model-checking of ctl on infinite kripke structures defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. ·...

20
Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie Quemener, Thierry J´ eron To cite this version: Yves-Marie Quemener, Thierry J´ eron. Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by Simple Graph Grammars. [Research Report] RR-2563, INRIA. 1995. <inria- 00074118> HAL Id: inria-00074118 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074118 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ ee au d´ epˆ ot et ` a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´ es ou non, ´ emanant des ´ etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´ etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´ es.

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jan-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures

Defined by Simple Graph Grammars

Yves-Marie Quemener, Thierry Jeron

To cite this version:

Yves-Marie Quemener, Thierry Jeron. Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke StructuresDefined by Simple Graph Grammars. [Research Report] RR-2563, INRIA. 1995. <inria-00074118>

HAL Id: inria-00074118

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074118

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

appor t de r ech er ch e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite KripkeStructures Defined by Simple Graph Grammars

Yves-Marie Quemener and Thierry Jeron

N˚ 2563Juin 1995

PROGRAMME 1

Page 3: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie
Page 4: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

� ��������� ������������� ���� ��� ��� ��� �!�"�$#%� & '(�$)"�*�+,#-'(."�/#0.�'1��243 �5�!����� 6�7 +��98 ):�;� <='�>?)@�

<='�>�8 8 >?'(2

ACB�DFE�GHJILK9MNDPO�Q�DSRTDSU�DSKVILU�WYX*Z0MNDSK�K9[]\_^DSKa`LUcb

d�egfihaekj9lml*n?oqp rqetsvuFwyxzn�sxz{Fegn�|%}~j9etj9�����n;��n�|��S��ji|�n�|q�Sn��Sfa�F���n;n�|��Fe��n�|�n�j�{F�n;x/|��F|�x$�n;lmn�|1�Sw�|�xgezw���{��n�|d%ezfi��n$x5d%j�l*}~j

�qj�}F}~fiezx��Sn_ezn�svuFn$ekskuFnY�����i�a�i��p �i{Fw�� o$�i�a��p o$��}~j�hin�|

 *¡�¢�£�¤�¥F¦i£¨§~©Pn�}Fezn�|�n;��x%j��*j���hafiezwyxzuFl«ª¬fae­svu�n�sv®�w���h�¯�uFn;xzu�n;e­j9�?wy�S°~�Fwyxzn�xzekj��~|�wyxzwyfi�|���|�xgn;lC���Sn�°��Fn��q���_j�hiekj�}Fu�haekj�l*lVj9e~f�ª±j1ezn�|�xzegw²s�xgn��q®�w��~�L�;w�|³j(lmf��Sn;��f9ª±j0ª¬faezlc{F�²jf9ª�xzuFn?xgn;l*}~fietj9�%�yfihiw�s�´�µ�¶%·³©Pn�°~et|�x_}Fegn�|�n;��x/xzuFnm|����Sxtj9��j9�~�CxzuFnc|�n;lVj��Sxgw²s;|�f9ª´�µ�¶%�Sxgu~j9x�j9ezn��Sn�°��Fn��?¯�w�xzucezn�|�}~n�s�x­xzf�xzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi�m|���|�xgn;lV|��a�²j9�~n;�y��n���¯�wyxzumj9xgfil*w�s}Fezfa}~f¨|�wyxzwyfi�~|·�µ1uFn;�³��¯1n�|�u�f9¯¸uFf�¯«xgfcji�Fj�}FxqxguFnqª¬faezlVj���w²|�l¹f�ª%haekj�}Fu�haekj9lmlVj9et|��ª¬fie?n;��}Fegn�|z|�w��Fh�|�{~skuºw��S°~��w�xzncxzetj9�~|�w�xgw�fi�»|��F|�xzn;lV|·P¼/{Fe?j���hafiezwyxzuFl½xzezn�j9xk|�|�{~sku»j°~�Fwyxzn*egn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�³��j9�~�:l*f���w¾ª¬��wyx;��n;�~|�{�ezw���h�xzu�j9x�xguFn*��j9�~n;���yw��Fh*ª¬fae¿ª¬fiegl�{��²ji|ezn;l�j9w���|¿sfiuFn;egn;��x�¯�w�xgu:xzu�n*xzeg{Fxzu:Àaj���{Fn�|�f�ª/xzuFn��Sw¾Á±n;egn;�Sx�|�xtj9xzn�|¿f9ª�xzu�n*w��S°��Fw�xgnxzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi��|���|�xzn$lC·Â�èijÅzÆ�Ç~¤�ÈÉ¢i§ l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®Swy�FhF�¨´�µ�¶%�SÀ¨n$ezw¾°Ìs;j9xgw�fi�Í�iw��S°��Fw�xgn;ÊË|�xkj�xzn_|��F|�xzn;lV|�ihietj9}Fuhietj9l*lVj�ek|

βÏ?ÐÑNÒ�Ó;Ô ÐÑ0ÕÉÖyÒ�×ÙØkÚ

Û�ܬÝÞܬß;à�á�â³ãvä/å�æ�ç³è;é­êÌégãkæ�ëíìíé�æ�áiîðïòñ�óôkõ;ö­Ý³é�÷�÷�é�çzáøîFÝÞà-ù�â³úÞû�úSï�ä5ãkìíë²ük÷aãvä/égýÉìíþ¬ìíç�ã9û ÿyþ

Unite de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France)

Telephone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – Telecopie : (33) 99 84 71 71

Page 5: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

� ��������L��������������� �C� � � 2­.C'=�C��2 2-#%'�.P�/#­.C'���2 �C�& '��$)P�*� �����º�P�$��2 � ��5�º�P�$��2 )">?' �C��2 ��'�>�8 8 >��$'1��2

�C� �c'1>?):�C��2 20��8 )@�$��2

���Ã�¢�����ø§�qfa{~|?}Fe��n�|�n;��xzfi��|�{F� j���hifaezwyxzuFl*n �¨{Fw/�1�n;xgn;ezl*wy�Fnc|�w�{�� |���|�x$�n;l*nm�Snxzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi� w��S°~��wË�~���n�°��Fw³}~j9e/{F�Fn�hietj9l*lVj�w�egn5�Sn�hietj9}FuFn�|q��� {F��x���}~n¿egn�|�xgezn;wy�Sx$�Sn�|�xfi{��Ffi��{F��l*f��±�n;��n-��� {��Fn%ª¬fiezlc{F�yn%�Sn��²j1�yfihiw��ð{�n0xgn;l*}~fiegn;���yn%´�µ�¶%·�/fi{~|³}Fe��n�|�n;��xzfa�~|���íj��~fiek� �²j |����Sxtj9��nCn;x*�²j |S�n;lVj��Sxgw��¨{Fn �Sn:´�µ�¶%���¨{Fw_|�fi��xV�1�n�°~��w�n�|*|�{Fw�Àaj��SxV��n�||���|�x$�n;l*n�|5��n�xgekj9��|�w�xgw�fa�~|"�n;xgw��¨{Fn;x��n�|(}�j9e?��n�|5}Fezfa}Ìfø|�wyxzw�fa�~|?j9xgfil*w��ð{�n�|�·±d%{Fw²|�Þ��fi{~|l*fi��xzegfi�~|ms�fil*lmn;�¨x?ja�Fj9}Fxgn;eV��nVª¬fiezl�j9��w�|�l*nm�Sn�|chiekj�l*lVj�w�ezn�|?�Sn�haekj9}�uFn�|*}~fi{Fen;��}Fezwyl*n;e³��n1xzn$�²|³|���|�x$�n;l*n�|³��n1xzetj9�~|�w�xgw�fi��w��S°��Fw²|·�qfixgezn�j���hafiezwyxzuFlmn%xzetj�Àaj�w����yn�|�{Fe­snx��S}~n/�Sn�egn;}Fe��n�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa��°~�Fwyn¨�in;x%��jql*f��Sw °~n���nqlVj��Fw��n$ezn��j_ji|z|�{Fezn$e��¨{Fn����z�n;xgw��¨{Fn;xkj�hin}~j9e­�yn�|Þª¬fiegl�{���n�|��Sn;l*n${Fezn�s�fau��n;ezn$�Sx­j;À¨n�s­��n�|�Àij���n;{�ek|%�Sn�À��n;egw�x��n��Sn�|­�Sw Á��n$ezn;��xk|��n$xkj9xt|�S{C|��F|�x$�n;lmn5�Sn_xgekj9��|�w�xgw�fa��w���°~�FwË·�YÇ�£�¢�Åk¦����Ã!§¸l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®�w��Fh��Ì´�µ�¶%�LÀ��n;ezw °±s;j�xzw�fa�³�~|���|�x$�n;l*n�|/���g�n;xkj�xqwy�S°~�Fw��Ìhaekj9lmÊlVj9wyezn_��n¿haekj�}FuFn�|

Page 6: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

������������ ��������������������! "�#�%$'&(�*)+�#��,�-.&0/1�0-./�&��32546�879�:���<;>=�?@&�A0)+ B?C&�A#D6D6A#&�2��

E �%�V#%'����P."�/#0�$�*�

F�f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®Swy�Fh:w�|*j!¯�w��Sn;���º{~|�n�� l*n$xzuFf��!ª¬fae,xguFn"À¨n;ezw °±s;j9xgw�fa� f9ªm��w²|�xgezwy�F{Fxzn��|���|�xgn;lV|�·±µ1uFn?f�À¨n;etj9���³�~n;u�j�À�w�fa{Fe5f�ª�jV�Sw�|�xgezw���{Fxzn�� |���|�xgn;l4w²|ql*f���n;��n��Vja|¿jcxzekj��FÊ|�wyxzw�fa�"|���|�xgn;lC�F¯�uFfø|�nc|�xtj9xgn�|qezn$}Fezn�|�n;��xqxguFn?hi�yfi�~j��­|�xtj9xzn�|qf9ª�xzu�n?�Sw�|�xzegw��F{�xzn�� |���|�Êxzn;l��¨j9�~�*¯�uFfø|�n5xgekj��~|�wyxzw�fa�Vezn;��j9xzwyfi�chiwyÀ¨n�|0xguFnq}~fø|z|�wy�F��n�n;À¨fi�y{Fxzwyfi�~|­f9ª�xzu�n_|���|�xgn;lC·GËx�s$j9�«�~nºskuFn�sk®¨n��!¯�u�n;xzuFn$e�|�{~sku«jºxzekj��~|�wyxzwyfi�Y|��F|�xzn;l w�|,jºl*f��Sn;�_f�ªcj!xgn;l*Ê}~fiekj��q�yfihaw²s�ª¬fiegl�{F��jS·IHq�Sxgw��­ezn�s�n;��xz���ø�Þlmf��Sn;��Ê�skuFn�sk®Swy�FhV¯�ji|�fa�F��� {~|�n��:ª¬fie�°~��w�xzn$Ê|�xtj9xzn"l*f��Sn$�²|�·9J1{Fx$�KF�{F���yn;emj9�~�ML�skuS{F}�}ON*FPL1Qa��R_|�uFf�¯�n�� xzu~j�xVxzuFn"}F{~|�u~�Sf�¯��FÊj9{FxgfilVj�xkjCxzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi�~|?hietj9}Fu�|�u~j;À¨nVj"�Sn�s�w��Fj9�F�yn*l*fa�~ji�Sw�sV|�n�s�fa�~�Sʬfiet�Sn;ecxzuFn;faez�¨·´­fi{Fets�n;�y��n¨�9N ´­fa{�Qi��R��³n;�Sxgn;�~�Sn���xgu~j9x�ezn�|�{F��x$�Þ��� |�uFf�¯�w���h�xzu�j9x?n��¨{~j9xgw�fa�~j9��hiekj�}Fu~|j9��|�fcu~j;À¨n_j?�Sn�s�w��Fj9����n_|�n�s�fi���SÊÙfaek�Sn$e�xzuFn;faez�¨��|�wy�~s�n�´�j�{~s;j9���SN ´�j�{~�i��R��F|�u�f9¯�n��*xzu~j�xxzuFn�}F{~|�u~�Sf�¯��FÊ�j9{FxgfilVj�xkj5xzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi��hiekj�}Fu~|­j9egn1n;��jisxz����xzuFn�ezf¨fixgn��L�;°~�Fwyxzn;Ê��Sn;haezn;n¨�n��¨{~j9xgw�fi��j9�~hietj9}Fu~|·+Tqn$�~s�n¨�a|�fal*n�w��S°��Fw�xgn;ÊË|�xkj�xzn�|���|�xzn$lV|És$j9�*u~j;À¨n1°~��w�xzn�egn;}Fegn�|�n;��Êxkj�xzw�fa�~|���¯�uFw²sku s;j�� �~nC{~|�n��!ª¬faeV�Sw ÁLn$ezn;��x�À¨n$ezw¾°Ìs;j9xgw�fi�»l*n;xguFf��F|�·9UFfie*n$�Fj�l*}F��nø�J1{Fez®aj�ezx?j��~�VL¨xznÁLn$�³�9N*J@L���W�RË�³}Fegn�|�n$�Sx�j9�@j9��hafiegw�xzu�l ª¬fae�xzu�n*l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®�w¾��h*f9ªxzuFn j���xzn$ez�~j�xzw�fa�Fʲª¬ezn;nVlc{FÊËs$j9�²s{F��{~|5fa�!}�{~|�u~��f9¯�� }�ezf�s�n�|g|�n�|·XF�n;xzu�f��F|�}F{F�F�yw²|�uFn��|�f�ª�j�e�|�xg{~�S�Y���#��-Z�3[�-\*�]&����­fie9)^/_2� `�#�#aI�b)^&����0�32�2��32�iw�· n¨·iegn�|�xgezw�s�xzn��?}Fegf�s�n�|z|�j9�yhin;�Fetji||�{~sku*xgu~j9x�xzuFn5wy�S°~�Fwyxzn/xzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi�*haekj�}Fu~|�f9ª�xzu�n;w�e­xzn$ezlV|%j�ezn5}�{~|�u~��f9¯���ÊËj�{FxzfalVj9xtjxzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi� hiekj�}Fu~|·©"n_j9egn5w���xzn$ezn�|�xzn��?w��Vxzu�n5l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®�w¾��h5f9ªc���#D6D6/��`����A�-d�����@7e�+�8-���f2(-dA�-Z�52]=g2(

