mapping scholarly debate uc scholarly debates – authors, books, articles, schools, debate subjects...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Mapping Scholarly Debate UC Scholarly debates – Authors, Books, Articles, Schools, Debate subjects – Book A (author X) …… Book B (author B) – Reacts_to,](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022072017/56649f035503460f94c1769f/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Mapping Scholarly Debate UC
• Scholarly debates– Authors, Books, Articles, Schools, Debate subjects– Book A (author X) …… Book B (author B)– Reacts_to, rebuttal_of, disagree_with, …
• Owner: William Waites, University of Edinburgh / Open Knowledge Foundation
• Goal– 1. capture evolution of thought– 2. … (reuse schemas/vocs ?)
• Target audience: students, researchers• Schemas: FRBR-like (Work, Manifestation), FOAF
![Page 2: Mapping Scholarly Debate UC Scholarly debates – Authors, Books, Articles, Schools, Debate subjects – Book A (author X) …… Book B (author B) – Reacts_to,](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022072017/56649f035503460f94c1769f/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Mapping Scholarly Debate UC
• Existing work: Bibliographica.org, 73977 persons, 53106 manifestations and 53106 works
• … but appears that no relations defined• … didn’t find the actual RDF schemas used (should
be in UC definition!)
• Cluster with: Digital Text Repository UC, NDNP UC, Publishing 20th Century Press Archives UC
![Page 3: Mapping Scholarly Debate UC Scholarly debates – Authors, Books, Articles, Schools, Debate subjects – Book A (author X) …… Book B (author B) – Reacts_to,](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022072017/56649f035503460f94c1769f/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Some observations on UCs• Some UCs document existing work (EP UC)• Others do not (MSD UC)
• Many cases clear need for shared metadata schema• Not so clear where linked data comes in; reuse of other vocabularies or not? Else it’s
Open Data, not Linked Open Data• Goals not very diverse;
– reuse of vocabs – Linking to other datasets
• Sometimes LLD principles are written down in application or goal section• Some UCs are really abstract
– UC Digital Preservation– UC Component Vocabularies– UC Language Technology– UC Recollection
• Isn’t UC International Registry for Authors about creating a new vocabulary?