meronews2
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
1/18
MERCITI C IaEWSLETTER
BULLETIN D'
INFuhituTION6
f.,
IITINOUIUEIS
NO
2 Avril
1969
Commc
le pr,(cldent, le
prdsent
Bulletin
d'Informatinns M(r~ritiqmues a It(, pr, par(, ,(dit6
et
dif-
fus6 sous tes
auspices du Centre
Documentaire
de
1'Ecole
Pratique des Hautes
Etudes (
V(me
section),
du
Centre
de
Recherches Egyptrl
rgiques de la
Sorbonne
et
de
l'Equipe
de
Lecherches n
0
32 du
Centre National
de
la
Recherche Scientifique,
Paris.
Adresser
t-ute
crrespondance
aux
6diteurs
du Bulletin
A. Heyler,
18,rue Monswiller,
Cr-nenbrurg,Strasbrurg
67,
France
J.
Leclant,
77,Rue
Georges
Lardennwis,
Paris
XIXe
75, France
-
et,
Bruce
G.
Trigger,
Department
-f
Anthrppplrgy,
Vc Gill
University
- Eintreal ,
Canada.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
2/18
A NOTE ON
ThT
PARTICLE BE-S
by
Nick
B.
IM'illet and
Andre
Heyler
Professor
Fr.
Hintze,
in
his
valuable
article
(i),
has
isolated
a
particle
be-s,
the
use of whilch
he analyses,
and
which
he tends
to
think has
reference
to a dual
"object"
in
clauses of
the type
he is
con-
cerned
with.
In
the time
since
Fr.
Hintze's
work
was
done, both
the
undersigned
have
given
some
attention to
this
problem, working
separately
on
groups
of
new
material discovered
during the
recent
Nubian
Salvage
Campaign,
and
since
both of
us anticipate
publication very
shortly
of
our
results
in
book
form,
it has
seemed
desirable
to collaborate
on
a prelimin-
ary
note
on
the subject,
in
which
stress
can
be laid
on
the areas
in
which
we
agree
on our
understandinv
of this
element
and its
function.
Further
refinements
of our
respective
points of
view can
then
be
taken
up in
our
final publications.
The
following
can then
be taken
as representing
conclusions
simultaneously
arrived
at by two persons
working
independently
on at least
partly different groups
of
new texts.
The
published
exanmples
in
which the
clement be-2
occurs
are
listed
below. We confrine
ourselves, as
did Fr.
Hintze,
to occurrences
drawn
from
the descriptive
sections of
funerary texts, leaving
aside several
instances
in other
texts.
1. seni Lni-s
Qeremtebelide
ate Belimetye kdis + be-s-ls
Kar. 89
=
REM
0289,
Struktur
/j 7
2.
belgl$ke
Np-te-te-li
Pedeme-te-li Ste +
be-s-l1
Kar. 125
=
R~E
0325,
Struktur
f297
3.
pqr-leb
peste-leb
yetmde
+
ao^-be-s-le
Kar.
25
=
R
oI
225,
Struktur
Obf
(1)
Hintze,
Struktur,
1963
in
M.I.0., IX,
1963, p. 1 -
29.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
3/18
4.
.pr
qeri-s
Far.
44
5. r re
4ri-s
Far.
44
=
L..Jkrer
Pqmie trer
IRiE
0544,
Struktur
?Pi
0544,
Hilntze,
yetrmde
+
qe-be-s-le
+ tq7-be-s-le
Struktu,
p.
4
6.
pelmes-leb
apte-leb -rphl-leb kdite + be-s-l1
Toshkd
= TWA
1C,.2)
=
i
1049
The last exasple
cited
has
been
more
recently
published
by
B.G. Trigger and is
sufiicient by
itself
to
show
that be-s is not
specifically
dual, but
rather plural
(2),
since not
to
but
three
co-
ordinated
plural nouns precede
the norphems to
which
be-s is bound.
Ex.5
above is,
as
it stands,
anoimalous,
since there
is
no
room for
another
name in the lIcuna. This
difficulty was recognised
by
Fr.Hintze
at
the timc; si ~ o hr
:iatter's are involved in the
elucidation
of this
problem, which wili
be
attepted by hi.B.
lillet in
his forthcoming
publication,
further discusoion
of
this
troublesome
example
must be post-
poned
till
then.
To these
exa:plis
c:(a
be added
some new
ones
Mreroitic
funerary texts
discovCered
at Gekol
Adda by
the
America- Res3earch Cernt- in
Egypt
in
the
period
7.
lh
mcd.-li-s-leb
yetmde
+
qe-be-s-le
GA
4,
unpublished
drawn from
the
the expedition
of
1962-1966.
