myers-perry black holes: beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_doukas.pdf ·...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
MYERS-PERRY BLACKHOLES: BEYOND THE
SINGLE ROTATION CASE
Jason DoukasYukawa Institute For Theoretical Physics
Kyoto University
Lunch meetingFEB 02, 2011
1/32
![Page 2: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Contents1. Introduction.
1.1 Myers Perry black holes.1.2 Motivation for considering more than one rotation.
2. Angular momentum constraints.2.1 Derivation.2.2 Results.
3. The Wald Gedanken experiment.3.1 4 dimensions.3.2 D dimensions.
4. Conclusion.
2/32
![Page 3: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
In 1986 Robert C. Myers and M. J. Perry presented thefirst examples of black hole solutions with angularmomentum in more than four dimensions.≈ 989 citations.
Perhaps the most striking discoveries of these resultswere:
I For a fixed mass, solutions may exist which havearbitrary large angular momentum. c.f. Kerr M > a.
I bD−12 c rotation parameters are required to describe
the rotation, where D is the total spacetimedimension.
3/32
![Page 4: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
In 1986 Robert C. Myers and M. J. Perry presented thefirst examples of black hole solutions with angularmomentum in more than four dimensions.≈ 989 citations.Perhaps the most striking discoveries of these resultswere:
I For a fixed mass, solutions may exist which havearbitrary large angular momentum. c.f. Kerr M > a.
I bD−12 c rotation parameters are required to describe
the rotation, where D is the total spacetimedimension.
3/32
![Page 5: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
In 1986 Robert C. Myers and M. J. Perry presented thefirst examples of black hole solutions with angularmomentum in more than four dimensions.≈ 989 citations.Perhaps the most striking discoveries of these resultswere:
I For a fixed mass, solutions may exist which havearbitrary large angular momentum. c.f. Kerr M > a.
I bD−12 c rotation parameters are required to describe
the rotation, where D is the total spacetimedimension.
3/32
![Page 6: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
The reason for more than one angular momentumparameter can be seen as follows:
Far away from the MP black hole the metric is flat, we canthen group the D− 1 spatial coordinates into pairs(x1, x2), . . . , (xi, xi+1), . . . .If D is odd the last pair will be (xD−2, xD−1);otherwise if D is even the xD−1 coordinate will beunpaired.Therefore there are bD−1
2 c such pairs.Writing each pair (xi, xi+1) in polar coordinates (ri, φi) wesee there is a rotation associated with each of the ∂φivectors.
4/32
![Page 7: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
The reason for more than one angular momentumparameter can be seen as follows:Far away from the MP black hole the metric is flat, we canthen group the D− 1 spatial coordinates into pairs(x1, x2), . . . , (xi, xi+1), . . . .
If D is odd the last pair will be (xD−2, xD−1);otherwise if D is even the xD−1 coordinate will beunpaired.Therefore there are bD−1
2 c such pairs.Writing each pair (xi, xi+1) in polar coordinates (ri, φi) wesee there is a rotation associated with each of the ∂φivectors.
4/32
![Page 8: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
The reason for more than one angular momentumparameter can be seen as follows:Far away from the MP black hole the metric is flat, we canthen group the D− 1 spatial coordinates into pairs(x1, x2), . . . , (xi, xi+1), . . . .If D is odd the last pair will be (xD−2, xD−1);
otherwise if D is even the xD−1 coordinate will beunpaired.Therefore there are bD−1
2 c such pairs.Writing each pair (xi, xi+1) in polar coordinates (ri, φi) wesee there is a rotation associated with each of the ∂φivectors.
4/32
![Page 9: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
The reason for more than one angular momentumparameter can be seen as follows:Far away from the MP black hole the metric is flat, we canthen group the D− 1 spatial coordinates into pairs(x1, x2), . . . , (xi, xi+1), . . . .If D is odd the last pair will be (xD−2, xD−1);otherwise if D is even the xD−1 coordinate will beunpaired.
Therefore there are bD−12 c such pairs.
Writing each pair (xi, xi+1) in polar coordinates (ri, φi) wesee there is a rotation associated with each of the ∂φivectors.
4/32
![Page 10: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
The reason for more than one angular momentumparameter can be seen as follows:Far away from the MP black hole the metric is flat, we canthen group the D− 1 spatial coordinates into pairs(x1, x2), . . . , (xi, xi+1), . . . .If D is odd the last pair will be (xD−2, xD−1);otherwise if D is even the xD−1 coordinate will beunpaired.Therefore there are bD−1
2 c such pairs.Writing each pair (xi, xi+1) in polar coordinates (ri, φi) wesee there is a rotation associated with each of the ∂φivectors.
