michael smith ethical naturalism

8/3/2019 Michael Smith Ethical Naturalism

1/6

!"#$%&'()%(*)'&+(,"&+$-#

!.'$%/(0112

!3&')%(!4'""45&%6&'7(89:(0112

;)6'-":($=(43"'"("?"'(@&-(&(>)%-"%-6-()=(6%A"'-4&%A$%/(&B)64(C'"&+$-#D:(&-(&(.3$+)-).3$>&+(4"'#()=(&'4:($4(

3&-(6%A)6B4"A+7(B""%(='&/#"%4"A(B7(43"(.'"--6'"-("E"'4"A(B7(43"(?&'$)6-(A"B&4"-F-)(#6>3(-)(43&4(&(

.3$+)-).3"'(@3)(&--"'4-(43&4(-3"($-(&('"&+$-4(&B)64(43")'"4$>&+(->$"%>":(=)'("E.+":()'("43$>-:(3&-(.')B&B+7:(

=)'(#)-4(.3$+)-).3$>&+(&6A$"%>"-:(&>>)#.+$-3"A(+$44+"(#)'"(43&%(4)(>+"&'(3"'(43')&4GH((IJ'$-.$%(K'$/34:(

!"#$%&'()&*+,-.$/0/$1:(.G(8L

!"#$%&'()*((+,-."/0(12,'.34(5+%6"0(7/"0,428

8G !#$43D-(#&.()=(43"(#"4&"43$>&+(+&%A->&."(I..G(8M8N8M0LO

&G *)'&+('"&+$-#(

$G *)'&+('"&+$-#($-(A"=$%"A(B7(4@)(>+&$#-O

8G P3"(-"%4"%>"-(@"(6-"(@3"%(@"(#&Q"(#)'&+(>+&$#-F-"%4"%>"-(+$Q"(;P)'46'$%/(

B&B$"-($-(@')%/HF&'"(>&.&B+"()=(B"$%/("$43"'(4'6"()'(=&+-"G

0G !)#"(-6>3(-"%4"%>"-('"&++7(&'"(4'6"G(

$$G P7."-()=(#)'&+('"&+$-#O

8G R)%N%&46'&+$-4$>

0G R&46'&+$-4$>

&G SE4"'%&+$-4

BG T%4"'%&+$-4

$G ,"+&4$?$-4$>

$$G R)%N'"+&4$?$-4$>

BG P@)(Q$%A-()=()..)%"%4-(4)(#)'&+('"&+$-#O

$G R$3$+$-#((I)'(43"(S'')'(P3")'7LO

8G !3&'"-(#)'&+('"&+$-#D-(=$'-4(>)##$4#"%4G

0G ,"U">4-(#)'&+('"&+$-#D-(-">)%A(>)##$4#"%4G((K3"%(@"("%/&/"($%(#)'&+(4&+Q(@"(

.'"-6..)-"(43&4('$/34%"--(&%A(@')%/%"--(&'"(="&46'"-(43&4(&>4-(>)6+A(.)--"--:(B64(@"(

&'"($%("'')'G((R)(#)'&+(-"%4"%>"-('"&++7(&'"(4'6"G

$$G SE.'"--$?$-#((I)'(R)%NJ)/%$4$?$-#LO((!3&'"-(%"$43"'(>)##$4#"%4()=(#)'&+('"&+$-#G((*)'&+(-"%4"%>"-(&'"(%)4(>&.&B+"()=(B"$%/(4'6"()'(=&+-"G((,&43"':(@"(6-"(#)'&+(-"%4"%>"-(4)("E.'"--(

)6'(=""+$%/-(&B)64(&>4-:(.").+":(-4&4"-()=(43"(@)'+A:(&%A(43"(+$Q"G((K3"%(@"(-&7(;P)'46'$%/(

B&B$"-($-(@')%/H($4($-(&-($=(@"(@"'"(-&7$%/(;V))(4)(4)'46'$%/(B&B$"-WH(

0G T-(43$-(6%A"'-4&%A$%/()=(#)'&+('"&+$-#($%-6==$>$"%4+7(A"#&%A$%/X(I..G(8M0N8MYL

&G P3"(@)''7O((T%(>)##)%(.&'+&%>":(-&7$%/(;CP)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/D($-(4'6"H($-(-$#.+7(&%(&+4"'%&4$?"(@&7()=(-&7$%/(@3&4(T(>)6+A(3&?"(-&$A(B7(-&7$%/(;P)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/GH((P36-($4(-""#-(43&4($=(T(

3&?"(&%7(#)'&+(>)##$4#"%4-(&4(&++:(&%A((&(>)#."4"%4(-."&Q"'()=(S%/+$-3:(43"%(T(43$%Q(43&4(#)'&+(

-"%4"%>"-(&'"(>&.&B+"()=(B"$%/(4'6"()'(=&+-"(&%A(43&4(-)#"()=(43"#(&'"(4'6"G((V64(43$-(-""#-(4)(#&Q"($4(

4))("&-7(4)(B"(&(#)'&+('"&+$-4G

BG Z(-6//"-4"A('"?$-$)%(4)(A"&+(@$43(43$-O((K3&4(#)'&+('"&+$-4-('"&++7(B"+$"?"($-(43&4(43"(-"%4"%>"-(@"(6-"(@3"%(@"(#&Q"(#)'&+(>+&$#-(&'"(>&.&B+"()=(B"$%/(4'6"()'(=&+-"(2$"/.$31&24-'5/(6:('&43"'(43&%(#"'"+7(