8.
perite
We-s-leb
GA
4,
unpublished
qeren
W7s-s-leb
yetmde
+
qe-be-s-1Y
(1) Bruce G. Trigger,
A 1croitic
Tomb Inscription from Toshka West in
Postilla,
Yale Peabody Museum of Natural Kistor, 72,
Dec.20,
New Haven,
p.
1-12.
(2) Cf. Andre'
Heyler,
Note sur 1,s articles
miroitiques
in
Comptes
rendus
du
G.L.E.C.S., tome
X l1966-1967,
2d
fasc., p. 109 and
119;
p. 128,
n.42;
p.150,
n.
56;
p.134,
n.105 and
n.113
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
4/18
9.
pelmes ate-li-s-leb 1h
Wrs-te-leb
lU
m@d-li-s-leb
hrpii
Sqeli-.te-leb
kdite
+
;e-s-1s
GA
20,
unpublished
10. ateqi Sbewyenkeli
pqr T11.enkeli
belele;e
Abyertli
ateqi rqye
GA
28
3,
unTpublished
ateqi
Sitkem^eli
ateqi
AGotrqli
belil$ke
Dskemhr
belel$ke Q(riteyli
kel7w yetmde
+
aq$-be-s-1e
11.
ant 'L
m-te-leb
kdite
+ ge-be-s-16
GA 29 A, unpublished
12.
wkite
T~i-te-leb
"te
+
GA
29
A,
unpublished
aae-be-s-l~
13.
mrreboe
kttre-leb
mreba~ erC.-s-leb
be-s-le
GA
29
T,
unpublislhed
kelw yetmde
+ be-s-le
Ss7
irerI
Le
kre leb
te
GA 37,
unpublished
15. perite W -s-leb'. qeren W 'es--sleb dite
GA 37,
unpuilished'
16.
.Je-leb
9te + be-s-1,
GA
37,
unpublishe..
17.
mlekeye's
+
be-s-l9e\
P(1)m/l7key^s
P mlekeyes P mleke.
_.-IsP alekey's
P
kelw yetmde + be-s-l1
(1)
Here
for
"personal
name",
fol~opwing'
the
usage
of
Fr.
Hintze.
+
ace-
.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
5/18
It
becomes
quite
clear
that
the
particle
*e-.
must
have
a
generally
plural
reference
rather
tha)n a dual
menaing,
and
that
the presence
of only a siigle
nounL in the
plural
(exx.
7,
11, 12,
14
(?),
16
(?))
is
sufficient
to
justify
its
presence.
The
particle
occurs
in
what can be
taken
as two
forms,
one
in which it
is
:immediately
bound to
the precedent
noun
of
relationship
(kdite,
"sister";
te,
mother ;
yetmdo, "relative"
?),
and
one where another
morjhem, rendered
as
e, aq
or as- intervenes.
This
element
is of quite
unknown
mean lilng,
but
seems
to
be
optional,
as indeed is the
element
be-s itself, since
the
corpus of
MIcroitic
funerary
texts includes
irmnnmrable
instances
where
the reference
is
plural
but the
clement
under
discussion
is missing.
It is
far
more
common
at
Adda
than
at
iT~hr Uars or Larang,
and
the
frecquncy
of
use may
reflect a dialect
peculiarity,
either
local
or chronological.
Let
us
examine the reorcs-ive
stiche:s withi final
nouns of
relationship
that
Professor
]intze
quotes in
his
"Struktur".
No
particle apparently
accompanies
the
nouns whose
complements
are
in the
singular,
we
find the snme absence
in thirty-two
instances
where
the complement
has
a
plural
meaning: the
anteposition
of
th e
latter
is
sufficient to
mark
its dependency
on
the
second one,
th e
noun
of
relationship.
Only
four or
five nouns of relationship
are
provided with a particle;
in all the clear instances
xx. -1
to 4 ,
the governed
syntagn
shows a
complex structure
and
therefore
assumes
some
length.
The texts
recently
discoverod
at
Toshka
and
at Gebel
Adda confirm
this
tendency
(cf. cxx, 6, 8, 9, 10, 13, 15
and
17).
(Qe-)be-s
seems to
strongthen the
relation
existing
between
the noun
of
relationship
and its
complement,
chiefly
when
this connection
is
likely to
be lost
sight
of.
lia-;
ij
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
6/18
There
are about
the same
nuaber of
particles
with
the
whole
series
of
nouns
kdis sister ,
kdite,
sister (?) ,
and
6te,
'bmother"
(type
D, 9e=x.) as
with
yetmde (type E,
0
exx.).
Th e
be-s
particle,
however,
occurs
seven
times with
the
nouns
of
type
D
and
only
once with
those
of
the type
E; ()e-be-s
twice
in all
with
type D
against seven
with
type E.
