may 2013 tax bulletin - building a better working world - … issuances • revenue regulations (rr)...

28
Tax bulletin May 2013

Upload: doanthuan

Post on 11-Mar-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

1

Tax bulletin May 2013

Page 2: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

2 Tax Bulletin

HighlightsBIR Rulings

• UndertheRP-JapanTaxTreaty,dividendspaidbyadomesticcorporationtoaJapanesecorporationaresubjecttothe10%preferentialtaxrateiftheJapanesecorporationdirectlyholdsatleast10%ofeitherthevotingsharesof,orthetotalsharesissuedby,thedomesticcorporation,duringtheperiodofsixmonthsimmediatelyprecedingthedateofpaymentofthedividends. (Page 4)

• UndertheRP-JapanTaxTreaty,interestonforeignloansextendedbyaresidentofJapantoaresidentofthePhilippinesmayqualifyforthe10%preferentialtaxrateonthegrossamountofinterestiftherecipientofsuchinterestisalsothebeneficialownerthereof.

Theloanagreementissubjecttodocumentarystamptax(DST)imposedunderSection179oftheTaxCodeattherateofPhp1.00oneachPhp200.00oftheissuepriceofsuchloanagreement. (Page 5)

• DividendspaidbyadomesticcorporationtoaresidentoftheCaymanIslandsaresubjecttothe15%finalwithholdingtax(FWT)underSection28(B)(5)(b)oftheTaxCode. (Page 5)

• Reconveyanceoflandtitlesbyvirtueoftherescissionofacontractofsaleisnotsubjecttocapitalgainstax(CGT)andDST.TheDSTpreviouslypaiduponexecutionofaDeedofAbsoluteSalecannotberefundedbyreasonoftherescissionofthecontractofsale. (Page 6)

• Foranorganizationtobeissuedacertificateoftaxexemption,ithastoprovebyactualoperationforatleastthreeyearsthatitisanorganizationexemptfromincometaxunderSection30(G)oftheTaxCode,subjecttootherrequirements. (Page 6)

BIR Issuances

• RevenueRegulations(RR)No.9-2013amendscertainprovisionsofRRNo.30-2002onthepaymentoftheamountofferedascompromisesettlementpursuanttoSection204oftheTaxCode. (Page 8)

• RRNo.10-2003amendsRRNo.2-98toincludeRealEstateServicePractitioners(i.e.,realestateconsultants,appraisersandbrokers):(1)whopassedthelicensureexaminationgivenbytheRealEstateService,pursuanttoRANo.9646“TheRealEstateServiceActofthePhilippines,”asamongthoseprofessionalsfallingunderSection2.57.2(A)(1)ofRRNo.2-98subjecttothe10%or15%creditable(expanded)withholdingtaxonprofessionals;and(2)thosewhodidnotpassordidnottakethelicensureexaminationgivenbytheRealEstateServiceamongthebrokersandagentsunderSection2.57.2(G)ofRRNo.2-98. (Page 9)

• RRNo.11-2013requiresthefiling/submissionofahardcopyoftheCertificateofCompensationPayment/TaxWithheld(BIRForm2316)coveringemployeeswhoarequalifiedforsubstitutedfiling. (Page 9)

• RevenueMemorandumCircular(RMC)No.34-2013clarifiestheproperaccomplishmentandfilingofestatetaxreturns. (Page 11)

Page 3: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

3

• RMCNo.35-2013circularizesthefulltextofDepartmentOrder(DO)No.18-2013,datedApril16,2013,oftheDepartmentofFinance(DOF)ontheamendmentofSection12ofDONo.03-08entitled“RulesandRegulationstoImplementRepublicAct9400,AnActAmendingRepublicAct7277,otherwiseknownastheBasesConversionandDevelopmentActof1992”. (Page 12)

• RMCNo.37-2013circularizesthefulltextofDOFDONo.17-2013datedApril11,2013. (Page 13)

• RMCNo.38-2013clarifiestheimplicationoflegalpetitionnotices/declarationsandsimilardocumentsontheaudit/assessmentprocess. (Page 14)

• RMCNo.39-2013prescribestheguidelinesforreceiptofprotestlettersonFinalAssessmentNoticesandothersimilarcorrespondences. (Page 14)

• RMCNo.41-2013publishesthefulltextoftheimplementingrulesandregulations(IRR)ofRepublicAct(RA)No.10165,otherwiseknownastheFosterCareActof2012. (Page 15)

• RevenueMemorandumOrder(RMO)No.12-2013prescribesadditionalpoliciesanduniformguidelinesandproceduresintheprocessingofAuthoritytoPrint(ATP)OfficialReceipts(ORs),SalesInvoices(SIs)andotherCommercialInvoices(CIs)intheinterimperioduntiltheOn-lineATPsystemisavailableforimplementation. (Page 17)

• RMONo.13-2013prescribeswork-aroundprocedurespendingtheavailabilityoftheOnlineSystemforAccreditationofPrinters(OCAP)pursuanttoRRNo.15-2012datedDecember3,2012. (Page 20)

BOC Issuance

• CustomsAdministrativeOrder(CAO)No.2-2013amendsCAONo.1-2007,whichrequiresthesubmissionofInwardForeignManifestandConsolidatedCargoManifest. (Page 21)

PEZA Issuance

• PEZAMemorandumCircular(MC)No.2013-013announcesthesecondextensionofthe50%reductioninallPEZAprocessingfeesforEcozoneImport/ExportFull-ContainerLoadShipmentsviatheBatangasInternationalPort(BIP). (Page 21)

SEC Issuances

• SECMemorandumCircular(MC)No.7prescribestheSingleBorrowerLimit(SBL)andCreditLimitonDirectors,Officers,StockholdersandRelatedInterests(DOSRI)ofalendingcompany. (Page 21)

• SECMCNo.8prescribestheguidelinesforcomplyingwiththeFilipino-foreignownershiprequirementsasprescribedintheConstitutionandexistinglawsbycorporationsengagedinnationalizedandpartlynationalizedactivities. (Page 22)

• SECMCNo.9extendsthedeadlinetosubmittheAnnualCorporateGovernanceReport(ACGR)forlistedcompaniesfromMay30,2103toJune30,2013. (Page 23)

Page 4: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

4 Tax Bulletin

BSP Issuance

• CircularNo.796amendsAppendix45(NotesonMicrofinance)ofSectionX361oftheManualofRegulationsforBanks(MORB). (Page 23)

Court Decisions

• AstipulationbetweentheBIRandthetaxpayerattheCourtofTaxAppeals(CTA)proceedings,thattaxeshavebeencorrectlyremittedtothegovernmentcannotbindthecourt.Thetaxpayerisstillrequiredtopresentproofthatitcorrectlyremittedthetaxes.

A20%delinquencyinterestisdueonunpaiddeficiencytaxesassessedbytheBIR,computedfromthedateprescribedfortheirpaymentuntilfullpaymentismade. (Page 23)

• WhiletheLocalGovernmentCode(LGC)prohibitsalllocalgovernmentunits(LGUs),includingprovinces,fromlevyingpercentagetaxes,theLGCallowsprovincestolevyandcollectanamusementtax,whichisapercentagetax,fromproprietors,lessees,oroperatorsoftheaters,cinemas,concerthalls,circuses,boxingstadia,andotherplacesofamusement.

Swimmingpools,bathhouses,andhotspringscannotbeconsideredas“otherplacesofamusement”subjecttoamusementtaxesundertheLGC. (Page 25)

• Interestincomefromloansandadvancestoaffiliatesisconsideredasrevenuerealizedfromservicesrenderedinthenormalcourseoftradeorbusinessthatissubjecttovalue-addedtax(VAT). (Page 26)

BIR Rulings

BIR Ruling No. ITAD 133-13 dated May 9, 2013

Facts:

JCo.,anon-residentJapanesecorporation,hasowned60%ofthetotaloutstandingsharesofPCo.,adomesticcorporation,since2009.In2012,PCo.declaredcashdividendsinfavorofJCo.,andpaidthesaiddividendsonMay23,2012.ATaxTreatyReliefApplication(TTRA)foravailingthe10%preferentialtaxondividendsundertheRP-JapanTaxTreatywasfiledwiththeInternationalTaxAffairsDivision(ITAD)oftheBIRonApril2,2012.

Issue:

ArethedividendspaidbyPCo.toJCo.entitledtothe10%preferentialtaxrate?

Ruling:

Yes.UnderArticle10(2)(a)oftheRP-JapanTaxTreaty,dividendspaidbyadomesticcorporationtoaresidentofJapanaresubjecttothe10%preferentialtaxrateonthegrossamountofdividends,ifthebeneficialownerisacompanywhichdirectlyholdsatleast10%ofeitherthevotingsharesofthecompanypayingthedividends,orthetotalsharesissuedbythatcompany,duringtheperiodofsixmonthsimmediatelyprecedingthedateofpaymentofthedividends.

UndertheRP-JapanTaxTreaty,dividendspaidbyadomesticcorporationtoaJapanesecorporationaresubjecttothe10%preferentialtaxrateiftheJapanesecorporationdirectlyholdsatleast10%ofeitherthevotingsharesof,orthetotalsharesissuedby,thedomesticcorporation,duringtheperiodofsixmonthsimmediatelyprecedingthedateofpaymentofthedividends.

Page 5: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

5

BIR Ruling No. ITAD-136-13 dated May 16, 2013

Facts:

JCo.,anon-residentforeigncorporationcreditorbasedinJapan,extendedaloantoPCo.,adomesticcorporation.PCo.agreedtopayJCo.theprincipalplusinterestattherateof0.54%perannum.Issues:

1. Aretheinterestpaymentsontheloanentitledtothe10%preferentialtaxrateundertheRP-JapanTaxTreaty?

2. Istheloanagreementsubjecttodocumentarystamptax(DST)?

Rulings:

1. Yes.UndertheRP-JapanTaxTreaty,interestonforeignloansmayqualifyforthe10%preferentialtaxrateonthegrossamountoftheinterestiftherecipientofsuchinterestisalsothebeneficialownerthereof.

