minutes of 158th meeting of executive committee held … · 2019. 9. 17. · 4. vananchal...

1Agenda Item 158th EC

COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINENEW DELHI

MINUTES OF 158TH MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEEHELD ON 28.6.2010 AT NEW DELHI.

Present

1. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma, President, CCIM Chairman2. Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan, Vice-President (Ayurved) Member3. Prof. Hakim Syed Khaleefthullah, Vice-President(Unani) Member4. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member5. Dr. PK Jain Member6. Vaidya Ved Prakash Tyagi Member7. Dr. Niranjan Singh Tyagi Member8. Dr. D Ramanathan Member9. Dr. V Arunachalam Member

10. Dr. Rashidullah KhanMemberDr. PR Sharma Secretary, CCIM

Special Invitee:-

Prof. Banwarilal Gaur

Dr. Khalid Siddqui could not attend the meeting.

Agenda Items No. 1 Confirmation of the minutes 157th

meeting of Executive Committeeheld on 28.05.2010 .

It was noted that 157th meeting of Executive Committee was held on28.05.2010 at New Delhi. The minutes of the same have been circulatedto all the member vide letter No. 5-1/2010 (157th) dated 14.06.2010 forperusal. Simultaneously the members were requested to suggest theaddition/deletion if any within 10 days from the date of issue of thesame. No comments were received.

It was also noted that while confirming the minutes, Vice-President(Unani), Prof. Hakim Syed Khaleefathullah raised the point that name ofthe members of Sub Committee constituted to assess the work load ofteaching staff of the college have not been mentioned in the minutes.

Executive Committee agreed to the same.

Executive Committee confirmed the same.


Agenda Items No.2 Ratification of the action taken byPresident, CCIM.

(i) Regarding Amrit Vishwavidyapeetham Coimbatore

It was noted that the request of Amrit Vishwavidyapeetham, Coimbatorewas forwarded by Government of India vide letter No.V.27016/1/2010-Ay. Desk dated 11.5.2010 for inclusion/recognition of Ayurvedacharya(BAMS) Qualification awarded by Amrita Vishwa Vidhyapeetham inSecond Schedule to IMCC Act 1970 for necessary action at the end ofCCIM as required under section 14(2) of IMCC Act 1970. Afterexamination of the proposal following observation were made.

1. Amrita School of Ayurved Amritapuri, Kollam is a part of thisUniversity.

2. University is following the syllabus, Curriculum and nomenclatureof the degree in toto as prescribed by CCIM.

Office Remarks After receipt of the proposal from Government of Indiaas required under Section 14 (2) of IMCC Act, 1970 and observing thatUniversity is fulfilling the requirement of the Act, and Regulations,President, CCIM agreed to send the recommendations to the Governmentof India for inclusion in Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970.Accordingly, recommendations were sent to the Government of Indiavide letter No.4-102/2010-Uni dated 15.6.2010.

Executive Committee ratified the same.

(i) Enhancement of the tenure of Ayurveda Experts

It was noted that following three Ayurveda Experts have joined office asper details given below for three months at first instance.

1. Dr. Kamini Kaushal2. Dr. Seema Ahlawat3. Dr. Aarti Mal

Accordingly tenure of Dr. Kamini Kaushal and Dr. Aarti Mal, AyurvedaExpert has over on 28.6.2010 & 07.7.2010 respectively, therefore,period of Dr. Kaminimi Kaushal and Dr. Aarti Mal, Ayurved Experts hasbeen extended for 11 months subject to satisfactory services after givingone day gap as under:-

S.No. Name of Ayurveda Expert Date of Joining1. Dr. Kamini Kaushal 28.6.2010 to 27.5.20112. Dr. Aarti Mal 07.7.2010 to 06.6.2011


Further, Dr. Seema Ahlawat Saroha has resigned from her duties on09.6.2010.

It was proposed that an Ayurved Expert appointed for smooth functioningof the office of CCIM, therefore, advertisement may be issued.

Executive Committee ratified the same and further decided toengage one Unani Expert and two Ayurveda Experts for smoothfunctioning of the office of CCIM.

Agenda Items No.3 Notification of amendment sanction Act, byGovt. of India under Section 36 of IMCC act.1970.

It was noted that detail programme of internship was not underconcerned Regulation 1989. Moreover, it was also felt that subject ofPanchkarma was also not in the Regulations, therefore, it was decided toamend the Regulations, therefore the proposal were passed by CCIM andwere sent to State Government for their comment as required underSection 22 of IMCC Act, 1970. Thereafter, the same were sent to Govt.of India for sanction as required under Section 36 of IMCC Act, 1970.The Government of India has conveyed the sanction for the same.

Executive Committee approved the draft notification for issuingNotification in the Gazette of India.

Agenda Items No.4 Consideration of visitation Report ofthe College to furnish therecommendation to Government ofIndia for Letter of Permission.

It was noted that in pursuance of decision of the Executive Committee atits meeting held on 28.5.2010 the following colleges have been visited tofurnish the recommendation to Government of India for issuing LOP inresponse of Letter of Intent issued by Government of India. VisitationReport was placed before the committee, after considering the visitationreport and relevant papers decided as under mentioned against thecollege:-

S.No. Name of the College Decision of Executive Committee1. Ayujyoti Educational &

Research Society’s,Ayurved Medical College,SIRSA, (Haryana)

After going through the visitationreport, gist and other all the relevantrecords, it was decided torecommend to Government of Indiafor issuing the Letter of Permissionfor the year 2010-11.


2. Sikar Vikas EvumShikshan AnusandhanSansthan’s, NationalAyurved Medical CollegeSIKAR (Rajasthan)

After going through the visitationreport, gist and other all the relevantrecords, it was decided not torecommend to Government of Indiafor issuing the Letter of Permissionfor the year 2010-11.

