SHOES 2014

The NHS as investment opportunity

Dr Lucy ReynoldsFaculty of Public Health Policy LSHTM

The Health and Social Care Act 2012reads as a patchwork of corporate lawyer wish lists from the following commercial interest groups

Insurance industryOther financial services and consultanciesCompetition lawyersPrivate equity investors (as providers of capital)US healthcare corporationsConstruction industryDatabase industryBig PharmaOutsourcers

Beneficiaries of HASCA

Construction industry bull PropCo created in clauses 300-302 and Schedule 22

QIPP 2009 report by McKinsey recommended sale of 65 of NHS land and buildings

Propco Quotes from trade journal Construction News Spring 2012

25 January

Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has announced details of the government-owned firm that will take over ownership and management of much of the NHS estate

23 February

Attempts to generate savings from the healthcare estate have been frustrated by legislative gridlock caused by the slow passage of the Health amp Social Care Bill through Parliament

17 May

More than 400 parcels of NHS land totalling more than 800 hectares identified as potentially ripe for development

13 June

The value of the portfolio to be taken on by the new NHS Property Services company is thought to be as high as pound5 billion more than double earlier estimates

Beneficiaries of HASCA data trawlers

Database industry eg Dr Foster

Big Pharma

Other parties interested in commercial or other exploitation of medical data

All research late amendment This added a duty on every level of the NHS system to export data to unspecified parties without compensation or profit share and with no consent system or confidentiality protection involved

UK health department criticised for secret deal

Roger Dobson BMJ Feb 10 2007 334(7588) 281

A pound12m (euro18m $24m) joint venture involving the DH and Dr Foster a private company specialising in health information was not subject to formal competitive tendering and could be open to legal challenge a report from the NAO said this week

Edward Leigh chairman of the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts said the department may have paid some pound4m more than its share was worth

The Health and Social Care Act 2012reads as a patchwork of corporate lawyer wish lists from the following commercial interest groups

Insurance industryOther financial services and consultanciesCompetition lawyersPrivate equity investors (as providers of capital)US healthcare corporationsConstruction industryDatabase industryBig PharmaOutsourcers

Beneficiaries of HASCA

Construction industry bull PropCo created in clauses 300-302 and Schedule 22

QIPP 2009 report by McKinsey recommended sale of 65 of NHS land and buildings

Propco Quotes from trade journal Construction News Spring 2012

25 January

Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has announced details of the government-owned firm that will take over ownership and management of much of the NHS estate

23 February

Attempts to generate savings from the healthcare estate have been frustrated by legislative gridlock caused by the slow passage of the Health amp Social Care Bill through Parliament

17 May

More than 400 parcels of NHS land totalling more than 800 hectares identified as potentially ripe for development

13 June

The value of the portfolio to be taken on by the new NHS Property Services company is thought to be as high as pound5 billion more than double earlier estimates

Beneficiaries of HASCA data trawlers

Database industry eg Dr Foster

Big Pharma

Other parties interested in commercial or other exploitation of medical data

All research late amendment This added a duty on every level of the NHS system to export data to unspecified parties without compensation or profit share and with no consent system or confidentiality protection involved

UK health department criticised for secret deal

Roger Dobson BMJ Feb 10 2007 334(7588) 281

A pound12m (euro18m $24m) joint venture involving the DH and Dr Foster a private company specialising in health information was not subject to formal competitive tendering and could be open to legal challenge a report from the NAO said this week

Edward Leigh chairman of the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts said the department may have paid some pound4m more than its share was worth

Beneficiaries of HASCA

Construction industry bull PropCo created in clauses 300-302 and Schedule 22

QIPP 2009 report by McKinsey recommended sale of 65 of NHS land and buildings

Propco Quotes from trade journal Construction News Spring 2012

25 January

Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has announced details of the government-owned firm that will take over ownership and management of much of the NHS estate

23 February

Attempts to generate savings from the healthcare estate have been frustrated by legislative gridlock caused by the slow passage of the Health amp Social Care Bill through Parliament

