m so sland zz residents perspective o 258
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
1/53
The Social Brain:The Social Brain:
Perspective of aPerspective of aPsychiatrist-in-Psychiatrist-in-
TrainingTrainingMorton SoslandMorton Sosland
Research CommitteeResearch Committee
Group for the Advancement of Psychiatry (GAP)Group for the Advancement of Psychiatry (GAP)Other committee members: Russell Gardner, Beverly Sutton, JohnOther committee members: Russell Gardner, Beverly Sutton, John
Beahrs, Jacob Kerbeshian, Fred Wamboldt, Alan Swann, JohanBeahrs, Jacob Kerbeshian, Fred Wamboldt, Alan Swann, JohanVerhulst, Michael Schwartz, Carlo Carandang, Doug Kramer, JohnVerhulst, Michael Schwartz, Carlo Carandang, Doug Kramer, John
LooneyLooney
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
2/53
Copyright SLACK IncorporatedCopyright SLACK Incorporated
Used with PermissionUsed with Permission
Reprint web siteReprint web siteHttp://www.slackinc.com/reprintsHttp://www.slackinc.com/reprints
Morton D. Sosland, The SocialMorton D. Sosland, The SocialBrain and the Psychiatrist inBrain and the Psychiatrist in
Training,Training, Psychiatric Annals,Psychiatric Annals,
35:10, pp 854-866, 2005.35:10, pp 854-866, 2005.
http://www.slackinc.com/reprintshttp://www.slackinc.com/reprintshttp://www.slackinc.com/reprints -
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
3/53
The Psychiatry TraineesThe Psychiatry Trainees
DilemmaDilemma
MS: Child Psychiatry Fellow on committeeMS: Child Psychiatry Fellow on committee
for 2 yearsfor 2 years
Psychiatry divided in biological &Psychiatry divided in biological &
psychologicalpsychological
Each gives different explanation:Each gives different explanation: For why patients sufferFor why patients suffer
For treatment choicesFor treatment choices
Divides psychiatric facultyDivides psychiatric faculty
Psychiatry training affected in residency andPsychiatry training affected in residency and
fellowshipfellowship
Affects available future professionalAffects available future professionalopportunitiesopportunities
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
4/53
T.M. Luhrmann wroteT.M. Luhrmann wrote
(in)(in)Of Two Minds: The Growing DisorderOf Two Minds: The Growing Disorder
in American Psychiatryin American PsychiatryYoung psychiatrists are supposed toYoung psychiatrists are supposed to
learn to be equally good at both talklearn to be equally good at both talk
therapy and drug therapy,therapy and drug therapy,
psychotherapy and biomedicalpsychotherapy and biomedical
psychiatry, and the Americanpsychiatry, and the American
Psychiatric Association thinks thatPsychiatric Association thinks that
this integration is what trainingthis integration is what trainingprograms in psychiatry teach.programs in psychiatry teach.
Psychiatrists are supposed toPsychiatrists are supposed to
understand these approaches asunderstand these approaches as
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
5/53
T.M. LuhrmannT.M. LuhrmannOf Two MindsOf Two Minds
Yet they are taught as different tools,Yet they are taught as different tools,
based on different models, and usedbased on different models, and used
for different purposes. Somefor different purposes. Some
psychiatrists do integrate them topsychiatrists do integrate them to
some extent. But those who do havesome extent. But those who do have
to integrate two approaches that areto integrate two approaches that are
different from the outset that carrydifferent from the outset that carrywith them different models of thewith them different models of the
person, different models ofperson, different models of
causation, and different expectationscausation, and different expectations
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
6/53
Problems for PatientsProblems for Patients
Psychiatrist division & confusion about thePsychiatrist division & confusion about thecause and treatment for illness so patientscause and treatment for illness so patientsfeel so equally or morefeel so equally or more Chemical imbalance or genetic in natureChemical imbalance or genetic in nature
(biological)?(biological)? Or social or psychological?Or social or psychological? If chemical or genetic in causation, why useIf chemical or genetic in causation, why use
psychotherapy?psychotherapy? If psychological/from family or upbringing, thenIf psychological/from family or upbringing, then
why medication?why medication? Social brain explanations clarifySocial brain explanations clarify
psychiatric illnesspsychiatric illness In my own mind,In my own mind,
In the minds of my patients,In the minds of my patients, And more effective treatment strate iesAnd more effective treatment strate ies
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
7/53
Social Brain Definition ISocial Brain Definition I
The social brain framework helpsThe social brain framework helps
organize and explain allorganize and explain all
psychopathology.psychopathology.