3. Gandhi USPS Samiti,Kisangarh, Renwal’s ShriShirdi Sai Baba Ayurvedacollege & Hospital,Mundigarh, Jaipur,Rajasthan.


4. Vananchal Educational &Welfare Trust, DevkiMahaveer AyurvedicCollege and ResearchHospital at Fariathiya,Garhwa, Jharkhand.


5. Banwarlal Nehata SamitiSansthan’s MandsaurInstitute of Ayurveda,MANDSAUR (MP)


6. Shri Ram CharitableTrust’s Shri DhanwantriAyurved College, Kheda,Gujarat


7. Ahaila InternationalAhalia Foundation’sAyurved College,PALLAKKAD (Kerala)


8. Shri Gurukripa ShikshanPrasarak Mandal’s VimlaDevi Ayurved MedicalCollege Chanderpur(Maharashtra)


9. Shri Maharashtra After going through the visitation


Education Society’sAyurved Meical college,Logte Tal. Khed Distt.Ratnagiri (Maharashtra)

report, gist and other all the relevantrecords, it was decided torecommend to Government of Indiafor issuing the Letter of Permissionfor the year 2010-11.

Agenda Items No. 5 Consideration of visitation Reportof the College

It was noted in pursuance of decision of Executive Committee in itsmeeting held 28.05.2010 under agenda item No.4. The visitation wasconducted to examine the Scheme submitted by the Society forestablishment of new Ayurved College under Section 13 A of IMCC Act,1970.

Executive Committee after consideration of Visitation Reports decided asfollows:-

S.No

Name of theCollege

Decision of the Executive Committee

1. Shiv Gomti JanKalyan Samiti Raisen,MP

After examination of proposal alongwith thevisitation report and all relevant papers theExecutive Committee decided not torecommend to Government of India forissuing the Letter of Intent.

2. Dr. D.P. SinghSamiti Seva SansthanShahjahanpur (UP)


3. Nirogdham JankalyanSeva Sansthan AkleraDist. Jhalawar,Rajasthan


4. MNS Medical &Educational Society,Bikaner, Rajasthan



5. Shri DhaneshwariManav MandalAurangabad (Smt.Shatdevi VedprakashPatil Ayurved College,Hatta


6. Shri Prabhav DevHem KamdhenuGirvihar TrsutDhariwal AyurvedCollege, Vagaldhara


7. Shri LabdhivikramRaj ArogyyadhamSansthan,Pararnagar, Durg,Chhatisgarh


It was noted that on the request of Government of Ponducherry andTripura visitation have been postponed.

Agenda Item No.6 Consideration of visitation Report of theCollege.

It was noted that visitation of Mannam Ayurved College, Pandalam couldnot be conducted because while Govt. of India vide letterNo.R.12011/29/2005-EP dated 30.12.2009 granting the permission forthe session 2009-10 had asked the college to fulfill the shortcomings by15 March /31 March, 2010. It is also submitted that visitation ofMayurbhaj Ayurved College, Baripada was also conducted becausecollege asked time of six months to fulfill the shortcomings pointed outby Government of India as recommendations has to be sent toGovernment of India, therefore, visitation was conducted and afterconsidering the visitation reports decided as under:-

S.No.Name of the college Decision of Executive Committee

1. Mannam AyurvedCollege, Pandalam

After examination the visitation reportand all relevant papers the ExecutiveCommittee decided not to


recommend to Government of Indiafor issuing the Letter of Permission forthe year 2010-11.

2. Mayurbanj AyurvedCollege, Baripada

After examination the visitation reportand all relevant papers the ExecutiveCommittee decided not torecommend to Government of Indiafor issuing the Letter of Permission forthe year 2010-11.

Agenda Item No.7. Approval of Annual Report and AuditedAccounts for the year 2009-10.

It was noted that the Annual Report and Annual Audited Accounts of theCentral Council of Indian Medicine for the year 2009-10 after printing areto be sent to the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare Dept. of AYUSHNew Delhi to be laid down on the table of both the Houses of Parliamentbe fore 30th November as usual.

It was noted that due to shortage of time the Annual Report and AuditedAccounts for the year 2009-10 could not be prepared, therefore,Executive Committee authorized Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan, Vice-President (Ayurveda) and Prof. Hakim Syed Khaleefathullah,Vice-President (Unani) to finalized the same.

Agenda Item No.8. Approval of Annual accounts for theyear 2009-10 under Non-Plan and Plan-regarding.

It was noted that Annual Account for the year 2009-10 (Plan and underPlan) are to be submitted to DGACR by 30th June to conduct the audit ofthe same in due course of time as per provisions of the GeneralRegulations of sub clause 1 of clause 86 .

Executive Committee approved the Annual Account for the year2009-10 to send DGCAR. It was also pointed out that receipt offee from the colleges be bifurcated in respect of Ayurveda, Unaniand Siddha colleges separately.


Agenda Item No.9 Reporting of decision on the proposal forstarting PG course/increasing intakecapacity in UG & PG Courses.

It was noted that in pursuance of decision of Executive Committee of themeeting held on 28.5.2010 the proposal for which LOI were issued by theGovernment of India received under Section 13 A of IMCC Act, 1970 inthe year 2009-10 for 2010-11 for starting PG course/increasing intakecapacity in UG/PG Course were examined by the Screening Committeeand recommendations has been sent to the Government of India in viewof the decided policy as follows:-

S.No Name of thecollege

13A demandingcapacity- LOIpermitted by GOI

Recommendation

1 ShriShivayogeshwarRural AyurvedicMedical College,Inchal

40-50[UG]PGDravyaguna 05Panchkarma 05Shalya 05

Recommended forincreasing intake capacityin UG 40 to 50Not Recommended for PGas underDravyaguna 05Panchkarma 05Shalya 05

2 Yerala MedicalTrust & AyurvedCollege, Mumbai

60-80 (UG)RecommendedPGRachna Sharir 04Kriya Sharir 04Shalya (Samanya) 02Shalya 04(Ksharkarma &Anushastra Karma)

