8/7/2019 Marcel Chelba: Ethical principles and pragmatic principles of polemics

1/6

Enp}n eikfgd

Kmg~u Eikfgd

my Hk}`nf @cnfmk& Hk} ?;& =?;; ;;105 kh

I ucibj tn a~pu tiubnppne k lkifne eikfgd~n kmg~u& I tg~fe }nc}kpn

ucn {~npuigb& cifgpgci`kf }npnk}`c kbe gfiui`kf `gbukhibkuigb my `~fu~}n"Ucn}n k}n pn|n}kf pihfn punp ucku& il tn lgffgt& tn `g~fe

~ben}pukbe h~`c mnuun}1

;" Tcnb yg~ nb`g~bun} k `gbu}k}y |int& ucn li}pu ucibd yg~ pcg~fe eg ip ug

eg~mu yg~} gtb gibigb" Pg iu ip -nuci`kf- kbe -cnkfucy-" Yg~ h~pu hkjnucip pu}kundi` pun mk`j ug }nn|kf~kun yg~} gpiuigb ug hkjn p~}n ucku tcku`gb`n}bp yg~& yg~ ck|n bgu hken kby hipukjn"

=" Bnsu& yg~ h~pu u}y ug fggj ku ucibdp l}gh ucn n}pn`ui|n gl ucn gucn}& a~pu

g~u gl }npn`u kbe `gblienb`n ib cip ibunffn`u~kf `ghnunb`n kbe cgbnpuy"Gucn}tipn ucn eikfgd~n tg~fe bgu ck|n kby pnbpn"

0" Tcku ihhneikunfy lgffgtp& bku~}kffy& ip e}ktibd ucn mg~bek}inp tiucib

tci`c nk`c ip }idcu" M~u ucip ip hn}nfy k u}~`n& mn`k~pn& l}gh ucip gpiuigb&nk`c `g~fe tiuce}kt ucni} gtb mk`jyk}e kbe fggj l~}ucn}& ibpgfnbufy& ug ucn

gucn}"

5" Yg~ h~pu libe k uci}e gpiuigb& l}gh tcgpn n}pn`ui|n ucn utg `gbu}k}y gpiuigbp `kb mn nsfkibne #a~puiline ib ucni} gtb gbugfgdi`kf gppimifiuy)

kbe uc~p }n`gb`ifne"

>" Mn`k~pn ucip fkpu pun `kb bgu bn|n} }nk`c cip ienkf& kff punp gl ucku

kfdg}iuch gl u}~uc h~pu }nnku kdkib kbe kdkib my nk`c k}ubn}& klun} nk`c`y`fn gl eikfgd~n"

Gl `g~}pn& ucip kfdg}iuch gl u}~uc di|np ucn nsn`une }np~fup gbfytcnb ucn ucg~dcu gl mguc k}ubn}p ip hg}kf g}inbune kbe `gblid~}ne my ucn

ibun}npu ib U}~uc"

A~pui`n tn jbgt l}gh Jkbu ip bgucibd m~u }k`ui`kf ns}nppigb&cipug}i`kffy enun}hibne& gl g~} ibun}npu ib U}~uc"

;

http://www.caslam.ro/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=5#p18http://www.caslam.ro/forum/viewtopic.php?p=18#p18http://www.caslam.ro/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=5#p18

8/7/2019 Marcel Chelba: Ethical principles and pragmatic principles of polemics

2/6

Tcnb ku fnkpu gbn enpipnp ucn gucn}& tkbup ug di|n cih fnppgbp& ugn}p~ken g} hipfnke cih& e}i|nb my }kdhkui` }ib`ifnp& ucnb ucn eikfgd~n

ip gh}ghipne"_}kdhkui` ucibjibd ip ucn p`g~}dn ucku ~pcnp g~} c~hkb pn`inp&

pfgtfy m~u p~}nfy& ugtk}ep eipkpun}"Tcku pkuiplk`uigb ip ucip1 ug mn ucn fkpu p~}|i|g} gl ucn fkbnu+7

I }nln} ug ein pggbn}"

