measurement of be(n,cp) at n tof: a big challenge for ...€¦ · ear2 the much higher flux in ear2...

36
Measurement of 7 Be(n,cp) at n_TOF: a big challenge for sample preparation and experimental setups M. Barbagallo, A. Musumarra, L. Cosentino, N. Colonna, P. Finocchiaro, A. Pappalardo, L. Damone, O. Aberle, B. Langhans, D. Schumann, E. Maugeri, S. Heinitz, R. Dressler, J. Andrzejewsky, J. Perkowski and the n_TOF Collaboration CHANDA Workshop on target preparation – the needs and the possibilities, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Upload: others

Post on 07-Aug-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF:a big challenge for sample preparation and experimental setups

M. Barbagallo, A. Musumarra, L. Cosentino, N. Colonna, P. Finocchiaro, A. Pappalardo,

L. Damone, O. Aberle, B. Langhans, D. Schumann, E. Maugeri, S. Heinitz, R. Dressler, J.

Andrzejewsky, J. Perkowski and the n_TOF Collaboration

CHANDA Workshop on target preparation – the needs and the possibilities, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Page 2: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Outline

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

• Physics Case: The Cosmological Lithium Problem

• 7Be(n,p) cross-section measurement at n_TOF-EAR2 (2016)

• 7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement at n_TOF-EAR2 (Aug-Oct 2015)

- the experimental setup and the facility- the procedures- preliminary results

Page 3: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Big Bang Nucleosynthesis

Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), together with Hubble expansion and Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation is one of the cornerstones for Big Bang Theory.

BBN gives the sequence of nuclearreactions leading to the synthesis oflight elements up to Na* in the earlystage of Universe (0.01-1000 sec)

At his first formulation, it depended on3 parameters:

-the baryon-to-photon ratio h,-the number of species of neutrino n,-the lifetime of neutron t.

Nowadays BBN is a parameter freetheory**, being the cross-sections ofreactions involved the only input tothe theory.

* A.Coc et al., The Astrophysical Journal, 744:158 (2012)

**D.N. Schramm and T.S Turner, Rev. Mod. Phys 70 (1998) 303

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Page 4: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

The Cosmological Lithium Problem

BBN successfully predicts the abundances

of primordial elements such as 4He, D and 3He.

* R.H.Cyburt et al., Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 11 (2008) 012

*

** A.Coc et al., The Astrophysical Journal, 744:158 (2012)

A serious discrepancy (factor 2-4) between

the predicted abundance of 7Li and the value

inferred by measurements (Spite et al, many

others.)

Cosmological Lithium Problem

(CLiP)

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Page 5: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Solution to CLiP?

Approximately 95% of primordial 7Liis produced from the electron capture decay of 7Be (T1/2=53.2 d).

A higher destruction rate of 7Becan solve or at least partiallyexplain the CLiP.

n + 7Be a + a Q= 19 MeVn + 7Be p + 7Li Q= 1.644 MeV

7Be is destroyed via (n,p) (~97%) and (n,a) (~2.5%) reactions

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Page 6: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Status of evaluations and experimental data: 7Be(n,p)

BBN calculations rely on extrapolation to higher energies of Koehler data or on indirect measurements

Direct measurements Indirect measurements

Only one direct measurement (Koehler et al., 1988, 0.025 eV - 13.5 keV),covering partially the range of BBN interest.

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Page 7: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Only one direct measurement (P. Bassi et al., 1963) at thermal energy

Bassi et al.

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Status of evaluations and experimental data: 7Be(n,a)

Page 8: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

n_TOF program on 7Be(n,cp)

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

185 m

20 GeV/c

protons

20 m

Spallation

Target

EAR1

EAR2

Two beam lines and experimental areas available at n_TOF, EAR1 and EAR2

Page 9: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

n_TOF program on 7Be(n,cp)

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

185 m

20 GeV/c

protons

20 m

Spallation

Target

EAR1

EAR2

Two beam lines and experimental areas available at n_TOF, EAR1 and EAR2

Page 10: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

n_TOF program on 7Be(n,cp)

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

185 m

20 GeV/c

protons

20 m

Spallation

Target

EAR1

EAR2

The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to:• measure samples of very small mass (<1 mg)

• measure short-lived radioisotopes (down to a few weeks)

• collect data on a much shorter time

• measure (n,charged particle) reactions with thin samples

Two beam lines and experimental areas available at n_TOF, EAR1 and EAR2

Page 11: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

n_TOF program on 7Be(n,cp)

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

185 m

20 GeV/c

protons

20 m

Spallation

Target

EAR1

EAR2

The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to:• measure samples of very small mass (<1 mg)

• measure short-lived radioisotopes (down to a few weeks)

• collect data on a much shorter time

• measure (n,charged particle) reactions with thin samples

Two beam lines and experimental areas available at n_TOF, EAR1 and EAR2

Two different measurements at n_TOF

i) n+7Be -> a+a - Coincidences technique

ii)n+7Be -> p+7Li - Telescope technique

Page 12: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

n_TOF program on 7Be(n,cp)

7Be(n,p)Silicon detectors (5x5 cm2, 20 and 300 mm thickness)outside of the beam

Detection of protons (E~ 1 MeV or 1.4 MeV)neutrons

7Be sample

Si detectorPurification of sample needed: ISOLDE

Sample:

• 100 ng of 7Be (material from water cooling of SINQ spallation source at PSI)

• Offline mass separation required at ISOLDE ≤1 day (starting from 100 GBq)

• Implantation on backing

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Page 13: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