Recommended forincreasing intake capacityfrom 60-80 in UGPG-Recommended asunderRachna Sharir 04Kriya Sharir 04Shalya (Samanya) 02Shalya 04(Ksharkarma & AnushastraKarma)

3 Dr. DY PatilPratishtan AyurvedCollege, Pimpri,Pune (MS).

50-80 (UG)PGPrasuti & Stri Rog 04Kayachikitsa 04Shalya 04

Recommended forincreasing intake capacityfrom 50-75 seat in UGRecommended for PG asunderPrasuti & Stri Rog 04Kayachikitsa 04Shalya 04


4 Karnataka LiberalEducation SocietyShri KarnatakaB.M. KankanwadiAyurvedMahavidyalaya,Belgaum

PGKayachikitsa 03Shalya 03Agadtantra 06Bhaishajyakalpana 06Kaumarbhrittya 06Panchkarma 06Sangyaharan 02

Not Recommended for PGas underKayachikitsa 03Shalya 03Agadtantra 06Bhaishajyakalpana 06Kaumarbhrittya 06Panchkarma 06Sangyaharan 02

5 AyurvedMahavidyalaya, OldHubli

PGPanchkarma 05Ay. Siddhant 05Rasashastra 05

Not Recommended for PGas underPanchkarma 05Ay. Siddhant 05Rasashastra 05

6 Annasaheb DangeAyurved College,Sangali

PGKriyasharir 05Rasashastra 05Shalya 05

Recommended for PG asunderKriyasharir 05Rasashastra 05Shalya 05

7 Shri DM College ofAyurved, Udupi

PGSamhita-05#Pending - Rachan Sharir5-6

Recommended for PG asunderSamhita- 05To increase intake capacityin PGRachan Sharir 5-6

8 Alva’s AyurvedicCollege, Moodbidri,Dakshin Kannada

PG in Rasashastra05Bhaishajya Kalpana05Kayachikitsa05Prasuti & Striroga05Agadtantra05

Recommended for PG asunderRasashastra 05Bhaishajya Kalpana 05Kayachikitsa 05Prasuti & Striroga 05-Not Recommended asunderAgadtantra 05

9 Vasant KusumRural Yoga &Ayurved SansthanSiddhakala AyurvedMahavidyalaya,Sangamner

PGKayachikitsa 02Shalya 02Rachna sharir 04

Recommended for PG asunderKayachikitsa 02Shalya 02Not Recommeded for PGas underRachna sharir 04

10 LokneteRajarambapu PatilAyurved College,Islampur Sangli

PGKayachikitsa 05Shalya 05Prasuti & Striroga 05

Not Recommended for PGas underKayachikitsa 05Recommended for PG asunderShalya for 2


seatsPrasuti & Striroga for3seats

11 Cap. KedariRedekar AyurvedCollege, Kolhapur

PGRognidan &Vikriti Vigyan 04Rasashastra 05Shalya 05

Recommended for PG asunderRognidan &Vikriti Vigyan 04Rasashastra 05

Not Recommended for PGas under

Shalya 05-12 Maharashtra

Arogya Mandal’sSumati Bhai ShahAyurvedMahavidyalaya,Hadapsar, Pune

PGAgadtantra 03Ayurved Siddhant 03Dravyaguna 03Roganidan &Vikriti Vigyan 03

Recommended for PG asunder

Agadtantra 03Ayurved Siddhant 03Dravyaguna 03Roganidan &Vikriti Vigyan 03

13 Jupiter AyurvedCollege & TariniAyurved Hospital,Nagpur

PGShrir Rachana 04Sharir Kriya 04Swasthvaritta 04

Not Recommended for PGas underShrir Rachana 04Sharir Kriya 04Swasthvaritta 04

14 College of Ayurveda& Research Centre,Akurdi

PGDravyaguna 02Samhita 02Prasuti & Striroga 02Panchkarma 02


Dravyaguna 02Samhita 02Prasuti & Striroga 02

Not Recommended for PGPanchkarma 02-

15 Tilak AyurvedMahavidyalaya,Pune

PGSangyaharan 03Seat increase in PGKayachikitsa 02Shalaya 01Rasashastra 03Dravyaguna 01Kriya Sharir 02Rachna Sharir 03


Sangyaharan 03-

Recommended forincreasing seat in PG

Kayachikitsa 02


Shalya 01Rasashastra 03Dravyaguna 01Kriya Sharir 02Rachna Sharir 03

16 Nangelil AyurvedCollege, Nangelil

UG-40-60 Not Recommended forIncreasing seatsfrom 40-60

17 Kisan DnyanodayMandal Gudhe’sAyurved College,Chalisgaon, Jalgaon

40-50 [UG] Not Recommended forIncreasing seat in UG from40-50

18 Nalasopara AyurvedCollege, Vasai,Thane

40-50 [UG] Recommended increasingintake capacity from 40-50in UG

19 DhanwantariAyurved CollegeUDGIR

40-50 [UG] Recommended forIncreasing seat in from 40-50 UG seat

20 JSS AyurvedMedical College,Mysore

PGPanchkarma 05Dravyaguna 04

Recommended for PG asunderPanchkarma 05Not Recommended for PGas underDravyaguna 04

21 Shri JG CooperativeHospital AyurvedMedical Collegeg,Ghataprabha

PGKayachikitsa 05Prasuti & Striroga 05Shalakya 05To increase seats in PGcourseShalya 2-5Dravyaguna 2-5

Not Recommended for PGas underKayachikitsa 05Prasuti & Striroga 05Shalakya 05Not Recommended forIncrease seats in PGcourse

Shalya 2-5Dravyaguna 2-5


22 SDM College ofAyurveda, Hassan

75-100 (U.G.)PGAy. Samhita 06Kriyasharir 06Kayachikitsa 06Prasuti & Striroga 06Increasing seats in PG-Manas Roga 2-5

Recommended forincreasing in take capacityfor UG 75-100Not Recommended for PGas under