A single gene-based disorder likeA single gene-based disorder like
Huntington disease is expressed to aHuntington disease is expressed to a
large extent as social dysfunction.large extent as social dysfunction.
Conversely, traumatic stress hasConversely, traumatic stress has
structural impact on the brain asstructural impact on the brain as
does the socially interactive processdoes the socially interactive process
of psychotherapy.of psychotherapy.
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
8/53
Social Brain Definition IISocial Brain Definition II
The social brain concept suggestsThe social brain concept suggests
Unifying explanation for how brainsUnifying explanation for how brains
developeddeveloped
Why mental illness exists and how itWhy mental illness exists and how it
affects usaffects us
It offers hope for how to treat mentalIt offers hope for how to treat mentalillness more effectively using aillness more effectively using a
unified approach.unified approach.
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
9/53
Social Brain Definition IIISocial Brain Definition III
Psychiatric disorders fundamentallyPsychiatric disorders fundamentally
entail social communicationentail social communication
problems for those afflictedproblems for those afflicted
Successful human interactionSuccessful human interaction
depends on communication withdepends on communication with
other peopleother people
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
10/53
Social Brain Definition IVSocial Brain Definition IV
Attachment stems from collaborativeAttachment stems from collaborative
communication.communication.
Secure attachment involves contingentSecure attachment involves contingent
communication,communication, Signals from one person gain direct response bySignals from one person gain direct response by
the otherthe other
Children learn from parentsChildren learn from parents
Good, loving and functional patterns of behaviorGood, loving and functional patterns of behavior
oror
Dysfunctional behaviors, e.g.Dysfunctional behaviors, e.g. AggressionAggression
Poor responses to stress, orPoor responses to stress, or
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
11/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
12/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
13/53
Social Brain IntegratesSocial Brain Integrates
When available and done in anWhen available and done in an
integrated manner, the teamintegrated manner, the team
approach worksapproach works
& all patients, even when no team& all patients, even when no team
involved,involved,
Benefit when viewed with 3 componentsBenefit when viewed with 3 components
combinedcombined
Doesnt replace BPS: social brainDoesnt replace BPS: social brain
idea extends itidea extends it
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
14/53
Social Brain IntegratesSocial Brain Integrates
Brain involved in & resulted fromBrain involved in & resulted from
social interactions, thereforesocial interactions, therefore
Social brain defines a biological systemSocial brain defines a biological system
at the biological, psychological, andat the biological, psychological, andsocial intersectionsocial intersection
All thoughts and emotions stem fromAll thoughts and emotions stem from
neural connections andneural connections andneurotransmitters in the context ofneurotransmitters in the context of
social learningsocial learning
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
15/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
16/53
Social Definition inSocial Definition in DSM-DSM-
IVIV Psychiatrys social componentPsychiatrys social component
critically figures in any DSM-IVcritically figures in any DSM-IV
diagnosisdiagnosis
Patients inability to function sociallyPatients inability to function socially
or occupationally (occupationsor occupationally (occupations
represent social functions) makes arepresent social functions) makes a
critical diagnostic distinction.critical diagnostic distinction.
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
17/53
Social Definition inSocial Definition in DSM-DSM-
IVIVThroughoutThroughout DSM-IVDSM-IV, we read:, we read:
The symptoms cause clinically significantThe symptoms cause clinically significant
distress or impairment in social, occupational, ordistress or impairment in social, occupational, or
other important areas of functioning.other important areas of functioning. Helps diagnose Major Depressive Episode,Helps diagnose Major Depressive Episode,
Dementia, Generalized Anxiety Disorder,Dementia, Generalized Anxiety Disorder,
Personality Disorders & others.Personality Disorders & others.
Other specialties differOther specialties differ Cardiologists do not need social function to defineCardiologists do not need social function to define
MIMI
How one works does not help define diabetes inHow one works does not help define diabetes in
endocrinologyendocrinology
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
18/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
19/53
Social Definition inSocial Definition in DSM-DSM-
IVIV Substance Abuse diagnosis includesSubstance Abuse diagnosis includes
the criterion of failure to fulfill majorthe criterion of failure to fulfill major
role obligations at work, school, orrole obligations at work, school, or
home.home.
