharge of nociceptors is from a result of mild noxious stimulation. Surgery which causes substantial injury, engages pathways involving this positive feedback cascade and therefore leads to a prolongation of hypersensitivity of peripheral tissues. [6] Such prolonged peripheral sensitization results in a sufficient barrage of nociceptive impulses into the spinal cord (and, perhaps, the brain) that the properties of the ‘receiving circuits’ there are sensitized. [6] Spinal cells (so called pain transmitting cells) response to central sensitization accounts for the response to non-noxious stimuli, which are conveyed by Ab-mechanoreceptors and accounts partly for the occurence of postoperative tactile allodynia, which is a common problem. The phenomenon of secondary hyperaesthesia: Where central sensitization is transmitted past the spinal neurones that are usually directly stimulated from the injured tissue, such that stimulation of surrounding areas, surrounding dermatomes, or even those on the contralateral side to the injury site now can cause pain. [6] Perioperatively, local anaesthetics are useful in affecting all three of these factors. During surgical manipulations, wound site local anaesthetic infiltration, and even deep into the surgical cavity, can attenuate the generation and propagation of injury-induced discharges. [6] This action may partly be due to inhibition of the transduction and sensitization steps in nociception, for specific local anaesthetics, examples like bupivacaine and amethocaine, which have been shown to inhibit a transducing channel, TRPV-1, which plays a vital role in the development of hyperalgesia after an insult like inflammation or injury. [6]

Page 110: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 18 of 25

The continuous delivery of local anaesthetics, from either slow-release formulations or catheters placed temporarily, may have an extention of impulse inhibition, days after surgery. Inflammatory and local sensitizing responses can be inhibited by local anaesthetics, which directly suppress some phases of the inflammation, which is, neutrophil priming, and by inhibiting some of the neuronal pathways that are activated by inflammation, which is protein kinase C, and certain G protein-coupled receptors.[6] Providing a persistent postoperative motor block, even of the peripheries (foot / ankle), creates another hurdle for the safety of mobilization in patients, extremely important after ‘ambulatory’ surgery. [6] Local anaesthetic concentration in systemic circulation, can alter postoperative pain profoundly. In the perioperative period , plasma lidocaine concentrations of 2–4 mg ml(8–15 mM), have exhibited a reduction of postoperative pain scores and opiate consumption; Circulatory presence of these drugs for a few hours, can suppress processes that would eventually escalate pain in the days following surgery[6] The plasma concentrations of local anaesthetics can be obtained and maintained by continuous i.v. infusions, at safe or effective rates, and also from the uptake of drugs by the vascular system, which is situated around a peripheral nerve or epidural site, for local / regional anaesthesia. The benefit of systemically circulating agents following the unintentional local anaesthetic administration is an unknown question. [6]

Ropivacaine vs Levobupivacaine

Levobupivacaine and ropivacaine, developed recently as longer-acting local anaesthetics, motivated as an alternative to bupivacaine, after severe toxicity was associated with its use.

Table: Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati†, Guido Fanelli

Page 111: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 19 of 25

Ropivacaine as compared to bupivacaine and levobupivacaine is 40-50% less potent due to its lower lipid solubility. Although it has a reduced potency, it does not imply that it has a lower efficacy than bupivacaine or levobupivacaine. The use of an equipotency ratio of 1.5 : 1 between ropivacaine and the other two drugs results in a significantly similar clinical profile with motor function having been preserved adequately. [7] A study has recently confirmed a better neurotoxic profile of levobupivacaine in comparison to racemic bupivacaine, thus making levobupivacaine safer in clinical practice. [7] CNS signs of intoxication are usually evident before the appearance of cardiovascular toxicity, as the CNS is more susceptible to the actions of local anaesthetics [7] Initial or early signs of CNS toxicity are usually excitatory in nature and include shivering, muscle twitching, and tremors. These are as a result of a preferential block of inhibitory central pathways. As the local anesthetic plasma concentrations increase, there is blockage of the excitatory pathway of CNS toxicity. Following signs of CNS excitation is generalized CNS depression featuring hypoventilation and respiratory arrest, eventually progressing to generalized convulsions. One objective measure of CNS toxicity is the convulsive threshold. [7] In human subjects only mildly toxic doses are given for ethical reasons. Local anaesthetics are administered intravenously deliberately only for research, until the appearance of initial subjective signs of CNS toxicity. [7] Bupivacaine Ropivacaine and levobupivacaine show a dose-dependent prolongation of cardiac conduction. There is an increase in the PR interval and QRS duration on ECG. This is caused by the persistent block of sodium channels into diastole phase, predisposing to re-entrant arrhythmias. [7] The inhibition of cardiac contractility is also proportional to the lipid solubility and nerve-blocking potency of the local anesthetics, in order of rank (from least to most) of the cardiotoxic potency of the three local anaesthetics with ropivacaine < S bupivacaine <racemic bupivacaine <R(+) bupivacaine [7] The comparison of levobupivacaine and ropivacaine regarding the CVS effects after IV injection in healthy volunteers, showed no differences in mean percentage changes from baseline to the end of infusion for stroke index, cardiac index, acceleration index, or for PR interval, QRS duration, QT interval and heart rate. [7]

