lyari expressway rehabilitation project.pptx

8/14/2019 Lyari expressway rehabilitation project.pptx

1/32

16th MCMC

Syndicate B

LYARI EXPRESSWAYRESETTLEMENT PROJECT

Sponsor A S! A"#ad I$%a& S"a"Date: 4th November, 2013

NATIONAL INSTITUTE OFMANAGEMENT, KA A!"I


2/32

Gro#$ !om$o%&t&o'

Sr'( Na#e

1( A&)a* A'+ar!hoha'

2( M#a*am A &Marr&

3( M( Kamra' Kha'

4( M%( Shahee'-( .#ba&r S&//& #e( M#hamma/

Am&r

Sr'( Na#e

( M( Fa&%a Kho har

( Dr( Na)eeb U ah5( a'a 6a ar A &

10( Sam "a

11( Ah%a' Kha' 7a%&r

2


3/32

e #&reme't%

)' isc*ss t"e c*rrent stat*s o+ LERP andcritica&&y e,a&*ate t"e process at p&annin- andi#p&e#entation sta-e' .o/ +ar it #et its

o%0ecti,es and co#p&ied /it" Nationa&Resett&e#ent Po&icy'

1' Identi+y t"e resett&e#ent areas /it"pec*&iarities and ana&y2e t"e i#pact o+ LERP onsocio3econo#ic conditions o+ t"e resett&ed

pop*&ation /it" specia& re+erence toco#pensation po&icy and re&ated iss*es /"et"ert"ose "a,e %een addressed4


4/32

e #&reme't% 8(( 9o't/(

5' Identi+y and e,a&*ate #ain iss*es6 +actors /"ic" ca*sin-de&ay in t"e co#p&etion o+ t"is pro0ect and s*--est t"e /ay+or/ard +or nonco#p&iance o+ t"e pro0ect so +ar7 and "o/%est t"e pro0ect co*&d %e i#p&e#ented s#oot"&y to addresst"e concerns o+ t"e sta8e"o&ders6 sett&ers4


5/32

Pri#arySo*rces

Mr' Ras"eedA"#ed Me#on

9enera&Mana-er Nort"

N.A

Tasnee#A"#ed

Siddi$*e 9*estSpea8er

Secondary

So*rces

Artic&es andne/s papers

Case st*dyMateria& o+ NIM

Metho/o o ;


6/32

LERP Lyari E:press/ay Resett&e#ent Pro0ect

NRP Nationa& Resett&e#ent Po&icy

TC; T"e Citi2en


7/32

Introd*ction

C*rrent Stat*so+ LERP

Critica&E,a&*ation o+p&annin- and

i#p&e#entation

Resett&e#entareas

I#pact ana&ysiso+ LERP

Main +actorsca*sin- de&ay

Way ;or/ard

S9heme o< =re%e'tat&o'


8/32

isc*ss t"e c*rrent stat*s o+ LERP andcritica&&y e,a&*ate t"e process at p&annin-and i#p&e#entation sta-e' .o/ +ar it #etits o%0ecti,es and co#p&ied /it" Nationa&

Resett&e#ent Po&icy'

e #&reme't > 1


9/32

I'tro/#9t&o'


10/32

Current Status of LERP


11/32

)' No +*nds "a,e %een re&eased since 1>>?3>@'

e,' /or8s stopped +or non c&earance o+ &ia%i&ities'

Sc"oo&in- discontin*ed +or >> st*dents d*e to non3pay#ent o+sa&aries to teac"ers =ESC iss*ed disconnection notices No sa&ary paid to Pro0ect sta++ +or t"e &ast ) year

1' Re$*ests to 9o,t +or pro,ision o+ +*nds*nresponded'

5' More t"an >> a++ectees "a,e +i&ed Petitions &'S&'/h "! a a&'%t Fe/era , =rov&'9&a ? !DGK


12/32

)' Nationa& .i-"/ay A*t"ority N.AD e#arcation o+ ROWF to assess re$*ired area +or

constr*ction o+ LEW'

1' Re,en*e epart#ent o+ C 9= S*r,ey &ists o+ a++ected +a#i&ies

5' Pro0ect irectorate o+ LERP P&annin- G e#arcation Ci,ic *ti&ities G A#enities Mana-in- Ser,ices Land e,e&op#ent S"i+tin- ;aci&itation Carin- Resett&e#ent

LERP process at Planning Stage


13/32

Survey and Compensation1st Stage: Initial Surveys by the Revenue Dept. of CDGK

2nd Stage: Verification of Survey Lists by Team of Revenue

Dept in collaboration with public representatives.rd Stage: Re verification by the Committee comprisin! oflar!er !roup of Revenue officers " public representatives.