2/6

3772-31&24-'5/(6G(()6'-"(43"%("?"'743$%/(46'%-()%(@3&4($4($-(4)(-."&Q(-4'$>4+7:(&-()..)-"A(4)(+))-"+7:(

@3"%(@"(-&7()=(-"%4"%>"-(43&4(43"7(&'"(4'6"()'(=&+-"G

[G *$%$#&+(#)'&+('"&+$-#(I.G(8M\L

&G Z>>)'A$%/(4)(#$%$#&+(#)'&+('"&+$-#O

$G *)'&+(-"%4"%>"-(&'"(4'6"()'(=&+-"(-4'$>4+7(-."&Q$%/:('&43"'(43&%(#"'"+7(+))-"+7(-."&Q$%/G

$$G !)#"()=(43"-"(-"%4"%>"-('"&++7(&'"(4'6"G

$$$G !4'$>4+7(-."&Q$%/:(43"(#"&%$%/-()=(43"(@)'A-(;4'6"H(&%A(;=&+-"H(&'"(=6++7("E.+&$%"A(B7(#$%$#&+$-#(&B)64(4'643G((Z>>)'A$%/(4)(#$%$#&+$-#(&B)64(4'643:(&++(43"'"($-(4)(Q%)@(&B)64(43"(

#"&%$%/()=(43"(@)'A(;4'6"H($-(43&4:(@3"%(;-H($-(&(#"&%$%/=6+(-"%4"%>"()=(S%/+$-3:(&%A(@3"%(

;C-D($-(4'6"H($-(&+-)(&(#"&%$%/=6+(-"%4"%>"()=(S%/+$-3:(-)#")%"(@3)(-&7-(;C-D($-(4'6"H(>)6+A(

U6-4(&-(@"++(3&?"(A$-]6)4"A(&%A(-&$A($%-4"&A(;-GH

BG !#$43D-()BU">4$)%(4)(#$%$#&+(#)'&+('"&+$-#O

$G *$%$#&+(#)'&+('"&+$-#(.'"-6..)-"-(#$%$#&+$-#(&B)64(4'643:(&%A(43"(+&44"'($-(6%&>>".4&B+"G(P3"(.')B+"#(@$43(#$%$#&+$-#(&B)64(4'643($-(43&4($4(=&$+-(4)(4"++(6-(43"(>)%A$4$)%-(43&4(%""A(4)(

B"(-&4$-=$"A(B7(;-H($%()'A"'(=)'(;C-D($-(4'6"H(4)(B"(&(#"&%$%/=6+(-"%4"%>"()=(S%/+$-3G

$$G SE.+"O(;C!%)@($-(@3$4"D($-(4'6"H($-(&(#"&%$%/=6+(-"%4"%>":(B64(;C^))'&7(=)'(43"(J3$>&/)(V6++-WD($-(4'6"H($-(%)4G((V64(@3&4(A)(43"(-4'$%/-()=(S%/+$-3(@)'A-(43&4(&'"(4'643N&.4(I-6>3(&-(

;!%)@($-(@3$4"HL(3&?"($%(>)##)%:(43&4(43"7(A)%D4(3&?"($%(>)##)%(@$43(43)-"(-4'$%/-()=(

S%/+$-3(@)'A-(43&4(&'"(%)%N4'643N&.4(I-6>3(&-(;^))'&7(=)'(43"(J3$>&/)(V6++-WHLX

$$$G P3"(-4&%A&'A(#$%$#&+$-4(&%-@"'O((!"%4"%>"-(-6>3(&-(;!%)@($-(@3$4"H(&%A(;P)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/H(&'"(4'643N&.4:(@3"'"&-(;^))'&7(=)'(43"(J3$>&/)(V6++-WH($-(%)4:(B">&6-"()=(&(.6'"+7(

21($'.$/.&="&46'"(43&4(43"7(.)--"--(&%A(43"(43$'A(+&>Q-G((P3"(=$'-4(4@)(-4'$%/-()=(S%/+$-3(@)'A-(

&'"()=(&%(&..').'$&4"(/'#&4$>&+(47."(4)(=$/6'"($%(&(@3)+"(&''&7()=(>)%4"E4-:(-6>3(&-(43"(

&%4">"A"%4-()=(>)%A$4$)%&+-:(.').)-$4$)%&+(&44$46A"(>)%4"E4-:(&%A(-)()%:(@3"'"&-(43"(43$'A($-(

%)4G

$?G !#$43D-('".+7O((!7%4&E($-(%)4(-6==$>$"%4(4)("-4&B+$-3(4'643N&.4$46A"G((SE.+"O(;CP3"(4)?"-(&'"(/7'$%/(&%A(/$#B+$%/($%(43"(@&B"D($-(4'6"H(+))Q-(4)(B"(&(@"++N=)'#"A(-"%4"%>":(B64(;P3"(4)?"-(

&'"(/7'$%/(&%A(/$#B+$%/($%(43"(@&B"H($-(%)4(4'643N&.4:(B">&6-"($%(-.$4"()=($4-(-7%4&E:($4D-(&(

%)%-"%-"(-"%4"%>"G

?G !)(@3&4:($%(&AA$4$)%(4)(43"('$/34(-7%4&E:($-('"]6$'"A($%()'A"'(=)'(&(-"%4"%>"(4)(B"(4'643N&.4X(!#$43D-(&%-@"'O((P3"(-"%4"%>"(3&-(4)(B"(;#"&%$%/=6+:('&43"'(43&%(%)%-"%-":(&%A(=)'(43$-(4)(B"(

