mba thesis - copy new
TRANSCRIPT
1. Introduction
In the age of Globalization, where the survival is a question mark
for the industries growth and development of the organization, depends
only on the employee relations with management. A company with strong
employee relations gets the benefit, because their employees are highly
motivated to expand their best efforts. In exchange, the employees expect
to be treated fairly and recognized for the achievements.. To develop and
sustain relation, employers must keep employees informed of company
policies and strategies. That way, employee can learn new behaviors or
skills as needed and understand the workings of the firm more fully. In
addition employers must have policies that allow employees to discuss
problems with or communicate important information to company
representatives that can fully respond effectively.
HR specialists play a crucial role in employee relations. If they
develop communication policies and procedures that apply appropriate
communication tool in a timely manner, employees can access more
abundant, higher quality information and can work in partnership to
ensure that the communication policies and procedures bolster employee
relations.
Good employee relations involve providing fair and consistent
treatment to all employees, so that they will be committed to the
organization. Companies with good employee relations are likely to have
an HR strategy that place a high value on employees as a stakeholder in
the business. Employees who are treated as stakeholders have certain
rights within the organization and can expect to be treated with dignity
and respect.
1
To enhance this idea one such measure that management can take
to enhance the employee relation is through the various welfare measures.
The welfare facilities are designed to take care of the well being of the
employees, but they do not usually result in any monetary benefit. It is
desirable to recollect the services of a typical worker in this context.
Again the employee welfare is that the facilities help to motivate and
retain employees. Most welfare facilities are hygiene factors, which,
according to Herzberg, create dissatisfaction if not provided. Remove
dissatisfaction, place the employee in a favorable position or mood,
provide satisfiers, then motivation will take place. Welfare facilities,
besides removing dissatisfaction, help develop loyalty in workers towards
the organization.
1.2 Employee Structure in Organization:
Every Organization has its own Employee Structure. However, in general
sense the employee structure of an organization is in hierarchical nature.
It goes up from bottom to top or in other words it comes down from top
to bottom. The Head of the Organization, generally known as Chairman
or CEO, is the chief boss or the head of the organization. Below him,
there are few Directors of the respective stream, say, Finance, Personnel
and Technical etc. Below the rank of Directors, there are Chief General
Manager and General Managers, heading the respective departments of
the organizations. The Chief General Manager/General Manager is the
controlling officer of the respective employees working in the
department. They include senior officers as well as junior officer and
Clerical Staff and Secretarial Staff. Peons are the at the bottom line of an
organization. The decision making power lies with the Head / CEO of the
2
Organization. Others are supposed to implement the decision taken at the
top level.
1.3 Role of Organization in the Development of Employees:
In the present scenario, an organization has to play an important
role for the development of Employees both in their mental and physical
activities. The behavioral, environmental and structural pattern of the
organization should be aiming towards wholesome development of the
employees. The occupational structure of manpower now-a-days has
moved to accommodate job changes. And realization of training of
people for different job is a must for development. A need for
recognizing various levels of employment and effective use of human
resources has resulted in manpower planning. Training and development
are the key factors for smooth running and success of organization.
Training became the modern euphoria in the wake-up rapid technological
revolution in the world. It is the root of productivity and efficiency.
Hence, training and development are emerged as panacea to all these
providing updated knowledge, skill, better inter-personal skill, better
cooperativeness, good understanding policy and procedure and their
effective implementation avoiding difference of opinions to enhance
productivity.
1.4 Employee Structure in MCL
The Employee Structure in MCL is hierarchical in nature. The
Chief of MCL is known as Chairman-cum-Managing Director, who
heads the company. Below him, four Functional Directors are working in
respective stream, such as Director(Personnel), Director(Finance),
3
Director(Operation) and Director(Project & Planning). Below the rank of
Directors, there are Chief General Managers and General Managers,
heading the respective departments of MCL, such as;
01. Chief General Manager (Finance)02. Chief General Manager (Materials Management)03. Chief General Manager (Production)04. Chief of Medical Services05. Chief General Manager (Sales & Mktg.)
06. General Manager (Quality Control) 07. General Manager (Civil/Construction) 08. General Manager (Management Training Institute) 09. General Manager (HRD)
10. General Manager (Project & Planning) 11. General Manager (Safety & Rescue)
12. General Manager (Envt.) 13. General Manager (Contract Management)
14. General Manager (Tech. Cordn.)15. General Manager (Finance/Cost & Budget)16. General Manager (Internal Audit)17. General Manager (Systems)18. General Manager (Personnel)19. General Manager (Excavation)20. General Manager (Electrical & Mechanical)21. General Manager (Land & Rehabilitation)22. General Manager (Washery) 23. Chief of Security24. Head of Legal25. Company Secretary 26. Public Relations Officer
The Chief General Manager/General Manager are the controlling
officer of the respective departments. They have under their control both
Executive and Non-Executive employees. Executive Employees are
Engineers of different discipline, Doctors, Personnel Officers and other
technical professionals.
4
The Non-Executive Employees of MCL include technical as well
as ministerial staff (non-technical). In technical cadre, the following
types of employees are engaged in different disciplines.
5
Sl. Discipline Position
1. Mining Over man, Mining Sirdar, Loader,
Dragline Operators, Dumper Operators
etc.
2. Electrical Foreman, Electrician etc
3. Excavation Foreman, Fitter etc
4. Civil Engineering Asst., Draftsman etc.
5. Production Surveyor
6. Quality Control Chemist, Technical Inspector
7. Materials Management Stores Keeper
8. Medical Nurse, Pharmacist etc.
9. Systems Computer Operator
10. Land & Revenue Amin
11. Security Security Inspector, Security Guards etc.
Besides, above technical staff, non-technical staffs like Office Superintendents, Clerks, PA, Accountant, Librarian etc. are working in different departments.
1.5 Programme of Training for the Development of Employees:
Administrators of training programmes have a great choice of
imparting learning to the trainees. The particular method is selected after
consideration of cost, time available, number of person to be trained,
6
depth of knowledge required, background of the trainees and many other
factors. The major training methods are:
1. On-the-job training method
2. Vestibule Training
3. Classroom Method
a) Lecture
b) Conference
c) Case study
d) Role playing
e) Programmed Institution
f) Computer Assisted instruction
4. Other methods
a) Demonstration
b) Simulation and games
5. Experimental methods like “3” & “4”
1. On – the – job training methods:
This method has the advantages of permitting the trainee to learn
on the actual equipment and in the environment of his job. He can
actually experience a feeling of accomplishment as he produces useful
products. This training may be done either by supervisor of a designated
non supervisory employee. Training on the job is given by variety of
7
methods. They are on the job training, job rotation, coaching job
instruction, training through step by step, syndicate method(working in
small groups).This type of training is useful for learning unskilled and
semi-skilled manual type jobs, clerical jobs and sales work.
2. Vestibule training.
Vestibule training is the term used to designate training in a
classroom for semiskilled production and clerical jobs. It is Particularly
appropriate when a large number of employees must be trained at the
same time for the same kind of work,. When it is used, there is a greater
likelihood that management will have well qualified instructors in charge.
The emphasis tends to be upon learning rather than production. This
method has been used to attract clerks, bank tellers, inspectors, machine
operators, tester’s typists etc.
3. Classroom Methods:
Classroom instruction is most useful when philosophy concepts,
attitudes, theories and problem solving attitudes have to be learned i.e. a
considerable depth of knowledge must be acquired there are certain
aspects of meanly all jobs that can be learned better in the classroom than
on the job. Various methods are being used for technical, professional
and management personnel. Some of the classroom methods are
8
a) Lecture (b) Conference (c) Case study (d) Role playing and
programmed instruction.
4. Simulation Method:
Simulation is a technique which duplicates as nearly as Possible,
the actual conditions encountered on a job. The Vestibule training method
are the examples of business Simulations. Simulation techniques have
been most widely used in aeronautical industry. This training is essential
in cased in which actual on the job. Practice might result in a serious
injury, a costly error or the destruction of valuable material or resources.
It is for this reason, that the technique is very experienced one.
5. Apprenticeship training.
Apprenticeship training is the oldest and most commonly uses
Method, for training in crafts, trades and in technical areas. The training
period may vary from two to three years for persons of superior ability
and four to five years for others. This training is offered to a range of jobs
of a draftsman, machinist, printer, tools maker, system designer,
mechanic, carpenter, weaver, fitter, jeweler, die sinker engineer and
electricians. A major part of training time is spent on the productive
work. Each apprentice is given a programme of assignments according to
a predetermined schedule, which provides for efficient training in trade
skills.
9
Steps in Training Programme.
Usually in the organization of training programmes, the following
Steps are considered necessary:
1. Identifying training needs
2. Getting ready for the job
3. Preparation of the learner
4. Presentation of learner and knowledge
5. Performance try-out
6. Follow-up and evaluation of the programme
Benefits.
Training is a vital and necessary activity in all organizations. It plays a
large part in determining the effectiveness and efficiency of the
establishment.
Following are the major contributions that training can make.
Reduces learning time to reach acceptable performance
By having qualified instructors and carefully controlled learning
situations.
Management in countless cases has been able to obtain short aimed
learning
Periods and higher productivity from new employees.
10
1. Improve performance of present job
Training is not only applied to new employees but to the experienced
people as well. It can help employees increase their level of performance
on their present job assignments.
Attitude Formation.
A common objective of company training programme is the mouldings of
employee attitudes to achieve support for company activities and obtain
better co-operation and greater loyalty.
