marketing to the heartland 2017 - fluent, inc. › ... › 2017 › 04 ›...
TRANSCRIPT
Marketing to the Heartland 1Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Marketing to the Heartland2017PART 1: WINNING HEARTS AND MINDS
Marketing to the Heartland 2Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Marketing to the Heartland
In the aftermath of the frenzied 2016 US Presidential election, many brands
and news outlets realized that they were missing the mark in understanding
and marketing to a massive swath of the US population – namely those who
live in the Heartland*. To help marketers better understand and reach this
demographic with more relevant messaging, we conducted a national survey
of 1,800 Americans with the purpose of identifying marketing strategies that
best resonate with this often overlooked and misunderstood audience.
In the following pages, we uncover the results of the study – sharing valuable
consumer insights and providing recommendations for marketers. In addition
to significant variances between the behaviors and values of consumers
living in the Heartland and those along the Coastal states, we saw notable
differences between consumers living in urban, suburban and rural areas.
For brands, understanding the difference in values and lifestyles between
Heartland and Coastal Americans is critical.
When making purchasing decisions, Americans living in the Heartland are more likely (53% vs. 48%) to shop with brands that share, or exemplify, their core values than coastal Americans. As such, it’s a troubling fact for marketers that 46% of Heartland Americans say they rarely or never see ads that appeal to their core values. This signals a direct need for marketers to redefine their messaging strategies to connect with this audience.
*See methodology for definition.
Marketing to the Heartland 3Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Here are some stark differences between Heartland consumers and their coastal counterparts:
Coastal consumers are more likely to… Heartland consumers are more likely to…
BE CONSERVATIVE +11%
BE SOCIALLY LIBERAL +10%
BE MORE ETHNICALLY DIVERSE +31% non-white
BE CAUCASIAN +21%
Be single +19%
Consider education more important +31%
Urban and Suburban Coastal consumers are more likely to deem cultural diversity (+20%) socio-economic equality (+19%) and political correctness (+15%) as important, compared to the rest of the country
Purchase from brands that share their core values +10%
View work-life balance as important +12%
Say that family is more important +12%
Say that saving money is 23% more important than education
Be married +24%
23% more likely to view traditional marriage as important to society
Learn about new brands and products via:
Friends (+30%)
Family (+23%)
Social Media (+18%)
TV segments on the shows they watch (+29%)
Colleagues (+33%)
Note: “+” indicates X% higher than the comparison group at a 95% CI
Marketing to the Heartland 4Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
In addition to the differences between those in various geographical regions, there are also several notable
distinctions between consumers who reside in urban, suburban or rural areas. Here are several cases of this:
Rural Suburban Urban
Faith is more important
Family is more important
Saving money is more important
Family is more important
Saving money is more important
Education is more important
More likely to pay more for higher quality products and pay more for convenience
Exhibit larger income inequality: more likely to make under $35K, but also more likely to make over $150K
More likely to find aspirational ads appealing
More likely to purchase items on sale, use coupons, and go out of their way to get a deal
Have more kids on average
Less likely to say they see ads that appeal to their core values
More likely to find ads that provide useful tips and tricks appealing
More likely to be CONSERVATIVE More likely to be CONSERVATIVE More likely to be LIBERAL
More likely to be WIDOWED More likely to be DIVORCED More likely to be SINGLE
Marketing to the Heartland 5Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Reaching Consumers in the Heartland
Tailor product messaging to consumers’ core values
By aligning their marketing efforts to these core principles, brands can capitalize on the current disconnect
in the marketplace. Currently, 46% of Americans living in the Heartland say they rarely, or never, see ads
that appeal to their core values. Even if every campaign is not explicitly tied to a value, it is important to
consider the audience and make sure that the messaging does not alienate or offend them. Presently, 15%
of customers in the Heartland say that they have stopped purchasing from a brand because they saw an
offensive ad, and another 10% say they have cut off a brand because it did not understand them.
Most Important to Consumers
Family FaithBeing Self-Sufficient Work/Life Balance Traditional Marriage
The core values for consumers in the Heartland include:
1
41%46%
Coastal Residents
Heartland Residents
Family
Marketing to the Heartland 6Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Being self-sufficient
Saving enough for retirement
Being able to afford big purchases
Finding a job I like
Starting a family
While all Americans find self-sufficiency and faith to be important, consumers in the Heartland additionally
stress the importance of work/life balance (66% vs. 59% of Coastal Americans) and are more likely to feel that
traditional marriage is important to society (59% vs. 48%).
Importance of values (Extremely/Very Important %)
Highest priority in life
Being self-sufficient
Faith
Work/life balance
Patriotism
Importance of traditional marriage to society
Cultural diversity
Socio-economic equality
Political correctness
23%
17%
11%14%
73%
61%
59%
59%
48%
51%
51%
40%
6%
24%
17%
13%11%
72%
65%
66%
62%
59%
51%
49%
43%
4%
When asked about their top priority in life, self-sufficiency is on top for all Americans, followed by the ability to
save enough for retirement. Coastal consumers tend to get married later, and therefore starting a family is a
current high priority for a larger number of them.
Coastal Consumers
Heartland Consumers
Coastal Consumers
Heartland Consumers
Marketing to the Heartland 7Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Inform consumers about how they can save moneySaving money is the second most important item for consumers living in the Heartland, right after family. On
the other hand, Coastal consumers tend to value education more, compared to their counterparts.