43"(>&-"(43"(>)%-4$46"%4(@)'A-($%(43"(-"%4"%>"F@)'A-(+$Q"(C4)?":D(C/7'":D(C/$#B+":D(&%A(

C@&B"DF@)6+A(3&?"(4)(B"(&--)>$&4"A(@$43(.&44"'%-()=(6-&/"(@3$>3(#&Q"($4(.+&$%(@3&4(

$%=)'#&4$)%(&B)64(43"(@)'+A(.").+"(@3)(6-"(43"(@)'A-($%(43)-"(@&7-($%4"%A(4)(>)%?"7(@3"%(

43"7(6-"(43"#H(I.G(8M_LG

?$G V64($4($-(&(-6B-4&%4$?"(=&>4(&B)64(&(-"%4"%>"(43&4($4-(>)%-4$46"%4(@)'A-(&'"(&--)>$&4"A(@$43(.&44"'%-()=(6-&/"(43&4(&++)@(43"#(4)(>)%?"7($%=)'#&4$)%(&B)64(.&'4$>6+&'(&-.">4-()=(43"(@)'+AG(T4($-(43"'"=)'"(&(2#+2$'($/0-&8'.$(&B)64(&(-"%4"%>"(43&4(@"(%""A(4)(A$->)?"'($%()'A"'(4)("-4&B+$-3(

43&4($4($-(4'643N&.4G((!)(43"(#$%$#&+$-4(&>>)6%4($-($%-6==$>$"%4(4)("E.+&$%(@3$>3(-"%4"%>"-(&'"(

4'643N&.4(&%A(@3$>3(&'"%D4G

?$$G !#$43D-(>+&$#O(;K"(%)@(Q%)@(@3&4(@)6+A(3&?"(4)(B"(43"(>&-"(=)'(-"%4"%>"-(+$Q"(CP)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/D(&%A(C`"".$%/(.')#$-"-($-('$/34D(4)(B"(>&.&B+"()=(B"$%/(4'6"()'(=&+-":(-4'$>4+7(

-."&Q$%/G((P3"(@)'A-(>)%4&$%"A($%(43"-"(-"%4"%>"-F@)'A-(+$Q"(C'$/34D(&%A(C@')%/DF@)6+A(

3&?"(4)(B"(&--)>$&4"A(@$43(.&44"'%-()=(6-&/"(43&4(#&Q"($4(.+&$%(@3&4($%=)'#&4$)%(&B)64(43"(

@)'+A(.").+"D-(6-"()=(43"#($-($%4"%A"A(4)(>)%?"7H(I.G(8MMLG

YG SE.'"--$?$-#(&%A($%4"'%&+$-#(I..G(8MMN891L

0


3/6

&G P3"($%4"'%&+$-#(>)%-4'&$%4O((Z>>)'A$%/(4)($%4"'%&+$-4-:(43"'"($-(&%($%4"'%&+()'(%">"--&'7(>)%%">4$)%(B"4@""%(43"(#)'&+(U6A/#"%4-(@"(#&Q"(&%A()6'(#)4$?&4$)%-G((T4D-(&(>)%-4'&$%4()%(43"(.')."'(6-"()=(

;P)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/H(43&4(-)#")%"(@3)(-$%>"'"+7(644"'-($4($-(&?"'-"(4)(4)'46'$%/(B&B$"-:(&4(+"&-4()43"'(43$%/-(B"$%/("]6&+(I$%()43"'(@)'A-:(&B-"%4(A".'"--$)%:(@"&Q%"--()=(@$++:(&%A(43"(+$Q"LG

BG SE.'"--$?$-4-(&'/6"O

$G V"+$"=-(&'"(-4&4"-(43&4(/$?"($%=)'#&4$)%(&B)64(43"(@)'+AG

$$G Z-(-6>3:(43"7(>&%(>)N"E$-4(@$43(&%7(.&44"'%()=(A"-$'":($%A$=="'"%>":(&%A(&?"'-$)%G(

$$$G !$%>"(.").+"D-(#)'&+(?$"@-(>&%D4(>)N"E$-4(@$43(&%7(.&44"'%()=(A"-$'":($%A$=="'"%>":(&%A(&?"'-$)%:($4(=)++)@-(43&4(43"(.')."'(')+"()=(43"(-"%4"%>"-(.").+"(6-"(@3"%(43"7(4"++(6-(&B)64(

43"$'(#)'&+(?$"@-(>&%%)4(B"(4)("E.'"--(B"+$"=-G

$?G P3"(.')."'(')+"()=(;P)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/H($-('&43"'(4)("E.'"--(&?"'-$)%(4)(4)'46'$%/(B&B$"-:(&%A(43"(.')."'(6-"()=(;`"".$%/(.')#$-"-($-('$/34H($-(4)("E.'"--(43"(A"-$'"(4)(Q"".(

.')#$-"-:(%)4(4)("E.'"--(&%7(B"+$"=G((*)'&+(-"%4"%>"-:(.')."'+7(6%A"'-4))A:(&'"('"&++7()%(.&'(@$43()43"'(6%>)%4')?"'-$&++7(%)%N4'643N&.4(-"%4"%>"-(-6>3(&-(;^))'&7(=)'(43"(J3$>&/)(V6++-WH(K3"%(@"(-&7()=(#)'&+(-"%4"%>"-(43&4(43"7(&'"(4'6"()'(=&+-":(@"(&'"(&4(B"-4(-."&Q$%/(+))-"+7:(