2. Aid in solving Operational problems.
Training of both supervisors and hourly employees can help Reduce
turnover, absenteeism, accidents and grievance rates. It can solve other
operational problems such as low morale, poor customer service,
excessive waste and scrap loss an poor work methods.
3. Fill Manpower needs.
One manufacturing company finds it impossible to recruit way to solve
his manpower problem is to establish own Apprentice training
programme.
4. Benefits to employees themselves.
As employees acquire new knowledge and job skills, they increase their
market value and earning power. The possession of useful skills enhances
11
their value to their employer and thereby increases their job security.
Training may also qualify them for promotion to more responsible job”2”
& “3”
1.6 Programme & Training for development of Non-Executives
For development of Non-Executives, different training
programmes are undertaken by the Organization. In wider sense, mainly,
the external training & internal training are given to the employees.
External Training.
Based on the needs, of the company as well as the specific needs of the
employees, the executives, supervisors and skilled category employees
are sent for specialized training to external organizations for upgrading
knowledge and skill.
Some employees, depending on the requirements of the company and
the potential of the individuals, are also sent for super specialized training
abroad, like Russia, Ukraine, Indonesia and Australia.
12
Internal Training.
Some employees, depending on the requirements of the company and the
potential of individual given training in the company or of the training
institute of company.
Further, most of the Training activities generally centers on
providing multidiscipline training such as:
1. General management Programmes.
2. Functional Skill Programmes
3. Functional skill Programmes
4. Cross-functional programmes
5. Supervisory Development Programmes;
6. Computer Development Programmes
7. Computer Awareness Programme
8. Safety Management Programmes
9. Vocational Training Programmes
10. Refresher Training programmes (Drivers)
11. R.I.Classes programmes
12. Coaching Classes programmes
13. Yoga Training programmes and
.Supervisory Development Programmes.
The Supervisory staff, employed by the company, in all the Technical
disciplines as well as non-technical disciplines, are impaired Training on
various subjects, aspects and activities being carried out by them in their
day to day work schedules for increasing their understanding of the same.
13
These programmes are generally of six days duration and the supervisors
are imparted the requisite training by Senior Management Faculties.
Computer Awareness Programmes.
Course comprises of:
Computer fundamentals and Internet, for potential Computer users
Update on latest Info Tech developments
Acquainting the employees with the various aspects of using the
computer, both theoretical and practical, this helps them in better
execution of their work and functions.
Functional Skill Programmes :
Functional skill programmes are conducted for upgrading skills of the
technical staff so that they can unleash their potentials and can enhance
their abilities and contribute whole heartedly the realization of the
objectives and goals of the company.
1.7 Problem of Study:
The research begins with the formulation of problem. The present
study attempts to examine and explain the Training & Development of
Non-Executives in a Public Sector Undertaking. The study focuses in the
examination of the various Training Programme imparted to the
employees for their wholesome development and the involvement of the
company in imparting proper and effective training to the employees.
Further more, the study would examine the results of such training
14
programme in PSU and finally it will examine whether the training
programme are actually helping for the development of the non-executive
employees in their service career.
1.8 Objectives:
The objective is the overall study of “Mahanadi Coalfields
Limited” in brief in order to know the detailed structure and functioning
of industry with special emphasis on “Training and Development”
function carried out there.
“Training & Development” studied in detail and cover areas like
1) How training needs are identified.
2) Training policy, programme and formulated methods
prevailing in the organization.
3) Aims of management training and role of trainer as Manager
Perceives trainer as an agent of management development.
4) Inter-action of trainees, trainer, trained employees.
Managerial and executives and how they react on the
objective.
5) How “Training & Development” system meet the
organization objective.
15
6) Effectiveness of Training & Development Programme.
Betterment of management workers and above all how it
affects Industrial Relation scene.
7) Study the attitudes of management and trainees in order to
predict the effectiveness of the Training Programme.
1.9 Hypothesis:
a) Training helps in personal development and satisfaction
b) Rate of absenteeism reduced due to training
c) Helps updating knowledge skill and attitude for testing
Invalidity.
d) Helps Employees in their promotion prospects.
e) Training increases productivity.
1.10 Plan of Thesis:
The study has been planned chapter-wise. There are 8 Chapters in
the said Study.
Chapter-I is the Introduction and it deals with Employee Structure
in Organisation, Role of Organisation in the development of Employees,
Employee Structure in MCL, Programme of Training for the
16
Development of Employees, Programme & training for development of
Non-Executive employees. Problem of Study, Objectives, Hypothesis etc.
Chapter-II is the Description of Field & Methodology and it deals
with MCL History, Location of the study, Employees & MCL,
Executives, Non-Executives, Methodology Research Design, Sampling,
Tools & Data Collection, Difficulties encountered etc.
Chapter-III is Socio Economic Background of the Respondents and
it deals with the Age, Sex, Position, Years of Service, and Education etc.
of the respondents.
Chapter-IV is History of Family Service and it deals with the
historical background of the parents of the respondents.
Chapter-V is History of Service of the Respondents, which deals
with the details service history of the respondents, the reasons and
change, if any, of the respondents.
Chapter VI is Entry in MCL, which deals with the recruitment and
appointment of employees in MCL.
Chapter VII is Training by MCL, which deals with different
training programme undertaken by MCL.
Chapter VIII is Opinion on Training, which deals with the opinion
of the employees of MCL with regard to the training they have received
and the benefits they have got through such trainings.
17
Chapter-IX is Conclusion. The researcher after completing the said
study, has tried to give a note of conclusion.
*******
18
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE FIELD & METHODOLOGY:
2.1 Introduction:
The status of methodology in any research work is of cardinal
significance. Methodology is the systematic and sequential operation of
steerage of scientific social survey and research. A proper planning and
methodology helps the researcher in drawing valid and logical inferences.
It would be tough to understand the principle and the contents of research
without an appreciation of the method we designate as scientific.
“Research Design” stands as an adjustment set by various pragmatic
consideration that are needed for a social research, it is not an exclusive
proposition to be strictly followed, but some what a beacon light for the
researcher to proceed in correct line of march. Thus, social research has
been defined as, “a critical and exhaustive investigation having as its aim
the revision of accepted conclusion in the life of newly discovered facts”.
Methodology involves the formulation of the problem and way to
arrive at the conclusion. The research is designed in such a way that the
conclusion and analysis of data will enable the researcher to arrive at a
conclusion. It would be difficult to comprehend the nature and content of
a research without an appreciation of the method. As Karl Pearson says,
“The scientific method is one and the same in all branches of science and
that method is the method of all logically trained minds. The unity of all
science consists along in its methods”.
19
2.2 MCL History:
Coal India Limited – The parent company.
Coal India Limited (CIL) is the diamond name of the coal industry
in India contributing almost 86% of coal production in India. Coal India
Limited is the third largest coal producing company in the world after
United States and China having about 5 Lakhs employees with the
headquarter located at Kolkata. It is a holding company under the
Ministry of Coal. Govt. Of India for whole of the coal industry in India.
Formation & Incorporation:-
The Coal India Limited was formed in 21st Oct 1975 as a holding
company having 5 subsidiaries and incorporated under the Companies
Act 1956 & it is now an undertaking company being shared by both govt.
and the private players. Its main objectives are to promote the
development and utilization of the coal reserves in the country for
meeting the present and future requirement of energy of the nation. With
the objective to provide for the energy requirement by the country. Coal
India Limited will give the due importance to the safety of the mines
workers in the industry.
20
Subsidiaries of the Coal India Limited.
From the time of incorporation, Coal India Ltd. was functioning as
the parent company of the 5-subsediaries but not it is operating through 8
–subsidiaries out of which 7 subsidiaries are producing coal and the 8 th
subsidiary is in the field of the planning and design consultancy.
Formation of MCL
Chronological sequence of restructuring of Coal India Limited is shown in the chart below :
November 1975Constitution of
holding company|
Coal India Limited
(NEC, DCC)
ECL BCCL CCL WCL CMPDILJanuary 1986
Further ReorganizationCoal India Limited
(NEC, DCC)
ECL BCCL CCL NCL WCL SECL CMPDIL
Further ReorganizationCoal India Limited
(NEC, DCC) (IICM)
ECL BCCL CCL NCL WCL SECLMCLApril 1992
CMPDIL
On 3rd April 1992 a new Company Mahanadi Coalfields was formed with a sizeable investment bifurcating from South Eastern Coalfields Ltd., Bilaspur. It is the 8th Subsidiary of Coal India Ltd. having its apex Corporate HQ. at Kolkata. At present this Company has 21 mines situated in the states of Orissa comprising 8 Underground Mines and 13
21
Open Cast Mines. MCL has 10 Areas in two coalfields, i..e Talcher Coalfields and IB Valley Coalfields. MCL is the 2nd largest coal producing company in Coal India Ltd. The total coal production was 23.14 MTe in the year 1992-93 which has increased to manifold to its record production in 2009-10 to 96.34MTe. It has its Headquarters in Sambalpur (Orissa). Recently the company has been honoured as ‘MINIRATNA” by the Govt. of India.
Power grade coal is mostly available in MCL. Coal from MCL is meeting the demands of different consumers like – Powerhouse, Steel, Cement Plant & Railway etc.
Pattern of Organization:
Organization can be defined as – is a harmonious adjustment of specialized parts for accomplishment of some common purpose.
The members of MCL are nominated jointly by Coal India Ltd. and Ministry of Coal. Board of Director administers MCL. In MCL men, machines and materials work efficiently and perfectly to accomplish the organizational goals.
MCL follows both Line and Staff Form of organizational structure for its administration.
