microencapsulation of vitamin c and … of vitamin c and gallic acid in whey protein concentrate by...
TRANSCRIPT
MICROENCAPSULATION OF VITAMIN C AND GALLIC ACID IN WHEY PROTEIN
CONCENTRATE BY SPRAY AND FREEZE DRYING - CHARACTERIZATION AND
DEGRADATION KINETICS
by
SHRIPAD RATNAKAR TANDALE
(Under the Direction of Manjeet Singh Chinnan)
ABSTRACT
Vitamin C and gallic acid were chosen as model antioxidants to be used as core material and
whey protein concentrate (WPC) was selected as wall materials for microencapsulation.
Microencapsulation methods used were spray and freeze drying. Vitamin C: WPC (w/w) ratios
and gallic acid: WPC ratios (w/w) were 1:4.0, 1:5.3, 1:8.0, and 1:16.0 for both spray and freeze
drying process. 1:4.0 ratio resulted in highest microencapsulation efficiency for both vitamin C
and gallic acid and therefore chosen for accelerated storage study. The various factors selected
for accelerated storage were temperature (25 and 45 ˚C), relative humidity (22, 44, 66, 85% RH),
UV light and dark, type of microencapsulation method (freeze and spray drying). Maximum
degradation was found at intermediate humidity level (66%) in vitamin C as well as gallic acid
powder. Microcapsules produced were characterized using scanning electron microscopy (SEM)
and particle size analysis (PSD). SEM revealed outer morphology and structure of capsules and
PSD determined average diameters and modal distribution.
INDEX WORDS: Microencapsulation, freeze drying, spray drying, scanning electron
microscopy, particle size distribution, storage study, vitamin C, gallic acid.
MICROENCAPSULATION OF VITAMIN C AND GALLIC ACID IN WHEY PROTEIN
CONCENTRATE BY SPRAY AND FREEZE DRYING - CHARACTERIZATION AND
DEGRADATION KINETICS
by
SHRIPAD RATNAKAR TANDALE
B. Tech., U.D.C.T., North Maharashtra University, India, 2000
MBA, Mumbai University, India, 2003
A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
MASTER OF SCIENCE
ATHENS, GEORGIA
2007
MICROENCAPSULATION OF VITAMIN C AND GALLIC ACID IN WHEY PROTEIN
CONCENTRATE BY SPRAY AND FREEZE DRYING - CHARACTERIZATION AND
DEGRADATION KINETICS
by
SHRIPAD RATNAKAR TANDALE
Major Professor: Dr. Manjeet S. Chinnan
Committee: Dr. Robert D. Phillips Dr. Yen-Con Hung
Electronic Version Approved: Maureen Grasso Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia December 2007
v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Firstly, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my major professor Dr. Manjeet S.
Chinnan for accepting me as his graduate student and for his careful attention, encouragement
and guidance throughout the research. His role is instrumental in my professional and personal
development.
I also thank my committee members Dr. Robert D. Phillips, and Dr. Yen-Con Hung for
serving me on my committee and providing invaluable suggestions. Dr. Phillips for his guidance
in complex reactions in chemistry and answering many doubts and questions. Dr. Hung for his
suggestions, asking about my progress and friendly smile.
I should admit that my research would have not been complete without technical help
and suggestions from Mr. Glenn D. Farrell. I thank him for everything from constructing the
storage chambers to troubleshooting the atomizer in spray dryer work. I also would like to thank
Mr. Lary Hitchcock, Joy Adams, Hannah Smith and Jessica Grubb for their everyday help in
work. I thank Dr. John Shields for his help in preparing Scanning Electron Micrographs, Litha
Sivanandan for her help in particle size analysis, Mr. Jerry Davis for SAS programming, and
Jerri Snodgrass for making many research manuscripts available.
My Friends, Mr. Neelanjan Ray, Neha Jain for company in innumerable coffee breaks
and general discussions. Also my friends Dharmendra Singh, Sudeep, Suvang Amit, Preya,
Deepti, Dr. Poonpat and VJ who have made things easier and for their encouragement.
I also would like to thank Dr. Rakesh Singh, Department Head and all faculty members
in Food Science and Technology who have contributed, directly or indirectly, to my educational
and career goals.
vi
The most important persons in my life my mom and dad and my brother Aniruddha for
everything, your unconditional love and support and blessings!
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.............................................................................................................v
LIST OF TABLES..........................................................................................................................ix
LIST OF FIGURES.........................................................................................................................x
CHAPTER
1 INTRODUCTION...............................................................................................................1
Functional foods.................................................................................................................1
Need of microencapsulation..............................................................................................1
Vitamin C............................................................................................................................2
Gallic acid...........................................................................................................................3
2 LITERATURE REVIEW....................................................................................................5
L-Ascorbic acid as an anti-oxidant...................................................................................6
Gallic acid as model anti-oxidant.....................................................................................8
Selection of wall material..................................................................................................9
Various types of microencapsulated ingredients..........................................................18
Different methods of microencapsulation......................................................................23
Shelf life of the spray dried microcapsule......................................................................34
Physical properties of spray dried particles..................................................................35
Characterization of microcapsules.................................................................................38
viii
3 MICROENCAPSULATION OF VITAMIN C IN WHEY PROTEIN CONCENTRATE
USING SPRAY AND FREEZE DRYING METHODS...................................................62
ABSTRACT.......................................................................................................................63
INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................64
MATERIALS AND METHODS.......................................................................................66
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS......................................................................................71
CONCLUSIONS………………………….......................................................................80
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS…...........................................................................................80
REFERENCES..................................................................................................................81
4 MICROENCAPSULATION OF GALLIC ACID IN WHEY PROTEIN
CONCENTRATE USING SPRAY AND FREEZE DRYING METHODS.....................95
ABSTRACT.......................................................................................................................96
INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................97
MATERIALS AND METHODS.....................................................................................100
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS....................................................................................105
CONCLUSIONS….........................................................................................................113
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.............................................................................................113
REFERENCES................................................................................................................114
5 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS..............................................................................127
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Page
Table 2.1: Methods used to reduce the loss of L-ascorbic acid in Foods......................................41
Table 2.2: Coating materials for encapsulating food ingredients..................................................42
Table 2.3: Strengths and weaknesses of some of the food grade materials with good
encapsulating properties ................................................................................................................43
Table 2.4: Methods of microencapsulation ..................................................................................44
Table 2.5: Different variables affecting fluidized-bed operation..................................................45
Table 2.6: Parameters affecting the release rate of core material….............................................46
Table 2.7: Different types of microencapsulated food ingredients and applications of
microencapsulation........................................................................................................................47
Table 2.8: Physical properties of L-ascorbic acid……………………………………………….48
Table 3.1: Microencapsulation efficiency of spray dried vitamin C ...........................................85
Table 3.2: Microencapsulation efficiency of freeze dried vitamin C…………….......................86
Table 4.1: Microencapsulation efficiency of spray dried gallic acid..........................................117
Table 4.2: Microencapsulation efficiency of freeze dried gallic acid….....................................118
x
LIST OF FIGURES
Page
Figure 2.1: Microencapsulation – particle morphology ................................................................49
Figure 2.2: Schematic diagram of ideal storage and release behavior...........................................50
Figure 2.3: Schematic diagram of spray-dry encapsulation process.............................................51
Figure 2.4: Controlled release mechanism of encapsulated food ingredients...............................52
Figure 2.5: Procedure for preparation of vitamin C encapsulated chitosan microspheres by spray
drying ............................................................................................................................................53
Figure 3.1: Wooden chambers fitted with black light constructed for storage of
microencapsulated powder ............................................................................................................87
Figure 3.2: SEM micrograph of freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C (vitamin C: WPC ratio
of 1:4) with magnifications of (A) 100X (B) 200 X (C) 500 X. SEM micrographs of spray dried
microencapsulated vitamin C (vitamin C: WPC ratio of 1:4) with magnifications of (D) 100X (E)
200X and (E) 573 X.......................................................................................................................88
Figure 3.3: Cumulative percentage particle size distribution of (A) spray dried microencapsulated
vitamin C powder (B) freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C powder...................................89
Figure 3.4: Particle size distribution of (A) spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C powder (B)
freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C powder........................................................................90
Figure 3.5: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 25˚C and
(A) UV Light and (B) Dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)...................................................91
Figure 3.6: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 45 ˚C and
(A) UV Light (B) Dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)...........................................................92
xi
Figure 3.7: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 25 ˚C and
(A) UV light and (B) dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)......................................................93
Figure 3.8: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 45 ˚C (A)
UV light (B) dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)………........................................................94
Figure 4.1: Folin-Ciocalteux Method of determination of total phenolics.................................119
Figure 4.2: SEM micrograph of freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid with gallic acid: WPC
ratio of 1:4 with magnifications of (A) 100X (B) 200 X and (C) 500 X SEM micrographs of
spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid with gallic acid: WPC ratio of 1:4 with magnifications
of (D) 100X (E) 200X and (F) 500X...........................................................................................120
Figure 4.3: Cumulative percentage particle size distribution of (A) spray dried (B) freeze dried
microencapsulated gallic acid powder.........................................................................................121
Figure 4.4: Particle size distribution of (A) spray dried (B) freeze dried, microencapsulated gallic
acid powder..................................................................................................................................122
Figure 4.5: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 25 ˚C and
(A) UV Light (B) dark conditions (G.A. denotes gallic acid).................................................... 123
Figure 4.6: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 45 ˚C and
(A) UV Light (B) dark condition (G.A. denotes gallic acid).......................................................124
Figure 4.7: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 25 ˚C
(A) UV Light and (B) dark condition (G.A. denotes gallic acid) .............................................. 125
Figure 4.8: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 45 ˚C
and (A) UV light and (B) dark condition (G.A. denotes gallic acid)…………………………...126
1
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION Functional foods
The recent advancements in food and nutritional science support the concept that diet
plays a significant role in improved state of well-being, prevention and mitigation of certain
diseases and important part of healthy lifestyle. There is an increasing trend of consumers’
preference for functional food products because of variety of health benefits offered by the
functional foods and growing awareness among the consumers about functional foods. It is
estimated that functional food market in US alone is $ 30 billion and is growing at 20% annually.
Functional foods include many nutritive compounds which offer some kind of health benefit/s to
consumers. There are various functional food ingredients such as antioxidants, phytochemicals,
vitamin A, β-carotene, ascorbic acid (vitamin C), vitamin D, vitamin E, soy isoflavones, omega 3
and omega 6 fatty acids particularly in fish oil, minerals such as calcium and iron, lutein,
lycopene, co-enzyme Q10, and probiotics. These functional food ingredients are added in various
food products in order to impart specific health benefit that consumer desires.
Need of microencapsulation
The incorporation of these compounds into food products has many challenges. These
functional food ingredients are susceptible to degradation due to environmental stress conditions
like temperature, humidity, light, oxygen and its interaction with other food ingredients and
therefore they loose their bioactivity and their nutritive value is compromised.
2
Microencapsulation is used as a tool in order to protect these sensitive bioactive compounds from
degradation. Microencapsulation has the ability to facilitate protected and targeted nutrition in a
number of processed food products. It is fast becoming the most successful delivery systems that
enable food ingredient companies to tap into fast growing functional foods market.
Additionally, there is a need to any off flavors of these nutrients. Consumers expect great
tasting products which are nutritious and seek for food products that offer convenience, good
taste, flavor and texture in addition to nutritive value. Due to increasing preference of functional
foods which accounts for substantial proportion of the global nutrition market, food companies
are looking at various ways to incorporate health promoting compounds in their products to
deliver some kind of health benefits. Microencapsulation technology is used by the food scientist
to address formulation challenges and to deliver these nutrients at specific sites under controlled
fashion.
Vitamin C
Vitamin C is having numerous health benefits and widely used in the food industry
as anti-oxidant, vitamin supplement and as a preservative. It has various biological,
pharmaceutical and dermatological functions. In United States, vitamin C market is segmented
into cosmetic formulations, dietary supplement, animal feed fortification and food and beverage.
The seven key manufacturers of vitamin C generated $ 151.7 million in 2005. Vitamin C is also
called as L-ascorbic acid. This vitamin is synthesized by mammals but not by humans and
therefore must be supplied in the diet. One of the principal biochemical reactions of vitamin C is
to destroy toxic free radicals (hydroxyl and perhydrolxyl) Thus when terminating free radicals,
L-ascorbic acid is converted into dehydroascorbic acid, which is again recycled into L-ascorbic
acid by reductase enzyme and co-factors. Vitamin C is considered as an important anti-oxidant in
3
neutralizing these free radicals. Free radicals cause oxidative stress, involved in various
degenerative diseases such as cancer, cardiovascular diseases, cataracts and Alzheimer’s disease.
Ascorbic acid is very reactive and is readily destroyed during food processing. Ascorbic acid
rapidly oxidizes in the presence of copper and iron ions, at neutral and above pH, temperature,
humidity and light conditions. Microencapsulation should aid in preventing interaction between
metal ions such as iron with ascorbic acid and will improve bioavailability of ascorbic acid
without compromising fortification with minerals.
Gallic acid
Muscadine grapes and blueberries have been reported to contain rich sources of
polyphenolic compounds (gallic acid, p-hydroxybenzoic acid, caffeic acid, ferulic acid, and
ellagic acid) and flavonoids (catechin, epicatechin, myricetin, quercetin, and kaempferol). These
compounds, due to its free radical scavenging action, possess variety of health benefits such as
protecting low density lipoprotein, preventing platelet aggregation and improving neuronal and
cognitive functions in elderly due to age related dementia. We choose gallic acid as one of the
model compound to microencapsulate considering high costs of other compounds and which will
serve as model compound for encapsulating polyphenolic muscadine extract to produce free
flowing, non-sticky powder to be marketed as dietary supplements and other food applications.
Spray drying is one of the most common methods of choice for microencapsulation.
It is widely used for encapsulating food flavors. Advantages of spray drying include its low cost,
wide choice of encapsulating material, easy scale up, good quality of microcapsules produced.
Freeze drying is comparatively costly method but the high value of nutraceutical extract and
ability to encapsulate heat sensitive compounds could justify such costs. Also high retention of
volatile compounds favors the freeze drying process in certain applications. The completion of
4
this project could generate useful information which could be used to generate pilot scale
production of microencapsulated muscadine extract powder and suitable storage conditions.
The objectives of the project were to
1) To microencapsulate vitamin C and gallic acid as model anti-oxidants by spray and
freeze drying methods; to compare protective effectiveness of each method in terms of
protection to anti-oxidant core.
2) To characterize the microcapsules produced by spray and freeze drying methods using
scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and particle size analysis using Malvern
Mastersizer.
3) To investigate degradation kinetics of microencapsulated gallic acid and vitamin C using
accelerated shelf life testing and to generate information which will serve to produce
microencapsulated muscadine grapes extracts as well as blueberry extracts which could
be potentially used in various food applications.
5
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Health continues to be the number one driver of food industry and worldwide consumers
are increasingly aware of the health benefits certain types of food provide. This is evidenced by
growing nutraceuticals and functional foods market. There are numerous evidences suggesting
the health promoting properties of polyunsaturated lipids, omega-3 fatty acids, phytochemicals,
vitamins etc. In order to benefit the population from the health benefits these nutraceuticals and
health promoting compounds are providing, these need to be fortified in the food. However, the
major challenges in incorporating these compounds in food matrix are their susceptibility
towards oxidative deterioration, these ingredients have unpleasant odor and it may affect the
organoleptic and sensory properties of the foods in which they are incorporated.
Microencapsulation is the process of coating tiny droplets of liquids, solids or gases (core
material) by thin film (coating) which protects the core material until it is subsequently released
(Sheu and Rosenberg 1995). Microencapsulation is also aimed at controlling mass transfer
between core material and the surrounding environment (Dziezak 1988; Jackson and Lee 1991;
Arshady 1993; Shahidi and Han 1993). Permeability of gases (oxygen) and volatiles is also
controlled through the wall system. The core can be released in a controlled fashion depending
on the conditions required. Microencapsulation is an important technique for food and flavor
industries for packaging flavors and sensitive ingredients to protect from heat, light and oxygen.
Demand for microencapsulation within the ingredients industry has grown significantly in recent
6
years. The demand for encapsulation technologies is increasing at around 10% annually with
new markets and opportunities opening up every year. (Source: www.foodnavigator.com).
L-Ascorbic acid as an anti-oxidant
L-ascorbic acid is also known as L-threo-2-hexenono-1, 4-lactone. Vitamin C or L-
ascorbic acid is known to prevent scurvy. One of the major biochemical reactions of L-ascorbic
acid is to destroy toxic free radicals (hydroxyl and perhydroxyl) in body resulting from metabolic
products of oxygen. The mixture of L-ascorbic acid and its oxidation product is considered as
‘redox buffer’ (Sapper and others 1982). While quenching free radicals, L-ascorbic acid is
converted into dehydroascorbic acid which is then recycled to L-ascorbic acid by reductase
enzyme and cofactors. Besides redox function in cells, other physiological actions of ascorbic
acid are related to compound’s chelation with metals and complexing with proteins (Gorman and
Clydesdale 1983; Fleming and Bensch 1983). One of the industrial methods of producing L-
ascorbic acid was first devised by Reichstein and Grussner (Crawford and Crawford 1980). The
second industrial method of production of ascorbic acid is based on production of key
intermediate L-xylo-2-hexenonic acid (2-keto-L-gluconic acid) by single recombinant bacterium
(Anderson and others 1985) or step-wise fermentation using two organisms.
L-ascorbic acid is one of pair of enantiomers having 2-hexenono-1, 4-lactone structure.
The other pair is D and L-isoascorbic acid which are also referred to as D and L erythorbic acid.
Based on L-ascorbic acid with 100% Vitamin C activity, other three stereoisomers namely, L-
isoascorbic acid, D-isoascorbic acid and D-ascorbic acid have 0-5% activity (Hay and others
1985). D-isoascorbic acid can be substituted for L-ascorbic acid in most functional uses in foods.
But the bread improving function of L-ascorbic acid is strereospecific. Also use of D-ascorbic
acid in foods is regulated due to its interference with bioavailability of L-ascorbic acid (Hornig
7
and others 1974). Ascorbic acid is widely used in various types of foods such as canned or
bottled fruits, vegetables, beer, wine and other beverages to prevent the development of oxidative
off-flavors and off-colors, especially during pasteurization (Bauernfeind 1982). Here, oxygen in
the headspace is reduced to water by ascorbate. According to Kirby and others (1991), the
significant loss of this vitamin is resulted during processing and storage of foods in the presence
of oxygen and metallic ions such as iron and copper. In order to preserve the Vitamin C in foods,
chemically modified form of ascorbic acid is added to foods to resist oxidation. L-ascorbate 2
phosphate is at least 10-20 times more resistant to oxidation than L-ascorbic acid (Sieb 1985).
The commercial forms of ascorbic acid available to the food industry are L-ascorbic acid and its
sodium and calcium salts and 6-palmitae ester.
One electron reduction by L-ascorbic acid
The most important chemical property of L-ascorbic acid is its ease of oxidation by either
one or two electron transfer. When one electron is transferred in rate limiting reaction, the first
product formed is L-ascorbic acid radical, which is also called as monodehydroascorbic acid
radical. L-ascorbic acid is a strong acid with pK0.45. The free radicals that oxidize lipids and
other readily oxidized compounds in foods and tissues are terminated by reduction with L-
ascorbate radical. Thus the oxidative rancidity in lipids is initiated when free radical attacks lipid
molecule to give alkyl radical. This initiation step is terminated by L-ascrobyl-6-palmitate. Thus
ascorbyl palmitate and L-ascorbic acid acts as typical anti-oxidants and prevent peroxide
formation in lipids and delay the onset of chain reaction that causes deterioration of vegetable
oils, animal fats, fish, milk, Vitamin A, carotenoids (Cort 1982). As an anti-oxidant L-ascorbic
acid reacts with superoxide radical, perhydroxyl radical, hydroxyl radical and singlet oxygen.
Ascorbyl palmitate is more effective anti-oxidant when used in combination with tocopherol
8
(Cort 1982). Tocopherol first reacts with free radicals and Ascorbyl palmitate then reduces
tocopherol radical to regenerate tocopherol and give ascorbate radical (Wayner 1986). The
regeneration of tocopherol persists until all ascorbate is consumed.
Two-electron reduction of dioxygen by L-ascorbic acid
The reaction of L-ascorbate with dioxygen in the presence of transition metal ions is very
important reaction. The transition metals such as cupric and ferric ions catalyze the autoxidation
by joining L-ascorbate and oxygen in ternary complex (Martell 1982). The two Π-electrons from
L-ascorbate in the complex are proposed to shift to oxygen through transition metal ions. The
complex dissociates into dehydroascorbic acid, hydrogen peroxide and metal ion. In most foods
dehydroascorbic acid is rapidly hydrolyzed to 2, 3-diketogluconic acid, this reaction being non-
reversible results in loss of vitamin C in foods.
The metal catalyzed reaction between oxygen and L-ascorbic acid increases when acidity
is decreased from pH 1.5 to 3.5. Autoxidative loss of L-ascorbic acid accelerates above pH 7.0.
A variety of metal chelating agents are known to retard the autoxidation of L-ascorbate such as
ethylenediamine tetraacetate (EDTA), oxalate, citrate, phosphates, uric acid, sugars, acidic
polysaccharides and flavonoids. Proteins, histidines may also retard autoxidation. Possible
complexing between proteins and L-ascorbic acid is known from activation of myrosinase with
L-ascorbic acid (Fleming and Bensch 1983).