Ay. SamhitaRecommended for PG asunder

Kriyasharir 06Kayachikitsa 06Prasuti & Striroga 06

Increasing seats in PGManas Roga 2-5for increasing seat

23 Institute of Post-graduate Training &Research, GujratAyurved University,Jamnagar

PG inKriya Sharir 05Swasthavritta 05


Kriya Sharir 05Swasthavritta 05

24 GovernmentAyurved College,Tripunitura

PGSwasthavaritta 04


Swasthavaritta 0425 Yashwant Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya,Kodoli

65-80(UG)PGAyurved Samhita 06Kayachikitsa 06Rasashastra 06Rachna Sharir 06Swasthavritta 06Prasuti & Striroga 06Kaumarbhrittya 06Shalya 06

Recommended forincreasing in take capacityfrom 65-80 in UG


Ayurved Samhita 06Kayachikitsa 06Rasashastra 06Rachna Sharir 06Prasuti & Striroga 06Kaumarbhrittya 06Shalya 06Not Recommended for PGas underSwasthavritta 06

26 JS AyurvedMahavidyalaya,Nadiad

Recommended40-50 [UG]

Not Recommendedincreasing intake capacityfor UG (40-50)Government of India has


already permitted for 40-50

27 Shri DGM AyurvedCollege, Gadag

Recommended.PGKaumarbhritya 05Swasthavritta 05Rognidan 05Prasuti & Striroga 05Shalya 05


Kaumarbhritya 05Swasthavritta 05Rognidan 05Prasuti & Striroga 05Shalya 05

28 Rajiv LochanAyurved MedicalCollege, Durg

40-60 (UG) Recommended forincreasing intake capacityUG (40-50)seat

29 Yagya Dutt SharmaAyurved College,Khurza

40-75 (UG)PGKriya sharir 05Shalya 05

Recommended forincreasing intake capacityfrom 40-75 in UGRecommended for PG asunderKriya sharir 05Shalya 05

30 Shri VijayMahentheshAyurvedic MedicalCollege PB No.15,ILKAL-587125Distt. Bagalkot

PGKayachikitsa 05Panchkarma 05Prasuti 05Shalya 05

Not Recommended for PGas underKayachikitsa 05Panchkarma 05Prasuti 05Shalya 05

31 Shri JagadguruGavisiddeshwarSansthan, Koppal

PGRasashastra 05Dravyaguna 05Shalya 05Panchkarma 05Swasthavritta 05

Recommended for PG asunderRasashastra 05Dravyaguna 05Shalya 05Panchkarma 05Swasthavritta 05

32 ShriKalabhairaveshwaraSwami AyurvedCollege, Bangalore

PGPanchkarma 05Prasuti & Striroga 05

Recommended for PG asunderPanchkarma 05Prasuti & Striroga 05

33 Shri SG MinorityAyurved College,Gazipur

40-60 (UG)PGRoganidan 04Prasuti & Striroga 04

Recommended forincreasing intake capacityfrom 40-60 in UG


Roganidan 04Prasuti & Striroga 04


34 Rani DhullaiyaAyurved College &Hospital, Bhopal

PGBasic Principles 05Rachana Sharir 05Swastha Vritta 05Agad Tantra 05Kaumar Bhrittya 05*50-75(UG) - decisionpending GOI

Recommended for PG asunderSwastha Vritta 05Not Recommended for PG

Basic Principles 05Rachana Sharir 05Agad Tantra 05Kaumar Bhrittya 05-

35 Pt. ShivshaktilalSharma AyurvedMahavidyalaya,Ratlam

PG-Ay. Siddhant 06Kayachikitsa 06Panchkarma 06

Not Recommended for PGas underAy. Siddhant 06Kayachikitsa 06Panchkarma 06

36 Bhagvan MahavirJain AyurvedCollege,Gajendergarh,Gadag

40-50 (UG)PGKayachikitsa 05Panchakarma 05Rasashastra 05Shalyatantra 05

Recommended forincreasing intake capacityfrom 40-50 in UG


Panchakarma with 05seatNot Recommended for PGas underRasashastra 05Shalyatantra 05Kayachikitsa 05

37 Sri Sai AyurvedCollege & Hospital,Aligarh

Recommended50-75 (UG)PG-PG -Prasuti & Striroga-04Shalya04

Not Recommended forincreasing intake capacityfrom 40-75 in UG


Prasuti & Striroga- 04Shalya 04



Agenda Item No.10 Reporting of Recommendation of the CCIMin respect of the Ayurved and UnaniColleges falling under section 13A & 13C ofIMCC Act 1970.

It was noted that as per decision of 156th and 157th meeting of theExecutive Committee the recommendation as mentioned against thename of Ayurved and Unani Colleges have been sent to the Govt. ofIndia as follows:-

S.NO Name of the College Decision of CCIM1. Dr. BRKR Ayurved College, Hyderabad Not Recommended

2. Dr. NR Sastry Govt.Ayurved College,Vijayawada

Not Recommended

3. SV Ayurved College, Tirupati Not Recommended4. Vaghdevi Ayurved Medical College,

WarangalNot Recommended

5. Shree Vageshwari Ayurved MedicalCollege, Karimnagar

Not Recommended

6. MNR Ayurved Medical College, Medak Not Recommended7. Government Ayurved College, Guwahati Not Recommended

8. Government Ayurved College PGTraining & Research Institute, Patna

Not Recommended

9. Ravindranath Mukherji Ayurved College,Motihari

Not Recommended

10. Swami Raghwendracharya TridandiAyurved Mahavidyalaya, Gaya

Not Recommended

11. Nitishwar Ayurvedic Medical College &Hospital, Muzzafarpur

Not Recommended

12. Dayanand Ayurved College & Hospital,Siwan

Not Recommended

13. Govt. Ayurved College, Raipur Not Recommended(UG & PG)

14. Chhatisgarh Ayurved Medical College,Rajnandgaon, Chhatisgarh

RecommendedUG 75 seat

15. Ayurved & Unani Tibbia College, NewDelhi

Not Recommended

16. Govt. Akhandanand AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Ahmedabad

Not Recommended(UG & PG)