-���Dh2Kiòª¬fae�|�uFfaezxq´9UXL1FC|�jt�iwË· n¨·i��w²|�xgezwy�F{Fxzn��?|���|�xzn$lV|É��n�|zs�egw��~n��?ja|-°��Fw�xgn;ÊË|�xkj�xzn�j9{FxgfiÊlVj9xtj?s�filml�{F��w²s;j�xzw �Fh_�S�ml*n�|z|gj9han�|1xzuFegfi{FhauBUkGZU%¼ �¨{Fn;{Fn�|�·F�-�n$ezfi� u~ji|�}Fegn�|�n;��xzn��j�|�n;l*w�Ê��Sn�sw²|�wyfi��}Fezf�s�n��S{Fezn�f9ª³xguFn/w��S°~��w�x���f�ª�xzuFn/xzetj9�~|�w�xzwyfi�V|��F|�xzn;l�|Éezn;}�ezn�|�n;�Sxgw��Fh´9UeL1FC|9N �-�n;et�i��R�·�µ1u~j9x�}Fezf�sn��S{Fegn��Sn;xgn�s�xt|És�n$ezxkj�w���|�n �ð{Fn$�~s�n�|Lxgu~j9x%¯�wy���a�Ìn�wy�S°~�Fwyxzn;�y�ezn;}~n�j�xzn��±·�l���xzn$�~�Sw���h?xzu~j�x�}Fezf�s�n��S{Feznø�F¯1n�j9egn�s{Fezegn;�Sxg���c�Sn$À¨n;��fa}Fw��Fh�j�xgn�|�x�¯�u�w²sku¯�w��y�¨n;�~j9����n1{�|Éxzf/n;��xzekjas�x;�;ª¬fie-s�n;egxkj�w���´9UXL1FC|���jqhaekj�}Fu?hietj9l*lVj�e³ezn;}�ezn�|�n;�Sxgw��Fh�xguFnw��S°��Fw�xgn?xzekj��~|�wyxzwyfi�"|���|�xgn;l f�ª�j�´9UXL1F:·mTqn;��s�n¨�F¯1ncj�ezn?wy�Sxgn;ezn�|�xzn��Vw��"j���hifaezwyxzuFlV|xzu~j�x�}~n;e�ª¬fiegl=l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®�w��FhVf9ª�w���°~�Fw�xgn*hietj9}Fu�|*�Sn�°~��n��:�S�:haekj�}Fu haekj9lmlVj9et|�·©Pn?}�ezn�|�n;�Sx�u�n;ezn�j�°~ek|�x_j9�yhifaezw�xguFl4f9ª�xzu�j9x/®Swy�~�L�~¯�uFw²skuVlVj9®¨n�j�l*f���n;��Ê�svu�n�sv®�w �Fhf9ª_xguFn*xgn;l*}~fietj9�1�yfihaw²s,´�µ�¶nNí´9loL1Qi��R�fi� j�haekj�}Fu �Sn°~�Fn��P���ºjC|�w�l*}F�yn?®Swy�~�:f9ªhietj9}FuChaekj9lmlVj9e$·©"n�°~et|�xc}Fezn�|�n;��x�xzu�n,xgn;l*}~fietj9����fihaw²s�´�µ�¶%�­j9���!xzu�n;�º¯1nV|�uFf�¯ uFf�¯¹xgfP{�|�n

s�n;egxkj9wy�*hietj9}FuVhaekj9lmlVj9et|��if�ª-j�|�wyl*}F�yn�®Swy�~�L�¨xzfc�Sn°~�Fn�s�n;ezxtj9wy��wy�S°~�Fwyxzn�|�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn�|�¯�uFw²skuVs;j��V�Ìn�{~|�n��Vja|�j�l*f��Sn;�~f9ª��Sw�|�xzegw��F{�xzn��*|��F|�xzn;l�|�·F´�µ�¶�ª¬faezlc{F�²ja|­j9ezn_wy�Sxgn;ezÊ

ÝÉÝ ÷Xp$ö�ó(q�ñ

Page 7: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

W ��� ��2(f��A#&(�f��� / �(D ���:�(&6A#�+�P�! `�f��&0&(=�����(&��#�

}Fezn$xzn���fa��xguFf¨|�n/|�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn�|�¨j9����¯�n�xzuFn;�?}�ezn�|�n;�Sx�fi{�e0lmf��Sn;��Ê�skuFn�sk®Swy�Fh�j���hifaezwyxzuFlC·µ1u~j9x�j9�yhifiegw�xguFlJu~ji|­xzf�l*f��Sw¾ª¬�_xguFn(°��Fw�xgnqegn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�?f9ª-j��*w��S°��Fw�xgn�xzekj��~|�wyxzwyfi�|���|�xgn;lC�Þª¬fae�n$�~|�{Fegw��Fh"xzu�j9x*xguFnV�²j9�~n;�y��wy�FhCf9ª�|�xkj�xzn�|�f�ª_xzu�n�°��Fw�xgn�ezn$}Fezn�|�n;��xkj9xgw�fa��S��|�{F�Sª¬faezlc{F�²ja|1f9ª­xguFn5ª¬fiegl�{F��j¿�~n;wy�Fhcsvu�n�sv®¨n���egn;lVj9wy�~|1sfiuFn;egn;��x�¯�w�xzuVxguFn_xzez{�xzuÀaj9��{�n�|�ª¬fae5xzu�n�|�xkj�xzn�|qf�ª­xzu�n�w���°~�Fw�xgn�|�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn¨·L¼/�Fn�w�l*}~faezxkj��Sx�}~faw���xqw�|(xgf*|�uFf�¯xzu~j�x­w�x�w²|É�Fn�s�n�|z|gj9eg��xzf�n;�S}���fiegn1fa�F����j(°~�Fwyxzn�}~j�ezx%f�ªLxguFn�w���°~�Fw�xgn1xgekj9��|�w�xgw�fa�c|���|�xzn$lª¬fie��Sn�s�w��Sw���h�¯�uFn;xguFn;e/jc|�xtj9xzn�|gj9xzw�|N°~n�|qj�ª¬fiegl�{F��j¿fae��Ffix$·

� ��� #%��8 )º�c'1>��º�$���*��� ���

´�µ�¶!w�|qj���ekj9��svuFwy�Fhiʬxzwyl*n_xzn;lm}Ìfaekj��³��fihaw²si�~¯�uFw�svu w²|�w���xzn;eg}Fezn;xgn��*¯�w�xgu�ezn�|�}~n�s�x5xgf|�xtj9xzn�|�f�ª�xzekj��~|�wyxzwyfi�~|V|���|�xgn;lV|·­µ1uFf¨|�n:|�xkj9xgn�|Vj9egnC�²j9�~n;�y��n��º¯�w�xgu¸j9xzfal*w²s*}Fegfi}~fiÊ|�wyxzw�fa�~|�·­µ1u�n�´�µ�¶ ª¬fiegl�{��²ji|�s;j9�º�~n*n;��}Fegn�|z|�n��ºji|¿ª¬fiegl�{��²ji|_f9ª�xzuFnml�{FÊ�s;j��²s�{F�y{~|¯�w�xguFfi{Fx�j9�yxzn;eg�~j9xgw�fa�*f9ª�°~��}Ìfaw���xk|·~µ1uFn;�Vs;j��Vn;�S}�ezn�|g|0}Fegfi}~n;ezxgw�n�|1f�ª­|gj�ª¬n;x��cfie/��wyÀ¨n;Ê�Fn�|g|��F�F{Fx/�Ffaxqf�ªÉª�j�w�ez��n�|z|·

��� �����������

���Jw²|qxguFn?{F�~�Sn$ez����w���h*|�n;x5f9ª�j�xzfilmw²s¿}�ezfi}~fø|�w�xgw�fa�~|�·�µ1uFn�ª¬faezlVj��%|��S��xkj��,ª¬fie�´�µ�¶ª¬fiegl�{F��ji|­w²|��

� l%À¨n;ez��j9xzfal*w²s�}Fegfi}~f¨|�w�xzwyfi�! !"#���Yw²|�j*´�µ�¶�ª¬fiegl�{��²jS·

� GÙª�$�%_j��~�&$('¿j�eznV´�µ�¶!ª¬fiegl�{F��ji|�ÌxguFn;�"|�f�j9egn�)�$(%;�*$�%,+#$('��.-�/0$�%k��1�/0$�%�-Xi2$�%435$�'�jk�.1^i6$�%635$�'�jk·

787 w�|qxzu�n?j9xgfil*w�s5}Fezfa}Ìfø|�wyxzw�fa�P¯�u�w²sku�w²|�xzeg{Fn�wy�Cj����-|�xkj�xzn�|·³µ1uFn_ª¬fi���yf�¯�w��FhV|��S��Êxkjas�xzw�s;j9���Sn°~�Fw�xgw�fa�~|�j9egn�ja�F�Sn��9�

� -Xi 787 35$ej�w²|�¯�ezwyxzxgn;�:-*;<$1�Fj��~�=1^i 7>7 35$ej%w�|1¯�ezwyxzxzn$�=1?;<$1·

� )*-*;�i>)($ej­w²|1¯�egw�xgxzn;�#1A@,$1��j9�~�#)B1^i8)�$Xj­w²|�¯�ezw�xgxzn;�C-�@,$1·GË�Sª¬faezlVj������ø�vxguFn1xgn;l*}~fietj9��s�fa�F�Fn�sxzw�À¨n�|³s;j9���Ìn/��n�|zs�egw��~n��_ji|³ª¬fi���yf�¯/|��D-�/0$ i¬ezn�|�}³·

1�/0$ej_w²|�xgez{Fn f9ª jP|�xkj9xgn�w ª_j�����i¬ezn�|�}³·­j9xc��n�ji|�x?fa�Fn�f�ª(j�wyxk|?|�{�s;s�n�|g|�fiet|�|gj9xgw²|Nª¬�E$,F-Xi2$ % 35$ ' j'i¬ezn�|�}³·G1^i2$ % 3H$ ' j3j�w²|qxgez{Fn?f�ª/j*|�xkj9xgn�I?w¾ª�fi� j9��� iÙezn�|�}³·~fi�"fi�Fn?f�ª(jqxguFn}~j9xgu~|�w²|z|�{Fn��*ª¬ezfilJIð�FxguFn�|�xtj9xzn�|1À¨n;ezw ª¬��$ % /1��-d�8��fi�Fn�|�xtj9xzn�|gj9xzw�|Nª¬�!$ ' ·

ܬù�ݳܲà

Page 8: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

������������ ��������������������! "�#�%$'&(�*)+�#��,�-.&0/1�0-./�&��32546�879�:���<;>=�?@&�A0)+ B?C&�A#D6D6A#&�2��

Tqn$�~s�n¨��w¾ªÍj_|�xtj9xzn |zj9xgw²|˪¬�H-*; $��9wyx0lmn�j9�~|�xzu~j�x;�¨w��?xguFn � ª¬{Fxz{�ezn��5f9ªÍxzu~j�x�|�xkj9xgn¨��j|�xtj9xzn�¯�uFw²skuV|gj9xzw�|Nª¬�!$:w�|1{F�~j;À¨fiw��Fj9�F�yn F 1?;<$@lmn�j9�~|­xzu~j�xqwyx1w�|1}Ìfø|z|�w��F�yn�xzf?egn�jisku j|�xtj9xzn_¯�uFw�svu�|zj9xgw²|˪¬��$1·�L¨w�lmw��²j�ez�y�¨�¨j�|�xkj�xzn�|zj�xzw²|˪¬�:-�@�$1�¨w¾ª-j9�y�LxguFn_|�xtj9xgn�|1ezn�jasvu�j9�F�ynª¬ezfalJxzu~j�x�|�xtj9xgn5|gj9xzw�|Nª¬�C$,Føj9�~�*j_|�xkj9xgn5|gj9xgw²|Nª¬��1A@,$Cw¾ª±xguFn;ezn/w²|-j¿}~j�xzucw²|z|�{Fn���ª¬ezfalxzu~j�x5|�xkj�xzn�fa�V¯�uFw²sku j9����|�xkj�xzn�|�|gj9xzw�|Nª¬� $1·

