modality central problems of philosophy
DESCRIPTION
Joseph meliaTRANSCRIPT
-
! "#
$%& '%
%( !#)$
"*
+$
,- !
!% !%
"".
# , "/
$ %(
'
&0 **
#''1 %
-
2%3445
'*+ 6
&34456
6!0780 9*':!87:;
/'+75?@7AB/'+75?>CAB
6
'0
"-(6!* !
-
#(
7 / 7
3 % 37
5 ; =5
? % >7
8 D 5* 7>
-
6
&0/'&,0!6%$ !& /' # ' & * * " 6 $&:%%$,-:%6%
6D#"# *!'%%!%,(
$
-(D%.
E 6:,'E9
E0
&/'
"% % F6 %G
A7
-
6!%"%F60$%,GA3443B78H5=#DE!
-
!!"# $%#%%%
'
() *+
*
*,
-
)
+
*+
*.
-
/
0
1/234234)0
3 )
35336!%6
6
)
3
3+30303/
.
2.4
2.4)
)
7
24
)2.
4
6
/
-
%8%9$
/
,(
/
3
234 3
234
7
2.4
. .
7
:24
)
-
3
.%8%9$
;
5
-
@
?
-
0
=C
= =:=)./
B
7
=
7
%)'
.
'
/
=?
=
)+
'
-
'
'
+
'
#
.
7D
E+
*
/
.
B
DE
D
-
?
'B 7 ;
6
!
?
*
*
*
C
/ +
=
>
%
-
B
):G='*
:G=
:G= B
=
CF/:G=
# ?
/2%8%9$42H!H42%8%9"42H!H4+
@
5B
B
!!H
B
B
!!H
B
/2 4
2 B
!!H4
>
( 24I
$ J
>
-
=
K
" .B
*J
*J
*L
-
5
+
)
*.
.
=
)
-
)(
7
+
-
%$4=7
@
,-
242D
E4/
) 5
-
.
.
=234=B
B
.
J
)
+
.+
@
.
%8%$?
-
'/ .
55
5
-
0 02
42
42
4
7
B
6
-
00
?
/
0
(
2!42"4
3
.
!" ! /!
!
6
5
5
7
;%8%9$%8%9$
%8%9$
-
.
234
)
F
J
. '
B/2 4
.
/
6
;
/
1
/
D
-
&
(
/
6
6
2
4
2
4
B
264B
247
+
.
-
'
5=
/
0
-
#
((
/
+
('
=
+
,
,
/
DE NODE
-
5!
/
24
24)24
0=+&
5
!
! #
!D! E
&DE&/! (
% NO
# .
!%
-
5
3
!"
"$N!N"ND"$E
-
3 ON
?234
D"O!E3"24
!24
7
)-?,.
!!0(2
!(4
! D!ON!E 0 (2
!
!(4)'
'
! J
-?, * (2
4242424
-?,
!D!E)-?,)
-?,2
!4
!
-
%
3/)=
3J3
.
=
6
! 5 /
!
!
)=
*;2 4
,
9 9
K)!/
!
&
(
-
2;4
-?,=
!
*7/
!)/!B
=)
1
24
-
N-?,F
/2NNNNNNNNNNNN4;
)
+
+
.3
3
+3
/2
4
2%8%9$46
5
-
5
53.
/6/.3
/QDO%ER)
7
F
+
-
-?,N
-?,)-?,
7
-?,
-
!"!#$%!&'(!
)&'(!!*
!+,+ -!% .!&'(!+&'(
.
!
/.
! "
!"!0&'(!
%
"!"!/
*- !#
!*1
1!
)
!%
-
!2&'(!)3!)45"
!67$#,!8!8.93!!)!):":!%&'(
9!
)1!)!5)
65)165)1
6
&'(!;;
0
!%
!:
!&'(,%:56!!*!
!!+,)56
!&'(.!
)5'
6!*795'65"
-
65%!6"
&'(!
" !
-
!)! 5 6!;@
(&'(8+(9A!"
!)1
!;B
?
&'( 9 5 6!
?
!M+
5Q!, R !%
R
1.+( 2, /Q!, R!#!+7,#
91 !
( < =!=!*"
-
= =!%
=!"! =!) ) =!>;
O
!)
&'(!!+!
C!% C ! ' &'(Q! C, R C!!)
