management of urban stormwater pollution: first 50 years
TRANSCRIPT
Management of Urban Stormwater Pollution:
First 50 Years Stockholm, Sweden
Nov. 13, 2012
Jiri Marsalek Water Science & Technology Branch
Burlington, ON, Canada
2
Presentation Outline
• Introduction – historical perspective
• Stormwater pollution characteristics
• Sources of pollutants in stormwater
• Stormwater pollution impacts • Solutions: Impact mitigation • Conclusions
3
INTRODUCTION
4
Urban Stormwater Pollution: Context
• Urban stormwater is defined here as surface runoff from urban areas
• It is conveyed by storm sewers (or open drains), or drains into combined sewers, where it contributes to combined sewer overflows (CSOs)(not addressed here)
• Increased surface runoff and the pollution conveyed by this runoff represent impacts of urbanization
• The issues of stormwater quality (the main topic of this talk) cannot be completely separated from those of stormwater quantity (flows contribute pollutants from the atmosphere, mobilize pollutants from the catchment surface and transport them)
5
Urbanization: Water Balance Changes (after Schueler)
6
Stormwater Pollution: Timelines
• First paper on stormwater pollution published in US by Weibel et al. (1964) – mostly conventional pollutants (also some pesticides and indicator bacteria)
• 1980s - reports on US EPA Priority pollutants in stormwater samples (US EPA, 1983), and in stormwater and sediment samples (a Canadian program)
• Makepeace et al. (1995) in a literature review identified 25 chemicals or groups with potential effects on human health and aquatic life
• By now, more than 600 substances identified, but not necessarily at environmentally significant levels
• Current challenges: control of some legacy pollutants and micropollutants (e.g., under EU Water Framework)
7
SW POLLUTION CHARACTERISTICS
8
Stormwater Pollutants of Environmental Interest • The list of pollutants of interest depends on local
receiving waters and the impacts caused by stormwater, and their selection and priorities vary accordingly
• In general, the main constituents (or groups of constituents) of concern include:
– suspended solids (transport attached contaminants, interfere with photosynthesis, blanket spawning beds, may damage fish tissues),
– trace metals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn – risk of toxicity), – trace organics from traffic by-products (polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons – risk of toxicity), – nutrients (P and N, in various forms - eutrophication),
9
Stormwater Pollutants of Environmental Interest (cont.)
– chloride (in cold climates - toxicity), – indicator bacteria (upstream of drinking water intakes, or
swimming waters – risk of faecal contamination), – waste heat (succession of cold water fisheries) – micropollutants (toxicity)
• Some of these pollutants occur in the form of solids (either being solids or particulates, or being attached to suspended solids and sediment)
• More information on these pollutants follows
10
Critical Constituents in Highway Runoff
• Solids (total and volatile) • Oxygen demanding substances (COD,
TOC) • Nutrients (NO2+3, TKN, PO4) • Heavy metals (Cu, Pb, Zn, Ni, Fe, Cd) • Hydrocarbons (including PAHs) • Phenols • Herbicides (weed control) • Deicing agents (chlorides, cyanides)
11
SWP Descriptors – physical & Chemical
• Physical: – Pollutants can be dissolved or chemicals attached to solids, or
sediment – Solids represent a wide spectrum of materials (primary particles
– clay, silt, sand, or flocculated aggregates) – Temperature (runoff heats up on impervious surfaces, ∆ T up to
10 C – Density (dissolved solids laden runoff)
• Chemical: – Up to 600 chemicals identified in SW – More attention paid to POPs, new emerging chemicals – Reporting totals no longer sufficient, often interested in
speciation
12
NURP SW Quality Data
Constituent EMC – median Site (NWRI)
EMC – 90th Percentile site
TSS [mg/L] 100 300 BOD [mg/L] 9 15 COD [mg/L] 65 140 T P [mg/L] 0.33 (0.28) 0.70 TKN [mg/L] 1.5 3.3 T Cu [µg/L] 34 (27) 93 T Zn [µg/L] 160 (490) 500
13
Metals in Sediment (µg/g)
• Assessment – grossly polluted sediment
Metal QEW MOEE Guidelines
LEL SEL
Cu 314 16 110
Ni 162 16 75
Pb 402 31 250
Zn 997 120 820
14
New Concerns - Micropollutants
• Micropollutants find their way into stormwater • Example – Perfluorinated chemicals (FFCs), used in a variety of