Gallic acid as model anti-oxidant
Rabbiteye blueberry (Vaccinium ashei), common in Georgia, is a rich source of various health
promoting compounds like phenolic acids (gallic acid, p-hydroxybenzoic acid, caffeic acid,
ferulic acid, and ellagic acid) and flavonoids (catechin, epicatechin, myricetin, quercetin, and
kaempferol) (Sellapan and Akoh 2002). These compounds neutralize free radicals associated
9
with number of degenerative diseases such as cancer, cardiovascular diseases, cataracts and
Alzheimer’s. However, these compounds are sensitive to degradation with exposure to
environmental conditions; such as temperature, oxygen, light and relative humidity. Rabbiteye
blueberry contains 259 mg/100 gm of gallic acid (a major phenolic acid). Intermediate extract of
muscadine grape contains sugars which makes it difficult to handle and may stick on the walls of
the spray dryer. High molecular weight compounds like hydrocolloids such as modified starch,
gum Arabic or proteins such as whey proteins will serve as coating material and make it non-
sticky powder. We chose gallic acid as model core material for microencapsulation considering
very high cost of other pure compounds. Two major protein groups of bovine milk are whey
protein and casein. Whey is derived as natural byproduct of cheese-making process. In addition
to proteins, the raw form of whey contains fat, lactose and other substances. The raw form is
processed to produce protein rich whey protein concentrate (WPC) and whey protein isolate
(WPI). Whey proteins have been reported to have excellent encapsulation properties and are
superior to those of commonly used ingredients. These studies have indicated that whey proteins
were very effective in encapsulating volatile, non-volatile, polar and non-polar compounds
(Moreau and Rosenberg 1996, 1998, 1999; Sheu and Rosenberg 1995; Young, Sarda and
Rosenberg 1993). Microencapsulation of gallic acid will help in understanding the protective
effect offered to the similar phenolic compounds under various environmental stress conditions.
Selection of wall material
The first step in encapsulating food ingredients the selection of suitable coating material which is
commonly called as shell material, wall material, carrier or encapsulation matrix.
10
These coating materials are film forming substances which are selected from various natural and
synthetic polymers depending upon the core material to be encapsulated and desired
characteristics in the microcapsule.
Ideal coating material should have the following characteristics (Shahidi and Han 1993).
• Good rheological properties. It should possess low viscosity at high solids concentration
to facilitate in encapsulating higher load of core (Reineccius 1988).
• The ability to emulsify the core and stabilize the emulsion.
• Solubility in solvent e.g. water, ethanol.
• Ability to seal and hold the active material within its structure during processing and
storage.
• It should be non-reactive to the core during high temperatures in processing as well as
during the storage.
• Should be non-toxic and generally recognized as safe (GRAS).
• Complete release of the core under desired conditions.
• Ability to protect maximum protection to core material against environmental condition
(light, heat, humidity etc) from oxidation, reactivity to food components etc.
• Should produce desired capsule solubility properties and active material release
properties.
• It should be economical and stable in supply.
The ideal carrier/shell material should have good emulsifying properties, should be able to form
good film, have low viscosity (Reineccius 1988). At 35-40% range, should exhibit low
hygroscopicity and should release the coated material in controlled manner or when desired,
should be low in cost, bland in taste, stable in supply and should not interact with the core
11
material and be non toxic. Since no single coating material can meet all of the criteria listed
above, in practice, combinations of coating materials are used or modifiers such as oxygen
scavengers, antioxidants, chelating agents and surfactants are added. Chemical modification of
the existing coating materials is also considered.
Maltodextrin and glucose syrup solids
Maltodextrin and glucose syrup solids have excellent oxidation protection but they exhibit poor
retention of volatiles (Qi and Hedges 1995). It is considered that since maltodextrins and corn
syrup solids have no emulsification properties, they produce coarse emulsion that results in poor
flavor retention during drying (Reineccius and Risch 1986). The major shortcoming of
maltodextrins is virtual lack of emulsifying capacity and low retention of volatile compounds
(Reineccius 1991). Maltodextrins and corn syrup solids offer varying degree of protection to the
core material from oxidation depending on DE of hydrolyzed starch. The product with highest
DE is extremely stable and would have shelf life of years without using anti-oxidants. High DE
maltodextrin protected encapsulated orange peel oil against oxidation, thus effect of DE on the
functionality of wall system is observed (Anandaraman and Reineccius 1986). It has been
suggested that higher DE systems are less permeable to oxygen and therefore, offer better
protection to encapsulated ingredient (Reineccius 1991). The mono and disaccharides are very
inexpensive and are used in blends with chemically modified starch and are used in blends with
chemically modified starch or gum acacia. These are used to reduce cost or improved protection
against oxidation.
Modified Starch
Modified starches which are used in encapsulation are chemically modified to incorporate
lipophilic groups into their molecules. The modified starch is produced by adding octenyl
12
succinate at 0.02 degree substitution. This results in modified starch with excellent
emulsification properties. Modified starch provides excellent retention of volatiles during spray
drying. Additional benefit of modified starch since it is substantially less viscous than gum
acacia is that it can be used at higher infeed solids level upto 50% whereas gum acacia cannot be
used at higher than 35%. The high solids level reduces the loss of encapsulated ingredients and
increases spray dryer output. Modified starch also has excellent emulsion stability. Solution of
gum acacia produced the average emulsion of about 3 µm and modified starch gave droplets of
about < 2 µm. The emulsions made with modified starch were more stable than with gum acacia.
Cyclodextrins
Cyclodextrins are cyclic molecules that are produced enzymatically from starch. Cyclodextrins
have the ability to entrap guest molecules within its ringed structures. Cyclodextrins started its
application in food industry in 1970s when Japan and Hungary began its use. They are produced
from starch by selected microorganisms such as Bacillus macerans and B. circulans. These
organisms contain cyclodextrin glycotransferase (CGTase) that converts partially hydrolyzed
starch into cyclic dextrins containing six (α), seven (β), or eight (γ) glucose monomers. These
monomers are connected to each other in a doublenut shaped ring, giving cyclodextrin a
molecular structure that is relatively rigid and a hollow cavity of specific diameter and volume.
The polar hydroxyl groups are oriented to outside thus imparting hydrophilic character and
internal cavity is hydrophobic in nature because of its high electron density due to hydrogen and
glycosidic oxygen oriented towards interior of cavity. Thus due to hydrophobic nature of the
cavity the molecules of suitable size, shape and hydrophobicity are able to interact noncovalently
with cyclodextrins to form inclusion complexes. β-cyclodextrins are able to form inclusion
complexes with flavor substances with molecular mass between 80 and 250. Linder (1982)
13
reported that molecules of nearly all natural spices and flavors fit into this range. Cyclodextrin
complexes protect the ingredients from oxidation, light induced reactions, thermal decomposition
and evaporation loss. Spices that have been complexed with cyclodextrins have shown controlled
release. Thermal stability was also increased when fats were added to them. Cyclodextrins have
been found to preserve the flavors of cookies, vegetable pastes, biscuits, citrus fruits, Japanese
onions, garlic and celery.
Sucrose
Sucrose is used as carrier material because of following properties
• Quick dissolution in water, producing clear turbidity free solution.
• Heat stability and non-hygroscopicity
• Indefinite shelf life under ambient condition
• Low cost
Sucrose along with maltodextrin is used as main coating material used in extrusion encapsulation
process. Mixtures of sucrose ad maltodextrins are commonly used coating for extrusion
encapsulation. It is also used for encapsulation of flavors with process of co-crystallization.
Structure of sucrose is modified from single perfect crystal to microsized, irregular,
agglomerated form before co-crystallization happens. This modified structure has an increased
void space and surface area and provides a porous bed for the incorporation of active material.
Chitosan
Chitosan is the principle product of the alkaline hydrolysis of chitin, main constituent of
exoskeleton of crustaceans such as crabs. Complex coacervate capsule formation takes place
between chitosan, a cationic polyglucosoamine and carageenan or alginic acid which is anionic
in nature. The gelling properties of chitosan allows wide range of application in food and
14
pharmaceuticals in gel entrapment of biochemicals, plant embryos, whole cells, microorganisms
or algae. This entrapment allows microencapsulation and controlled release of flavors, nutrients
and drugs. Polycationic chitosan molecules can be incorporated with oppositely charged
polymers to form coacervate having good mechanical strength. The permeability of these
coacervate capsules can be controlled by altering type of chitosan and counterion.
Cellulose
Cellulose is a main constituent of plant cell walls and it has been used as dietary fiber. Cellulose
has also been investigated for food preservation and as an edible film for food coating has been
studied. The permeability of cellulose can be changed by combination with other coating
materials (Vodjani and Torres 1990). It was found that methyl and Hydroxypropyl
methylcellulose mixed with lauric, palmitic, stearic and arachidic acids significantly lowered
permeation rate compared to cellulose ether films containing no fatty acids. Cellulose is used in
encapsulation of water soluble food ingredients like sweeteners and acids. Cellulose is also used
for encapsulation of enzymes and cells (Poncelet 1989).
Gums
Hydrocolloids are gums which are long chain polymers that dissolve or disperse in water to give
thickening or viscosity building effect. Gums are generally used as texturing ingredients. They
are also used for stabilization of emulsion, suspension of particulates, controlling crystallization
and inhibition of syneresis. Various sources of gums include plant materials such as seaweed,
seeds and tree exudates; others are products of microbial synthesis, and also chemically modified
natural polysaccharides.
15
Gum arabic
Gum arabic is used as an encapsulating material because of its low viscosity, solubility and
emulsification properties. And its good retention of volatile compounds makes it suitable for
many encapsulating methods. Also wall material is ideally suited for encapsulation of liquid
droplets because of its role as surface active agent and drying matrix. The application of gum
arabic within food industry is limited because gum arabic is more expensive than maltodextrin
(Kenyon 1995; Shiga and others 2001) and its availability and cost are subject to fluctuations. As
an alternative mixtures of gum arabic and maltodextrin have been tried and it has been promising
for use in high solid carriers, yielding acceptable viscosities in studies of microencapsulation of
cardamom oil by spray drying (Sankarikutty and others 1988). When a mixture of ethyl
propionate, ethyl butyrate, orange oil, cinnamic aldehyde and benzaldehyde was encapsulated in
a blend of gum arabic and maltodextrin a general trend of increase in retention of core was
observed when gum arabic fraction was increased (Reineccius 1991). Spray dried particles
formed by mixtures of maltodextrin with gum arabic are typically 10-200 µm in size and
retention of volatile depends on number of variables such as inlet temperature of spray dryer, the
emulsion concentration and viscosity and proportion of gum arabic to maltodextrin (Williams
and Phillips, 2000). Apintanapong and Noomhorm (2003) used different ratios of gum arabic and
maltodextrin to investigate the appropriate wall materials for encapsulation using spray drying.
These authors showed that the best quality microcapsules were obtained by using 70:30
combination of gum arabic and maltodextrin gave best quality results.
Alginates
Alginates are made up of D-mannuronic acid and L-gluconic acid. Both the ratio of mannuronic
acid to gluconic acid and the structure of polymer determine the solution properties of the
16
alginate. It has been reported that water-soluble alginate was capable of forming encapsulated
liquid capsules. Viscous high fat foods can also be encapsulated with Ca-alginate.
Lecithins
Pure lecithin is surface active substance and W/O (water-in-oil) emulsifier. Lecithin vesicles
have recently been used for encapsulation of food enzymes because of the formation of lecithin
capsules can be achieved under relatively low temperatures. With lecithin vesicles it was found
that the encapsulation efficiency was best when the pH was close to enzyme’s isoelectric point.
Proteins
Whey protein isolate (W.P.I.) has been shown to provide a good barrier against oxidation for
microencapsulated orange oil (Kim and Morr 1996). In international market, whey proteins are
available as whey protein isolate (95-96% protein) or whey protein concentrate (WPC-50, WPC-
70) powders. Whey proteins in combination with carbohydrates have been used as carrier
material in encapsulation of volatile material in encapsulation of volatile material (Young and
others, 1993b; Sheu and Rosenberg 1995). In this combination whey proteins served as
emulsifying agents and carbohydrate (maltodextrin and corn syrup solids) formed the matrix
structure (Sheu and Rosenberg 1998). Whey proteins have been found to exhibit excellent
encapsulation properties and are superior to commonly used agents (Young, Sarda and
Rosenberg 1993). These studies indicated that whey proteins have been found to be very
effective in encapsulating volatile, non-volatile, polar as well as non-polar, liquid and crystalline
compounds for food and pharmaceutical applications and both water soluble and water insoluble
microcapsules can be prepared. Wall matrices consisting of whey protein isolate (W.P.I.) were
extremely effective in protecting encapsulated lipids against oxidation and exhibited
encapsulation properties superior to whey protein concentrate (W.P.C.). Encapsulation of lipids
17
in carbohydrate based wall materials has benefit of pH-independent high solubility and excellent
drying properties of these materials. Even though these carbohydrate based wall materials are
inexpensive, they offer relatively poor protection against the oxidation. Whey protein
concentrates have been shown to contain residual lipids and phospholipids that compromise the
functionality of the whey proteins as encapsulating agents. The presence of these materials
represents a pro-oxidative factor that accelerates the oxidative deterioration of the encapsulated
material (lipids, aroma, vitamins, etc). In addressing these issues, we have focused on developing
microcapsule prototypes with wall systems consisting of WPI and inexpensive carbohydrates.
This approach can reduce the cost per unit mass of microcapsules while maintaining the unique
functionality of whey proteins delivered by WPI. We have developed microcapsules consisting
of anhydrous milk fat encapsulated in a blend of WPI and dextrins. The oxidative stability at
accelerated condition was excellent. This approach in developing affordable, yet highly
functional microcapsules may open opportunities for commercialization of our technology.
Other proteins
Protein based material such as polypeptone, soy protein or gelatin derivatives form stable
emulsion with volatile compounds. Limitations include their solubilities in cold water, potential
to react carbonyls and their high cost. Addition of gelatin (1%) into maltodextrin and gum arabic
carrier increased the retention of ethyl butyrate in spray drying and provided better controlled
release ability. This suggests that gelatin would promote the formation of crust on the surface of
droplet (Yoshii and others 2001). The sodium caseinate offers physical and functional
characteristics required to encapsulate oil materials (Hogan and others 2001). Also mixture of
casein and carbohydrate such as maltodextrin and corn syrup solids, may offer potential as a cost
18
effective, functional, core encapsulating material. Sodium caseinate has also shown to provide
effective wall material for retention of orange oil (Kim and Morr, 1996).
Various types of microencapsulated ingredients
Vitamins
The rationale behind microencapsulating vitamins is either extending the shelf life by protecting
them from oxidation or by preventing reactions with other components of food systems such as
iron, copper etc. Both lipid soluble (e.g. Vitamin A, β-carotene, Vitamin D, Vitamin E and K) or
water soluble vitamin (e.g. L-ascorbic acid) can be encapsulated. Ascorbic acid is added to
various food products as anti-oxidants or as vitamin supplement (Kirby and others 1991).
Vitamin C (L-Ascorbic Acid) is added in various types of foods as vitamin supplement and to
fortify foods in order to increase its nutritive value. However, according to Kirby and others
(1991) functional properties of vitamin C is limited by its reactivity and low stability in the
presence of air, oxygen, humidity, light and metallic ions such as iron and copper. The oxidation
is accelerated at neutral to alkaline pH. Losses of ascorbic acid can also occur enzymatically.
Attempts have been made to encapsulate vitamin C in tripolyphosphate cross-linked chitosan
microspheres by spray drying (Desai and Park 2005). Their objective was to develop the oral
delivery route and to characterize microspheres using scanning electron microscope (SEM),
transmission electron microscope (TEM), X-ray diffraction (XRD), Fourier Transform infrared
(FTIR) etc. Chitosan was chosen because it has been biodegradable compound of low toxicity
and is degraded by the microflora available in colon. Uddin, Hawlader and Zhu (2001)
investigated the characteristics of ascorbic acid microcapsules using carboxymethylcellulose,
gelatin, β-cyclodextrin, various combinations of starch and carboxymethylcellulose, gum, β-
cyclodextrin. Release ratio is defined as the ratio of ascorbic acid released to the solution to its
19
initial encapsulated weight. The results showed that there were significant differences in the
initial release of ascorbic acid for three different coating materials i.e. ethyl cellulose (7, 45 and
100 cps). Effect of plasticizer on the release rate of ascorbic acid was also studied. Uddin and
coworkers (2001) observed that presence of plastisizer (triethyl citrate) decreased the release rate
of ascorbic acid from the microcapsules. It was attributed to the incorporation of plasticizer
improved the flexibility of the film and formed a less porous network. Plastisizer exerts its effect
by interposing between the polymer chains, hence reducing cohesion between the polymers. For
w/w system, the product consisted of homogenously blended matrix of the polymer entrapping
the core. For spray dried microcapsules using various encapsulating wall materials like gelatin,
carboxymethylcellulose (CMC), β-cyclodextrin and various ratios of starch and CMC, b-
cyclodextrin, gum, the loss of vitamin C was within 2% range. In storage studies, it was found
that starch and β-cyclodextrin had improved active content. The storage studies were conducted
at 38 ˚C and 84% relative humidity. Lipid soluble vitamins such as Vitamin A, β-carotene and
vitamin D, E or K are easier to encapsulate than water soluble ingredients. A spay drying is
method of choice for encapsulation of oil based compounds such as flavors, vitamins and fatty
acids. Riboflavin, thiamin and niacin are partially destroyed during processing and cooking of
pasta products. Studies on unprotected vs. encapsulated thiamine, riboflavin and niacin in cooked
enriched spaghetti showed the concentration of three B vitamins tested were higher in cooked
pasta that contained encapsulated vitamins (Berglung, Dick and Dreher 1987). Stability of
vitamin A in skim milk was found to have been substantially increased by encapsulation in
gelatin. Loss of vitamin in fortified milk was in gelatin. Loss of vitamin in fortified milk powder
was minimal after storage at 28˚C for 40 weeks (DeMan and Wygerde 1986). Vitamin A
20
palmitate was encapsulated in modified gelatin film and degradation under test condition was
significantly reduced by microencapsulation.
Minerals
Fe is one of the most nutritionally important mineral and its deficiency affects about one-third of
the population including developed nations. The best way to overcome this problem is through
food fortification of Fe. However, in fortification, its bioavailability is negatively affected by
interactions with food ingredients like tannins, phytates and polyphenol. Additionally, Fe
catalyses oxidative processes in fatty acids, vitamins and amino acids and affects sensory
characteristics and nutritional value. Microencapsulation is used to prevent these reactions and
improve nutritional and sensory characteristics including increasing bioavailability. FeSO4 or
ferrous lactate is readily soluble in water compared to ferrous fumarate. Fe bioavailability study
on enriched milk was done with FeSO4 encapsulated in lecithin liposome (Boccio and others
1997; Uicich and others 1999). Heat treatment and storage for 6 months did not result in
decreased Fe bioavailability of Fe fortified milk. Calcium fortification as been attempted in soy
milk. Soy milk contains much less calcium (12mg/100gm soy milk) compared with cow’s milk
(120 mg/100 g of cow’s milk). Attempts to fortify soy milk with Ca salts have been unsuccessful
because this process causes soybean proteins to coagulate and precipitate (Weingarten and others
1983). By encapsulating Ca salts (calcium lactate) in lecithin liposome it was possible to fortify
100 gm soy milk with upto 110 mg Ca, equivalent to cow’s milk. Soy milk remained stable at 4
˚C for 1 week.
Enzymes
The enzymes are used in food system to alter the properties of food system in a favorable way.
The stability and functionality of enzymes are enhanced by use of microencapsulation since
21
enzymes are complex biomolecules which are vulnerable to inactivation by other components or
food systems. By properly selecting wall materials we can choose when, where and how it can
react with intended substrate. Microcapsules can be made to accumulate to specific location
within food altering its surface properties and thus influence its textural properties. In multistage
process, we can control release time of enzyme depending on whether we want to release it
earlier or later at specific time. A variety of other stabilizing agents such as buffers, chelating
agents or anti-oxidants can be included to protect them from antagonistic effects. Penetrating
ions can be removed by buffers, chelating agents. Thermostabilizers such as sugars will protect
from extreme processing conditions such as dehydration or freezing. Control of cheese ripening
using encapsulated enzymes has been successful (Magee 1979; Magee and Others 1981).
Microorganisms
Encapsulation of bacterial cell has been successfully attempted in milk fat wall material by Kim
and Olson (1989). The bacteria using methionine to produce methanethiol and other sulfur
compounds contribute to cheddar cheese flavor of low fat cheese product. The advantages of
using microencapsulated bacteria over encapsulated isolated cheese enzymes are stability of
enzymes in intact cells is greater than that of extracts. Also, the production of the enzymes by
cells can be manipulated by controlling substrate concentration in microcapsules. Thus,
microencapsulated enzymes are useful in reducing the ripening time of blue cheese. Probiotics
are living organisms which when ingested have numerous beneficial effects on the equilibrium
and functions of human intestinal microflora. Probiotics have been defined as ‘live organisms
which transit gastro-intestinal tract and in doing so benefit the health of the consumer (Tannock
and others 2000). Probiotics have been reported to play therapeutic role by modulating
immunity, lowering cholesterol, improving lactose tolerance and preventing certain cancers.
22
Probiotics survival is affected by many factors such as poor survival in intestinal pH, hydrogen
peroxide formation, oxygen toxicity and post-acidification during storage, storage temperatures,
stability in dried or frozen form, compatibility with traditional culture, poor growth in milk. The
materials used as excipients are gentle and non-toxic. The most common material is sodium
alginate as it offers advantages such as non-toxicity, forms gentle matrices with calcium chloride
to trap sensitive bacteria, viability of bacteria during storage and release of entrapped bacteria as
gels are solubilized by sequestering calcium ions and releasing entrapped cells (Sheu and
Marshall 1993; Shah and Ravula 2000). Several other gelling agents used as excipients are
pectate, kappa-carageenan, locust bean gum, gellan gum and agar.