9 C!*
Q! C, RQ! C, CR5Q! C, CR6
5 CQ! C, CR6!+
!)1Q! C, CR!
3.+( 2((,( /'
.!"FI!
-
+!@
-
!/Q! C+ RQ! C+ R3!"1Q! C+ R
!?Q! C+ R Q! C+ R!Q! C+ R!*Q! C+ R!*
!
)!%
!*
!
!)
!$
)9&'(!(&'(Q! C+ R N!/
1!
(!1
!"!"
!!"!
-
!*,?,"
,)
,%
. ! %
(7!)
9
!"
9
!
!-!>B
"!)
!4 !&:!+!)
!+
-
!?.1
!11,
?Q! C+ R ! /
!%! C+!#!+1!"!+
!"!%!+
!)
!
) ! "
1!%
"
-
! !"
!#$%$ !
!#$$%#$%#$%&'(( !
!
)
)
*+
,
-
.
!/ !"
0& ! !#.%&
(
-
1)1 )
)
2*3,
. )
)(
45/
6)789:&8
-
7 ",;8481
-
8 ),>?))) ) ) @
)&) ) ) #%A5).)
&:
(
)B)BB))B
()
-):':-
)B'-'' )!'
):): !7B !7)B) !, ! A!-
-
0 !7 ! !7B)
"):- )!B0
B5#ACADE%#$%-)0 )!,ACADE$-)
89:))
4,:A(A
))89:
089:
7))&)
)7))
0>
"
7) )
)
(
-
FF )
0G
))-)7)/)/ )
01( ) -)
7
A) 0)
7()0)
-
91) 55 *
67
8#%E 5 H8
08
?)
/19
7)
81
)
-
0 44 0 / FF)(
7)
)7)) ")
5))#D % !-#$%#$3"%#3"%#$% # 3 "%7 !DB ! B!8)
:
"
9 6 )&
-
=! ID
&
A! .I3
7)#%#I% A! A!4&
*! .3
063 ) -
. =! *! A7
89:
1#%#%# %+ J#%#5
3%0-
)81
-5,#77%K
0 0
-
&I7
8# %=L:
-
("::10
))6&:7:1&
(! . 0!
7 (! (!&
0 0!
/) (!%0 0!& 0!
. 0!
:, 0!)# %
#%-0 (! 0! (!:17 (!1 #% ) # %
-
?:1
4
&
)M
)J)/) 7))"#%-#%#%#%7)) 7 ) #(
%#(0%0#(%0#%#0%(#0%#
%((
7# %9#(%:1&)#(%
$#%)#%)(#%
-
9#7 %#7 %.=A)=A5=A0=A)7)=A.=DA
0M=DA))
) .
/(
))
71
818
6(8
8 781
-
"
#% F#.ACADE%
#ACADE%"1#.NI31%#I%#.N31%#I%1
#I3%I#3%
"#%=EG
#.%(#.ACADE%#7ACADE%#7ACADE%
"#% #.3%) 8 # 3!%,3>I3I0
3 3 587#I%#
3!%0#%#
3!%
,
0)(#. OB!%)B# , # 3!%1,#.3%#%#%)(#3%71
-81)
581=H8 3
-
0?8
781F3F
I718"
8 30 F#.3%08)
,>J5#%,)28(8#(81
& 81 "
-
?0781
MI3
(
M8785&)0)
>6>, ) >0
: ) -!7!$!B
!$5$BB5 5).
-
1B0
4 )
:#,>,
>%#)%=+
6 7
"1,0 (6)
= " 7($(&$
&7
1
A ((6 =
-
&0,$#%$
$" (
$7$
* " %(/($HPAQ"$+P$
0$#HPAQ%& ( $
,)81
8
-
9) #7 % 7
2 8 /
0& &) &(
1.
)
-
*)F)1)
.4
"
0
0
7
(11 5
$ 0 $&89: !M#$0%
0A < 89: )
. F
-
)
JA)
-
G&
SBOSBBO
7
2)
)#
%(M )
0
5 RR)0#%/)1))-
))1
)7
&T B!' 'RB!U=0)
4&
!'R!