UFfie�n�jisku�ª¬fiegl�{F��jH$Pf�ª�´�µ�¶%�F¯1n_�Ffaxzn5I���i2$ej­xzuFn�|�n;x1f�ª�j9�y�³|�{��Sª¬fiegl�{F��ji|­f9ª $1�w��~s��{~�Swy�FhC$:w�xt|�n;� ªg·

��6 ����� �,�,���� µ1uFn?|�n;lVj��Sxgw²s;|­f9ª�´�µ�¶�ª¬faezlc{F�²ja|1w²|��Sn°~�Fn��*¯�w�xgu�egn�|�}~n�s�x�xgf*j $'&(�*)+�#��2(-.&0/1�0-./�&��k·r�� egw�}F®¨n |�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn_w²|�j?xzegw�}F�yn���� i����������oj1¯�u�n;ezn �

� �:w�|qj?|�n;x�f9ª0|�xkj�xzn�|·� � w�|0j_�Fw���j9ez�?egn;�²j�xzwyfi�cfi��� i�� �!�#"$�Xjt�i¯�uFw²skucw²|%xzuFn/xzetj9�~|�w�xgw�fi�mezn;��j9xzwyfi�³·� lc{~|�x1�~n -d��-.A��í�~wË· nø· -GI�"%����1 7 "&���]i6I'� 7 j "(��·

� � �)�+* �-,/.»ji|g|�w�ha�~|qxgf*n�jisku"|�xtj9xgn�xzu�nc|�n;x/f9ª�j9xgfil*w�s¿}Fegfi}~f¨|�w�xgw�fi��| ¯�u�w²skuj9egn�xgez{Fn_w��mxzu~j�x5|�xkj9xgn¨·

r )+A�-� ?w�|5j*|�n �ð{Fn$�~s�n�f�ª�|�xkj�xzn�|'i6I10�� I %1�121212j/|�{~sku�xzu�j9x -435�>i6I167� I1698 %0j�":��·³µ1uFn�Ffixtj9xgw�fi�$��� I10�; �!<ml*n�j��~|Éxzu�j9x­xzuFn�ª¬fiegl�{��²j=<cuFfa�²�F|�j9x�|�xtj9xzn I>0�w��?xguFn5|�xzeg{~s�xz{�ezn�:·9©"n��Sezfa}?�¹¯�u�n;�_w�x�� |Lfi��ÀSwyfi{~|Lª¬ezfal«xzu�n�s�fa�Sxgn;�Sx³¯�u�w²sku_|�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn�w²|³s�fa�~s�n;eg�Fn��L·µ1uFn�egn;�²j�xzwyfi�@;�«w�|��Sn�°~�Fn���wy�~�S{~sxzw�À¨n$���cji|1ª¬fi�y��f�¯/|��

� I10�; � Vw¾Á !"&�Ki2I>0(jk·� I10�; � )($ºw¾ÁC��fix>i2I10�; � $ejt·� I10�; � $(% + $�'(w Á I10�; � $�%qj��~� I10A; � $�'�·� I 0 ; � 1�/0$:w¾Á 1 7 "&���]i6I 0 � 7 j "(�]j9�~� 7 ; � $1·� I10�; � -(/0$Pw¾Á - 7 "&���]i6I10�� 7 j "(�CB 7 ; � $1·� I10�; � 1^i2$�%435$�'0j­w¾ÁCª¬fae/|�fal*n5}~j�xzu i2I10�� I %D�1212E2 jk�1F3�NHGAI!3KJML + I>6N; � $�'�+�-PO!NQG=I:ORJS3KB IDT�; � $�%ZR8R�·

� I10�; � - i6$�% 35$�'0j­w¾ÁCª¬fae/j9�y�³}~j9xgu~|hi2I10�� I %D�1212E2 jt�1F3�NHGAI!3KJML + I>6N; � $�'�+�-PO!NQG=I:ORJS3KB IDT�; � $�%ZR8R�·

ÝÉÝ ÷Xp$ö�ó(q�ñ

Page 9: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

� ��� ��2(f��A#&(�f��� / �(D ���:�(&6A#�+�P�! `�f��&0&(=�����(&��#�

� +V#%'(."�/#0.�'1��2 �C�5�º�C��� 6�7 �c'1>?):� �c'1>�8 8 >?'�2

���� � �������)� ����� �K F�B�,� � � � �´­n;ezxtj9wy�:w��S°��Fw�xgn?hiekj�}Fu~|?s;j��:�~n�°~�Fwyxzn;�y�C�Sn�|zs�egw��~n��C�S�Chaekj9}�u~|�hietj9l*lVj�ek|·mGË�Sª¬fiegÊlVj9�y���¨�¨xguFf¨|�n�hietj9}Fu�|5j9egn�sfil*}~f¨|�n��*f9ª�j�°~�Fwyxzn5��{Flc�~n;e1f�ª­}~j9xgxzn;eg�~|�xzu~j�x/j9ezn�w��S°�Ê�Fw�xgn;���ms�fal*}~fi{F�~��n��*w�� j�egn;hi{��²j9e�¯�j;�¨·

UFfiecn;��}Fezn�|z|�wy�Fh"xzuFn hi��{�w��Fh"f9ª_}�j9xzxgn;ez��|��­w�xcw²|cs�fi��À¨n;�Fwyn;�Sx�xzf"{~|�nCu���}Ìn$ekj9ets;|��¯�uFw²sku j9egn�j�eks;|���wy�F®�w��Fh�fi�Fn_fie/l*faezn_|�xkj9xgn�|��Fwy�~|�xgn�ji�Vf9ª-x�¯1f�ª¬fie�s���ji|z|�w²s;j��³j�eks;|·~µÞfn�jisku���j9�~n;�y��n��_uS��}~n;ekj�eks0w�|%ji|g|�f�s�w�j9xgn��?jqhietj9}FuAFixzuFn�|�xtj9xzn�|�f�ª~xzu�n�uS��}~n;ekj�eks0wy�~�Sw�s;j9xgn¯�uFn;egn*xzuFnchi�y{Fw���h�lc{~|�x5�~nclVji��n¨·³µ1uFfø|�nVez{F�yn�|��Íji|z|�f�s�w²j�xzwy�Fh"j9�:u���}Ìn$ekj9ets�j��~�ºj°~�Fwyxzn5haekj9}�u³�ðª¬fae/s�fil*}~fa{F�~�Swy�Fh�}~j�xzxgn;ez�~|�s�film}Ìfø|�n_j_hietj9}FuVhietj9l*l�j9e;·øµ1uFn_j9}�}F��wyÊs;j9xgw�fa�~|(f�ª�xzuFn_ez{���n�|1f�ª�j�hietj9}Fu hietj9l*lVj�e1xgf*j��Cw��Fwyxzw²j��³j��Swyfil4hietj9}Fu��Sn;xzn$ezl*wy�Fn�|j�{F�Fw��ð{�n¿wy�S°~�Fwyxzn_hietj9}Fu ¯�uFn;� xzuFn�hiekj�l*lVj�e1w²|/�Sn;xgn;ezlmw��Fw�|�xzw�s9�^��������¯�uFn;��xguFn;egn¿w�|fi�F�y�*fi��n�ez{���nqª¬faeqn�jasvuV®�w��~�cf9ª­u��S}~n;etj9etsi·©"n*ezn�|�xzegw²s�x_fa{Fek|�n;��À¨n�|_xzf�|�w�lm}F��n?wy�S°~�Fwyxzn*haekj9}�u~|�·­µ1uFnmhiekj�}Fu~|?¯1nm|�xg{~�S�ºj�ezn

lVji��n¿f�ª�j9� w��Fwyxzw�j9�Lhaekj�}Fu³�±j9�~��f�ª­xzuFn�s�fal*}~fi{F���Sw��Fhcf9ª-fi��n�®�w��~�*f9ª�}~j9xgxzn;eg��w���j��wy�Fn�j9e�¯�j;�¨�m��������fi�F�y�*fi�Fn_}~j�xzxgn;ez� w²|�s�fal*}~fi{F�~��n��*xzfcj?}Fezn�sn��Sn;��x1}~j�xzxgn;ez�³·

���6 � ��� ��8�) � � ©Pn?{�|�n?j?ª¬fiezl�j9��w�|�l |�wyl*w���j9e�xzfmxzu~j�xqf�ª1haekj�}FuChietj9l*lVj�ek|0ª¬faeq°~�Fwyxzn;�y�*n;��}Fezn�|g|�wy�Fhs�n;egxkj9wy� wy�S°~�Fwyxzn |�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn�|�·­©Pn�ji�Fj�}Fx*w�xcxzf s�fa}ÌnC¯�wyxzu»xzuFn �²j9�~n;�y��wy�FhCf9ª�|�xkj�xzn�|¯�w�xgu:j�xzfilmw²s�}Fegfi}~f¨|�w�xzwyfi�~|·0¼/{Fe_}Fegn�|�n;��xkj�xzwyfi�"w²|qwy�~|�}Fwyezn��C¯�w�xguCxzuFnc}Fegn�|�n;��xkj�xzwyfi�f9ª­haekj�}Fu�haekj9lmlVj9et|0lVja�Sn5w�� Ní´�j9{~�a��RË·

�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§Lr �#&�A#����� A�� )+ `A#;0��-�� w²|�j�°~�Fwyxzn�|�n$x�f9ª­�yn;xzxgn;ek|�F¯�uFn;ezn�j?}~f¨|�wyxzwyÀ¨nw���xzn;han;e/w²|�ji|g|�f�s�w�j9xgn���¯�wyxzu n�jiskuV��n;xgxzn;e�� "���·~µ1u~j�x5w���xzn;han;e�w²|�xzu�n<A#&(�8-d=qf�ª �É·��s;j9� �~n¿}�j9ezxgw�xgw�fi���Fn��*w�� |�n$xk| � 6¬�F¯�w�xzu �#"!� 6³w Á"xzuFn�j�ezw�x��cf9ª ��w�| 3z·

�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§~¶Ln;x � �~n?j�haekja�Sn��Vj9�y}Fu~j9�~n;x$·Lr/� `=�)��(&32(-d&(/1�0-d/1&�� � w�|�j?s�fi{F}���ni ���#"%$�j?¯�uFn;egn%� � i���$ ���&$ ����$Cj?w²|*jP°~��w�xzn#�5ezw�}�®¨nC|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn¨��j9���'"%$ w�|j,°~�Fwyxznm|�n;x�f9ª' `=�)��(&3A#&���2 �.I % 21212�I�(F·%µ1u�n*uS��}~n;ekj�eksR�.I % 2E212 I�( w²|¿��j9�~n;�y��n��C�S�CxguFn�+�#��d-Z�(&(D6���+A�� �&")� ( j��~�,xguFn5I 6 j�ezn��Sw²|�xzw���s�x�|�xkj9xgn�|�f9ª � $ ·µ1uFn uS��}~n;ekj�eks;|cji���Sn��!xgf:xzu�nCs���ji|z|�w²s;j����5ezw�}�®¨n�|�xzeg{~s�xz{�ezn�¯�wy����n;��j9�F�yn�{~|�xgf

w��~��w²s;j�xzn_¯�uFn;egn¿xguFn_hi�y{Fw��Fh?f�ª%faxzuFn$e �5ezwy}F®¨n_|�xzez{�s�xz{Fegn�|1lc{~|�x��Ìn_lVja�Sn¨·�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§Fr 2(-.&0/1�0-./�&��9�#&3A#D6D6A#&�*:w²|�j °~��w�xzn |�n;x�f9ª�u��S}~n;etj9eks/ezn;}F��jis�n$l*n;��x

ez{F�yn�|

ܬù�ݳܲà

Page 10: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

������������ ��������������������! "�#�%$'&(�*)+�#��,�-.&0/1�0-./�&��32546�879�:���<;>=�?@&�A0)+ B?C&�A#D6D6A#&�2��

�.I % 2E212 I�( * �:�L¯�uFn$eznR�.I % 21212 I�(mw²|5j��Pu��S}~n;etj9etsi�Lj��~� � w�|5j9�"u��S}~n;et|�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn¨�j9�~�VxzuFn5I16-j9ezn��Sw�|�xgw��~s�x�|�xtj9xzn�|(f�ª ��$5·µ1uFn ez{F�yn�|?f9ª�|�{~sku¸jPhaekj9lmlVj9e?wy�~�Sw²s$j9xznV¯�u~j�x*}~j�xzxzn$ez� u~ja|�xzf:�~nCha��{Fn�� xgf

j9�ºw���w�xzw�j9�­u��S}~n;et|�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn¨��j��~�Pxzu�nV|�xtj9xzn�| I 6 w��~��w²s;j�xznc¯�uFw²sku:|�xkj�xzn�|�u~j;À¨ncxzfC�~nl*n;eghin���ª¬fae�ha��{Fwy�FhCxzu�n,}�j9xzxgn;ez�Í·­µ1uFw²|�ha��{Fwy�FhPfa}~n;ekj�xzw�fa� w�|�}Fezn�sw²|�n$���"�Sn�°��Fn��ºji|ª¬fi�y��f�¯/|�·

�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§��/wyÀ¨n;�:jV|�xzez{�s�xz{Fegn�haekj�l*lVj9e *«j9�~� j9�:u��S}~n;et|�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn �J� �&��(aI&0�8-Z�32 ���%�#���c2(-Z�d)�xzf?j5u��S}~n;et|�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn �P��j��~��¯1n���fixzn � *�� �:�iw ªg�øª¬fae�|�filmnez{F�yn i �.I % 21212 I�(A* �Pj�"!*��S¯�n¿u�j�À¨n �Ê�1^i 7 %D�E212121� 7 (#j " i��� j ( �/� 7 % 212E2 7 ( "!"�ÊH-�3 "��¨o �1212E2D�� ��H�'��$5i2I>6\jN�S���<i 7 6\jÊcj9���L�Sª¬fie�|�fal*nql�j9xkskuFwy�Fh¿ª¬{F��s�xzwyfi���Vl�j9}F}Fwy�Fh I16³xgf 7 6��Fj��~�,lVj�}F}Fwy�Fh�wy�i��n�s�ÊxzwyÀ¨n;���?xguFn_fixguFn;e�|�xkj�xzn�|�f9ª ��$¸xzfc|�xtj9xgn�|(fa{Fxk|�w²�Sn_f�ª ����Ê "�+� i "������� 7 % 212E2 7 (���j��������^i2I %0jP21212��^i2I�(#j����.I % 21212 I�( ")"%$��Ê ��+� ������ �^i2I_j�� I�"&��$��Ê � � �M� � ���#i!�^i6I�j����^i 7 j3j��>i6I'� 7 j("%� $ �Ê � � � � � * � , � w²|/�Sn�°��Fn���ja|�ª¬fa���yf9¯/| F)� � i6I�j � � � i2I_j�w¾ªBI�"@� � fae���@i2I�j�� � $ i 7 j­w¾ª I=���^i 7 j%ª¬fie�|�fal*n 7 "%��$

© uFn$��j��_uS��}~n;ek|�xzez{�s�xz{Fegn­ezn;¯�egw�xzn�|Ìw���j��FfixguFn;e;��|�fil*n�|�xkj�xzn�|³f9ª�xzu�n0wy�Fw�xgw²j��¨|�xgez{~sÊxz{Fegn�u~j;À¨n­xzf5�~n�l*n;eghin��5¯�wyxzu?|�xkj�xzn�|Éf�ª±xzuFn�}~j9xgxzn;eg�³·9©"n1wyl*}~f¨|�n1xzu�j9x%xguFn1��j9�~n;���yw��Fhf9ª�xguFf¨|�n5l*n;eghin��c|�xtj9xzn�|0w²|%xguFn_|zj�l*n¨�iu�n;�~s�n/¯1n�s;j9���Sn�°~�Fn�{F�~j9lc�Fwyhi{Ffa{~|��y��xzu�n5�²j�Ê�~n;���yw��Fh?f�ª%xguFn�|�xkj�xzn�|�f9ª�xzuFn_ezn�|�{F�yxzw���h?uS��}~n;ek|�xzez{�s�xz{Fegn¨·µ1uFn1°�hi{Fegn5fi�cxzuFn1ª¬fa���yf9¯�wy�Fh_}~j9hanq}�ezn�|�n;�Sxt|­j haekj�}Fu*hietj9l*l�j9e *(�øs�fil*}~fø|�n��?f9ª

fi�Fn/ez{���n¨�ixgu~j9x­{~|�n�|%xzuFn�u���}Ìn$ekj9ets#"�o;�a�S��j9�~�cx�¯�f_|�{�s;s�n�|g|�w�À¨n�ezn;¯�egw�xgw��Fhø|0jas;s�faek�Swy�Fhxzfcxzu~j�xqeg{F��nø·

UFezfal �Ff�¯ fi�³��¯1n"ezn�|�xzegw²s�xmfi{Fe |�xg{~�S� xgf |�w�l*}���nC|�xzeg{~s�xz{�ezn"hiekj�l*lVj�ek|��­wË· n¨·hietj9l*lVj�ek|­¯�w�xzuVfa�F���*fa�Fn�eg{F��nø�S¯�uFfø|�n�egw�hauSx�l*n$l?�Ìn$e0u�ji|�fi�F�y�*fi�Fn_u��S}~n;etj9etsi·¶Ln;x$� �~n�j��~j9xg{Fekj��Ë�±j9�~�%"]j���j9�~n;�³f9ª-u��S}~n;etj9eks5f�ª�j9egw�x��&�"·¶Ln;x('�0 � i��*),+����-).+����(),+0j³�~n�j(°~�Fwyxzn �5egw�}F®¨n�|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn1¯�w�xgu/� ��w²|�xgw��Fha{Fw²|�uFn��L�

}~j9wyez¯�w�|�n���w²|�xgw��~sx;�;|�xkj�xzn�|�#i�021 6fj � % ��j��~�H� �Mi�� , ��� , ��� , j±j�°��Fw�xgn �5egw�}F®¨n­|�xzeg{~s�xz{�ezn

ÝÉÝ ÷Xp$ö�ó(q�ñ

Page 11: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

Q ��� ��2(f��A#&(�f��� / �(D ���:�(&6A#�+�P�! `�f��&0&(=�����(&��#�

��

����

� � �

¯�w�xgu*� � ��w²|�xgw��Fha{Fw²|�uFn��L��}~j�w�ez¯�w�|�n/�Sw�|�xgw��~s�x�|�xkj�xzn�|�+i 3 6fj � % j9���%i�� 7 6fj � % ·i©Pn1ª¬{�ezxzu�n;ew�l*}~fø|�n_xzu~j�xD� -43�" N o 2 2 �%R����(),+>i 0 1 6�jN�M� , i 3 6fjN�M� , i��� 7 6\jk·¶Ln;x '�0��Mi ' 0��#"/),+ � � " 021 % 212E2 021��$��jk�;j��~� �!� i6��� " , � � " �� 7 %42E212��� 7 �$��j Fj9�~�V��n;x *)0��~n�xzuFn�|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn¿haekj�l*lVj9e­¯�wyxzuVxzuFn_{F��w��¨{Fn_ez{F�yn"A3 .%21212�3 �+* �_·©"nC|�uFf�¯ xgu~j9xmxzuFn w��S°~��w�xzn w�xgn;ekj�xzw�À¨n j�}F}F��w�s;j9xgw�fa� f9ª�xguFn�{F��w��¨{Fn�eg{F��n f9ª�*)0

fi�"xzuFn?u���}Ìn$ek|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn ' 0 �Sn;xzn$ezl*wy�Fn�|�j�{F��w��¨{Fn?w��S°��Fw�xgn?�5ezwy}F®¨n�|�xzeg{~s�xg{FeznR� �i������A���ojk·

�_¤�dzÇ��k§mUÉwyek|�x$�F¯1n�|�u�f9¯Txzu~j�xqxguFn�{F��w��¨{Fn_ez{F�yn¿f�ª * 0 s;j9� �Ìn_wy�S°~�Fwyxzn;�y�*j�}F}F��wyn��fi� ' 0 ·

L¨wy�~s�n�¯�n�u~j;À¨n-"/0 1 % 2E212 021 � "!" ).+ �Sj��~��-43�" N o 2 2 �%R���� ),+ i�021 6 jN�S� , i 3 6 jk�a¯1ns;j9� j9}�}F���CxguFn�{��Fw��¨{Fn?ez{���n?f9ª * 0 xzf ' 0 ·L©"ncu~j;À¨n � ' 0 *�� + ' % �³j9����¯�n*s;j���� � %xzuFn_lVj�xkskuFw���h¿ª¬{F�~sxzw�fa� ji|z|�f�s�w²j�xzn��Vxzfcxzu~j�xqegn;¯�ezwyxzwy�Fh?|�xzn;}³·

L¨wy�~s�n " , � � " �� 7 % 212E2��� 7 �$�¨�­¯1n�u�j�À¨n)"/)��&� � "-� %>i��� 7 %�j 2E212�� %>i��� 7 �@j��¨�j9�~�±� -43�" N o 2 2 �%R����()��0i � %>i��� 7 6\j3jK�M� , i��� 7 6\jN�S� , i�3 6\jk·©"n�|�{F}F}~fø|�n�xgu~j9x/xzu�n;ezn5n$�Sw�|�xk|KOcuS��}~n;ek|�xzeg{~s�xz{�ezn�| ' %1� ' '1�1212E21� ' T/|�{~svuVxgu~j9x �Ê '�0 * � + '�% * � + ' ' * � +�21212 * � + ' T

ܬù�ݳܲà

Page 12: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

������������ ��������������������! "�#�%$'&(�*)+�#��,�-.&0/1�0-./�&��32546�879�:���<;>=�?@&�A0)+ B?C&�A#D6D6A#&�2��

�1^i��0%D�1212E21��� �Kj�"&� �)�� "/)

�� � "�� % 212E2�� �-�B+ -43�""N¾o 2 2 �<R ���()

�i��-6\jN�S� , i�3 6\j

µ1uFn$�³�Swy�*xzuFn |zj9lmn5¯�j;�mji|0ª¬fie '�0���¯1n_s;j�� j9}F}F�y��xguFn5eg{F��n5f�ª *)0�xgf ' T��S¯�u�w²skuezn;¯�egw�xgn�|(wy�Cfi�Fnc|�xzn;} xzf ' T�8 %;·³µ1uFn�u���}Ìn$ek|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn ' T�8 %¿À¨n;egw¾°~n�|1xguFncs�fa�~�Sw�xgw�fa�~|xzu~j�x�j9ezn/�Fn�sn�|z|gj9ez��xzf�j9}�}F����fi�Fn/l*fiegn1xgw�l*n­xzu�nqeg{F��n�f9ª�*)0­xgf ' T 8 %�·i©Pn/sfi�~|�xzez{�s�xw��Vxzu�j9x/¯�j;�Vj9� w��S°��Fw�xgn_|�n;x�f�ª­u��S}~n;et|�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn�| ' T��Sª¬fie/j����³}~f¨|�w�xgw�À¨n_w���xzn;han;ek|�O~·©"n_�Ff�¯«�Sn°~�FnA��� i����������oj �Ê �@���N�*)

��Sª¬fie/j����³}~f¨|�w�xzwyÀ¨n5w���xzn$hin;et|KOÌ·

ÊR�C� �#i6I'� 7 j�� 1 O'�]i6I'� 7 j "(� ) � �¨·ÊH- I�"&�����Ki2I_jN�M�()

�i6I�j��¨ª¬fie�j OV|�{~skuVxzu~j�x�IH"&�*)

�· @

�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§F©Pn�|zj;�*xgu~j9x'i�'�0�� �5j­w²|�j�79�+�8-Z�'&��d)^&��32��(��-.A�-d���#�?f9ª �:·©"n5s$j9���.� 6±xzuFn/lVj�xkskuFw��Fh/ª¬{F�~s�xgw�fi�mji|g|�f�s�w�j9xgn���xzf�xzuFn 3Ùxgu�egn;¯�ezwyxzw���h�|�xzn;}mf9ª³xguFn

hietj9l*lVj�e *)0/fi� '�0i��j9�~�&� 05xzuFn_w��Sn;��xzw�x��?fa� �*).+�·©"n_u~j;À¨n � -GI�"&� � 1 7 " i��*),+(�(� , j���1F35� I � � 6.i 7 jGË�Vhin;��n;ekj��Ë� 7 w²|��Ffax5{F�Fw��ð{Fnø·S©"n?s;j������ 0� !i6I�j�xguFn�|�n;x/f9ª�|�xkj9xgn�| 7 " i��*),+ ��� , j|�{~skuVxzu~j�xq¯�n_u~j;À¨n � 1F35� I � � 6di 7 jk·©"n"�Sw²|�xzwy�Fhi{Fw�|�uT�Sw¾Á±n;egn;��xVs;j9xgn;hifaezwyn�|�f9ª�|�xtj9xzn�|,f9ª � ª¬faeVlVj9®�w��Fh n�ji|�w�n;e*xguFn

}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�Vf9ª­xguFn�j9��hafiegw�xzu�lC·�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§9©"n�|gj��_xgu~j9x(IH"&�Vw�|³j9�����+�:��&�f2(-.A�-Z�Éf�ª~xzuFn 3Ùʬn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi�Í�#iÙezn�|�}³·�f9ª

xzuFn G9ʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�!jk�~w¾Á 1 7 "@� , � ��3 % �121212 ��3 � ���� 7 % �1212E2D���� 7 � �'� I�� � 6 i 7 jk�mi¬ezn�|�}³·1 7 "&� ),+ ��� 021 % �12E2121� 021 � �'� I=��� 0 i 7 j3jk·

�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§S©"n5|gj��cxzu�j9x�I5"&�"w²|1jK�]&3�#��-.�f�(&�f2(-.A�-��%f�ª�xzuFn 3ÙÊÙn$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�³��i¬ezn�|�}³·f9ª�xzuFn G9ʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�!jk��w¾Á 1 O " N¾o 2 2 �<R � IS� � 6 i��� 7 T j&� � 6 8 % i�3 T jt��iÙegn�|�}³·�1 O "N¾o 2 2 �<R � I � � 0�i�021 T�jN� � %>i 3 PT(j3jt·¶Ln;x i�'A��� j­�~n_j¿°~��w�xzn�ezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi�*f�ª­j��Vw��S°~��w�xzn�|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn��:·�¶Ln;x�$:�~n�j

´�µ�¶�ª¬fiegl�{��²jS·�¶Ln;x����~n�j?�²j9�~n;�y��wy�Fh¿ª¬{F��s�xzwyfi�Vfi�Vxzu�n�|�xkj�xzn�|�f9ª 'Yj��~���*�¨ª¬fie/j9�y�xzuFn�|�{F�Sª¬fiegl�{��²ji|1f�ª $�F ��C��i��*)��(�� kj "#I���i2$ejN* ������ 0 �#����� I 0 �¨·

�VÃ������ò£��ÙÇ��­§Ì©"n?|gj�� xzu~j�x6i�'A��� jt�~|�{F}�}F��wyn��,¯�wyxzu(�~�Fw²|6��� ���&��(��-Lª¬fae�$!¯�wyxzu� w¾Á

-GI�"%���>- $ 0 "#I���i6$Xj,� I ; � $ 0�� - 7 "�� 0� ^i6I�j���� i 7 � $ 00jN������ 0UFfiemj9�y�, " ���?�­¯1n��Sn�°~�Fn#���0� -GI " � ),+ �+� , ������i6I'�6 �j������ 0mw¾Á I "

� ),+ +C " � ).+ i6I�j�fie5I�"S� , +C "+� , i6I�jk· H5|�wy�Fh*xzu�n�|�n?��j9�~n;���yw��Fhø|��L¯�n�u~j;À¨n¨�~���

ÝÉÝ ÷Xp$ö�ó(q�ñ

Page 13: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

o1G ��� ��2(f��A#&(�f��� / �(D ���:�(&6A#�+�P�! `�f��&0&(=�����(&��#�

s�fi��|�xzeg{~s�xgw�fi�Í�Éxzu�j9x<i�'�0�� �5jqw�|�j,°~��w�xznmezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi�³��s�fauFn;egn;�Sx5ª¬fae�xzu�nVj9xgfil*w�s}Fezfa}~f¨|�wyxzwyfi�~|q¯�wyxzu �:·µ1uFn5ª¬fa����f�¯�wy�Fh�°~hi{�ezn_hiwyÀ¨n�|�j9�Vn;��j9l*}���n5f�ª­|�{~svu j�°~�Fwyxzn5egn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�³·

¶ki j5�/} ¶ki j5� �

��� %� ô �

��� % ���2%� �

GË��xgu~j9x�s;ja|�n¨�~xzu�n?uS��}~n;ekj�eks¿¯�u�w²sku�w����Sw²s;j�xzn�|/xzuFn�hi��{�w��Fh*f�ª�}~j�xzxgn;ez�~|/w��~s��y{~�Sn�|fi�F�y�*fi��n?|�xtj9xgn¨·~µ1uFn_�²j��Ìn$����wy�Fh����Vj�xzfilmw²s�}Fezfa}Ìfø|�wyxzw�fa�~|5�Sw�|�xgw��Fha{Fw²|�u,fa�F���mx�¯�fc|�n;xt|f9ª�|�xtj9xzn�|�·~µ1uFn5°~et|�x/|�n$x1w²|�s�film}Ìfø|�n��*f�ª%xguFn5{F�Fw��ð{�n_|�xtj9xzn�j�x�xzuFn5n$�Sxgezn;l*wyx��¿f�ª%xguFnw��S°��Fw�xgn�|�xzeg{~s�xz{�ezn¨��xzuFn_fixguFn;e�|�n;x�w�|�s�film}Ìfø|�n��*f�ª­j����³xzu�n¿faxzuFn$e/|�xkj�xzn�|·

� � ��� >��;�c�c'(�$#0�"8

���� ��� �����= ��� ��� ��� � ��������)8�����r ��wy�Fn�j�e�j9�yhifaezw�xguFlJª¬fie/skuFn�sk®Swy�Fh?´�µ�¶�ª¬faezlc{F�²ja|�fa�*°~�Fw�xgn_|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn�|0¯�ji|1}Fegn�|�n;��Êxzn��Vw�� N ´9loL1Qa��RË·�µ1uFw²|/j9�yhifiegw�xguFl fi}~n;etj9xgn�|qja|�ª¬fa���yf9¯/| �~j�°��Fw�xgn�|�xzeg{~s�xz{�ezn_w²|1haw�À¨n;�*Fj9�y�³|�xtj9xgn�|1¯�w��y�Ì�~n5��j9�~n;�y��n������cj9�y�³|�{F�Sª¬fiegl�{��²ji|­f9ª($P¯�u�w²skuVj9egn5xzeg{Fn5w��mxzuFn;l��i¯1faezÊ®Swy�Fh?w���s�ezn;lmn;�Sxtj9�y���¨���~n;hiwy�F�Fw���h�¯�wyxzuVxzuFn�|�w�l*}F�yn�|�x�|�{F�Sª¬fiegl�{��²ji|·~µ1uFw²|1¯�wy���±n;�~|�{�eznxzu~j�x;�Fn�jasvumxzw�lmn�xzuFn_j���hafiezwyxzuFl�u~ja|(xgf�À¨n;egw¾ª¬�cj�hiwyÀ¨n;�?ª¬fiezlc{F��jS�¨xzuFn�xzez{�xzu*Àaj9�y{Fn_f9ªj9�y�³xzuFn_}~n;ezxgw��Fn$�Sx�|�{F�Sª¬faezlc{F�²ja|1¯�w��y�L�~n�®��Ff�¯��*ª¬fie/j9�y��|�xtj9xzn�|(f�ª­xzuFn�|�xzez{�s�xz{Fegn¨·¼/{Fe_j���hafiezwyxzuFl4ª¬fie�skuFn�sk®Swy�Fh?w��S°��Fw�xgnR� egw�}F®¨n�|�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn�|q{~|�n�| xguFnc|zj�l*n�}�ezw���Ê

s�w�}���n¨·~r °~�Fwyxzn�ezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi�Vf9ª�j���w���°~�Fw�xgn?|�xzez{�s�xz{Fegn_w²|�hiw�À¨n$�³�F¯�w�xguCj���j9�~n;���yw��Fhs�fiu�n;ezn;��x1ª¬fie/xzu�n�j�xzfal*w²sq}�ezfi}~fø|�w�xgw�fa�~|�·L©"n_}Fezfahiegn�|z|�w��~sezn;l*n$�Sxtj9���y�i���Sn�s�w²�Swy�Fh�xguFn�²j��Ìn$����wy�Fh_f9ª�l*faezn�j9�~�cl*fiegn/s�fil*}���n;��|�{F�Sª¬faezlc{F�²ja|Þª¬fie�xzuFn |�xkj�xzn�|­f9ª�fa{Fe0°~��w�xzn/ezn$Ê}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�³·�J1{Fx$�Fxzu~j�xqegn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�Vl�{~|�x1egn;lVj9wy�Vs�fauFn;ezn$�Sx�¯�wyxzu�xguFn_w��S°��Fw�xgn|�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn5ª¬fae5j�����|�{��Sª¬fiegl�{F��ji|·

UFfie/�~f¨fi�yn�j9� s�fi���Fn�s�xgw�À¨n�|�Sxzu�n�xzeg{Fxzu Àaj9��{�n�f9ª�j�haw�À¨n;� |�xkj9xgn?fi�F�y� �Sn;}~n;�~�F|�fi�xzuFnmxzez{�xzu:Àaj9�y{Fncf9ª/xzu�n*|�{F�Sª¬fiegl�{��²ji|_j�x�xzu�nV|zj�l*nc|�xtj9xznø·kTqn;��s�n¨�̪¬fae�n;��j9l*}���n¨�±j

ܬù�ݳܲà

Page 14: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

������������ ��������������������! "�#�%$'&(�*)+�#��,�-.&0/1�0-./�&��32546�879�:���<;>=�?@&�A0)+ B?C&�A#D6D6A#&�2øoio

s�fiu�n;ezn;��x�egn;}Fegn�|�n;��xkj�xzwyfi�Pª¬fae?xzuFnV|�{F�Sª¬faezlc{F�²ja|H$�%?j��~� $�'�¯�w��y�1ezn$lVj9wy�:s�fauFn;egn;�Sxª¬fie/xzuFn5ª¬faezlc{F�²j5$�%�+ $�'��Fw ª%¯�n��Sn�°~�Fn�ja|�ª¬fa����f�¯/|1xguFn_�²j9�~n;�y��wy�Fh?� ��� ��D�

� - I�"&�*),+(��� , �>- $�� % "#I���i2$�%0j���� ��� ��]i6I'� $�� % jN�M� � i6I'� $�� % j� - I�"&� ),+ ��� , �>- $ � ' "#I���i2$ ' j���� ��� �� i6I'� $ � ' jN�M� �� i6I'� $ � ' j� - I " �*),+�S� , ���

�� ��>i6I'� $(% + $�'0j � ���� 0�� � � i2I'� $�%�j � � �� 0H+����i6I'� $�'�j�� � �� 0

µ1uFw�|(w�|q�Ff*lmfiezn_xgez{Fn�ª¬fae5xzn;lm}Ìfaekj���s�fi�F��n�s�xzwyÀ¨n�|��F�~n�s$j9{~|�n?xzuFn�xzez{�xzuCÀaj9�y{Fn?f9ªj�xzn$l*}~fiekj��Lª¬fiegl�{F��j¿ª¬fie_jc|�xtj9xgnc�Sn;}~n;�~�F|�fi�CxguFn�xgez{FxguCÀaj9��{�n�f9ª0|�{F�Sª¬faezlc{F�²ja|�ª¬faefixguFn;e�|�xkj�xzn�|·F©Pn_¯�wy���LxguFn;�Vu~j;À¨n_xzf?l*f���w¾ª¬�cfi{Fe�°~�Fwyxzn_ezn;}�ezn�|�n;�Sxtj9xgw�fi�Í·

UFfie/xzu�nH-�/1i6$Xj�j9�~� 1�/1i6$ej­ª¬fiegl�{F��ji|�FxzuFn�|�xkj�xzn�|5f�ª1xguFn�wy�S°~�Fwyxzn�|�xzeg{~s�xg{Fezn¨�~ezn$Ê}Fezn�|�n;��xzn��C����fi��n*|�xkj9xgn�f�ª ���Lu~j;À¨ncj����%xguFn*|gj9l*n?wyl*l*n$�Sw²j�xzn�|�{�s;s�n�|g|�fiet|��³n;��s�n;}Fx¯�uFn;�CxguFn;� j9egn�hiwyÀ¨n;�����VxzuFn_°~ek|�xqn$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�Cf�ª1xguFn�haekj�l*lVj9e$·+GË��xgu~j9x s;ji|�n¨�ÌxguFnw��FÊ�|�xtj9xgn�|(f�ª��Yj9egn�l*n;eghin��c¯�w�xzu xzuFn_n;��Ê�|�xkj�xzn�|�f9ª�xzuFn_w���w�xzw�j9�±hiekj�}Fu '�0��~j9�~�VxzuFn$�s;j9� u~j;À¨n�wyl*l*n��Swyj�xzn?|�{~s;s�n�|z|�faek|_w���' 0a�³¯�uFn;egn�ji|�ͪ¬fae�xguFn�ª¬fi�y��f�¯�w���h,n$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�~|�xzuFncw���ÊË|�xkj9xgn�|5j�ezncl*n;ezhan��,¯�wyxzuCxguFn?fi{FxgÊË|�xkj�xzn�|_f9ª�xzuFn?}�ezn�s�n��Sw��Fhmn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi�Í�³j9�~�xzuFn$w�e_w�l*lmn;�Sw�j9xgn�|�{~s;s�n�|z|�faek|5u~j;À¨nmj9���-xzuFnm|zj�l*n?�²j��Ìn$����wy�Fh�ª¬fae�xzu�nc|�{F�Sª¬faezlc{F�²j $1·µ1uFn;egn�ª¬fiegn¨�Éwyx¿l�j��C�~n*��n�s�n�|g|zj9eg�Pxgf�l*f���w¾ª¬�Cxzu�n*ezn;}�ezn�|�n;�Sxtj9xgw�fi�ͷɵ1u�w²|¿w�|�|�w�l*}F�y�jiskuFw�n$À¨n������*xkj�®Swy�Fhcji|�xzuFn_�Fn$¯ wy�Fw�xgw²j9�±hietj9}Fu xzuFn_l*n;eghiwy�Fh�f�ª '�05j��~� ��·