consumer products (adhesives, cleaning products, repellent coatings)
• Produced adverse health effects in laboratory animals (impact immune, liver and thyroid function)
• Transported with wet deposition (in-cloud and below cloud scavenging); their concentration may reflect local atmospheric contamination
• Annual fluxes of PFCs for four locations in Japan and USA were estimated at 11,000 – 22,800 ng/m2 , in urban areas, a large fraction of this burden will be transported by stormwater
• As new contaminants appear, we may be able to derive their stormwater fluxes from relevant environmental data
15
SWP Descriptors - toxicological
• Difficulties with all-encompassing chemical protocols led to toxicity measurements
• Various types measured – acute, chronic or genotoxicity
• Toxicity testing often conducted in batteries of tests – to cover different toxicity types and bioassay properties
• Most common – Microtox®, Daphnia magna, fathead minnow (7-day), SOS chromotest
• Biomonitoring
16
Frequencies of Toxicity Detection
00.10.20.30.40.50.60.7
No Potential Confirmed Severe
Toxicity
Frac
tion
MLDH RunoffUrban Runoff
MLDH runoff - severely toxic
17
Descriptors – microbiological
• Interested in pathogens and parasites • Difficulties in measuring techniques led to studies of
indicator organisms (to detect fecal pollution) • Large progress in DNA probes identifying specific
organisms • Common indicators – fecal coliform, E. coli
18
Indicator Bacteria in Stormwater
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
10000
E. coli / 100 mL
R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 R8 CO IN HW BMP1 BMP2 BMP3
Stormwater source / land use
Residential SW Ponds
Commercial
Industrial
Highway
19
SOURCES of POLLUTANTS
20
Sources of Pollutants in Stormwater
• Atmospheric deposition – Wet and dry deposition, air transport from local and
remote sources
• Catchment surface – Materials released by erosion, attrition or elution of
catchment surface (e.g., soil erosion, attrition of pavements, elution or dissolution of building materials – mostly metals)
• Land use activities – Traffic and road maintenance (metals, oil & grease,
PAHs, spills, applications of road salts and abrasives), residential land activities (garden chemicals, grass clipping, litter, pets)
21
U.S.A
250 500 750
1000 100
100
0 5 Km
N
PAH Deposition in Sault Ste. Marie (Canada)
Isoloading Contours
(ug/m ) 2
22
Sediment Yield vs. Urbanizing Drainage Area
10
10
10
10
10
2
3
4
5
0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000 10000
URBAN – FULLY DEVELOPED
Drainage Area (km2)
SED
IME
NT
YIE
LD
(t /
km2
/ yea
r)
23
General Sources of Heavy Metals
Heavy Metals
Highest median C [ug/L]
Source
Cd 8 Vehicle service
Cr 100 Landscaped area Cu 160 Urban rec. water Pb 75 CSO Ni 40 Parking lot Zn 100 Roof runoff
24
Sources of pollutants in traffic byproducts (major = , minor = )
Constituent Brakes Tires Fuel, liquids
Asphalt Deicing
Solids – organic
Solids, inorganic
Hydrocarbons
Cu
Pb
Zn
Chloride
25
Sources of Heavy Metals in Urban Stormwater (Fuchs 2006)
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Cu Pb Zn
OthersTrafficBuildings
26
STORMWATER POLLUTION IMPACTS
27
Impact Scales
• Impact can be summarized in a chart showing both temporal and spatial scales (after Lijklema et al. 1989)
Accumulation in sediments
Sedimentation (coarse material)
Resuspension
Mixing in rivers
Acute toxicity
Coagulation and
flocculation in lakes
BOD - O 2 Bacterial die-off
Mixing in lakes
Changes in benthic communities
Algal blooms
Bioaccumulation of toxicants in
fish
Year
Week
Decade
Month
Day
Hour
Minute
Local Whole system
Effects on Macro-
phytes
28
Physical Impacts: Temperature Rise of Urban Runoff
• Urban areas contain many sources of heat which increase the temperatures of surface runoff
• In summer months, rainwater is heated on hot impervious surfaces (pavements, roofs) or in stormwater ponds and wetlands
• Stormwater runoff temperatures may exceed those in the receiving waters by up to 10° C
• Thermal impacts of heated runoff are particularly noticeable during low flows in receiving streams
• Uncontrolled thermal enhancement may cause the original cold-water fishery to be succeeded by warm-water fishery (the same for invertebrates)
29
Measured and Modelled SW Pond Water Temperatures (after Van Buren et al.)