Flavors
Flavors play very important role in consumer satisfaction. Flavors improve the product quality
and acceptability; improve sensory characteristics and influence purchasing and consumption of
food products. Food processing and storage conditions, packaging materials and ingredients in
foods often cause modification in overall flavor either by reducing aroma compound intensity or
producing off-flavor compounds (Lubbers and others 1998). Encapsulation can be employed to
retain the aroma in food product during storage, protect the flavor from undesirable interactions
with other food ingredients, minimize flavor-flavor interactions, protect against light induced
degradation and oxidation, increase in product shelf life and achieve controlled delivery at the
desired site and time (Reneccius 1991; Tari and Singhal, 2002). Retention of flavors is governed
by chemical nature of flavors such as molecular weight, chemical functionality, polarity, relative
volatility, properties of encapsulating material and various parameters of encapsulating technique
used. The design of appropriate encapsulation system requires physico-chemical understandings
of the mechanisms by which flavor compounds are encapsulated, stored and released under right
23
stimulus (Chang and others 1988; Whorton 1995; Whorton and Reineccius 1995; Goubet and
others 1998). Examples of commonly used encapsulated flavors are citrus oils, mint oil, onion
and garlic oils, spice oleoresins and whole spices. Citrus oils are especially vulnerable to
oxidation due to sites of unsaturation in their mono and sesquiterpenoid structures. Oxidative
deterioration results in painty or turpentine like off-flavors. Encapsulated citrus oil in
maltodextrin matrix has better stability than unprotected oil (Anandaraman and Reineccius
1986). Many volatile liquids can be encapsulated and subsequently dried to form free flowing
powders with minimal loss of activity. Flavors encapsulated by inclusion complexation in β-
cyclodextrin were protected against volatilization and degradation by oxidation. The storage
stability of flavors encapsulated in β-cyclodextrin under non-stress conditions at room
temperature showed that molecular encapsulation provided almost perfect preservation for up to
10 years. For encapsulation of flavor compounds, carrier material should not be reactive to
flavor compound, should possess low viscosity at high concentration, allow complete elimination
of solvent in any process requiring a phase of desolvatation, give maximum protection to active
ingredient, and ensure good-emulsion stabilization properties and effective redispersion behavior
in order to release the flavor at time and place desired.
Different methods of microencapsulation
Spray Drying
Among many encapsulating techniques, spray drying is the most common to produce flavor
powders in few seconds. More than 90% of the encapsulated flavors are produced by this method
(Reifsteck and Jeon 2000). Encapsulation by spray drying has been widely used in the food
industry from late 1950s to provide flavor oils protection against the oxidation and also it is
24
particularly easy to convert the flavors which are liquid at room temperature to free flowing
powders. Following are the major steps in spray drying process.
Preparation of emulsion/aqueous carrier phase
This is the first step in the spray drying of microencapsulated flavors. It is important to use
particular infeed solid levels which are optimum for each carrier. The infeed solids level is the
most significant factor in retention of the flavor during spray drying process (Reineccius 1991).
Increasing the solid levels up to the point that the additional solids are no longer soluble benefits
the flavor retention by decreasing the required drying time to form high solids surface film
around the drying droplets. When droplet surface reaches 10% moisture, flavor molecules cannot
diffuse through this surface film, whereas relatively smaller water molecule continue to diffuse
through this surface film and are lost to drying air (Bomben 1973). High infeed solid level
facilitates the formation of this semi permeable membrane quickly and helps in flavor retention.
Insoluble carrier solids do not create barrier to the diffusion of the flavor molecules and do not
help in retention of flavor compounds. Thus for each carrier material there is an optimum infeed
solid level. The most important factor in determination of retention of volatiles during drying is
the infeed solids content. High infeed solids increase retention during drying primarily by
reducing the time required to form the semipermeable membrane at the drying surface of the
droplet. Earlier it was suggested to use the highest infeed solids possible, but later from
subsequent experiments it was found that there is optimum infeed solid content for the drying of
flavoring material (Reineccius and Bangs 1982). There could be two reasons for optimum solids
infeed level. The constant ratio of infeed solids and carrier solids is used, after adding more
material exceeds carrier solubility. Although it is possible to pump and atomize at this solids
content, the undissolved carrier does not provide any encapsulating effect and poorer retention is
25
observed after drying process. Also there is the effect of solids content on the viscosity of infeed
material. Excessive infeed solids viscosity can delay the formation of the particle which will
results in the volatile losses during drying. After carrier material is solubilized, the core material
is added. Generally, 20% of core load is selected. Higher solid levels generally result in
unacceptable high losses of flavors in the dryer. Compared to 10% flavor loading when 25%
flavor loading was used, 33 to 50% of flavor was retained during drying. Brenner (1976)
obtained the patent for a process which can produce high load spray dried flavorings. He found
that high surface oil and poor flavor retention is the result of particle shrinkage and cracking
during drying process. Brenner and others (1976) used combination of polysaccharides (e.g. gum
Arabic, starch derivatives and dextrinized and hydrolyzed starches) and polyhydroxy compounds
(e.g. sugar alcohols, lactones monoethers and acetals) to prepare carrier material which can
remain plastic during the drying process (Brenner and others U.S. Patent 3, 971, 852, 1976).
Homogenization of the dispersion
Following the addition of emulsifier, the heated dispersion is homogenized before spray drying.
Risch and Reineccius (1988) have demonstrated that there is direct relationship between degree
of homogenization and retention of orange peel oil during spray drying.
Atomization of the infeed emulsion
Atomization parameters have significant effect on the particle size distribution of the resultant
powder Chang and others (1988) showed that there is optimum particle size for flavor retention
However, Bomben (1973) showed that particle size is insignificant if high infeed solids were
used. Although particle size has not significant effect on flavor retention, larger particle sizes are
preferred since smaller particles are difficult to disperse and float on the liquid surface.
26
Large particles can be obtained by using large orifice size/low atomization pressure (in case of
pressure nozzle) and high infeed solids, high infeed viscosity, low wheel speed (centrifugal
atomizer).
Dehydration of Atomized particles
The atomized particles assume spherical shape as they pass through the gaseous medium. The
evaporation takes place very rapidly as the droplet comes in contact with hot air. The core
temperature is kept below 100˚C despite the high temperatures used in the experiment because of
rapid evaporation of the coating. Thus the major advantage of spray drying method is its ability
to handle heat labile materials.
Spray cooling/ chilling
Spray cooling and spray chilling are two encapsulation processes that are similar to spray drying.
Both involve dispersing the core material in liquid coating material and spraying through heated
nozzle in controlled environment. The major difference lies in the temperature of the air in the
drying chamber and the type of shell material used. Spray drying uses the heated air in
volatilizing the solvent from coating dispersion, in spray cooling/chilling air used is at ambient
or refrigerated temperature considerably below the solidification point of a molten fat or wax
coating. In spray chilling there is no mass transfer, evaporation from the atomized droplets, i.e.
evaporation from the atomized droplets; hence these solidify almost perfect spheres which result
in free flowing powders without the dents on the surface. The shell material is selected from a
variety of vegetable oils with lower melting points between 32 to 42˚C. Coating material with
lower melting point than this also can be used and it requires specialized handling and storage
conditions (Taylor 1983). In spray chilling, material to be encapsulated is mixed with the carrier
and atomized by cooled or chilled air instead of heated air in spray drying (Risch 1995). The
27
carrier material is usually vegetable oil when spray cooling (45 to 122˚C) is used or
hydrogenated vegetable oil in case of spray chilling (32 to 42˚C). Spray chilling is used to
encapsulate solid food additives such as ferrous sulfate, acidulants, vitamins and solid flavors
and solid flavors as well as for sensitive materials. The product formed is in the form of fine
beads which are water soluble but they release their content at melting point. These spray-chilled
products are used in bakery products, dry soup mixes and foods with high fat contents (Blenford
1986).
Freeze drying/ lyophilization
Freeze drying method is also called as lyophilization. Freeze drying method is suitable for the
heat sensitive compounds which are unstable in aqueous solutions and volatile flavors. The
complete dehydration takes place at low temperature and low pressure conditions and therefore it
has high retention of volatile compounds. Studies by Flink and Karel (1970), Thijssen and co-
workers (1972) showed that retention of volatile compounds during freeze drying is dependent
on the composition of wall and core material. The retention was found to be higher when low
molecular weight carbohydrates were used and total soluble solids were increased to 20%.
Freeze drying method was used by Kopelman and others (1977) for the production of citrus
aroma powders which can be used as natural flavor ingredient in soft drink dry mixes. In this
process corn syrup and sugars (mono and disaccharide) were added in the aroma solutions at
25% (w/w) and subjected to freeze drying. Buffo and Reineccius (2001) compared spray drying,
tray drying, drum drying and freeze drying to encapsulate cold pressed orange oil and reported
that freeze drying process gives most desirable properties. Minemoto and others (1997)
compared oxidation of menthyl linoleate when encapsulated in gum arabic by hot air drying and
freeze drying. Menthyl linoleate encapsulated by freeze drying was more slowly oxidized at any
28
relative humidity. Heinzelmann and Franke (1999) showed that the production of dried
microencapsulated fish oil by freezing and subsequent freeze drying resulted in product with
good resistance to oxidation. Freeze drying is a simple technique except the long dehydration
period (20 hour). Also the cost of this process is 50 times higher than spray drying (Desorby and
others 1997) and storage & transport of particles produced is extremely expensive (Jacquot and
Pernetti 2003).
Fluidized bed coating
Fluidized bed technology was first developed by D.E. Wurster in 1950s and therefore also called
as “Wurster process”. Fluidized bed technology is very efficient way of applying uniform layer
of shell material on solid particles. This is a very versatile technology in the sense that any kind
of shell material (e.g. polysaccharides, proteins, emulsifiers, fats, complex formulations and
enteric coating) can be used as coating material. Therefore, controlled release possibilities are
considerably more versatile with fluidized bed technology than any other technology. This
technique is applicable for hot-melt coatings such as hydrogenated vegetable oil, fatty acids,
emulsifiers, waxes or solvent based coatings such as starches, gums and maltodextrins. For hot
melts, cool air is used to harden the carrier; whereas, for solvent based coatings, hot air is used to
evaporate the solvent. Hot melt ingredients release active core material by increase in
temperature or physical breakage of the capsule, whereas water based coatings release their
content when water is added. There are three different fluidized-bed coating methods: 1) top
spray; 2) bottom-spray; and 3) tangential spray. In top spray method, the coating solution is
sprayed through top and air is passed from bottom through the bed of core particles to suspend
and coat them. The coated particles travel through coating zone into expansion chamber and then
fall back into product container and continue cycling throughout the process. Top spray method
29
is used to coat particles as small as 100 µm. But Thiel and Nguyen (1984) have demonstrated the
possibility of encapsulating very fine particles (2-5 µm). In top spray configuration, by
controlling distance the droplet travels before contacting substrate is impossible and coating
imperfections can occur. In bottom spray, both air and coating solution is passed through the
bottom. The advantage of this method is path of droplets towards core particles is extremely
short and premature droplet evaporation is almost absent. Additional advantages include, coating
solution can spread out at lower viscosity producing very dense film with superior physical
strength. A fascinating advancement has been reported by Matsuda and others (2001) for the
fluidization and coating of very fine particles in a fluidized bed. In this process, gravitational
force is multiplied through use of rotating perforated drum that contains the particle. The airflow
is applied tangentially to the rotation of the drum as compensation to the gravity force (upto 37
g) of normal gravitational force. This ensures complete fluidization of the particles. This
technique is used to encapsulate nutritional substances such as vitamin C, B vitamins, ferrous
sulfate, ferrous fumarate, sodium ascorbate, potassium chloride and a variety of vitamin/mineral
premixes. These are used as nutritional supplements. In bakery products, the above mentioned
technique has been used to encapsulate leavening ingredients, vitamin C, acetic acid, lactic acid,
potassium sorbate, sorbic acid, calcium propionate and salt. In meat industry, several food acids
have been fluid-bed encapsulated to develop color and flavor system. Encapsulated acids are
used to achieve a reproducible pH in cured meat products and shorten processing time. Fluid-bed
encapsulated salt is used in meats to prevent development of rancidity, as well as premature set
due to myofibrilar settings.
30
Extrusion
Encapsulation of food ingredients by extrusion is relatively new process compared to spray
drying. It is relatively low temperature encapsulation method which involves forcing of core
material dispersed in molten carbohydrate mass through a series of dies into a bath of
dehydrating liquid (e.g. alcohol). Upon contacting the liquid, the coating material that forms
encapsulating matrix hardens to entrap the core material. The extruded filaments are separated
from the liquid bath, dried to mitigate hygroscopicity (anticaking agent such as calcium
triphosphate can be added). The first patent for flavor encapsulation was awarded to Swisher in
1957. The primary benefit claimed in the patent was maintenance of fresh flavor of citrus oil
which can easily oxidize during storage to produce off-flavors. This involved addition of citrus
oil in molten solution of sucrose and dextrose, cooling solution to form hard slab like rock candy
and then grinding the solid to desired size. Beck (1972) made some improvement in the process
in which he replaced the high DE corn syrup solids with low DE maltodextrin and combined
55% sucrose with 41% maltodextrin (10 to 13 DE). This low DE maltodextrin/sucrose matrix
was considerably less hygroscopic than Swisher. Barnes and Steinke were awarded patent for
their improvement in the process in which they replaced sucrose by modified starch which
possess good emulsifying properties and also due to its lipophilic characteristic would absorb
flavor oil in the matrix. Barnes and Steinke (1987) claimed that modified starch would increase
the loading capacity of the flavors upto 40%. Additional benefits include total replacement of
sucrose with modified starch and product that was sugar-free. Also sucrose inverts into glucose
and fructose at low pH and high temperature. This will result in product becoming more
hygroscopic and will readily participate in nonenzymatic browning. The extrusion process is
particularly useful for heat-sensitive compounds and has been used to encapsulate flavors,
31
vitamin C and colorants. It offers outstanding protection to oxidation of flavors. The accelerated
shelf life testing done by Swisher (1957) on encapsulated orange oil containing antioxidant
resulted in one year of shelf life. Westing and others (1988) showed that shelf life of single fold
orange peel oil was in excess of four years. This is much superior to any other flavor
encapsulation process in commercial use.
Coacervation
Coacervation is also called as phase separation which was developed first by National Cash
Register Co., Dayton, USA for production of carbonless copy paper. Coacervation involves
separation of liquid phase of coating from polymeric solution and wrapping of that phase as
uniform layer around the suspended core particle. It consists of three steps which are carried
under continuous agitation. a). Formation of three immiscible chemical phases. This can be done
by one of these two methods. 1) Direct addition- coating insoluble waxes, immiscible polymer
solution and insoluble liquid polymer is added to liquid manufacturing solution. 2) In-situ
separation- Monomer is dissolved in liquid vehicle and subsequently polymerized at the
interface. b). Deposition of coating-deposition of liquid polymer coating around core material
can occur if the coating polymer is sorbed at the interface formed between core material and
liquid vehicle phase. c). Solidification of the coating: Solidification of coating takes place by
thermal, cross-linking or desolvation technique. Coacervation can also be divided into
nonaqueous phase separation and aqueous phase separation. In aqueous phase separation,
hydrophilic coating material like gelatin, gum arabic is used for coating water-insoluble material
such as citrus oil, vegetable oil and vitamin A where the core material can be released by
pressure, hot water or chemical reaction. In non-aqueous phase separation, hydrophobic coating
is used whereas core can be water soluble or insoluble. This process is investigated for
32
encapsulation of solid food additives like ferrous sulfate. Coacervation has limited use in food
industry for flavor encapsulation because of evaporation of volatiles, dissolution of active
compound into the processing solvent and oxidation of product since residual core materials
sometimes cling to exterior of capsule (Floros and others 1992). Also, limited suitable
encapsulated materials that are food approved are available for coacervation.
Co-crystallization
Co-crystallization is relatively simple and economical process compared with other flavor
encapsulation processes. Chen and others (1988) described number of products that can be
encapsulated such as fruit juices, essential oils, flavors and brown sugar. In this process
spontaneous crystallization of supersaturated sucrose syrup is achieved at high temperature
(above 120˚C) and low moisture (95-97 ˚Brix) and aroma compounds can be added at the time of
spontaneous crystallization (Bhandari and others 1998). The crystal structures of sucrose can be
modified to incorporate flavors either by inclusion within the crystals or by entrapment. This
serves to enhance flavor stability (Mullin 1972; Chen and others 1988). The granular product has
low hygroscopicity and good flowability and dispersion properties (LaBell 1991; Quellet and
others 2001). During the process, some heat sensitive compound may get degraded (Bhandari
and others 1998). Beistain and others (1996) encapsulated orange peel oil using co-
crystallization method. The authors demonstrated that co-crystallization product retained as
much volatile oil as spray dried and extruded products. Addition of strong anti-oxidant was
necessary to retard the development of oxidized flavors during storage.
33
Inclusion complexation or molecular inclusion
Cyclodextrins are enzymatically modified starch molecules which are made by the action of
cyclodextrin glucosyltransferase on starch in which the ends are joined to form circular molecule
with α (1-4) linkage. The inclusion complexes are defined as the result of interaction of
compounds in which guest molecule fits and is surrounded by lattice of other (Godshall 1997).
Structure of β-cyclodextrin is such that inner cavity is hydrophobic and is torus shaped and its
molecular dimension allows total or partial inclusion of range of aroma compounds. The outer
surface is having hydrophilic nature. Pagington (1986) and Bhandari and others (1999) have
listed several methods for complexing β-cyclodextrin with flavor compounds. The following
methods are commonly used for complexing.
1. Stirring or shaking cyclodextrin with flavors in aqueous solution and filtering off
precipitated complex.
2. Blending solid cyclodextrin with guest molecule in powerful mixer and bubbling flavors
as vapors through the solution of cyclodextrin.
3. Kneading the flavor substances with cyclodextrin-water paste.
Cyclodextrins are relatively expensive product and around $ 6.00 per kg (Gouin 2004).
Therefore, the application is found in the area of high value added and specialty flavor chemicals
(Uhlemann and others 2002).
Microencapsulation efficiency
Microencapsulation efficiency (MEE) is defined as the proportion of the core that could not be
extracted by the solvent under test conditions. (Young and others 1993). Jimenez and others
(2004) microencapsulated conjugated linoleic acid using whey protein concentrate as wall
material and defined microencapsulation efficiency as below
34
MEE= (total oil – extractable oil) X 100 / total oil.
Desai and Park (2005) reported the microencapsulation efficiency 45.05 to 58.30 % for vitamin
C encapsulated in tripolyphosphate cross linked chitosan microspheres. It was observed that as
the amount of cross linking agent increased, the encapsulation efficiency decreased. This was
attributed to the surface irregularities observed of chitosan microspheres as the amount of cross
linking agent was increased. It was hypothesized that damaged microspheres with surface
irregularities, fragmentation or holes are likely to cause the loss of substantial amount of vitamin
C during the spray encapsulation process.
The shelf life of the spray dried microcapsule
Spray dried encapsulated flavor have the shelf life of 6 months or more depending on the type of
the core material/flavor compound used, carrier material used, absence of the surface oil (which
oxidizes rapidly), moisture content of the powder, powder surface properties and moisture
absorption during storage (Bhandari and D’Arcy 1996). The porosity of the dried particle is also
proposed to be the major determinant of the shelf life of the spray dried flavor microcapsule
(Reineccius 1988). A large portion of the dry flavorings produced in the industry includes some
citrus oil. These citrus oils are prone to oxidation during storage. The industry requires at least
one year of shelf life. In order to improve upon shelf life, the encapsulated flavor must be
protected from oxidation. This brings up consideration for the presence of antioxidants (natural),
trace metals, entrained air and oxygen barrier properties of final spray dried particle.
Anandaraman and Reineccius (1986) have shown that there is a very strong protective effect of
higher dextrose equivalent (DE) starch hydrolysates (corn syrup solids) against oxidative
deterioration of spray dried orange peel oil. Many authors suggest that glass transition (Tg) plays
a major role in determination of oxidative stability of foods (Bhandari and others 1999).
35
Physical Properties of spray dried particles
Particle size and shape
Particle size is the result of the selection of the operating parameters chosen for atomization.
Spherical particle size is desirable because of better aroma retention (spherical particle has least
surface to volume ratio and therefore least exposure to the surface with maximum core is
encapsulated in spherical particle). Highest bulk densities and best flowability is obtained in
spherical particles. For wheel atomization, particle size is determined by the speed of the
atomizer and the physical properties of the emulsion (e.g. viscosity and solids concentration). In
case of nozzle atomization, particle size is determined by the nozzle orifice and the spray
pressure (or air flow for the two fluid atomizer. A high pressure and small orifice will result in
smaller particles and low pressure and larger particle. Particle size can be influenced by the
operating temperatures also. High drying rates (High inlet temperature and low ΔT, i.e.,
temperature difference between inlet and exit temperatures) will result in slightly larger particles
compared to slow drying. This is because fast drying does not allow the particles to shrink
compared to slow drying. Also particles dry quickly if solid contents are high and are expected to
produce larger particles and cannot shrink as much (Masters 1991). Zakarian and King have
shown that if both volatile loss and rate of drying are diffusion controlled, volatile retention
should be independent of particle size. It is desirable to produce larger particles to facilitate
rehydration. The smaller particles tend to disperse very poorly, especially in cold water and
instead form lumps on liquid surface. Larger particles can be obtained by controlling dryer
operating temperatures (e.g. high infeed viscosity and solids, low pressure large-orifice if using a
pressure spray atomizer or low wheel speed if using centrifugal atomizer) or using agglomeration
techniques.
36
Absolute and bulk densities
Absolute density is defined as the weight of a given particle volume of powder while bulk
density is defined as the weight of a given total (bed) volume of powder. Absolute density can be
determined by the He pycnometry and takes into account only the volume of particles that is not
permeable to the displacing gas. Helium displacement methods have been used to determine
absolute densities for many years. Some materials such as modified starches foam excessively
during hydration and blending. This entrapped air is retained during drying and thus results in a
powder of low absolute density. Degassing of the infeed material conversely increases the
absolute density. The absolute density is influenced by the amount of air in the infeed matrix or
included during atomization process, steam formation within the particle during drying and the
rate of drying. These factors can be influenced by the dryer air temperature, particle size,
atomization conditions and infeed matrix (material, entrapped gas and solids content) (Verhey
1972). The smaller particles are usually denser than larger particle. Higher inlet temperatures and
lower ΔT result in lower density powder since rapid drying of the particle and forming the
particle structure before much water has evaporated (Verhey 1972). The bulk density is primarily
determined by placing a given weight of powder in a graduated cylinder and then vibrating or
shaking the cylinder until the powder bed reaches a constant volume. The rate and intensity of
agitation is important in influencing this value. Bulk density is important in packaging and
shipping considerations. Absolute density, particle shape and size influences bulk density.