(M#7 ) ) )1)%
-
-
)#%&1
0 !'R!5 !RR/)0 !)( )! ! F )! "038)
####=>
B) # 8
$*######## # ## C # ###
2#
)
## )##8)
# 8
-
##18)
-
#G
$+=+2#
:##"2"
!"(2"
()###"#
/0#
G #")#/0/0"H#/0"/20
* #
2#
##8# # #%##
H/0#####)#)#
-
)#
/0:##/0)
#
##))+#C+##+"#)
#$
; # #)#H#
)$#&13'
:$/0 /0# )##/0
###
#/0
+I
*$#8)
#))##$#"##$#######
-
*$D;9$"%####$'
1
$D;9$J/; 0 /0##
.! ! /0
! *#)
#! ##
#*#
#8#/
0/K0/L(0"8
###$#
-
:
7#78M#)NI
$)82#/
#0J) $# # H# 8$8;
82#/"
"0#"
-
#
&/0
3#$/2
0#)#$/20/#0#
"
72
3%$2#*)7
"+FOI+F>I#)
#
$##8##&
##
(#$#2#$;%)#2
$#P%#)# )#+N# 8)
#
#
-
?8
; ### )$QG+N# %!&)($+N#J#### # $#G##$#$###$"##
2#$#)#1#C#(:)/"
"02
$ #2#
&*
H)3
##)
-
)
#(B##)#(
P
# (#@'#
###
#C##
##(##2#
$
$##+
$'
*##"
%# # ##C
&P9
#$
#
"#""$)(9%#))#
-
($##(####
"%$%1#3##$
#$%#9%$ *Q
3
J$#))))!#8# 1#?# #K#($##($)#K
(
(K
($($K##8=)
"
H$#$")(?## $'
$ ) ( &
#G#2#
# #
-
#
)$"
$#$
/#$0)&)##
$/#$0O()
1$/
#$0(#
*$
#
#%$/
#$0/#$90
2##)$)(#("#(')##
##(#(1"(###
#7
9####:#)
$($
!
! !!
.#9#
(3###()
"
$(1
-
###$$/0/)
0
/0"$(
$##*#)/0@
##2##$
:%8 $ 2
#@ # 3
3
).
)&
$#
!8)$ ')#
?(@K@$"
+=$+=&
$28)
'#$
7>
2#%"
-
#$
C
%/0*
(&9%
2$)
( K
#K
#K$
#'$(1))E#$#+#$#=%##)(K+K=))'8
(
*
(
)
9(
($M (! (!/0"#
#
29#$9##$"$##
#"#"
-
#9%#)DC
$
)
):D9
###;
#
###?$$#
8
($(#('(1(%#%
"J9%#
#'
/:# 0##
## /0 3 :
)# N
&("/:#0###:#M
:
#:R
3:#
-
(*1#%): &&%)
: #8)#%: !#*
!:)#
2
#9%)
3#S2#3#
K$#K&K
$#K
"/K# 0$1K$?9% / K 0' *#
K$K?#
#K & # ?9%)KK#2#
#9'/
KK0@#
-
:$@72 9% #
1#
##$$#))##8##(!###))##
*$
)#$8#:)##.8/K0#8F/#0/$##(
$##01J/;0
/#
0+I
J9%/0$#
)(("
B%
(C#/;
0++"%"%#$#
)'$)))7$
-
)#$#$J')/0)/$0():%##
##
)79%#
#))
#
##
;$##$!
$
#C#+=
*
#
28$#
#1/"%0%
'2#
#
#&$%#
*#$"$#)9%$"###
-
$
9$#+O.)
##
$9%29###19%((C(J
BJ)$#'#
# J # # )
T#
#9(#
29%J##
###C##J9
#%)"""9
MM#:($" & " 9% "(19%
9$#(J#)""#$'
-
"##
($##)
@##$"$#($+>2###B$1$$)(#%#A*%$#
:$
#$#'($L3(#$"$
7..$#( ' $($2###
#$#(#$L3
B#$$2#$(" $(*$
$
2#
).##")#
#+N*##
J'
-
)& 9 # 9
($)
?$ )#
9#
9##'88+R2
8 +IOI8+I>I28
)8
98#)8)
989
#
8#)U1$
U1$
2U1
U1#$#E8
H98)9%#9
-
(2(8
($9#J)###@#9%$)#
!
?#$1
"
)J
H$
#
#'
""
3
)#
#)
. 3 !