Does
1-e
play
a
part
which is
more
appropriate to
tie
stiches
of
type
E
than
to those
of
the
type D?(
A comparable
sequence, c,
occurs
fairly
often in
the
texts. We
shall
retain
only three
examples,
attested
in
the stiches
whose
analysis
is
relatively
easy;
ge-s
seems to
appear here
as
a
particle of the
same
family
as
(qe-)7e-s.
18.
yetmde
+ _e7.s P
qewi Kar. 15
=
REM
0215
19.
mrte + g~-s-le
EK
32b =
REI
1024B
20. x s
+ _-s-1
Mer.
Inscr.
108
=
~E 0108
The
stich
of
exc:ple
18
intervenes in an epitaph showing
the
names
of
two
persons; it follows
the
nomination
of the second
person
and
plays
the
part of
on epithet
adjoined
to the latter.
Like
(qe-)be-s,
which
is
always
found
in
connection -ith one
term
or with a group
of terms in
anteposition,
qe-s
may
refer
to a ter
which precedes it; here, it
might be the
name of
the dec sed vwhich occurs
in the
first
nomination;
two differences
might be
pointed
out between qe-be-s
and
be-s: th e
particle
(oe-)be-s refers,
in the
analysed
examples,
to
terms
which
are
located
in the
same stich
astlhe
particle
and are 1plural
in
meaning;
ge-s would
here
refer to a
singular entity,
that
is,
the
first
nominated
defunct,
which
is
not mentioned
in
the
same
stich.
1)
For the
distinction
between
these
types,
of.
Heyler,
Note
su r
les
"articles", p. 116
et p. 118-120.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
7/18
Stich 19
is the
second one
of
a legend
attached to a young
boy;
this
child
is
represented next
to
a
lady, the
defunct,
who
putsher
hand
on
his
head; this gesture seems
to
be a
gesture
of
protection
or
acknowledgement.
Qe-s
might
here
refer to
the feminine
personage.
Stich
20 is
the
second
one
in a legend
which
presents
a rather
small
person accompcanyiing
a notable
in
the "procession"
carved
on th e
walls of the
't"ieroitic
chamber"
of Philae.
QE-s might
here
refer
to
this dignitary.
If ge-be
- s alternates
;ith
a simpler
form
be-s,
then
can we
not
expect that qe-s will alternate
with a
simpler
form -s?
Thus,
as
we know a
syntag-n
mte +
ge-s,
we expect a
syntagm
such
as
mte + s.
Indeed, we
cannot exclude the
possibility that
some examples of
this
term
occurringin- Kar.i7
=
R
0247
are, in
some
way, related
to
this
expectation.
21.
k'i
akl;
5 nw htckoke
Sde-te-l mte
+
s-le
Kar.
47
= d7i
247,
Struktur
53-7
22.
qeresmle
Dewekdil
mte
+
s-le
Kar.
47 =
iZ24.7,
Struktur
L2~ 7
23.
Arutl
imtr +
s-le
Kar.
47 =
EPE 0247,
Struktur
87
Ex.22 seems
to
be
the
cloarust one.
The defunct
might
claim
a mte
relationship
with the
consort of
the
linEg,
C-diI.-
Here,
-s might
possibly
emphasise
the
relation
with
the
person
concerned;
a possible
"translation"
should be:
He
(the
deceased)
is
mte
of
her, the
-nnsort
of
the
king, g'ekfil".
An-yhos',
as
it
was
the case
of-be-s and
ge-be-s,
the
antecedent
might
be in
the
three
instances
a determinated
word
or
nominal
group
and might
be
in
the same
stich.
The words
Sdegtel,
Dewekdil
and Arwvtl
do show the
ep.Icted
article.
Thiskind of
structure,
N-1
+
V/N +
s-l
cannot,
of
course,
be confused
with the
well-known
N +
N-s
or N-li-s
structure,
Cr
"genitive"
structure.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
8/18
We
might attempt
to
analyse
the data we have
so far
considered as
follows(l)
A. Progressive groups
N
+ N-s
ant +
:ini-s
ms + gere-s
N + ~e-s
ms
+ ge-s
/V
+
e-s
mte
+
qe-s
V
+
e-s
Yetm e +_
c
-
B.
Regressive
stiches
N-i
+
V testg-1 +
yetmde
N-leb +
V pest8-leb + vetmde
C.
IMixed stichcs
with
redundance
GIT-i + Y/V + s,
Sresmle
I)enekdil
"prophet of
Amon ;
ms
(titl;)
of
the
king";
ms
of
him,
his mso ;
"her
mte";
"his
kinsman":
"kinsman
of
the
viceroy";
"kinsman of (the)
viceroys".
etc.
