medusa101013 lpv icao framework - telespaziogalileo.cs.telespazio.it/medusa/public/medusa technical...

27
ICAO framework for LPV enav.it Patrizio Vanni GNSS expert Torrejon, 10-10-2013

Upload: trinhnhan

Post on 23-May-2018

245 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

ICAO framework for LPV

enav.it

Patrizio Vanni

GNSS expert

Torrejon, 10-10-2013

Main topics

• PBN framework

• GANP & ASBU concept

• PBN Manual

• GNSS Manual

• Italian experience

• Conclusions

2

The challenges

• Air Traffic is going to growth in next decades (but less than previously estimated)

• Transition to GNSS-based services

• PBN concept

• Fuel consumption and CO2 emission reduction

3

What and why PBN?

• Performance-based Navigation (PBN) defines performance requirements for aircraft

navigating on an ATS route, terminal procedure or in a designated airspace.

Benefits:

– reduce aviation congestion (capacity, efficiency)

– conserve fuel

– protect the environment

– reduce the impact of aircraft noise

– great flexibilityNAVAID NAVAID

infrastructureinfrastructure

NAV NAV specificationspecification

NAV NAV applicationapplication

– great flexibility

– Increase of safety

• A37-11 urges all States to complete a national

PBN implementation plan as soon as possible to achieve:

– PBN for en route and terminal areas,

according to established timelines and intermediate milestones;

– PBN approach procedures with vertical guidance (APV) for all instrument runway ends (as

primary or back-up for precision approach) by 2016

4

PBN Concept

infrastructureinfrastructure

Nav Applications

Com Surv ATM

Airspace Concept

Nav

ICAO Performance Based Navigation Concept

5

RNP SpecificationsRNAV Specifications

RNAV10

(RNP 10)

RNAV 5

RNAV 2

RNAV 1

RNP 2

RNP 1

Advanced RNP

RNP 0.3

RNP APCH

RNP AR APCH

RNP w/

Added

Requirements

e.g. 3D, 4D

RNP 4

Nav Specifications Nav Infrastructure

Relevant ICAO Annexes

Annex 10Annex 10

Aeronautical Aeronautical TelecommunicationsTelecommunications

SARPs

SIS

Annex 11Annex 11

Air Traffic ServicesAir Traffic Services

Annex 4Annex 4

Aeronautical chartsAeronautical charts

Annex 14Annex 14

AerodromesAerodromes

Annex 15Annex 15

Aeronautical Aeronautical Information ServicesInformation Services

NOTAMNOTAM

6

SIS performance

GNSS receiver

performance

Relevant ICAO publications

Doc 4444 Air Doc 4444 Air Traffic ManagementTraffic Management

PANS ATM

Doc 9992 Doc 9992

PBN Airspace PBN Airspace design manualdesign manual

PBN implementation processes

Doc 9849 GNSS Doc 9849 GNSS ManualManual

GNSS context

Doc 9613Doc 9613

PBN ManualPBN Manual

Implementation guidance

Doc 8168Doc 8168

PANSPANS--OPSOPS

Obstacle clearance

Doc 9905Doc 9905

RNP AR APCH RNP AR APCH

Doc 8071Doc 8071

Manual on testing of Manual on testing of radio navigation aids radio navigation aids

GNSS testing

7

ATC phraseology

FPL

SpecificationsProcedure

design

Applicability Nov 2014 (subject to ANC review)

Air Navigation Conference #12

• Held from 19 till 30 November 2012

• Attended by 1032 participants from 120 Contracting States and 30 Observer

Delegations

• Endorsement of Global Air Navigation Plan as unified planning mechanism

• Endorsement for short term Block Upgrades (Block1)

• Strategic directions for medium and long term Block Upgrades (Block 2 & 3)

• Today’s priorities are:

–– PerfomancePerfomance--based Navigationbased Navigation

–– Continuous Descent OperationsContinuous Descent Operations

– Continuous Climb Operations

• GNSS is a key element for Air Navigation Systems

8

ANC#12 recommendations

• Rationalization of radio systems

• That ICAO and other stakeholders to explore strategies for the decommissioning of some navigation aids

and ground stations, and the rationalization of the on-board communications, navigation and surveillance

systems while maintaining safety and coordinating the need for sufficient system redundancy.

• PBN for terminal and approach operations implementation

– That States and stakeholders:

• urgently implement, where appropriate, PBN for terminal and approach operations in accordance with

Assembly Resolution A37-11;

• urgently adopt efficient operations approval procedures and support the mutual recognition of other • urgently adopt efficient operations approval procedures and support the mutual recognition of other

States’ operational approvals;

• share their best practices including required navigation performance authorization-required

implementation initiatives as well as relevant flight operational safety assessment documentation with

other States;

• determine operational requirements in support of their airspace concept in accordance with the

processes described in the Performance-based Navigation (PBN) Manual in order to select the

appropriate PBN specification;

• including regulators, airport authorities, air navigation service providers, commercial operators, General

