mixing methods in the discipline of politics by renske doorenspleet
DESCRIPTION
Mixing Methods in the Discipline of Politics by Renske Doorenspleet. (A) Quantitative and Qualitative Methods. Qualitative methods : Words Small-N Cases central Points of view of participants Researcher close Theory development Process Unstructured Contextual understanding - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Mixing Methods
in the Discipline of Politics
by Renske Doorenspleet
2 of 10
Quantitative methods:
NumbersLarge-NVariables centralPoint of view of researcherResearcher distantTheory testing StaticStructuredGeneralization Hard, reliable dataMacro
Qualitative methods:
WordsSmall-NCases centralPoints of view of participantsResearcher closeTheory developmentProcessUnstructuredContextual understandingRich, deep dataMicro
see also Bryman (2004: pp.286-288)
(A) Quantitative and Qualitative Methods
3 of 10
(B) Mixing Methods: Lieberman’s framework
How would you investigate the same questions by using mixed methods?
Tarrow (1995): triangulation: use of qualitative and quantitative methods to answer one and the same research question
But how? Read: Lieberman, E.S. (2005). ‘Nested Analysis as a Mixed-Method Strategy for Comparative Research’ in American Political Science Review, vol. 99, no. 13, pp. 435-452
4 of 10
Explanation framework
Two crucial steps:1. large-N quantitative analyses (LNA)2. small-N qualitative analyses (SNA)
a. model testingb. model building
(B) Mixing Methods: Lieberman’s framework
5 of 10
Some examples of studies using framework
1. Relationship economic development and democracy
2. Relationship civic culture and welfare
3. Relationship international trade and human rights
(B) Mixing Methods: Lieberman’s framework
6 of 10
(C) Mixing Methods: Strengths and Weaknesses
Strengths: combination of best of both worlds
1. Better concepts and measurements; caused by more internal validity (SNA) and more external validity (LNA)
2. Better case selection; clear guidelines and criteria for case selection in SNA
3. Better contribution to theory development
7 of 10
Weaknesses
1. Not always better concepts and measurements
2. SNA is nested within LNA, so in the end LNA determines research agenda
3. Incompatibility thesis
(C) Mixing Methods: Strengths and Weaknesses