2. Yes.TheloanagreementissubjecttoDSTimposedunderSection179oftheTaxCodeattherateofPhp1.00oneachPhp200.00oftheissuepriceofsuchloanagreement.

BIR Ruling No. 168-13 dated April 30, 2013

Facts:

CCo.,anon-residentforeigncorporationbasedintheCaymanIslands,owns65%ofthesharesinPCo.,adomesticcorporation.In2009,PCo.declaredcashdividendstoCCo.ACertificateofUndertakingastotheTaxConcessionsLawoftheCaymanIslandswaspresentedtoprovethatnolawimposinganytaxonprofits,income,gainsorappreciationsshallapplytoCCo.oritsoperations.

Issue:

ArethecashdividendsdeclaredbyPCo.infavorofCCo.subjecttothe15%FWTunderSection28(B)(5)(b)oftheTaxCode?

Ruling:

Yes.The15%FWTondividendsdistributedtonon-residentforeigncorporationspursuanttoSection28(B)(5)(b)oftheTaxCodeappliesintwoinstances:(1)whenthecountryofdomicileofthenon-residentforeigncorporationreceivingthedividendsallows,asacreditagainstthetaxdueintherecipient’shomecountry,adeemedpaidtaxcreditequivalentto15%;or(2)whenthecountryofdomicileofthenon-residentforeigncorporationreceivingthedividendsdoesnotimposeanytaxondividends.SincethelawsoftheCaymanIslandsdonotimposeanytaxonprofits,income,gainsorappreciationsofitsresidentcorporations,anydividendstobepaidbyPCo.toCCo.aresubjecttothe15%FWTunderSection28(B)(5)(b)oftheTaxCode.

UndertheRP-JapanTaxTreaty,interestonforeignloansextendedbyaresidentofJapantoaresidentofthePhilippinesmayqualifyforthe10%preferentialtaxrateonthegrossamountofinterestiftherecipientofsuchinterestisalsothebeneficialownerthereof.

TheloanagreementissubjecttoDSTimposedunderSection179oftheTaxCodeattherateofPhp1.00oneachPhp200.00oftheissuepriceofsuchloanagreement.

DividendspaidbyadomesticcorporationtoaresidentoftheCaymanIslandsaresubjecttothe15%FWTunderSection28(B)(5)(b)oftheTaxCode.

Page 6: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

6 Tax Bulletin

BIR Ruling No. 178-13 dated May 17, 2013

Facts:

ACo.,adomesticcorporation,soldtwoparcelsoflandtoBCo.,anotherdomesticcorporation.TheDSTontheDeedofAbsoluteSalewaspaid.TheTransferCertificatesofTitle(TCTs)inthenameofsellerACo.weresubsequentlycancelledandnewTCTswereissuedinthenameofbuyerBCo.However,forfailureofBCo.tocomplywithcertainobligations,thecontractbetweenACo.andBCo.wasrescindedbyvirtueofacourtorder.Pursuanttothecourtorder,BCo.wasorderedtoreconveytheTCTstoACo.

Issues:

1. IsthereconveyanceofTCTssubjecttocapitalgainstax(CGT)andDST?

2. IstheDSTpaidupontheexecutionofDeedofAbsoluteSalerefundable?

Ruling:

1. No.Therescissionofacontractwouldnotgiverisetoataxableeventfortworeasons:(1)Theresultofrescissionisasiftherewasnosale,transferorexchange.Hence,noincomeisrealized.(2)Thereturnoftheobjectoftherescindedcontractisnotformonetaryconsiderationandismerelyanacknowledgementorconfirmationofthetitleandownershipoftheoriginalowneroftheproperty.Hence,thereconveyanceofTCTsbyvirtueofarescissionofthecontractofsaleisnotsubjecttoCGTandDST.

2. No.IntheSupremeCourtcaseofPhilippine Home Assurance Corporation, et al. vs Court of Appeals, et al.,(G.R.No.119446datedJanuary21,1999),theCourtruledthattheDSTmustbepaidupontheissuanceofinstruments,withoutregardtowhetherthecontractswhichgaverisetothemarerescissible,void,voidable,orunenforceable.Hence,thesubsequentcancellationofthetransactiontowhichtheDSTliabilityattachesdoesnothavetheeffectofcancellingtheDSTliability.

BIR Ruling No. 184-2013 dated May 20, 2013

Facts:

ACo.isadomesticorganizationengagedintheadministrationofactivitiesforthewelfareofthephysical,mental,educationalandspiritualfacultiesofmanthroughpreaching,healthseminarsandservices,andthetrainingofmembersformissionaryactivities.ACo.requestedfortheissuanceofacertificateoftaxexemptionasacivicleagueororganizationnotorganizedforprofitbutoperatedexclusivelyforthepromotionofsocialwelfare,pursuanttoSection30(G)oftheTaxCode.

Issues:

1. CanacertificateoftaxexemptionbeissuedtoACo.?

2. IsACo.subjecttointernalrevenuetaxes?

3. IsACo.subjecttoanytaxreportingobligations?

ReconveyanceoflandtitlesbyvirtueoftherescissionofacontractofsaleisnotsubjecttoCGTandDST.TheDSTpreviouslypaiduponexecutionofaDeedofAbsoluteSalecannotberefundedbyreasonoftherescissionofthecontractofsale.

Foranorganizationtobeissuedacertificateoftaxexemption,ithastoprovebyactualoperationforatleastthreeyearsthatitisanorganizationexemptfromincometaxunderSection30(G)oftheTaxCode,subjecttootherrequirements.

Page 7: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

7

Rulings:

1. No.AnorganizationhastoprovebyactualoperationforatleastthreeyearsthatitisreallyanorganizationexemptfromincometaxunderSection30(G)oftheTaxCode.Forthispurpose,anorganizationcanfilethenecessaryannualinformationreturn,insteadofanincometaxreturn,onorbeforethe15thdayofthe4thmonthfollowingtheendofitstaxableyear,asrequiredunderSection24ofRRNo.2-40.Basedontheinformationreturn,theBIRwillconductaninvestigationontheactivitiesundertakenbytheorganizationduringthatperiod,andacertificateoftaxexemptionmaybeissueddependingontheresultsoftheinvestigation.

Forpurposesofsecuringapermanentexemptionafterthethree-yearperiod,ACo.isrequiredtosubmitthefollowingpursuanttoRMCNo.14-2001:

a. CertifiedtruecopyoftheCertificateofRegistrationwiththeSEC;

b. CertifiedtruecopyoftheArticlesofIncorporation,whichincludesthefollowingprovisions:

i. ThatACo.isnon-stockandnon-profit;

ii. ThattheprimarypurposeforwhichitwascreatedisoneofthoseenumeratedunderSec.30oftheTaxCode;

iii. Thatnopartofthenetincomeshallinuretothebenefitofanyofitsmembers;

iv. Thatthetrusteesdonotreceiveanycompensation;and

v. Thatincaseofdissolution,assetsofthecorporationshallbetransferredtosimilarinstitutionsortothegovernment;

c. CertifiedtruecopyoftheBy-Laws;

d. CertifiedtruecopyoftheAnnualInformationReturnsandFinancialStatementsforthelastthreeyearsofoperation;

e. CertificationunderoaththattherehasnotbeenanychangeintheBy-Laws,ArticlesofIncorporation,mannerofactivitiesaswellasthesourcesanddispositionofincome;and

f. BIRCertificateofRegistration.

2. Yes.ACo.issubjecttothefollowinginternalrevenuetaxes:

a. Taxonincomederivedfromitsproperties,realorpersonal,oranyactivityconductedforprofitregardlessofthedispositionthereof;

b. 20%FWToninterestincomefromcurrencybankdepositsandyieldoranymonetarybenefitsderivedfromdepositsubstitutesandfromtrustfundsandsimilararrangements,androyaltiesderivedfromsourceswithinthePhilippines;and

c. 7.5%FWToninterestincomederivedfromadepositorybankundertheexpandedforeigncurrencydepositsystem.

Page 8: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

8 Tax Bulletin

3. Yes.ACo.issubjecttothefollowingreportingobligations:

a. Filingonorbeforethe15thdayofthe4thmonthfollowingtheendoftheaccountingperiodaProfitandLossStatementandBalanceSheetwiththeAnnualInformationReturnunderoath,statingitsgrossincomeandexpensesincurredduringtheprecedingperiodandacertificateshowingthattherehasnotbeenanychangeinitsBy-Laws,ArticlesofIncorporation,mannerofoperationandactivitiesaswellassourcesofdispositionofincome;

b. Actingasawithholdingagentofthegovernmentifitactsasanemployeranditsemployeesreceivecompensationincomesubjecttowithholdingtax,orifitmakesincomepaymentstoindividualsorcorporationssubjecttoexpandedwithholdingtax(EWT);

c. Maintenanceofbooksofaccountandotherpertinentrecordsoftax-exemptorganizationsorgranteesoftaxincentives,whichshallbesubjecttoBIRexamination;

d. PaymentofannualregistrationfeeofPhp500.00;and

e. Issuanceofdulyregisteredreceiptsorsalesorcommercialinvoicesforeachsaleortransferofmerchandiseorforservicesrendered,whicharenotdirectlyrelatedtotheactivitiesforwhichtheassociationisregistered.