17. Shri OH Nazar Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,Surat

Not Recommended

18. Shri Gulab Kunverba AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Jamnagar

Not Recommended


19. Institute of Post-graduate Training &Research, Gujrat Ayurved University,Jamnagar

RecommendedPGBasic Principal- 06Dravyaguna- 05Kayachikitsa 02

20. Parul Institute of Ayurved, Limda,Vadodra

Not Recommended

21. Govindbhai Jorabhai Patil AyurvedMedical College, Gujarat

Not Recommended

22. Shri Baba Mastnath Ayurved College,Asthal Bohar, Rohtak

Recommended underProcess

23. Gaur Brahmin Ayurved College &Hospital, Distt. ROHTAK Haryana

UG 70 seatRecommended

24. Seth Murarilal Rasiwasia Ayurved College& Hospital, Charkhi Dadri

Not Recommended

25. Rajiv Gandhi Rajkiya GovernmentAyurvedic Post-graduate College, DisttKangra, Paprola (HP)

Not Recommended

26. Jammu Institute of Ayurved & Research,Jammu Tawi

RecommendedUG – 90 SeatPG –Kriya Sharir,Shalya

27. Govt. Ayurved College & Hospital,Mysore


28. ALN Rao Memorial AyurvedMahavidyalya, Koppa

RecommendedUG - 60-50 SeatPG –Dravyaguna- 06Kayachikitsa 05Bhaishayjakalpna-05

29. Govt. Ayurved College, Bangalore Recommended UG-60Not Recommended PG

30. Govt. Taranath Ayurved College, Ballary Not Recommended31. AV Samiti’s Ayurved Mahavidyalya,

BijapurNot Recommended

32. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Old Hubli Recommended UG-50seatPG Shalya -02

33. Karnataka Liberal Education Society ShriKarnataka B.M. Kankanwadi AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Belgaum

Recommended UG-75PG NotRecommended

34. Ashwini Educational Association’sAyurved College, Davangare



35. NK Jabashetty Siddharudh MathAyurved Medical College, Bidar


36. Dr. BNM Rural Ayurved College &Hospital, Bijapur


37. JSS Ayurved Medical College, Mysore RecommendedUG-50 seatPGNot Recommended

38. Shri Vijay Mahenthesh Ayurvedic MedicalCollege, Ilkal, (Karnataka)

Recommended UG-50seat

39. TMAE Society’s Ayurved Medical College,Hospet

Not Recommended

40. SDM College of Ayurveda, Hassan RecommendedUG - 75 seatPG –Shalya -05Kaumar Bharitya 05Swashtvaritta -04Manas Roga -02Panchkarma -01Shalakya -04

41. KVG Ayurved Medical College & Hospital,Sulliya

RecommendedUG—50 seatPGPanchkarma - 05Dravyaguna - 06Shalya - 05

42. Shri JG Cooperative HospitalAyurvedMedical Collegeg, Ghataprabha

Not Recommended

43. Shri Kalabhairaveshwara Swami AyurvedCollege, Bangalore

RecommendedUG-60 seat

44. Indian Institute of Ayurvedic Medicine &Research, Bangalore

Not Recommended

45. Alva’s Ayurvedic College, Moodbidri,Dakshin Kannada

Recommended UG-100 seatPG –Panchkarma- 05Shalya 05Kaumarbhritya- 05RachnaSharir -05Ayurved Siddhant-05

46. SNVV Samasthe’s SGV Ayurved College,BAILHONGAL, Belgaum

Not Recommended

47. Mahaganpati Ayurvedic College,Hoysalnagar. Dharwad

-

48. Shri Jagadguru GavisiddeshwarSansthan, Koppal



49. Kalmathada Pujya Shri VirupakshaShivacharya Ayurved College, Manvi,Raichur


50. Shri DGM Ayurved College, Gadag RecommendedUG-50 seatPGRasashastra -05Dravyaguna-04Panchkarma-04

51. Kannada Balag Society’s Rural AyurvedCollege, Belgaum

Not Recommended

52. Bhagvan Mahavir JainAyurved College,Gajendergarh, Gadag

RecommendedUG-40

53. Kalidas Ayurvedic College, Badami,Bagalkot

Not Recommended

54. Muniyal Institute of Ayurved Sciences,Manipal

Not Recommended

55. Dhanwantari Ayurved College & Hospital,Siddhapur

Not Recommended

56. Rama Krishna Ayurved College,Bangalore

Not Recommended

57. Shri SDM College of Ayurved, Udupi RecommendedUG - 75 seatPGKayachikitsa 06Shalya 06Prasuti- 06Panchkarma 05Roga Nidan 03Dravyaguna- 05,Rasashastra - 03Bhashajya, Kalpana- 2Rachna Sharir- 05

