n b5 as budgets for broadcast news shrink, networks ...udel.edu/~pollack/acct351/handouts/public...

1
N B5 THE NEW YORK TIMES, MONDAY, MARCH 1, 2010 address that.” The easy answer would seem to lie in NBC’s structure, because in contrast to its competitors, that news organization is flush, making an estimated $400 million in profit a year. “We actually think we have a completely different model,” Steve Capus, the president of NBC News, said. That model: win every significant ratings competition on the broadcast side and rely on MSNBC’s reve- nue stream of advertising plus cable subscriber fees to subsidize the high costs of news gathering. The effectiveness of that for- mula inevitably resurrects pre- dictions that a marriage with a cable news organization is imper- ative for CBS and ABC. The obvi- ous partner is CNN, and both those networks have been in courtships with it before. To date, the cultural challenges have been insurmountable. CNN, which says last year was its most profit- able since its founding in 1980, would seem to have little incen- tive to rush to the aid of a net- work. And neither network wants to cede editorial control to CNN. “If it were easy or obvious, it would have happened by now,” Mr. Heyward said. But a longtime network news executive, who asked not to be identified because of connections to previous private negotiations involving CNN, said that ABC or CBS was likely to enter into an al- liance with a partner like CNN “within the next few years.” Even Mr. Westin, who said he did not see how a match with CNN “makes sense for us,” con- ceded: “In general, in business, when there is real decline, con- solidation inevitably happens.” Already, outlines of consolida- tion are discernible. Several CNN stars contribute to “60 Minutes” on CBS. And CBS executives, mindful that Katie Couric’s con- tract expires in a little over a year, have talked to Anderson Cooper of CNN about an anchor job, according to two TV veterans informed of the meeting. In recent months, a handful of ABC News reporters has ap- peared on the business channel Bloomberg, and the two organ- izations have tried to jointly hire at least one person, according to two staff members who asked not to be named because they were not authorized by their employ- ers to speak. Those two, and two others, labeled the sharing by ABC and Bloomberg — what one person called flirting — a pos- sible prelude to a broader news- gathering pact. A Bloomberg spokeswoman said that the company was a cli- ent of ABC’s affiliate service and declined to comment on any talks about a broader relationship be- tween the organizations. An ABC spokesman said the current level of cooperation with Bloomberg was “hardly unusual.” Network news divisions have historically been family jewels for their parent corporations, lending prestige and an aura of public service — as well as a shield against government intru- sion. Mr. Heyward called the net- work evening newscasts a “bas- tion of serious news coverage at a time when so much of television has become tabloid and trivial.” While they have steadily shed viewers, to a cumulative 22 mil- lion in 2009, from about 50 million in 1980, the newscasts still amass an audience that dwarfs any show on a cable news channel. In the last five years, the more lu- crative network morning shows have also shown declines, Tom Rosenstiel, director of the Project for Excellence in Journalism, said. “What’s occurring in broad- cast news is not some sudden cri- sis. This has been a glacial ero- sion,” he said. A survey by the Pew Research Center last year reported that three-quarters of respondents thought the cancellation of the evening newscasts would be an “important loss” to the country. Mr. Rosenstiel said, “None of these news division presidents wants to be the first guy to kill an evening newscast.” Not that it would be their call. That decision would fall to the networks’ corporate parents. Ex- ecutives from CBS News and ABC News said the top corporate executives for both networks re- mained outspoken supporters of the news divisions. ABC employees were review- ing buyout packages last week- end. Eligible staff members have until March 26 to decide whether to leave. If ABC cannot meet its goal, layoffs will follow. Mr. Westin said ABC News could no longer afford to support a worldwide staff of about 1,500, with bureaus in cities foreign and domestic, most with traditional TV news work forces: camera op- erators, sound engineers, tape editors, assignment editors and, of course, correspondents, many with substantial salaries. More journalists will become jacks-of-all-trades, wielding cam- eras, microphones and lights, as well as lists of interview ques- tions. More production work will be conducted out