Tiuc fg|n&

Hk}`nf @cnfmkWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

]n1 Enp}n eikfgd #Enp}n dbei}nk }kdhkui`)

Kmg~u Eikfgd~n #|intnel}ghk }kdhkui`n}pn`ui|n)

my Hk}`nf @cnfmk& Hk} ?3& =?;; ;?154 h

I `ghn mk`j& enk} H}" @gbpukbuib Kpfkh& ug pcgt yg~ ucku& u~}bne ~pienegtb& kff ucnpn punp kmg|n #gl ucn kfdg}iuch gl u}~uc) tiff dnbn}kun ucn

p}kdhkui` ucibjibd #~b`gbeiuigbkffy ~``n) kfdg}iuch"

;" Tcnb yg~ nb`g~bun} k `gbu}k}y |int& ucn li}pu ucibd yg~ pcg~fe eg ip ugeg~mu ucn gibigb gl ucn gucn} ug bgu fgpn yg~} pnfl(`gblienb`n"

=" Yg~ h~pu eg n|n}yucibd ug hg}kffy kbe ibunffn`u~kffy eip`}neiu ucn gucn}"

Enpu}gyibd cip }n~ukuigb& ucn}n tiff mn bg bnne ug k}d~n yg~} gtb gpiuigb"Ib ucn nynp gl ucn hkppnp& yg~} gibigb tiff kpp kp u}~n #my }ne~`uig kekm~}e~h)"

0" Kby gibigb `k}}inp tiuc iu k pnne gl u}~uc& m~u ucn }gmfnh ip bgu libeibducn u}~uc k l~uifn kuunhu kbe egghne ug lkif~}n l}gh ucn puk}u m~u ug

ihgpn yg~} gtb |intp kp k pg`ikf bg}h lg} gucn}"

5" Il yg~ p~g}u yg~} gpiuigb tiuc lkbkui`iph& tiuc kb ibnsck~puimfn bn}|n&

enpiun kff ucn n|ienb`n& yg~} ggbnbu$p `gblienb`n ib cip gtb k}d~hnbup

=

http://www.caslam.ro/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=5#p24http://www.caslam.ro/forum/viewtopic.php?p=24#p24http://www.caslam.ro/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=5#p24

8/7/2019 Marcel Chelba: Ethical principles and pragmatic principles of polemics

3/6

tiff mndib ug `gffkpn& kp ucn tkffp gl An}i`cg" Yg~} hg}kf hguug pcg~fe mn

pn}hkbnbu gllnbi|n `gbuib~g~ }n|gf~uigb"

>" Ucn}n ip bg kmpgf~un u}~uc& n|ienbu my iupnfl" U}~uc ip tcku yg~ fijn iu

tcku pkuiplinp yg~} n}pgbkf ibun}npu kbe ucn ibun}npup gl yg~} d}g~" Eg bgumn pne~`ne my ucn fgdi` #ucn kk}nbu kgei`ui` }idg} gl }kuigbkf ucibjibd)"

Bgucibd pcg~fe pug yg~ l}gh nk}bibd yg~} tky ug p~}nhk`y ucn`gb{~npu gl gfiui kf `gbu}gf g|n} gucn}p" Klun} yg~ jiff ucnh& yg~ `kb

`gb`nen ucnh ucni} pck}n gl u}~uc"

Iu pnnhp `fnk} ucku p~`c ucibjibd ip hg}kffy e}i|nb gbfy my ucnibun}npu ib gfiui`kf `gbu}gf g|n} gucn}p"

Ucip }kdhkui` kfdg}iuch ip ucn hku}is ucku }npckne g~} }kuigbkfucibjibd& klun} fgpibd iup gbugfgdi`kf fkbehk}jp #`kfim}kune my ucn ibun}npu gl

g~} c~hkb mnibd ug g}inbu ibpien ucn mg~befnppbnpp gl bku~}n) kbe }nu}nkunemncibe ucn fihiune cg}iqgb gl g~} pg`ikf nsipunb`n"