Line Organization – Direct vertical relationship through which authority flows is called line organization.
Welfare Amenities in MCL:
Right from its inception MCL has launched a lot of welfare measures to make sure the quality of life to workmen. The details of welfare amenities and welfare expenditure on capital and revenue head are given hereunder:
Particulars AS on 03.04.1992 As on 31.03.2011Bank Branches 05 16Extension Counter 05 12Play Ground 08 12Stadium 01 02Children Park 06 16Canteen 19 34Kalyan Mandap 00 02
22
Workers Institute 11 14Golf Courses 00 04ATMs 00 07Auditorium 05 14Houses 11666 16736
Year Revenue Capital1992-93 1295.08 9822.151993-94 1796.33 3368.001994-95 2094.26 3394.001995-96 2934.10 4008.001996-97 3604.47 2873.001997-98 4349.93 3256.001998-99 4631.53 3208.001999-00 4698.90 4203.002000-01 5971.93 543.002001-02 6285.98 2018.002002-03 6813.67 989.002003-04 10147.80 875.002004-05 9307.92 189.962005-06 9549.76 281.002006-07 9891.83 761.252007-08 12399.64 441.462008-09 12354.19 409.572009-10 13367.23 427.291010-11 14267.33 489.00
The yearly welfare budget of the Company is submitted in the Welfare Board of the Company consisting of members from both Management and Workers side. The members from the workers side are representatives of recognized Trade Union covered under Industrial Relations System in the Company. The Board, after discussions and suggestions proposed the bill (budget) to be approved by the competent authority.
Housing:
The housing satisfaction of the Company was 55.33% at the time of its formation in April’ 1992 having 11666 houses of various kinds. By the end of 31.03.2011 the housing satisfaction has improved to around 80% with 16736 houses. According to the MCL management information
23
efforts are being made to provide housing accommodation to more employees and the welfare budget, each year provided adequate funds towards it.
Water Supply:
In 1992, 61,320 persons were covered for supply of drinking water whereas by the end of 01.04.2007, it has increased to 83110. Filtered water generated during 1992 was 7.70 MGD and now as on 01.04.2011, it has a capacity of 15.70 MGD.
Medical:
As per the provisions of the National Coal Wage Agreement (NCWA) – VII, the employees hospital bed ratio is 1:120. In MCL this ratio is 1:59. In every mine/ project of MCL, there is a well-equipped dispensary with adequate number of qualified medical and Para-medical persons. Besides, there are 5 big hospitals in the Company and out of which two are central Hospitals (250 bed capacity) each at Talcher and Ib Valley Coalfields. These hospitals are having almost all modern facilities and specialist Doctors.
Description 1992 2011( Up to 31.03.2011)
Hospitals 04 06Total No. of Beds 198 364Ratio of Bed and employee 1:101 1:57Total No. of Dispensaries 09 13Total No. of Ambulance 21 38Total Doctors 59 103
a) Specialist --- 36b) GDMO --- 64c) Dental --- 03
24
Education:
As a part of Welfare activities considerable emphasis has been given on Education of our employees Children. Though education is a State Subject MCL provides grants/ financial assistance to different schools/ Institutions functioning in and around our Coalfields Areas. The Status of Educational institutions are as follows:-
Type of Institutions Numbers.
DAV Public School 09
Privately Managed Schools 19
NK Mahavidyalaya 01
In addition to the above, MCL is also paying 40% Recurring grant to Indira Gandhi Institute of Technology, Sarang, Talcher which is an institution awarding Engineering Diploma in Electrical, Mechanical and Civil branches. Recurring Grant of 40% is also being given to Orissa School of Mining Engineering Keonjhar for Diploma in Mining. In these Two Institutes 40% seats are reserved for the Wards of Non- Executives of MCL in specified disciplines.
25
COALFIELDSOF
MCL
TALCHER IB VALLEY COALFIELDS COALFIELDS
1. JAGANNATH AREA 1. ORIENT AREA 2. BHARATPUR AREA 2. IB VALLEY AREA 3. TALCHER AREA 3 LAKHANPUR AREA 4. LINGARAJ AREA 4. BASUNDHARA-5. HINGULA AREA GARJANBAHAL AREA6. CWS(X) TALCHER 5. CWS(X) IB VALLEY
MCL HAS NINE AREAS IN TWO COALFIELDS WITH 7 UNDERGROUND
MINES AND 15 OPEN CAST MINES.
BESIDES, MCL HAS TWO JOINTVENTURE PROJECTS, NAMELY:
MNH SHAKTI LIMITED MJSJ COAL LIMITED
Name of the Areas Name of the Coal Mining Projects
Talcher Coalfield
Jagannath Area Jagannath OCP, Ananta & Bhubaneswari OCPs.Talcher Area Talcher UGM, Nandira UGMBharatpur Area Bharatpur OCP, Chhendipada OCPLingraj Area Lingraj OCP
26
Hingula Area Hingula OCP, Balaram OCP
IB CoalfieldIB Valley Area Samaleswari, Lajkura OCPsLakhanpur Area Lakhanpur, Lilari & Belpahar OCPs.Orient Area Orient Mine Nos. 2,3 &4, HRC & HBIBasundhara Area Basundhara(East) & West, Kulda, Garjanbahal
In addition to the above Areas, there are other 11 non-mining projects are also in MCL. They are, two Central Workshops, two Central Hospitals, two Integrated Water Supply Schemes, two Regional Stores, Two Integrated Power Supply Schemes, One Training Institute etc.
27
COALFIELD WISE COAL RESERVES IN ORISSA AS ON 31.03.2011
TALCHER IB VALLEY
39.64 BT, 22.36 BT 63.94% 36.06%
2.3 JAGRITI VIHAR:
28
The Corporate Building of MCL Headquarter is situated at Jagriti
Vihar, Burla, Sambalpur with sightsee ting environment and huge amount
of water resources.
CORPORATE BUILING OF MCL HEADQUARTERS
29
LOCATION:
Mahanadi Coalfields Limited has two Coalfields i.e. Talcher Coalfield and Ib Valley Coalfield have different areas and projects under its administrative control. The collieries in Talcher Coalfields are located in Districts of Dhenkanal and Angul and Ib Valley fields are located in Jharsuguda and Sundargarh Districts of Orissa. The Headquarters of MCL is situated at Jagriti Vihar, Burla, Sambalpur on the west of National Highway - 6 at a distance of about 14Km away from Sambalpur City towards Mumbai.
TALCHER FIELD
Talcher Coalfield, the largest Coalfield in the country is located in Brahmani Valley to the north of Mahanadi river. Major part of the coalfield falls in Angul district with parts spreading over to the neighbouring district of Dhenkanal, Deogarh and Sambalpur of Orissa. The coalfield is well connected by both rail and road. The Sambalpur-Talcher-Cuttack railway line of south-eastern railway passes near the southern boundary of the coalfield connecting Angul and Talcher Railway Station. The National Highway – 42 connects Sambalpur and Cuttact. N.H. 5 also passes through south of the coalfield maintaining a distance of 10 to 12 Km. The N.H. 23 connects N.H. 42 and N.H. 6 and it also passes through the eastern part of the coalfield.
30
IB FIELD
IB Coalfield, the 3rd largest coalfield in India has derived its name from the river Ib. The coalfield is located in the district of Jharsuguda and Sundargarh in the north western part of Orissa and covers an area of about 1460 Sq.Km. The coalfield is well connected by both rail and road, the Howrah-Mumbai main railway of South Eastern Railway passes through the southern and south-eastern part of the coalfield. It is also approachable by all weather road from Jharsuguda, Sundargarh and Rourkela which are situated at a distance of about 14 Kms, 70Kms and 150 Kms respectively from the coalfield.
2.4 EMPLOYEE STRUCTURE:
In this type of organization subordinates should be divided according to the type of work involved.
At present the company is headed by Chairman-cum-Managing Director at Corporate HQ. and Chief General Manager/General Manager at Area level
31
Administrative Setup of MCLChairman-cum-Managing
DirectorSri Shree Ramji Upadhyay
Director (Personnel)
Sri S C Padhy
Director (T)(Operation)
Sri Arun Kumar Tiwari
Director (Finance)
Sri B Mohapatr
a
Director (T)(P&P)
Sri A.K.Singh
C.V.OSri N.
K. Pradha
nChief of Medical Services,
CGM(Civil)-for Welfare,PD & Town Admn.,
CGM (A&EE/Welfare
)
GM (P&IR)
Chief of Security,
GM (HRD)
HOD (Legal) Public Relation
Officer
CGM (Production),
CGM(S&M),
GM (S&R/UG),
GM (Excavation),
GM (E&M),
GM (QC),
HOD(IED),
CGM/ GMs of IBV CF
CGM (Finance),
GM (Fin) (CA&T),
GM (Fin) (C&B),
GM (Systems),
Chief of I. A. ,
Company Secretary
CGM(Civil),
CGM (MM),
GM (Envt.),
GM (CP&P),
GM (TC),
GM (CMC),
GM (L&R),
CGM/ GMs of Tal CF
Mgr. (Vig.)