30
Densimetric Stratification
• Densimetric stratification can be caused by physical (thermal) or chemical (salt) phenomena
• Impacts on transport, mixing and water quality (inhibits vertical mixing)
• Where salt is used in winter road/street maintenance, chemostratification (high TDS, chloride) dominates
31
Densimetric Stratification in a Frozen Stormwater Pond
Ice
Outlet Inlet
Temp.= 1.6 C, TDS = 860 mg/L
Temp.= 2.3 C, TDS = 1080 mg/L
Temp.= 2.5 C, TDS = 1300 mg/L
Temp.= 0.5 C, TDS = 664 mg/L 0.4 m
0.8 m
1.1 m
32
Chemical Impacts
• Reduced DO - not a major concern for stormwater • Nutrient enrichment and eutrophication - a significant
concern for impoundments • Eutrophication degrades ecosystems by reducing
food to herbivores, water clarity, algal decomposition (oxygen demand)
• Stormwater may cause both acute and chronic toxicity
33
Toxicity
• When assessing chemical effects, concentrations of individual constituents are compared to the levels known to cause biological effects (effective concentrations, EC)
• In SW, WW and CSOs, biological effects may be caused by ammonia, chloride, chlorine, trace metals, and trace organics (last two, higher in SW)
• Difficulties with interpretation of chemical data (establishing ECs for all chemicals, chemical bioavailability, influences of ambient conditions - e.g., hardness, pH, and combined effects of chemical cocktails) led to the use of biomonitoring
• The most common form – toxicity testing
34
Applications of Road Salts
• Chloride concentrations in urban winter runoff and snowmelt frequently occur above the toxic levels (chronic 150-389, acute 600-860 mg/L)
• Management tools are studied/applied in a number of countries
35
Dissolved Oxygen
• DO is important for: – aquatic life and plants (need some minimum DO
levels) – stream capacity to assimilate waste, and – the processes at the bottom sediment/water
column interface • The precise definition of harmful (low) DO levels is
under discussion, but minimum levels for cold-water biota are usually specified as 9.5 mg DO/L in the early stages of life and 6 mg/L for warm-water biota
• Hypoxia may occur in stormwater ponds in summer, or under the ice cover
36
Nutrients: TN and TP
• Nitrogen and phosphorus are two most important constituents affecting the productivity of aquatic systems
• Originate from both natural or anthropogenic sources
• Fully or partly treated wastewater and CSOs carry higher concentrations in both soluble and particulate fractions than stormwater
• N and P occur in various species, which have different implications with respect to toxicity or eutrophication
37
Microbiological Pollution Impacts
• High levels of indicator bacteria in stormwater (104-
5/100 mL) have to be reduced to 102, or even 0, for specific water uses
• Control of microbiological pollution on beaches is complicated by wildlife – birds represent a major source
38
Combined Impacts
Biological Community
Performance
Chemical Variables
Flow Regime
Habitat structure
Biotic Interactions
Energy Sources
39
Terraview Pond
40
Benthic Community Structure
• Only 2 species present at all sites • No evidence of severe contamination
02468
101214161820
0 20 150 400 450 475 500 600
Distance from An Upstream Reference Point (m)
Tax
a R
ich
nes
s
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
0 20 150 400 450 475 500 600
Distance from An Upstream Reference Point (m)
Tot
al B
enth
os C
oun
ted Storm
PondStorm Pond
n/a
41
Solutions: Impact Mitigation
• Best Management Practices, including: – Source controls – Low Impact Development (LID) – Structural measures
• Applied at three scales: – On site – In the neighbourhood – On the catchment scale
42
Source controls – success stories
• Phasing lead out of gasoline (preventing Pb releases) • Brake pads – reducing Cu (from 15% to 0.1%) • Banning lead weights for wheel balancing • Reducing salt application in winter road maintenance
(smart salting, alt. deicers)(5 x 106 t used in Canada) • Public awareness / education / participation (banning