Iu ip bgu ucku p}kdhkui` ucibjibdtg~fe bgu mn fgdi`kffy `g}}n`u }kdhkuipup lnnf |n}y `ghlg}ukmfn my ucip gibu gl |int m~u ucku iu ip

hg}kfy t}gbd g}inbune"_}kdhkui` ucibjibd ip nhibnbufy gfiui`kf bgu gbugfgdi`kf g}

cn}hnbn~ui` m~ulk`u~kf"_}kdhkui` ucibjibd ip ucn kuun}b gl ucn bnidcmg}cgge m~ffy$p hibe&

tci`c mndkb ug e}nkh ku k uihn& ug `gb{~n} ucn tg}fe ucn pu}nnu my pu}nnu&`iuy my `iuy& `g~bu}y my `g~bu}y"

Pib`n}nfy&

Hk}`nf @cnfmk

#]ghkbik& ]nik& 3 hk}uin =?;;)

WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

Kbe bgt& ~u ~p ucnpn utg ksighkui` mki gl Eikfgd~n ib k ukmfn& ug mn`ghk}ne hg}n nkpify"

0

8/7/2019 Marcel Chelba: Ethical principles and pragmatic principles of polemics

4/6

_}ib`ifnp gl Eikfgd~n

Eikfgd~nucn nuci`kf n}pn`ui|n Eikfgd~nucn }kdhkui` n}pn`ui|n

;

Tcnb yg~ nb`g~bun} k `gbu}k}y|int& ucn li}pu ucibd yg~ pcg~feeg ip ug eg~mu yg~} gtb gibigb"Pg iu ip -nuci`kf- kbe -cnkfucy-"

Yg~ h~pu hkjn ucip pu}kundipun mk`j ug }nn|kf~kun yg~}

gpiuigb ug hkjn p~}n ucku tcku

`gb`n}bp yg~& yg~ ck|n bguhken kby hipukjn"

Tcnb yg~ nb`g~bun} k `gbu}k}y|int& ucn li}pu ucibd yg~ pcg~fe egip ug eg~mu ucn gibigb gl ucn gucn} ug bgu fgpn yg~} pnfl(`gblienb`n"

=

Bnsu& yg~ h~pu u}y ug fggj kuucibdp l}gh ucn n}pn`ui|n glucn gucn}& a~pu g~u gl }npn`u kbe

`gblienb`n ib cip ibunffn`u~kf`ghnunb`n kbe cgbnpuy"

Gucn}tipn ucn eikfgd~n tg~febgu ck|n kby pnbpn"

Yg~ h~pu eg n|n}yucibd ughg}kffy kbe ibunffn`u~kffyeip`}neiu ucn gucn}" Enpu}gyibd cip

}n~ukuigb& ucn}n tiff mn bg bnneug k}d~n yg~} gtb gpiuigb" Ib ucn

nynp gl ucn hkppnp& yg~} gibigbtiff kpp kp u}~n #my }ne~`uig ke

km~}e~h)"

0

Tcku ihhneikunfy lgffgtp&bku~}kffy& ip e}ktibd ucnmg~bek}inp tiucib tci`c nk`c ip

}idcu" M~u ucip ip hn}nfy k u}~`n&mn`k~pn& l}gh ucip gpiuigb& nk`c

`g~fe tiuce}kt ucni} gtb mk`jyk}e kbe fggj l~}ucn}&

ibpgfnbufy& ug ucn gucn}"

Kby gibigb `k}}inp tiuc iu k pnnegl u}~uc& m~u ucn }gmfnh ip bgulibeibd ucn u}~uc k l~uifn kuunhu

kbe egghne ug lkif~}n l}gh ucnpuk}u m~u ug ihgpn yg~} gtb

|intp kp k pg`ikf bg}h lg} gucn}"

5

Yg~ h~pu libe k uci}e gpiuigb&l}gh tcgpn n}pn`ui|n ucn utg`gbu}k}y gpiuigbp `kb mn

nsfkibne #a~puiline ib ucni} gtbgbugfgdi`kf gppimifiuy) kbe uc~p

}n`gb`ifne"

