mr. kris hefton chief operating officer and director vane ......jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
Mr.KrisHeftonChiefOperatingOfficerandDirector
VANEMinerals(US)LLC
TestimonyBeforetheSubcommitteeonEnergyandMineralResourcesMiningInAmerica:TheAdministration’sUseofClaimMaintenanceFees
June13,2013ChairmanLamborn,RankingMemberHoltandmembersoftheSubcommittee,thankyoufortheopportunitytoprovidetestimonyonBLM’sMiningClaimFee.MynameisKrisHefton,andIamChiefOperatingOfficerandDirectorofVANEMinerals(US)LLCofTucson,Arizona.Bywayofbackground,mycompanyholds675unpatentedminingclaimsintheKaibabNationalForestandtheBLM’sArizonaStripDistrictwithintheareawithdrawnfrommineralentrybytheObamaAdministrationonJanuary9,2012.Ibeganmycareerasauraniumgeologistinthisarea34yearsagoandamoneofonlyahandfulofpeoplehavingdetailedknowledgeofarea’suraniumresources.BeforeIfocusonminingclaimholdingfees,Iwouldliketosharewiththesubcommittee,abriefhistoryofthebackgroundofthepoliticalagreementpertainingtomininginnorthernArizona,theimpactsonminingandtheeconomyandwhatournorthernArizonaprojectwouldhavehadifwehadbeenallowedtoproceedtofullyexploreanddevelopourminingclaims.In1983,thelateChairmanofthisCommittee,Arizona’sMorrisUdallinstructedtheuraniumindustrytositdownwithenvironmentalistsandotherimpactedgroupstodeterminewhichlandsshouldbemadewildernessandwhichshouldremainopentouraniummining.Afterayearoftortuousnegotiations,anagreementwasreachedwhichledtothesigningofPublicLaw98‐406,theArizonaStripWildernessActof1984.Thatbillsetaside387,000acresforBLMandForestServiceWildernessandspecificallyreleased540,000acresformultipleuseactivitiesincludinguraniummining.ChairmanUdallontheflooroftheHousehailedtheagreementashistoricandatruecompromisewhereneithersidereceivedeverythingtheywanted,butbothsidesbenefited.AllsidesunderstoodthatMiningofthesebrecciapipeswouldgoforward.FreshmanHousememberJohnMcCainwaspartofthatagreementwhichstoodthetestoftimerightupuntilthisAdministrationabrogatedit.ItwasbasedonthislawandthesuccessfultrackrecordofyearsofsuccessfuluraniumminingthroughtoreclamationinthisareathatIrecommendedmycompanyinvestintheArizonaStripdistrict.Nowmovingtoourday.HadVANEandtheotherexplorationcompaniesbeenallowedtogoforward,wewouldhavecollectivelyemployed400peopledirectlyandbeenresponsibleforindirectlyemployingsome700otherswiththeeconomicmultiplierthataccompaniessuchprojects.Thesearehigh‐paying,skilledjobsthatwouldprovideaboontoanareadominatedbytouristjobsthataverageclosetothenationalpovertylevel.Themineralvalueoverthelifeoftheprojectedminingactivityisestimatedat$2.3billion.TheironyofthewithdrawalisthatthegeologicformationsfoundinnorthernArizonaknownasbrecciapipesprovideforthemostenvironmentallybenignminingofuraniumanywhere.Effectively,whattheAdministrationdidwastowithdrawthemostenvironmentallyclean
![Page 2: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