17 May

More than 400 parcels of NHS land totalling more than 800 hectares identified as potentially ripe for development

13 June

The value of the portfolio to be taken on by the new NHS Property Services company is thought to be as high as pound5 billion more than double earlier estimates

Beneficiaries of HASCA data trawlers

Database industry eg Dr Foster

Big Pharma

Other parties interested in commercial or other exploitation of medical data

All research late amendment This added a duty on every level of the NHS system to export data to unspecified parties without compensation or profit share and with no consent system or confidentiality protection involved

UK health department criticised for secret deal

Roger Dobson BMJ Feb 10 2007 334(7588) 281

A pound12m (euro18m $24m) joint venture involving the DH and Dr Foster a private company specialising in health information was not subject to formal competitive tendering and could be open to legal challenge a report from the NAO said this week

Edward Leigh chairman of the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts said the department may have paid some pound4m more than its share was worth

Propco Quotes from trade journal Construction News Spring 2012

25 January

Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has announced details of the government-owned firm that will take over ownership and management of much of the NHS estate

23 February

Attempts to generate savings from the healthcare estate have been frustrated by legislative gridlock caused by the slow passage of the Health amp Social Care Bill through Parliament

17 May

More than 400 parcels of NHS land totalling more than 800 hectares identified as potentially ripe for development

13 June

The value of the portfolio to be taken on by the new NHS Property Services company is thought to be as high as pound5 billion more than double earlier estimates

Beneficiaries of HASCA data trawlers

Database industry eg Dr Foster

Big Pharma

Other parties interested in commercial or other exploitation of medical data

All research late amendment This added a duty on every level of the NHS system to export data to unspecified parties without compensation or profit share and with no consent system or confidentiality protection involved

UK health department criticised for secret deal

Roger Dobson BMJ Feb 10 2007 334(7588) 281

A pound12m (euro18m $24m) joint venture involving the DH and Dr Foster a private company specialising in health information was not subject to formal competitive tendering and could be open to legal challenge a report from the NAO said this week

Edward Leigh chairman of the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts said the department may have paid some pound4m more than its share was worth

Beneficiaries of HASCA data trawlers

Database industry eg Dr Foster

Big Pharma

Other parties interested in commercial or other exploitation of medical data

All research late amendment This added a duty on every level of the NHS system to export data to unspecified parties without compensation or profit share and with no consent system or confidentiality protection involved

UK health department criticised for secret deal

Roger Dobson BMJ Feb 10 2007 334(7588) 281

A pound12m (euro18m $24m) joint venture involving the DH and Dr Foster a private company specialising in health information was not subject to formal competitive tendering and could be open to legal challenge a report from the NAO said this week

Edward Leigh chairman of the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts said the department may have paid some pound4m more than its share was worth

UK health department criticised for secret deal

Roger Dobson BMJ Feb 10 2007 334(7588) 281

A pound12m (euro18m $24m) joint venture involving the DH and Dr Foster a private company specialising in health information was not subject to formal competitive tendering and could be open to legal challenge a report from the NAO said this week

Edward Leigh chairman of the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts said the department may have paid some pound4m more than its share was worth

Beneficiaries of HASCA insurers

Insurance industry

CCGs = HMUs created to enable insurance industry takeover

Clauses 1 amp 4 (govt hand-washing and autonomy)

Research late amendment for data trawl of past GP records

hospital records already soldgifted to them ongoing GP records to be available to them via insurersrsquo imminent purchasefunding of Commissioning Support Units referrals cannot be processed without these details

Thatcher NHS Plan conclusion (ASI lsquo88)

We could meet the health needs of everyone without the need for the government itself to provide health services through the NHS simply by requiring that all individuals have medical insurance cover for a range of services that are deemed to be the acceptable minimum standard of health care

Of course those who wished to have a superior standard of service could take out a more extensive policy there would be no objection to individuals insuring themselves for additional or more costly services as long as the basic requirements were met

Cont

Thatcher NHS Plan conclusion (ASI lsquo88)