$")$
$#"*)"
$)
#"B
3 $: $ $)#'8# ( "$%(
-
B##)
9#
$#$ $
/#0'9/##0+!9:$)7
*
"" # # & '")
)#:7
9##$
:$'"#$#$
##2
J##'
1(((
)C
*($)8.9
-
+F(
(#1## # # ##%*####%2#
#% %#)#'
G # &C$)
$
##=I
*#!
!
'
1((
#
#)J@$###@#
&()(
-
. ( %1!%#)
!!! 2##!#C)&2#
#$)#$"
2####"#
#7
2# #G### ###.#.#.%#)
"#
#####.*%#()'2)#
# # $#)##
-
#72
)# #
)
#*)'
2##)
2)$)#2)#.
##"2)#
*##'
2
:7)
#))7*2 )
$ & 2 # 7
2#2
&$(*#2
$
-
8.
#
(2#$ #
%2(
(
### "##28
#&$#*$
# # 2# #)
)%'###$#)2
#2
%
#)$#8)#
*##
*$#
-
&%8
2$2 ###'
2V 1(
B
*#!$)8'
MHP H$2V
9(MHP $$*
)($8
'"+"= "G((("+"O)"=V+B(((12V (*"="> 3=((*(
###(##"+"O "V+# ( #(
&((;((
#"+
-
!
! "#$ "%&%
' &('"#"
#
")"
" #%))"*
-
+"),-"./"/))'"))))0
#%1"))2))3&4%( 5 "))-')678)1)"..).-4')-)9:&;:
-
;:;:;&&:;-+
-
&)&"@@"%A(B&-%&)C
)/))2
&""(26&)) ))+
4(3'-:;3
A4C):;C))!:;+)))("!)!#4/-+
-
:;0)#
,-
-
0C'))C:!;:,;"'4'4#%
'
-
%"!C
G(
3
02"))&%4412('%""-)1'") ))A:&;4:&;4*%4*
2
12303+)
-
): ;!):;&"): ;C).
(&"!&
#""1&%@"@/@"@
"=H# #-"3>)
0)
C@4&4&2IA,%4
-
+!!#'4"
&)% "IA,IA,"(4%/
-
&
'-&)*%*0-)3
.
=='.%)
&).- #"!))C)//)!"2(:') ( "%& !!;=7 #I-
-
%))1C))4:;&
#:;"%&!!#&()*+,&-.:;'):-;:-;140#%&!!I I # %& #!& !! %&!!%&"4"
0- 30 "%1%&"3#I-&))#))%&!!#!&%!&!!>#%)
-
#4%& !(.*.,&+#)#-", # #" &""%
C-
4#):;:;."):;#
03'0%&!!%&'%'
&"0
4)
'%&!!))=%&3&)
)
-
'C%))-&)4
03#)"-##!')%)4"%&!!I&.-C.)"(&"#!&!!
04)03#)#-%
%
1-).--)@)"
2.
!))'
-
'#0##2
1.(4& # (@"/4@
0 ) 39 >'!
%
+2 .)5&!!" ! !!.))
'4/IA,%%%0:&;
-
2 "& ."#!""!""%%!"4)"
#))%
-
") "31 ! "'-!"02"
&%%"C""E&"C1EC%#"0-0
+ & % 2 C -# @=&"0%$"%K0LK0LK$LK$LK$LK$L.%0%/
-
% 9 1%'56(
#"-,MK0LK$LN#0A$$92$
C0"%/-%)1'
'5?",!,390 !%00% #%)
+--
-
4%
,C,)C)%",& 522404% 20 4%G)!'#%2=8"-%
)4(-
C4"-)% " @%%-4
#"#4%:&
-
;:A;
= 1!2+2
%C2
>2%)%'#%
(5-%)
& 2&)%( 2=? ! %
7 1!2&) ' " ! &
" ! %)
-
#!(%
.="%7! &%%%% ' - %
! =B0#
'!-
"4I'# )'-&!" C
-
C)%!!& " C
"///)//)
-
4 )=6'",-0 4)%,(
) 4,-)
0#4(
O 4-)4"%@4%
O ')@4 (
C4
()"))))
,-4"# =D&$$!!"'
