memorandum of law in support of defendants' motion to · pdf file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 :...

32
86B$&7,9(??? 81,7(' 67$7(6 ',675,&7 &2857 6287+(51 ',675,&7 2) 1(: <25. &DVH 1R &9 .%) ,Q UH /XOXOHPRQ 6HFXULWLHV /LWLJDWLRQ 0(025$1'80 2) /$: ,1 6833257 2) '()(1'$176¶ 027,21 72 ',60,66 7+( &2162/,'$7(' &/$66 $&7,21 &203/$,17 25 ,1 7+( $/7(51$7,9( 72 67$< 7+( $&7,21 :(,/ *276+$/ 0$1*(6 //3 )LIWK $YHQXH 1HZ <RUN 1< 7HOHSKRQH )D[ $WWRUQH\V IRU 'HIHQGDQWV OXOXOHPRQ DWKOHWLFD LQF DQG &KULVWLQH 'D\ 'HFHPEHU Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 1 of 32

Upload: haque

Post on 16-Feb-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 1 of 32

Page 2: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 2 of 32

Page 3: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 3 of 32

Page 4: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 4 of 32

Page 5: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 5 of 32

Page 6: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 6 of 32

Page 7: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 7 of 32

Page 8: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 8 of 32

Page 9: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 9 of 32

Page 10: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 10 of 32

Page 11: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 11 of 32

Page 12: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 12 of 32

Page 13: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 13 of 32

Page 14: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 14 of 32

Page 15: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 15 of 32

Page 16: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 16 of 32

Page 17: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 17 of 32

Page 18: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 18 of 32

Page 19: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 19 of 32

Page 20: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 20 of 32

Page 21: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 21 of 32

Page 22: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 22 of 32

Page 23: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 23 of 32

Page 24: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 24 of 32

Page 25: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 25 of 32

Page 26: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 26 of 32

Page 27: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 27 of 32

Page 28: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 28 of 32

Page 29: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 29 of 32

Page 30: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 30 of 32

Page 31: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 31 of 32

Page 32: Memorandum of Law in support of Defendants' Motion to · PDF file&hqw 6wdwhv 6 ( 6 : $uhdv 3hqvlrq )xqg y )hg +rph /rdq 0ruwj &rus : ... &lw\ ri 7d\oru *hq (psv 5hw 6\v y 0djqd ,qw¶o

26 US_ACTIVE:\44382439\2\60373.0003

Dated: December 4, 2013 New York, New York

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Joseph S. Allerhand Joseph S. Allerhand Caroline Hickey Zalka Melanie A. Conroy Robert S. Ruff III WEIL, GOTSHAL & MANGES LLP 767 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10153 Telephone: (212) 310-8000 Facsimile: (212) 310-8007

Attorneys for Defendants lululemon athletica, Inc. and Christine Day

Case 1:13-cv-04596-KBF Document 36 Filed 12/04/13 Page 32 of 32