Each individual would receive from the state a health voucher The voucher can be used towards the purchase of private health insurance or exchanged for treatment within the public sector health system

The actual provision of health care services in such a system of universal private medical insurance would be undertaken by private sector doctors and hospitals and the nationalized health sector in the shape of the National Health Service would lose its reason for existence

UnitedHealth Fox Buys Into Hen House

Beneficiaries of HASCA middlemen amp investors

Other financial services and consultancies bull whole Act ndash they will be middlemen for all the

private sector deals and most of the public sector reactions

Investors banks and private equitybull Whole Act all of the replacements for the NHS will

need working capital funding and guarantees

Governmentrsquos on the side of investors

In 2000 Gordon Brown reportedly marketed PFI schemes by inviting financiers to invest in

core services which the government is statutorily bound to provide and for which

demand is virtually insatiable

Your revenue stream is ultimately backed by Government Where else can you get a

business opportunity like thatldquo

BBC Radio 4 6 July 2004

Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen

Competition lawyers

bull s75+ its competition law regs

bull Monitor cases amp court cases

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Thatcher NHS Plan conclusion (ASI lsquo88)

We could meet the health needs of everyone without the need for the government itself to provide health services through the NHS simply by requiring that all individuals have medical insurance cover for a range of services that are deemed to be the acceptable minimum standard of health care

Of course those who wished to have a superior standard of service could take out a more extensive policy there would be no objection to individuals insuring themselves for additional or more costly services as long as the basic requirements were met

Cont

Thatcher NHS Plan conclusion (ASI lsquo88)

Each individual would receive from the state a health voucher The voucher can be used towards the purchase of private health insurance or exchanged for treatment within the public sector health system

The actual provision of health care services in such a system of universal private medical insurance would be undertaken by private sector doctors and hospitals and the nationalized health sector in the shape of the National Health Service would lose its reason for existence

UnitedHealth Fox Buys Into Hen House

Beneficiaries of HASCA middlemen amp investors

Other financial services and consultancies bull whole Act ndash they will be middlemen for all the

private sector deals and most of the public sector reactions

Investors banks and private equitybull Whole Act all of the replacements for the NHS will

need working capital funding and guarantees

Governmentrsquos on the side of investors

In 2000 Gordon Brown reportedly marketed PFI schemes by inviting financiers to invest in

core services which the government is statutorily bound to provide and for which

demand is virtually insatiable

Your revenue stream is ultimately backed by Government Where else can you get a

business opportunity like thatldquo

BBC Radio 4 6 July 2004

Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen

Competition lawyers

bull s75+ its competition law regs

bull Monitor cases amp court cases

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Thatcher NHS Plan conclusion (ASI lsquo88)

Each individual would receive from the state a health voucher The voucher can be used towards the purchase of private health insurance or exchanged for treatment within the public sector health system

The actual provision of health care services in such a system of universal private medical insurance would be undertaken by private sector doctors and hospitals and the nationalized health sector in the shape of the National Health Service would lose its reason for existence

UnitedHealth Fox Buys Into Hen House

Beneficiaries of HASCA middlemen amp investors

Other financial services and consultancies bull whole Act ndash they will be middlemen for all the

private sector deals and most of the public sector reactions

Investors banks and private equitybull Whole Act all of the replacements for the NHS will

need working capital funding and guarantees

Governmentrsquos on the side of investors

In 2000 Gordon Brown reportedly marketed PFI schemes by inviting financiers to invest in

core services which the government is statutorily bound to provide and for which

demand is virtually insatiable

Your revenue stream is ultimately backed by Government Where else can you get a

business opportunity like thatldquo

BBC Radio 4 6 July 2004

Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen

Competition lawyers

bull s75+ its competition law regs

bull Monitor cases amp court cases

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

UnitedHealth Fox Buys Into Hen House

Beneficiaries of HASCA middlemen amp investors

Other financial services and consultancies bull whole Act ndash they will be middlemen for all the

private sector deals and most of the public sector reactions

Investors banks and private equitybull Whole Act all of the replacements for the NHS will

need working capital funding and guarantees

Governmentrsquos on the side of investors

In 2000 Gordon Brown reportedly marketed PFI schemes by inviting financiers to invest in

core services which the government is statutorily bound to provide and for which

demand is virtually insatiable

Your revenue stream is ultimately backed by Government Where else can you get a

business opportunity like thatldquo

BBC Radio 4 6 July 2004

Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen

Competition lawyers

bull s75+ its competition law regs

bull Monitor cases amp court cases

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Beneficiaries of HASCA middlemen amp investors