NON-EXECUTIVE EMPLOYEE :
The manpower of MCL at the time of inception of MCL i.e. on 3.4.1992 was 21742 and the manpower as on 31.03.2011 was 20932 and out of which 1245 are executives. The category wise and year wise details are given below:
Area Executive Non-Executives Grand
32
s TotalMonthly
rated
Daily rated
Piece rated
Badlis Total
Ib-valley122 723 970 1 0 1694 1816
Orient 136 719 3801 200 1 4721 4857Basundhara 74 228 475 0 0 703 777
Talcher 79 339 2504 10 0 2853 2932
Jagannath 124 742 1559 0 0 2301 2425
Bharatpur 87 307 1009 0 0 1316 1403
Hingula 95 368 1199 0 0 1567 1662
CWS (X) TAL
30 79 346 0 0 425 455
Kolkata 8 12 2 0 0 14 22
Bhubneswar 4 15 6 0 0 21 25
CWS, IBV 18 41 183 0 0 224 242
Lingaraj 70 332 974 0 0 1306 1376
Lakhanpur 124 554 1299 0 0 1853 1977
NSCH & RH 49 135 136 0 0 271 320
Grand Total 1245 4878 14601 211 1 19698 20943
2.5 Executives:
As on March, 2011, there are 1245 Executives posted in MCL, out
of which 225 Executives are posted in MCL HQ. alone. The discipline
and grade wise executives posted in MCL HQ. are given below :-
Discipline E1 E2 E3 E4 E5 E6 E7 E8 Total
33
Co.Secy 1 1
Civil 1 12 5 1 19
Coal
Preparation
2 2
Coal Tech. 1 1
Chemical
Engg.
0
E&M 6 7 11 3 27
E&T 1 3 4
Envt. 1 1 1 3
Estate 1 1
Excavation 2 5 5 1 13
Finance 1 11 13 4 4 1 34
Geology 0
Hindi 1 1
HRD/MD&T 1 1
Industrial
Engg.
1 1 2
Legal 1 1
Materials
Management
6 2 1 1 10
Medical 2 1 1 1 5
Mining 2 12 12 13 3 42
Personnel 11 9 2 1 1 23
Public
Relation
0
34
Safety &
Rescue
0
Sales &
Mktg.
4 4 1 1 1 11
Security 1 1
Secretarial 3 4 7
Statistics 1 1
Survey 4 2 6
Systems 3 2 1 6
Vigilance 1 1
Total 0 3 15 41 77 51 31 7 225
2.6 Non-Executives:
There are 19698 Non-Executives working in MCL as on
January,2011. Out of which, 429 are posted in MCL HQ. The Non-
Executives are divided into Daily Rated and Monthly Rated. Out of 429
non-executives in MCL HQ., 23 are female non-executives. The
following table shows the details posting of MR & DR & Female non-
executives in different departments of MCL HQ.
Deptt. MR DR Female Total
Administration 15 29 1 44
35
Civil Deptt. 19 16 35
CMD Sectt. 9 4 13
Commercial 1 0 1
Company Sectt. 3 1 4
Contract Management Cell 6 2 8
Director(Personnel) Sectt. 3 5 1 8
Director(T) Sect. 4 4 8
Director(T/PP) Sectt. 3 3 6
Director(F) Sect. 2 3 5
E&M 8 18 26
E&T 11 1 12
E Procurement 1 1 2
Environment 3 1 4
Excavation 4 1 5
Executive Estb 5 4 9
Finance 24 4 1 28
HRD 2 2 1 4
L&R 3 3 1 6
Legal 6 0 6
MM 8 2 10
Medical 14 11 11 25
MTI 4 4 1 8
MNH 4 1 1 5
Personnel 7 6 2 13
Pension Cell 2 2 4
Prodn. & IED 6 2 8
Project & Planning 5 1 1 6
36
Public Relation Officer 5 0 5
Quality Control 5 0 5
Safety & Rescue 2 1 3
Sales & Mktg. 10 0 1 10
Security 63 8 71
Systems 3 1 4
Tech.Sectt. 3 0 3
Vigilance 5 4 9
Welfare 5 1 1 6
Total 283 146 23 429
Objectives of MCL
To carry on the business of the Coal mining
Acquisition of coal mining
Production, sale and dispatch of coal mines taken over by
the Govt.
Policy formulation and advisory functions
To act as the entrepreneur on the behalf of the state in
respect of coal industry
To finance the replacement expenditure
To develop the technical know-how
Exploration & prospecting
To manufacture and self coal as a patent fuel.
Main Functions of Mahanadi Coalfields Limited
37
To act towards achieving corporate objectives and approve and review
strategies for Achievement of this objectives.
2.7 Methodology, Research Design :
Methodology refers to the methods allowed to arrive at a
Conclusion.
A study or research design is a plan comprising of the researcher’s
decisions about the procedures, sampling, collection and analysis of data
for a given study, which aims to fulfill the purpose without wasteful
expenditure of time, energy and money. It is economical in the long run
because, it forestalls the possibility of a fruitless inquiry. It differs
according to the research purpose and its categorized under four groups,
viz. (1) Exploratory, (2) Description, (3) Diagnosis, and (4)
Experimentation.
In the present study, exploratory cum descriptive study design has
been followed.
2.8 Sampling:
Sampling is the smaller representation of the larger whole. It is the
representation of the universe in miniature. Sampling method is
economical in terms of time, money and energy. Detail study is possible
due to contact with every sample units and it has a scientific base. There
are only two requirements of the sampling procedure: It must be
38
representative and adequate, there are different methods of sampling such
as random sampling, stratified sampling, purposive sampling etc.
In the present study 50 workers were selected at random from the
universe. The researcher personally met the respondent by asking them
various questions regarding their own life, relationship with the
management and their involvement in trade unions.
2.9 Tools & Data Collection:
Having drawn adequate samples from the universe the next step of
research was collection of data regarding the various aspects of the study.
There are several tools of data collection like Observation, Case study,
Interview schedule, Questionnaire etc.
Here the interview schedule has been used as the main tool for data
collection, and side by side observation in a non-participant way.
Interview is the development of precision focus reliability is
another common social act conversation. The objections of interview may
be exchange of ideas and experiences, eliciting information pertaining to
a wide range of data in which the interviewer may wish to rehearse his
past, define his present and canvas his future possibilities. It is a mutual
view of each other. According to P.V. Young, “Interview may be
regarded as a systematic method by which a person enters more or less
imaginatively, into the life of a comparative stranger. In interviewing the
interviewee, we make use of the interview schedule. Interview schedule
39
consists of a number of questions which the interviewer himself has to
ask and fill up after getting information from the respondents.
While applying interview schedule, the researches made use of the
observation technique in a non-participant form. Although, the external or
non-participant observer is not welcomed to the group, but, he can
maintain a distance without involving into the group situation. It gives the
way for a more systematic study. So while interviewing the respondents
the researcher observed the behaviour, facial expression, without
participating in group situation.
The Interview Schedule deals with the socio-economic background
or the bio-data of the respondents, the service history of the respondents
and finally the opinion / views regarding training they are receiving from
the organization.
A heap of collected data serves no purpose for any study as it does
not give any specific information or knowledge. So in order to derive
proper information, the collected data must be interpreted and analysed
which in turn involves a number of tasks like classification and
tabulation.
In classification, the collected data were arranged in different
groups on the basis of their similarities. In the present study, the data
collected have been classified on the basis of their different education
level, caste, type of family income etc.
40
The next step is tabulation. For this purpose the researcher has
placed some data in different tables to find out the number of frequency
and percentage of each group.
Information collected from both the sources i.e. primary and
secondary.
i) Primary:
Some data collected by observing employees and asking questions
are called primary data. For collection of primary data, questionnaires
were prepared depending on category of personnel involved. It is a form
containing some questions which are to be filled by respondent.
ii) Secondary
Secondary data are collected both from published and non-
published sources, Published sources include magazines, bulletins,
memoranda, pamphlets etc… Non-published sources include official
files, record, log books etc. Booklets quarterly reports, annual reports,
journals, records of the Company are also used. Text books, published
and non-published project reports are also referred for proper
understanding of study.
2.10 Difficulties encountered:
The experience during the field work has left an indelible
impression and was both a bitter and sweet one. The respondents were
41
personally contacted and duly told what it was all about. Some of the
respondents were very co-operative and even agreed for formal
interviews, whereas some respondents failed to understand the essence of
data collection and refused to give time for the interview as they were
busy with their work.
2.11 Conclusion:
“Training & Development” find its vital role in recent decade. And
every industry for its survival must have to embrace “Training &
Development” and try to absord its good results in day-to-day working
and use its side effects in a constructive purpose. Hence, one month
period was very short to study. “Training & Development” and its
effectiveness in a quality concerned industry. Period was very short again
to watch the same group of workers before training and after it.
The present study undertaken by the researcher suffers from some
limitations. The sample drawn was on random basis and can not be
generalized. The data collected only from 50 respondents do not differ
any valid ground for drawing generalization.
*******
42
3. SOCIO-ECONOMIC BACK-GROUND OF THE
RESPONDENTS:
3.1 Introduction:
The caste, religion, occupation and life experiences of an
individual are crucial in determining how one will think and act in
different situations. Individuals are substantially affected, by nature and
mechanism of socialization, family background and socio-economic
attitude set up which in turn affect their attitudes, ways of training and
philosophy of life.
In other words the implicit assumption is that the beliefs,
role, perception and behaviour learned as a result of social antecedent and
the social environment in which one is brought up are more influential in
determining the extent of role commitment and role performance. The
chapter seeks to identify the socio-economic profile of the 50 respondents
of Mahanadi Coalfields Limited, Burla of Sambalpur District of Orissa
43
State in terms of their Age, sex, occupation, income, educational
qualification.
All the data relating to the socio-economic background of
the respondents have been represented in the tabular form.