BIR Issuances

Revenue Regulations No. 9-2013 dated May 10, 2013

• Section6ofRRNo.30-2002isamendedtoreadasfollows:

“SECTION6.APPROVALOFOFFEROFCOMPROMISE–ExceptforoffersofcompromisewheretheapprovalisdelegatedtotheREBpursuanttothesucceedingparagraph,allcompromisesettlementswithinthejurisdictionoftheNationalOffice(NO)shallbeapprovedbyamajorityofallthemembersoftheNEBcomposedoftheCommissionerandthefourDeputyCommissioners.AlldecisionsoftheNEB,grantingtherequestofthetaxpayerorfavorabletothetaxpayer,shallhavetheconcurrenceoftheCommissioner.

xxx

Thecompromiseoffershallbepaidbythetaxpayeruponfilingoftheapplicationforcompromisesettlement.Noapplicationforcompromisesettlementshallbeprocessedwithoutthefullsettlementoftheofferedamount.Incaseofdisapprovaloftheapplicationforcompromisesettlement,theamountpaiduponfilingoftheaforesaidapplicationshallbedeductedfromthetotaloutstandingtaxliabilities.”

xxx

• TheseRegulationsshalltakeeffect15daysafterpublicationinanynewspaperofgeneralcirculation.

[Editor’s Note: RR No. 9-2013 was published in the ManilaBulletin on May 11, 2013.]

RRNo.9-2013amendscertainprovisionsofRRNo.30-2002onthepaymentoftheamountofferedascompromisesettlementpursuanttoSection204oftheTaxCode.

Page 9: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

9

Revenue Regulations No. 10-2003 dated May 2, 2013

• Section2.57.2(A)(1)ofRRNo.2-98,aslastamendedbyRRNo.30-2003,isfurtheramendedtoreadasfollows:

“Section 2.57.2. Income payments subject to creditable withholding tax and rates prescribed thereon. - xxx xxx

(A) Professional fees, talent fees, etc., for services rendered by individuals.–Onthegrossprofessional,promotionalandtalentfeesoranyotherformofremunerationfortheservicesofthefollowingindividuals–15%ifthegrossincomeforthecurrentyearexceedsPhp720,000.00,and10%ifotherwise:

(1) Thoseindividuallyengagedinthepracticeofprofessionorcallings:xxxdesigners,realestateservicepractitioners(RESPs),(i.e.,realestateconsultants,realestateappraisersandrealestatebrokers)requiringagovernmentlicensureexaminationgivenbytheRealEstateService,pursuanttoRepublicActNo.9646,andallotherprofessionsrequiringgovernmentlicensureexaminationsregulatedbytheProfessionalRegulationsCommission,SupremeCourt,etc.xxx”

• Section2.57.2(G)ofRR2-98,aslastamendedbyRR14-2002,isfurtheramendedtoreadasfollows:

“(G) Income payments to certain brokers and agents.-Ongrosscommissionsofcustoms,insurance,stock,immigrationandcommercialbrokers,feesofagentsofprofessionalentertainersandrealestateservicepractitioners(RESPs),(i.e.,realestateconsultants,realestateappraisersandrealestatebrokers)whofailedordidnottakeupthelicensureexaminationgivenbyandnotregisteredwiththeRealEstateServiceundertheProfessionalRegulationsCommission–10%.”

• TheseregulationsshalltakeeffectonJune1,2013andshallcoverincomepaymentstobepaidorpayablestartingJune1,2013,whicharerequiredtoberemittedwithinthemonthofJuly,2013.

[Editor’s Note: RR No. 10-2013 was published in the ManilaBulletin on June 8, 2013.]

Revenue Regulations No. 11-2013 dated May 20, 2013

• Section2.83ofRRNo.2-98isfurtheramendedtoreadasfollows:

“Sec.2.83.StatementsandReturns.—

Section2.83.1.Employees Withholding Statements (BIR Form No. 2316).—Ingeneral,everyemployerorotherpersonwhoisrequiredtodeductandwithholdthetaxoncompensation,includingfringebenefitsgiventorankandfileemployees,shallfurnisheveryemployeefromwhosecompensationtaxeshavebeenwithheldtheCertificateofCompensationPayment/TaxWithheld(BIRFormNo.2316)onorbeforeJanuary31ofthesucceedingcalendaryear,orifemploymentisterminatedbeforethecloseofsuchcalendaryear,onthedayonwhichthelastpaymentofcompensationismade.Failuretofurnishthesameshallbeagroundforthemandatoryauditofpayor’sincometaxliabilities(includingwithholdingtax)uponverifiedcomplaintofthepayee.

RRNo.10-2003amendsRRNo.2-98toincludeRealEstateServicePractitioners(i.e.,realestateconsultants,appraisersandbrokers):(1)whopassedthelicensureexaminationgivenbytheRealEstateService,pursuanttoRANo.9646“TheRealEstateServiceActofthePhilippines,”asamongthoseprofessionalsfallingunderSection2.57.2(A)(1)ofRRNo.2-98subjecttothe10%or15%EWTonprofessionals;and(2)thosewhodidnotpassordidnottakethelicensureexaminationgivenbytheRealEstateServiceamongthebrokersandagentsunderSection2.57.2(G)ofRRNo.2-98.

RRNo.11-2013requiresthefiling/submissionofhardcopyoftheCertificateofCompensationPayment/TaxWithheld(BIRForm2316)coveringemployeeswhoarequalifiedforsubstitutedfiling.

Page 10: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

10 Tax Bulletin

EmployersofMinimumWageEarners(MWEs)arestillrequiredtoissueBIRFormNo.2316(June2008Encsversion)totheMWEsonorbeforeJanuary31ofthefollowingyear.

Asarule,theemployershallfurnisheachemployeewiththeoriginalandduplicatecopiesofBIRFormNo.2316showingthenameandaddressoftheemployer;employer’sTIN;nameandaddressoftheemployee;employee’sTIN;amountofexemptionsclaimed,amountofpremiumpaymentsonhealthand/orhospitalizationinsurancenotexceedingPhp2,400.00,ifany;thesumofcompensationpaidincludingthenon-taxablebenefits;theamountofstatutoryminimumwagereceivedbyMWEs;Overtimepay,holidaypay,nightshiftdifferentialpayandhazardpayreceivedbyMWEs;theamountoftaxdue;theamountoftaxwithheldduringthecalendaryearandsuchotherinformationasmayberequired.Thestatementmustbesignedbyboththeemployerorotherauthorizedofficerandtheemployee,andshallcontainawrittendeclarationthatitismadeunderthepenaltiesofperjury.IftheemployeristheGovernmentofthePhilippines,itspoliticalsubdivision,agencyorinstrumentalityorgovernment-ownedorcontrolledcorporation,thestatementshallbesignedbythedulydesignatedofficeroremployee.

However,incasescoveredbysubstitutedfiling,theemployershallfurnisheachemployeewiththeoriginalcopyofBIRFormNo.2316andfile/submittotheBIRtheduplicatecopynotlaterthanFebruary28followingthecloseofthecalendaryear.

xxx”

• Anyemployer/withholdingagent,includingthegovernmentoranyofitspoliticalsubdivisionsandgovernmentownedandcontrolledcorporations,who/whichfailstocomplywiththeabovefiling/submissionofBIRFormNo.2316withinthetimerequiredbyRRNo.11-2013,maybeheldliableunderSection250oftheTaxCodewhichprovides:

“Inthecaseofeachfailuretofileaninformationreturn,statementorlist,orkeepanyrecord,orsupplyanyinformationrequiredbythisCodeorbytheCommissioneronthedateprescribedtherefor,unlessitisshownthatsuchfailureisduetoreasonablecauseandnottowillfulneglect,thereshall,uponnoticeanddemandbytheCommissioner,bepaidbythepersonfailingtofile,keeporsupplythesame,Php1,000.00foreachsuchfailure:Provided,however,ThattheaggregateamounttobeimposedforallsuchfailuresduringacalendaryearshallnotexceedPhp25,000.00.”

• However,anyemployer/withholdingagent,includingthegovernmentoranyofitspoliticalsubdivisionsandgovernmentownedandcontrolledcorporations,who/whichfailstocomplywiththeabovefiling/submissionofBIRForm2316withinthetimerequiredbyRRNo.11-2013fortwoconsecutiveyearsmaybedealtwithinaccordancewithSection255whichprovidesinpart:

“AnypersonrequiredunderthisCode,orbyrulesandregulationspromulgatedthereunder,topayanytax,makeanyreturn,keepanyrecord,orsupplycorrectandaccurateinformation,whowilfullyfailstopaysuchtax,makesuchreturn,keepsuchrecord,orsupplysuchcorrectandaccurateinformation,orwithholdorremittaxeswithheld,orrefundexcesstaxeswithheldoncompensation,atthetimeortimesrequiredbylaworrulesandregulationsshall,inadditiontootherpenaltiesprovidedbylaw,uponconvictionthereof,bepunishedbyafineofnotlessthanPhp10,000.00andsufferimprisonmentofnotlessthanoneyearbutnotmorethan10years.”

Page 11: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

11

• Insettlementunderthissituation,thecompromisefeeshallbePhp1,000.00foreachBIRFormNo.2316notfiledwithoutanymaximumthreshold.

• RRNo.11-2013shalltakeeffectbeginningwiththecalendaryear2013.

[Editor’s Note: RR No. 10-2013 was published in the ManilaBulletin on June 8, 2013.]

Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 34-2013 dated April 22, 2013

• Responsibilities of the Heir/Executor/Administrator

1. Estatetaxreturnshallbefiledunderanyofthefollowingsituations:

a. Inallcasesoftransferssubjecttoestatetax;or

b. Where,thoughexemptfromestatetax,thegrossvalueoftheestateexceedsPhp200,000.00;or

c. Where,regardlessofthegrossvalue,theestateconsistsofregisteredorregistrablepropertysuchasrealproperty,motorvehicles,sharesofstockorothersimilarproperty,forwhichaclearancefromtheBIRisrequiredasaprerequisiteforthetransferofitsownershipinthenameofthetransferee.