58. Shushrutha Ayurved College, Bangalore Recommended59. Sri Sri College of Ayurvedic Sciences &

Research, BangaloreNot Recommended

60. Ashwin Ayurved College, Tumkur Not Recommended61. CB Guttal Ayurved Medical College,

DharwadNot Recommended

62. Atreya Government Ayurved College,Banglore

Not Recommended

63. Shri Raghvendracharya Ayurved MedicalCollege, Chitradurga

Not Recommended

64. SDM Ayurved Medical College, Terdal Not Recommended


65. Smt. Rajeshwari Karpurmath MemorialAyurved Medical College, Bijapur

Not Recommended

66. Sri Siddharameshwar Ayurved MedicalCollege, Hospital, Bidar

Not Recommended

67. Shri Siddhvinayak Rural AyurdvedicMedical College, Belgaum

Not Recommended

68. Acharya Desh Bhushan Ayurved MedicalCollege, Bedkihal, Belgaon

Not Recommended

69. PN Panicker Sauhruda Ayurved MedicalCollege, Kasaragod

Not Recommended

70. VPS Varier Ayurved College, Edarikode RecommendedUG-50 seatPG –Swasthavirtta-04Dravyaguna -04 seat

71. KMCT Ayurved Medical College,Kozhikode

Not Recommended

72. Mannam Ayurved Medical College,Pandalam

-

73. PNMM Bharteeyasastra VidyapeethAyurved College, Shoranur

Not Recommended

74. Govt. Ayurved College,Thiruvanathapuram

Not Recommended

75. Shri Narayan Institute of AyurvedicStudies and Research, Puthur

Not Recommended

76. Government Ayurved College, Kannur RecommendedUG-40 seatPG Roga Nidan -05

77. Amrita Ayurved Medical College, Kollam Not Recommended

78. College of Ayurved Medical College &Hospital, Baraghata, Gwalior

Not Recommended

79. Pt. Shivshaktilal Sharma AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Ratlam


80. Smt. Dharia Prabhadevi SojatiyaAyurved Medical College, Bhanpura

Not Recommended

81. Govt. Ayurved College & Hospital,Burhanpur

Not Recommended

82. Acharya Gyan Ayurved College, Indore Not Recommended

83. Ajivan Swasthya Samvardhan AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Satna

Not Recommended

84. Rani Dhullaiya Ayurved College &Hospital, Bhopal

RecommendedUG 50 seat


85. Om Ayurved College, Betul Not Recommended86. Bharti Vidyapeeth’s College of Ayurved,

PuneRecommendedU-100 seatsPGRachna -04Kayachikitsa 05Prasuti & Striroga -04Shalakya-04Swasthavritta- 05

87. Tilak Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Pune RecommendedUG- 100 seatPGRachana Sharir -2Dravyaguna -2Kayachikitsa- -4RogNidan -4,Prasuti Striroga -4,Shalya -3,Rasashastra -2

88. Ashtang Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Pune Not Recommended(UG & PG)

89. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Nasik RecommendedUG-50 seatPGNot Recommended

90. Shri Gangadhar Shastri Gune AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Ahmednagar

Not Recommended

91. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya , RahuriFactory, Ahmednagar

RecommendedUG-60 seatPGKayachikitsa-6,Rasashastra-4,Roga Nidan-4Shalakaya-4

92. Maharashtra Arogya Mandal’s SumatiBhai Shah Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Pune

RecommendedUG-60seatPGKriya Sharir-3,Rachna Sharir-3,Prasuti & Striroga-03Shalya-3


Kayachikitsa-03

93. College of Ayurveda & Research Centre,Akurdi

RecommendedUG-60.seat.PG- recommendedRachanaShrir 04Kachikitsa- 04,Kriya Sharir- 02,RogaNidan- 02,Swasthavritta- 02,Shalya- 02

94. Sangam Sevabhavi Trust’s AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Sangamner


95. Bharatiya Sanskriti Darshan TrustAyurved Mahavidyalaya, Wagholi

RecommendedUG-60-PG.Not Recommended

96. Chhatrapati Sahu Maharaj ShikshanSansthan Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,Aurangabad

RecommendedUG 100 seatPGKayachikitsa -04

97. Yashwant Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,Kodoli

RecommendedUG-65PGRoga Nidan-02,Agad Tantra &Vyavharayurved -02,Shalakya -02

98. Hanuman Shikshan Prasarak Mandal’sAyurved Mahavidyalaya, Kolhapur

Not Recommended

99. Chaitanya Ayurved Mahavidyala, Jalgaon Not Recommended100. RA Podar Ayurved College, Worli,

MumbaiRecommendedUG-60-50 seatPGSamhita-03Shalya-05Kriya Sharir-03Kayachikitsa-08Rognidana-02.

101. Smt. KG Mittal Punarvasu AyurvedMahavidyalaya , Mumbai

RecommendedUG 50 seatPG-


Ayurved Samhita &Darshan- 04Dravyaguna-02Rasashastra-02

102. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Sion, Mumbai RecommendedUG-50 seatPGSamhita -02 seat

103. Yerala Medical Trust & AyurvedCollege, Mumbai

RecommendedUG -60 &PGDrvyaguna- 04Rasashastra-04,Kayachikitsa04,Shalakya-04,Bhashajya Kalpana -04

104. Nalasopara Ayurved College, Vasai,Thane

Recommended

105. Bhau Saheb Maulak AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Nagpur


106. Govt. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Nagpur RecommendedUG-50 seatPGin Kriya Sharir-04,Roganidan-01 andKayachikitsa-02.

107. Shri Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Nagpur RocommendedUG-50 (70-50)PGIn Rasashastra-04 seat

108. Vidarbha Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,Amrawati

Not Recommended

109. DMM Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Yeotmal Not Recommended(UG & PG)

110. Shri Gajanan Maharaj Sansthan AyurvedMahavidyalaya, Pusad


111. Gramin Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Patur Not Recommended112. Lt. Sunil Ramshingji Chunawale Ayurved