UFfie_xguFn 1^i2$�%435$�'0j_j��~�=- i6$�% 35$�'0j�ª¬fiezlc{F��ji|��±xzuFncl*f��Sw °±s;j9xgw�fa�C¯�w����­�~ncl*fiegns�film}F��w�s;j9xgn��L�i�~n�s;j�{~|�n_xguFn5xzeg{FxzumÀij���{Fn�f9ª�j?|�xkj�xzn5ª¬fie�|�{~skuVj¿ª¬faezlc{F�²j_s;j�����n;}~n;�~�fi�»j9�y�1wyxk|�|�{~s;s�n�|z|�faek|�%j9���@��fix�fa�F���"xzu�n*w�l*lmn��Sw²j�xzn�fi�Fn�|·É©"n*}Fegn�|�n;��x���f9¯JxguFnj9�yhifiegw�xguFl ª¬fie�1 $�% 3H$('�ª¬faezlc{F�²ja|�·�µ1uFnVj���hifaezwyxzuFl ª¬faeH-Xi2$�% 3H$�'0j�w²|�À¨n;eg�"|�wyl*w���j9ej9�~�Vw²|1�Ffaxq}�ezn�|�n;�Sxgn���uFn$ezn¨·

���6 �� � ������ � 8���=� �������� ������� ö�� � � � ��� ��N ¶Ln;x i '�0�� �hj/�~n*j*°~�Fw�xgn?ezn;}�ezn�|�n;�Sxtj9xgw�fi�"f9ª�j��:w���°~�Fw�xgnc|�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn � � i���������� jt�¯�w�xguC�²j9�~n;�y��wy�Fh¨| � � j9�~�%���;�³s�fauFn;egn;�Sx/¯�w�xgu $�%_j9�~� $�';·L©"nc|�u�f9¯YuFn$ezn?uFf�¯ xgffi�Fxtj9wy�ºj,�Fn$¯Jezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi�"i�'�� 0 � ��� jk��j��~�:j,��j9�~n;�y��w���h����� ��� ��;��s�fauFn;egn;�Sx_¯�wyxzu1^i6$�%635$�'�jt·L©"n��~n;hiwy�P��� |�uFf�¯�wy�Fh*xzu�ezn;n?�yn;l*lmji|���xzu~j�x5n;�~j��F��n?{�|qxzf*egn�|�xgezw�s�xqxguFn|�n�j�eksku*f9ª�j¿��n;¯ ezn;}�ezn�|�n;�Sxtj9xgw�fi�mxzf�xguFn_|�xz{~�S�mf9ª�xzu�nqª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj9xgn�|���j9�~�cxzuFn;�m¯1n}Fezn�|�n;��x�fi{Fe�j9�yhifaezw�xguFlC·

ÝÉÝ ÷Xp$ö�ó(q�ñ

Page 15: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

o;� ��� ��2(f��A#&(�f��� / �(D ���:�(&6A#�+�P�! `�f��&0&(=�����(&��#�

��������� � ¤�ÃSà �¬Ã � �º¥F¢�1à � �!¥ � §1©"nCs$j9� ®��Ff�¯¹ª¬fiem|�{Fegn�xgu~j9xVj�� wy�F�Fn;egÊË|�xkj9xgn#I�f�ª�xguFn(3¬ÊÙn;��}~j��~|�wyfi�|zj�xzw²|Ë°~n�|:1^i6$(%63H$�'�jk��w¾ª/¯1nm®S�Ff�¯�w¾ª/xguFn�ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj�xzn�|�f�ª5xguFnBi 3��Yo�jËʬn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi�j9�~�Vf9ª­xguFnA3Ùʬn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi� |gj9xzw�|Nª¬� 1^i2$�%63H$('0jk·

�_¤�dzÇ��k§Frq�y�SxguFn/}~j9xgu~|0w�|z|�{�n���ª¬egfil I5j9egn(°~et|�x�s�fal*}~f¨|�n���f�ª³xzu�nqwy�F�Fn;egÊË|�xkj9xgn�|%f9ªxzuFn 3Ùʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�³·�µ1uFn;�cj9egn_s�fal*}~f¨|�n���f�ª³fixguFn;e�|�xtj9xgn�|0fa�F���cj;ª¬xzn;e­xzu�n;�?w��~s��{~�Sn�xguFnª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj9xgn�|�f9ª­xguFn i�3 � o�jËÊ�fie 3ÙÊÙn$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�³·^Tqn;��s�n¨�Sw ª%¯�n�®��Ff�¯«w¾ª-xzu�n¿ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;e|�xtj9xzn�|�f�ª³xguFn i�3 �Co jËʱj��~� 3Ùʱn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi�m|zj�xzw�|Nª¬��1^i6$�% 3H$('0jk�i¯�n/�Sfi� � x­�Fn;n���xgf�|�xz{~���xzuFn�}�j9xzu�|�w�|z|�{Fn�� ª¬egfil Ið�a¯�uFw²sku?s;j��?w��~s��{~�Sn�j���wy�S°~�Fwyxzn1��{Flc�~n;e³f9ªÍ|�xtj9xgn�|��i�~n;�¨fa�~�xzuFfø|�n_ª¬ezfi��xzwyn;e�|�xkj�xzn�|·�@

qfaxkjV�Ìn$�Fn �SUFfie�xguFncw��F�Fn$ezÊ�|�xkj�xzn�|_f9ª/xguFn G9ʬn;��}~j9��|�w�fa�³�K����� �³xzuFnV|�xkj�xzn�|_f9ª�'�0��n;��s�n;}Fx?xguFn |�xkj�xzn�|<i�021 6�jk�%wyx?w²|�n;�Ffa{Fhiu»xzf"®S��f9¯�w¾ª�xzu�n�ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�|�f9ª_xguFn G9Ên;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�:�S��������xzuFn�|�xkj9xgn�|5i�021 6 jt�~|zj�xzw²|˪¬� 1^i6$�%635$�'0jt·

��à � �:¥ � §É©"ncs;j��C®S�Ff�¯Yª¬fie_|�{Fezn?xgu~j9x�j�ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj9xgnCI ��� 6di��� 7 T(jk�L¯�wyxzu3 �Toi�Sf�ª�xzuFn 3Ùʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�V|zj�xzw²|Ë°~n�|,1^i6$�%635$�'0jt�ðw ª±¯1n/®S�Ff�¯ w ª³xzu�n(ª¬egfi��xzw�n$ezÊ�|�xkj�xzn�|­f9ªxzuFn'i 3 �Co�jËʬn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi�m|zj�xzw�|Nª¬��1^i6$�% 3H$('0jk�i���c|�xg{~�S��w��Fh_xzu�n��²j9�~n;�y��wy�Fhqª¬fie�$�%�j9�~�C$�'f9ªÍxzuFn�wy�F�Fn;egʳj9����ª¬egfi��xzw�n$ezʳ|�xkj�xzn�|%f9ªÍxzuFn5i�3�� o j�Êz��i 3��*�#jËÊg� 21212 �+i 3��&�BjËʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�~|��¯�uFn;egn� w²|1xguFn_�S{�l��~n;e­f9ª0|�xkj�xzn�|5i�021 T jt�mi 3 T j­fae i��� 7 T jk·

�_¤�dzÇ��k§oGÙª/¯�n�°~�~�Pwy� � j�}~j9xgu i��� 7 T � I 0 � I % �E21212 � I ( j5¯�wyxzu:� �� i6I ( � $ ' j?�� �� 0�j9�~�S� � i6I���� $ % j�� � �� 0a��-�� ��G!I � J É��¯1nCs$j9�Ts�fi�~s��{~�Sn xzu~j�x I �� 6 i��� 7 T j�; � 1^i6$ % 35$ ' jk��|�wy�~s�n/¯1n/®S��f9¯»xzu~j�x1xguFn;ezn/w²|%wy� � j¿}~j�xzuBi � 6 i��� 7 T j���� 6 i6I % j��212121� � 6 i6I ( j�jk�1¯�wyxzu � 6 i6I ( jS;� $ ' j9��� -�� ��G I � J ��� 6 i6I�� j ; � $ % �/|�w��~s�nCxguFn�²j��Ìn$����wy�Fh¨| � � j9�~�R� �� j�ezn/s�fauFn;ezn$�Sx%¯�wyxzu $ % j9�~�C$ ' ·i©"n/s;j��*s�fa�~s��y{~�Sn�xzu�n/|zj9lmnw¾ª-¯1n5°~�~�V|�{~svu j?}~j9xgu�wy� ���Sw²|g|�{Fn��mª¬egfil 3 T;��|�wy�~s�n5I=��� 6Zi��� 7 T(jN� � 698 % i�3 PT(jk·¶Ln;x |�{F}F}~f¨|�n!¯�n:��fi� � x,°~�~�Tj9��� f9ªcxzu�f¨|�n }~j9xgu~|�· G�ª�¯1nC°~�~� wy� � j!}�j9xzu

i��� 7 T � I10�� I %D�E212121� I�((� 3 � j5¯�wyxzu:� � i2I16 � $�%0jA� � �� 0 �>-�35� G�I 3=I É�³¯1nVs$j9��Sn�s�w��Sn_w¾ª-xzu~j�x5}~j�xzu�n$�~j9�F�yn�|�{~|(xgf*sfi�~s��y{~�Sn_xzu�j9x�I ; � 1^i6$�% 3H$�'0jt�~|�wy�~s�n_¯1n�®S�Ff�¯¯�uFn;xguFn;e­xzuFn1ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�f�ª³xguFn5i 3 � o j�ÊÙn;��}~j��~|�wyfi�/� 6��?% i��� 7 � jN� � 6di 3 � j%|gj9xgw²|N°�n�|1^i6$�%635$�'�j�fie/�Ffix$·mJ1{Fx;�Fw ª­¯1n5°~����w��#�]|�{~skuCj?}~j�xzu�ª¬ezfal 3 PT�xzf �� 7 � �Ìwyxqlmn�j9�~|xzu~j�x5¯1n�u~j;À¨n�wy�(�=j�}�j9xzu�ª¬egfil � 6.i��� 7 T0j � � 698 %>i 3 PT(j�xzf/� 698 %�i��� 7 � jt�Lj��~�L�Lfa�Cj9�y�xzuFnc|�xkj�xzn�|qf�ª�xgu~j9x5}�j9xzuÍ�*$�%quFfa�²�F|·mTqn;��s�n¨�F¯1n?u�j�À¨n�xzf*l�j9®¨n�j��Fn;¯Yn;��}F�yfiekj�xzwyfi�f9ª/xguFn�}�j9xzxgn;ez� ���³�~n;hiwy�F�Fwy�Fh j9x �� 7 � j9�~� 3 � ·SJ1{Fx;�Lw ªNO&���~�³¯1ncu~j;À¨ncj9��egn�ji���lVji��n5xzu~j�x�n;��}F��faekj9xgw�fa�³·:L¨wyl*w���j9eg���¨��w¾ª�xguFn;ezn/w²|�j�}�j9xzu*ª¬egfil 3 � xgf �� 7�� �Fj��~���)�:O

ܬù�ݳܲà

Page 16: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

������������ ��������������������! "�#�%$'&(�*)+�#��,�-.&0/1�0-./�&��32546�879�:���<;>=�?@&�A0)+ B?C&�A#D6D6A#&�2øo;�

fie�� � �~�¨¯1n��Sfi� � x1��n;n��?xzf?|�xz{~����xguFnq}�j9xzu�|1w�� � w�|z|�{�n���ª¬ezfal 3 � fae �� 7 � ·+Tqn;��s�n¨�w�x�w�|1�Fn�s�n�|g|zj�ez�*xgf*|�xz{~�S��j9x/l*f¨|�x � n;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi��|qj;ª¬xzn;e�xguFnA3ÙÊÙn$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�³· @

qfaxkj5�~n;�Fn �_U�fae­xzuFn�ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj9xgn�|Éf�ª³xzu�n G�ÊÙn;��}~j��~|�wyfi�³�¨xzu�nqn;��}F�yfiekj�xzwyfi�cf9ª�'�0|�xtj���|Þª¬faeÉxguFn­n;�S}���fietj9xgw�fi��f9ª9�º¯�uFw²sku�|�xgfi}~|%j�xÉxguFn0ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�|Lf9ª±xzuFn­}Fegn�s�n���n;�Sxn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�³·

��à � �:¥ � §�L¨{F}�}Ìfø|�n�xzuFn;egn_n;�Sw�|�xt| 3%j9�~�ROV|�{~skuVxzu~j�xD�

- �C" N¾o 21212 �%R � � 6 i��� 7 �>j ; � 1^i6$ % 3H$ ' j� � T i�� 7 �>j ; � 1!i2$ % 35$ ' jµ1uFn$�³�S¯�n¿u�j�À¨n �

- �C" N¾o 21212 �%R � � 6 8 % i��� 7 � j ; � 1^i6$�% 3H$�'0j� ��T�8 % i�� 7 � j ; � 1!i2$�%635$�'�j