Other financial services and consultancies bull whole Act ndash they will be middlemen for all the

private sector deals and most of the public sector reactions

Investors banks and private equitybull Whole Act all of the replacements for the NHS will

need working capital funding and guarantees

Governmentrsquos on the side of investors

In 2000 Gordon Brown reportedly marketed PFI schemes by inviting financiers to invest in

core services which the government is statutorily bound to provide and for which

demand is virtually insatiable

Your revenue stream is ultimately backed by Government Where else can you get a

business opportunity like thatldquo

BBC Radio 4 6 July 2004

Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen

Competition lawyers

bull s75+ its competition law regs

bull Monitor cases amp court cases

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Governmentrsquos on the side of investors

In 2000 Gordon Brown reportedly marketed PFI schemes by inviting financiers to invest in

core services which the government is statutorily bound to provide and for which

demand is virtually insatiable

Your revenue stream is ultimately backed by Government Where else can you get a

business opportunity like thatldquo

BBC Radio 4 6 July 2004

Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen

Competition lawyers

bull s75+ its competition law regs

bull Monitor cases amp court cases

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen

Competition lawyers

bull s75+ its competition law regs

bull Monitor cases amp court cases

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Republican Main Street Partnership 8000Conservatives Organized to Advance Tmrw (Affi liate Dan Coats (R-Ind)) 750McConnell Victory Kentucky 750Reclaim America PAC (Affi liate Marco Rubio (R-Fla)) 750Heartland Values PAC (Affi liate John Thune (R-SD)) 750Bluegrass Cmte (Affi liate Mitch McConnell (R-Ky)) 750Rhode Island Hope PAC (Affi liate Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) 7500Every Republican is Crucial PAC (Affi liate Eric Cantor (R-Va)) 7000New Millennium PAC (Affi liate Robert Menendez (D-NJ)) 6000Senate Conservatives Fund (Affi liate Jim DeMint (R-SC)) 500North Carolina Republican Executive Cmte 500Kelly PAC (Affi liate Kelly Ayotte (R-NH)) 500Moving America Forward (Affi liate Bill Nelson (D-Fla)) 500Nebraska Leadership PAC (Affi liate Ben Nelson (D-Neb)) 5000Impact (Schumer) (Affi liate Charles E Schumer (D-NY)) 5000Campaign for Our Country (Affi liate John Kerry (D-Mass)) 5000Committee to Strengthen America (Affi liate Robert E Andrews (D-NJ)) 5000Democratic Party of Nevada 5000Narragansett Bay PAC (Affi liate Jack Reed (D-RI)) 5000Rock Island Cnty Democratic Central Cmte 5000Cantwell Victory 2012 5000OSay Can You See Pac 5000Green Mountain PAC (Affi liate Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)) 4500National Republican Congressional Cmte 30000Democratic Senatorial Campaign Cmte 30000National Republican Senatorial Cmte 30000Republican National Cmte 30000Democratic Congressional Campaign Cmte 30000Citizens for Prosperity in America Today (Affi liate Pat Toomey (R-Pa)) 3500Cantor Joint Fundraising Cmte 2500Rhode IslandOhio Victory Fund 2500Common Sense Colorado (Affi liate Michael F Bennet (D-Colo)) 2500Democratic State Central CmteMaryland 2500TFP-FOJB Cmte 2500Freedom amp Security PAC (Affi liate John Kline (R-Minn)) 2500Victory Now PAC (Affi liate Chris Van Hollen (D-Md)) 2000Pioneer PAC (Rob Bishop) (Affi liate Rob Bishop (R-Utah)) 2000Unknown (Filer Error) 2000Defend America PAC (Affi liate Richard C Shelby (R-Ala)) 2000Real Estate Roundtable 10000Together PAC 10000Great Land PAC (Affi liate Mark Begich (D-Alaska)) 10000International Franchise Assn 10000Country First PAC (Affi liate John McCain (R-Ariz)) 1750Unknown (Filer Error) 1500Freedom Fund (Affi liate Mike Crapo (R-Idaho)) 1500Rock City PAC (Affi liate Bob Corker (R-Tenn)) 1500Louisiana Reform PAC (Affi liate David Vitter (R-La)) 1500Boehner for Speaker Cmte 1500Road to Freedom PAC (Affi liate Ed Royce (R-Calif)) 1500OrrinPAC (Affi liate Orrin G Hatch (R-Utah)) 1250Prairie PAC (Affi liate Dick Durbin (D-Ill)) 1000A New Direction PAC (Affi liate Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)) 1000Democratic Party of Virginia 1000San Diego County Republican Central Cmte 1000Big Red PAC (Affi liate Lee Terry (R-Neb)) 1000TRUST PAC (Affi liate Fred Upton (R-Mich)) 1000Reinventing a New Direction (Affi liate Rand Paul (R-Ky)) 1000Tallatchee Creek Inc (Affi liate Jeff Sessions (R-Ala)) 1000