uraniumminesthatalsohappentocontainthehighest‐gradeoresofanyoftheuraniumminesfoundintheUnitedStates.Inresponsetothehueandcryofenvironmentalgroups,theAdministration,throughitswithdrawaloftheselandsmadeAmericaevenmoredependentonforeignsourcesofuraniumeventhoughtheyknewourdomesticutilitiesalreadyimportover90%oftheuraniumcurrentlyusedinAmerica’s102operatingreactors.TheNuclearEnergyInstitute(NEI)estimatesthatthewithdrawnnorthernArizonabrecciapipedepositsat375millionlbsofuraniumoxide,containtheenergyequivalenttopowerallthehomesinColoradofor115yearsandNewJerseyforover74years.Mr.Chairman,theUnitedStateshasmorethanenoughuraniumtoprovideforallitsneeds.Infact,30yearsago,America’snuclearreactorsuseddomesticuraniumtoprovidefor100%(ALL)ofourdomesticneedsforvirtuallythesamereactorsweoperatetoday.Ithasbeenapolicydecision,thatis,apoliticaldecisiontoimportover90%ofoururanium.TheObamaAdministration’swithdrawalofthesemorethan1millionacreshastogodownas one of the dumbest moves ever made for public policy. However, an EnvironmentalImpactStatement(EIS)waspreparedaspartoftheprocesstowithdrawaloftheselands.TheNationalParkService’sownscientificstaffitselfconcluded;“It ismy opinion that the DEIS grossly overestimates the potential for impacts towaterresourcesofGrandCanyonNationalParkandtheColoradoRiverfromuraniumminingandexplorationon landsadjacent to thepark. The reality is that theorebodiesare relativelysmalland isolated, surroundedby low‐permeabilitygeologic formations. It isunlikely thatthere couldbeanymigrationofdissolvedmineralsorother contaminants frommine sites,particularlyviaagroundwaterflowpath.Previousstudieshavebeenunabletodetectsignificantcontaminationdownstreamofcurrentorpastminingoperations,e.g.theHackCanyonmines.(TheexceptionstothisstatementistheOrphanMineandHornCreek.TheOrphanMineisanold,unclaimedminesiteatthesouthrimofthecanyon.Waterflowsthroughtheabandonedmine,flushingmineralsintoHornCreek.ThisisinnowayasuitablecomparisontothehydrogeologicsettingorconditionsexpectedatpotentialminesitesevaluatedintheDEIS.)TheorebodiesoccurinassociationwiththeHermitFormationandareabout1000feetabovetheregionalwatertable.GeologicformationsbetweentheorebodyandthewatertableareprimarilysiltstoneandmudstoneoftheHermitFormationandSupaiGroup.Theseformationshaveverylowpermeability.Thereisnoexplanationofhowpotentialcontaminantsmighttravelfromthemineareastotheregionalwatertable,butitisassumedthatsomehowthatoccursandthencontaminantsflowmanymilesthroughtheregionalaquiferwithnodilution,nodegradation,andnoattenuationtodischargeatsprings.Evenunderthoseconditions,thereisonlyaminusculechangeinconcentrationofthemostlikelycontaminants(arsenicanduranium)atspringsthatdischargefromtheregionalaquifer;andthesechangesarefurtherdilutedbymixingwithsurfacewatersdownstreamfromthedischargeareas.
![Page 3: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Theremaylegitimatereasonstobeconcernedaboutpotentialuraniumminingoperationsinareasadjacenttothepark,butadverseimpactstowaterresourcesisnotoneofthosereasons.Thisisobviouslyatouchycasewherethehardsciencedoesn’tstronglysupportapolicyposition.Probablythebestwayto“finesse”thiswouldbefallbackonthe“precautionaryprinciple”andtakethepositionthatinabsenceofevenmorecompletecertaintythatthereisnoconnectionbetweenuraniumminesandregionalgroundwater,weneedtobecautious??ItsoundsliketheDEISisbasicallyheadinginthatdirection.”WhilethereisnoscientificbasisintheEIStoprovethatanenvironmentalemergencyexistedorthatawithdrawalofthismagnitudewasjustified.TheEISevenleftouttheArizonaStripWildernessActof1984whenitlistedallthelawsandstatutesbywhichthiswithdrawalwouldbejustified.TheEISimpliedthatthesuddenappearanceofthousandsofnewminingclaims,over5,000tobeexact,wascauseforsomethingtobedone