3.2 Age & Sex:
Age reveals the experience on as gained about life. An individual’s
working capability and strength is known from his age. It is a temporary
concept as we all know. “Time and tide waits for none”, similarly with
the passage of time an individual age also grows and a time comes when
the individual decays.
The following table reveals the age composition of 50
respondents.
TABLE – 3.1
Age Composition
Various categories of
respondents on the basis of Age
Total No. Percentage
18 – 25 Nil Nil
25 – 35 16 32%
35 – 50 33 66%
44
50 & above 1 2%
TOTAL 50 100%
The table 3.1 shows that out of 50 (100%) respondents, no one lie
within 18 – 25, 16 (32%) within 25 – 32, 33 (66%) with 35 – 50 and 1
(2%) lie within 50 and above group. Hence majority of respondents
belong to the 35 – 50 age group.
SEX COMPOSITION:
The following table reveals the sex composition of 50 respondents.
TABLE – 3.2
Sex Composition
Various categories of
respondents on the basis of Sex
Total No. Percentage
Male 45 90%
Female 5 10%
TOTAL 50 100%
The table 3.2 shows that out of 50 (100%) respondents, 45 (90%)
are male and 5 (10%) are female. Hence majority of respondents belong
to male.
3.3 Position held:
45
The following table reveals the position held by the 50
respondents.
TABLE – 3.3
Position held by the Respondents
Various categories of
respondents on the basis of
position held
Total No. Percentage
Clerk 30 60%
PA 10 20%
Electrician 2 4%
Storekeepers 2 4%
Peon Nil 0%
Others 6 12%
TOTAL 50 100%
The table 3.3 shows that out of 50 (100%) respondents, 30 (60%)
are Clerk, 10 (20%) are Pas, 2 (4%) are Electrician, 2 (4%) are
Storekeepers and 6 (12%) belong to other categories. Hence majority of
respondents belong to Clerk.
3.4 Years of Service:
The years of service refers the length of service the respondents
have already put in in the organization. This shows the experience in their
respective service career The following table reveals the years of service
of the 50 respondents.
46
TABLE – 3.4
Years of Service
Various categories of
respondents on the basis of
Years of Service
Total No. Percentage
0 – 3 Years Nil Nil
3 – 5 Years 10 20%
5 – 10 Years 15 30%
10 - 15 Years 20 40%
Above 15 years 5 10%
TOTAL 50 100%
The table 3.4 shows that out of 50 (100%) respondents, no one lie
within 0-3, 10 (20%) within 3 – 5, 15 (30%) within 5 – 10, 20 (40%)
within 10-15 and 5 (10%) lie above 15 years group. Hence majority of
respondents belong to the 10-15 years group.
3.5 Education:
47
Education is the important means of socialization and one of the
basic activities in all human societies. Anderson is of the view that
“education is the social process by which an individual learns the things
necessary to fit him to the life of his society”. It is the process whereby
the social heritage of a group is passed on from one generation to another
and whereby the child learns the rules of social behaviour. It is an attempt
to shape the development of the coming generation in accordance with
the social ideals of life.
Hence, it is necessary to know the educational background of the
respondents. It is depicted in the following table.
TABLE – 3.5
Educational Qualification
Various categories on the basis
of Education
Total No. Percentage
Under Matric 2 4%
Matric 10 20%
Inter-mediate 3 6%
Graduation 20 40%
Above Graduation 15 30%
TOTAL 50 100%
48
The above table shows that, out of 50(100%) respondents, 2 (4%)
were under matric, 10 (20%) were educated upto Matric, 3 (6%) were
intermediate, 20 (40%) were graduate and 15 (30%) were above
Graduation. Hence, majority of respondents were educated.
3.6 Conclusion:
As the study has been conducted in the semi-urban area of Burla of
Sambalpur district in Orissa, the place of resident of all the respondents is
semi-urban. The respondent’s age group is ranging from 25 to 50 years. It
is a male dominated industry. The education level of the respondents is
very good. Majority of them, that is, nearly 40% were graduate.
The socio-economic background of the respondents reveals that,
majority of the respondents are males, well educated and have got
experience in their service field. .
49
4. HISTORY OF FAMILY SERVICE:
4.1 Introduction:
Family plays the first and most important role in formulating the
career of an individual. It mostly depends on the background of the
family, which affects the behaviour of the human beings. It is seen that a
good and peaceful family always provides a better platform for the
members to perform well in every sphere of his life. Similarly,
family having bad reputation accordingly reflects otherwise.
4.2 Fa Fa :
The record of service of the parents of the respondents is also
notable in order to reach into a state of mind about their position and
psychological attachment to the organization. The table shows the history
of service of the parents group in the organization.
50
TABLE – 4.1
History of Service in the Organization of the parents of 50
respondents
Generation Service No. % Service
Fa 25 50%
Mo 10 20%
Fa fa 5 10%
FaMo 10 20%
TOTAL 50 100%
The above table shows that, out of 50(100%) respondents, father of
25 (50%) were in service, whereas mother of 10 (20%) were in service
and both father and mother of 10 (20%) were in service.
4.4 Father:
Father is the pivotal member of a family. He is in charge of the
livelihood of the family. All the major decision of the family is taken by
him. His position determines the status of the family. The ideology of a
father is injected to the next generation. It is found that if the father of a
respondent was an employee of the organization, his economical
condition is better than others and the respondents has got proper
education and are well established in the society.
4.5 Conclusion:
The History of family service provides a clear picture about the
position of the individual at present. The father and mother of whose
51
respondents are in service, his economical condition is much better, but
sometimes they have been neglected in their building a good career, due
to absence of both father and mother in the home. Where the father is the
only service holder and mother is a house-wife, it is found that such
family are very peaceful as well as very successful.
*******
5. HISTORY OF SERVICE OF THE RESPONDENTS:
5.1 Introduction:
History is the past record. The history of Service record confirms
the background of the person. The more the service period, the more the
experience gained in the respective field. About experience, one can say
it is gradually achieved through the passage of time. Hence, History of
service is essentially required to be noted, to reach at a more concrete
conclusion.
5.2 History of Service:
In the present study, it was found that the some respondents before
joining MCL, were engaged in different organizations. And in
comparison, their experience in dealing and discharging official work is
better than those who were initially in MCL.
52
Hence, it is necessary to know the History of Service of the
respondents. It is depicted in the following table.
TABLE – 5.1
History of Service of the 50 respondents
Organisation No. %
MCL 25 50%
Public Sector 3 6%
Govt. Sector 7 14%
Private Sector 15 30%
TOTAL 50 100%
The above table shows that, out of 50(100%) respondents, 25
(50%) were in MCL from the beginning, whereas 3 (6%) from Public
Sector, 7 (14%) from Govt. Sector and rest 15 (30%) from Private Sector.
Hence, 50% were from outside organization, before joining MCL.
5.4 Reasons and Change:
When asked about the reasons for changing / switching over to
MCL from other organizations, majority of respondents answered in
53
terms of better salary and facilities in MCL in comparison to other Govt.
and Private sector. It is also noted that the respondents who were in
private sector, got the service in MCL on rehabilitation scheme. Hence,
they chose to join MCL and left the private organization obviously.
5.5Conclusion :
We can derive from the aforesaid facts that better emoluments and
facilities can attract people from other sectors. Moreover, in this process,
an organization is benefited in getting more experienced people. In the
present organization, more persons from private sectors have joined not
from Govt. Sectors.
6. ENTRY IN MCL:
6.1 Introduction:
MCL is a Coal Producing Company. The target of Coal production
has now surpassed 110 MT, which is a huge task. The primary steps for
producing coal is acquisition of Land, where coal can be excavated. The
land may be both forest land as well as cultivable and residential land of
the land owners. To acquire forest land, the company has to approach the
Govt. for mining purpose on the same and is dealt accordingly as per the
Forest Land Act. However, for acquisition of private land, there is lot of
difficulties faced by the company. Before acquiring the private land,
proper rehabilitation of the inhabitants and nearby villagers are required
to be done. As per the rule, the company has to provide service to the
family members of the land owners accordingly to their size of land.
Hence, people get appointment through rehabilitation scheme. In order to
get technical staff to run the company, MCL through open advertisement,
also appoints various staff in various discipline/cadre.
54
6.2 Type of Entry:
As discussed, there are two types of entry in MCL i.e. direct entry
through open recruitment and Rehabilitation entry through land
acquisition policy. There is also another entry on medical ground/death
case, whereby due medical unsuitability or death of the employees, their
children get employment, as per terms of the company.
TABLE – 6.1
Type of Entry in MCL (50 respondents)
Type of Entry No. %
Direct Recruitment 10 20%
Through Rehabilitation scheme 30 60%
On death/medical ground 10 20%
TOTAL 50 100%
The above table shows that, out of 50(100%) respondents, 10
(20%) got the job in MCL by direct recruitment, whereas 30 (60%)
through rehabilitation scheme on losing their land and rest 10 (20%) on
medical ground/death case of their father. Hence, majority of 60%
entered MCL through Rehabilitation scheme.
6.4 Years & Change of Service in MCL :
The years of service refers the length of service the respondents
have already put in the organization. This shows the experience in their
55
respective service career. The following table reveals the years of service
of the 50 respondents.
TABLE – 6.2
Years of Service in MCL
Various categories of
respondents on the basis of
Years of Service
Total No. Percentage
0 – 3 Years Nil Nil
3 – 5 Years 10 20%
5 – 10 Years 15 30%
10 - 15 Years 20 40%
Above 15 years 5 10%
TOTAL 50 100%
The table 6.2 shows that out of 50 (100%) respondents, no one lie
within 0-3, 10 (20%) within 3 – 5, 15 (30%) within 5 – 10, 20 (40%)
within 10-15 and 5 (10%) lie above 15 years group. Hence majority of
respondents belong to the 10-15 years group.
