maine.govmar 16, 2020  · 4. maine state trooper patrick flanagan and maine state trooper robert...

63

Upload: others

Post on 30-Mar-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 2: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 3: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 4: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 5: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 6: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination

ATTACHMENTS INDEX

Attachment 1: Maine State Police’s response dated January 29, 2020 Attachment 2: ILAP’s response dated February 13, 2020 Attachment 3: ACLU’s response dated March 6, 2020 Attachment 4: Motion to Suppress in State of Maine v. Kam Leung,

Cumberland County Docket Nos. CR-2019-0623 and CR-2017-6994

Page 7: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination

ATTACHMENT 1

Page 8: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 9: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination

ATTACHMENT 2

Page 10: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 11: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination

ATTACHMENT 3

Page 12: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 13: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 14: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 15: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 16: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 17: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 18: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 19: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 20: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 21: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 22: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 23: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 24: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 25: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 26: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 27: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 28: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 29: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 30: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 31: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 32: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 33: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 34: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 35: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 36: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 37: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 38: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 39: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 40: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 41: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 42: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 43: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 44: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 45: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 46: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 47: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 48: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 49: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 50: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 51: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 52: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 53: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 54: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 55: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 56: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 57: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 58: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 59: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 60: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 61: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination
Page 62: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination

' '

STA TE OF MAINE CUMBERLAND COUNTY, ss

ST A TE OF MAINE,

Plaintiff

V,

KAM LEUNG,

Defendant

SUPERIOR COURT SITTING AT: PORTLAND CR!MlNAL ACTION DOCKET NO. CUMCD-CR-2019-0623

CUMCD-CR-2017-6994 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

MOTION TO SUPPRESS PURSUANT TO M.R.Crim.P. 41A

NOW COMES the Defendant, Kam Leung, by and through his Attorney, Robert C. Andrews and respectfully requests this Court to grant this Motion to Suppress for the fol lowing reasons:

I. Charges against if operating after suspension and violation of conditions of release are currently pending in the Superior Court in Cumberland County.

2. The charges are in whole or in paii based on evidence that was illegally obtained.

3. The evidence was obtained in violation of the United States Constitution and the Constitution of the State of Maine.

4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination based on race in violation of the Due Process and Equal Protection clauses of United States Constitution and the Constitution of the State of Maine. See State v. Soto, 734 A.2d 350 (NJ. 1996)

WHEREFORE, the Defendant, Kam Leung, requests this Court to ORDER:

I. All evidence illegally obtained and all evidence obtained as a result of illegally obtained evidence he suppressed and excluded from the State's case in chief.

• I •

ATTACHMENT 4

Page 63: Maine.govMar 16, 2020  · 4. Maine State Trooper Patrick Flanagan and Maine State Trooper Robert Burke are engaged in selective law enforcement tactics that involve discrimination

' '

. ,--"

Dated: August 16, 2019

PROPOSED ORDER

.. ·-, ' I

dklttk"#/{ Robert C. Andl'ews Y Bar Number 8980 117 Auburn St., Suite 201 Portland, Maine 04103 207-879•9850

It is hereby ORDERED after hearing and consideration that the Motion to Suppress is:

GRANTED DENIED

Dated:_, ________ _ Justice, Maine Superior CoUti

- 2 -