2. Theheirs/authorizedrepresentative/administrator/executorshallfiletheestatetaxreturnwith,andpaythecorrespondingestatetaxto,theAuthorizedAgentBank(AAB),RevenueCollectionOfficer(RCO)ordulyauthorizedtreasurerofthecityormunicipalityintheRevenueDistrictOffice(RDO)havingjurisdictionovertheplaceofdomicileofthedecedentatthetimeofhisdeath.

3. Incaseofanon-residentdecedentwithanexecutororadministratorinthePhilippines,theestatetaxreturnshallbefiledwiththeAABoftheRDOwheresuchexecutor/administratorisregisteredorisdomiciled,ifnotyetregisteredwiththeBIR.

4. Fornon-residentdecedentwithnoexecutororadministratorinthePhilippines,theestatetaxreturnshallbefiledwiththeAABunderthejurisdictionofRDONo.39–SouthQuezonCity.

5. Infillingoutthereturn,theexecutor,administratororanyofthelegalheirsshallexerciseduediligenceinaccomplishingthesameproperly,fillingoutcompletelyitemswithvaluesandentering“0”intheboxtoindicatenoneornil,ifthereisnoapplicablevalue.

6. Theheir/authorizedrepresentative/administrator/executorshallsubmitalltheapplicabledocumentaryrequirementsasprescribedinAnnexesA-6andA-6.1ofRevenueMemorandumOrder(RMO)No.15-2003andproofofpaymenttotheRDOwhichhasjurisdictionovertheplaceofresidenceofthedecedent,ortotheRDOwheretheexecutororadministratorisregistered,ortoRDONo.39–SouthQuezonCity,whicheverisapplicable.

RMCNo.34-2013clarifiestheproperaccomplishmentandfilingofestatetaxreturns.

Page 12: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

12 Tax Bulletin

• Responsibilities of the RDO and Document Processing Division (DPD)

1. TheRDOshallprocesstheestatetaxreturninaccordancewiththeprocedureindicatedinRMONo.15-2003.

2. ExemptestatetaxreturnswhichhavetobefileddirectlywiththeRDO,andestatetaxreturnswithpayment,whichshallbereceivedbytheRCO,shallnotbereceivedbytheRDO/RCOiftheyarenotproperlyaccomplished.

3. TheRDOorDPD(forRegionalOfficeswithDPD)shallscrutinizetheentriesinthereturnsanddetermineanymissing/incompleteinformationforthetaxreturnswithpaymentfileddirectlywiththeAABs.

4. Withinfivedaysfromdiscovery,theDPDheadshalltransmitalistofestatetaxreturnswithmissing/incompleteinformation.

5. Withinfivedaysfromreceiptofthelist,theRDOshallviewandprintthereturnsandshallnotifyinwritingtheheir/authorizedrepresentative/administrator/executoroftheestateofsuchfactandrequiretheamendmentofthereturnwithinfivedaysfromreceiptofthewrittennotice.

6. TheRDOshallalsoimposethecompromisepenaltyforviolationofSection255oftheTaxCode,asprescribedunderRMONo.19-2007.Incaseoflatefiling,theapplicablepenaltiesundertheTaxCodeshallbeimposed.

Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 35-2013 dated April 25, 2013

“DEPARTMENT ORDER NO. 18-2013

AMENDMENTOFSECTION12OFDEPARTMENTORDERNO.03-08ENTITLED‘RULESANDREGULATIONSTOIMPLEMENTREPUBLICACT9400,ANACT

AMENDINGREPUBLICACT7227,OTHERWISEKNOWNASTHEBASESCONVERSIONANDDEVELOPMENTACTOF1992,ANDFOROTHERPURPOSES.’

SECTION1.Section12ofDOFDepartmentOrderNo.03-08isherebyamendedtoreadasfollows:

Section12.Availment of Incentives-Itisunderstoodthathenceforth,registeredEcozoneandFreeportEnterprisesalreadyavailingoftheincentivesandbenefitsunderRA9400inaccordancewiththeserules,shallbeexpresslydisqualifiedfromavailingoftheincentivesandbenefitsdefinedand/orgrantedunderotherlaws,rulesandregulations.QualifiedenterprisesalreadyenjoyingincentivesunderotherpreferentialregimesshouldhavetheirregistrationsthereundercancelledbeforetheymaysubsequentlyavailofthebenefitsprovidedunderRA9400.

SECTION2.RepealingClause-Allorders,circulars,memoranda,andotherissuances,orpartsthereof,whichareinconsistentwiththisDepartmentOrder,areherebyrepealedormodifiedaccordingly.SECTION3.Effectivity-ThisDepartmentOrdershalltakeeffect15daysafteritspublicationintheOfficialGazetteorintwonewspapersofgeneralcirculation.”

[Editor’s Note: DO No. 18-2013 was published in the PhilippineDailyInquirer on April 29, 2013.]

RMCNo.35-2013circularizesthefulltextofDONo.18-2013datedApril16,2013oftheDOFontheamendmentofSection12ofDONo.03-08entitled“RulesandRegulationstoImplementRepublicAct9400,AnActAmendingRepublicAct7277,otherwiseknownastheBasesConversionandDevelopmentActof1992”.

Page 13: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

13

Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 37-2013 dated April 25, 2013

• Salient Features of DOF DO No. 17-2013:

1. Port Accreditation–Onlyparticularportswillbeaccreditedforsensitivecommoditiessuchasoil,steel,grains,tiles,goldandvehicles,subjecttostandards,technicalrequirementsandapplicablelaws,rulesandregulations.AccreditedportsaretosubmittotheDOFmonthlytradestatisticalreportsthatwillbecross-checkedwithdatafromtheDepartmentofEnergy(DOE),PhilippinePortsAuthority(PPA),andotherrelevantagencies,onaper-volumeandper-vesselbasistoeliminatediscrepanciesinimportandconsumptiondata.

2. Submission of a Rolling Import Plan-Inordertobetteranticipateimports,theBOCshallrequireallimportersofsensitivecommoditiestosubmittheirannualrollingimportplanindicatingquantity,type,sourceandlocationofintendedportarrival.TheCommissionerofCustomsshallpre-authorizeimportationofsensitivecommoditiesinaccordancewiththeannualimportplan.

3. Trade Statistics Reconciliation–PortsshallsubmittotheBOCandtheDOFamonthlylistofimportationsarrivingperport,whetherseaorairport,internationalordomestic,andshallincludedetails,suchasdateofarrival,nameofcountry/portoforigin,capacityofvessel/aircraft,typeofcommodities,andconsigneedetails.

Collecteddatafromtheportsshallbecross-checkedwithdatafromtheDOE,PPA,andotherrelevantagencies,onaper-volumeandper-vesselbasis.

MonthlylistofimportationsfromJanuary2013shouldbesubmittedwithin10daysfromthedateofthisOrder.

4. Other measures

a. StrictimplementationofRRNo.2-2012,whichrequiresimporterstopayvalue-addedtax(VAT)andexcisetaxonalloilimportsuponarrivalinthePhilippines.

b. SubmissionofIncomeTaxReturnasreceivedbytheBIRasoneoftherequirementsforaccreditationofimporterswiththeBOC.

c. Conductofpost-auditexaminationsonimportationofsensitivecommodities.

d. BOCshallworkcloselywiththeBIRandtherespectivelocalgovernmentunits,subjecttoexistinglawsonexchangeofinformationwithregardtoimportersofsensitivecommodities.

e. ImprovereportingformsandadministrativesupporttotheBOCStatisticsOfficeandtheManagementInformationSystemandTechnologyGrouptocapturedatarequired.

5. Regular monitoring of cases filed against oil smugglers

a. Casesinvolvingoilsmugglingshallbeestablishedandpursued.

b. AsidefromthemonthlyRunAfterTheSmugglers(RATS)report,BOCshallsubmittotheDOFabimonthlystatusreportofoilsmugglingcases.

RMCNo.37-2013circularizesthefulltextofDOFDONo.17-2013datedApril11,2013.

Page 14: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

14 Tax Bulletin

Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 38-2013 dated May 2, 2013

• On the audit/investigation pursuant to issued Letters of Authority (LOAs)

1. Thenormalprocessand/orproceduresrelatedtoaudit/investigationarisingfromelectronicLettersofAuthority(eLAs)issuedwillnotbesuspendednotwithstandingthereceiptofLegalPetitionNotices(LPNs)questioningthevalidityandenforceabilityoftheeLAs.

2. TheNationalOfficeshallnolongerentertainanyLPNquestioningthevalidityandenforceabilityoftheeLAdulyissuedbytheconcernedRegionalDirectorfortheauditofataxpayerwithintheregion,inasmuchastheissuehasalreadybeenclarifiedunderRMCNo.6-2013.

3. Thereshallbenoimpedimenttotheinvestigationofthetaxpayer’sinternalrevenuetaxliabilitiesandtheeventualrecommendationfortheissuanceofaSubpoena Duces Tecum(SDT),ifwarranted,inaccordancewithRMONos.45-2010and88-2010.

• On the issuance of Preliminary Assessment Notice (PAN), Formal Letter of Demand (FLD) and Final Assessment Notice (FAN)

1. UponreceiptofthePANorFLDandFAN,thetaxpayerisgiven15or30days,asthecasemaybe,torebuttheassessmentuponcompliancewiththerequirementsoffilingaprotestpursuanttoRRNo.12-99.