%)4(-4'$>4+7G((!4'$>4+7(-."&Q$%/(#)'&+(-"%4"%>"-(>&%%)4(B"(4'6"()'(=&+-"G

\G R&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-#(I..G(891N890L(

&G Z>>)'A$%/(4)(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-#O

$G P3"(-"%4"%>"-(@"(6-"(4)(#&Q"(#)'&+(>+&$#-(&'"(>&.&B+"()=(B"$%/(4'6"(&%A(=&+-"(I-4'$>4+7(-."&Q$%/LG

$$G !)#"('"&++7(&'"(4'6"G

$$$G K3&4(#&Q"-(43"(4'6"()%"-(4'6"(&'"(%&46'&+$-4$>(="&46'"-()=(43"(@)'+A:(="&46'"-("%&B+"(4)(

6%A"'-4&%A$%/($%(->$"%4$=$>(4"'#-G

BG P3"(-6."'?"%$"%>"(>)%-4'&$%4O((T4D-(&(>)%>".46&+(4'643(43&4(43"(#)'&+(="&46'"-()=(&>4-(-6."'?"%"()%(43"$'(%&46'&+$-4$>(="&46'"-O(4@)(&>4-(@3$>3(&'"($A"%4$>&+($%(&++()=(43"$'(%&46'&+(="&46'"-(#6-4(B"(&+$Q"($%(43"$'(

#)'&+(="&46'"-(&-(@"++G((K3"%(@"(&..+7(;'$/34H(&%A(;@')%/H(4)(&>4-:(@"(&'"(436-(>)%-4'&$%"A(4)(A)(-)(

$%(43"(B"+$"=(43&4(43"(&>4-($%(]6"-4$)%(3&?"(-)#"(%&46'&+$-4$>(="&46'"(43&4(@&''&%4-(43"(&->'$.4$)%()=(

;'$/34H()'(;@')%/GH(I.G(898L

>G K37(>&%D4(@"(-&7(43&4(&>4-(&'"(&+$Q"($%(&++(%&46'&+$-4$>('"-.">4-:(&%A(7"4(A$=="'(#)'&++7X((P3"(&%-@"'(=&?)'"A(B7(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4-($-(43&4(43$-($-(B">&6-"(#)'&+(="&46'"-('"-(%&46'&+(="&46'"-G

AG SE.+"O((T=(43"(%&46'&+$-4$>(="&46'"()=(&>4-(43&4(@&''&%4-(43"(&->'$.4$)%()=('$/34%"--(46'%-()64(4)(B"(64$+$47(#&E$#$a&4$)%:(43"%(&>>)'A$%/(4)(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4-:('$/34%"--(/2&64$+$47(#&E$#$a&4$)%G

2G *))'"D-()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4O((;K"(>&%:(@$43)64(-"+=N>)%4'&A$>4$)%:(&/'""(43&4(&%(&>4(#&E$#$a"-(64$+$47(B64(A"%7(43&4($4($-('$/34G((T4(43"'"=)'"(=)++)@-(43&4(43"(]6"-4$)%(CP3$-(&>4(#&E$#$a"-(64$+$47:(B64($-($4('$/34XD($-(%)4(&(

.372-)&9#-2$/7(F)%"(@3)-"(&%-@"'($-($##"A$&4"+7()B?$)6-(4)(&%7)%"(@3)(6%A"'-4&%A-(43"(#"&%$%/-()=(43"(@)'A-FB64($-:('&43"':(&%(74-(&9#-2$/7(F)%"(@3)-"(&%-@"'($-()."%(4)('"&-)%"A(&'/6#"%4G((C,$/34%"--D(&%A(

C64$+$47(#&E$#$a&4$)%D(&'"(436-(%)4(&%&+74$>("]6$?&+"%4-G((P3"7(A)(%)4(.$>Q()64(43"(-"(="&46'"H(I.G(89[LG(

*)'")?"':(%)(#&44"'(@3$>3(%&46'&+(="&46'"-(@"(>3))-":(43$-(&'/6#"%4(&..+$"-G((T=(-)6%A:(43"%:(43$-(&'/6#"%4(

>)%-4$464"-(&(A">$-$?"('"=64&4$)%()=(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-#G

_G (R)%N%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-#(I..G(89[N89YL

&G >)'A$%/(4)(%)%N%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-#O

[


4/6

$G P3"(-"%4"%>"-(@"(6-"(4)(#&Q"(#)'&+(>+&$#-(&'"(>&.&B+"()=(B"$%/(4'6"(&%A(=&+-"(I-4'$>4+7(

-."&Q$%/LG

$$G !)#"('"&++7(&'"(4'6"G

$$$G K3&4(#&Q"-(43"(4'6"()%"-(4'6"(&'"(%)%N%&46'&+$-4$>(-4&4"-()=(43"(@)'+A:(-4&4"-(43&4("+6A"(

6%A"'-4&%A$%/($%(->$"%4$=$>(4"'#-G

>G !#$43D-()BU">4$)%-(4)(%)%N%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-#O

$G b$'-4(.')B+"#O((P3"(?$"@(#6-4("E.+&$%(3)@(@"(>)#"(B7(Q%)@+"A/"()=(43"-"("E4'&:(-.))Q7:(

%)%N%&46'&+(.')."'4$"-G

$$G !">)%A(.')B+"#O((T=(%)%N%&46'&+(.')."'4$"-(&'"(A$-4$%>4(=')#(%&46'&+(.')."'4$"-(43"%($4(-""#-(@"(-3)6+A(B"(&B+"(4)(.6++(43"#(&.&'4(#)A&++7G((V64(/$?"%(43&4(#)'&+(.')."'4$"-(-6."'?"%"()%(

%&46'&+(.')."'4$"-:($4(=)++)@-(43&4(@"(>&%D4(.6++(43"#(&.&'4(#)A&++7G((R)%N%&46'&+$-4-(&'"(=)'>"A(

4)(?$"@(43"(-6."'?"%$"%>"()=(43"(%)%N%&46'&+()%(43"(%&46'&+(&-(&(B'64"(#7-4"'7G

MG P3"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(&%A(#)'&+(%$3$+$-#(I.G(89YL(

&G G

BG V64(-$%>"(%)(&>4-(3&?"(-6>3(%)%N%&46'&+(="&46'"-:(&++()6'(#)'&+(B"+$"=-(I&B)64(43"(%)%N%&46'&+(="&46'"-(

.)--"--"A(B7(&>4-L(&'"(=&+-"G

>G Z>>)'A$%/(4)(43$-(&'/6#"%4:(43"(.')."'(>)%>+6-$)%()=(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4($-(#)'&+(%$3$+$-#G

AG P3"(.')B+"#(@$43(43$-:(&>>)'A$%/(4)(!#$43O((P3$-(@&7()=(43$%Q$%/(>)%>"A"-(43"($%4"++$/$B$+$47()=(

*))'"&%(%)%N%&46'&+(.')."'4$"-c(7"4(43"(.')B+"#-(A"->'$B"A(&B)?"(-6//"-4(43"-"(.')."'4$"-(&'"%D4(

$%4"++$/$B+"(&4(&++G

9G P3"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(&%A("E.'"--$?$-#(I..G(89\N892L

&G *&%7(3&?"(4&Q"%(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(4)(.')?$A"(&(A">$-$?"(+$%"()=(&'/6#"%4(=)'("E.'"--$?$-#G

BG Z>>)'A$%/(4)(!#$43:(3)@"?"':("E.'"--$?$-#($4-"+=($-(?6+%"'&B+"(4)(&(?"'-$)%()=(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4G((P3)6/3("E.'"--$?$-#(-"4-($4-"+=(&/&$%-4(43"(?$"@(43&4(;P)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/H($-(

&%&+74$>&++7("]6$?&+"%4(4)(-)#"(%&46'&+$-4$>(>+&$#(&B)64(43"(@&7(43"(@)'+A($-:($4(A)"-(-)(B7($%-$-4$%/(43&4(

-"%4"%>"-(+$Q"(;*$>3&"+(U6A/"-(43&4(4)'46'$%/(B&B$"-($-(@')%/H(/2(&%&+74$>&++7("]6$?&+"%4(4)(43"(-"%4"%>"(

;*$>3&"+("E.'"--"-(3$-(&?"'-$)%(4)(4)'46'$%/(B&B$"-GH((V64(3"'"(@"(>&%('6%(&(?"'-$)%()=(43"()."%(

]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4O((P3"(]6"-4$)%(;*$>3&"+("E.'"--"-(3$-(&?"'-$)%(4)(4)'46'$%/(B&B$"-:(B64(A)"-(3"(

U6A/"($4(4)(B"(@')%/XH($-(&%()."%(]6"-4$)%F)%"(@3)-"(&%-@"'($-()."%(4)('"&-)%"A(&'/6#"%4G(

*)'")?"':($4(A)"-%D4(-""#(4)(#&44"'(@3$>3()=(43"(?&'$)6-(%&46'&+(="&46'"-()=(*$>3&"+(@"(>)%-$A"'G((T=(

-)6%A:(43"%:(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(-""#-(4)(-3)@(43&4(*$>3&"+D-(U6A/$%/($4(@')%/(4)(4)'46'"(

B&B$"-($-%D4(&%&+74$>&++7("]6$?&+"%4(4)(&%7(%&46'&+(="&46'"()=(*$>3&"+G((T4(436-(>)%-4$464"-(&(A">$-$?"(

'"=64&4$)%()=("E.'"--$?$-#(I&>>)'A$%/(4)(!#$43LG

81G P3"(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4D-(=$'-4('"-.)%-"(4)(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(I..G(892N899L

&G P3"('"-.)%-"O((P3"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(&--6#"-:(@')%/+7:(43&4($=('$/34%"--(&%A(43"(.')."'47()=(#&E$#$a$%/(64$+$47(@"'"()%"(&%A(43"(-"(.')."'47:(43"%($4(@)6+A(3&?"(4)(B"(&%(&(.'$)'$(4'643:()%"(