+ mte
+ s
"rmte
of
her, the
consort
of
th e
king"
N-1
+
1N/v
+
ae-s
not
found;
GlT-leb
+
Gi--lob
+
V
+
be-s
rte-s- leb + geren
- s-
perite
-s-leb
+ Js-s-leb
+ kdite +
be-s
"sister of them,
the agents of
Isis and the
Cerens
of Isis";
GNT-1eb +
C-leu +
V + oe-be-s.
perite
ess-leb
+ _re
, s -s-leb +
yt.nde
+
e-be-s
"kinsman
of
them
, i
,
etc"
The ce-1ni
i e ending S
se-ms
to
be e-endent
from a support
in the
structure 17
+
it-s,
and with the particles
ge-s, be-s
and
qe-be-s;
when
-s
seems
to
be
independent,
as
in
exx.tl
to
23,
-s
might assume a
new
value
that .;e
have tried
to express
by
nmecns of
of her
(ex.22, cf. C.,
supra).
1) The
letter
V
represents
here
the
different
terms
of
relationship
as
in Hintze,
Struktur,
1963;
GN
represents
a nominal
group.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
9/18
Bo)
is well-1known
as a mark
of the
plural
in
the article
lob
and seems
to have the
same
value in g~-be-s.
(e)
operates
as a support of the
genitive
-s in be-s;
it seems
to assume
here a
new
value that
we have
tried
to express by acans
of the
third
person personal pronoun them
(ex. 83 cf.
C, slpy). The same pronoun "thom"
might express th e
element
-b-
of the particle
bhe that
follows
the radical
of the
verbs
of
benediction provided
with
a
plural protagonist .
Qo
operates as
a support of the genitive
particle in ge-s
and
in th e
genitive plural compound
ce-be-s. We
tried to express
this value
by
means
of the third person singular pronoun "him" or "her" (see
under A,
In conclusion, -e )( c--z
assumes
the shape of a kind of series
we have
tried
to express
by difforont
possessive
pronouns, or
their
equivalents.
Toe
refuse
to
assign to these elements
a
definitive
meaning.
It
is
only by a
provisional rendering that
we
assigned
e.g.
to
ge-r
the
value
of
a
possessive pronoun of the third person singular,
with
perhaps a demonstrative shade.
After
the relationship nouns,
be-s and
oe-be-s
serve to
recall
and
to bring together
the whole
of
a
plural complement,
mostly
when
t
latter
has
some extesion,
in the
immediate vicinity
of
the
governed
radical.
This succinct account
clearly:
requires
complements
and modifications.
Any
further
suggestion
on
these
problems
will
be
welcom
g
.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
10/18
-10
ELIJINAIiiRES
A~
UANliXEI
lIE
D,'EIIGItAIRIE
tMERITIQUE
(
REk )
par
Jean
Leclant
& Andrd
Hieyler
-o
o~ oo o
o
(
suite
de
UL.
.L.,
n
1,
p.
9-18)
Le dernier
tucite m-rriti'lue
irivctnri,}
dass
n-tre prc'(d.dcnt
article
iiM tC1.5)
a-vait
Gt(
p
ubli,
en
1.927. I
fa
1
lut attendre,
sermble-t-il,
1'ann,,e 93
p-:ur
la
publicati--n
de n-uvelles
ins-
cripti-ns,
n-s iii l101 s ,. La
rs,rente
liste d-ntie
1'invent-iire,
avec
bibli
-raphie
s-r
airc,
des
textes
publ
i(s
entre
1935 et
1,95C,
A l exception de ceux
jgr-upe(s
dans
les grandes
series;
IBEY,
C60
sq =
,jacadam,
IIawa, 1, 19,'9.
REM
C 8 1 =
Dunham, i.C
K
195U sq .
1016
EK 23
Caire
4
RIeste
d'un
tcxte
apparelmmrent
suivi
trac(
1
'encre
n,-ire
sur
un
f'ragment
d'-strac-n
tr',ovt;
dans
lc b-urg
" r-rain
(
mais-n
I,
piece
1, surfice,
-bjut
n' ;) de
Cuadi el-Arab.
Emery-Kirwan,
Wadi
es-Sebua
-
Adindan,
1935,I,p.
11U,115
et
531;
II,
f. s.
p1
.5
In
:cr.
n
0
2;).
SLes
&d1cuments
( i~i
I C-l1U2 5) prvenanrit
du
survey
mend entre
Cuadi
es-Sebfta
et
Adiindan -nt,
lp-vsls
-au ,iLfe
du Caire
(cf.
c-^urrier
de
L.P.
Ki.rwan,
'4.X. 1968);
il
nfi
-us
a pas
0t',
prssible
d'en
d, ie-rmine:r
1e
num4r-
uu
-urnal
d'Entr(,e
du
,"us.e.--
-d
i
Li.+4-.n
nsdnoAdesc
diau
Emery-Kirwan
W'adi
es-
Ieboua
-Adindan,
I,
195_,p.