Particle geometry also determines the bulk density. Spherical particles fit the best in the pack and
have highest bulk density if other factors are equal. The particle density is decreased by steam
formation in the drying droplet thereby expanding the particle whose dimensions become fixed
as drying continues (Verhey 1972).
37
Flowability
Flowability is important since if powder does not flow well then manufacturing process becomes
problematic. Flowability is measured by pouring a fixed weight of volume through a selected
funnel configuration. The powder is allowed to flow through the funnel and the angle of powder
pile above horizontal (angle of response) is measured. Smaller the angle better is the flowability.
The more common method is measuring the amount of time required for the powder to flow
through funnel. However, the values obtained are extremely dependent on experimental set-up
(e.g. the funnel diameter and/or height above a table). Flowability is influenced by particle
geometry (spherical particles flow best), density (high density gives better flow ability) and
surface oil. The particles with high surface oil become sticky and do not flow well. Flowability
can be improved by using silica free flowing agents (<2% of weight of product).
Dispersability
Dispersability is primarily influenced by the particle size, density and carrier matrix used. Small
and low density particle are difficult to disperse. Particle size can be increased through
instantizing processes. This can be done by rewetting the powder in a fludized bed, allowing the
powder to agglomerate and then again drying it. Gum acacia are particularly difficult to disperse
and therefore agglomerated forms of gum acacia is available. Ingredients difficult to disperse are
preblended with other ingredients such as sugar or salt to improve dispersability. The appearance
of spray dried microencapsulated color (e.g. colorings, many spice oils, or other coloring
materials) is greatly influenced by the particle size. The small particles produced by spray drying
method have light color. Large or agglomerated particles are darker and richer in color. Thus, the
particle size, agglomeration influences the appearance of the powder.
38
Structural Strength
Structural strength assumes importance when dry blending powder with salt or sugar or when the
active material inside the microcapsule is liquid or soft paste. The dry blending process is very
abrasive and will crack or damage powders high in liquid actives or those that are low in density.
The industry has accepted spray dried powder containing 20% flavor and if one uses (>40%
flavor), the particle loses structural integrity during blending and fracture. This results in
exposure of flavor to oxygen which results in rapid degradation during storage. Thus it may be
necessary to produce high density low load powder in case the flavor is susceptible to oxidation.
Characterization of microcapsules
Varieties of methods are available to characterize the microcapsules. These include electron
microscopy (EM), radio tracers, fluorescence quenching, ultrasonic absorption, electron spin
resonance (ESR) spectroscopy, Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) can be used to
characterize the microcapsules. Each of these techniques have characteristic advantages.
Electron Microscopy (EM)
Electron Microscopy can reveal the average size distribution of microcapsules. Negative staining
and freeze fracture are the methods most commonly used, especially liposome structures.
(Dreamer and Uster 1983). However, other properties, such as the permeability and stability of
microcapsule cannot be studied by this technique.
Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM)
The protection to the core material provided by the wall material depends on the flow properties
of the inner and outer microstructures of the microcapsule and the organization of the core
material within the microcapsule. These characteristics of microcapsules can be studied by SEM
in secondary electron imaging (SEI) with great depth of field and sufficiently high resolution
39
(Rosenberg and others 1985). Rosenberg and others (1985) developed new embedding and
microtoming technique that enables the study of inner structure of fractured microcapsule. The
SEM technique was improved by Rosenberg and others (1984) for studying the effects of wall
composition and drying conditions for inner and outer structure of spray dried microcapsules.
Thus, it can be observed how the core material is organized in solid wall matrix, about the
existence of one or more internal voids in the microcapsule, indentation and caps on exterior of
microcapsule, and how the microstructure features are affected by the solid’s concentration in the
sprayed emulsion, temperature of feed and drying air.
Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) Spectroscopy
The permeability of liposomes has been studied using ESR spectroscopy in conjunction with
water-soluble electron paramagnetic resonance probe, trimethyl-4-amino-2, 2, 6, 6-tetramethyl-
1-oxy-piperidine (CAT1) (Kim and others 1991). Release of CAT1 from liposomes can be
measured by adding the spin label quenching agent potassium ferricyanide to the suspension and
monitoring the reduction of ESR signal strength. The movement of CAT1 and ferricyanide ions
across the liposomes membrane could be monitored by increasing the temperature to the phase
transition point. The ESR signal light at Tc is smaller than that below Tc because of the
reduction of CAT by ferricyanide ion. Thus, ESR spectra can be used to test the stability and
permeability of liposomes. However, this method is only intended for the testing of liposomes in
research laboratories and will not be useful for quality control of processed food due to toxicity
of most spin labels.
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Spectroscopy
NMR spectroscopy uses electromagnetic radiation in the radio frequency range to induce
transitions between nuclear spin energy levels in the presence of strong magnetic field. When
40
nuclear spin relaxes back to their equilibrium state, voltage is induced in a detection coil; this
voltage is NMR or ‘free induction decay’ signal. NMR relaxation techniques provide rapid
sensitive and nondestructive means of obtaining detailed information about molecular dynamics
and intermolecular interactions in complex systems like foods. The NMR spectroscopy is faster
and more suitable to characterize microcapsules like liposomes than fluorescence method.
Recently, such technique has been used to study many complex food proteins (Baianu IC and
others 1982; Myers-Betts PA and others 1990) and starches (Yakubu PI and others 1990).
Fluorescence Quenching
A number of flurophore-modified starch lipids have been used to label liposomes and to study
liposome stability and liposome-cell interactions. One effective method of assessing liposome
properties uses the carboxyfluorescein self-quenching method (Hagins 1978).
Fluorescence self-quenching is simple and effective means of testing liposome characteristics
such as stability and integrity. The fluorescence quenching is based on the loss of fluorescence
efficiency due to probe-probe interactions when fluorophore molecule is present at high
concentration. Carboxyfluorescein is a highly water-soluble derivative of fluorescein that can be
trapped within liposomes at various concentrations. The molecule does not fluoresce
significantly when trapped within liposomes at high concentration because of the fluorescence
quenching phenomenon (Kim and others 1991).
41
Table 2.1: Methods used to reduce the loss of L-ascorbic acid in foods (Liao and others 1988).
Principle Example
1. Limit Oxygen Deaerate by vacuum, boil or purge with Nitrogen
Add glucose oxidase plus catalase
Add sulfite
Add yeast
2. Limit Cu(ii) and Fe(iii) Avoid brass, bronze, monel, steel and iron
Chelate with citrate, phosphates, EDTA, protein
3. Limit complexing between metal ion and L-ascorbic acid
Lower water activity
Lower pH
Coat L-ascorbic acid or use derivative substituted at O2
Add selected proteins
42
Table 2.2: Coating materials for encapsulating food ingredients
Carbohydrates Starch, maltodextrin, corn syrup, dextran, sucrose, cyclodextrins
Cellulose Carboxy methylcellulose, methylcellulose, ethylcellulose, nitrocellulose, acetylcellulose, cellulose acetate-phthalate
Gums Gum acacia, agar, sodium alginate, carageenan
Lipids Wax, paraffin, beeswax, tristearic acid, diglycerides, monoglycerides, oils, fats, hardened oils
Proteins Whey protein concentrate, whey protein isolate, sodium caseinate, gelatin, albumin, peptides
43
Table 2.3: Strengths and weaknesses of some of the food grade materials with good
encapsulating properties
Material Strength Weakness
A/B- gelatin Very good emulsion, safe source Non-kosher, BSE (B-gelatin)
Fish gelatin Excellent emulsion, Kosher Expensive, availability (?)
Casein/whey protein Very good emulsion, Kosher
Instabilities at low pH, allergenic potential
Soya protein, gluten zein Very good emulsion, Kosher, animal-free, safe source, cheap
Allergenic potential, GMO
Modified starches Very good emulsion, kosher, cheap
Sometimes varying quality, not universally usable owing to regulatory
situation.
Gum acacia Good emulsion, very good inclusion of volatiles
Varying quality, price depending on
availability
Sucrose, maltodextrin, dextrin
Very good oxygen barrier, cheap No/ limited emulsion stabilization
Lecithin Generally usable in all foods GMO
44
Table 2.4: Methods of microencapsulation (Thies 2001)
Chemical Process Mechanical process
Complex Coacervation
Spray Drying
Polymer/polymer incompatibility
Spray Chilling
Interfacial Polymerization
Fluidized Bed
In situ polymerization
Electrostatic deposition
In-liquid drying
Centrifugal Extrusion
Thermal and ionic gelation in liquid media
Spinning disk or rotational suspension separation
Desolvation in liquid media
Polymerization at liquid/gas or solid/gas interface, Pressure extrusion, Hot-melt extrusion
45
Table 2.5: Different variables affecting fluidized-bed operation (Desai and Others 2005).
Sr. No. Variables
1 Process conditions 1. Inlet air temperature 2. Inlet air velocity 3. Spray rate 4. Solution temperature 5. Solution dry matter content 6. Atomization pressure 2 Ambient air conditions 1. Temperature 2. Relative humidity 3 Thermodynamic 1. Outlet air temperature 2. Outlet air relative humidity
46
Table 2.6: Parameters affecting the release rate of core material
Coating Properties
Density, crystallanity, orientation, solubility, plasticizer level, cross-linking, pretreatments
Capsule Properties
Size, wall thickness, configuration, conformity, coating layers, post treatment
Experimental parameters
Temperature, pH, moisture, solvent, mechanical action, partial pressure differential (inside and outside coating)
47
Table 2.7: Different types of microencapsulated food ingredients and application of microencapsulation (Desai and others 2005)
No Category of Food Ingredient
Examples Preferred mode of encapsulation
Applications
1. Used to assist in the development of color and flavor in meat emulsion and dry sausage products
1 Acidulants Lactic acid, glucono-∂-lactone, Vit. C, Acetic acid, potassium sorbate, sorbic acid and calcium propionate.
Fluidized-bed coating, Extrusion
2. Baking industry use stable acid and baking soda in wet and dry mixes to control the release of CO2 during processing.
2 Flavoring agents
Citrus oil, mint oils, onion oils, garlic oils and spice oleoresins
Inclusion complexation extrusion, centrifugal extrusion, spray-drying.
1. To transform liquid flavorings into stable and free flowing powders, which are easier to handle & incorporate in food products.
3 Sweeteners Sugar, nutritive or artificial sugars and aspartame
Co-crystallization, fluidized bed coating
1. Reduce hygroscopicity, improve flowability and prolong sweetness perception.
4 Colorants Annato, β-carotene and turmeric
Extrusion 1. Encapsulated colors easier to handle and offer improved solubility, stability to oxidation and control over stratification from dry blends.
5 Lipids Fish Oil, linoleic acid, rice bran oil and sardine oil.
Spray-drying Freeze drying, vacuum drying
1. To prevent oxidative degradation during processing and storage
6 Vitamins and Minerals
Fat soluble- Vit. A, D, E and K. Lipid soluble: Vit C, Vit B1, B2, B6, B12, Niacin, folic acid and Choline (Vit B4)
Coacervation, Inclusion Complexation, spray-drying, liposome entrapment
1. To reduce off-flavors. 2. To permit time release of nutrients 3. Enhance stability in extreme temperature and moisture 4. Reduce each nutrient interaction with other ingredients
7 Enzymes and Microorganisms
Lipase, Invertase, Penicillium roquefortii, Brevibacterium linens.
Coacervation, Spray-drying, liposome entrapment
1. To improve stability, 2. To reduce ripening time 3. Improve survivability
48
Table 2.8: Physical properties of L-ascorbic acid (Liao and others 1988)
Appearance: White colorless crystals
M.P. : 190-2 ˚C
Optical Activity: [α ]D 25 + 21˚ (c 1.0, water)
[α ]D 25 + 48˚ (c 1.0, methanol)
Solubility: g/100 ml
Water 33 Ethanol 2
Propylene glycol 5 Glycerol 1
95% ethanol 3.3 Lipid Solvents insoluble
UV
pH 2: λ max 243 nm, ε mM 10.0
pH 7: λ max 265 nm ε mM 16.5
49
Figure 2.1: Microencapsulation – particle morphology (Zeoli and others 1983)
Simple Microcapsule
Multi-wall microcapsule
Multi-core microcapsule
Matrix particle
Irregularly shaped
microcapsule
50
Figure 2.2: Schematic diagram of ideal storage and release behavior (Thies 2001)
Core Core
Storage Release
Components of surrounding environment
Trigger
event
Components of surrounding environment
Or
51
Figure 2.3: Schematic diagram of spray-dry encapsulation process (Shahidi and others 1993).
Core material
Solvent + Shell material
Homogenize
Heated gas
Drying Chamber Separator
Solvent vapor and exhaust gas
Dry Capsule powder
52
Figure 2.4: Controlled release mechanism of encapsulated food ingredients (Shahidi and others
1993)
EXTERNAL FORCE Pressure, shearing. Grinding, ultrasonics
INTERNAL FORCE Expansion Selective permeation
FRACTURATION
Core
CONTROLLED BY (Moisture, pH, Temperature, Agitation, Coating Structure, etc.)
DIFFUSION Driven by Conc. Gradient & interchain attractive.
DISSOLUTION OR MELTAGE By solvent or heating
BIODEGRADATION (Enzymatic release)
53
Figure 2.5: Procedure for preparation of vitamin C encapsulated chitosan microspheres by spray
drying (Desai and others 2005)
Chitosan solution (1% w/v)
Vitamin C solution (1% w/v)
Vitamin C and chitosan mixture
Homogenizing (8000 rpm, 10 min)
10 ml 20 ml 30 ml
1% w/v TPP Homogenizing (8000 rpm, 20 min)
Spray Drying
Inlet temp. 175 ˚C Pump rate 3mL/min Compressed air flow 10 L/min
Vitamin C encapsulated chitosan microspheres
54
References
Anandaraman S, Reineccius GA. 1986. Stability of encapsulated orange peel oil. Food
Technology (40): 88-93.
Apintanapong M, Noomhorm A. 2003. The use of spray-drying to microencapsulate 2-acetyl-1-
pyrroline, a major flavor component of aromatic rice. International Journal of Food Science and
Technology, (38), 95–102.
Arshady R. Microcapsules for food. 1993. Journal of Microencapsulation. 10(4):413-35
Baianu IC, Johnson LF, Waddel DK. 1982. High-resolution proton, carbon-13 and nitrogen-15
nuclear magnetic resonance studies of wheat proteins at high magnetic fields. J. Sci. Food
Agricu. 33(4) 373.
Bauernfeind JC. 1982. Ascorbic acid technology in agricultural, pharmaceutical, food and
industrial applications. In Ascorbic acid: Chemistry, Metabolism and Uses. Ed. Seib PA, Tolbert
BM, Adv. Chem. Ser. No. 200. American Chemical Society. Washington D.C. 81-99.
Barnes JM, Steinke JA. 1987. Encapsulation matrix composition and encapsulate containing
same, U.S. patent, 4,689,235.
Beck EE. 1972. Essential Oils, U.S. patent 43,704,137.
Beristain CI, Vazquez A, Garcia HS, Vernon-Carter EJ. 1996. Encapsulation of orange peel oil
by co-crystallization. Lebensmittel-Wissenschaft und-Technologie (29):645-647.
Bhandari BR, D’Arcy BR. 1996. Microencapsulation of flavor compounds. Food Australia
(48): 547-551.
Bhandari BR, Datta N, D’Arcy BR, Rintoul GB. 1998. Co-crystallization of honey with sucrose.
Lebensmittel-Wissenscchaft und-Technologie, (31):138-142.
55
Bhandari BR, Howes TJ. 1990. Implication of glass transition for the drying and stability of
dried foods. Food Engineering (40): 71-79.
Blenford D. 1986. Fully protected. Food Flavor ingred Proc. Packg. 43.
Bloch A, Thomson CA. 1995. Position of the American dietic association: photochemical and
functional foods. J. American Dietic. Association (95): 493-96.
Bomben JL, Bruin B, Thijssen HAC, Merson RL. 1973. Aroma recovery and retention in
concentration and drying of foods. Adv. Food Res. 20(1)1.
Boscovic MA, Salleb FZ, Chuang LY, Vindal SM, Popp W, Fioriti JA. Structure and stability of
encapsulated flavor particles, predictive value of different quality probes. In controlled Release
Society 5th Workshop, Amsterdam, The Netherland
Brenner. 1976. Process of encapsulating an oil and product produced thereby, U.S. Patent 3, 971,
852.
Chang YI, Scire J, Jacob B. 1988. Effects of particle size and microstructure properties on
encapsulated orange oil, in Flavor Encapsulation, Risch SJ and Reineccius GA, eds, ACS
Symposium Series No. 370, American Chemical Society, Washington D.C., 87.
Chen AC, Veigra MF, Anthony BR. 1988. Co-crystallization: an encapsulation process. Food
Technology (42): 87-90.
Crawford TC, Crawford SA. 1980. Synthesis of L-ascorbic acid. Adv. Carbohydr. Chem. 37, 79-
155.
Cort WM, 1982. Anti-oxidant properties of ascorbic acid in foods. In ascorbic acid: Chemistry,
Metabolism and Uses, Ed. Seib PA, Tolbert BM, Adv. Chem. Ser. No. 200. American Chemical
Society. Washington D.C. 533-50.
56
Deamer DW, Uster PS. Liposome preparation: methods and mechanisms, in Liposomes, Ostro,
M.J. Ed., Marcel Dekker, New York, 1983, 27.
Desai KGH, Park HJ. 2005. Recent developments in microencapsulation of food ingredients.
Drying Technology, (23):1361-1394.
Dziezak JD. 1988. Microencapsulation and encapsulated ingredients. Food Technology. 42(4):
136-148, 151.
Flink J and Karel M. 1970. Retention of organic volatiles compounds in freeze drying slabs of
maltodextrin. J. Food Technology, 7(1):79
Fleming JE, Bensch KG. (1983). Effect of amino acids, peptides and related compounds on the
autoxidation of ascorbic acid by hydroxyl radical. Int. J. Peptide Protein Res., (22), 355-61.
Floros RJ, Wall MD, Carnahan DW and Orofino TA. 1992. An investigation of internal phase
losses during the encapsulation of fragrances. Journal of Microencapsulation (3):287-307.
Godshall MA. 1997. How carbohydrates influence food flavor. Journal of Food Technology.
(51):63-67.
Gorman JE, Clydesdale FM. 1983. The behavior and stability of iron-ascorbate complexes in
solution. Journal of Food Science (48): 1217-20, 1225.
Goubet I, Le Quere JL, Voilley A. 1998. Retention of aroma compounds by carbohydrates:
influence of their physicochemical characteristics and of their physical state. Journal of
Agricultural of Food Chemistry, (48): 1981–1990.
Gouin S. 2004. Microencapsulation: industrial appraisal of existing technologies and trends.
Trends in Food Science and Technology (15): 330-347.
57
Hagins WA, Yoshikami S. 1978. Intracellular transmission of visual excitation in
photoreceptors: electrical effects of chelating agents introduced into rods by vesicle fusion. In
Vertebrate Photoreception, Fatt P. and Barlow HB. Eds., Academic Press, New York, 97.
Hogan SA, McNamee BF, O’Riordan ED, O’Sullivan M. 2001. Microencapsulating properties of
whey protein concentrate-75. Food Engineering and physical properties (66): 675-680.
Hornig D, Weber F, Wiss O. 1974. Influence of erythorbic acid on vitamin C status in guinea
pigs. Experientia, (30):173-4.
Jackson LS, Lee K. Microencapsulation and food industry. 1991. Ebensmittel - Wissenschaft
Technologie (24): 289-297.
Kenyon MM. 1995. Modified starch, maltodextrin and corn syrup solids as wall material for
food encapsulation. In: Encapsulation and controlled release of Food Ingredients (Edited by
Risch SJ, Reineccius GA. page no. 43-50 ACS Symposium Series 590. Washington D.C:
American Chemical Society.
Kim H-H Y, Baianu IC. 1991. Novel liposome microencapsulation techniques for food
applications. Trends in Food Science and Technology 2(3): 55.
Kim YD, Morr CV, Schenz TW. 1996. Microencapsulation properties of gum arabic and several
food proteins: Spray dried orange oil emulsion particles. Journal of Agricultural and Food
Chemistry (44): 1314-1320.
Kopelman IJ, Meydav S, Wilmersdorf P. 1977. Freeze drying encapsulation of water-soluble
citrus aroma. J. Food Technology 12(1): 65.
LaBell F. 1991. Co-crystallization process aids dispersion and solubility. Food Processing (52):
60-63.
58
Lakkis J, Pfizer Inc. Session 17 Advances in Microencapsulation technologies and application in
the food industry.
Liao M-L, Seib PA. 1988. Chemistry of L-ascorbic acid related to foods. 289-312.
Lubbers S, Landy P, Voilley A. 1998. Retention and release of aroma compounds in food
containing proteins. Journal of Food Technology, (52): 68–74.
Maggi EL. 1979. Microencapsulation of cheese ripening systems in milkfat. Diss. Abstr. Int. B,
40(5): 2103.
Maggi EL, Olson NF. 1981. Microencapsulation of cheese ripening systems: production of
diacetyl and acetol in cheese by encapsulated bacterial cell free extract. J. Dairy Science. 64(4):
616.
Matsuda S, Hatano H, Kuramoto K, Tsutsumi A. 2001. Fluidization of ultrafine particles with
high G. Journal of Chemical Engineering (34): 121-125.
Moreau DL, Rosenberg M. 1996. Oxidative stability of anhydrous milkfat microencapsulated in
whey proteins. (61): 39-43.
Moreau DL, Rosenberg M. 1998. Porosity of whey protein based microcapsule containing
anhydrous milkfat measured by gas displacement pycnometry. Journal of Food Science 63(5)
819-823.