�_¤�dzÇ��k§³µ1uFw�|1w²|/j��Swyezn�sx�s�fa�~|�n��¨{Fn;��s�n_f9ª­xguFn_��n;l*l�j¿��·Lµ1u�n¿��j9�~n;�y��w���h¨|0ª¬fie $�%j9�~� $�'cj9ezn xzuFn |gj9l*n�ª¬fae�xguFn |�xtj9xzn�|�f�ª5xguFn � ª¬fa����f�¯�wy�FhCn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�~|�j;ª¬xzn;e?xguFni 3 � o j�Ê­j9�~��i O �:o�jËʬn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi��|��~|�wy�~s�n/xzuFn$�*j�ezn/xzuFn5��j9�~n;�y��w���h¨|N� � j��~� ����f9ª(��·Tqn;�~sn¨�FxzuFn�fi�F�y� �Sw¾Á±n;egn;�~s�n�|�¯�uFw�svu s;j��"j9ezw�|�n_ª¬fie/xzuFn?xgez{Fxgu�Àaj9�y{Fn�|1ª¬fieH1^i6$(%435$�'0jf9ª�xzu�n ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�|(f�ª­xzuFn�i 3 � o�jËÊ�j9�~��i O �¸o�jËʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�~|5j9egn�xguFf¨|�n��~n;x�¯1n;n$�xzuFn?ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj�xzn�|5f9ª�xzuFnR3¬Ê/j9�~� O¨ÊÙn;��}~j��~|�wyfi�~|·�GÙª�xzuFn;��j9egn�w��Sn;��xzw²s$j9�Ë�FxguFncxzez{�xzuÀaj9��{�n�|(f�ª%xguFn5ª¬fi�y��f�¯�w��Fh�ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�|1¯�w����±�~n�w²��n;�Sxgw²s;j��Ë·9@

������� � �VÃð£�¥ � �¬¢�Ç��/£ Ã�¥ ���~Ç̤ �²£ �¼/{Fe5j���hafiezwyxzuFl w²|��Sn�sfil*}~f¨|�n���wy�,xguFn5ª¬fi�y��f�¯�w��Fhc|�xzn;}�|��

� �¬¤�¢�£º¢�£�Ã��­§(©"nClVj�®¨n�j"l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®Swy�Fh�f�ª�xzuFnV°~�Fw�xgn"|�xgez{~s�xg{Fezn�| '�0 j9�~����Lxgu~j9x_hiwyÀ¨n�|5j�°~et|�x_xzeg{Fxzu"Àaj9��{�n�f�ª�1^i6$�% 3H$('0j(ª¬fae_xzuFn?n;��Ê�|�xkj�xzn�|5f�ª-'�0?j��~��xguFnw��FÊ�|�xtj9xgn�|_j9�~�Cfi{FxgÊË|�xkj�xzn�|5f9ª ��·Íµ1uFn;�³�L¯�n?|�n;n;®�xguFn?}~j�xzu~|5w���'�0i�~fi�"¯�uFw²sku#$(% w�|j9�y¯�j;�F|�xzez{�n¨�;xzu~j�x­s�fa�F�Fn�s�x-j9�?n$�SÊ�|�xtj9xzn�xgf_j9��fixzu�n;e%n;��ÊË|�xkj�xzn¨�aj9�~��xguFn�|�w�l*wy�²j�eL}~j�xzu~|w�� �!ª¬ezfal�j9�*wy���;fa{FxzÊ�|�xtj9xzn�xzf�j9�FfaxzuFn$e1w���;fi{�xzÊ�|�xkj�xzn¨·�µ1uFw�|­s;j9�c�~n5�Sfa�Fn5����l*f���n;��Êsvu�n�sv®�w���h¨|¿f�ª_xzu�n�ª¬faezlc{F�²ja|�1 $�%63 i6$�%�+ 6djk�%¯�u�n;eznC 6/w²|?j�� j�xzfilmw²s�}Fegfi}~f¨|�w�xgw�fi�¯�uFw²sku¸w²|�fa�F��� xgez{Fn"f9ª�j@haw�À¨n;� n$��$w����$fi{FxgÊË|�xkj9xgn¨·CTqn;�~sn¨�0¯�nP��n;n�� xzf»lVj9®¨n��l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®�w��Fhø|�f�ª ' 0 j��~��� � lmf��Sn;��Ê�skuFn�sk®Sw �Fhø|�f�ª���·

�ÍÃS¦¨Ç���È«¢�£�Ã��­§­µ1uFn�egn�|�{���xk|/f9ª/xzu�n�°~ek|�x?|�xgn;}"¯�w����-n;�~j9����n?{~|_xzf �Sn;xgn;ezl*wy�Fn_w¾ªxzuFn1ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�|Éf9ª±xzu�n/�Sw¾Á±n;egn;�Sx�n;��}~j9��|�w�fa�~|%|gj9xzw�|Nª¬�C1!i2$ % 35$ ' jt·¨µ1uFn�xzn$l*}~fiekj�ez�xzeg{FxzuºÀaj9�y{Fn�|�hiwyÀ¨n;�"�S�"xzuFn*°~et|�xc|�xzn;}:wy�~�Sw�s;j9xgn*¯�uFn;xguFn;e�xguFn;egn*w²|�j�}~j9xgu³�%w��:xguFnw�l*lmn��Sw²j�xznc�Fn;wyhiu��Ìfa{Fe*}~j�xzxgn;ez�~|*f�ª?j"hiw�À¨n$�@ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xznø�0fa� ¯�uFw�svu $ % uFfa�²�F|�

ÝÉÝ ÷Xp$ö�ó(q�ñ

Page 17: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

o0W ��� ��2(f��A#&(�f��� / �(D ���:�(&6A#�+�P�! `�f��&0&(=�����(&��#�

¯�uFw²skuC��n�ji�F|qxgf j*|�xtj9xzncfi�"¯�uFw�svu $�'5uFfi���F|�·mF�faezn?}Fegn�s�w�|�n;�y�¨�Fw¾ª�¯1ncs$j9��� 7 0��� ^i6IDT(jxzuFn_xgn;l*}~fietj9ez�mxzez{�xzuVÀaj9��{�n¿fa�Fxkj�w��Fn���ª¬fie/j���n;��Êg�Sw���Êz�Ffaeqfa{FxzÊ�|�xtj9xznø�̯�n5u~j;À¨n �

� 7 0��� ^i�021 T jN����� 0�B 0 1 T ; � 1!i2$ % 35$ ' j

� 7 0��� ^i 3 T(jK����� 0�B -435��G�I!3 ��� 6di 3 PT(j ; � 1^i6$�% 3H$�'0j

� 7 0��� ^i��� 7 T0jN� � �� 0�B -�3 ��G=J 35��� 6di�� 7 T(j�; � 1^i6$�% 3H$�'0jJ1{Fx$�̪¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj�xzn�|_s;j��ºj9��|�f |zj�xzw²|˪¬� 1^i2$�%435$�'0j/�~n�s;j9{�|�n*f�ª�xzu�n�n;��w²|�xzn;��s�n?f9ª

j�}~j9xgu³�Éfa�:¯�uFw�svu $�%�uFfa�²�F|�ɯ�uFw�svu � haf¨n�|�xguFezfa{FhiuP�Cj,}~j�xzxzn$ez� ��·-µ1uFf¨|�n*}~j�xzu~|j9egnc�Sn;xzn�s�xzn��cw���xguFn¿°�ek|�x�|�xgn;}�f�ª�xzuFn�j9��hafiegw�xzu�lC·+UFfie/n;��j9l*}���n¨��w¾ª-xzuFn;egn�w�|q|�{~svu�j}~j9xgu�ª¬ezfal 3 T/xzf �� 7 � �±j9�~� 7 0�� !i�� 7 � j � ���� 0i�~¯1n�s;j9��s�fi��s���{~��n�xzu�j9x -435��G?I35��� 6di�3 PT(j�; � 1^i6$(%63H$�'0jt·r5s$s�fiet�Sw��Fh�xzf?�yn;l*lVj5���Fw�x�w�|�|�{���s�w�n$�Sx­xzfc|�xz{~����j�x�l*f¨|�x � n;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�~|�j�ª¬xgn;e

j�hiwyÀ¨n;�Pn$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�Pª¬fae?�Sn�s�w²�Swy�Fh�¯�u�n;xzuFn$e¿xguFn�ª¬egfi��xzw�n$ezÊ�|�xkj�xzn�|_f9ª/xgu~j9x?n;��}~j��~|�wyfi�|zj�xzw²|˪¬�Vfie5�Ffax�1^i2$�%435$�'0jk·^Tqn;��s�n¨�S¯�n�s;j9���Sn�s�w��Sn_w�x1ª¬fie�xzuFn5ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj�xzn�|�f9ª­xguFnG9ʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�!wy�:xzu�n�ª¬fa����f�¯�wy�Fh�¯�j��9�³¯1n*��{Fw����Pj � " � lVj�xzezwy�Chietj9}Fu:¯�wyxzu:xguFnxzn;lm}Ìfaekj�ez��xgez{FxguCÀaj9��{�n�|(ª¬fie_xguFn�ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj9xgn�|qf�ª�xzu�n�°~ek|�x5n;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�~|���j9����¯1n}Fezfa}~j9høj9xgn5xzuFn�}~fø|�w�xgw�À¨n�xzez{�xzu?Àaj9�y{Fn�|É�~jasv®�¯�j�ek�F|�xzuFn��yw��F®�|Þ�~n;x�¯�n;n;�¿ª¬egfi��xzwyn;e%|�xkj�xzn�|¯�uFw²skuVu~j;À¨n5�~n;n;���Sn;xzn$ezl*wy�Fn��?j9x/xzu�n °�ek|�x/|�xzn;}Í·r5|c|�f¨fa�«ja|�¯1n u~j;À¨nVxzuFn��Sn�°~�FwyxzwyÀ¨n,xgez{Fxgu Àaj9�y{Fn�|�ª¬fae�xguFn,ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�|�f9ª

xzuFn#G9ʬn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�³�1¯1n s;j�� {~|�nCj:|�w�l*wy�²j�e�}Fegf�s�n��S{Fegn¨�­jis$s�fiet�Sw��Fh"xzf ��n;l*lmj����0xgf�Sn;xgn;ezl*wy�Fn­|�{~s;s�n�|g|�wyÀ¨n;���/xzuFn­xgez{Fxgu�Àaj9�y{Fn�|³f9ª±xzuFn�|�{~s;s�n�|g|�wyÀ¨n0n$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�~|·9©"n1wyxzn;etj9xgnxzu~j�xq}�ezf�s�n���{Fezn�{F�Sxgw��±¯1n��Sn;xgn�s�x1xgu~j9x/xzu�n ª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ�|�xtj9xzn�|1f9ª­xguFn� Sʬn;�S}�j9�~|�w�fi��j9�~�f9ª�xzu�n���ÊÙn$�S}~j��~|�wyfi�»u~j;À¨n,xguFnC|gj9l*n �Sn°~�Fw�xgw�À¨n*xgez{Fxgu Àaj9�y{Fn�|�0¯�wyxzu �J��S·­µ1uFw�|w�xgn;ekj�xzw�fa�?w²|É�~fa{F�~��xgf5xzn;egl*w���j9xzn�|�w��~s�n�xguFn;egn1w²|-j9x­l*f¨|�x­� � }Ìfø|z|�w��F�yn/s�filc�Fw���j9xzwyfi�~|f9ª­xguFn � �Sn�°~��w�xzwyÀ¨n5xzeg{FxzuVÀaj9�y{Fn�|1f�ª­xzuFn5ª¬egfi��xzw�n$ezÊ�|�xkj�xzn�|1f�ª�j�hiwyÀ¨n;�Vn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�³·r5s$s�fiet�Sw��Fh/xzf_�yn;l*lmj��S�¨j��~�����_w�xgn;ekj�xzw���h5w�xɪ¬fae%xzu�n/|�{~s;sn�|z|�w�À¨n�|�n;xk|�f9ªLª¬egfi��xzwyn;ezÊ

|�xtj9xzn�|��~¯1n5u~j;À¨n_xzu�n;�*�-435��G�I!3 �>- O " N o 2 2 �%R���� � 8 6\i��� 7 T(j�; � 1^i6$�% 3H$�'0j� ��� 8 6Zi�� 7 T(j�; � 1^i6$�% 3H$�'0jGË�"fixzu�n;e_¯1fiet�F|��-j�ª¬xgn;e_xzuFn?ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj9xgn�|¿f�ª�xguFn�°~et|�x� Pn;��}~j��~|�wyfi�~|�Éxzu�n*�Sn$Ê

°~�Fwyxzw�À¨n?xgez{FxguPÀaj���{Fn�|_f9ª�xzuFn?ª¬ezfa�Sxgw�n;egÊË|�xkj9xgn�|5f9ª/xguFn�ª¬fa���yf9¯�wy�FhVn;��}~j9�~|�w�fa�~|¿¯�wy���%�~nezn;ha{F�²j�ez�y�,egn;}~n;xzn��,jas;s�faek�Swy�Fh�xgf*jc}~j9xgxzn;eg��f9ª0|�w$n��-�# ±·Lr�s;s�fiet�Sw���h?xzfc��n;l*l�j�oa�xzuFnm|zj�l*n�u�fi�²��|�ª¬fae5xzu�n?w��F�Fn$ezÊ�|�xkj�xzn�|·mGËx5w²|/xzuFn;� �Swyezn�s�x/xzu�j9x�j�°~�Fw�xgn�egn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�Êxzwyfi��i�' �0 � � � jk�¨sfiuFn;egn;��xɪ¬fie�1^i6$ % 35$ ' jɯ�wyxzuR�:��s;j����~n/�Sn�°��Fn��L·,' �0 w²|%fi�Fxtj9wy�Fn������

ܬù�ݳܲà

Page 18: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

������������ ��������������������! "�#�%$'&(�*)+�#��,�-.&0/1�0-./�&��32546�879�:���<;>=�?@&�A0)+ B?C&�A#D6D6A#&�2øo;�

j9}F}�����w��Fh �xgw�l*n�|ÉxzuFn/ez{���n�f9ª *)0�xzf/'�0i· ���Sw�|%fi�Fxtj9w���n�������l*n;eghiwy�Fh �(�: c}~j9xgxzn;eg�~|���F�~n;hiwy�F�Fwy�Fhcj9x/xzuFn� �ÊÙn;��}~j��~|�wyfi�³·

� �¬¤�È ¢�£�Ã��0§L©"n_®S��f9¯YxguFn��Sn�°~�FwyxzwyÀ¨n5xzeg{Fxzu Àij���{Fn�|(f�ª­xzuFn�n;��Êz�Fwy�FÊz�±j9���,fi{�xzÊ|�xtj9xzn�|�f�ª?xguFnCs�fauFn;egn;�Sxmezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi� i�' �0 � � � jt·0©"n"s;j�� �Ff�¯4lVj�®¨n�j:l*f���n;��Êsvu�n�sv®�w���h,f�ªH1^i2$ % 35$ ' jqª¬faecj9�y�1xzu�nV|�xtj9xzn�|�f9ª�xzu~j�x?ezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi�³·-r5s;s�faek�Swy�Fh�xgf��n;lmlVj?oi�Fxzu�j9x�¯�w��y�³hiwyÀ¨n5{~|�jcs�fiuFn$ezn;��x��²j��Ìn$����wy�Fh?� � � � � ���� ·

��� � � � � % �*�=2� �¶Ln;x�; '�0';Lj��~�!; � ;~�Ìncxzu�nV|�w ;n�|qf�ª/xzuFncx�¯1f�}�j9ezxt|¿f�ª/j�°��Fw�xgn�egn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�Pf�ª�j�5ezw�}�®¨n�|�xgez{~sxz{Fegn��:�¨j9�~�(; $�;�xguFn���n;��hixzu?f�ª³xguFnq´�µ�¶,ª¬faezlc{F�²j1¯�n/svuFn�sv®5fa� �:·_U�fael*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®�w��FhC$1�~xzu�ncj9��hafiegw�xzu�l ¯�w��y���Sn;xgn;ezl*wy�Fn ; $ ;��Sw ÁLn$ezn;��x5�²j��~n;���yw��Fhø|(f�ª1xguFn°~�Fwyxzn*egn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�³��ji|_w�x�}�ezf�s�n�|g|�n�|_{F}�¯�j9et�F|��-j9�~� s�fil*}�{Fxzn�|5l*faeznmj9�~�"l*fiegns�film}F��n;��|�{F�Sª¬faezlc{F�²ja|�·F©"n?s;j���� � ���+i2$ej�xzuFn?��{Flc�Ìn$e1f9ª - 3Jj9�~�&103�s�fa�F�Fn�s�xgw�À¨n�|w�� $1·¨µ1uFn/n;À¨n;��xz{�j9�Fl*f���w¾°±s;j�xzwyfi�~|Éf�ª³xguFn(°��Fw�xgn�ezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi�ms;j9�clVj�®¨n1hiegf�¯ w�xt|f�À¨n;ekj����³|�w;n_{F}Vxgf&; ' 0'; � ; � ; � ����� � �Ë·©"n_f9À¨n$ezÀaj9�y{Fn_xzuFn�s�fal*}F��n$�Swyx��?f�ª­fi{�e5j���hifaezwyxzuFl4���*xkj�®Swy�Fh*ja|qxzu�n¿wy�Fw�xgw²j���|�w$n

f9ª�fi{Fe5°~�Fwyxzn?egn;}Fezn�|�n;��xkj�xzw�fa�S; '�0';�� ; � ; � ������ � �Ë·L©Pncj�h¨j�w��:f�À¨n;egÀij���{Fn��S� xkj�®Swy�Fhª¬fie�j9�y� ; $ ;�|�xzn;}~|1xguFn�s�film}F��n;��w�x���f9ª-xzuFn�|�xzn$}~|0ª¬fie,- 3Jj9�~� 103Js�fa�F�Fn�sxzw�À¨n�|�·µ1uFn?°~et|�x?|�xzn;} f9ª/xzu�n*j���hifaezwyxzuFl w�|��Sn�sfil*}~f¨|�n��Cw�� j,l*f��Sn$��Ê�svuFn�sv®�w��Fhcf9ª�'�0

j9�~�!����ª¬fi���yf�¯1n��?�S� �4l*f��Sn;�yÊËskuFn�sk®�w¾��h¨|Éf�ª(' 0�j9�~�m� � l*f��Sn$��Ê�svuFn�sv®�w �Fh¨|Éf�ª(� ª¬fae°~�~�Swy�FhcxzuFn_}~j�xzu~| � hafiw���h�xguFezfa{Fhiu �c}~j9xgxzn;eg�~|�·µ1uFn�|�n�s�fi����|�xgn;}Vw²|/s�film}Ìfø|�n��*f�ª­j�xql*fø|�x/� � l*f���n;��Ê�svu�n�sv®�w �Fh¨|%f�ª�j�haekj�}FuCf9ª

|�w ;n � ' ·µ1uFn�xzuFwyek�*|�xzn;}*w�|0xguFn_�Sn�°��Fw�xgw�À¨n�l*f��Sn$��Ê�svuFn�sv®�w �Fh5f9ª-xzu�n(°~��w�xzn�ezn;}Fegn�|�n$�Sxtj9xzwyfi�³·Tqn$�~s�n"xzuFn:f�À¨n;etj9�y�_s�film}F��n;��w�x��ºw²|Vw�����iD; $ ; N i � �]� jE; '�0'; � i3i � ��o�j1; � ; �

� jN� ����� � � 8 % R\jk·

� �*�P���9."2­�$���

µ1uFn_j���hifaezwyxzuFl�¯1n5u�j�À¨n/}Fegn�|�n;��xzn���w�|0j¿°�ek|�x�j9xgxzn;l*}�x­j9x�l*f���n;��Ê�svu�n�sv®�w �Fh5wy�S°~�Fwyxzn;Ê|�xtj9xzn"|��F|�xzn;l�|¿¯�uFw�svu s;j9�»�ÌnV°~�Fwyxzn;�y�:ezn;}�ezn�|�n;�Sxgn��:�S� hiekj�}Fu hietj9l*l�j9ek|·XGËx?u~ji|�~n;n;�:wyl*}F��n$l�n;�¨xgn��Vji|?jVd%ja|zs;j��1}Fegfihietj9lC·STqf�¯�n;À¨n;e;�~w�x_w�|¿|�xzwy���%xgf¨fC��w�lmw�xzn��L·~µ1uFnj9�yhifiegw�xguFl xgu~j9x*¯�nCj�ezn"s�{Fegezn;��xz�y�º�Sn;À¨n$��fi}�w��FhCw�|*�Sn�|�w�hi��n��@ª¬fae*n;��xzekjas�xzwy�Fh"l*fiegnhin;��n;ekj��Éhaekj9}�uChiekj�l*lVj�ek|���f9ª­xguFn¿ª¬fa���yf9¯�wy�Fh?®�w��~�.�~j��Cw��Fwyxzw�j9�Lhaekj�}Fu � s;j�����|5�cj�°~ek|�x

ÝÉÝ ÷Xp$ö�ó(q�ñ

Page 19: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

o;� ��� ��2(f��A#&(�f��� / �(D ���:�(&6A#�+�P�! `�f��&0&(=�����(&��#�

}~j9xgxzn;eg� � %;�L¯�uFw²sku � s$j9����|5�*w�xt|�n;� ª�j9�~�"j9�:faxzuFn$e¿}�j9xzxgn;ez� ��'�³j9�~� |�fVfi�³�³{F}"xzf�j}~j9xgxzn;eg�C� � ��¯�uFw�svu�fi�F�y� � s;j9�y�²| �(wyxk|�n$�¾ªg·;©"n1¯�w��y�¨xzuFn$��u~j;À¨n­xzf5n$�Sxgn;�~�5fi{Fe�j9��hafiegw�xzu�lª¬fie/�~n;w��Fhcj��F��n_xgf*s�fa}~n¿¯�wyxzu |�{�svuVhietj9l*l�j9ek|·¼/xzu�n;eVw���xzn;egn�|�xgw��Fh:egn�|�n�j9ekskuT�Sw�egn�s�xzwyfi�~|*¯�wy���5�~n:xgf!xgez�¸xzfºn;��xzn;��� xguFnP�yfihaw²s

svu�n�sv®¨n��L��j9�~�:xzf"{~|�n,faxzuFn$e�l*n$xzuFf��F|_f9ª_lmf��Sn;��Ê�skuFn�sk®Sw �Fh��Þ�yw�®¨ncxzuFnV�yf�s;j9��l*f���n;��Êsvu�n�sv®�w���hF�¨fie/xzuFn�|��Slc�~fi��w�s(lmf��Sn;��Ê�skuFn�sk®Swy�FhF·

�=�_�¨�_'1���P�(��2

N*J@L���W�R ¼�·]J1{Fez®aj9egx�j9�~�'J5· L¨xgn�Á±n;�³·ad%{~|�u~��f9¯���d%ezf�s�n�|g|�n�| ��d­j9ekj����yn;�S´­fal*}~f¨|�wyxzwyfi�j��~�VF�f���n;�q´­uFn�sv®�w��Fh�·�GN�O�����b����� ��� � ��6��,��������É}�j9hin�|���Q��~oao;��·Lø}Fezwy�Fhin;e$�³o;�a� WF·

N ´�j�{~�i��R���·i´�j9{~s;j��Ë·F¼/�_xzuFn���n;hi{F��j9ekL¨xgez{~sxz{Fegn0f�ª±d%ezn�°��_�(n$¯�ezw�xgw��Fhø|�·S�! ����#&���-.����A���X�#D@)^/#-Z�(&@,^�>�f�(�+�0�t�%o1Ga� �í��o�� Qi�S�­o$�i�i��·

N ´9loL1Qa� R6l�· F:·Ì´­�²j�ez®¨n¨�`l�·ír�·`l�lmn;ek|�fi�³��j9�~�Vr�· dÉ·:Løw²|�xg�²j�·­rq{FxzfalVj9xgw²s �­n;ezw °±s;j9xgw�fa�f�ªXU�w��Fwyxzn;ÊZL¨xkj�xzn�´­fa�~s�{Fegezn;��x�L¨��|�xgn;lV|oH�|�w���h?µ³n;l*}~fietj9��¶Lfihaw²s L¨}~n�s�w °±s;j�Êxgw�fa�~|�·��'��� �`&3A#� 2]A#�0-.���#� 2 �#��� &3���#&3A#D6D6����� SA#���#/�A>�1�32�A#�+� ,:=g2(-Z�(Dh2�Q1iË�#jk��o;��Qa�S·

N ´­fa{�Qi��RVJ5·¨´­fi{�eks�n;�y��n¨·�µ1uFnCF�fa�~ji��w²scLøn�s�fi���SÊ�¼/et�Sn;e­¶Lfahiw²s1f�ª��qetj9}Fu�|��#GZG ��GË�S°��Fw�xgn�/etj9}Fu~|_f9ª J1fa{F�~�Sn��C© w²��xzu³·<��A�-� ��(D6A�-d����A��S,^=g2(-Z�(Dh2 �! ����#&0=��L��o ��o]Q ����a�i���Éo$��Qi��·

N �-�n;et�i��R µ5·��%�n;egfi�³· µ³n�|�xzw���h�ª¬fae�{F���~fi{F���Sn��S�Fn�|z|�f�ª5°Fª¬f svu~j��F�Fn;��|�· �! ����#&���-.����A���X�#D@)^/#-Z�(&@,^�>�f�(�+�0�t�%oio$� �í�a����oio �ø�­o;�i�a�S·

N*FPL1Qa� R ��·�F�{�����n$e­j9�~�mdÉ·+L�skuS{F}�}³·Lµ1u�n_µ1uFn;faez�?f9ªIl%�~��|���d%{~|�u~��f9¯�� rq{�xzfil�j9xkjj��~� L¨n�sfi�~�SÊ�¼/ek�Sn$e*¶Lfahiw²sa· �! ����#&���-.����A����X�#D@)^/#-Z�(& ,^�]�f�(�+�0�k��� � � �So�� �����o$��Qa�S·

ܬù�ݳܲà

Page 20: Model-Checking of CTL on Infinite Kripke Structures Defined by … · 2016. 12. 27. · Model-Checking of CTL on In nite Kripke Structures De ned by Simple Graph Grammars Yves-Marie

Unite de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technopole de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique,615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LES NANCY

Unite de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES CedexUnite de recherche INRIA Rhone-Alpes, 46 avenue Felix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex 1

Unite de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY CedexUnite de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex

Editeur

INRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)

ISSN 0249-6399