114
:
1H-use
15.
An
ins-
cribed
'erotLic
stela,
plund'red
petrhajs
.r-rm
the neighb-uring
Cemetery
1.54,
had
been
used
t- serve
as a
d--rstep
. Ibid.,
p.
532:
"EK
28.
Fragment
-fa
sandst-ne
table
-f
,fferings
ins-
orib
e d
with
a
eroihic
textr
ize
24
x 2.
cms.
Irvenance
:;the
.Rman
-wn
at
Wadi
el-Arab;
1r-nt,
the
surface
in
front
'*f
HUHuse I.
::
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
11/18
-A'i
1i017
a
26
Cairo
Epitaphe
trave
en
cursive
au
n-m
de
Nberihi,
parall.lement
au
;us 1i-ng
c
^t*i
'un autel-
5
apex
inf
ricur,
tr-uv6 rem-
p.i
,
d:JAs
1,
b'-'.rt
na
n
(maisn-n
1,1i:.ce
5,-bjet
n
0
17)
de
Cuadi
el-Ar
ib,rais
pr.vcnant
vraisemblable:
,ent
du
Cimetibre
154.
Emery-Kirwan,
Wadi
cs-bebua
- Adindan,1935,I,p.
11C,,et
532;
eII,
ph-t.
pl.
29:,A
(
Iscr.
n"20)
.
UInrneret
de
Vil
ard,
Aeg;jptus,
XX,
1
9 4
C,p..
62.
id.,
Kush,
VlI,196u,p.
104-I16
et
ph.t,
pl
.
XXVII,a
(Testi
Nubia
Sett.,
nO
8).
~~-
-V
SHintze,
"Struktur,4
2-7
,
LtJ
,L187,
L:
249
J7,
1283-,
L
L uC
2I
etL
C246
7
se
suivent
et appart
iehnnent
a
un
seul-
mnme stiche.
EE:
2 4 Caire *
Resttl
j 'un tlexte
en
eursive,
app'irceteent
suivi, trc:-
a 1 enore
sur un fr fr:nt
''r-st-lra-n
tr-u'v;w
"
ns
e
lber: rrmain"
(mai'"-..n
j,
i',c
2,
-bjet
,o
,ic
Cuadi el-Ar:
b.
Emery-Kirwan,
:.adi
cs-bebua
-
Adind n,1935,1,v.l11u,1A
eot 531;
II,f.-s.
pl.58
(Insor.no24).
EK 25
Caire
Nrtts de
ertabil
it6 tr.ac'-os
en
cursive,
5 l 'ercre
n-ire,sur
le
rect- (
- LE I018
A
) et
le versc (
LEE 1018
B)
d'un tstracon
tr-uvC
dans
le
Cir.eti're
15>i
( t-mbe 15,-bjet
no
3) de
Cuadi
el-Arab.
Emery-Kirwan,
Wadi
es-Sebua
- Adindan,
1
9 3 5
,I,p.
125
et
531;
II,f.-s.pl.58
(lnscr.no
25).
L nneret
e Villard,
Kush,
VIII,196C,p.
106-107(
Testi
Nubia
Sett., nO 9)
1018t
et B
1019
1-rter--ss,,
T.b.
VII
1 p.:
64.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
12/18
AIC2C
EK 27
Caire
X
EpithLithe
au
n-m d'Awedegrer
grav,e
en
cursive
;ur une uierre
i
ac"x
in"frrieur
-
un
a.;tl
?
-
tr-uvie
duns
le
Cimet.ihre
157
t-nbe
1,oi.et
no
1),v
isin
d'el-'Filki,
rais
mar.;iue
15
rreur..JL.L.
1
1
P-rter-,i
ss,
T.u.,
VII,
1951,p,.
64.
Eumeri-
Kirw'an,
iadi
es-,lebua-Adind:r
n,
19.),5,I,p.
71,149,15C
et
532;
II,:h4t.pi.
29,
B
(
Irntci.nO 27).
Lennerct
dte
Villr-d,
1
c.yptus,
6XX,1I.,p.
2.
id.,
.s.,
VIII,
9
6
,.
-t.
p.
XXV,
1
c
Ai
irubia
ett.,
no
7)
iintse,
strUktor,L
J
LC5
j L
C
ICc.9c7 LV157 L-2s_8
,
I
21
K 29
Caire
Epitaphe
au
n-m
in
id
-AU
avc
oen
c.rsive
,.u
ue
st'
le
tr-u-
voe
ar.:;
Ile
Cimetinre
15.7
(t-:be
S,
-I,.et
I
),
viin
d'ol-
".Ai+,i
'
i
rcu.e155
~'r
rreur.