Many childhood psychiatric disordersMany childhood psychiatric disorders
possess definitions partially based onpossess definitions partially based on
the childs poor social interactionsthe childs poor social interactions Pervasive developmental disordersPervasive developmental disorders
quintessentially defined by socialquintessentially defined by social
interactionsinteractions
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
20/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
21/53
ADHD Selected ForADHD Selected For
Some have examined ancient human ancestorsSome have examined ancient human ancestors GAP Child Committee asked:GAP Child Committee asked:
Did social environment affect human brains inDid social environment affect human brains inevolutionary times?evolutionary times?
Through an evolutionary biological lens, someThrough an evolutionary biological lens, somemental disorders seem an adaptive response tomental disorders seem an adaptive response toearly pathogenic environmentsearly pathogenic environments
And/or they reflect the optimization of brainAnd/or they reflect the optimization of brainfunction to some environments at the cost offunction to some environments at the cost of
poorer response to the demands of otherpoorer response to the demands of otherenvironmentsenvironments
Given current estimated frequency of ADHD (3% toGiven current estimated frequency of ADHD (3% to5%):5%):
Seems likely such prevalence maintained by selectionSeems likely such prevalence maintained by selectionforcesforces
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
22/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
23/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
24/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
25/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
26/53
Group MembershipGroup Membership
A neuroimaging study examined subjectsA neuroimaging study examined subjects
rejected by peers in a computer gamerejected by peers in a computer game
Brain reacted to social rejection as it reacted toBrain reacted to social rejection as it reacted to
painpain In same mannerIn same manner In same anterior cingulate cortex locationIn same anterior cingulate cortex location
Our brains wire us as social animals.Our brains wire us as social animals.
Anciently survival likely depended onAnciently survival likely depended ongroup-membership so thatgroup-membership so that
Pain of social rejectionPain of social rejection people to remain inpeople to remain in
social groupssocial groups
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
27/53
Gene-Life StressorsGene-Life Stressors
Interact For DepressionInteract For Depression 5-HTT gene has a promoter region5-HTT gene has a promoter region
either short or long alleleeither short or long allele
Result: Depression more likely withResult: Depression more likely with
double or single copies of shortdouble or single copies of short
alleles (s/l or s/s)alleles (s/l or s/s)
Stressful life events = problems withStressful life events = problems with
employment, finances, housing,employment, finances, housing,
relationships and the social stress ofrelationships and the social stress of
physical health problemsphysical health problems
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
28/53
Gene-Life StressorsGene-Life Stressors
Interact For DepressionInteract For Depression
More detal: if 4 or more stressful lifeMore detal: if 4 or more stressful life
events happen between the ages ofevents happen between the ages of
21 and 26,21 and 26,
33% of those with at least one short33% of those with at least one short
allele (s/s or s/l) became depressedallele (s/s or s/l) became depressed
compared to 17% of those with the l/lcompared to 17% of those with the l/l
genotype.genotype.The study also examinedThe study also examined
associations between childhoodassociations between childhood
maltreatment between ages 3 andmaltreatment between ages 3 and
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
29/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
30/53
Verbal CommunicationVerbal Communication
Adaptation over evolutionary timeAdaptation over evolutionary timewired human brains forwired human brains forcommunication among peoplecommunication among people
Large brain proportion forLarge brain proportion forcommunicationcommunication
Cerebral cortex does verbal &Cerebral cortex does verbal &nonverbal messagingnonverbal messaging pattern recognition & pattern generationpattern recognition & pattern generation
for writingfor writing
facial recognitionfacial recognition
planning behaviorsplanning behaviors
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
31/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
32/53
Learning Through SocialLearning Through Social
InteractionsInteractions Research on stress and genesResearch on stress and genes
indicatesindicates
Social interactionsSocial interactions neural connectionsneural connections
do not end in early development.do not end in early development.