of New York. “The ones who fear the most from the cuts are the ones that have a single function,” one ABC staff member said. Mr. Westin said high-priced and purely cosmetic talent would become an increasingly endan- gered species. “There have been people in television news — very successful people — who do not write,” he said. “We are going to definitely require more of our journalists.” Mr. Westin said he did not think the cuts would compromise ABC’s journalism, but not every- one shares his confidence. One veteran ABC News executive said, “Clearly the signal is: It’s not important to create anything new. We simply have to figure out a way to manage it cheaply.” CBS, similarly, is trying to do the same with less. In an in- terview after its layoffs in early February, the CBS News presi- dent, Sean McManus, said the or- ganization was figuring out how to “utilize our resources in a more efficient way.” NBC News, meanwhile, re- mains the envy of the business, largely because of its decision in 1996 to start up a separate cable news channel. The total work force at NBC News — which includes MSNBC — is 1,100, the size ABC now as- pires to be. CBS is believed to have fewer than 1,400 on staff. So far, Web revenue is a rather small part of the broadcast net- works’ bottom lines, although Mr. Westin said ABC’s digital income was “up substantially.” But if digital revenue cannot offset ad losses, Mr. Heyward suggested there was high ground from the flood if the networks could find a way to make their news stand out. “The notion of investing more in distinctiveness and less in sameness is critical,” he said. That means more enterprise re- porting and less overlapping cov- erage of news that cable handles, like reporters standing in snow drifts with yardsticks. But the networks will surely stick it out, he predicted, if only because they do not want to see their competitors win. “I sometimes compare it to three people in a leaky boat,” Mr. Heyward said. “Each one sees an island shimmering in the dis- tance and starts thinking: I could jump out and swim for the island and maybe I could make it. “On the other hand, I could drown and make the boat lighter so the other two make it. I think you are going to see everybody staying in the game because ev- erybody knows leaving guaran- tees a longer lease on life for their competitors.” As Budgets for Broadcast News Shrink, Networks Consider New Paths IDA MAE ASTUTE/ABC David Westin, left, the president of ABC News, with Jim Mur- phy, senior executive producer of “Good Morning America.” From First Business Page By MICHAEL J. de la MERCED Merck of Germany said on Sunday that it had agreed to buy Millipore, an American provider of purifiers and filters for biotech- nology laboratories, for about $7.2 billion, including debt. With the Millipore acquisition, Merck will become the latest health care company to strike a deal during a period of industry- wide consolidation. The takeover will give the German drug maker a big presence in products for the biotechnology industry. Under the terms of the deal, Merck will pay $107 a share in cash, a 13 percent premium to Millipore’s closing price of $94.41 on Friday. “This transaction is very at- tractive to shareholders, custom- ers and employees of both com- panies,” Karl-Ludwig Kley, Merck’s chairman, said in a statement. “This is a combination with an excellent strategic fit.” Millipore shares have risen more than 34 percent since last week, when news reports said that it had received a $6 billion bid from another company, Ther- mo Fisher Scientific. Millipore later confirmed that was consid- ering selling itself. Millipore, based in Billerica, Mass., had $1.7 billion in sales last year. It has about 6,000 employ- ees in more than 30 countries. The deal is expected to close in the second half of the year. Merck plans to pay for the deal with a mix of cash on hand and loans from Bank of America Mer- rill Lynch, BNP Paribas and Commerzbank, though it expects to issue bonds to replace some of the bank financing. Merck was advised by Gug- genheim Securities, Perella Weinberg Partners and the law firm Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom. Millipore was advised by Goldman Sachs and the law firms Cravath, Swaine & Moore and Ropes & Gray. Merck to Pay $7.2 Billion For Millipore 38 ST W. , #325   OFF 8th AVE 500, 700, 1400 sf. Totally reno ofcs. New elevs. 24-hr Drmn. Internet access falconproperties.com 212-302-3000 Madison/48th 11 inside offices Full floor identity, 3,300 sq.ft. Suitable for accounting, legal or medical offices. 212-926-2500 or [email protected] 6th Ave. Corner 39th St. 3 small stores for rent, NO FEE falconproperties.com 212-302-3000 Offices−Manhattan 105 RETAIL SPACE (200) Manhattan 205