A$->)?"'"A(B7('"=+">4$)%()%(43"(#"&%$%/-()=(43"(@)'A-(;'$/34%"--H(&%A(;43"(.')."'47()=(#&E$#$a$%/(

64$+$47GH((V64($4(43"'"B7()?"'+))Q-(43"(.)--$B$+$47(43&4($4(#&7(B"(&%(&(.)-4"'$)'$(4'643:()%"(A$->)?"'"A(

43')6/3()B-"'?&4$)%(&%A($%="'"%>"G((SE.+"-O(@&4"'(&%A( 0"('"=+">4&%>"(

.')."'47(dG(

BG !#$43D-()BU">4$)%(4)(43$-('"-.)%-"O

$G R&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4-(@3)(#&Q"(43$-('"-.)%-"(#6-4(-3)@(3)@($4(>)6+A(B"(&%(&(.)-4"'$)'$(

4'643(43&4(;'$/34%"--H(&%A(;43"(.')."'47()=(#&E$#$a$%/(64$+$47H(.$>Q()64(43"(-"(="&46'"G((V64(

43)-"(@3)(=&>"(6.(4)(43$-(>3&++"%/"('6%($%4)(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(&++()?"'(&/&$%G

Y


5/6

$$G SE.+"O((Z>>)'A$%/(4)(#&%7(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4-:(43"('"&-)%($4D-(&%(&(.)-4"'$)'$(4'643(43&4('$/34%"--($-(43"(.')."'47()=(#&E$#$a$%/(64$+$47($-(43&4(@"($%?)Q"('$/34%"--(&%A(@')%/%"--(

4)("E.+&$%(?&'$)6-("#.$'$>&+(.3"%)#"%&:(&%A(43"%(@"(A$->)?"':(&(.)-4"'$)'$:(43&4(43"(#&E$#$a&4$)%()=(64$+$47()>>6.$"-(43"('"+"?&%4("E.+&%&4)'7(')+"G((SE.+"O((,$/34(&>4$)%-(&'"(

>&6-&++7('"-.)%-$B+"(=)'(&(4"%A"%>7(4)@&'A(-)>$&+(-4&B$+$47:(-)($4(=)++)@-(43&4(@"(>&%(=$E(43"(

'"="'"%>"()=(43"(4"'#(;'$/34H(?$&(43"(A"->'$.4$)%(;43"(.')."'47()=(&>4-:(@3&4"?"'($4($-:(43&4($-(

>&6-&++7('"-.)%-$B+"(=)'(43"$'(4"%A"%>7(4)@&'A-(-)>$&+(-4&B$+$47GH

$$$G V64(@3&4(-)'4()=(U6-4$=$>&4$)%(>&%(B"(/$?"%(=)'(43"(>+&$#(43&4(@"(>&%(=$E(43"('"="'"%>"()=(

;'$/34%"--H(?$&(43$-(A"->'$.4$)%X((T4(>+"&'+7($-%D4(-6..)-"A(4)(B"(&%)43"'(&(.)-4"'$)'$(4'643G(

,&43"':($4($-(-6..)-"A(4)(B"(&%(&(.'$)'$(4'643:()%"(@3$>3($-("$43"'(-4$.6+&4"A($%(43"(&>4()=(

'"="'"%>"(=$E$%/()'("+-"(A$->)?"'"A(B7('"=+">4$)%()%(43"("?"'7A&7(#"&%$%/()=(;'$/34GH

$?G V64(*))'"D-()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4($-(-6..)-"A(4)('"=64"('33&>+&$#-(4)(43"("==">4(43&4(;'$/34%"--H($-(&%&+74$>&++7()'(&(.'$)'$("]6$?&+"%4(4)(&(4"'#(&->'$B$%/(%&46'&+(="&46'"-(4)(&>4-:(%)(

#&44"'(@3$>3(%&46'&+(="&46'"-(&'"($%(]6"-4$)%G((T=(-)6%A:($4(436-("?"%('"=64"-(43"(>+&$#(43&4($4($-(

&(.'$)'$(43&4('$/34%"--($-(43"(.')."'47(&>4-(.)--"--(@3"%(43"7(4"%A(4)@&'A-(-)>$&+(-4&B$+$47G?G !#$43D-(>)%>+6-$)%O((R&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4-(3&?"(%)(&+4"'%&4$?"(B64(4)(=&>"(3"&AN)%(43"(

>+&$#(43&4(@"(>&%:(?$&(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4:('"=64"(43"(>+&$#(43&4(43"'"($-(-)#"(

%&46'&+$-4$>(&%&+74$>()'(&(.'$)'$("]6$?&+"%4(=)'(;'$/34%"--GH

88G P3"(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4D-(-">)%A('"-.)%-"(4)(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(I..G(899N011L

&G !#$43D-(/"%"'&+(.$>46'"()=(>)%>".46&+(&%&+7-$-O

$G P3"'"(&'"(&++(-)'4-()=(>)%-4'&$%4-()%(43"(@&7(@"(6-"(?&'$)6-(@)'A-G((SE.+"O((T4D-(&(>)%-4'&$%4(

)%(43"(.')."'(6-"()=(>)+)'(@)'A-(43&4(@"(6-"(43"#(4)(.$>Q()64(.')."'4$"-(43&4(>&6-"(6-(4)(3&?"(

>"'4&$%(?$-6&+("E."'$"%>"-c(&(>)%-4'&$%4(43&4(@"(6-"(43"#(4)(.$>Q()64(="&46'"-(43&4(&'"(#)'"(