Social interactions more influenceSocial interactions more influence
receptive brains earlyreceptive brains early
Neurons more plastic thenNeurons more plastic then But brains continue development throughoutBut brains continue development throughout
lifelife
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
33/53
Learning Through SocialLearning Through Social
InteractionsInteractions Learning causes new connections inLearning causes new connections in
brainbrain
This happens through relationshipsThis happens through relationships
People learn new ways of handlingPeople learn new ways of handling
situationssituations
Such happens through psychotherapy.Such happens through psychotherapy.
Important learning with parents,Important learning with parents,
siblings, spouses, friends, children,siblings, spouses, friends, children,
workplace & communityworkplace & community
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
34/53
BeliefsBeliefs
We frequently test beliefs andWe frequently test beliefs and
change themchange them
In isolation, belief change harderIn isolation, belief change harder
Versus discussing ideas with anotherVersus discussing ideas with another
whowho
Reinforces orReinforces or
Provides a new perspectiveProvides a new perspective
If a new perspective stems fromIf a new perspective stems from
another, one changes beliefs moreanother, one changes beliefs more
readilyreadily
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
35/53
BeliefsBeliefs
Some stick to dysfunctionalSome stick to dysfunctional
relationship patternsrelationship patterns
Those thrive best if open to life-longThose thrive best if open to life-long
learninglearning
They work on improving relationshipsThey work on improving relationships
byby
Testing out old patterns of behaviorTesting out old patterns of behavior
Rejecting dysfunctional beliefsRejecting dysfunctional beliefs
Developing new beliefsDeveloping new beliefs
Evolving new approaches to lifeEvolving new approaches to life
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
36/53
Social Learning TheorySocial Learning Theory
Rockland: Behavior, personal factors, andRockland: Behavior, personal factors, and
social forces all operate as interlockingsocial forces all operate as interlocking
determinants of one anotherdeterminants of one another
Behavior stems from the environmentBehavior stems from the environment People play roles in creating the social milieu &People play roles in creating the social milieu &
other circumstances that arise in their dailyother circumstances that arise in their daily
transactions.transactions.
Humans: advanced capacity forHumans: advanced capacity forobservational learningobservational learning
Enables them knowledge and skills expansionEnables them knowledge and skills expansion
From modeling influencesFrom modeling influences
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
37/53
Two Memory SystemsTwo Memory Systems
Learning involves two memory systemsLearning involves two memory systems
used togetherused together
Declarative or explicit system andDeclarative or explicit system and
Procedural or implicit system involvesProcedural or implicit system involves Striatum mediate skills & habitsStriatum mediate skills & habits
Amygdalae (+ neocortex & cerebellum) mediateAmygdalae (+ neocortex & cerebellum) mediate
emotionsemotions
Unconscious physical & emotional memories work inUnconscious physical & emotional memories work in
thesethese
When something new learned, declarativeWhen something new learned, declarative
memory works 1memory works 1stst & procedural memory to variable extents& procedural memory to variable extents
Constant repetition moves declarative toConstant repetition moves declarative to
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
38/53
Two Memory SystemsTwo Memory Systems
Experience of frightening situation orExperience of frightening situation or
traumatic eventtraumatic event declarative memories in hippocampus mixdeclarative memories in hippocampus mix
with emotional memories in amygdalawith emotional memories in amygdala Person may later feel depressed & anxiousPerson may later feel depressed & anxious
when emotional memories reactivatewhen emotional memories reactivate
Procedural and emotional memories in theProcedural and emotional memories in the
amgydalaamgydala MayMay bodys autonomic systembodys autonomic system
leading to fight or flight reactionsleading to fight or flight reactions
Faster breathing & heart rate with sweating skinFaster breathing & heart rate with sweating skin
Reactions = PTSD symptoms.Reactions = PTSD symptoms.