Mullin JW. 1972. Crystallization kinetics. Crystallization. Pp. 213-216. Cleveland, OH: CRC
Press Inc.
Myers-Betts PA, Baianu IC. 1990. Approaches to protein hydration and activity in food proteins
by nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation and vapor pressure equilibration techniques. J. Agric.
Food Chemistry. 38(5): 1171.
Pagington JS. 1986. Beta-cyclodextrin. Perfumer and Flavorist (11): 49-58.
59
Thiel WJ, Nguyen LT. 1984. Fluidized bed film coating of an ordered powder mixture to
produce microencapsulated ordered units. Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology (36): 145-152.
Qi ZH, Hedges AR. 1995. Use of cyclodextrin for flavors, in: Ho, C. T., Tan C., Tong, C. eds
Flavor Technology. ACS Sym Ser 610, Washington D.C.: American Chemical Society, 231-243.
Quellet C, Schudel M, Ringgenberg R. 2001. Flavors and fragrance delivery systems. Chimia
(55): 421-428.
Reifsteck BM, Jeon IJ. 2000. Retention of volatile flavors in confections in extrusion processing.
Food Reviews International (16):435-452.
Reineccius GA. 1991. Carbohydrates for flavor encapsulation. Food Technology (46):144.
Reineccius GA. 1988. Spray Drying in Food flavors Page 45 in flavor encapsulation.
Reineccius GA, Bangs WE. 1982. Spray drying of food flavors. Optimum infeed concentration
for the retention of artificial flavors. Perum Flavor 9: 27-29.
Risch SJ. 1995. Encapsulation: Overview of uses and techniques in Encapsulation and controlled
release of Food Ingredients, Eds. Risch SJ and GA Reineccius, pp1-7. ACS symposium series
590. Washington, DC: American Chemical Society.
Risch SJ, Reineccius GA. 1988. Spray-dried orange oil: effect of emulsion size on flavor
retention and shelf stability, in Flavor Encapsulation, Risch SJ and Reineccius GA. eds, ACS
Symposium Series No. 370, American Chemical Society, Washington D.C., 67.
Rosenberg M, Talmon Y, Kopelman IJ. 1984. The microstructure of spray dried microcapsules.
Food Microstructure 7-15.
Rosenberg M, Talmon Y, Kopelman IJ. 1985. A scanning electron microscopy study of
microencapsulation. Journal of food science 50(1): 139.
60
Sankarikutty BM, Sreekumar CS, Narayana, Mathew AG. 1988. Studies on microencapsulation
of cardamom oil by spray drying technique. J. of Food Science Technology (25):352.
Shahidi F, Han X. 1993. Encapsulation of food ingredients. Critic. Rev. Food Sci. and Nutr.
33:501-547.
Sheu TY, Rosenberg M. 1995. Microencapsulation by Spray Drying Ethyl Caprylate in Whey
Protein and Carbohydrate Wall Systems. Journal of Food Science 60(1): 98–103.
Shiga H, Yoshii H, Nishiyama T. 2001. Flavor encapsulation and release characteristics of spray-
dried powder by the blended encapsulant of cyclodextrin and gum arabic. Drying Technology,
19, 1385–1395.
Swisher HE. 1957. U.S. patent 2,809,895.
Tari TA, Singhal RS. 2002. Starch based spherical aggregates: reconfirmation of the role of
amylose on the stability of a model flavouring compound, vanillin. Carbohydrates Polymers,
(50), 279–282.
Taylor AH, 1983. Encapsulation systems and their applications in flavor industry. Food Flavor
Ingredient Packaging proc. (5): 48-49, 51-52.
Uhlemann J, Schleifenbaum B, Bertram HJ. 2002. Flavor encapsulation technologies: an
overview including recent developments. Perfumer and Flavorist (27): 52-61.
Verhey JGP. 1972. Vacuole formation in spray dried powder particles. Atomization and droplet
drying. Netherlands Milk Dairy Journal (27): 3-18.
Verhey JGP. 1972. Vacuole formation in spray powder particles. Air incorporation and bubble
expansion. Netherlands Milk Dairy Journal (26): 186-202.
Westing LL, Reineccius GA, Caporaso F. Shelf life of orange oil: effects of encapsulation by
spray drying, extrusion and molecular inclusion, in Flavor Encapsulation, Risch SJ, Reineccius
61
GA, Eds., ACS Symposium Series No. 370, American Chemical Society, Washington D.C.
1988, 110.
Whorton C. 1995. Factors influencing volatile release from encapsulation matrices. In:
Encapsulation and Controlled Release of Food Ingredients (edited by Risch SJ, Reineccius GA).
Pp. 134–142. Washington, D.C.: American Chemical Society.
Williams PA, Phillips GO. 2000. Gum arabic. In: Handbook of hydrocolloids (edited by Phillips
GO. and Williams PA. Cambridge: Woodhead Publishing Limited. P No. 155-168.
Yoshii H, Soottitantawat A, Liu X.D. 2001. Flavor release from spray-dried maltodextrin/gum
arabic or soy matrices as a function of storage relative humidity. Innovative Food Science and
Emerging Technologies (2): 55–61.
Yakubu PI, Baianu IC, Orr PH. 1990. Unique hydration behavior of potato starch as determined
by deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance. J. Food Science 55(2) 458.
Young SL, Sarda X, Rosenberg M. 1993. Microencapsulating properties of whey proteins 2.
Combination of whey proteins with carbohydrates. Journal of Dairy science 76(10): 2878-2885.
Zeoli LT, Kydonieus AF 1983. In Controlled Release Technology (Das, K.G. ed.), page no. 61-
120, John Wiley and Sons.
62
CHAPTER 3
MICROENCAPSULATION OF VITAMIN C IN WHEY PROTEIN CONCENTRATE (WPC-
80) USING SPRAY AND FREEZE DRYING METHOD
______________________________
1 S. R. Tandale, M. S. Chinnan, and R. D. Phillips. To be submitted to the Journal of Food Science.
63
ABSTRACT
Microencapsulation of ascorbic acid was carried out using spray drying and freeze drying
method in which whey protein concentrate (WPC) was used as coating material. Ascorbic acid:
WPC (w/w) ratio of 1:4.0, 1:5.3, 1:8.0 and 1:16.0 was selected to determine microencapsulation
efficiency which showed 1:4 ratio had highest efficiency for both spray dried (96.35%) and
freeze dried process (98.23%) processes. 1:4 ratio was selected for further analysis. Morphology
of microcapsules was examined by scanning electron microscope (SEM) which revealed good
sphericity with some outer pores in spray dried microencapsulated ascorbic acid powder. Freeze
dried powder was found to be irregularly shaped. Some agglomeration of small capsules was
observed in spray dried powder. Particle size analysis was conducted using the Mastersizer
which revealed multi-modal distribution (4.17-36.54 µm) in spray dried powder with average
diameter of 17.46 µm. Freeze dried powder had single peak distribution (3.33-8.18 µm) with
average diameter of 11.51 µm. Accelerated shelf life testing was carried out under various
environmental conditions, temperature (25 and 45 ˚C), Humidity (22, 44, 66 and 85% RH), Light
(UV light and dark), and 100% oxygen in sealed container for 7 weeks. Freeze dried
microencapsulated vitamin C powder provided better protection from degradation compared to
spray dried powder at all the RH conditions. This could be attributed to the difference in bulk
density. Freeze dried powder was considerably denser compared to spray dried powder and thus
minimizing the area of exposure to environmental degradation conditions.
INDEX WORDS: Microencapsulation, spray drying, freeze drying, ascorbic acid, stability, and
microencapsulation efficiency.
64
INTRODUCTION
Microencapsulation is defined as the process of coating solids, liquids and gaseous
materials in microscopic, sealed microcapsules which release their active contents at controlled
rate under specific stimuli (Dziezak 1988, Risch 1995). These microcapsules can range from
several microns to millimeters and are usually spherical in shape. However, their shape is largely
influenced by the structure of the original core material as well as drying conditions. One of the
many objectives of microencapsulation is protecting active core content from various
degradation factors that can cause its oxidation or deterioration such as temperature, humidity,
light, oxygen and its interaction with various minerals such as copper, iron, and zinc.
Microencapsulation is also used to prevent off-flavors produced by vitamins, minerals, taste
masking certain food ingredients, preventing interaction among various food ingredients,
improve the stability and handling of colors, improve flavor and texture of food product. In short,
microencapsulation gives flexibility in terms of using food ingredients in food formulation in the
hands of food scientist who can come up with innovative food products using this technology.
Spray drying is the most common method used for encapsulation in the food industry for
variety of reasons; such as economics, flexibility of the process, ready availability of equipment,
wide choice of carrier material, good retention of volatile material, good stability of finished
product and large scale production in continuous mode (Reinecccius 1989). The advantage of
spray drying method is that heat-labile (low boiling point) and heat sensitive materials can also
be encapsulated because of the lower temperature that the core material reaches (Dziezak 1988).
Microencapsulation by spray drying process involves formation of emulsion or suspension of
coating and core material, followed by atomization and spraying of the mixture in a hot chamber.
65
Ascorbic acid is used as vitamin supplement in many food products. The commercial
forms of ascorbic acid used in the food industry are L-ascorbic acid, its sodium and calcium salts
and 6 palmitate ester. One of the important biochemical reactions of L-ascorbic acid is to destroy
free radicals (hydroxyl and perhydroxyl). In this role, L-ascorbic acid and its oxidation product
dehydroascorbic acid acts as ‘redox buffer’ (Sapper 1982). When terminating free radicals, L-
ascorbic acid is converted to dehydroascorbic acid which is then recycled to L-ascorbic acid by
reductase enzyme and cofactors. Since ascorbyl palmitate and L-ascorbic acid reacts with anti-
oxidants, they prevent peroxide formation in lipids and delay onset of chain reactions that causes
deterioration of vegetable oils, animal fat, fish, margarine, milk, vitamin A and carotenoids (Cort
1982). For certain applications, excess amounts of vitamin C is added prior to packaging in order
to remove the free oxygen and to replenish losses anticipated during storage. However, this can
increase the risk of undesirable interactions with other components.
Microencapsulated ascorbic acid could be used to prevent its interaction with other
ferrous and copper ions which can cause its oxidation. It can be incorporated in powder form in
cake mixes, pudding, gelatin dessert, chewing gum, milk powder and breakfast cereals.
Microencapsulated vitamin C can be incorporated in the dry form to prevent browning in potato
chips by Milliard Reaction, the adverse effects of this reaction are food darkening, development
of off-flavors, and reduced bioavailability of certain amino acids especially lysine.
The objective of this study was to develop microencapsulated ascorbic acid to protect it
from degradation and to be used as anti-oxidant in the foods to increase the shelf life of foods.
Another objective was Microencapsulated ascorbic acid was produced by using two methods
freeze and spray drying and characterization of microcapsules was done using scanning electron
66
microscopy (SEM), particle size analysis, loading efficiencies and storage stability studies under
various environmental conditions.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
Vitamin C (L-ascorbic acid) was purchased from Sigma Aldrich (St. Louis, MO). Whey protein
concentrate-80 (WPC) as AVONLAC 180TM was graciously provided by Glanbia Foods (East
Gooding, ID, USA). According to certificate of analysis, composition of WPC was protein (dry
basis) – 79.3%, Moisture – 3.7%, Fat - 8.9%. All other chemicals used were of analytical grade.
Deionized water was used throughout the study.
Microencapsulation of ascorbic acid by spray drying
Eighty grams of WPC was dissolved in 400 ml deionized water at room temperature (22 ˚C) and
kept for hydrating overnight at 4˚C. Following day, 5, 10, 15 and 20 gram of L-ascorbic acid was
measured and dissolved in 20, 45, 70 and 95 ml of deionized water using magnetic stirring for 20
minutes under dark condition. The ascorbic acid was readily dissolved in water. These ascorbic
acid solutions were dissolved in four WPC solutions prepared a day earlier. The four weight ratio
of ascorbic acid: WPC was 1:4, 1:5.3, 1:8, 1:16 (w/w) and the total solids level was maintained
at 20.2% (w/v) in all four weight ratios. Homogenization of the wall solutions was carried out
using LabTek homogenizer (Omni International Inc., Gainesville, VA) at 8000 rpm for 20
minutes for all the four solutions. The solutions were covered with aluminum foils at all the time
and homogenization was carried out in subdued light condition. The spray drying of feed
solution was carried out using pilot scale spray dryer (Anhydro Inc., Olympia Fields, IL, USA).
The inlet and outlet temperature were 180 and 92 ˚C respectively, and atomization speed was
67
kept at 30,000 RPM (60% of maximum 50,000 RPM). The feed flow rates were 37, 42, 47 and
52 ml/min for 1:16.0, 1:8.0, 1:5.3 and 1:4.0, respectively. The powder was collected in opaque
plastic bottles and kept in refrigerator at 4 ˚C until further analysis.
Microencapsulation of ascorbic acid by freeze drying
The spray drying procedure was followed until the homogenization of the ascorbic acid (AA)
solution in whey protein concentrate (WPC). The AA: WPC weight ratios were as 1:4.0, 1:5.3,
1:8.0 and 1:16.0. Here too, total solids level were maintained at 20.2% (w/v). After
homogenization, the solution was poured in plastic trays and was covered with aluminum foils
for protection from light. Homogenization was conducted under subdued light condition and
these trays were kept for freezing for 24 hours. The freeze drying was carried out using Virtis
Genesis SQ freeze dryer (Gardiner, NY, USA). It was recommended (from manual) that
knowing eutectic point will conserve time and energy and produce highest quality freeze dried
product. The freeze dried product was frozen below -20 ˚C. Care was taken that homogenously
blended matrix was completely frozen in plastic trays before loading them in freeze dryer
shelves. The thermocouples were inserted in frozen matrix to monitor the changes in the
temperature. The shelf temperature was allowed to reach below -40 ˚C before turning on
condenser. Once the condenser temperature dropped below -40 ˚C, the vacuum was turned on
until it indicated vacuum 100 millitors. Following that the freeze drying was started and the
product was periodically monitored. The trays were covered with aluminum foils to protect from
light conditions and some holes were made in the foil to allow water vapor to escape from the
trays. After freeze drying was completed, the samples were ground using mortar and pastel under
subdued light conditions and were stored in opaque plastic bottles and kept in refrigerated
conditions at 4 ˚C until further analysis.
68
Scanning electron microscopy
Morphology of microcapsules was observed using variable pressure scanning electron
microscope Zeiss 1450 EP (Carl Zeiss MicroImaging Inc. One Zeiss Drive, Thornwood, NY).
using methodology described by Sheu (1998). The powders were fixed on 10 mm stubs with
double sided adhesive tape and then were made electrically conductive by coating in vacuum
with gold using SPI-module sputter coater for 60 s. (15.3 nm). The SEM pictures were taken at
excitation voltage of 15kV and 100, 200 and 500 X magnification for freeze dried powder and
100, 200 and 573 X magnification for spray dried powder.
Particle size analysis
Particle size analysis was done using Malvern Mastersizer S laser diffraction system with QSpec
small volume sample dispersion unit operating at 3000 rpm (Malvern Instruments,
Worcestershire, U.K.). Mastersizer type used was S 300 RF with particle size range between 0.5
to 900 µm. The Mastersizer S uses the Mie theory of light diffraction for particle size
measurement which assumes an equivalent sphere size of particles and performs particle size
calculations on the fact that angle of light diffraction is inversely proportional to particle size.
(Rawle 2002). To establish standard operating procedure (SOP) for particle size measurements, 3
replicate samples were used for both spray dried and freeze dried microencapsulated ascorbic
acid powder. The 10% (w/w) solution of freeze or spray dried powder was prepared in deionized
water and allowed to hydrate for 10 minutes and stirred before applying to dispersion unit of the
Mastersizer. The raw measurement data obtained from the Mastersizer consisted of particle size
distribution (PSD, di = 0.05-865 µm) of the respective sample expressed as volumetric diameter
of particles. Additionally, particle size percentiles, volumetric mean diameter, summary statistics
69
of PSD was calculated using the Mastersizer data acquisition software package (Mastersizer S-
long Bed v2.19).
Microencapsulation efficiency
In order to determine microencapsulation efficiency (ME), 200 mg of microencapsulated powder
was measured and dissolved in 100 ml of 0.1N HCl. This solution was further diluted 100 times
and measured at 244 nm wavelength (λ max of vitamin C in 0.1N HCl) using Hewlett Packard
8451A diode array spectrophotometer (Avondale, PA, USA). For determination of vitamin C
concentration equivalent amount of WPC absorbance at 244 nm was subtracted from total
absorbance of microencapsulated vitamin C. Experiments were performed in triplicate and ME
was determined based on the formula below (Desai and Park 2005).
Accelerated shelf life testing
Vitamin C: WPC (w/w) ratio of 1:4 was selected for accelerated shelf life studies due to
high microencapsulation efficiency obtained in spray dried (96.35%) and freeze dried (98.75%)
powders. Microencapsulated ascorbic acid was spread in small cups and care was taken that the
layer of powder did not exceed more than a few millimeters to avoid uneven exposure to
humidity and UV light conditions. Two wooden chambers were constructed for storage at 25 and
45 ˚C and each wooden chamber had two shelves. The upper top shelf was fitted with black light
which emitted UV light confined to top shelf. Dark condition was maintained in bottom shelf.
Both the shelves were covered with opaque black plastic covers to avoid outside light exposure.
The small cups were covered with transparent loosely knitted cloth to allow the passage of UV
ME (%) Calculated vitamin C concentration
Theoretical vitamin C concentration = X 100
70
light and moisture but which will prevent cross-contamination between samples. Saturated salt
solutions of potassium acetate (22.5% RH), potassium carbonate (44.7% RH), sodium nitrite
(65% RH) and potassium chloride (85% RH) were prepared and transferred to transparent glass
containers. The RH inside the glass containers was monitored using temperature-humidity data
loggers. Once saturated salt solutions reached the optimum RH levels, sample cups containing
freeze dried and spray dried microcapsules were kept over the circular disc mounted on stand
which would allow free circulation of humid air over the saturated salt solutions. Out of two
wooden chambers, one was maintained at 25 ˚C and the other at 45 ˚C. Eight glass containers
were kept in 25 ˚C; four containers with four different humidity conditions (22.5, 44.7, 65, 85%
RH) in UV light and remaining four in dark conditions. Remaining eight glass containers were
kept at 45 ˚C under similar light and dark conditions. The ‘zero’ week concentration of vitamin
C was the beginning concentration at the start of storage conditions. 100 mg each of spray and
freeze dried powder was measured and dissolved in 100 ml 0.1N hydrochloric acid using
magnetic stir bars for 20 minutes (1gm/L). The subdued light conditions were maintained during
the assay. The vitamin C concentration was measured by absorbance at 244 nm (λ max of
vitamin C in 0.1 N HCl) after 10 times dilutions. Special arrangement was made which would
maintain the constant oxygen environment inside the glass containers. On the glass cover, a
small aperture was made and rubber septas were glued over that aperture which allowed a metal
needle to pass through the septas so that glass containers could be filled with oxygen. Septas
were again sealed with the glue to prevent oxygen to escape. Digital headspace analyzer (Check-
mate 9900, Topac Inc., Hingham, MA, USA) was used to monitor residual oxygen concentration
inside glass containers. The samples were withdrawn every week from glass containers to
71
determine oxidative degradation and glass containers were filled with 100% oxygen
concentration before placing back to storage conditions.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
Scanning electron microscopy
The objective behind using scanning electron microscopy was a) to observe the degree to which
microcapsules are well formed; b) examine the porosity, size, shape, outer topography to reveal
the surface dents and shrinkage, tendency to agglomerate and c) presence of extraneous matter, if
any. The morphology of the microcapsules was observed using scanning electron microscope
(SEM) for both freeze dried as well as spray dried microcapsule. However, here we should
remember that in preparing freeze dried microcapsules, the freeze dried matrix (homogeneously
blended whey protein concentrate and ascorbic acid) was subjected to mortal and pastel to obtain
the free flowing powder which was used for analytical purposes. Freeze dried microcapsules
were observed at 100, 200, 500 X and spray dried microcapsules were observed at 100, 200 and
573 X magnification. Freeze dried microcapsule particles, as expected, were irregular shaped.
The edges of the capsules are considerably sharper. In fig. 3.2 (A), (B) and (C), we can see the
slab like structure of irregularly shaped microcapsule having thickness of 20 µm. Spray dried
microcapsules were having good sphericity as we can observe in fig.3.2 (C), (D) and (E). Some
of the microcapsules were broken, thus increasing the area exposed to surrounding air. However,
there were many spherical shaped microcapsules compared to broken microcapsule in the spray
dried sample. Some of the smaller capsules of spray dried microcapsules showed the tendency of
agglomeration which explains less free flowing characteristic of spray dried microcapsules.
72
Particle size distribution
The cumulative percentage size distribution of spray and freeze dried samples are also shown in
fig. 3.3 (A) and (B) respectively. The particle size distribution of both spray dried and freeze
dried samples are shown in the fig. 3.4 (A) and (B). In spray dried microencapsulated ascorbic
acid powder, the mean particle size diameter was 17.5 µm and the particle size ranged from 1.3
to 83.2 µm. In freeze dried microcapsules, the mean diameter was 11.5 µm and the particle size
ranged from 1.3 to 77.2 µm. Spray dried microcapsules showed multi-modal distribution with
first mode from 3.8-11.0µm and second mode from 11.0-36.5µm. In freeze dried
microencapsulated powder; particle size distribution showed single mode distribution with main
mode in intermediate diameter range 3.5 – 6.5 µm. Narrower particle size distribution results in
more homogenous particles which can ensure better stability and accurate release of the core
material (Finotelli and Leao 2005). The larger particles observed under SEM compared to
particle size distribution may be attributed to the some dissolution of in water while measuring
the particle size in Malvern Mastersizer. Ethanol as a solvent could yield more accurate
information about the particle sizes. Finotelli and Leao (2005) obtained ascorbic acid
microcapsules with Capsule TM from National Starch, maltodextrin and combination of Capsule
and maltodextrin but the method used was spray drying. Capsule is octenyl succinate substituted
starch also called as modified starch. In particle size analysis, multi-modal distribution of
particles was observed in all the microcapsules. According to Trindade and Grosso (2000), mean
diameter of ascorbic acid microcapsule using gum arabic coating was 8 µm and starch containing
1% and 2% gelatin was 20.5 and 17.7 µm, respectively. This is similar to our average particle
size of 17.5 µm in spray dried powder although the coating material was different. Trindade and
others (2000) also found that ascorbic acid in gum arabic had multimodal distribution with range
73
from 0.3 to 90 µm. This also is similar to our spray dried powder range of 1.3 to 83.2 µm. It
seems that spray drying method of microencapsulation probably produce multi-modal
distribution (Finotelli and others 2005; Trindade and Grosso 2000).