.WhenIwasinvolvedinexplorationearlyinmycareertherewereover20,000miningclaimsinthisarea.WeconcludedfromourworkatthattimetheareawherewethoughthadthebestpotentialandIincludedamapthatdepictsthisarea.IalsoincludedamapfromtheEIS(Figure3.4‐1)thatillustratesthedensityofminingclaims.ItisinterestingtonotethattheboundaryoftheEISisdrawnaroundthoseclaims.ThereisnoindicationthatabufferzonewasbeingconsideredastheGrandCanyon‐ParashantNationalMonumentwascompletelyignored.Anothermapincluded(Figure3.15‐2),illustratesbythenumberofexistingroadswithintheboundary,thatitisnotparticularlyremoteorinaccessible.And,whereisthescientificevidencethatjustifiesthisboundarydecision?Bytheway,the$2.3billionfigurementionedearlier,wasquotedfromtheDraftEIS,butwasremovedfromtheFinalEIS.ItisappallingthatSecretaryofInteriorKenSalazar,noranyonefromtheObamaAdministration,whowereinvolvedinmakingadecisiontowithdrawover1millionacresoflandthatwouldimpactthelivesofmanyindividualsaswellasimpactthegovernment’sowntaxbase,botheredtovisitthearea,speakwiththepeopleandindustrywhoweregoingtobeimpactedbythisdecision,andverifywhethertheenvironmentalgroups’claimshadanyscientificbasis.Andfinally,thewithdrawalwasannouncedevenbeforetheFinalEISwasreleased.ItisafactthatanumberofthesebrecciapipeuraniumdepositslocatedonlandsalreadyclosedtominingincludingGrandCanyonNationalParkareerodinguraniumintotheaquiferandColoradoRiverwatershed.Thebrecciapipeslocatedonlandsnotclosedareslowlyleachinguranium.ConsideringthattheprimaryconcernisabouturaniumleachingintotheaquiferandColoradoRiverwatershed,cananyoneexplaintomewhyitissobadthatthesedepositsarebeingmined,theuraniumremoved,andhauledoutofstate?Thisisaremediationprojectthatdoesn’tcostthetaxpayeracent,butevengeneratesrevenue.Andtotopitoff,noone,ortheenvironmentisbeingharmed.Thesefactsdidn’tstoptheAdministrationfromcarryingoutitspoliticalagenda.Sadly,weallshouldhavelearnedthestoryaboutChickenLittle.FortheObamaInteriorDepartment
![Page 4: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
togrosslyexaggeratetheimpactsofuraniumminingontheGrandCanyonNationalParkinthiswayandyetignoreitsownscientificfindings,showsthatChickenLittlestilllives.ItbegsthequestionastowhyweshouldweeverbelievetheDOIandthisAdministration?Mr.Chairman,SecretarySalazarissuedasegregationorderonJuly21,2009,whicheffectivelyshutdownallactivitiesexceptforongoingminingatafewlocations.Thelanguageoftheorderstated;“Neitherthesegregationnoranywithdrawal,however,wouldprohibitongoingorfutureminingexplorationorextractionoperationsonvalidpre‐existingclaims.”ThetruthofthismatteristhattheDOIvieweda“valid”claimasoneonwhichaneconomicdepositwasalreadyprovenandthatitplannedtoconduct,attheclaimowner’sexpense,avalidityexamonanyclaimwhereaprojectwasproposed.DOIclearlystatedinadvancethatifeconomicquantitiesofmineralcouldnotbedemonstrated,theclaimwouldbedeclaredinvalid.Inotherwords,youhadtoproveyouhadaminewithoutbeingabletodotheworkrequiredtoshowproof.Exceptforthefewlocationsmentioned,alltheprojectsonalltheotherclaimswereinthecorroborationorconfirmationstagetodetermineifaneconomicdepositexisted.Therefore,explorationactivitiesceasedandemployeesandcontractorswerelaidoff.However,theselandsremainopentothemineralleasing,geothermalleasing,andmineralmaterialslaws.Asyouknow,thiswithdrawalhastriggeredanumberoflawsuitschallengingthelegalityofthewithdrawalaswellassuingformonetarydamages.VANEandtheotherclaimholdersinnorthernArizonawererequiredbyBLMtocontinuetopaytheannualmineclaimholdingfeesbyeachSeptember1st.Thewithdrawalitselfdidn’tformallyoccurforanothertwoandahalfyears,butwehaveallbeenrequiredtopaysinceJulyof2009,tohaveanyhopeofrecourseandsincethatdate,paymentshavetotaled$2.75million.Ifweholdontoourclaimsthroughtheentire20yearwithdrawalperiodplustheearlierperiodheredescribed,VANEandtheothercompanieswillhavebeenrequiredtopay$8.3millioneventhoughwewillhavebeenprohibitedfromminingtheseclaimsanddeposits.Tounderstatewhatseemsobvious,thisseemsinequitabletous.WerespectfullyrequestthattheCongresstakeactiontoremedytheinequity.Onewaytorepairthisinequitywouldbetosuspendallminingclaimholdingfeeswithinwithdrawnareasaswellascost‐recoveryfeessuchasvalidityexamsconnectedwithminingclaims.Anotherquestionhere,whichtheCommitteeshouldaddress,ishowBLMmanagesminingclaimreceipts.Oftheapproximately$60milliondollarsgeneratedannuallybyminingclaimpayments,BLMspends$38milliontoadministerthemininglaw.Mindyou,Iamnottalkingabouttotalgovernmentreceiptsfromhardrockmining,evenwithoutroyalties,thatamountisinthebillionstakingintoaccountcorporateandpersonalincometaxespaidtothetreasury.
![Page 5: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Thecurrentprogramgeneratessufficientrevenuetoprocessfederalexplorationandminingpermits,yettheBLMandForestServicearenotoriouslyslowinprocessingtheseapplicationsandencourageapplicantstocovertheseexpensesinordertoobtainpermitsinatimelymanner.ThishaslargerimplicationsontheminingclimateintheU.S.Forexample,aninternationallyrespectedmineralsindustryadvisoryfirm,BehreDolbear,preparesanannualreportrankingthetwenty‐fivelargestmineralproducingcountriesintheworld.Thelatestreportisentitled2012RankingofCountriesforMiningInvestment‐‐Where“NottoInvest”andisattachedandincorporatedbyreference.BehreDolbearconsiderssevencriteriainrankingcountries:
Thecountry’seconomicsystem Thecountry’spoliticalsystem Thedegreeofsocialissuesaffectingmininginthecountry Delaysinreceivingpermitsduetobureaucraticandotherdelays Thedegreeofcorruptionprevalentinthecountry Thestabilityofthecountry’scurrency Thecountry’staxregime
WhiletheUnitedStatesrankshigh(eightoraboveonaonetotenscale)foritseconomicandpoliticalsystem,theUnitedStatesreceivedarankingofthreewithrespecttosocialissuesaffectingmining;rankedlastwithPapuaNewGuineainpermittingdelays(scoring2ontheonetotenscale)andaratingoffourwithrespecttoitstaxregime.BehreDolbearconsidersthetotaltaxesapplicabletoaminingproject,includingincometaxes,severanceandexcisetaxes,dutiesandimposts,androyalties.TheUnitedStatescorporatetaxrateis35%plus,which,whencombinedwithstatelevieseffectivelymakeitthehighestcorporatetaxrateintheworld.ThishighcorporatetaxrateprovidesasignificantdisincentiveformineralinvestmentintheUnitedStates.Agrossroyaltywouldonlyexacerbatethisdisincentive,andanynetroyaltymusttakeintoconsiderationtheoverall“governmenttake.”Thebenefitsofagrossroyaltywouldlikelyendupbeingcancelledoutbecauseincometaxpaidwoulddecreaseaccordinglywhenthisroyaltyisdeductedasanoperatingexpense.AccordingtotheDolbearstudy,whenthe“governmenttake”fromcombinedtaxesandroyaltyreaches50%,aminingproject’seconomicviability,duringperiodsofnormalcommoditypricing,isthreatened.