Most important to consumers
2
41%
16% 14%17%
8%4%
46%
16% 15%13%
6% 5%
Family Saving Money Faith Education Wealth Gain status in my community
Additionally, 29% of Americans say they want to see ads from brands that provide them with information on
how they can save money.
Ads consumers want to see from brands
Coastal Consumers
Heartland Consumers
Providing info on how I can save
Showcasing products or services
Ads with a socially responsible message
Providing useful tips and tricks
31% 29%
29%12%
Marketing to the Heartland 8Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Americans in general are very cost-conscious; 65% say they look for the cheapest price all, or most, of the time
and 54% purchase items on sale all, or most, of the time. Another 43% will go out of their way to find a deal.
Interestingly, consumers living in urban areas are the most ardent deal shoppers. They are also most likely
to pay more for quality and convenience. These trends may be driven by a greater availability of retailers in
densely populated areas as well as income stratification in urban centers.
How often do you… (% All the time/most of the time)
Look for cheapest price
Purchase items on sale
Go out of way to get a deal
Use coupons
Pay more for higher quality products
Pay more for convenience
Wait for sales to buy large items
66%
51%
40%
33%
29%
27%
26%
58%
53%
43%
40%
32%
33%
32%
71%
60%
48%
50%
43%
39%
39%
65%
54%
43%
40%
34%
33%
32%
Total US Rural Suburban Urban
Marketing to the Heartland 9Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Highlight the high quality of products and emphasize products made in the USA All American consumers agree that the quality of a product is their most important criterion when deciding on
a purchase. As the conversation about the cost of globalization and outsourcing continues in the US, it has be-
come increasingly important for brands to support local production. While conventional wisdom would have
one believe that people in areas affected most by job outsourcing would feel stronger about the importance of
US produced goods, this consideration is equally important to Heartland and Coastal residents. More than 6 in
10 Americans feel that it is very important to them that brands produce goods in the US.
Important criteria when deciding on a purchase(Extremely/Very Important %)
3
Brand has high quality products
Brand produces goods in USA
Brand has cheap prices
Brand shares my core values
Brand is green/environmentally conscious
Brand is active in the local community
Brand has an online presence
Coastal Consumers
Heartland Consumers
71%
61%
55%
48%
47%
47%
44%
75%
65%
57%
53%
49%
48%
47%
Marketing to the Heartland 10Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Word of mouth is paramount. Invest in customer service and develop an organic following on social media.Americans living in the Heartland are more community oriented and are far more likely to say they learn about
new brands and products via family and friends than Coastal consumers. Heartland consumers are also more
likely to be influenced by social media as well as recommendations, so word of mouth recommendations are
paramount.
Share of consumers who learn about new products and brands via…
4
Friends
Colleagues
Websites
TV ads
Social M
edia
In-app ads
TV segments
Family
Search engine
News Outle
ts
Browsin
g in st
ore
Celebrities
Email newsle
tter
43%
43%
34%
33%
24%
21%
14% 16
%
12%
13%
10%
9%
4%
56%
53%
40%
37%
24%
20%
18%
17%
16%
14%
12%
10%
4%
Coastal Consumers
Heartland Consumers
Marketing to the Heartland 11Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Urban dwellers, whether they live in the Heartland or are Coastal, are more likely to learn about new brands
and products through websites and in-app ads compared to their suburban counterparts. They are also more
influenced by news outlets and celebrity endorsements than consumers living in rural areas. These findings
highlight the importance of varied messaging, depending on the location of consumers a brand is trying to
reach.
Share of consumers who learn about new products and brands via...
Websites
News Outlets
In-app ads
Celebrities
Rural
Suburban
Urban
23%
16%
11%
7%
21%
22%
10%
9%
28%
23%
15%
13%
5 Reach consumers in the Heartland via social media and ads on relevant TV segmentsSince Americans in the Heartland are more likely to learn about new brands and products through social
media and TV segments they watch, there is an opportunity for brands to reach these consumers through
targeted ads via these channels.
Share of consumers who learn about new products and brands via...
Social Media TV segments
34%
14%
40%
18%
Coastal Consumers
Heartland Consumers
Marketing to the Heartland 12Arrow indicates significantly higher than comparison group at 95% CI
Methodology*The Heartland region is comprised of 26 states in the Southwest, Midwest and parts of the Southeast (AL,
AR, FL, GA, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MI, MN, MO, MS, NC, ND, NE, OH, SC, SD, TN, TX, VA, WI, WV) and is based
on a definition designed by the New Heartland Group.
Fluent’s “Marketing to the Heartland” study was conducted online within the United States by Fluent, LLC on
March 20, 2017 among 1,865 US consumers (aged 18 and up). Respondents were randomly selected, and
the findings are statistically significant at a 95% confidence level. Due to rounding, percentages may not
always add up to 100%. Fluent’s proprietary ad serving technology includes a real-time survey module that
was used to facilitate the data collection for this study.
Data was weighted to US Census 2010 population distribution and Census Bureau, 2011-2015 American
Community Survey 5-Year Estimates.
https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/index.xhtml
ABOUT FLUENTFluent, LLC, a cogint company (Nasdaq: COGT), is an industry leader in people-based digital marketing and customer acquisition, serving over 500 leading consumer brands and direct marketers. Leveraging a massive reservoir of proprietary audience data, as well as millions of real-time survey interactions with consumers every day, Fluent enables advertisers to more effectively target and acquire their most valuable customers, with precision, at a massive scale. The company is headquartered in New York City. For more information visit www.fluentco.com.
fluentco.com I [email protected] I 646.647.2966