Microencapsulation efficiency
Microencapsulation efficiency is an important criterion for successful microencapsulation. It
indicates the loss of the core during the process. The retention of core material during
microencapsulation by spray drying is affected (among other things) by the properties and
composition of the emulsion and by spray drying conditions. An ideal microencapsulation
process should not result in any losses of encapsulated core during the process. Effects of process
conditions and compositional aspects on core retention during microencapsulation by spray
drying have been discussed pertaining to volatiles and essential oils (Rosenberg, Kopelman and
Talmon 1990). High drying rates that lead to rapid crust formation around drying droplets can
lead to high core retention. Losses can occur before the formation of dry crust. The
microencapsulation efficiencies (ME) of spray freeze dried vitamin C powders are shown in
table 3.1 and 3.2. The ME of 96.25% in spray drying condition for 1:4 ratio indicates that there
was not much loss during spray drying and some loss could be attributed to loss of vitamin C
before formation of the crust due to the drying temperatures. There is possibility that vitamin C
migrating to the surface and undergoing some degradation. In freeze dried powder,
microencapsulation efficiency of 98.75% indicates the low temperature maintained in freeze
drying resulted in better protection of vitamin C. Lee and others (2004) have reported similar ME
of 1:5 for L-ascorbic acid: polyacylglycerol monostearate which resulted in 94.2% ME and
efficiency decreased by increasing the coating to core ratio of 10:1, 15:1 and 20:1
(polyacylglycerol: L-ascorbic acid) as 86%, 85% and 80%, respectively.
74
Accelerated shelf life testing
Ascorbic acid is added to foods primarily for two reasons; as vitamin supplement to increase
recommended dietary allowance and to protect food from oxidative deterioration. However, its
use in food is compromised due to its instability and high reactivity with transitional metals ions
such as copper and iron (Liao and Seib, 1988). Other environmental factors that can compromise
stability of vitamin C are temperature, pH value, UV rays, X-rays and humidity. Oxidation is
accelerated at neutral and above pH (Csuros and Petro, 1955). The degradation of vitamin C can
occur in foods by variety of mechanisms. Copper and iron acts as catalyst in oxidation of vitamin
C. Enzymatic destruction can occur by enzymes such as ascorbate oxidase and ascorbate
peroxidase (Pollard and Timberlake 1971). Losses can also occur by anaerobic mechanism in
strongly acidic conditions, in the presence of fructose and derivatives (Heulin 1953) and by
amino acids (Kurata 1973).
Number of metal chelating agents are known to prevent autoxidation of L-ascorbate
including ethylenediamine tetraacetate (EDTA), oxalate citrate, phosphates, histidines, uric acid,
sugars, acidic polysaccharides and flavonoids. Agents that complex with L-ascorbic acid such as
protein, EDTA and histidine may retard oxidation of L-ascorbic acid (Fleming and Bensch,
1983). Therefore, we thought of choosing whey protein concentrate as coating material. In our
study we wanted to examine the effect of temperature, UV light, water activity and the type of
drying method on protective effect of ascorbic acid in whey protein concentrate. Therefore, we
selected two temperatures levels: 25 and 45 ˚C; UV light and dark condition; four relative
humidity levels: 22, 44, 66 and 85 %; and two dying methods: freeze and spray drying.
Microencapsulation efficiency was determined by total amount of ascorbic acid present after
spray and freeze drying process. The microencapsulation efficiency was 96.35 in spray dried
75
powder and 98.23% in freeze dried powders. Finotelli (2005) obtained 100% retention of
ascorbic acid by spray drying in capsul and maltodextrin. Trindade (2000) reported ascorbic acid
recovery after spray drying as 99.7 and 97.6% for starch containing 1 and 2% gelatin and 98.8
for gum arabic containing 30% ascorbic acid. Esposito (2002) used Eudragit® for
microencapsulation of ascorbic acid who reported microencapsulation efficiencies between 98-
100%. Eudragit are methylacrylate copolymers which are inert and freely soluble in organic
solvents. This is pH dependent enteric polymer composed of methacrylic acid-methyl ester
copolymers soluble at pH 6. The pH of the stomach is 7.5 and therefore is used for delivery of
ascorbic acid in this lower part of intestine (Esposito 2002). Since drying time in spray drying is
short between 5-30 s, it is not significant for the degradation of vitamin C. Also, during spray
drying process, the droplet temperature is maintained at low temperature due cooling effect of
evaporation resulting in lesser degree of degradation (Dziezak 1988). In 100 mg of spray dried
powder (1:4 ratio), the beginning concentration was 19.26 mg and in 100 mg of freeze dried
powder (1:4 ratio), the beginning concentration was 19.75 mg of ascorbic acid. This was the
beginning concentration at 0 week of storage. During the accelerated storage studies,
microencapsulated vitamin C powder in whey protein coating material exhibited color changes
specific to relative humidity levels after 2 weeks of storage. The color of the microencapsulated
powder ranged from dark pink, light brown to dark brown. At 22 % RH initially light pink color
changed into dark pink color as the storage time progressed. Maximum dark brown color was
observed at 85% RH followed by 65% RH. At 44% RH, light brown color was observed. This
may be attributed to series of chemical reactions that may be taking place. The first initial
product of oxidation of L-ascorbic acid in the presence of dioxygen in water is dehydroascorbic
acid and hydrogen peroxide. In aqueous solution dehydroascorbic acid exists primarily in the
76
bicyclic structure having 6, 3-hemiketal ring and C2-gen-diol group as opposed to its diketo
form. Streker degradation reaction between dehydroascorbic acid and an amino acid give
aldehyde and scorbamic acid. However, dehydroascorbic acid can form brown pigment in the
absence of amino acids too. In Streker degradation, initial product is Schiff base that
decarboxylates and then undergoes hydride shift to give a second Schiff base or substituted imine
intermediate. This substituted imine hydrolyses to release aldehyde and scorbamic acid. This
amino reductone, L-scorbamic acid (SCA) is presumed to be an important intermediate in the
formation of an assortment of colored compounds (Hayashi 1983, 1980). This SCA reacts with
molecule of dehydroascorbic acid to give red pigment; this is chain reaction. Thus, we can
explain why pink color was observed at 22% RH and subsequently dark brown pigment was
observed at higher 85% RH. This was further substantiated by higher degradation found at
higher humidity than lower humidity levels. Dehydroascorbic acid can be quantitatively reduced
back to L-ascorbic acid by hydrogen sulfide, dothiothreitol, reduced glutathione and stannous
ions plus thiourea, among others. In practical applications, this dehydroascorbic acid is involved
in browning of citrus juices and some dehydrated foods (Kurata 1973). Favorable reaction
between protein and dehydroascorbic acid has been proposed to explain the improvement of
bread when ascorbic acid is added to bread formula. This dehydroascorbic acid acts as cross
linking agent between gluten and thus increasing the elasticity of dough. One of the potential
application of microencapsulated ascorbic acid is incorporation in bread formulation in which
required concentration of ascorbic acid can be used for cross linking between gluten to improve
the elasticity of dough and at the same time some concentration could be preserved by
microencapsulation thereby increased bioavailability of vitamin C in addition to improved bread
texture.
77
We can observe from the degradation plots (fig. 3.5 to fig. 3.8) the different trends in
degradation due to various factors. Humidity plays significant role in the degradation kinetics. At
25 ˚C, we can see lowest degradation at 22% RH in both freeze and spray dried samples and
under light and dark conditions. However, at 45 ˚C there is lowest degradation in 44% RH in
both freeze dried and spray dried samples and both light and dark conditions. Therefore, higher
temperature may be causing more degradation at 22% compared to 44% RH. Also there is
interesting trend in 66% and 85% RH. At 25˚C, greater degradation is observed in 66% RH
compared to 22%, 44% and 85% RH in spray dried vitamin C samples in both light and dark
conditions. But at 45 ˚C maximum degradation is found in 85% RH in both light and dark
conditions. Serris and Biliaderis (2001) reported that degradation kinetics of beetroot pigments
consisting of betalain was highest at intermediate moisture content (aw = 0.64) for all the
matrices (pullulan and two maltodextrin samples). The reaction rates (K) and half-life period
(T1/2) for encapsulated beetroot pigments were compared at 0.23, 0.43, 0.64, 0.75 and 0.84 aw
levels and at 30, 40 and 50˚C. The maximum reaction rate (k) was observed at 0.64 aw. However,
reaction rates (K) at 0.23 and 0.44 aw levels were lower than 0.75 and 0.84 aw. The reaction rates
(K) increased with increase in temperature. This trend can be explained by the fact that the
degradation reaction is controlled by the mobility of the reactants. This type of behavior has been
exhibited in many systems according to Von Elbe (1987). Saguy (1984) has reported that with
increasing aw, there is increase in oxygen concentration and this in turn increases degradation
rates since oxygen accelerates the reaction. In dry environment, water is strongly bound to
surface polar sites and is generally not available for any kind of reaction. This fact explains the
lower reaction rates observed at aw of 0.23 and 0.43. At high Aw, reactant dilution effect have
been claimed to be predominant (Von Elbe 1987). As a result, reaction rate may reach maximum
78
at intermediate aw and then decline with further increase in aw. Thus, Serris and Biliaderis (2001)
reported maximum reaction rates at aw = 0.64 for all three temperatures. Although, our core
material is vitamin C, similar trends of degradation kinetics have been observed in our studies.
Comparing spray dried powder with freeze dried powder, freeze dried powder provided
better protection to microencapsulated vitamin C at all the RH’s studied. The bulk density of
freeze dried powder was about 4 times higher compared to spray dried powder. Higher the
density, lesser the surface area exposed compared to lower density powder. This may explain the
higher degradation in spray dried powder compared to freeze dried powder. Cai and Corke
(2000) reported that in spray dried Amaranthus betacyanin extracts, the bulk density of pigment
powder decreased with increase in spray drying temperature. Although higher drying rate was
obtained at higher drying temperature, higher ratio of surface-to-volume for the spray dried
powder caused lower bulk density of the powder. The lower the bulk density, the more occluded
air within the powders and therefore, greater the possibility of oxidative degradation of pigments
and reduced storage stability.
Among all the samples, 70.4 % of active vitamin C content was preserved in freeze dried
microencapsulated vitamin C powder stored at 25 ˚C, dark and 22% RH conditions and at these
conditions 70.4 % of retention was maximum among all the storage conditions. This proves the
ideal condition of storage and preferred method of drying as freeze drying. Trindade and Grosso
(2000) have found that pure ascorbic acid did not find much decrease in concentration. However,
at 45 C and 90.7 % RH the encapsulated ascorbic acid showed great losses in ascorbic acid
concentration. The explanation for lower stability in uncovered form than crystalline form was
due to dissolved ascorbic acid distributed itself in layers around starch granules during spray
drying process thus establishing the larger surface area than pure unencapsulated ascorbic acid
79
thus more susceptible to degradation from oxygen. Kirby (1991) has found that in the absence of
other potential reactants or antagonists, ascorbic acid is significantly more stable in concentrated
form. Ascorbic acid in free solution exposed to normal condition of dissolved oxygen and stored
under excess head space air and dark conditions, was completely disappeared from solution after
storage for 18 days at 4 ˚C at the starting concentration of 1.15 mM. At 22 ˚C and no light
conditions, the same amount was lost after only 6 days. When liposome encapsulated ascorbate
was suspended in appropriate buffers under identical conditions, the retention of ascorbate at
both 4 and 22 ˚C in dark were significantly increased. At 4 ˚C, more than 50% ascorbate was
retained after 50 days of storage; whereas about 50% was lost at room temperature. Thus, Kirby
(1991) has successfully shown that when in free solution form, ascorbic acid could be
substantially protected from degradation by microencapsulating in liposomes. Kirby (1991) has
also studied the effects of various antagonists such as ascorbic acid oxidase, copper ions and
lysine on degradation of liposome encapsulated ascorbic acid in various buffer solutions. Free
ascorbate in the presence of 10 ppm copper ions, oxidized rapidly and was completely gone after
30 hours. However, loss of ascorbate in liposomes was considerably reduced. After 50 days,
level of ascorbate remaining in liposomes were only 18% less than liposomes stored in the
absence of copper ions which proved the protective effect of microencapsulation. Lysine which
is one of the amino acids acts as antagonist on ascorbic acid. This amino acid resulted in
accelerated loss in free solution. At 7.0 pH and 4 ˚C the ascorbate disappeared completely within
10 days. At 22 ˚C in free solution in the presence of lysine, ascorbate disappeared completely
within 5 days and brown coloration was observed. However, microencapsulation within
liposomes gave almost complete protection and after 40 days the level of ascorbic acid was less
than 5% lower compared to the solution in which lysine was absent. This is important from our
80
studies since whey protein contains lysine as one of the amino acids and the relative rapid loss of
vitamin C could be explained due to the presence of lysine as one of the amino acid.
CONCLUSIONS
The results from this study demonstrate that it is possible to successfully microencapsulate
vitamin C using WPC as wall material. The maximum retention of vitamin C after 7 weeks of
storage was found under 25 ˚C, dark and 22% RH conditions whereas 70.4 % of original
concentration was retained. Compared to spray dried powder, freeze dried powder protected the
core material at all 22, 44, 66 and 85% RH; light and dark; 25 and 45 ˚C. Thus, freeze dried
powder was superior under all storage conditions compared to spray dried powder. Thus, results
from this study could be used to prepare microencapsulated muscadine and blueberry extracts
which could be utilized for variety of food applications. Scanning electron microscopy revealed
production of well formed microcapsules with fewer dents is possible by spray drying process.
Freeze dried microcapsules were irregularly shaped but it did not affect the retention of the
vitamin C. In fact, freeze dried powder produced powder with high bulk density. Maximum
microencapsulation efficiency was found at 1:4 (vitamin C: WPC) w/w ratio for both spray and
freeze dried powder.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank Glanbia Foods for graciously providing whey protein
concentrate. The authors would like to thank Mr. Glenn D. Farrell for his technical help. We
would also like to thank Dr. John Shields for preparing scanning micrographs and Mr. Jerry
Davis for his help in statistical analysis.
81
REFERENCES
Beristain CI, Azuara E, Tamayo TT, Vernon-Carter EJ. 2003. Effect of caking and stickiness on
the retention of spray dried encapsulated orange peel oil. Journal of the Science of Food and
Agriculture 83:1613-1616.
Cai YZ, Corke H. 2000. Production and properties of spray dried Amaranthus betacyanin
pigments. Journal of Food Science 65:1248-1252.
Cohen E, Gaguy I. 1983. Effect of water activity and moisture content on the stability of beet
powder pigment. Journal of Food Science 48:703-707.
Cort WM. 1982. Antioxidant properties of ascorbic acid in foods. In: Seib PA, Tolbert BM.
editors. Ascorbic acid: Chemistry, Metabolism and Uses. Adv. Chem. Ser. No. 200. American
Chemical Society Washington DC p 533-50.
Dziezak JD. 1988. Microencapsulation and encapsulation ingredients. Food Technology 42:136-
151.
Desai KGH, Park HJ. 2005. Encapsulation of vitamin C in tripolyphosphate cross-linked
chitosan microspheres by spray drying. Journal of Microencapsulation 22(2): 179-192.
Desai KGH, Liu C, Park HJ. 2005. Characteristics of vitamin C immobilized particles and
sodium alginate beads containing immobilized particles. Journal of Microencapsulation 22(4):
363-376.
Esposito E, Cervellati F, Meneghatti E, Nastruzzi C, Cortesi R. 2002. Spray dried Eudragit
microparticles as encapsulation devices for vitamin C. International Journal of Pharmaceutics
242: 329-334.
82
Finotelli PV, Rocha-Leao M. 2005. Microencapsulation of ascorbic acid in maltodextrin and
capsule using spray drying. http://www.enpromer2005.eq.ufrj.br/nukleo/pdfs/0022_aa.pdf Paper
accessed October 18th 2007.
Hayashi T, Terao A, Ueda S, Namiki M. 1985. Red pigment formation by the reaction of
oxidized ascorbic acid and protein in food model system of low moisture content. Agricultural
and Biological chemistry 49: 3139-44.
Kirby CJ, Whittle CJ, Rigby N, Coxon DT, Law BA. 1991. Stabilization of ascorbic acid by
microencapsulation in liposomes. International Journal of Food Science and Technology 26:
437-449.
Knezevic Z, Gosak D, Hraste M, Jansenjak I. 1998. Fluid bed microencapsulation of ascorbic
acid. Journal of Microencapsulation 15(2): 237-252.
Lee J-B, Ahn J, Lee J, Kwak H-S. 2004. L-ascorbic acid microencapsulated with
polyacylglycerol monostearate for milk fortification. Bioscience, Biotechnology and
Biochemistry 68(3): 495-500.
Rawle A. 2002. The importance of particle sizing to the coatings industry Part 1: Particle size
measurement. Advances in Color Science and Technology 5(1):1-12.
Reineccius GA. 1989. Flavor encapsulation. Food Reviews International 5: 147-176.
Righetto AM, Netto FM. 2006. Vitamin C stability in encapsulated green West Indian cherry
juice and in encapsulated synthetic ascorbic acid. Journal of the science of food and agriculture
86: 1202-1208.
Rosenberg M, Kopelman IJ, Talmon Y. 1990. Factors affecting retention in spray drying
microencapsulation of volatile materials. Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry 38: 1288-
1294.
83
Rosenberg M, Kopelman IJ, Talmon Y. 1985. A scanning electron microscopy study of
microencapsulation. Journal of Food Science 50:139-144.
Sapper H, Kang SO, Paul HH, Lohmann W. 1982. The reversibility of the vitamin C redox
system. Electrochemical reasons and biological aspects. Z Naturforsch [C] 37(10):942-6.
Saguy I, Goldman M, Bord A, Cohen E. 1984. Effect of oxygen retained on beet powder on the
stability of betanine and vulgaxanthine I. Journal of Food Science 49(1): 99-101.
Serris G, Biliaderis CG. 2001. Degradation kinetics of beetroot pigment encapsulated in
polymeric matrices. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 81:691-700.
Sheu TY, Rosenberg M. 1998. Microstructure of microcapsules consisting of whey proteins and
carbohydrates. Journal of Food Science 63(3):491-494.
Schrooyen PMM, Van Der Meer R, De Kruif CG. 2001. Microencapsulation: Its application in
nutrition. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 60:475-479.
Tolbert BM, Ward JB. 1982. Dehydroascorbic acid. In: Seib PA, Tolbert BM. Editors. Ascorbic
acid: Chemistry, Metabolism and Uses. Adv. Chem. Ser. No. 200. American Chemical
Society, Washington D.C. 101-23.
Trindade MA and Grosso CRF. 2000. The stability of ascorbic acid microencapsulated in
granules of rice starch and gum arabic. 17(2): 169-176.
Uddin MS, Hawlader MNA, Zhu HJ. 2001. Microencapsulation of ascorbic acid: effect of
process variable on product characteristics. Journal of Microencapsulation 18(2): 199-209.
Von Elbe JH. 1987. Influence of water activity on pigment stability in food products. In:
Rockland LB, Beuchat LR. Editors. Water Activity: Theory and applications to food. Marcel
Dekker, New York, p 55-57.
84
Young SL, Sarda X, Rosenberg M. 1993. Microencapsulating properties of Whey Proteins. 1.
Microencapsulation of anhydrous milk fat. Journal of Dairy Science 76: 2868-2877.
85
Table 3.1: Microencapsulation efficiency of spray dried vitamin C
Vitamin C (g) WPC (g) Vitamin C: WPC ratio (w/w)
Microencapsulation efficiency (%)
5 80 1:16.0 75.41c
10 80 1:8.0 85.71b
15 80 1:5.3 84.61b
20 80 1:4.0 96.35a a,b,c Values followed by different letters in the same column are significant (α=0.05)
86
Table 3.2: Microencapsulation efficiency of freeze dried vitamin C
Vitamin C (g) WPC (g) Vitamin C: WPC ratio (w/w)
Microencapsulation efficiency (%)
5 80 1:16.0 79.11 b
10 80 1:8.0 80.40 b
15 80 1:5.3 85.97 b
20 80 1:4.0 98.23 a a, b, c Values followed by different letters in the same column are significant (α=0.05)
87
Figure 3.1: Wooden chambers fitted with black light constructed for storage of microencapsulated powder
UV light source Top and
bottom shelf
Dark conditions
Glass containers
Wooden chamber
88
Figure 3.2: SEM micrograph of freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C (vitamin C: WPC ratio of 1:4) with magnifications of (A) 100X (B) 200 X (C) 500 X. SEM micrographs of spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C (vitamin C: WPC ratio of 1:4) with magnifications of (D) 100X (E) 200X and (E) 573 X.