'"+$&B+7(A"4">4"A($%(A&7+$/34(43&%($%(43"(A&'Q:("4>G

$$G K3"%(@"(4'7(4)(>)#"(6.(@$43(&%(&%&+74$>("]6$?&+"%4()=(;E($-('"A:H()6'(4&-Q($-(4)(>)#"(6.(@$43(

-)#"43$%/(43&4(>&.46'"-(43$-(>)#.+"E(-"4()=(>)%-4'&$%4-F$G"G:(4)(>)#"(6.(@$43(&%(&>>)6%4()=(

@3&4('"A%"--(#"&%-(43&4("%4&$+-(43"#G

BG V64($=(43$-($-('$/34:(43"%(43"(-6>>"--()'(=&$+6'"()=(&%(&%&+7-$-($-(%)4(4)(B"(U6A/"A(B7(43"()B?$)6-%"--()=(43"(&%&+7-$-:(%)'($-($4(4)(B"(U6A/"A(B7(@3"43"'(43"(&%&+7-$-($-()."%(4)('"&-)%"A(&'/6#"%4G((>)6%4:(43"(-6>>"--()=(&%(&%&+7-$-(:/33(B"()."%(4)('"&-)%"A(&'/6#"%4(B">&6-"($4(@$++(B"()."%(4)(

'"&-)%"A(&'/6#"%4(@3&4(43"(>)#.+"E(-"4()=(>)%-4'&$%4-()%(43"(6-"()=(43"(@)'A(B"$%/(&%&+7a"A($-(&%A(

@3"43"'()'(%)4(43$-(>)#.+"E(-"4($-("%4&$+"A(B7(43"(.').)-"A(&%&+7-$-G

>G *))'"D-()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4(=&$+-:(43"%:(B">&6-"(43"'"(>&%(B"(6%)B?$)6-(&%&+7-"-G((P3"()B?$)6-%"--()=(&%(&%&+7-$-($-(B"-$A"(43"(.)$%4c(43"(;)%+7('"+"?&%4(]6"-4$)%($-(@3"43"':()%('"=+">4$)%:(@"(

43$%Q(43&4(43$-(&%&+7-$-("%4&$+-(43"(>)#.+"E(-"4()=(>)%-4'&$%4-()%(43"(@&7($%(@3$>3(@"(6-"(43"(@)'A(

C'$/34DH(I.G(011LG

AG K3$+"(43"()."%(]6"-4$)%(&'/6#"%4($-%D4(-)6%A:($4(#&Q"-(>+"&'(43"("%)'#)6-(4&-Q(43&4(+$"-(B"=)'"(

%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-4-G((P3"-"('"&+$-4-(#6-4(/$?"(&%(&>>)6%4()=(43"(%&46'&+$-4$>(="&46'"(43"7(4&Q"(4)(B"($A"%4$>&+(@$43(?&'$)6-(#)'&+(="&46'"-:(&%A($%(A)$%/(-):(43"7(#6-4(=$%A(%&46'&+$-4$>(="&46'"-(43&4(&'"(

I)%('"=+">4$)%L(&%&+74$>&++7()'(&(.'$)'$("]6$?&+"%4(4)(43)-"(#)'&+(="&46'"-G

80G P@)(Q$%A-()=(%&46'&+$-4$>(#)'&+('"&+$-#

&G SE4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-#(I..G(018N(010L

$G SE4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-#(O((P3)6/3(@"(>&%:(B7('"=+">4$%/()%(43"(@&7-($%(@3$>3(@"(6-"(#)'&+(@)'A-:(=$%A(&(%&46'&+$-4$>("]6$?&+"%4(=)'(43"(4"'#(;'$/34%"--:H(43"(%&46'&+$-4$>("]6$?&+"%4(