Il yg~ p~g}u yg~} gpiuigb tiuclkbkui`iph& tiuc kb ibnsck~puimfnbn}|n& enpiun kff ucn n|ienb`n&

yg~} ggbnbu$p `gblienb`n ib cipgtb k}d~hnbup tiff mndib ug

`gffkpn& kp ucn tkffp gl An}i`cg"Yg~} hg}kf hguug pcg~fe mn

pn}hkbnbu gllnbi|n `gbuib~g~}n|gf~uigb"

> Mn`k~pn ucip fkpu pun `kb bgubn|n} }nk`c cip ienkf& kff punp gl Ucn}n ip bg kmpgf~un u}~uc& n|ienbumy iupnfl" U}~uc ip tcku yg~ fijn iu

5

8/7/2019 Marcel Chelba: Ethical principles and pragmatic principles of polemics

5/6

ucku kfdg}iuch gl u}~uc h~pu}nnku kdkib kbe kdkib my nk`c

k}ubn}& klun} nk`c `y`fn gleikfgd~n"

tcku pkuiplinp yg~} n}pgbkfibun}npu kbe ucn ibun}npup gl yg~}

d}g~" Eg bgu mn pne~`ne my ucnfgdi` #ucn kk}nbu kgei`ui` }idg}

gl }kuigbkf ucibjibd)" Bgucibdpcg~fe pug yg~ l}gh nk}bibd yg~}

tky ug p~}nhk`y ucn `gb{~npugl gfiui`kf `gbu}gf g|n} gucn}p"

Klun} yg~ jiff ucnh& yg~ `kb`gb`nen ucnh ucni} pck}n gl u}~uc"

WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

]~fnp gl @i|ifipne _gfnhi`p

Npukmfipcne ku ucn Gslg}e ^bi|n}piuy& ib ;39?

Ib kby p`inbuili`& pg`ikf kbe gfiui` gfnhi`p& ucn eip`~ppigb pcg~fe `gblibnug ucn `ckbdn gl ienkp kbe gbfy ku ucgpn ienkp tci`c ck|n kllibiuy tiuc ucku

ipp~n"

Ucn k}uinp ib gfnhi`p ~pn kp k}d~hnbu niucn} p`inbuili` ucng}inp& g}`gb`}nun lk`up& }nfn|kbu ib }npn`u gl ucn }gmfnh eip`~ppne"

Ucn k}uinp eg bgu ck|n ucn }idcu ug m}ibd ibug eip`~ppigb ucn ggbnbup

`ck}k`un}& unhn}khnbu g} kpu& kp ucgpn bniucn} `gbli}h& bg} ib|kfiekun ucn|kfieiuy gl ucn ienkp ucny kppn}u"

Ucn k}uinp eg bgu ck|n ucn }idcu ug eip`~pp ucn }nkpgbp tci`c enun}hibn ucnggbnbup ienkui` kuuiu~en& kp cn ei|n}up ucn eip`~ppigb l}gh ucn ipp~n iupnfl"

Fkmnfibd ucn ggbnbu my hnbuigbibd ucn ucibjibd p`cggf& }glnppigbkfg}dkbiqkuigb g} gfiui`kf k}uy cn mnfgbdp ug `gbpuiu~unp k |igfkuigb gl ucn

gfnhi`p }~fnp kbe }g|np ucn fk`j gl k}d~hnbup tnkjbnpp"

Ib k `i|ifiqne gfnhi`p iu hkuun}p gbfy ucn k}d~hnbup m}g~dcu my ucnggbnbu kp k n}pgb kbe bgu kp hnhmn} gl k p`cggf g} g}dkbiqkuigb" Yg~

k}n bgu }idcu mn`k~pn yg~ k}n k hkun}ikfipu ucibjn}& kb gtbn} g} k tg}jn}& m~ugbfy il yg~} k}d~hnbup k}n `gb|ib`ibd g} bgu"

>

8/7/2019 Marcel Chelba: Ethical principles and pragmatic principles of polemics

6/6

Pg~}`n1 cuu1''ttt"n}n~mfij" gh'nb'k}ui`fn'}nd~fifn(gfnhi ii(`i|ifiqkun(}~fnp(gl(`i|ifipne(gfnhi`p(40?30