Aviation and the military, work together at all levels and in close coordination to ensure successful

performance-based navigation implementation

9

ICAO General Assembly #38

• Hosted in Montreal from 24th September till 4th of October

• Endorsement of ICAO Doc 9750 Global Air Navigation Plan

• Areas related to GNSS:

– SBAS L1/L5 signal specification

– Reflection of GPS L5 specifications in Annex 10– Reflection of GPS L5 specifications in Annex 10

– Request from Russian federation on developing instructions material to assist States on

implementing GNSS

• Output assessment on going…

10

ICAO Global Air Navigation Plan• First draft presented at ANC#12, reviewed by States, ICAO Aviation partners and

industry stakeholders

• Provides the potentials to increase system capacity and efficiency, decreasing impacts

on environment

• Block Upgrade concept is a flexible approach to implementation, not all modules are

necessary for States and Regions

Ch.1 Global Air Navigation Policy

Ch.2 Standardization: Aviation System Block Upgrades

Ch.3 Continuing Strategic Planning

Ch.4 Implementing Globally Interoperable ATM

Ch.5. Aviation System Reporting & Performance Adjustments

11

Air Space Block Upgrade Concept

Block 0 (2013)

Block 1 (2018)

Block 2 (2023)

Block 3 (2028>)

AIRPORT AIRPORT OPERATIONS OPERATIONS

Optimization of approaches procedures

including vertical guidance

Optimized airport accessibility

GLOBALLY INTEROPERABLE

SYSTEMS AND

Performance

Improvement

Areas

12

SYSTEMS AND DATA

OPTIMUM CAPACITY AND

FELXIBLE FLIGHTS

Improved Operations through Optimized ATS

Routing

EFFICIENT EFFICIENT FLIGHT PATHSFLIGHT PATHS

Improved Flexibility and Efficiency in

Descent Profiles using Continuous Descent Operations (CDOs)

Improved Flexibility and Efficiency in Descent Profiles

(CDOs) using VNAV

Improved Flexibility and Efficiency in Descent Profiles

(CDOs) Using VNAV, Required Speed and

Time at Arrival

.

PBN Manual

• ICAO Doc 9613 Performance-based Navigation Manual 4th ed. was published on

March 2013

• Guidance to States, Air Navigation Service Providers and Airspace Users on how to

implement RNAV and RNP applications.

• Volume I: Concept and Implementation guidance

– Part A The PBN Concept– Part A The PBN Concept

– Part B Implementation Guidance

• Volume II: Implementing RNAV and RNP Operations

– Part A General

– Part B Implementing RNAV Operations

– Part C Implementing RNP Operations

13

Airspace d

esig

nP

roje

ct p

lan

nin

g

1111 • Operational requirement

2222 • PBN Implementation team

3333 • Project objectives and scope

4444 • Reference scenario

5555 • Safety and Performance criteria

6666 • CNS/ATM Assumptions

7777 • Route design

8888 • Initial Procedure Design

• Airspace Volumes

Imple

menta

tion

Valid

ation &

Imple

menta

tion

pla

nnin

g

Airspace d

esig

n

9999 • Airspace Volumes

10101010 • Confirm Navigation Specifications

11111111 • Validate airspace concept

12121212 • Finalize procedure design

13131313 • Instrument flight procedure + Flight Inspection

14141414 • ATC system integration consideration

15151515 • Awareness and training material

16161616 • Implementation

17171717 • Post-implementation review14

PBN Manual: Navigation Service Monitoring

• Information on the operational status of radio navigation service

– If the service is essential by the State � GNSS monitoring tool

– NOTAMs (predictive GNSS service availability)

OR

– Pilot reports based on status information provided by the avionics

ADDITIONAL

– Independent real-time ground based stations (GNSS status information)

• Differences in RAIM algorithms• Differences in RAIM algorithms

• Satellites in view

• Receiver mask angle

• Integration with other sensors (DME/DME, baro, inertial)

� risk to have conflicting status information, which sensor trust (avionic or ground)?

• Can be used also for data recording and archiving

15

PBN Manual: Implementing RNP APCH

• LNAV/VNAV minima

• Elements to be considered

– Missed approach (can be based also upon conventional NAVAID)

– Risk of loss of RNP APCH capability

– Obstacle clearance

– Verification of SBAS signal and SBAS provider against national regulation

– Air Traffic Controllers training– Air Traffic Controllers training

– FAS DB creation (quality of data)

• SBAS availability

– Can be checked by NOTAM or Prediction Services (to be decided by the operating authority)

– Prediction tools assess the expected capability

16

PBN Manual requirements for pre-flight

• RAIM levels required for RNP APCH down to LNAV or LNAV/VNAV minima can be

verified by :

– NOTAMs (where available)

– prediction services

• The service may be provided by:

– ANSP,

– avionics manufacturer,

– other entities, – other entities,

– airborne receiver RAIM prediction capability

• LP or LPV service availability prediction should take into account the latest GPS

constellation and SBAS system status NOTAMs and avionics model (when available).

The service may be provided by:

– ANSP,

– avionics manufacturer,

– other entities

– through an airborne receiver LP or LPV service prediction capability.