4/32
![Page 11: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
The MP metric(s)
Even D; ds2 = −dt2 + r2dα2 +d
∑i=1
(r2 + a2
i
) (dµ2
i + µ2i dφ2
i
)+
2MrΠF
(dt +
d
∑i=1
aiµ2i dφi
)2
+ΠF
Π− 2Mrdr2,
Odd D; ds2 = −dt2 +d
∑i=1
(r2 + a2
i
) (dµ2
i + µ2i dφ2
i
)+
2Mr2
ΠF
(dt +
d
∑i=1
aiµ2i dφi
)2
+ΠF
Π− 2Mr2 dr2,
F = 1−d
∑i=1
a2i µ2
ir2 + a2
i, Π =
d
∏i=1
(r2 + a2i ), d =
{D−2
2 , D evenD−1
2 , D odd.
5/32
![Page 12: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
The full MP metric is complicated and in analysing thesolutions it is common to set all but one angularmomentum parameter to zero, this is known as the simplyrotating black hole.
This can be looselyjustified in braneworld scenario’s,where collidingparticle momentumwill be confined to abrane and thereforeany black hole createdon this brane wouldonly spin in thisdirection.
6/32
![Page 13: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
The full MP metric is complicated and in analysing thesolutions it is common to set all but one angularmomentum parameter to zero, this is known as the simplyrotating black hole.
This can be looselyjustified in braneworld scenario’s,where collidingparticle momentumwill be confined to abrane and thereforeany black hole createdon this brane wouldonly spin in thisdirection.
6/32
![Page 14: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
However, if the braneis thick then there isalso the potential forangular momentum tooccur in otherdirections. ����
����������������������������������������������������
��������������������������������������������������������
���������������������������������
���������������������������������
Furthermore, one could imagine planck-scale processesnot confined to the brane (i.e., gravitons/strings etc)creating black holes in the bulk spacetime with arbitraryangular momentum. We are thus motivated to explore thesolutions with more than one angular momentumparameter.
7/32
![Page 15: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
However, if the braneis thick then there isalso the potential forangular momentum tooccur in otherdirections. ����
����������������������������������������������������
��������������������������������������������������������
���������������������������������
���������������������������������
Furthermore, one could imagine planck-scale processesnot confined to the brane (i.e., gravitons/strings etc)creating black holes in the bulk spacetime with arbitraryangular momentum. We are thus motivated to explore thesolutions with more than one angular momentumparameter.
7/32
![Page 16: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Angular momentumconstraints
8/32
![Page 17: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Horizons hide singularities from outside observers.
Even in four dimensions for certain values of M and a theKerr solution can admit solutions without any horizon.This occurs when:
∆ = r2 + a2 − 2Mr > 0
orM < a
D > 4? For simply rotating black holes (⇒ only one a)D = 5 is the only case where the angular momentum isconstrained. In particular it is known that M > a2/2.Why is D = 5 special?To “explain” this we calculate the angular momentumconstraints in higher dimensions in general with allangular momentum parameters.
9/32
![Page 18: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Horizons hide singularities from outside observers.Even in four dimensions for certain values of M and a theKerr solution can admit solutions without any horizon.This occurs when:
∆ = r2 + a2 − 2Mr > 0
orM < a
D > 4? For simply rotating black holes (⇒ only one a)D = 5 is the only case where the angular momentum isconstrained. In particular it is known that M > a2/2.Why is D = 5 special?To “explain” this we calculate the angular momentumconstraints in higher dimensions in general with allangular momentum parameters.
9/32
![Page 19: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Horizons hide singularities from outside observers.Even in four dimensions for certain values of M and a theKerr solution can admit solutions without any horizon.This occurs when:
∆ = r2 + a2 − 2Mr > 0
orM < a
D > 4?
For simply rotating black holes (⇒ only one a)D = 5 is the only case where the angular momentum isconstrained. In particular it is known that M > a2/2.Why is D = 5 special?To “explain” this we calculate the angular momentumconstraints in higher dimensions in general with allangular momentum parameters.
9/32
![Page 20: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Horizons hide singularities from outside observers.Even in four dimensions for certain values of M and a theKerr solution can admit solutions without any horizon.This occurs when:
∆ = r2 + a2 − 2Mr > 0
orM < a
D > 4? For simply rotating black holes (⇒ only one a)D = 5 is the only case where the angular momentum isconstrained. In particular it is known that M > a2/2.