!th Stage: #ayment of cash compensation an$ allotment of %&s' y$s plot to the affectees as per verifie$ survey lists of RevenueDepartment( CDGK in open )atchery by the L*R#.

"th Stage: #ayment of compensation of lease$ property un$erthe law by the Revenue Department CDGK.

LERP process at #mplementation Stage


14/32

$ame of Resettlement site %rea&%cres'

PlannedPlots

&() S* yrd'

+a,-s.ay Scheme/!2 Sectors/ 60 1) 21( " (!

3aiser 3o,n Scheme/!" Sectors/ "0 60 6/% part of Sector ")0"1

664 161"

5aldia 3o,nship Scheme/2 Sector/215 1!! 2 2!

Lastly added areas at 3aiser 3o,n foraccommodating revised ))11/ family units &underdevelopment'

& Less' 3otal

2)"12 !

-&2)'121!

""2))"(1

/&"")')) 1

Land %llocations Planned Plots

LERP process at #mplementation Stage 7 cont


15/32

Revision of Survey Report : RE%S8$S+ffecte$ family units from ,-(%,, /ri!inal #C,0 to 1-(-,2 Revise$#C,0 an$ 3&(&,, Re revise$ #C,0 were revise$ $ue to 4

19 3he decision of +igh Court to count each Level of Multi/storied5uilding as a Separate nit9

29 ;ifference in #nitial instead of treating them as Single nit9

9 Changes in the R8? of LE? .y the $9+9% 9

!9 Commercial units not compensated9 ?hile Religious 5uildingsRelocated &"6/Mos*ues0 6/#mam 5argahs /Churchs 1/ 3emple'

LERP process at #mplementation Stage 7 cont


16/32

ISSHESC&earance o+ re#ainin- '5 8# ROW o+ LEW G

&ia%i&ities'C&earance o+ t"e Co#pensation Pac8a-e'Per#ission +ro# t"e 9o,t to "and o,er roads7

sanitation7 /ater s*pp&y7 se/era-e7 sc"oo&s etcto re&e,ant epts'

Per#ission o+ t"e 9o,t to prepare Stat*sPositionF G Co#p&etion ReportF so t"at pro0ect

can %e /ind *p'

LERP has $ot completely met its 8.@ectives


17/32

A,oid or #ini#i2e ad,erse i#pactsin a pro0ect /"ere,er possi%&e7 and/"ere ad,erse i#pacts cannot %ea,oided7 t"e #iti-ation #eas*res Gresett&e#ent acti,ities s"o*&d %econcei,ed and e:ec*ted asde,e&op#ent pro-ra#s and t"ea++ected persons %e pro,idedopport*nity to s"are t"e pro0ect%ene+its'

Pro0ect A++ected Persons %epro,ided /it" s*++icientco#pensation G assistance +or &ostassets7 t"at /i&& assist t"e# toi#pro,e or at &east restore t"eir&i,in- standards7 inco#e earnin- orprod*ction capacity to t"e pre3pro0ect &e,e&s'So#e o+ t"ere&e,ant Po&icy

O%0ecti,es

$ational Resettlement Policy &March 2))2'


18/32

No e++orts /ere #ade to #ini#i2e t"e socia&i#pacts'T"e resett&e#ents "a,e %een esta%&is"ed +ar3a/ay +ro# t"e sett&ers< /or8p&aces' So

additiona& cost o+ transportation "as to %einc*rred %y t"e a++ectees'

T"ose /"o /ere "a,in- s#a&& %*siness in t"eire,icted p&aces /ere depri,ed o+ t"eir