17

GNSS Manual

• ICAO DOC 9849 Global Navigation Satellite System Manual 2nd ed.

18

GNSS Manual

• GNSS vulnerabilities

– Effective spectrum management

– Adequate regulatory framework (repeaters and pseudolites) created by States

– Compatibility of DME/TACAN infrastructure with GNSS

– Risk assessment on intentional interference

– Ionosphere and Solar activity

• Certification and Operational approvals• Certification and Operational approvals

– Airworthiness approval

– Smooth IFR operations

– Technology mature

– Acceptable risks

– SIS performance

– Quality of procedure design

– DB integrity

– Training

19

GNSS Manual: GNSS monitoring and recording

•• ObjectiveObjective: Monitor and record relevant GNSS data to support accident /incident

investigation and confirm periodically GNSS performances (accuracy, integrity,

continuity and availability)

• Recording point located in representative locations in the service area

• Recording system independent of the GNSS service and can be delegated to other

entities (for EGNOS, in Europe done by ESSP)

• Parameters to be considered for all GEOs:

– GEO C/N0– GEO C/N0

– GEO raw pseudo-range code and carrier phase

– SBAS data messages

– Receiver status information

• Can be used as support to RFI detection

20

GNSS Manual: Aeronautical Information Services

• Provide relevant information (terms & conditions, procedures, training req, etc)

• Background information about SBAS technology

• Means: AIP, AIC or advisory circular

• Service status notifications can be provided via NOTAM or on alternative ways (e.g.

internet)

• NOTAM can be used in case of:

– Widespread SBAS service outages– Widespread SBAS service outages

– Confirmed local signal interferences

21

ENAV background in GNSS

• 1997: AIC A4/97 introduction of B-RNAV based on VOR/DME infrastructure

• September 2010: Italian PBN TF constitution, AIC A5/2010 EGNOS SoL introduction

over Italian Airspace

• April 2011: AIC A1/2011 Introduction of P-RNAV in the terminal airspace of Italy based

on GNSS, DME/DME

• November 2011: First draft for National RNP Approaches Safety Case • November 2011: First draft for National RNP Approaches Safety Case

• May 2012: EWA signature with ESSP

• June 2012: National PBN Implementation Plan approved by National Regulator

• September 2012: National RNP Approaches Safety Case approval by NSA

• November 2012: AIC A17/2012 Introduction of RNP APCH in Italy

• December 2012: first LPV publication for Linate Airport

22

Italian LPV implementation plan

• The plan is in line with the ICAO Assembly Resolution A37/11

• Short term 2012-2014

– LPV procedures for major airports as backup of ILS

– Radar monitoring mitigation

• Medium term 2014-2016

– LPV for airports with site critical issues

• Long term 2016-2020

– Cost/benefit analysis to assess where is possible to dismiss conventional navaids– Cost/benefit analysis to assess where is possible to dismiss conventional navaids

• Future steps

1. Consider impacts of new PBN IR

2. Perform feasibility studies of LPV implementation on small airports without radar monitoring

service

3. Review National safety case in order to update some mitigations

4. Consider EGNOS evolutions

5. Update National PBN plan, if necessary

23

Approach phase

• Consultation with operators in progress by means of periodical ENAV Customer Care

meeting

• RNP APCH procedures initially implemented with LNAV and LPV minima

• Airports already involved:

– LIRF => Main runway ends (16L/R, 34L/R);

– LIML RWY 36, LIMC RWY 35L, LIPZ RWY 22L;

• Next airports: Further 8 runway ends expected before next summer LIML (RWY 18),

LIMC (RWY 35R), LIRQ (RWY 05), LIPE, LIMF (RWY 36), LIME; LIMJLIMC (RWY 35R), LIRQ (RWY 05), LIPE, LIMF (RWY 36), LIME; LIMJ

• Implementation , expected during next year, on two runway ends at the moment served

only by circling approach (LIMJ RWY 10 – LIPX RWY 22).

• LPV helicopter approach procedures developed and validated for Milan Linate and

Bergamo airports in the framework of ACCEPTA Project;

• GNSS monitoring: Activities in progress in order to deploy a national GNSS strategy

and to overcome some of the Safety Requirements needed for the implementation of

RNP APCH procedures.

24

Training Plan

• Training modules for Procedure designers in the framework of continuous training

activities

• Training modules on PBN familiarization and P-RNAV procedures, including

operational aspects, for ATCOs operating in radar CTR

• Training module on GNSS approach procedure for ATCOs planned accordingly to

implementation schedule

• Operational training modules on PBN and related procedure management for ATCOs

instructors operating at ENAV Academy

• Training modules on PBN familiarization for all people involved in operational activities.

25

Conclusions

• Some points need to be further developed under ICAO and European framework in

order to have an harmonized approach:

– Clarifications on requirements for GNSS monitoring,

– Actions to take in case of SIS performance degradation

• GNSS vulnerabilities

• SBAS evolutions:

– DF (L1, L5) + DC (GPS, Galileo)

– Improvements in service flexibility, availability, level of service and safety

26

27