-
=F/""
,- 4 )%
"',)4%7H
!)(
% &))7=
1
))
0)-/4&4,-'"
,))77&!''#,(
(
))/ / : ) );/
))9
-
1:%;7
,(4)>$)2$C2$22$789))!$&$
)$
)$
'))5"!'2
-
# "
&*44"
,2"(4
/%
'
-:;,:
" ';7?9 & 0'
'"4( 27B& !MN/2
"12) !%2 &9%%A)%,
-
%76@ ,-
, ,- ( 4
4%-(%)))),%"
1(
0)"'"0
137D
&244G''%))"("
#"&"$223'$23'$1!&!!2#"4)'! )
-
!'!!& !''& A%1 &"
'
-))!''
:";%
!'''
&(!'' ) )0"-!
-)) ! ' ' "&
"%
&/"014%%&@"!%!%
!
"0"%
-
$"$$
#",,)
""(7F
",CC1"%C"9C"0"C".C-
#+
"%C"1"11%
!,2C1
"
#1
,2))''''(
'))/
-
" 03H
#
%
"))9,)
"4
"
* , -
-
!!"# $ #%#%&
'(&)*+'' % ,
'
%!##!#-
!!./0
#!%-
1
# 2$#!
-
1
&''''%#1'3&
3%
$'
#/%
$!!
4!!2#!!2
!
'$'
"# '2' .'5%'# 1 %%6#
-
+#'112
'!'
'$'$-1''''
#%$#'#'
#!!%&''5''''.'%!
' 5 '!()'%
'3'7''''8'
%'!'%/''/.1
-
7%' , '
'!
-
' /
"!%,!-!'()'%'$! % $%
!'
2%!()'9'.!"% ! - /%!!%!!!!
$'-:
-
'
.;
-
!'$''3'()@3'
()!1'A'
()!!'
/ ! %!02'2''1%''05+'-#
+%B C3 %% 3 % , D
+'!'%''-%%+ - +"!
'%$',
-
?-
*'()BC
; * ' ( )B C
= %
2!# %!*%
!'%1 4' (=B>) %
!'
=#!'
+'-2'! 1 ' 1!+=%'%!!$
% ' 2 ' ? '!!
-
!-1!
!'''''';=''$
()9''
2() '#!'%='!'
#!'2' ($')!7
7 ' 2 '1
&',1
! % 1E
-
9 19!
%
!%1!%!
"
2
'%F
$%!%.%
!%2'%G
*!%!
() % /'HH H
%!'''! 0/%!&!'%
-
': 3> ' '
+ %'"%%1
$
:1"1'"0
+ 1
'?''%1'1#$%
#'%''()()'/ '-#2%I+! J
-
''1% +
-..1+-2''
/!
&' ' -
'
/ ' : ?''1'1-2
%% 0:!"%
'+%%
$#2%%%
/%09!!'
&'''%!
-
'!#!!%'*11"#$!'1"#'"1"#$'' ;
"63'''3'1"
5!5
'':1 $ % $$%-
6 2%
'
" # !' =
-
'$%%%.
$:2$'
5%%%!''
%%- % % %%2%$&%&$
#!%-
KLM $&NH$"H H&H&"H H$&H$H$H&
"%%1!'%% + %%
KLM'%%
9%%%
9%% >$ ! !!
-
-
%
/ ' 0#!!''%''
:%%/%%0-% % %.%%%%6 '' %%%
'.%
%
/&%%'
'9'$'
-
.'
$%!
$
-
%!B#( C'%%%+%%%!#('#(%
/ ' %%/'%3%
*B#( CB#(, C$ &, $Q&
; *B#( CB#, C($ '&, $&
' : KH#(H#M
KH#H#(M%4%&'% %''$!%'
$ ' #$KH$M'%#(KH(M4
-
2 ' !$+
%2#!!%%!
# 1 '2'#$&KH$H&M
'()0#! $&KH$H&M'()&'
-
'.'%!% @
-
## # +
(!)%#%
% #$(+%)!
8#5,%$%'
KH#(H#MKH#H#(M8'KH#MKH#(M
$KH$M
# & % # '$%2#
21 %
!2%$%$
-
5'!2 % 0
!+!'-
''1 D
'&!!(KM'R'!)(
'R) E
$1%
:++'2?!
5%"'S'2!'+!5'%
-
%'
5-'7 %(+) (+ 2) 2::(+)(+2)!2%+%
! 3
(+)3()$
$!#
%#$
!''#'%#&'
-
'%%%%
91
%!%
$%
'%
''!'$''%!% '
'
"!'"!''.'8''''%
''
*!