@"(>)#"(6.(@$43(@$++(+"&?"($4(>)#.+"4"+7()."%(@3"43"'(-)#")%"(@3)(B"+$"?"-(&%(&>4(4)(B"(

'$/34(@$++(A"-$'"(4)(."'=)'#($4:()'(B"($%A$=="'"%4(4)(."'=)'#$%/($4:()'(B"(&?"'-"(4)(."'=)'#$%/($4G

\


6/6

$$G SE.+"O((Z(?$"@(@3$>3(>+&$#-(43&4('$/34%"--(=$++-(43"(A$-4$%>4$?"("E.+&%&4)'7(')+"()=(

6%A"'@'$4$%/(&(4"%A"%>7(4)@&'A(-)>$&+(-4&B$+$47G

$$$G P3"(>3&++"%/"-(=&>"A(B7(-6>3(?$"@-O

8G P3"7(#6-4(>)#"(6.(@$43(&%("E.+&%&4$)%()=(@37:(@3"%(@"('"=+">4()%(43"(@&7($%(

@3$>3(@"(6-"(#)'&+(@)'A-:(@"(-3)6+A(>)%>+6A"(43&4('$/34%"--(3&-(43"(%&46'&+$-4$>(

"]6$?&+"%4(43"7(.)-$4G((SE.+"O(P3"7(#6-4(4"++(6-(@3&4($4($-(&B)64(43"(@&7($%(@3$>3(

@"(6-"(#)'&+(@)'A-(43&4($-(-6..)-"A(4)(#&Q"($4(>'"A$B+"(43&4('$/34%"--($-(43"(.')."'47(

)=(&>4-:(@3&4"?"'($4($-:(43&4($-(>&6-&++7('"-.)%-$B+"(=)'(43"$'(4"%A"%>7(4)@&'A(-)>$&+(

-4&B$+$47G

0G P3"7(#6-4(4'7(4)("E.+&$%(&@&7(43"(=&>4(43&4(-)(#&%7(.").+"(3&?"(B""%($%>+$%"A(4)(

43$%Q(43&4()6'(6-"()=(#)'&+(@)'A-($-(-6BU">4(4)(43"($%4"'%&+$-4(>)%-4'&$%4G((K37(3&?"(

-)(#&%7(.").+"(B""%($%>+$%"A(4)(43$%Q(43&4(B"+$"?$%/(43&4(&%(&>4($-('$/34('"]6$'"-(&(

A"-$'"(4)(."'=)'#(-6>3(&%(&>4:(&4(+"&-4(&B-"%4(A".'"--$)%:(@"&Q%"--()=(@$++:(&%A(43"(

+$Q"X

BG T%4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-#(I..G(010N012L

$G T%4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-#(O((P3"-"('"&+$-4-(&/'""(@$43("E4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-4-(43&4(@"(>&%(>3&'&>4"'$a"('$/34%"--($%(4"'#-()=($4-(A$-4$%>4$?"("E.+&%&4)'7(')+":(B64(43"7(3)+A(43&4(43"(

"E.+&%&4)'7(')+"(>3&'&>4"'$-4$>()=('$/34%"--($-:(B')&A+7(-."&Q$%/:(43&4()=("+$>$4$%/(A"-$'"(6%A"'(

>"'4&$%($A"&+$a"A(>)%A$4$)%-()=('"=+">4$)%G

$$G SE.+"(I!#$43D-()@%(?$"@LO((Z(?$"@(@3$>3(>+&$#-(43&4('$/34%"--($-(43&4(="&46'":(@3&4"?"'($4($-:(43&4(@"(@)6+A(A"-$'"()6'(&>4-(4)(.)--"--($=()6'(A"-$'"-(=)'#"A(&(-"4(43&4($-(#&E$#&++7(

$%=)'#"A:(>)3"'"%4(&%A(6%$=$"AG(

$$$G T%4"'%&+$-4('"&+$-4-()=(43$-(Q$%A(@$++(&'/6"(43&4(43$-(&%&+7-$-()=('$/34%"--(=$%A-(-6..)'4($%(43"(@&7($%(@3$>3(@"(6-"(#)'&+(@)'A-G((T#.)'4&%4+7:($4("E.+&$%-(43"($%4"'%&+$-4(>)%-4'&$%4()%(43"(6-"()=(#)'&+(@)'A-G

$?G P@)(Q$%A-()=($%4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-#O

8G ,"+&4$?$-4$>($%4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-#(O((K3"%(@"(-&7(43&4(&>4$)%-()=(&(>"'4&$%(-)'4(&'"('$/34:(@"(&'"('"&++7(-&7$%/(43&4(&(-6B-"4()=('&4$)%&+(>'"&46'"-F43)-"(@3)(3&?"(

A"-$'"-(+$Q"()6'()@%F&'"(-6>3(43&4(43"7(@)6+A(A"-$'"(43&4(@"(&>4($%(43&4(@&7($=(43"7(

3&A(A"-$'"-(43&4(=)'#"A(&(#&E$#&++7($%=)'#"A:(>)3"'"%4:(&%A(6%$=$"A(-"4G((V64()43"'(

."'=">4+7('&4$)%&+(>'"&46'"-(>)6+A(A$=="'(=')#(6-G((P3"(>3&++"%/"(4)(-6>3(&(?$"@O((T4D-(

$#.+&6-$B+"(&-(&(>)%>".46&+(&%&+7-$-G((^)@(>)6+A(@3"43"'()'(%)4(&%(&>4($-('$/34()'(

@')%/:(43"(.&'&A$/#()=(&(%)%N&'B$4'&'7(=&>4(&B)64(&%(&>4:(B"(/')6%A"A($%(-)#"43$%/(

-)(&'B$4'&'7(&-(@3"43"'()'(%)4(-)#")%"(3&.."%-(4)(3&?"(>"'4&$%(>)%4$%/"%4(&%A(

'&4$)%&++7().4$)%&+(>6+46'&++7($%A6>"A(A"-$'"-X

0G R)%N'"+&4$?$-4$>($%4"'%&+$-4(%&46'&+$-4$>('"&+$-#(O((Z>4-(&'"('$/34()'(@')%/(A"."%A$%/()%(@3"43"':(%)4@$43-4&%A$%/(&%7(>)%4$%/"%4(&%A('&4$)%&++7().4$)%&+(>6+46'&++7($%A6>"A(

A$=="'"%>"-($%()6'(&>46&+(A"-$'"-:(@"(@)6+A(&++(A"-$'"()'(B"(&?"'-"(4)(43"(."'=)'#&%>"(

)=(-6>3(&>4-($=(@"(3&A(&(-"4()=(A"-$'"-(43&4(@&-(#&E$#&++7($%=)'#"A:(>)3"'"%4(&%A(

6%$=$"AG((P3"(>3&++"%/"(4)(-6>3(&(?$"@O((T-($4('"&++7(.+&6-$B+"(4)(43$%Q(43&4($%-"-&/2(&(

-"4()=(A"-$'"-(43&4(@"(@)6+A(&++(>)%?"'/"(6.)%($=(@"(3&A(&(-"4()=(A"-$'"-(43&4(@&-(

#&E$#&++7($%=)'#"A:(>)3"'"%4(&%A(6%$=$"AX

2

michael smith ethical naturalism

Documents