Why is D = 5 special?To “explain” this we calculate the angular momentumconstraints in higher dimensions in general with allangular momentum parameters.
9/32
![Page 21: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Horizons hide singularities from outside observers.Even in four dimensions for certain values of M and a theKerr solution can admit solutions without any horizon.This occurs when:
∆ = r2 + a2 − 2Mr > 0
orM < a
D > 4? For simply rotating black holes (⇒ only one a)D = 5 is the only case where the angular momentum isconstrained. In particular it is known that M > a2/2.Why is D = 5 special?
To “explain” this we calculate the angular momentumconstraints in higher dimensions in general with allangular momentum parameters.
9/32
![Page 22: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Horizons hide singularities from outside observers.Even in four dimensions for certain values of M and a theKerr solution can admit solutions without any horizon.This occurs when:
∆ = r2 + a2 − 2Mr > 0
orM < a
D > 4? For simply rotating black holes (⇒ only one a)D = 5 is the only case where the angular momentum isconstrained. In particular it is known that M > a2/2.Why is D = 5 special?To “explain” this we calculate the angular momentumconstraints in higher dimensions in general with allangular momentum parameters.
9/32
![Page 23: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
In D-even dimensions the condition for the location of thehorizon is:
∆ = Π− 2Mr = 0, Π =d
∏i=1
(r2 + a2i ).
There are only three possibilities for the number ofhorizons:
r�r
D
Let r̃ be the unique minima of ∆ for positive r.
10/32
![Page 24: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
In D-even dimensions the condition for the location of thehorizon is:
∆ = Π− 2Mr = 0, Π =d
∏i=1
(r2 + a2i ).
There are only three possibilities for the number ofhorizons:
r�r
D
Let r̃ be the unique minima of ∆ for positive r.10/32
![Page 25: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Then the black hole will be free of naked singularities(that is to say a horizon exists) if:
∆(r̃) ≤ 0, r̃ > 0.
The inequality is saturated when ∆(r̃) = 0, equalityoccurs iff r̃ is also an r-intercept. Therefore,
M ≥ Π(r̃h)
2r̃h,
where r̃h is a solution to the simultaneous set of equations
∆(r̃h) = 0, ∂r∆(r̃h) = 0.
Or:0 = r̃h∂rΠ(r̃h)−Π(r̃h)
11/32
![Page 26: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Then the black hole will be free of naked singularities(that is to say a horizon exists) if:
∆(r̃) ≤ 0, r̃ > 0.
The inequality is saturated when ∆(r̃) = 0, equalityoccurs iff r̃ is also an r-intercept.
Therefore,
M ≥ Π(r̃h)
2r̃h,
where r̃h is a solution to the simultaneous set of equations
∆(r̃h) = 0, ∂r∆(r̃h) = 0.
Or:0 = r̃h∂rΠ(r̃h)−Π(r̃h)
11/32
![Page 27: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Then the black hole will be free of naked singularities(that is to say a horizon exists) if:
∆(r̃) ≤ 0, r̃ > 0.
The inequality is saturated when ∆(r̃) = 0, equalityoccurs iff r̃ is also an r-intercept. Therefore,
M ≥ Π(r̃h)
2r̃h,
where r̃h is a solution to the simultaneous set of equations
∆(r̃h) = 0, ∂r∆(r̃h) = 0.
Or:0 = r̃h∂rΠ(r̃h)−Π(r̃h)
11/32
![Page 28: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Using the product expansion:
j
∏i=1
(r2 + a2i ) =
j
∑i=0
r2iAj−ij ,
with the coefficients conveniently defined as
Akn = ∑
ν1<ν2<...νk
a2ν1
a2ν2
. . . a2νk
,
where vk are summed over [1, n], 0 ≤ k ≤ n andA0
k ≡ 1,
we can write
P2(r̃h) =d
∑i=0
(2i− 1)r̃2ih Ad−i
d = 0.
d ≤ 4→ D− 22≤ 4→ D ≤ 10
12/32
![Page 29: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Using the product expansion:
j
∏i=1
(r2 + a2i ) =
j
∑i=0
r2iAj−ij ,
with the coefficients conveniently defined as
Akn = ∑
ν1<ν2<...νk
a2ν1
a2ν2
. . . a2νk
,
where vk are summed over [1, n], 0 ≤ k ≤ n andA0
k ≡ 1, we can write
P2(r̃h) =d
∑i=0
(2i− 1)r̃2ih Ad−i
d = 0.