2. AnyLPN,declarationoranysimilardocumentprotestingtheassessmentaddressedtotheCommissioneroranyofficialintheNationalOffice,withouttheissuanceofaFinalDecisiononDisputedAssessment(FDDA)fromtheregionaloffice,shallbeconsideredprematureandinvalid.

• Responsibility of Taxpayers on their LPN

1. TheBIRcanrefusetotransactofficialbusinesswithtaxagents/practitionerswhoarenotaccreditedbeforeit,asstatedinSection9ofRRNo.11-2006,asamendedandclarifiedinRMCNo.6-2013;

2. Theresponsibilityisonthetaxpayerstoensurethatthetaxagents/practitionerswhomtheychoosetoengageareaccreditedwiththeBIR.

Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 39-2013 dated April 4, 2013

• Allprotestletters,requestsforreinvestigation/reconsiderationandsimilarcorrespondencesshallonlybefiledbythetaxpayersortheirdulyauthorizedrepresentatives,inpersonorthroughregisteredmailwithreturncard,withtheOfficeoftheconcernedRegionalDirector(RD),AssistantCommissioner-LargeTaxpayersService(ACIR-LTS)andAssistantCommissioner-EnforcementService(ACIR-ES),whosignedthePANs,FANsandFLDs,forproperrecordingoftheprotestsandevaluationofthesameinaccordancewithSection228oftheTaxCode.

• Iftheaforesaidproceduresarenotfollowed,thenthelettersofprotest,requestsforreinvestigation/reconsiderationandsimilarcorrespondencesshallbeconsideredvoidandwithoutforceandeffect.

RMCNo.38-2013clarifiestheimplicationoflegalpetitionnotices/declarationsandsimilardocumentsontheaudit/assessmentprocess.

RMCNo.39-2013prescribestheguidelinesforreceiptofprotestlettersonFANsandothersimilarcorrespondences.

Page 15: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

15

• Theaboverevenueofficialsshallbeprimarilyresponsibleinensuringthepreparationofacomplete/accuratereportonallproteststhatwerefiledintheirrespectiveofficesanditspromptsubmissiontotheCommissionerofInternalRevenue(CIR)everyMondayofeachweekinhardandsoftcopies.

• Basedontheweeklyreport,theOfficeoftheCIRshallcreateadatabaseof

alllettersofprotest,requestsforreinvestigation/reconsiderationandsimilarcorrespondencesreceivedbythedifferentofficesoftheBIR.

• Anyprotestletter,requestforreinvestigation/reconsideration,orothersimilarcommunicationallegedlyfiledbyanytaxpayer,butnotincludedinthedatabase,shallbedeemedasnotofficiallyfiledwiththeBIRandshallnotbeusedasbasisforthegrantofanyrequestforreinvestigation/reconsiderationofanyFANorFDDAissuedagainstthetaxpayer.

• Allprotestletters,requestsforreinvestigation/reconsiderationorsimilar

correspondencesthatwillbeacceptedfromtaxpayersbeginningApril29,2013shallbeguidedbythisCircular.

Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 41-2013 dated April 17, 2013

• Definition of Terms

1. Childreferstoapersonbelow18yearsofage,oronewhoisover18butisunabletofullytakecareof,orprotect,himselforherselffromabuse,neglect,cruelty,exploitationordiscriminationbecauseofaphysicalormentaldisabilityorcondition.

2. Foster ChildreferstoachildplacedunderFosterCare.

3. Foster ParentreferstoapersondulylicensedbytheDSWDtoprovideFosterCare.

4. Agencyreferstoanychild-caringorchild-placinginstitutionlicensedandaccreditedbytheDSWDtoimplementtheFosterCareProgram.

• Who may be placed under Foster Care

1. Achildwhoisabandoned,surrendered,neglected,dependentororphaned;

2. Achildwhoisavictimofsexual,physical,oranyotherformofabuseorexploitation*;

3. Achildwithspecialneeds*;

4. Achildwhosefamilymembersaretemporarilyorpermanentlyunableorunwillingtoprovidethechildwithadequatecare;

5. Achildawaitingadoptiveplacementandwhowouldhavetobepreparedforfamilylife,includingachildwhohasalreadybeenmatchedforadoptionbutcontinuestoreceiveinstitutionalcare;

6. Achildwhoneedslong-termcareandclosefamilytiesbutwhocannotbeplacedfordomesticadoption*;

7. Achildwhoseadoptionhasbeendisrupted;

RMCNo.41-2013publishesofthefulltextoftheimplementingrulesandregulations(IRR)ofRepublicAct(RA)No.10165,otherwiseknownastheFosterCareActof2012.

Page 16: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

16 Tax Bulletin

8. Achildwhoisundersociallydifficultcircumstancessuchas,butnotlimitedto,astreetchild,achildinarmedconflictoravictimofchildlaborortrafficking*;

9. Achildwhocommittedaminoroffensebuthasbeenreleasedonrecognizance,orwhoisincustodysupervision,orwhosecasehasbeendismissed*;and

10. Achildwhoisinneedofspecialprotectionasassessedbyasocialworker,anagency,ortheDSWD*.

* Inthesecases,thechildmusthavenofamilywillingandcapableofcaringandprovidingforhim/her.

• Qualifications of a Foster Parent

1. Mustbeoflegalage;

2. Mustbeatleast16yearsolderthantheFosterChild,unlesstheapplicantisarelativeoftheFosterChild;

3. Musthaveagenuineinterest,capacityandcommitmentinparentingtheFosterChildandabletoprovidetheFosterChildwithafamilialatmosphere;

4. Musthaveahealthyandharmoniousrelationshipwitheachfamilymemberlivingwithhim/her;

5. Mustbeofgoodmoralcharacter;

6. Mustbephysicallyandmentallycapableandemotionallymature;

7. Musthavesufficientresourcestobeabletoprovideforthefamily’sneeds;and

8. Mustbewillingtobetrainedorreceiveadviceforthepurposeofincreasingorimprovinghisorherknowledge,attitudesandskillsincaringforachild.

9. ForanalientoqualifyasaFosterParent,he/shemust:(a)belegallydocumented;(b)possessallthequalificationsabove-stated;(c)haveresidedinthePhilippinesforatleast12continuousmonthsatthetimeoftheapplication;and(d)undertaketomaintainsuchresidenceuntiltheterminationofplacementbytheDSWDorexpirationoftheFosterFamilyCareLicense.

10. Forpurposesofdeterminingcontinuousresidence,thealienmustnothavespentmorethan60daysofthelast12-monthperiodpriortothefilingoftheapplicationoutsideofthePhilippines,andthenonlyformeritoriousreasons.

• Additional Exemption for Dependents

1. Thedefinitionoftheterm“dependent”underSection35(B)oftheTaxCodeshallbeamendedtoincludea“FosterChild”;

2. AFosterParentshallbeallowedanadditionalexemptionofPhp25,000.00foreachqualifieddependentprovided,however,thatthetotalnumberofdependents,includingaFosterChildqualifiedtobeclaimedasadependent

Page 17: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

17

forwhichadditionalexemptionsmaybeclaimed,shallnotexceedfour,asprovidedunderRANo.9504;

3. ThePhp25,000.00additionalexemptionforaFosterChildshallbeallowedonlyiftheperiodoffostercareisatleastacontinuousperiodofonetaxableyear;

4. OnlyoneFosterParentcantreattheFosterChildasadependentforaparticulartaxableyear.Assuch,nootherparentorFosterParentcanclaimsaidchildasadependentforthatperiod.

• Incentives to Agencies

1. ExemptionfromIncomeTax–AgenciesshallbeexemptfromincometaxonincomederivedbythemassuchorganizationspursuanttoSection30oftheTaxCode,asimplementedbyRRNo.13-98.

2. QualificationasaDoneeInstitution–Agenciescanalsoapplyforqualificationasdoneeinstitutions.

• Incentives to Donors

1. AllowableDeductions–DonorsshallbegrantedallowabledeductionsfromtheirgrossincometotheextentoftheamountdonatedtoAgenciesinaccordancewithSection34(H)oftheTaxCode.

2. ExemptionfromDonor’sTax–DonorsshallbeexemptedfromDonor’sTaxunderSection101oftheTaxCode,providedthatnotmorethan30%oftheamountofdonationsshallbespentforadministrativeexpenses.

Revenue Memorandum Order No. 12-2013 dated May 2, 2013

• OnlyBIRAccreditedPrintersshallbeauthorizedtoprintPrincipalandSupplementaryReceiptsandInvoicespursuanttoRRNo.15-2012.

• Printersthatwereissuedaprovisionalaccreditationnumbershallalsobeallowedtoprintprincipalandsupplementaryreceipts/invoices.Sub-contractingtonon-accreditedprinter/sisstrictlyprohibited.

• Taxpayersengagedinbusiness,whethergovernmentorprivate,thatusemanually-issuedreceipts/invoicesshallabidebytheguidelinesandproceduresprescribedinthisRMO.

• Taxpayersengagedinbusiness,whethergovernmentorprivate,thatusereceipts/invoicesissuedthroughCashRegisterMachine/Point-Of-SaleMachines(CRM/POS)and/orComputerizedAccountingSystem(CAS)arenotcoveredbythisRMO,butshallbecoveredbyaseparaterevenueissuance.

• AlltheinformationrequiredunderthisRMOintheprintingofORs/SIs/CIsshallbepreprintedonthefaceoftheloose-leafreceipts/invoicesusingcomputer-aidedmachines(e.g.,MSExcel).

• Nationalgovernmentagencies,governmentownedandcontrolledcorporationsandlocalgovernmentunitsreferredtohereasGovernmentInstrumentalities(GIs),shallbeguidedbythefollowingpolicies:

RMONo.12-2013prescribesadditionalpoliciesanduniformguidelinesandproceduresintheprocessingofATPORs,SIsandotherCIsintheinterimperioduntiltheOn-lineATPsystemisavailableforimplementation.