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
39/53
Brain-Affected PatientsBrain-Affected Patients
Combined medication &Combined medication &
psychotherapy works better thanpsychotherapy works better than
either aloneeither alone
Even diagnoses viewed as primarilyEven diagnoses viewed as primarily
biological benefit frombiological benefit from
psychotherapypsychotherapy
Psychotherapy of course is notPsychotherapy of course is notunbiologicalunbiological
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
40/53
ADHDADHD
ADHD exemplifies a disorder with a largeADHD exemplifies a disorder with a large
neurobiological & genetic componentneurobiological & genetic component
NIMH Collaborative Multisite MultimodalNIMH Collaborative Multisite Multimodal
Study of Children with Attention-Study of Children with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (MTA):Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (MTA):
Combined medication-behavior management =Combined medication-behavior management =
68% success68% success
Medical management only = 56% successMedical management only = 56% success Behavior therapy alone = 34% successBehavior therapy alone = 34% success
Combined improvement compared to othersCombined improvement compared to others
statistically significantstatistically significant
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
41/53
Combined BipolarCombined Bipolar
Treatment BestTreatment Best Agreement: one with bipolar disorderAgreement: one with bipolar disorder
needs medicationneeds medication Yet psychotherapy makes a significantYet psychotherapy makes a significant
differencedifference
LamLam et alet al examined cognitive therapyexamined cognitive therapyadjunctivelyadjunctively 103 patients with bipolar disorder103 patients with bipolar disorder
Randomized designRandomized design
Cognitive tx group: 14 psychotherapyCognitive tx group: 14 psychotherapysessions in 1sessions in 1stst half year 2 booster sessionshalf year 2 booster sessionsduring 2during 2ndnd half yearhalf year
Relapse results over the year:Relapse results over the year:
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
42/53
Combined Bipolar Tx: MoreCombined Bipolar Tx: More
ResultsResults Controls without cog tx:Controls without cog tx:
>3-fold more time in bipolar episodes (mean, 88>3-fold more time in bipolar episodes (mean, 88
days)days) Compared with cognitive therapy group (mean, 27Compared with cognitive therapy group (mean, 27
days).days). 33% without cog tx needed hospital adm for33% without cog tx needed hospital adm for
bipolar episodesbipolar episodes Compared to 15 % of patients with therapyCompared to 15 % of patients with therapy
Cognitive therapy: patients developedCognitive therapy: patients developedskills to monitor moodsskills to monitor moods
Plus any prodromal symptomsPlus any prodromal symptoms
Modified moods/behavior before prodrome full-Modified moods/behavior before prodrome full-
blownblown
C bi d S hi h iC bi d S hi h i
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
43/53
Combined SchizophreniaCombined Schizophrenia
TxTx Psychotic beliefs blossom ifPsychotic beliefs blossom if
Isolation continuedIsolation continued
No opportunity nor desire to reality-testNo opportunity nor desire to reality-test
Cognitive Behavioral therapists encourage patientsCognitive Behavioral therapists encourage patients
To examine alternative explanationsTo examine alternative explanations With sometimes profound results, e.g.,With sometimes profound results, e.g.,
When auditory hallucinations become not outside forceWhen auditory hallucinations become not outside force
But strong thoughts in their heads.But strong thoughts in their heads.
Patient may also learn behavioral techniques thatPatient may also learn behavioral techniques that
stop voicesstop voices This reduces stress to internal voice with lessenedThis reduces stress to internal voice with lessened
reactionreaction
Changes in cells and molecules still result inChanges in cells and molecules still result inschizophrenia butschizophrenia but Isolation + lack of reality testingIsolation + lack of reality testing worsened illnessworsened illness
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
44/53
MS Experience with OP TxMS Experience with OP Tx
of Schizophreniaof Schizophrenia
Co-led with M.W. Deibler group withCo-led with M.W. Deibler group with
schizophrenia.schizophrenia.