Inaddition,theAdministrationdoesn’tseemtounderstandthatourlifestyleandstandardoflivingismadepossiblebymining.Furthermore,itdoesn’tunderstandthattheproductionofsolar,windandgeothermalelectricitycapacityrequiresminerals.TheAdministrationproposeskeyfundingincreasesforrenewableenergydevelopmentwhileproposingnewfeesandtaxesonmineralproduction,proposinganewleasingsystemandenactingpoliciesthatwilladverselyimpactthesecurityoftenurenecessarytoattractmineralinvestment,andfailingtoaddresssignificantworkforceissuesintheMiningLawprogram.AsImentioned,Iamoneoffewpeopleknowledgeableonthebrecciapipedistrictandasweretiresogoestheexpertise.Thebottomlineisthatallenergyproduction,includingrenewableenergyrequiresminerals,andlotsofthem.AndtheyneedAmerican
![Page 6: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
minerals–unless,ofcourse,wearewillingtotradeourunhealthydependenceonforeignoilforadangerousdependenceonforeignsourcesofcriticalminerals.In1995,theUnitedStatesGeologicalSurveyreportedthattheUnitedStateswasimportrelianton43nonfuelmineralswitha$51billionvalue.In2011,theU.S.hadbecomeimportrelianton67minerals(anincreaseof4over2010),and100%relianton19mineralswithavalueof$90.4billion.TheU.S.ismoreimport‐dependenton43non‐fuelmineralsthanitisoncrudeoil.Unfortunately,thePresident’sbudgetandlegislativeproposalswilldiscouragemineralproductionintheUnitedStatesandfurtherincreaseourNation’srelianceonforeignsourcesofminerals.IcanspeaktothedisincentivetoinvestinminingintheU.S.firsthand:
(1) Ispentover10yearsofmygeologycareerlivingandworkingoverseasbecauseIcouldnotfindworkintheU.S.AndImadebettermoney!
(2) ThisincidentIspokeofinnorthernArizonahasallbutclosedVANE’soperationsintheU.S.andwenowfocusonMexicowherewehavesuccessfulminingandmillingoperationsandminingisprotectedbyMexico’sconstitution.(VANEisofcoursenotaloneinitsviewtooperateoutsidetheU.S.)
(3) TheabilityofpoliticstosonegativelyimpactbusinessasinthecaseofthewithdrawaloflandsinnorthernArizonathatsobadlyimpactedmycompany.ThemandateoftheBLMistoresponsiblydevelopthemineralresourcesonpubliclands,yetapoliticaladministration,asinthecaseofthenorthernArizonawithdrawal,cancircumventlawtoadvanceitspoliticalagendaandwithnoapparentaccountability.
IwanttoworkintheUnitedStates.Thisismyhome.Iwouldliketoseethepolicyonminingchangetoencouragedomesticinvestment.Mr.Chairmanandmembersofthesubcommittee,thankyouforthisopportunitytotestifyonanimportantissueforourcountry.‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐Attachments:3maps
![Page 7: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Comparison of Withdrawal Area to Resource Potential
St George
Fredonia
Kanab
• Past exploration has shown that < 1/2 of the district has pipes with uranium mineralization
• The rest of the pipes are probably barren
• Current exploration is focusing on blind or unmapped pipes
OPEN
OPEN
Not all of the district has mineralized pipes
AREA OF KNOWN URANIUM MINERALIZATION
![Page 8: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Chapter 3 Northern Arizona Proposed Withdrawal Final Environmental Impact Statement
3-228 October 2011
Figu
re 3
.15-
2. T
rans
porta
tion
map
.
![Page 9: Mr. Kris Hefton Chief Operating Officer and Director VANE ......Jun 13, 2013 · 2 uranium mines that also happen to contain the highest‐grade ores of any of the uranium mines found](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022070901/5f445fe53db7d142915441ca/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Northern Arizona Proposed Withdrawal Final Environmental Impact Statement Chapter 3
October 2011 3-43
Figure 3.4-1. Regional location map.