T
-ut
rcery-Kirwan, ,.-i
es-,oebua - /dilan,
19,I,p.
7,
1.,
9
,
15C
+
tt
b.>2; 11,i+h
t. pl.,;T , C (l:+ser.
no
0)
)
Sun'rct
i -Vi
ard,
.ah,
,Vii,
P
", .i
-
:1
,ht.
p.i.VL1
(
Testi
iupia
bett.,
n
6) .
Hintze,
2truktur,C7,-d
7.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
13/18
1022
EK
30
Caire
*
Epitaphe
au
ncm
de
Nyweneke
gravee en
cursive
sur-un
autel.
(F)
tr-uvW
dans le Cimtitre
214
t-mbe
3C,cbjet no I),
v-isin
d'Ab-u Simbel.
P-rter--ss,
T.B.,
VII,
1951, p.
119.
Emery-Kirwan, W'adi
es-uebua
-
Adindan,1935,I,p.
417,423
(
avec fig.S09) et 532; II
,ph-t.pl.
.9,
D(
Inser.no
30).
~lcnneret
de Villard, Kush, VIII,
196C,
p. 95-06
(Testi Nubia
Sett.,
no
3).
-(P)
L'autel
ccmip-rtait
primitivement un bec (cf.les
deux
cr i'uis
je
I:Ia
fig;.
399, .c.,p.
423);
apr
s
la
dispa-
riti-n
de ce
bec
(
-.c., p. 29,iD),
le
texte
so tr'uvel--m-
put(
de ss-n
incipit
W ie ; et
la fin en
est
actuallement
tr-nqui(e,
leb[ kwi
(
c-ntra
.:Mnneret
de Villard).
IC23 EK 31 Caire X
Epitaphe
grav4e en
cursive sur un autel trouv4
dans
le
CimetiBre
214
(
tombe
.C3
surface,
objet
no 1
))v isin
d'Ab-u
Limbel.
P-rter--ss, T.1., VII,
1951,
p. 11.9.
Emery-Krwan,
Wladi
es-Sebua
- Adindan,
1935,1I
p.
4 3 et
532
;
II,
ph-t.
pl. 29,
E
Inscr.
no
31).
SUnnneret
de
Villard,
Kush, VIl,
1960C,
p.
97-98 et pht.
pl.
XXVII,
b
( Testi
Nubia
Sett.,
no
4).
1
1
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
14/18
SCus P u,
caire
A et B
Epitaphe
( htfitn2:4
A) uu Irrm
e
i1iye,
acc-mpa,,:nant
1'ef-
figie
d'une
femme.
Leii'enie ( Elk, IC:1o
) pr~csentant 1 eiifant
figur & ses
Ott3.
Le2
deux
tLxt;u
s-
nt
71ravs
en
cursive
sur
un
bas-relief
.
sr3m-ret cintrd
et A
dis:Iue aild, tr-.uv( dans
le
Cimetibre
214
(
t-mbe
121., bjet no 1
)j v'isin
d'Ab-u
Simbel.
rter-f,-ss,
T.B. V1.1,
951,. 19.
Emery -K:i
rv an,
W,,adi es- :ebua
- Adind n,
1935, I,p.
417,
441
et
32; I,
ph-.
p. 2,
I; of.p. 7
(
Inscr.
r:1 2 .
L, aneut
je
Villd1 u
VIII, 1
C~ p.
01-95
(t
pht . p.
XIX, a
( ::ti u,
bia
Lett., nri 2).
H fmann,
Llil t:l,
19C)7,[.
3'P ; -.
CR4
i nhhnglp.
; ph-t.
il.
V11,
1.
1 2-5
--
3
Caire )K
estes J
uri texte,
une
,it.aphe
esans
6
(?),
,tav
en
cur.ivten
ur
f
n
fragrroenl
e stb.c
tr-,uvy
-n: urfaue
dans
le
Cimeti:
.,
.
l
y
v-
i s i n
d
Ab--u
'imbel.
,:
bs,-T.B., Vl
951, .
11
.1
Emery-Kirwan,
, adi es-Dobua
- adindan,1.95,
I,p.
532;
II,
ph^t.
pl.
29,F
(
Inscr.
no
33).
..
1-nnere1,
de
Villard,
YKluh,
VlII,
19CC,p.
3
(
Te.ti
Nubia
lett., no
).
-
Hintze,
5truktur 1
2
2.
t
lil~~~~n
,tTr r.