Several heard auditory hallucinations duringSeveral heard auditory hallucinations during
sessions.sessions. Focused on testing out behavioral strategies,Focused on testing out behavioral strategies,
such as humming or reading, to control auditorysuch as humming or reading, to control auditory
experienceexperience
Plus looked at alternative explanations forPlus looked at alternative explanations forvoicesvoices
Social form of group therapy provedSocial form of group therapy proved
helpful to severalhelpful to several
Isolative hallucination changed to controllableIsolative hallucination changed to controllable
ki f
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
45/53
Turkington: OP Tx ofTurkington: OP Tx of
SchizophreniaSchizophrenia
Psychologic meanings help in psychotxPsychologic meanings help in psychotx
adjunctive to medicationadjunctive to medication
Beneath systematized delusions and derogatoryBeneath systematized delusions and derogatory
hallucinations lies a personalized meaning, or ahallucinations lies a personalized meaning, or aschema, that drives symptomsschema, that drives symptoms
A personal storylineA personal storyline
I am a bad person idea may foster aI am a bad person idea may foster a
voice that expresses itvoice that expresses it In response, patient forms beliefs about theIn response, patient forms beliefs about the
voice,voice,
e.g., devil speaks, or alien sources produce thee.g., devil speaks, or alien sources produce the
soundssounds
T ki t OP T fT ki t OP T f
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
46/53
Turkington: OP Tx ofTurkington: OP Tx of
SchizophreniaSchizophrenia Frightening interpretations may triggerFrightening interpretations may trigger
anxiety & withdrawalanxiety & withdrawal This worsens more hallucinations & otherThis worsens more hallucinations & other
symptomssymptoms
Cognitive & behavioral interventionsCognitive & behavioral interventions Include alternative explanations for the voicesInclude alternative explanations for the voices
Relaxation training to reduce anxiety,Relaxation training to reduce anxiety,
Activity scheduling,Activity scheduling,
A voice diary to encourage patients to disputeA voice diary to encourage patients to disputethe content of the voicesthe content of the voices therefore to gain control over themtherefore to gain control over them
Plus other strategies for advanced copingPlus other strategies for advanced coping
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
47/53
Split Treatment: ChallengeSplit Treatment: Challenge
So social brain thinking withSo social brain thinking with
implications meansimplications means
Psychotherapy & other socialPsychotherapy & other social
interventions should happen as well asinterventions should happen as well asmedicationmedication
Challenge: combined approachChallenge: combined approach
difficultdifficult In era of managed careIn era of managed care
Split model of psychiatrist-therapistSplit model of psychiatrist-therapist
Separate functions determined bySeparate functions determined by
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
48/53
Split Treatment: ChallengeSplit Treatment: Challenge
Many work where medicating =Many work where medicating =
responsibilityresponsibility
But patients social relationships helpBut patients social relationships help
understand recoveryunderstand recovery
Should enhance the placebo effect toShould enhance the placebo effect to
its fullestits fullest
Engage meaningfully with patientEngage meaningfully with patient
Inquire on complianceInquire on compliance
Including reasons for non-complianceIncluding reasons for non-compliance
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
49/53
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
50/53
Split Treatment: ChallengeSplit Treatment: Challenge
Many psychiatrists for various reasonsMany psychiatrists for various reasonschoose to focus more on the biologicalchoose to focus more on the biologicalside of psychiatry,side of psychiatry, They limit their model of diagnosis & treatmentThey limit their model of diagnosis & treatment
But error to omit recognition/appreciationBut error to omit recognition/appreciationof the social side of treatmentof the social side of treatment Incredibly importantIncredibly important
regardless of how intervention happensregardless of how intervention happens
Plus we need to assist patients in socialPlus we need to assist patients in socialinteractions in the community and withinteractions in the community and withtheir familiestheir families
Think of vocational training or continuingThink of vocational training or continuingeducationeducation
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
51/53
Split Treatment: ChallengeSplit Treatment: Challenge
Even with a newest antipsychotic orEven with a newest antipsychotic or
antidepressantantidepressant
Just sitting home alone boredJust sitting home alone bored
Patients more likely relapse into depression orPatients more likely relapse into depression orpsychosispsychosis
As one woman with schizoaffectiveAs one woman with schizoaffective
disorder saiddisorder said
An idle mind is the devils workshop.An idle mind is the devils workshop.
Vocational Training doesnt work in allVocational Training doesnt work in all
cases, butcases, but
When it does it gives a purpose in lifeWhen it does it gives a purpose in life
--
MS C l i fMS C l i f
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
52/53
MS Conclusions forMS Conclusions for
Psychiatrist in TrainingPsychiatrist in Training
As a psychiatrist in training, I felt excitedAs a psychiatrist in training, I felt excited
About using various sociophysiologicalAbout using various sociophysiological
interventionsinterventions
Only with both communication & drugscan oneOnly with both communication & drugscan onemost effectively treatmost effectively treat
Psychiatric AnnalsPsychiatric Annals offered a past issue onoffered a past issue on
treatment resistant depressiontreatment resistant depression
ECT, adjunctive medication, & cognitiveECT, adjunctive medication, & cognitivebehavior therapy each possessed empiricalbehavior therapy each possessed empirical
supportsupport
To help patients bestTo help patients best
Patients need biological, psychological & socialPatients need biological, psychological & social
R fReferences
-
7/31/2019 m So Sland Zz Residents Perspective o 258
53/53
ReferencesReferences Luhrmann TM.Luhrmann TM. Of Two Minds: The Growing Disorder in American Psychiatry.Of Two Minds: The Growing Disorder in American Psychiatry. NewNew
York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf; 2000. p. 7.York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf; 2000. p. 7. Jensen, PS, Mrazek D, Knapp PK, Steinberg, L, Pfeffer, C, Schowalter J, Shapiro, T.Jensen, PS, Mrazek D, Knapp PK, Steinberg, L, Pfeffer, C, Schowalter J, Shapiro, T.
