Nam Theun 2 Local Consultations

Part 1 – The Process

Coverage

LOCAL CONSULTATIONON

NAM THEUN II

LOCAL CONSULTATIONON

NAM THEUN II

PAPs PARTICIPATION IN LOCAL CONSULTATIONS

WHY IMPORTANT ?WHY IMPORTANT ?

LOCAL CONSULTATIONS : PRINCIPLES & METHODOLOGY

HOW DO PAPs PARTICIPATE?HOW DO PAPs PARTICIPATE?

LOCAL CONSULTATIONS : MEANINGFUL RESPONSES

HOW DOES NT2 RESPOND?HOW DOES NT2 RESPOND?

1

2

3

11 PAPs PARTICIPATION IN LOCAL CONSULTATIONS

WHY IMPORTANT?WHY IMPORTANT?

GLOBAL CONSULTATION

LOCALCONSULTATION

PAPsETHNICAL

SOCIALCULTURALDIVERSITY

EAMP

SDP

RAP

SEMFOP

LIMITEDACCESSIBILITY

COMMUNICATIONCONSTRAINTS

CONTEXTCOMPLEXITY

XBF

MAE KHONG

NCBANNT - NPA

3 MINI - WATERSHEDS• NAM SOD• NAM NOI• NAM THEUN

NAM THEUN

TALK

TALK TO ALL

TO TO TO

ALL ALL ALL

PAPs

PAP

VILLAGE

ALL

ALL TO TALK

SMALLGROUP

DIALOGUE

2

SHIFT

PROCESS

3LOCAL CONSULTATIONS : PRINCIPLES & METHODOLOGY

HOW DO PAPs PARTICIPATE?HOW DO PAPs PARTICIPATE?

2.1

TRANSPARENCY

MEANINGFULBALANCE

3

PRINCIPLES

• WIN - WIN VALUE• +/- IMPACT• MITIGATION• COMPENSATION & GRIEVANCE PROCEDURES

• VILLAGE - BASED• INFORMATION CENTER• REPORT TO ALL• MIS - MULTIMEDIA

• GENDER• ETHNIC• MULTI - PARTITE DIALOGUE• INDEPENDENT MONITOR/FOLLOW UP

• MUTUAL CONSENSUS• MAJOR CONCERNS / RECOMMENDATIONS• NT2 RESPONSES• VILLAGE - BASED ON GOING CONSULTATION

PAPs

VILLAGER

PEOPLE

HOW DO PAPs

PARTICI PATE?CHECK+

INDEPENDENT

MONITOR

• SM

ALL

GROUP

DIA

LOGUE

VFs

• VIL

LAGE

INFORM

ATION

CENTER

FACT

SHEET

POSTER

MULTI-MEDIAKIT

+

+

10VILLAGE

FACILITATORs

VFs

HEADMEN

COMMUNITYGROUP

INFORMALLEADERs

ELDERs

YOUTHs

WOMEN

4

5

HEAD MAN ELDER WOMEN YOUTH INFORMAL LEADER

STEP

4 VFs• LEARNING WHAT WAS LEARNED• PLANNING NEXT ACTIONS

VFs• LEARNING WHAT WAS LEARNED• PLANNING NEXT ACTIONS

STEP

110 VFs

LEARNING TO LEARN/ASK

10 VFsLEARNING TO LEARN/ASK

STEP

2 VILLAGE FORUM• ALL HH-GENDER-ETHNIC• SMALL GROUP DIALOGUE• CONCERNS & RECOMMENDATIONS

VILLAGE FORUM• ALL HH-GENDER-ETHNIC• SMALL GROUP DIALOGUE• CONCERNS & RECOMMENDATIONS

STEP

3 SUMMARY - REPORT• VILLAGE CONCENSUS• CONCERNS & RECOMMENDATIONS

SUMMARY - REPORT• VILLAGE CONCENSUS• CONCERNS & RECOMMENDATIONS

4 STEPS OF VILLAGE - BASED LOCAL CONSULTATION4 STEPS OF VILLAGE - BASED LOCAL CONSULTATION2.2

VILLAGECONSULTATION

“PROCESS”

10 VFsLEARNING TOLEARN & ASK

VILLAGE FORUM

• ALL HH - GENDER - ETHNIC

• SMALL GROUP DIALOGUE

• CONCERNS & RECOMMENDATIONS

VILLAGECONSENSUS

VFs

• LESSON LEARNED

• NEXT ACTIONS

DISTRICTTEAM

/AGENCY

TEAM

REPORT VIDEOMIS

RECOMMENDATIONS

VILLAGECONSULTATION

“OUTPUT”

LIST OF VFs VFs’ CONCERNS

• WHO ARE THEY?• GENDER/ETHNIC

BALANCE

• WHY?• LEARN TO ASK

No No1 2

LIST OF HHs GROUP DIALOGUE

• % PARTICIPATION• WHO MISSED?• WHY MISSED?