6.5 Conclusion:
MCL is a coal producing industry. Land acquisition is always a
major problem in the coal industry. Proper rehabilitation and resettlement
of the people is a challenge for the company. In the rehabilitation scheme,
the land owners are offered job in the industry in lieu of their lands in
addition to cash compensation. Hence, the majority of employees of MCL
have got service through rehabilitation scheme.
56
*******
7. TRAINING BY MCL:
7.1 Introduction:
The Department of Human Resource Development of MCL lays
emphasis on imparting the requisite technical, operational & executives,
Supervisory staff and other employees. , commensurate with the rapidly
changing economic scenario and its HRD Policy . Keeping in view the
hazardous nature of the coal industry, specific attention is given to
increase the safety awareness and safety management standards among
the employees.
Hence, the company is focusing on the upgrade of the skills of the
entire manpower inventory, based on the needs of the organization as
well as those of its importance.
HRD Policy.
Training & Development of the employees of MCL through need-based
57
Training programmes to help, create and nature for the organization
around and healthy work culture conducive to all around excellence.
Objectives
In line with the broad based policies of the company, as narrated above,
the following objectives are sought to be accomplished.
Assessing the discipline-wise, level-wise, job-wise grade-wise training
need of the company.
To strive to fulfill the training needs of entry level, middle level and
senior level executives through formal and non-formal means, for
meeting the organization goal.
To bring about attitutional change and harness managerial potential in
pursuit of individual and organizational excellence.
To disseminate knowledge through workshop, conference, seminar , etc.
To catalyze creativity, fellowship bond, leadership, team spirit, discipline
and respect for values.
7.2 Training Programme in MCL:
In MCL mainly the external training & internal training are given
to the employees.
External Training.
58
Based on the needs, of the company as well as the specific needs of the
employees, the executives, supervisors and skilled category employees
are sent for specialized training to external organizations for upgrading
knowledge and skill.
Some employees, depending on the requirements of the company and the
potential of the individuals, are also sent for super specialized training
abroad, like Russia, Ukraine, Indonesia and Australia.
Internal Training.
Some employees, depending on the requirements of the company and the
potential of individual given training in the company or of the training
institute of company.
In MCL most of the Training activities generally centers on providing
multidiscipline training and comprise of:
1. General Management Programmes.
2. Functional Skill Programmes(for Executives)
3. Functional Skill Programmes (for workmen)
4. Cross-functional programmes(for executives)
5. Supervisory Development Programmes;
6. Computer Development Programmes
7. Computer Awareness Programme(for Management & Workmen)
8. Safety Management Programmes
9. Training programmes for Members of Safety Committee
59
10. Induction Training programme
11. Vocational Training Programmes
12. Refresher Training programmes(Drivers)
13. R.I.Classes programmes
14. Coaching Classes programmes
15. Special programmes in collaboration OEMs;
16. Yoga Training programmes and
17. Workshops, Seminars, Symposiums.
General Management Programme
This programme is structured for the Executives of all Disciplines from
E 1 to E-2 grade and is a week long programme with focus on impairing
up-to date knowledge of various disciplines that are strategically linked to
the core activities of the Company.
Focus of the programme is on;
1. Developing strategic intent;
The Executives through these programmes,. are given exposure of the
cross functional areas of the organizational problems while taking a
decision.
.Supervisory Development Programmes.
The Supervisory staff, employed by the company, in all the Technical
disciplines as well as non-technical disciplines, are impaired Training on
60
various subjects, aspects and activities being carried out by them in their
day to day work schedules for increasing their understanding of the same.
These programmes are generally of six days duration and the supervisors
are imparted the requisite training by Senior Management Faculties.
Computer Awareness Programmes.
Course comprises of:
Computer fundamentals and Internet, for potential Computer users
Update on latest Info Tech developments
Instructors and faculties from reputed Computer education and training
Institutes like NIIT, APTECH AND SSI are engaged throughout the year
for acquainting the employees with the various aspects of using the
computer, both theoretical and practical, which helps them in better
execution of their work and functions.
.Specialised Computer Programmes.
Training on advance applications like Oracle, Java, etc. are also held in
between the Computer Awareness Programmes for equipping the Officers
and Supervisory staff of the Systems Deptt. with advanced knowledge
regarding the various Software applications.
1. Cost Management
2. Quality management and customer care;
3. Attitudinal change
4. Human values and Business ethics.
61
Thus, the programme attempts to bring awareness in the key-result areas,
to enhance the capabilities of Exercise in handling various situations and
bring about quality management in their domain of operations.
Functional Skill Programme(for Executives)
The programme aims to upgrade the existing skills and knowledge of the
Executives in their functional areas by equipping them applications
therein taking place in Indian coal mining industry.
Functional programmes are held for the following disciplines:
Mining Excavation, Electrical & Mechanical.
Civil Computer, Finance and Personal & Administration
Functional Skill Programmes for Workmen;
Functional skill programmes are conducted in different batches at BTI
Bandhabahal & MEETI, Talcher for upgrading skills of the Dumper
Operators, Fitters and Electrical, other HEMM Operations and medical
staff so that they can unleash their potentials and can enhance their
abilities and contribute whole heartedly the realization of the objectives
and goals of the company.
Cross Functional Programmes
These programmes are held for the objectives in the following cross
disciplines: Finance, Materials Management, and Personal & IR.
These programmes are conducted by the experienced
faculties/instructions of organizations like TATA CONSULTANCY
SERVICES, APTECH, etc
62
PROGRAMMES FOR THE MEMBERS OF THE SAFETY
COMMITTEES AND SAFETY MANAGEMENT PROGRAMMES..
Due to the hazardous nature of the Coal industry, for working in deep
coal zones(in underground coal mining) as well as in the vast expanses of
open-cast quarries(with fast and enormous activities taking place due to
numerous Heavy Earth Moving Machines) it is imperative to instill
absolute safety awareness amongst the people working there.
With the above objective, regular programmes are held on the safety
management and for the Safety Committees to inculcate the requirement
(to adhere to the safety norms)amongst all the persons engaged in the
mining activities so that they go to their workplaces, work safely and
come back to their homes to rejoin their families.
1. INDUCTION TRAINING PROGRAMMES;
TRAINING OF NEW ENTRANTS: The newly appointed or promotes to
executive cadres are given Induction Training.
Focus is on development of:
.Knowledge and skills for earlier contribution to productivity,
profitability
.Customer satisfaction
.Physical and mental fitness
.Spirit of fellowship, fraternity belongingness
63
.Leadership quality.
For those workers joining the Computer for the first time, in order to
equitant the with the working environment as well as impart the requisite
knowledge about the task that they will be entrusted to, these programmes
are held as an absolute necessity. The programmes are especially
designed are conducted for certain skilled category of personal like
Mining Sirdar, Jr.Overman and Operator Trainees, Fitter Trainees, Amin
and Trainees, nursing trainees etc.
2. Vocational Training Programmes
These programmes are conducted at a Group Vocational Training Centres
in the Coalfields Areas and relates to various programmes for improving
the knowledge and efficiency of the Operators, Fitters, Technical
Supervisory staffs and other skilled and semi skilled workmen deployed
in the underground as well as open cast mines.
3. Refresher Training Programmes
Employees, working as Drivers, in various department in the Coalfields
are imparted Refresher Training to brush-up their existing knowledge
with respect to driving various vehicles and to make themselves
acquainted with the working conditions in the mining premises,
especially in the open cast mines, so that they can adhere to the safety
requirements.
64
4. R.I.Classes for Trade Apprentices:-
The Related Instructions classes organized and conducted at BTI and
MEETI Talcher
5. Coaching Classes programmes.
For those employees who aspire to come Managers, coaching classes are
held for their actual Examinations for preparing them and make them
conversant with the various subjects of their discipline so that it receipts
them in realizing their aims and mobilizations.
For conducting such programmes, the company makes the services
arrangements making available the services of highly convinced and
senior faculties so that the employees can prepare well for the required.
6. Special Programmes in Collaboration with the OEMs
Due to diverse range of equipment that in operation in the Mines
premises and these equipment being complex, for making the employees
aware of the various pros and cons of the equipment, its working
procedures the techniques associated for putting in use during particular
situations, the company organizes specific related programmes of their
equipment from time to time. These programmes are conducted in
collaboration with the Original Equipment Manufactures and held
throughout the establishments wherever these equipment are installed/put
in operation. These OEMs are from the Public as well as the private
sectors, are organizations like BEML, GMMCO INGERSOLL RAND,
RECP, L&T, LuCAS, CATERPILLAR, CUMMIS,
7. Yoga Training Programmes.
65
A healthy body and healthy mine is the foremost requirement of every
human being for every activity that is done. The significance of this
increases more if one is employed in an industry and even much more if it
happens to be a vast and hazardous one like coal.
Therefore, for imparting certain basis yoga education and certain special
need-based Yogic Abhyas Qualified Instructors from Yoga Darshan
Ashram, Sambalpur (which is guided by Bihar School of Yoga, Munder)
regularly conducts classes, round the at the Yoga Prashikshan Kendra, in
the Management Institute Premises, Company Headquarters. The
employees interested, as well as their dependents, receive training at this
Kendra.