105 mg/cm2 thick LiF converter (LNS)2.05 MeV a-particles are stopped in DE detector2.73 MeV tritons loose ~1 MeV

Hosted in vacuum chamber

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Commissioning of the setup for 7Be(n,p) measurement

Inside SiMon2 chamber in EAR2

Page 14: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

105 mg/cm2 thick LiF converter (LNS)2.05 MeV a-particles are stopped in DE detector2.73 MeV tritons loose ~1 MeV

Hosted in vacuum chamber

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Commissioning of the setup for 7Be(n,p) measurement

Inside SiMon2 chamber in EAR2

Page 15: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Commissioning of the setup for 7Be(n,p) measurement

Amplitude of signals vs neutron energy for thin and thick detectors

at

t

Page 16: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Commissioning of the setup for 7Be(n,p) measurement

E-DE matrix for coincidence eventsTritons region clearly visible

Measurement scheduled for 2016 campaign

Page 17: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

neutrons

Silicon 1

Silicon 2

sampleaa

Silicon detectors directly inserted in the beam(3x3 cm2 active area, 140 mm thickness)

Detection of high energy a-particles

Strong rejection of background (sample preparation)

n_TOF program on 7Be(n,cp)

7Be(n,a)

Page 18: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

neutrons

Silicon 1

Silicon 2

sampleaa

Silicon detectors directly inserted in the beam(3x3 cm2 active area, 140 mm thickness)

Detection of high energy a-particles

Strong rejection of background (sample preparation)

1

2

3

4

neutrons

Two different sandwiches of silicon detectors

n_TOF program on 7Be(n,cp)

7Be(n,a)

Page 19: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Det 1

Det 2

Possible to detect coincidences

7Be(n,a): Commissioning of the experimental setup

- LiF converter on mylar foil in the sandwich- Sandwich placed in the lower part of EAR2 beam dump

In-beam test

Page 20: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Upper energy limit (selecting one particle) 10 keV

7Be(n,a): Commissioning of the experimental setup

- LiF converter on mylar foil in the sandwich- Sandwich placed in the lower part of EAR2 beam dump

In-beam test

Page 21: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Inverse current increasing with protons on target, but energy resolution still satisfactory

7Be(n,a): Commissioning of the experimental setup

- LiF converter on mylar foil in the sandwich- Sandwich placed in the lower part of EAR2 beam dump

In-beam test

Page 22: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Inverse current increasing with protons on target, but energy resolution still satisfactory

7Be(n,a): Commissioning of the experimental setup

- LiF converter on mylar foil in the sandwich- Sandwich placed in the lower part of EAR2 beam dump

In-beam test

Page 23: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

a - no g source

a - g source

ch

co

un

ts

Test with a-source (241Am) and g-source (137Cs, 35 GBq) at INFN-LNS

Detector (and electronic) can stand to high flux of g with minor degradation of the signal

7Be(n,a): Commissioing of the experimental setup

Page 24: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Samples

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

2 different samples:(3.5 mg total mass)

Electrodeposited

Evaporated

Evaporated Electrodeposited

Backing Stretched PE (0.6 mm)

Aluminum(5 mm)

Activity 20 GBq 19 GBq

Diameter 30 mm 31.6 mm

Prepared in hot-cell at PSI

Page 25: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Mechanic and Procedure

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

1-bare scattering chamber

2-detector and sample support

3-shielded chamber

4-dose rate

1 2

4

3

Page 26: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Mechanic and Procedure

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Insertion of the samples and shipment

Insertion of the samples and shipment

Page 27: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

7Be(n,a) chamber

Installation at n_TOF-EAR2

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Page 28: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

First signal

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

Page 29: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

First signal

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

Page 30: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

First signal

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

Page 31: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Two different sandwiches of silicon detectors

1

2

3

4

neutrons

Possible to evaluate random coincidences comparing uncorrelated couples of detectors

Page 32: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Two different sandwiches of silicon detectors

1

2

3

4

neutrons

Possible to evaluate random coincidences comparing uncorrelated couples of detectors

Page 33: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Coincidences as a function of time after last separation should show a constant behaviour if normalized to sample mass.

Need to compensate for worsening of charge collection

Page 34: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Coincidences as a function of time after last separation should show a constant behaviour if normalized to sample mass.

Need to compensate for worsening of charge collection

Page 35: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015

Neutron energy

Co

un

ts

First evidences of 7Be(n,a) reactions above 0.025 eV

Page 36: Measurement of Be(n,cp) at n TOF: a big challenge for ...€¦ · EAR2 The much higher flux in EAR2 allows to: • measure samples of very small mass (

Conclusions

• Uncertainties in nuclear data strongly affect the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis calculations for theabundance of 7Li and could probably explain (at least partially) the Cosmological LithiumProblem.

• n_TOF at CERN presented an experimental program to measure the two neutron inducedreactions responsible for the destruction of 7Be.

• 7Be(n,p) cross-section measurement is planned for 2016 at n_TOF-EAR2.- For the (n,p) measurement, isotopic purity of the sample will be done at ISOLDE (final mass 100 ng)

starting from 7Be collected at PSI.- Telescope technique will be used to detect protons coming out from the reaction.

• 7Be(n,a) cross-section measurement has been already performed, using n_TOF-EAR2 neutronbeam and two samples prepared at PSI.

• Coincidences of two a particles coming from 7Be(n,a) reaction have been observed for thefirst time above 0.025 eV.

M. Barbagallo, ‘’Measurement of 7Be(n,cp) at n_TOF’’, CHANDA Workshop on target preparation, PSI, 23-25 November 2015