Upload: others

Post on 30-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: N B5 As Budgets for Broadcast News Shrink, Networks ...udel.edu/~pollack/Acct351/handouts/public offer ad2.pdf · ing buyout packages last week-end. Eligible staff members have until

N B5THE NEW YORK TIMES, MONDAY, MARCH 1, 2010

address that.”The easy answer would seem

to lie in NBC’s structure, becausein contrast to its competitors,that news organization is flush,making an estimated $400 millionin profit a year.

“We actually think we have acompletely different model,”Steve Capus, the president ofNBC News, said. That model:win every significant ratingscompetition on the broadcastside and rely on MSNBC’s reve-nue stream of advertising pluscable subscriber fees to subsidizethe high costs of news gathering.

The effectiveness of that for-mula inevitably resurrects pre-dictions that a marriage with acable news organization is imper-ative for CBS and ABC. The obvi-ous partner is CNN, and boththose networks have been incourtships with it before. To date,the cultural challenges have beeninsurmountable. CNN, whichsays last year was its most profit-able since its founding in 1980,would seem to have little incen-tive to rush to the aid of a net-work. And neither network wantsto cede editorial control to CNN.

“If it were easy or obvious, itwould have happened by now,”Mr. Heyward said.

But a longtime network newsexecutive, who asked not to beidentified because of connectionsto previous private negotiationsinvolving CNN, said that ABC orCBS was likely to enter into an al-liance with a partner like CNN“within the next few years.”

Even Mr. Westin, who said hedid not see how a match withCNN “makes sense for us,” con-ceded: “In general, in business,when there is real decline, con-solidation inevitably happens.”

Already, outlines of consolida-tion are discernible. Several CNNstars contribute to “60 Minutes”on CBS. And CBS executives,mindful that Katie Couric’s con-tract expires in a little over ayear, have talked to AndersonCooper of CNN about an anchorjob, according to two TV veteransinformed of the meeting.

In recent months, a handful ofABC News reporters has ap-peared on the business channelBloomberg, and the two organ-izations have tried to jointly hireat least one person, according totwo staff members who asked notto be named because they werenot authorized by their employ-ers to speak. Those two, and twoothers, labeled the sharing byABC and Bloomberg — what oneperson called flirting — a pos-sible prelude to a broader news-gathering pact.

A Bloomberg spokeswomansaid that the company was a cli-ent of ABC’s affiliate service anddeclined to comment on any talksabout a broader relationship be-tween the organizations. An ABCspokesman said the current levelof cooperation with Bloombergwas “hardly unusual.”

Network news divisions havehistorically been family jewelsfor their parent corporations,lending prestige and an aura ofpublic service — as well as ashield against government intru-

sion. Mr. Heyward called the net-work evening newscasts a “bas-tion of serious news coverage at atime when so much of televisionhas become tabloid and trivial.”

While they have steadily shedviewers, to a cumulative 22 mil-lion in 2009, from about 50 millionin 1980, the newscasts still amassan audience that dwarfs anyshow on a cable news channel. Inthe last five years, the more lu-crative network morning showshave also shown declines, TomRosenstiel, director of the Projectfor Excellence in Journalism,said. “What’s occurring in broad-cast news is not some sudden cri-sis. This has been a glacial ero-sion,” he said.

A survey by the Pew ResearchCenter last year reported thatthree-quarters of respondents

thought the cancellation of theevening newscasts would be an“important loss” to the country.Mr. Rosenstiel said, “None ofthese news division presidentswants to be the first guy to kill anevening newscast.”

Not that it would be their call.That decision would fall to thenetworks’ corporate parents. Ex-ecutives from CBS News andABC News said the top corporateexecutives for both networks re-mained outspoken supporters ofthe news divisions.

ABC employees were review-ing buyout packages last week-end. Eligible staff members haveuntil March 26 to decide whetherto leave. If ABC cannot meet itsgoal, layoffs will follow.

Mr. Westin said ABC Newscould no longer afford to support

a worldwide staff of about 1,500,with bureaus in cities foreign anddomestic, most with traditionalTV news work forces: camera op-erators, sound engineers, tapeeditors, assignment editors and,of course, correspondents, manywith substantial salaries.

More journalists will becomejacks-of-all-trades, wielding cam-eras, microphones and lights, aswell as lists of interview ques-tions. More production work willbe conducted out of New York.“The ones who fear the mostfrom the cuts are the ones thathave a single function,” one ABCstaff member said.

Mr. Westin said high-pricedand purely cosmetic talent wouldbecome an increasingly endan-gered species. “There have beenpeople in television news — verysuccessful people — who do notwrite,” he said. “We are going todefinitely require more of ourjournalists.”