Evolution and Revolution in Child Psychiatry: ADHD as a Disorder of Adaptation. J. AmEvolution and Revolution in Child Psychiatry: ADHD as a Disorder of Adaptation. J. AmAcad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 36:12, Dec 1997. 1672-1679.Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 36:12, Dec 1997. 1672-1679.
Eisenberger NI, Lieberman MD, Williams KD.Eisenberger NI, Lieberman MD, Williams KD. Does rejection hurt? An fMRI study ofDoes rejection hurt? An fMRI study ofsocial exclusion.social exclusion. Science.Science. 2003;302:290-292.2003;302:290-292.
Caspi A, Sugden K, Moffitt TE, Taylor A, Craig IW, Harrington H, McClay J, Mill J, MartinCaspi A, Sugden K, Moffitt TE, Taylor A, Craig IW, Harrington H, McClay J, Mill J, MartinJ, Braithwaite A, Poulton R. Influence of life stress on depression: moderation by aJ, Braithwaite A, Poulton R. Influence of life stress on depression: moderation by apolymorphism in the 5-HTT gene. Science. Vol 301, 18 July 2003, 386-389.polymorphism in the 5-HTT gene. Science. Vol 301, 18 July 2003, 386-389.
Hjelle, L.A. and Ziegler, DJ, Personality Theories: Basic Assumptions, Research, andHjelle, L.A. and Ziegler, DJ, Personality Theories: Basic Assumptions, Research, and
Applications, third edition. McGraw-Hill, Inc., USA, 1992 p 336.Applications, third edition. McGraw-Hill, Inc., USA, 1992 p 336. Rockland, LH. Supportive Therapy: A Psychodynamic Approach. Basic Books, (1989)Rockland, LH. Supportive Therapy: A Psychodynamic Approach. Basic Books, (1989)United States of America. pp. 250-251.United States of America. pp. 250-251.
Kandel, ER. Biology and the Future of Psychoanalysis: A new intellectual frameworkKandel, ER. Biology and the Future of Psychoanalysis: A new intellectual frameworkfor psychiatry revisited. Am J. Psychiatry 156:4. April 1999. 505-524.for psychiatry revisited. Am J. Psychiatry 156:4. April 1999. 505-524.
Swanson, JM. Clinical Relevance of the Primary Findings of the MTA: Success RatesSwanson, JM. Clinical Relevance of the Primary Findings of the MTA: Success RatesBased on Severity of ADHD and ODD Symptoms at the End of Treatment. J of ChildBased on Severity of ADHD and ODD Symptoms at the End of Treatment. J of Childand Adolescent Psychiatry. 40 (2), Feb 2001, pp 168-179.and Adolescent Psychiatry. 40 (2), Feb 2001, pp 168-179.
Lam DH, Watkins ER, Hayward P, Bright, J, Wright K, Kerr N, Parr-Davis G, Sham P. ALam DH, Watkins ER, Hayward P, Bright, J, Wright K, Kerr N, Parr-Davis G, Sham P. A
randomized controlled study of cognitive therapy for relapse prevention for bipolarrandomized controlled study of cognitive therapy for relapse prevention for bipolaraffective disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry. Vol 60, Feb 2003. 145-152.affective disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry. Vol 60, Feb 2003. 145-152.
Turkington, D. Psychologic Mechanisms of Psychosis. Johns Hopkins UniversityTurkington, D. Psychologic Mechanisms of Psychosis. Johns Hopkins UniversitySchool of Medicine Advanced Studies in Medicine. Vol 3, Sept. 2003. S773-S775.School of Medicine Advanced Studies in Medicine. Vol 3, Sept. 2003. S773-S775.