!'
-
$'T; T!%
+:== $!$
'*
S82'*+,:-:%"', GF=
> 48-.
*=8:2-/H!: GFE@;
@ 9'%'%!!2'!%T*=3EE
-
F 91
'&'! ' S 82+:-:"', GEF#(5/!$"')'
* %
+ +
9-:, GG
; $:>25,
I*'/ #-S! GEE A**9-! GFG
= $''%++
%
> !
A'
@ +%
D 53%
E :-44*44
F 2:=G $':=/
T!' J $
'%!%($)%($%%)&'%%%!
$T8#7%:>
; $($)'%'+%%%%()'%%%*%'.
-
1
%'
%
$&'!%
= 5!3%%
> 2,/#%4'
!
!! /'%'
@ 9 ?%'
-
;@ $2!''+%'!-'
''%'$'
%'' %'* H!BCBC!BC2'' ' 1 '!'V*'1
;D +AI(?:,)
.
2- 5%& GDE I % 2%6
%'$ %
;E 9''
;F 2.(.);G $(B'0C)=J $?
'= 9:
5!!
=; $()/!
()()
== 2'''%
=> /%B CB'L2'C1B C2'$1
(
$!+'+$.1,()'0+'+U3.'%
-
=@ $ /!%
=D $!+4/#*#
=E *'::/'9-9"', GGF
/WT'6(:82-8$, GDJ; $%%$
()BC
= A*(9+?)/
'"
,AH8! 9-! GFJ
> $(1)1'%'
@ *:'-?:.+:#-"':, G>E
D $1$' G>J G@J!%!$'
E ()?
F 5//#*$-"'$, G@G
G $&!!- $'
-
@ $+2*+(8S%)1 * G>F= 3E
D #!.
?L; +
-1= $> 2%
@ ,!:,!(5$
$)1* GEF>E=3@JJ$W*W(R5R$-2*+#$2)":#2S"'8228+I*(,%-,:,/),
*'/ D3D **
D E +L%
!'%S'
F ?1'
G +**G J ,!(5$$)7
!"# /'
#3 ' & '
; T'8
5%'
= +/#($$,/)#/
0
> $1
@ +I!++9-! GFJD +2&7(:$+8#)1
GEG= G3=F
-
E 2,/++9-:, GE>F #,/#
:;,/#!1#!+S#(:$T8#)1 GDF =3;D
G +%'/'-
J 5'47
?L ; #
= S##9-! GE= > 9(4'1
')($'),-1''
@ : S 3 ./5 ' :-:"', G==8S820#/:-:"', GFG D/&5%+/ /#-?HI, GFJ:>
D ##FE E $
-
':!
G 2:E!
J :@!'
+,/++(2,%/)/ GED =G3DJ
; ,(2,/) = +'''
2.S820' 0:-:"', GGE
> $''1'&:E521'
@ &'20#/%'
D + E #6
' E>3G F $()
* 5
''
G 5()#*#''!%
'%
;J A' # ' 1
; #6
' EE;; - EE;= - EF;> +,'($:,/).
GFD F@3; =;@ #6
' EG;D +'($:,/);E #6
';E3DG;F - FJ;G +:@=J #6
' FJ
-
%&'( #6
' D@3E>; :.+= ? D ?+!-:82-8$, GF> G E
-
$- ##!.9-9"',
GE $!'%
T'
; 8#//056-:"', GEG '!
$'%!
)*$!- 2,/++9-:, GE>$
!%'
; S#6
' 9-! GFD2#' : '
!$!#'
=
-
(2$:) */5?9-! GDFGF3 ;'*%;9-! GFD# 2 ++ 3 -: 2 # 56- : "' , GG= ?'%
*A?(8*). GGJ=;E3@>.A?(8**)0 GG@DE3E=.
-
$#!.T*%S#(:+)+S#($) 8I87,I"56!-56!"', GE>#' 9-9"', GF=;@J3DJ: J+&!*:-:"', GEF
T * ! T D>3F.S5(?") GGD;=G3D;.
-
28) GG>DDG3FF./#(?'S#R9,/)1 GFF>;3E.