Mr. Westin said he did notthink the cuts would compromiseABC’s journalism, but not every-one shares his confidence. Oneveteran ABC News executivesaid, “Clearly the signal is: It’snot important to create anythingnew. We simply have to figure outa way to manage it cheaply.”

CBS, similarly, is trying to dothe same with less. In an in-terview after its layoffs in earlyFebruary, the CBS News presi-dent, Sean McManus, said the or-ganization was figuring out howto “utilize our resources in amore efficient way.”

NBC News, meanwhile, re-mains the envy of the business,

largely because of its decision in1996 to start up a separate cablenews channel.

The total work force at NBCNews — which includes MSNBC— is 1,100, the size ABC now as-pires to be. CBS is believed tohave fewer than 1,400 on staff.

So far, Web revenue is a rathersmall part of the broadcast net-works’ bottom lines, although Mr.Westin said ABC’s digital incomewas “up substantially.”

But if digital revenue cannotoffset ad losses, Mr. Heywardsuggested there was high groundfrom the flood if the networkscould find a way to make theirnews stand out.

“The notion of investing morein distinctiveness and less insameness is critical,” he said.That means more enterprise re-porting and less overlapping cov-erage of news that cable handles,like reporters standing in snowdrifts with yardsticks.

But the networks will surelystick it out, he predicted, if onlybecause they do not want to seetheir competitors win.

“I sometimes compare it tothree people in a leaky boat,” Mr.Heyward said. “Each one sees anisland shimmering in the dis-tance and starts thinking: I couldjump out and swim for the islandand maybe I could make it.

“On the other hand, I coulddrown and make the boat lighterso the other two make it. I thinkyou are going to see everybodystaying in the game because ev-erybody knows leaving guaran-tees a longer lease on life for theircompetitors.”

As Budgets for Broadcast News Shrink, Networks Consider New Paths

IDA MAE ASTUTE/ABC

David Westin, left, the president of ABC News, with Jim Mur-phy, senior executive producer of “Good Morning America.”

From First Business Page

By MICHAEL J. de la MERCED

Merck of Germany said onSunday that it had agreed to buyMillipore, an American providerof purifiers and filters for biotech-nology laboratories, for about$7.2 billion, including debt.

With the Millipore acquisition,Merck will become the latesthealth care company to strike adeal during a period of industry-wide consolidation. The takeoverwill give the German drug makera big presence in products for thebiotechnology industry.

Under the terms of the deal,Merck will pay $107 a share incash, a 13 percent premium toMillipore’s closing price of $94.41on Friday.

“This transaction is very at-tractive to shareholders, custom-ers and employees of both com-panies,” Karl-Ludwig Kley,Merck’s chairman, said in astatement. “This is a combinationwith an excellent strategic fit.”

Millipore shares have risenmore than 34 percent since lastweek, when news reports saidthat it had received a $6 billionbid from another company, Ther-mo Fisher Scientific. Milliporelater confirmed that was consid-ering selling itself.

Millipore, based in Billerica,Mass., had $1.7 billion in sales lastyear. It has about 6,000 employ-ees in more than 30 countries.

The deal is expected to close inthe second half of the year.

Merck plans to pay for the dealwith a mix of cash on hand andloans from Bank of America Mer-rill Lynch, BNP Paribas andCommerzbank, though it expectsto issue bonds to replace some ofthe bank financing.

Merck was advised by Gug-genheim Securities, PerellaWeinberg Partners and the lawfirm Skadden, Arps, Slate,Meagher & Flom. Millipore wasadvised by Goldman Sachs andthe law firms Cravath, Swaine &Moore and Ropes & Gray.

Merck to Pay

$7.2 Billion

For Millipore

38 ST W. , #325����   OFF 8th AVE500, 700, 1400 sf. Totally reno ofcs.

New elevs. 24-hr Drmn. Internet accessfalconproperties.com     212-302-3000

Madison/48th 11 inside officesFull floor identity, 3,300 sq.ft. Suitable for

accounting, legal or medical offices.212-926-2500 or [email protected]

6th Ave. Corner 39th St.3 small stores for rent, NO FEE

falconproperties.com     212-302-3000

Offices−Manhattan 105

RETAILSPACE

(200)

Manhattan 205