d ≤ 4→ D− 22≤ 4→ D ≤ 10
12/32
![Page 30: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Using the product expansion:
j
∏i=1
(r2 + a2i ) =
j
∑i=0
r2iAj−ij ,
with the coefficients conveniently defined as
Akn = ∑
ν1<ν2<...νk
a2ν1
a2ν2
. . . a2νk
,
where vk are summed over [1, n], 0 ≤ k ≤ n andA0
k ≡ 1, we can write
P2(r̃h) =d
∑i=0
(2i− 1)r̃2ih Ad−i
d = 0.
d ≤ 4→ D− 22≤ 4→ D ≤ 10
12/32
![Page 31: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
In the D-odd case the location of the horizon is found bythe equation:
∆ = Π(l)− 2Ml = 0, Π =d
∏i=1
(l + a2i ).
where l = r2.
Performing the same analysis again we findthat:
l̃h∂lΠ(l̃h)−Π(l̃h) = 0, M ≥ Π(l̃h)2l̃h
and the polynomial for the odd case is:
P1(l̃h) =d
∑i=0
(i− 1)l̃ihAd−id = 0.
d ≤ 4→ D− 12≤ 4→ D ≤ 9
13/32
![Page 32: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
In the D-odd case the location of the horizon is found bythe equation:
∆ = Π(l)− 2Ml = 0, Π =d
∏i=1
(l + a2i ).
where l = r2. Performing the same analysis again we findthat:
l̃h∂lΠ(l̃h)−Π(l̃h) = 0, M ≥ Π(l̃h)2l̃h
and the polynomial for the odd case is:
P1(l̃h) =d
∑i=0
(i− 1)l̃ihAd−id = 0.
d ≤ 4→ D− 12≤ 4→ D ≤ 9
13/32
![Page 33: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
In the D-odd case the location of the horizon is found bythe equation:
∆ = Π(l)− 2Ml = 0, Π =d
∏i=1
(l + a2i ).
where l = r2. Performing the same analysis again we findthat:
l̃h∂lΠ(l̃h)−Π(l̃h) = 0, M ≥ Π(l̃h)2l̃h
and the polynomial for the odd case is:
P1(l̃h) =d
∑i=0
(i− 1)l̃ihAd−id = 0.
d ≤ 4→ D− 12≤ 4→ D ≤ 9
13/32
![Page 34: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
D=7 an example:
The polynomial is:
2l̃3h + l̃2h(a21 + a2
2 + a23)− a2
1a22a2
3 = 0
and the solution can be written in closed form:
l̃h =16
(−(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3) +1p(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3)2 + p
),
p3 = −(a21 + a2
2 + a23)
3 + 54a21a2
2a23 + 6
√3
×√−(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3)3a2
1a22a2
3 + 27(a41a4
2a43),
and the constraint reads:
M ≥(l̃h + a2
1)(l̃h + a22)(l̃h + a2
3)
2l̃h.
14/32
![Page 35: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
D=7 an example:
The polynomial is:
2l̃3h + l̃2h(a21 + a2
2 + a23)− a2
1a22a2
3 = 0
and the solution can be written in closed form:
l̃h =16
(−(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3) +1p(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3)2 + p
),
p3 = −(a21 + a2
2 + a23)
3 + 54a21a2
2a23 + 6
√3
×√−(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3)3a2
1a22a2
3 + 27(a41a4
2a43),
and the constraint reads:
M ≥(l̃h + a2
1)(l̃h + a22)(l̃h + a2
3)
2l̃h.
14/32
![Page 36: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
D=7 an example:
The polynomial is:
2l̃3h + l̃2h(a21 + a2
2 + a23)− a2
1a22a2
3 = 0
and the solution can be written in closed form:
l̃h =16
(−(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3) +1p(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3)2 + p
),
p3 = −(a21 + a2
2 + a23)
3 + 54a21a2
2a23 + 6
√3
×√−(a2
1 + a22 + a2
3)3a2
1a22a2
3 + 27(a41a4
2a43),
and the constraint reads:
M ≥(l̃h + a2
1)(l̃h + a22)(l̃h + a2
3)
2l̃h.
14/32
![Page 37: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Results. M = 1.
(left) D = 5. (right) D = 6.
15/32
![Page 38: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Results. M = 1.
(left) D = 7. (right) D = 8.