Page 112: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 20 of 25

Table 9: Summary of surgically placed wound catheters with type of surgery, infusion used and whether they were opioid sparing and of analgesic benefit [10]

Page 113: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 21 of 25

COST FACTOR

Fig 1: Mean time spent by nursing professionals to commence and supervise the analgesic technique. [8]

When calculating all the resources consumed, the Continuous Wound Infusion arm (Euros : 6460) is economically superior when compared with i.v.-PCA (Euros: 7273) and Epidural Anaesthesia (Euros: 7500). [8] The proportion of patients successfully controlled for their postoperative pain management are 77.4%, 53.9%, and 72.9% for Continuous Wound Infusion, i.v.-PCA, and Epidural Anaesthesia, respectively, demonstrating the Continuous Wound Infusion procedure to be both economically and clinically dominant. Continuous Wound Infusion has remained cost saving in 70.4% of cases when compared with Epidural Anaesthesia and in 59.2% of cases when compared with PCA. [8]

Page 114: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 22 of 25

DISCUSSION Optimal management of postoperative pain, a shorter length of hospital stay and a fast turnover after a major surgery have been important concerns among surgeons, anaesthetists and hospital administrators. [9] As epidural puncture is always associated with side effects such as neuraxial hematoma and nerve damages, patients with spinal malformations, infectious puncture site, and anticoagulant therapy are normally not included in the criteria for epidural analgesia use [9] In the case of hepatectomy, opioid administration even at lower doses can induce oxidative stress in the liver, leading to hepatocyte apoptosis and liver enzyme elevation [9] Patient satisfaction, safety and cost-effectiveness are all achieved using local anesthetic wound infusion catheters. In the event of failure or partial effectiveness, rescue analgesia is available and a smaller amount can be given. This is certainly an option for district level hospitals where turnover is high and bed space is at a premium with staff shortages and fewer resources.

Page 115: Local Anaesthetic Wound Infusion Catheters · Page 3 of 25 WOUND INFUSION CATHETERS INTRODUCTION Continuous Wound Infusion: Continuous Wound Infusion is a technique which uses a multi-holed

Page 23 of 25

REFERENCES 1. British Journal of Anaesthesia 107 (5): 656–8 (2011) doi:10.1093/bja/aer293

2. Efficacy and safety of paravertebral blocks in breast surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsA. Schnabel, S. U. Reichl , P. Kranke, E. M. Pogatzki-Zahn and P. K. Zahn

3. Effectiveness of continuous wound infusion of 0.5% ropivacaine by On-Q pain relief system for postoperative pain management after open nephrectomy E. Forastiere1, M. Sofra, D. Giannarelli, L. Fabrizi and G. Simone

4. Quality of analgesia with multi-versus two few-hole catheters in patients after colorectal surgerySTELA MARI] LJILJA [TEFAN^I] LJILJANA POPOVI] MIROSLAV BANOVI] KATA [AKI]

5. Efficacy of Continuous Wound Catheters Delivering Local Anesthetic for Postoperative Analgesia: A Quantitative and Qualitative Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials Spencer S Liu, MD, Jeffrey M Richman, MD, Richard C Thirlby, MD, FACS, Christopher Lwu,

6. Novel ideas of local anaesthetic actions on various ion channels to ameliorate postoperative pain G. R. Strichartz

7. Pharmacology, toxicology, and clinical use of new long acting local anesthetics, ropivacaine and levobupivacaine Stefania Leone, Simone Di Cianni, Andrea Casati, Guido Fanelli Department of Anesthesia and Pain Therapy, University Hospital of Parma, Parma (Italy)

8. Cost-effectiveness analysis comparing epidural, patient-controlled intravenous morphine, and continuous wound infiltration for postoperative pain management after open abdominal surgery P. Tilleul1,2, M. Aissou3,4, F. Bocquet1, N. Thiriat1, O. le Grelle1, M. J. Burke5, J. Hutton5,6 and M. Beaussier

9. Efficacy of Postoperative Continuous Wound Infiltration With Local Anesthesia After Open Hepatectomy Yu Xin , Hong et al

10. Peripheral nerve catheters and local anesthetic infiltration in perioperative analgesia Christopher K. Merritt, MD, Associate Professor Edward R. Mariano, MD, MAS, Associate Professor Alan David Kaye,MD, PhD, DABA,DABPM, DABIPP, Professor and Chairman, Jonathan Lissauer, MD, Assistant Professor Kenneth Mancuso, MD, Assistant Professor Amit Prabhakar, MD, MS, Senior Resident Richard D. Urman, MD, MBA, CPE, Assistant Professor of Anesthesia

11. http://www.pajunk.com

12. http://www.qtechnologiesgroup.co.uk/index.php/q-medical/accufuser