making history with volturnus · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 acma most creative composites product •...

46
Making History With VolturnUS Dr. Habib Dagher, University of Maine - Orono July 11, 2013 OFFSHORE WIND ACCELERATOR PROJECT WEBINAR SERIES

Upload: others

Post on 24-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Making History With VolturnUS Dr. Habib Dagher, University of Maine - Orono

July 11, 2013

OFFSHORE WIND ACCELERATOR

PROJECT WEBINAR SERIES

Page 2: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

2

Housekeeping

All participants will be placed in “listen-only” mode when joining

the webinar. You will be connected to audio using your computer’s

microphone and speakers (VoIP). Or you may select Use Telephone after

joining the Webinar: Make sure to enter your phone Audio PIN, shown in

the webinar control panel, if you choose the option to join by telephone.

You are encouraged to type in questions regarding today’s presentations at

any time during the webinar by entering your question in the Question

Box on the webinar console. Questions will be answered as time allows

following all of today’s presentations.

This webinar is being recorded and will be made available after the call at

www.cleanenergystates.org under Events. Previous webinar

recordings are also posted.

Page 3: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Today’s Agenda

• Presentation by Dr. Habib Dagher,

founding Director of the Advanced

Structures and Composites Center at the

University of Maine - Orono

• Time for questions

Page 4: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Please Submit Questions

Questions submitted from webinar participants will be

addressed following the presentation. Please type your

questions in the webinar console’s Question box at any

time during the broadcast.

Page 5: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

CESA is a non-profit organization working with states, federal

agencies, and municipalities to advance the renewable energy

sector through:

- Information Exchange & Analysis

- Partnership Development

- Networking and Collaboration

www.cleanenergystates.org

Clean Energy States Alliance

Page 6: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Offshore Wind Accelerator Project

OWAP Objective: Address key challenges facing offshore wind in five focus areas

1. Ensure cooperation and communication among stakeholders and government leaders on priority problem-solving.

2. Improve regulatory approaches to support smart siting while reducing review costs & timelines.

3. Advance investment through power procurement collaborative networks and use of new financing mechanisms.

4. Advance opportunities, strategies, and collaboration to build a domestic OSW industry.

5. Implement a communication effort to ensure public education and stakeholder access to objective information.

6

Page 7: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Stay connected to OWAP!

• Offshore Wind WORKS campaign website:

http://www.offshorewindworks.org

• Like us on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/offshorewindworks

• Follow us on Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/OSWindWorks

Page 8: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Today’s Presenter

Dr. Habib

Dagher

8

Dr. Dagher joins us from the University of Maine’s

Advanced Structures and Composites Center, where he

oversees 40 associated faculty and full-time staff and150

graduate and undergraduate students. The University of

Maine recently launched the U.S.’s first grid-connected

floating offshore wind turbine, the VolturnUS prototype,

which Dr. Dagher will discuss today.

Dr. Dagher received his doctorate in structural

engineering from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

He holds two masters degrees in structural engineering

and in engineering mechanics.

Page 10: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Making History with VolturnUS

OWAP Webinar

Prof. Habib Joseph Dagher, Ph.D., PE Director, DeepCwind Consortium

Director, Advanced Structures and Composites Center University of Maine

[email protected], 207-581-2138

July 11, 2013

1

Page 11: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Outline

• The UMaine Composites Center

• Maine 5 GW by 2030 Plan

• 1:50 scale testing program

• VolturnUS 1:8 development

• DOE Advanced Technology Demo. Project

2/6/2012 2

Page 12: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Composites Industry

Construction Industry

Advanced Structures and Composites Center

180 personnel 87,000 ft2 space 15 years

Page 13: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Advanced Structures and Composites Center World Leader in Composites Materials Development, Design and Testing

• 2007 ACMA Best of Show

• 2007 ACMA People’s Choice

• 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites

Product

• 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites

Product

• 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

2

Page 14: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Longest Composite Bridge in the World, 540ft (Maine, 2011)

From the Lab

Page 15: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Composite Pilings

Spinoff company: Harbor

Technologies, Brunswick, ME

Technology: FRP tubes designed and developed at UMaine

Pilot line: built and now selling product throughout the world.

6

Page 16: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

“Bridge-in-a-Backpack”

Image Credit – NY Times/University of Maine

Technology: Hybrid bridge system combining benefits of high-performance composites with cast-in-place concrete

Page 17: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Penobscot Narrows Bridge, Maine

CFRP Strands

Page 18: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Composite Ship Structures MAKO Composite Patrol Craft

Page 19: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

“Family Energy”1,2 = 50% Transportation 40% Heating 10% Electric Power

Energy ~5% Energy ~20%2

at $4/gallon

Energy ~40%3

1 Source:, Dr. George Hart, UMaine 2 Based July ’08 energy costs 3 Assumes that health care costs do not grow past 30% of the average family budget in 2008-2018

Maine Family Budget

, 2012

Page 20: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Maine Plan: 5GW Floating 2030

• Maine’s 5GW by 2030 plan • $/kWh Can Floating Turbines Compete? • DeepCwind Technology Roadmap

– Floating Design Competition – 1:50 Scale Testing (April-May 2011) – 1:3 Scale Testing (July 2012, 2013) – 25 MW Pilot Farm (2017) – 0.5-1GW Floating Farm (2020)

• UMaine Deepwater Test Site • UMaine Offshore Wind Laboratory

Page 21: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

1:8

12

Maine Timeline: 5GW Floating by 2030

2013

Maine Just Won 2 of 7 DOE FOAs Pilot Farms.