:
-
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
15/18
AT 11
~HE1026
Kawa
Z-2169
J
Ashmrl.ean
iuseum
1936.438
Deux
cart-uches
en hitlr-kyphique, dnnt
I'un au
nom du
rfi
Mnhble,
sur
un objet
c'ni'ue
on
br-n,:e
creux trrnuv(
pros
du
ki-,sque
Cucst a
Kawa,
dans le site IIl ( rmaison 1 ,pice
2).
i Frtcer-as;s,
T.L.,
VII,
1951,
p.
192.
Kirwan, J.E.A.,
XXII,
1936, p.
2C8; phrt.
pl. XXIII.
1,-nnmier.t
dc
Villard,
Aegyptus,
XVII,
1937,
p.
1C1-l10.
Kirwan
dans
lEacadam,
Kawa,
II,
19
5
5,p.
56,230
et
236-237;
des.sin
pl . XXXV,
/-92169
7; phvt.
pl.
CVI
/--a
et d j.
Dunham,
R.C.K.,
IV,
1957,
p.
IC
ot 11;
dessin
fig. ,
'4b.
Hintze,
Studien,
1959,
p.
45,
njl et
f.-s. fig.
3, p.
19.
Monneret de
Villard,
Kush,
VIII, 196C,
p. 12u-122
Testi
Nubia
Sett, no
25).
Shinnie,
Merce, 1967,
p.
48-49;dessin
fig. 6.
RiEC1027
Fer
de lance
de
,,ustul
Caire
J.E.
70676
Inscriptin
de
cin
si
es cursifs
.;rav
sur
un
fer de lance
tr-uv
4
dtan::
I e tumul us
14
de .ustul.
. ' ,rtcr-Loss,
iT.
., VII
17951
, p.
-123.
Emer,, iallana-Qustul,
1938, I, p.
24 17J;
II,pht.pl.
50C,
A,
n
0
42
et cdessin~ipl.
116,3.
Mk-nneret
de
Villard,
Kush,
VIII, 196C,
p.
113
( Testi
NFubia
retta,
Tno X p n2).n
1irwan,
The
X-Group
Enigma,
1963,
p.
72 et
fig.
7, p. 77.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
16/18
1C28
Caire
Rles'
:fd'.
n tex:te, une
'l~itaphe
sans
dcute, gi ravy` en
cursive
sur
un
fragment de ;ti~le. t.r.uv. dains
e
Ciret ire
:2C
(tmnbe
8 a)
Q
rustul.
-rter-,
.. VII,
1951, p.
12
.
Emery, .-.la1paxa-
-ust~l
1938, I, p.
C7; II,
tessin pl:. 116,2.
1iinncret
uc
Villard,
IKush, VIII,
1'
C,
i. 122
(
Te-,ti
Nubia
ett.
,
n
2EG).
1.029
Graffi tr
de u -m
c]-baikkar
In
'itu
Gra'ff it-
(e det.cx
1
i
1-
c ouu,.;Jiv(e
aQiieinne
f
frave
sUIr
un
r-ch.,,Tr
Cie
J rri
ll-al'.kar,
ti
1
e Guadi
ci
-Ar.:
( rive
1.4rd),
pr[
:u . ' 'it' ,:i-ptiun d jintei .
Dunbar,
.ck-
1
ictui'es
-ff LT-werc
iubia,
1.941 , phv t.
pl .VI,
fig. 24.
Bintze,
i:ush
,
1X,
961
,
p.
2;3
r
IRE0C60
Khartrum
5162
Epitaphe
grav,e
en
,.ursive
au
noa
d'Aretebik.r;
la
sVt3fle
Cli
sl gr
reneut
sculptei
n bas-rel
ief;
1es.mIet
cintr(
ov-ue
usrc
p~i.rc
'aie
jl-~-es
ot
p-rte
le
textc;
au-
dcssrus,
un
h-,n;me
ie
r-'uve:
re.;rsentC,;
1a
p:artie
inf, ;rioure
Sest
perdue;
1
e
1om'numeunt
pr~
vjent
vrais;.;emblab
errent
de:
Serra-
Cuest.
.
o'rter-
ss,
T.Bi. VII,
19l1,
p.
128.
Macadam,
J.E.A.,
.35,
.1950
i.4-
et phet.
.
XI,1(I
Hintze,
Struktur,
L- 1
6
a
- 1-177
1,
186
.7.
IEeyler,
I.
d E
,
16,1.94,
j.3C
et
32-34;
p.36
Dnoer).
j
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
17/18
1631
Khart um 5261
Epitaphe
:au n m de
1 , dme
o
Tphidye
(-u
Lphidye
,sel-n
la
lecturee
de
.acadan,:)
r: ave
crn
, ,ursive d;uis
1
champ
d'une
stile
s -'mmet
cintr
-
,
vec
rucp
snt
ti-n
'ne
fe :n .
c
en
bts-re lie
;
let ieu do
d,'o-uve-te
vr-b':bl
e
est
Lerra-Cuest.