College, Chikhli, BuldanaRecommendedUG-40

113. Dr. DY Patil Pratishtan Ayurved College,Pimpri, Pune (MS).

RecommendedUG-50 SeatPGSamhita -04 Rachnasharir-04


114. Government Ayurved College, Nanded UG -50 seatPG not permitted

115. Jupiter Ayurved College & TariniAyurved Hospital, Nagpur

RecommendedUG-40 Seat

116. Annasaheb Dange Ayurved College,Sangali

RecommendedUG-50 SeatPGRachana Sharir 02

117. Manjara Ayurved College & Hospital,Latur

RecommendedUG-50 Seat

118. Loknete Rajarambapu Patil AyurvedCollege, Sangli


119. Rural Institute of Ayurved & ResearchCentre, Hospital, Myani

Not Recommended

120. Mahatma Gandhi Ayurved College,Hospital & Research Centre, Wardha

Not Recommended

121. Mahila Utkarsh Ayurved College,Hospital & Research Centre, Washim

Not Recommended

122. SSUD Ayurved Medical & Hospital,Washim

Not Recommended

123. Shri KR Pandav Ayurved College &Hospital, Nagpur

Not Recommended

124. Padamshri Dr. DY Patil College ofAyurved & Research Institute, Narul,Navi Mumbai

RecommendedUG -100 seat

125. Mayurbhanj Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,Distt MAYURBHANJ

126. Government Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,Patiala

Not Recommended

127. Desh Bhagat Ayurvedic College &Hospital, Fatehgarh Sahib

Not Recommended

128. Mai Bhago Ayurvedic College forWomen Muktsar


129. Guru Nanak Ayurved College & HospitalMuktsar


130. Guru Nanak Ayurved College &Research Institute, Ludhiana

Not Recommended

131. Shaheed Kartar Singh Sarabha AyurvedCollege & Hospital, Ludhiana

Not Recommended


132. Babe Ke Ayurved College & Hospital,Moga

Not Recommended

133. Saint Sahara Ayurved Medical College &Hospital, Bhatinda

Not Recommended

134. National Institute of Ayurved , Jaipur Recommended-UG-92 seatPG-Not Recommended( All Subject)

135. MMM Govt. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,Udaipur


136. Shri Bhanwar Lal Dugar AyurvedVishwabharti, Sardar Shehar

Not Recommended

137. JR Tatia’s Shriganganagar College ofAyurvedic Sciences, Shriganganagar

RecommendedUG-50seat

138. Punjab Ayurved Medical College &Hospital, Sriganganagar

Not Recommended

139. College of Ayurved, Rajasthan,Rajasthan University, Jodhpur

Not Recommended

140. Shikhawati Ayurved Medical College,Pillani


141. Govt. Ayurvedic College, Kottar,Nagercoil, T.N

Not Recommended

142. Government Rishikul Ayurved College,Haridwar

Not Recommended

143. Himalayaiya Ayurved Medical college,Dehradun

Not Recommended

144. Patanjali Ayurved Medical College,Roorki, Haridwar

Not Recommended

145. State Ayurved College, Luck now Not Recommended146. Rajkiya Lalit Hari Ayurved College,

PilibhitNot Recommended

147. Shri SG Minority Ayurved College,Gazipur


148. Aligarh Ayurved & Unani College &Hospital, Aligarh

Not Recommended

149. Yagya Dutt Sharma Ayurved College,Khurza


150. Sri Sai Ayurved College & Hospital,Aligarh

Not Recommended

151. JD Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital,Aligarh

Not Recommended

152. Major SD Singh Ayurved Medical College& Hospital, Farrukhabad

Not Recommended

153. Faculty of Ayurved, Institute of Medical Not Recommended


Sciences Banaras Hindu University,Varanasi

154. Shri Dhanwantry Ayurved MedicalCollege, Mathura (U.P.)

Not Recommended

155. Bharat Ayurvedic Medical College,Muzaffarnagar (UP)


156. JB Roy State Ayurved College, Calcutta Not Recommended157. Institute of PG Ayurved Education &

Research at Shyamdas Vidya ShastraPeeth, Calcutta

Not Recommended

Unani

S.No. Name of the college Decision of CCIM1. Govt. Nizamia Tibbia

College,HYDERABAD (A.P.)Not Recommended

2. Ayurvedic & Unani Tibbia College, NEWDELHI

Not Recommended

3. Jamia Hamdard, NEW DELHI UG- RecommendedPG- Not Recommended

4. Unani Medical College & Hospital, IAMS,SRINAGAR (J & K)

Not Recommended

5. Kashmir Tibbia College, SRINAGAR (J &K)

Not Recommended

6. Jamia Tibbia Deoband, Distt.SAHARANPUR (U.P.)

UG recommended,PG not recommended

7. Ajmal Khan Tibbia College, ALIGARH(U.P.)

UG recommended,PG recommended in nonclinical subjects but notin Clinical subject

8. Aligarh Unani Medical College & A.C.N.Hospital, ALIGARH (UP)

Recommended


Agenda Item No.11 Declaration of Resolution/notificationPassed/issued by CCIM regardingpractice of Modern Medicine by ISMpractitioners.-as ultra virus.

It was noted that Civil Writ Petition No. 10033/2005 was filed by NationalIntegrated Medical Association before High Court of Kerala atEranakulum. The petitioners were holding ISM qualification and were also


practicing Modern Medicine on the basis of CCIM notification issued fromtime to time (especially notification dated 19.05.2004 and 30.10.1996)and wanted protection of the Court. The Court vide judgment dated7.02.2006 dismissed the above petition and observed that CentralCouncil cannot issue notifications enabling ISM practitioners to practiceModern Medicine. If the practitioners are having enrolment on StateMedical Council of Modern Medicine under the Indian Medical Council Act,1956, only then they are entitled to practice modern medicine.Therefore, National Integrated Medical Association filed and LPA againstabove judgment vide W A No. 1260/2006 which has also been dismissedby stating that Medical Advances mentioned in Section 2 (e) of the IMCCAct, 1970 can not be interpreted to means Allopath Medicine.

The SLP was filed by the Central Council of Indian Medicine in Hon’bleSupreme Court of India. The Supreme Court of India has dismissed thesame.

As opinion of the Retainer was obtained regarding the legality ofnotification issued by CCIM opined as under:-

“1. I have pursued the case file Ld Single Judge, Division Bench of HighCourt, Sr. Adv. PP Rao of Supreme Court and the Supreme Court itself,are all in agreement on this issue i.e. ISM practitioners can not bepermitted to practice ‘modern scientific medicine’, which is an altogetherseparate system of medicine and regulated by altogether differentenactment.

2. As per law recently settled by the Apex Court, once any provisionhas been declared ultra virus by any High Court, it is not onlyapplicable in that State, but to the whole country. As such, ourNotification dated 19.5.2004 stands quashed.

3. An analysis of the said Notification dated 19.5.2004 also revealstwo glaring details;

a) Firstly, it empowers ISM practitioners to practice “modern scientificmedicine”, which is untenable.

b) Secondly, emphasis has been made on “modern advances”, whichgives impression of advances made in modern medicine, i.e.allopathic system of medicine.