Page 22: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

156 GW off Maine

55 million people

Source: “Assessment of Offshore Wind Energy Resources for the United States”, by Marc Schwartz, Donna Heimiller, Steve Haymes, and Walt Musial, Technical Report, NREL/TP-500-45889, June 2010

Challenges & Opportunities for Offshore Wind in the Northeast US

Page 23: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

14

Source: Jake Ward, UMaine Maine PUC data - Not inflation adjusted

#1 Challenge:

Reduce Cost of Offshore Wind

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

cost

($

/kW

hr)

# years aft 2000

Supply Standard Offer - Historic and Projected - BHE

Small

Medium

Large

Linear (Small)

Linear (Medium)

Linear (Large)

Challenging Goal: 10 cents/kWh in 2020’s @ Grid?

Dr. H. J. Dagher, (207) 581-2138 [email protected]

Page 24: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Dr. H. J. Dagher, (207) 581-2138 [email protected]

+

>30 m Shallow < 30 m

Transitional 30-60 m

Deepwater > 60 m

Page 25: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Gulf of Maine Region Lacks Heavy Offshore Construction Assets

Page 26: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

17

Pile Pile

Pile

Gulf of Maine Region Lacks Heavy Offshore Construction Assets

Page 27: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Normalized Annual Production in Gulf of Maine: Hilltop, Near-shore, and Far Offshore Sites

0.8

0.9

1.0

1.1

1.2

1.3

1.4

0 6 7 8 11 13 42 56

Miles Offshore

Sites on Map A B C D E F G H

Hill Top Near Shore Far Offshore

Sites Considered (12 years of data)

33%

Page 28: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

All viable! Choice depends on local conditions

3 Hulls, 60 Metocean Conditions

Page 29: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

20

1:50 Scale Test Results

Low Nacelle Surge Accelerations

Low Tower Bending Moment

Wave Energy

Wave Energy

Page 30: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

VolturnUS 1:8 Scale

!. UMaine Fabrication 2. Brewer Assembly-Launch 3. Castine Testing:

1:8 scale wave environment

Downsize turbine

Page 31: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Construction of VolturnUS 1:8 at UMaine Offshore Wind Lab

2/6/2012 22

Page 32: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Completed VolturnUS 1:8 Hull at UMaine Offshore Wind Lab

2/6/2012 23

Page 33: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award
Page 34: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

25

Page 35: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

2/6/2012 26

Page 36: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

2/6/2012 27

Page 37: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award
Page 38: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award
Page 39: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award
Page 40: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

2/6/2012 31

Page 41: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

2/6/2012 32

Page 42: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

33 Confidential

Aqua New England

Aqua Ventus I 2x6MW = 12MW

New England DOE FOA DE-FOA-0000410

Advanced Technology Demonstration Projects

Grid Parity Goal

2013 – 50% design 2014 – 100% design, costs 2015 - Start construction 2016 – 1st turbne connect grid 2017 – 2nd turbine connect grid

Page 43: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

UMaine Monhegan Island Test Site

UMaine Deepwater Offshore Wind Test Site at Monhegan Island in the Gulf of Maine.

• Established by Maine Public Law 270

• 9.2 m/s winds at 90 meters.

• 12 years of metocean data.

• Bottom characterization/core sampling.

• Fish, bird, bat, benthic invertebrate and marine mammal pre-deployment monitoring accomplished.

• FONSI received for scale project in 2011.

Page 44: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Summary

35

• Maine 5GW by 2030 plan • VolturnUS:

– Unique semisubmersible concrete & composite materials – Can be manufactured dock-side – No jack-up barges, No heavy cranes offshore – Reduce O&M costs, extend life beyond typical 20-25 years

• VolturnUS development: – 1:50 scale tests of 3 designs (2008-2009) – 1:8 scale VolturnUS (2013); deepCLIDAR (2013) – Full-scale demo 12 MW DOE FOA (2016) – Commercial farm 500 MW (2020’s)

• Data Collection on VolturnUS 1:8, about 1 year

Page 45: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

Acknowledgments DOE, NSF, UMaine, MTI, State of Maine

36

Page 46: Making History With VolturnUS · 7/11/2013  · • 2009 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2010 ACMA Most Creative Composites Product • 2011 ASCE Pankow Innovation Award

2/6/2012 37

In Castine, Maine, on June 13, 2013, at noontime, the first offshore wind electrons started to flow into the US electricity grid.