&i,e&i"ood'Rs >7>>> /as not a S*++icientF co#pensationa#o*nt +or t"e constr*ction o+ "o*se on a ?>s$ yards p&ot'

%$%LAS#SBiolation of $ational Resettlement Policy


19/32

Identi+y t"e resett&e#ent areas /it"pec*&iarities and ana&y2e t"e i#pact o+ LERP

on socio3econo#ic conditions o+ t"e resett&edpop*&ation /it" specia& re+erence to

co#pensation po&icy and re&ated iss*es

/"et"er t"ose "a,e %een addressed4

e #&reme't > 2


20/32

o/nstrea# o+Lyari ri,er a&&otted

.a/8s%ay

Hpstrea# o+ Lyariri,er a&&ottedTaiser to/n

Midd&e area peop&ea&&otted Ba&dia

to/n

e%ett eme't area%


21/32

"a+ %ba; re%ett eme't

Landarea

P&ots Occ*pancy

No o+Sc"oo&s6co&&e-es

Mos$*es

Par8s Co##ercia&Area

.ospita&s

21A9re%

-,434 -100 1 0 21 11 31


22/32

Ta&%er To+' re%ett eme't

Landarea

P&ots Occ*pancy

No o+Sc"oo&s6co&&e-es

Mos$*es

Par8s Co##ercia&Area

.ospita&s

A9re%21,000 1-,000 41 21 3 - 5


23/32

a /&a To+' re%ett eme't

Landarea

P&ots No o+Sc"oo&s6co&&e-es

Mos$*es

Par8s Co##ercia& Area

.ospita&s

4- A9re% 2,524 0 04 0 21 02


24/32

Ed*cationa& opport*nities /ere &i#ited

.ea&t" +aci&ities /ere ins*++icient

Co##*nity depended on +is"in- and -ar%a-eco&&ectionWo#en /ere /or8in- in "o*ses as #aids ande#%roidery /or8

Li,in- conditions /ere *n"y-ienic

No proper /aste disposa&

.ot %ed o+ cri#es &i8e dr*- a%*se6tra+ic8in-

L&


25/32

Cas" co#pensation Rs >7>>>6

?> S$*are yards p&ot

S*r,ey cond*cted %y Re,en*e eptt

No care ta8en o+ disa%&ed7 /o#en and e&der&ypersons

Ba&dia To/n co*&d not attract resett&es

Taiser To/n occ*pancy is a%o*t >

Sa &e't Feat#re% o7>>> is ins*++icient +or constr*ction o+ a "o*se Resett&e#ent sites too +ar +ro# /or8p&aces o+ sett&ers

ca*sin- ,ario*s di++ic*&ties'

.i-" transport costs7 increased tra,e&&in- ti#e and &ac8o+ p*%&ic transport

Socia& depri,ation Peop&e "ad a++i&iation /it" t"eir "o#es /"ere t"ey

/ere &i,in- +ro# a-es'

Socia& press*re o+ &osin- &i,e&i"ood7 0o%s7 sc"oo&s o+c"i&dren etc' Peop&e resist to c"an-e P"ysio&o-ica& a++ectD

Po&itica& inter+erence 6 Land #a+ia It "as %een a&&e-ed t"at Land Ma+ia and Po&itica&

e&e#ents are a&so in,o&,ed

Ma&' I%%#e%


30/32

Ta8in- a&& t"e sta8e"o&ders on %oard

I##ediate re&ease o++*nds Ens*re Pro,ision o+ %asic

"ea&t" and ed*cation+aci&ities

Constr*ct "o*ses

instead o+ -i,in- #oney

Con+idence %*i&din-

%y

6a; For+ar/30


31/32

Brin-in-

,ario*s N9Osinto t"eresett&e#ent

pro0ect

Or-ani2ations &i8e TC;ed*cationD7 OPP"o*sin- andin+rastr*ct*reD7 Ed"i"ea&t"D can "e&pde,e&op ,ario*s sectors

Pro,isiono+

e#p&oy#ent

opport*nities

Pro,isiono+ p*%&ictransport

6a; For+ar/31


32/32

Tha' 7o#Fee/ba9 B C?A

lyari expressway rehabilitation project.pptx

Documents