2'S820#/:-:"', GFG!2.S#(?'S22R2:$,)0
1 GG;; 3;>
1:%+,A($+$)0 GF> ;JD3F. + 1 (2 + $ ,/0)0 GF@D>.=3@D
*#,'($:,/). %7
-
''
.''
=>3D@ 3;F=3G.%.
' F F=3>FGGD3E2?8 ;>= D3; >J3>
D 3E;.. F3G ;2S8 E=;JF
== = => @F D 3;.
!, D= D@ DF:S ;
:? DE@ @@ 3> F:: D;=E ;> =E3>= @E3
F
>J3>
@E3F >J
@3; >G3@J
D@3F @3D G J =J3
= => @= G
J =J3= @=
EG J@3 J @ =J >G3@=
JG3 JI!1 JE3F JD3E J#S.
= .=
G3 JS' E
=
J= @3 D =F >G3@=
4G% J 3=
JG 3 > 3; J =3 >
; ;D > @3 D =F3G
>G3@> J >3;
-
J@3 #S
*I FG@*A G@G*A DE JF
AXI F3G
D 3E;%' D 3;% D;3@
&72 JED&A GD&!!
D=3E; =3 > >;3@> @3 D >G3@='! JD3E
@@3E;
@E3F D 3E;
#H!1 D=3E;
#%
DF3EJ
DJ3E;%! @D3F
() @ER @@3D @G
#!# DG3E;EF
' D=3F% >;;3==J===F3>
D=3G% ; =J=F>J.
T8#.,/#
' JJ#/ J>=
84 E
.
% 3 ; >3 @
3 @.
T/W
F 3GF
T8#(2) F=3>
FG3G;
' F;3G;'
G;3F F 3;
G=1 F
'' E3 F@;3= F3G' =;=D JG =D D' ;3>E 3;ED
JD3F G3 J 3 ; = @ F' ;F=E@G
-
!
D3E@=E> D= D
= @@;3=@G% > ;3 =G=3@ D@;3=% J3 @ F D3E =' JE@ >
' .'
T8#
E; =F3>F@F @;3>@E3DJ =>3D@ 3;
@@3D D 3; DJ3D= >F3D;EE @E >D3E@D3E' @E3DJ' ==3@@D3E
T8#.,/#
;=3E;...
5%+/& ; @ F3G @G3DJ
.
'
=3 > ;= ;G''' =3 >
;D3G.
,!: FG@GE
.,2 JF ;>> = 3@=.
' ===D@@3DDJD;EEF;F@ ;=3= =@ =G >E @= @G3DJ.
! EG J@3 J @ ;=3@
@@3E;.
G J =J3= @=
;> =E3> .
;>
;> = 3E >=3@>.
%
F3;J=DDJ3D; JJ3 J@ ;=3D
' EJ @D ;> ;D3= @@3E;.
,/# ==3D>F3D;.T8#
' @3 D,25H*I ; ;
;3> > F;@3=JE
D3; >J3> D;3E;.
@3D = ;3> > F;@3=JE J= JE >=3@=
' @F3G
%% DD3E;
=>3@G> JG =G
-
' ==3>F@ ;=3= =G
% T/W.%..
T8# =E3G@F =>3DF;3G;G>
JG =J =E =F3>F =F' =G3>F
,/# ;@3D = 3
E >=3@> >=3@> ==3E > 3;' =@3ET8#
=@3E'
>=3@= = 3> @=3>
T/W > D; =;EGD;3EGF G@ JE
ED3G''
E=3G D=3EG% E>3D
DF3E=E@ DE
@3; >G3@= @@3DJ
' =F3G%
DF3E=E@
EJ DGE;3=
;==>>F3G@;3> ;>3D >=3@= @@3E;
.
% >E== = =E >D3E @E3F
++ ; ;;=+!+ D= ;+! ;>; D +2* E@ @+!? ;=@ EJ ;> = 3>.
' .%
'
$!2 JF @E;3= EE
J@3 J JD
JF%'
DD3E;
'
;=3D() @ ;=3D @@3
E() @ 3;
%! = 3; =>$2 JF
' T8#.'
', >@;> >D;DW* FG@
/5 DG
CoverCopyrightContentsAcknowledgements1. Introduction to modality2. Modal language and modal logic3. Quinian scepticism4. Modalism5. Extreme realism6. Quiet moderate realism7. Possible worlds as sets of sentencesNotesFurther readingIndex