:^rter-T-ss,
JT.., VII, 1951,p.
1
2R.
acada ,
J.E..,
I,
,195C,
i.
1,-4;
et
ipht.
pl.
XI,,(Inscr.ho2)
Lintze,
Struktur, L2
2
1. 39 27
[34 2, 2452
,
-/ 84,7, -327
2.
Hao~ec-ck,
J.3..A.,
5b,
1967,
p.
117.
1C3 2
1Khartnum
3725
Epitaphe
au n-m
de
la
dame
Yi.i.n:mks,
g-ravv
en cursive
sur
une stele
cintr4e
et
-rnfse d'un
disque
ail-
flanqu(O
de
ses
deux uraeus;
tr-uvde
au
Gebel
Dabar-sa.
IP-rtr-:
ss
T.B.,
VII,
1951,p.
128.
Vacadam,
J.E.A.,
36, 190C,p.
46-47
et phrt.
pl.XI,3(Inscr.no3),
Hintze,
Struktur,L
151 .7,L
295
J.
1033
TKhhart
um
3732
DIbuts
des cinrl
lignes
d'une
~4pitaphe
grave
en cursive,
c^nservis
sur
une
m-itid
de linteau
compijrtant
une
c-rniche
et
une
frise
.
g-rge
dc-~rSe
d'un
dis
iue;~
ai1
trl uv6 Argin.
P-rter-'V>ss,
T..
VIi
1951,p.
128.
Macadam,
J.E.A.,
36,
195Cp.
47
et
pht.
pl.
XI,4
(Inser.nO4).
Heyjler, -Rd E.,
16,
194,
p.
27-28
et
dessin
fig.
4;
of. p.
32-35
(
Dc.
e). .
Hintze,
Struktur,
Z-93
L7179j7.
-
8/9/2019 MeroNews2
18/18
CCLLU;UE
IN)i-TTlAL
DU
CNITNTIONAL
iE L.-. li
CH UCINTI
iU
EAinbILLE,
7 -
11
YViIL
1969
sur
1'"En'plri
des
cal
culateurs
en
archil-,ie,
VublrTies
sdi-l~giques
et mathematiques"
0
-
O
) 0 O
. OC*
* . *
Crganis4. par
le
ir-fessaur J.C. Gar'din au Cenrtre
d'Analyse Dcuarentaire 1:-ur I'Arch:1]gie
de aroseille, ce
c-,ll-
j.ue
a rduii du lundi 7
au venldredi
11 avril 19619
prs
d'une
tren-
taine
de participm'nts
auxquels se s-rit j-ints
je nrmbrcux auditozurs
appartelnaL
t vux 'i4.-ci:lines s(Ciun:tif lucs
lcs
-,lus
divcrses -
es-
senti lee.nt r es . t:. .tit
l
is ct rosrci-1 -. ues -; , delr-
ni--s
.
nt C hfrr:
ata 1cur; e-,:>
t.[ViS
ut
1 urj
Le xIp1ri.cCs .arti-
cul ibZrcs
IutI-.ur du tl.
cix;etra du c-ll:-iue.
D;as 1,
r
i-ine
dec -tudes
mI:er-~tii
ues,
.
1:retti
et
G.i.
darri
Ceo:trc .ii
Cibe-rnetica c
di .. ttivitq Lirguji-ticie
dull
'Universlt:
de -1i 't.di
"'illn), i.iej.r
et J. LeoolIt
( Ec
e
r'ati
u
o
:ttt Pl
des,
V
0
becti
n,
f'ris)nt
V'
v-"qud
l es ,
.Lr--b ,Jes
i~,~r
n
I vur
eitre:it
e
et au
traiter'.nt
de
d-'cur;n:ts ,i.ilr:uhiues
r;di.s
.
znc
une
Ian
ne
,-
.nc--re ,aichif-
f
Irce, ,or-;itique";
cet.te
>-rrunicati-n
a ,r-ups~ les -bscrva-
t-
nas effccta
,c tan.t:ti-e
r
tbr:Tatt:iie:,
u
r
.e
prrjram-
mateur -u 1 s
:rci:V-1-' u- u1
'nt
ab-rd,
,
enimbe
1 s .juestircns
n-mbrouses
et c-mplexes
rue-sse 1'ernu]-i
de
c:alculatrUrs
p-ur
les
Lextes
-
.rni'tiques.
Les
act~Ic de
e
-cl-qlued-iveit
etre
publi .,s
pr^chainement
s-us
I e
auspices
du
Centre
-vati--,al
de
la
::cciher-
che' icientifique,
I-ris.
o o 0 0 0 0o 0
0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
S00
O O O
O
0 0 a 0 0
O O 0O O