A
B
C
D
E
F
89
Figure 3.3: Cumulative percentage particle size distribution of (A) spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C powder (B) freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C powder.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Cumulative (%)
Particle size (µm)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0 20 40 60 80 100 120Cumulative (%)
Particle Size (µm)
A
B
90
Figure 3.4: Particle size distribution of (A) spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C powder (B) freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C powder
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
0.1 1 10 100 1000 Particle size (µm)
Volume (%)
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
0.1 1 10 100 1000 Particle size (µm)
Volume (%)
A
B
91
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
Figure 3.5: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 25˚C and (A) UV Light and (B) Dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)
A
B
92
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH 44% RH 66% RH85% RH
Figure 3.6: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 45 ˚C and (A) UV Light (B) Dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)
A
B
93
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH 44% RH 66% RH 85% RH
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH 44% RH85% RH
Figure 3.7: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 25 ˚C and (A) UV light and (B) dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)
A
B
94
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8Week
VC m
g/L
22% RH 44% RH 66% RH
Figure 3.8: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated vitamin C stored at 45 ˚C (A) UV light (B) dark condition (VC denotes vitamin C)
A
B
95
CHAPTER 4
MICROENCAPSULATION OF GALLIC ACID IN WHEY PROTEIN CONCENTRATE
(WPC) USING SPRAY AND FREEZE DRYING METHODS
______________________________
1 S. R. Tandale, M. S. Chinnan, and R. D. Phillips. To be submitted to the Journal of Food Science.
96
ABSTRACT
Gallic acid as a model core was selected and microencapsulation of gallic acid was
carried out with whey protein concentrate (WPC) as wall material, using spray drying and freeze
drying methods. Gallic acid: WPC (w/w) ratio of 1:4.0, 1:5.3, 1:8.0 and 1:16.0 was selected to
determine microencapsulation efficiency which showed 1:4 ratio had highest efficiency for both
spray dried (99.39%) and freeze dried (99.54%) processes. Therefore, 1:4 ratio was further
selected for analysis. Morphology of spray and freeze dried microcapsules was examined by
scanning electron microscope (SEM). Spray dried gallic acid microcapsules were well formed,
spherical in shape with few capsules having visible surface dents. Freeze dried powder was
found be irregularly shaped. Some agglomeration of small capsules was seen in spray dried
powder. Particle size analysis was carried out which revealed for spray dried powder, single-
mode distribution with particle size range (1.4-104.2 µm) with average diameter of 29.9 µm was
observed. Freeze dried powder had multi-modal distribution with particle size range (1.4-
255.7µm) with average diameter of 38.8 µm. Accelerated shelf life testing was carried out under
various environmental conditions, temperature (25 and 45 ˚C), humidity (22, 44, 66 and 85%
RH), light (UV light and dark), and 100% oxygen in sealed container for 8 weeks. The maximum
degradation of gallic acid was observed at intermediate 66% RH in both spray and freeze dried
microcapsules.
INDEX WORDS: Microencapsulation, spray drying, freeze drying, gallic acid, stability,
microencapsulation efficiency.
97
INTRODUCTION
Microencapsulation is defined as the technology of packaging solids, liquids and gaseous
materials in miniature, sealed microcapsules which releases their active contents at controlled
rate under right stimulus (Dziezak 1988, Risch 1995). The structure formed by the
microencapsulating agent around microencapsulated material (core) is called wall or coating
material. These microcapsules can range from several microns to millimeters and they are ideally
spherical in shape but their shape is heavily influenced by the structure of the original
unencapsulated material as well as drying conditions. The shape of the microcapsules could be
single core within single wall with spherical or irregular shape, single core within multiple walls
or numerous cores within same wall. One of the many objectives of microencapsulation is
protecting active core content from various factors that can cause its oxidation or deterioration
such as temperature, humidity, light, oxygen and its interaction with various minerals such as
copper, iron, and zinc. Other important objectives of microencapsulation are to prevent the off-
flavors produced by vitamins, minerals and bioactive compounds, taste masking certain food
ingredients, preventing interaction among various food ingredients, prevent nutritional loss,
transform liquids into easily handled solid ingredients, and improve flavor and texture of food
product (Balassa and Fanger 1971).
Spray drying is the most common method used for encapsulation in the food industry for
variety of reasons such as the process is economical and flexible, ready availability of
equipment, wide choice of carrier material, good retention of volatile material, good stability of
finished product and large scale production in continuous mode (Reinecccius 1989). The
advantage of spray drying method is heat-labile (low boiling point) and heat sensitive materials
can also be encapsulated because of the lower temperature that the core material reaches
98
(Dziezak 1988). Microencapsulation process involves formation of emulsion or suspension of
coating and core material, followed by atomization and spraying of the mixture in hot chamber.
Freeze drying technique, which is also called as lyophilization, is useful for drying thermo-
sensitive compounds. Buffo & Reineccius (2001) have compared spray drying, tray drying and
freeze drying to encapsulate cold-pressed orange oil Valencia with gum arabic and modified
food starch and concluded that freeze drying process gave most desirable properties compared to
spray dried powder. Minemoto (1997) compared oxidation of menthyl linoleate when
encapsulated in gum arabic by hot air drying and freeze drying and showed that freeze drying
was better than hot air drying in terms of protection from oxidation. Heizelmann & Franke
(1999) reported that microencapsulated fish oil by freeze drying offered good resistance to
oxidation. Freeze drying is less attractive than spray drying because costs are about 50 times
higher compared to spray drying (Desorby 1997). However, nutraceutical powder produced from
muscadine grapes which is high value added product could utilize this technique to produce
microencapsulated powder which could result in better protection from oxidation compared to
spray drying.
Rabbiteye blueberry (Vaccinium ashei), common in Georgia, is rich source of various
health promoting compounds like phenolic acids (gallic acid, p-hydroxybenzoic acid, caffeic
acid, ferulic acid, and ellagic acid) and flavonoids (catechin, epicatechin, myricetin, quercetin,
and kaempferol) (Sellapan and Akoh 2002). These compounds neutralize free radicals associated
with number of degenerative diseases such as cancer, cardiovascular diseases, cataracts and
Alzheimer’s. However, these compounds are sensitive to degradation with exposure to
environmental conditions; such as temperature, oxygen, light and relative humidity. Rabbiteye
blueberry contains 259 mg/100 gm of gallic acid (a major phenolic acid). Intermediate extract of
99
muscadine grape contains sugars which makes it difficult to handle and may stick on the walls of
the spray dryer. High molecular weight hydrocolloids such as modified starch, gum arabic or
proteins such as whey proteins could be used to make non-sticky nutraceutical powder. We
chose gallic acid as model core material for microencapsulation considering very high cost of
other pure compounds. Two major protein groups of bovine milk are whey protein and casein.
Whey is derived as natural byproduct of cheese-making process. In addition to proteins, the raw
form of whey contains fat, lactose and other substances. The raw form is processed to produce
protein rich whey protein concentrate (WPC) and whey protein isolate (WPI). Whey proteins
have been reported to have excellent encapsulation properties and are superior to those of
commonly used ingredients. These studies have indicated that whey proteins are very effective in
encapsulating volatile, non-volatile, polar and non-polar compounds (Moreau and Rosenberg
1996, 1998, 1999; Sheu and Rosenberg 1995; Young, Sarda and Rosenberg 1993). The
microencapsulation of gallic acid will help in understanding the protective effect offered to the
similar phenolic compounds under various environmental stress conditions.
The objective of this study was to microencapsulate gallic acid to protect it from
degradation and generate data which will serve as a model for developing nutraceutical powder
from muscadine grapes. Microencapsulated gallic acid was produced by using two methods:
freeze drying and spray drying and characterization of microcapsules was done using scanning
electron microscopy (SEM), particle size analysis, loading efficiencies and storage stability
studies under various environmental conditions.
100
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
Gallic acid and sodium bicarbonate and Folin-Ciocalteu reagent were purchased from
Sigma Aldrich (St. Louis, MO, USA). Whey protein concentrate-80 (WPC) as AVONLAC
180TM was graciously provided by Glanbia Foods Inc. (East Gooding, ID, USA). As per
certificate of analysis, composition of WPC was protein (dry basis) – 79.3%, moisture – 3.7%
and fat - 8.9%. All other chemicals used were analytical grade and deionized water was used
throughout experiment.
Microencapsulation of gallic acid by spray drying
Four batches of 100 gram of WPC dissolved in 500 ml deionized water at room
temperature (22 ˚C) were kept for hydrating overnight at 4 ˚C. Following day, 6.25, 12.5, 18.75
and 25 gram of gallic acid was dispersed in 20, 45, 70 and 95 ml of deionized water and
temperature was increased upto 80 ˚C along with magnetic stirring for 20 minutes to completely
dissolve gallic acid crystals for better dispersion of gallic acid in WPC solution. These gallic
acid solutions were dispersed in WPC solutions which were kept for soaking earlier day. Four
ratios of gallic acid: WPC (w/w) were 1:4.0, 1:5.3, 1:8.0, 1:16.0 and the total solids level were
maintained at 17.85, 18.26, 18.75 and 19.31 % (w/v) respectively. Homogenization of the
solutions was carried out using LabTek (Omni International Inc., Gainesville, VA) homogenizer
at 8000 rpm for 20 minutes for all the four solutions. Prior to homogenization, nitrogen was
flushed through the mixing jar for 10 minutes to avoid contact with oxygen while
homogenization at high speed. The solutions were covered with aluminum foils at all the time
and homogenization was carried out under subdued light conditions. The spray drying of feed
solution was conducted using pilot scale spray dryer (Anhydro Inc., Olympia Fields, IL, USA).
101
The dryer had evaporation capacity of 7.5 kg/hr and chamber diameter was 1 meter. Drying was
carried out in co-current mode. The inlet and outlet temperature were 180 and 91 ˚C respectively,
and atomization speed was kept at 30,000 RPM (60% of maximum 50,000 RPM). The feed flow
rates were 65, 58 ml/min for 1:16.0 and 1:8.0 gallic acid: WPC ratio respectively and 47 ml/min
for 1:5.3 and 1:4.0 ratio of gallic acid: WPC ratios. The microcapsules were collected at the
bottom of cyclone and were stored in plastic jars protected from light and stored at 4 ˚C until
further analysis.
Microencapsulation of gallic acid by freeze drying
For freeze drying of the gallic acid microcapsules, the procedure is same till the
homogenization of the gallic acid solution in WPC. The weight ratios gallic acid: WPC (w/w)
were 1:4.0, 1:5.3, 1:8.0 and 1:16.0 and total solids maintained were 17.85, 18.26, 18.75 and
19.31% (w/v) respectively. After homogenization, the solutions were poured in plastic trays and
covered with aluminum foils for protection from light. Homogenization was carried out under
subdued light condition and these trays were kept for freezing at -20 ˚C for 24 hours. The freeze
drying was carried out using Virtis Genesis SQ Super ES freeze dryer (Gardiner, NY, USA). It
was recommended (from manual) that knowing eutectic point will conserve time and energy and
produce highest quality freeze dried product. The care was taken that homogenously blended
matrix was well frozen in plastic trays before loading in freeze dryer shelves. The thermocouples
were inserted in frozen matrix to monitor the changes in the temperature. The shelf temperature
was allowed to reach below -40 ˚C before turning on condenser. Once the condenser temperature
dropped below -40 ˚C, the vacuum switch was turned on until vacuum reached 100 millitor.
After that, the freeze drying was started and the product was periodically monitored. The trays
were covered with aluminum foils to protect from light conditions and some holes on foils were
102
made to facilitate escape of water vapors. Once the freeze drying was completed, the
microencapsulated mass in trays was subjected to grinding by mortar and pastel to form freeze
dried powder. These microcapsules were stored in plastic jars and kept in refrigerator at 4 ˚C
until further analysis.
Scanning electron microscopy
Morphology of microcapsules was observed using variable pressure scanning electron
microscope Zeiss 1450 EP (Carl Zeiss Micro Imaging Inc. One Zeiss Drive, Thornwood, NY).
using methodology described by Sheu (1998). The powders were fixed on 10 mm stubs with
double sided adhesive tape and then were made electrically conductive by coating in vacuum
with gold using SPI-module sputter coater for 60 s. (15.3 nm). The SEM pictures were taken at
excitation voltage of 15kV and 100, 200 and 500 X magnification for freeze dried powder and
200, 500 and 573 X magnification for spray dried powder.
Particle size analysis
Particle size analysis was done using Malvern Mastersizer S laser diffraction system with
Q Spec small volume sample dispersion unit operating at 3000 rpm (Malvern Instruments,
Worcestershire, U.K.). The Mastersizer type used was S 300 RF with particle size range between
0.5 to 900 µm. The Mastersizer S uses the Mie theory of light diffraction for particle size
measurement which assumes an equivalent sphere size of particles and performs particle size
calculations based on the fact that angle of light diffraction is inversely proportional to particle
size (Rawle 2002). To establish standard operating procedure (SOP) for particle size
measurements, 3 replicate samples were used for both spray dried and freeze dried
microencapsulated gallic acid powder. The 10% (w/v) solutions of freeze and spray dried powder
were prepared in deionized water and allowed to hydrate for 10 minutes and stirred before
103
applying to dispersion unit of the Mastersizer. The raw measurement data obtained from the
Mastersizer consisted of particle size distribution (PSD, di = 0.05-865 µm) of the respective
samples expressed as volumetric diameter of particles. Additionally, particle size percentiles,
volumetric mean diameter, summary statistics of PSD was calculated using the Mastersizer data
acquisition software package (Mastersizer S-long Bed v2.19).
Microencapsulation efficiency
Microencapsulation efficiency (ME) was determined by Folin-Ciocalteu method (fig 4.1)
and the absorbance was compared against standard solution of gallic acid at λmax= 766 nm using
Hewlett Packard 8451A diode array spectrophotometer (Avondale, PA, USA) Two hundred mg
of microencapsulated gallic acid powder was measured and dissolved in 100 ml of deionized
water using magnetic stir bars for 20 minutes. Out of this solution, 0.2 ml was measured in test
tube and 0.8 ml of deionized water was mixed in test tube. Five ml of 0.2 N Folin-Ciocalteu
reagent (2N of Folin-Ciocalteu reagent is diluted to 0.2 N) and 4.0 ml of sodium carbonate
solution (7.5 gm in 100 ml) was added to the solution and blue coloration was allowed to
develop by keeping solution under dark condition for 2 hours. The concentration of gallic acid
was determined by comparing the values with standard curve generated by equivalent amount of
gallic acid. Experiments were performed in triplicate and ME was determined based on
following formula.
ME (%)
= Calculated gallic acid concentration X 100 Theoretical gallic acid concentration
104
Accelerated shelf life testing
Gallic acid: WPC (w/w) ratio of 1:4 was selected for accelerated shelf life studies due to
high microencapsulation efficiency obtained in spray dried (99.39%) and freeze dried (99.52%)
powders. Microencapsulated gallic acid was spread in sample cups and care was taken that the
layer of powder did not to exceed few millimeters so that uneven exposure to humidity and UV
light conditions could be avoided. Two wooden chambers were constructed for investigating
degradation kinetics at 25 and 45 ˚C. Each wooden chamber had two shelves. The upper top
shelf was fitted with black light which emitted UV light confined to top shelf. Both the shelves
were covered with opaque black plastic covers to avoid outside light exposure. The figure is
shown in chapter 3 (Fig. 3.1). The sample cups were covered with transparent loosely knitted
cloth to allow the passage of UV light and moisture but which will prevent cross-contamination
between samples. Saturated salt solutions of potassium acetate (22.5% RH), potassium carbonate
(44.7% RH), sodium nitrite (65% RH) and potassium chloride (85% RH) were prepared and kept
in glass containers to test the RH inside the glass containers using temperature-humidity data
loggers. Once saturated salt solutions reached the optimum relative humidity levels, sample cups
containing freeze and spray dried microcapsules were kept in sample plastic cups over the
circular disc mounted on stand which would allow free circulation of humid air over the
saturated salt solutions. Out of two wooden chambers, one was maintained at 25 ˚C and the other
at 45 ˚C. Eight glass containers were kept in 25 ˚C and the remaining eight at 45˚C. In 25 ˚C
chamber, four containers with four different humidity conditions (22.5, 44.7, 65, 85% RH) in UV
light and remaining four in dark conditions. ‘The zero week’ gallic acid concentration in both
freeze dried and spray dried sample was determined using spectrophotometer. Fifty mg of spray
dried and freeze dried gallic acid microcapsules was measured and dissolved in 100 ml of
105
deionized water using magnetic stirrer bars for 20 minutes. The gallic acid released by the
microcapsules was determined using Folin-Ciocalteu method as described in Figure 4.1.
Duplicate measurements were taken. The experiment was carried out in subdued light condition.
The gallic acid absorbance was measured at 766 nm using Hewlett Packard 8451A diode array
spectrophotometer (Avondale, PA, USA) and compared with standard solutions of freshly
prepared gallic acid. The concentration was determined using standard curve. Special
arrangement was made which would maintain the constant oxygen environment inside the glass
containers. On the glass cover, small aperture was made and rubber septas were glued over that
aperture which would allow metal needle to pass through the septas so that glass containers
could be filled with oxygen. Septas were again sealed with the glue to prevent oxygen to escape.
Digital headspace analyzer of type Check-mate 9900 (Topac Inc., Hingham, MA, USA) was
used to monitor residual oxygen concentration inside glass containers. The samples were
withdrawn every week from glass containers to determine oxidative degradation and glass
containers were filled with 100% oxygen concentration before placing back to storage
conditions.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
Scanning electron microscopy
The objective behind using scanning electron microscopy is to observe the degree to
which microcapsules are well formed, check the porosity, size, shape, outer topography which
reveals the surface dents and shrinkage, tendency to agglomerate and the presence of extraneous
matter, if any. The morphology of microcapsules was conducted using scanning electron
microscope (SEM) for both freeze dried and spray dried microcapsule. However, here we should
remember that in preparing freeze dried microcapsules, the freeze dried slabs (obtained in freeze
106
dried trays of homogeneously blended whey protein concentrate and ascorbic acid) were
subjected to mortal and pastel to obtain the free flowing powder which was used for analytical
purposes. 100X, 200X and 500X magnifications of freeze dried micro capsules were obtained
and 200X, 500X and 573X magnifications were obtained for spray dried microcapsules. Freeze
dried microcapsule particles exhibited irregular shape and gallic acid was part of whey protein
concentrate in matrix. The freeze dried microcapsules showed larger particle size than spray
dried microcapsules. The edges of the microcapsules are considerably sharper in freeze dried
microcapsules compared to spray dried microcapsules. In figure 4.2 (A), (B) and (C), we can see
the slab like structure of irregularly shaped microcapsule having thickness of 20 µm. SEM
micrographs of spray dried microcapsules are shown in fig. 4.2 (C), (D) and (E). Spray dried
microcapsules were spherical in shape. Some of the microcapsules were broken increasing the
surface area exposed to surrounding air. However, there were many spherical intact
microcapsules compared to broken microcapsule in spray dried powder. Some of the smaller
capsules of spray dried microcapsules showed the tendency of agglomeration which explains
lesser degree of free flowing characteristic of spray dried microcapsules compared to freeze
dried powder.
Particle size distribution
The cumulative percentage size distribution of spray and freeze dried samples are shown
in fig. 4.3 (A) and (B) respectively. The particle size distribution of spray and freeze dried
samples are shown in the fig. 4.4 (A) and (B) respectively. In spray dried microencapsulated
gallic acid powder; the mean particle size diameter was 29.9 µm with particle size ranging from
1.4 to 104.2 µm. In freeze dried microcapsules; the mean diameter was 38.85 µm and particle
size ranged from 1.4 to 255.7 µm.
107
Spray dried microcapsules showed single mode distribution with first mode from 2.9 to
53.1 µm. In freeze dried microencapsulated powder, particle size distribution showed multi-
modal distribution with first mode from 3.8 to 11.0 µm and the second mode from 66.5 to 130.4
µm. Narrower the particle size distribution, more homogenous particles are which can ensure
better stability and accurate release of the core (Finotelli and Leao 2005).
Microencapsulation efficiency
Microencapsulation efficiency (ME) is important criteria for successful
microencapsulation. It indicates the loss of the core during the process of microencapsulation.
The retention of core material during microencapsulation by spray drying is affected (among
other things) by the properties and composition of the suspension/emulsion and by spray drying
conditions. An ideal microencapsulation process should not result in any loss of encapsulated
core during the process of drying. Effects of process conditions and compositional aspects on
core retention during microencapsulation by spray drying have been discussed pertaining to
volatiles and essential oils (Rosenberg, Kopelman and Talmon 1990). High drying rates that lead
to rapid crust formation around drying droplets can lead to high core retention. Losses can occur
before the formation of dry crust. In our study, gallic acid becomes part of the matrix and is not
volatile material. The microencapsulation efficiency of 99.39% in spray drying condition for 1:4
ratio indicates that there was little or no loss during spray drying and also gallic acid is non-
volatile compound. The ME of spray and freeze dried powders are shown in table 4.1 and 4.2
respectively. In freeze dried powder, microencapsulation efficiency of 99.52% for 1:4 ratio
indicates the low temperature maintained in freeze drying did not result in loss of gallic acid. The
process of making freeze dried powder by mortal and pastle could have uncovered some of the
gallic acid crystals and that could explain extra losses during freeze drying process. Young and
108
others (1993) have reported ME ranging from 92.5 to 99.2% for 25% fat loading and using
various wall material type and wall solution concentration using spray drying technique. The
milk fat being non-volatile material, these efficiencies are similar to reported by us.