DLA Piper US political party donations 2012 httpwwwopensecretsorgpacspac2pacphpcycle=2012ampcmte=C00151340

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE

ALEC drafts model legislationrdquo that then often becomes law

ALEC claims one third of state legislators as members 2400 across both political parties It lobbies

ldquoto advance the Jeffersonian Principles of free markets limited government federalism and individual libertyldquo

Transnational-funded ALECrsquos 2002 budget was $5025388

ldquoBy paying to be members corporations are allowed the opportunity to sit down at the table and discuss the issues that they have an interest inrdquo

Dennis Bartlett ALEC 1997

ALECrsquos power can only be understood in the context of the well coordinated network of right wing think tanks

Indeed it is ALECrsquos corporate-funded hub which connects them

Public v private case study in child death rates

What to do to help the NHS nowWhy donrsquot we

tackle the corruption causing its loss

• SHOES 2014 The NHS as investment opportunity
• The Health and Social Care Act 2012
• Beneficiaries of HASCA
• Propco Quotes from trade journal Construction News Spring 2012
• Beneficiaries of HASCA data trawlers
• UK health department criticised for secret deal
• Beneficiaries of HASCA insurers
• Thatcher NHS Plan conclusion (ASI lsquo88)
• Slide 9
• UnitedHealth Fox Buys Into Hen House
• Beneficiaries of HASCA middlemen amp investors
• Slide 12
• Governmentrsquos on the side of investors
• Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen
• Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers
• Slide 16
• Slide 18
• Slide 19
• American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE
• Slide 21
• Slide 22
• Public v private case study in child death rates
• Slide 24
• What to do to help the NHS now

What to do to help the NHS nowWhy donrsquot we

tackle the corruption causing its loss

• SHOES 2014 The NHS as investment opportunity
• The Health and Social Care Act 2012
• Beneficiaries of HASCA
• Propco Quotes from trade journal Construction News Spring 2012
• Beneficiaries of HASCA data trawlers
• UK health department criticised for secret deal
• Beneficiaries of HASCA insurers
• Thatcher NHS Plan conclusion (ASI lsquo88)
• Slide 9
• UnitedHealth Fox Buys Into Hen House
• Beneficiaries of HASCA middlemen amp investors
• Slide 12
• Governmentrsquos on the side of investors
• Beneficiaries of HASCA more middlemen
• Beneficiaries of HASCA lobbyists amp lawyers
• Slide 16
• Slide 18
• Slide 19
• American Legislative Exchange Council POWERBASE
• Slide 21
• Slide 22
• Public v private case study in child death rates
• Slide 24
• What to do to help the NHS now