16/32
![Page 39: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
D All ai non-zero a1 = 04 M ≥ a1 M ≥ 0
5 2M ≥ a21 + a2
2 + |a1a2| M >a2
22
6 M ≥ (r̃2h+a2
1)(r̃2h+a2
2)2r̃h
;3r̃4
h + (a21 + a2
2)r̃2h − a2
1a22 = 0
M ≥ 0
7 M ≥ (l̃h+a21)(l̃h+a2
2)(l̃h+a23)
2l̃h;
2l̃3h + l̃2h(a21 + a2
2 + a23)− a2
1a22a2
3 = 0M >
a21a2
22
8M ≥ (r̃2
h+a21)(r̃
2h+a2
2)(r̃2h+a2
3)2r̃h
;5r̃6
h + 3(a21 + a2
2 + a23)r̃
4h
(a21a2
2 + a21a2
3 + a22a2
3)r̃2h − a2
1a22a2
3 = 0M ≥ 0
......
...
17/32
![Page 40: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Conclusion
18/32
![Page 41: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
I It is not only theoretically interesting to study blackholes with angular momentum in higher dimensions,but there are also good physical reasons one shouldconsider beyond single rotation MP solutions.
I I derived the mass/angular momentum constraintsthat apply to MP- black holes.
I In particular, it was shown that exact closed formexpressions could be obtained for dimensions lessthan or equal to ten.
I These results can be used to show that none of theMP black holes can be spun into naked singularitiesusing the Wald type gedanken experimentgeneralised into D dimensions.
I It is worth mentioning that even if a black holesatisfies the constraints presented it may not bestable; classical instabilities of the Gregory-Laflammetype are known to arise in the ultra spinning regimes.
19/32
![Page 42: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
I It is not only theoretically interesting to study blackholes with angular momentum in higher dimensions,but there are also good physical reasons one shouldconsider beyond single rotation MP solutions.
I I derived the mass/angular momentum constraintsthat apply to MP- black holes.
I In particular, it was shown that exact closed formexpressions could be obtained for dimensions lessthan or equal to ten.
I These results can be used to show that none of theMP black holes can be spun into naked singularitiesusing the Wald type gedanken experimentgeneralised into D dimensions.
I It is worth mentioning that even if a black holesatisfies the constraints presented it may not bestable; classical instabilities of the Gregory-Laflammetype are known to arise in the ultra spinning regimes.
19/32
![Page 43: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
I It is not only theoretically interesting to study blackholes with angular momentum in higher dimensions,but there are also good physical reasons one shouldconsider beyond single rotation MP solutions.
I I derived the mass/angular momentum constraintsthat apply to MP- black holes.
I In particular, it was shown that exact closed formexpressions could be obtained for dimensions lessthan or equal to ten.
I These results can be used to show that none of theMP black holes can be spun into naked singularitiesusing the Wald type gedanken experimentgeneralised into D dimensions.
I It is worth mentioning that even if a black holesatisfies the constraints presented it may not bestable; classical instabilities of the Gregory-Laflammetype are known to arise in the ultra spinning regimes.
19/32
![Page 44: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
I It is not only theoretically interesting to study blackholes with angular momentum in higher dimensions,but there are also good physical reasons one shouldconsider beyond single rotation MP solutions.
I I derived the mass/angular momentum constraintsthat apply to MP- black holes.
I In particular, it was shown that exact closed formexpressions could be obtained for dimensions lessthan or equal to ten.
I These results can be used to show that none of theMP black holes can be spun into naked singularitiesusing the Wald type gedanken experimentgeneralised into D dimensions.
I It is worth mentioning that even if a black holesatisfies the constraints presented it may not bestable; classical instabilities of the Gregory-Laflammetype are known to arise in the ultra spinning regimes.
19/32
![Page 45: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
I It is not only theoretically interesting to study blackholes with angular momentum in higher dimensions,but there are also good physical reasons one shouldconsider beyond single rotation MP solutions.
I I derived the mass/angular momentum constraintsthat apply to MP- black holes.
I In particular, it was shown that exact closed formexpressions could be obtained for dimensions lessthan or equal to ten.
I These results can be used to show that none of theMP black holes can be spun into naked singularitiesusing the Wald type gedanken experimentgeneralised into D dimensions.
I It is worth mentioning that even if a black holesatisfies the constraints presented it may not bestable; classical instabilities of the Gregory-Laflammetype are known to arise in the ultra spinning regimes.
19/32
![Page 46: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
If you are interested in these results please see my paper:
arXiv:1009.6118
20/32
![Page 47: Myers-Perry black holes: Beyond the single rotation caselunch.seminar/files/110202_Doukas.pdf · MYERS-PERRY BLACK HOLES: BEYOND THE SINGLE ROTATION CASE Jason Doukas Yukawa Institute](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042319/5f08535e7e708231d4217403/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Questions
21/32