8. RAJVASHA (Hindi)
Special emphasis is being given to promote Rajvasha of MCL. For this
purpose regular training to increase knowledge about Rajvasha is being
conducted at project level/Area Level as well as Hqr. level. Healthy
competitive examination/Seminar for Rajvasha is conducted.
Training Institutes
Internal Training Programmes are conducted by the following Institutes
located at three Central locations within the company namely.
1. Management Training Institute (MTI) at MCL HQ, Sambalpur
66
2. Belpahar Training Institute (BTI) at Belpahar in Lakhanpur Area of
MCL
3. Mining, Engineering & Excavation Training Institute (Popularly
known as (TTI) in Talcher Coalfields of MCL.
MTI is conducting both Managerial and Supervisory Training
Programmes.
BTI, & MEETI Talcher are conducting, especially, the Vocational
Training Programmes for workmen.
Management Training Institute, Sambalpur.
On 08.06.1998 under dynamic leadership of the then CMD
Shri N.Sharma this Institute was started in the vacated premises of earlier
office of the CMD, with the objective to impart Training to the Junior
level Executives (e-1 to E5 Grade) and the Supervisors of all Disciplines
so that the First-level people, who are directly in touch with the workers
and staff, can efficiently and economically manage for realization of the
company’s objectives.
Gradually, Computer Awareness programmes for the Staff, Supervisors
and Executives were commenced with the mission to make them
acquinted with the functioning of the Computer, a must nowadays for
every organization to grow at a fast pace. During the course of time it
also became imperative to conduct several Functional, Cross-functional
programmes, short programmes as well as need-based programmes,
67
including Coaching Classes for Examinations in various disciplines,
Induction programmes as well as re-orientation programmes.
Over the years, the Institute has grown to such extent that
Work-shops/Seminars on Rajbhasa as well as other Specific subjects are
also being conducted in the Institute. The Institute also house a
Library(with 2980 books in Hindi, English and Oriya); several
National/Regional Magazines, periodicals and Newspapers are also
subscribed to, for the benefit of the interested readers.
Activities of the Sambalpur Chapter of India (ISTD), opened from July
1999, are organized too in the Institute premises Most of the programmes
conducted as Residential as well equipped accommodation in the trainees,
from the Coalfields, is provides at Kalinga Bhavan, having 30 bed
capacity.
In the MTI premises a Prasikshan Kendra has been functioning the
9.1.2004. The Trainees coming to MTI to various Training Programmes
also participate in Yoga Training.
Belpahar Training Institute (BTI)
Training Institute at Belpahar Original set up as MEETI(Mining
Engineering & BTI,is imparting training to the employees especially the
Technical Staff and worksmen for upgrading their skills commensurate
with the changing working environment.
Situated in the Industrial Belt of Belpahar (with Tata Refractories Ltd. IB
thermal Power Station in close vicinity) the Training Institute, with all its
infrastructure including a Hill-top Hostel, Auditorium Conference rooms,
68
Museum, HEMM culture Models, Environment Laboratory, Library etc.
began functioning from 1993.
The various programmes being conducted by the Institute are:
1. Supervisory Development Programmes
2. Maintenance Management Programmes
3. Safety Management trainees
4. Training programmes for Management Trainees
5. R.I.Classes for Trade Apprentices
6. Basic training programmes for Dumper Operators,Fitters,Auto
electricians etc.
7. Refresher Training programmes for Drivers.
8. Training programme for Office Staff.
9. Special Training Seminars in collaboration with OEMS
10. Need-based Training programmes Seminars (Symposium and
Workshops)
11. Exhibition by District Administration & other Departments a and
when required and permitted by the Management.
69
MEETI, Talcher
This Institute was inaugurated on 3.2.09. The Institute has started
Training programmes for workers and Supervisor personal of Talcher
Coalfields. This Institute is mainly conducting programmes such as:-
Refresher Course for Operators of different HEMMs.
Refresher Course for Fitters and Electricians working in different
HEMMs
Basic Training Course for Operators and Fitters.
Group Vocational Training Centres.
There are Group Vocational Training Centres in Orient, Lakhanpur and
Basundhara Areas in the IB-Valley Coalfields & in Talcher and
Jagannath Areas in the Talcher Coalfields. These Centres(Lakhanpur,
Basundhara and Jagannath) are conducting Statutory, Initial, Special and
Refresher Training programmes for the Company employees as wellas
for the Contractors Workers engaged in Mines as per V.T.Rules. The
Orient and Talcher GVTCs are imparting training to only the Company’s
employees working in underground Collieries below ground and on
surface.
MEETI, Talcher
70
This Institute was inaugurated on 3.2.09. The Institute has started
Training programmes for workers and Supervisor personal of Talcher
Coalfields. This Institute is mainly conducting programmes such as:-
Refresher Course for Operators of different HEMMs.
Refresher Course for Fitters and Electricians working in different
HEMMs
Basic Training Course for Operators and Fitters.
Group Vocational Training Centres.
There are Group Vocational Training Centres in Orient, Lakhanpur and
Basundhara Areas in the IB-Valley Coalfields & in Talcher and
Jagannath Areas in the Talcher Coalfields. These Centres (Lakhanpur,
Basundhara and Jagannath) are conducting Statutory, Initial, Special and
Refresher Training programmes for the Company employees as well as
for the Contractors Workers engaged in Mines as per V.T.Rules. The
Orient and Talcher GVTCs are imparting training to only the Company’s
employees working in underground Collieries below ground and on
surface.
DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION.
1-Year wise employee trained.
Year Executive
Development
Programme
Supervisory
Development
Programme
Skill
Development
Programme
Total
1993-94 250 203 203 453
1994-95 250 103 330 683
1995-96 366 382 308 1056
1996-97 255 148 574 977
1997-98 277 216 481 974
71
1998-99 824 480 726 2030
1999-00 1013 591 944 2548
2000-01 1037 615 1106 2758
2001-02 1202 707 1069 2978
2002-03 1334 589 744 2667
2003-04 1189 497 922 2608
2004-05 1412 656 1038 3106
2005-06 1684 610 1007 3301
2006-07 944 965 1593 3502
2007-08 980 977 1599 3556
2008-09 1212 1023 1621 3856
2009-10 1259 1129 1681 4069
2- Training imparted by different institution.
Year External MTI BTI MEETI
1993-94 -- -- 453 --
1994-95 -- -- 683 --
1995-96 -- -- 1056 --
1996-97 -- -- 977 --
1997-98 -- -- 974 --
1998-99 478 381 1171 --
1999-00 732 616 956 244
2000-01 726 729 883 420
2001-02 838 710 1071 359
2002-03 989 443 1001 234
2003-04 1075 575 776 182
2004-05 938 717 972 258
2005-06 1033 441 674 134
72
2006-07 1112 440 1112 421
2007-08 935 421 781 380
2008-09 1021 486 957 397
2009-10 1156 549 1125 402
3.Outside training of employees
Year Executive
Development
Programme
Supervisory
Development
Programme
Skill
Development
Programme
Total
2006-07 378 149 595 1122
2007-08 684 32 19 735
2008-09 660 148 60 868
2009-10 540 132 149 821
2010-11 389 75 120 584
4-Inside Training of employees
Year Executive
Development
Programme
Supervisory
Development
Programme
Skill
Development
Programme
Total
2006-07 566 816 998 2380
2007-08 153 435 744 1332
2008-09 203 744 609 1556
2009-10 289 826 786 1901
2010-11 337 679 897 1913
Training imparted by BTI, & MEETI, at MCL.
73
2010-11: Vocational training =
132
Field training =
179
Vocational training on MBA = 49
Vocational training on summer degree = 42
Vocational training on degree engg. = 17
Vocational training on Diploma engg =
435
Study tour =
139
Foreign Training
(2006-2011) for last 5 year = 24
7.3 Training received by Non-Executives:
Mostly the following training programme are conducted for non-
executive employees of MCL :-
1. General management Programmes.
2. Functional skill Programmes (for workmen)
3. Supervisory Development Programmes;
4. Computer Development Programmes
5. Computer Awareness Programme(for Management & Workmen)
6. Safety Management Programmes
74
7. Induction Training programme
8. Vocational Training Programmes
9. Refresher Training programmes(Drivers)
10. R.I.Classes programmes
11. Coaching Classes programmes
12. Special programmes in collaboration OEMs;
13. Yoga Training programmes and
14. Workshops, Seminars, Symposiums.
The following table shows the duration of training programme
conducted by the Training Deptt. of MCL HQ. in a year :-
TABLE – 7.1
Duration of Training Programme in MCL HQ.
Duration of Training Programme Total No.
3 Days 10
5 Days 05
7 Days 20
30 days 05
The table 7.1 shows that one week training programme are
frequently being conducted by the Training Institute.
As discussed above different types of training programme are
being conducted by MCL. However, the following major training
programmes for non-executive employees are being done through out the
year, as depicted in the table:
75
TABLE – 7.2
Types of Training Programme availed by Non-Executives at HQ.
(Out of 50 programme)
Types of Training availed Total No. Percentage
Supervisory Development Programme 10 20%
Computer Awareness Programme 10 20%
Vocational Training Programme 08 16%
Functional skill Programme 10 20%
Refresher Training programme 7 14%
Yoga Training programme 5 10%
TOTAL 50 100%
7.4 Conclusion:
It is found that in MCL different training programme are almost
equally distributed through out the year. Even Yoga training are being
conducted for the non-executive employees, for their physical fitness and
mental concentration. Supervisory development and skill development of
the workers are also taken care off. Computer Awareness amongst the
workers has also been given due importance.
