mesoscale convective systems (mcss) in different ......squall line north america ku convectivecfads...

1
Schematic MCS cross section with a trailing stratiform region, copied from Houze (1989, QJRMS). Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCSs) in Different Environments: GPM Observations Xiaowen Li 1,2 Takamichi Iguchi 3,2 Chuntao Liu 4 Toshi Matsui 3,2 Wei-Kuo Tao 2 1. GESTAR Program, Morgan State University; 2. NASA Goddard Space Flight Center; 3. ESSIC, University of Maryland, College Park; 4. Texas A&M, Corpus Christi We are interested in Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCSs) with extensive stratiform regions. These organized precipitation systems have relatively long lifespans, with quasi-steady mature stages that last more than several hours. The extensive, homogeneous stratiform region show consistent characteristics which can be reliably sampled by GPM satellite. Our goal is to find common statistics observed by GPM satellite, use them to understand cloud microphysical processes (e.g., aggregation of ice- phase particles), and to validate microphysical schemes in the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model. This study focuses on well-organized MCSs with widespread stratiform regions. For example, one type of highly organized form of MCS is a squall line, with a linear leading convective region, trailed by a wide stratiform region. These squall lines occur frequently during the summer months in North American Great Plains and West African, which are chosen to be our study areas. The squall line initiation mechanisms are similar at these two locations. The mountain ranges interact with mean flow and trigger convection downwind. These convection propagate with the mean flow and are often organized into MCSs by vertical wind shears. The GPM Precipitation Feature database with collocated level 2 data between May 1 and September 1, 2014~2017, are used in this study. Vertical variations of radar CFADs show remarkable agreements between squall line cases and general MCS cases in the stratiform region. Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCSs) with widespread stratiform region are identified at two different locations (North America Great Plains and West African), where they occur with high frequencies during summer months, using GPM observations between 2014 and 2017. It is found that vertical profiles of the maximum radar CFADs are nearly identical above melting layer, between the heights of 6km and 12km, in two different groups of MCSs: the highly organized squall lines and the less organized MCSs with trailing stratiform regions). This may be a manifestation of the homogeneous structure in the trailing stratiform region, where ice-phase particles fall through a weak updraft zone above melting level. The main particle growth mechanisms are through aggregation and deposition. Convective regions have much wider distributions in radar reflectivity. However, the maximum radar CFADs still have a very similar profile as the stratiform region. Further study are needed to understand the causes. Study of MCSs in two different environments confirms that, long-term TRMM/GPM observations (with single time frames for different cases) can provide meaningful constraints to cloud-resolving model simulations (with multiple time frames for a single case). With the robust vertical profile found this this study, GPM data can be used to validate and improve microphysical schemes with high confidence. In addition to GPM DPR data, distributions of GMI brightness temperature also show consistent characteristics across different MCS systems and in different environmental conditions. New variables observed by GPM, e.g., the differential reflectivity, 166 GHz brightness temperature and polarization, potentially can offer additional constraints and new insights in dynamical microphysical processes in MCSs. Using GPM data to validate cloud-resolving model requires satellite simulators to convert model output to GPM observables. Preliminary comparisons between WRF simulations of the May 20 MC3E case and the GPM observed statistics will be presented by Xiaowen Li on Thursday morning. Suggestions and comments will be highly appreciated. North American Great Plains West Africa Squall Line Linear leading convective region with extensive trailing stratiform region; Along line length > cross line width in 89 GHz PCT. 18 cases for North America 74 cases for West Africa MCS General Generally shows leading convective region and trailing stratiform region, but not well- defined; length < width Number pixel > 1000 99 cases for North America 89 cases for West Africa MCS Other Has both convective and stratiform regions, but convection are embedded and scattered; include stratiform only; Number pixel > 1000 Not tallied for North America 92 cases for West Africa Images are GPM 89 GHz PCT, with dark red and orange lines representing Ku band 40 and 20 dBZ contours 89 GHz PCT Statistics of precipitation feature properties show more total volume rain per MCS, larger feature sizes, and much stronger convection in West African MCSs than in North American ones. The calculations exclude “MCS other” category. West Africa Ku stratiform CFADs Squall line West Africa Ku stratiform CFADs MCS general West Africa Ku stratiform CFADs MCS other North America Ku stratiform CFADs Squall line North America Ku stratiform CFADs MCS general Trailing stratiform region in MCSs has nearly identical profiles of maximum radar reflectivity CFADs value between 5km and 12km. West Africa Max CFADs values North America Max CFADs values When the Ku band radar reflectivity CFADs calculations are repeated in convective region, the same maxima profiles still exist. This may be because of some misclassifications of heavy stratiform rain into convective region. It could also be produced by similar physical processes, West Africa 89 GHz PCT PDF Squall line West Africa 89 GHz PCT PDF MCS general West Africa 89 GHz PCT PDF MCS other North America 89 GHz PCT PDF MCS general North America 89 GHz PCT PDF Squall line 89 GHz Polarization Corrected Brightness Temperature (PCT) also show consistant characteristics between the two different environments, as well as across different stratifications of MCSs. West Africa Ku stratiformCFADs Squall line West Africa Ku convective CFADs Squall line North America Ku stratiformCFADs Squall line North America Ku convective CFADs Squall line i.e., decaying convection sharing similar processes with stratiform rain. Further studies are needed to fully resolve this issue.

Upload: others

Post on 04-Feb-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Schematic MCS cross section with a trailing stratiform region,copied from Houze (1989, QJRMS).

    Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCSs) in Different Environments: GPM ObservationsXiaowen Li1,2 Takamichi Iguchi3,2 Chuntao Liu4 Toshi Matsui3,2 Wei-Kuo Tao2

    1. GESTAR Program, Morgan State University; 2. NASA Goddard Space Flight Center; 3. ESSIC, University of Maryland, College Park; 4. Texas A&M, Corpus Christi

    We are interested in Mesoscale ConvectiveSystems (MCSs) with extensive stratiformregions. These organized precipitation systemshave relatively long lifespans, with quasi-steadymature stages that last more than several hours.The extensive, homogeneous stratiform regionshow consistent characteristics which can bereliably sampled by GPM satellite. Our goal is tofind common statistics observed by GPMsatellite, use them to understand cloudmicrophysical processes (e.g., aggregation of ice-phase particles), and to validate microphysicalschemes in the Weather Research andForecasting (WRF) model.This study focuses on well-organized MCSs withwidespread stratiform regions. For example,one type of highly organized form of MCS is asquall line, with a linear leading convectiveregion, trailed by a wide stratiform region. Thesesquall lines occur frequently during the summermonths in North American Great Plains andWest African, which are chosen to be our studyareas. The squall line initiation mechanisms aresimilar at these two locations. The mountainranges interact with mean flow and triggerconvection downwind. These convectionpropagate with the mean flow and are oftenorganized into MCSs by vertical wind shears. TheGPM Precipitation Feature database withcollocated level 2 data between May 1 andSeptember 1, 2014~2017, are used in this study.

    Vertical variations of radar CFADs show remarkable agreements between squall linecases and general MCS cases in the stratiform region.

    • Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCSs) with widespread stratiform region are identified attwo different locations (North America Great Plains and West African), where they occurwith high frequencies during summer months, using GPM observations between 2014 and2017. It is found that vertical profiles of the maximum radar CFADs are nearly identicalabove melting layer, between the heights of 6km and 12km, in two different groups ofMCSs: the highly organized squall lines and the less organized MCSs with trailing stratiformregions). This may be a manifestation of the homogeneous structure in the trailingstratiform region, where ice-phase particles fall through a weak updraft zone abovemelting level. The main particle growth mechanisms are through aggregation anddeposition. Convective regions have much wider distributions in radar reflectivity.However, the maximum radar CFADs still have a very similar profile as the stratiformregion. Further study are needed to understand the causes.

    • Study of MCSs in two different environments confirms that, long-term TRMM/GPMobservations (with single time frames for different cases) can provide meaningfulconstraints to cloud-resolving model simulations (with multiple time frames for a singlecase). With the robust vertical profile found this this study, GPM data can be used tovalidate and improve microphysical schemes with high confidence.

    • In addition to GPM DPR data, distributions of GMI brightness temperature also showconsistent characteristics across different MCS systems and in different environmentalconditions. New variables observed by GPM, e.g., the differential reflectivity, 166 GHzbrightness temperature and polarization, potentially can offer additional constraints andnew insights in dynamical microphysical processes in MCSs.

    • Using GPM data to validate cloud-resolving model requires satellite simulators to convertmodel output to GPM observables. Preliminary comparisons between WRF simulations ofthe May 20 MC3E case and the GPM observed statistics will be presented by Xiaowen Li onThursday morning. Suggestions and comments will be highly appreciated.

    North American Great Plains

    West Africa

    Squall LineLinear leading convective

    region with extensive trailing stratiform region; Along line

    length > cross line width in 89 GHz PCT.

    18 cases for North America 74 cases for West Africa

    MCS General Generally shows leading

    convective region and trailing stratiform region, but not well-

    defined; length < width Number pixel > 1000

    99 cases for North America89 cases for West Africa

    MCS OtherHas both convective and stratiform regions, but

    convection are embedded and scattered; include stratiform only; Number pixel > 1000

    Not tallied for North America92 cases for West Africa

    Images are GPM 89 GHz PCT, with dark red and orange lines representing Ku band 40 and 20 dBZ contours

    89 GHz PCT

    Statistics of precipitation feature properties show more total volume rain per MCS, larger feature sizes, and much stronger convection in West African MCSs than in North American ones. The calculations exclude “MCS other” category.

    West AfricaKu stratiform CFADsSquall line

    West AfricaKu stratiform CFADsMCS general

    West AfricaKu stratiform CFADsMCS other

    North AmericaKu stratiform CFADsSquall line

    North AmericaKu stratiform CFADsMCS general

    Trailing stratiform region in MCSs has nearly identical profiles of maximum radar reflectivity CFADs value between 5km and 12km.

    West AfricaMax CFADs values

    North AmericaMax CFADs values

    When the Ku band radar reflectivity CFADs calculations are repeated in convective region, the same maxima profiles still exist. This may be because of some misclassifications of heavy stratiform rain into convective region. It could also be produced by similar physical processes,

    West Africa89 GHz PCT PDFSquall line

    West Africa89 GHz PCT PDFMCS general

    West Africa89 GHz PCT PDFMCS other

    North America89 GHz PCT PDFMCS general

    North America89 GHz PCT PDFSquall line

    89 GHz Polarization Corrected Brightness Temperature (PCT) also show consistant characteristics between the two different environments, as well as across different stratifications of MCSs.

    West AfricaKu stratiform CFADsSquall line

    West AfricaKu convective CFADsSquall line

    North AmericaKu stratiform CFADsSquall line

    North AmericaKu convective CFADsSquall line

    i.e., decaying convection sharing similar processes with stratiform rain. Further studies are needed to fully resolve this issue.