4. Since CCIM is duty bound to incorporate newer improvements inthe field of medicine, an accordingly improve our curriculum etc.,there may be a case to move away from the word “modern” and toissue a fresh notification incorporating “technological advances ofrelevance” in the field of Indian Medicine, that gets support fromthe ‘Mukhtiar Chand’ Judgment.


5. This issue needs to be deliberated by the Ex-Council/CCIM before afinal decision is arrived at.”

As per legal opinion on the notification 2004 issued by CCIM regardingpractice of modern medicine is referred above the notification andother letters issued in this respect by the CCIM does not sustained inLaw.

Executive Committee decided to withdraw the notification alsodecided to obtain the legal opinion from Advocate of SupremeCourt and call him for discussion in the ensuing meeting ofExecutive Committee.

Agenda Item No.12 Reporting of the decision in respect ofrecommendations of CCIM furnish tothe Government of India under Section13 A of IMCC Act, 1970.

It was noted that recommendations in respect of following colleges weresent to the Government of India as required under Section 13 A of IMCCAct, 1970. Now, the Government of India has conveyed the decision asmentioned against them in addition to inform in previous meetings. It isalso noteworthy to mention here that Government of India also pointedout certain shortcomings and askrd to fulfill the shortcomings by30.6.2010. College was also submitted the compliance.

S.No.

Name of theCollege

Purpose ofVisitation

Decision ofExecutiveCommittee

Decision ofGovt. of India

1. Nitishwar Ay.MedicalCollege &HospitalBawan Bigha,KanhauliP.O. RamanaMUZZAFARPUR842002

To start PG in

Kayachikitsa 06Shalya 06Panchkarma 06Shalakya 06Prasuti & Striroga 06Kaumarbhritya 06Rasashastra 06Dravyaguna 06Sangyaharan 06

Notrecommended

Government ofIndia also didnot agree toissue the Letterof Intent.

2. DGM AyurvedMedicalCollege, Gadag

PGKaumarbhritya 05Swasthavritta 05Rognidan 05Prasuti & Striroga 05Shalya 05

Recommended toissue the Letterof Intent to startPG Course asfollows:-

Government ofIndia has issuedthe Letter ofIntent vide letterNo. R.14011/34/


Kaumarbhritya 05Swasthavritta 05Rognidan 05Prasuti & Striroga 05Shalya 05

2009-EP dated07.6.2010.

Executive Committee noted the same.

Addl. Agenda Item No.1 To consider the fixation ofemoluments for Consultant RTI,Legal Consultant and 04 Assistantfor the office of the CCIM.

It was noted that as Executive Committee in its various meetings haddecided to engage the Consultant RTI, Legal Consultant and 04 Assistantfor the office of the Council.

Earlier there was a provision of fixation of emolument for re-employmentof Consultant after the retirement. But now Government of India videOM No.16012/30/2008-Estt. (Allowance) dated 8.4.2009 has withdrawnthe same.

In view of the above, following emoluments are suggested by the office.

i) Consultant (RTI & Legal) Rs.20,000/- per months(consolidated)

ii) Assistant Rs.15,000/- per months(consolidated)

Executive Committee approved the same.

Addl. Agenda Item No.2 Ratification of the Action Taken byPresident, CCIM.

It was noted that the Shri Lal Babu Mahto, UDC after rendering theservices of 37-1/2 years in this council is going to retire on 30.06.2010on superannuation.

As preparation and maintenance of Central Register of Indian Medicine isone important work of the CCIM and office is facing the acute shortagestaff since long, therefore, services of Shri Lal Babu Mahto may beobtained after the retirement. President, CCIM agreed to it.

Executive Committee ratified the action taken of President, CCIMand decided to pay Rs.12,000/- per month as consolidated salary.


Addl. Agenda Item No.3 Approval of the Minutes ofrecommendations of meeting ofthe Committee constituted toengage Consultant (R.T.I.) heldon 28th June, 2010 at New Delhi

It was noted that as Executive Committee in its various meetings hasdecided to engage the Consultant RTI, Legal Consultant and 04 Assistantfor the office of the Council.

In view of the above, advertisement was issued to engage Consultant(RTI) in newspaper and interview was held on 28.6.2010 and theSelection Committee consisting of following members decided as under:-

1. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma President, CCIM2. Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan Vice-President, (Ayurved)3. Prof. Hakim Syed Khallefathullah Vice-President (Unani)4. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha)5. Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi Member EC

“The Committee agreed to engage the following candidate temporarily forR.T.I. work/purpose on consolidated salary for a period of three monthsinitially and after assessing the work, the further continuation may beconsidered. If not the candidate from the waiting list may be engaged :-

1. Shri Gopal Prasad Chand

Waiting List :-

1. Shri Vijay Kumar Joshi2. Shri Ram Swaroop”

Executive Committee approved the same.

Addl. Agenda Item No.4 Other matters discussed by theExecutive Committee

Recommendations in respect of NIUM, Bangalore and NIS, Chennai besent as per policy letter issued by Government of India.

Recommendations in respect of Rajasthan Unani Medical College beconveyed as per policy decision.


Executive Committee decided to conduct the visitation of ZVM UnaniMedical College, Pune by Dr. Bashir Ahmed, Member, Unani Committeeand Dr. Shamshad Bano, Unani Expert for verification of the figure of IPDrecord in respect of number of OPD, Number of bed days occupied andnumber of patients admitted in the hospital specifically.

It was noted that Dr. Rashidullah Khan pointed out that the workdistribution of the employees of CCIM were not equal. In view of thesame, Executive Committee authorized Dr. Rashidullah Khan toassess the work of the employees of CCIM weekly for two monthsand reported to the President, CCIM.

Meeting concluded with the vote of thanks to the Chair.

^*^^*^*^

^*^*^*^

minutes of 158th meeting of executive committee held … · 2019. 9. 17. · 4. vananchal...

Documents