Page 18: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

18 Tax Bulletin

1. ForGIsengagedingovernmentalfunctions:

a. ApplyforregistrationwiththeBIRforunregisteredgovernmentalfunctions.

b. NotrequiredtosecureATPinprintingofGovernmentAccountableFormNo.51,RevenueOfficialReceipts(RORs),TaxReceiptsandotherreceiptsinwhatevernameorformbeingissuedforgovernmentalfunctions.

2. ForGIsengagedinproprietaryfunctions:

a. Forunregisteredproprietaryfunctions

Iftheregisteredaddressofthebusinessactivityissimilarorco-locatedwiththeGIwhosegovernmentalfunctionisalreadyregistered,theGIshallfilearegistrationinformationupdatebyfilingBIRFormNo.1905forthefollowing:

i. BusinessActivity/ies

ii. AdditionalTaxType/sDetails

iii. TradeName(ifapplicable)

iv. BooksofAccounts

v. IftheregisteredaddressofthebusinessactivityisotherthantheregisteredaddressoftheGI,theGIshallfileanApplicationforRegistrationasBranchusingBIRformNo.1903.

b. Forregisteredproprietaryfunctions,theGIisrequiredtosecureATPpriortotheprintingofitsprincipalandsupplementaryreceipts/invoicesindicatingallinformationrequiredunderthisRMO.

• TheapplicationforATP(BIRFormNo.1906,asrevised),togetherwiththe

necessarydocumentaryrequirements,shallbesubmittedtotheRevenueDistrictOffice(RDO)/LargeTaxpayerOffice(LTOffice)havingjurisdictionovertheHeadOffice(HO)ofthetaxpayer-applicant.

• TheoldBIRFormNo.1906shallstillbeuseduntiltherevisedformbecomesavailable.

• Intheinterim,allapplicationsforATPshallbeprocessedusingtheRegistrationSystemoftheIntegratedTaxSystem(ITS),whichshallgeneratetheprescribedATPunderRMONo.83-99,asamendedbyRMONo.28-2002.

• ThefollowinginformationshallbetypedorprintedontheATPthatwillserveasguide/referenceforaccreditedprintersinprintingprincipalandsupplementaryreceiptsandinvoices:

1. DateofATP

2. ValidityperiodoftheATP

3. Printer’sAccreditationNumber

4. DateofAccreditation

Page 19: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

19

• TheprincipalandsupplementaryreceiptsandinvoicesoftheHOandeachofthebranchesshallhaveitsownindependentseriesofserialnumbers.

• Ataxpayerwithexpiringprincipalandsupplementaryreceipts/invoicesshallapplyforanewATPnotlaterthan60dayspriortotheactualexpirydate.

• Procedurefortaxpayerapplicant:

1. Submitinventorylisting/sandsurrenderthehardcopiesoftheunused/expiredreceipts/invoices,togetherwithphotocopiesoftheoldandnewATPsandcorrespondingPrinter’sCertificateofDeliverytotheRDOwhereitisregistered.Branchoffice/sshallsubmitandsurrenderthesametotheRDO/LTOfficewherethebranchisregistered;

2. ChoosetheBIRAccreditedPrinterfromtheupdatedlistofdulyaccreditedprintersavailableintheBIRwebsite;

3. FiletheapplicationforATPwiththesupportingdocumentslistedbelow(attheRDO/LTOfficeconcernedwheretheHOisregisteredusingtheprescribedBIRForm):

a. Originalcopyofsamplelayout/templateofOR/SI/CI

b. OriginalPrinter’sJobOrder

c. PhotocopyofpreviousATP.Ifnotavailable,thelastseriesoftheprintedOR/SI/CI.Thenewsetofreceipts/invoicesshallcontinuewiththelastserialnumberindicatedinthepreviousATPissued.However,forprintingmachineswithlimitedcapacityastothemaximumrangeofserialnumbers,theserialnumbermaystartfromoneandprefixedwithaspecial/alphacodetoavoidduplication(e.g.,A0001)

d. PhotocopyofLoose-leafPermit,ifapplicable;

4. Anauthorizedrepresentativeisaduly-designatedresponsibleofficer/employeeofthecompanywithawrittenauthorizationdulysignedbythetaxpayer-applicantoraresponsibleofficer/employeeoftheaccreditedprinterasindicatedintheATPApplicationForm;

5. SignintheofficelogbookasproofofactualreceiptoftheapprovedATP;

6. BIRAccreditedPrintersshallsubmitthefollowingtotheRDO/LTOfficeconcerned:

a. QuarterlyReportofPrinter(BIRFormNo.1932,asrevised),onorbeforethe20thdayofthemonthfollowingtheendofeachcalendarquarter

b. Printer’sCertificateofDeliveryofReceipts/InvoicesandtheSwornStatementofthetaxpayerpursuanttoSection4ofRRNo.26-2003.

• Allunused/unissuedprincipalandsupplementaryreceipts/invoicesprintedpriortoJanuary19,2013(effectivityofRRNo.18-2012)andthoseprintedbyprinters,whicharenotcompliantwiththisRMO,shallbevaliduntilJune30,2013.

Page 20: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

20 Tax Bulletin

• Thetaxpayershallsubmitaninventorylistofprincipalandsupplementaryreceipts/invoices,andsurrenderthehardcopiesofthereceipts/invoicestotheRDO/LTOfficewherethetaxpayerisregisteredonorbeforeJuly10,2013.

• BranchOffice/sshallsubmitandsurrenderthesametotheRDO/LTOfficewherethebranchisregistered.

• Allnewset/sofprincipalandsupplementaryreceipts/invoicestobeprinted,whicharecompliantwiththerequirementsprescribedunderthisRMO,shallhaveavalidityperiodoffiveyears.

• Allunused/expired/expiringORs/SIs/CIsshallbesurrenderedtogetherwithaninventorylistingtotheBIROfficehavingjurisdictionoverthetaxpayerfordestructiononorbeforethe10thdayafterthevalidityperiodoftheexpiredreceipts/invoices.

• PendingtheavailabilityoftheOn-lineATPSystem,thescannedcopyoftheissuedATPshallbeprintedattheinsidebackportionofthecardboardcoverofeachbooklet/padofprincipalandsupplementaryreceipts/invoicesprinted.

• ATPsgeneratedthroughtheITSpursuanttothisRMOshallbemigratedtotheOn-lineATPSystemuponitsavailability,thenecessaryguidelinesandproceduresofwhichshallbeprescribedinaseparaterevenueissuance.

Revenue Memorandum Order No. 13-2013 dated May 2, 2013

• AllregisteredprintersintheITSwhoappliedforaccreditation,andwereinitiallyevaluatedbytheRDOs/officesunderLargeTaxpayersService(LTS)astothecompletenessofthedocumentaryrequirementsperOperationsMemorandumdatedJanuary24,2013shallbepublishedorpostedintheBIRwebsiteas‘deemedAccreditedPrinters’.

• AProvisionalAccreditationNumbershallbeissuedtoall‘deemedAccreditedPrinters’.

• TheProvisionalAccreditationshallbegivenavalidityperiodofsixmonthsfrompostingintheBIRwebsite.

• ACertificateofAccreditationwithPermanentAccreditationNumbershallbeissuedtotheprinteronlyafterevaluationandapprovalbytheNational/RegionalAccreditationBoard(N/RAB)withtheexclusionofthoseundertheInformationSystemsGroup(ISG).

• TheAccreditedPrinterswithCertificateofAccreditationshallceaseusingtheassignedProvisionalAccreditationNumber.

• ThePermanentAccreditationNumbershallbeusedinprintingORs,SIsand/orinvoices.

• The‘deemedAccreditedPrinters’,whichwereissuedRevocationNoticesshallnotbeallowedtoapplyforAuthoritytoPrint(ATP)ReceiptandInvoices.However,allreceiptsandinvoicesprintedbytheseprintersshallremainvaliduntilexpirationoruntilfullutilization,whichevercomesfirst.

• AllprintersissuedtheLetterofDenial/RevocationNoticewhointendtobeaccreditedwillobservethesameprocedureasanewapplicantforaccreditation,andshallundergothesameaccreditationprocess.

RMONo.13-2013prescribeswork-aroundprocedurespendingtheavailabilityoftheOnlineSystemforAccreditationofPrinters(OCAP)pursuanttoRRNo.15-2012datedDecember3,2012.

Page 21: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

21

• AlistofregisteredprintersintheITSandtaggedasTPENGAGEDINPRTGforatleastthreeyearsasofDecember31,2012shallbetheinitialcandidatesforaccreditation.

BOC Issuance

Customs Administrative Order No. 2-2013 dated May 2, 2013

• Immediatelyuponarrivalofthecarryingvessel,themasteroragentthereofmustsubmittothePiersandInspectionDivision(PID)oritsequivalentunitfoursetsoftheInwardForeignManifest,tobedistributedasfollows:

1. PIDorequivalentoffice;

2. IntelligenceEnforcementGroup;

3. AssessmentandOperationsCoordinatingGroup;

4. COAResidentAuditor.

• TheCommissionerofCustoms,uponconsultationwithprivatestakeholders,shallissuetherulesandregulationstoimplementCAONo.2-2013.

• Allorders,memoranda,circularsorpartsthereof,whichareinconsistentwithCAONo.2-2013aredeemedrevoked,amended,ormodifiedaccordingly.

• CAONo.2-2013shalltakeeffect15daysafterpublicationinanewspaperofgeneralcirculation.

[Editor’s Note: CAO No. 2-2013 was published in the ManilaTimes and ManilaStandardToday on May 9, 2013.]