cosmetic pesticides, recycling, cleaning up after pets) • Protecting coatings of metal roofs (prevents Zn elution) • Self-cleaning concrete (TiO2 nanoparticles,
photocatalysis) • Near source – street sweeping
43
Phasing Pb out of gasoline
• Phasing Pb out of gasoline was higly effective
• Highway runoff data indicate reduction of Pb in runoff about 30 times (equivalent to preventing 97% of releases)
• This is actual prevention, not just a diversion
US Highway Data (1970s)
CDN Highway Data (1990s)
10
1
.01
.001
Pb (mg/L)
Z score-2 -1 0 1 2
Reduction 97%
44
LID - Definition
• A comprehensive, landscape-based approach to sustainable urban development encompassing strategies to maintain existing natural systems, and their
hydrology and ecology • Typical LID literature focuses on site hydrology
and water balance and its preservation • LID measures: rainwater use, green roofs,
enhanced soil water storage, disconnection of impervious areas, maintaining vegetative canopy, infiltration, on-site storage (bioretention)
45
Green Roofs (GR)
• GR either extensive or intensive • Hydrological benefits: reduced runoff (Q & V) • Ecological benefits: reduced runoff pollution (caution:
nutrients in roof runoff)
46
Minimize DCIA
• Minimize directly connected impervious areas/surfaces: reduce areas, drain impervious onto pervious, pervious pavement
• Hydrological benefits: reduced runoff (Q and V), improved
groundwater recharge • Ecology benefits: reduce pollution,
improved aquatic habitats
47
Vegetative canopy
48
Drainage by swales (photos Kerr Wood Leidal)
• Traditional drainage by curb & gutter generates too much of fast runoff
• Replaced by swales
49
Infiltration Facilities
• Trenches, wells, and basins
• Suitable for clean stormwater (e.g., roof runoff), watch out for chloride
• Pretreatment and regular maintenance is required
50
On-site Runoff storage
• Storage without volume control reduces only peak flows; in conjunction with infiltration, it also reduces runoff volume
• Various types exist: rooftop storage, vault storage under parking lots, bioretention areas, swales
• Ecological benefits: storage facilities serve as aquatic habitats, and support flora and terrestrial habitats
Credit: M. Dietz
51
LID Maintenance
• To sustain benefits, attention must be paid to maintenance and monitoring
• Some tasks are simple (sediment removal), others more involved (mulch replacement)
• Schedules of maintenance should be specified for individual types of structures/ facilities
• Maintenance on private property – requires homeowners education/cooperation, means of enforcement
• Some communities may require permanent sureties or bonds to be used when homeowners fail to maintain LID on their property
• Assign maintenance responsibilities
52
Conventional BMPs: Stormwater Ponds
• Provide flow control, quality control, and recreational amenities
• Chemostratification reported for the Kingston (stormwater management) Pond (1997)
• In the following years, several other stormwater ponds were surveyed in winter and found stratified
Cataraqui Stormwater Pond
53
Constructed wetlands
Purpose - detention and treatment in shallow pools with vegetation removing pollutants through a number of processes
54
Riparian buffer zones
• Buffers are important for both urban and rural creeks • Main functions: overland flow treatment, flow storage,
habitat and ecological functions • Narrow buffers do not fulfill all of these functions
55
Conclusions
• Stormwater runoff and pollution are significant factors to be considered in environmental protection
• Characteristics and impacts need to be assessed for devising effective controls
• Best estimates of SW pollution are obtained by field data collection, or modelling in the case of planning
• Impact mitigation can be achieved by BMPs comprising source controls, LID, and conventional measures
• Large achievement of the past 50 years – development of BMP and LID practices