Accelerated shelf life testing
Georgia-produced muscadine grapes and rabbiteye blueberries contain an array of
polyphenolic antioxidants including hydroxylbenzoic and hydroxycinnamic acid derivatives as
well as flavonoids such as catechin, epicatechin, quercetin, myricetin, kaempferol and gallic
acid. These plant antioxidants counteract the subcellular-, cellular- and systemic-level oxidative
stress in humans and other health promoting benefits including prevention of cancer,
cardiovascular disease, cataracts, rheumatoid diseases and diabetes. Biswas and Phillips (2006)
proposed a scheme by which these health-promoting compounds could be isolated and produced
commercially as nutraceutical powders. However, these phenolic antioxidants are labile to
oxidation as their name and function imply. Factors which affect the color and stability of
anthocyanins include structure and concentration, pH, temperature, light, presence of
copigments, self association, metallic ions, enzymes, oxygen, ascorbic acid, sugar and their
degradation products, proteins and sulphur dioxide (Francis 1989; Mazza and Miniati 1993;
Rodriguez-Saona, Giusti, & Wrolstad, 1999). For this reason it is important that they be
protected from accidental degradation until they are needed. Before studying the complex
mixtures resulting form extraction of blueberries or muscadine, gallic acid which is one of the
phenolic compounds was chosen as core compound considering the high costs of other pure
compounds. In our experiments, we proposed to examine the effect of temperature, UV light,
relative humidity and the type of drying method on protective effect of gallic acid in whey
protein concentrate. Two temperatures levels 25 and 45 ˚C; UV light and dark condition; four
109
relative humidity (RH) levels 22, 44, 66 and 85 % and two dying method i.e. freeze and spray
drying were selected for shelf life investigation. Microencapsulation efficiency (ME) was
determined by total gallic acid present after spray and freeze drying process. For 1:4 (gallic acid:
whey protein concentrate) ratio, ME was 99.38% in spray dried powder and 99.54% in freeze
dried powder. This ratio was selected for accelerated storage study.
Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid have been shown in
fig. 4.5 and 4.6 while freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid in fig. 4.7 and 4.8. Humidity
plays significant role in the degradation of gallic acid. Maximum degradation of gallic acid was
found at intermediate 66% RH in both spray dried and freeze dried gallic acid, in both light and
dark and both 25 and 45˚C. The only exception was freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid at
25 ˚C and dark condition; at this condition more degradation was found in 85% RH compared to
66% RH. Thus, the trend shows intermediate RH 66% plays role in higher degradation of gallic
acid. In freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid for 66% RH, at 25 ˚C and UV light, the initial
gallic acid concentration of 99.39 mg/L was reduced to 79.39 mg/L and 25 ˚C and in dark it
reduced to 89.12 mg/L. At 45 ˚C, the freeze dried gallic acid at 66% RH and UV light conditions
reduced to 77.2 mg/L and in dark conditions it reduced to 85.12 mg/L from initial concentration
of 99.39 mg/L. This also shows higher degradation at higher temperature (fig. 4.7 and 4.8.).
Gallic acid degradation phenomenon is more pronounced at spray dried powder kept at 45 ˚C
temperature. In 25 ˚C, 66% RH and UV light condition spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid
concentration at the end of 8th week, reduced to 67.8 mg/L and in dark condition it reduced to
66.4 mg/L from the initial concentration of 99.39 mg/L (fig. 4.5 A and B) whereas at 45 ˚C the
concentration at the end of 8th week the concentration reduced to the level of 50.3 and 36.5 mg/L
110
for UV light and dark condition respectively (fig. 4.6 A and B). Thus, we can say that freeze
dried product better protected gallic acid from degradation at 66% RH.
Serris and Biliaderis (2001) reported that degradation kinetics of beetroot pigments
consisting of betalain was highest at intermediate moisture content (aw = 0.64) for all the
matrices (pullulan and two maltodextrin samples). The reaction rates (K) and half-life period
(T1/2) for encapsulated beetroot pigments were compared at 0.23, 0.43, 0.64, 0.75 and 0.84 water
activity (aw) levels and at 30, 40 and 50 ˚C. The maximum reaction rate (k) was observed at 0.64
aw. However, reaction rates (K) at 0.23 and 0.44 aw levels were lower than 0.75 and 0.84 aw. The
reaction rates (K) increased with increase in temperature. This trend can be explained by the fact
that the degradation reaction is controlled by the mobility of the reactants. This type of behavior
has been exhibited in many systems according to Von Elbe (1987). Saguy and Cohen (1983)
have reported that with increasing aw there is increase in oxygen concentration and this in turn
increases degradation rates since oxygen accelerates the reaction. In dry environment, water is
strongly bound to surface polar sites and is generally not available for any kind of reaction. This
fact explains the lower reaction rates observed at aw of 0.23 and 0.43. At high aw, reactant
dilution effect have been claimed to be predominant (Von Elbe 1987). As a result, reaction rate
may reach maximum at intermediate aw and then decline with further increase in aw. Thus, Serris
and Biliaderis (2001) reported maximum reaction rates at aw= 0.64 for all three temperatures.
There is increasing oxygen concentration with increase in water activity level. Thus it reaches
maximum at aw= 0.64. But at aw above 0.64 the reactant dilution rates have been predominant.
Therefore. at aw= 0.64, maximum degradation rates have been observed. Although, our core
material is gallic acid, similar trends of degradation kinetics have been observed in our studies.
111
In addition, we have also found higher degradation rate of microencapsulated gallic acid
at intermediate moisture levels. Cai and Corke (2000) reported that in spray dried Amaranthus
betacyanin extracts, the bulk density of pigment powder decreased with increase in spray drying
temperature. Although higher drying rate was obtained at higher drying temperature, higher ratio
of surface-to-volume for the spray dried powder caused lower bulk density of the powder. The
lower the bulk density, the more occluded air within the powders and therefore, greater the
possibility of oxidative degradation of pigments and reduced storage stability. Chou and Breene
(1972) also observed the spray dried product had high specific surface area and carotene surface
concentration on surface causes very rapid oxidation. Desorby and Labuza (1998) observed that
freeze drying of β-carotene using maltodextrin provided better protection when compared to
spray dried powder. They also observed the better protection by drum dried maltodextrin which
was assumed to reduce the surface of exchange between oxygen in air and carotene. This proves
to minimize the contact between oxygen and core and better protection offered to freeze dried
microencapsulated β- carotene compared to spray dried microencapsulated β-carotene. Also
according to Nelson and Labuza (1992), matrix-carotenoid complex is critical and the right wall
material is needed to have oxygen impermeable matrix in glassy state below the monolayer
moisture. Nelson and Labuza (1992) reported limonene oxidation was inhibited below the
monolayer moisture because of a very impermeable glassy layer of the matrix material. In our
studies, at the end of 5th week of storage, spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid powder was
clumped together and the capsule walls were fused together at 66% and particularly at 85%
relative humidity (RH). In addition to that at the end of 5th week, the dark brown coloration was
observed in microencapsulated gallic acid and color was lighter at 85% RH. At 22 and 44% RH,
the color of microcapsule was still white. This again substantiates, qualitatively, higher
112
degradation found at intermediate humidity level. Beristain and others (2003) have shown the
effect of caking and stickiness on retention of spray dried microencapsulated orange peel oil
using mesquite gum as wall material. They observed surface caking temperature and advance
caking temperature decreased with increase in storage water activity. Beristain and others (2003)
have also compared the retention of orange oil as function of different water activity. High
retention of oil was obtained upto aw of 0.743 but oil retention dropped sharply in Aw range of
0.743-0.972 as the dissolution of polymer wall. Total loss was recorded at 0.972 where the
structure was completely lost. They also observed the samples stored at water activity upto 0.654
and 0.628 showed change from glassy state to rubbery state. Since we have obtained higher
degradation rates at 66% RH, particularly in spray dried gallic acid powder and marked
degradation at 45˚C temperature as we can see from Fig. 4.8 and 4.9., it would be interesting to
see if we can explain this phenomenon using glass transition theory.
Glass transition theory is increasingly applied to the biological materials due to
limitations of water activity since water activity theory does not indicate the state of water
present and how it is bound to substate (Rahman and Labuza 1999). The glass transition theory
has been proposed in diffusion process, texture and structure, stickiness, pore formation,
oxidation, enzymatic and non-enzymatic browning, enzymes and vitamin inactivation, oxidation
and denaturation of the protein (Rahman 2006). All these phenomenon are important in
predicting the shelf life of the core material and the shelf stability of the active core inside the
microcapsule. Recently, it has been stated that glass transition greatly influences food stability,
as the water in the concentrated phase becomes kinetically immobilized and therefore does not
participate in reactions (Rahman 1999). Glass transition is the nature of second-order time
temperature dependent transition, which is characterized by discontinuity in physical,
113
mechanical, electrical, thermal properties of material. As far as oxidation is concerned, it has
been observed that oxidation of unsaturated lipids entrapped in sugar based matrices is affected
by physical changes such as collapse or crystallization occurring above glass transition (Shimada
and others 1991). Thus, it is necessary to store the microencapsulated powder in dry, free
flowing form at low temperatures to minimize degradation.
CONCLUSIONS
The microencapsulation of gallic acid was successfully carried out using whey protein as
coating material using spray dying and freeze drying as methods of microencapsulation. The
scanning electron micrographs revealed the morphology of the capsules and particle size analysis
helped in understanding the powder characteristics and size distribution. The accelerated storage
study carried could be potentially useful in production and storage of microencapsulated
nutraceutical powder which could be used in various food applications such as dietary
supplements or meat products to determine its antimicrobial properties. Microencapsulated
powder could also be used as an anti-oxidant in variety of foods.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank Glanbia Foods Inc. for graciously providing whey protein
concentrate. The authors would like to thank Mr. Glenn D. Farrell for his technical help. We
would also like to thank Dr. John Shields for preparing scanning micrographs and Mr. Jerry
Davis for his help in statistical analysis.
114
REFERENCES
Beristain CI, Azuara E, Tamayo T-T, Vernon-Carter EJ. 2003. Effect of caking and stickiness on
the retention of spray dried encapsulated orange peel oil. Journal of the Science of Food and
Agriculture 83:1613-1616.
Buffo RA, Reineccius GA. 2001. Comparison among assorted drying processes for the
encapsulation of flavors. Perfumer and flavorist 26:58-67.
Cai YZ, Corke H. 2000. Production and properties of spray-dried Amaranthus betacyanin
pigments. Journal of Food Science 65(7): 1248–1252.
Cohen E, Saguy I. 1983. Effect of water activity and moisture content on stability of beet powder
pigment. Journal of Food Science 48(3): 703-707.
Desorby S, Netto FM, Labuza TP. 1997. Comparison of spray-drying, drum-drying and freeze-
drying for β-carotene encapsulation and preservation. Journal of Food Science 62:1158-1162.
Desorby S, Netto FM, Labuza TP. 1998. Preservation of β-carotene from carrots. Critical
Reviews in Food science and Nutrition 38(5):381-396.
Dziezak JD. 1988. Microencapsulation and encapsulation ingredients. Food Technology 42:136-
151.
Ersus S, Urdagel U. 2007. Microencapsulation of anthocyanins pigments of black carrot
(Dauccuscarota L.) by spray dryer. Journal of Food Engineering 80: 805–812.
Finotelli PV, Rocha-Leao M. 2005. Microencapsulation of ascorbic acid in maltodextrin and
Capsule using spray drying http://www.enpromer2005.eq.ufrj.br/nukleo/pdfs/0022_aa.pdf Paper
accessed October 18th 2007.
Francis FJ. 1989. Food Colorants: anthocyanins. CRC Critical Reviews in Food Science and
Nutrition. 28 (4) 273-315.
115
Frankel EN. 1993. In search of better methods to evaluate natural antioxidants and oxidative
stability in food lipids. Trends in Food Science and Technology 4: 220-225.
Giusti MM, Wrolstad RE. 1996. Radish anthocyanins extract as a natural red colorant for
maraschino cherries. Journal of Food Science 61(4), 688–694.
Heinzelmann K, Franke K. 1999. Using freeze drying techniques of emulsion for
microencapsulation of fish oil to improve oxidation stability. Colloids and Surfaces B:
Biointerfaces. 12:223-229.
Huang AS, Von Elbe JH. 1987. Effect of pH on the degradation and regeneration of betanine.
Journal of Food Science 52(6) 1689-1693.
Keogh MK, O’Kennedy BT. 1999. Milk fat microencapsulation using whey proteins.
International Dairy Journal 9:657-663.
Mazza G, Miniati E. 1993. Anthocyanins in fruits, vegetables and grains. London: CRC Press.
Minemoto Y, Adachi S, Matsuno R. 1997. Comparison of oxidation of menthyl linoleate
encapsulated with gum arabic by hot air drying and freeze drying. Journal of Agricultural and
Food Chemistry 45:4530-4534.
Moreau DL, Rosenberg M. 1996. Oxidative stability of anhydrous milkfat microencapsulated in
whey proteins 61: 39-43.
Moreau DL, Rosenberg M. 1998. Porosity of whey protein based microcapsule containing
anhydrous milkfat measured by gas displacement pycnometry. Journal of Food Science 63(5):
819-823.
Moreau DL, Rosenberg M. 1998. Porosity of microcapsules with wall systems consisting of
whey proteins and lactose measured by gas displacement pycnometry. Journal of Food Science
64(3): 405-409.
116
Nelson KA, Labuza TP. 1992. Relationship between water and lipid oxidation rates: water
activity and glass transition theory. ACS Symp. Ser. Am. Chem. Soc. 500: 93-103.
Reineccius GA. 1989. Flavor encapsulation. Food Reviews International 5: 147-176.
Rodriguez-Saona LE, Giusti MM, Wrolstad RE. 1999. Color and pigment stability of red radish
and red fleshed potato anthocyanins in juice model systems. Journal of Food Science 64: 451–
456.
Rosenberg M, Kopelman IJ, Talmon Y. 1988. Factors affecting retention in spray drying
microencapsulation of volatile materials. Journal of Agricultural Food Chemistry 38:1238.
Rosenberg M. Kopelman IJ, Talmon Y. 1985. A scanning electron microscopy study of
microencapsulation. Journal of Food Science 50:139.
Serris GS, Biliaderis CG. 2001. Degradation kinetics of beetroot pigment encapsulated in
polymeric matrices. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 81(8): 691-700.
Shahidi F, Han XQ. 1993. Encapsulation of Food ingredients. Critical Reviews in Food Science
and Nutrition 33(6): 501-547.
Sheu TY, Rosenberg M. 1995. Microencapsulation by Spray Drying Ethyl Caprylate in Whey
Protein and Carbohydrate Wall Systems. Journal of Food Science 60(1): 98–103.
Wagner LA, Warthesen JJ. 1995. Stability of spray-dried encapsulated carrot. Journal of Food
Science 60(5): 1048-1053.
Young SL, Sarda X, Rosenberg M. 1993. Microencapsulating properties of whey proteins. 1.
Microencapsulation of anhydrous milk fat. Journal of dairy science 76: 2868-2877.
117
Table 4.1: Microencapsulation efficiency for spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid
Gallic acid
(g)
WPC (g)
Vitamin C: WPC ratio
(w/w)
Microencapsulation efficiency (%)
6.25 100 1:16.0 82.15b
12.5 100 1:8.0 83.16b
18.75 100 1:5.3 96.58a
25 100 1:4.0 99.38a a, b, c Values followed by different letters in the same column are significant (α=0.05)
118
Table 4.2: Microencapsulation efficiency for freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid
a, b, c Values followed by different letters in the same column are significant (α=0.05)
Gallic acid
(g)
WPC (g) Vitamin C: WPC ratio
(w/w)
Microencapsulation efficiency (%)
6.25 100 1:16.0 96.14ab
12.5 100 1:8.0 90.36bc
18.75 100 1:5.3 89.01c
25 100 1:4.0 99.54a
119
Figure 4.1: Folin-Ciocalteux Method of determination of total phenolics
Start
Take 0.2 ml of sample in a test tube
Add 0.8 ml of distilled water
Add 5.0 ml of 0.2 N Folin-Ciocalteux reagent.
Add 4.0 ml of sodium carbonate solution (7.5 g/100 ml)
Read the absorbance at 766 nm after incubation at room temperature for two hours.
120
Figure 4.2: SEM micrograph of freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid with gallic acid: WPC ratio of 1:4 with magnifications of (A) 100X (B) 200 X and (C) 500 X SEM micrographs of spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid with gallic acid: WPC ratio of 1:4 with magnifications of (D) 100X (E) 200X and (F) 500X
A
B
C
D
E
F
121
Figure 4.3: Cumulative percentage particle size distribution of (A) spray dried (B) freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid powder
0 10
20 30 40
50 60 70 80
90 100
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Cumulative (%)
Particle size µm
0
25
50
75
100
125
150
175
200
225
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Cumulative (%)
Particle size µm
122
Figure 4.4: Particle size distribution of (A) spray dried (B) freeze dried, microencapsulated gallic acid powder
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
0.1 1 10 100 1000 Particle size (µm)
Volume (%)
-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
0.1 1 10 100 1000
Particle size (µm)
Volume (%)
123
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9Week
GA mg/L
22% RH 44% RH 66% RH85% RH
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9Week
GA mg/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
Figure 4.5: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 25 ˚C and (A) UV Light (B) dark conditions (G.A. denotes gallic acid)
124
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Week
GA mg/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Week
GA mg/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
Figure 4.6: Degradation kinetics of spray dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 45 ˚C and (A) UV Light (B) dark condition (G.A. denotes gallic acid)
125
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Week
GA mg/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9Week
GA mg/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
Figure 4.7: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 25 ˚C (A) UV Light and (B) dark condition (G.A. denotes gallic acid)
126
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Week
GA mg/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH 85% RH
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Week
GA mg/L
22% RH44% RH66% RH85% RH
Figure 4.8: Degradation kinetics of freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid stored at 45 ˚C and (A) UV light and (B) dark condition (G.A. denotes gallic acid)
127
CHAPTER 5
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
Many researchers have reported that muscadine grapes contain a variety of health
promoting phenolic compounds which may be used to produce nutraceutical powder. The
potential commercial applications of this powder is dietary supplements, use as antioxidants in
foods, antimicrobial agent and natural colorants. Potency of these compounds is compromised
due to their susceptibility to oxidation due to their reactivity to various environmental factors
such as temperature, humidity and light.
Gallic acid, one of the phenolic compounds found in muscadine grape and grape seed
extract, was selected as model anti-oxidant to microencapsulate in order to test protective
effectiveness of microencapsulation from various environmental degradation factors. Vitamin C
was another anti-oxidant selected as model due to its high reactivity and susceptibility to
oxidation. Many researchers have demonstrated good film forming and oxygen barrier properties
of whey protein concentrate (WPC). Microencapsulation of gallic acid was carried out using
WPC as wall material by spray and freeze drying method. The gallic acid: WPC (w/w) ratios of
1:4.0. 1:5.3, 1:8.0 and 1:16.0 were selected for both spray and freeze drying method. Maximum
microencapsulation efficiency (MEE) was found in 1:4 ratio for spray dried (99.38%) and freeze
dried (99.54%) powders. Similarly vitamin C was microencapsulated in spray dried and freeze
dried powders. Vitamin C: WPC (w/w) ratios of 1:4.0, 1:5.3, 1:8.0 and 1:16.0 were selected to
investigate ratios resulting in highest MEE. Maximum MEE was found in 1:4 ratio for both spray
dried (96.35%) and freeze dried (98.23%) powders. The microcapsules were characterized by
128
scanning electron microscope (SEM) and particle size analysis using Malvern Mastersizer. The
objective behind the SEM was to a) examine degree to which microcapsules are well formed b)
to observe outer morphology (presence of pores, surface cracking and dents), c) tendency of
agglomeration and presence of extraneous matters, if any. SEM micrographs revealed that spray
dried vitamin C microcapsules were spherical in shape and some capsules were broken. There
were few pores formed indicating effectiveness of drying process. Some small capsules showed
tendency to agglomerate which may interfere with free flowing properties. Freeze dried
microcapsules were irregularly shaped but the edges were considerably sharper. Vitamin C was
part of the matrix of WPC. SEM micrographs of gallic acid revealed similar structure to that of
vitamin C microcapsules. However, gallic acid microcapsules of both freeze and spray dried
were considerably larger than vitamin C microcapsules. Spray dried microcapsules were well
formed spherical in shape. Very few capsules were broken and small number showed visible
shrinkage indicating effectiveness of microcapsule formation and drying conditions. Particle size
distribution revealed the average size, range of the microcapsule size and the modal distribution
of the microcapsules. Spray dried microencapsulated vitamin C (SDVC) and freeze dried
microencapsulated vitamin C (FDVC) had particle size range between 1.3 – 83.2 µm and 1.3 –
77.2 respectively. SDVC and FDVC showed mean particle size diameter 17.5 and 11.5 µm
respectively. SDVC showed multi-modal distribution while SDVC showed single-modal
distribution. Spray dried gallic acid (SDGA) microcapsule had particle size range of 1.4 - 104.2
µm and mean particle size of 29.9 µm. Freeze dried gallic acid microcapsules (FDGA) had
particle size range of 1.4 to 255.7 µm and mean particle size diameter of 38.85 µm. SDGA
showed single modal distribution while FDGA showed multi-modal distribution.
129
Microencapsulated vitamin C and gallic acid were subjected to accelerated storage
condition to investigate the degradation kinetics of these anti-oxidants. The various factors
selected were temperature (25 and 45 ˚C), RH (22, 44, 66 and 85%), UV light and dark, type of
drying method (spray and freeze drying). It was observed that humidity played significant role in
degradation kinetics. For spray and freeze dried microencapsulated gallic acid at 25 ˚C,
maximum degradation was found at 66% RH and at 45 ˚C maximum degradation was observed
at 85% RH. Compared to spray dried powder, freeze dried powder provided better protection to
vitamin C at all the RH conditions. This was attributed to the difference in the bulk density
between spray dried and freeze dried powder. The spray dried powder was considerably less
dense (about 4 times) compared to freeze dried powder which increased surface area exposed to
environmental condition and therefore caused greater degradation. In microencapsulated gallic
acid (spray and freeze dried), maximum degradation was found at 66% RH in both UV light and
dark condition and at both 25 and 45 ˚C. The only exception was freeze dried gallic acid at 25 ˚C
and dark condition where maximum degradation was found at 85% RH.
Similar trend of degradation was found by some of the researchers. It was reported that by
increasing aw, there is an increase in oxygen concentration, this in turn increases degradation rate
since oxygen accelerates the degradation rate. In dry environment, water is strongly bound to
polar sites and does not participate in reaction which explains lower degradation rates at 22 and
44% RH compared to 66 and 85% RH.
The results showed that it should be possible to microencapsulate muscadine grape extract based
on the information generated from this project. Since the phenolic compounds in muscadine
grapes are similar to gallic acid, it can be expected that those compounds will also show similar