PEZA Issuance

Memorandum Circular No. 2013-013 dated April 30, 2013

• The50%reductioninallPEZAprocessingfeesforecozoneimport/exportfullcontainerloadshipmentsattheBatangasInternationalPort(BIP)isextendedforanotheryear(January-December2013).

• ThePhilippinePortsAuthorityhasalsoreduceditsportcharges(portduesanddockageforvessels)by50%foraperiodofoneyear(January-December2013).

SEC Issuances

SEC Memorandum Circular No. 7 dated April 8, 2013.

• DuringitsmeetingonApril8,2013,theSECEn BancapprovedtheamendmentofRule3oftheImplementingRulesandRegulationsoftheLendingCompanyActof2007(RANo.9474)byrequiringlendingcompaniestocomplywiththeSingleBorrower’sLimit(SBL)andcreditlimitonDirectors,Officers,StockholdersandRelatedInterests(DOSRI).

• Thetotalcreditthatalendingcompanymayextendtoitsdirectors,officersandstockholdersshallnotexceed15%ofitsnetworth.

CustomsAdministrativeOrder(CAO)No.2-2013amendsCAONo.1-2007,whichrequiresthesubmissionofInwardForeignManifestandConsolidatedCargoManifest.

PEZAMCNo.2013-013announcesthesecondextensionofthe50%reductioninallPEZAprocessingfeesforEcozoneImport/ExportFull-ContainerLoadShipmentsviatheBIP.

SECMCNo.7prescribestheSBLandCreditLimitonDOSRIofalendingcompany.

Page 22: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

22 Tax Bulletin

• Forthispurpose,loansandothercreditextendedbyalendingcompanytothefollowingrelatedinterestsshallbedeemed“extendedtoitsdirectors,officersandstockholders”:

1. Spouseorrelativeswithinthefirstdegreeofconsanguinityoraffinity,orrelativesbylegaladoption,oftheofficer,directororstockholderofthelendingcompany;

2. Partnershipinwhichadirectororofficerorstockholderofthelendingcompany,ortheirspouseorrelativesreferredtointheprecedingitem1isageneralpartner;

3. Corporationswhereadirectororofficerorstockholderofthelendingcompanyortheirspouseorrelativesreferredtoinitem1aboveisalsoadirectororofficerofthecorporation;

4. Corporationswheremorethan20%ofitssubscribedcapitalstockisownedbyadirectororofficerorstockholderofthelendingcompanyortheirspouseorrelativesreferredtoinitem1above;

5. Corporationswhollyormajority-ownedorcontrolledbyentitiesmentionedinitems2,3and4above.

• Thetotalcreditthatalendingcompanymayextendtoanyperson,company,corporationorfirmshallnotexceed30%ofitsnetworth.

[Editor’s Note: SEC MC No. 7 was published in ManilaStandardToday on May 9, 2013.]

SEC Memorandum Circular No. 8 dated May 20, 2013.

• Allcoveredcorporationsshall,atalltimes,observetheConstitutionalorstatutoryownershiprequirement.

• TherequiredpercentageofFilipinoownershipshallbeappliedtoBOTH:

1. Thetotalnumberofoutstandingsharesofstockentitledtovoteintheelectionofdirectors;AND

2. Thetotalnumberofoutstandingsharesofstock,whetherornotentitledtovoteintheelectionofdirectors.

• AllCorporateSecretariesofcoveredcorporationsaredirectedtomonitorandobservecompliancewiththeownershiprequirements.TheCorporateSecretarycannotdelegatethisresponsibilitywithouttheexpressauthorityfromtheBoardofDirectorsorTrustees.

• Allcoveredcorporationswhicharenon-compliantshallbegivenaperiodofoneyearfromthedateofeffectivityofthisMCwithinwhichtocomplywithsaidownershiprequirement.

[Editor’s Note: SEC MC No. 8 was published in the BusinessMirror on May 22, 2013.]

SECMCNo.8prescribestheguidelinesforcomplyingwiththeFilipino-foreignownershiprequirementsasprescribedintheConstitutionandexistinglawsbycorporationsengagedinnationalizedandpartlynationalizedactivities.

Page 23: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

23

SEC Memorandum Circular No. 9 dated May 20, 2013

• OnMarch20,2013,theSECissuedMCNo.5,requiringalllistedcompaniestosubmitonMay30,2013theirAnnualCorporateGovernanceReport(ACGR)inaccordancewiththeguidelinessetforththerein.

• However,duetothenumberofrequestsreceivedandconsideringfurtherthatthisisthefirsttimesaidcompaniesshallbefilingthesaidreport,theSECinitsmeetingonMay20,2013approvedthegrantingofa30-dayextension(i.e.,untilJune30,2013)togiveampletimetoalllistedcompaniesincludingtheirrespectivesignatoriestocomplywithMCNo.5.

[Editor’s Note: SEC MC No. 9 was published in the PhilippineStar on May 23, 2013.]

BSP Issuance

BSP Circular No. 796 dated May 3, 2013

• TheprovisionsoftheManualofRegulationsforBanks(MORB)onthegeneralfeaturesofamicrofinancesavingsdepositaccountareamendedasfollows:

“G.GeneralFeaturesofaMicrofinanceSavingsDepositAccount

1. MinimummaintainingbalancenotexceedingPhp100.00

2. Notsubjecttodormancycharges

3. OnlyforindividualmicrofinanceclientswhoseaveragedailysavingsaccountbalancedoesnotexceedPhp40,000.00

xxx”

• ThisCircularshalltakeeffect15calendardaysfollowingitspublicationeitherintheOfficialGazetteorinanewspaperofgeneralcirculation.

[Editor’s Note: Circular No. 796 was published in the ManilaTimes on May 10, 2013.]

Court Decisions

First Lepanto Taisho Insurance Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSupremeCourt(ThirdDivision)G.R.No.197117promulgatedApril10,2013

Facts:

TheBIRassessedPetitionerFirstLepantoTaishoInsuranceCorporation(FirstLepanto),anon-lifeinsurancecorporationandalargetaxpayer,variousdeficiencytaxesfortheyear2007.

BecauseofinactionbytheBIRonitsprotest,FirstLepantoappealedtotheCourtofTaxAppeals(CTA)whichupheldthedeficiencytaxassessmentsforwithholdingtaxoncompensation(WTC),expandedwithholdingtax(EWT)andfinalwithholdingtax(FWT).TheCTAalsoorderedthepaymentofa20%delinquencyinterestfromthedateFirstLepantoreceivedtheFormalLetterofDemand(FLD)untilactualpaymentismade.

SECMCNo.9extendsthedeadlinetosubmittheACGRforlistedcompaniesfromMay30,2103toJune30,2013.

CircularNo.796amendsAppendix45(NotesonMicrofinance)ofSectionX361oftheMORB.

AstipulationbetweentheBIRandthetaxpayerattheCTAproceedingsthattaxeshavebeencorrectlyremittedtothegovernmentcannotbindthecourt.Thetaxpayerisstillrequiredtopresentproofthatitcorrectlyremittedthetaxes.

A20%delinquencyinterestisdueonunpaiddeficiencytaxesassessedbytheBIRcomputedfromthedateprescribedfortheirpaymentuntilfullpaymentismade.

Page 24: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

24 Tax Bulletin

FirstLepantoappealedtotheSupremeCourt.FirstLepantocontendedthat:(i)paymentstodirectors,notbeingemployees,shouldnotbesubjecttoWTC;and(ii)itnolongerneedstopresentevidenceontheEWTonitspaymentsforcontractorsandpurchases,sinceithadalreadystipulatedwiththeBIRattheCTAproceedingsthattheCompanywithheldthecorrectEWTonitspaymentsforcontractorsandpurchases.Issue:

IsFirstLepantoliableforthedeficiencytaxesandfordelinquencyinterest?

Ruling:

Yes.FirstLepantoisliablefordeficiencyWTC,EWTandFWTandfordelinquencyinterest.

OntheWTCassessment,adirectorwasconsideredanemployeeundertheWithholdingTaxRegulationstheninforce.TheCompanyfailedtoprovewithdocumentsthatthedirectorswerenotitsemployees.Hence,thepaymentsareproperlysubjecttoWTC.

TheCompanyalsofailedtoprovewithrelevantsourcedocuments(suchasreimbursementforms/voucherswithattachedSIs/ORs,withappropriatetracingtospecificgeneralledgerentries)thatthepaymentsoffixedtransportation,subsistenceandlodgingallowances,andfixedrepresentationexpensestoemployeesweremerereimbursementsofactualexpenses.Becauseofthis,theallowancesaretreatedasemployees’compensationsubjecttoWTC.

OntheEWTassessment,FirstLepantofailedtopresentdocuments(likereinsuranceagreements/contracts)toshowthatthecommissionswerepaidtoinsurancecompanies,whicharenotagentsorbrokers,andtherefore,shouldnotbesubjecttoEWT.Therewasalsounder-withholdingofEWTontheCompany’soccupancycosts.

OntheargumentthattheBIRandtheCompanyhavejointlystipulatedattheCTAproceedingsthattheCompanyhadcorrectlywithheldtheEWTdueonpaymentsforcontractorsandpurchases,and,therefore,isnolongerrequiredtopresentevidenceontherelatedEWTremittance,stipulationscannotdefeattherightoftheStatetocollectthecorrecttaxesduebecausetaxesarethelifebloodofournationanditscollectionshouldbeactivelypursued.

OntheFWTassessment,FirstLepantofailedtopresentproofofFWTremittanceonpaymentsofdividendsandcomputerizationexpensestonon-residentforeigncorporations.