*********
76
8. OPINION ON TRAINING:
8.1 Introduction:
Training & Development is considered as an investment in the
organization. It is felt that training and development deptt. is very
beneficiary for all the employees. Training in the organization provided
for future development of the employees. Training helps in increasing
efficiency/work culture of employees in the organization. With these
propositions, the researcher tried to find out the opinion of the
respondents.
8.2 Training Received:
As discussed training is beneficiary for all the employees. It helps
in increasing efficiency/work culture amongst the employees. The
following table shows the training received by the respondents of MCL:-
77
TABLE – 8.1
Training received by the Respondents (50)
Total No. Percentage
Training received 35 70%
Training not received 15 30%
TOTAL 50 100%
The table 8.1 shows that out of 50 (100%) respondents, 35 (70%)
have received training, whereas 15 (30%) have not. Hence majority of
respondents have received training.
8.3 Benefits received:
In general it can be said that the training and development deptt. of
MCL fulfill the objective as most the workers feel that training and
development deptt. is very beneficiary for them. The Employees are
getting promotion to the higher posts through adequate training. The
following table shows the benefits received by the respondents.
TABLE – 8.2
Benefits received by the Respondents (50)
Total No. Percentage
Benefits received 30 60%
Benefits not received 20 40%
TOTAL 50 100%
78
The table 8.1 shows that out of 50 (100%) respondents, 30 (60%)
have received training, whereas 20 (40%) have not. Hence majority of
respondents have received benefits out of training they have received.
8.4 Suggestion:
In order to increase the satisfaction and educational level of the
employees the following measures can be adopted
Pay greater attention to the detail courses and appoint respective
officers to know where the employees are lacking behind or in which
field they are deficient.
Invite recommendations from the employees themselves relating to
their respective areas of concern.
The management should ensure that the planning of providing
important training not only be put on paper but also should be practiced
so that the employees be trained and motivated to the new works.
Employees also on the other hand try to cooperate with the
management in times of delay in ensuring any kind of training facilities
so that smooth and effective relations are developed between them.
For better result of T&D programme the management should
increase the infrastructure of training institution present in different
places.
79
8.5 Conclusion:
The study reveals that “Most of time, Training in the organization
is provided for future development in MCL”. It can be seen that workers
of MCL are agreed to the proposition that the assessment facility of
training needs by MCL for future development of the employees.
It can be concluded that training is provided to employees in the
case of promotion so that the employee doesn’t face any difficulty to cope
up with the work which he will get after promotion.
In general it can be concluded that the assessment of training needs
require the performance of workers, change in strategy of the
organization, emergence of machine needs and whether the workers have
KAS(Knowledge, ability, Skill). The facility provided by MCL is quite
good and is beneficiary for the employees for the training of the
employees and for future development.
*********
80
9. CONCLUSION
The training and development facility provided by MCL can be truly
measured by the level of knowledge and skill being experienced by their
employees. Survey analysis and data interpretation have proved to be a
yardstick in the process of measurement and the degree of development.
The entire project has showed that the employees of this organization
are quite satisfied by the training facility being extended to them.
Training and Development courses are beneficiary to the employees of
the MCL.
The employees of the MCL are very much satisfied by the given
training facilities. The workers, supervisors, clerks and officers are
getting the initial, promotional and refresher trainings from time to time
according to the situations and needs, which improve the performance of
81
the employees, to help them how to cope up with the changing strategies,
providing them knowledge about the modern machines. The training is
helping them in getting the respective knowledge needed for the
respective work necessary ability needed for that work and last but not
the least the skill needed to perform the work and complete it
successfully. However a greater degree of effort is needed on the part of
the management to provide technical & educational benefits to the
employees such as providing more and improved knowledge about the
upcoming machines launched in the market for their benefit so that when
they will be said to use it, they wouldn’t face any difficulty and assessing
them with the required knowledge needed for the respective post.
Therefore to conclude it can be said that the MCL needs to extend
its training and development courses facilities to a great extent so that it
can ensure greater training facility and development of the employees to
reap greater rewards and profits.
****************************
82
PREFACE
The present dissertation paper is an outcome of about a month long
field work undertaken as a preliminary training in fulfillment of PGDM,
realizing the potential significance involved in the study of employees of
MCL.
For the convenience sake, the research study has been divided into
few chapters where a different dimension of Training & Development on
Non-Executive Employees of MCL has been discussed. The criteria like
83
Training Programme, Benefits of Training Programme, and Opinion of
Employees on Training etc. shows here to define.
Finally in the last i.e. concluding chapter the essence of the report
is summed up briefly and systematically from a sociological stand point.
(SURAJ KUMARPATEL) (ASIT KUMAR SAHANI)
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Mr. SURAJ KUMAR PATEL done his PGDM dissertation work on “Training & Development of Non-Executive Employees in Public Sector Undertakings, “A Study among the Employees of MCL in Jagriti Vihar, Burla”, District Sambalpur, Orissa, under my supervision and guidance for the part time fulfillment of “POST GRADUATE DIPLOMA IN MANAGEMENT” for REGIONAL COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT (Autonomous) College, BHUBANESWAR. I further verify that his thesis is the record of the original work conducted by him and that to the best of my knowledge no part of the content has ever been submitted either by him or anybody else. I am forwarding his thesis to be examined for part fulfillment of PGDM REGIONAL COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT(Autonomous)COLLEGE, BHUBANESWAR.
84
(R.C. SAMAL) Sr. Manager (Personnel), Mahanadi Coalfields Limited, At/Po: Jagriti Vihar, Burla, Sambalpur-768020
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This came out, is positively not my single soul effort. Rather
I would say it’s even incomplete without the extension of gratitude to
them who figures behind this issue. Here, I appreciate from my heart, my
guide regardless who fed me healthy. Specifically Shri R.C. Samal, Sr.
Manager (Personnel) master mind has a prevailing role throughout the
whole work. Sri R.P. Nanda’s tips and counseling in incredible in
systematizing and presentation of the stocks; Mr. D. Chattopadhyay,
GM(HRD), MCL, field supervision and advice at the time of need has
some splendid share. Above all Shri R.C. Samal, Sr. Manager
(Personnel)’s important tips helped me a lot to complete this work. This
thesis could not have been possible without the timely help of the above
mentioned figures.
85
Again it is a reserve of my gratitude for the employees of Mahanadi
Coalfields Ltd., for their marvelous response in the field work. Special
credit goes to Mr. D. Sethi and Mr. M.R. Pujari of HRD Deptt. of MCL,
for their enormous help during the field study.
Specially I am thankful to my friends for providing me with some
important materials related to my topic. But apart, the Central Library, as
a whole remained an exclusive resort for substantial.
(SURAJ KUMAR PATEL)
(ASIT KUMAR SAHANI)
CONTENTS
SL.NO. CHAPTER SUBJECT PAGES
1. INTRODUCTION 1 to 181.1 Introduction1.2 Employee Structure in Organization1.3 Role of Organization in the
Development of Employees1.4 Employee Structure in MCL1.5 Programme of Training for the
Development of Employees1.6 Programme & Training for
development of Non-Executives1.7 Problem & Study1.8 Objectives1.9 Hypothesis1.10 Plan of Thesis
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE FIELD & METHODOLOGY
19to 42
2.1 Introduction 2.2 MCL History
86
2.3 Jagriti Vihar, Location2.4 Employees & MCL2.5 Executives2.6 Non-Executives2.7 Methodology Research Design2.8 Sampling2.9 Tools & Data Collection2.10 Difficulties encountered2.11 Conclusion
3. SOCIO-ECONOMIC BACKGROUND OF THE RESPONDENTS
43 to 49
3.1 Introduction3.2 Age & Sex3.3 Position held3.4 Years of Service3.5 Education3.6 Conclusion
4. HISTORY OF FAMILY SERVICE 50 to 514.1 Introduction4.2 Fa Fa 4.3 Father4.4 Conclusion
5. HISTORY OF SERVICE OF RESPONDENT 52 to 535.1 Introduction5.2 History of Service5.3 Reasons & Change5.4 Conclusion
6. ENTRY IN MCL 54 to 566.1 Introduction6.2 Type of Entry6.3 Years & Change of Service in MCL6.4 Conclusion
7. TRAINING BY MCL 57 to 767.1 Introduction7.2 Training Programme in MCL7.3 Training received by Non-Executives7.4 Conclusion
8. OPINION ON TRAINING 77 to 808.1 Introduction8.2 Training received8.3 Benefits received
87
8.4 Suggestion8.5 Conclusion
9. CONCLUSION 81 to 8210. APPENDIX – I : BIBLIOGRAPHY
CHAPTER – 1
INTRODUCTION
88
CHAPTER – 2
DESCRIPTION OF THE FIELD
& METHODOLOGY
89
CHAPTER – 3
SOCIO-ECONOMIC
BACKGROUND OF THE
90
RESPONDENTS
CHAPTER – 4
HISTORY
OF
FAMILY
SERVICE
91
CHAPTER – 5
HISTORY OF THE
SERVICE
RESPONDENT
92
CHAPTER – 6
ENTRY
IN
MCL
CHAPTER – 7
93
TRAINING
BY
MCL
CHAPTER – 8
OPINION
94
ON
TRAINING
CHAPTER – 9
CONCLUSION
95
APPENDIX – I
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. L.M. Prasad : Human Resource Management
2. P. Subha Rao : Human Resource and Personnel Management
3. R.K. Sahu : Training for Development
4. T.N. Chabra : Training and Development
96
APPENDIX – II
INTERVIEW SCHEDULE
97
98