ISSUES

No No3 4

CONCERNS

VILLAGE CONCERNS

ALL GROUP

CONCERNS

No 5

VILLAGER’S RECOMMENDATIONS

ALL GROUP

RECOMMENDATIONS

VFs’ LESSON

WHAT

WAS

LEARNED?

No 6

VFs’ NEXT ACTION

• WHO MISSED?• HOW TO REACH THEM?• HOW TO FACILITATE?

LEARNED

+ +

6

FOLLOWUP

MONITOR

SELFON - GOING

VILLAGECONSULTATION

COMMONCONCERNS

&RECOMMENDATIONS

VILLAGE

CONSENSUS

POSTER

REPORT

MIS

GISUP DATE

SAFEGUARDDOCUMENT

SAFEGUARDDOCUMENTS

UP DATE

VILLAGECOMPENSATION

COMMITTEE

VILLAGEINFORMATION

CENTER

VILLAGEACTION

PLAN

VFsVILLAGE

FACILITATORS

NT2DISTRICT

TEAMS

LEARNED

• NT 2

• IMPACT

• MITIGATION

• COMPENSATION & GRIEVANCE STEP

• FACILITATION SKILL

+-

7

8

WATERSHEDPIZ

AREA

RESERVOIRAREA

DOWNSTREAMXBF

AREA

PROJECTCONSTRUCTION

AREA

3 LOCAL CONSULTATIONS: MEANINGFUL RESPONSES

HOW DOES NT2 RESPOND?HOW DOES NT2 RESPOND?

STEP

1VILLAGE - BASED

LOCAL CONSULTATION

VILLAGE - BASEDLOCAL CONSULTATION

STEP

2 COMMUNITY CONCERNCOMMUNITY PROPOSAL

COMMUNITY CONCERNCOMMUNITY PROPOSAL

NT2NT2

GOLGOL

FURTHERCONSULTATIONSTEP

3 SAFEGUARD DOCUMENTUPDATE

SAFEGUARD DOCUMENTUPDATE

FOLLOW - UP THROUGH/ FORIMPLEMENTATION READINESS

FOLLOW - UP THROUGH/ FORIMPLEMENTATION READINESS

STEP

4

GOL

NT IIWBADB

WMPA

NAKAIKAMKERDNAKAI

GNOMMA

LARD

MAHAXAI

BULAPA

MAHAXAI

XEBUNG

FAI

NONGBOK

XAIBULINAKAIKAMKERD

NNT - NPAWATERSHED AREA

(12 VILLAGES)

PIZ

AREA(28

VILLAGES)

DOWNSTREAM

XBF

AREA(130

VILLAGES)

PROJECTCONSTRUCTION AREA

NAKAI RESERVOIRAREA(17 VILLAGES)

LOCAL CONSULTATIONCAPACITY BUILDING : ACHIEVEMENTS

LOCAL CONSULTATIONCAPACITY BUILDING : ACHIEVEMENTS

9

LOCAL CONSULTATIONS : IMPLEMENTATION PHASELOCAL CONSULTATIONS : IMPLEMENTATION PHASE

TRAININGMATERIALPREPARATION

PHASE1

REVIEW

SAFEGUARDDOCUMENTS

FACTSHEETS

MULTI MEDIA KIT

WORKSHOP

SESSIONDESIGN

WORKSHOP

MANUAL

RESOURCETEAM

FACILITATORTEAM+

TRAININGWORKSHOPPILOT VILLAGE

PHASE2

DISTRICTFACILITATOR

&VILLAGE FACILITATOR

WORKSHOP

PILOTVILLAGE

WORKSHOP

VF

MONITORFOLLOW

UP

VILLAGE

CONSULTATION

MIS

REPORT

SYNTHESIS OFVILLAGE - BASEDCONSULTATION

PHASE3

VILLAGE-BASEDSYNTHESISWORKSHOP

ISSUE - REPONSESYNTHESISWORKSHOP

MULTIMEDIA

REPORT

MIS

VBINFORMATION

CENTER

SAFEGUARDDOCUMENT UPDATE &RESPONSES

PHASE4

AGENCY’SRESPONSE

CONSULTATION

INTERAGENCYRESPONSE

CONSULTATION

SAFEGUARDDOCUMENT

REVIEWWORKSHOP

VILLAGE - BASEDRESPONSES

&ACTION PLANWORKSHOP

10