Finally,theCompanyfailedtopaythedeficiencytaxassessedwithinthetimeprescribedforitspayment.Hence,the20%delinquencyinterestiscorrectlyimposedontheunpaiddeficiencytaxesassessed,reckonedfromthedateprescribedforitspaymentuntilfullpaymentismade.

Page 25: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

25

Pelizloy Realty Corporation vs. The Province of BenguetSupremeCourt(ThirdDivision)G.R.No.183137promulgatedApril10,2013

Facts:

PetitionerPelizloyRealtyCorporation(Pelizloy)ownsPalmGroveResort,whichhasfacilitieslikeswimmingpools,spa,andfunctionhallslocatedinTuba,Benguet.

TheProvinceofBenguetenactedtheBenguetRevenueCodeof2005,whichlevieda10%amusementtaxongrossreceiptsfromadmissionsto“resorts,swimmingpools,bathhouses,hotspringsandtouristspots.”

PelizloyquestionedthevalidityoftheprovisionbeforetheSecretaryofJustice.UponfailureoftheSecretarytodecidewithinthe60day-periodprovidedundertheLGC,PelizloyfiledaPetitionforDeclaratoryReliefwiththeRegionalTrialCourt(RTC)inLaTrinidad,Benguet.

PelizloyarguedthattheBenguetRevenueCodeimposedapercentagetax,whichprovincesarenotallowedtolevyunderthecommonlimitationsonthetaxingpowersofLGUs.Section133(i)oftheLGCprohibitsLGUsfromimposingpercentagetaxorVATonsales,barters,exchangesorsimilartransactionsongoodsorservices,exceptwhenotherwiseprovidedbytheLGC.

TheRTCdismissedthepetition.PelizloyappealedtotheSupremeCourt.

Issues:

1. IstheamusementtaxapercentagetaxwhichtheProvinceofBenguetisnotallowedtolevy?

2. Canprovincesimposeamusementtaxesonadmissionfeestoresorts,swimmingpools,bathhouses,hotspringsandtouristspots?

Ruling:

1. Yes.TheamusementtaxleviedundertheBenguetRevenueCodeisapercentagetax.However,aprovinceisallowedtolevyamusementtaxesundertheLGC.

Apercentagetaxisataxmeasuredbyacertainpercentageofthegrosssellingpriceorgrossvalueinmoneyofgoodssold,barteredorimported;orofthegrossreceiptsorearningsderivedbyanypersonengagedinthesaleofservices.TheTaxCodelistsamusementtaxesasamongthepercentagetaxes,whichareleviedregardlessofwhetherornotataxpayerisalreadyliabletopayVAT.

Amusementtaxesarefixedatacertainpercentageofthegrossreceiptsincurredbyspecifiedestablishments.Hence,theamusementtaxleviedundertheBenguetRevenueCodeisapercentagetax.

WhiletheLGCprohibitsallLGUs,includingprovinces,fromlevyingpercentagetaxes,theLGCallowsprovincestolevyandcollectanamusementtax,whichisapercentagetax,fromproprietors,lessees,oroperatorsoftheaters,cinemas,concerthalls,circuses,boxingstadia,andotherplacesofamusement.

Swimmingpools,bathhouses,andhotspringscannotbeconsideredas“otherplacesofamusement”subjecttoamusementtaxesundertheLGC.

Page 26: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

26 Tax Bulletin

However,provincesarenotbarredfromlevyingamusementtaxesbecauseSection133(i)oftheLGCspecificallyprovidesthattheprohibitionissubjecttoexceptionswhichmaybeprovidedundertheLGC.Section140oftheLGCexpresslyallowstheimpositionbyprovincesofamusementtaxes“tobecollectedfromtheproprietors,lessees,oroperatorsoftheaters,cinemas,concerthalls,circuses,boxingstadia,andotherplacesofamusement.”

2. No.Provincesmaynotimposeanamusementtaxonadmissionfeestoswimmingpools,resorts,bathhouses,hotsprings,andtouristspots,asthesefacilitiesdonotqualifyas“otherplacesofamusement”undertheLGC.

Section131(c)oftheLGCdefines“amusementplaces”as“theaters,cinemas,concerthalls,circusesandotherplacesofamusementwhereoneseeksadmissiontoentertainoneselfbyseeingorviewingtheshoworperformances.”Accordingly,“otherplacesofamusement”mustbeinterpretedasvenueswhereoneseeksadmissiontoentertainoneselfbyseeingorviewingtheshoworperformancesorasvenuesprimarilyusedtostagespectaclesorholdpublicshows,exhibitions,performances,andothereventsmeanttobeviewedbyanaudience.

Waterfront Philippines, Inc. vs. Commissioner of Internal RevenueCourtofTaxAppeals(SpecialFirstDivision)CaseNo.8024promulgatedApril24,2013

Facts:

RespondentCommissionerofInternalRevenue(CIR)assessedPetitionerWaterfrontPhilippines,Inc.(Waterfront)forallegeddeficiencytaxesfortaxableyear2006,includingVAToninterestincomederivedfromloansgrantedtoaffiliatesMetroAllianceHoldingsandEquitiesCorporationandWellexGroup,Inc.

TheCIRclaimsthatintheordinarycourseofbusiness,Waterfrontextendsandobtainscashadvancesandloanstoandfromrelatedpartiestomeetworkingcapitalrequirementsandtofinancetheconstructionandoperationofitshotelprojects,infurtheranceoftheprimarypurposestatedintheArticlesofIncorporation.TheCIRallegesthatsaidinterestincomeissubjecttoVAT.Waterfrontprotestedtheassessment.

UpondenialofitsprotestbytheCIR,WaterfrontfiledaPetitionforReviewwiththeCTA.TheCTAFirstDivisionruledthattheinterestincomefromloansoradvancesgrantedtoaffiliatesbyWaterfront,whichisnotengagedinthebusinessoflendingmoney,isnotsubjecttoVAT.TheCIRfiledaMotionforReconsiderationandarguedthatWaterfrontwasassessedfordeficiencyVATnotasalendinginvestorbutforinterestincomerealizedfromloansandadvancesgrantedtorelatedpartiesintheordinarycourseoftradeorbusiness.

InterestincomefromloansandadvancestoaffiliatesisconsideredasrevenuerealizedfromservicesrenderedinthenormalcourseoftradeorbusinessthatissubjecttoVAT.

Page 27: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

27

Issue:

IstheinterestincomederivedbyWaterfrontfromloansandadvancesgrantedtoaffiliatessubjecttoVAT?

Ruling:

Yes.TheinterestincomefromloansandadvancesextendedbyWaterfronttoitsaffiliatesissubjecttoVAT.

TheCIRassessedWaterfrontfordeficiencyVATnotasalendinginvestorbutbecausetheinterestincomereceivedisrevenuerealizedfromservicesrenderedinitsnormalcourseoftradeorbusiness.

Section105oftheTaxCodedefines‘inthecourseoftradeorbusiness’astheregularconductorpursuitbyanypersonofacommercialoraneconomicactivity,includingtransactionsincidentalthereto.Section108oftheTaxCodealsoprovidesthatVATisdueonthe‘saleorexchangeofservices’ortheperformanceofallkindsofservicesinthePhilippinesforothersforafeeorconsiderationregardlessofwhethertheperformanceofsuchservicescallsfortheexerciseoruseofphysicalormentalfaculties.

TheCTAcitedDiaz, et al. vs. Secretary of Finance, et al. promulgated on July 19, 2011,wheretheSupremeCourtheldthatVATisimposedonallkindsofservicesinthePhilippinesforafee.TheenumerationofservicessubjecttoVATinSection108oftheTaxCodeisnotexclusive.ThelistingofspecificservicesillustrateshowbroadtheVATcoverageis.Everyactivitythatcanbeimaginedasaformofservicerenderedforafeeshouldbedeemedincludedunlessaspecificprovisionoflawexcludesit.Thus,whetherWaterfrontisalendinginvestorwouldnotbematerialasitisonlyoneoftheactivitiessubjecttoVATenumeratedinSection108oftheTaxCode.

Waterfrontextendedcashadvancestoitsaffiliates,whichisclearlyaperformanceofserviceforafee(withinterestasthefeeorconsideration)thatiscoveredbytheVATprovisionsoftheTaxCode.Whiletheactofextendingcashadvanceswithinteresttoaffiliatesmaybeanisolatedtransaction,itdoesnotfollowthatthesamecannotbetreatedasanincidentaltransactionsubjecttoVAT.

[Editor’s Note: This is an ‘Amended Decision’ of the CTA Special First Division reversing the ruling of the CTA First Division in its ‘Decision’ promulgated on November 13, 2012, which was published in the November 2012 Tax Bulletin.]

Page 28: May 2013 Tax bulletin - Building a better working world - … Issuances • Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 9-2013 amends certain provisions of RR No. 30-2002 on the payment of the amount

28 Tax Bulletin

Wewelcomeyourcomments,ideasandquestions.PleasecontactMa.FidesA.Baliliviae-mailatMa.Fides.A.Balili@ph.ey.comorattelephonenumber894-8113andMarkAnthonyP.Tamayoviae-mailatMark.Anthony.P.Tamayo@ph.ey.comorattelephonenumber894-8391.

SyCip Gorres Velayo & Co.6760AyalaAvenue,MakatiCity,PhilippinesTelephone:(632)891-0307Fax:(632)819-0872

©2013SyCipGorresVelayo&Co.AllRightsReserved.FEAno.1000065

SGV&Co.maintainsofficesinMakati,Cebu,Davao,Bacolod,CagayandeOro,Baguio,GeneralSantosandCavite.

ForanelectroniccopyoftheTaxBulletinorforfurtherinformationaboutTaxServices,pleasevisitourwebsitewww.sgv.ph

Expirydate:noexpiry